In-building facility arrangement design support system

The in-building equipment layout design support system optimizes elevator and escalator placement by applying an optimization method to a flow line evaluation formula, addressing inefficiencies in current design methods and improving movement efficiency and congestion prevention within buildings.

WO2024232009A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-14MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC BUILDING SOLUTIONS CORP +1
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2023/017419
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-09
Publication Date
2024-11-14

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current methods for designing elevator and escalator layouts in buildings are inefficient, as they primarily focus on elevator specifications and performance without considering overall building movement efficiency, leading to a high workload and suboptimal solutions due to the complexity of combining elevator and escalator installations with trial-and-error approaches in multi-agent simulations.

Method used

An in-building equipment layout design support system that calculates the optimal specifications, number, and placement of elevators and escalators by applying an optimization method to a flow line evaluation formula, combining both vertical and horizontal movement, reducing the need for trial-and-error through mathematical expression of movement parameters.

Benefits of technology

This system reduces the design workload by providing an optimal equipment layout plan that improves movement efficiency within buildings, minimizing travel time, power consumption, and preventing congestion, while allowing for tailored solutions based on specific design objectives.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2023017419_14112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2023017419_14112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

An in-building facility arrangement design support system according to the present disclosure comprises: an input unit that inputs building information pertaining to a building, user information pertaining to users who use the building, and a target value for a facility arrangement design plan that includes parameters pertaining to any of arrangement of facilities in the building, and the specifications, number of installations, and arrangement of elevators arranged in the building; a first calculation unit that calculates, on the basis of the building information, the user information, and the target value input by the input unit, a ratio of the number of users for each type of elevator installed in the building; and a second calculation unit that calculates, on the basis of the ratio for each type of elevator, a parameter that achieves the target value by applying an optimization method to a movement path evaluation formula, which mathematically expresses a movement time of horizontal movement by walking of the users in the building and a movement time of vertical movement by the elevators.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Building facility layout design support system

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a building facility layout design support system.

[0002] When installing elevators or other elevating equipment in a building, an installation plan, such as the number of elevators required, is determined based on the results of a traffic calculation formula that calculates the elevator's five-minute transportation capacity or average operating interval. Patent Document 1, for example, discloses an elevator installation plan support device that outputs an elevator design plan that combines elevator specifications and performance to achieve a service performance target. This installation plan support device includes an inference means that repeatedly improves and evaluates the elevator specifications based on elevator traffic demand and an input elevator service performance target until the service performance target is achieved.

[0003] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 3-288777

[0004] The installation planning support device in Patent Document 1 outputs only the elevator design plan portion, i.e., the combination of elevator specifications and performance calculated by the inference means. However, travel efficiency within a building must be considered taking into account the entire movement from the building entrance to the destination room, and cannot be determined solely by the elevator specifications and performance.

[0005] However, when trying to determine an equipment installation plan that includes an elevator installation plan (how many elevators and escalators to place where in a building, and what specifications they have) as well as an installation plan for each room and staircase within the building, the number of combinations becomes enormous, making it difficult to find an optimal solution.

[0006] One known method for designing building traffic flow, elevator shaft layout, and elevator parameters from this vast number of combinations is to conduct advance studies using simulations such as multi-agent simulation. Multi-agent simulation is a simulation in which multiple agents, each with their own individuality and autonomy, act while interfering with each other according to their own rules. Multi-agent simulation allows for the virtual creation of a building under design, and by varying the speed, number, and placement of elevators and escalators, it is possible to check where congestion will occur, whether the elevator speed and number are sufficient, and so on.

[0007] However, multi-agent simulation requires a great deal of time for both model creation and calculation, and designers must repeatedly modify the model and check the results by trial and error when it comes to elevator speed and placement. Therefore, when using multi-agent simulation to conduct preliminary design studies, the workload at the design stage becomes enormous. Furthermore, multi-agent simulation does not propose optimal solutions tailored to specific objectives.

[0008] The present disclosure has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and provides an improved building equipment layout design support system that reduces the workload when designing equipment layout within a building and enables the presentation of design plans for equipment layout within a building.

[0009] The building equipment layout design support system of the present disclosure comprises an input unit that inputs building information about the building, user information about users who will use the building, and target values ​​for an equipment layout design plan that includes parameters related to any of the specifications, number of elevators to be installed, and location of elevators to be installed in the building, and the location of equipment in the building; a first calculation unit that calculates the proportion of the number of users for each type of elevator installed in the building based on the building information, user information, and target values ​​input by the input unit; and a second calculation unit that calculates parameters that achieve the target values ​​by applying an optimization method to a flow line evaluation formula that mathematically formulates the travel time for horizontal walking movement of users within the building and the travel time for vertical movement by elevator, based on the proportions for each type of elevator.

[0010] According to the building equipment layout design support system disclosed herein, the horizontal and vertical movement of people walking within a building is expressed as a formula for evaluating the flow of people within the building, and an optimization technique is applied to this formula. This makes it possible to calculate an optimal solution for the parameters of the equipment installation plan simply by changing the numerical parameters of the flow of people evaluation formula. This reduces the burden of trial and error work when designing the equipment layout within a building.

[0011] 1 is a block diagram showing an overall configuration of an intra-building equipment layout design support system according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing the flow of input and output of information in each unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing a processing procedure in an information input unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating processing by a first calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of the relationship between the number of floors traveled by an elevator and an escalator and travel time. FIG. 6 is a diagram illustrating calculation conditions for calculation by a first calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 7 is a diagram illustrating an example of a calculation result by a first calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 8 is a diagram illustrating processing by a second calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 9 is a diagram illustrating an example of parameters used in a flow line evaluation formula used in the second calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 10 is a diagram illustrating a calculation result of calculation by a second calculation unit included in the intra-building equipment layout design support system according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. 11 is a diagram illustrating an example of the utilization probability and travel time of elevators and escalators on each floor in a building when a calculation is performed by a second calculation unit included in an in-building equipment layout design support system according to a second embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 12 is a diagram illustrating a Nash equilibrium point calculated in the case of the preconditions shown in FIG. 11 when a calculation is performed by a second calculation unit included in an in-building equipment layout design support system according to a second embodiment of the present disclosure.

[0012] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. In each drawing, the same or corresponding parts are designated by the same reference numerals, and the description thereof will be simplified or omitted.

[0013] Embodiment 1. Figure 1 is a block diagram showing the overall configuration of a building facility layout design support system according to this embodiment. The building facility layout design support system (hereinafter also referred to as the "support system") 100 can output an evaluation of a facility layout design plan, including optimal specifications and the number of elevators to be installed, the placement of elevators on a layout pattern, and each room and staircase in the building. As shown in Figure 1, the support system 100 includes an information input unit 110, a first calculation unit 120, a second calculation unit 130, and a calculation result output unit 140. The functions of the information input unit 110, the first calculation unit 120, the second calculation unit 130, and the calculation result output unit 140 included in the support system 100 are realized by a processing circuit. The processing circuit may be dedicated hardware or a central processing unit (CPU) that executes a program stored in memory.

[0014] 2 is a diagram showing the flow of information input and output in each unit of the support system. Information input to the information input unit 110 includes building information, user information, design target values, and constraints. Note that, hereinafter, the design target values ​​and constraints are collectively referred to simply as "target values." The information input to the information input unit 110 may be input by a person such as a designer, or may be information calculated or acquired by a function separate from the support system 100 and acquired by the information input unit 110.

[0015] The first calculation unit 120 receives building information, user information, and target values ​​from the information input unit 110. When multiple types of elevators, such as elevators and escalators, are installed in a building as means of vertical transportation, the first calculation unit 120 calculates the allocation of the number of users to each type of elevator in the building based on the input information, and outputs the user population ratio for each elevator type. Note that the vertical transportation means in the building here refers to means for moving from one floor of the building to another floor.

[0016] The second calculation unit 130 receives building information, user information, and target values ​​from the information input unit 110, and also receives the user population ratio for each elevator type, which is the calculation result of the user population allocation, from the first calculation unit 120. The second calculation unit 130 stores an in-building flow line evaluation formula that mathematically expresses the horizontal walking movement of users within the building and the vertical movement by elevator. Based on the input information, the second calculation unit 130 applies an optimization method to the flow line evaluation formula to optimize the in-building equipment installation plan, i.e., the specifications, number, and placement of elevators, the placement of each room and staircase, etc.

[0017] The calculation result output unit 140 receives as input the results of calculation by the second calculation unit 130 the specifications, number, and placement of each elevator, as well as the optimization results of the placement of each room, staircase, etc. The calculation result output unit 140 outputs this information, the five-minute transportation capacity of the elevators when the optimal conditions are applied, the average operating interval, and the cost of each elevator, as well as the result of whether these meet the target values.

[0018] The following is a specific description of the functions of each unit 110 to 140 of the support system 100. Fig. 3 is a diagram showing the processing procedure in the information input unit 110. As shown in Fig. 3, in step S111, the information input unit 110 accepts input of building information and user information.

[0019] The building information input in step S111 is information about the building. The building information may include the floor area of ​​the building, the shape of the building, the number of floors of the building, the height of each floor, information about each room of the tenant or facility on each floor, and the layout of the building's entrances and exits. The information about each room of the tenant or facility on each floor may be information that allows for a rough estimation of the number of users per time period. For example, if the information about each room indicates that it is an "office," the number of users will be high in the morning and evening, which are the hours when people arrive and leave work, and if the information about it indicates that it is a "restaurant," the number of users will be high during the lunch hour, and so on. This allows for estimating and classifying changes in the number of users per time period.

[0020] The input user information is information related to the expected number of users who will use the building, etc. The user information may include the expected number of users entering and exiting the building at each entrance and exit for each time period, the expected number of users in each room for each time period, the expected number of users on each floor, and the expected total number of users. Note that some of this user information may be calculated based on the information on each room, etc. included in the building information, and the user information.

[0021] Next, in step S112, an evaluation function is set. That is, an object to be optimized (e.g., maximized or minimized) is selected. The set evaluation function evaluates one of the following indicators: elevator cost, travel time, five-minute transport capacity, and average headway between trains. The evaluation function may also be a combination of multiple indicators. In this case, for example, a weighting ratio for each indicator may be arbitrarily set, such as 70% for cost and 30% for travel time. Note that the indicators for the evaluation function are not limited to those described above; for example, the elevator area or power consumption may also be used as an indicator. Furthermore, if the building is a commercial facility, the evaluation function can be set according to various needs, such as lengthening the walking time to encourage as many people as possible to walk in front of the store to stimulate consumption, or uniforming the number of pedestrians in the aisles as much as possible to avoid crowding people in one place.

[0022] Next, in step S113, a target range for optimization is selected. The target range may include, for example, the specifications, number, and layout of elevators, such as elevators, and the layout of each room. There may be one target range or multiple target ranges. Elevator specifications may include elevator speed, car capacity, number of elevators, and escalator speed. For example, if the layout of elevator shafts in a building has already been determined and only the optimal elevator specifications are to be calculated, only the elevator specifications are selected as the target range. Multiple target ranges may be selected, so multiple combinations of target ranges to be optimized can be set, such as elevator specifications and hoistway layout, elevator specifications and the layout of each room, or elevator specifications, hoistway layout, and room layout.

[0023] In step S114, target values ​​are input. Here, the target values ​​are information regarding the design goals and constraints to be achieved. The target values ​​may include, for example, target values ​​to be achieved for the five-minute transport capacity of the elevators, the average elevator operation interval, and elevator costs, or tolerance ranges for costs, travel time, the five-minute transport capacity, and the average operation interval. For example, when cost is selected as the evaluation target of the evaluation function to minimize costs, at least a lower limit for the five-minute transport capacity (e.g., a certain percentage or more) or an upper limit for the average operation interval (e.g., a certain number of seconds or less) is set as a constraint to prevent an optimization result in which the number of elevators is zero. This allows the evaluation function to be optimized within the range of the set target values.

[0024] For example, the five-minute transportation capacity of an elevator is preferably 11 to 25% if the building is an office building, 3.5 to 5% if the building is an apartment building, and 8 to 10% if the building is a hotel, and these ranges can be used as constraints. Furthermore, for example, the average operation interval is preferably 30 seconds or less if the building is an office building, 90 seconds or less if the building has one elevator, 60 seconds or less if the building has two or more elevators, and 40 seconds or less if the building is a hotel. Therefore, these preferred ranges of the five-minute transportation capacity and the average operation interval can be used as constraints.

[0025] 4 is a diagram for explaining the processing by the first calculation unit 120. As shown in Fig. 4, the first calculation unit 120 calculates the optimal user-count ratio for each type of elevator, i.e., elevator and escalator, from the building information, user information, and target values ​​input by the information input unit 110.

[0026] First, the concept of a method for allocating users to elevators and escalators will be explained using Figure 5. Figure 5 is a diagram illustrating travel times to each floor by elevator and escalator. In Figure 5, the horizontal axis represents the distance to the destination floor, and the vertical axis represents travel time. Also in Figure 5, graph a represents travel time when using an escalator, and graphs b and c represent travel time when using an elevator. Note that travel time here refers to the time required for vertical travel, and refers to the time from the arrival time of the elevator at the landing to the arrival time of the elevator at the disembarkation point.

[0027] Escalators are slower than elevators. Therefore, as shown in FIG. 5, the slope of graph a for escalators is greater than the slope of graphs b and c for elevators. Furthermore, since there is no waiting time for escalators, the intercept of graph a for escalators is 0. On the other hand, since there is a waiting time for elevators, graphs b and c for elevators have intercepts corresponding to the waiting time. Note that a specific value for the waiting time for an elevator is, for example, the value obtained by dividing the average interval between elevator operations, which is input as a constraint condition in the information input unit 110, by 2.

[0028] For example, since the elevator graphs b and c have a small slope but an intercept, when the destination floors are close, the escalator takes less time to travel and passengers are assigned to the elevator. On the other hand, as the destination floor becomes farther away and at a certain distance D, the graphs for the elevator and escalator reverse, and the elevator takes less time to travel. Therefore, it is presumed that passengers traveling beyond a certain distance D will use the elevator. As shown in graphs b and c, the slope changes depending on the elevator's speed, and the distance at which the elevator and escalator travel times become shorter also changes. For example, as in the case of graph c, when the elevator is fast, the travel time is shorter even when the destination floors are close, so more passengers are assigned to the elevator.

[0029] The first calculation unit 120 calculates the optimal ratio of users of elevators and escalators according to the building information, user information, and target values, based on the relationship between the distance to each floor and the travel time as shown in Fig. 5. In other words, it calculates the estimated ratio of users of each type of elevator when elevator users are allocated, for each number of floors, to either the elevator or the escalator that results in the shortest travel time.

[0030] Specifically, if the height of the first floor is H, the number of floors a user travels to is n, and the target waiting time for the elevator is Tw, the elevator travel time Tel and the escalator travel time Tes are respectively expressed by the following formulas (1) and (2). The first calculation unit 120 calculates the ratio of the number of users when users are allocated to the route that will result in the shorter calculated travel time Tel or Tes according to the following formulas (1) and (2).

[0031] An example of the results of calculation of the user number allocation by the first calculation unit 120 will be described with reference to Fig. 6 and Fig. 7. Fig. 6 shows the calculation conditions, and Fig. 7 shows the calculation results of the user number ratio. In Fig. 7, the horizontal axis represents the elevator speed (m / min), and the vertical axis represents the elevator user number ratio (%).

[0032] Condition 1 specifies that the building has 30 floors and the target waiting time is 20 seconds, and condition 2 specifies that the building has 5 floors and the target waiting time is 45 seconds.

[0033] In a building with many floors, as in condition 1, elevators are faster than escalators, so more users will have a shorter travel time by elevator. Therefore, under condition 1, the elevator user rate will be high, as shown in Figure 7. On the other hand, in a building with few floors, as in condition 2, there is no (zero) waiting time for the escalator, so more users will have a shorter travel time by escalator. Therefore, under condition 2, the calculated elevator user rate will be lower than under condition 1.

[0034] Furthermore, as shown in Figure 7, it is estimated that the travel time in an elevator is shorter when the elevator is fast than when it is slow. Therefore, under both Condition 1 and Condition 2, the elevator user ratio is higher when the elevator is fast. Note that in Condition 2, the plot of the user ratio stops at 120 m / min because elevators cannot travel faster than that in low-rise buildings.

[0035] For example, in the results of Figure 7, if an elevator with a speed Vel of 100 m / min is used in a building under condition 1, 98% of the total number of users is expected to use the elevator. On the other hand, if an elevator with a speed Vel of 100 m / min is used in a building under condition 2, 25% of the total number of users is expected to use the elevator. Note that although Figure 7 shows the results when the escalator speed is constant, the user rate calculated by the first calculation unit 120 is a value that changes depending on the escalator speed.

[0036] 8 is a diagram showing the processing by the second calculation unit 130. The second calculation unit 130 receives as input the user information and target values ​​input by the information input unit 110, and the user number ratio calculated by the first calculation unit 120. From the input information, the second calculation unit 130 calculates optimal parameters for the elevators by optimizing indicators according to a set evaluation function, such as elevator and escalator speeds, car capacity, elevator width and other elevator specifications, the number of elevators installed, their placement, the placement of each room, and the placement of stairs.

[0037] The second calculation unit 130 stores an evaluation formula for the flow line within a building, which is a formula that combines the flow lines of people moving horizontally by walking and those moving vertically by elevators and escalators within a building.

[0038] In calculating the vertical travel time in this flow line evaluation formula, the above formula (2) is used for the travel time of escalator users. On the other hand, for elevator users, the elevator traffic calculation is used. Here, the number of escalator and elevator users is calculated according to the user ratio calculated by the first calculation unit 120.

[0039] 9 is a diagram showing an example of parameters used in the traffic calculation formula of the flow line evaluation formula stored in the second calculation unit 130. Using the parameters shown in FIG. 9 , the traffic calculation formula can calculate the total expected number of elevator stops F, total running time, door opening / closing time Td, passenger entry / exit time Tp, lost time Tl, elevator round trip time RTT, average operation headway Ti, five-minute transportation capacity P, average waiting time Tw, etc., which can then be used to mathematically express the vertical travel time.

[0040] An example of a calculation formula for each value used in the traffic calculation formula is shown below. The expected number of elevator stops for going up fu, the expected number of elevator stops for going down fd, and the total expected number of elevator stops F can be expressed by the following formulas using the number of service floors n, the number of passengers going up ru, and the number of passengers going down rd.

[0041] The average upward travel distance Su and the average downward travel distance Sd per elevator operation are expressed by the following formulas using the ascent / descent stroke L, the expected number of upward stops fu, and the expected number of downward stops fd.

[0042] Furthermore, the upward running time Tru, the downward running time Trd, and the total running time Tr are expressed by the following equations using the elevator's acceleration / acceleration time t0, maximum acceleration am, acceleration time ta, acceleration distance sa, speed V, ascending / descending stroke L, and the above-mentioned expected number of upward stops fu and expected number of downward stops fd: Here, the acceleration time ta [s] and acceleration distance Sa are preset as values ​​corresponding to the rated speed.

[0043] The door opening / closing time Td is expressed by the following formula using the total predicted number of stops F shown in the formula above and the door opening / closing time td: Note that the door opening / closing time td is a value set in advance depending on the width of the entrance / exit and the type of door (for example, two-leaf single sliding door, two-leaf double sliding door, etc.).

[0044] The passenger entry and exit time Tp is expressed by the following formula using a coefficient K according to the width of the entrance and exit.

[0045] The lost time Tl is expressed by the following formula using the door opening / closing time Td and the passenger entry / exit time Tp.

[0046] Furthermore, the elevator round trip time RTT is expressed by the following equation using the total running time Tr, the door opening / closing time Td, the passenger entry / exit time Tp, and the lost time Tl.

[0047] The average operation interval Ti is expressed by the following formula using the elevator round trip time RTT and the number of elevators N.

[0048] The five-minute transport capacity P is expressed by the following formula using the number of occupants Q and the above-mentioned average operation interval Ti.

[0049] The average waiting time Tw is expressed by the following formula using the average train interval Ti.

[0050] On the other hand, the horizontal movement time in the flow line evaluation formula is calculated based on the length of the flow line (passageway) and the walking speed of people. Specifically, for example, the horizontal movement time is expressed as a formula using the following calculation formula for walking time T_travel and exit passing time T_queue, which is described in "Explanation of the Evacuation Safety Verification Method and Calculation Examples and Their Explanations" [2] published by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.

[0051] Here, l l is the walking distance [m], v is the walking speed [m / min], and p is the occupancy density [persons / m 2 ], Aarea is the floor area of ​​each part of the building [m 2], Neff is the effective flow coefficient [persons / min m], and Beff is the effective exit width [m]. The walking speed is preset as a value according to the purpose of the building or each room, the type of part of the building (i.e., stairs, seating, other parts, etc.), and the direction of movement. The occupant density is preset as a value according to the type of each room, i.e., living room, bedroom other than living room, conference room, store, office, restaurant, etc. The effective flow coefficient is a value determined according to the floor area, capacity, exit width, required retention area, etc. of each part of the evacuation route, etc., and is preset.

[0052] 10 is a diagram for explaining the calculation results of the flow line evaluation formula of the second calculation unit 130. As shown in Fig. 10, the flow line evaluation formula can calculate travel time and the like for each time period and each destination according to the layout pattern being evaluated.

[0053] The second calculation unit 130 uses this flow line evaluation formula to perform optimization so as to minimize or maximize the evaluation function set in the information input unit 110. There are no limitations on the optimization method. For example, the optimization method used here may be a metaheuristic (heuristic approximation method) such as mathematical programming or PSO (Particle Swarm Optimization). Optimization methods are well known, and detailed description thereof will be omitted.

[0054] The calculation result output unit 140 outputs the optimization results calculated by the second calculation unit 130, including elevator specifications such as elevator speed, elevator speed, car capacity, number of elevators, and escalator speed, as well as elevator placement, number of elevators installed, and layout of each room and staircase. It also outputs the cost, travel time, five-minute transport capacity, average headway between elevators, elevator area, power consumption, round trip time, and aisle density for the optimal parameters. These output results can be used as a reference for facility layout design within a building.

[0055] As described above, the assistance system 100 according to this embodiment uses a flow-line evaluation formula that combines all movements within a building, including horizontal movement by walking and vertical movement by elevators and escalators, into a single mathematical formula. Then, by applying an optimization method to this flow-line evaluation formula, the numerical parameters of the flow-line evaluation formula can be automatically modified. This allows designers to obtain optimized results for elevator specifications, the number of elevators installed, elevator placement, and the placement of rooms and staircases, without requiring trial and error. Furthermore, the evaluation function can be used to set the target for optimization evaluation. Therefore, flow lines can be optimized to meet the needs or preferences of clients and designers, not just those focused on improving (minimizing) travel time, but also those focused on minimizing elevator space, power consumption, extending the time spent circulating within the building, and avoiding crowding in one location within the building. Therefore, the assistance system 100 can obtain an optimal solution tailored to the objective.

[0056] Furthermore, in the support system 100, the first calculation unit 120 calculates the allocation of the number of users before the optimization calculation by the second calculation unit 130. This reduces the calculation load for optimization on the second calculation unit 130 and shortens the calculation time.

[0057] Embodiment 2 The support system of Embodiment 2 has the same configuration as the support system 100 of Embodiment 1, except that the first calculation unit calculates the user population ratio using Nash equilibrium. Specifically, while the first calculation unit 120 of Embodiment 1 is configured to calculate the user population ratio for each elevator type based on a comparison of elevator and escalator travel times for each floor (distance), the first calculation unit of Embodiment 2 calculates the user population ratio for each elevator type using the Nash equilibrium method. Here, Nash equilibrium is a basic concept of non-cooperative games in game theory formulated by John Nash, and refers to a state in which all game participants select optimal strategies that maximize their own gains under certain rules.

[0058] For example, let us consider a case where a Nash equilibrium is used to determine the proportion of users of each type of elevator that optimizes the travel time for residents on each floor in a three-story building equipped with elevators and escalators. Figure 11 shows the usage probability and travel time for elevators and escalators on each floor of the building. The numbers in parentheses shown in Figure 11 represent the travel time (s) for second-floor residents, and the latter represents the travel time (s) for third-floor residents. Let x be the probability that second-floor residents will use the elevator, and y be the probability that third-floor residents will use the elevator.

[0059] Figure 12 is a diagram illustrating the Nash equilibrium point for the mixed strategy under the assumptions in Figure 11. The Nash equilibrium point shows that travel time throughout the building is shortest when one-third of the residents on the second floor and one-third of the residents on the third floor use the elevator, and two-thirds use the escalator.

[0060] The first calculation unit calculates the user ratios of elevators and escalators according to the ratios at the Nash equilibrium point where the expected payoff is highest. The calculated user ratios are used by the second calculation unit 130, and as in the first embodiment, travel time can be optimized for the entire building.

[0061] In the above embodiments, when the number, quantity, amount, range, etc. of each element is mentioned, the present invention is not limited to the mentioned numbers unless otherwise specified or clearly specified in principle. Furthermore, the structures, etc. described in the embodiments are not necessarily essential to the present invention unless otherwise specified or clearly specified in principle.

[0062] 100 Support system, 110 Information input unit, 120 First calculation unit, 130 Second calculation unit, 140 Calculation result output unit

Claims

1. An intra-building equipment layout design support system comprising: an input unit for inputting building information about a building, user information about users who will use the building, and target values ​​for an equipment layout design plan including parameters related to any of the specifications, number of elevators to be installed, and location of elevators to be installed in the building, and the location of equipment within the building; a first calculation unit for calculating the proportion of the number of users for each type of elevator installed in the building based on the building information, user information, and target values ​​input by the input unit; and a second calculation unit for calculating the parameters that will achieve the target values ​​by applying an optimization technique to a flow line evaluation formula that mathematically represents the travel time of the users' planar movement by walking within the building and the travel time of the users' vertical movement by the elevator, based on the proportions for each type of elevator.

2. The building equipment layout design support system as described in claim 1, wherein the elevators include at least one elevator and at least one escalator, and the first calculation unit calculates the ratio based on a comparison of the travel time when using the elevator and the travel time when using the escalator.

3. The building equipment layout design support system according to claim 1, wherein the first calculation unit calculates the ratio using a Nash equilibrium method.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Building internal comprehensive traffic simulation system

    JP2000044134A

  • Device for managing facility on basis of flow line

    JP2003022309A

  • Device and method for arranging and designing elevator machine facility in building

    WO2022097222A1