Modeling method for streamer discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization in bubbles
By constructing a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model and plasma chemical reaction, the ionization process of gas molecules inside the bubble was simulated, which solved the lack of research on the influence of bubbles on stream propagation, revealed the influence of bubble size on stream development, provided the basis for the theory of liquid dielectric breakdown, and promoted the development of new insulating materials.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202511977495.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-12-25
- Publication Date
- 2026-05-05
AI Technical Summary
Existing research lacks numerical studies on the propagation of streams due to the ionization of gas molecules inside bubbles, and the presence of bubbles in natural ester insulating oil increases the probability of breakdown in practical engineering scenarios, but the mechanism of this effect is not yet fully understood.
A two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model was constructed, and plasma chemical reactions were introduced to simulate the ionization process of gas molecules inside the bubble. Combined with the drift-diffusion-reaction process of plasma inside the bubble, a hydrodynamic model of streamer discharge was established to quantify the enhancing effect of the bubble on streamer development.
By simulating the evolution of stream morphology in natural ester insulating oil, the influence of bubble size on stream propagation was revealed, providing a basis for understanding the breakdown theory of liquid dielectrics and laying the foundation for the development of new liquid insulating materials.
Smart Images

Figure CN121983193A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of electrical breakdown, specifically a method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil that considers ionization within bubbles. Background Technology
[0002] In recent years, the electrical breakdown characteristics of insulating fluids have become a research hotspot, with applications spanning insulating oil synthesis, power equipment reliability assessment, and environmental remediation. However, despite extensive research, the electrical breakdown nature of dielectric fluids (especially natural esters) remains controversial. Generally, the flow development in a liquid is extremely sensitive to the waveform and polarity of the applied voltage, electrode geometry, and gap distance. However, most of the aforementioned studies are based on pure dielectrics, and such ideal conditions are difficult to achieve in practical engineering scenarios.
[0003] Natural ester insulating oil, as a dielectric fluid, possesses excellent environmental performance and its insulating properties are comparable to mineral oil, thus it is widely used in high-voltage power equipment. Numerous studies have shown that under thermal stress or localized electric fields, impurities such as bubbles, fibers, and metal particles may be generated inside transformers. These impurities increase the probability of insulating oil breakdown. The formation of bubbles in transformer oil has various causes, including enthalpy changes during discharge, mechanical vibration, insufficient vacuum lubrication, and aging of seals. Under atmospheric pressure, the dielectric constant of natural ester is approximately three times that of bubbles, which leads to distortion of the electric field inside the bubbles, resulting in a significantly higher breakdown field strength for the pure liquid compared to the bubble-containing liquid.
[0004] The presence of bubbles in dielectric fluids increases the probability of breakdown, and thus this phenomenon has attracted considerable attention. These studies involve various parameters, such as the gas composition within the bubble, the dielectric constant or conductivity of the liquid and gas, the bubble geometry, electrode arrangement, and power supply type. However, numerical studies on how the ionization of gas molecules inside the bubble affects stream propagation remain relatively scarce. Summary of the Invention
[0005] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil that considers the ionization within bubbles, comprising the following steps:
[0006] Step 1) Construct a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model for simulating the jet discharge of bubbles in natural ester insulating oil under lightning impulse voltage;
[0007] Step 2) Introduce plasma chemical reaction to construct a hydrodynamic model of natural ester insulating oil jet discharge current coupled with the ionization process of gas molecules inside the bubble;
[0008] Furthermore, after applying a set voltage to the two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model, the hydrodynamic model of the natural ester insulating oil streamer discharge current simulates the evolution process of the natural ester insulating oil streamer morphology.
[0009] Furthermore, when simulating the evolution of the flow morphology of natural ester insulating oil, bubbles located within the natural ester insulating oil are generated in a random simulation manner.
[0010] Furthermore, the two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model includes a liquid phase region, a gas phase region, and a simulated electrode.
[0011] Furthermore, the liquid phase region simulates the region of natural ester insulating oil.
[0012] Furthermore, the gas phase region is the region that simulates plasma.
[0013] Furthermore, the discharge electrode extends from the gas phase region into the liquid phase region.
[0014] Furthermore, the hydrodynamic model of the discharge current of the natural ester insulating oil is shown below:
[0015] (1)
[0016] (2)
[0017] (3)
[0018] (4)
[0019] (5)
[0020] In the formula, , These are charge carriers generated by field ionization and collisional ionization; Electric field strength; , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , The values are: relative permittivity of insulating oil, vacuum permittivity, positive ion charge density, negative ion charge density, electron charge density, positive ion mobility, charged particle generation source term, H function, recombination rate of positive and negative ions, recombination rate of positive ions and electrons, electron charge, electron adsorption time, temperature, thermal conduction time, insulating oil density, specific heat capacity, current density, and flow rate.
[0021] Furthermore, the charge carriers generated by field ionization are shown below:
[0022] (6)
[0023] Furthermore, the charge carriers generated by collisional ionization are shown below:
[0024] (7)
[0025] In the formula, , , , , , , , For molecular number density, intermolecular distance, effective electron mass, ionization energy, Planck constant, pre-exponential coefficient, electron mobility, and exponential coefficient.
[0026] The technical effects of this invention are undeniable. This invention investigates the influence of bubble size on streamer propagation in natural ester insulating oil. The study employs a plasma fluid model, self-consistently solving the drift-diffusion-reaction process of plasma within bubbles with the Poisson equation. It integrates the plasma generation process within bubbles under a strong electric field into existing streamer discharge models and quantifies the enhancing effect of bubble presence on streamer development in oil. This contributes to understanding the breakdown theory of liquid dielectrics and provides a basis for developing new liquid insulating materials. Attached Figure Description
[0027] Figure 1 The diagram shows the geometry of the needle-plate electrode, (a) the overall computational domain and (b) the enlarged mesh of the plasma region (bubble) and the transformer oil region.
[0028] Figure 2 The flow morphology of natural ester insulating oil at 80kV voltage is shown in (a) pure oil and (b) with bubbles.
[0029] Figure 3 The electric field variation inside a 25μm bubble under 80kV voltage;
[0030] Figure 4 The effect of air bubbles on needle tip flow;
[0031] Figure 5 The development process of a 25μm bubble stream;
[0032] Figure 6 The development process of a 50μm bubble stream;
[0033] Figure 7 Stream morphology diagrams of bubbles of different sizes at 80kV;
[0034] Figure 8 The effect of bubble displacement on the initiation of the stream;
[0035] Figure 9 This is a diagram of the bubble displacement stream morphology at 80kV. Detailed Implementation
[0036] The present invention will be further described below with reference to embodiments, but it should not be construed that the scope of the present invention is limited to the following embodiments. Various substitutions and modifications made based on ordinary technical knowledge and common practices in the art without departing from the above-described technical concept of the present invention should be included within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0037] Example 1:
[0038] See Figures 1 to 9 A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, comprising the following steps:
[0039] Step 1) Construct a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model for simulating the jet discharge of bubbles in natural ester insulating oil under lightning impulse voltage;
[0040] Step 2) Introduce plasma chemical reaction to construct a hydrodynamic model of natural ester insulating oil jet discharge current coupled with the ionization process of gas molecules inside the bubble;
[0041] After applying a set voltage to the two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model, the hydrodynamic model of the natural ester insulating oil stream discharge current simulates the evolution process of the natural ester insulating oil stream morphology.
[0042] Example 2:
[0043] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering the ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as in Example 1, further comprising a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model including a liquid phase region, a gas phase region, and a simulation electrode.
[0044] Example 3:
[0045] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering the ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-2, further wherein the liquid phase region is a region simulating natural ester insulating oil.
[0046] Example 4:
[0047] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-3, further wherein the gas phase region is the region simulating plasma.
[0048] Example 5:
[0049] A method for modeling the flow discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering the ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-4, further wherein the discharge electrode extends from the gas phase region into the liquid phase region.
[0050] Example 6:
[0051] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-5, further wherein the jet discharge current dynamics model of natural ester insulating oil is shown below:
[0052] (1)
[0053] (2)
[0054] (3)
[0055] (4)
[0056] (5)
[0057] In the formula, , These are charge carriers generated by field ionization and collisional ionization; Electric field strength; , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , The values are: relative permittivity of insulating oil, vacuum permittivity, positive ion charge density, negative ion charge density, electron charge density, positive ion mobility, charged particle generation source term, H function, recombination rate of positive and negative ions, recombination rate of positive ions and electrons, electron charge, electron adsorption time, temperature, thermal conduction time, insulating oil density, specific heat capacity, current density, and flow rate.
[0058] Example 7:
[0059] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-6, further showing that the charge carriers generated by field ionization are as follows:
[0060] (6)
[0061] Example 8:
[0062] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-7, further showing that the charge carriers generated by collisional ionization are as follows:
[0063] (7)
[0064] In the formula, , , , , , , , For molecular number density, intermolecular distance, effective electron mass, ionization energy, Planck constant, pre-exponential coefficient, electron mobility, and exponential coefficient.
[0065] Example 9:
[0066] A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles is disclosed. The technical content is the same as any one of Examples 1-8. The natural ester insulating oil jet discharge hydrodynamic model is used to simulate the evolution of the jet morphology. Specifically, it is a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model with a set voltage applied and bubble sizes randomly set. When the jet develops from the pointed electrode to the flat electrode, the channels connect, and breakdown occurs. The presence of bubbles increases the development of the jet channels and reduces the breakdown voltage. The natural ester insulating oil jet discharge hydrodynamic model describes the migration and diffusion process of particles within the bubbles under a strong field through plasma chemical reactions.
[0067] Example 10:
[0068] A method for modeling the flow discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering the ionization within bubbles, with the same technical content as any one of Examples 1-9, further comprising generating bubbles within the natural ester insulating oil in a random simulation manner when simulating the evolution of the flow morphology of the natural ester insulating oil.
[0069] Example 11:
[0070] A modeling method for the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil that considers ionization within bubbles is described below:
[0071] 1. Model Description
[0072] The discharge mechanisms of liquid dielectrics include field ionization, collisional ionization, photoionization, and electron emission. This paper studies the streamer propagation in bubble-containing natural ester insulating oil. Although gas ionization is involved, the main component of the bubbles is nitrogen. According to the research of Marskar et al., the excited state radiation wavelength of nitrogen is usually lower than its own ionization threshold (about 15.6 eV), so the generated photons cannot directly ionize nitrogen molecules. Based on this, this paper mainly considers the effects of field ionization and collisional ionization. The expressions for the generation of charge carriers by field ionization and collisional ionization are shown in Equations (1) and (2), respectively:
[0073] (1)
[0074] (2)
[0075] This paper introduces plasma chemical reactions to describe the migration and diffusion processes of particles within bubbles under strong fields, enabling a more accurate reflection of the bubble's influence on streamer discharge. Furthermore, the plasma transport equations are solved only within the bubble region, allowing charge accumulation at the boundary between the bubble and the insulating liquid. Compared to previous studies, this method considers the difference in dielectric constants between the gas and liquid phases, as well as the ionization process of gas molecules within the bubble, thus better explaining the evolution from partial discharge to streamer discharge within the bubble.
[0076] 1.1 Geometric Model Description
[0077] This paper establishes a two-dimensional axisymmetric model to study the influence of bubbles on the electric field, streamer branching, and propagation in transformer oil under lightning impulse voltage. A schematic diagram of the model is shown in Figure 1. The computational domain includes two phases: a liquid phase represented by natural ester insulating oil and a gas phase represented by air (plasma region). Furthermore, this paper studies the streamer evolution process on a nanosecond timescale, within which bubbles can be considered as static structures. The radius of curvature of the needle electrode is 50 μm, and the needle-plate electrode spacing is 15 mm.
[0078] In addition, the lightning voltage waveform function applied in the simulation is set as follows:
[0079] (3)
[0080] In the formula, K is the voltage correction coefficient. ; To apply voltage; , Here are the time parameters for the wavefront and wavetail, and t is the application time.
[0081] From a microscopic perspective, the characteristic of streamer discharge is the generation, migration, and dissipation of charged particles within a dielectric under the influence of an applied electric field. This paper establishes a streamer discharge model for natural ester insulating oil containing bubbles based on an electrohydraulic dynamics model. The governing equations include the Poisson equation (4), the continuity equations (5)-(7), and the heat conduction equation (8). The Poisson equation and the continuity equation are solved throughout the entire computational domain, while the heat conduction equation is solved only within the bubble region (plasma region). Algorithmically, the two regions use the same discretization method, but the oil region and the bubble region are distinguished by setting different dielectric constants and reaction mechanisms. To gain a deeper understanding of the streamer branching characteristics, this numerical model not only considers field ionization and collision ionization effects, but also introduces a carrier density source term based on the research of Zuo et al.
[0082] (4)
[0083] (5)
[0084] (6)
[0085] (7)
[0086] (8)
[0087] 1.2 Plasma Chemistry Module Setup
[0088] Under a strong electric field, electrons collide with neutral particles at high speed, exciting and activating gas molecules to form a discharge plasma region. Therefore, a plasma chemistry module is introduced to study the process of charge generation, migration, and diffusion inside bubbles. Air is mainly composed of nitrogen (78%), oxygen (21%), and trace gases such as rare gases and carbon dioxide (1%). The presence of these components makes the chemical behavior of air in the plasma state extremely complex. From a microscopic perspective, a strong electric field accelerates electrons, causing them to collide with neutral gas molecules, thereby triggering molecular ionization, dissociation, and excitation. Ultimately, the gas composition changes from being dominated by ground-state nitrogen and oxygen molecules to a complex mixture containing molecules, atoms, ions, and electrons. The main purpose of this simulation is to study the density distribution and current characteristics of charged particles. To improve computational efficiency, this paper focuses on the dominant role of nitrogen and uses a simplified reaction set to simulate the interaction of charged particles inside bubbles in oil under a strong electric field. The specific reactions are shown in Table 1.
[0089] Table 1 Nitrogen reaction process
[0090]
[0091] 2. Results and Analysis
[0092] Figure 2 The flow morphology of pure oil and insulating oil containing bubbles was compared. At 20 ns, the flow streams in pure oil exhibited a typical filamentous branching structure, while in insulating oil containing bubbles, the number of branches at the needle tip was significantly greater, and the flow stream length was also longer. Overall, bubbles significantly enhanced the flow stream branching phenomenon and promoted flow stream development.
[0093] The difference in dielectric constant between the bubbles and the insulating oil leads to local electric field distortion. As the local field strength increases to the threshold field strength, the plasma chemical reaction inside the bubble intensifies, ionizing a large number of electrons. The migration speed of electrons is much greater than that of positive ions; therefore, positive ions are stationary relative to electrons during electron diffusion. The discontinuity at the gas-liquid interface causes electrons to concentrate at the upper end of the bubble. During this process, a large number of space charges appear inside the bubble. These space charges, on the one hand, form a local high-field region at the bubble-oil interface, equivalent to artificially creating a "virtual needle tip," thus making it easier for the stream to generate new branches at the bubble interface; on the other hand, the electric field direction they generate is opposite to that in the oil, causing the electric field inside the bubble to be weakened. The entire process is as follows: Figure 3 As shown.
[0094] Furthermore, when air bubbles are present in natural ester insulating oil, the flow stream exhibits a tendency to be "attracted" by the bubbles. This is essentially a result of the difference in dielectric constant between the air bubbles and the insulating oil. Figure 4As shown, the closer the streamer head is to the bubble, the stronger the local electric field. At 11 ns, the streamer head has approached the top of the bubble, and a streamer is also generated at the top of the bubble under the influence of the high electric field. At this time, an electric field gradient pointing towards the center of the bubble is formed inside the bubble, causing the high-density space charge at the streamer head to migrate towards the edge of the bubble and expand along the edge, as shown. Figure 4 As shown in (ce). From an energy perspective, streamers tend to develop along the path with the least electric field distortion, and the edge of the bubble just provides such a channel, causing the streamer to exhibit behavior of being "attracted" by the bubble.
[0095] 2.2 Influence of bubble size on the discharge of natural ester insulating oil
[0096] Figure 5 and Figure 6 The images depict the propagation process of streams from bubbles with radii of 25 μm and 50 μm, located 90 μm downstream of the needle tip. At 7.5 ns, the 25 μm bubble, due to its smaller radius of curvature, exhibits a more pronounced electric field concentration. At 11 ns, the propagation of the oil stream is observed to be "impeded" near the 50 μm bubble. This is because the gas molecules inside the bubble ionize under a strong electric field, generating a large number of high-mobility electrons. These electrons accumulate at the top of the bubble under the influence of the electric field, repelling the electrons at the head of the oil stream. The 25 μm bubble, due to its small size and limited charge accumulation, exhibits a weaker repulsive effect. By 14.5 ns, the gas molecules in both bubbles are fully ionized, significantly weakening the electric field strength near the bubbles. It can be seen that... Figure 7 (c) The number of stream branches at the needle tip is significantly greater than Figure 8 (c) This is because the larger volume of the large bubble makes its effect of weakening the electric field more significant.
[0097] In the later stages of stream propagation, the dynamic distribution of space charge becomes the dominant factor in stream development. At 27 ns, compared to 25 μm microbubbles, 50 μm microbubbles have more high-field-strength points, exacerbating the electric field distortion at the gas-liquid interface and triggering more stream branching within the oil. From 33.5 to 40 ns, due to further diffusion of space charge, the electric field gradient inside the stream channel of 50 μm microbubbles is significantly greater than that of 25 μm microbubbles. Therefore, overall, the branching phenomenon is more pronounced in large bubbles, while the lateral branching of small bubbles is sparse and tends to develop into a single channel.
[0098] When a bubble is located in the stream propagation path, the difference caused by its size effect becomes more obvious. As the bubble size increases, although the development of stream branching at the tip is significantly suppressed, it will promote the stream at the location of the bubble to generate more branches, which will damage the insulation.
[0099] Figure 9This study examines the impact of bubble displacement of different sizes on the propagation of streams in insulating oil. At 10.5 ns, the local electric field generated by the bubble causes the needle tip streams to deflect to the left in various ways. At 12 ns, the larger electric field gradient inside the large bubble causes the head stream to propagate along the bubble surface, while streams are just beginning to form at the top of the small bubble. At 15.5 ns, streams have formed at the bottom of all bubbles, and the branching development of the streams at the needle tip is also affected to varying degrees. Compared to the denser and more leftward-shifted streams at the tip of the large bubble, the streams at the small bubble branch more uniformly. Ultimately, this results in longer streams with more branches in the insulating oil containing large bubbles, posing a greater threat to insulation.
[0100] 3. Conclusion
[0101] This study investigated the impact of bubble size on streamer propagation by considering the collisional ionization process of gas molecules inside bubbles through plasma chemical reactions. The results show that the model can effectively reflect the morphology and propagation process of streamer discharge in bubble-containing natural ester insulating oil, and also clearly demonstrates the effect of bubbles on promoting streamer development. Based on this, the influence of bubble size on streamer propagation was studied. The results indicate that larger bubbles have a greater impact on the streamer propagation path. Near the needle tip, the volume effect of large bubbles inhibits streamer branching at the tip, but significantly enhances streamer branching and propagation distance at the bubble location. Simultaneously, due to the discontinuity of the gas-liquid interface and the difference in gas-liquid dielectric constants, the streamer propagates along the bubble surface until it merges with the nearest adjacent streamer branch. Studying the influence of bubbles on streamers helps to understand the theory of liquid dielectric breakdown and provides a basis for the development of new liquid insulating materials.
Claims
1. A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: Step 1) Construct a two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model for simulating the jet discharge of bubbles in natural ester insulating oil under lightning impulse voltage; Step 2) Introduce plasma chemical reaction to construct a hydrodynamic model of natural ester insulating oil jet discharge current that couples the ionization process of gas molecules inside the bubble.
2. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... After applying a set voltage to the two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model, the hydrodynamic model of the natural ester insulating oil stream discharge current simulates the evolution process of the natural ester insulating oil stream morphology.
3. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 2, is characterized in that... When simulating the evolution of the flow morphology of natural ester insulating oil, bubbles located in the natural ester insulating oil are generated in a random simulation manner.
4. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The two-dimensional non-axisymmetric model includes a liquid phase region, a gas phase region, and a simulated electrode.
5. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The liquid phase region simulates the region of natural ester insulating oil.
6. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The gas phase region is the region that simulates plasma.
7. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The discharge electrode extends from the gas phase region into the liquid phase region.
8. The method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 1, is characterized in that... The hydrodynamic model of the discharge current of natural ester insulating oil is shown below: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) In the formula, , These are charge carriers generated by field ionization and collisional ionization; Electric field strength; , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , The values are: relative permittivity of insulating oil, vacuum permittivity, positive ion charge density, negative ion charge density, electron charge density, positive ion mobility, charged particle generation source term, H function, recombination rate of positive and negative ions, recombination rate of positive ions and electrons, electron charge, electron adsorption time, temperature, thermal conduction time, insulating oil density, specific heat capacity, current density, and flow rate.
9. A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 8, is characterized in that... The charge carriers generated by field ionization are shown below: (6) In the formula, , , , , Let be the molecular number density, intermolecular distance, effective electron mass, ionization energy, and Planck's constant.
10. A method for modeling the jet discharge process in natural ester insulating oil considering ionization within bubbles, as described in claim 8, is characterized in that... The charge carriers generated by collisional ionization are shown below: (7) In the formula, , , For the exponential coefficient, electron mobility is the coefficient of the exponential term.
