Nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system, and nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method
The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system uses muon trajectory detectors to accurately assess the neutron multiplication factor, addressing the challenge of criticality evaluation in stored nuclear fuel, ensuring subcriticality even under severe conditions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023090680
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-06-01
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods struggle to accurately measure the criticality of nuclear fuel stored in air, as they rely on simulations with unknown fuel composition and shape, and cannot evaluate the neutron multiplication factor under severe criticality conditions, such as when a moderator is added, posing safety risks.
A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system using muon trajectory detectors and an evaluation computer to non-destructively measure muon scattering and derive the neutron multiplication factor, enabling evaluation of the system's effective multiplication factor under various conditions, including the presence of a moderator.
Enables accurate criticality management of nuclear fuel by evaluating the maximum effective multiplication factor, ensuring subcriticality even under severe conditions, thus enhancing safety during storage and transport.
Smart Images

Figure 2024172749000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] An embodiment of the present invention relates to a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement technique. [Background technology]
[0002] Nuclear fuels such as uranium are strictly controlled internationally from the viewpoint of nuclear security. In particular, nuclear fuel requires criticality management according to its criticality. It is important to understand the neutron multiplication factor of a system including nuclear fuel in order to manage the criticality of nuclear fuel. The neutron multiplication factor is a value that indicates the ratio of the number of neutrons generated to the number of neutrons annihilated per unit time in the system including the fuel. In particular, in a finite system, the effective neutron multiplication factor that takes into account the effect that a certain number of generated neutrons leak out of the system is treated as the effective multiplication factor (keff). When the keff of a system is 1, the system is considered to be critical. In general, in criticality management, a limit value such as keff of 0.98 or 0.95 or less is set, including a certain margin, and management is performed so that this limit value is not exceeded even under strict conditions for criticality management, such as conditions in which the system contains a neutron moderator or is covered with a reflector.
[0003] In a nuclear reactor, the neutron multiplication factor can be measured from the time variation of the number of neutrons in the reactor because the reactor actually reaches a critical state during operation. On the other hand, when nuclear fuel is stored, it is not in a critical state, so it is difficult to measure the multiplication factor of the system.
[0004] When storing nuclear fuel, criticality control is required to prevent the system from going critical. In the case of nuclear fuel stored in air, there is no neutron moderator in the surrounding area, so the possibility of criticality is extremely low, but in terms of criticality control, it is necessary to ensure that not only is the system subcritical under normal conditions, but that it will not go critical even if the maximum anticipated reactivity is applied to the system.
[0005] For fuel stored in air, a realistic hazardous event would be for the system to become submerged, causing it to fill with moderator and become surrounded by reflectors.
[0006] Therefore, in fuel management, it is necessary to evaluate not only the multiplication factor of the nuclear fuel itself, but also the multiplication factor under strict conditions of criticality control, such as when a moderator is added to a system containing nuclear fuel.
[0007] Under realistic measurement conditions, it is not possible to add moderator to stored fuel to bring it closer to a critical state, for safety reasons. Therefore, in general, subcriticality evaluations are performed by reproducing the system in a simulation and evaluating the multiplication factor under the condition of adding moderator. However, if the composition and shape of the fuel are unknown, it is not possible to perform an appropriate simulation.
[0008] A method for measuring the subcriticality of existing nuclear fuel is known to measure gamma rays or neutrons emitted from the fuel. However, this conventional method is based on the assumption that the shape and initial composition of the nuclear fuel are known, and the subcriticality is determined by estimating the burnup from the measured value, making it difficult to apply when prior information about the fuel is insufficient.
[0009] In addition, a non-destructive measurement method using cosmic ray muons has been proposed as an effective method for non-destructively measuring materials including nuclear fuel. The muon scattering method measures the trajectory of a muon incident on a material and the trajectory of a muon that has passed through the material, and measures the change in the trajectory as a muon scattering value.
[0010] Muon track detectors include devices with stacked drift tube detectors using ionized gases and stacked multi-channel scintillation detectors. Muons have high penetrating power, and many of the muons that enter the measurement target pass through the material. Here, muons cause multiple Coulomb scattering depending on the composition and shape of the material. The scattering angle θ0 of muon scattering is shown in the following formula 1. Here, the scattering angle θ0 changes depending on the radiation length X0 specific to the atomic number of the material.
[0011]
number
[0012] Here, p is the momentum of the muon, βc is the speed of the muon, z is the charge of the muon, and x is the distance the muon travels through the material. Since the radiation length X0 varies depending on the material, the material present at the coordinates where the scattering occurred can be estimated from the analyzed scattering angle θ0. Muon scattering is characterized by being largely scattered by heavy elements with high atomic numbers, so the weight of nuclear fuel contained in the material is the dominant factor determining the magnitude of muon scattering in materials that contain a large amount of nuclear fuel material.
[0013] However, while conventional methods can estimate the amount of nuclear fuel in a material, they cannot evaluate the criticality of the system. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0014] [Patent Document 1] JP 2023-30894 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2017-161465 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0015] In general criticality management, restrictions were placed on the amount and shape of nuclear fuel handled under assumed conditions where the total amount and enrichment level of the fuel were known, so it was not possible to deal with fuel for which there was no prior information, or fuel debris generated by accidents.
[0016] An embodiment of the present invention has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and aims to provide a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement technology that can evaluate the maximum effective multiplication factor of a system that affects the nuclear fission reaction of nuclear fuel for which there is little prior information, and perform criticality management of the nuclear fuel. [Means for solving the problem]
[0017] A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to an embodiment of the present invention includes a radiation detector that measures at least one of radiation passing through a nuclear fuel to be measured or radiation emitted from the nuclear fuel, a measurement value evaluation unit that evaluates in advance the measurement values of the radiation detector corresponding to each of a plurality of conditions related to a system that affect the nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel, a multiplication factor evaluation unit that evaluates in advance a neutron multiplication factor corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions, an evaluation function creation unit that associates the result of the measurement value evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit with the result of the neutron multiplication factor evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit and creates an evaluation function that derives an effective multiplication factor from the measurement value, a measurement value accumulation unit that accumulates the measurement values actually measured by the radiation detector, and a subcriticality evaluation unit that calculates the effective multiplication factor from the measurement values accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit and the evaluation function to evaluate the subcriticality of the system. Effect of the Invention
[0018] According to an embodiment of the present invention, a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement technique is provided that can evaluate the maximum effective multiplication factor of a system that affects the nuclear fission reaction of nuclear fuel with little prior information, and perform criticality management of the nuclear fuel. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0019] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing a first nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system. [Diagram 2]FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system. [Diagram 3] 4 is a flowchart showing a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method. [Figure 4] A diagram showing the normal system. [Diagram 5] FIG. [Figure 6] A schematic diagram showing an infinite system. [Figure 7] 1 is a graph showing the effective multiplication factor versus the nuclear fuel filling rate in the storage container. [Figure 8] Graph showing muon scattering angle versus nuclear fuel filling rate in the storage container. [Figure 9] 1 is a graph showing the effective multiplication factor versus the muon scattering angle. [Figure 10] FIG. 11 is a configuration diagram showing a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to a second embodiment. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a configuration diagram showing a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to a third embodiment. [Figure 12] FIG. 13 is a configuration diagram showing a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to a fourth embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0020] (First embodiment) Hereinafter, embodiments of a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system and a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. First, a first embodiment will be described with reference to FIGS.
[0021] Reference numeral 1 in Fig. 1 denotes a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to the first embodiment. This nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 includes a muon trajectory detector 2 and an evaluation computer 5. The muon trajectory detector 2 is connected to the evaluation computer 5. This muon trajectory detector 2 serves as a radiation detector according to the first embodiment.
[0022] The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 measures the subcriticality of an object 6 that is the measurement target. For example, the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 evaluates the criticality of a system that includes nuclear fuel by measuring radiation related to the nuclear fuel. Note that the "system" refers to a system that affects the nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel.
[0023] There is little prior information about the substances contained in the object 6. For example, the object 6 is waste (nuclear fuel debris) containing nuclear fuel generated at a nuclear power plant or the like. The object 6 may also be spent nuclear fuel.
[0024] During nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement to evaluate the degree of subcriticality, the object 6 is stored in a specified storage container 7. The storage container 7 may be a mesh-like container that is less affected by radiation for nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement. For example, if the result of the subcriticality evaluation indicates that the nuclear fuel may become critical in an infinite system (FIG. 6) described later, the object 6 is stored in a dedicated container such as a cask that is used for transporting or storing nuclear fuel. The cask shields radiation emitted from the object 6 and is a container that ensures the subcriticality of the stored nuclear fuel. On the other hand, if the subcriticality of the nuclear fuel can be maintained even in an infinite system, a cask may be used to store the object 6, or a storage container 7 that is less expensive than a cask may be used.
[0025] At least one pair of muon trajectory detectors 2, which are provided facing each other across the target object 6, measure muons μ, which are charged particles. These muon trajectory detectors 2 are provided outside the storage container 7, and at the upper and lower positions of the storage container 7, respectively. In this manner, the state of the nuclear fuel inside the storage container 7 can be grasped non-destructively by utilizing the muons μ.
[0026] Muon μ is radiation that passes through a storage container 7 that contains the object 6 (nuclear fuel) to be measured. This muon μ exists mainly as a cosmic ray. Muon μ is a type of secondary cosmic ray that is generated when primary cosmic rays that enter the earth from space react with the earth's atmosphere. Muon μ has a positive or negative charge and a high energy of 3 to 4 GeV on average, so it has a high penetrating power. Muon μ can also be artificially generated using an accelerator.
[0027] As shown in Fig. 2, the evaluation computer 5 includes a processing circuit 10, an input unit 11, an output unit 12, a storage unit 13, and a communication unit 14. The processing circuit 10 includes a measurement value evaluation unit 20, a multiplication factor evaluation unit 21, an evaluation function creation unit 22, a measurement value accumulation unit 23, and a subcriticality evaluation unit 24. These are realized by a central processing unit (CPU) executing a program stored in a memory or a hard disk drive (HDD). The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method of this embodiment is realized by having a computer execute various programs.
[0028] Each component of the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 does not necessarily have to be provided in one evaluation computer 5. For example, one nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 may be realized by a plurality of computers connected to each other via a network. For example, one nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 may be configured by one computer equipped with the measurement value evaluation unit 20, the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21, and the evaluation function creation unit 22, and another computer equipped with the measurement value accumulation unit 23 and the subcriticality evaluation unit 24.
[0029] The processing circuit 10 is a circuit including, for example, a CPU, a GPU (Graphics Processing Unit), or a dedicated or general-purpose processor. This processor executes various programs stored in the storage unit 13 to realize various functions. The processing circuit 10 may also be configured with hardware such as an FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array) or an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit). Various functions can also be realized by such hardware. The processing circuit 10 can also realize various functions by combining software processing by a processor and a program with hardware processing.
[0030] Predetermined information is input to the input unit 11 in response to operations by a user who uses the evaluation computer 5. The input unit 11 includes input devices such as a mouse, a keyboard, and a touch panel. In other words, predetermined information is input to the evaluation computer 5 in response to operations of these input devices.
[0031] The output unit 12 outputs predetermined information. The evaluation computer 5 includes a device for displaying images, such as a display that outputs the analysis results. In other words, the output unit 12 controls the images displayed on the display.
[0032] The storage unit 13 stores various information required when executing the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method. For example, the storage unit 13 stores a predetermined program executed by the processing circuit 10. The storage unit 13 stores each measurement value acquired by the muon trajectory detector 2.
[0033] The communication unit 14 communicates with other computers and predetermined devices via a predetermined communication line. The predetermined devices include the muon trajectory detector 2.
[0034] Next, there will be described a nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method executed by using the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1. The evaluation procedure by the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 is mainly divided into three stages: pre-evaluation, measurement, and post-evaluation.
[0035] For example, as shown in the flowchart of Fig. 3, first, in the pre-evaluation, the measurement value evaluation unit 20 executes a measurement value evaluation process (step S1), and the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 executes a multiplication factor evaluation process (step S2). Furthermore, the evaluation function creation unit 22 executes an evaluation function creation process (step S3).
[0036] Here, the measurement value evaluation unit 20 evaluates in advance the measurement values of the muon track detector 2 corresponding to each of a plurality of system-related conditions that affect the nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel inside the storage vessel .
[0037] The measurement value evaluation unit 20 also reproduces the system as a simulation model. This measurement value evaluation unit 20 sets the arrangement and shape of the radiation detector and the presence or absence of a storage container 7 as fixed conditions related to the measurement system, and sets multiple conditions that change the content, composition, and shape of the nuclear fuel as variable conditions related to the measurement target. The measurement value evaluation unit 20 then calculates the measurement values of the muon trajectory detector 2 corresponding to each of the multiple conditions, and creates an analysis result of the measurement values.
[0038] Moreover, the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 evaluates in advance the neutron multiplication factors corresponding to each of a plurality of conditions.
[0039] The multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 is a system related to the measurement target that includes nuclear fuel, and creates a normal system with a reference composition and an evaluation system in which a moderator is added to the reference composition, and calculates at least one of the infinite multiplication factor or the effective multiplication factor for the evaluation system.
[0040] The multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 also reproduces the system as a simulation model, sets the presence or absence of the storage vessel 7 as a fixed condition for the measurement system, and sets multiple conditions for varying the content, composition, and shape of the nuclear fuel as variable conditions for the measurement target. The multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 also calculates the effective multiplication factor for each of the systems corresponding to each of the multiple conditions, which are a normal system with a reference composition, a moderator system in which a moderator is added to the reference composition, and an infinite system formed by adjacently forming multiple systems in which a moderator is added to the reference composition. The multiplication factor evaluation unit 21 then creates an analysis result for the effective multiplication factor.
[0041] In addition, the evaluation function creation unit 22 corresponds the measurement value results evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit 20 to the neutron multiplication factor results evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21, and creates an evaluation function that derives the effective multiplication factor from the measurement value.
[0042] Moreover, the evaluation function creation unit 22 creates an evaluation formula showing the relationship between the measurement value and the effective multiplication factor from the result of the measurement value for the nuclear fuel content evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit 20 and the result of the neutron multiplication factor for the nuclear fuel content evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21. Then, the evaluation function creation unit 22 creates an evaluation function that converts the measurement value accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit 23 into the effective multiplication factor.
[0043] In the next measurement stage, the measurement value accumulating unit 23 executes a measurement value accumulating process (step S4). Here, the measurement value accumulating unit 23 accumulates the measurement values actually measured by the muon trajectory detector 2.
[0044] In the next post-evaluation, the subcriticality evaluation unit 24 executes a subcriticality evaluation process (step S5). Here, the subcriticality evaluation unit 24 calculates an effective multiplication factor from the measurement values accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit 23 and the evaluation function created by the evaluation function creation unit 22, and evaluates the subcriticality of the system.
[0045] Further, the subcriticality evaluation unit 24 outputs the effective multiplication factor by inputting the measurement value accumulated in the measurement value accumulation unit 23 and the evaluation function created in the evaluation function creation unit 22 into the evaluation function. Here, the subcriticality evaluation unit 24 judges that the nuclear fuel is critical if the output effective multiplication factor exceeds a reference value, and judges that the nuclear fuel is subcritical if the output effective multiplication factor falls below the reference value. The evaluation computer 5 outputs the judgment result.
[0046] Next, a specific example of each step of the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method will be described. First, in the pre-evaluation, before the measurement using the muon track detector 2 is performed, the evaluation computer 5 performs a pre-evaluation using a simulation in order to create an evaluation function for evaluating the multiplication factor from the measurement value.
[0047] In this preliminary evaluation, a Monte Carlo simulation code capable of performing particle transport analysis is used. Representative examples of the code include MCNP, PHITS, and Geant4. In the first embodiment, a form using MCNP is illustrated.
[0048] First, a simulation model that reproduces the measurement system is created in the evaluation computer 5. The basic device system in this model is fixed, and only the conditions inside the storage container 7 in which the sample is placed are variable. The model may be created automatically by the evaluation computer 5, or a model created manually by the user may be input to the evaluation computer 5.
[0049] The evaluation computer 5 sets an analysis case in which a composition including nuclear fuel is placed inside the storage vessel 7. The analysis case set here is regarded as one case, and simulations are performed for a plurality of cases in which the nuclear fuel conditions are changed.
[0050] The evaluation computer 5 evaluates two values for each analysis case: one is the neutron multiplication factor of the system, and the other is the muon scattering value.
[0051] First, we will explain how to calculate the neutron multiplication factor of a system for a set analysis case. The neutron multiplication factor is a value that indicates the ratio of the number of neutrons generated in the system to the number of neutrons generated by the next nuclear fission, with the number of neutrons generated in the system as the reference. If the reference system is considered to be an infinite system with a homogenous material composition, the infinite multiplication factor is expressed by the following formula 2.
[0052]
number
[0053] Here, ε is the fast neutron fission efficiency of U-238; p is the fraction that escapes resonance absorption of U-238; f is the thermal neutron utilization rate; and η is the number of neutrons emitted per absorbed thermal neutron. Assuming a hypothetical homogeneous system that extends to infinity, a system becomes critical when the infinite multiplication factor (k-inf) is 1, and becomes subcritical when it is less than 1. The value of k-inf can be derived from the value of the material composition.
[0054] The above explanation is an evaluation for a hypothetical system that is infinite, but in a realistic finite system, the effective multiplication factor (k-eff) is used, which takes into account neutron leakage from the system.
[0055] The effective multiplication factor (k-eff) of a system with a certain size is expressed by the following formula 3. Note that k-inf is the infinite multiplication factor. M 2 is the moving area. B 2 is a buckling.
[0056]
number
[0057] Here, the value of buckling varies depending on the shape of the system, and the value is generally determined for representative shapes. For example, if the system is a rectangular parallelepiped, the value can be calculated from the following formula 4, where x, y, and z are the lengths of each side.
[0058]
number
[0059] Therefore, when the composition and shape of a system are specified, the infinite multiplication factor and effective multiplication factor of that system can be evaluated.
[0060] On the other hand, in the case of fuel debris generated by an accident, it is possible that it may have various shapes and that the composition inside the system may be distributed non-homogeneously. Therefore, in order to deal with systems that include more complicated conditions, the evaluation computer 5 evaluates the effective multiplication factor through simulation. MCNP, a Monte Carlo simulation code, calculates the effective multiplication factor of the system by repeating the process of generating neutrons in the simulation system and calculating the reaction in which the neutrons react with the nuclear fuel to cause nuclear fission.
[0061] The calculation of the effective multiplication factor is performed by evaluating multiple sample conditions for one case. Figures 4 to 6 show examples of evaluation systems for the effective multiplication factor.
[0062] Figure 4 shows the normal system (reference system). This is the condition where dry fuel is contained inside the storage vessel 7. This is the condition that reproduces the sample in the actual measurement, and the multiplication factor is the lowest.
[0063] Figure 5 shows a moderator system. The inside of the storage vessel 7 is filled with water 8 as a moderator, and the periphery of the storage vessel 7 is surrounded by water 8 as a reflector. This is the system for evaluating the maximum multiplication factor of a single system.
[0064] FIG. 6 shows an infinite system. The inside of the storage vessel 7 is filled with water 8, which is a moderator, and the same system is adjacent to an infinite number of systems, which is the most severe condition in terms of criticality safety. This condition assumes not only neutron multiplication in a single system but also neutron incidence from an adjacent system when storing multiple storage vessels 7 containing nuclear fuel. In order to evaluate such a system, it is necessary to perform calculations assuming a condition in which an infinite number of identical systems are arranged. Generally, in Monte Carlo codes such as MCNP, evaluations are performed to reproduce the condition in which neutrons that flow out of the system flow back into the system by setting the boundary surface of the system to a total reflection condition.
[0065] By performing the above analysis, the evaluation computer 5 can evaluate the minimum effective multiplication factor assumed for one case, the maximum effective multiplication factor in a single system, and further the maximum effective multiplication factor in the case of multiple adjacent systems.
[0066] The above evaluation is considered as one case, and evaluations will be conducted on multiple cases in which the amount of nuclear fuel contained in the system is changed.
[0067] As an example, the system of the storage container 7 is assumed to be a cubic system of 500 mm x 500 mm x 500 mm, and an evaluation of the relationship between the nuclear fuel loading rate and the effective multiplication factor is shown when the weight of uranium dioxide (UO2) fuel containing uranium with an enrichment of 5% is varied.
[0068] The graph in Figure 7 shows the relationship between the effective multiplication factor and the nuclear fuel filling rate inside the storage vessel 7. The effective multiplication factor is evaluated for each of the following systems: (a) a normal system, (b) a moderator system, and (c) an infinite system. Here, the values corresponding to each system will be explained as effective multiplication factor (a), effective multiplication factor (b), and effective multiplication factor (c).
[0069] The effective multiplication factor (a) is the multiplication factor of the system itself, but under dry conditions, it is extremely unlikely that this value will exceed 1 and become critical.
[0070] The effective multiplication factor (b) is the result of evaluating the possibility of criticality of the storage vessel 7 alone, and if the storage vessel 7 is submerged, it may become the multiplication factor shown in this graph. This value is used when checking the subcriticality of the storage vessel 7 alone.
[0071] The effective multiplication factor (c) is the most severe evaluation result, assuming that multiple identical storage containers 7 are stored side by side, and the entire system is submerged in water. This value is used when multiple storage containers 7 are stored in the same area.
[0072] As shown in the graph in Figure 7, the effective multiplication factor of the system increases or decreases with the weight of the nuclear fuel. Note that the effective multiplication factor evaluated here is a value that can only be determined by analysis and cannot be actually measured.
[0073] Next, the evaluation computer 5 evaluates muon scattering using the created simulation model. Figure 1 shows an example of a measurement system for muon scattering. When simulating muon scattering, muons μ are generated from above the upper muon track detector 2 toward the lower muon track detector 2 (incident muons). The generated muons μ cause Coulomb multiple scattering when passing through the material of the sample, so the track of the muons μ (scattered muons) measured by the lower muon track detector 2 fluctuates. The evaluation computer 5 records this fluctuation in the track of muons μ between the upper and lower stages as a muon scattering value.
[0074] Since the magnitude of muon scattering varies depending on the composition of the sample, the results of the muon scattering simulation also vary depending on the sample setting conditions.
[0075] When simulating muon scattering, analysis is performed only for the normal system in Figure 4. This is because normal measurements are performed in a dry state, which is the safest state for criticality control, and measurements in the moderator system in Figure 5 and the infinite system in Figure 6 are not actually envisaged. Under the above conditions, similar to the analysis of the effective multiplication factor, the evaluation computer 5 evaluates the value of muon scattering relative to the fuel weight under conditions in which the nuclear fuel weight is varied.
[0076] The graph in Figure 8 shows the relationship between the nuclear fuel filling rate inside the storage vessel 7 and muon scattering. As shown in the graph, the muon scattering angle varies depending on the weight of the nuclear fuel in the system. Note that, unlike the effective multiplication factor, whose actual value cannot be measured, the muon scattering value is a value that can actually be measured.
[0077] Here, in order to evaluate the subcriticality of a system through measurement, it is necessary to create a function that indicates the relationship between the measurement value and the subcriticality.
[0078] The simulation evaluation process described above evaluates the minimum and maximum effective multiplication factors for the set cases and the muon scattering values. These values are combined to create a function that derives the minimum and maximum effective multiplication factors for the system from muon scattering.
[0079] The graph in Figure 9 shows a function for deriving the effective multiplication factor from muon scattering. The derived effective multiplication factor is shown for (a) a normal system under the reference condition where the system is dry, (b) a moderator system under the condition where the system is filled with moderator, and (c) an infinite system under the condition where the system filled with moderator is adjacent. Each evaluation function will be explained as Evaluation Function (a), Evaluation Function (b), and Evaluation Function (c).
[0080] From the above evaluation results, the maximum effective multiplication factor that the system can have can be evaluated from the measured values.
[0081] Next, in the measurement stage, the evaluation computer 5 measures muon scattering on the measurement target including the nuclear fuel.
[0082] The evaluation computer 5 creates a system in which a container 7 containing an object 6 to be measured is sandwiched between two muon trajectory detectors 2, one above the other, as in the measurement system shown in Fig. 1. Here, the object 6 is assumed to be a material containing nuclear fuel.
[0083] As in the simulation evaluation, the magnitude of muon scattering increases according to the proportion of nuclear fuel contained in the storage vessel 7. However, in the actual measurement, the value of the nuclear fuel contained inside the storage vessel 7 is unknown, so it is not possible to directly evaluate its criticality.
[0084] The measured values (muon scattering values) are sent to the measured value accumulator 23 (Fig. 2) and accumulated. Since the measured values are statistics, statistically processed values such as their average values are used for analysis. These measured values are input to an evaluation function and converted into effective multiplication factors.
[0085] The evaluation computer 5 can derive the effective multiplication factor of the system from the measured values by the above process.
[0086] Next, in the post-evaluation, the evaluation computer 5 judges the subcriticality of the system from the effective multiplication factor obtained from the measurement value. The effective multiplication factor used to judge the subcriticality varies depending on the assumed conditions. As a general judgment condition, when the measurement error is expected to be small, keff = 0.98 is used as the standard condition, and when the error is expected to be large, keff = 0.95 is used as the standard condition.
[0087] As an example, if keff = 0.95 is set as the subcritical condition, when the effective multiplication factor derived from the evaluation function is less than 0.95, the system is judged to be subcritical.
[0088] Here, if the evaluation function (b) is less than 0.95, the system is guaranteed to be subcritical by itself. Also, if the evaluation function (c) is less than 0.95, subcriticality is guaranteed even when multiple systems are placed adjacent to each other. Therefore, when subcriticality is guaranteed by evaluation function (c), it is possible to store multiple equivalent storage containers 7 side by side or stacked. However, when subcriticality is only achieved by evaluation function (b), there is a possibility of criticality occurring when multiple containers are placed side by side, so multiple storage containers 7 cannot be stored in the same area.
[0089] Next, the impact assessment of the inhomogeneity effect will be explained. For example, a method that takes into account the inhomogeneity effect of nuclear fuel in order to perform a safer assessment based on the above-mentioned nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method can be considered.
[0090] For example, the evaluation computer 5 (FIG. 2) reproduces the system as a simulation model, sets the nuclear fuel to have a non-homogeneous shape in the simulation model, and creates at least one of the analysis results of the measurement values, the analysis results of the effective multiplication factor, and the evaluation function. These processes are executed by at least one of the measurement value evaluation unit 20, the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21, and the evaluation function creation unit 22.
[0091] In a moderator system (Figure 5) in which nuclear fuel is mixed with a moderator such as a target object 6 and water 8, it is known that neutron multiplication is more likely to occur when the two are present in a non-homogeneous manner under certain conditions than when they are mixed homogeneously. This phenomenon is called the non-homogeneity effect.
[0092] In particular, the heterogeneity effect is high under conditions where the fuel rods are arranged in a lattice at regular intervals, such as in the fuel assemblies used in light water reactors. From the viewpoint of criticality safety, it is necessary to assume the highest possible multiplication factor for the system. Therefore, in the preliminary analysis, the fuel in the sample system is assumed to be a lattice-like heterogeneous system, so that the highest possible effective multiplication factor for the system can be calculated. The multiplication factor that reflects the heterogeneity effect can be reflected in the subcriticality evaluation function used in the subsequent subcriticality evaluation process, making it possible to achieve a safer method of measuring nuclear fuel subcriticality.
[0093] Next, the evaluation of the influence of the mixture will be described. In the above-mentioned embodiment, the evaluation is mainly focused on the nuclear fuel and the moderator, which have a high effect of affecting the criticality. However, in the fuel debris generated by the accident, in addition to the nuclear fuel, the structure inside the nuclear reactor may be mixed.
[0094] In order to evaluate the effects of such mixtures, a method of performing an analysis by including the composition of materials other than nuclear fuel in the simulation conditions is considered. If the composition of the materials and their content ratios are known, the measurement conditions can be reproduced by using those values. However, if they are unknown, the evaluation is performed by varying the composition of the mixture and its content ratio as parameters.
[0095] For example, the evaluation computer 5 (FIG. 2) reproduces the system as a simulation model, sets the nuclear fuel and other structures as contained materials in the simulation model, and creates at least one of the analysis results of the measurement values, the analysis results of the effective multiplication factor, and the evaluation function. These processes are executed by at least one of the measurement value evaluation unit 20, the multiplication factor evaluation unit 21, and the evaluation function creation unit 22.
[0096] Finally, as in the previous embodiment, an evaluation function is created that estimates the effective multiplication factor from the measured values. If there are fluctuation factors, the measured values and the effective multiplication factor are plotted as a scatter diagram with variations. In this case, the evaluation function can be created using approximation such as fitting using the least squares method.
[0097] As described above, according to the first embodiment, when measuring nuclear fuel material about which there is little prior information, the maximum effective multiplication factor of the measured system can be evaluated, thereby enabling criticality management of the system.
[0098] In the above-mentioned embodiment, the measurement is performed by the muon scattering method using the muons μ of cosmic rays, but other modes may be used. For example, the use of artificially generated muons μ is considered. The muons μ of cosmic rays are natural muons μ generated in the atmosphere, but it is also possible to artificially generate muons μ using an accelerator or the like. This artificially created muon μ may be applied to the above-mentioned embodiment.
[0099] Second embodiment Next, a second embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 10. Note that the same components as those shown in the above-mentioned embodiment are denoted by the same reference numerals and the duplicated description will be omitted.
[0100] In the second embodiment, measurements are performed using radiation other than muon μ. Muon scattering is the most suitable measurement method because it has high penetrating power and is less affected by neutron absorbing materials and shielding materials, but even if other measurement methods are used, evaluation can be performed in principle, although a decrease in measurement accuracy is expected. For example, X-rays such as X-ray radiography and X-ray CT can be used. Another example is neutron radiography. Furthermore, neutrons or gamma rays emitted from nuclear fuel can be used.
[0101] The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 of the second embodiment includes an X-ray generator 30 and an X-ray detector 31. The X-ray generator 30 and the X-ray detector 31 are connected to an evaluation computer 5.
[0102] The X-ray generator 30 and the X-ray detector 31 are disposed to sandwich the storage container 7 (FIG. 1), and X-rays as radiation emitted from the X-ray generator 30 pass through the storage container 7 and the target object 6 (FIG. 1) and are detected by the X-ray detector 31. This X-ray detector 31 serves as the radiation detector of the second embodiment.
[0103] The X-ray detector 31 measures the X-rays that have passed through the object 6, and the measured value is input to the evaluation computer 5. Then, the evaluation computer 5 creates an evaluation function that derives the multiplication factor from the measured value.
[0104] According to the second embodiment, there is no need for a large-scale device such as the muon trajectory detector 2, and the maximum effective multiplication factor of the system can be evaluated using X-rays emitted from a relatively small X-ray generator 30.
[0105] Third embodiment Next, a third embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 11. Note that the same components as those shown in the above-mentioned embodiments are denoted by the same reference numerals and the duplicated description will be omitted.
[0106] The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 of the third embodiment includes a neutron generator 32 and a neutron detector 33. The neutron generator 32 and the neutron detector 33 are connected to an evaluation computer 5.
[0107] The neutron generator 32 and the neutron detector 33 are arranged to sandwich the storage container 7 (FIG. 1), and neutrons as radiation emitted from the neutron generator 32 pass through the storage container 7 and the target object 6 (FIG. 1) and are detected by the neutron detector 33. This neutron detector 33 serves as the radiation detector of the third embodiment.
[0108] The neutron detector 33 measures the neutrons that have passed through the object 6, and the measured value is input to the evaluation computer 5. Then, the evaluation computer 5 creates an evaluation function that derives the multiplication factor from the measured value.
[0109] According to the third embodiment, there is no need for a large-scale device such as the muon trajectory detector 2, and the maximum effective multiplication factor of the system can be evaluated by using neutrons emitted from the neutron generator 32.
[0110] (Fourth embodiment) Next, a fourth embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 12. Note that the same components as those shown in the above-mentioned embodiments are denoted by the same reference numerals and the duplicated description will be omitted.
[0111] The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 of the fourth embodiment includes a neutron detector 34 and a gamma ray detector 35. The neutron detector 34 and the gamma ray detector 35 are connected to an evaluation computer 5.
[0112] The neutron detector 34 and the gamma ray detector 35 are disposed inside the storage container 7, and neutrons and gamma rays as radiation emitted from an object 6 (FIG. 1) including nuclear fuel are detected by the neutron detector 34 and the gamma ray detector 35. The neutron detector 34 and the gamma ray detector 35 constitute a radiation detector of the fourth embodiment.
[0113] The neutron detector 33 measures neutrons emitted from the object 6, and the measured value is input to the evaluation computer 5. In addition, the gamma ray detector 35 measures gamma rays emitted from the object 6, and the measured value is input to the evaluation computer 5. Then, the evaluation computer 5 creates an evaluation function that derives the multiplication factor from the measured value.
[0114] According to the fourth embodiment, a device for generating radiation such as the neutron generator 32 is not necessary, and the maximum effective multiplication factor of the system can be evaluated using the radiation emitted from the object 6.
[0115] In the fourth embodiment, the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 is illustrated as having both the neutron detector 34 and the gamma ray detector 35, but other configurations are also possible. For example, the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 may be equipped with either the neutron detector 34 or the gamma ray detector 35 and measure either neutrons or gamma rays.
[0116] When the measurement method is changed as in the second to fourth embodiments, the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 creates an evaluation function that derives the multiplication factor from the measurement value by performing a simulation that reproduces the measurement value of the measurement method applied to each analysis case. In addition, the accuracy can be improved by performing measurement using a combination of the above-mentioned multiple measurement methods.
[0117] Although the present invention has been described above based on the first to fourth embodiments, the configuration applied in any of the embodiments may be applied to other embodiments, and the configurations applied in each embodiment may be combined. For example, the nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system 1 of the second to fourth embodiments may additionally include the muon trajectory detector 2 of the first embodiment.
[0118] In the above-mentioned flowchart, the steps are executed in series, but the order of the steps is not necessarily fixed, and the order of some steps may be interchanged. Also, some steps may be executed in parallel with other steps.
[0119] The evaluation computer 5 described above includes a control device, a storage device, an output device, an input device, and a communication interface. Here, the control device includes a highly integrated processor such as a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU), a field programmable gate array (FPGA), or a dedicated chip. The storage device includes a read only memory (ROM), a random access memory (RAM), a hard disk drive (HDD), a solid state drive (SSD), etc. The output device includes a display panel, a head mounted display, a projector, a printer, etc. The input device includes a mouse, a keyboard, a touch panel, etc. This evaluation computer 5 can be realized by a hardware configuration using a normal computer.
[0120] The program executed by the evaluation computer 5 is provided by being preinstalled in a ROM or the like. Additionally or alternatively, the program is provided by being stored in a computer-readable non-transitory storage medium as a file in an installable or executable format. The storage medium includes a CD-ROM, a CD-R, a memory card, a DVD, a flexible disk (FD), and the like.
[0121] The programs executed by the evaluation computer 5 may be stored in a computer connected to a network such as the Internet and provided by downloading them via the network. The evaluation computer 5 may also be configured by combining separate modules that independently perform the functions of the components and are mutually connected via a network or dedicated lines.
[0122] In the above example, the evaluation computer 5 performs various processes (including various processes such as evaluation, creation, and setting), but other processes may be used. For example, a user may perform some of the various processes described above, and the evaluation computer 5 may receive input of the processing results and use them in its own processing.
[0123] According to at least one of the embodiments described above, the effective multiplication factor is calculated from the measurement values and the evaluation function to evaluate the subcriticality of the system, thereby making it possible to evaluate the maximum effective multiplication factor of the system that affects the nuclear fission reaction of nuclear fuel about which there is little prior information, and to perform criticality management of the nuclear fuel.
[0124] Although some embodiments of the present invention have been described, these embodiments are presented as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. These embodiments can be implemented in various other forms, and various omissions, substitutions, modifications, and combinations can be made without departing from the spirit of the invention. These embodiments or modifications thereof are within the scope of the invention and its equivalents as described in the claims, as well as within the scope and spirit of the invention. [Explanation of symbols]
[0125] 1...nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system, 2...muon trajectory detector, 5...evaluation computer, 6...target object, 7...storage container, 8...water, 10...processing circuit, 11...input section, 12...output section, 13...memory section, 14...communication section, 20...measurement value evaluation section, 21...multiplication factor evaluation section, 22...evaluation function creation section, 23...measurement value accumulation section, 24...subcriticality evaluation section, 30...X-ray generator, 31...X-ray detector, 32...neutron generator, 33, 34...neutron detector, 35...gamma ray detector, μ...muon.
Claims
1. a radiation detector that measures at least one of radiation passing through a nuclear fuel to be measured and radiation emitted from the nuclear fuel; a measurement value evaluation unit that evaluates in advance measurement values of the radiation detector corresponding to each of a plurality of system-related conditions that affect the nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel; a multiplication factor evaluation unit that evaluates in advance a neutron multiplication factor corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions; an evaluation function creation unit that associates the result of the measurement value evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit with the result of the neutron multiplication factor evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit, and creates an evaluation function that derives an effective multiplication factor from the measurement value; a measurement value accumulating unit that accumulates the measurement values actually measured by the radiation detector; a subcriticality evaluation unit that calculates the effective multiplication factor from the measurement value accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit and the evaluation function to evaluate the subcriticality of the system; Equipped with Nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system.
2. The radiation passing through the nuclear fuel is radiation passing through a container that contains the nuclear fuel, the measurement value of the radiation detector evaluated in advance by the measurement value evaluation unit is the measurement value of the radiation detector corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions related to the system inside the storage container, The nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 .
3. The radiation detector is at least one pair of muon track detectors that measure muons and are disposed opposite each other across the nuclear fuel.
3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
4. The measurement value evaluation unit is Reproducing the system as a simulation model; setting the plurality of conditions for the system in which the content, composition, and shape of the nuclear fuel are changed; calculating the measurement values of the radiation detector corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions, and generating an analysis result of the measurement values; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
5. The multiplication factor evaluation unit is creating an evaluation system for the system relating to the composition and shape of the nuclear fuel, the evaluation system including a normal system of a reference composition and a moderator system in which a moderator is added to the reference composition; Calculating at least one of the infinite multiplication factor or the effective multiplication factor for the evaluation system; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
6. The multiplication factor evaluation unit is Reproducing the system as a simulation model; setting the plurality of conditions for the system in which the content, composition, and shape of the nuclear fuel are changed; the effective multiplication factor is calculated for each of the systems corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions, the effective multiplication factor being a normal system of a standard composition, a moderator system in which a moderator is added to the standard composition, and an infinite system formed by adjacently forming a plurality of systems in which the moderator is added to the standard composition, and an analysis result of the effective multiplication factor is generated; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
7. The evaluation function creation unit is creating an evaluation formula showing a relationship between the measurement value and the effective multiplication factor from the result of the measurement value for the nuclear fuel content evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit and the result of the neutron multiplication factor for the nuclear fuel content evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit; creating the evaluation function for converting the measurement value accumulated by the measurement value accumulating unit into the effective multiplication factor; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
8. The subcriticality evaluation unit includes: Using the measurement values accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit and the evaluation function created by the evaluation function creation unit, The measurement value is input to the evaluation function to output the effective multiplication factor; determining that the nuclear fuel is critical when the outputted effective multiplication factor exceeds a reference value, and determining that the nuclear fuel is subcritical when the outputted effective multiplication factor falls below the reference value; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
9. At least one of the measurement value evaluation unit, the multiplication factor evaluation unit, and the evaluation function creation unit is Reproducing the system as a simulation model; setting the nuclear fuel to a non-homogeneous shape in the simulation model; creating at least one of the analysis result of the measurement value, the analysis result of the effective multiplication factor, and the evaluation function; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
10. At least one of the measurement value evaluation unit, the multiplication factor evaluation unit, and the evaluation function creation unit is Reproducing the system as a simulation model; Setting the nuclear fuel and other structures as contained materials in the simulation model; creating at least one of the analysis result of the measurement value, the analysis result of the effective multiplication factor, and the evaluation function; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
11. the radiation detector measures at least one of X-rays passing through the nuclear fuel, gamma rays or neutrons emitted from the nuclear fuel; 3. A nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement system according to claim 1 or 2.
12. The method is carried out using a radiation detector that measures at least one of radiation passing through a nuclear fuel to be measured and radiation emitted from the nuclear fuel, a measurement value evaluation unit that evaluates in advance the measurement values of the radiation detector corresponding to each of a plurality of system-related conditions that affect the nuclear fission reaction of the nuclear fuel; a multiplication factor evaluation unit that evaluates in advance neutron multiplication factors corresponding to each of the plurality of conditions; an evaluation function creation unit creates an evaluation function that associates the result of the measurement value evaluated by the measurement value evaluation unit with the result of the neutron multiplication factor evaluated by the multiplication factor evaluation unit, and derives an effective multiplication factor from the measurement value; a measurement value accumulating unit accumulating the measurement values actually measured by the radiation detector; a subcriticality evaluation unit that calculates the effective multiplication factor from the measurement value accumulated by the measurement value accumulation unit and the evaluation function to evaluate the subcriticality of the system; Nuclear fuel subcriticality measurement method.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Measurement device and measurement method for heavy element inclusion
JP2017161465A
Spent nuclear fuel degree-of-subcriticality measurement device and spent nuclear fuel criticality management method
JP2023030894A
