Credit assessment system and credit assessment method

The credit determination system enhances credit evaluation accuracy and efficiency by using personal and credit status information to automatically assess eligibility through individual and aggregate scoring, addressing the challenges of existing systems by incorporating multiple evaluation criteria and exclusion conditions.

JP7578410B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-06SANIN SHINMON CO LTD
View PDF 8 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2020067209
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2020-04-03
Publication Date
2024-11-06
Estimated Expiration
2040-04-03

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing credit evaluation systems face challenges in achieving accurate and efficient credit determination, often resulting in increased risk of non-collection due to low threshold settings to extend credit to a certain number of cases, leading to decreased examination accuracy.

Method used

A credit determination system and method that utilizes personal attribute and current credit status information, determines individual evaluation scores for multiple evaluation items, calculates an aggregate score, and applies suitability judgments based on predefined rules to automatically determine credit eligibility, considering both credit disapproval and automatic judgment exclusion conditions.

Benefits of technology

Improves the accuracy and efficiency of credit determination by ensuring that credit eligibility is based on a comprehensive evaluation of multiple criteria, reducing the risk of non-collection and maintaining high accuracy even in cases where automatic judgment is not possible.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007578410000001
    Figure 0007578410000001
  • Figure 0007578410000002
    Figure 0007578410000002
  • Figure 0007578410000003
    Figure 0007578410000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a technique capable of enhancing the accuracy of credit determination while achieving the standardization and efficiency improvement of the credit determination.SOLUTION: A credit determination system includes: means for acquiring case information about credit cases; means for determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items on the basis of the case information, and calculating a totaling evaluation score on the basis of a plurality of determined individual evaluation scores; means for performing propriety determination of the credit case in terms of the plurality of credit selection conditions on the basis of the case information; and means for automatically determining one of credit acceptance, credit rejection, or exemption from automatic determination, for the credit case on the basis of a determination result about the totaling evaluation score and a result of the propriety determination, and generating credit determination information showing a result of the automatic determination.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a technology for automatically carrying out credit decisions using a computer. [Background technology]

[0002] In transactions between companies and between individuals and companies, credit is extended, i.e., credit is given. For example, financial institutions provide loans, guarantees, and credit card limits. However, since credit comes with a risk of non-repayment, each company conducts credit screening to reduce the risk of non-repayment when extending credit. These credit screenings are carried out manually using in-house manuals and tools, etc. And for about half of the cases, it is not possible to uniformly determine whether credit is acceptable or not, and it is left to the discretion of each person in charge or their superiors.

[0003] In response to this, a supplier support system has been proposed that enables standardization of screening accuracy while speeding up credit processing (see Patent Document 1 below). This system accepts credit applications from potential customers via the affiliate's homepage, performs an automatic screening using a scoring system based on the contents of the credit application and the results of an automatic search of data from an external credit information agency for the applicant, and notifies the potential customer of the results of this automatic screening. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2002-207873 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0005] When financial institutions conduct credit screening, they want to extend credit to as many cases as possible in order to ensure profits. However, when conducting credit screening using only a scoring method, in order to extend credit to a certain number of cases, the threshold must be set low, which may increase the risk of non-payment. In this way, credit decisions are closely related to the risk of non-repayment, and as mentioned above, there are only a limited number of cases where a uniform credit assessment can be made, so there is a possibility that the accuracy of credit reviews will decrease if the credit review is based solely on a scoring method.

[0006] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and provides a technique that can improve the accuracy of credit judgments while achieving standardization and efficiency of credit judgments. [Means for solving the problem]

[0007] One aspect of the present invention relates to a credit assessment system that is configured by one or more computers and performs credit assessment on an applicant's credit case. The credit assessment system according to the one aspect employs the following configuration in order to solve the above-mentioned problems. That is, the credit assessment system according to the one aspect includes at least personal attribute information and current credit performance information on the applicant. Muyo Regarding credit cases Multiple types of information are included as individual information for each type of information The present invention relates to an acquisition means for acquiring project information, a score calculation means for determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired project information, and for calculating an aggregate evaluation score from the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores using a predetermined calculation method, and a score calculation means for calculating an aggregate evaluation score from each of a plurality of credit screening conditions using individual information associated with each credit screening condition included in the acquired project information. Meet the credit screening criteriaand an information generating means for automatically judging whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and for automatically judging the credit application as either creditable, non-creditable, or non-automatic judgment based on the result of the aggregated evaluation score judgment and generating credit judgment information indicating the result of the automatic judgment. The score calculation means holds, for each of the plurality of evaluation items, a decision rule for an individual evaluation score to which an information type included in the application information is associated and which uses individual information of the associated information type, and determines an individual evaluation score for each of the plurality of evaluation items by applying the individual information of the information type associated with each evaluation item included in the acquired application information to the decision rule for each evaluation item held therein. The decision rule for the individual evaluation score held by the score calculation means and the above-mentioned predetermined calculation method are set so that the calculated aggregated evaluation score shows a high correlation with credit risk, and the plurality of credit screening conditions include a plurality of non-creditable conditions and a plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, and the appropriateness judgment means holds, for each of the plurality of non-creditable conditions, For each of the above, whether or not the individual information associated with each of the credit denial conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit denial condition. After the suitability assessment, satisfy If there are no credit disallowance conditions, Multiple Automatically determined exclusion conditions For each of the above, whether or not the individual information associated with each automatic determination exclusion condition included in the acquired case information satisfies the automatic determination exclusion condition. The information generating means performs a suitability judgment, and even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, a predetermined number of the multiple credit disqualification conditions are not satisfied. The suitability determination means determines that the condition is satisfied. If a predetermined number of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are exceeded, the credit application is judged to be uncreditable. The suitability determination means determines that the condition is satisfied. In this case, the credit application is judged to be outside the automatic judgment, and the aggregate evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and none of the multiple credit denial conditions and the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions are satisfied. The suitability determination means determines that the condition is not satisfied. In this case, the credit application is judged to be credit approved.

[0008] Another aspect of the present invention relates to a credit judgment method for making a credit judgment regarding a credit case of an applicant. The credit judgment method according to the other aspect employs the following configuration in order to solve the above-mentioned problems. That is, the credit judgment method according to the one aspect includes: Muyo Regarding credit cases Multiple types of information are included as individual information for each type of information The method includes the steps of: acquiring project information; determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired project information; and calculating an aggregate evaluation score from the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores using a predetermined calculation method; and calculating, for each of a plurality of credit screening conditions, individual information associated with each credit screening condition included in the acquired project information. Meet the credit screening criteria the application information information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, the application information storing means storing a credit score for each of the plurality of evaluation items, In a calculation step, a computer determines an individual evaluation score for each of the multiple evaluation items by applying individual information of an information type associated with each evaluation item included in the acquired project information to a decision rule for each evaluation item held in the calculation step, and the decision rule for the individual evaluation score held in the calculation step and the predetermined calculation method are set so that the calculated aggregate evaluation score shows a high correlation with credit risk, and the multiple credit screening conditions include multiple credit denial conditions and multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions, and one or more computers determine the multiple credit denial conditions in the suitability judgment step. For each of the above, whether or not the individual information associated with each of the credit denial conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit denial condition. After the suitability assessment, satisfy If there are no credit disallowance conditions, Multiple Automatically determined exclusion conditions For each of the above, whether or not the individual information associated with each automatic determination exclusion condition included in the acquired case information satisfies the automatic determination exclusion condition.In the automatic judgment step, even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, a predetermined number of the plurality of credit disqualification conditions are not satisfied. It is judged in the suitability judgment step that the condition is satisfied. If a predetermined number of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are exceeded, the credit application is judged to be uncreditable. It is judged in the suitability judgment step that the condition is satisfied. In this case, the credit application is judged to be outside the automatic judgment, and the aggregate evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and none of the multiple credit denial conditions and the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions are satisfied. It is judged in the suitability judgment step that the condition is not satisfied. In this case, the credit application is judged to be credit approved.

[0009] In addition, as another aspect of the present invention, for example, it may relate to a computer program for causing one or more computers to execute the above-mentioned credit assessment method, or it may relate to a computer-readable storage medium on which such a program is recorded. Effect of the Invention

[0010] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a technique that can improve the accuracy of credit judgments while achieving standardization and efficiency of credit judgments. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0011] [Figure 1] 1 is a diagram conceptually illustrating a hardware configuration of a credit assessment system according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] 2 is a diagram conceptually illustrating the software configuration of a credit decision server. FIG. [Diagram 3] 11 is a diagram showing, in table form, some of the rules for determining individual evaluation scores in this embodiment. FIG. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing, in table form, some of the credit screening conditions in this embodiment. [Diagram 5] 13 is a flowchart showing a flow of a credit decision process in a credit decision server. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0012] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. The following embodiment is an example, and the present invention is not limited to the configuration of the following embodiment. Below, a credit assessment system (hereinafter, may be referred to as this system) is illustrated as one embodiment of the present invention.

[0013] [overview] Before describing the details of this system, an overview of the features of this system will be given. This system is configured with one or more computers, and the computers execute computer programs to realize the acquisition means, score calculation means, suitability determination means, and information generation means in this system. The computer constituting this system may include a general-purpose computer such as a PC (Personal Computer), may include a dedicated computer such as an embedded microcomputer, or may include both. In addition, the computer may be only a stationary computer, may be only a portable computer such as a smartphone, or may be both.

[0014] The acquiring means acquires case information relating to a credit case, which includes at least personal attribute information relating to an applicant and current credit performance information. "Personal attribute information on the applicant" includes, for example, gender, age, occupation, family structure, housing category, years of residence, years of employment, etc. The attribute types included in the personal attribute information are not limited to these examples, and may include information on other attribute types, or may not include information on some of the attribute types described above. "Current credit performance information regarding the applicant" is current information and past performance information regarding the applicant's credit, and may include some or all of the credit information provided by a personal credit information agency, or may include some or all of the credit information managed within the company that conducts the credit screening. "Current credit performance information regarding the applicant" includes, for example, the number of inquiries, the number of contracts, the loan balance, the number of late payments, the number of in-house repayments, the number of contracts with other companies, etc. Personal credit information agencies are institutions that accumulate and manage personal credit information, and include the Credit Information Center (CIC), the Japan Credit Information Service Co., Ltd. (JICC), and the National Bank Personal Credit Information Center (KSC), among others. The "case information on the credit case" acquired by the acquisition means needs to include at least the above-mentioned "personal attribute information on the applicant" and "current credit performance information on the applicant", and may or may not include other information. For example, this case information may include application information on the credit case that is the subject of screening, such as the number of repayments.

[0015] There are no limitations on the method by which the acquisition means acquires the case information. For example, the acquisition means may acquire the case information (e.g., current performance information) via communication from a personal credit information agency's system or an in-house system. The acquisition means may also acquire the case information from a portable storage medium such as a USB (Universal Serial Bus) memory, or may acquire the case information through input operations by a credit applicant or a person in charge at a company that performs credit screening.

[0016] The score calculation means determines an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the case information acquired by the acquisition means, and calculates an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores. Each evaluation item is associated with a type of information included in the case information in advance, and a method for determining an individual evaluation score using the information of the type of information is determined in advance. The individual evaluation score may indicate a positive value or a negative value, or may indicate a positive or negative value depending on the evaluation item. A method for calculating an aggregate evaluation score based on a plurality of individual evaluation scores is also determined in advance. There is no limitation on the method of determining the individual evaluation scores and the method of calculating the aggregate evaluation score. For example, the aggregate evaluation score may be calculated by adding up all the individual evaluation scores (positive or negative values), or may be calculated by further adding a constant, or may be calculated by subtracting all the individual evaluation scores from a constant. Furthermore, there is no limitation on the number of evaluation items.

[0017] The suitability determining means determines suitability of the credit application with respect to a plurality of credit screening conditions based on the application information acquired by the acquiring means. Each credit screening condition is associated with individual information included in the case information, and the individual information is used to determine whether or not the credit screening condition is met (suitability determination). There are no limitations on the specific content of each credit screening condition or the number of credit screening conditions.

[0018] The information generating means automatically judges whether the credit application is credit approved, credit rejected, or not automatically judged, based on the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculating means and the result of the suitability judgment by the suitability judgment means, and generates credit judgment information indicating the result of the automatic judgment. The information generating means will not judge the credit application as credit approved based on only one of the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score or the suitability judgment result, but may judge the credit application as not credit approved. Here, the "judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score" is the result of a binary or ternary judgment using the aggregated evaluation score. When a binary judgment is performed, the judgment result is, for example, the result of comparing the aggregated evaluation score with a predetermined threshold. When a ternary judgment is performed, the judgment result is, for example, the result of comparing the aggregated evaluation score with two thresholds. "Not automatically determined" may be any determination result that is neither creditworthy nor creditworthy.

[0019] The credit decision information generated by the information generating means can be output from one or more of a display device, a printer, an audio output device, etc. The credit decision information may also be transmitted to an external system, or may be transmitted to a mobile terminal of a credit applicant. In this way, the generated credit decision information can be used in a variety of ways.

[0020] As described above, in this system, multiple individual evaluation scores are determined for multiple evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the case information of the credit case, an aggregate evaluation score is calculated based on the determined individual evaluation scores, and a suitability judgment is made for multiple credit screening conditions. Then, based on the judgment result regarding the aggregate evaluation score and the suitability judgment result, the credit case is automatically judged as credit OK, credit NG, or not automatically judged, and credit judgment information indicating the result of the automatic judgment is generated. Therefore, this system can standardize and streamline credit decisions. Furthermore, when the credit approval or disapproval can be automatically determined based on the aggregated evaluation score and the suitability of the credit screening conditions, the system displays "approved" or "disapproved," and in other cases displays "not automatically determined," which can improve the accuracy of credit decisions.

[0021] [Details of the credit assessment system] The credit assessment system (this system) 1 having the above-mentioned characteristics will be described in detail below.

[0022] [Hardware configuration] FIG. 1 is a diagram conceptually showing the hardware configuration of the present system 1. As shown in FIG. As shown in FIG. 1, the system 1 includes a credit judgment server 10 and one or more user terminals 20 that can communicate with the credit judgment server 10 via a communication network 2. Although one credit judgment server 10 and one user terminal 20 are shown in FIG. 1, the present system 1 may include a plurality of credit judgment servers 10 and a plurality of user terminals 20. The communication network 2 is configured by a combination of a mobile phone network, a Wi-Fi (Wireless Fidelity) network, an Internet communication network, a dedicated line network, a LAN (Local Area Network), etc. However, the communication method and communication form within the communication network 2 are not limited.

[0023] The credit judgment server 10 and the user terminal 20 are so-called computers (information processing devices) and have, for example, a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 12 or 22, a memory 13 or 23, an input / output interface (I / F) 15 or 25, a communication unit 14 or 24, etc., which are interconnected by a bus. The credit decision server 10 and the user terminal 20 may be general-purpose computers or dedicated computers. The user terminal 20 is a computer used by a person in charge of a business (a financial institution is exemplified in this embodiment) that performs credit screening for credit applications, and may be only a portable computer such as a notebook PC or tablet, or may be a stationary computer.

[0024] The CPU 12 or 22 may include, in addition to a general CPU, an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a digital signal processor (DSP), a graphics processing unit (GPU), and the like. The memory 13 or 23 is a random access memory (RAM), a read only memory (ROM), or an auxiliary storage device (such as a hard disk). The input / output I / F 15 or 25 can be connected to a user interface device such as an output device or an input device. The output device includes a display device 26, a printer, etc., and the display device 26 is a device such as an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display) or CRT (Cathode Ray Tube) display that displays a screen corresponding to drawing data processed by the CPU 12 or 22, etc. The input device is a device that accepts input of user operations such as a keyboard, mouse, etc. The display device and the input device may be integrated and realized as an input / output device 27 such as a touch panel. In FIG. 1, a display device 26 and an input / output device 27 are connected to the input / output I / F 25, and nothing is connected to the input / output I / F 15, but a user interface device may also be connected to the input / output I / F 15.

[0025] The communication unit 14 or 24 communicates with other computers via the communication network 2 and exchanges signals with other devices. A portable storage medium such as a USB memory can also be connected to the communication unit 14 or 4. In this embodiment, the communication unit 14 can communicate with a personal credit information agency's system, an in-house DB (Database) system of a financial institution to which the user of the user terminal 20 belongs (hereinafter referred to as the company) via the communication network 2, and the like. The credit judgment server 10 and the user terminal 20 may include hardware elements not shown in Fig. 1, and the number of those hardware elements is not limited to the example shown in Fig. 1. The hardware configuration of the credit judgment server 10 and the user terminal 20 is not limited. In addition, in this embodiment, an in-house DB system and a CIC system are exemplified as external systems with which the credit judgment server 10 can communicate, but the credit judgment server 10 may communicate with systems of other personal credit information agencies or with other external systems.

[0026] [Software configuration] FIG. 2 is a diagram conceptually showing the software configuration of the credit judgment server 10. As shown in FIG. The credit judgment server 10 includes an information storage unit 30, an information acquisition unit 31, a score calculation unit 32, a suitability judgment unit 33, a credit judgment unit 34, an information generation unit 35, etc. Each of these components is a software element that is realized, for example, by loading a computer program stored in the memory 13 into the CPU 12 and executing it. The computer program may be installed, for example, from a portable storage medium such as a CD (Compact Disc) or a memory card, or from another computer on a network via the communication unit 14, and stored in the memory 13.

[0027] The information storage unit 30 is deployed on the memory 13, and stores case information related to a credit case to be examined (hereinafter, referred to as a target credit case). The case information stored in the information storage unit 30 is as described in the [Overview] section. In this embodiment, application information for the target credit case, credit information regarding the applicant for the target credit case obtained from the CIC system (hereinafter referred to as CIC credit information), and credit information regarding the applicant obtained from the company's internal DB system (hereinafter referred to as internal credit information) are stored as case information regarding the target credit case in the information storage unit 30. However, the case information stored in the information storage unit 30 is not limited to the example shown in this embodiment.

[0028] The application information includes the applicant's name, date of birth, address, telephone number, sex, age, family composition, occupation, and years of service, the credit type of the target credit case (credit card, individual installment payment, financial guarantee, etc.), application amount, number of repayments, purchase quantity, etc. In this way, the application information in this embodiment includes the applicant's personal attribute information and detailed information on the target credit case. However, the application information is not limited to such examples, and may include further information, or may not include some of the above-mentioned information. The CIC Credit Information includes credit and loan application information, payment status information, reference information, etc. registered by CIC member companies regarding the applicant. The CIC Credit Information need only include publicly known information. The internal credit information includes application information on credit cases already contracted by the company with respect to the applicant, information on the current payment status and past payment performance, payment reminder information, etc. The internal credit information may include any information that the company can obtain regarding credit cases already contracted by the company, and there are no restrictions on the specific content.

[0029] The information acquisition unit 31 acquires case information related to the target credit case, and stores the case information in the information storage unit 30. The information acquisition unit 31 is a specific example of the acquisition means described above. The method of acquiring the case information by the information acquisition unit 31 is as described for the acquisition means, and is not limited in any way.

[0030] In this embodiment, the information acquisition unit 31 acquires the above-mentioned application information regarding the target credit case from the user terminal 20 via communication, and uses the applicant identification information contained in the application information to acquire CIC credit information and internal credit information regarding the applicant from the CIC system and the internal DB system via communication. The applicant identification information is information for identifying an individual applicant in the CIC system or the in-house DB system, and is, for example, a combination of the applicant's name, date of birth, telephone number, and postal code. However, the specific contents of the applicant identification information available in the CIC system and the applicant identification information available in the in-house DB system may be different. Therefore, the information acquisition unit 31 can be said to be an acquisition means capable of acquiring current credit performance information on the applicant provided from another system (such as a CIC system or an in-house DB system).

[0031] Here, due to some abnormality such as a system down or network failure, the credit decision server 10 may be unable to access the CIC system or the in-house DB system. If the information acquisition unit 31 is unable to access the CIC system, it determines that there is a CIC system error, and if it is unable to access the in-house DB system, it determines that there is an in-house DB system error. In such a case, a credit decision for the target credit case is not performed, and error information indicating a CIC system error or an in-house DB system error is generated by the information generation unit 35, which will be described later.

[0032] On the other hand, there are cases where the applicant's CIC credit information is not registered in the CIC system, or where the applicant is transacting with the company for the first time and the applicant's internal credit information is not registered in the internal DB system. In the former case, the information acquisition unit 31 acquires CIC non-reference information from the CIC system, and in the latter case, the information acquisition unit 31 acquires internal non-reference information from the internal DB system. The CIC non-reference information is included in the case information as CIC credit information, and the internal non-reference information is included in the case information as internal credit information and stored in the information storage unit 30.

[0033] The score calculation unit 32 determines an individual evaluation score for each of the multiple evaluation items based on the case information stored in the information storage unit 30, and calculates an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined multiple individual evaluation scores. That is, the score calculation unit 32 is a specific example of the above-mentioned score calculation means. The score calculation unit 32 holds individual evaluation score determination rules for each evaluation item, and determines each individual evaluation score by applying the determination rule for each evaluation item to the individual information corresponding to that evaluation item contained in the case information.

[0034] FIG. 3 is a diagram showing, in table form, some of the rules for determining individual evaluation scores in this embodiment. Figure 3 shows some examples of evaluation items, such as "gender," "age," "family composition," "occupation," "years of employment," "number of repayments," "number of inquiries," and "number of contracts." In the determination rule for the evaluation item "gender", the individual evaluation score is determined to be "-20" if the applicant is "male" and "0" if the applicant is "female". According to the determination rule for the evaluation item "age", the individual evaluation score is determined to be the value obtained by multiplying the applicant's age by "-1". According to the determination rules for the evaluation item "Family Composition," the individual evaluation score is determined to be "10" if the applicant's family composition category is "1. Married, no children," "12" if the category is "2. Married, with children," "5" if the category is "3. Single, no children," "2" if the category is "4. Single, with children," and "-1" if the category is "0. Unknown." In the determination rule for the evaluation item "job type," individual evaluation scores are determined as "10," "20," "-5," etc., depending on the job type category. The rules for determining the evaluation item "length of service" are as follows: if the length of service category is "not employed / unknown," the individual evaluation score is determined to be "-20," if the category is "less than 1 year," the score is determined to be "-30," if the category is "1 to 3 years," the score is determined to be "-25," if the category is "3 to 10 years," the score is determined to be "0," and if the category is "10 years or more," the score is determined to be "10." In the determination rules for the evaluation item "Number of repayments," the individual evaluation score is determined to be "0" if the category of the number of repayments is "credit card application," "15" if the category is "1 to 3 individual installments," "10" if the category is "4 to 12 individual installments," "5" if the category is "13 to 24 individual installments," and "0" if the category is "25 or more individual installments." According to the determination rule for the evaluation item "number of inquiries," the individual evaluation score is determined as the applicant's number of inquiries multiplied by "-20." According to the determination rules for the evaluation item "number of contracts," the individual evaluation score is determined as "-30" if the category of the number of contracts is "1 or less," as "-20" if the category is "2 to 4," as "-10" if the category is "5 to 15," and as "0" if the category is "16 or more."

[0035] The score calculation unit 32 determines an individual evaluation score for each of the evaluation items "gender", "age", "family composition", "occupation", and "years of service" by applying the applicant's personal attribute information ("gender", "age", "family composition", "occupation", and "years of service") included in the application information of the case information to the decision rules for each of the evaluation items "gender", "age", "family composition", "occupation", and "years of service". In addition, the score calculation unit 32 determines an individual evaluation score for the evaluation item "number of repayments" by applying the credit type and number of repayments of the target credit case included in the application information of the case information to the decision rules for the evaluation item "number of repayments".

[0036] In addition, the score calculation unit 32 determines individual evaluation scores for each evaluation item of "number of inquiries" and "number of contracts" by applying the number of inquiries and the number of contracts contained in the CIC credit information of the project information to the determination rules for the evaluation items of "number of inquiries" and "number of contracts." In this way, the evaluation items include specific evaluation items (evaluation items of "number of inquiries" and "number of contracts" in FIG. 3) whose individual evaluation scores are determined using the CIC credit information of the project information. In addition, although not shown, the evaluation items may include specific evaluation items whose individual evaluation scores are determined using the internal credit information of the project information.

[0037] Here, the multiple evaluation items include at least quantitative items corresponding to the quantitative data included in the case information, and categorical items corresponding to the qualitative data included in the case information. In the example of Figure 3, the evaluation items "age," "years of service," "number of repayments," "number of inquiries," and "number of contracts" are quantitative items, and the evaluation items "gender," "family composition," and "occupation" are categorical items.

[0038] The quantitative items can further be said to include a first quantitative item whose individual evaluation score is determined proportionally to the first quantitative data included in the case information, and a second quantitative item whose individual evaluation score is determined by a score constant assigned to each of a plurality of intervals into which the data range into which the second quantitative data included in the case information can be taken is divided. Here, "quantitative data" refers to data that can be directly expressed in numbers, such as years, frequency, and number of cases, while "qualitative data" refers to data that cannot be directly expressed in numbers, such as gender and occupation.

[0039] In the example of Figure 3, the evaluation items "age" and "number of inquiries" correspond to the first quantitative items, and the evaluation items "years of service," "number of repayments," and "number of contracts" correspond to the second quantitative items. For example, the individual evaluation score for the evaluation item "age" (first quantitative item) is determined by multiplying the "age" included in the case information by a score coefficient (-1). Meanwhile, for the evaluation item "years of service" (second quantitative item), the possible data range of "years of service" included in the case information (0 or unknown to over 10 years) is divided into five intervals (categories), and each interval is assigned a score constant of "-20", "-30", "-25", "0", and "10", respectively.

[0040] In addition, for the category items of the evaluation items, a score constant is assigned to each of the multiple categories, and the score calculation unit 32 determines an individual evaluation score for a category item corresponding to qualitative data included in the case information, using the score constant assigned to the category indicated by the qualitative data. The score calculation unit 32 calculates an aggregated evaluation score based on the multiple individual evaluation scores thus determined. As described in the [Overview] section, the method of calculating the aggregated evaluation score is not particularly limited as long as it is based on the individual evaluation scores. In this embodiment, the score calculation unit 32 calculates a value obtained by adding a preset score constant to the sum of all the individual evaluation scores as the aggregated evaluation score.

[0041] Here, the decision rules, score constants, and score coefficients for each of the above-mentioned evaluation items are set so that the aggregate evaluation score calculated based on the individual evaluation scores shows as high a correlation as possible with the credit risk. For example, for each quantitative item, a decision rule is designed as to whether to set the item as a first quantitative item or a second quantitative item so that the aggregated evaluation score shows the highest possible correlation with the credit risk. Specifically, a quantitative item in which the credit risk increases or decreases proportionally in response to the quantitative data of the project information is set as a first quantitative item, and other quantitative items are set as second quantitative items. In addition, for the second quantitative item, a division of the data range is designed so that the aggregated evaluation score shows the highest possible correlation with the credit risk.

[0042] In this embodiment, the required evaluation items and rough decision rules for each evaluation item were designed using the incidence rate of two-month overdue based on the performance information of past credit cases, and the above-mentioned score constant or score coefficient was determined using multivariate analysis. Specifically, the score constant and score coefficient were calculated so that the difference in the average value of the respective aggregate evaluation scores between the group of credit cases that were two-month overdue by discriminant analysis (black zone) and the group of credit cases that completed repayment without two-month overdue (white zone) was maximized. In this manner, in this embodiment, the determination rules, score constants, and score coefficients for each evaluation item are set using the incidence rate of two-month overdue payments as information indicating credit risk, but the method of setting these is not limited to the example of this embodiment. The incidence rate of default on repayment may be used as information indicating credit risk, or the incidence rate of three-month overdue payments may be used. In this way, according to this embodiment, individual evaluation scores are determined and aggregate evaluation scores are calculated using decision rules and score constants, etc., that are set to show as high a correlation as possible with credit risk, thereby improving the accuracy of credit judgment.

[0043] As described above, there are cases where CIC non-reference information is set as CIC credit information in the case information, or where internal non-reference information is set as internal credit information in the case information. Even in such a case, the score calculation unit 32 determines individual evaluation scores for all evaluation items (including the specific evaluation items described above) and calculates an aggregate evaluation score based on these individual evaluation scores. For example, when the score calculation unit 32 applies information to the decision rules for evaluation items corresponding to the CIC credit information and internal credit information of the case information, the score calculation unit 32 applies the initial value corresponding to each evaluation item to decide the individual evaluation score. In the example of FIG. 3, in the decision rule for the evaluation item "number of inquiries" ("number" x "-20"), the number of inquiries is set to 0, and an individual evaluation score of "0" is decided. Also, in the evaluation item "number of contracts", if the number of contracts is set to 0, it falls into the category "1 or less", and an individual evaluation score of "-30" is decided. This makes it possible to properly calculate the individual evaluation score and aggregate evaluation score even if it is the applicant's first credit application, and ultimately to properly make a credit decision.

[0044] The suitability determination unit 33 determines the suitability of a target credit case with respect to a plurality of credit screening conditions, based on the case information stored in the information storage unit 30. That is, the suitability determination unit 33 is a specific example of the suitability determination means described above. The suitability judgment unit 33 may make a suitability judgment regarding the plurality of credit screening conditions when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation unit 32 satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and may not make a suitability judgment when the threshold condition is not satisfied. In the latter case, the credit judgment unit 34 described later will automatically judge the target credit application as uncreditable. Here, the specific content of each credit screening condition and the number of credit screening conditions are not limited, but it is preferable that the number of credit screening conditions is greater than the number of evaluation items of the individual evaluation scores. More preferably, the number of credit screening conditions is more than twice the number of evaluation items. In this way, since not only the aggregated evaluation score but also many credit screening conditions are filtered, the accuracy of the credit judgment can be improved, and the load of the credit judgment process can be reduced and the speed can be increased. This is because, whereas the suitability judgment of many credit screening conditions requires the suitability judgment of the credit screening conditions, the threshold judgment of the aggregated evaluation score can narrow down the targets for suitability judgment.

[0045] In this embodiment, the threshold condition is that the aggregated evaluation score exceeds a predetermined score threshold. This score threshold may be appropriately determined according to the degree of acceptable credit risk based on performance information of past credit cases. For example, the aggregate evaluation score group calculated from performance information of past credit cases may be divided into a plurality of intervals, and the ratio of the loss amount (loss due to delayed repayment) to the profit amount (fee profit) in the credit cases belonging to each interval of the aggregate evaluation score may be calculated, and the score threshold may be determined based on the difference in this ratio for each interval.

[0046] FIG. 4 is a diagram showing, in table form, some of the credit screening conditions in this embodiment. Each credit screening condition is associated in advance with individual information included in the case information, and the suitability determination unit 33 uses the individual information to determine whether or not the credit screening condition is met. In the example of Figure 4, the credit screening condition numbered "1" is associated with the applicant's current delinquent information in the internal credit information of the project information in question, the credit screening condition numbered "2" is associated with the applicant's payment status information for the most recent three months in the CIC credit information of the project information in question, and the credit screening condition numbered "3" is associated with the applicant's age in the application information of the project information in question and the payment status information for the most recent month in the CIC credit information. In the examples of "Last 3 Months XXX", "Last Month X", and "Last 3 Months XOX" shown in Figure 4, "X" indicates that no payment has been made or that only a partial payment has been made, and "O" indicates that the payment has been made normally. The credit selection condition numbered "21" is associated with the late payment status information of the joint guarantee receivable in the internal credit information of the relevant case information, the credit selection condition numbered "22" is associated with the reference information in the CIC credit information of the relevant case information (for example, if reference information is registered, it is determined that there is CIC warning information), and the credit selection condition numbered "23" is associated with the applicant's payment status information for the most recent three months in the CIC credit information of the relevant case information. The credit screening condition numbered "24" is associated with the application amount in the application information for the project information, the credit screening condition numbered "25" is associated with the applicant's age and number of repayments in the application information for the project information, the credit screening condition numbered "26" is associated with the purchase quantity and purchased item information in the application information for the project information, and the credit screening condition numbered "27" is associated with the CIC non-inquiry information for the project information.

[0047] The multiple credit screening conditions include multiple credit denial conditions and multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions. In the example of Figure 4, the credit screening conditions with numbers "1", "2" and "3" are credit denial conditions, and the credit screening conditions with numbers "21" to "27" are automatic judgment exclusion conditions. After making a suitability judgment regarding a plurality of credit denial conditions, if there is no matching credit denial condition, i.e., if none of the credit denial conditions are satisfied, the suitability judgment unit 33 makes a suitability judgment regarding the automatic judgment exclusion conditions. In this embodiment, if any one of the plurality of credit denial conditions is met, the target credit application is automatically determined to be uncreditable. If none of the credit denial conditions is met and any one of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions is met, the target credit application is determined to be outside the automatic judgment.

[0048] 4, the multiple credit screening conditions can be said to include a credit information non-reference condition that is met when the information acquisition unit 31 is unable to acquire current credit performance information (CIC credit information) relating to the applicant because the current credit performance information (CIC credit information) is not registered in the personal credit information agency's system (in this embodiment, the CIC system). This credit information non-reference condition (credit screening condition numbered "27") is treated as an automatic judgment exclusion condition. Therefore, even if the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation unit 32 satisfies the threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, if it meets the credit information non-inquiry condition, it can be said that the suitability judgment unit 33 automatically judges the credit case to be outside the automatic judgment. Cases in which credit information is not registered in the personal credit information agency's system include cases in which a specified period has passed since personal bankruptcy. Therefore, when CIC non-inquiry information is obtained, the case is determined to be outside the scope of automatic judgment, allowing for careful manual credit judgment, which in turn improves the accuracy of credit judgment.

[0049] The credit judgment unit 34 automatically judges whether the credit application is creditable, creditless, or not based on the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score and the judgment result regarding the suitability of the credit screening conditions. That is, the credit judgment unit 34 is a specific example of the above-mentioned information generating means. In this embodiment, the credit judgment unit 34 automatically judges the target credit case as uncreditable when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation unit 32 does not satisfy a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and automatically judges the target credit case as creditable when the threshold condition related to the aggregated evaluation score is satisfied and there is no matching credit screening condition. Furthermore, the credit judgment unit 34 automatically judges the target credit case as uncreditable when at least one of the credit denial conditions is satisfied even when the threshold condition related to the aggregated evaluation score is satisfied. Furthermore, the credit judgment unit 34 judges the target credit case as not eligible for automatic judgment when at least one of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions is satisfied even when the threshold condition related to the aggregated evaluation score is satisfied and there is no matching credit denial condition.

[0050] In this embodiment, as described in the [Overview] section, a credit approval determination will not be made based solely on either the judgment result regarding the aggregate evaluation score or the judgment result regarding the suitability of the credit screening conditions, but there may be cases in which a credit disapproval determination is made. That is, according to this embodiment, credit is determined to be available only when many conditions are met, thereby preventing a decrease in the accuracy of automatic credit determination. In addition, even if the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score is good, if even one of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions of the credit screening conditions is met, it will be judged as not being automatically judged. As a result, if it is possible to automatically judge whether or not to grant credit based on the aggregated evaluation score and the suitability of the credit screening conditions, credit is displayed as either OK or not, and in other cases, it is displayed as not being automatically judged, so that the accuracy of the credit judgment is maintained without forcing an automatic judgment.

[0051] The information generating unit 35 generates credit judgment information indicating the result of the automatic judgment by the credit judgment unit 34. That is, the information generating unit 35 is a specific example of the above-mentioned information generating means. The generated credit judgment information is not limited in any way as long as it indicates the result of the automatic judgment by the credit judgment unit 34. For example, the credit judgment information may include a part of the case information so that the target credit case can be identified. Furthermore, when the result of the automatic judgment indicates that the credit is not allowed or that the automatic judgment is not satisfied, the credit judgment information may include information on the cause of such a result (for example, the content of the credit screening conditions that were met, or the fact that the aggregated evaluation score was equal to or lower than a predetermined score threshold).

[0052] The information generating unit 35 transmits the generated credit decision information to the user terminal 20. As a result, the credit decision information may be displayed on the display device 26 of the user terminal 20, or may be output in some form from the input / output device 27.

[0053] Although not shown, the user terminal 20 also has a software configuration that performs the following processes by loading a computer program stored in the memory 23 into the CPU 22 and executing it. The user terminal 20 displays a user interface screen that can be operated by the company's user on the display device 26, and transmits application information for a target credit case in response to a user operation on the user interface screen to the credit judgment server 10. The application information may be input by the user via the user interface screen. However, the application information may be generated by the user terminal 20 based on data read by the input / output device 27 (such as a scanner). There is no limitation on the method of generating the application information. The details of the application information are as described above.

[0054] Furthermore, the user terminal 20 receives the credit judgment information generated by the credit judgment server 10 (information generation unit 35) as described above, and presents the result of the credit judgment for the target credit case to the user. The user terminal 20 may display the result of the credit judgment on the display device 26, or may output it in another form to the input / output device 27. The user terminal 20 may also output, together with the result of the credit judgment, information that can identify the target credit case, and cause information when the result of the credit judgment is not creditworthy or falls outside the automatic judgment. There are no limitations on the form in which the result of the credit judgment on the user terminal 20 is presented to the user.

[0055] [Example of operation (processing flow)] Next, as an operation example of the present system 1, the credit judgment process flow in the credit judgment server 10 will be described with reference to Fig. 5. Fig. 5 is a flowchart showing the credit judgment process flow in the credit judgment server 10. Note that the processing contents of each step of the credit judgment process flow are similar to the processing contents executed by each of the above-mentioned software configurations, and therefore the description will be omitted as appropriate.

[0056] In this embodiment, first, the credit judgment server 10 acquires application information on the target credit case from the user terminal 20 through communication (S51). As described above, the application information includes personal attribute information of the applicant such as name, date of birth, and telephone number, and detailed information on the target credit case such as the credit type (credit card, individual installment payment, financial guarantee, etc.), application amount, and number of repayments. In this embodiment, when application information is transmitted from the user terminal 20 to the credit decision server 10, a credit decision is made for the credit cases indicated by the application information. However, the timing for executing the credit decision process shown in Fig. 5 is not limited to this example. The credit decision process may be executed as a batch process according to a predetermined schedule, or may be executed when an instruction is received from the user terminal 20 separately from the acquisition of the application information. For this reason, when the credit decision process is executed as a batch process, application information for multiple credit cases may be sent to the credit decision server 10 collectively or sequentially, and the multiple application information may be collectively subjected to a credit decision at a predetermined timing.

[0057] The credit decision server 10 uses the applicant identification information (applicant's name, date of birth, etc.) included in the application information to obtain internal credit information and CIC credit information regarding the applicant from the internal DB system and the CIC system via communication (S52) (S53). At this time, if the applicant's internal credit information is not registered in the internal DB system, the credit judgment server 10 acquires internal non-reference information (S52), and if the applicant's CIC credit information is not registered in the CIC system, it acquires CIC non-reference information (S53). The credit judgment server 10 retains the application information obtained in (S51), the internal credit information or internal non-inquiry information obtained in (S52), and the CIC credit information or CIC non-inquiry information obtained in (S53) as case information related to the target credit case (stores them in the information storage unit 30). Although FIG. 5 shows an example in which (S52) and (S53) are executed in parallel, (S52) and (S53) may be executed in order.

[0058] When the credit judgment server 10 acquires case information on a target credit case (S51), (S52), (S53), it determines an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items based on the case information (S54). For each evaluation item, a determination rule, a score constant, a score coefficient, etc. are determined in advance, and the individual evaluation score for each evaluation item is calculated by applying the individual information in the case information corresponding to that evaluation item to the determination rule for that evaluation item.

[0059] At this time, if internal non-reference information has been acquired in (S52), the credit decision server 10 calculates an individual evaluation score for the evaluation item corresponding to the internal credit information by applying an initial value corresponding to the evaluation item to the decision rule for the evaluation item corresponding to the internal credit information (S54). Similarly, if CIC non-reference information has been acquired in (S53), the credit decision server 10 calculates an individual evaluation score for the evaluation item by applying an initial value corresponding to the evaluation item to the decision rule for the evaluation item corresponding to the CIC credit information (S54). In other words, the credit decision server 10 determines individual evaluation scores for all evaluation items even when CIC non-reference information or internal non-reference information is acquired.

[0060] Next, the credit judgment server 10 calculates an aggregated evaluation score based on all the individual evaluation scores determined in (S54) (S55). In this embodiment, the aggregated evaluation score is calculated by adding a predetermined score constant to the sum of all the individual evaluation scores.

[0061] The credit decision server 10 judges whether the aggregated evaluation score calculated in (S55) satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold (S56). In this embodiment, it is judged whether the aggregated evaluation score exceeds the predetermined score threshold. If the total evaluation score does not exceed the predetermined score threshold (S56; NO), the credit decision server 10 automatically determines that the target credit application is not creditworthy (S57).

[0062] On the other hand, if the aggregated evaluation score exceeds the predetermined score threshold (S56; YES), the credit decision-making server 10 further judges the suitability of the target credit application with respect to a plurality of credit screening conditions based on the application information. In this embodiment, the multiple credit screening conditions include multiple non-credit conditions and multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions, and the credit judgment server 10 first judges whether the non-credit conditions are appropriate (S58). For example, a judgment order is determined in advance for the multiple non-credit conditions, and the credit judgment server 10 judges whether the non-credit conditions are appropriate one by one in accordance with the judgment order. Of course, the multiple non-credit conditions may be judged in parallel.

[0063] If it is determined that the credit denial condition is met as a result of the judgment on the suitability of the credit denial condition in (S58) (S59; YES), the credit judgment server 10 automatically judges the subject credit application to be uncreditable (S57). On the other hand, if it is determined that the credit denial condition is not met (S59; NO), the credit decision server 10 determines whether the suitability judgment of all credit denial conditions has been completed (S60), and if not completed (S60; NO), it makes a suitability judgment of the next credit denial condition (S58).

[0064] Then, if none of the credit denial conditions are met (S59; NO) and the suitability judgment for all the credit denial conditions has been completed (S60; YES), the credit judgment server 10 then starts the suitability judgment for the automatic judgment exclusion conditions (S61). The order of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions is also determined in advance, and the credit judgment server 10 may judge the suitability of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions one by one according to the order of judgment. Also, the suitability of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions may be judged in parallel.

[0065] If it is determined that the automatic judgment exclusion condition is met as a result of the suitability determination of the automatic judgment exclusion condition in (S61) (S62; YES), the credit judgment server 10 determines that the target credit application is not subject to automatic judgment (S63). Then, if none of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met (S62; NO) and the suitability judgment for all the automatic judgment exclusion conditions has been completed (S64; YES), the credit judgment server 10 automatically judges that the target credit application is credit appropriable (S65).

[0066] In this manner, in this embodiment, if the aggregated evaluation score does not satisfy the threshold condition using the predetermined score threshold (S56; NO), it is immediately and automatically determined that credit is not allowed (S57). Furthermore, even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies the threshold condition using the predetermined score threshold (S56; YES), if any one of the credit denial conditions is met (S59; YES), it is automatically determined that credit is not allowed (S58). On the other hand, even if the aggregated evaluation score meets the threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold (S56; YES) and does not match any of the credit denial conditions (S59; NO), if it meets even one of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions (S62; YES), it will be judged as not being eligible for automatic judgment (S63). Then, the credit is automatically determined to be granted only if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies the threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold (S56; YES), does not match any of the credit denial conditions (S59; NO), and does not match any of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions (S62; NO).

[0067] The credit decision server 10 generates credit decision information indicating at least the result of the decision (S57), (S63) or (S65) (S66) and transmits the credit decision information to the user terminal 20. As a result, the user terminal 20 presents the result of the credit decision on the target credit case to the user.

[0068] [Variations] The above-described embodiment is an example of the credit determination system 1. The credit determination system 1 is not limited to the above-described configuration, and may be partially modified as appropriate as long as it has at least a part of the above-described configuration. For example, the present system 1 according to the embodiment described above includes the credit judgment server 10 and the user terminal 20, but may be formed only by the user terminal 20. In this case, it is sufficient that the user terminal 20 can access the CIC system and the in-house DB system, and all of the software configuration of the credit judgment server 10 described above is realized on the user terminal 20. Furthermore, even when the present system 1 includes the credit judgment server 10 and the user terminal 20, part of the above-mentioned software configuration of the credit judgment server 10 may be realized on the user terminal 20.

[0069] In the above-described embodiment, the suitability judgment unit 33 performs a suitability judgment regarding the multiple credit screening conditions when the aggregate evaluation score calculated by the score calculation unit 32 satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and does not perform a suitability judgment regarding the multiple credit screening conditions when the threshold condition is not satisfied. However, the above-mentioned threshold condition regarding the aggregated evaluation score may be included in the credit denial condition of the credit screening conditions. In this case, the suitability judgment unit 33 judges the suitability of the credit denial conditions one by one in a predetermined judgment order, and when judging the suitability of the threshold condition regarding the aggregated evaluation score, which is one of the credit denial conditions, determines the individual evaluation scores and calculates the aggregated evaluation score. Then, when the threshold condition (credit denial condition) regarding the aggregated evaluation score is satisfied, the suitability judgment unit 33 may judge the suitability of the remaining multiple credit screening conditions, and when the threshold condition is not satisfied, may not judge the suitability of the remaining multiple credit screening conditions.

[0070] In addition, in the above-described embodiment, if even one of the multiple credit denial conditions was met, it was determined that credit was not allowed, but it may also be determined that credit was not allowed if a predetermined number or more of the multiple credit denial conditions were met. In addition, in the above-described embodiment, if none of the credit denial conditions were met and even one of the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions was met, the credit was judged to be outside the automatic judgment range, but it may also be determined to be outside the automatic judgment range if a predetermined number of two or more of the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met. Furthermore, the plurality of credit denial conditions may include conditions for which a credit denial is determined if even one of the conditions is met, and conditions for which a credit denial is determined if two or more predetermined conditions are met. Similarly, the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions may include conditions for which a credit denial is determined if even one of the conditions is met, and conditions for which a credit denial is determined if two or more predetermined conditions are met.

[0071] In addition, in the above-described embodiment, one score threshold was used as the threshold condition for the aggregated evaluation score, but it is also possible to select and use a score threshold corresponding to the credit type of the target credit case from a plurality of mutually different score thresholds predetermined for each credit type (credit classification). In this way, the score threshold can be changed for each credit type, making it possible to perform credit judgments with higher accuracy.

[0072] Furthermore, when a target credit case in which the credit type is a credit card application is judged to be credit-approved, the credit limit of the credit card may be automatically determined according to the aggregated evaluation score. For example, the data range of the aggregated evaluation score may be divided into a plurality of intervals in advance, and the value of the credit limit may be set in advance for each interval. Specifically, when the system is designed so that the higher the credit risk, the lower the aggregated evaluation score, the smaller the credit limit may be set. In this way, the credit limit can be set automatically along with the credit approval determination, thereby further improving the efficiency of operations related to credit determination.

[0073] The contents of the above-described embodiment and modified examples can also be specified as follows. (Appendix 1) A credit decision system for making a credit decision regarding an applicant's credit case, an acquisition means for acquiring case information regarding the credit case, the case information including at least personal attribute information and current credit performance information regarding the applicant; a score calculation means for determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired case information, and calculating an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores; a suitability determination means for determining suitability of the credit application with respect to a plurality of credit screening conditions based on the acquired application information; an information generating means for automatically determining whether the credit application is creditable, creditless, or not based on a result of the judgment regarding the aggregated evaluation score and the result of the suitability judgment, and generating credit judgment information indicating the result of the automatic judgment; Equipped with The information generating means may not determine credit approval based on only one of the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score or the suitability judgment result, but may determine credit disapproval in some cases. Credit assessment system. (Appendix 2) the number of the plurality of credit screening conditions is greater than the number of the plurality of evaluation items; the suitability determination means performs a suitability determination for the plurality of credit screening conditions when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation means satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and does not perform the suitability determination when the threshold condition is not satisfied; The information generating means automatically determines that the credit application is not to be granted if the threshold condition is not satisfied. 2. A credit decision system as described in appendix 1. (Appendix 3) The plurality of credit screening conditions include a plurality of credit denial conditions and a plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, the suitability determination means, after performing the suitability determination regarding the plurality of credit denial conditions, performs the suitability determination regarding the automatic judgment exclusion condition when there is no matching credit denial condition; The information generating means automatically judges the credit application as uncreditable if one or more of the plurality of credit denial conditions are met even when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation means satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, judges the credit application as not eligible for automatic judgment if one or more of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met, and judges the credit application as eligible for automatic judgment if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies the threshold condition and none of the plurality of credit denial conditions and the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met. 3. A credit decision system according to claim 1 or 2. (Appendix 4) the plurality of evaluation items include at least a quantitative item corresponding to quantitative data included in the case information; The quantitative items include a first quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined in proportion to first quantitative data included in the case information, and a second quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined by a score constant assigned to each of a plurality of intervals into which a data range that second quantitative data included in the case information can take is divided, The multiple intervals in the second quantitative item include one or more intervals having interval widths different from other intervals. 4. A credit decision system according to any one of claims 1 to 3. (Appendix 5) the plurality of evaluation items include at least category items corresponding to qualitative data included in the case information; the score calculation means determines the individual evaluation score for the category item corresponding to the qualitative data included in the case information, using a score constant assigned to a category indicated by the qualitative data; 5. A credit decision system as described in appendix 4. (Appendix 6) the plurality of evaluation items include specific evaluation items for which the individual evaluation score is determined using current credit performance information on the applicant included in the project information; The acquiring means is capable of acquiring current credit performance information regarding the applicant provided from another system, The score calculation means determines the individual evaluation score for each of the plurality of evaluation items including the specific evaluation item, even if the acquisition means is unable to acquire current credit performance information regarding the applicant because the current credit performance information regarding the applicant is not registered in the other system, and calculates an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores. 6. A credit decision system according to any one of appendix 1 to 5. (Appendix 7) The other system is a system of a personal credit information agency, the plurality of credit screening conditions include a credit information non-reference condition that is met when the acquisition means is unable to acquire current credit performance information regarding the applicant because the current credit performance information regarding the applicant is not registered in the personal credit information agency's system, The suitability determination means automatically determines that the credit application is not eligible for automatic determination when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation means satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and when the aggregated evaluation score meets the credit information non-reference condition. 7. A credit decision system as described in Appendix 6. (Appendix A) The case information further includes a credit type related to the credit case, The information generating means selects a predetermined score threshold corresponding to the credit type included in the case information from among a plurality of predetermined score thresholds different from each other and determined in advance for each credit type (individual, card, guarantee), and determines whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using the selected predetermined score threshold. 8. A credit decision system according to any one of claims 1 to 7. (Appendix 8) A credit judgment method for making a credit judgment regarding an applicant's credit case, comprising the steps of: One or more computers acquiring case information relating to the credit case, the case information including at least personal attribute information and current credit performance information relating to the applicant; a calculation step of determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired case information, and calculating an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores; a suitability determination step of determining suitability of the credit case with respect to a plurality of credit screening conditions based on the acquired case information; an automatic judgment step of automatically judging whether the credit application is creditable, creditless, or not based on a judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score and a result of the suitability judgment; A generating step of generating credit decision information indicating a result of the automatic decision; Run In the automatic judgment step, the credit approval is not determined based on only one of the judgment result regarding the aggregated evaluation score or the result of the suitability judgment, but the credit approval may be determined as not being possible. Credit evaluation method. (Appendix 9) the number of the plurality of credit screening conditions is greater than the number of the plurality of evaluation items; In the suitability determination step, if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, a suitability determination is made for the plurality of credit screening conditions, and if the threshold condition is not satisfied, the suitability determination is not made; In the automatic judgment step, if the threshold condition is not satisfied, it is automatically judged that the credit application is not to be granted. The credit assessment method described in Appendix 8. (Appendix 10) The plurality of credit screening conditions include a plurality of credit denial conditions and a plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, In the suitability determination step, after performing the suitability determination regarding the plurality of credit denial conditions, if there is no matching credit denial condition, the suitability determination regarding the automatic judgment exclusion condition is performed; In the automatic judgment process, even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, if one or more of the multiple credit denial conditions are met, the credit application is automatically judged as not credit denial, if one or more of the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met, the credit application is judged as not eligible for automatic judgment, and if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies the threshold condition and none of the multiple credit denial conditions and the multiple automatic judgment exclusion conditions are met, the credit application is judged as eligible for credit. 10. A credit assessment method as set forth in appendix 8 or 9. (Appendix 11) the plurality of evaluation items include at least a quantitative item corresponding to quantitative data included in the case information; The quantitative items include a first quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined in proportion to first quantitative data included in the case information, and a second quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined by a score constant assigned to each of a plurality of intervals into which a data range that second quantitative data included in the case information can take is divided, The multiple intervals in the second quantitative item include one or more intervals having interval widths different from other intervals. 11. A credit assessment method according to any one of appendices 8 to 10. (Appendix 12) the plurality of evaluation items include at least category items corresponding to qualitative data included in the case information; In the calculation step, the individual evaluation score is determined for the category item corresponding to the qualitative data included in the case information by a score constant assigned to the category indicated by the qualitative data. 12. A credit assessment method as described in Appendix 11. (Appendix 13) the plurality of evaluation items include specific evaluation items for which the individual evaluation score is determined using current credit performance information on the applicant included in the project information; In the acquiring step, current credit performance information on the applicant provided from another system can be acquired, In the calculation step, even if the acquisition means is unable to acquire current status performance information of credit for the applicant because the current status performance information is not registered in the other system, the individual evaluation score is determined for each of the plurality of evaluation items including the specific evaluation item, and an aggregate evaluation score is calculated based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores. 13. A credit assessment method according to any one of appendices 8 to 12. (Appendix 14) The other system is a system of a personal credit information agency, the plurality of credit screening conditions include a credit information non-reference condition that is met when the acquisition means is unable to acquire current credit performance information regarding the applicant because the current credit performance information regarding the applicant is not registered in the personal credit information agency's system, In the suitability determination step, even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, if the aggregated evaluation score matches the credit information non-reference condition, the credit application is automatically determined to be outside the automatic determination. A credit assessment method as described in Appendix 13. (Appendix B) The case information further includes a credit type related to the credit case, In the automatic judgment step, a predetermined score threshold corresponding to the credit type included in the case information is selected from among a plurality of predetermined score thresholds different from each other and determined in advance for each credit type (individual, card, guarantee), and it is judged whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using the selected predetermined score threshold. 15. A credit assessment method according to any one of appendices 8 to 14. [Explanation of symbols]

[0074] 1 Credit judgment system (this system), 2 Communication network, 10 Credit judgment server, 12 CPU, 13 Memory, 14 Communication unit, 15 Input / output I / F, 20 User terminal, 22 CPU, 23 Memory, 24 Communication unit, 25 Input / output I / F, 26 Display device, 27 Input / output device, 30 Information storage unit, 31 Information acquisition unit, 32 Score calculation unit, 33 Appropriateness judgment unit, 34 Credit judgment unit, 35 Information generation unit

Claims

1. A credit decision system that is configured by one or more computers and that makes a credit decision regarding an applicant's credit case, an acquisition means for acquiring case information including a plurality of types of information on the credit case, the information including at least personal attribute information on the applicant and current credit performance information, as individual information for each information type; a score calculation means for determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired case information, and calculating an aggregate evaluation score from the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores using a predetermined calculation method; a suitability determination means for determining whether or not individual information associated with each of a plurality of credit screening conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit screening condition; an information generating means for automatically determining whether the credit application is creditable, creditless, or not automatically determined based on a result of the determination of whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and a result of the suitability determination, and generating credit determination information indicating the result of the automatic determination; Equipped with The score calculation means holds, for each of the plurality of evaluation items, a determination rule for an individual evaluation score to which an information type included in the case information is associated and which uses individual information of the associated information type, and determines an individual evaluation score for each of the plurality of evaluation items by applying the individual information of the information type associated with each evaluation item included in the acquired case information to the determination rule for each evaluation item held therefor; the rule for determining the individual evaluation score and the predetermined calculation method stored in the score calculation means are set so that the calculated aggregate evaluation score shows a high correlation with credit risk, The plurality of credit screening conditions include a plurality of credit denial conditions and a plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, the suitability determination means performs a suitability determination for each of the plurality of credit denial conditions as to whether or not individual information associated with each of the credit denial conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit denial condition, and then, if no credit denial condition is satisfied, performs a suitability determination for each of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions as to whether or not individual information associated with each of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the automatic judgment exclusion condition; The information generating means Even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, if the suitability determination means determines that a predetermined number of the plurality of credit denial conditions are satisfied, the credit application is judged to be unsuitable for credit, and if the suitability determination means determines that a predetermined number of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are satisfied, the credit application is judged to be outside of automatic judgment, When the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and the suitability determination means determines that the aggregated evaluation score satisfies none of the plurality of credit denial conditions and the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, the credit application is determined to be credit approved. Credit assessment system.

2. the number of the plurality of credit screening conditions is greater than the number of the plurality of evaluation items; the suitability determination means performs a suitability determination for the plurality of credit screening conditions when the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation means satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and does not perform the suitability determination when the threshold condition is not satisfied; The information generating means automatically determines that the credit application is not to be granted if the threshold condition is not satisfied. The credit decision system according to claim 1 .

3. the plurality of evaluation items include at least a quantitative item corresponding to quantitative data included in the case information; The quantitative items include a first quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined in proportion to first quantitative data included in the case information, and a second quantitative item in which the individual evaluation score is determined by a score constant assigned to each of a plurality of intervals into which a data range that second quantitative data included in the case information can take is divided, The multiple intervals in the second quantitative item include one or more intervals having interval widths different from other intervals. The credit decision system according to claim 1 or 2.

4. the plurality of evaluation items include at least category items corresponding to qualitative data included in the case information; the score calculation means determines the individual evaluation score for the category item corresponding to the qualitative data included in the case information, using a score constant assigned to a category indicated by the qualitative data; The credit decision system according to claim 3 .

5. the plurality of evaluation items include specific evaluation items for which the individual evaluation score is determined using current credit performance information on the applicant included in the project information; The acquiring means is capable of acquiring current credit performance information regarding the applicant provided from another system, The score calculation means determines the individual evaluation score for each of the plurality of evaluation items including the specific evaluation item by applying an initial value to the decision rule for the specific evaluation item even when the acquisition means is unable to acquire the current credit performance information regarding the applicant because the current credit performance information regarding the applicant is not registered in the other system, and calculates an aggregate evaluation score based on the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores. The credit decision system according to claim 1 .

6. The other system is a system of a personal credit information agency, the plurality of credit screening conditions include a no credit inquiry condition; The suitability determination means determines that the credit information non-reference condition is met when the acquisition means is unable to acquire current credit performance information regarding the applicant because the current credit performance information regarding the applicant is not registered in the personal credit information agency's system, and determines that the credit information non-reference condition is met even if the aggregated evaluation score calculated by the score calculation means satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, if the credit information non-reference condition is met, the suitability determination means determines that the credit case is not eligible for automatic judgment. The credit decision system according to claim 5 .

7. A credit judgment method for making a credit judgment regarding an applicant's credit case, comprising the steps of: One or more computers acquiring case information including a plurality of types of information on the credit case, the information including at least personal attribute information on the applicant and current credit performance information, as individual information for each information type; a calculation step of determining an individual evaluation score for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to potential credit risk based on the acquired case information, and calculating an aggregate evaluation score from the determined plurality of individual evaluation scores using a predetermined calculation method; a suitability determination step of determining whether or not individual information associated with each of a plurality of credit screening conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit screening condition; an automatic judgment step of automatically judging whether the credit application is creditable, creditless, or not automatically judged based on a judgment result of whether the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and a result of the suitability judgment; A generating step of generating credit decision information indicating a result of the automatic decision; Run the one or more computers respectively store, for each of the plurality of evaluation items, an information type included in the case information that is associated with the each of the plurality of evaluation items, and a rule for determining an individual evaluation score using individual information of the associated information type; In the calculation step, the one or more computers determine individual evaluation scores for each of the plurality of evaluation items by applying individual information of an information type associated with each evaluation item included in the acquired case information to a decision rule for each evaluation item stored in the calculation step; the determination rule for the individual evaluation score and the predetermined calculation method are set so that the calculated aggregate evaluation score shows a high correlation with credit risk, The plurality of credit screening conditions include a plurality of credit denial conditions and a plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions, In the suitability determination step, the one or more computers perform a suitability determination for each of the plurality of credit denial conditions as to whether or not individual information associated with each of the credit denial conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the credit denial condition, and if no credit denial condition is satisfied, perform a suitability determination for each of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions as to whether or not individual information associated with each of the automatic judgment exclusion conditions included in the acquired case information satisfies the automatic judgment exclusion condition; In the automatic judgment step, the one or more computers judge the credit application as uncreditable if the suitability judgment step judges that a predetermined number of the plurality of credit denial conditions are satisfied even if the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold, and judge the credit application as not eligible for automatic judgment if the suitability judgment step judges that a predetermined number of the plurality of automatic judgment exclusion conditions are satisfied, When the aggregated evaluation score satisfies a threshold condition using a predetermined score threshold and the suitability determination step determines that none of the plurality of credit denial conditions and the plurality of automatic determination exclusion conditions are satisfied, the credit application is determined to be credit approved. Credit evaluation method.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Supplier support system

    JP2002207873A

  • Automatic transaction device and transaction method using the same

    JP2003108764A

  • System and method for supporting credit examination, and program making computer execute the same method

    JP2005196267A

  • Terminal equipment for settlement of credit card, settlement system and settlement method

    JP2006313440A

  • Credit determination device, credit determination method, and credit determination program

    JP2016184394A