Electronic game evaluation device, electronic game evaluation program, and electronic game evaluation method
The electronic game evaluation device efficiently evaluates new characters by clustering feature vectors, selecting representative vectors based on expected rewards, and updating distributions, addressing the inefficiencies of conventional methods.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2020037247
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2020-03-04
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-20
- Estimated Expiration
- 2040-03-04
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods require actual gameplay to evaluate new characters in electronic games, and reinforcement learning is inefficient and time-consuming, making it difficult to accurately assess their impact on game balance.
An electronic game evaluation device and method that clusters feature vectors, selects a representative vector based on expected rewards, performs battle evaluations, and updates the expected reward distribution to efficiently evaluate new characters before introduction.
Enables effective pre-introduction evaluation of new characters, improving learning accuracy and reducing the time required to assess their impact on game balance.
Smart Images

Figure 0007587348000002 
Figure 0007587348000003 
Figure 0007587348000004
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to an electronic game evaluation device, an electronic game evaluation program, and an electronic game evaluation method. [Background technology]
[0002] There are known electronic games that are played using a variety of characters with different game parameters. In such electronic games, the game parameters assigned to the characters are a major factor in determining the progress of the game. Therefore, the presence of an extremely strong character may upset the balance of the progress of the electronic game.
[0003] Therefore, when a new character is introduced into an electronic game, it is necessary to evaluate the impact of the introduction of the character on the electronic game. For example, a method is used in which the new character is actually made available for use in an electronic game, played, a play log is accumulated, and the character is evaluated by supervised learning using the play log. Also, a method is used in which an artificial intelligence agent that plays an electronic game using a character is trained using reinforcement learning (Patent Document 1). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2019-197592 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] However, in conventional techniques, it is not possible to evaluate a new character without actually introducing it into a game. In addition, when using reinforcement learning, it is difficult to improve the accuracy of learning, and there is a risk that learning will take a huge amount of time. Therefore, there is a need for a technique that can effectively evaluate the characteristics of a new character before introducing the character. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] One aspect of the present invention is an electronic game evaluation device for evaluating competitive electronic games, comprising: an expression vector search means for clustering feature vectors indicating an object to be evaluated, determining a representative vector from the set of clustered feature vectors, selecting one of the representative vectors as an alternative vector based on an expected reward distribution indicating the probability of an expected reward to be obtained in the electronic game for the object corresponding to the representative vector, and setting the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation means for using an existing strategy learner to perform a match evaluation between a state in the electronic game including the new object and a state in the electronic game not including the new object; and an expected reward distribution update means for updating the expected reward distribution for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector in accordance with the result of the match evaluation by the match evaluation means, and the electronic game evaluation device is characterized in that it repeats processing in the expression vector search means, the match evaluation means, and the expected reward distribution update means.
[0007] Another aspect of the present invention is an electronic game evaluation program for evaluating a competitive electronic game, comprising: a computer that functions as an expression vector search means for clustering feature vectors indicating an object to be evaluated, determining a representative vector from the set of clustered feature vectors, selecting one of the representative vectors as an alternative vector based on an expected reward distribution indicating the probability of an expected reward to be obtained in the electronic game for the object corresponding to the representative vector, and setting the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation means that utilizes an existing strategy learner to perform a match evaluation between a state in the electronic game including the new object and a state in the electronic game not including the new object; and an expected reward distribution update means that updates the expected reward distribution for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector in accordance with the result of the match evaluation by the match evaluation means, and the electronic game evaluation program is characterized in that it repeats processing in the expression vector search means, the match evaluation means, and the expected reward distribution update means.
[0008] Another aspect of the present invention is an electronic game evaluation method for evaluating a competitive electronic game, comprising: an expression vector search step of clustering feature vectors indicating an object to be evaluated, determining a representative vector from the set of clustered feature vectors, selecting one of the representative vectors as an alternative vector based on an expected reward distribution indicating the probability of an expected reward to be obtained in the electronic game for the object corresponding to the representative vector, and setting the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation step of using an existing strategy learner to perform a match evaluation between a state in the electronic game including the new object and a state in the electronic game not including the new object; and an expected reward distribution update step of updating the expected reward distribution for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector in accordance with the result of the match evaluation in the match evaluation step, wherein the electronic game evaluation method is characterized in that it repeats processing in the expression vector search step, the match evaluation step, and the expected reward distribution update step.
[0009] Here, it is preferable to provide evaluation means for presenting to a user a statistical value based on the result of the match evaluation obtained by the match evaluation means.
[0010] It is also preferable that the expected reward is an expected winning rate in an electronic game, and the expected reward distribution update means updates the expected reward distribution for the representative vector in accordance with the outcome of a match in the match evaluation means.
[0011] It is also preferable that the object is a character used in an electronic game, and the battle evaluation means performs a battle evaluation when a deck in the electronic game that combines a new character as the new object with an existing character is pitted against a deck in the electronic game that does not include the new character and combines existing characters. Effect of the Invention
[0012] An object of the embodiments of the present invention is to realize an electronic game evaluation device, an electronic game evaluation program, and an electronic game evaluation method that can effectively evaluate the characteristics of a new character before the character is added. Other objects of the embodiments of the present invention will become apparent by referring to this specification as a whole. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0013] [Figure 1] 1 is a diagram showing a configuration of an electronic game evaluation device in an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an expression learning unit and a strategy learning device (battle AI) in the embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 3] 1 is a flowchart showing an electronic game evaluation method according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 4] 5A to 5C are diagrams illustrating examples of expression vectors of each character according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of an expected reward distribution of a representative vector in an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 6] 11A to 11C are diagrams illustrating a selection process of an alternative vector according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 7] 11A to 11C are diagrams illustrating a deck search process according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 8] 13A to 13C are diagrams illustrating the process of constructing a deck including a new character in an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is a diagram illustrating the update process of the expected reward distribution in the embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 10] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of an evaluation of an electronic game according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of an evaluation of an electronic game according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 12] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of an evaluation of an electronic game according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 13] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of an evaluation of an electronic game according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0014] [Device configuration] As shown in FIG. 1, the electronic game evaluation device 100 in the embodiment of the present invention includes a processing unit 10, a storage unit 12, an input unit 14, an output unit 16, and a communication unit 18. The processing unit 10 includes a means for performing arithmetic processing such as a CPU. The processing unit 10 executes an electronic game evaluation program stored in the storage unit 12 to realize the evaluation process in the electronic game in the embodiment. The storage unit 12 includes a storage means such as a semiconductor memory or a memory card. The storage unit 12 is connected to the processing unit 10 so as to be accessible, and stores the electronic game evaluation program and information required for the processing. The input unit 14 includes a means for inputting information. The input unit 14 includes, for example, a keyboard, a touch panel, a button, etc. for receiving input from an administrator. The output unit 16 includes a means for outputting the processing result in the electronic game evaluation device 100, such as a user interface screen (UI) for receiving input information from the administrator. The output unit 16 includes, for example, a display for presenting an image to the administrator. The communication unit 18 includes an interface for communicating information with an external user terminal, etc., via the network 102. The communication by the communication unit 18 may be wired or wireless.
[0015] [Electronic game evaluation processing] In this embodiment, an electronic game evaluation process that enables appropriate evaluation of the possible impact on a competitive electronic game when a new character is introduced into the electronic game will be described. Specifically, an electronic game evaluation program that executes the following process is executed in the electronic game evaluation device 100, and a process is performed to present the impact of the new character on the electronic game to the game planner, etc., using the multi-armed bandit method.
[0016] In addition, as an example of an electronic game, a game in which each player constructs a deck consisting of a group of multiple characters, and the multiple players have the characters that make up their decks battle each other to determine the winner will be described. However, the scope of application of the electronic game evaluation method in this embodiment is not limited to this.
[0017] The electronic game evaluation device 100 uses an artificial intelligence agent for playing an electronic game using multiple characters. For example, the artificial intelligence agent may be an information processing device described in JP 2019-197592 A. Specifically, as shown in FIG. 2, expression learning is performed based on a play log (battle log), which is data showing the progress history of a game played in an electronic game in the past. This makes it possible to obtain an expression learning unit that outputs a feature vector (hereinafter referred to as an expression vector) showing the features of each character by inputting the game parameters of each character used in the electronic game. In addition, learning of an electronic game strategy regarding the use of each character (or the use of a deck including each character) is performed while using the feature vector of each character learned by the expression learning unit. This makes it possible to obtain a strategy learning unit (battle AI) that outputs a preferred strategy, win / loss rate, etc. in an electronic game when each character is used (or a deck including each character is used). In the electronic game evaluation device 100 of this embodiment, such expression learning unit and strategy learning unit are used to generate and output information for evaluating the impact of introducing a new character into an electronic game.
[0018] The electronic game rating method executed by the electronic game rating device 100 will be described below with reference to the flowchart of FIG.
[0019] In step S10, a process of searching for an expression vector of a new character is carried out. Through the process in this step, the electronic game assessment device 100 functions as an expression vector searching means.
[0020] The processing unit 10 clusters the expression vectors for existing characters obtained by expression learning for past play logs (battle logs). For example, k-means processing can be applied to the clustering processing of the expression vectors. However, this is not limited to this, and other clustering processing methods may be applied.
[0021] Fig. 4 shows an example of expressing multiple existing characters in an electronic game with their respective expression vectors using an existing expression learning unit. Fig. 4 shows an example of expressing the expression vectors of each character with two-dimensional expression vectors (dots in the figure). However, the dimension of the vector representing the expression vector is not limited to this.
[0022] After clustering the expression vectors, a representative vector is determined from each cluster. The representative vector is preferably, for example, the centroid (center of gravity vector) of each cluster. Note that the representative vector can also be selected by randomly selecting a character from each cluster, or by using a bandit algorithm or the like from characters within a cluster.
[0023] Figure 4 also shows the results of clustering the expression vectors of multiple existing characters in an electronic game. In Figure 4, each cluster is shown surrounded by an ellipse. The centroid (center of gravity vector) of each cluster is also shown with a star-shaped mark. Therefore, the representative vector of each cluster is represented as the expression vector shown with a star-shaped mark.
[0024] Next, an expected reward distribution is generated for each representative vector. The expected reward distribution is a distribution indicating the probability of occurrence in an electronic game for an expected reward for an electronic game for each representative vector of each cluster. For example, if the expected reward is an expected win rate, the distribution indicates the probability of having the expected win rate when a character having a representative vector of each cluster is used in an electronic game. The expected reward is not particularly limited as long as it is a value related to an electronic game, but can be an expected maximum offensive power, an expected maximum defensive power, an expected occurrence rate of some game skill, etc. in addition to the expected win rate.
[0025] In the following, an example will be described in which the expected element value is the expected winning percentage in this embodiment, as shown in Fig. 5. In Fig. 5, the probability of obtaining the expected winning percentage for the representative vector in each cluster is shown by a mountain-shaped probability distribution.
[0026] The probability distribution may be set appropriately, but it is preferable to apply the beta distribution (β distribution) shown in formula (1). In the beta distribution, the initial values of the parameters α and β are 1. The expected reward distribution is changed by the update process described later. However, the specific expected reward distribution and update process are not limited to this, and a frequency count or frequency distribution based on a binomial distribution or trial results may be applied.
number
[0027] Next, the expected reward for each representative vector is calculated from the expected reward distribution for each cluster, and the representative vector with the highest expected reward is selected as the replacement vector for the newly introduced character. The selection may be performed probabilistically based on the Boltzmann distribution or beta distribution with reference to the expected reward. In other cases, the selection may be performed deterministically using an evaluation function such as UCB1 or its derivatives. Figure 6 shows an example of calculating the expected reward for the representative vector in each cluster of the expression vectors shown in Figure 4. In this case, representative vector 1 with the highest expected reward is selected as the replacement vector for the new character.
[0028] In addition, the expected reward and the selection condition may be determined depending on what kind of expected reward a new character is evaluated as in the expected reward that is the subject of evaluation of the electronic game. In the case of this embodiment, the winning rate is a representative evaluation subject, and the purpose is to evaluate the change in the electronic game when a new character that increases the winning rate is introduced, so the expected reward is set as the winning rate, and the representative vector with the maximum expected reward is selected as the alternative vector for the new character. For example, when the damage inflicted on an enemy character is a representative evaluation subject, and the purpose is to evaluate the change in the electronic game when a new character that increases the damage is introduced, the representative vector with the maximum damage may be selected as the alternative vector based on the expected reward distribution that indicates the probability of inflicting the damage as the expected reward.
[0029] In step S12, a search process for a deck including a new character is performed. Through the process in this step, the electronic game assessment device 100 functions as a deck search means.
[0030] In this step, first, a process is performed to prepare a deck into which the new character represented by the alternative vector selected in step S10 is to be incorporated. The prepared deck is a deck composed of a combination of multiple existing characters. In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 7, multiple decks that are candidates for incorporating the new character are prepared.
[0031] For example, multiple decks are prepared by combining existing characters according to the intentions of the planner of the electronic game. Also, multiple decks are prepared including existing characters that are thought to be similar to the new characters according to the planner's intentions for using new characters in the electronic game (such as a strategy using a new character in an electronic game). Also, multiple decks may be selected from decks that have been used in the past from a play log of the electronic game. In this case, for example, decks with a high win rate or decks that are likely to be used for a specific strategy may be extracted from the characteristics in the play log.
[0032] Next, as shown in FIG. 7, an expected reward distribution is generated for each existing character constituting each prepared deck. Then, one of the prepared decks is randomly selected. Then, as shown in FIG. 8, an expected reward for each character is calculated from the expected reward distribution generated for each existing character constituting the selected deck, and a deck including a new character is generated by replacing the character with the highest expected reward with the new character selected in step S10. In the example of FIG. 8, the expected reward of character 1 is 0.9, which is the highest value among characters 1 to k included in the randomly selected deck 1, so a new deck is constructed by replacing character 1 with the new character in deck 1.
[0033] In addition, in the case of an electronic game in which a deck combining multiple characters is not used, but rather individual characters are played against each other, this step may be omitted.
[0034] In step S14, a battle evaluation process is performed between the deck including the new character and another deck. Through the process in this step, the electronic game evaluation device 100 functions as a battle evaluation means.
[0035] The processing unit 10 selects one deck that does not include a new character from the decks prepared in step S12. The deck may be selected randomly from the decks prepared in step S12. Then, using a strategy learning unit (battle AI) that has been machine-learned using past play logs, the deck selected here is matched against the deck that includes the new character generated in step S12, and the match result is obtained.
[0036] The results of a match include any information that can be obtained when an electronic game match is actually played, such as the outcome of the match between the decks, the outcome of the match between the characters, the parameter values of each character at the end of the match (e.g., parameter values such as hit points, attack power, defense power, etc.), the damage each character inflicted on the opposing character, and the damage each character has been dealt, etc.
[0037] In the case of an electronic game in which a deck is not constructed and characters battle each other, the new character selected in step S10 is made to battle against an existing character, and the battle results are obtained.
[0038] In step S16, an expected reward distribution update process is performed. Through the process in this step, the electronic game assessment device 100 functions as an expected reward distribution update means.
[0039] The processing unit 10 uses the battle result in step S14 to update the expected reward distribution for the characters constituting the deck including the new character. Specifically, the expected reward distribution for the representative vector of the cluster corresponding to the alternative vector selected as the new character in step S10 is updated. For example, when the representative vector 1 with the maximum expected reward is selected as the alternative vector for the new character in step S10, a process of updating the expected reward distribution for the representative vector 1 is performed.
[0040] Also, for other characters that compose the deck including the new character, the expected reward distribution for the expression vector for that character may be updated in consideration of the possibility of generating a synergistic effect with the new character. Also, using the battle result in step S14, the expected reward distribution for the characters in the original deck that were replaced with the deck including the new character prepared in step S12 may be updated.
[0041] At this time, if the result of the match in step S14 is a win, the expected reward distribution is updated so as to have a probability distribution in which the expected reward increases, and if the result of the match in step S14 is a loss, the expected reward distribution is updated so as to have a probability distribution in which the expected reward decreases.
[0042] When the expected reward distribution is expressed by a beta distribution, the expected reward distribution is updated by changing parameters α and β of the beta distribution according to the match result in step S14. When the match result in step S14 is a win, a process is performed to increase the parameter α by a predetermined adjustment value. The predetermined adjustment value may be, for example, 1. When the match result in step S14 is a loss, a process is performed to decrease the parameter β by a predetermined adjustment value. The predetermined adjustment value may be, for example, +1. This makes it possible to update the expected reward distribution so that the expected reward in the expected reward distribution increases when the match result is a win, and the expected reward in the expected reward distribution decreases when the match result is a loss.
[0043] In the case of an electronic game in which a deck is not constructed and characters battle each other, it is only necessary to update the expected reward distribution of the representative vector corresponding to the alternative vector of the new character.
[0044] In step S18, an end determination process is carried out. By the process in this step, the electronic game assessment device 100 functions as an end determination means.
[0045] The processing unit 10 judges whether or not the condition for terminating the repetition of the processing of the above steps S10 to S16 is satisfied, and if the termination condition is satisfied, the processing proceeds to step S20, and if the termination condition is not satisfied, the processing returns to step S10. When the processing returns to step S10, the expected reward for each representative vector is calculated from the expected reward distribution for each cluster based on the expected reward distribution updated in step S16, and the representative vector having the highest expected reward is newly selected as an alternative vector for the new character. Then, the processing of steps S12 to S16 is performed again for the newly selected new character.
[0046] In this way, by repeating the processes of steps S10 to S16 multiple times, the expected reward distribution of the representative vector corresponding to the alternative vector of the new character is updated based on the result of the battle evaluation in step S14 for the deck including the new character that is reselected each time. That is, as shown in FIG. 9, the parameters of the expected reward distribution change and the expected reward distribution is updated. As the battle evaluation is repeated, the variance of the expected reward distribution becomes smaller, and when the expected winning rate increases, the position of the peak of the expected reward distribution moves toward the higher expected reward, and when the expected winning rate decreases, the position of the peak of the expected reward distribution moves toward the lower expected reward. And, the more the position of the peak of the expected reward distribution moves toward the higher expected reward, the more likely it is to be selected as an alternative vector in step S10, and the number of battle evaluations increases. Note that when the outcome of the battle is 50-50, the expected reward distribution has a peak in the middle part (around 0.5 in the example of FIG. 9), and shows a distribution that is greatly expanded with respect to the value of the expected reward. Therefore, when an expected reward distribution with a high expected reward peak position begins to exist, the representative vector having such an expected reward distribution is less likely to be selected as an alternative vector in step S10.
[0047] The termination condition in this step may be an upper limit set on the time or number of times the processes in steps S10 to S16 are repeated, and the process may terminate when the upper limit is exceeded. However, the termination condition is not limited to this.
[0048] In step S20, a process related to the evaluation of a new character is performed. Through the process in this step, the electronic game evaluation device 100 functions as an evaluation means. Here, the process related to the evaluation is performed using the statistical index obtained by applying the multi-bowl bandit realized in the above steps S10 to S18. For example, the process may present the obtained statistical index (statistical value) to a user such as a planner, or display a warning when the obtained statistical index exceeds a predetermined reference value.
[0049] For example, as shown in FIG. 10, when a deck is constructed by replacing each character constituting each pre-prepared deck with a new character, the evaluation value of the deck with the highest win rate in the electronic game can be presented to the user.
[0050] Also, for example, as shown in Fig. 11, when a deck is constructed by replacing each character constituting each deck prepared in advance with a new character, the deck with the highest win rate in an electronic game is plotted on the vertical axis, and the deck that does not include the new character and is composed only of existing characters is plotted on the horizontal axis, and information showing the win rate for each combination can be presented to the user. In Fig. 11, the combinations with a high win rate for decks including new characters compared to decks containing only existing characters are shown with low brightness, and the combinations with a low win rate are shown with high brightness.
[0051] This information makes it possible to extract decks that include new characters that have a uniformly high win rate compared to decks that do not include the new character. Since such decks may upset the balance of the electronic game, it is possible to make a judgment such as not introducing new characters that would allow the construction of such decks.
[0052] It is also possible to extract a new method of using characters that increases the winning rate, as shown in Fig. 12. For example, it is possible to know information such as how the winning rate changes depending on the order in which characters are used in a deck that is replaced with new characters, compared to the winning rate when characters are used in a specified order in a deck that is composed only of existing characters.
[0053] It is also possible to identify in advance which decks will have a higher average win rate if they include new characters, as shown in FIG.
[0054] In the above evaluation, the winning rate for each combination of decks is shown, but this is not particularly limited to any information that can be used to evaluate an electronic game and that can be obtained in the battle evaluation in step S14, such as the difference in remaining hit points after the match, the difference in maximum attack power, etc.
[0055] In addition, in the case of electronic games in which characters battle each other without constructing a deck, the difference in winning rate in the electronic game between the new character and other existing characters can be the subject of evaluation.
[0056] In this embodiment, the character used in the electronic game is the subject of evaluation, but other objects used in the electronic game can also be the subject of evaluation. For example, the skills of the character in the electronic game (parameters that give attack power, defense power, and other game effects), items in the electronic game, and other objects used in the electronic game can be the subject of evaluation. In this case, the object to be evaluated can be applied instead of the character in the above description and processed.
[0057] In addition, in the electronic game evaluation device 100 in this embodiment, the expression vector search means, deck search means, battle evaluation means, expected reward distribution update means, end determination means, and evaluation means are realized in one computer system. However, these means may be realized in a distributed manner in different devices or different execution entities. For example, some of these means may be realized by sharing the functions of multiple computers that can communicate with each other. [Explanation of symbols]
[0058] 10 processing unit, 12 memory unit, 14 input unit, 16 output unit, 18 communication unit, 100 electronic game evaluation device, 102 network.
Claims
1. An electronic game evaluation device for evaluating a competitive electronic game using an object, comprising: an expression vector search means for determining a representative vector from a set of clustered feature vectors representing a plurality of existing objects, which is different from the existing objects, selecting the representative vector having the highest expected reward as an alternative vector based on an expected reward distribution indicating the probability of an expected reward of a predetermined type to be obtained in an electronic game when an object corresponding to the representative vector is used in the electronic game, and designating the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation means for evaluating an electronic game between a deck including the new object and a deck not including the new object, using an existing strategy learner; an expected reward distribution update means for updating an expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector in accordance with the predetermined type of reward obtained as a result of the battle; Equipped with Setting an initial value of the expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector, and selecting one of the representative vectors as the alternative vector; In the match evaluation means, an object corresponding to the selected alternative vector is set as the new object, and an electronic game match is performed between a deck including the new object and a deck not including the new object; the expected reward distribution update means updates an expected reward distribution for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector according to the predetermined type of reward obtained as a result of the battle; the representative vector search means selects, as a new alternative vector, the representative vector having the highest expected reward based on an expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the updated representative vector; The electronic game evaluation device is characterized in that by repeating the above process, a change in the balance of the electronic game when the new object is added is evaluated.
2. 2. The electronic game evaluation device according to claim 1, an evaluation means for presenting to a user a statistical value based on the result of the match evaluation obtained by said match evaluation means;
3. 3. The electronic game evaluation device according to claim 1, the predetermined type of reward is a winning rate in an electronic game, and the expected reward is an expected winning rate in the electronic game; The electronic game evaluation device, wherein the expected reward distribution update means updates the expected reward distribution for the representative vector in accordance with the outcome of the match in the match evaluation means.
4. The electronic game evaluation device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, the object is a character used in an electronic game, The electronic game evaluation device is characterized in that the battle evaluation means performs a battle evaluation when a deck in an electronic game that combines a new character and an existing character as the new object is pitted against a deck in an electronic game that does not include the new character and combines existing characters.
5. An electronic game evaluation program for evaluating a competitive electronic game using objects, comprising: Computer, an expression vector search means for determining a representative vector from a set of clustered feature vectors representing a plurality of existing objects, which is different from the existing objects, selecting the representative vector having the highest expected reward as an alternative vector based on an expected reward distribution indicating the probability of an expected reward of a predetermined type to be obtained in an electronic game when an object corresponding to the representative vector is used in the electronic game, and designating the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation means for evaluating an electronic game between a deck including the new object and a deck not including the new object, using an existing strategy learner; an expected reward distribution update means for updating an expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector in accordance with the predetermined type of reward obtained as a result of the battle; Functioning as a Setting an initial value of the expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector, and selecting one of the representative vectors as the alternative vector; In the match evaluation means, an object corresponding to the selected alternative vector is set as the new object, and an electronic game match is performed between a deck including the new object and a deck not including the new object; the expected reward distribution update means updates an expected reward distribution for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector according to the predetermined type of reward obtained as a result of the battle; the representative vector search means selects, as a new alternative vector, the representative vector having the highest expected reward based on an expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the updated representative vector; The electronic game evaluation program is characterized in that the above process is repeated to evaluate a change in balance of the electronic game when the new object is added.
6. 1. A method for evaluating a competitive electronic game using an object, comprising: determining a representative vector from a set of clustered feature vectors representing a plurality of existing objects, the representative vector being a vector different from the existing objects; setting an initial value of the expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector; selecting one of the representative vectors as the alternative vector; and setting the object corresponding to the alternative vector as a new object; a match evaluation step of playing an electronic game between a deck including the new object and a deck not including the new object by using an existing strategy learner; an expected reward distribution update step of updating an expected reward distribution regarding the predetermined type of reward for the representative vector selected as the alternative vector according to the predetermined type of reward obtained as a result of the battle; a representation vector search step of selecting the representative vector having the highest expected reward based on the expected reward distribution for the predetermined type of reward for the updated representative vector as the new replacement vector; and evaluating a change in balance of the electronic game when the new object is added by repeating the above steps.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Information processor and information processing program
JP2019197592A
