Methods and systems for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on control tower visibility.
By combining theoretical calculations with human-in-the-loop testing, a comprehensive evaluation index system was constructed, which solved the problem of insufficient adaptation of existing tower visibility assessment methods in the scenario of proposed buildings, and realized a comprehensive and accurate assessment and optimization suggestions for tower visibility.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310741524.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-06-20
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-06-20
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for assessing tower visibility are insufficiently adapted to scenarios involving proposed airport buildings, rely heavily on human experience parameters, and lack contextual awareness. This results in significant discrepancies between the assessment results and the actual situation, failing to accurately reflect the impact of the proposed buildings on tower visibility.
By combining theoretical calculations with human-in-the-loop testing, a comprehensive evaluation index system is constructed. Through a combination of theoretical analysis and human-in-the-loop testing, the impact of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility is assessed, thus optimizing traditional analysis methods.
It enables a comprehensive and intuitive assessment of the tower's visibility capabilities, resulting in more accurate results. It can propose measures to fill blind spots, improving the objectivity and accuracy of the assessment and adapting to the needs of airport expansion and renovation.
Smart Images

Figure CN116739285B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of tower visibility analysis technology, and is specifically for the scenario of proposed airport buildings, namely, an assessment method and system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on tower visibility. Background Technology
[0002] As the civil aviation industry enters a stage of high-quality development, airports already in operation are facing a strong demand for expansion and renovation. As the command center for aircraft arrivals and departures, the control tower needs to simultaneously meet a series of operational requirements, including visibility of the airport's maneuvering area, visibility of key targets, and identification of key targets. Therefore, during the airport expansion and renovation phase, the proposed buildings will have varying degrees of impact on the tower's visibility capabilities, necessitating a scientific and reasonable approach to thoroughly analyze the impact.
[0003] In existing technologies, the methods for assessing tower visibility are relatively traditional, mostly based on the relevant provisions and requirements in the "Technical Demonstration Method for the Location and Height of Control Towers." These methods involve constructing theoretical calculation models for factors such as line-of-sight obstruction range, line-of-sight angle, lateral resolution angle, key target detection, and key target recognition probability to theoretically analyze tower visibility. However, these existing theoretical calculation models suffer from insufficient adaptability and rely heavily on human experience parameters. When applied to actual visibility assessments, these models can easily lead to discrepancies between theoretical calculations and actual conditions, thus reducing the objectivity and accuracy of the assessment results. Furthermore, current theoretical calculation methods do not specifically consider the impact of proposed buildings during airport expansion and renovation phases, preventing controllers from experiencing the obstruction caused by completed buildings firsthand. This hinders their ability to develop situational awareness and requires additional time to adapt. Summary of the Invention
[0004] The purpose of this invention is to overcome the difficulty of applying existing tower visibility assessment methods to new scenarios such as proposed airport buildings, while also addressing the shortcomings of existing technologies, such as the reliance on numerous human experience parameters, lack of situational awareness, and a relatively singular assessment method. This invention comprehensively assesses the impact of proposed airport buildings on tower visibility by combining theoretical calculations with human loop testing, and specifically optimizes traditional analysis methods. Compared to traditional methods, this invention offers a more comprehensive and intuitive visibility assessment process, more accurate results, and can also propose optimization suggestions such as blind spot filling measures based on the assessment conclusions, demonstrating excellent application prospects.
[0005] The present invention employs the following technical solutions to achieve its objective:
[0006] A method for assessing the impact of a proposed airport building on the visibility of the control tower, the method comprising the following steps:
[0007] S1. Collect basic data of the target airport, perform preprocessing operations on the basic data to obtain various key point data; the key point data includes: characteristic points of the reaction maneuver zone, characteristic points representing the building configuration, key points of the operation of the scene around the building, the path points of key aircraft targets, and the viewpoint of the tower controller.
[0008] S2. Construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability, determine the calculation indicators for the theoretical analysis stage and the human loop test stage, and determine the calculation formula for the comprehensive impact index of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability.
[0009] S3. Construct a theoretical calculation model for the measurement indicators in the theoretical analysis stage; based on the key point data of the target airport, set the corresponding calculation parameters, conduct theoretical analysis, and obtain the theoretical analysis results;
[0010] S4. For the calculation indicators of the human-loop test, based on the feature points representing the building configuration in the key point data, construct a three-dimensional model of the proposed building; build an augmented reality model based on the three-dimensional model; and conduct a human-loop test in the control tower of the target airport with the participation of air traffic controllers to obtain the human-loop test results.
[0011] S5. Combining the theoretical analysis results with the results of human-on-loop testing, output the comprehensive impact index of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility capability, and complete the visibility capability assessment process.
[0012] Furthermore, in step S2, the indicators in the comprehensive evaluation indicator system include: visibility of the maneuvering area, visibility of key points, visibility of key targets, probability of detection of key targets, probability of identification of key targets, and reaction time for identification of key targets.
[0013] Preferably, in step S5, the comprehensive impact index V is calculated according to the formula by combining the theoretical analysis results and the results of the human loop test. For each index in the comprehensive evaluation index system, the value is 0 or 1. When the final calculated comprehensive impact index V value is 1, it means that the impact of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility is within an acceptable range.
[0014] Furthermore, based on the results of the comprehensive impact index V value and the impact found during the assessment process, a schematic diagram of the visual obstruction of the proposed building can be drawn, thereby determining the blind spot filling measures to optimize the tower's visibility.
[0015] This invention also provides an assessment system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability. The system includes: a data acquisition module, a data preprocessing module, a theoretical analysis module, a human-loop testing module, and a conclusion output module.
[0016] The data acquisition module is used to collect basic data of the target airport and store the basic data in a corresponding storage medium; the storage medium is used to transmit the basic data to the evaluation system.
[0017] The data preprocessing module is used for feature extraction and feature output of basic data, thereby preprocessing the basic data into various key point data, including: feature points of the reaction maneuver zone range, feature points representing the building configuration, key points of the operation of the scene around the building, path points of key aircraft targets, and tower controller viewpoints.
[0018] The theoretical analysis module is used to perform theoretical calculations based on key point data. By setting corresponding calculation parameters, it calculates the index values of visibility of the maneuvering area, key point visibility, and key target visibility, which are used as the theoretical analysis results.
[0019] The human-loop test module is used to construct an augmented reality model based on key point data and a 3D model of the proposed building, and to recreate the proposed building on the control tower using augmented reality technology and display it on the control platform screen. It is also used to provide human-loop test items for controllers as test subjects, record process data, and calculate the human-loop test results.
[0020] The conclusion output module is used to combine theoretical analysis results with human loop test results to calculate and output the comprehensive impact index of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility capability, and to draw an evaluation conclusion.
[0021] In summary, due to the adoption of this technical solution, the beneficial effects of this invention are as follows:
[0022] The method and system of this invention, based on airport control-related regulations and combined with the availability of data, comprehensively and systematically considers various dimensions of indicators affecting the visibility of controllers in the control tower. This results in the construction of a comprehensive evaluation index system for the visibility of the control tower under the influence of proposed buildings, which is complete and universal. Furthermore, the method incorporates theoretical calculations and human loop testing.
[0023] After applying this invention, air traffic controllers in the control tower can also use augmented reality technology to conduct on-site assessments of the impact of proposed airport buildings on their visibility. Compared with existing visibility assessment methods, this invention is more comprehensive, intuitive, and accurate, and can also propose optimization suggestions such as blind spot filling measures based on the assessment conclusions. Given the continuous development of civil aviation technology and the increasing demand for airport expansion and renovation, this invention will have a promising application prospect. Attached Figure Description
[0024] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating the evaluation method of the present invention;
[0025] Figure 2 This is a block diagram showing the structural composition of the evaluation system of the present invention;
[0026] Figure 3 A schematic diagram of a scenario for basic data acquisition and processing;
[0027] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram for the visibility analysis of the maneuvering area;
[0028] Figure 5 A schematic diagram for key point visibility analysis;
[0029] Figure 6 A schematic diagram for visibility analysis of key objectives;
[0030] Figure 7 A schematic diagram illustrating the augmented reality scene of a building model. Detailed Implementation
[0031] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and advantages of the embodiments of the present invention clearer, the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only some embodiments of the present invention, and not all embodiments. The components of the embodiments of the present invention described and shown in the accompanying drawings can generally be arranged and designed in various different configurations.
[0032] Therefore, the following detailed description of the embodiments of the invention provided in the accompanying drawings is not intended to limit the scope of the claimed invention, but merely to illustrate selected embodiments of the invention. All other embodiments obtained by those skilled in the art based on the embodiments of the invention without inventive effort are within the scope of protection of the invention.
[0033] Example 1
[0034] A method for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility. Figure 1 The overall flow of the method is shown below, and the specific steps are summarized as follows:
[0035] S1. Collect basic data of the target airport, process the basic data, and obtain various key point data; the key point data includes: characteristic points of the reaction maneuver zone, characteristic points representing the building configuration, key points of the operation of the scene around the building, the path points of key aircraft targets, and the viewpoint of the tower controller.
[0036] S2. Construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability, determine the calculation indicators for the theoretical analysis stage and the human loop test stage, and determine the calculation formula for the comprehensive impact index of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability.
[0037] S3. Construct a theoretical calculation model for the measurement indicators in the theoretical analysis stage; based on the key point data of the target airport, set the corresponding calculation parameters, conduct theoretical analysis, and obtain the theoretical analysis results;
[0038] S4. For the calculation indicators of the human-loop test, based on the feature points representing the building configuration in the key point data, construct a three-dimensional model of the proposed building; build an augmented reality model based on the three-dimensional model; and conduct a human-loop test in the control tower of the target airport with the participation of air traffic controllers to obtain the human-loop test results.
[0039] S5. Combining the theoretical analysis results with the results of human-on-loop testing, output the comprehensive impact index of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility capability, and complete the visibility capability assessment process.
[0040] Figure 2 The composition structure of the evaluation system corresponding to this method is given; this embodiment focuses on the evaluation method itself and provides a detailed and optimal description of the implementation process of each step.
[0041] In this embodiment, the visibility capability of the control tower under the influence of the proposed airport building is scientifically evaluated by combining theoretical calculation and analysis with human-based loop testing. The evaluation covers the visibility of the maneuvering area, the visibility of key points, the visibility of key targets, the probability of detection of key targets, and the probability of identification of key targets. The evaluation outputs an impact index and forms a comprehensive evaluation conclusion, providing decision-making reference for airports and air traffic control units.
[0042] Step S1: Collection and processing of basic data for the target airport; the data scenario for collection and presentation can be found in [reference needed]. Figure 3 The illustration.
[0043] The basic data includes: airport surface structure parameters, typical activity trajectory data of transport aircraft and general aviation aircraft, planning and design parameters of proposed buildings, physical structure parameters of the control tower, layout parameters of the control tower room, and line-of-sight parameters for controllers.
[0044] When processing basic data and obtaining key point data, multiple key point data of the same type are sorted by subscript μ.
[0045] Based on the airport surface structure parameters, the airport surface elevation M is derived. A Airport reference point geographic coordinates G A Select the characteristic point S within the reaction maneuver zone. μ (μ=1,2,3,...), output the geographic coordinates corresponding to the feature points.
[0046] Based on typical activity trajectory data of transport aircraft and general aviation aircraft, data at altitudes above H are extracted. ATypical transport aircraft arrival and departure track data TR below the value A Extract typical general aviation aircraft activity trajectory data (TR) within a specific distance from the building. G ; Transfer data TR A and data TR G waypoints as key targets for aircraft Output the geographic coordinates of key targets and their altitude from the airport surface.
[0047] Based on the planning and design parameters of the proposed building, select characteristic point J representing the building's configuration. μ (μ=1,2,3,...), output the geographic coordinates of the building feature points and their distance H from the airport surface. J From feature point J μ Select the center point J of the building on the horizontal plane. z And two base points K1 and K2, respectively measure the distance between base points K1 and K2 and the airport reference point G. A and the building's center point J Z The included angles of the lines connecting the points are used as base point angles α1 and α2; simultaneously, considering the aircraft surface operations at the proposed building location, key points of the surface operations around the building are selected, and the key points of surface operations are determined and output. The corresponding geographic coordinates.
[0048] Based on the tower's physical structure parameters, output the tower reference point G. T Geographic coordinates, distance H from the control tower to the airport surface T Based on the tower control room layout parameters and controller line-of-sight parameters, output the geographical coordinates G of the control seat with the number of control seats n and the controller's viewpoint number i. i The average height H of the controller's line of sight from the control room floor C .
[0049] Step S2: Construction of the comprehensive evaluation index system for tower visibility capability and calculation of the impact index.
[0050] The indicators in the comprehensive evaluation indicator system include: visibility of the maneuver zone, visibility of key points, visibility of key targets, probability of detection of key targets, probability of identification of key targets, and reaction time for identification of key targets; the specific definitions of each indicator are as follows.
[0051] Visibility of the maneuvering area: Determine the visibility of the maneuvering area by considering the visual obstruction areas near the proposed building;
[0052] Visibility of key points: The visibility of key points in the operation of the site due to the influence of the proposed building;
[0053] Visibility of key targets: The aircraft at each point in a typical activity trajectory are taken as key targets, and the visibility of key targets under the influence of the proposed building is assessed.
[0054] Probability of detecting critical targets: The probability that an air traffic controller will detect critical targets such as aircraft near a proposed building;
[0055] Probability of identifying key targets: The probability that an air traffic controller can identify key targets such as aircraft near a proposed building;
[0056] Target identification reaction time: The time it takes for controllers to identify key targets such as aircraft near a proposed building.
[0057] Based on the constructed comprehensive evaluation index system, the values of various indicators to be calculated in the theoretical analysis and human-on-the-loop testing phases were determined. Specifically, the indicators for the theoretical analysis phase include: visibility of the maneuvering area, visibility of key points, and visibility of key targets; the indicators for the human-on-the-loop testing phase include: visibility of the maneuvering area, visibility of key points, visibility of key targets, probability of key target detection, probability of key target recognition, and reaction time for key target recognition.
[0058] In this embodiment, the formula for calculating the comprehensive impact index V of the proposed airport building on the control tower's visibility capability is as follows:
[0059]
[0060] In the formula, n represents the number of control seats, and i represents the controller's viewpoint number; the values of each indicator are calculated using two methods: theoretical analysis and human-in-the-loop testing. A i1 To A iw The values of index w are obtained based on theoretical analysis and calculation; B i1 To B ig The values of the g-item index are based on human-based loop testing.
[0061] A iw With B ig All values follow the rule of taking a value of 0 or 1. When the value of V is 1, it means that the impact of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility is within an acceptable range and meets the relevant operational requirements and specifications.
[0062] Step S3: Theoretical analysis based on the theoretical calculation model.
[0063] This step, the tower controller visibility assessment process based on theoretical calculations, includes: constructing a coordinate system for assessing tower controller visibility, analyzing the visibility of the maneuvering area, analyzing the visibility of key points, and analyzing the visibility of key targets.
[0064] In this embodiment, based on the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate system and related theories, the viewpoints of controllers at different control positions are used as the perspective analysis points V. i The horizontal projection point is taken as the origin O, the y-axis parallel to the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate system is taken as the X-axis, the x-axis parallel to the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate system is taken as the Y-axis, and the Z-axis is perpendicular to the airport surface, thus establishing a tower visibility assessment coordinate system.
[0065] Combining the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate system and related theories, the geographic coordinates of the target point and the viewpoint analysis point are first transformed into coordinates in the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate system. The target point coordinates are denoted as (x... t ,y t ), perspective analysis point V i The coordinates are denoted as (x0, y0); then in the tower's line-of-sight assessment coordinate system, the coordinates of this target point are (y0, y0). t -y0, x t -x0,h T ), h T This refers to the altitude of the target point above the airport surface.
[0066] The following is the specific calculation process of the measurement indicators in the theoretical analysis stage.
[0067] S3-1, visibility of the maneuvering area, can be viewed simultaneously. Figure 4 The illustration.
[0068] Partial feature points J μ and convergence point M μ The resulting shape is considered as the visual obstruction surface S around the building. inv Determine the plane S inv With the maneuver zone feature point S μ The horizontal plane S of the maneuvering zone M Does an overlapping portion exist? If not, then A i1 Select 1 otherwise select 0, as shown in the following formula:
[0069]
[0070] Convergence point M μ The coordinates are determined as follows: The tower controller starts from viewpoint V. i Looking directly at any feature point J on the outer surface of the building μ The gaze passed through J μ After point M, the scene intersects with the airport. μ ,So:
[0071]
[0072]
[0073]
[0074] in, For feature point J μ In the tower visibility assessment coordinate system, h represents the feature point J. μ The height of the distance from the airport surface, L, is the feature point J on the airport surface projection plane. μ With viewpoint V i The distances between them are as follows:
[0075]
[0076] S3-2, Key point visibility, can be viewed simultaneously. Figure 5 The illustration.
[0077] Let D be the surface of the proposed building. μ (μ=1,2,3,...), determine the viewpoint analysis point V i Key points of the scene around the building connection With building surface feature point J μ Does it have an intersection point? If it does, and the intersection point is not at the surface endpoint, then the key point is considered to be obscured by a building, and the corresponding value will be set accordingly. Take 0 otherwise; then use A i2 V, as a point of view for analysis i The key visibility index is as follows:
[0078]
[0079] When A i2 When the value is 1, it means that there is no problem with the visibility of the key points.
[0080] S3-3, Key Target Visibility, can be viewed simultaneously. Figure 6 The illustration.
[0081] Let D be the surface of the proposed building. μ (μ = 1, 2, 3, ...), determine the viewpoint analysis point v i Waypoints to key aircraft targets connection With building surface feature point J μ Does it have an intersection point? If it does, and the intersection point is not at the surface endpoint, then the key target is considered to be obscured by a building, and the corresponding value will be set accordingly. Take 0 otherwise; then use A i3 V, as a point of view for analysis i The key target visibility indicators are as follows:
[0082]
[0083] When A i3 When the value is 1, it means that there is no problem with the visibility of the key target.
[0084] Step S4: Human-in-the-loop test based on augmented reality.
[0085] In this embodiment, this step first combines the feature points of the proposed building to construct a three-dimensional model of the proposed building, and then imports the constructed three-dimensional model into the Unity development platform to further construct an augmented reality model; then, a real-world registration operation is performed on the building model, and by matching the geographical coordinates of the horizontal projection center point of the newly built building with the altitude of the airport surface, the position of the simulation model after real-world augmentation is locked, thereby realizing the positioning of the augmented reality model.
[0086] The specific registration and positioning operation is as follows: Select two different points on the horizontal projection plane of the augmented reality model as key points K and L, and simultaneously obtain the angles α and β between key points K and L and the lines connecting the airport reference point and the building center point; Combine the planning information of the proposed building with the pre-processed building center point J. Z Using two base points K1 and K2, and base point angles α1 and α2, the augmented reality model is rotated around the vertical axis of the building's center point. Rotation stops when the angles α and β between key points K and L and the lines connecting the airport reference point and the building's center point simultaneously match the base point angles α1 and α2. This completes the registration of the augmented reality model of the proposed building. For a scenario of augmented reality model registration, please refer to [link to relevant documentation]. Figure 7 The illustration.
[0087] The following describes the specific details of controllers conducting human-on-loop testing on the control platform.
[0088] S4-1, visibility of the maneuvering area.
[0089] Based on augmented reality visuals, controllers dynamically verify whether proposed buildings will obstruct the view of the maneuvering area via a control platform. When obstruction of view exists in the maneuvering area, B... i1 The value is 0 otherwise the value is 1.
[0090] S4-2, Visibility of key points.
[0091] Based on augmented reality visuals, controllers dynamically assess key operational points through a control platform. Whether it is visible; if there is no obstruction, then... The value is 1 if it is not 0 otherwise; this corresponds to indicator B. i2 The calculation formula is as follows:
[0092]
[0093] S4-3, Visibility of key objectives.
[0094] Based on augmented reality visuals, controllers dynamically determine the waypoints of critical targets for aircraft through a control platform. Whether it is visible; if there is no obstruction, then... The value is 1 if it is not 0 otherwise; this corresponds to indicator B. i3 The calculation formula is as follows:
[0095]
[0096] Subsequently, based on augmented reality images, controllers observed the activities of key targets such as aircraft and support vehicles around the proposed building N times, and conducted tests on the probability of key target detection, the probability of key target recognition, and the reaction time for key target recognition.
[0097] S4-4, Probability of detecting key targets.
[0098] For the k-th test, when the controller is able to detect the critical target, D is ordered to... k =1, otherwise D k =0; then the probability of detecting the key target P1 is calculated as follows:
[0099]
[0100] B i4 As a metric for measuring the probability of detecting key targets, when the P1 value reaches 95.5% or higher, B... i4 The value is 1 if it is not 1, otherwise the value is 0.
[0101] S4-5, Probability of identifying key targets.
[0102] For the k-th test, when the controller is able to identify the key target, let R... k =1, otherwise R k =0; then the probability of detecting the key target P2 is calculated as follows:
[0103]
[0104] B i5 As a metric for measuring the probability of identifying key targets, when the P2 value reaches 11.5% or higher, B... i5 The value is 1 if it is not 1, otherwise the value is 0.
[0105] S4-6, Response time for identifying key targets.
[0106] For the k-th test, the reaction time from the appearance of the critical target to the controller's detection and identification is t. k(s); then the mean T of the key target identification reaction time is as follows:
[0107]
[0108] B i6 As a metric for measuring reaction time in key target identification, when the mean T does not exceed 4 seconds, B i6 The value is 1 if it is not 1, otherwise the value is 0.
[0109] Step S5: Output the comprehensive evaluation conclusion.
[0110] After completing the above theoretical analysis and human-loop testing, and obtaining the calculation results of each test item, an evaluation conclusion can be formed.
[0111] Based on theoretical analysis and the results of human-in-the-loop testing, the comprehensive impact index V is calculated. When V is 1, it means that the impact of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility is within an acceptable range and meets relevant operational requirements and specifications. When V is 0, further optimization suggestions such as blind spot mitigation measures can be proposed based on the specific impact situation.
[0112] Example 2
[0113] Based on Example 1, this example specifically introduces the evaluation system corresponding to the evaluation method, and the system composition structure is as follows: Figure 2 As shown.
[0114] An assessment system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability, the system comprising: a data acquisition module, a data processing module, a theoretical analysis module, a human-loop testing module, and a conclusion output module.
[0115] 1. Data acquisition module;
[0116] This module includes a basic data acquisition unit and a basic data transmission unit.
[0117] 1-1. Basic Data Acquisition Unit: Primarily used to manually collect and record basic data such as airport surface structure parameters, typical activity trajectory data of transport aircraft and general aviation aircraft, planning and design parameters of proposed buildings, physical structure parameters of the control tower, layout parameters of the control tower room, and line-of-sight parameters of controllers; the basic data is then stored in a storage medium.
[0118] 1-2. Basic data transmission unit; mainly used to transmit basic data from the storage medium to the evaluation system via a physical interface.
[0119] 2. Data processing module;
[0120] This module includes a feature extraction unit and a feature output unit.
[0121] 2-1. Feature Extraction Unit; mainly used to select feature points S within the reaction maneuver zone. μ The intercepted height above the ground is H A Typical transport aircraft arrival and departure track data TR below the value A Extract typical general aviation aircraft activity trajectory data (TR) within a specific distance from the building. G ; Transfer data TR A and data TR G waypoints as key targets for aircraft Selecting feature points J that characterize the building configuration μ From feature point J μ Select the center point J of the building on the horizontal plane. Z And two base points K1 and K2; select key points for the operation of the scene around the building.
[0122] 2-2. Feature Output Unit; mainly used for: outputting the airport surface altitude (M). A Airport reference point geographic coordinates G A Characteristic points S of the maneuvering zone μ Output the geographic coordinates of key targets and their distance from the airport surface. Output building feature points J μ Geographic coordinates and distance from the airport surface at altitude H J Output the building center point J Z Base points K1, K2 and base point angles α1, α2; output key points of the scene operation. Geographic coordinates; output tower reference point G A Geographic coordinates, distance H from the control tower to the airport surface T Number of control seats n, and geographical coordinates G of control seat i (controller's viewpoint number). i The average height H of the controller's line of sight from the control room floor C .
[0123] 3. Theoretical Analysis Module;
[0124] This module includes a calculation parameter setting unit and a theoretical calculation unit.
[0125] 3-1. Calculation parameter setting unit; mainly used to set corresponding calculation parameters by combining theoretical calculation models such as visibility of maneuvering area, visibility of key points, and visibility of key targets.
[0126] 3-2. Theoretical Calculation Unit: Primarily used to calculate the values of indicators such as visibility of the maneuvering area, visibility of key points, and visibility of key targets.
[0127] 4. Human-in-the-loop testing module;
[0128] This module includes a reality augmentation model building unit, a reality registration unit, a test execution unit, and a test recording unit.
[0129] 4-1. Augmented Reality Model Building Unit: This unit is mainly used to build a 3D model of the proposed building by combining the building's feature points, and then import the built 3D model into the Unity development platform to further build an augmented reality model.
[0130] 4-2. Reality Registration Unit: Primarily used to import the geographic coordinates of the center point of the proposed building and the altitude of the airport surface, locking the position of the augmented reality model; and to rotate the augmented reality model around the vertical axis of the building's center point. When the angle between the selected base point, the airport reference point, and the building's center point matches the corresponding data, the rotation stops, thus achieving the positioning and registration of the augmented reality model.
[0131] 4-3 Test Execution Unit; mainly used for: based on augmented reality technology, to recreate the proposed building on the control tower and display it on the control platform screen. The controller can then conduct multiple tests by controlling the control platform.
[0132] The test items include: visibility of the maneuvering area, visibility of key points, visibility of key targets, probability of detection of key targets, probability of recognition of key targets, and reaction time for recognition of key targets.
[0133] 4-4. Test Recording Unit; mainly used to record test data of various indicators during the testing process, automatically calculate and generate the corresponding B for each test item. i1 To B i6 Calculated values: When visual obstruction occurs during the test, or when the detection and recognition probability and reaction time do not meet the standards, the corresponding test index value is recorded as 0, and the visual obstruction area is captured; otherwise, the test index value is recorded as 1.
[0134] 5. Conclusion Output Module;
[0135] This module is mainly used to: when the comprehensive impact index is 1, provide an assessment conclusion that meets the actual operational needs and regulatory requirements of the airport; when the comprehensive impact index is 0, lock and present the indicators that are 0 in the theoretical analysis results and the human loop test results, and then combine the captured diagrams of line-of-sight obstruction in the maneuvering area, line-of-sight obstruction at key points, and line-of-sight obstruction at key targets to determine the blind spot filling measures to optimize the tower's visibility capability, which will be used as the assessment conclusion.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the impact of a proposed building on the tower visibility at an airport, characterized in that, The method includes the following steps: S1. Collect basic data of the target airport, process the basic data, and obtain various key point data; the key point data includes: characteristic points of the reaction maneuver zone, characteristic points representing the building configuration, key points of the operation of the scene around the building, the path points of key aircraft targets, and the viewpoint of the tower controller. S2. Construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability, determine the calculation indicators for the theoretical analysis stage and the human loop test stage, and determine the calculation formula for the comprehensive impact index of proposed airport buildings on the tower's visibility capability. S3. Construct a theoretical calculation model for the measurement indicators in the theoretical analysis stage; based on the key point data of the target airport, set the corresponding calculation parameters, conduct theoretical analysis, and obtain the theoretical analysis results; S4. For the calculation indicators of the human-loop test, based on the feature points representing the building configuration in the key point data, construct a three-dimensional model of the proposed building; build an augmented reality model based on the three-dimensional model; and conduct a human-loop test in the control tower of the target airport with the participation of air traffic controllers to obtain the human-loop test results. S5. Combining the theoretical analysis results with the results of human-in-the-loop test, output the comprehensive impact index of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility capability, and complete the visibility capability assessment process. In step S1, the basic data includes: airport surface structure parameters, typical activity trajectory data of transport aircraft and general aviation aircraft, planning and design parameters of the proposed building, tower physical structure parameters, tower control room layout parameters, and controller line of sight parameters; the acquisition process of multiple key point data is as follows: multiple key point data of the same type are indexed as the sorting sequence number; According to the airport scene structure parameters, derive the airport scene altitude , the airport reference point geographic coordinates , select the feature points of the reaction maneuver area range , output the geographic coordinates corresponding to the feature points; Based on the typical activity trajectory data of transport aircraft and general aviation aircraft, the typical transport aircraft approach and departure trajectory data with the height from the ground below ; Based on the planning and design parameters of the proposed building, select characteristic points that represent the building's configuration. Output the geographic coordinates of the building's feature points and their distance from the airport surface. From feature points Select the center point of the building on the horizontal plane. and 2 base points , Measure the base points respectively , Airport reference point and the center point of the building The angle between the lines connecting the two points is used as the base angle. , Simultaneously, based on the aircraft surface operations at the proposed building location, key points of the surface operations around the building are selected, and the critical points of surface operations are determined and output. Corresponding geographic coordinates; Output the tower reference point based on the tower's physical structure parameters. Geographic coordinates, distance from the control tower to the airport surface Based on the tower control room layout parameters and controller line-of-sight parameters, output the number of control positions. The controller's viewpoint number is Geographic coordinates of the control seat Average height of controllers' line of sight from the control room floor ; In step S2, the indexes in the comprehensive evaluation index system include: maneuvering area visibility, key point visibility, key target visibility, key target detection probability, key target identification probability, and key target identification reaction time length; and the determined comprehensive influence index The calculation formula of the comprehensive influence index is as follows: In the formula, To control the number of seats, The controller's viewpoint was assigned a number; the values of each indicator were calculated using two methods: theoretical analysis and human-based loop testing. to Based on theoretical analysis and calculation Item indicator value; to Based on human-based loop testing Item indicator value.
2. The method for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S3, a theoretical analysis is conducted. Taking the projection point of the controller's viewpoint on the designated control position onto the airport surface as the origin, a tower visibility assessment coordinate system parallel to the Gauss-Kruger projection coordinate axis is constructed from the origin based on the Gauss-Kruger projection theory. By combining the corresponding geographic coordinates and altitude information of each key point and feature point in the key point data, multiple key points and feature points are presented in the tower visibility assessment coordinate system, thereby constructing a theoretical calculation model; Then, based on each indicator in the comprehensive evaluation indicator system, corresponding theoretical calculations are carried out. The theoretical calculations include: visibility calculation of the maneuvering area, visibility calculation of key points, and visibility calculation of key targets.
3. The method for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 2, characterized in that: In step S4, the 3D model is imported into the Unity development platform to build an augmented reality model; Based on the geographic coordinates of the center point and the angle relationship of the base point of the 3D model, and combined with the corresponding planning and design parameters of the proposed building in the key point data, the proposed building model is restored on the control platform display screen using augmented reality technology. In the control tower of the target airport, controllers conduct multi-scenario human-in-the-loop tests on the control platform to intuitively determine whether the controller's view is obstructed by buildings, and comprehensively analyze and evaluate whether all indicators in the indicator system meet the actual operational needs of the airport.
4. The method for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step S5, the comprehensive impact index is calculated based on the formula, combining the theoretical analysis results with the human-in-the-loop test results. For each indicator in the comprehensive evaluation indicator system, its value is either 0 or 1. When the final calculated comprehensive impact index... A value of 1 indicates that the impact of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility is within an acceptable range.
5. The method for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 4, characterized in that: Based on the comprehensive impact index Based on the results of the assessment and the impact identified during the evaluation process, a diagram showing the visual obstruction of the proposed building was drawn, and measures to improve the tower's visibility were determined.
6. A system for assessing the impact of proposed airport buildings on control tower visibility, implementing the method of claim 1, characterized in that, The system includes: a data acquisition module, a data processing module, a theoretical analysis module, a human-loop testing module, and a conclusion output module; The data acquisition module is used to collect basic data of the target airport and store the basic data in a corresponding storage medium; the storage medium is used to transmit the basic data to the evaluation system. The data processing module is used for feature extraction and feature output of basic data, thereby processing the basic data into various key point data, including: feature points of the reaction maneuver zone, feature points representing the building configuration, key points of the operation of the scene around the building, path points of key aircraft targets, and tower controller viewpoints. The theoretical analysis module is used to perform theoretical calculations based on key point data. By setting corresponding calculation parameters, it calculates the index values of visibility of the maneuvering area, key point visibility, and key target visibility, which are used as the theoretical analysis results. The human-loop test module is used to construct an augmented reality model based on key point data and a 3D model of the proposed building, and to recreate the proposed building on the control tower using augmented reality technology and display it on the control platform screen. It is also used to provide human-loop test items for controllers as test subjects, record process data, and calculate the human-loop test results. The conclusion output module is used to combine theoretical analysis results with human loop test results to calculate and output the comprehensive impact index of the proposed airport building on the tower's visibility capability, and to draw an evaluation conclusion.
7. The assessment system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 6, characterized in that: The human-in-the-loop testing module includes a reality augmentation model construction unit, a reality registration unit, a test execution unit, and a test recording unit; The augmented reality model building unit is used to build a three-dimensional model of the proposed building, and further build an augmented reality model based on the three-dimensional model; The real-world registration unit is used to lock the position of the augmented reality model based on the feature points representing the building configuration in the key point data. When the data of the augmented reality model matches the corresponding data by rotating around the axis, the proposed building model is restored on the control platform display screen. The test execution unit is used to conduct tests on the visibility of the maneuvering area, the visibility of key points, the visibility of key targets, the probability of detection of key targets, the probability of recognition of key targets, and the reaction time of recognition of key targets. The test recording unit is used to record the process data of each test item during the loop test. When there is visual obstruction during the test, or when the detection and recognition probability and reaction time are not up to standard, the index value of the corresponding test item is recorded as 0 and the visual obstruction area is captured. Otherwise, the index value of the test item is recorded as 1.
8. The assessment system for the impact of proposed airport buildings on the control tower's visibility capability according to claim 6, characterized in that: The conclusion output module is also used to: when the comprehensive impact index is 1, give an assessment conclusion that meets the actual operation needs and standard requirements of the airport; when the comprehensive impact index is 0, lock and present the indicators that are 0 in the theoretical analysis results and the human loop test results, and then determine the blind spot filling measures to optimize the tower's visibility capability based on the visual obstruction diagram of the proposed building, as the assessment conclusion.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Aircraft accident prediction and three-dimensional visualization system
CN111091617A
Method for identifying operation intention of moving target on apron scene based on radar track construction
WO2020228228A1
