Adaptive enhancements for automated driving with map and camera issues
By comparing the curvature of map data and camera data in autonomous driving vehicles, identifying mismatch situations and adjusting confidence levels, the problem of mismatch between map data and camera data is solved, and the efficiency and reliability of the autonomous driving system are improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311380558.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-01
- Filing Date
- 2023-10-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, in autonomous driving vehicles, when map data and camera data do not match, manual identification of reasons is required, which leads to time-consuming and lacks an automatic correction mechanism.
By comparing the curvature in the camera data at the road location and map data, identifying mismatch situations, generating situation reports, and adjusting the confidence level of the data based on the report, determining rationality and escalation events, using the trajectory of human driving vehicles to compare with the data, Generate a situation report and exclude the impact of environmental conditions.
It realizes automatic identification of errors in map data and camera data, improves the accuracy and efficiency of data matching, reduces manual intervention, and improves the reliability of the autonomous driving system.
Smart Images

Figure CN119066438A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The subject disclosure relates to autonomous vehicles and, more particularly, to systems and methods for calibrating map data and / or camera data used in guiding an autonomous vehicle along a stretch of road. Background Art
[0002] Autonomous driving of a vehicle relies on map data and / or camera data to identify the direction of a road and the curvature of a road. When the camera data and the map data do not match each other at a given location, a technician is called in to manually identify the cause of the mismatch and come up with a solution to improve the integrity of the data. This reliance on technicians is time consuming. Therefore, it is desirable to provide a system that determines which of the map data and the camera data is erroneous and makes the necessary corrections. Summary of the invention
[0003] In an exemplary embodiment, a method of operating a vehicle is disclosed. Camera data of a road location is obtained, the camera data being used by the vehicle to traverse the location. Map data of the road location is obtained, the map data being used by the vehicle to traverse the location. A first curvature of the road at the location is determined based on the camera data. A second curvature of the road at the location is determined based on the map data. A mismatch between the first curvature and the second curvature of the road at the location is identified. When a mismatch occurs, a condition report is generated for one of the map data and the camera data at the location. Based on the condition report, one of a confidence level in the map data and the camera data is adjusted for the location.
[0004] In addition to one or more features described herein, the method also includes determining the rationality of one of the map data and the camera data by determining one of the following: a swing of one of the first curvature and the second curvature and an oscillation of one of the first curvature and the second curvature. The method also includes determining the occurrence of an upgrade event when one of the first curvature and the second curvature is determined to satisfy a rationality condition. The method also includes comparing the trajectory of a human-driven vehicle with the trajectory of one of the camera data and the map data at the location. The method also includes generating a situation report for each time a vehicle crosses the location. The method also includes generating a situation report for multiple vehicles crossing the location at different times. The method also includes excluding situation reports for camera data based on environmental conditions.
[0005] In another exemplary embodiment, a system for operating a vehicle is disclosed. The system includes a camera, a map database, and a processor. The camera is configured to obtain camera data of a location of a road that the vehicle is traversing. The map database is configured to provide map data of the road location. The processor is configured to determine a first curvature of the road at the location based on the camera data, determine a second curvature of the road at the location based on the map data, identify a mismatch between the first curvature and the second curvature at the road location, generate a condition report for one of the map data and the camera data at the location when a mismatch occurs, and adjust one of the confidence levels in the map data and the camera data for the location based on the condition report.
[0006] In addition to one or more features described herein, the processor is further configured to determine the rationality of one of the map data and the camera data by determining one of the following: a swing of one of the first curvature and the second curvature and an oscillation of one of the first curvature and the second curvature. The processor is also configured to determine the occurrence of an upgrade event when one of the first curvature and the second curvature is determined to meet the rationality condition. The processor is also configured to compare the trajectory of the human-driven vehicle with the trajectory of one of the camera data and the map data at the location. The processor is also configured to generate a situation report each time the vehicle passes through the location. The processor is also configured to generate a situation report for multiple vehicles passing through the location at different times. The processor is also configured to exclude situation reports for camera data based on environmental conditions.
[0007] In yet another exemplary embodiment, a vehicle is disclosed. The vehicle includes a camera, a map database, and a processor. The camera is configured to obtain camera data of a location of a road that the vehicle is traversing. The map database is configured to provide map data of the road location. The processor is configured to determine a first curvature of the road at the location based on the camera data, determine a second curvature of the road at the location based on the map data, identify a mismatch between the first curvature and the second curvature at the road location, generate a condition report for one of the map data and the camera data at the location when a mismatch occurs, and adjust one of the confidence levels in the map data and the camera data for the location based on the condition report.
[0008] In addition to one or more features described herein, the processor is further configured to determine the plausibility of one of the map data and the camera data by determining one of the following: a swing of one of the first curvature and the second curvature and an oscillation of one of the first curvature and the second curvature. The processor is further configured to determine the occurrence of an upgrade event when one of the first curvature and the second curvature is determined to satisfy a plausibility condition. The processor is further configured to compare a trajectory of a human-driven vehicle with a trajectory of one of the camera data and the map data at the location. The processor is further configured to generate a situation report each time a vehicle crosses the location. The processor is further configured to generate a situation report for multiple vehicles crossing the location at different times.
[0009] The above features and advantages and other features and advantages of the present disclosure will become apparent from the following detailed description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0010] Other features, advantages and details appear, by way of example only, in the following detailed description, which refers to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0011] Figure 1 A vehicle capable of operating in an autonomous mode or a cruise control mode is shown according to an exemplary embodiment;
[0012] Figure 2 A flow chart of a method for enhancing autonomous driving in an embodiment is shown;
[0013] Figure 3 A flow chart showing a method for identifying problems in enhancing the use of map data and camera data in enhanced driving;
[0014] Figure 4 A timeline diagram showing a vehicle trajectory following a selected data set in an embodiment;
[0015] Figure 5 A timeline graph showing a vehicle trajectory following a selected data set in another embodiment is shown;
[0016] Figure 6 A flow chart showing a method for determining plausibility of curvature oscillation of a trajectory;
[0017] Figure 7 A flow chart showing a method of determining the plausibility of curvature oscillations;
[0018] Figure 8 showing a first curvature of a trajectory of a human-driven vehicle and a second curvature of a trajectory based on a data set; and
[0019] Fig. 9 A flow chart illustrating a method of position analysis is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] The following description is merely exemplary in nature and is not intended to limit the present disclosure, its application, or uses. It should be understood that throughout the drawings, corresponding reference numerals indicate the same or corresponding parts and features.
[0021] According to an exemplary embodiment, Figure 1 A vehicle 100 is shown that can operate in an autonomous mode or a cruise control mode. The vehicle 100 includes a drive system 102 that controls the movement of the vehicle along a section of road. The drive system 102 may include a camera 104 that obtains information about the surrounding environment of the vehicle 100, including the road on which the vehicle is moving. The drive system 102 also includes a map database 108 that provides a map of the section of road that the vehicle is traversing. The vehicle 100 may obtain map data and camera data. The vehicle includes a controller 106 that performs various calculations using one or more of the map data and the camera data to operate the vehicle.
[0022] The controller 106 may include processing circuitry, which may include an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), an electronic circuit, a processor (shared, dedicated, or group) executing one or more software or firmware programs and a memory, a combinational logic circuit, and / or other suitable components that provide the functionality described. The controller 106 may include a non-transitory computer-readable medium storing instructions that, when processed by one or more processors of the controller 106, implement a method for determining a difference between map data and camera data, and adjusting parameters related to the map data or the camera data for subsequent use. The method includes selecting one of the map data and the camera data to create a trajectory for the vehicle, and maneuvering the vehicle along the trajectory.
[0023] The vehicle 100 may also include a communication unit 110 that allows the controller 106 to communicate with a map server 120. In an alternative embodiment, map data may be received from a map database 108, and calculations at the controller 106 may be transmitted to the map database for implementation.
[0024] Figure 2 A flowchart 200 of a method for enhancing autonomous driving in an embodiment is shown. At block 202, data is obtained at the vehicle 100 for autonomous driving of the vehicle. The data includes camera data obtained from the camera 104 and map data from the map database 108 or the map server 120.
[0025] At block 204 , a first curvature of the road at a selected location of the road is determined based on the map data, and a second curvature of the road at the selected location is determined based on the camera data.
[0026] At block 206, the first curvature and the second curvature are compared to each other to determine if there is a mismatch between them. When the first curvature and the second curvature differ from each other by an amount less than a match threshold (i.e., the curvatures match), the method may return to block 202 where a new data set is obtained from the map database 108 and the camera 104. If the first curvature and the second curvature differ from each other by an amount greater than a match threshold (i.e., the curvatures do not match), the method proceeds to block 208.
[0027] At box 208, the rationality of each of the first curvature and the second curvature may be checked. The rationality of the curvature is determined by quantifying the swing or oscillation of the road curvature into a value and then comparing the value with a threshold. If the value of the first curvature (i.e., map data) or the second curvature (i.e., camera data) is greater than the threshold, their curvatures are determined to be unreasonable. If the value is greater than the threshold, the method proceeds to box 210. Otherwise, if the value is less than or equal to the threshold, the method proceeds to box 212.
[0028] Referring first to box 210, a situation report is generated for the unreasonable data set. Each time the location is crossed, a situation report is generated. This may include each time the same vehicle crosses the location, or may include multiple vehicles crossing the location, or both. At box 222, situation reports associated with the location or section of the road are accumulated and counted. From box 222, the method proceeds to box 224 or box 226. If there are a large number of situation reports for the map data (i.e., greater than a threshold). The method proceeds to box 224. If there are a large number of situation reports for the camera data, the method proceeds to box 226.
[0029] At box 224, the map is updated with the corrected map of the location or segment of the road. At box 226, external environmental conditions that may have an impact on the data are checked. In addition, nighttime viewing, rainy weather, etc. can cause poor camera data quality, even for cameras in good condition. These data are related to environmental conditions. At box 228, the camera confidence level for the road segment is reduced or adjusted based on the environmental conditions.
[0030] Referring now to box 212, the camera data is reviewed to determine if an upgrade event occurred at the same time as the curvature mismatch. For example, an illustrative upgrade event includes a lane touch event. If the upgrade event did not occur at the same time as the curvature mismatch, the method proceeds to box 214. Otherwise, the method proceeds to box 218 for position analysis.
[0031] At box 214, the trajectory of the human-driven vehicle is compared to the map data and the camera data to determine whether the human-driven vehicle follows the map data or the camera data or is substantially aligned with the map data or the camera data. At box 216, data sets that are not followed by the human-driven vehicle are marked as potentially incorrect data. From box 216, the method proceeds to box 222 for position analysis.
[0032] Returning to block 218, it is determined whether a curvature mismatch occurs after the upgrade event. If a mismatch does occur after the upgrade event, the method proceeds to block 214. Otherwise, the method proceeds to block 220. At block 220, the number of map data instances and the number of camera data instances are identified. From block 220, the method proceeds to block 222.
[0033] Figure 3 A flow chart 300 of a method for identifying problems with the enhanced use of map data and camera data is shown. The method begins at box 302, where a mismatch occurs in a first curvature at a location in a road based on map data at the road location and a second curvature at a location in the road based on camera data. At box 304, the first curvature and the second curvature are compared to various reasonableness thresholds to determine whether the curvature is reasonable or unreasonable. At box 306, a decision is made based on the results of the calculations performed at box 304. If the first curvature (map data) is unreasonable, the method proceeds to box 308. If the second curvature (camera data) is unreasonable, the method proceeds to box 310. If both the first curvature and the second curvature are reasonable, the method proceeds to box 320.
[0034] At box 308 (first curvature is unreasonable), a situation report is generated indicating a potential map problem. At box 310 (second curvature is unreasonable), a situation report is generated indicating a potential camera problem. At box 312, a location is identified with a large number of situation reports. When there is a potential map problem (i.e., a large number of situation reports for map data), the method proceeds from box 312 to box 314. At box 314, the map database is updated for the location. From box 314, the method proceeds to box 330, where the method ends.
[0035] Referring again to block 312, when there is a potential camera problem (i.e., a large number of condition reports of the camera data), the method proceeds to block 316. At block 316, the effect of weather conditions on the camera data is taken into account. At block 318, the confidence level of the camera data is adjusted (or lowered) based on the camera data problem and the effect of weather conditions on the camera data. From block 318, the method proceeds to block 330, where the method ends.
[0036] Referring now to box 320, when both the map data and the camera data are determined to be reasonable, the processor determines whether an escalation event has occurred. If an escalation event has not occurred, the method proceeds to box 322. At box 322, data indicating the path of the human-driven vehicle is compared to the map data and the camera data to determine whether the human-driven vehicle is following the map data or the camera data. If the path of the human-driven vehicle is aligned with the camera data, the method proceeds to box 308. If the path of the human-driven vehicle is aligned with the map data, the method proceeds to box 310. Separately, if the path of the human-driven vehicle is not aligned with the map data or the camera data, the method proceeds to box 328, where further analysis is requested.
[0037] Returning to box 320, if an upgrade event has occurred, the method proceeds to box 324. In box 324, the data is checked to determine whether a curvature mismatch occurred after the upgrade event. If a curvature mismatch exists after the upgrade, the method proceeds to box 322. If there is no curvature mismatch after the upgrade event, the method proceeds to box 326. In box 326, the map data and camera data are reviewed to determine whether a curvature change has occurred in the map data or the camera data. If a curvature change occurs in the map data, the method proceeds to box 308. If a curvature change occurs in the camera data, the method proceeds to box 310. If no change occurs in either the camera data or the map data, the method proceeds to box 328. In box 328, further analysis is requested and / or performed. From box 328, the method proceeds to box 330, where the method ends.
[0038] Figure 4 A timeline graph 400 of a vehicle trajectory 402 following a selected data set is shown. Time in seconds (s) is shown along the abscissa and amplitude (A) is shown along the ordinate axis. A portion of the trajectory 402 can be isolated using a sliding window 404, and the curvature within the sliding window can be analyzed. In an embodiment, the oscillation of the curvature can be checked to see if it is reasonable.
[0039] To analyze the swing, three curvature amplitudes are determined. The first curvature amplitude (Curv A ) is the curvature of the rear part of the sliding window. The second curvature amplitude (Curv B ) is the curvature with the highest value in the sliding window. The third curvature magnitude (Curv C ) is the curvature in front of the sliding window. By comparing the curvature with various amplitude-based conditions (as shown in equations (1)-(4)), the plausibility of the swing can be determined. The change in curvature between any two curvatures can be compared with a relative threshold, as shown in equation (1):
[0040] |Curv1-Curv2|>max|Curv|*Threl Equation (1)
[0041] where the index (1,2) can be (A,B) or (B,C), Curv is a dataset of all curvature values, and Th rel is a relative threshold that can be determined in advance. The change in curvature can also be compared with an absolute threshold, as shown in equations (2) and (3):
[0042] |Curv A -Curv B |>Th abs Equation (2)
[0043] |Curv B -Curv C |>Th abs Equation (3)
[0044] In addition, check whether the product of the curvature change is positive or negative, as shown in equation (4):
[0045] (Curv A -Curv B )*(Curv B -Curv C )<0 Equation (4)
[0046] When all equations (1)-(4) are satisfied for a data set, the curvature of the data set is considered unreasonable.
[0047] Figure 5 A timeline graph 500 of a vehicle trajectory 502 following a selected data set in another embodiment is shown. Time in seconds (s) is shown along the abscissa and amplitude (A) is shown along the ordinate axis. A portion of the trajectory 502 may be isolated by a sliding window 404. Oscillations of curvature may be calculated.
[0048] To analyze the oscillation, three curvature amplitudes are determined. The first curvature amplitude (Curv A ) is the point with the local minimum curvature value in the sliding window. The second curvature magnitude (Curv B ) is the curvature with the highest curvature value in the sliding window. The third curvature magnitude (Curv C ) is the curvature at the inflection point in the curvature after the magnitude of the second curvature. The plausibility of the oscillation can be determined by comparing the curvature to various conditions based on the magnitude (as shown in equations (5)-(8)). The change in curvature between any two curvatures can be compared to a relative threshold as shown in equation (5):
[0049] |Curv1-Curv2|>max|Curv|*Th rel Equation (5)
[0050] The change in curvature can also be compared to an absolute threshold, as shown in equations (6) and (7):
[0051] |Curv A -Curv B |>Th abs / 2 Equation (6)
[0052] |Curv B -Curv C |>Th abs / 2 Equation (7)
[0053] In addition, check whether the product of the curvature change is positive or negative, as shown in equation (8):
[0054] (Curv A -Curv B )*(Curv B -Curv C )<0 Equation (8)
[0055] Additionally, the traces were examined to determine whether the same pattern occurred within 10-s intervals.
[0056] Figure 6 A flow chart 600 of a method for determining curvature swing plausibility is shown. The method begins at box 602. At box 604, a sliding window is identified. If a sliding window with a preselected duration cannot be identified, the method proceeds to box 610. In the illustrative embodiment, the preselected duration is 3 seconds. At box 610, an output is generated indicating that there is no curvature swing. The method then proceeds to box 614, where the method ends.
[0057] Returning to block 604, if a sliding window is identified, then the curvature point can be located and tested as the method proceeds to block 606. Otherwise, the method returns to block 604. At block 606, a first curvature (Curv A ) and the second curvature (Curv B ). If equation (2) and equation (1) satisfy the first curvature and the second curvature, the method proceeds to box 608. Otherwise, the method returns to box 604. At box 608, a third curvature (Curv C ). If equation (3), equation (1) satisfies the second curvature and the third curvature, and equation (4) is satisfied, the method proceeds to block 612. Otherwise, the method returns to block 604. At block 612, an output is generated indicating the presence of curvature oscillation.
[0058] Figure 7A flow chart 700 of a method for determining the plausibility of curvature oscillations is shown. The method begins at box 702. At box 704, a sliding window is identified. If a sliding window with a preselected duration cannot be identified, the method proceeds to box 712. At box 712, an output indicating that there are no curvature oscillations is generated. The method then proceeds to box 716, where the method ends.
[0059] Returning to block 704, if a sliding window is identified, a curvature point may be located and tested as the method proceeds to block 706. At block 706, a first curvature (Curv A ) and the second curvature (Curv B ). If equation (6) and equation (5) satisfy the first curvature and the second curvature, the method proceeds to box 708. Otherwise, the method returns to box 704. At box 708, a third curvature (Curv C ). If equation (7), equation (5) satisfies the second curvature and the third curvature and equation (8) is satisfied, the method proceeds to box 710. Otherwise, the method returns to box 704. At box 710, a check is made to determine whether another portion of the timeline satisfies these conditions within the 10 second window. If the conditions are satisfied within the 10 second window, the method proceeds to box 714. Otherwise, the method returns to box 704. At box 714, an output is generated indicating the presence of curvature oscillation.
[0060] Figure 8 A first curvature 802 of a trajectory of a human driven vehicle and a second curvature 804 of a trajectory based on a data set (from map data or camera data) are shown. Time (t) is shown along the abscissa and curvature (C) is shown along the ordinate axis. These curvatures can be compared to determine whether the vehicle follows the data set. With reference to the first curvature 802, curvature values CV0, CV1, ..., CVn are calculated at certain intervals over a sampling period ΔS. Similar curvature values (second curvature 804) include curvature values CM0, CM1, ..., CMn of the map data and / or curvature values CC0, CC1, ..., CCn of the camera data, which are calculated at the same intervals as the human driven vehicle. The area sum of the vehicle data is shown in equation (9):
[0061] SV=(Cv0+CV1+…+CVn)*ΔS Equation (9)
[0062] Similarly, the area sum of the map data is shown in equation (10):
[0063] SM=(CM0+CM1+…+CMn)*ΔS Equation (10)
[0064] And the area sum of the camera data is as shown in equation (11):
[0065] SC=(CC0+CC1+…+CCn)*ΔS Equation (11)
[0066] The difference between the vehicle curvature and the map data curvature is calculated as follows:
[0067] D1=SV-SM Equation (12)
[0068] And the difference between the vehicle curvature and the camera data curvature is calculated by:
[0069] D2=SV-SC Equation (13)
[0070] if:
[0071] D2-D1≥Th Curv Equation (14)
[0072] Among them, Th Curv is a calibratable threshold that can be determined at design time, then the vehicle follows the map data. Otherwise, if:
[0073] D1-D2≥Th Curv Equation (15)
[0074] Then the vehicle is following the camera data.
[0075] Fig. 9 A flowchart 900 illustrating a method of position analysis is shown (eg, Figure 2 Box 222 or Figure 3 The method starts at frame 902. At frame 904, the cases are organized to be placed in case order. At frame 906, the cases are checked to see if there is a pair of unprocessed cases. If there is no unprocessed case, the method proceeds to frame 916, where the method ends.
[0076] If there is an unprocessed case, the method proceeds to box 908. At box 908, the distance is compared to the distance threshold. If the distance is less than the distance threshold, the method returns to box 906. Otherwise, the method proceeds to box 910. The distance can be determined using the following formula:
[0077]
[0078] in, and are the latitude of point 1 and the latitude of point 2, respectively, and λ1 and λ2 are the longitude of point 1 and the longitude of point 2, respectively.
[0079] At box 910, the cases are checked to see if they are associated with the same VIN (vehicle identification number) and the same date. If they are associated, the method returns to box 906. Otherwise, the method proceeds to box 912. At box 912, the cases are compared to see if they are from the same side of the road. If they are not from the same side of the road, the method returns to box 906. Otherwise, the method proceeds to box 914. At box 914, the two cases are placed in the same group. If no existing group can accommodate both cases, a new group is created.
[0080] The terms "one" and "an" do not indicate a limitation of quantity, but rather indicate the presence of at least one of the referenced items. The term "or" means "and / or", unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. References to "an aspect" throughout the specification mean that a particular element (e.g., feature, structure, step, or characteristic) described in conjunction with that aspect is included in at least one aspect described herein, and may or may not be present in other aspects. In addition, it should be understood that the described elements may be combined in any suitable manner in various aspects.
[0081] When an element such as a layer, film, region, or substrate is referred to as being “on” another element, it can be directly on the other element or intervening elements may also be present. In contrast, when an element is referred to as being “directly on” another element, there are no intervening elements present.
[0082] Unless otherwise indicated herein, all test standards are the most recent standards in effect as of the filing date of the present application or, if priority is claimed, the filing date of the earliest priority application in which the test standards appear.
[0083] Unless defined otherwise, technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this disclosure belongs.
[0084] Although the above disclosure has been described with reference to exemplary embodiments, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for its elements without departing from the scope thereof. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt specific situations or materials to the teachings of the disclosure without departing from the essential scope of the disclosure. Therefore, it is intended that the disclosure is not limited to the specific embodiments disclosed, but will include all embodiments falling within its scope.
Claims
1. A method of operating a vehicle, comprising: obtaining camera data of a road location, the camera data being used by a vehicle to traverse the location; obtaining map data of a road location, the map data being used by the vehicle to traverse the location; determining a first curvature of the road at the location based on the camera data; determining a second curvature of the road at the location based on the map data; identifying a mismatch between a first curvature and a second curvature at the road location; When a mismatch occurs, generating a situation report for one of the map data and the camera data at the location; as well as Based on the situation report, one of the confidence levels in the map data and the camera data is adjusted for the location.
2. The method of claim 1 , further comprising determining the plausibility of one of the map data and the camera data by determining one of: (i) a swing of one of the first curvature and the second curvature; and (ii) an oscillation of one of the first curvature and the second curvature. 3 . The method according to claim 1 , further comprising determining the occurrence of an upgrade event when one of the first curvature and the second curvature is determined to satisfy a rationality condition. 4 . The method of claim 1 , further comprising comparing a trajectory of a human-driven vehicle to a trajectory of one of camera data and map data at the location.
5. The method of claim 1 further comprising generating the situation report for one of: (i) each time a vehicle traverses the location; and (ii) multiple vehicles traversing the location at different times.
6. A system for operating a vehicle, comprising: a camera configured to obtain camera data of a location of a road that the vehicle is traversing; a map database configured to provide map data of road locations; Processor, which is configured as: determining a first curvature of the road at the location based on the camera data; determining a second curvature of the road at the location based on the map data; identifying a mismatch between a first curvature and a second curvature at the road location; When a mismatch occurs, generating a situation report for one of the map data and the camera data at the location; as well as Based on the situation report, one of the confidence levels in the map data and the camera data is adjusted for the location.
7. The system according to claim 6, wherein: The processor is further configured to determine plausibility of one of the map data and the camera data by determining one of: (i) a wiggle of one of the first curvature and the second curvature; and (ii) an oscillation of one of the first curvature and the second curvature.
8. The system according to claim 6, wherein: The processor is further configured to determine the occurrence of an upgrade event when one of the first curvature and the second curvature is determined to satisfy a rationality condition.
9. The system according to claim 6, wherein: The processor is also configured to compare a trajectory of the human-driven vehicle to a trajectory of one of the camera data and the map data at the location.
10. The system according to claim 6, wherein: The processor is also configured to generate the situation report for one of: (i) each time a vehicle traverses the location; and (ii) when multiple vehicles traverse the location at different times.
