METHOD FOR REGULATURE IN A PROCESS ENGINEERING APPARATUS
Patent Information
- Application Number
- DE502022002089
- Authority / Receiving Office
- DE · DE
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-04-15
- Filing Date
- 2022-04-05
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-28
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-04-05
AI Technical Summary
Existing temperature control methods in process engineering apparatuses suffer from non-linear control characteristics, weak control quality, and oscillation behavior, particularly during dynamic load changes and disturbances.
A method that involves calculating a control signal based on the heat flow and temperature difference between the actual and setpoint values, using a control algorithm to manipulate the flow rate of the liquid through the heat exchanger and the heat transfer medium, thereby stabilizing temperature control.
This approach results in more stable and precise temperature control, improving control quality during dynamic processes and disturbances by directly addressing heat flow dynamics.
Description
[0001] The invention relates to a method for controlling the temperature in a process engineering apparatus, in which a liquid is conveyed from the apparatus in a primary circuit, at least partially fed to a heat exchanger and at least partially returned to the apparatus.
[0002] Known temperature controls in a process engineering apparatus are described, among others, in the following publication on pages 165 - 171: H. Schuler, Prozessführung, Oldenbourg Verlag München Wien, 1999. Here, for example, temperatures are determined by sensors or flow rates by valve positions or flow sensors and used for the control as controller input signals.
[0003] Various concepts based on heat transfer elements within the reactor are known for controlling the temperature in a reactor. Such heat transfer elements can include, among other things, coiled tubing or a cooling or heating jacket on the outside of the reactor. For some exothermic reactions, however, a cooling jacket is not sufficient to dissipate the heat released during the reaction. In these cases, the reaction mixture is usually pumped from the reactor into a primary circuit containing a heat transferer and a return line to the reactor. The heat transferer removes the reaction heat from the reaction mixture. Details on the use, design, and function of heat transfer devices are disclosed, among other things, in Chapter 8.29 of the following document: BG Liptak, Process Control and Optimization, Instrument Engineers' Handbook, Volume Two, Taylor & Francis Inc., 4th Edition, 2005.
[0004] In a specific application for hydroformylation, document WO 2015 / 047723 A1 (THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY) discloses a temperature control system for a reactor. The temperature in the reactor is measured by a temperature sensor, and a control algorithm adjusts the flow rate through a heat exchanger in a primary circuit to maintain the reactor temperature at its setpoint. In an alternative variant, the primary circuit includes a bypass parallel to the heat exchanger, allowing the flow in the primary circuit to be split into two parallel substreams. In this case, the reactor temperature can also be controlled by influencing the flow through the bypass.
[0005] The disadvantages of these disclosed temperature controls are the non-linear control characteristics, the weak control quality and the oscillation behavior that occurs during dynamic processes such as a temporal load change or the influence of disturbance variables.
[0006] The challenge was therefore to provide a more stable and precise control system for the temperature in a process plant. This also aimed to improve the control quality in the event of dynamic load changes and process disturbances.
[0007] This object was achieved according to the invention by a method according to claim 1. Advantageous embodiments of the method according to the invention are specified in claims 2 to 12.
[0008] The method according to the invention for controlling the temperature in a process-engineering apparatus, in which a liquid is conveyed from the apparatus in a primary circuit, at least partially fed to a heat exchanger and at least partially returned to the apparatus, wherein the heat exchanger is cooled or heated by a heat transfer medium in a secondary circuit, comprises the steps: Providing a setpoint value for the temperature of the liquid in the device, detecting an actual value for the temperature of the liquid in the device, calculating the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint value of the liquid in the device.
[0009] According to the invention a heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit by the heat exchanger is determined, a control signal is calculated on the basis of a predetermined control algorithm, wherein the control algorithm is configured such that the control signal results from the heat flow and the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint value of the liquid in the apparatus, and the flow rate of the liquid flow through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit and / or a mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit is manipulated on the basis of the control signal.
[0010] It has been shown that taking heat flow into account when controlling the temperature in a process engineering device enables both more stable control and better control quality.
[0011] The control algorithm is configured such that the control signal is determined based on the heat flow and the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the fluid in the device. For the purposes of this document, this means that the heat flow and the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the fluid in the device are taken into account when calculating the control signal. With regard to the determination of the control signal based on the specified control algorithm, the terms "calculated" and "generated" are used synonymously in this document.
[0012] The terms "considered" and "consideration" in this document, with reference to the control algorithm, mean that an output variable calculated by the control algorithm, for example, a control signal, depends on the respective variable taken into account. These terms are not to be understood as exclusive. Considering a variable X does not preclude the consideration of a variable Y in the control algorithm. For example, considering the heat flow in the control algorithm means that the control signal is calculated based on the heat flow value, and considering the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the fluid in the device in the control algorithm means that the control signal is calculated based on the temperature difference.The dependency can be expressed, for example, by a mathematical function f of the form "control signal = f(heat flow, temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the fluid in the device)." Such a function can also contain other parameters or influencing variables besides the heat flow and the temperature difference, for example, disturbances.
[0013] In this document, a "process apparatus" is understood to mean an apparatus that can accommodate a volume of liquid and is suitable for the flow of a liquid through it, for example a reactor, a stirred vessel, a column, a phase separator, or a tank. In preferred embodiments of the process according to the invention, the process apparatus is a reactor.
[0014] In this document, a "heat exchanger" is understood to mean a device that can transfer heat from one medium to another. Plate heat exchangers or shell-and-tube heat exchangers can be used, for example, in the process according to the invention.
[0015] In this document, a "primary circuit" represents a circuit flow in which a fluid is pumped from the process equipment, at least partially fed to a heat exchanger, and at least partially returned to the equipment. The primary circuit may also contain branches, for example, as a bypass parallel to the process equipment. Multiple heat exchangers may also be present in the primary circuit, for example, as parallel circuits, series circuits, or combinations of parallel and series circuits.
[0016] A "control algorithm" as defined in this document generates a control signal for manipulating the flow rate of the liquid stream through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit depending on one or more control deviations, including the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid temperature in the device. According to the invention, the control algorithm additionally generates the control signal depending on the heat flow removed or added by a heat exchanger. The heat flow, like the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in the device, represents an influencing variable for the control algorithm. Other influencing variables can be considered in the control algorithm to calculate the control signal, for example, reactant flow rates or variables that represent a chemical reaction in the device.
[0017] The control algorithm can be created through the direct electronic interconnection of hardware components. Examples of hardware components include PID controllers, temperature sensors, flow sensors, and actuators for adjusting the heat transfer medium flow rate in the secondary circuit or the fluid flow rate in the primary circuit. The control algorithm can also be created through the interaction of hardware and software components, with the software components calculating one or more output signals based on input variables using computer-implemented numerical algorithms. The output signal can, for example, be the control signal for an actuator that adjusts, for example, the fluid flow rate.
[0018] The concrete design of how the individual influencing variables are related to each other and how the influencing variables generate the control signal in detail can be described, for example, by a mathematical relationship, preferably by a mathematical, algebraic function, or by partial or ordinary differential equations.
[0019] In many cases, process engineering processes are controlled and / or regulated by a process control system, which preferably uses single-variable controllers. Single-variable controllers receive an input signal and output an output signal according to their control algorithm. Thus, a single-variable controller can preferably also be a PID controller.
[0020] The mathematical relationships for the PID controller are explained below as examples. y t = K P e t + 1 T i ∫ 0 t e τ dτ + T d de t dt
[0021] Here y(t) is the controller output as a function of time t, e ( t) the control deviation as a function of time t, K P the controller gain, which represents the proportional part of the controller function, T i the integration time constant, which represents the integral part of the controller function, τ the integration variable and T d the derivative time constant, which represents the differential component of the controller function. The control deviation e ( t ) is calculated as the difference between the setpoint w(t) and the actual value x(t) to e ( t ) = w ( t ) - x ( t ) .
[0022] The control algorithm can also be an adaptive control algorithm. For example, the control algorithm can be configured so that a parameter of the control algorithm, e.g. the controller gain K P , is not fixed, but its value is calculated over time depending on certain process variables. For example, the controller gain K P as a function of the heat capacity flow on the primary and / or secondary sides of the heat exchanger to compensate for nonlinearities in the heat exchanger characteristics. The nonlinearities for the different flow patterns can be taken from well-known specialist literature, for example, the VDI Heat Atlas (VDI Heat Atlas, Springer Vieweg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 12th edition, 2019, ISBN 978-3-662-52988-1, eBook: 978-3-662-52989-8).
[0023] In this document, a "disturbance" is defined as a measured or estimated process variable that interferes with the controlled variable and is not influenced by the control algorithm. For example, this could be a raw material flow into the process equipment or a heat flow added or removed.
[0024] In this document, "feedforward control" means that the control algorithm takes a disturbance into account when calculating a control signal.
[0025] In this document, a "liquid" is defined as a single-phase or multi-phase fluid. The liquid is therefore free-flowing and can be pumped through the primary circuit. The liquid may also contain gas and / or solid components, provided such a liquid is still pumpable.
[0026] In this document, the term "liquid flow" refers to the "flow rate of the liquid stream" in the sense of the "flow rate of the liquid stream," unless the context otherwise indicates. Therefore, these three terms are used interchangeably in this document.
[0027] In this document, a "heat transfer medium" refers to a single-phase or multi-phase fluid, such as a liquid, a gas, a vapor, or mixtures thereof. The heat transfer medium is therefore fluid and can be pumped through the secondary circuit. The heat transfer medium can also contain solids, provided such a heat transfer medium is still pumpable. In some applications, the heat transfer medium is preferably heating steam, air, or filtered river water.
[0028] In a preferred embodiment of the method according to the invention, the control algorithm determines a heat flow difference between the determined heat flow as the actual value and a predetermined setpoint heat flow that can be fixed or variable over time. Based on this heat flow difference and the determined temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint temperature of the liquid in the device, a control signal is calculated, based on which the flow rate of the liquid through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit and / or the mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit is manipulated.
[0029] In a preferred embodiment of the method according to the invention, the heat flow is determined from the liquid flow through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the liquid before and after the heat exchanger in the primary circuit. In an alternative preferred embodiment, the heat flow is determined from a mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the heat transfer medium before and after the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit.These two preferred embodiments can also be combined so that the heat flow is determined from a liquid flow through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the liquid before and after the heat exchanger in the primary circuit and from a mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the heat transfer medium before and after the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit.
[0030] Determining the heat flow according to this embodiment has the advantage of being easy to implement in measurement technology. Proven and reliable flow and temperature sensors are commercially available for various applications, so that a simple and reliable determination of the heat flow can be achieved according to this embodiment of the method according to the invention. Furthermore, by recording the flow rates and temperatures used for the determination in the vicinity of the heat exchanger, any disturbances or fluctuations that may occur there can be quickly detected and taken into account in the temperature control before the disturbances or fluctuations affect the temperature in the process equipment.
[0031] In a further preferred embodiment of the method according to the invention, the control algorithm comprises a temperature controller and a heat flow controller, wherein the temperature controller calculates a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit by the heat exchanger as an output signal depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint value of the liquid in the apparatus, this setpoint is transferred to the heat flow controller, and the heat flow controller generates the control signal for manipulating the liquid flow in the primary circuit and / or for manipulating the mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit as an output signal depending on the difference between the actual value and the setpoint value of the heat flow.This design of the control algorithm corresponds to a cascade control with the temperature controller as the master controller and the heat flow controller as the slave controller.
[0032] In an advantageous embodiment of the cascade control, the master controller and the slave controller are each implemented as PID controllers. To construct the cascade, the controller output y 1 ( t ) of the master controller is equal to the setpoint w 2 ( t ) of the slave controller. The actual values are derived from the temperature measurement in the device and the determined heat flow.
[0033] In a particularly preferred embodiment of the cascade control, the following equations are implemented in the master controller and the slave controller: y 1 t = w 2 t = Q ˙ HE , soll = K P , 1 T R , soll t − T R t + 1 T i , 1 ∫ 0 t T R , soll τ − T R τ dτ + T d , 1 d T R , soll t − T R t dt y 2 t = m ˙ HE , soll = K P , 2 Q ˙ HE , soll t − Q ˙ HE t + 1 T i , 2 ∫ 0 t Q ˙ HE , soll τ − Q ˙ HE τ dτ + T d , 2 d Q ˙ HE , soll t − Q ˙ HE t dt
[0034] Here are Q̇ HE,soll the setpoint of the heat flow determined by the master controller, K P,1 is the controller gain of the master controller for the temperature of the liquid in the apparatus, T R,soll the setpoint temperature of the liquid in the device, T R the actual value of the temperature of the liquid in the device, T i, 1 is the integration time constant of the master controller for the temperature of the liquid in the apparatus, T d ,1 is the derivative time constant of the master controller for the temperature of the liquid in the apparatus, ṁ HE,soll the setpoint of the controlled mass flow through the heat exchanger, K P ,2 the controller gain of the slave controller for the heat flow, Q̇ HE the actual value of the heat flow, T i ,2 is the integration time constant of the heat flow follower controller and T d, 2 the derivative time constant of the heat flow follower controller.
[0035] It has been found that the heat flow removed from or added to the fluid in the primary circuit by the heat exchanger reacts more quickly to control algorithm interventions or disturbances than the temperature measurable in the process equipment. Cascading a temperature controller as a master controller and a heat flow controller as a slave controller has the advantage of exploiting the differences in the dynamics of the sub-control loops to adjust the setpoint temperature in the process equipment more quickly and precisely in the event of setpoint changes or disturbances. This improves the control quality of the control algorithm.
[0036] In a preferred embodiment, at least one bypass is connected in parallel to the heat exchanger in the primary circuit. This allows the liquid flow in the primary circuit to be designed more flexibly. This is advantageous, for example, when there are technical or process-related restrictions that affect the liquid flow in the primary circuit. For example, when using a cost-efficient air cooler as a heat exchanger, the cooling capacity can usually only be adjusted in stages or only to a constant value. In such a case, in which the air cooler is operated constantly, a bypass in the primary circuit also has the advantage that the flow of the liquid through the heat exchanger can be very easily controlled, as the temperature in the process apparatus can be controlled by manipulating the liquid flow through the bypass.
[0037] The manipulation of the fluid flow through the heat exchanger in the primary circuit can be realized in different ways, for example directly, indirectly or by a combination of direct and indirect manipulation.
[0038] In the case of direct manipulation of the fluid flow through the heat exchanger, at least one actuator and / or a pump for manipulating the fluid flow on the basis of the control signal is preferably present in the primary circuit in the supply line to the heat exchanger or in the discharge line from the heat exchanger or in both the supply line to the heat exchanger and the discharge line from the heat exchanger.
[0039] In the case of indirect manipulation of the liquid flow through the heat exchanger, at least one actuator and / or a pump for manipulating the liquid flow through the heat exchanger on the basis of the control signal is preferably present in a bypass connected in parallel to the heat exchanger.
[0040] In a combination of direct and indirect manipulation, at least one actuator for manipulating the fluid flow based on the control signal is preferably provided in a bypass connected in parallel to the heat exchanger. Furthermore, in this variant, at least one actuator for manipulating the fluid flow based on the control signal is provided in the primary circuit in the supply line to the heat exchanger or in the discharge line from the heat exchanger, or in both the supply line to the heat exchanger and the discharge line from the heat exchanger.
[0041] In order to manipulate the mass flow of the heat transfer medium through the heat exchanger in the secondary circuit on the basis of the control signal, at least one control element is preferably present in the supply line to the heat exchanger or in the discharge line from the heat exchanger or in both the supply line to the heat exchanger and the discharge line from the heat exchanger.
[0042] Suitable control elements are known to those skilled in the art. The control element is preferably a control valve capable of quickly and precisely adjusting a flow rate.
[0043] According to the invention, a heat flow is removed from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit by a heat exchanger. Furthermore, the liquid flow through the heat exchanger and / or the mass flow of the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit is manipulated by a control signal. However, the invention is not limited to exactly one heat exchanger. The invention also encompasses embodiments in which multiple heat exchangers are present in the primary circuit. These can be arranged in parallel circuits, series circuits, or combinations of parallel and series circuits. In this case, the liquid flow is manipulated by at least one heat exchanger. However, liquid flows through multiple heat exchangers can also be manipulated by the method according to the invention.
[0044] In one embodiment, an additional heat exchanger is connected in parallel to the first heat exchanger in the primary circuit, so that the process equipment can be tempered by two heat exchangers if necessary. Such a configuration increases flexibility with regard to the provision of heat or cooling capacity. One application example in which this flexibility can be exploited economically is the coupling of heat or cooling capacity from other process stages or other systems that would otherwise remain unused and cannot be influenced within the scope of the inventive control system.
[0045] In a further embodiment, at least one actuator and / or a pump for manipulating the fluid flow on the basis of the control signal is present in the primary circuit in the supply line to the first and second heat exchanger.
[0046] In a further embodiment, at least one actuator and / or a pump for manipulating the fluid flow on the basis of the control signal is present in the primary circuit in the supply line to the first and second heat exchangers and in a bypass connected in parallel to the heat exchangers.
[0047] In designs that have an actuator in a bypass and / or at least two heat exchangers with associated actuators, the fluid flow can be limited by the respective heat exchanger. This is particularly advantageous when, for example, a pump for the primary circuit can only deliver a constant fluid flow.
[0048] In an embodiment in which the liquid flow in the primary circuit is pumped by a pump with a variable flow rate, this pump can advantageously be used to manipulate the flow rate of the liquid flow through the heat exchanger on the basis of the control signal, for example by the control signal specifying the speed of the pump.
[0049] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm comprises a split-range control in which, instead of one control signal, at least two control signals are calculated and at least two currents in the primary circuit and / or in the secondary circuit are manipulated, wherein a first current is manipulated as a function of a first control signal and a second current is manipulated as a function of a second control signal.
[0050] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm comprises a split-range control in which at least two control signals are calculated and at least two flows in the primary circuit are manipulated, wherein a first liquid flow is manipulated in dependence on a first control signal and a second liquid flow is manipulated in dependence on a second control signal.
[0051] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm comprises a split-range control in which at least two control signals are calculated and at least two flows in the secondary circuit are manipulated, wherein a first mass flow is manipulated in dependence on a first control signal and a second mass flow is manipulated in dependence on a second control signal.
[0052] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm comprises a split-range control in which at least two control signals are calculated and at least two flows, one in the primary circuit and one in the secondary circuit, are manipulated, wherein a liquid flow in the primary circuit is manipulated in dependence on a first control signal and a mass flow in the secondary circuit is manipulated in dependence on a second control signal.
[0053] Designs with split-range controls are particularly advantageous when actuators with different nominal diameters and thus significantly different flow rates are present. In such a case, precise control of the heat transfer medium flow rate can be ensured by arranging a large actuator designed for large flow rates and a small actuator designed for small flow rates in parallel.
[0054] In a preferred embodiment of the method according to the invention, in which at least one bypass is connected in parallel to a heat exchanger in the primary circuit, the amount of liquid conveyed from the process apparatus into the primary circuit is adjusted to a predetermined target value by determining the actual value of the liquid quantity, calculating an output signal from the comparison between the actual value and the target value, and manipulating the liquid flow through the bypass using the output signal. This embodiment is particularly advantageous when the liquid flow conveyed from the process apparatus into the primary circuit should or must be kept constant, but at the same time, efficient temperature control in the apparatus is desired.
[0055] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm considers at least one disturbance variable when calculating the control signal, wherein the disturbance variable comprises a measured or estimated process variable. For example, the disturbance variable can represent a raw material flow fed into the process equipment. The disturbance variable can also include one or more other heat flows. This offers the advantage, among other things, that the control system can react in a timely manner to, for example, an impending change in the heat released or consumed in the equipment due to changes in the input flows. Multiple or combined disturbance variables can also be considered.
[0056] In a further embodiment, a chemical or biological, endothermic or exothermic reaction or an exothermic or endothermic physical process takes place in the process apparatus.
[0057] In a preferred embodiment, the reaction is a hydroformylation, etherification, ether cleavage, enalization, dehydrogenation, pyrolysis, hydrogenation or a cracking process.
[0058] In a particularly preferred embodiment, the hydrogenation is a full hydrogenation, selective hydrogenation or core hydrogenation.
[0059] In such reactions and processes, significant load changes or influences from disturbances can occur. The method according to the invention ensures rapid and robust adjustment of the desired temperature in the process equipment, especially for such demanding control tasks.
[0060] In a further embodiment, the control algorithm is a multivariable controller, preferably a model predictive controller or a state-space controller. This offers the advantage, among other things, that several physical variables can be simultaneously recorded in the process and used for control.
[0061] The invention is explained in more detail below with reference to the drawings. The drawings are to be understood as schematic representations. They do not represent a limitation of the invention, for example, with regard to specific dimensions or design variants. They show: Fig. 1: Process engineering apparatus with external heat exchangers and control structure for controlling the reactor temperature according to the prior art Fig. 2: Process engineering apparatus with external heat exchangers and control structure for controlling the reactor temperature according to a first embodiment of the invention Fig. 3: Process engineering apparatus with external heat exchangers and control structure for controlling the reactor temperature according to a second embodiment of the invention Fig. 4: Process engineering apparatus with external heat exchangers and control structure for controlling the reactor temperature according to a third embodiment of the invention Fig. 5: Process engineering apparatus with external heat exchangers and control structure for controlling the reactor temperature according to a fourth embodiment of the invention Fig. 6: Control behavior with a setpoint change of 1°C for example 1 with control according to the prior art with temperature-temperature cascade Fig.Fig. 7: Control behavior when the setpoint changes by 1°C for example 1 with inventive control using a temperature-heat flow cascade. Fig. 8: Fault behavior when the propene feed changes by 10% for example 1 with state-of-the-art control using a temperature-temperature cascade. Fig. 9: Fault behavior when the propene feed changes by 10% for example 1 with inventive control using a temperature-heat flow cascade. Fig. 10: Fault behavior when the heat flow to be extracted changes by heat integration by 10% for example 1 with state-of-the-art control using a temperature-temperature cascade. Fig. 11: Fault behavior when the heat flow to be extracted changes by heat integration by 10% for example 1 with inventive control using a temperature-heat flow cascade. List of reference symbols used:
[0062] 101 Process equipment 102 Primary circuit 103 Heat exchanger 104 Secondary circuit 105 Temperature controller with temperature sensor in the process equipment 106 Heat flow sequence controller 108, 109 Actuator 110 Pump 111 Material recovery line 112 Temperature sensor in the return line of the primary circuit to the process equipment 113 Temperature sequence controller including a temperature sensor in the return line of the heat exchanger 120 Line (synthesis gas) 121 Line (propene) 122 Line (solvent) 123 Line for the discharge of the target product 124 Controller for the liquid level in the process equipment 125 Pressure regulator 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 140 Actuator 141External pressure signal specification 142Heat exchanger 143Flow controller for adjusting the fluid flow through the heat exchanger 144Secondary circuit 145Temperature sensor after the heat exchanger 201 Process equipment 202 Primary circuit 203 Heat exchanger 204 Secondary circuit 205 Temperature controller with temperature sensor in the process equipment 206 Heat flow sequence controller 208 Actuator 209 Large actuator for adjusting the heat transfer medium flow of the heat exchanger 210 Pump 211 Line (exhaust gas) 212 Temperature sensor in the return line of the heat exchanger 214 Small actuator 220 Line for inert gas (nitrogen) 221 Line (aldehyde) 222 Line (water with catalyst) 223 Line for the discharge of the target product 224 Controller for the liquid level (water) in the phase separator 226, 227, 228, 229, 230 Actuator 231 Line for the wastewater 232Regulator for the liquid level (target product) in the phase separator 233Actuator 234Split-range regulator 240Phase separator 243Pressure regulator for controlling the exhaust gas flow 301 Process equipment 302 Primary circuit 303 Heat exchanger 304 Secondary circuit 305 Temperature controller with temperature sensor in the process equipment 306 Heat flow sequence controller 307 Bypass 309 Actuator 310 Pump 311 Line for the exhaust gas 312 Temperature sensor in the return line of the heat exchanger 315 Temperature sensor directly before the return of the liquid flow to the process equipment 316 Actuator 320 Line (hydrogen) 321 Line (alkene) 323 Line (crude alcohol) 324 Controller for the liquid level in the process equipment 325 Pressure regulator 326, 327, 329, 330 Actuator 343 Flow controller which controls the mass flow (crude alcohol) pretends 401 Process equipment 402 Primary circuit 403 Heat exchanger 404 Secondary circuit 405 Temperature controller with temperature sensor in the process equipment 406 Heat flow sequence controller 407 Bypass 408, 409 Actuator 410 Pump 412 Temperature sensor in the return line of the heat exchanger 415 Temperature sensor immediately before the return of the liquid flow to the process equipment 416 Actuator 417 Disturbance calculation 420 Line (ammonium nitrate) 421 Line (water) 423 Line for the discharge of the target product 424 Controller for the liquid level in the process equipment 426, 427, 430 Actuator 435 Pressure controller for regulating the heat transfer medium flow for the heat exchanger
[0063] Fig. 1 shows a process flow diagram of a prior art process in which the temperature in a reactor 101, as a process apparatus, is adjusted via external heat exchangers 103, 142. Feed materials are fed to the reactor 101 via separate lines, and are converted into one or more products in the reactor. In the example shown, a gaseous feed material is fed via line 120, and liquid or gaseous feed materials are fed via lines 121 and 122. The feed of the feed materials in lines 121 and 122 is quantity-controlled via two control valves 127, 128 in the feed lines. The quantity of gaseous feed material fed into line 120 is adjusted via a pressure regulator 125 and a control valve 126 in the feed line so that a predetermined pressure is maintained in the reactor 101.
[0064] Gaseous reaction products and any unreacted gaseous feedstocks are removed from the reactor via a gaseous reactor discharge 111. In the example shown, the discharge is volume-controlled via a control valve 129 in the reactor discharge 111. Liquid reaction products are discharged via a pump 110 into a primary circuit 102, which connects the reactor 101 to two external heat exchangers 103, 142. The liquid flow conveyed from the reactor 101 into the primary circuit 102 is divided between the two heat exchangers and can be adjusted via actuators 108, 140 in the respective feed lines to the heat exchangers. The partial flows of the primary circuit heated or cooled in the heat exchangers are returned to the reactor. A portion of the liquid flow is withdrawn from the primary circuit 102 as liquid reactor discharge 123.The withdrawal takes place via a control valve 130 in the withdrawal line and via a level controller 124 in such a way that a predetermined liquid level is maintained in the reactor.
[0065] The temperature in reactor 101 is set to a predetermined value. Depending on whether the reaction in the reactor is endothermic or exothermic, heat must be added to or removed from the reactor. The two heat exchangers make different contributions to this. While the second heat exchanger 142 carries a base load for heat exchange, the first heat exchanger 103 is used to regulate the temperature. The quantity of heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 144 of the second heat exchanger 142 is not volume-controlled, whereas the quantity of heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 104 of the first heat exchanger 103 is set to a predetermined value via a control valve 109.In the example shown, the amount of fluid flowing from the primary circuit into the second heat exchanger is adjusted via a flow controller 143 and the control valve 140 in the inlet so that a certain temperature is maintained in a subsequent process stage. This process stage is shown in . Fig. 1 Not shown. The setpoint flow rate as the controller output of the temperature controller in the process stage not shown is symbolized by the dashed line 141.
[0066] To regulate the temperature in reactor 101, a cascade control system is provided, comprising a first temperature controller 105 as the master controller and a second temperature controller 113 as the slave controller. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 101 is specified to master controller 105. The actual value of the temperature in reactor 101 is recorded by a temperature sensor. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in the reactor, master controller 105 calculates a setpoint for the temperature of the liquid as an output signal. The liquid is fed back to the reactor as return from the heat exchangers in the primary circuit. This setpoint is passed to slave controller 113, which generates a control signal for control valve 108 in the inlet to the first heat exchanger from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the temperature of the returned liquid as an output signal.
[0067] Fig. 2 shows a schematic process flow diagram of a process according to a first embodiment of the process according to the invention, in which the temperature in a reactor 101 is adjusted via external heat exchangers 103, 142. The arrangement and connection of the apparatus as well as the basic controls in the feed and discharge lines are identical to the process according to the prior art, so that in this regard, reference is made to the above statements on Fig. 1 is referred to.
[0068] However, the process according to the invention differs from the prior art process in the structure for controlling the reactor temperature. Fig. 2 In the example shown, a cascade control system is provided for controlling the temperature in reactor 101, which comprises a temperature controller 105 as the master controller and a heat flow controller 106 as the slave controller. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 101 is specified to master controller 105. The actual value of the temperature in reactor 101 is recorded via a temperature sensor. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in the reactor, master controller 105 calculates a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in primary circuit 102 by heat exchangers 103 and 142 as an output signal. This setpoint is transferred to heat flow slave controller 106, which generates a control signal for control valve 108 in the inlet to the first heat exchanger from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the heat flow as an output signal.
[0069] In the Fig. 2 In the example shown, the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit 102 by the heat exchangers 103 and 142 is calculated from a portion of the first heat exchanger 103 and a portion of the second heat exchanger 142. The portion of the first heat exchanger 103 is determined from the liquid flow flowing through the control valve 108 in the inlet to the heat exchanger and from the temperature difference between the temperature of the liquid before and after the heat exchanger 103 in the primary circuit. The actual value of the reactor temperature 105 is used as the temperature before the heat exchanger. The temperature after the heat exchanger is determined via a temperature sensor 112 in the outlet of the heat exchanger.Similarly, the share of the second heat exchanger 142 is determined from the fluid flow flowing through the control valve 140 in the inlet to the heat exchanger and from the temperature difference between the fluid temperature before and after the heat exchanger 142 in the primary circuit. The actual value of the reactor temperature 105 is used as the temperature before the heat exchanger. The temperature after the heat exchanger is determined via a temperature sensor 145 in the outlet of the heat exchanger.
[0070] Controlling the process via the heat flow leads to a significantly better control quality compared to the control method known from the state of the art, as can be seen from the following Comparative Example 1 and Example 1.
[0071] In a variant of the first embodiment of the method according to the invention according to Fig. 2 Disturbances are taken into account when calculating the control signal for control valve 108. In the example shown, the disturbances are changes in the composition and / or quantity of the feedstocks. The flow rates of the feedstocks are recorded in control valves 126, 127, and 128. Thus, both the absolute quantities and their ratios to one another are known. The measured values of these measured process variables are fed to heat flow controller 106. Knowledge of the disturbances and their consideration when calculating the control signal for control valve 108 in the inlet to the first heat exchanger 103 enables even faster response to control deviations and thus even better control quality.
[0072] Fig. 3 shows a schematic process flow diagram of a process according to a second embodiment of the process according to the invention, in which the temperature in a reactor 201 as a process apparatus is adjusted via an external heat exchanger 203. A liquid feedstock 221 is fed to the reactor 201 via a line, which is converted into one or more products in the reactor. The feed is volume-controlled by a control valve 227. A further liquid stream containing catalyst 222 is added in a predetermined ratio to the liquid flow of the feed, which is also volume-controlled by a control valve 228.
[0073] The liquid product produced in reactor 201 is withdrawn together with the catalyst-added liquid 222 in the upper region of reactor 201 and fed to a phase separator 240.
[0074] To prevent the potential formation of an explosive atmosphere in the phase separator 240, an inert gas 220 is pumped into the phase separator 240 at a controlled rate. The pressure in the phase separator 240 is regulated by the discharge of exhaust gas 232 through a control valve 229, which receives its control signal from the gas pressure regulator 243 in the phase separator 240. The exhaust gas can include inert gas, such as nitrogen, as well as any gaseous or vaporized reaction products.
[0075] The level of the phase interface between the two liquid phases is controlled by a level controller 224 via the discharge of the wastewater 231. The upper total level in the tank is controlled via the product discharge of the liquid product 223. This control is carried out by a level controller 232, whose control signal controls the control valve 230.
[0076] A partial flow of the liquid phase in reactor 201 is forced into a primary circuit 202 via a pump 210, which connects reactor 201 to an external heat exchanger 203. The flow rate conveyed from reactor 201 into primary circuit 202 is adjustable by control valve 208. The flow in the primary circuit heated or cooled in heat exchanger 203 is returned to reactor 201.
[0077] In the example shown, the heat flow removed from or added to the fluid in primary circuit 202 by heat exchanger 203 is calculated. The heat flow removed from or added to the fluid in heat exchanger 203 is determined from the fluid flow flowing through control valve 208 in the inlet to the heat exchanger and from the temperature difference between the fluid temperature before and after heat exchanger 203 in the primary circuit. The actual value of the reactor temperature 205 is used as the temperature before the heat exchanger. The temperature after the heat exchanger is determined via a temperature sensor 212 in the outlet of the heat exchanger.
[0078] In the example shown, a cascade control system is provided for controlling the temperature in reactor 201, comprising temperature controller 205 as the master controller and a heat flow controller 206 as the slave controller. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 201 is specified to master controller 205. The actual value of the temperature in reactor 201 is recorded via a temperature sensor. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in reactor 201, master controller 205 calculates a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in primary circuit 202 by heat exchanger 203 as an output signal. This setpoint is passed to heat flow slave controller 206, which generates a control signal for control valve 208 in the inlet to heat exchanger 203 from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the heat flow as an output signal.
[0079] The control algorithm comprises a split-range control in which two control signals are calculated and two mass flows in the secondary circuit 204 are manipulated, wherein a first mass flow is manipulated in dependence on a first control signal and a second mass flow is manipulated in dependence on a second control signal.
[0080] The flow rate in the secondary circuit 204 is split into two parallel flow streams before they reunite and flow through the heat exchanger 203. By splitting the flow rate in parallel, an actuator can be arranged in each of the two resulting streams to manipulate the respective flow rate. In this example, the two actuators are provided with different nominal diameters, allowing significantly different flow rates to be set. This ensures precise control of the heat transfer medium flow rate by designing the larger of the two actuators for large flow rates and the smaller of the two actuators for small flow rates.
[0081] When using, for example, river water as the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 204, the river water is drained out of the system after passing through the heat exchanger 204.
[0082] The Fig. 3 The second embodiment of the process according to the invention shown is suitable, for example, for processes for the enalization of aldehydes. In such processes, free-jet reactors 201 are typically used to react aldehydes with water in the presence of a catalyst to obtain enals as the target products. During the production of enals, heat is released, which is removed via the external heat exchanger 203.
[0083] An aldehyde is fed to reactor 201 in a controlled manner as liquid feedstock 221. An aqueous liquid stream 222 containing a catalyst in an aqueous phase is fed to reactor 201 in a predetermined ratio to the aldehyde stream. The liquid product enal formed in reactor 201 is withdrawn together with the catalyst-added liquid 222 in the upper region of reactor 201 and fed to a phase separator 240. To prevent the possible formation of an explosive atmosphere, nitrogen is fed to phase separator 240 as inert gas 220. In phase separator 240, the liquid phase containing the catalyst is withdrawn via line 231. The target product enal is withdrawn in the organic phase via line 223.
[0084] A partial flow of the liquid phase in reactor 201 is forced into a primary circuit 202 as a recirculating flow via a pump 210. This liquid flow is selected such that intensive mixing of the organic and aqueous phases occurs in reactor 201. This results from a power input introduced into the liquid by the recirculation. The power input into reactor 201 by the liquid flow is thus adjustable.
[0085] In this embodiment, the heat flow is advantageously regulated by the mass flow of the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 204.
[0086] To control the various control loops, PID controllers with controller parameters optimized for the desired steady state are preferably used. The actual value of the heat flow extracted in the heat exchanger 203 is calculated using the measured temperature value. T in in reactor 201, the measured temperature T out ,1 212 after the heat exchanger 203, the measured value of the mass flow ṁ 1 through the control valve 208 in the inlet to the heat exchanger 203 and the parameter of the heat capacity cl for the medium of the liquid flow according to the formula Q̇ 1 = cl ṁ 1 ( T in - T out ,1 ).
[0087] Fig. 4 shows a schematic process flow diagram of a process according to a third embodiment of the process according to the invention, in which the temperature in a reactor 301 as a process apparatus is adjusted via an external heat exchanger 303. A liquid feedstock 321 is fed to the reactor 301 via a line, which is converted into one or more products in the reactor. The feed is volume-controlled by a control valve 327.
[0088] A gas stream 320 is added to reactor 301, the flow of which is controlled by a control valve 326. The control valve 326 receives its control signal from a pressure regulator 325, which regulates the pressure in the reactor. Gaseous byproducts are removed from the reactor via a gaseous outlet 311 and a control valve 329 in a controlled manner.
[0089] The liquid product produced in the reactor 301 is pumped by a circulation pump 310 from the reactor 301 into a primary circuit 302, which connects the reactor 301 to an external heat exchanger 303.
[0090] The fluid flow through heat exchanger 303 can also be indirectly adjusted by a control valve 316 located in a bypass 307 in the primary circuit. The bypass in the primary circuit is connected in parallel to heat exchanger 303.
[0091] The stream heated or cooled in the heat exchanger 303 as well as the stream through the bypass 307 in the primary circuit are returned to the reactor 301.
[0092] A portion of the liquid stream is withdrawn from the primary circuit 302 as liquid reactor effluent 323. The withdrawal occurs via a flow regulator 343 and a control valve 330 in the withdrawal line and via a level regulator 324 in such a way that a predetermined liquid level is maintained in the reactor.
[0093] In the example shown, the heat flow removed from or added to the fluid in the primary circuit 302 by the heat exchanger 303 is calculated from the fluid flow through the heat exchanger 303 and from the temperature difference between the fluid temperature before and after the heat exchanger 303 in the primary circuit. The actual value of the reactor temperature 305 is used as the temperature before the heat exchanger. The temperature after the heat exchanger is determined via a temperature sensor 312 in the heat exchanger outlet.
[0094] In this example according to the invention, a cascade control system is provided for controlling the temperature in reactor 301, comprising temperature controller 305 as the master controller and a heat flow follower controller 306. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 301 is specified to temperature controller 305. The actual temperature in reactor 301 is detected by a temperature sensor 305. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in reactor 301, heat flow follower controller 306 calculates a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in primary circuit 302 by heat exchanger 303 as an output signal. This setpoint is transferred to heat flow follower controller 306, which generates a control signal for control valve 316 in bypass 307 from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the heat flow as an output signal.
[0095] The quantity of heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 304 of the heat exchanger 303 is controlled by a control valve 309 and is usually set to a fixed value. The heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 304 is selected according to the required cooling or heating capacity. In the case of cooling, river water or chilled water is preferably used as the heat transfer medium.
[0096] The Fig. 4 The third embodiment of the process according to the invention shown is suitable, for example, for processes for the hydrogenation of alkenes and aldehydes, selective hydrogenations such as the selective hydrogenation of butadiene, and etherifications. In such processes, fixed-bed reactors 301 are typically used to convert the starting materials into the target products.
[0097] In the example of a hydrogenation, the liquid feedstock to be hydrogenated is fed to reactor 301 via line 321 in a controlled manner. Hydrogen is fed to reactor 301 in gaseous form via line 320 under pressure control. Gaseous by-products are removed from the reactor via a gaseous outlet 311 through a control valve 329 in a controlled manner. The liquid product produced in reactor 301, for example, butanol, is withdrawn from the primary circuit via line 323 in a controlled manner.
[0098] To control the various control loops, PID controllers with controller parameters optimized for the desired steady state are preferably used. The actual value of the heat flow extracted in heat exchanger 303 is calculated using the measured temperature value. T in in reactor 301, the measured temperature T out ,1 312 after the heat exchanger 303, the measured value of the mass flow ṁ 1 in the inlet to the heat exchanger 303 and the parameter of the heat capacity cl for the medium of the liquid flow according to the formula Q̇ 1 = c l ṁ 1 ( T in - T out, 1 ).
[0099] Fig. 5 shows a schematic process flow diagram of a process according to a fourth embodiment of the method according to the invention, in which the temperature in a reactor 401 is adjusted via an external heat exchanger 403. A first liquid feedstock 421 is fed to the reactor 401 via a line, which is converted into one or more products in the reactor. The feed is quantity-controlled by a control valve 427. A second liquid feedstock 420 is added to the reactor 401, which is controlled via a control valve 426 based on a measured substance concentration (Q1) in the liquid flow of the primary circuit 402. The substance concentration can also be determined using a substitute variable, for example conductivity, density, viscosity, or speed of sound, insofar as the substitute variable allows a conclusion to be drawn about the substance concentration.
[0100] The liquid product produced in reactor 401 is pumped by a circulation pump 410 from reactor 401 into a primary circuit 402, which connects reactor 401 to an external heat exchanger 403. The flow rate through heat exchanger 403 can be adjusted indirectly by a control valve 416 in a bypass 407 and directly by a control valve 408 upstream of heat exchanger 403.
[0101] The stream heated or cooled in the heat exchanger 403 as well as the stream through the bypass 407 in the primary circuit are returned to the reactor 401.
[0102] A portion of the liquid stream is withdrawn from the primary circuit 402 as liquid reactor discharge 423. The withdrawal occurs via a flow controller and a control valve 430 in the withdrawal line and via a level controller 424 such that a predetermined liquid level is maintained in the reactor.
[0103] In this example, the heat flow removed from or added to the fluid in the primary circuit 402 by the heat exchanger 403 is calculated from the fluid flow through the heat exchanger 403 and from the temperature difference between the fluid temperature before and after the heat exchanger 403 in the primary circuit. The actual value of the reactor temperature 405 is used as the temperature before the heat exchanger. The temperature after the heat exchanger is determined via a temperature sensor 412 in the heat exchanger outlet.
[0104] In this example according to the invention, a cascade control system is provided for controlling the temperature in reactor 401, comprising the temperature controller 405 as the master controller and a heat flow controller 406 as the slave controller. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 401 is specified to the master controller 405. The actual temperature in reactor 401 is detected by a temperature sensor 405. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in reactor 401, the master controller 405 calculates, as an output signal, a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in primary circuit 402 by heat exchanger 403. This setpoint is transferred to the heat flow slave controller 406, which calculates control signals from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the heat flow.The control algorithm of the slave controller 406 is implemented as a split-range control, in which two control signals are calculated. Depending on a first control signal, the fluid flow in the bypass 407 is manipulated via the control valve 416. Depending on a second control signal, the fluid flow in the primary circuit 402 is manipulated by the control valve 408 in the inlet of the heat exchanger 403. Depending on the fluid flows to be adjusted, the two control valves 408, 416 can be adjusted independently of each other between their closed and open positions.
[0105] In the Fig. 5 In the example shown, the control algorithm also takes disturbance variables into account when calculating the control signal. One disturbance variable that is known in the exemplary process is the influence of the supplied quantity of feedstock on the heat development in the reactor. Depending on whether the reaction is exothermic or endothermic, the supply of the second feedstock 420 to the first feedstock 421 causes the temperature in the reactor 401 to increase or decrease. The positive or negative heat quantity due to the supplied quantity of second feedstock 420 is calculated and applied to the slave controller 406 as a disturbance variable. The heat quantity can be calculated within the slave controller or, as in Fig. 5 shown in a separate model module 417. By taking the disturbance variable into account, the control algorithm is able to react proactively to the expected change in temperature in reactor 401, even before the change is detectable via temperature sensor 405. This allows load changes, fluctuations, or setpoint changes in the process to be controlled more quickly and effectively, leading to improved control quality.
[0106] The flow rate of the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 404 of the heat exchanger 403 is adjusted by a control valve 409 and a pressure regulator 435 so that a predetermined pressure is maintained in the heat transfer medium inlet to the heat exchanger. This is particularly advantageous when heating steam is used as the heat transfer medium. The heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 404 is selected according to the requirements for the required cooling or heating capacity. In the case of a heating system, heating steam is preferably used as the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit 404.
[0107] The Fig. 5 The fourth embodiment of the method according to the invention shown is suitable, for example, for methods in which the process apparatus 401 is a stirred vessel in which different substances are mixed with one another or one substance is to be dissolved in another substance.
[0108] In the example of producing an aqueous solution of ammonium nitrate, water is supplied to the stirred tank 401 via line 421 at a controlled rate. The ammonium nitrate to be dissolved is supplied to the stirred tank via line 420. The supply is controlled at a controlled rate, with the flow controller (FC) acting as a slave controller receiving its setpoint from a master controller (QC), which acts as a quality controller and regulates a predetermined concentration of a component or a predetermined substitute variable that allows a conclusion to be drawn about the concentration of a component in the liquid flow drawn into the primary circuit 402.
[0109] The quality controller ensures a constant composition of the produced solution. For example, the conductivity of the discharged solution serves as an easily accessible quality measure. The level in the stirred tank 401 is controlled by a level controller 424, which manipulates the discharge of the produced solution 423 through a control valve 430. The process is endothermic, so the heat extracted in the stirred tank 401 must be re-supplied through the heat exchanger 403. Heating steam is used for this purpose, the pressure of which in the supply line 404 is regulated by a pressure regulator 435, which controls the control valve 409.
[0110] To control the various control loops, PID controllers with controller parameters optimized for the desired steady state are preferably used. The actual value of the heat flow extracted in the heat exchanger 403 is calculated using the measured temperature value. T in in reactor 401, the measured temperature T out ,1 412 after the heat exchanger 403, the measured value of the mass flow ṁ 1 in the inlet to the heat exchanger 303 and the parameter of the heat capacity cl for the medium of the liquid flow according to the formula Q̇ 1 = c l ṁ 1 (T in - T out, 1 ).
[0111] As a disturbance variable feedforward, the expected heat quantity flow to be supplied is recorded on the basis of the ammonium nitrate 420 by a heat quantity calculation 417 and fed to the heat quantity controller 406 as a disturbance variable. Examples: Comparison example 1
[0112] The hydroformylation of propene is carried out industrially in a bubble column reactor using a rhodium-triphenylphosphine complex as a catalyst. Heat is released during the reaction, which must be removed from the reactor. The process flow diagram of such a state-of-the-art process is shown in Fig. 1 specified.
[0113] Hydrogen and carbon monoxide are fed together as so-called synthesis gas via line 120 as a gaseous feedstock to the bubble column reactor 101. Liquid propene is added as a further feedstock at a controlled rate via line 121. In order to obtain a liquid phase under the specified reaction conditions, a liquid solvent containing a catalyst is added at a controlled rate via line 122. The feedstocks, which are gaseous under the reaction conditions, dissolve in the solvent and react in the presence of the homogeneous catalyst to form the desired reaction products. Unreacted gaseous feedstocks, in particular hydrogen and carbon monoxide, are removed via the gaseous reactor effluent 111. The target product of the reaction is withdrawn from the primary circuit 102 via the liquid reactor effluent 123.Since the reaction is exothermic, the liquid reactor contents are cooled to maintain the reactor temperature at a desired constant value. This is achieved by cooling the liquid flow in the primary circuit 102 in the heat exchangers 103 and 142, for example, using river water as the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuits. PID controllers with controller parameters optimized for the desired steady state are used to control the various control loops. Example 1
[0114] The same process as in Comparative Example 1 is carried out with a controller configuration according to the invention as in Fig. 2 In this case, too, PID controllers with controller parameters optimized for the desired steady state are used to control the various control loops. The optimal controller parameters were determined using suitable tuning rules, as explained, for example, in the following specialist literature: Otto Föllinger, Control Engineering, 8th edition, 1994, Hüthig Verlag. Heinz Unbehauen, Control Engineering I, 13th edition, 2005, Vieweg Verlag. S. Skogestad and Ian Postlethwaite, Multivariable Feedback Control, 2005, Wiley Verlag. The systematic design of PID controllers using Nyquist stability (DOI: 10.23919 / ECC.2001.7075961)
[0115] In the Fig. 2 In the example shown, a cascade control system is provided for controlling the temperature in reactor 101, which comprises a temperature controller 105 as the master controller and a heat flow controller 106 as the slave controller. A setpoint for the temperature of the liquid in reactor 101 is specified to master controller 105. The actual value of the temperature in reactor 101 is recorded via a temperature sensor. Depending on the temperature difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the liquid in the reactor, master controller 105 calculates a setpoint for the heat flow removed from or added to the liquid in primary circuit 102 by heat exchangers 103 and 142 as an output signal. This setpoint is transferred to heat flow slave controller 106, which generates a control signal for control valve 108 in the inlet to the first heat exchanger from the difference between the actual value and the setpoint of the heat flow as an output signal.
[0116] The calculation of the actual value of the heat flow extracted in the first heat exchanger 103 is carried out using the measured value of the temperature T in in reactor 101, the measured temperature T out ,1 after the first heat exchanger 103, the measured value of the mass flow ṁ 1 through the control valve 108 in the inlet to the first heat exchanger 103 and the parameter of the heat capacity cl for the medium of the liquid flow according to the formula Q̇ 1 = c l ṁ 1 (T in - T out, 1 ) . The calculation of the actual value of the heat flow extracted in the second heat exchanger 142 is carried out using the measured value of the temperature T in in reactor 101, the measured temperature T out, 2 after the second heat exchanger 142, the measured value of the mass flow ṁ 2 through the control valve 140 in the inlet to the second heat exchanger 142 and the parameter of the heat capacity cl for the medium of the liquid flow after the Formel Q ˙ 2 = c l m ˙ 2 T in − T out , 2 .
[0117] The prior art process and the process according to the invention were simulated using the "Aspen Plus Dynamics" simulation tool from AspenTech (20 Crosby Drive, Bedford, MA 01730, USA, www.aspentech.com). The simulation model was based on the following assumptions and parameters: The total pressure in reactor 101 is given by the sum of the partial pressures of hydrogen, carbon monoxide, solvent, and propene. No other components in the gas phase are considered. The catalyst molar fraction x Cat remains constant throughout the simulation. Furthermore, no heat is exchanged between reactor 101 or the pipes and the environment, so adiabatic conditions are assumed. The boundary conditions of the simulation are listed below: The heat flow coefficient of the external heat exchangers is constant U = 850 W m 2 K The inlet temperature of the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit is T in,C = 48 °C. The outlet temperature of the heat transfer medium in the secondary circuit of the first heat exchanger 103 at normal load is T out,C,nom = 73 °C. The heat flow extracted by the first heat exchanger 103 at nominal load is Q̇ HE,nom = 21600 kW. The heat flow extracted by the second heat exchanger 142 when simulating the disturbance behavior is Q̇ HE 1 ,nom = 2160 kW, where the total stationary heat flow through both heat exchangers Q̇ TOT,nom = Q Reak,nom = 21600 kW This means that the heat release remains unaffected by the disturbance. The fluid flow to the first heat exchanger at normal load is m ˙ HE , PF = 1816 t h The fluid flow to the second heat exchanger when simulating the disturbance behavior is m ˙ HE 1 , PF = 181,6 t h The heat flow equation is: Q̇ HE = U *A * Δ T m = ṁ PF,HE c PF,l ( T in,PF - T out,PF ) = ṁ HE,C c C,l ( T out,C - T in,C ) The only heat sinks are the two heat exchangers. The temperature of the liquid flow T in,PF is equal to the reactor temperature T R . Both heat exchangers operate on the counterflow principle: T out , PF - T 1, PF , T in,PF = T 2 ,PF , T in,C = T 1 ,C and T out,C = T 2, C The mean logarithmic temperature difference is given by: Δ T m = Δ T 1 − Δ T 2 ln Δ T 1 Δ T 2 = T 1 , PF − T 1 , C − T 2 , PF − T 2 , C ln T 1 , PF − T 1 , C T 2 , PF − T 2 , C The reactor temperature at normal load is T R = 95 °C. The response rate at normal load is r ˙ nom = 5,6 mol l h . The total pressure in the reactor is p = 10 bar. The partial pressure of carbon monoxide at normal load is P CO,nom = 3 bar. At normal load, the ratio between hydrogen and carbon monoxide in stream 120 should be chosen so that the partial pressure of hydrogen PH 2 ,nom equal to that of carbon monoxide p CO,nom The reaction rate is calculated by r ˙ = k R , 0 e − E A R T R c Propene c Cat c CO 1 + K CO c CO 2 c H 2 1 + K H 2 c H 2 Here are c CO , c H 2 , C Propene and c Cat Concentrations of the individual components in mol / l, E A is the activation energy and k R ,0 is the pre-exponential factor. The enthalpy of the reaction is calculated using the enthalpy model (Aspen Properties) provided in the simulation tool for the liquid phase and applying Hess's theorem.
[0118] The parameters K CO , K H 2 , E A and k R ,0 of the reaction kinetics were adjusted to reflect the negative correlation of the reaction rate with increasing carbon monoxide partial pressure. The parameters used are: K CO = 45000 dm 6 mol 2 , K H 2 = 500 dm 3 mol , E A = 60000 J mol and k R , 0 c Cat = 4.2465 10 15 mol 2 dm 3 h .
[0119] Since the catalyst concentration c Cat unknown, but constant, this was calculated with the pre-exponential factor k R ,0. This is equivalent to the numerical value of 1 for the catalyst concentration c Cat . The reaction rate is a function of the concentrations without taking partial pressures into account.
[0120] The correlation between the partial pressures and the concentrations can be determined from the known solubilities of the individual gases in the liquid phase. The solubility of the gases depends on the solvent in which the reaction takes place. The solvent is generally a mixture of rhodium catalyst, ligand, and n-butyraldehyde, isobutyraldehyde, dimers, trimers, and higher oligomers of butyraldehyde. This means that the solvent consists largely of high-boiling components formed by the side reactions of the hydroformulation. For simplicity, it was assumed that the mixture (including catalyst and ligand) can be described by simulating a single representative component. The component Texanol was chosen as the solvent because its parameters are available in Aspen Properties and these correspond well to the described real mixture.
[0121] The physical equation of state "Predictive Soave Redlich Kwong" (PSRK) was used to determine solubility and other properties and to perform the dynamic simulations. Solubility is a function of pressure, temperature, and the components of the liquid phase, which is calculated using the equation of state.
[0122] To dimension reactor 101, a conversion for the single pass of synthesis gas 120 and propene 121 must be specified. The conversion in the single pass X SP,Propene is defined here as the quotient of the mass flow of butanal ṅ Butanal,Rework, which is fed to the processing section, to the mass flow of propene ṅ Propene,Feed , which is fed to reactor 101. This definition was chosen because the exhaust gas contains a significant portion of the unreacted propene and thus the sum of several streams would have to be calculated if the unreacted propene were to be determined. The conversion for the single pass of the synthesis gas 120 is set so that the molar fraction of carbon monoxide in the gaseous reaction output y CO,Vent,nom towards reappraisal 0.3 mol mol amounts.
[0123] The syngas composition in the feed stream is adjusted so that the molar fraction of hydrogen in the gaseous reaction effluent at normal load is equal to the molar fraction of carbon monoxide in the gaseous reaction effluent at nominal load. The partial pressure of hydrogen and carbon monoxide is approximately 3 bar, and the hydroformulation reaction is in the range of negative correlation between the partial pressure of carbon monoxide and the reaction rate.
[0124] A comparison of the simulation results between comparative example 1 and example 1 for the control behavior of the controller when the setpoint of the reactor temperature changes from 95°C to 92°C and back to 95°C is shown in Fig. 6 and Fig. 7 shown. In both examples, no second heat exchanger 142 is added.
[0125] In Comparative Example 1, a temperature-temperature cascade is used to control the temperature in the reactor. In contrast, in Inventive Example 1, a temperature-heat flow cascade is used to control the temperature in the reactor. To stabilize the process in the simulations, the process boundary conditions, such as the reactor temperature or the reactant flows, are kept constant for the first 60 minutes in both cases. "Aspen Plus Dynamics" is used for this purpose. After one hour of simulation time, the reactor temperature setpoint is instantaneously reduced from 95°C to 92°C. After a further four hours of simulation time, the reactor temperature setpoint is reset to its original value of 95°C. Fig. 6 and Fig. 7 In each case, the dashed line shows the setpoint of the reactor temperature, the solid line the actual value of the reactor temperature, and the dash-dotted line the control signal of the master controller 105. In the case of the comparative example, this is a setpoint temperature for the slave controller; in the case of the example according to the invention, it is a setpoint heat flow for the slave controller. As can be clearly seen from a comparison of the curves of the actual values of the reactor temperature, the setpoint is reached significantly faster by the method according to the invention than by the method according to the prior art. The control quality is thus better.
[0126] For Comparative Example 1 and Inventive Example 1, simulation calculations are performed for a further scenario. After a simulation time of one hour, the propene mass flow 121 to the reactor is instantaneously reduced by 10%. After a further four hours of simulation time, the propene mass flow is reset to its original value. In this case, a second heat exchanger 142 is not added for either example.
[0127] In Fig. 8 and Fig. 9 In each case, the dashed line shows the setpoint of the reactor temperature, the solid line the actual value of the reactor temperature, and the dash-dotted line the control signal of the master controller 105. As in the case of the setpoint jump, a comparison of the curves of the actual values of the reactor temperature clearly shows that the setpoint is reached significantly faster using the method according to the invention than using the method according to the prior art. The control quality is therefore also better in this scenario.
[0128] For Comparative Example 1 and Inventive Example 1, the following simulation calculations are performed for a further scenario. After one hour of simulation, a second heat exchanger 142 is switched on. The heat flow extracted from the fluid in the primary circuit by the second heat exchanger was set to 10% of the heat flow extracted up to that point by the first heat exchanger 103. The amount of heat released by the reaction remains unaffected. After five hours of simulation, the second heat exchanger 142 is switched off again, and the first heat exchanger again takes over the entire heat flow.
[0129] In Fig. 10 and Fig. 11In each case, the dashed line shows the setpoint of the reactor temperature, the solid line the actual value of the reactor temperature, and the dashed-dotted line the control signal of the master controller 105. As in the case of the previous simulation examples, a comparison of the curves of the actual values of the reactor temperature clearly shows that the setpoint is reached significantly faster with the method according to the invention than with the method according to the prior art. The control quality is therefore also better in this scenario.
[0130] These simulation results show that using a temperature-heat flow cascade achieves significantly better control performance than using a temperature-temperature cascade according to the state of the art.
Claims
1. A method of closed-loop control of the temperature in a chemical engineering apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), in which, in a primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402), a liquid is conveyed out of the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), fed at least partly to a heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) and recycled at least partly back to the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), where the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) is cooled or heated by a heat transfer medium in a secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404), comprising the steps of - providing a target value for the temperature of the liquid in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), - detecting an actual value for the temperature of the liquid in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), - calculating the temperature difference between the actual value and the target value of the liquid in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), wherein - a heat flow taken from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) by the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) is ascertained, - a control signal is calculated on the basis of a defined closed-loop control algorithm, where the closed-loop control algorithm is configured such that the control signal is dependent on the heat flow and the temperature difference between the actual value and the target value of the liquid in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401), and - the flow rate of the stream of liquid through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) and / or a flow rate of the heat transfer medium through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404) is / are manipulated on the basis of the control signal.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the heat flow is ascertained from the liquid flow through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the liquid upstream and downstream of the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) and / or the heat flow is ascertained from a flow rate of the heat transfer medium through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404) and from a temperature difference between the temperature of the heat transfer medium upstream and downstream of the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404).
3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the closed-loop control algorithm comprises a temperature controller and a heat flow controller, where the output signal calculated by the temperature controller is dependent on the temperature difference between the actual value and the target value of the liquid in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401) and is a target value for the heat flow taken from or added to the liquid in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403), this target value is transmitted to the heat flow controller, and the output signal generated by the heat flow controller is dependent on the difference between the actual value and the target value of the heat flow and is the control signal for manipulation of the liquid flow through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) and / or for manipulation of the flow rate of the heat transfer medium through the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) in the secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404).
4. The method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein there is at least one bypass (307, 407) in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) that runs parallel to the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403).
5. The method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein there is at least one control unit for manipulation of the liquid flow on the basis of the control signal in the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) in the feed to the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) and / or in the drain from the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) and / or in the bypass (307, 407).
6. The method according to any of the preceding claims, characterized in that there is at least one control unit for manipulation of the flow rate of the heat transfer medium on the basis of the control signal in the secondary circuit (104, 204, 304, 404) in the feed to the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403) and / or in the drain from the heat transferer (103, 203, 303, 403).
7. The method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the closed-loop control algorithm has a split range control function where, rather than one control signal, at least two control signals are calculated and at least two streams in the primary circuit and / or in the secondary circuit are manipulated, where a first stream is manipulated as a function of a first control signal and a second stream as a function of a second control signal.
8. The method according to any of the preceding claims, characterized in that the liquid flow conveyed from the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401) into the primary circuit (102, 202, 302, 402) is set to a defined target value.
9. The method according to any of the preceding claims, characterized in that the closed-loop control algorithm, in calculating the control signal, takes account of at least one perturbation parameter, where the perturbation parameter comprises a measured or estimated process parameter, especially at least one raw material flow and / or at least one further heat flow.
10. The method according to any of the preceding claims, characterized in that a chemical or biological, endothermic or exothermic reaction or an exothermic or endothermic physical process is proceeding in the apparatus (101, 201, 301, 401).
11. The method according to claim 10, wherein the reaction is a hydroformylation, etherification, ether cleavage, enalization, dehydrogenation, pyrolysis, hydrogenation, or a cracking process.
12. The method according to claim 11, wherein the hydrogenation is a full hydrogenation, selective hydrogenation or ring hydrogenation.
