Reinforcement Planning Methods and Systems for Flexible Power Generation and Transmission Systems to Adapt to Unexpected Impacts of Ice Storms
By employing bibliometric optimization techniques and fuzzy set modeling, a reinforcement planning method for resilient power generation and transmission systems adapted to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms was constructed. This method addresses the uncertainties of unexpected transmission line failures and wind power output losses, achieving both system resilience enhancement and economic efficiency under ice storm conditions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611265095.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-08-20
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies lack modeling for the uncertainties of unexpected transmission line failures and unexpected wind power output losses during ice storms, making it difficult for traditional extended planning schemes to maintain continuous power supply and achieve rapid recovery during disasters, and posing risks of large-scale outages or performance degradation.
By employing the sub-Blu-rod optimization technique, a fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines and unexpected power output losses in wind power is constructed. A sub-Blu-rod differentiated reinforcement planning model for a resilient power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure is established. The model is solved by a layered iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to coordinate the relationship between reinforcement decisions and the investment cost of energy storage configuration and the system's elastic performance.
It has achieved an enhanced resilience of the power transmission system under ice storm conditions, reduced the risk of wasted investment, balanced economic efficiency with disaster resilience, effectively avoided the problems of increased investment costs and insufficient information utilization caused by excessive conservatism, and enhanced the system's robustness in dealing with extreme and severe scenarios.
Smart Images

Figure CN123121540A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning technology, specifically to a flexible power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method and system that adapts to the unexpected impact of ice storms. Background Technology
[0002] Power transmission and generation systems not only need to cope with the foreseeable impacts of ice storms, but also face uncertainties arising from the spatiotemporal evolution of these storms. These uncertainties manifest as abnormally high line failure rates and unexpected wind power output losses due to the influence of disaster-causing factors. These uncertainties make it difficult for systems under traditional extended planning schemes to maintain continuous power supply and achieve rapid recovery during disasters, exacerbating the risk of large-scale outages or severe performance degradation. Therefore, to further improve the adaptability of power transmission and generation systems to unexpected disaster impacts under uncertain environments, it is necessary to conduct differentiated reinforcement of weak links in the power transmission and generation system based on existing extended planning and acceptable economic costs. Current technical solutions lack a solution for modeling the uncertainties of unexpected transmission line failures and unexpected wind power output losses under ice storms, and for establishing a resilient power transmission and generation system reinforcement planning model that takes these uncertainties into account. Summary of the Invention
[0003] To address the aforementioned shortcomings in existing technologies, this invention provides a method and system for reinforcing and planning flexible power generation and transmission systems to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms.
[0004] According to a first aspect of the present invention, a method for reinforcing and planning a resilient power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms is provided, comprising: Based on the bibliometric optimization technique, this paper describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line failure rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected fault decisions of transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set for unexpected output loss of wind power. Based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in the transmission line and the uncertain set of unexpected output loss of wind power, and considering the reinforcement measures of transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a flexible power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure is constructed. A layered iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm is used to solve the reinforcement planning model, resulting in a power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elastic advancement improvement requirements under ice storm weather.
[0005] According to a second aspect of the present invention, a resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning system for adapting to the unintended impacts of ice storms is provided, comprising: The uncertainty set construction module, based on the bibliometric optimization technique, describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line failure rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected fault decision dependence of transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set of unexpected output loss of wind power. The reinforcement planning model construction module is based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults of the transmission line and the uncertain set of unexpected output loss of wind power. It considers the reinforcement measures of transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather and constructs a differentiated reinforcement planning model of the elastic power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure. The model solving module uses a hierarchical iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to solve the reinforcement planning model and obtain a power transmission and distribution system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elastic advancement improvement requirements under ice storm weather.
[0006] By adopting the above technical solution, the present invention has at least one of the following beneficial effects compared with the prior art: This invention models the dual uncertainties of unexpected transmission line failures and unexpected wind power output losses under ice storms in the reinforcement planning of power generation and transmission systems. This enables the reinforcement scheme to not only cope with expected failure scenarios, but also adapt to unpredictable risks caused by the spatiotemporal evolution of disaster characteristics.
[0007] This invention constructs an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on the characteristics of the reinforcement decision-dependent design and the optimization of the design, so that the reinforcement decision can accurately characterize the impact of the fault rate.
[0008] This invention solves a sub-Bruker reinforcement planning model with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure, coordinating the relationship between the investment cost of differentiated reinforcement of transmission lines and energy storage configuration and the cost of system elastic performance loss, and obtains a reinforcement planning scheme that takes into account both economy and disaster resistance under the constraint of reinforcement investment budget.
[0009] Compared to traditional stochastic programming and bibliometric bar programming based solely on moment information, the bibliometric bar reinforcement programming method based on unexpected fault enhancement fuzzy sets in this invention can utilize historical sample data to mine fault distribution characteristics, reducing the risk of investment waste due to excessive conservatism and insufficient flexibility due to insufficient information utilization under the unexpected impact of disasters, and achieving a balance between the economic efficiency of planning investment and the flexibility of power generation and transmission systems.
[0010] This invention fully considers the dependence of transmission line failure rate uncertainty on reinforcement decisions in the construction of fuzzy sets, and can accurately characterize the changes in line vulnerability after taking different levels of reinforcement measures, thereby guiding the planning scheme to carry out efficient and differentiated reinforcement of weak links.
[0011] This invention increases the failure rate deviation coefficient and the Wasserstein sphere radius confidence level, thereby expanding the coverage of the fuzzy set and incorporating more extreme failure probability distribution scenarios. This prompts the planning model to choose a more conservative line reinforcement and energy storage configuration scheme to avoid high risks, effectively preventing the problem of rising investment costs and load losses.
[0012] This invention utilizes energy storage power stations to compensate for the limitations of line reinforcement in dealing with network topology damage, and employs differentiated reinforcement strategies to avoid severe losses caused by the concurrent occurrence of expected and unexpected faults. The combination of the two takes into account both the robustness of reinforcement planning strategies in dealing with extreme and harsh scenarios and the economy of planning investment. Attached Figure Description
[0013] Other features, objects, and advantages of this application will become more apparent from the following detailed description of non-limiting embodiments with reference to the accompanying drawings: Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating the workflow of a preferred embodiment of the present invention for a resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method to adapt to the unexpected impact of ice storms.
[0014] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the impact of different levels of reinforcement measures on the failure rate of transmission lines in a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0015] Figure 3 This is a framework diagram of the planning model for the reinforcement of the distribution rod in a flexible power transmission system according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0016] Figure 4 This is the solution process for the sub-Bruker reinforcement planning model based on a nested column and constraint generation algorithm in a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0017] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram of the constituent modules of a flexible power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning system adapted to the unexpected impact of ice storms in a preferred embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0018] The present application will now be described in detail with reference to specific embodiments. These embodiments will help those skilled in the art to further understand the present application, but do not limit the present application in any way. It should be noted that those skilled in the art can make several modifications and improvements without departing from the concept of the present application, and these all fall within the protection scope of the present application. Parts not described in detail in the following embodiments can be implemented using existing technology.
[0019] Existing technical solutions lack a method to model the uncertainties of unexpected transmission line failures and unexpected wind power output losses under ice storms, and to establish a reinforcement planning model for resilient power generation and transmission systems that takes into account the aforementioned uncertainties.
[0020] To address the aforementioned issues, one embodiment of the present invention provides a resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms. The planning model constructed by this method is geared towards the resilient advancement of power generation and transmission systems under ice storm scenarios, and takes into account the dual uncertainties of transmission line faults and wind power output losses under ice storm weather.
[0021] Specifically, such as Figure 1 As shown in the embodiment, the resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method for adapting to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms provided may include: S1, based on the sub-Bruker optimization technique, describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. At the same time, it considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line fault rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected fault decisions for transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set of unexpected output losses for wind power. S2, based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines and the uncertain set of unexpected output losses in wind power, considering reinforcement measures for transmission lines and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, constructs a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a flexible power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure. S3 employs a layered iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to solve the reinforcement planning model, thereby obtaining a reinforcement planning scheme for the power generation and transmission system that meets the requirements for resilient advancement under ice storm weather.
[0022] In some preferred embodiments, S1 above, based on the sub-Bruker optimization technique, describes the uncertainty of unexpected transmission line faults under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line fault rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected transmission line fault decisions, and establishes an uncertainty set for unexpected wind power output losses. It may further include: S11, based on an adaptive two-stage sub-Bruker optimization model, sets the unexpected failure rate deviation of transmission lines and constructs a fuzzy set of unexpected failures of transmission lines based on moment information, which is used to describe the uncertainty of unexpected failures of transmission lines under ice disaster scenarios. S12, Based on the fuzzy set of unexpected faults of transmission lines based on moment information, the confidence interval based on Wasserstein distance is used as a statistical distance constraint to construct an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults of transmission lines that incorporates Wasserstein distance. S13, the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on transmission line failure rate is reflected in the moment information to obtain the transmission line failure rate interval used to characterize the impact of different levels of reinforcement decisions on the uncertainty of line failure; based on the enhanced fuzzy set and the transmission line failure rate interval, a decision-dependent enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected transmission line failures is constructed. S14. The wind power output loss budget in the expected transmission line fault scenario is taken as the expected output loss, and the output loss after considering uncertainty is taken as the unexpected output loss. The uncertainty of the unexpected wind power output loss is characterized by the robust box uncertainty set, and the uncertainty set of the unexpected wind power output loss is obtained.
[0023] In some preferred embodiments, S2 above, based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines and the uncertain set of unexpected output losses in wind power, and considering reinforcement measures for transmission line strengthening and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, constructs a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a resilient power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure, which may further include: S21. Based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected transmission line faults and the uncertain set of unexpected wind power output losses, a two-stage, three-layer model framework for a differentiated reinforcement planning model of a resilient power generation and transmission system is established. The fuzzy set serves as the feasible region for the middle-level model to search for the worst-case fault state; it also serves as the optimization space for calculating the expected worst-case probability distribution in the objective function; and it outputs the worst-case line fault state for use in lower-level operational constraints. The uncertain set serves as the feasible region for the middle-level model to search for the worst-case output loss state; it outputs the worst-case output loss state for use in wind farm output constraints; and it is jointly optimized with line faults in the worst-case search of the objective function.
[0024] S22, considering the reinforcement planning investment measures for transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, the objective function of the differentiated reinforcement planning model of the flexible power generation and transmission system is to minimize the sum of reinforcement planning investment cost and system elastic performance loss cost; S23, Considering the uncertainty of unexpected faults in transmission lines and the uncertainty of unexpected power loss in wind power, establish the constraints of the differentiated reinforcement planning model of the flexible power generation and transmission system. S24. Through the above steps, the final elastic power generation and transmission system differential reinforcement planning model with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure is constructed.
[0025] In some preferred embodiments, the above-mentioned S21, the two-stage, three-layer model framework, may further include: The first stage corresponds to the upper-level model, with the goal of minimizing the sum of the investment cost of the reinforcement plan and the cost of the loss of system elasticity performance, and then passing the planning decision scheme to the second-stage model; The second stage corresponds to the middle and lower layer models. First, the middle layer model, based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected transmission line faults and the uncertainty set of unexpected wind power output loss, reveals the dual uncertainty of line fault uncertainty and output loss uncertainty under ice storm weather. By maximizing the cost of elastic performance loss, it finds the worst line fault situation and wind power output loss. Then, the probability distribution of the worst line unexpected faults, fault states, and worst wind power output loss states affected by the transmission line reinforcement decision are passed to the lower layer model. The lower layer model conducts operation simulation based on planning decisions and uncertainty revelation, responds to the results of the worst uncertainty revelation, and then makes an operation decision scheme that adapts to uncertainty.
[0026] In some preferred embodiments, the objective function in step S22 above may further include: The system resilience performance loss cost is calculated based on the worst-case probability distribution of unexpected line failures and unexpected wind power output loss conditions. The investment cost for the reinforcement plan includes: the cost of reinforcing transmission lines and the cost of configuring grid-side energy storage; among which, the reinforcement of transmission lines includes a first reinforcement measure and a second reinforcement measure. The first reinforcement measure is used to reinforce lines with anticipated faults, and the second reinforcement measure is used to reinforce lines with anticipated faults and lines with unintended faults; the configuration of grid-side energy storage is used to provide emergency power support and rapid recovery support.
[0027] In some preferred embodiments, the above-mentioned constraint S23 may further include: Investment limits for power transmission line reinforcement are used to set an upper limit on the investment budget for power transmission line reinforcement. Node power balancing is used to ensure that the active power injection and outflow of each bus node remain balanced at all times, satisfying Kirchhoff's current law. The DC power flow equation for transmission lines is used to describe the relationship between the active power flow of each transmission line and the phase angle difference of the voltage at both ends of the bus based on the DC power flow model. Transmission line capacity is used to limit the active power transmitted by each transmission line from exceeding its thermal stability limit capacity. Conventional unit combination is used to determine the start-up and shutdown status, start-up actions and shutdown actions of each conventional unit, and to meet the minimum start-up and shutdown time constraints of the units; The output of conventional units is used to limit the active power output of each conventional unit within its technical output upper and lower limits. The logical relationship of the operating status of conventional units is used to describe the logical consistency constraints between the start-up and shutdown status, start-up actions and shutdown actions of conventional units; The ramp / down ramp rate of conventional units is used to limit the upward and downward adjustment of the active power output of conventional units between adjacent time periods from not exceeding their ramp capacity limit. The system's spinning reserve capacity is used to ensure that the positive and negative spinning reserve capacity configured in the system is not less than the minimum reserve requirement needed to cope with uncertainties such as load forecast deviations and unit outages; Wind farm output is used to limit the actual grid-connected power of a wind farm from not exceeding its maximum output available based on wind speed conditions, and takes into account the impact of unexpected output loss factors. The output of a photovoltaic power station is used to limit the actual grid-connected power of a photovoltaic power station from not exceeding its maximum output available based on sunlight conditions. The operation of energy storage power stations is used to constrain the charging and discharging power, state of charge, and energy timing relationship of energy storage power stations, so as to ensure that energy storage does not exceed the limits and meets the energy balance during charging and discharging. The operation of pumped storage power stations is used to constrain the power limits, mutual exclusion logic of operating conditions, upper and lower limits of reservoir capacity, and the time-series recursive relationship of water balance under two operating conditions: pumping and power generation. The transmission of incoming power from outside the tie bus area is used to constrain the power received from outside the area through the tie bus to not exceed its transmission capacity limit, and to meet power factor and availability constraints. Bus load shedding is used to limit the amount of load shedding at each bus node at any given time to not exceed the total actual load demand of that node. The logical relationship between the availability status of power sources and busbars describes the logical association between the availability status of various power sources (conventional units, wind farms, photovoltaic power stations) and the availability status of their respective grid-connected busbars, ensuring that power sources can only supply power to the system when the grid-connected busbars are available; Transmission line repair status and actions are used to describe the logical recursive relationship between the repair status and repair initiation actions of each transmission line at each moment, and to clarify the timing process of the line entering the repair state from the fault state. The logical relationship between the repair and restoration states of transmission lines describes the timing transition logic between the restoration and commissioning state and the repair state after the repair of the transmission line, ensuring that the line can be restored to usability only after the repair is completed; The bus islanding status logic relationship is used to determine whether each bus is in an islanding operation state isolated from the main grid based on the availability status of the transmission line and the topological connection relationship between the buses. The logic relationship of bus island failure status is used to determine whether the power supply function of the bus has failed when it is in island operation and there is no available power source in the island. The restoration requirements for transmission lines and busbars are used to determine the restoration priority and restoration requirement status of each transmission line and busbar based on the busbar islanding failure status, load importance level, and load loss. The differentiated reinforcement status of transmission lines is used to restrict each transmission line to only one level (level 1 or level 2) of differentiated reinforcement measures at any given time, so as to avoid conflicts in reinforcement schemes; The logical relationship between the differentiated reinforcement of transmission lines and their fault state, recovery state and availability state is used to establish the coupling logical constraints between the differentiated reinforcement state of the transmission line and its expected fault state, unexpected fault state, recovery state and final availability state, so as to ensure that the impact of reinforcement measures on the line fault rate and availability is accurately characterized. The logical relationship between the construction status and availability status of the candidate energy storage power station is used to constrain the candidate energy storage power station from being put into operation before construction, and it can only participate in the system's charging and discharging scheduling after construction.
[0028] In some preferred embodiments, S3 above employs a hierarchical iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to solve the reinforcement planning model, obtaining a power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elasticity enhancement requirements under ice storm weather. It may further include: S31, the reinforcement programming model is a mixed integer nonlinear programming problem with both continuous and discrete variables; the reinforcement programming model is transformed in layers to obtain a first-stage model after reconstruction and transformation of the expected value of the objective function of the middle-level model, and a second-stage model consisting of uncertain variables revealed by the middle-level model and simulated response by the lower-level model; the three-level nested model is divided into three optimization problems: outer loop master problem, inner loop master problem, and inner loop subproblem; S32 employs a customized NC&CG algorithm to iteratively solve the three optimization problems of the three-layer nested model. This enables the alternating updating of different types of variables, including planning decision variables, uncertain variables related to line faults and wind power output loss, continuous variables, and discrete variables, to obtain the final flexible power transmission and generation system reinforcement planning scheme.
[0029] In some preferred embodiments, the above-mentioned S31, the partial reconstruction and transformation of the expected value of the objective function of the intermediate model, may further include: S311, convert the reinforcement planning model into matrix form; S3121, based on the matrix form, expands the expected value part of the objective function of the middle layer model in the reinforcement planning model (dual), and expands the various probabilistic constraints contained in the enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected fault decisions of transmission lines; among them, the various probabilistic constraints include: probability normalization constraint, first-order moment constraint and Wasserstein distance constraint. S3122 utilizes duality theory to transform the expanded model and employs the sample average approximation method to handle the Wasserstein distance, thereby obtaining the first-stage model after reconstruction of the expected value portion.
[0030] In some preferred embodiments, the above-mentioned S31, which includes a second-stage model with uncertain variables, may further include: S313, after the expected value part is reconstructed and transformed, the original reinforced planning model is transformed into a three-level planning model of min-max-min that can be directly processed in layers; the two-level max-min model is combined into one through duality theory, and in the second-stage model containing uncertain variables, another layer of loop is set to separate the discrete and continuous variables of the max-min model.
[0031] In some preferred embodiments, the above-mentioned S313, where the three-level nested model is divided into three optimization problems—an outer loop master problem, an inner loop master problem, and an inner loop sub-problem—may further include: The outer loop master problem seeks the optimal transmission line differentiated reinforcement and energy storage configuration planning scheme based on the worst-case unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst-case unexpected power loss state of wind power obtained from the inner loop master problem, as well as the original cutting plane stored by iterative solution, and then returns it to the inner loop. The inner loop master problem transforms the max-min model into a max single-layer model through duality. Based on the planning scheme obtained from solving the outer loop master problem, the discrete variable values obtained from solving the inner loop subproblems, and the original cutting plane stored by the inner loop master problem itself through iterative solution, the worst-case unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst-case unexpected power loss state of wind power are found and fed back to the outer loop master problem or the inner loop subproblem. The inner loop subproblem, based on the planning scheme and dual variables of the constraints obtained from solving the outer loop main problem, as well as the worst-case unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst-case unexpected power loss state of the wind power obtained from solving the inner loop main problem, seeks the discrete variable optimization results under the worst-case unexpected impact of the disaster, and feeds the obtained discrete variable optimization results back to the inner loop main problem.
[0032] Among them, the discrete variable optimization results include: transmission line restoration decision scheme, conventional unit operation status decision scheme, energy storage charging and discharging decision scheme, pumped storage / hydropower generation decision scheme, and interconnection bus availability status decision scheme.
[0033] In some preferred embodiments, S32 above, which employs a customized NC&CG algorithm to iteratively solve the three optimization problems of the three-layer nested model, may further include: S321, based on the NC&CG algorithm, does not consider the constraints of transmission line and bus restoration requirements in the inner loop subproblem, making the inner loop subproblem solvable in the iteration process; for multi-scenario problems of the inner loop main problem, parallel mode is used for computation to obtain a customized NC&CG algorithm. S322, using a customized NC&CG algorithm, solves the following iteratively for three optimization problems of a three-layer nested model: Perform outer loop initialization, including: setting the initial value of the upper bound of the outer loop, the initial value of the lower bound of the outer loop, and the number of iterations of the outer loop. And set the outer loop convergence gap, and give the initial values of the unexpected fault state variables of the transmission line and the initial values of the unexpected output loss state of the wind power. make Substituting the unexpected fault state of the line and the wind power output loss state, the outer circulation master problem is solved to obtain the reinforcement planning scheme; the lower bound of the outer circulation is calculated and updated. Perform inner loop initialization, including: setting the initial value of the upper bound of the inner loop, the initial value of the lower bound of the inner loop, and the number of iterations of the inner loop. And set the inner loop convergence gap; make The reinforcement planning scheme, unexpected line fault state, unexpected wind power output loss state, and dual variables of the outer loop master problem are substituted into the inner loop subproblem for solution to obtain discrete variable values; the lower bound of the inner loop is calculated and updated. Substitute the reinforcement planning scheme and discrete variable values into the inner loop master problem, perform parallel solution for multiple scenarios, obtain the unexpected fault state of the line and the unexpected output loss state of wind power under each ice disaster scenario, and use them to solve the outer loop master problem; calculate and update the upper bound of the inner loop. Based on the updated upper and lower bounds of the inner loop and the set inner loop convergence gap, determine whether the inner loop has converged. If it has converged, recalculate and update the upper bound of the outer loop, and exit the inner loop to check for outer loop convergence. Otherwise, return to the steps of solving the inner loop subproblem and continue iterating. Based on the updated upper bound and lower bound of the outer loop and the set outer loop convergence gap, determine whether the outer loop has converged; if it has converged, terminate the algorithm and output the final reinforcement planning scheme; otherwise, return to the steps of solving the outer loop main problem and continue iterating.
[0034] The working principle and process of the reinforcement planning method provided in this embodiment will be further explained in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and technical principles.
[0035] Before proceeding with the following detailed explanation, the following technical features are first defined: Anticipated failure refers to the failure that is targeted by reinforcement measures, as opposed to "unexpected failure".
[0036] Unexpected failures refer to uncertainties represented by fuzzy sets, with 0-1 state variables and support set constraints.
[0037] The first line reinforcement measure is used to avoid anticipated failures and serves as the primary reinforcement level.
[0038] The second line reinforcement measure is used to avoid both expected and unexpected faults, and serves as a secondary reinforcement.
[0039] I. Uncertainty modeling under ice storm weather for step S1: S11, Fuzzy set of transmission line faults based on blobs optimization.
[0040] Distributed Robust Optimization (DRO) is an optimization method that seeks the optimal solution under the worst-case probability distribution when the uncertainty distribution information is not fully known. Its model can be generally divided into two types: a single-stage static programming model and a two-stage adaptive programming model. The single-stage DRO model lacks an internal decision feedback mechanism; therefore, this invention adopts an adaptive two-stage DRO model. The general form of the adaptive two-stage DRO model is shown in equation (1). Its decision-making process is divided into two stages. Some decision variables need to be determined in the first stage before the uncertain parameters, while other decision variables are determined in the second stage after the specific realization of the uncertainty is observed. This framework allows decision-makers to adaptively adjust subsequent decisions based on the gradual revelation and feedback of uncertainty probability information, and to obtain the optimal solution under the worst-case probability distribution conditions through continuous pursuit.
[0041] (1) In the formula, These are the decision variables for the first stage; These are the decision variables for the second stage. and It is a coefficient matrix; This indicates the goal of obtaining the expected value. and These are respectively an uncertain probability distribution and an uncertain variable; It is a set with an uncertain probability distribution, i.e., a fuzzy set; This represents the feasible region of the decision variables in the second stage.
[0042] The uncertainty of transmission line faults under the impact of ice storms is characterized as a fuzzy set composed of probability distributions. A two-stage sub-Bruker programming model based on fuzzy sets is established. Then, within the fuzzy set satisfying a specific support set, the loss cost under the worst-case probability distribution is calculated. This cost is then fed back to the planning layer to continuously adjust the decision-making process, thereby obtaining a reinforcement planning scheme for the power transmission system under the worst-case probability distribution. Based on this, the deviation of the unexpected fault rate of transmission lines is set as... Then, the fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information can be described as shown in equation (2): (2) In the formula, A fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information; This represents the probability distribution of unexpected faults in transmission lines. The support set for the fault state of the transmission line is shown in Equation (3); The set of all failure probability distributions on the support set; for Transmission lines Unexpected fault conditions; A collection of transmission lines; for Transmission lines The expected failure rate.
[0043] (3) In the formula, the first term represents the maximum number of occurrences at each time point. The first term indicates that an unexpected fault occurs on a transmission line; the second term indicates the sequential nature of the fault state, meaning that the line will remain in a fault state for the rest of the time after the fault occurs; the third term is used to limit the range of transmission lines where unexpected faults occur, indicating that lines that have experienced expected faults will no longer experience unexpected faults; the fourth term limits the time at which unexpected faults occur on a line, meaning that unexpected faults can only occur when the expected fault rate of the line is greater than a certain threshold. This refers to the number of transmission lines; for Transmission lines Expected fault state; For power transmission lines The moment when the expected failure rate exceeds the threshold; Represents a moment.
[0044] S12, Enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines after incorporating Wasserstein distance.
[0045] However, for low-probability, high-impact extreme weather disasters like ice storms, traditional fuzzy sets based on moment information are prone to over-conservatism when characterizing their uncertainty due to insufficient information utilization. This is mainly because moment information struggles to fully integrate the probability distribution characteristics inherent in actual sample data, and moment information estimation is susceptible to errors, causing the constructed fuzzy set to potentially cover a large number of probability distribution scenarios that rarely occur in reality. This leads planning models to tend to make overly conservative decisions to avoid extreme possibilities, resulting in increased investment costs and decreased resource utilization. To improve the effectiveness of fuzzy set characterization, statistical distance constraints are further introduced on top of moment information to enhance the fuzzy set. Among these, confidence intervals based on Wasserstein distance have good convergence and full utilization of historical data, and are widely used to construct compact and reliable sets of distributed uncertainty.
[0046] Suppose we have a sample of transmission line faults under ice storm weather. common The empirical distribution of line faults is defined as shown in equation (4): (4) In the formula, The empirical sample distribution of transmission line faults. For fault samples The Dirac measure.
[0047] For the probability distribution of unexpected faults in transmission lines Its distribution with historical experience samples The 1-Wasserstein distance between them is given by equation (5).
[0048] (5) In the formula, For probability distribution and historical experience sample distribution The 1-Wasserstein distance between them; Uncertain fault variables and historical fault samples The joint probability distribution of ; Represents 1-norm operations.
[0049] Enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines after incorporating Wasserstein distance As shown in equation (6), where Representative with A 1-Wasserstein sphere with radius .
[0050] (6) In the formula, It is the set of all failure probability distributions on the support set.
[0051] 1-Wasserstein sphere radius It can be calculated using equation (7), where Confidence level; The radius of the sphere is a property parameter that can be obtained by calculating equation (8) using the bisection search method; As an auxiliary variable, it is used to generate the infimum of the sphere radius property parameters; This represents the average value of the empirical sample data.
[0052] (7) (8) S13, The impact of hardening decisions on fault fuzzy sets.
[0053] To directly mitigate the power supply losses caused by line faults to the power generation and transmission system, transmission line reinforcement measures are adopted to enhance the disaster resistance level of the lines, thereby achieving system elastic reinforcement. Line reinforcement measures directly affect the line failure rate under ice storms. Without reinforcement or with only the first level of reinforcement, the physical vulnerability of the lines is high, and the failure probability curve increases steeply with the intensity of the disaster. However, as the reinforcement level increases, the structural strength and disaster resistance of the lines are enhanced, and the failure probability curve, representing vulnerability, shifts downward and tends to flatten. A schematic diagram illustrating the impact of different reinforcement levels on the transmission line failure rate is shown below. Figure 2 As shown, where and The figures show the changes in line failure rates after reinforcement measures of levels A and B, respectively. As can be seen from the figures, for different vulnerability curves, the corresponding transmission line failure rate ranges for each ice storm intensity are different. For the ice storm intensity shown in the figures... After implementing Class A reinforcement measures, the line failure rate range is: After adopting level B reinforcement measures, the failure rate range becomes... This means that line reinforcement decisions will affect the fuzzy set of line faults. Therefore, in order to accurately characterize the uncertainty of line faults, this decision-dependent fault uncertainty feature needs to be reflected in the fuzzy set.
[0054] Based on the above analysis, the impact of reinforcement decisions on line failure rates is reflected in the moment information, resulting in the transmission line failure rate range shown in equation (9): (9) In the formula, For level transmission lines The reinforcement decision is a 0-1 variable, where 1 represents reinforcement and 0 represents no reinforcement. To adopt a level The deviation in line failure rate after reinforcement measures.
[0055] Therefore, based on the aforementioned characteristics of the impact of enhanced fuzzy sets and different levels of reinforcement decisions on the uncertainty of line faults, a decision-dependent enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected faults of transmission lines is constructed. As shown in equation (10): (10) S14, Uncertain set of wind power output loss.
[0056] The degree of wind power output loss under ice storm weather is also uncertain. The wind power output loss in the expected transmission line fault scenario is taken as the expected output loss, and the output loss after considering uncertainty is taken as the unexpected output loss. The uncertainty of the unexpected wind power output loss is characterized by a robust box uncertainty set, as shown in Equation (11): (11) In the formula, Robust uncertainty set for wind power output loss; To characterize Shike Wind Farm The 0-1 state variable represents whether an output loss has occurred, where 1 indicates that the wind farm has experienced an unexpected output loss, and 0 indicates that no unexpected output loss has occurred. Budget losses due to unexpected wind power output; For wind farms.
[0057] II. For step S2, construct a resilient power generation and transmission system sub-bulb reinforcement planning model to adapt to unexpected disaster impacts: Two reinforcement measures are considered: transmission line reinforcement and grid-side energy storage configuration, to address unexpected transmission line failures and unexpected wind power output losses under uncertain environments. In transmission line reinforcement, two levels of reinforcement measures are employed to provide differentiated system strengthening. The first level of reinforcement measures can prevent expected transmission line failures, while the second level can prevent both expected transmission line failures and more serious unexpected failures.
[0058] S21, Model Framework.
[0059] Considering the uncertainties in line failure rate and wind power output loss under ice storm conditions, a two-stage, three-layer reinforcement planning model framework for a resilient power generation and transmission system is established, such as... Figure 3 As shown, the model framework consists of two phases. The first phase corresponds to the upper-level model, aiming to minimize the sum of investment costs for reinforcement planning (multi-level reinforcement of lines and grid-side energy storage configuration) and system resilience performance loss costs, and then passes the planning decision scheme to the second-level model. The second phase corresponds to the middle and lower-level models. The middle-level model first reveals the dual uncertainties under ice storm weather, and by maximizing the resilience performance loss cost, it finds the worst-case line fault situation and wind power output loss. Then, it passes the worst-case line fault probability distribution, fault state, and worst-case wind power output loss state affected by the reinforcement decision to the lower-level model. The lower-level model then conducts operational simulations based on planning decisions and uncertainty revelation, responds to the results of the worst-case uncertainty revelation, and then makes operational decision schemes that adapt to uncertainty.
[0060] S22, Objective Function The objective function of the resilient power transmission and distribution system reinforcement planning model is to minimize the sum of the reinforcement planning investment cost and the system resilience performance loss cost. The system resilience performance loss cost is calculated based on the worst-case scenario of unexpected line failure probability and unexpected wind power output loss, as shown in Equation (12). Reinforcement planning measures include transmission line reinforcement and grid-side energy storage configuration. Transmission line reinforcement is divided into first-level reinforcement and second-level reinforcement, with different investment costs. First-level reinforcement measures can be used to reinforce lines with anticipated failures, while second-level reinforcement measures are used to reinforce lines with both anticipated and unexpected failures. Grid-side energy storage configuration is used to provide emergency power support and rapid recovery support for weak links in the power grid.
[0061] (12) In the formula, and Transmission lines The unit investment cost of using first-level reinforcement measures and second-level reinforcement measures; and Transmission lines The first and second level reinforcement decisions (reinforcement status) are 0-1 variables, where a value of 1 represents reinforcement and a value of 0 represents no reinforcement. For potential energy storage power stations The unit construction cost; For potential energy storage power stations The construction status is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents construction and a value of 0 represents no construction. It is a vector that includes the hardening decision variables for all transmission lines at both the first and second levels; and These are vectors representing the continuous state variables and vectors representing the discrete state variables in the second-stage model, respectively. and They are respectively and The feasible domain; This is a collection of potential grid-side energy storage power stations; The discount rate for transmission line reinforcement planning; The number of years required for the reinforcement of transmission lines; The discount rate configured for energy storage; The investment period for configuring energy storage; Enhanced fuzzy sets for unexpected faults in transmission lines affected by reinforcement decisions; The total cycle for the planning horizontal year; Penalty cost for system unit load loss; busbar exist Load loss at any given moment; The discrete time step; For a specific moment; For the busbar. In equation (12), Corresponding to the worst-case scenario of unexpected line failure probability distribution, This corresponds to the worst-case scenario of unexpected wind power output loss.
[0062] S23, Constraints The reinforcement plan for power generation and transmission systems to adapt to unexpected disaster impacts under uncertain environments is only geared towards ice storm scenarios. It only considers the system operation constraints under ice storm scenarios, as detailed below: 1) Investment restrictions on transmission line reinforcement Given that the investment in transmission line reinforcement is only used to improve the disaster response capability of the power generation and transmission system and has no substantial contribution to the expansion of the system scale, an upper limit is set on the investment budget for transmission line reinforcement to avoid economic losses, as shown in equation (13): (13) In the formula, Budget for investment costs for reinforcing the line.
[0063] 2) Node power balancing is used to ensure that the active power injection and outflow of each bus node remain balanced at each time, satisfying Kirchhoff's current law, as shown in equation (14): (14) In the formula, For conventional units exist Power output at any given moment; For wind farm exist Power output at any given moment; For photovoltaic power station exist Power output at any given moment; For power transmission lines exist Active power transmission at any given moment; and Energy storage power stations exist The charging power and discharging power at any given time; and Pumped storage power stations exist Pumping power and power generation at any given time; For connecting bus exist The power of incoming power from outside the area received at any time; busbar exist The workload of the moment; and They are connected to the bus. A combination of support units and flexible units; and They are connected to the bus. A collection of wind farms and photovoltaic power stations; To connect to the bus The existing collection of energy storage power stations; To connect to the bus The set of connecting busbars.
[0064] 3) The DC power flow equations for transmission lines are used to describe the relationship between the active power flow of each transmission line and the phase angle difference of the voltage at both ends of the bus, as shown in equation (15): (15) In the formula, For power transmission lines The susceptance; and Transmission lines The first and last nodes are in Voltage phase angle at any given moment; For power transmission lines exist The availability status at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents that the transmission line is available and a value of 0 represents that the transmission line is unavailable. It is a relatively large positive number.
[0065] 4) Transmission line capacity, used to limit the active power transmitted by each transmission line from exceeding its thermal stability limit capacity, as shown in equation (16): (16) In the formula, For power transmission lines Maximum transmission capacity.
[0066] 5) Conventional unit combination, used to determine the start-up and shutdown status, start-up actions and shutdown actions of each conventional unit, to meet the minimum start-up and shutdown time constraints of the units, as shown in equations (17) to (20): (17) (18) (19) (20) In the formula, Let g be a 0-1 variable representing the operating state of a conventional unit g at time t, where a value of 1 indicates that the unit is running and a value of 0 indicates that the unit is shut down. For conventional units exist The operating status at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents that the unit is running and a value of 0 represents that the unit is shut down. For conventional units In the scene middle The power-on status variable is 0-1, where a value of 1 represents that the unit is powered on and a value of 0 represents that the unit is not powered on. For conventional units exist The shutdown action status is a 0-1 variable at any given time, where a value of 1 represents that the unit is shut down and a value of 0 represents that the unit is not shut down. and For conventional units Minimum startup and shutdown times.
[0067] 6) Output of conventional units, used to limit the active power output of each conventional unit within its technical output upper and lower limits, as shown in equation (21): (twenty one) In the formula, and They are conventional units The maximum and minimum output.
[0068] 7) Logical relationship of conventional unit operation status, describing the logical consistency constraints between the start-up and shutdown status, start-up actions and shutdown actions of conventional units, as shown in equation (22): (twenty two) 8) Ramp / descend rate of conventional units, used to limit the upward and downward adjustment of the active power output of conventional units between adjacent time periods from exceeding their ramp capacity limit, as shown in equations (23) to (24): (twenty three) (twenty four) In the formula, For conventional units exist Power output at any given moment; For conventional units exist The running state at any given time is a 0-1 variable; For conventional units Maximum output; For conventional units Maximum climbing rate; For conventional units The maximum downhill rate.
[0069] 9) System spinning reserve capacity, used to ensure that the positive and negative spinning reserve capacity configured in the system is not less than the minimum reserve requirement required to cope with uncertainties such as load forecast deviations and unit outages, as shown in equations (25) to (26): (25) (26) In the formula, The required spin-up reserve capacity factor for the system; The required spin-down spare capacity factor for the system; busbar exist The workload of the moment.
[0070] 10) Wind farm output, used to limit the actual grid-connected power of the wind farm from not exceeding its maximum output available based on wind speed conditions, and taking into account the impact of unexpected output loss coefficient, as shown in equation (27): (27) In the formula, for Shike Wind Farm Unexpected output loss coefficient; For wind farm exist Power loss at any given moment; For wind farm exist Availability status at any given moment; For wind farm exist Predicting output at any given moment.
[0071] 11) The output of the photovoltaic power station is used to limit the actual grid-connected power of the photovoltaic power station from not exceeding its maximum output available based on the illumination conditions, as shown in equation (28): (28) In the formula, For photovoltaic power station exist Power output at any given moment; A collection of photovoltaic power plants; For photovoltaic power station exist Availability status at any given moment; For photovoltaic power station exist Predicting output at any given moment.
[0072] 12) The operation of the energy storage power station is used to constrain the charging and discharging power, state of charge, and energy timing recursion of the energy storage power station, to ensure that the energy storage does not exceed the limits and meets the energy balance during the charging and discharging process, as shown in equations (29) to (35): (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) (34) (35) In the formula, For energy storage power stations exist The charging state at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents charging and a value of 0 represents not charging. and For energy storage power stations The upper and lower limits of discharge power; For energy storage power stations exist The discharge state at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents discharge and a value of 0 represents no discharge; Energy storage power station exist The availability status at any given time; a value of 1 indicates availability, and a value of 0 indicates unavailability. For energy storage power stations exist The amount of stored energy at any given time; For energy storage power stations The installed capacity; and Energy storage power stations The upper and lower limits of the state of charge; and For energy storage power stations The charging efficiency and discharging efficiency; For energy storage power stations The initial capacity; This represents the number of discrete time steps in the simulation.
[0073] 13) Operation of pumped storage power stations, used to constrain the power limits, mutual exclusion logic of operating conditions, upper and lower limits of reservoir capacity, and the time-series recursive relationship of water balance under the two operating conditions of pumping and power generation, as shown in equations (36) to (48): (36) (37) (38) (39) (40) (41) (42) (43) (44) (45) (46) (47) (48) In the formula, and Pumped storage power stations exist Pumping power and power generation at any given time; and Pumped storage power station The upper and lower limits of pumping power; and For pumped storage power station The upper and lower limits of power generation; Pumped storage power station exist The availability status at any given time; a value of 1 indicates availability, and a value of 0 indicates unavailability. and Pumped storage power stations exist The status of pumping / power generation at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents the start of pumping / power generation and a value of 0 represents the stop of pumping / power generation. and Pumped storage power stations exist The status of the pumping / power generation shutdown action at any given time is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 represents shutting down the pumping / power generation and a value of 0 represents not shutting down the pumping / power generation. For pumped storage power station exist Storage capacity at any given time; and Pumped storage power stations Upper and lower limits of storage capacity; and For pumped storage power station Pumping and power generation efficiency; For pumped storage power station The initial storage capacity.
[0074] 14) Power transmission from outside the tie bus area, used to constrain the power received from outside the area through the tie bus to not exceed its transmission capacity limit, and to meet power factor and availability constraints, as shown in equations (49) to (55): (49) (50) (51) (52) (53) (54) (55) In the formula, and They are respectively the connecting busbars exist The upper and lower limits of the outside power received at any given time; For connecting bus exist The availability status at any given time; a value of 1 indicates availability, and a value of 0 indicates unavailability. and They are respectively the connecting busbars Upper limits of upward and downward ramp rates for power delivery; and They are respectively the connecting busbars exist The transmission power at any given time is a 0-1 variable representing the upward / downward adjustment status, where a value of 1 indicates upward / downward adjustment and a value of 0 indicates no adjustment. For connecting bus The minimum time interval that must be maintained after the direction of power transmission is adjusted.
[0075] 15) Busbar load shedding, used to limit the load shedding amount of each busbar node at each time to not exceed the total actual load demand of that node, as shown in equation (56): (56) In the formula, busbar exist Load loss at any given moment; busbar exist The workload of the moment.
[0076] 16) The logical relationship between the availability status of power sources and busbars is used to describe the logical association between the availability status of various power sources (conventional units, wind farms, photovoltaic power stations) and the availability status of their respective grid-connected busbars, ensuring that the power source can only supply power to the system when the grid-connected busbar is available, as shown in equations (57) to (62): (57) (58) (59) (60) (61) (62) In the formula, busbar exist The availability status variable at any given time is 0-1. A value of 1 indicates that the bus is available, and a value of 0 indicates that the bus is unavailable.
[0077] 17) Transmission line repair status and actions, used to describe the logical recursive relationship between the repair status and repair initiation actions of each transmission line at each moment, and to clarify the timing process of the line entering the repair state from the fault state, as shown in equations (63) to (65): (63) (64) (65) In the formula, For power transmission lines exist The repair status variable at any given time is 0-1. A value of 1 indicates that the transmission line is in a repair state, and a value of 0 indicates that it is not in a repair state. For power transmission lines exist The repair action at any given moment is a 0-1 variable, where a value of 1 indicates that the transmission line is undergoing repair action, and a value of 0 indicates that no repair action is performed. This refers to the repair time for power transmission lines; This represents the maximum number of transmission lines under repair at any given time. The time taken from the time a line fault occurs to the time it takes to begin repair work.
[0078] 18) The logical relationship between the repair and restoration states of transmission lines is used to describe the timing transition logic between the restoration and commissioning state and the repair state after the repair of the transmission line, ensuring that the line can be restored to use only after the repair is completed, as shown in equations (66) to (69): (66) (67) (68) (69) In the formula, For power transmission lines exist The recovery status variable at any given time is 0-1, where a value of 1 indicates that the transmission line has been restored, and a value of 0 indicates that the transmission line has not been restored.
[0079] 19) The logic relationship of bus islanding status is used to determine whether each bus is in an islanding operation state isolated from the main grid based on the availability status of the transmission line and the topological connection relationship between the buses, as shown in equations (70) to (72): (70) (71) (72) In the formula, To judge Does the time exist with respect to the bus? The available lines connected are 0-1 variables, where a value of 1 indicates that there is an available line connected to the bus, and a value of 0 indicates that none of the lines connected to the bus are available. busbar exist The islanding state variable at time 0 is 0-1, where a value of 1 indicates that the bus is not in an islanding state, and a value of 0 indicates that it is in an islanding state. Indicates the line Both ends are busbars Transmission lines; The time required to restore power to a transmission line after both busbars are in an islanded state.
[0080] 20) The logic relationship of bus islanding failure status is used to determine whether the power supply function of the bus is in a state of islanding operation and there is no available power supply in the island, as shown in equations (73) to (76): (73) (74) (75) (76) In the formula, To determine in Time bus A 0-1 variable indicating whether the load has been completely cut off. A value of 1 indicates that the load on the bus has not been completely cut off, and a value of 0 indicates that the load on the bus has been completely cut off. It is a very small positive number.
[0081] 21) Transmission line and bus restoration requirements are used to determine the restoration priority and restoration requirement status of each transmission line and bus based on the bus islanding failure status, load importance level, and load loss, as shown in equations (77) to (79): (77) (78) (79) In the formula, The recovery period for running the simulation.
[0082] 22) Differentiated reinforcement status for transmission lines, used to constrain each transmission line to select only one level (first level or second level) of differentiated reinforcement measures at any given time, to avoid conflicts in reinforcement schemes, as shown in equation (80): Each transmission line can only be reinforced with one reinforcement level, as shown in equation (80).
[0083] (80) In the formula, For power transmission lines First-level hardening decision (hardening status) 0-1 variables; For power transmission lines Second-level hardening decision (hardening state) 0-1 variables.
[0084] 23) The logical relationship between the differentiated reinforcement of transmission lines and their fault state, recovery state, and availability state is used to establish the coupling logical constraints between the differentiated reinforcement state of the transmission line and its expected fault state, unexpected fault state, recovery state, and final availability state, so as to ensure that the impact of reinforcement measures on the line fault rate and availability is accurately characterized, as shown in equations (81) to (82): After considering differentiated reinforcement measures of different levels, the availability status of transmission lines is simultaneously affected by the first-level reinforcement status, the second-level reinforcement status, the expected fault status, the unexpected fault status, and the recovery status, as shown in equation (81). In addition, transmission lines reinforced with differentiated reinforcement measures no longer require recovery, as shown in equation (82).
[0085] (81) (82) 24) The logical relationship between the construction status and availability status of the candidate energy storage power station is used to constrain the candidate energy storage power station from being put into operation before construction, and it can only participate in the system's charging and discharging scheduling after construction, as shown in equations (83) to (85): (83) (84) (85) In the formula, For energy storage power stations exist Availability status at any given moment; busbar exist Availability status at any given time is a 0-1 variable; For potential energy storage power stations The construction status is a 0-1 variable.
[0086] III. Solving the model for S3: S31, Solution Method S311, the reinforcement programming model of the bar is a multi-layered structure of upper-middle-lower layers, and is a mixed integer nonlinear programming problem with both continuous and discrete variables. It cannot be solved directly and needs to be transformed in layers and then solved step by step using a commercial solver. The Nested Column and Constraints Generation (NC&CG) algorithm is used to solve it. For ease of introduction, it is further preferred that the reinforcement programming model be converted into matrix form, as shown in equations (86) to (92): (86) (87) (88) in: (89) (90) (91) (92) In the formula, To reinforce the unit investment coefficient vector of planning measures; To reinforce the planning measures' construction status, a vector of 0-1 variables is formed; and The vector consists of 0-1 variables representing the fault state of transmission lines and the power output loss state of wind power, respectively. Construct vectors from continuous variables; A vector is constructed using 0-1 variables; , , , , , , This is the coefficient matrix for each variable; The coefficient vector on the right side of the objective function in equation (89); The constant vector on the right side of equation (90) is constrained; The constant vector on the right side of equation (90) is constrained; and These are the dual variables of equations (90) and (91), respectively; Budget for investment costs for reinforcing the line.
[0087] S312, Expected Value Model Reconstruction and Transformation.
[0088] Since the middle layer of the model includes the part for obtaining the expected value, and the enhanced fuzzy set contains the Wasserstein distance nonlinear constraint, it needs to be reconstructed and transformed. First, the expected value part of the objective function of the middle layer model is expanded, as shown in Equation (93), and the probability constraints contained in the fuzzy set are expanded, as shown in Equations (93) to (97), where Equation (94) is the probability normalization constraint, which ensures that the total probability on the entire support set is 1; Equations (95) and (96) are the first-order moment constraint expansion terms; and Equation (97) is the Wasserstein distance constraint.
[0089] (93) (94) (95) (96) (97) In the formula, and These are the lower and upper bound vectors of the line fault probability, respectively; The failure probability bias vector resulting from the reinforcement decision; For the dual variable corresponding to equation (94), used for the dual transformation of the middle-level model; and For the dual variables corresponding to equations (95) and (96); is the dual variable of equation (97).
[0090] Equations (93) to (97) belong to convex programming problems and satisfy the strong duality condition. Therefore, the above model can be transformed using duality theory, and the Wasserstein distance can be handled by the Sample Average Approximation (SAA) method, as shown in equations (98) to (100): (98) (99) (100) In the formula, The lower-level objective function value corresponding to each sample.
[0091] To eliminate the norm term in equation (99) and improve the robustness of the model, it is transformed into an equivalent form that can be handled based on the Slater condition, as shown in equations (101) and (102). As an auxiliary variable, it is used for the norm term in the transformation equation (99); This represents the search for the infinite norm.
[0092] (101) (102) In the formula, A vector is constructed for the continuous variables corresponding to each sample i.
[0093] Thus, the first-stage model after the reconstruction and transformation of the expected value is obtained as shown in equations (103) to (106): (103) (104) (105) (106) S313, two-stage model hierarchical transformation.
[0094] After reconstructing and transforming the expected value model, the original model becomes a three-level programming model of min-max-min that can be directly processed hierarchically. During hierarchical processing, duality theory is needed to combine the two-level max-min models into one. However, the second-stage model, which includes uncertain variables, also contains discrete variables, making direct duality impossible. Therefore, an additional loop is set up to separate the discrete and continuous variables of the max-min model. Based on this, a customized NC&CG algorithm is proposed to solve the two-stage three-level programming model. By dividing the model into master and sub-problems and setting up inner and outer double loops, the algorithm achieves alternating updates of different types of variables, including planning decision variables, uncertain variables related to line faults and wind power output losses, continuous variables, and discrete variables, thus achieving the cyclical solution of the multi-level model. According to the three-level nested model, it is divided into three optimization problems: an outer loop master problem, an inner loop master problem, and an inner loop sub-problem. The specific models for each optimization problem are as follows: S3131, outer loop main problem.
[0095] The outer loop master problem seeks the optimal transmission line differentiated reinforcement and energy storage configuration scheme based on the worst line fault probability distribution obtained from the inner loop, wind power output loss, and the original cutting plane stored by iterative solution. It then returns the solution to the inner loop. The outer loop master problem model is shown in equations (107) and (108). (107) (108) In the formula, and The first Sample scenario during the second outer loop The optimization variables, where, This refers to continuous optimization variables such as conventional unit output, line power flow, and energy storage charging and discharging power. This refers to discrete optimization variables such as line repair schemes, line restoration schemes, and energy storage charging and discharging schemes; This represents the current outer loop iteration count; and For sample scenarios The fault status of transmission lines and the power output loss status of wind power are determined by the first The outer loop is obtained by solving the main problem of the inner loop.
[0096] Equation (107) contains a dual variable. , and planning decision variables The bilinear terms of the product are introduced with an auxiliary variable according to the McCormick envelope method. , and , Linearizing it, the outer loop main problem becomes equations (109) and (110): (109) (110) In the formula, and These are all auxiliary variables used to optimize problem solving; and These are all auxiliary variables used to optimize problem solving; and Variables and The upper limit.
[0097] S3132, the main problem of the inner loop.
[0098] The inner loop master problem transforms the max-min model into a max single-layer model through duality. Based on the planning scheme obtained from solving the outer loop master problem, the transmission line recovery decision scheme obtained from solving the inner loop sub-problems, the operating status of conventional units, the energy storage charging and discharging decision scheme, the pumped storage / hydropower generation decision scheme, the availability status of the interconnecting bus, etc., and the original cutting plane stored by the inner loop master problem itself through iterative solution, it seeks the worst-case unexpected failure result of the transmission line and the worst-case unexpected output loss of wind power. Then, the optimization results of each scenario are returned to the outer loop master problem or the inner loop sub-problems. The inner loop master problem model is shown in equations (111) and (112).
[0099] (111) (112) In the formula, For sample scenarios The auxiliary variable of the inner loop main problem refers to the objective function of the inner loop main problem; and The first Sample scenario during the second inner loop The dual variable; This represents the current inner loop iteration count; For the first The planning and decision scheme obtained by solving the main problem of the outer loop during the second outer loop; , and The first The optimization result of the dual variable obtained by solving the main problem of the outer loop in the second outer loop; For the first The discrete variable optimization results obtained from solving the inner loop subproblems during the second inner loop include discrete optimization variables such as line repair schemes, line restoration schemes, and energy storage charging and discharging schemes.
[0100] Equation (112) contains dual variables and uncertain variables. , Introducing auxiliary variables for multiplicative bilinear terms. , and , Linearization is used to eliminate continuous variables of bilinear terms in the model, so that the inner loop master problem model can be solved directly. The linearized inner loop master problem is shown in equations (113) and (114).
[0101] (113) (114) S3133, Inner Loop Subproblem.
[0102] The inner loop subproblem uses the planning and decision schemes obtained from solving the outer loop main problem, the dual variables of the constraints, and the worst-case unexpected line faults and unexpected wind power output losses obtained from solving the inner loop main problem to find the optimization results of discrete variables such as line recovery and energy storage charging and discharging under the worst-case unexpected impact of disasters, and returns them to the inner loop main problem. The specific models of the inner loop subproblem are shown in equations (115) and (116).
[0103] (115) (116) In the formula, and The first During the second inner cycle, the transmission line fault status and wind power output loss status are obtained by solving the main problem of the inner cycle.
[0104] S32, the solution process based on nested column and constraint generation algorithms.
[0105] Based on the aforementioned outer loop master problem, inner loop master problem, and inner loop subproblem model, a model solution method based on a customized NC&CG algorithm is proposed. Firstly, to ensure the proposed model can be solved effectively and to improve solution efficiency, the following settings are added to the NC&CG algorithm: 1) The constraints on transmission line and bus restoration requirements are not considered in the inner loop subproblems, making the inner loop subproblems solvable during the iteration process; 2) For the multi-scenario problem of the inner loop master problem, parallel computation is adopted.
[0106] The specific solution steps for the customized NC&CG algorithm are shown below.
[0107] Step 1: Initialize the outer loop. Set the initial value of the upper bound of the outer loop. Initial value of the lower bound of the outer loop Number of outer loop iterations And set the external circulation convergence gap. Given the initial values of the unexpected fault state variables of the transmission line and the initial values of the unexpected output loss state of the wind power; Step 2: Let Substitute the line fault state and wind power output loss state into the equation (117) to solve the outer circulation master problem and obtain the reinforcement planning scheme. Calculate the lower bound of the outer circulation according to the equation (117) and update it. (117) In the formula, , , , and For the first The outer loop main problem optimization variable values obtained from the second outer loop include: the reinforcement planning scheme, the dual variable value of the corresponding equation (94), the auxiliary variable value for eliminating nonlinear terms, the auxiliary variable value for eliminating nonlinear terms, and the dual variable of the corresponding equation (97).
[0108] Step 3: Inner loop initialization. Set the initial value of the upper bound of the inner loop. Initial value of the lower bound of the inner loop Number of inner loop iterations And set the external circulation convergence gap. ; Step 4: Let The planning scheme, unexpected line fault status, unexpected wind power output loss status and the dual variables of the outer circulation master problem are substituted into the inner circulation subproblem to solve the discrete variable values such as line recovery status, conventional unit operation status and energy storage charging and discharging status. The lower bound of the inner circulation is updated according to equation (118). (118) In the formula, For the first The optimization variable values of the inner loop subproblem obtained by solving the inner loop once; , and For the first The values of the dual variables of the outer loop principal problem are retained during the next outer loop iteration; For the first During the inner loop iteration, the unexpected fault states of the line are obtained from solving the main problem of the inner loop.
[0109] Step 5: Substitute the planning scheme and the discrete variable values obtained in Step 4 into the inner loop main problem, perform parallel solution for multiple scenarios, obtain the unexpected fault state of the line and the unexpected power loss state of wind power under each ice disaster scenario, and update the upper bound of the inner loop according to Equation (119). (119) In the formula, For the first The objective function values of the main problem in the inner loop of each sample scenario are obtained by solving the inner loop.
[0110] Step 6: Determine whether the inner loop converges according to equation (120). If it converges, calculate the upper bound of the outer loop according to equation (121) and exit the inner loop to proceed to step 7; otherwise, return to step 4. (120) (121) Step 7: Determine whether the outer loop converges according to equation (122). If it converges, terminate the algorithm and output the reinforcement planning results, including the primary transmission line reinforcement scheme, the secondary transmission line reinforcement scheme, and the energy storage configuration scheme; otherwise, return to step 2 to continue iterating.
[0111] (122) The solution process based on nested columns and constraint generation algorithms is as follows: Figure 4 As shown.
[0112] Based on the same inventive concept, another embodiment of the present invention provides a resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning system to adapt to the unintended impact of ice storms.
[0113] Specifically, such as Figure 5 As shown, the resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning system for adapting to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms provided in this embodiment may include: The uncertainty set construction module, based on the bibliometric optimization technique, describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line failure rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected fault decision dependence of transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set of unexpected output loss of wind power. The reinforcement planning model construction module is based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines and the uncertain set of unexpected output losses in wind power. It considers reinforcement measures for transmission lines and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, and constructs a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a flexible power generation and transmission system with an adaptive three-layer structure of upper, middle and lower layers. The model solving module uses a hierarchical iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to solve the reinforcement planning model, thereby obtaining a reinforcement planning scheme for the power generation and transmission system that meets the requirements for resilient advancement under ice storm weather.
[0114] It should be noted that the steps in the method provided by the present invention can be implemented using corresponding modules, devices, units, etc. in the system. Those skilled in the art can refer to the technical solution of the method to realize the composition of the system. That is, the embodiments in the method can be understood as preferred examples for building the system, and will not be elaborated here.
[0115] The technical solution provided by the above embodiments of the present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to a specific verification example.
[0116] The resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method proposed in the above embodiments of this invention is verified and analyzed using an improved IEEE-30 node standard simulation system. By differentially reinforcing transmission lines with anticipated and unexpected faults and configuring energy storage, the resilience of the power generation and transmission system under ice storm conditions is further enhanced. Two levels of reinforcement measures are selected for transmission line reinforcement: Level 1 reinforcement can avoid anticipated line faults, and Level 2 reinforcement can avoid both anticipated and unexpected line faults. The unit resilience performance loss cost is $10,000 / MWh, the transmission line reinforcement budget is $2.8, and the selected energy storage specification is 25 MW / 50 MWh. By clustering the line fault rate, fault state, and wind power output loss coefficient under five ice storm scenarios generated by Monte Carlo, the expected fault rate, expected fault state, and expected wind power output loss of the transmission lines are obtained. For unexpected line faults and unexpected wind power output losses, the deviation of the unexpected line fault rate is set to... Furthermore, k is set to 4 for the uncertain set Nk of unexpected faults in the supporting centralized transmission lines, and the budget for unexpected wind power output loss is set to 3. A total of 100 empirical samples of unexpected faults in transmission lines in regions 1 and 2 are generated using the Monte Carlo method, and clustered to obtain 8 typical empirical sample scenarios. The data confidence level of the empirical samples is set to 0.9.
[0117] To verify the effectiveness of the proposed reinforcement planning method in mitigating the uncertain impacts of ice storms, four case studies were set up to compare the reinforcement planning results: Case 1 used stochastic optimization based on empirical sample scenarios; Case 2 constructed a fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information, without using Wasserstein distance to enhance the fuzzy set; Case 3 constructed a fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information and Wasserstein distance, but did not consider the impact of reinforcement decisions on the fuzzy set; Case 4 constructed a fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information and Wasserstein distance, while considering the impact of reinforcement decision dependence features on the fuzzy set of unexpected faults in the line, i.e., the proposed planning method. The comparison of uncertainty handling methods in different cases is shown in Table 1. In addition, Cases 2-4 all used box uncertainty sets to characterize the uncertainty of unexpected wind power output losses.
[0118] Table 1 Comparison of Uncertainty Handling Methods for Each Case in the Standard Examples The reinforcement planning results for each case are shown in Table 2. As can be seen from the table, all four reinforcement planning methods can reduce load loss to zero, meaning no further load loss occurs. Case 1, based on stochastic optimization, has the lowest total cost at $2.20, with only 3 secondary reinforcement lines. This is because Case 1 only plans based on empirical sample scenarios, underestimating the risk of load loss due to unexpected disaster impacts, making the planning scheme more economical than conservative in disaster response. Case 2, considering only moment information, has the most reinforcement lines (12 primary reinforcement lines and 6 secondary reinforcement lines), with the highest corresponding investment and total cost of $3.70. This is because while Case 2 considers moment information related to fault uncertainty, it ignores the probability distribution information of historical empirical samples, leading to the model generating too many unrealistic and unexpected fault scenarios, resulting in an overly conservative reinforcement planning scheme. Case 3 significantly reduces the number of reinforcement lines compared to Case 2, but has the most secondary reinforcement lines, with a total cost of $3.28. Although Case 3 constructed an enhanced fuzzy set, ignoring the impact of hardening decision dependence on the fault fuzzy set meant that the line fault rate no longer changed with hardening decisions. Consequently, the risk of system power supply loss no longer decreased with line hardening. Faced with high loss risk, decision-makers tended to implement second-level line hardening measures to reduce risk, resulting in a conservative planning scheme. Case 4, which adopted the proposed method, considered both the enhanced fuzzy set and hardening decision dependence characteristics. Compared to Cases 2 and 3, it achieved zero load loss while having the lowest total cost of 2.54 M$. Unlike the planning scheme in Case 3, Case 4 did not perform secondary hardening on lines 2-4, but performed primary hardening on lines 15-23, which underwent secondary hardening in Case 1. This indicates that after considering the impact of hardening decisions on the fuzzy set, the overall line fault probability interval shifted downward, reducing the actual system power supply loss risk. No further secondary hardening measures were needed, thus reducing investment costs while avoiding system power supply loss.
[0119] Table 2 Results of Power Transmission System Enhancement Planning for Each Case in the Standard Calculation Example Note: In the results of the energy storage power station access bus number, configuration power, and configuration capacity, " / " indicates that no energy storage power station has been built.
[0120] To further verify the resilience enhancement effect of the reinforcement planning scheme, referring to historical experience distribution and the failure rate of transmission lines after reinforcement in each case, the Monte Carlo method was used to generate 1000 line failure scenarios corresponding to each case. The line failure states of these scenarios were combined with the originally expected line failure states to obtain the out-of-sample test scenario set, and the unexpected wind power output loss state in each scenario was set to reach the budget. Based on this operational simulation model, the system resilience performance loss of different cases' reinforcement planning schemes under each out-of-sample scenario was found, and the average and maximum values of the system load shedding in all out-of-sample test scenarios for each case were recorded, as shown in Table 3.
[0121] As shown in Table 3, the comparison of the verification results reveals that Case 1, which only planned based on empirical sample scenarios, failed to reflect the possibility of unexpected line failures under the worst-case scenario. Faced with a large number of random failure scenarios, its reinforcement planning scheme exhibited the weakest robustness, resulting in the worst simulation test results. The average and maximum load shedding amounts reached a maximum of 17.84 MWh and 211.18 MWh, respectively. Case 2, although having the largest number of reinforced lines, did not match the distribution of faulty lines generated from real-world empirical samples. This resulted in a mediocre effect of the reinforcement scheme when facing a large number of out-of-sample scenarios, with average and maximum load shedding amounts reaching 10.79 MWh and 136.85 MWh, respectively. For Cases 3 and 4, after considering the historical empirical distribution information of unexpected line failures in the planning method, the obtained reinforcement planning schemes were able to cope well with out-of-sample failure scenarios, with relatively small load shedding results. Case 3, with its more conservative reinforcement scheme, achieved average and maximum load shedding amounts of 0.86 MWh and 21.32 MWh, respectively. In contrast, Case 4 only had 0.02 MWh and 1.16 MWh higher average and maximum load shedding, but saved 0.74 M$ in investment costs.
[0122] Table 3 shows the out-of-sample simulation results of the reinforcement planning schemes for each case in the standard example. The above embodiments of the present invention provide a resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning method and system adapted to the unexpected impact of ice storms. Based on the sub-Bruker reinforcement planning method using enhanced fuzzy sets for unexpected faults, this method can utilize historical sample data to mine fault distribution characteristics, reducing the risk of investment waste due to excessive conservatism and insufficient resilience due to inadequate information utilization under unexpected disaster impacts. It achieves a balance between the economic efficiency of planning investment and the resilience of the power generation and transmission system. The fuzzy set construction fully considers the dependence of transmission line fault rate uncertainty on reinforcement decisions, accurately characterizing the changes in line vulnerability after implementing different levels of reinforcement measures, thereby guiding the planning scheme to efficiently and differentiatedly reinforce weak links. The addition of a fault rate deviation coefficient and a Wasserstein sphere radius confidence level expands the fuzzy set coverage and incorporates more extreme fault probability distribution scenarios, prompting the planning model to choose more conservative line reinforcement and energy storage configuration schemes to avoid high risks, effectively preventing the problem of rising investment costs and load losses. Using energy storage power stations can compensate for the limitations of line reinforcement in dealing with network topology damage. Using differentiated reinforcement strategies can avoid serious losses caused by the concurrent occurrence of expected and unexpected failures. The combination of the two takes into account both the robustness of reinforcement planning strategies in dealing with extreme and harsh scenarios and the economy of planning investment.
[0123] Any matters not covered in the above embodiments of the present invention are well-known in the art.
[0124] The foregoing has described some specific embodiments of this application. It should be understood that this application is not limited to the specific embodiments described above, and those skilled in the art can make various modifications or variations within the scope of the claims, which do not affect the substantive content of this application. The above-described preferred features can be used in any combination without conflict.
Claims
1. A method for reinforcing and planning a resilient power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms, characterized in that, include: Based on the bibliometric optimization technique, this paper describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line failure rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected fault decisions of transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set for unexpected output loss of wind power. Based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in the transmission line and the uncertain set of unexpected output loss of wind power, and considering the reinforcement measures of transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a flexible power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure is constructed. A layered iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm is used to solve the reinforcement planning model, resulting in a power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elastic advancement improvement requirements under ice storm weather.
2. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms according to claim 1, characterized in that, The aforementioned fuzzy set based on the bibliometric optimization technique describes the uncertainty of unexpected transmission line faults under different ice storm scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line fault rate, establishing an enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected transmission line fault decisions, and establishing an uncertainty set for unexpected wind power output losses, including: Based on an adaptive two-stage sub-Bruker optimization model, the deviation of the unexpected failure rate of transmission lines is set, and a fuzzy set of unexpected failures of transmission lines based on moment information is constructed to describe the uncertainty of unexpected failures of transmission lines under ice disaster scenarios. Based on the aforementioned fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines based on moment information, a confidence interval based on Wasserstein distance is used as a statistical distance constraint to construct an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in transmission lines that incorporates Wasserstein distance. The impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on transmission line failure rates is reflected in the moment information to obtain transmission line failure rate intervals that characterize the impact of different levels of reinforcement decisions on line failure uncertainty; based on the enhanced fuzzy set and the transmission line failure rate intervals, a decision-dependent enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected transmission line failures is constructed. The wind power output loss budget in the expected transmission line fault scenario is taken as the expected output loss, and the output loss after considering uncertainty is taken as the unexpected output loss. The uncertainty of the unexpected wind power output loss is characterized by the robust box uncertainty set, and the uncertainty set of the unexpected wind power output loss is obtained.
3. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms according to claim 1, characterized in that, Based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in the transmission lines and the uncertain set of unexpected wind power output losses, and considering reinforcement measures for transmission line strengthening and energy storage configuration under ice storms, a differentiated reinforcement planning model for a resilient power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure is constructed, including: Based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults in the transmission line and the uncertain set of unexpected output loss of wind power, a two-stage, three-layer model framework for the differentiated reinforcement planning model of the flexible power generation and transmission system is established. Considering the reinforcement planning investment measures for transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather, the objective function of the differentiated reinforcement planning model of the resilient power generation and transmission system is to minimize the sum of reinforcement planning investment cost and system elastic performance loss cost. Considering the uncertainties of unexpected faults in transmission lines and unexpected power loss in wind power, constraints are established for the differentiated reinforcement planning model of the flexible power generation and transmission system. The above steps are used to construct the final elastic power generation and transmission system differential reinforcement planning model with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure.
4. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms as described in claim 3, characterized in that, The two-stage, three-layer model framework includes: The first stage corresponds to the upper-level model, with the goal of minimizing the sum of the investment cost of the reinforcement plan and the cost of the loss of system elasticity performance, and then passing the planning decision scheme to the second-stage model; The second stage corresponds to the middle and lower layer models. First, the middle layer model, based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected transmission line faults and the uncertainty set of unexpected wind power output losses, reveals the dual uncertainty of line fault uncertainty and output loss uncertainty under ice storm weather. By maximizing the cost of elastic performance loss, it finds the worst line fault state and the worst wind power output loss state. Then, the probability distribution of the worst line unexpected faults, the worst line fault state, and the worst wind power output loss state affected by the transmission line reinforcement decision are passed to the lower layer model. The lower layer model conducts operation simulation based on the planning decision scheme and uncertainty revelation, responds to the results of the worst uncertainty revelation, and then makes an operation decision scheme that adapts to uncertainty.
5. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms according to claim 3, characterized in that, The objective function includes: The system elastic performance loss cost is calculated based on the worst-case probability distribution of unexpected line failures and the unexpected power output loss conditions of wind power. The investment cost of the reinforcement plan includes: transmission line reinforcement cost and grid-side energy storage configuration cost; wherein, the transmission line reinforcement includes first-level reinforcement and second-level reinforcement, the first-level reinforcement is used to reinforce lines with anticipated faults, and the second-level reinforcement is used to reinforce lines with anticipated faults and lines with unintended faults; the grid-side energy storage configuration is used to provide emergency power support and rapid recovery support.
6. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms according to claim 3, characterized in that, The constraints include: investment restrictions on transmission line reinforcement, node power balance, DC power flow equations for transmission lines, transmission capacity of transmission lines, conventional unit combination, output of conventional units, logical relationship of conventional unit operating status, ramp-up and ramp-down rates of conventional units, system spinning reserve capacity, output of wind farms, output of photovoltaic power plants, operation of energy storage power plants, operation of pumped storage power plants, transmission of power from outside the interconnection busbar area, busbar load shedding, logical relationship of power supply and busbar availability status, transmission line repair status and actions, logical relationship between transmission line repair and recovery status, logical relationship between busbar islanding status, logical relationship between busbar islanding failure status, transmission line and busbar recovery requirements, differentiated reinforcement status of transmission lines, differentiated reinforcement and fault status of transmission lines, logical relationship between recovery status and availability status, and logical relationship between the proposed energy storage construction status and availability status.
7. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms according to claim 1, characterized in that, The layered iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm is used to solve the reinforcement planning model, resulting in a power transmission and power generation system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elasticity enhancement requirements under ice storm weather, including: The enhanced programming model is a mixed integer nonlinear programming problem with both continuous and discrete variables. The enhanced programming model is transformed in layers to obtain a three-layer nested model consisting of a first-stage model reconstructed from the expected value of the objective function of the middle-level model and a second-stage model containing uncertain variables. The three-layer nested model is divided into three optimization problems: an outer loop master problem, an inner loop master problem, and an inner loop subproblem. A customized NC&CG algorithm is used to iteratively solve the three optimization problems of the three-layer nested model, realizing the alternating update of different types of variables, including planning decision variables, uncertain variables of line fault and wind power output loss, continuous variables and discrete variables, to obtain the final flexible power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning scheme.
8. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms according to claim 7, characterized in that, The reconstruction and transformation of the expected value of the objective function of the intermediate model includes: Convert the reinforcement planning model into matrix form; Based on the matrix form, the expected value part of the objective function of the middle layer model in the reinforcement planning model is expanded, and the various probabilistic constraints contained in the enhanced fuzzy set for unexpected fault decision of transmission lines are expanded; wherein, the various probabilistic constraints include: probability normalization constraint, first-order moment constraint and Wasserstein distance constraint. Using duality theory, the expanded model is transformed, and the sample average approximation method is used to process the Wasserstein distance, resulting in the first-stage model after reconstruction of the expected value part. The second-stage model containing uncertain variables includes: After the expected value part is reconstructed and transformed, the original reinforced planning model is transformed into a three-level planning model of min-max-min that can be directly processed in layers. The two-level max-min model is combined into one through duality theory, and a loop is set in the second-stage model containing uncertain variables to separate the discrete and continuous variables of the max-min model. The three-layer nested model is divided into three optimization problems: the outer loop master problem, the inner loop master problem, and the inner loop subproblems, including: The outer loop master problem seeks the optimal transmission line differentiated reinforcement and energy storage configuration planning scheme and dual variables based on the worst unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst unexpected power loss state of wind power obtained from the inner loop master problem, as well as the original cutting plane stored by iterative solution, and then returns it to the inner loop master problem. The inner loop master problem transforms the max-min model into a max single-layer model through duality. Based on the planning scheme obtained from solving the outer loop master problem, the discrete variable values obtained from solving the inner loop subproblems, and the original cutting plane stored by the inner loop master problem itself through iterative solution, the worst unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst unexpected power loss state of wind power are found and fed back to the outer loop master problem or the inner loop subproblem. The inner loop subproblem seeks the discrete variable optimization results under the worst-case unexpected impact of the disaster based on the planning scheme and constraint dual variables obtained from solving the outer loop main problem, as well as the worst-case unexpected fault state of the transmission line and the worst-case unexpected power output loss state of the wind power obtained from solving the inner loop main problem, and feeds the obtained discrete variable optimization results back to the inner loop main problem.
9. The method for reinforcing and planning a flexible power generation and transmission system to adapt to the unintended impacts of ice storms according to claim 7, characterized in that, The customized NC&CG algorithm is used to iteratively solve the three optimization problems of the three-layer nested model, including: Based on the NC&CG algorithm, the constraints of transmission line and bus restoration requirements are not considered in the inner loop subproblem; for the multi-scenario problem of the inner loop main problem, parallel mode is used for computation to obtain a customized NC&CG algorithm. Using the customized NC&CG algorithm, the three optimization problems of the three-layer nested model are solved iteratively as follows: Perform outer loop initialization, including: setting the initial value of the upper bound of the outer loop, the initial value of the lower bound of the outer loop, and the number of iterations of the outer loop. And set the outer loop convergence gap, and give the initial values of the unexpected fault state variables of the transmission line and the initial values of the unexpected output loss state of the wind power. make Substitute the unexpected fault state of the line and the unexpected output loss state of wind power into the outer circulation master problem to obtain the reinforcement planning scheme and dual variables; calculate and update the lower bound of the outer circulation. Perform inner loop initialization, including: setting the initial value of the upper bound of the inner loop, the initial value of the lower bound of the inner loop, and the number of iterations of the inner loop. And set the inner loop convergence gap; make The reinforcement planning scheme, unexpected line fault state, unexpected wind power output loss state, and dual variables of the outer loop master problem are substituted into the inner loop subproblem for solution to obtain discrete variable values; the lower bound of the inner loop is calculated and updated. Substitute the reinforcement planning scheme and the discrete variable values into the inner loop master problem, perform parallel solution for multiple scenarios, obtain the unexpected fault state of the line and the unexpected output loss state of wind power under each ice disaster scenario, and use them to solve the outer loop master problem; calculate and update the upper bound of the inner loop. Based on the updated upper and lower bounds of the inner loop and the set inner loop convergence gap, determine whether the inner loop has converged. If it has converged, recalculate and update the upper bound of the outer loop, and exit the inner loop to check for outer loop convergence. Otherwise, return to the steps of solving the inner loop subproblem and continue iterating. Based on the updated upper bound and lower bound of the outer loop and the set outer loop convergence gap, determine whether the outer loop has converged; if it has converged, terminate the algorithm and output the final reinforcement planning scheme; otherwise, return to the steps of solving the outer loop main problem and continue iterating.
10. A resilient power generation and transmission system reinforcement planning system adapted to the unforeseen impacts of ice storms, characterized in that, include: The uncertainty set construction module, based on the bibliometric optimization technique, describes the uncertainty of unexpected faults of transmission lines under different ice disaster scenarios. It also considers the impact of different transmission line reinforcement decisions on the transmission line failure rate, establishes an enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected fault decision dependence of transmission lines, and establishes an uncertainty set of unexpected output loss of wind power. The reinforcement planning model construction module is based on the enhanced fuzzy set of unexpected faults of the transmission line and the uncertain set of unexpected output loss of wind power. It considers the reinforcement measures of transmission line reinforcement and energy storage configuration under ice storm weather and constructs a differentiated reinforcement planning model of the elastic power generation and transmission system with an upper-middle-lower three-layer adaptive structure. The model solving module uses a hierarchical iterative nested column and constraint generation algorithm to solve the reinforcement planning model and obtain a power transmission and distribution system reinforcement planning scheme that meets the elastic advancement improvement requirements under ice storm weather.
