Multi-dimensional evaluation method for blast furnace process extreme energy efficiency technology

By constructing a ternary index system and the TOPSIS evaluation method, the problems of singularity and detachment from reality in the energy efficiency technology evaluation of blast furnace processes were solved, realizing multi-dimensional economic-environmental synergistic evaluation of blast furnace processes and providing accurate basis for technology selection.

CN120893908APending Publication Date: 2025-11-04HUAZHONG UNIV OF SCI & TECH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202511077786.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-08-01
Publication Date
2025-11-04

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies for evaluating the energy efficiency of blast furnace processes suffer from problems such as a single evaluation dimension, insufficient consideration of synergy, and a lack of specificity. They also lack a comprehensive analysis of the economic costs and environmental benefits throughout the entire life cycle of the blast furnace process.

Method used

A three-element index system based on the energy-saving supply curve model and cost-benefit analysis method is constructed. The energy-saving cost per unit of technology, net present value and internal rate of return are used as indicators. Combined with the TOPSIS evaluation method, the energy-saving and emission-reduction potential and economic feasibility of the blast furnace process are quantified, and a collaborative evaluation system of economic and environmental benefits is established.

Benefits of technology

It enables a multi-dimensional comprehensive evaluation of energy efficiency technologies for blast furnace processes, dynamically balances economic feasibility and environmental friendliness, provides a scientific basis for technology selection, and improves the accuracy and applicability of the evaluation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN120893908A_ABST
    Figure CN120893908A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a multi-dimensional evaluation method of a blast furnace process extreme energy efficiency technology, and relates to the field of steel production energy efficiency evaluation. Aiming at six extreme energy efficiency technologies of a blast furnace process, a'technical unit energy-saving cost (CCEa)-net present value (NPV)-internal return rate (IRR) 'ternary index system is constructed, an energy-saving supply curve and a cost-benefit analysis method are combined, and comprehensive evaluation is realized through four steps: calculating the energy-saving and emission-reducing potential when the blast furnace uses anthracite, and introducing exclusive emission factor correction; calculating the unit energy-saving cost considering the multi-pollutant synergistic benefit, and combining the exclusive reachable rate of the technology; the full-life-cycle cost effectiveness is analyzed from the perspective of enterprises, and technology maturity correction is introduced; and carrying out dynamic weighted sorting based on a TOPSIS method, and outputting technical priorities. The method breaks through the limitation of single-dimensional evaluation, realizes the collaborative evaluation of economic and environmental benefits, and provides a decision basis for the low-carbon transformation of the blast furnace.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

TECHNICAL FIELD

[0001] The present application relates to the field of steel production blast furnace process technology evaluation, and particularly relates to a comprehensive evaluation method for energy saving and emission reduction potential and energy saving cost change after application of extreme energy efficiency technology in steel production, which is suitable for quantitative analysis of "economic-environmental benefits" and selection decision of extreme energy efficiency technology of blast furnace process. BACKGROUND

[0002] As the core link of energy consumption and pollutant emission of steel industry, blast furnace process needs to realize energy efficiency improvement and cost reduction and emission reduction. The current evaluation of extreme energy efficiency technology for blast furnace process has significant limitations:

[0003] 1. Single evaluation dimension: the existing technology mainly uses single indicators such as ton iron energy consumption and thermal efficiency to evaluate energy saving effect, or only uses simple economic indicators to evaluate feasibility, lacking comprehensive analysis of economic cost and environmental benefits in the whole life cycle of the technology;

[0004] 2. Lack of coordination: steel production process is complex, and there is coupling correlation between economic benefits (such as energy saving benefits and cost recovery) and environmental impact (such as multi-pollutant emission reduction) of enterprises after the input of new technology, but the existing method does not establish a linkage evaluation mechanism of "energy saving-economy-environment";

[0005] 3. Lack of pertinence: the general evaluation model is not adapted to the specific process characteristics (such as multi-energy medium coupling and non-smoke coal fuel structure) of blast furnace process, resulting in disconnection between the evaluation results and actual production needs.

[0006] Therefore, it is urgent to develop a comprehensive evaluation method from the perspectives of technology and enterprise, which can simultaneously quantify energy saving and emission reduction potential, economic feasibility and environmental benefits, and provide a scientific basis for selection of extreme energy efficiency technology of blast furnace process. SUMMARY

[0007] (1) Invention purpose

[0008] The present application aims to overcome the single dimension limitation of blast furnace process energy efficiency technology evaluation in the prior art, and provides a multi-dimensional comprehensive evaluation method, which realizes the coordinated evaluation of economic feasibility and environmental benefits of extreme energy efficiency technology by constructing a three-index system of "technology unit energy saving cost-net present value-internal rate of return", and provides a quantitative basis for selection of technology route of steel enterprises, and promotes the dynamic balance between technology economy and environmental friendliness in low-carbon transformation of blast furnace process.

[0009] (2) Technical scheme

[0010] For six kinds of extreme energy efficiency technologies of blast furnace process, combined with the cost saving supply curve (CSC) model and cost-benefit analysis method, the technology unit energy saving cost (CCE a), net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR) three indicators, to establish a comprehensive evaluation system of "economic-environmental benefits" based on TOPSIS evaluation, the specific steps are as follows:

[0011] Step 1: Calculate the energy saving and emission reduction potential of technology

[0012] This step provides the core basic data for subsequent evaluation, by quantifying the energy saving potential and multi-pollutant emission reduction, to establish the correlation between technology and environmental benefits, and introduce the exclusive parameters of blast furnace for correction:

[0013] The formula for calculating the energy saving potential of blast furnace using anthracite: ESP T = ECR P × HV sc × Q × 0.9428

[0014] ESP T : the energy saving potential of technology when blast furnace uses anthracite, GJ; ECR P : the process energy consumption reduction of technology, kgce / t-iron; HV sc is the standard coal heat value, 3GJ / kg, Q is the product output, t.

[0015] The formula for calculating the pollutant emission reduction amount adapted to the fuel characteristics of blast furnace anthracite:

[0016]

[0017] i is CO2 or SO2 or NO x or inhalable particulate matter (PM 10 ); is the emission reduction amount of corresponding pollutants (kg) when blast furnace uses anthracite; indicates the respective anthracite emission factors of the four substances, see Table 1: CO2 is 2.460tCO2 / tce, SO2 is 5.0tSO2 / tce (exclusive for anthracite), NO x is 1.1tNOx / tce (exclusive for anthracite), PM 10 is 2.2tPM 10 / tce (exclusive for anthracite); 0.9428 is the anthracite conversion factor. For the characteristics of blast furnace coal, exclusive emission factors and conversion factors of anthracite are used for correction to ensure that the calculation of pollutant emission reduction is consistent with actual production.

[0018] Table 1 Standard coal greenhouse gas and pollutant emission factors

[0019]

[0020] Note: SO2, NO x and PM 105.0tSO2 / tce, 1.1tNOx / tce and 2.2tPM / tce X 10 The anthracite coal conversion factor is 0.9428, and the data is from the energy statistics report system formulated by the National Bureau of Statistics.

[0021] Step 1: Energy consumption reduction amount ECR P This core parameter links the energy-saving potential of blast furnaces using anthracite coal with pollutant emission reduction, forming a quantitative basis for "energy saving and emission reduction", and using anthracite coal parameters specific to blast furnaces for correction to ensure that the basic data are consistent with the actual process, providing data support for subsequent coupling analysis of economic cost and environmental benefits.

[0022] Step 2: Calculate the energy-saving cost per unit of technology considering synergistic benefits

[0023] Based on the energy-saving and emission reduction data in Step 1, integrate the life cycle cost of technology and environmental benefits, introduce the synergistic mechanism of multiple pollutants and technology-specific achievable rate, and quantify the economic nature of the technology itself:

[0024]

[0025] Where:

[0026] CCE a is the unit energy-saving cost after considering the synergistic benefits of energy-saving, emission reduction and pollution reduction, yuan / GJ;

[0027] C is the comprehensive cost of technology (yuan), and the calculation formula is: K is the capital cost (yuan / t), d is the discount rate (10%), n is the technology life (years), and ΔO&M is the annual operation and maintenance cost;

[0028] EB is the energy-saving benefit of blast furnace using anthracite coal (yuan / year), and the calculation formula is: EB = ECR P × Q × P sc × 0.9428 (P sc is the standard coal price);

[0029] CO2 emission reduction benefit of blast furnace using anthracite coal (yuan / year), calculation formula: ( CO2 price, see Table 2);

[0030] Atmospheric pollutant emission reduction benefit of blast furnace using anthracite coal (yuan / year), calculation formula: ( see Table 2);

[0031] ​ The atmospheric pollutant synergistic emission reduction benefit for the blast furnace using anthracite (yuan / year) (introducing the synergistic elasticity coefficient a): Where, a = 0.35 (the synergistic elasticity coefficient of CO2 and SO2 emission reduction in the blast furnace combustion process, through 3200m 3 Fitting of the measured data of the blast furnace); The industry average CO2 emission reduction amount;

[0032] Table 2 Carbon dioxide and main atmospheric pollutants price / monetization value

[0033]

[0034] TA i The technology-specific achievable rate (%):

[0035] High-efficiency blast furnace gas recovery technology: TA 煤气回收 = 0.7 + 0.3 x η (η is the coal gas recovery rate, the value range is [0.8, 1.0]);

[0036] Oxy-combustion technology: TA 富氧燃烧 = 0.85 + 0.005 x (ω - 21) (ω is the oxygen purity, the value range is [21, 30]).

[0037] Step 2, by calculating the net difference of "cost-energy saving benefit-emission reduction benefit", the environmental benefit (ER i 高炉 ) of step 1 is converted into economic value And introducing a coefficient to quantify the synergistic benefit of pollutants, combined with the correction of the actual application efficiency of the technology-specific achievable rate, breaking through the traditional single cost accounting mode, finally obtaining the unit energy saving cost CCE a reflecting the economic nature of the technology itself.

[0038] Step 3: Enterprise cost-benefit analysis

[0039] Based on the cost and benefit data of step 2, the economic feasibility of the technology full life cycle is evaluated from the enterprise perspective:

[0040] Net present value (NPV) calculation formula:

[0041] The internal rate of return (IRR) meets:

[0042] Where, CF i is the cash inflow in the i-th year (yuan), CF Directly quoted the benefit data of Step 2), CF0 is the initial investment (ten thousand yuan), r is the discount rate (8%), n is the project life (20 years), TRL (Technology Readiness Level): Technology Maturity, divided into 5 levels between 0-1.

[0043] Step 3: The energy saving benefit (EB) and emission reduction benefit of the blast furnace in Step 2 are integrated into the enterprise cash flow (CF i ), which quantifies the long-term economic value of the technology to the enterprise through NPV and IRR, and introduces technology maturity (TRL) correction to make the evaluation more in line with the actual decision-making needs of the enterprise.

[0044] Step 4: TOPSIS evaluation

[0045] Integrate the index data of Step 2 and Step 3, and determine the technology priority through multi-objective decision-making method:

[0046] Standardize the index (max / min index is processed respectively);

[0047] Max index standardization processing (NPV, IRR):

[0048]

[0049] Min index standardization processing (CCE a ):

[0050]

[0051] Construct the weighted matrix Z:

[0052] Z=(z ij ) n×m =(x′ ij *w j )(w j is the weight, w NPV =0.3,w IRR =0.2);

[0053] Determine the positive and negative ideal solutions:

[0054] (Reference blast furnace industry benchmark, such as optimal CCE=120 yuan / GJ)

[0055] (Take the blast furnace technology limit value, such as CCE upper limit=300 yuan / GJ);

[0056] Calculate the distance of each sample from the positive and negative ideal solutions:

[0057]

[0058] Calculate the closeness of each evaluation object to the optimal scheme:

[0059]

[0060] According to C i Sort to determine the priority of the technology.

[0061] Step 4 combines the unit energy saving cost (CCE a ) of the technology level with the NPV and IRR of the enterprise level, and the ideal solution is anchored to the actual blast furnace industry to solve the defects of traditional TOPSIS that are detached from the process scene, and outputs accurate technology selection sorting to provide clear decision conclusions for enterprises.

[0062] (3) Advantage

[0063] 1. Breakthrough single-dimensional evaluation limitations: existing technologies rely on a single indicator, and the present invention dynamically correlates energy saving potential, multi-pollutant emission reduction and economic benefits through a three-dimensional index system, and quantifies the linkage value with the help of synergistic elasticity, solving the one-sidedness of traditional evaluation.

[0064] 2. Adapt to the characteristics of blast furnace process: According to the characteristics of blast furnace anthracite fuel, exclusive emission factors and modified calculation of standard coal coefficients are used to customize the achievable rate formula for different technologies, so that the deviation rate of the evaluation results from the actual process is reduced.

[0065] 3. Build a full-process logical closed loop: from basic data collection to comprehensive sorting, the data of each step is mutually referenced to form a complete closed loop. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS

[0066] Figure 1 The flowchart of the calculation steps of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0067] In order to make the technical scheme of the present invention clearer, the following will be combined with the actual production data of a 3200m 3 high blast furnace to explain the technical scheme of the present invention in detail. The blast furnace uses anthracite as the main fuel, with an annual capacity of 1.8 million tons, and six extreme energy efficiency technologies (high-efficiency blast furnace gas recovery, oxygen-enriched combustion, waste heat recovery, etc.) are planned to be evaluated, and the specific steps are as follows:

[0068] Example: Extreme energy efficiency technology evaluation based on a 3200m 3 high blast furnace

[0069] Step 1: Calculate the energy saving and emission reduction potential of the technology

[0070] Take "high-efficiency blast furnace gas recovery technology" as an example, the known data is:

[0071] Energy consumption reduction ECR P = 8.5 kgce / t-iron;

[0072] Product output Q = 180 x 10 4 t;

[0073] Standard coal heat value HV sc = 3 GJ / kg;

[0074] Anthracite coal conversion factor = 0.9428;

[0075] Anthracite coal emission factor (Table 1): CO2= 2.460 tCO2 / tce,

[0076] Calculation process:

[0077] (1) Energy saving potential (ESP T ):

[0078] ESP T = ECR P x HV sc x Q x 0.9428 = 8.5 x 3 x 180 x 104 x 0.9428 = 4.27 x 10 6 GJ / year

[0079] (2) Pollutant emission reduction

[0080]

[0081] Similarly, the calculation results are:

[0082] Step 2: Calculate the energy saving cost of technical unit considering synergistic benefits

[0083] Known data:

[0084] Capital cost K = 120 yuan / t, discount rate d = 10%, technical life n = 15 years, annual operation and maintenance cost ΔO&M = 5 million yuan / year;

[0085] Standard coal price P sc = 1200 yuan / t;

[0086] Pollutant price (Table 2):

[0087] Coal gas recovery rate η = 0.92 (corresponding to the achievable rate TA 煤气回收 = 0.7 + 0.3 x 0.92 = 0.976);

[0088] Industry average CO2 emission reduction Synergy elasticity coefficient a = 0.35.

[0089] Calculation process:

[0090] Technical comprehensive cost (C):

[0091]

[0092] Energy saving benefit (EB):

[0093] EB = 8.5 x 180 x 10 4 × 1200 x 0.9428 ≈ 1.71 x 10 7 yuan / year

[0094] Emission reduction benefit:

[0095]

[0096] Synergy correction:

[0097]

[0098] Unit energy saving cost (CCE a ):

[0099]

[0100] Step 3: Enterprise cost benefit analysis

[0101] Known data:

[0102] Initial investment CF0 = 2.8 x 10 4 million yuan;

[0103] Discount rate r = 8%, project life n = 20 years;

[0104] Technical maturity TRL = 0.8 (corresponding to the fourth level);

[0105] Annual cash inflow

[0106] Calculation process:

[0107] 1. Net present value 2. Internal rate of return (IRR):

[0108] Through iterative calculation

[0109] Step 4: TOPSIS evaluation

[0110] Repeat steps 1-3 for the six technologies to obtain index data:

[0111]

[0112] Evaluation process:

[0113] 1. Index standardization (with large index NPV, IRR and small index CCE a as an example);

[0114] 2. Weighted matrix (weight w NPV = 0.3, w IRR = 0.2);

[0115] 3. Positive and negative ideal solution: Z + = [max(z ij )], Z - = [min(z ij )];

[0116] 4. Proximity calculation: the gas efficient recovery technology C i ≈ 0.82, the oxygen-enriched combustion technology C i ≈ 0.78, so the priority is "gas efficient recovery > oxygen-enriched combustion".

[0117] Conclusion

[0118] This example verifies the feasibility of the present application through the actual data of a 3200m 3 high furnace, each step strictly follows the formula and logic of the technical scheme, the calculation result can be directly used for the technical selection decision, and it is proved that the present application has practical application value.

Claims

1. A multi-dimensional evaluation method for ultimate energy efficiency technology in blast furnace processes, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: Step 1: Calculate the energy saving and emission reduction potential of the technology. Based on the characteristics of blast furnaces using anthracite, calculate the energy saving potential (ESP) using a formula. T ) and pollutant emission reduction Among them ESP T =ECR P ×HV sc ×Q×0.9428, This represents the anthracite emission factor for each of the four substances; Step 2: Calculate the cost per unit of energy saving (CCE) that takes into account synergistic benefits. a The formula is: in To introduce the synergistic elasticity coefficient (α = 0.35) of the synergistic emission reduction benefits of using anthracite in blast furnaces, TA i For technology-specific reachability; Step 3: Conduct a cost-benefit analysis of the enterprise, and calculate the net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). IRR satisfies CF i This represents the annual cash inflow in year i. Step 4: Conduct a comprehensive evaluation based on the TOPSIS method, through index standardization, constructing a weighted matrix, and calculating the closeness (C). i Sorting determines the priority of technologies.

2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 1, the anthracite emission factors of the four substances are respectively... Including: CO2 of 2.460 tCO2 / tce, SO2 of 5.0 tSO2 / tce, NO x 1.1tNO x / tce, PM 10 2.2tPM 10 / tce; 0.9428 is the standard coal conversion factor for anthracite.

3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 2, the formula for calculating the comprehensive technology cost (C) is as follows: Where K is the cost of capital (yuan / t), d is the discount rate, n is the technology life (years), and ΔO&M is the annual operation and maintenance cost.

4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 2, the energy saving benefit (EB) = ECR P ×Q×P sc ×0.9428, P sc The price is the standard coal price; 5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 2, the in 6. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 2, the technology-specific reachability (TA) i )include: High-efficiency blast furnace gas recovery technology: TA 煤气回收 =0.7 + 0.3 × η, where η is the gas recovery rate (0.8 ≤ η ≤ 1.0); Oxygen-enriched combustion technology: TA 富氧燃烧 =0.85+0.005×(ω-21), where ω is the oxygen purity (21≤ω≤30).

7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 3, the cash inflow in the i-th year TRL stands for Technology Maturity Level (0-1), and r is the discount rate.

8. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 4, the weights of the weighting matrix are: w NPV =0.3,w IRR =0.2; The standardized formula for extremely large indicators is Minimal indicators are 9. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step 4, the proximity These represent the distances from the positive and negative ideal solutions, respectively. The positive ideal solution is based on the benchmark of the blast furnace industry, while the negative ideal solution represents the technical limit of the blast furnace.

10. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The ultimate energy efficiency technology includes at least one of the following: high-efficiency recovery of blast furnace gas, oxygen-enriched combustion, and waste heat recovery.