Testing Systems

The test system optimizes test item measurement orders to minimize conflicts between measuring instruments, reducing waiting times and enhancing efficiency by prioritizing tests that do not overlap with other control devices.

JP7586845B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19KOKUSAI DENKI ELECTRIC INC
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2022014038
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-02-01
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2042-02-01

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional test systems experience inefficiencies and prolonged waiting times due to competition between measuring instruments when multiple control devices perform tests in parallel, placing a heavy burden on workers and lacking effective methods to reduce such waiting times.

Method used

A test system where control devices store series of test items with provisional rankings, calculate effective times for each item, and determine measurement orders to minimize overlaps and conflicts, prioritizing tests that do not require waiting by using measuring devices already in use by other devices.

Benefits of technology

This approach reduces overall waiting time and improves test efficiency by ensuring tests that do not conflict with other control devices are performed first, thereby shortening the total test duration.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007586845000001
    Figure 0007586845000001
  • Figure 0007586845000002
    Figure 0007586845000002
  • Figure 0007586845000003
    Figure 0007586845000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a test system that can improve test efficiency by reducing a waiting time due to overlap of measuring instruments when multiple control devices perform tests in parallel.SOLUTION: A test system comprises a control device 1 that memorizes a series of test items performed in a test together with a preliminary test order, subtracts a measurement time of each test item from a total measurement time obtained by adding the measurement time of each test item, calculates an effective time for each test item by subtracting measurement times of other test items when a measuring instrument to be used for the test item is also to be used for the other test items, compares a test item for an own device and a series of test items inquired to other control devices, determines whether or not the measuring instrument to be used for the own device overlaps with the other control devices, and decides a measurement order following the preliminary order with regard to the test item that does not overlap, and decides the measurement order in ascending order of the effective time with regard to the test item that overlaps.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a test system in which multiple control devices use multiple measuring devices to test multiple devices under test, which reduces waiting time caused by contention among the measuring devices and enables efficient testing. [Background technology]

[0002] Description of the Prior Art A test system tests various devices (devices under test, equipment under test) installed in an aircraft to check whether they are operating normally. Conventionally, a test system has multiple control devices and tests multiple equipment under test in parallel. In addition, a number of general-purpose measuring instruments are used in testing the EUT, with different measuring instruments being used for each detailed test item.

[0003] When multiple control devices (control device A, control device B) perform tests in parallel using the same measuring device, if, for example, control device A is using the measuring device, control device B determines that it cannot be used due to a conflict and stops the test until control device A's test is completed, and then resumes the test after control device A's test is completed.

[0004] In reality, when the measuring device used by control device B conflicted with that used by control device A, the operator of control device B would temporarily stop the test, first conduct a test that did not use the same measuring device, and then resume the test after the test by control device A was completed. This placed a burden on the operators even though multiple control devices were being operated, and was time-inefficient.

[0005] Furthermore, in the past, there was a test system in which each control device shared information on the usage status of a general-purpose measuring instrument and stored information on the measuring instrument to be used for each test item, thereby enabling the general-purpose measuring instruments to be used more efficiently to perform tests in parallel (Patent Document 1).

[0006] Patent Document 1 describes a method in which multiple control devices are used to test multiple test devices simultaneously, with each control device having a detailed test item data table that stores the measuring devices to be used in each detailed test (test item), and a measuring device data table that stores the used / unused status (released status) of each measuring device, with a flag set for measuring devices in use to ensure exclusive use, and in the event of a conflict between measuring devices, the detailed test is put on hold and another detailed test is performed.

[0007] [Measurement Instrument Data Table: Figure 9] An example of the measuring instrument data table will now be described with reference to Fig. 9. Fig. 9 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the measuring instrument data table. As shown in FIG. 9, the measuring device data table stores which measuring device is used for each control device. In the example of Figure 9, three control devices, control device A, control device B, and control device C, are registered as control devices, and a power meter, phase detector, spectrum analyzer, standard signal generator, low-frequency analyzer, etc. are stored as measuring devices that can be commonly used by these control devices.

[0008] In the meter data table, for each control device, a meter in use is set to "1," and a meter not in use (before use or released after use) is set to "0." A meter not in use is referred to as "unused" here.

[0009] When the control device uses a measuring device, it reserves the device by setting it to "1." When it is no longer in use and the device is no longer in use, it sets it to "0" and releases the measuring device. In the example of FIG. 9, control device A is using a power meter and control device B is using a standard signal generator. Additionally, since control device C has not performed any measurements, all of the values ​​are "0."

[0010] The information in the measuring device data table is shared (shared (stored) common information) by all control devices in the system. That is, when each control device starts using a meter, it sets "1" in its own meter data table and notifies all other control devices of information indicating that the meter is "in use." When it finishes using the meter, it sets "0" in the meter data table and notifies the other control devices of information indicating that the meter is "released." Then, when each control device receives information on the use / release of a measuring device from another control device, it updates the measuring device data table stored in the own device based on that information.

[0011] [Previous detailed test item data table: Figure 10] Next, a conventional detailed test item data table will be described with reference to Fig. 10. Fig. 10 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a conventional detailed test item data table. As shown in FIG. 10, a conventional detailed test item data table stores, for each detailed test item (sometimes written as test item or item), the measuring device used for that detailed test item and the measurement time required for the test.

[0012] For example, a test item for transmission output uses a power meter and the measurement time is 30 seconds. The phase detector is also used in the test items for the transmit frequency accuracy and the side tone output, and it is stored that the transmit frequency accuracy test requires 30 seconds and the side tone output test requires 60 seconds. In other words, the test items for the transmit frequency accuracy and the sidetone output cannot be performed at the same time. The information in the detailed test item data table is shared by all control devices.

[0013] [Conventional test method] A test method in a conventional test system having a measuring device data table and a detailed test item data table will be briefly described. For example, when control devices A and B are conducting tests in parallel, control device A, which starts the test first, refers to the detailed test item data table, extracts (identifies) the measuring instruments to be used for the test items to be conducted, checks the usage status for each item in the measuring instrument data table, and if the measuring instrument in question is not being used, sets "1" to ensure exclusive use of the measuring instrument. When one test item is completed, the completed measuring device is set to "0" and the usage status is checked for the next test item.

[0014] Similarly, when control device B starts a test, it refers to the detailed test item data table to extract the measuring instruments to be used for the test items to be performed, and checks the usage status of the measuring instruments for each item in the measuring instrument data table. If the usage status of the measuring device to be used is set to "1" and the device is already in use, that test item will be put on hold, and if there is a test item that does not use the measuring device in use (a test item that uses a measuring device with its usage status set to "0"), that test item will be carried out first.

[0015] If there are no test items that do not use the measuring instrument that is currently in use, the test is stopped, the test items of the measuring instrument that is being used in competition with another control device (here, control device A) are terminated, and the system waits for the test to finish until the usage status in the measuring instrument data table is set to "0." When waiting for the test to finish, control device B monitors the measuring device data table to periodically check the usage status, and when the test of control device 1 finishes and "0" is set, it performs the test of control device 2.

[0016] However, in the method of Patent Document 1, even if a competing detailed test is put on hold and another detailed test is performed, later on, only the detailed test using the same measuring device remains, and ultimately a waiting period for the measuring device occurs.

[0017] Furthermore, in the past, there was a test system that enabled parallel testing by using a measuring instrument with the same function used in another block when a measurement instrument conflict occurred (Patent Document 2). In the test system of Patent Document 2, a batch file of test combinations that prevents measurement instrument conflicts is created before the start of testing, realizing parallel testing.

[0018] However, since not all measuring instruments with the same function are available within the test system, waiting will occur if a measuring instrument with the same function is not available. Also, with batch files, if a different test is performed later during a test, the measuring instrument will not be able to respond and will wait.

[0019] [Related Technology] Conventional technologies relating to test systems include those disclosed in Japanese Patent Laid-Open No. 2007-292723 "Automatic Test System" (Patent Document 1) and Japanese Patent Laid-Open No. 2011-169606 "Test System" (Patent Document 2). Patent Document 1 describes a test system in which each control device shares and stores information about the usage status of measuring instruments and information about the measuring instruments used for each test item, thereby enabling efficient parallel testing. Furthermore, Patent Document 2 describes that when a contention occurs between measuring instruments, a measuring instrument with the same function used in another block can be used to enable parallel testing. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0020] [Patent Document 1] JP 2007-292723 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2011-169606 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0021] As described above, in conventional test systems, when tests were performed in parallel using multiple control devices, the waiting time for testing could be long because other control devices were using measuring instruments, resulting in poor efficiency and a heavy burden on workers.

[0022] Furthermore, Patent Documents 1 and 2 do not mention that each control device performs a measurement order determination process to appropriately change the measurement order of test items before measuring the test items using a measuring device, thereby reducing waiting time due to competition for measuring devices with other control devices.

[0023] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above-mentioned situation, and has an object to provide a test system that can improve the efficiency of testing by shortening the waiting time caused by contention of measuring instruments when testing is performed in parallel using multiple control devices. [Means for solving the problem]

[0024] In order to solve the problems of the conventional example described above, the present invention provides a test system having a plurality of control devices connected thereto that controls tests in which a series of test items are measured on a plurality of devices under test using a plurality of measuring devices according to a measurement order, wherein a specific control device is a local device that stores a series of test items with provisional orders assigned thereto, and the control device inquires of the other control devices about the series of test items in the other control devices, calculates a total measurement time by adding up all the measurement times for each test item in the series of test items in the local device, subtracts the measurement time from the total measurement time for each test item, and if the measuring device used in the test item is also used in other test items, also subtracts the measurement time for the other test items to calculate an effective time for each test item, compares the series of test items in the local device with the series of test items in the other control devices, and if the measuring device used in the test items in the local device does not overlap with the measuring device used in the test items in the other control devices, determines the measurement order of the series of test items according to the provisional orders, and if the measuring device used in the test items in the local device overlaps with the measuring device used in the test items in the other control devices, determines the measurement order of the series of test items in ascending order of effective time.

[0025] Furthermore, the present invention is characterized in that in the above-mentioned test system, when a particular control device has a mixture of test items in which the measuring instruments used in a series of test items in its own device do not overlap with the measuring instruments used in test items in other control devices, and test items in which the measuring instruments overlap with the measuring instruments used in test items in other control devices, the control device determines the ranking of the test items in which the measuring instruments do not overlap as higher.

[0026] Furthermore, the present invention is characterized in that in the above-mentioned test system, a specific control device calculates a measurement ranking determination time for each test item by subtracting the measurement time of that test item from the effective time, and changes the measurement ranking of the series of test items in ascending order of measurement ranking determination time.

[0027] Furthermore, the present invention is characterized in that in the above-mentioned test system, a specific control device inquires about the usage status of a measuring device used by other control devices before starting measurement of a test item, and if the measuring device is unused, causes measurement of the test item to be performed.

[0028] Furthermore, the present invention is characterized in that in the above test system, the specific control device determines the measurement order of the test items at the start of testing the series of test items.

[0029] Furthermore, the present invention is characterized in that in the above-mentioned test system, a specific control device obtains the completion status of a series of test items from other control devices, and test items for which measurement has been completed in other control devices are excluded from comparison with the series of test items in the own device. Effect of the Invention

[0030] According to the present invention, there is provided a test system connected to a plurality of control devices which controls a test in which a series of test items are measured for a plurality of devices under test according to a measurement order using a plurality of measuring devices, and a specific control device is a device itself which stores a series of test items with provisional orders assigned thereto, and which queries other control devices about the series of test items in the other control devices, calculates a total measurement time by adding up all the measurement times for each of the test items in the series of test items in the device itself, subtracts the measurement time from the total measurement time for each test item, and further, when a measuring device used in the test item is also used in other test items, subtracts the measurement time for the other test items as well to calculate an effective time for each test item, and This test system compares a test item with a series of test items in other control devices, and if the measuring instrument used for the test items in its own device does not overlap with the measuring instrument used for the test items in the other control devices, it determines the measurement order of the series of test items according to the provisional ranking.If the measuring instrument used for the test items in its own device overlaps with the measuring instrument used for the test items in the other control devices, it determines the measurement order of the series of test items in order of shortest effective time.Therefore, if a measuring instrument overlaps with another control device, the test items that have the longest measuring instrument usage time and are most likely to conflict with the other control devices are performed in order, which has the effect of shortening the overall waiting time and improving the efficiency of the test.

[0031] Furthermore, according to the present invention, when a particular control device has a series of test items in which the measuring instruments used in the device itself are a mixture of test items that do not overlap with measuring instruments used in test items in other control devices and test items that overlap with measuring instruments used in test items in other control devices, the test system determines the ranking of the test items in which the measuring instruments do not overlap as higher, so there is no risk of conflict with other control devices, and test items that do not incur waiting times can be performed first, thereby shortening the overall test time.

[0032] Furthermore, according to the present invention, a specific control device is configured as the test system in which, for each test item, a measurement ranking determination time is calculated by subtracting the measurement time of that test item from the effective time, and the measurement ranking of a series of test items is changed in ascending order of measurement ranking determination time, thereby having the effect of easily determining the measurement ranking even when there are test items with the same effective time.

[0033] Furthermore, according to the present invention, a specific control device is a test system that determines the measurement order of a series of test items at the start of testing the test items, so that an appropriate measurement order can be determined before the measurements are performed, thereby improving the efficiency of the test. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0034] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram showing the configuration of the present test system. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a configuration block diagram of a control device 1. [Diagram 3] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of a detailed other device test item table. [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a self-device detailed test item table. [Diagram 5] 13 is a flowchart showing a detailed test item table generating process; [Figure 6] 13 is a flowchart showing details of a measurement order determination process. [Figure 7] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing a comparison of test times when two control devices perform tests in parallel. [Figure 8] 13 is a flowchart showing a test implementation process. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a measuring device data table. [Figure 10] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a conventional detailed test item data table. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0035] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS An embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. [Outline of the embodiment] A test system according to an embodiment of the present invention (this test system) has multiple control devices testing devices under test in parallel, and before each control device measures a test item using a measuring instrument, it appropriately changes the measurement order of the test items, thereby reducing waiting time caused by measuring instrument contention with other control devices and improving test efficiency.

[0036] Specifically, in this testing system, the control device stores a series of test items with a provisional ranking set, and compares the test items of its own device with a series of test items in other control devices to determine whether the measuring instrument used in its own device is also used in other control devices (whether there is an overlap).For test items that are not used, the measurement order of the test items is determined according to the provisional ranking.For test items that are used, an effective time reflecting the number of test items for which the measuring instrument is used and the length of time it is used is calculated for each test item, and the measurement order of the test items is determined in order of the shortest effective time.By first performing test items for which a measuring instrument is not used in other control devices without waiting time, and then determining the measurement order so that test items using a measuring instrument that is likely to compete with other control devices are performed early, even when the same measuring instrument as other control devices is used, the overall waiting time can be shortened and testing can be performed efficiently.

[0037] More specifically, in this testing system, the control device subtracts the measurement time for each test item from the total measurement time, which is the sum of the measurement time for each test item, for a series of test items in the device itself, and if the measuring device used for that test item is also used for other test items, the measurement times for those other test items are also subtracted to calculate the effective time for each test item.By determining the testing order of the test items in order of shortest effective time, overall waiting time can be shortened and testing can be performed efficiently.

[0038] [Test system configuration: Figure 1] The configuration of this test system will be described with reference to Fig. 1. Fig. 1 is an explanatory diagram showing the configuration of this test system. As shown in FIG. 1, the test system includes a plurality of control devices 1 (control device A (1a), control device B (1b), control device C (1c)...), a group of general-purpose measuring instruments 2, a group of dedicated testing instruments 3, a connection box 4, and a LAN (Local Area Network) 5, and the plurality of control devices 1 are connected to the group of general-purpose measuring instruments 2, the group of dedicated testing instruments 3, and the connection box 5 via the LAN 5.

[0039] The general-purpose measuring instrument group 2 includes general-purpose measuring instruments such as a standard signal generator and a phase detector. The dedicated tester group 3 includes dedicated testers such as dedicated tester AAA and dedicated tester BBB. The connection box 4 is a connection section that connects a plurality of devices under test (devices under test) 6 (device under test 6-1, device under test 6-2, device under test 6-3, . . . ) to the LAN 5.

[0040] The control device 1 controls general-purpose measuring instruments and dedicated test instruments to carry out tests on a plurality of test devices 6 connected to a connection box 4, and acquires, stores, and displays the results. In this test system, multiple control devices 1 perform tests in parallel. At that time, as a feature of this test system, the control device 1 performs a process of determining the measurement order so as to optimize the order in which tests are performed for multiple test items (measurement order). The configuration and operation of the control device 1 will be described later.

[0041] [Configuration of control device 1: Figure 2] Next, the configuration of the control device 1 will be described with reference to Fig. 2. Fig. 2 is a block diagram of the configuration of the control device 1. As shown in FIG. 2, the control device 1 is composed of a personal computer (PC) or the like, and has a control unit 11, a memory unit 12, an operation unit 13, a display unit 14, and a communication interface unit (communication I / F) 15.

[0042] The control unit 11 is a processing unit that executes various processes associated with the testing of the EUT 6. In the control device 1 of this test system, a test item determination process, a detailed test determination process, a measurement order determination process, a measuring device determination process, a result acquisition process, a measuring device process, and the like are executed. Among these, the measurement order determination process is a feature of this test system, and will be described in detail later.

[0043] The operation unit 13 is an input unit through which the person in charge performs operations. The display unit 14 displays the test results and the like. The communication interface 15 connects each measuring instrument in the general-purpose measuring instrument group 2 and the dedicated test instrument group 3 to the control unit 11 via the LAN 5 . The storage unit 12 includes, in addition to the processing programs executed by the control unit 11, a self device detailed test item table 16, a other device detailed test item table 17, and a measuring device data table . The processing program is executed by the control unit 11 to realize the functions described below.

[0044] The own device detailed test item table 16 is a characteristic part of this test system, and stores information used for determining the measurement order in addition to the conventional detailed test item table shown in Fig. 10. The detailed test item data table 16 will be described later.

[0045] In addition to its own device detailed test item table 16, the control device 1 of this test system also acquires information on test items from other control devices 1 and generates and stores other device detailed test item tables 17 for testing the other control devices. Then, the self device detailed test item table 16 is compared with the other device detailed test item table 17 to determine whether the measuring device used in the test is also used in the other devices, and the result is used to determine the measurement order.

[0046] Meter data table 18 has the same configuration as the measuring instrument data table shown in FIG. 9, and stores information indicating the usage status of the measuring instrument for each control device. As in the conventional method, when the control device 1 starts to use a measuring device, it refers to the measuring device data table 18 to confirm that a "1" is not set corresponding to that measuring device, then it sets a "1" indicating a used state to secure that measuring device and performs measurement.

[0047] Furthermore, when the measurement is completed, the control device 1 sets "0" indicating an unused state to the corresponding measuring device in the measuring device data table 18. Then, the control device 1 transmits information indicating the use / release (unused) of the measuring device to the other control devices 1. The other control devices 1 update their stored measuring device data tables 18 based on the received information.

[0048] [Other Equipment Detailed Test Item Table 17: Figure 3] The other device detailed test item table 17 will be described with reference to Fig. 3. Fig. 3 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the other device detailed test item table. Note that, for the sake of simplicity, the other device detailed test item table 17 for the control device A (1a) stored in the control device B (1b) is shown here.

[0049] 3, the control device B (1b) stores the number, the measuring device to be used, the measurement order, the measurement time, and the measurement completion flag for each test item performed in the control device A (1a), which is another control device, as the other device detailed test item table 17 of the control device A (1a). The test items stored in the other device detailed test item table 17 correspond to the series of test items in the other control device described in the claims. The measurement completion flag is a flag indicating that the measurement of the corresponding test item has been completed, and is set to "1" when the measurement has been completed.

[0050] In this test system, when the control device B (1b) starts a test, it inquires of the control device A (1a) about the EUT to be tested, the test items to be performed, the measurement order, and the test completion flag, and based on the received information, the control device B (1b) generates a table 17 of other device detailed test items for the control device A (1a). Incidentally, the measurement time for each detailed test item is stored in advance in all the control devices 1.

[0051] The numbers are test item numbers and correspond to provisional measurement rankings (provisional rankings). The measurement order is the measurement order (measurement ranking) of the test items determined by the control device A (1a). If there is a change in the measurement order, the control device A notifies the control device B of the change, and the control device B updates the other device detailed test item table 17 accordingly.

[0052] [Detailed test item table: Figure 4] Next, the own device detailed test item table 16 will be described with reference to Fig. 4. Fig. 4 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the detailed test item table. Here, the detailed test item table of the control device B (1b) is shown. As shown in FIG. 4, the device's own detailed test item table 16 stores information about the detailed test items of the device itself, and in addition to the information stored in the other device's detailed test item table 17 shown in FIG. 3, it stores the effective time and the measurement order determination time, which are characteristic parts of this test system.

[0053] 4, the test items of transmission output, transmission frequency accuracy, spurious intensity, reception output level, reception sensitivity, and side tone output are stored corresponding to numbers (provisional ranks) 1' to 6', and the measuring device to be used, the determined measurement order (measurement rank), the measurement time, the validity time, the measurement rank determination time, and the measurement completion flag are stored corresponding to each test item. The test items stored in the own device detailed test item table 16 correspond to the series of test items for the own device described in the claims.

[0054] In addition, here, to distinguish from the numbers of the test items in the control device A (1a), "'" is added to the numbers, but the provisional measurement ranking is the ranking represented by the numbers without "'". The control device 1 of this test system compares the test items in its own device detailed test item table 16 with the other device detailed test item table 17, and if the same measuring instrument is not used at all, there is no risk of conflict, so it determines the provisional ranking as the measurement ranking as is. In this specification, "contention" is used to mean a situation in which multiple control devices 1 attempt to use the same measuring device at the same time.

[0055] In addition, while some test items use the same measuring instruments as other devices (overlapping measuring instruments), if there are test items that do not use the same measuring instruments (no overlapping measuring instruments), the measurement order for the test items that do not use the same measuring instruments is determined in order from highest to lowest provisional ranking. Furthermore, for test items that use the same measuring device as other control devices, the measurement order is determined based on the effective time and the measurement order determination time, which will be described later.

[0056] [Effective time calculation] The effective time is information that characterizes this test system, and serves as a judgment index when determining the measurement order of test items that use the same measuring device as other devices. For each test item, a specific measuring device is used for a specific measurement time, but when we look at the measuring device, there are some that are used for only one test item and some that are used for many test items. Also, the usage time (measurement time) of the measuring device varies.

[0057] Here, when comparing a test item in which only one measuring device is used for a short period of time with a test item in which multiple measuring devices are used for a long period of time, the former is less likely to cause a measuring device to compete with other control devices 1 than the latter, and even if there is a competition, the measuring device can be quickly released and secured by putting it on hold. In contrast, the latter method is more likely to be competitive and requires longer usage times, making it difficult to secure measuring equipment.

[0058] Taking these circumstances into consideration, this testing system prioritizes test items that require measuring instruments that are also used by other devices, and for which it is difficult to secure measuring instruments. Specifically, test items with short effective times are prioritized. In this way, by first measuring test items that use measuring devices that are likely to conflict with other devices, the probability of conflict later on is reduced, thereby shortening waiting times.

[0059] A method of calculating the effective time in the control device 1 will be described below. Here, the control device B (1b) will be described as an example. The control device B (1b) first refers to the local device detailed test item table 16, and calculates the total measurement time by adding up the measurement times of all registered test items. In the example of FIG. 4, the total measurement time is 315 seconds. Then, for each test item, the effective time is calculated by subtracting from the total measurement time the total measurement time of the test items in which the measuring device used in that test item is used.

[0060] For example, a power meter is used for the transmission output of test number 1', and a power meter is not used for other test items, so the effective time is determined by subtracting 30 seconds, the measurement time for the transmission output, from the total measurement time. In other words, the effective time for the transmission output test item is 315-30=285 (seconds).

[0061] In addition, a phase detector and low-frequency analyzer are used for sidetone output in test number 6' (measurement time 60 seconds), but the phase detector is also used for transmit frequency accuracy in test number 2' (measurement time 30 seconds), and the low-frequency analyzer is also used for receive output level in test number 4' (measurement time 45 seconds) and receive sensitivity in test number 5' (measurement time 60 seconds). Therefore, the total measurement time of the phase detector and low frequency analyzer used in the sidetone output of test number 6' is 30+45+60+60=195 (seconds). Therefore, the effective time of the sidetone output for test number 6' is 315-195=120 (seconds). The control device B (1b) similarly calculates the effective times for the other test items and stores them in its own device detailed test item table 16.

[0062] [Calculation of measurement ranking decision time] Furthermore, the control device B (1b) calculates a measurement ranking determination time as a judgment index when the ranking cannot be determined based on the effective time. The measurement ranking determination time is a value obtained by subtracting the measurement time from the effective time of each test item.

[0063] For example, the measurement order decision time for the transmission power of test number 1' is valid time-measurement time, which is 285-30=255 (seconds). Similarly, the measurement ranking decision time for the sidetone output of test number 6' is 120-60=60 (seconds). In the same manner, the control device B (1b) calculates and stores the measurement ranking determination times for all test items in the detailed test item data table.

[0064] [Determining the measurement order] The control device B (1b) then determines the measurement order based on the other device detailed test item table 17 and its own device detailed test item table 16 of the control device A (1a). First, the control device B (1B) compares its own device detailed test item table 16 with the other device detailed test item table 17 of the control device A (1a) to check whether there are test items that use the same measuring device. If there are test items that use measuring devices that are not used by other devices, the measurement order is determined in ascending order of provisional order from highest to lowest, such as 1st (number 1), 2nd, and so on. In the examples of Figures 3 and 4, there are no test items that use measuring devices that are not used by other devices.

[0065] For test items that use measuring instruments that are also used in other devices, the measurement order is determined based on the shortest effective time. In the example of FIG. 4, the side tone output of test number 6', which has the shortest effective time, is ranked first in the measurement ranking. Also, when the effective time is the same, the measurement order is determined in ascending order of measurement order determination time. For example, the effective time of the receiving output level of test number 4' and the receiving sensitivity of test number 5' are both 150 (seconds), but the measurement order determination time is 105 (seconds) for the receiving output level and 90 (seconds) for the receiving sensitivity, so the receiving sensitivity of test number 5' is ranked second (number 2) and the receiving output level is ranked third (number 3).

[0066] The control device B (1b) similarly determines the measurement order for all test items and stores the order in its own device detailed test item table 16. In the example of FIG. 4, the measurement order is determined as follows: first, sidetone output, second, reception sensitivity, reception output level, spurious intensity, transmission frequency accuracy, and transmission output, in that order up to the sixth place. Then, the control device B (1b) performs the test according to the measurement priority in the self device detailed test item table 16.

[0067] [Generating detailed test item table: Figure 5] The process performed by the control device 1 of this test system will now be described. When starting a test, the control device 1 generates the above-mentioned other device detailed test item table 17 and its own device detailed test item table 16. The process of generating the detailed test item table and the other device detailed test item table in the control device 1 will be described with reference to FIG. 5 is a flow chart showing the detailed test item table generation process executed at the start of a test. Here, the process in the control unit 11 of the control device B (1b) will be described as an example.

[0068] At the start of a test, the control device B (1b) first inquires of another device (here, the control device A (1a)) about the test items (100). When the control device B (1b) receives information on the EUT to be tested, the test items to be performed, the measurement order, and the test completion flag from the control device A (1a), the control device B (1b) generates (102) a other device detailed test item table 17 for the control device A (1a) as shown in FIG. 3 based on the received information and the measurement time information for each test item that has been stored in advance.

[0069] Next, the control device B (1b) generates its own device detailed test item table 16 as shown in FIG. 4 based on the information specifying the test items input from the operation unit 13 (104). Furthermore, the control device B (1b) calculates the effective time and the measurement order determination time for each test item (106). Then, the control device B (1b) stores the calculated effective time and the measurement order determination time in the detailed test item table, and proceeds to the measurement order determination process described later. In this manner, the process of generating a detailed test item table at the start of testing is carried out.

[0070] [Measurement order determination process: Figure 6] Next, the measurement order determination process will be described with reference to Fig. 6. Fig. 6 is a flowchart showing the details of the measurement order determination process. As shown in FIG. 6, the control device 1 sets one test item according to the provisional ranking in the local device detailed test item table 16 (300). Then, the control device 1 compares the test item with all test items in the other device detailed test item table 17 (302) and determines whether the measurement device overlaps with the other device (whether the same measurement device is used) (304). Here, the control device 1 excludes from the comparison test items in the other device detailed test item table 17 that have already been set to measurement complete.

[0071] If it is determined in process 304 that the same measuring device will be used, the control device 1 reserves the decision on the measurement order of the item, selects the next item according to the provisional order (306), and returns to process 300 to set the item and check the measuring device. Note that process 306 excludes items whose measurement order has already been decided, and only considers undecided items.

[0072] Furthermore, if it is determined in process 304 that the same measuring device as the other device is not used, the control device 1 determines the item as the next measurement order and stores it in the local device detailed test item table 16 (310). Here, the "next measurement order" refers to the top of the measurement orders (pending orders) for which a measurement item has not been decided.

[0073] Then, the control device 1 judges (312) whether all the test items in the control device detailed test item table 16 have been checked, and if there are any items that have not been checked (No), it returns to process 306 and checks the next item.

[0074] Furthermore, if all items are checked in process 312 (YES), the control device 1 determines the item with the shortest measurement order determination time as the next order among the items for which the measurement order has not been determined, and stores this in its own device detailed test item table 16 (314). If all items have been checked in process 312, the order of items that do not use the same measuring device as other devices has already been determined, and therefore in process 314, the measurement order determination times for items that use the same measuring device are compared.

[0075] In the process 314, the order is determined only based on the measurement order determination time, but it is also possible to determine the order based on the validity time first, and if this does not result in a decision, to determine the order based on the measurement order determination time. Specifically, for test items for which the measurement order has not been determined (items that use the same measuring device as other devices), the measurement order is determined in ascending order of effective time. If the effective time is the same, the measurement order is changed so that the test item with the shorter measurement order determination time is ranked higher.

[0076] Then, the control device 1 judges whether all the measurement orders in the detailed test item table 16 of the own device have been determined (316). If all the measurement orders have not been determined, the control device 1 selects the top of the items whose measurement orders have not been determined (318) and returns to the process 300 of the test item set of the own device to perform the check again. In this case, in order to determine the next test item of the other device to be compared, the measurement time of the measurement items of the own device whose measurement order has been determined is totaled, and the measurement item of the other device that is being performed when the total time has elapsed is set as the next comparison item. In this case, the test items of the own device are compared with the test items of the other device in the process 302, but when the measurement order is determined and the test items of the other device are compared again, an operation of determining which item to compare with is not required. In other words, if the test items of the other device have a longer test time than the test items determined by the own device, the test of the other device has not been completed even when the test of the own device has been completed, so the test items of the other device are not changed and are compared with the next test item of the own device. On the other hand, if the test items of the other device have a shorter test time than the test items determined by the own device, the test of the other device has been completed during the test of the own device, so it is necessary to determine which test item to compare with. Also, in process 316, if the measurement order has been determined for all (Yes), the measurement order determination process ends. In this manner, the measurement order determination process is carried out.

[0077] [Test time comparison: Figure 7] Next, we will explain the test time in this test system and the conventional test system. Figure 7 is an explanatory diagram showing a comparison of the test time when two control devices perform tests in parallel. In Figure 7, the test of control device A (1a) is shown in light gray, and the test of control device B (1b) is shown in dark gray.

[0078] Fig. 7(a) shows the conventional method (1), which waits for the measurement device to be released in the event of contention and then measures the test items according to the provisional ranking. This method has a long waiting time (the blank period), and it also takes the longest test time for both control devices to finish the test.

[0079] FIG. 7(b) shows the case where, in the conventional method (2), if there is a conflict, the test item in question is put on hold and the measurement of the next test item is carried out according to the provisional ranking. Since there was a conflict with test item number 1, the test of item number 2 is carried out first. In this case, the waiting time and the overall test time are shorter than in method (a).

[0080] FIG. 7(c) shows a case where a test was performed in the measurement order in this test system. When measurements were performed in the measurement order of this test system, the waiting time was shorter and the overall test time was also the shortest, as shown in FIG. 8(c). In this way, in this test system, by changing the measurement order when testing multiple control devices 1 in parallel, the probability of contention can be reduced, waiting time can be shortened, and test time can be shortened.

[0081] [Test implementation process: Figure 8] Next, the test execution process in the control device 1 of this test system will be described with reference to Fig. 8. Fig. 8 is a flowchart showing the test execution process. As shown in FIG. 8, when test equipment is selected at the start of a test (400), the control device 1 first performs the detailed test item table generation process shown in FIG. 5 (402). Next, the control device 1 performs the measurement order determination process shown in FIG.

[0082] Then, the control device 1 sets the test items for which measurement has not yet been completed according to the measurement priority in the device's own detailed test item table 16 (406), and refers to the measuring device data table 18 to determine the usage status of the measuring device used for the test item (408). If the measuring device is in use in measuring device data table 18 (if "1" is set), control device 1 returns to process 406 and sets the next test item.

[0083] Also, if the measuring device is in an unused state (if "0" is set) in process 408, the control device 1 sets the measuring device data table 18 to a used state ("1") (410) and performs measurement (412). Then, when the measurement is completed, the unused state ("0") is set in the measuring device data table 18 (414), and measurement completion is set in the own device detailed test item table 16 (416).

[0084] Then, the control device 1 checks whether or not all test items have been measured (418), and if not, proceeds to step 406 to set the next test item. If measurements for all test items are completed in process 418, the process ends. In this manner, the test execution process in the control device 1 of the present test system is carried out.

[0085] [Effects of the embodiment] According to this testing system, the control device 1 stores a series of test items with provisional priorities set, and compares the test items of its own device with a series of test items in other control devices to determine whether the measuring instrument used in its own device overlaps with that of the other control devices. For test items that do not overlap, the measurement order of the test items is determined according to the provisional priorities. For overlapping test items, an effective time reflecting the number of test items for which the measuring instrument is used and the length of time it is used is calculated for each test item, and the measurement order of the test items is determined in order of the shortest effective time. By first performing test items for which no measuring instrument is used in other control devices 1 without waiting time, and then determining the measurement order so that test items using measuring instruments that are likely to compete with other control devices 1 are performed early, the overall waiting time can be shortened even when the same measuring instrument as other control devices 1 is used, and testing can be performed efficiently. [Industrial Applicability]

[0086] The present invention is suitable for a test system that can improve the efficiency of testing by shortening the waiting time caused by contention of measuring instruments when testing is performed in parallel by a plurality of control devices. [Explanation of symbols]

[0087] 1...Control device, 2...General-purpose measuring instruments, 3...Dedicated test instruments, 4...Connection box, 5...LAN, 6...EUT, 11...Control section, 12...Memory section, 13...Operation section, 14...Display section, 15...Communication interface, 16...Self-device detailed test item table, 17...Other device detailed test item table, 18...Measuring instrument data table

Claims

1. A test system in which a plurality of control devices are connected to control a test in which a plurality of measuring devices are used to measure a series of test items according to a measurement order for a plurality of devices under test, The specific control device is a device itself that stores the series of test items with provisional rankings, queries other control devices about the series of test items in the other control devices, calculates a total measurement time by adding up all the measurement times for each test item in the series of test items in the specific control device, subtracts the measurement time from the total measurement time for each test item, and further, if a measuring device used in the test item is also used in other test items, subtracts the measurement time for the other test items to calculate an effective time for each test item. A test system characterized by comparing a series of test items in the own device with a series of test items in the other control device, and if a measuring instrument used in the test items in the own device does not overlap with a measuring instrument used in the test items in the other control device, determining a measurement ranking for the series of test items in accordance with the provisional ranking, and if a measuring instrument used in the test items in the own device overlaps with a measuring instrument used in the test items in the other control device, determining a measurement ranking for the series of test items in order of shortest effective time.

2. The test system described in claim 1, characterized in that when the specific control device has a mixture of test items in which the measuring instruments used in the series of test items in the device itself do not overlap with the measuring instruments used in the test items in the other control devices, and test items in which the measuring instruments used in the series of test items in the other control devices overlap, the specific control device determines the ranking of the test items in which the measuring instruments do not overlap as higher.

3. The test system according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the specific control device calculates a measurement ranking determination time for each test item by subtracting the measurement time of the test item from the effective time, and changes the measurement ranking of the series of test items in order of the shortest measurement ranking determination time.

4. The test system according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that the specific control device inquires about the usage status of a measuring device used by the other control devices before starting measurement of a test item, and if the measuring device is unused, causes the other control devices to perform measurement of the test item.

5. 5. The test system according to claim 1, wherein the specific control device determines the measurement order of a series of test items at the start of testing the test items.

6. A test system as described in any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that the specific control device obtains the completion status of a series of test items from the other control devices, and excludes test items for which measurement has been completed in the other control devices from being compared with the series of test items in the specific control device.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Testing system for information processor

    JP1995253898A

  • Setting method for executing order of radio apparatus test item

    JP1999202013A

  • Automatic test system

    JP2007292723A

  • Test system

    JP2010190851A

  • Test system

    JP2011169606A