Method determination system, communication device, method for determining method, and program
The method determination system dynamically selects authentication or key exchange methods using negotiation protocols, addressing the inflexibility and replacement challenges in conventional hybrid technologies by enabling secure and flexible method combinations for hybrid authentication or key exchange.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2023/018378
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-17
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
AI Technical Summary
Conventional hybrid authentication and key exchange technologies lack flexibility in method combination and face challenges in agreeing on replacement sets when a method becomes compromised, leading to difficulties in implementing secure communication with communication partners.
A method determination system that allows communication devices to dynamically determine and agree on a set of authentication or key exchange methods using a negotiation protocol, where one device generates a list of available methods and the other device selects a method set based on predetermined extraction methods, such as priority, policy, or distance-based criteria, enabling flexible combination and secure hybrid authentication or key exchange.
This approach provides flexible combination of authentication or key exchange methods, allowing for secure hybrid authentication or key exchange with communication partners, reducing the risk of compromise and streamlining the process of replacing compromised methods.
Smart Images

Figure JP2023018378_21112024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Method determination system, communication device, method determination method, and program
[0001] The present disclosure relates to authentication technology and key exchange technology.
[0002] In the technical fields of authentication and key exchange technology, there are many authentication and key exchange methods. However, if a single method is used, there is a risk that the system using that technology will be exposed to threats if the technology related to that method is suddenly compromised. Therefore, hybrid technologies exist that combine multiple authentication and key exchange methods.
[0003] ETSI TS 103 744 v1.1.1(2020-12), CYBER; Quantum-safe Hybrid Key Exchanges. <URL:https: / / www.etsi.org / deliver / etsi_ts / 103700_103799 / 103744 / 01.01.01_60 / ts_103744v010101p.pdf>
[0004] However, hybrid technology requires that the set (combination) of methods to be combined be determined in advance. Therefore, a recognizable identifier must be shared between devices that use that set to perform authentication or key exchange. Therefore, conventional hybrid technology lacks flexibility in how methods are combined, and when a specific method is compromised, there is a high possibility that agreement cannot be reached with the other device with which the technology is being communicated. Another issue is that it takes a long time for the industry to agree on and prepare an alternative set. While theoretically it is possible to define and share all possible sets in advance, there are issues that make it difficult to achieve such definition and sharing.
[0005] In order to solve the above problems, the present disclosure aims to provide a technology that is flexible in how authentication methods or key exchange methods are combined and that implements hybrid authentication or hybrid key exchange that can be realized between communication partners.
[0006] To solve the above problem, one aspect of the present disclosure provides a scheme determination system for determining multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange, comprising a first communication device and a second communication device. The first communication device comprises a request generation unit that outputs a first list containing multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the first communication device to the second communication device, and a response reception unit that receives a scheme set that is a combination of the multiple schemes determined by the second communication device and determines whether to perform authentication or key exchange using the scheme set. The second communication device comprises a combination determination unit that determines a scheme set from the first list and a second list containing multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the second communication device based on a predetermined extraction method, and a response generation unit that outputs the scheme set to the first communication device.
[0007] According to the present disclosure, it is possible to flexibly combine authentication methods or key exchange methods, and to implement feasible hybrid authentication or hybrid key exchange with a communication partner.
[0008] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of a scheme determination system according to the present disclosure. FIG. 2 is a sequence diagram showing an example of processing by the scheme determination system 1. FIG. 3 is a flowchart showing an example of processing by the combination determination unit 22. FIG. 4 is a diagram for explaining a method based on priority. FIG. 5A is a diagram showing a specific example based on a solution to the knapsack problem. FIG. 5B is a diagram showing the relationship between possible scheme combinations and usage costs in FIG. 5A. FIG. 5C is a diagram showing the relationship between possible scheme combinations and security levels in FIG. 5A. FIG. 6A is a diagram for explaining a method based on the distance between sets indicating features. FIG. 6B is a diagram showing an example of a target list LT for the features defined in FIG. 6A. FIG. 6C is a diagram showing an example of the calculation results of the Simpson coefficient in FIG. 6B. FIG. 7 is a diagram illustrating an example of the functional configuration of a computer.
[0009] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0010] [Scheme Determination System] As shown in Fig. 1, a scheme determination system 1 according to an embodiment of the present disclosure includes a communication device 10 and a communication device 20. In Fig. 1, the communication device 10 is a so-called initiator, and the communication device 20 is a so-called responder. The negotiation protocol used in this embodiment may be any protocol, but it is conceivable to apply, for example, Internet Key Exchange or TLS 1.3.
[0011] (Communication Device 10) The communication device 10 includes a communication unit 11, a request generation unit 12, a response reception unit 13, and an authentication / key exchange processing unit 14.
[0012] The communication unit 11 performs various communications with the communication device 20 via a communication network. The communication unit 11 may be configured to communicate with devices other than the communication device 20.
[0013] The request generation unit 12 generates a list (list L1) including multiple methods used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the communication device 10, and outputs it to the communication device 20. The request generation unit 12 may be configured to have list L1 from the beginning, without performing the process of generating list L1. The request generation unit 12 may be configured to request other conditions including the number of methods N and extraction method EX in addition to list L1. The number of methods N refers to the number (number) of methods to be combined included in the set. The extraction method EX refers to an extraction method for extracting a set of methods (method set α) that is a combination of multiple methods used for authentication or key exchange. Details of the extraction method EX will be described later.
[0014] The response receiving unit 13 receives the scheme set α determined by the communication device 20 and determines whether to perform authentication or key exchange using the scheme set α. The response receiving unit 13 may be configured to output a determination result R to the communication device 20, including the determined content, that is, either agreement for authentication or key exchange or non-agreement for authentication or key exchange (hereinafter also referred to as "NG").
[0015] The authentication / key exchange processing unit 14 performs authentication or key exchange processing. The authentication / key exchange processing unit 14 may be configured to perform both authentication processing and key exchange processing, or to perform only one of these processing.
[0016] (Communication Device 20) The communication device 20 includes a communication unit 21, a combination determination unit 22, a response generation unit 23, and an authentication / key exchange processing unit 24.
[0017] The communication unit 21 performs various communications with the communication device 10 via a communication network. The communication unit 21 may be configured to communicate with devices other than the communication device 10.
[0018] The combination determination unit 22 generates a list (list L2) including multiple methods used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the communication device 20, and determines the method set α based on a predetermined extraction method using this list L2 and the received list L1. The combination determination unit 22 may be configured to have list L2 from the beginning without performing the process of generating list L2.
[0019] The response generation unit 23 outputs the method set α determined by the combination determination unit 22 to the communication device 10 .
[0020] The authentication / key exchange processing unit 24 performs authentication processing or key exchange processing. The authentication / key exchange processing unit 24 may be configured to perform both authentication processing and key exchange processing, or to perform only one of these processes.
[0021] [Method of Determining Scheme] The method of determining schemes according to the present embodiment is realized by the method of determining schemes system 1 performing the process shown in Fig. 2. Here, as an example, in the process between communication device 10 and communication device 20, communication device 10 functions as an initiator that requests authentication processing or key exchange processing, and communication device 20 functions as a responder that receives a request from communication device 10, determines method set α, which is a set of multiple possible authentication processing or key exchange processing, and replies to the request.
[0022] First, the request generation unit 12 of the communication device 10 generates a list L1 based on information input by the user and outputs it to the communication device 20 (step S12). If the user has specified the number of methods N and the extraction method EX, these are also output to the communication device 20. This step corresponds to a so-called negotiation request.
[0023] The combination determination unit 22 of the communication device 20 determines a method set α from the input list L1 and the list L2 generated based on information input by the user, based on the determination method described below (step S22).
[0024] The response generation unit 23 outputs the method set α determined by the combination determination unit 22 to the communication device 10 (step S23). It is possible that there are no common methods between lists L1 and L2, or that the method set α determined by the combination determination unit 22 does not satisfy the requested number of methods N. In such cases, the communication device 20 may be configured to output the maximum number of methods that can be output as method set α, or to output a negative result, and send the determined result to the communication device 10. If the number of methods N is specified by the communication device 10, the combination determination unit 22 may be configured to follow this, or may be configured to determine the number of methods by the communication device 20 itself. Alternatively, the combination determination unit 22 may be configured to determine the number of methods by comparing the number of methods included in list L1 with the number of methods included in list L2. If the combination determination unit 22 is configured to determine the number of methods by comparing lists L1 and L2, it may also be configured not to output a negative result to the communication device 10.
[0025] The response receiving unit 13 receives the method set α determined by the communication device 20, determines whether to perform authentication or key exchange using the method set α, and outputs the determination result R to the communication device 20 (step S13).
[0026] If the content of the judgment result R is an agreement on authentication or key exchange, the authentication / key exchange processing unit 14 and the authentication / key exchange processing unit 24 perform authentication processing or key exchange processing using multiple methods determined in the method set α (step S14, step S24).
[0027] If the content of the determination result R is non-agreement (NG) on authentication or key exchange, the authentication process or key exchange process is not performed (is aborted) by the communication device 10 and the communication device 20. Note that if the content of the determination result R is non-agreement (NG) on authentication or key exchange, the response receiving unit 13 may be configured not to output the determination result R to the communication device 20.
[0028] <Method of Determining Method Set α by Combination Determining Unit 22> The method of determining the method set α by the combination determining unit 22 is realized, for example, by performing the processes of steps S22-1 to S22-3 described below and shown in FIG.
[0029] The combination determination unit 22 generates a list of common methods (common list LC) (step S22-1). The combination determination unit 22 generates the common list LC indicating the methods listed in both lists, from list L1 received by the communication device 20 and list L2 generated (or possessed) by the communication device 20. For example, if list L1 lists methods A, B, C, D, and E and list L2 lists methods B, D, C, and F, the generated common list LC will list three methods: B, C, and D.
[0030] The combination determination unit 22 generates a list of extraction targets (target list LT) by excluding the specified method from the common list LC (step S22-2). The types of methods to be excluded from the common list LC may be configured as a list (exclusion list LX). The exclusion list LX may be received from the communication device 10 or may be stored in the communication device 20. For example, if the common list LC contains methods B, C, and D and B is listed in the exclusion list LX, the target list LT will contain two methods, C and D. If no method is listed in the exclusion list LX, the target list LT will contain content equivalent to that of a process that does not involve step S22-2. Alternatively, the process of step S22-2 may be omitted, and the common list LC may be used as the target list LT, and the processes from step S22-3 onward may be performed. Alternatively, the exclusion list LX may be generated by the communication device 20 inquiring of the communication device 10 about a compromised list of methods and based on the response.
[0031] The combination determination unit 22 applies an extraction method (extraction method EX) exemplified below to the target list LT (step S22-3). The method set α is determined by applying the extraction method EX to the target list LT. Specific examples of the extraction method EX are described in (1) to (5) below. Applying the extraction method EX allows for flexibility in how authentication methods or key exchange methods are combined. Regarding which extraction method EX to use, if the type of extraction method EX is specified by the communication device 10, the extraction method may be configured to follow that specification, or the communication device 20 may decide by itself. Alternatively, the method may be configured so that only either the communication device 10 or the communication device 20 can decide.
[0032] (1) Method based on priority This extraction method is applied when the information listed in List L1 and List L2 includes not only multiple methods used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled, but also information on the priority of each listed method within each list.
[0033] For example, as shown in Figure 4, list L1 lists five methods A, B, C, D, and E, with priorities A to E numbered 1 to 5. List L2 lists four methods B, D, C, and F, with priorities 1 to 4 in that order. In this example, the exclusion list LX for methods to be excluded contains no methods, and the number of methods to be extracted (number of methods N) is set to 2.
[0034] In the case of Figure 4, the target list LT after the processing of steps S22-1 and S22-2 described above consists of methods B, C, and D, which are surrounded by thick lines in Figure 4. Here, it is assumed that in the event of a tie, the method with the higher priority is extracted. Of methods B, C, and D in the target list LT, method B, which has the lowest total priority in lists L1 and L2, and of methods C and D with the same priority, method D, which has the higher priority, are extracted, and methods B and C are determined to be the method set α.
[0035] (2) Policy-based method In this extraction method, in addition to the multiple methods used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled as information listed in lists L1 and L2, a method set α is determined according to the method selection conditions (policy P) specified by communication device 10 or communication device 20.
[0036] In order to determine whether a policy P is fulfilled or not, attribute values necessary for the determination are assigned in advance to each policy P. Here, the following (a) to (c) are explained as examples of the policy P, but the policy P is not limited to these and other method selection conditions may also be used.
[0037] (a) Quantum Computer Resistance This is an extraction method in which quantum computer resistance is the policy P. One example is to assign attribute information of 1 / 0 indicating whether or not quantum computer resistance is available. Another example is to adopt the above-mentioned idea of priority and assign attribute information such as, in descending order of priority, 1: information theoretical security, 2: computational security, and 3: conventional encryption method not having quantum resistance.
[0038] (b) Key Length This is an extraction method in which the key length of the authentication key or exchange key is set as policy P. For example, a key with a longer length may be preferentially extracted.
[0039] (c) Designated Algorithm This is an extraction method in which a designated algorithm is used as policy P. For example, when an algorithm such as lattice cryptography, code-based cryptography, or multivariate public key cryptography is designated in list L1 or list L2, if the corresponding algorithm is extractable, it is conceivable that the algorithm is preferentially extracted (or not extracted).
[0040] (3) Method based on solving the knapsack problem This is an extraction method that uses the idea of solving the knapsack problem as policy P. In other words, this is an extraction method that extracts the optimal combination based on the weight values and the value value to be maximized.
[0041] For example, as shown in Figure 5A, suppose that methods A, B, C, D, and E are listed in list L1, and as other conditions, the weights of methods A to E are set as usage costs of 4, 3, 3, 3, and 2, respectively. Also, suppose that the security levels, as the value of each method, are set as 5, 2, 3, 4, and 1, respectively, respectively. Note that the indices for the weights and values of this extraction method are not limited to usage costs and security levels, and other indices may be used.
[0042] In the example of FIG. 5A, suppose the conditions specified are that the number of methods to be selected (method number N) is two and that the usage cost is seven or less. In this case, in step S22-3, a combination that maximizes the total security level is selected. FIG. 5B is a diagram showing the relationship between the possible combinations of methods and the usage costs in FIG. 5A. FIG. 5C is a diagram showing the relationship between the possible combinations of methods and the security levels in FIG. 5A. In this case, the combination of methods A and D, surrounded by a thick line in FIG. 5C, is determined as method set α, as the combination that maximizes the total security level and has a usage cost of seven or less.
[0043] (4) Method Based on Distance Between Sets Indicating Features This extraction method extracts optimal combinations based on a distance index between sets representing features corresponding to the methods. For example, when combining two methods with the most different features, the method extracts the two methods with the furthest distance (similarity) between the sets representing the features of each method in list L1 and list L2. Note that communication device 10 and communication device 20 may be configured to combine three or more methods by setting them.
[0044] In this extraction method, it is assumed that the attributes of the set are defined in advance between communication device 10 and communication device 20. For example, as shown in FIG. 6A , the characteristics of the algorithm are indicated by lowercase letters, each representing the following: a: lattice cryptography, b: code-based cryptography, c: multivariate public key cryptography, d: isogenous mapping cryptography, e: elliptic curve cryptography, f: third-party service. Resistance to quantum computers is indicated by numbers, each representing the following: 1: information-theoretic security, 2: computational security, 3: conventional cryptography (cryptography not resistant to quantum computers). Threat resistance is indicated by Greek letters, each representing the following: α: third-party involvement risk, β: side-channel attack risk.
[0045] Under the above definition, suppose that the target list LT for a certain case after steps S22-1 and S22-2 is as shown in Figure 6B, where Method A is (a, 2), Method B is (a, 2, β), Method C is (d, 2), Method D is (f, 1, α), and Method E is (e, 3, β).
[0046] In the example of Fig. 6B, if the number of methods to be selected (number of methods N) is two and the Simpson coefficient is used to calculate the distance between the sets, the distance between the sets will be as shown in Fig. 6C, where the Simpson coefficient S(X, Y) is calculated using the following formula (1): In formula (1), X and Y are sets. The denominator of formula (1) calculates the smaller of the number of elements in set X and the number of elements in set Y. The numerator of formula (1) calculates the number of common elements between set X and set Y. The value range of S(X, Y) is [0, 1], and the closer the distance, the closer it is to 1. For example, in the case of the combination of methods A and B shown in Figure 6B, the number of elements in method A is 2 and the number of elements in method B is 3, so the denominator of formula (1) is 2, which is the smaller number of elements. Furthermore, since the common element between methods A and B is (a, 2), the number of elements is 2, and the numerator of formula (1) is 2. Therefore, S(X, Y) = 2 / 2 = 1. Similarly, the Simpson coefficients calculated for the possible combinations are shown in Figure 6C. In the above description, the Simpson coefficient is used as the distance index between sets, but this embodiment is not limited to this, and other indices may be used as long as they can calculate the distance between sets, such as the Jaccard coefficient or the Dice coefficient.
[0047] (5) Combination Method This extraction method is an extraction method in which a plurality of methods are combined from among all possible extraction methods EX, including the above-mentioned methods (1) to (4) and extraction methods other than the above-mentioned methods (1) to (4). For example, an extraction method can be a combination of two or three of the above-mentioned methods (1) to (4).
[0048] For example, suppose a negotiation request between communication device 10 and communication device 20 specifies the following items (i) to (viii) in a case where a combination of three extraction methods, namely, (1) a priority-based method, (2) a policy-based method, and (4) a distance-based method between sets of characteristics, is applied. (i) Schemes A, B, C, D, and E are listed in list L1. (ii) The set of schemes A to E is listed in FIG. 6B under the definition in FIG. 6A. (iii) The number of schemes N is specified as 2. (iv) Nothing is listed in the exclusion list LX. (v) The usage priority of schemes (1) above is specified as 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, respectively. (vi) Policy P in (2) above specifies that quantum computer resistance should be configured as either 1: information-theoretic security or 2: computational security (see FIG. 6A). (vii) The condition in (4) above specifies that the usage cost must be equal to or less than 7. (viii) Methods A, B, C, D, E, F, and G are listed in list L2.
[0049] In this case, when three extraction methods, (1) a method based on priority, (2) a method based on policy, and (4) a method based on the distance between sets indicating characteristics, are combined, the target list LT after steps S22-1 and S22-2 will contain methods A, B, C, D, and E. Furthermore, as a result of applying the above methods (1), (2), and (4) in step S22-3, the combination of methods A and D will be determined as method set α.
[0050] The above is an example, and the combination method is not limited to this. For example, various conditions can be considered for determining the methods to be combined, such as combining methods with different resistances and as many resistances as possible (e.g., a combination in which the Simpson coefficient is not 1 and the denominator is the largest).
[0051] The scheme determination system 1 determines a scheme set α including multiple schemes from lists L1 and L2 based on a predetermined extraction method EX. Therefore, the system has flexibility in how authentication or key exchange schemes are combined, and can realize hybrid authentication or hybrid key exchange that can be implemented with a communication partner. Furthermore, by extracting scheme set α from schemes listed in both lists L1 and L2, hybrid authentication or hybrid key exchange can be implemented each time using the scheme that provides the most effective combination from a security perspective, tailored to the communication partner.
[0052] Although the embodiments of this disclosure have been described above, the specific configuration is not limited to the present embodiment, and it goes without saying that appropriate design changes, etc., are included in this disclosure as long as they do not deviate from the spirit of this disclosure. The various processes described in this embodiment may not only be executed chronologically in the order described, but may also be executed in parallel or individually depending on the processing capacity of the device executing the processes or as needed. For example, the process in Figure 3 may be configured to start with the process of step S22-2, and then proceed through the processes of steps S22-1 and S22-3 to determine the scheme set α.
[0053] [Program, Recording Medium] The various processes described above can be implemented by loading a program that executes each step of the above method into the recording unit 2020 of the computer 2000 shown in FIG. 7, and operating the control unit 2010, input unit 2030, output unit 2040, display unit 2050, etc.
[0054] The program describing the processing contents can be recorded on a computer-readable recording medium, which may be, for example, a magnetic recording device, an optical disk, a magneto-optical recording medium, a semiconductor memory, or any other suitable recording medium.
[0055] The program may be distributed by, for example, selling, transferring, lending, etc. portable recording media such as DVDs and CD-ROMs on which the program is recorded. Furthermore, the program may be stored in a storage device of a server computer, and then transferred from the server computer to other computers via a network, thereby distributing the program.
[0056] A computer that executes such a program may first temporarily store the program recorded on a portable recording medium or transferred from a server computer in its own storage device. Then, when executing a process, the computer reads the program stored on its own recording medium and executes the process in accordance with the read program. Alternatively, the computer may read the program directly from a portable recording medium and execute the process in accordance with the program. Furthermore, the computer may execute the process in accordance with each program transferred from the server computer. Alternatively, the server computer may not transfer the program to the computer, but may instead execute the process through a so-called ASP (Application Service Provider) service, which realizes the processing function by issuing an execution instruction and obtaining the results. In this embodiment, the program includes information used for processing by a computer that is equivalent to a program (e.g., data that is not a direct instruction to the computer but has properties that define computer processing).
[0057] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the device is configured by executing a predetermined program on a computer, but at least a part of the processing contents may be realized by hardware.
[0058] REFERENCE SIGNS LIST 1 Scheme determination system 10, 20 Communication device 11, 21 Communication unit 12 Request generation unit 13 Response reception unit 14, 24 Authentication / key exchange processing unit 22 Combination determination unit 23 Response generation unit A, B, C, D, E, F, G Scheme EX Extraction method L1, L2 List LC Common list LX Exclusion list LT Target list N Number of schemes P Policy R Judgment result α Scheme set
Claims
1. A scheme determination system for determining multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange, comprising: a first communication device; and a second communication device; the first communication device having a request generation unit that outputs a first list to the second communication device, the first list including multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the first communication device; and a response receiving unit that receives a scheme set that is a combination of the multiple schemes determined by the second communication device, and determines whether to perform authentication or key exchange using the scheme set; the second communication device having a combination determination unit that determines the scheme set from the first list and a second list including multiple schemes to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the second communication device, based on a predetermined extraction method; and a response generation unit that outputs the scheme set to the first communication device.
2. The method determination system according to claim 1, wherein the combination determination unit determines the method set from methods included in both the first list and the second list based on the specified extraction method.
3. The method determination system of claim 2, wherein the combination determination unit determines the method set based on the specified extraction method after excluding a specified method from methods included in both the first list and the second list.
4. The method determination system of claim 1, wherein the predetermined extraction method is an extraction method using at least one of a priority-based method, a policy-based method, a knapsack problem solution-based method, and a distance-based method between sets.
5. A communications device for determining multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange, comprising: a combination determination unit that determines a method set, which is a combination of multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange, based on a predetermined extraction method from a first list including multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by another communications device, and a second list including multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the communications device itself; and a response generation unit that outputs the determined method set to the other communications device.
6. A method for determining multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange, comprising: a first communication device outputs a first list including multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the first communication device to a second communication device; the second communication device determines a method set, which is the multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange, from the first list and a second list including multiple methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the second communication device based on a predetermined extraction method; the second communication device outputs the method set to the first communication device; and the first communication device receives the method set and determines whether to perform authentication or key exchange using the method set.
7. A method for determining a plurality of methods to be used for authentication or key exchange by a communications device, comprising the steps of: determining a method set, which is a combination of a plurality of methods to be used for authentication or key exchange, based on a predetermined extraction method from a first list including a plurality of methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by another communications device, and a second list including a plurality of methods to be used for authentication or key exchange that can be handled by the communications device itself; and outputting the determined method set to the other communications device.
8. A program for causing a computer to function as the communication device according to claim 5.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Rekeying a Security Association SA
JP2022519416A
