Methods for Determining Seismic Amplification Factor and Seismic Assessment of Transformer Body under Soil-Integrated Effects

By obtaining the strain values ​​of ultra-high voltage transformers under different soil types through simulation experiments, and combining the soil-structure interaction, the seismic dynamic amplification factor was determined, which solved the problem of insufficient seismic assessment accuracy in the existing technology and achieved more accurate seismic assessment and functional assurance of transformers.

CN112903223BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-17CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE CO LTD +2
View PDF 1 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202011578729.9
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2020-12-28
Publication Date
2026-11-17
Estimated Expiration
2040-12-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies fail to effectively consider the impact of soil-structure interaction on seismic waves of ultra-high voltage transformers, resulting in insufficient accuracy of seismic assessment results.

Method used

The strain values ​​of ultra-high voltage transformers under different soil types were obtained through simulation experiments. Combined with soil-structure interaction, the seismic dynamic amplification factor was determined, and seismic assessment was carried out based on this, including the assessment of bushing displacement limits and safety factors.

Benefits of technology

It improves the accuracy of earthquake simulation experiments, provides a more accurate method for seismic assessment of UHV transformers, ensures that transformers are not damaged under major earthquakes, and guarantees the normal operation of electrical functions.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112903223B_ABST
    Figure CN112903223B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention provides a method for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction, comprising: conducting a simulation experiment based on a set seismic excitation to obtain the strain values ​​of an ultra-high voltage transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction; and determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the ultra-high voltage transformer body under different site soil types based on the considered strain values ​​and the unconsidered strain values. Considering soil-structure interaction in determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor improves experimental accuracy. A seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction includes: conducting a seismic simulation experiment based on a selected seismic fortification intensity; determining the seismic assessment index value of the ultra-high voltage transformer considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type; and evaluating the seismic performance of the ultra-high voltage transformer based on the seismic assessment index value and a pre-set assessment index threshold. Considering soil-structure interaction addresses the deficiency in current assessment methods that do not consider the dynamic amplification effect of soil.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of seismic resistance of power facilities, specifically to a method for determining the seismic amplification factor of transformer bodies under soil-bonded effects and for seismic assessment. Background Technology

[0002] After seismic waves travel through the soil to the transformer, their spectral characteristics and peak acceleration change due to the nonlinear stiffness and damping properties of the soil. Current seismic performance assessments for UHV transformers do not consider the dynamic interaction between the soil and the transformer, affecting the accuracy of the assessment results. There is an urgent need to develop a seismic performance assessment method for UHV transformers that considers the dynamic interaction between the soil and the structure, thereby improving the level of seismic design and performance assessment for transformers. Summary of the Invention

[0003] To address the aforementioned problems in the prior art, this invention provides a method for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction, comprising:

[0004] Simulation experiments were conducted based on the set seismic excitation to obtain the strain values ​​of ultra-high voltage transformers under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction.

[0005] The seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV subsurface at different sites is determined based on the considered and unconsidered strain values.

[0006] Preferably, determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV main body based on the average value of the strain amplification values ​​includes:

[0007] When the average strain amplification value is less than the set value, it is determined according to the conventional seismic dynamic amplification factor of the body.

[0008] Conversely, the product of the average strain amplification value and the conventional local seismic dynamic amplification factor is calculated as the seismic dynamic amplification factor.

[0009] Based on a unified inventive concept, this invention provides a system for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction, comprising: an acquisition module and a formulation module;

[0010] The acquisition module conducts a simulation experiment based on the set seismic excitation to obtain the strain value of the UHV transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction.

[0011] The formulation module determines the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the underground ultra-high pressure body for different sites based on the considered strain value and the unconsidered strain value.

[0012] Based on the same inventive concept, this invention provides a seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers that considers soil-structure interaction, including:

[0013] Earthquake simulation experiments were conducted based on the selected seismic fortification intensity, and the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type was considered to determine the seismic evaluation index value of the UHV transformer.

[0014] The seismic performance of ultra-high voltage transformers is evaluated based on the seismic evaluation index values ​​and the pre-set evaluation index thresholds.

[0015] The evaluation indicators include: bushing displacement limit and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformer; the seismic dynamic amplification system adopts the coefficient determined in a method for determining seismic dynamic amplification coefficient that considers soil-structure interaction.

[0016] Preferably, the step of conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determining the safety factor of the UHV transformer bushing by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type includes:

[0017] Seismic simulation experiments were conducted based on the seismic acceleration corresponding to the seismic fortification intensity to obtain the combined stress of the casing load.

[0018] The safety factor of UHV transformer bushings is determined based on the ratio of bushing failure stress to bushing load combined stress.

[0019] Preferably, the combined stress of the casing load is calculated using the following formula:

[0020] α=γ G S G +γ W S W +γ E S E +S M

[0021] In the formula: α: is the combined stress of the load; γ G : is the partial factor for gravity load; S G : represents gravity load; γ W : is the wind load partial factor; S W : represents wind load; γ E Seismic load partial factor; S E Seismic load; S M : Seismic action effect value.

[0022] Preferably, the safety factor threshold of the UHV transformer bushing and the displacement limit threshold of the UHV transformer are both determined by the selected (seismic fortification standard).

[0023] Preferably, the evaluation of the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic assessment index value and the pre-set assessment index threshold is determined by the selected seismic fortification target.

[0024] Based on the idea of ​​a seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers that considers soil-structure interaction, this invention provides a seismic assessment system for ultra-high voltage transformers that considers soil-structure interaction, including: an index acquisition module and a performance assessment module;

[0025] The index acquisition module conducts earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determines the seismic evaluation index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type.

[0026] The performance evaluation module evaluates the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic evaluation index value and the pre-set evaluation index threshold.

[0027] The evaluation indicators include: bushing displacement limit and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformer; the seismic dynamic amplification system adopts the coefficient determined in a method for determining seismic dynamic amplification coefficient that considers soil-structure interaction.

[0028] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows:

[0029] (1) A method for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction, comprising: conducting a simulation experiment based on a set seismic excitation to obtain the strain values ​​of an ultra-high voltage transformer under different site soil types considering soil-structure interaction; and determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the ultra-high voltage transformer body under different site soils based on the considered strain values ​​and the unconsidered strain values. The value of the seismic dynamic amplification factor considers soil-structure interaction, which allows the influence of soil-structure interaction to be incorporated into the seismic simulation experiment, thereby improving the accuracy of the experiment.

[0030] (2) A seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage (UHV) transformers considering soil-structure interaction, comprising: conducting seismic simulation experiments based on a selected seismic fortification intensity, and determining the seismic assessment index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type; evaluating the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic assessment index value and a pre-set assessment index threshold. This method proposes a seismic assessment approach for UHV transformers from aspects such as seismic fortification standards, fortification objectives, the selection of the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV transformer body considering soil-structure interaction, and the regulations on bushing safety factors and displacement limits, in order to address the shortcomings of current assessment methods that do not consider the dynamic amplification effect of soil. Attached Figure Description

[0031] Figure 1This is a flowchart of the method for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction according to the present invention.

[0032] Figure 2 This is a flowchart of the ultra-high voltage transformer seismic assessment method of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0033] To better understand this invention, the following description, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and examples, will further illustrate the invention.

[0034] Example 1: A method for determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor considering soil-structure interaction, such as... Figure 1 As shown, it includes:

[0035] S1: Based on the set seismic excitation, a simulation experiment was conducted to obtain the strain values ​​of the UHV transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction.

[0036] S2: Determine the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV subsurface at different sites based on the considered and unconsidered strain values.

[0037] Preferably, determining the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV main body based on the average value of the strain amplification values ​​includes:

[0038] When the average strain amplification value is less than the set value, it is determined according to the conventional seismic dynamic amplification factor of the body.

[0039] Conversely, the product of the average strain amplification value and the conventional local seismic dynamic amplification factor is calculated as the seismic dynamic amplification factor.

[0040] Example 2:

[0041] This invention provides a system for determining seismic dynamic amplification factors that consider soil-structure interactions, based on a method for considering soil-structure interactions. The system includes:

[0042] Get the module and specify the module;

[0043] The acquisition module conducts a simulation experiment based on the set seismic excitation to obtain the strain value of the UHV transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction.

[0044] The formulation module determines the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the underground ultra-high pressure body for different sites based on the considered strain value and the unconsidered strain value.

[0045] Example 3: A seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction, such as... Figure 2 As shown, it includes:

[0046] Step 1: Conduct earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity, and determine the seismic assessment index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type.

[0047] Step 2: Evaluate the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic assessment index values ​​and the pre-set assessment index thresholds;

[0048] The evaluation indicators include: bushing displacement limit and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformer; the seismic dynamic amplification system adopts the coefficient determined in a method for determining seismic dynamic amplification coefficient that considers soil-structure interaction.

[0049] Preferably, the step of conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determining the safety factor of the UHV transformer bushing by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type includes:

[0050] Seismic simulation experiments were conducted based on the seismic acceleration corresponding to the seismic fortification intensity to obtain the combined stress of the casing load.

[0051] The safety factor of UHV transformer bushings is determined based on the ratio of bushing failure stress to bushing load combined stress.

[0052] Preferably, the combined stress of the casing load is calculated using the following formula:

[0053] α=γ G S G +γ W S W +γ E S E +S M

[0054] In the formula: α: is the combined stress of the load; γ G : is the partial factor for gravity load; S G : represents gravity load; γ W : is the wind load partial factor; S W : represents wind load; γ E Seismic load partial factor; S E Seismic load; S M : Seismic action effect value.

[0055] Preferably, the safety factor threshold of the UHV transformer bushing and the displacement limit threshold of the UHV transformer are both determined by the selected (seismic fortification standard).

[0056] Preferably, the evaluation of the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic assessment index value and the pre-set assessment index threshold is determined by the selected seismic fortification target.

[0057] Example 4:

[0058] Based on the inventive concept of a seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction, this invention also provides a seismic assessment system for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction, comprising:

[0059] Metrics acquisition module and performance evaluation module;

[0060] The index acquisition module conducts earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determines the seismic evaluation index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type.

[0061] The performance evaluation module evaluates the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic evaluation index value and the pre-set evaluation index threshold.

[0062] The evaluation indicators include: bushing displacement limit and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformer; the seismic dynamic amplification system adopts the coefficient determined in a method for determining seismic dynamic amplification coefficient that considers soil-structure interaction.

[0063] Example 5:

[0064] This invention proposes a seismic assessment method for UHV transformers, addressing the shortcomings of current assessment methods that do not consider the dynamic amplification effect of soil. This method considers aspects such as seismic fortification standards, fortification objectives, the seismic dynamic amplification factor of UHV transformer body considering soil-structure interaction, and the safety factor and displacement limit of bushings.

[0065] (1) Seismic fortification standards

[0066] Seismic design standards are a measure of the level of seismic fortification requirements, determined by seismic intensity or design ground motion parameters and the seismic fortification category of buildings. The formulation of seismic design standards directly affects the performance of engineering buildings and facilities during earthquakes, thus influencing the losses caused by earthquakes. The level of seismic design standards directly relates to the cost of the project. Higher fortification standards result in higher project costs and less earthquake damage, while lower fortification standards result in lower project costs and greater earthquake damage. Determining the optimal fortification standard requires collaboration among various disciplines and is constrained by both scientific and technological levels, economic conditions, and national seismic fortification policies.

[0067] The relevant domestic and international standards stipulate the following regarding seismic design standards for electrical equipment:

[0068] (1) The Code for Seismic Design of Electrical Equipment in Industrial Enterprises (GB 50556-2010) stipulates that important electrical equipment should be subject to seismic measures at a level one degree higher than the seismic fortification intensity of the region. However, when the seismic fortification intensity is 9 degrees, seismic measures should be taken at a higher level than 9 degrees. The basic design seismic acceleration value used in the calculation of seismic action should be increased by 0.05g, but it should not be increased further when the basic design seismic acceleration is 0.2g or above.

[0069] (2) The American Seismic Design Code for Substations (IEEE 693) defines three basic seismic design levels: high, medium, and low, with peak acceleration values ​​of 0.1g, 0.25g, and 0.5g, respectively. Seismic acceleration response spectrum (RRS) curves are provided for each design level under damping ratio conditions of 2%, 5%, and 10%. The dominant frequency range of each response spectrum is (1.1–8) Hz. Response spectrum accelerations above 33 Hz are considered zero-period accelerations. The response spectrum comprehensively considers the spectral characteristics, magnitude, distance, and site conditions of different ground motions, and has broad representativeness. This code stipulates that the seismic performance of equipment can only meet the corresponding seismic design level if the equipment passes through a ground motion time history with a response spectrum consistent with the corresponding design level requirements. In addition, to meet higher customer requirements, the code also defines two seismic performance levels (PL): high and medium, with response spectrum values ​​twice the corresponding RRS values ​​and peak acceleration values ​​of 1.0g and 0.5g, respectively.

[0070] (3) The Japanese Electrical Equipment Seismic Design Guidelines (JESC) stipulate that the design horizontal seismic acceleration for outdoor porcelain-type electrical equipment is 0.3g. The Japan Electric Power Corporation calculated the surface acceleration based on the predicted maximum bedrock acceleration over the next 75 years by analyzing typical substations. The probability of the surface acceleration value exceeding 0.3g is very small. Therefore, the standard design horizontal seismic force is set at 0.3g, which is equivalent to a magnitude 7 earthquake in Japan.

[0071] (4) The Code for Seismic Design of Power Facilities (GB50260-2013) stipulates that for general electrical equipment, the probability level of the design earthquake is generally taken as 10% of the 50-year exceedance probability, that is, the seismic fortification is carried out according to the fortification intensity. Important electrical equipment can be fortified according to the fortification intensity increased by 1 degree, but the fortification intensity is not increased when it is 9 degrees or above.

[0072] By comparing the relevant provisions of the above-mentioned standards on the seismic fortification standards for electrical equipment, and taking into account the importance of UHV transformer equipment and its consistency with existing domestic and international standards, UHV transformers should be seismically fortified according to a 50-year exceedance probability of 2% or according to a seismic intensity 1 degree higher than the fortification intensity, and no further increase is required when the fortification intensity is 9 degrees or above.

[0073] (2) Seismic fortification targets

[0074] Seismic design objectives refer to the specific goals that an engineering project must achieve based on seismic design principles. These objectives vary depending on the importance of the engineering structure. From general buildings, major bridges, and hydropower facilities to nuclear power plants, the importance and safety requirements increase progressively, leading to increasingly stringent seismic design objectives. For example, the seismic design objectives in the *Code for Seismic Design of Buildings* (GB50011-2010) are: "No damage in minor earthquakes, repairable in moderate earthquakes, and no collapse in major earthquakes"—a three-level seismic design objective. Minor, moderate, and major earthquakes are determined using probabilistic methods based on the national basic intensity seismic zoning map. The basic intensity is defined as an intensity with a 50-year exceedance probability of 10% and a return period of 475 years, equivalent to a moderately designed earthquake. Domestic and international standards specify the following seismic design objectives for electrical equipment:

[0075] (1) The seismic design objective of the Code for Seismic Design of Electrical Equipment in Industrial Enterprises (GB 50556-2010) is that electrical equipment designed for seismic resistance in accordance with this code shall not be damaged when subjected to an earthquake of the same intensity as or below the seismic fortification intensity of the region and shall continue to be used.

[0076] (2) The seismic design objective of the U.S. Substation Seismic Design Recommendation Code (IEEE 693) is: when encountering a given level RRS earthquake, the equipment is completely undamaged and can continue to operate; when encountering a given level PL earthquake, the equipment is slightly damaged, but most of the equipment can continue to operate.

[0077] (3) The seismic design objective of the Japanese Electrical Equipment Seismic Design Guide (JESC) is: the equipment structure shall not be damaged when subjected to a given level of seismic action.

[0078] (4) The seismic design objective of the "Code for Seismic Design of Power Facilities" (GB50260-2013) is: when subjected to an earthquake of intensity equivalent to or lower than the local seismic fortification intensity, the equipment should not be damaged and should still be usable; when subjected to a rare earthquake of intensity higher than the local seismic fortification intensity, the equipment should not be severely damaged and should be able to be restored to use after repair. Considering that this code stipulates that important electrical facilities can be fortified with a seismic fortification intensity one degree higher, the seismic design objective stipulated in the code can also be understood as electrical equipment should remain undamaged under earthquake action and possess the electrical functions required for normal operation.

[0079] Electrical equipment differs significantly from building structures in both structural form and functional requirements. Building structures allow for the dissipation of seismic energy through the plastic deformation of relevant components during major earthquakes, ensuring that the building does not collapse and thus protecting lives and property. Electrical equipment, however, is different. If any part of electrical equipment is damaged or destroyed during an earthquake, its electrical function will fail, affecting the safe and stable operation of the entire power grid. Therefore, the seismic design objective for ultra-high voltage (UHV) transformers should be "no damage under major earthquakes," meaning that UHV transformers should be guaranteed to remain undamaged under seismic forces and maintain good electrical functionality.

[0080] (3) Determination of seismic dynamic amplification factor for UHV transformer body considering soil-structure interaction

[0081] 1) Distribution law of seismic dynamic amplification factor of UHV transformer body considering soil-structure interaction

[0082] When the local vibration excitation is small, after considering the soil-structure dynamic interaction, the acceleration response at each bushing riser and the strain response of the bushing are amplified to varying degrees compared with the case without considering the soil-structure dynamic interaction. When simulating Class I soil, the average amplification values ​​of acceleration and strain at the bushing riser compared with the case without considering the soil are 1.28 and 1.41, respectively. When simulating Class II soil, the average amplification values ​​of acceleration and strain at the bushing riser compared with the case without considering the soil are 1.73 and 2.11, respectively.

[0083] As the peak ground acceleration (PGA) of the seismic excitation gradually increases, the corresponding PGA values ​​in the model range from 0.8 to 1.2 g (0.2 to 0.3 g in the prototype). Considering the soil-structure dynamic interaction, the acceleration response and strain response of the bushings at each riser point of the transformer tend to decrease compared to the case without considering soil-structure dynamic interaction. When simulating Class I soil, the average amplification values ​​of acceleration and strain at the riser points relative to the case without soil consideration are 0.75 and 0.87, respectively. When simulating Class II soil, the average amplification values ​​are 0.94 and 1.23, respectively. Except for the Class II soil case where the strain amplification value is greater than 1, the acceleration and strain amplification values ​​in other cases are less than 1. This indicates that as the seismic excitation intensity increases, factors such as the nonlinear mechanical behavior of the soil lead to an increase in the soil damping ratio, which to some extent inhibits the response of the superstructure.

[0084] Since the transformer bushing is the weakest link and part of the overall structure under seismic action, and the bushing stress is a key indicator for evaluating the seismic resistance of the bushing, the subsequent study on the dynamic amplification effect of soil-structure interaction on the seismic response of the transformer should be based on the amplification of strain (stress).

[0085] 2) Determination of the seismic dynamic amplification factor for the UHV transformer body considering soil-structure interaction

[0086] Since the current seismic design of transformers does not consider the dynamic interaction between soil and structure, and as can be seen from the above analysis results, when the dynamic interaction between soil and structure is not considered and the seismic excitation is small, the seismic response of the transformer under both Class I and Class II soil conditions is amplified when the peak ground acceleration of the corresponding prototype is less than or equal to 0.1g. The average amplification of the strain of each bushing in Class I soil plus one standard deviation is 1.74, and the average amplification of the strain of each bushing in Class II soil plus one standard deviation is 2.69.

[0087] When the peak ground acceleration of the corresponding prototype is 0.2g to 0.3g, the strain of each bushing in the soil of Class I site is smaller than that when the soil-structure dynamic interaction is not considered. The average strain amplification value is 0.87, and the standard deviation is 1.05. It can be basically considered that under seismic excitation greater than 0.2g, the seismic response of each bushing of the transformer in Class I site soil after considering the soil-structure dynamic interaction is small.

[0088] When the peak ground acceleration of the corresponding prototype is 0.2g to 0.3g, the average amplification of the strain of each casing in the soil of Class II site relative to the value when soil-structure dynamic interaction is not considered is 1.23, and the value is 1.74 after doubling the standard deviation.

[0089] Considering that UHV transformers mainly fail under relatively large seismic excitation, especially under 0.1g seismic excitation, even considering soil-structure interaction, the safety factor of the bushings is much greater than 2, indicating high safety. Therefore, the refined seismic design of transformers considering soil-structure interaction mainly targets conditions greater than or equal to 0.2g. The above analysis shows that under Class I site soil conditions, considering soil-structure dynamic interaction has a relatively small impact on the seismic response of each transformer bushing, and seismic design can be carried out according to the conventional transformer bottom consolidation. Under Class II site soil conditions, when the peak ground acceleration of the prototype seismic input is 0.2g to 0.3g, the average value of the bushing stress amplification under these conditions, considering and not considering soil-structure interaction, plus one standard deviation, can be used as the basis for seismic design. Summarizing and analyzing the data, it is recommended that the bushing stress calculated according to the conventional transformer bottom consolidation seismic design be multiplied by 1.23 as the basis for seismic design and evaluation of Class II site soil.

[0090] Previous studies have proposed a seismic dynamic amplification factor of 2.0 for UHV transformers without considering soil-structure interaction. Considering soil-structure interaction, when the peak ground acceleration of the prototype seismic input is 0.2g–0.3g, the seismic dynamic amplification factor for UHV transformers in Class I site soil can continue to be 2.0, while the seismic dynamic amplification factor for UHV transformers in Class II site soil can be 2.0 × 1.23 = 2.46. For other types of site soil, foundation treatment should be performed to adjust their mechanical properties to those of Class I or Class II site soil.

[0091] (4) Regulations on the safety factor and displacement limit of the casing

[0092] 1) Safety Factor Regulations. The "Code for Seismic Design of Electrical Equipment in Industrial Enterprises" (GB 50556-2010) stipulates that the stress value at the critical section of equipment under seismic load should be less than or equal to the allowable design stress value of the material at the verification location. However, when calculating the stress value at the critical section, the material imbalance coefficient should be considered, multiplying the measured or calculated value by a coefficient of 1.67. The US "Recommended Code for Seismic Design of Substations" (IEEE 693) stipulates that when using allowable stress design, for materials without a clear yield point, the maximum stress of the equipment under seismic load should not exceed 50% of the failure stress; for materials with a clear yield point, the maximum stress should not exceed 80% of the yield stress. The Japanese "Guideline for Seismic Design of Electrical Equipment" (JESC) considers that if the maximum stress value of each component obtained during the test is below the allowable stress of each component, then the component can be determined to meet the seismic requirements, and it can be assumed that its function will not exhibit abnormal phenomena after inputting the specified design seismic force. The "Code for Seismic Design of Power Facilities" (GB50260-2013) stipulates that the seismic strength verification of electrical facilities should ensure that the stress value generated at the root of the equipment and device or other dangerous sections is less than the allowable stress value of the equipment or material. When the failure stress or failure moment is used for verification, the porcelain bushing should meet the requirement of 1.67 times the safety factor.

[0093] After comprehensively comparing domestic and international standards regarding seismic assessment methods, seismic load combinations, and safety factors for electrical equipment, and considering the structural characteristics, usage requirements, operating conditions, and frequency of load occurrence of UHV transformers, as well as the consistency with existing domestic and international standards, the seismic assessment method for UHV transformers is specified as follows: When assessing the seismic performance of electrical equipment, this study adopts the safety factor method to rate the safety and reliability of the equipment under different loads. The safety factor is the ratio of the equipment's destructive stress to the calculated stress value. Referring to the requirements of DL / T5352-2006 "Technical Specification for Design of High Voltage Power Distribution Equipment", it is stipulated that under long-term action of loads such as strong winds, the safety factor for the corresponding destructive stress of the equipment should not be less than 2.5. Referring to the requirements of GB50260-2013 "Code for Seismic Design of Power Facilities" and Q / GDW 11132-2013 "Technical Specification for Seismic Design and Installation and Maintenance of Vibration Reduction Devices for UHV Porcelain Insulated Electrical Equipment", it is stipulated that under short-term action of seismic loads, the safety factor for the corresponding destructive stress of the equipment should be greater than or equal to 1.67. While meeting the above mechanical performance requirements, the electrical equipment should also ensure the functions required for its normal operation. The load combination methods and stress safety factor limits under different working conditions are shown in Table 1.

[0094] Table 1 Load Combinations and Minimum Safety Factors

[0095] Calculation of operating conditions Load Combination Safety factor Wind load 1.0 × Gravity load + 1.0 × Wind load 2.50 Earthquake conditions 1.0 × Gravity load + 0.25 × Wind load + 1.0 × Seismic load + Equipment operating load 1.67

[0096] 2) Displacement Limits. Currently, relevant domestic standards do not specify displacement limits for electrical equipment under seismic loading. Internationally, only the US "Recommended Code for Seismic Design of Substations" (IEEE 693) specifies the maximum permissible deflection limits for composite bushings under RRS seismic loading, as follows: 21cm for 138kV–230kV equipment, 26cm for 230kV–361kV equipment, 31cm for 361kV–500kV equipment, and 46cm for 500kV–800kV equipment. Considering that ceramic equipment is brittle and its displacement under seismic loading is relatively small, specific displacement limits are not required for ceramic equipment. However, because ultra-high voltage composite electrical equipment is more flexible than ceramic equipment, its displacement under seismic loading is increased. To avoid excessive equipment displacement and increased seismic coupling effects, it is necessary to consider displacement limits when evaluating the mechanical properties of composite electrical equipment.

[0097] The China Electric Power Research Institute has conducted extensive seismic simulation shaking table tests on composite material electrical equipment. The results show that composite material CVTs exhibit a displacement of 346 mm under a 0.2g seismic load, composite material post insulators experience a top displacement of 600 mm under a 0.4g seismic load, high-resistance bushings experience a top displacement of 330 mm under a 0.5g seismic load, and surge arresters experience a top displacement of 530 mm under a 0.5g seismic load. Considering the asynchronous displacement between adjacent devices in an interconnected system, the relative displacement between devices will be greater than the displacement of a single device. In this case, the sliding groove will require a large sliding length when installing sliding hardware, which will pose significant difficulties for hardware support and installation. Furthermore, the large redundant length of flexible conductors in flexible conductor connections will cause sag, reducing the insulation distance between the conductor and the ground, necessitating raising the equipment or support height. All these factors indicate the significant importance of controlling the displacement of composite material equipment.

[0098] The IEEE 693 standard stipulates that the design of busbar redundancy settings, ensuring electrical clearances, and preventing short-circuit interactions must consider the top displacement of composite equipment under seismic loads. Specifically, the top displacement is controlled at 210 mm for equipment below 230 kV; 260 mm for equipment between 230 kV and 361 kV; 310 mm for equipment between 361 kV and 500 kV; and 460 mm for equipment between 500 kV and 800 kV. These recommended values, proposed in 2005, did not consider the displacement requirements of composite material electrical equipment in UHV AC / DC projects.

[0099] The following analysis addresses the displacement limits of composite material electrical equipment in UHV AC / DC engineering projects. Firstly, unlike load-bearing capacity, the displacement limits of equipment during earthquakes are not solely determined by the equipment's seismic resistance, but also by the design of sliding hardware or flexible conductors in interconnected electrical equipment. Excessive top displacement of the equipment will cause manufacturing difficulties for sliding hardware. For example, if the displacements of adjacent individual equipment are 0.4m and 0.5m respectively, considering the possibility of opposite movements between adjacent equipment, a conservative estimate would be a single-sided sliding groove length of 0.9m, and a total sliding groove length of 1.8m. Currently, in the design of composite material interconnection equipment at the Weifang UHV substation, the 1.1m long sliding groove for hardware has already created certain difficulties in hardware manufacturing and installation. If flexible conductors are used for connection, excessive equipment displacement will require a large redundancy in the flexible conductors. This large redundancy will create sag, reducing the insulation distance of the conductors and causing problems such as increased terminal tension under wind load.

[0100] On the other hand, the limit on top displacement can have a reciprocal effect on the structural parameter design of the equipment. By increasing the stiffness of the equipment, the displacement of composite material equipment under seismic loads can be controlled. However, overly strict displacement limits will cause difficulties in bushing manufacturing and waste of materials. Therefore, the setting of displacement limits should, on the one hand, ensure that most current equipment can meet the requirements without major modifications, and on the other hand, provide guidance for the bushing design of future composite equipment. This project conducted tests on most of the ultra-high voltage composite material support equipment currently used in China. The top displacement results were linearly converted to the value of 0.5g fortification acceleration level, and considering the support amplification factor according to different equipment types, the top displacement of the composite CVT is 780mm (the safety factor of this equipment is also insufficient, and vibration damping devices need to be installed in engineering applications), the top displacement of the composite surge arrester is 312mm, the top displacement of the two-section support bushing with an outer diameter of 358mm is 564mm, the top displacement of the five-section support bushing with an outer diameter of 280mm is 767mm, the top displacement of the GIS bushing is 75mm, and the top displacement of the high-resistance bushing is 340mm.

[0101] Based on the above analysis, and considering the seismic displacement response of currently used UHV AC / DC composite material electrical equipment, the installation of sliding fittings and flexible conductors, the economic efficiency of equipment design and manufacturing, and compliance with IEEE standards, the top displacement limit for UHV composite material support structures is determined by the smaller of 600 mm and 1 / 18 of the equipment height (when the displacement is 600 mm, the statistical displacement angle of each piece of equipment is below 1 / 18). For UHV transformers using composite material bushings, considering that equipment displacement is mainly caused by bushings, the bushing displacement should also be determined by the smaller of 600 mm and the 1 / 18 displacement angle as the limit index under seismic loading.

[0102] Obviously, the described embodiments are only some, not all, of the embodiments of the present invention. All other embodiments obtained by those skilled in the art based on the embodiments of the present invention without inventive effort are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0103] Those skilled in the art will understand that embodiments of this application can be provided as methods, systems, or computer program products. Therefore, this application can take the form of a completely hardware embodiment, a completely software embodiment, or an embodiment combining software and hardware aspects. Furthermore, this application can take the form of a computer program product embodied on one or more computer-usable storage media (including but not limited to disk storage, CD-ROM, optical storage, etc.) containing computer-usable program code.

[0104] This application is described with reference to flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams of methods, apparatus (systems), and computer program products according to embodiments of this application. It will be understood that each block of the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams, and combinations of blocks in the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams, can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, special-purpose computer, embedded processor, or other programmable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such that the instructions, which execute via the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing apparatus, generate instructions for implementing the flowchart... Figure 1 One or more processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A device that provides the functions specified in one or more boxes.

[0105] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable storage medium that can direct a computer or other programmable data processing device to function in a particular manner, such that the instructions stored in the computer-readable storage medium produce an article of manufacture including instruction means, which are implemented in a process Figure 1 One or more processes and / or boxes Figure 1 The function specified in one or more boxes.

[0106] These computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing equipment to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer or other programmable equipment to produce a computer-implemented process, thereby providing instructions that execute on the computer or other programmable equipment for implementing the process. Figure 1 One or more processes and / or boxes Figure 1 The steps of the function specified in one or more boxes.

[0107] The above are merely embodiments of the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc., made within the spirit and principles of the present invention are included within the scope of the claims of the present invention pending approval.

Claims

1. A seismic assessment method for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction, characterized in that, include: Earthquake simulation experiments were conducted based on the selected seismic fortification intensity, and the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type was considered to determine the seismic evaluation index value of the UHV transformer. The seismic performance of the UHV transformer is evaluated based on the seismic evaluation index values ​​and the pre-set evaluation index thresholds. The seismic assessment indicators include: bushing displacement and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformers; The seismic dynamic amplification factor is determined by the following steps: Simulation experiments are conducted based on a set seismic excitation to obtain the strain values ​​of the UHV transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction; the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV transformer body under different site soil types is determined based on the strain values ​​considering soil-structure interaction and those not considering soil-structure interaction; when the average strain amplification value is less than the set value, the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV transformer body is determined according to the conventional body seismic dynamic amplification factor; otherwise, the product of the average strain amplification value and the conventional body seismic dynamic amplification factor is calculated as the seismic dynamic amplification factor. The process of conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determining the seismic assessment index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type includes: obtaining the bushing displacement and bushing load combined stress of the UHV transformer by conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the seismic acceleration corresponding to the seismic fortification intensity; and determining the bushing safety factor of the UHV transformer based on the ratio of the bushing failure stress value to the bushing load combined stress. The combined stress of the casing load is calculated using the following formula: In the formula: : represents the combined stress of the load; : is the partial factor for gravity load; : refers to gravity load; : is the wind load partial factor; : For wind load; Seismic load partial factor; Seismic load; : Seismic action effect value.

2. The seismic assessment method as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The safety factor threshold and displacement threshold of the UHV transformer bushing are determined by the selected seismic fortification standard.

3. The seismic assessment method as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The seismic performance of the UHV transformer, which is evaluated based on the seismic assessment index value and the pre-set assessment index threshold, is determined by the selected seismic fortification target.

4. A seismic assessment system for ultra-high voltage transformers considering soil-structure interaction, characterized in that, include: Metrics acquisition module and performance evaluation module; The index acquisition module conducts earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determines the seismic evaluation index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type. The performance evaluation module evaluates the seismic performance of the UHV transformer based on the seismic evaluation index value and the pre-set evaluation index threshold. The evaluation indicators include: bushing displacement and bushing safety factor of ultra-high voltage transformers; The seismic dynamic amplification factor is determined by the following steps: Simulation experiments are conducted based on a set seismic excitation to obtain the strain values ​​of the UHV transformer under different site soil types, considering soil-structure interaction; the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV transformer body under different site soil types is determined based on the strain values ​​considering soil-structure interaction and those not considering soil-structure interaction; when the average strain amplification value is less than the set value, the seismic dynamic amplification factor of the UHV transformer body is determined according to the conventional body seismic dynamic amplification factor; otherwise, the product of the average strain amplification value and the conventional body seismic dynamic amplification factor is calculated as the seismic dynamic amplification factor. The process of conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the selected seismic fortification intensity and determining the seismic assessment index value of the UHV transformer by considering the seismic dynamic amplification factor corresponding to the site soil type includes: obtaining the bushing displacement and bushing load combined stress of the UHV transformer by conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the seismic acceleration corresponding to the seismic fortification intensity; and determining the bushing safety factor of the UHV transformer based on the ratio of the bushing failure stress value to the bushing load combined stress. The combined stress of the casing load is calculated using the following formula: In the formula: : represents the combined stress of the load; : is the partial factor for gravity load; : refers to gravity load; : is the wind load partial factor; : For wind load; Seismic load partial factor; Seismic load; : Seismic action effect value.

5. The ultra-high voltage transformer seismic assessment system as described in claim 4, characterized in that, The indicator acquisition module includes: The data acquisition submodule is used to obtain the bushing displacement and bushing load combined stress of the UHV transformer by conducting earthquake simulation experiments based on the earthquake acceleration corresponding to the seismic fortification intensity. The coefficient calculation submodule is used to determine the safety factor of UHV transformer bushings based on the ratio of bushing failure stress value to bushing load combined stress.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Earthquake simulation vibration test method and device for transformer equipment

    CN111024343A