Method and system for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of cardiac implants - Patents.com

The method predicts cardiac implant failure by simulating deformation over cardiac cycles using a 4D anatomical model, addressing the challenge of long-term implant failure due to cardiac cycles and anatomical changes, enabling optimal implant selection.

JP7586498B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19FEOPS NV
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021553066
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2019-03-08
Filing Date
2020-03-06
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2040-03-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing cardiac implants are subjected to repeated deformation and loading due to cardiac cycles, leading to potential failure, which current methods fail to predict accurately, especially considering long-term patient-specific anatomical changes.

Method used

A method for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure using a 4D patient-specific anatomical model to simulate cardiac implant deformation over multiple cardiac cycles, incorporating finite element analysis to determine the risk of failure based on deformation history and mechanical properties.

Benefits of technology

Enables prediction of cardiac implant failure due to repeated loading before installation, allowing for the selection of optimal implant devices and positions that minimize long-term failure risk.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007586498000001
    Figure 0007586498000001
  • Figure 0007586498000002
    Figure 0007586498000002
  • Figure 0007586498000003
    Figure 0007586498000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method and system for patient-specific prediction of cardiac implant cyclic loading failure includes providing an implant model representing a three-dimensional, mesh-based representation of the cardiac implant, and providing a four-dimensional, 4D, patient-specific anatomical model representing the mesh-based representation of the patient-specific cardiac region, including the placement position of the cardiac implant, at multiple states corresponding to multiple moments in the cardiac cycle. A computer calculates deformation of the implant model placed at the placement position as or before the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed across the multiple states, and the computer determines the risk of cardiac implant cyclic loading failure based on the calculated implant deformation.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of pre-operative planning of transcatheter structural cardiac interventions, for example in valve treatments such as valve implantation and / or repair. More particularly, the present invention relates to pre-operative prediction of cyclic loading failure of cardiac implants. [Background technology]

[0002] US Patent No. 5,999,333 discloses a method for obtaining preoperative insight into the interaction of an implant device with a patient's specific anatomical structures, to better predict complications such as regurgitation, to better predict the hemodynamic performance of implants placed in the aortic valve, and to better select and stratify patients.

[0003] US Patent No. 5,399,633 discloses a method for predicting the degree of hemodynamic deterioration as an acute consequence of a transcatheter structural cardiac intervention, for example at multiple moments during the cardiac cycle. Hemodynamic deterioration after placement can also be determined.

[0004] Although these have provided great advances in preoperative planning and have allowed the selection of the appropriate implant device for each individual patient to improve acute outcomes, more information is needed on the long-term interaction of the implant device with the specific patient anatomy to further improve preoperative planning. It would be of great value to take into account the anatomical remodeling of the heart that is altered by the long-term presence of the implant when assessing the chronic outcome of an intervention. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0005] [Patent Document 1] International Publication No. 2013 / 171039 [Patent Document 2] International Publication No. 2018 / 141927 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0006] Implant devices in the heart and other moving organs are subject to repeated deformations and cyclic loading. For example, cardiac implants are subject to cyclic loading through the cardiac cycle. During systole, the cardiac implant compresses and during diastole, the cardiac implant may loosen. It has been found that implant devices determined to be optimal when considering acute outcomes (e.g., during placement) are not necessarily optimal when considering chronic outcomes (e.g., failure due to cyclic loading, such as high cycle fatigue failure). Furthermore, it has been found that the performance of an implant device when considering failure due to cyclic loading can be highly dependent on the patient-specific cyclic loading caused by the patient's unique anatomy. [Means for solving the problem]

[0007] Therefore, according to the present invention, a method for predicting the failure of a cardiac implant due to cyclic loading in a patient-specific manner is provided. The prediction method can be performed before the actual installation of the actual cardiac implant device in the patient's anatomy. The method includes providing an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of the cardiac implant. The method also includes providing a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region including the installation positions of the cardiac implant in a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments of the cardiac cycle. According to the method, a computer calculates the deformation of the implant model installed in the installation position as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states, for example by using finite element analysis, and determines the risk of failure due to cyclic loading of the cardiac implant based on the calculated deformation and deformation history of the implant. This has the advantage that the failure of the implant device due to cyclic loading can be predicted before the installation of the implant device based on the patient-specific anatomy.

[0008] Optionally, the method includes determining a risk of failure due to cyclic loading of the cardiac implant based on the calculated implant deformation and data representative of a deformation history, which may include, for example, elapsed time, number of cycles, predicted implant device movement, predicted anatomical changes over time, etc., and also implant deformation during loading into the catheter and advancing the implant towards the placement position, elapsed time, number of cycles, predicted implant device movement, predicted anatomical changes over time, etc.

[0009] Optionally, the method includes calculating deformation of the implant model during the successive deformation of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model through a plurality of states after placing the implant model at the placement position. The implant model may be placed at the placement position without modeling a beating heart during placement. Alternatively, the implant model may be placed at the placement position while modeling a beating heart during placement. The method may include calculating deformation of the placed implant model during the successive deformation of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model through a plurality of states.

[0010] Optionally, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model represents a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific cardiac region in multiple states corresponding to multiple instants of the cardiac cycle prior to placement, such that nodes of the 4D anatomical model change to multiple states in response to displacements of the patient-specific cardiac region in the absence of the implant device.

[0011] Deformations of the patient-specific anatomical model representing the patient-specific heart region are presented to the implant device due to contact between the anatomical model and the implant model, so deformations of the patient-specific heart region as a result of the presence of the implant device are not taken into account, which has been found to provide a good approximation for relatively flexible implant devices, i.e. devices that are much more flexible compared to the hosting anatomy.

[0012] Optionally, a 4D patient-specific intermediate model is provided, whose nodes are associated with the nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model. The 4D patient-specific intermediate model represents a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region in multiple states corresponding to multiple instants of the cardiac cycle before placement. The associated nodes of the 4D intermediate model are thus deformed to multiple states according to the displacement of the patient-specific heart region in the absence of the implant device. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model is then deformed to multiple states by applying displacements to the associated nodes of the 4D intermediate model via rigidity or dashpot elements connecting the associated nodes of the 4D intermediate model and the nodes of the anatomical model. The deformation of the 4D patient-specific intermediate model is thus driven by the nodes of the intermediate model associated with the nodes of the anatomical model, while the nodes of the anatomical model can move (elastically) relative to the associated nodes of the intermediate model. The deformation of the implant model is achieved by contact between the 4D patient-specific anatomical model and the implant model. The deformation of the patient-specific heart region due to the presence of the implant device is thus taken into account. It has been found that this provides a good approximation for relatively stiff implant devices, i.e. devices that deform into the hosting anatomical structure. It will be appreciated that which of these two options (applying deformation directly to the anatomical nodes or indirectly using associated nodes connected to the anatomical nodes via mechanical stiffness and / or dashpot elements) is most suitable for the implant device under investigation can be verified, for example through comparative testing.

[0013] Optionally, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model has mechanical properties including stiffness and / or viscosity. In such cases, the overall mechanical behavior of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model depends on a combination of the mechanical properties of the 4D anatomical model and the mechanical properties of stiffness and / or dashpot elements connecting relevant nodes to the 4D anatomical model.

[0014] Optionally, the method includes determining the mechanical stress and / or strain in each mesh element of the implant model. Optionally, the method includes determining the mechanical stress and / or strain in each mesh element of the implant model for each of a plurality of states over the course of a cardiac cycle. The mechanical stress and / or strain in the mesh elements of the implant model are representative of cyclic fatigue loading. The mechanical stress and / or strain in the mesh elements of the implant model and its variation over the course of a full cycle are representative of cyclic fatigue loading.

[0015] Optionally, the method includes determining, for each mesh element of the implant model, a magnitude of mechanical stress and / or strain occurring during the course of a cardiac cycle, the determined magnitude being representative of risk of failure due to cyclic loading.

[0016] Optionally, the cardiac implant is a valve implant, a stent, or the like.

[0017] Optionally, failure due to cyclic loading includes one or more of high cycle fatigue failure, such as material fatigue, implant migration, and valve failure.

[0018] Optionally, if the cyclic loading simulation is predictive of the first failure, a second (post-failure) cyclic loading simulation can be performed using the fractured implant model, optionally with altered anatomical models and / or loading conditions, which can be repeated multiple times to assess the effect of subsequent cyclic loading on failure.

[0019] Optionally, the risk of failure due to cyclic loading is determined by an SN curve, as known in the art. Optionally, the risk of failure due to cyclic loading is determined by a rainflow counting algorithm, as known in the art. Optionally, the risk of failure due to cyclic loading is determined by strain amplitude (e.g., for a Nitinol component).

[0020] Optionally, the method includes providing a 4D patient-specific anatomical model or associated nodes thereof based on one or more of: a) segmentation of a 4D pre-operative image; b) a plurality of landmarks in a plurality of 4D pre-operative images; c) a 3D or 4D pre-operative image in combination with patient-specific blood volume, flow and blood pressure measurements taken before and / or after placement of the implant; d) a 3D or 4D pre-operative image in combination with non-patient-specific insight into cardiac pathophysiology such as expected motion; or e) a 3D or 4D pre-operative image in combination with non-patient-specific insight into chronic cardiac remodeling such as tissue overgrowth limiting implant motion occurring weeks or months after treatment.

[0021] According to one aspect, the method includes receiving at least pseudo three-dimensional 3D medical images representing a patient-specific cardiac region in multiple states corresponding to multiple instants of a cardiac cycle and constructing a 4D patient-specific anatomical model thereon, such that the 4D patient-specific anatomical model can be efficiently constructed from the available medical images.

[0022] Optionally, the method includes constructing a patient-specific 3D mesh-based representation of the cardiac region based on one of the medical images, determining changes from one medical image to the next, and applying the changes to the constructed 3D mesh-based representation to provide a 4D patient-specific anatomical model. The 3D mesh-based representation represents a 3D patient-specific anatomical model of the cardiac region. Thus, only a single 3D mesh-based representation needs to be constructed, and the change of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model (or the 4D patient-specific intermediate model) continuously through the multiple states is obtained from changing the medical image to the multiple states (e.g., using an elastic registration algorithm). It will be appreciated that the change of the medical image through the multiple states can utilize a 4D vector field.

[0023] Optionally, the method includes, for each of the medical images constructing a patient-specific 3D mesh-based representation of the cardiac region, determining changes from one 3D mesh-based representation to a next, and determining a 4D patient-specific anatomical model based on the multiple 3D mesh-based representations (e.g., first determining a 4D patient-specific intermediate model based on the multiple 3D mesh-based representations). It will be appreciated that changes in the mesh through multiple states may only have 4D vectors available at the nodes of the mesh.

[0024] Optionally, the method includes placing the implant model at a number of different locations within the 4D patient-specific anatomical model, determining the risk of failure due to cyclic loading for each location, and selecting the location associated with the lowest risk for actual implantation. Thus, an optimal location for the implant device can be determined with respect to minimizing the risk of failure due to cyclic loading.

[0025] Optionally, the method includes providing a plurality of different implant models, each of which represents a geometric characteristic (including, for example, a size of the same implant device) and / or a material characteristic of a corresponding actual implant device, determining a risk of failure due to repeated loading of the cardiac implant for each of the implant models, and selecting for actual implantation the implant device associated with the implant model calculated to have the lowest risk. Thus, an optimal implant device may be selected in terms of minimizing the risk of failure due to repeated loading. It will be appreciated that a plurality of different installation positions may be utilized for each of the plurality of different implant models.

[0026] According to one aspect, a method is provided for designing reference loading conditions for experimental fatigue testing (accelerated wear testing, or fatigue testing machine). A benchmark is designed and the loading conditions for the experimental fatigue testing are adjusted using the highest risk of failure due to repeated loading. From the patient-specific deformation or stress or strain of the implant device, the highest risk of failure due to repeated loading can be reproduced in a simplified benchmark that runs accelerated cycles, and by running cycles at a higher frequency, the fatigue safety of the implant device can be tested in a time shorter than the in vivo time.

[0027] According to one aspect, a system for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of a cardiac implant is provided. The system includes a processor. The processor receives an implant model representing a three-dimensional, mesh-based representation of the cardiac implant. The processor receives a four-dimensional, 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific heart region including placement positions of the cardiac implant at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments of a cardiac cycle. The processor calculates deformation of the implant model placed at a placement position as or before the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed across the plurality of states. The processor determines a risk of cyclic loading failure of the cardiac implant based on the calculated deformation.

[0028] According to one aspect of the invention, there is provided a computer program product comprising computer executable instructions which, when executed by a programmable computer, cause the computer to obtain an implant model that is a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of a cardiac implant; obtain a 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing the mesh-based representation of a patient-specific heart region including an installation site of the cardiac implant at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in a cardiac cycle; calculate deformation of the implant model installed at the installation site as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model deforms continuously across the plurality of states; and determine a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated deformation.

[0029] It will be understood that all features and options mentioned in terms of the method apply equally to the system and computer program product, and it will also be apparent that any one or more of the above aspects, features and options may be combined. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0030] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings.

[0031] [Figure 1] 1 is a schematic diagram of a system according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of a method according to an embodiment. [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of a method according to an embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of a method according to an embodiment. [Diagram 5] 5A-5D are exemplary diagrams of a model according to an embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0032] 1 is a schematic diagram of an exemplary system 1 for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of an implanted device 2. In this example, the implanted device 2 is a cardiac implant, such as a stent or replacement valve.

[0033] The system 1 comprises a first receiving unit 4 arranged to receive an implant model 6. The first receiving unit 4 can receive the implant model 6 from a first source 8, such as a memory, a database, a network, such as the Internet, etc. The implant model 6 represents a three-dimensional, 3D mesh-based representation of the implant device 2. The system 1 comprises a second receiving unit 10 arranged to receive a four-dimensional, 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12. The second receiving unit 10 can receive the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 from a second source 14, such as a memory, a database, a network, such as the Internet, a medical imaging device, such as a CT device, an MRI device, an ultrasound device, etc. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model represents a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific anatomical region, including the placement position of the implant device, in a number of states corresponding to a number of instants of a working cycle. The states represent successive instants during the working cycle. Thus, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model can be considered here as a 3D patient-specific anatomical model represented in a number of discrete states, plus a fourth dimension, time. Thus, the 3D patient-specific anatomical model 10 transforms from one state to the next. In this example, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 represents a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region, including the placement positions of the cardiac implants, in a number of states corresponding to a number of moments of the cardiac cycle. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 includes at least two states, e.g., a first state associated with systole and a second state associated with diastole. Preferably, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 10 includes more states in the cycle, e.g., 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 16, 20, 24, 32, 64 or 128 states. However, other numbers of states in the cycle are also possible.

[0034] The system 1 includes a processor 16. The processor is provided for virtually placing the implant model 6 at a placement position. The processor 16 is provided for calculating deformations of the placed implant model 6 while the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is successively deformed into a plurality of states. The processor 16 is also provided for determining a risk of failure due to repeated loading of the implant device 2 based on the calculated deformations. The system 1 of this embodiment further includes a reporting unit 20. The reporting unit 20 is provided for making a user aware of the processing results, such as the estimated risk. The reporting unit 20 can be connected to a visualization device 22, for example, a monitor or a printer. Alternatively or additionally, the reporting unit can be connected to a communication network, such as the Internet. The reporting unit 20 can be provided for generating a numerical report and / or a report including an image.

[0035] As shown in Fig. 2, in a method for patient-specific prediction of failure due to repeated loading of a cardiac implant 2, the system 1 can be used as follows: In step 200, an implant model 6 is obtained from a first source 8. In step 202, a 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is obtained from a second source 14. In step 204, the processor 16 virtually places the implant model 6 at a placement position of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12. In this example, the implant model 6 is virtually placed in the 4D patient-specific anatomical model while the 4D anatomical model 12 is stationary. Alternatively, the implant model 6 can be virtually placed in the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 while the 4D anatomical model 12 is continuously deforming through multiple stages, i.e. while the heart is beating.

[0036] In step 206, the processor 16 calculates the deformation of the implant model 6 placed in the placement position as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is deformed successively through the multiple states. In addition, the processor 16 can calculate, for example, the shape and optionally the position of the implant model 6 placed in the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 for each of the multiple states. The deformation of the implant model 6 follows the shape of the implant model 6 in each state.

[0037] To determine the deformation of the implant model 6 in each state, one can start from the deformation of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12. When changing from one state to the next, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 contains information representing the displacement of each node of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12. The displacement of each node of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is used to determine the displacement of each node of the implant model 6. This can be done for each state.

[0038] In a first example, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 represents a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region in a number of states corresponding to a number of moments of the heart cycle before the placement of the implant device. The nodes of the 4D anatomical model 12 are thus deformed into a number of states following a displacement of the patient-specific heart region in the absence of the implant device. Here, a deformation of the patient-specific anatomical model 12 representing the patient-specific heart region is imposed on the implant model 6 by contact between the anatomical model 12 and the implant model 6. The displacement of each node of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is applied to all or a part of the nodes of the implant model 6 depending on the mechanical contact between the two models 6, 12. In this way, the deformation of the implant model 6 is determined, here for each of a number of states, in this example using a finite element analysis (FEA). Thus, deformation of the patient-specific heart region as a result of the presence of the implant device is not taken into account. This has been found to provide a good approximation in the case of relatively flexible implant devices.

[0039] In a second example, a 4D intermediate patient-specific anatomical model is provided having associated nodes associated with nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model. The 4D intermediate patient-specific anatomical model represents a mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region in multiple states corresponding to multiple moments of the cardiac cycle before installation. The associated nodes of the 4D intermediate patient-specific anatomical model 12 are thus deformed to multiple states following displacements of the patient-specific heart region in the absence of the implant device. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is deformed to multiple states by transferring the displacements of the associated nodes of the 4D intermediate model to the nodes of the patient-specific anatomical model 12 by means of rigid elements (e.g., spring-dashpot systems) attached to some or all of the nodes of the mesh of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model can thus move (elastically) relative to the associated nodes of the 4D intermediate patient-specific anatomical model. The deformation of the implant model 6 is achieved by contact between the 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 and the implant model 6. Thus, the deformation of the implant model 6 is now determined for each of a number of states, in this example using finite element analysis (FEA), thus taking into account the patient-specific deformation of the heart region as a result of the presence of the implant device, which has been found to provide a good approximation for a relatively stiff implant device.

[0040] In step 208 , the processor 16 determines the risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated displacements (deformations and / or movements) of the implant model 6 .

[0041] In one example, the processor 16 determines the mechanical stress and / or strain in each mesh element of the implant model 6. The processor 16 may, for example, determine the mechanical stress and / or strain in each mesh element of the implant model 6 for each of a plurality of states over the course of a cardiac cycle. The mechanical stress and / or strain in the mesh elements of the implant model 6 is representative of cyclic loading fatigue. The mechanical stress and / or strain in the mesh elements of the implant model and its variation during the full cycle is representative of cyclic loading fatigue. The risk of failure due to cyclic loading may be determined, for example, using a rainflow counting algorithm, as known in the art.

[0042] In one example, the processor 16 determines, for each mesh element of the implant model 6, the amplitude of mechanical stress and / or strain occurring during the course of a cardiac cycle. For each mesh element, a maximum value of the stress and / or strain among a plurality of states may be determined. For each mesh element, a minimum value of the stress and / or strain among a plurality of states may be determined. The amplitude of each mesh element may be determined as the difference between the respective maximum and minimum values. The determined amplitude is representative of the risk of failure due to cyclic loading. The risk of failure due to cyclic loading may be determined, for example, by an SN curve, as known in the art.

[0043] In step 202, a 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 is obtained from a second source 14. The 4D patient-specific anatomical model can be constructed, for example, as follows. The construction of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model can be performed by a construction unit 18 using a method as shown in FIG. 3 or FIG. 4. The construction unit 18 can be integrated in the processor 16, can be a dedicated unit of the system 1, or can be a system independent of the system 1. In steps 300, 400, the construction unit 18 receives a plurality of, at least pseudo, 3D medical images. Each 3D medical image represents the patient-specific heart region in one of a succession of states corresponding to a plurality of instants of the heart cycle. Also, the plurality of 3D medical images represents the patient-specific heart region in all of the plurality of states. The construction unit constructs the 4D patient-specific anatomical model based on the plurality of 3D medical images.

[0044] In a first example, the construction unit 18 in step 302 captures a first image of the 3D medical images and constructs a first 3D mesh-based representation of the patient-specific heart region based on the medical image. Furthermore, in step 304, the construction unit determines for each of the medical images a transformation from one medical image to the next medical image, such as a B-spline transformation. Thus, a plurality of transformations is obtained, each suitable for transforming one of the medical images into the next medical image (a first transformation for transforming the first medical image into a second medical image, a second transformation for transforming the second medical image into a third medical image, etc.). In step 306, the first transformation is applied to the first 3D mesh-based representation to obtain a second 3D mesh-based representation, and the second transformation is applied to the second 3D mesh-based representation to obtain a third 3D mesh-based representation. Thus, a plurality of 3D mesh-based representations is obtained, one representation associated with each state of the heart cycle. In step 308, the multiple 3D mesh-based representations are combined to form a 4D patient-specific anatomical model.

[0045] In the second example, in step 402, the construction unit 18 takes each 3D medical image and constructs a 3D mesh-based representation of each 3D medical image. Furthermore, in step 404, the construction unit 18 determines, for each 3D mesh-based representation, a change from one representation to the next. Thus, a plurality of changes is obtained, each suitable for changing one of the 3D mesh-based representations to the next 3D mesh-based representation (a first change for changing the first 3D mesh-based representation to the second 3D mesh-based representation, a second change for changing the second 3D mesh-based representation to the third 3D mesh-based representation, etc.). Thus, a plurality of 3D mesh-based representations is obtained, one representation associated with each state of the cardiac cycle. In step 408, the plurality of 3D mesh-based representations and their changes are combined to form a 4D patient-specific anatomical model.

[0046] 5A-5D show a typical example of an implant model 6, here representing a replacement heart valve, placed in a 4D patient-specific anatomical model 12 in four successive states during the cardiac cycle. The deformation of the implant model 6 can be easily observed. The strain of the implant device 6 is shown in pseudocolor in FIGS. 5A-5D (grayscale represents the maximum principal logarithmic strain (MPLE) of the implant model 6, white indicates MPLE≦0.01%, black indicates MPLE≧0.1%).

[0047] It will be understood that a plurality of different implant models 6 can be provided. Each implant model 6 can represent the geometric and / or material characteristics of a corresponding real implant. The implant models 6 can differ, for example, in size, brand, structure, material, etc. Each implant model can then be placed in the patient-specific anatomical model 12. A risk of failure due to repeated loading is then determined for each implant model 6. From this analysis, it can be determined which implant model among the plurality of implant models has the lowest risk of failure due to repeated loading. The heart valve implant corresponding to the implant model 6 having the lowest risk of failure due to repeated loading can then be selected for the actual percutaneous implantation procedure. It will be understood that each implant model 6 can also be placed in the patient-specific anatomical model 12 in a plurality of different positions. Thus, for each implant model, a position at which there is a risk of failure due to repeated loading can be determined. The lowest risk of failure due to repeated loading for each implant model 6 can then be compared to select the heart valve implant for the actual percutaneous implantation procedure.

[0048] It will also be understood that each implant model 6 can be placed in multiple different positions on the patient-specific anatomical model 12 and the respective images can be analyzed. In this way, it is possible to determine which of the different positions has the lowest risk of failure due to repeated loading for each implant model. It is also possible to determine which of the different positions has the highest risk of failure due to repeated loading for each implant model. The highest and lowest risks of failure due to repeated loading for each implant model 6 can then be compared to select a heart valve implant for actual percutaneous implantation. Alternatively, the highest risk of failure due to repeated loading can be used to design a benchmark and adjust the reference load conditions for experimental fatigue testing (accelerated wear test (AWT) in a fatigue tester). From the deformation or stress or strain of the patient-specific device, the conditions with the highest risk of failure due to repeated loading can be reproduced in a simplified benchmark that performs accelerated cycles, and by performing cycles at a higher frequency, the fatigue safety of the device can be tested for a shorter period than in vivo.

[0049] The present invention will now be described with reference to illustrative embodiments of the invention. However, it will be apparent that various modifications and changes may be made thereto without departing from the essential elements of the invention. Although features are described herein as part of the same or separate embodiments for clarity and concise description, alternative embodiments combining all or some of the features described in these separate embodiments are also envisioned.

[0050] Generally, a method for predicting cyclic loading failure of an implant device in a patient-specific manner is provided. The method includes providing an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of the implant device. The method also includes providing a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific anatomical region including a placement location for the implant device at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments of a motion cycle, such as a cardiac cycle. The method allows a computer to calculate deformation of the implant model placed at the placement location as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states, and to determine a risk of cyclic loading failure of the implant device based on the calculated deformation. This provides the advantage of predicting cyclic loading failure of the implant device prior to placement of the implant device based on the patient-specific anatomy. It will be appreciated that representative motion cycles can be defined even when the motion is not strictly cyclic.

[0051] It will be appreciated that the method can also be used after implantation of a device, for example by starting from pre-operative medical images and incorporating measurements made after implantation.

[0052] The processor, the first receiving unit, the second receiving unit, the constructing unit, and / or the reporting unit may be embodied as dedicated electronic circuits, possibly including software code portions, or as software code portions executed on and stored in a memory of a programmable device, such as a computer, tablet, or smartphone.

[0053] Although the embodiments of the invention described with reference to the drawings comprise a computing apparatus and steps executed on the computing apparatus, the invention also extends to a computer program arranged to put the invention into practice, in particular a computer program on or in a carrier. The program may be in source, object code or any other form suitable for use in the execution of the steps according to the invention. The carrier may be any entity or device capable of carrying the program.

[0054] For example, the carrier may include a storage medium, such as a ROM, e.g. a CD-ROM, a semiconductor ROM, or a magnetically readable medium, e.g. a floppy disk, a hard disk, etc. Further, the carrier may be a transmissible carrier, such as an electrical or optical signal, which may be conveyed via an electrical or optical cable, or by radio or other means, e.g., via the internet or the cloud.

[0055] When the program is embodied in a signal conveyed directly by a cable or other device or means, the carrier may comprise the cable or other device or means, or alternatively, the carrier may be an integrated circuit in which the program is embedded, the integrated circuit being adapted to perform, or for use in the performance of, the relevant steps.

[0056] However, other modifications, variations, and alternatives are possible. Accordingly, the specification, drawings, and examples are to be regarded in an illustrative rather than a restrictive sense.

[0057] Although features are described herein as part of the same or separate embodiments for clarity and conciseness of description, it will be understood that the scope of the invention may include embodiments having all or some combination of the described features.

[0058] Any reference signs placed between parentheses in the claims shall not be interpreted as limiting the claims. The word "comprising" does not exclude the presence of other features or steps than those listed in the claim. Moreover, the words "a" or "an" shall not be interpreted as being restricted to "one" but are instead used to mean "at least one" and do not exclude a plurality. The mere fact that certain measures are recited in mutually different claims does not indicate that a combination of these measures cannot be used to advantage.

[0059] (Additional Note) (Appendix 1) 1. A method for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of a cardiac implant, comprising: providing an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of a cardiac implant; providing a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of the cardiac implants at multiple states corresponding to multiple moments of the cardiac cycle; causing a computer to calculate deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position while the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; causing the computer to determine a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; The method includes:

[0060] (Appendix 2) causing the computer to determine a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on data representative of the calculated implant deformation and deformation history; 2. The method of claim 1, comprising:

[0061] (Appendix 3) the 4D patient-specific anatomical model represents a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region in a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in the cardiac cycle prior to placement; The method described in Appendix 1.

[0062] (Appendix 4) providing a 4D patient-specific intermediate model having associated nodes associated with nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model, the 4D patient-specific intermediate model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region in a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of instants of the cardiac cycle prior to placement, the patient-specific anatomical model morphing to the plurality of states by communicating displacements of associated nodes of the 4D intermediate model to the nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model via stiffness and / or dashpot elements. 3. The method according to claim 1 or 2.

[0063] (Appendix 5) the 4D patient-specific anatomical model has mechanical properties including stiffness and / or viscosity, and the overall mechanical behavior of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model depends on a combination of the mechanical properties of the 4D anatomical model and the mechanical properties of stiffness and / or dashpot elements connecting relevant nodes to nodes of the 4D anatomical model; The method described in Appendix 4.

[0064] (Appendix 6) determining mechanical stress and / or strain within each mesh element of said implant model; 6. The method of any one of claims 1 to 5, comprising:

[0065] (Appendix 7) determining mechanical stresses and / or strains within each mesh element of the implant model for each of the plurality of states during the cardiac cycle; 7. The method of claim 6, comprising:

[0066] (Appendix 8) determining, for each mesh element of the implant model, the magnitude of mechanical stresses and / or strains experienced during the course of the cardiac cycle and determining a risk of failure due to cyclic loading based on the determined magnitudes; 8. The method of claim 7, comprising:

[0067] (Appendix 9) The cardiac implant is a valve implant, a stent, etc. 9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8.

[0068] (Appendix 10) The failure due to cyclic loading includes one or more of high cycle fatigue failure, implant migration, and valve failure; 10. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 9.

[0069] (Appendix 11) Segmentation of one 4D preoperative image and A plurality of landmarks in a plurality of 4D preoperative images; one 3D or one 4D pre-operative image combined with patient-specific blood volume, blood flow and blood pressure measurements taken before and / or after placement of said implant; One 3D or one 4D preoperative image combined with non-patient specific findings on cardiac pathophysiology such as expected motion, One 3D or one 4D preoperative image combined with non-patient-specific findings on cardiac remodeling in the chronic phase and providing said 4D patient-specific anatomical model or associated nodes thereof based on one or more of: 11. The method of any one of claims 1 to 10, comprising:

[0070] (Appendix 12) receiving a plurality of at least simulated 3D medical images representing a patient-specific cardiac region at said plurality of states corresponding to said plurality of instants of the cardiac cycle and constructing said 4D patient-specific anatomical model thereon; 12. The method of any one of claims 1 to 11, comprising:

[0071] (Appendix 13) constructing a 3D mesh-based representation of the patient-specific cardiac region based on one of the medical images; determining changes from one medical image to a next medical image; applying the transformations to the constructed 3D mesh-based representation to provide the 4D patient-specific anatomical model; 13. The method of claim 12, comprising:

[0072] (Appendix 14) For each of said medical images constructing a 3D mesh-based representation of said patient-specific cardiac region; determining a change from one 3D mesh-based representation to a next 3D mesh-based representation; determining the 4D patient-specific anatomical model based on the plurality of 3D mesh-based representations; 10. The method of claim 9, comprising:

[0073] (Appendix 15) placing an implant model at a plurality of different locations within said 4D patient-specific anatomical model, determining a risk of failure due to repeated loading for each of said locations, and selecting for actual implantation the location associated with the lowest risk; 15. The method of any one of claims 1 to 14, comprising:

[0074] (Appendix 16) providing a plurality of different implant models, each implant model representing geometric and / or material properties of a corresponding actual implant device, determining for each of the implant models a risk of failure of said cardiac implant due to cyclic loading, and selecting for actual implantation the implant device associated with the implant model calculated to have the lowest risk; 16. The method of any one of claims 1 to 15, comprising:

[0075] (Appendix 17) Designing benchmarks and adjusting reference load conditions for experimental fatigue testing using those with the highest risk of failure due to cyclic loading; 15. The method of any one of claims 1 to 14, comprising:

[0076] (Appendix 18) 1. A system for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of a cardiac implant, comprising: receiving an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of a cardiac implant; receiving a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of the cardiac implants at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in the cardiac cycle; calculating deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position as or before the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; determining a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; 23. A system including a processor configured to:

[0077] (Appendix 19) 1. A computer program product comprising computer-executable instructions, which when executed by a programmable computer, cause the computer to: obtaining an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of the cardiac implant; obtaining a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of the cardiac implants at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in the cardiac cycle; calculating deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; determining a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; Computer program products.

Claims

1. 1. A method for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of a cardiac implant, comprising: providing an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of a cardiac implant; providing a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of the cardiac implants at multiple states corresponding to multiple moments of a cardiac cycle; causing a computer to calculate deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position while the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; causing the computer to determine a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; Including, determining, for each mesh element of the implant model, the magnitude of mechanical stresses and / or strains experienced during the course of the cardiac cycle and determining a risk of failure due to cyclic loading based on the determined magnitudes; The method further comprises:

2. causing the computer to determine a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on data representative of the calculated implant deformation and deformation history; 2. The method of claim 1, comprising:

3. the 4D patient-specific anatomical model represents a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region in multiple states corresponding to multiple instants of the cardiac cycle prior to placement; The method of claim 1.

4. providing a 4D patient-specific intermediate model having associated nodes associated with nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model, the 4D patient-specific intermediate model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region in a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of instants of the cardiac cycle prior to placement, the 4D patient-specific anatomical model deforming to the plurality of states by communicating displacements of associated nodes of the 4D patient-specific intermediate model to the nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model via stiffness and / or dashpot elements. The method according to claim 1 or 2.

5. the 4D patient-specific anatomical model has mechanical properties including stiffness and / or viscosity, and the overall mechanical behavior of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model depends on a combination of the mechanical properties of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model and the mechanical properties of stiffness and / or dashpot elements connecting relevant nodes to nodes of the 4D patient-specific anatomical model. The method according to claim 4.

6. determining mechanical stress and / or strain within each mesh element of the implant model; The method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, comprising:

7. determining mechanical stresses and / or strains within each mesh element of the implant model for each of the plurality of states during the cardiac cycle; 7. The method of claim 6, comprising:

8. The cardiac implant is a valve implant or a stent.

8. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

9. The failure due to cyclic loading includes one or more of high cycle fatigue failure, implant migration, and valve failure.

9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8.

10. Segmentation of one 4D preoperative image; A plurality of landmarks in a plurality of 4D pre-operative images; one 3D or one 4D preoperative image combined with patient-specific blood volume, blood flow and blood pressure measurements taken before and / or after placement of said implant; One 3D or one 4D pre-operative image combined with non-patient specific knowledge of cardiac pathophysiology such as expected motion; one 3D or one 4D preoperative image combined with non-patient specific findings on cardiac remodeling in the chronic phase; providing said 4D patient-specific anatomical model or associated nodes thereof based on one or more of:

10. The method of any one of claims 1 to 9, comprising:

11. receiving a plurality of at least simulated 3D medical images representing a patient-specific cardiac region at said plurality of states corresponding to said plurality of instants of the cardiac cycle and constructing said 4D patient-specific anatomical model thereon; 11. The method of any one of claims 1 to 10, comprising:

12. constructing a 3D mesh-based representation of the patient-specific cardiac region based on one of the 3D medical images; determining changes from one medical image to a next medical image; applying the transformations to the constructed 3D mesh-based representation to provide the 4D patient-specific anatomical model; 12. The method of claim 11, comprising:

13. for each of said 3D medical images constructing a 3D mesh-based representation of said patient-specific cardiac region; determining changes from one 3D mesh-based representation to a next 3D mesh-based representation; determining the 4D patient-specific anatomical model based on the plurality of 3D mesh-based representations; 12. The method of claim 11, comprising:

14. placing an implant model at a plurality of different locations within said 4D patient-specific anatomical model, determining a risk of failure due to cyclic loading for each of said locations, and selecting for actual implantation the location associated with the lowest risk; 14. The method of any one of claims 1 to 13, comprising:

15. providing a plurality of different implant models, each implant model representing geometric and / or material properties of a corresponding actual implant device, determining for each of the implant models a risk of failure of said cardiac implant due to cyclic loading, and selecting for actual implantation the implant device associated with the implant model calculated to have the lowest risk; 15. The method of any one of claims 1 to 14, comprising:

16. Designing benchmarks and adjusting reference load conditions for experimental fatigue testing using those with the highest risk of failure due to cyclic loading; 14. The method of any one of claims 1 to 13, comprising:

17. 1. A system for patient-specific prediction of cyclic loading failure of a cardiac implant, comprising: receiving an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of a cardiac implant; receiving a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of the cardiac implants at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in a cardiac cycle; calculating deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position as or before the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; determining a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; a processor arranged to the processor is further configured to determine, for each mesh element of the implant model, a magnitude of mechanical stress and / or strain occurring during the course of the cardiac cycle and determine a risk of failure due to cyclic loading based on the determined magnitude. system.

18. A computer program comprising computer executable instructions, said instructions, when executed by a programmable computer, causing said computer to: obtaining an implant model representing a three-dimensional mesh-based representation of the cardiac implant; obtaining a four-dimensional 4D patient-specific anatomical model representing a mesh-based representation of a patient-specific cardiac region including placement locations of said cardiac implants at a plurality of states corresponding to a plurality of moments in a cardiac cycle; calculating deformations of the implant model installed at the installation position as the 4D patient-specific anatomical model is successively deformed through the plurality of states; determining a risk of failure of the cardiac implant due to cyclic loading based on the calculated implant deformation; The computer executable instructions further cause the computer to determine, for each mesh element of the implant model, a magnitude of mechanical stress and / or strain occurring over the course of the cardiac cycle and determine a risk of failure due to cyclic loading based on the determined magnitude. Computer program.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method and system for comprehensive patient-specific modeling of the heart

    JP2012024582A

  • Pre -operative simulation of trans - catheter valve implantation

    WO2013171039A1

  • Method and system for determining a risk of cardiac conduction abnormalities

    WO2016177647A1

  • Method and system for determining a risk of hemodynamic compromise after cardiac intervention

    WO2018141927A1