Method for measuring reactor core power under low power of nuclear power plant
By utilizing the thermal balance between the primary and secondary sides of the steam generator under low power conditions in nuclear power plants, measuring the heat sources outside the reactor core and the decay heat power, and calibrating the decay heat formula, the problem of accuracy in reactor core power measurement under low power conditions in nuclear power plants was solved, and the scientific nature of commissioning and mode switching was improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202511936518.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-12-22
- Publication Date
- 2026-04-14
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies cannot accurately measure core power at low power levels in nuclear power plants, leading to uncertainties in commissioning tests and mode switching, especially during prototype reactor commissioning.
By utilizing the thermal balance or quasi-thermal balance of the primary and secondary sides of the steam generator at low power, the power of the heat source outside the reactor core and the decay heat power are measured, and the input parameters in the semi-empirical formula for decay heat are calibrated. The reactor core power is then measured using the method of separation of variables.
It enables accurate measurement of core power at low power levels, improving the scientific rigor and accuracy of commissioning tests and mode transitions, and reducing uncertainties.
Smart Images

Figure CN121862469A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of reactor design and operation technology, and specifically relates to a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions. Background Technology
[0002] The power output of a typical pressurized water reactor nuclear power plant can be classified in different ways. Based on the location of generation, it can be divided into core power, primary loop power, and secondary loop power. Core power, based on the measurement method, can be further divided into nuclear power and thermal power. During the power increase process, the coefficients of core nuclear power and thermal power are not constant and need to be calibrated at different power levels. The conventional power calibration method is the primary and secondary loop thermal balance measurement method. This involves measuring the thermal power using a test instrumentation system under primary and secondary loop thermal balance conditions to obtain the primary loop thermal power; then subtracting the thermal power outside the core (including main pump power, charging and discharging power, etc.) from the primary loop thermal power to obtain the core thermal power; finally, the coefficients of the nuclear instrumentation system are calibrated using the core thermal power to obtain the core nuclear power.
[0003] The test instrumentation system operates only after the condenser is in operation, with a minimum power of 3%FP. At this power level, the power measurement method yields an error of approximately 25%, making it unsuitable for calibrating other power levels. However, some commissioning tests require operation at a fixed power level, such as the natural circulation heat transfer test: to verify that core decay heat (simulated using 3%FP reactor power) can be carried away by the steam generator through primary loop natural circulation (main pumps shut down). Furthermore, the operational technical specifications also use 2%FP of core thermal power as the basis for transitioning from Mode 2 to Mode 1.
[0004] This leads to a paradox: at low power levels, there is no measured core power as a baseline, but relevant commissioning tests and mode transitions require accurate core thermal power. The traditional approach is to calculate using coefficients from similar units, which can meet the requirements to some extent, but it is not scientifically rigorous, especially during prototype reactor commissioning, where this approach introduces significant uncertainties. Summary of the Invention
[0005] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions. This method utilizes the thermal balance or quasi-thermal balance of the primary and secondary sides of the steam generator to achieve power cross-calibration and obtain accurate core power under low power conditions.
[0006] Technical solution to achieve the purpose of this invention:
[0007] A method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions includes:
[0008] Step 1: During the initial zero-power commissioning, measure the thermal power of heat sources outside the reactor core;
[0009] Step 2: Measure the power of decay heat during the zero-power period after power operation;
[0010] Step 3: Use the measured decay heat to calibrate the input parameter of the semi-empirical decay heat formula, which is the time remaining until the reactor shutdown time.
[0011] Step 4: Measure the core power at low power after operation.
[0012] Step 1 includes: during the initial zero-power commissioning period, there is no decay heat in the reactor core, and the nuclear heat output is negligible; the heat output on the primary side of the steam generator is the heat output outside the reactor core, and the heat output on the secondary side of the steam generator is the heat output emitted into the air after the feedwater evaporates; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the heat output outside the reactor core is calculated based on the heat output emitted into the air after the feedwater evaporates.
[0013] In step 1, the formula for calculating the thermal power outside the reactor core is:
[0014]
[0015] In the formula:
[0016] —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from heat sources outside the reactor core;
[0017] W TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air;
[0018] W ΔSG —Increased thermal power from the steam generator;
[0019] W TTB —The heat power lost during steam generator blowdown;
[0020] V i —Water supply flow rate;
[0021] V e —Sewage discharge flow;
[0022] V ΔSG —The water volume increase flow rate per unit time in the steam generator;
[0023] ρ i —Water supply density;
[0024] ρ e —Sewage discharge density;
[0025] ρ SG —Saturated water density;
[0026] H i —Specific enthalpy of water supply;
[0027] He —Specific enthalpy of wastewater discharge;
[0028] H r —Latent heat of vaporization;
[0029] H w —Specific enthalpy of saturated water;
[0030] H g — Enthalpy of saturated vapor.
[0031] Step 2 includes: during the zero-power period after power operation, there is decay heat in the reactor core and heat sources outside the reactor core, and the core core heating power is negligible; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the core decay heat power in the current state is calculated based on the heat power of steam discharged into the air and the heat power outside the reactor core.
[0032] In step 2, the formula for calculating the core decay heat power in the current state is:
[0033]
[0034] In the formula:
[0035] W′ D —Current state of core decay thermal power;
[0036] W′ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state;
[0037] W′ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state;
[0038] W′ TTB —The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state;
[0039] —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from external heat sources in the current state, using values measured during the initial zero-power period. replace.
[0040] Step 3 includes: using the core decay heat power obtained from the calculation formula of the current state in step 2, calibrating the time from the current reactor shutdown time in the semi-empirical formula of decay heat, and back-calculating the equivalent shutdown time.
[0041] In step 3, the semi-empirical formula for decay heat is:
[0042] W D(t,T) =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 )
[0043] In the formula:
[0044] W D(t,T) —The decay heat of the reactor after it has been running for T days and shut down for t days;
[0045] t—Time remaining until the reactor shutdown time;
[0046] T—Reactor operating time, expressed in days at equivalent full power;
[0047] P—Reactor's long-term stable operating power before shutdown;
[0048] Using the core decay heat power obtained in step 2, the time from the reactor shutdown time in the semi-empirical formula for decay heat is calibrated. The formula is as follows:
[0049] W D(t,T) =W′ D =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 )
[0050] Iterate for t until the equation holds true, and then deduce the equivalent shutdown time.
[0051] Step 4 includes: increasing the unit power to approximately 1%FP and stabilizing it for a period of time before the condenser is put into operation; at this time, there are core power, decay heat, and external heat sources in the reactor core; among them, decay heat and core power are coupled together, and the method of separation of variables is used to ignore the influence of 1%FP core power on decay heat, and decay heat is calculated using a semi-empirical formula for decay heat; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the core power in the current state is calculated based on the external heat power and the core decay heat power in the current state.
[0052] In step 4, the formula for calculating the core power in the current state is:
[0053]
[0054] In the formula:
[0055] W″ R —The current core power refers to the power generated by nuclear fission;
[0056] W″ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state;
[0057] W″ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state;
[0058] W″ TTB—The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state;
[0059] —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from external heat sources in the current state, using values measured during the initial zero-power period. replace;
[0060] W″ D —The core decay thermal power in the current state, i.e., W D(t,T) .
[0061] The beneficial technical effects of this invention are as follows:
[0062] 1. This invention provides a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions. During the initial zero-power commissioning period, the measured secondary loop thermal power is used to obtain accurate power of external heat sources.
[0063] 2. The present invention provides a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions. During the zero-power period after power operation, the measured secondary loop thermal power is used to subtract the power of heat sources other than the core. To obtain accurate decay heat power W′ D .
[0064] 3. This invention provides a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions, using accurate decay thermal power W′. D Calibrate the semi-empirical formula for decay heat W D(t,T) The equivalent shutdown time is obtained by back-calculating the input parameter t.
[0065] 4. The present invention provides a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions. Under low power conditions, the measured secondary loop thermal power is used to subtract the power of heat sources other than the core. and calibrated decay heat power W D ″ To obtain accurate core power. Attached Figure Description
[0066] Figure 1 A flowchart of a method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant under low power conditions provided by the present invention;
[0067] Figure 2 This is a graph showing the change of coolant temperature over time during the commissioning of the hot zero-power state in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0068] Figure 3 This is a graph showing the change of core decay heat power over time in an actual unit according to an embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0069] The present invention will now be described in further detail with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0070] like Figure 1 As shown, this invention provides a method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions, specifically including the following steps:
[0071] Step 1: During the initial zero-power commissioning, measure the thermal power of heat sources outside the reactor core.
[0072] During the initial zero-power commissioning, there is no decay heat within the reactor core, and the core remains below the Doppler heating point, meaning the nuclear heat power is negligible. The primary-side thermal power of the steam generator consists of the power generated outside the core, such as the main pumps and the charging and discharging systems. The secondary-side thermal power is the power released into the atmosphere after feedwater evaporation. By adjusting the opening of the atmospheric release valve on the main steam pipeline, the average temperature of the primary coolant is kept stable, and the steam generator pressure is controlled at the pressure value corresponding to the load. At this time, the unit is in thermal equilibrium, and the following relationship can be obtained:
[0073]
[0074] In the formula:
[0075] —The heat power input to the reactor coolant system from heat sources outside the reactor core, such as the main pump and the charging and discharging pumps;
[0076] W TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air;
[0077] W ΔSG —Increased thermal power from the steam generator;
[0078] W TTB —The heat power lost during steam generator blowdown;
[0079] Expanding formula (1), we get:
[0080]
[0081] In the formula:
[0082] V i —Water supply flow rate;
[0083] V e —Sewage discharge flow;
[0084] V ΔSG —Water volume growth rate per unit time in the steam generator;
[0085] ρ i —Water supply density;
[0086] ρ e—Sewage discharge density;
[0087] ρ SG —Saturated water density;
[0088] H i —Specific enthalpy of water supply;
[0089] H e —Specific enthalpy of wastewater discharge;
[0090] H r —Latent heat of vaporization;
[0091] H w —Specific enthalpy of saturated water;
[0092] H g — Enthalpy of saturated vapor.
[0093] Step 2: Measure the power of decay heat during the zero-power period after power operation.
[0094] During the zero-power period after power operation, the reactor core contains decay heat and heat sources outside the core, such as the main pumps and charging / draining systems. The core is still below the Doppler heating point, meaning the nuclear heat output is negligible. When the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the following relationship can be obtained:
[0095]
[0096] In the formula:
[0097] W′ D —Current state of core decay thermal power;
[0098] W′ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state;
[0099] W′ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state;
[0100] W′ TTB —The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state;
[0101] —The heat power input to the reactor coolant system from heat sources outside the reactor core, such as the main pumps and charging / draining systems, in the current state can be measured during the initial zero-power period. replace.
[0102] Step 3: Using the measured decay heat, calibrate the input parameter t of the semi-empirical decay heat formula, which is the current time t from the reactor shutdown time.
[0103] The decay heat after reactor shutdown is caused by captured products. 239 U and 239The decay heat consists of the decay heat generated by Np, as well as the decay heat generated by other actinide nuclides besides 239U and 239Np, and their fission products. Rigorous decay heat calculations should follow relevant standards, but these are quite complex. In engineering practice, simplified semi-empirical decay heat formulas are generally sufficient. The semi-empirical decay heat formula is as follows:
[0104] W D(t,T) =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 )……(4)
[0105] In the formula:
[0106] W D(t,T) —The decay heat (MW) of the reactor after it has been running for T days and shut down for t days;
[0107] t—Time (days) remaining until the reactor shutdown time;
[0108] T—Reactor operating time, expressed in days at equivalent full power;
[0109] P—Reactor's long-term stable operating power (MW) before shutdown.
[0110] The calculation result of formula (4) is only related to three known parameters: P, T, and t. Among them, P and T are fixed, while t needs to be calibrated according to the actual situation. During the actual shutdown process, the unit may stay at different power platforms, causing the accumulation of decay parameter precursor nuclei to be inconsistent with the model of the semi-empirical formula. Therefore, the decay thermal power W′ obtained by formula (3) needs to be used. D Calibrate t, that is:
[0111] W D(t,T) =W′ D =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 )……(5)
[0112] Iterate for t until the equation holds true, and then deduce the equivalent shutdown time.
[0113] Step 4: Measure the core power at low power levels after operation.
[0114] The unit's power output is increased to approximately 1% FP (the higher the power, the smaller the error), and then stabilized for a period before the condenser is put into operation. During this time, the reactor core contains core power, decay heat, and external heat sources such as the main pumps and charging / draining systems. Decay heat is coupled with core power; using the method of separation of variables, the influence of 1% FP core power on decay heat is ignored, and the decay heat is calculated using a semi-empirical formula W. D(t,T)The calculations show that when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the following relationship can be obtained:
[0115]
[0116] In the formula:
[0117] W″ R —The current core power refers to the power generated by nuclear fission;
[0118] W″ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state;
[0119] W″ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state;
[0120] W″ TTB —The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state;
[0121] —The heat power input to the reactor coolant system from heat sources outside the reactor core, such as the main pumps and charging / draining systems, in the current state can be measured during the initial zero-power period. replace.
[0122] W″ D —The core decay thermal power in the current state, i.e., W D(t,T) .
[0123] Example 1
[0124] Taking the first cycle of a prototype reactor unit as an example, this invention provides a detailed explanation of a method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant under low power conditions, specifically including the following steps:
[0125] Step 1: During the initial zero-power commissioning, measure the thermal power of heat sources outside the reactor core.
[0126] Step 1.1: During the commissioning of the hot zero-power state, export the unit data related to the calculation at a frequency of one point per minute. Select a period of time where the average temperature fluctuation of the primary loop coolant is small but the average value is stable [12:28-14:52], such as... Figure 2 The interval between the two black dashed lines is shown.
[0127] Step 1.2: Calculate the physical property parameters based on the average values of each thermal parameter during the time period [12:28-14:52]. The parameter data are shown in Table 1.
[0128] Table 1. Unit physical property data during the initial zero-power period of commissioning [12:28-14:52]
[0129]
[0130] Since the thermal parameters of the three loops are very similar, the average value of the thermal parameters of the three loops is used directly instead.
[0131] Step 1.3: Combining the average values of other parameters during this time period [12:28-14:52], calculate the power on the secondary side of the steam generator.
[0132] Table 2 Data on water supply volumetric flow rate, SG water volumetric growth flow rate, and wastewater discharge flow rate during the initial zero-power commissioning period.
[0133]
[0134] The SG level change is the average of the level changes of multiple level gauges during the start and end times of [12:28-14:52].
[0135] The result is obtained according to formula (2):
[0136]
[0137] Step 2: Measure the core decay heat at zero power after operation.
[0138] During the zero-power period of the unit, the unit data related to the calculation is exported at a frequency of one point per minute. The data is processed according to the method in steps 1.1-1.3, and the results are shown in Table 3-4.
[0139] Table 3. Unit physical property data at zero power after operation.
[0140]
[0141] Table 4 Data on water supply volumetric flow rate, SG water volumetric growth flow rate, and wastewater discharge flow rate under zero power conditions after operation.
[0142]
[0143] Similarly, the calculation yields:
[0144]
[0145] The result is obtained according to formula (3):
[0146]
[0147] Step 3: Use the measured decay heat to calibrate the input parameter t of the semi-empirical formula for decay heat.
[0148] Given that P = 3073 MW and T = 286 days (equivalent full power days) before shutdown, substituting into formula (5), we get t = 2.33 days.
[0149] like Figure 3 As shown, the actual unit reduced its power to zero at 6:00 on October 1, 2025, and the power output remained at zero until 8:00 on October 3, with a time interval of t = 2.08 days. To make the calculated decay heat more accurate, t is replaced with 2.33 days instead of 2.08 days, and the equivalent shutdown time is calculated to be 0:04 on October 1, 2025.
[0150] Step 4: Measure the core power at low power levels after operation.
[0151] During periods of low unit power, the relevant unit data is exported at a frequency of one point per minute. The time period on October 4th, when the average temperature of the primary coolant in the first loop fluctuates less but the average value is stable [1:46-2:05], is selected.
[0152] Based on formula (4) and the equivalent shutdown time obtained in step 3, the calibrated decay heat W is calculated. D ″ It is 8.933MW.
[0153] The data was processed according to steps 1.1-1.3, and the results are shown in Table 5-6.
[0154] Table 5. Unit physical property data under low power conditions after operation.
[0155]
[0156] Table 6 Data on water supply volumetric flow rate, SG water volume increase flow rate, and wastewater discharge flow rate under low power conditions after operation.
[0157]
[0158] Similarly, the calculation yields:
[0159]
[0160] ×12.236 / 3600×994.277=43.610MW
[0161] The core power in the current state is calculated according to formula (6):
[0162]
[0163] The present invention has been described in detail above with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments. However, the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and various changes can be made within the scope of knowledge possessed by those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit of the present invention. All contents not described in detail in the present invention can be derived from existing technologies.
Claims
1. A method for measuring the core power of a nuclear power plant under low power conditions, characterized in that, include: Step 1: During the initial zero-power commissioning, measure the thermal power of heat sources outside the reactor core; Step 2: Measure the power of decay heat during the zero-power period after power operation; Step 3: Use the measured decay heat to calibrate the input parameter of the semi-empirical decay heat formula, which is the time remaining until the reactor shutdown time. Step 4: Measure the core power at low power after operation.
2. The method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step 1 includes: during the initial zero-power commissioning period, there is no decay heat in the reactor core, and the nuclear heat output is negligible; the heat output on the primary side of the steam generator is the heat output outside the reactor core, and the heat output on the secondary side of the steam generator is the heat output emitted into the air after the feedwater evaporates; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the heat output outside the reactor core is calculated based on the heat output emitted into the air after the feedwater evaporates.
3. The method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 2, characterized in that, In step 1, the formula for calculating the thermal power outside the reactor core is: In the formula: —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from heat sources outside the reactor core; W TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air; W ΔSG —Increased thermal power from the steam generator; W TTB —The heat power lost during steam generator blowdown; V i —Water supply flow rate; V e —Sewage discharge flow; V ΔSG —The water volume increase flow rate per unit time in the steam generator; ρ i —Water supply density; ρ e —Sewage discharge density; ρ SG —Saturated water density; H i —Specific enthalpy of water supply; H e —Specific enthalpy of wastewater discharge; H r —Latent heat of vaporization; H w —Specific enthalpy of saturated water; H g — Specific enthalpy of saturated vapor.
4. The method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 3, characterized in that, Step 2 includes: during the zero-power period after power operation, there is decay heat in the reactor core and heat sources outside the reactor core, and the core core heating power is negligible; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the core decay heat power in the current state is calculated based on the heat power of steam discharged into the air and the heat power outside the reactor core.
5. The method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant under low power conditions according to claim 4, characterized in that, In step 2, the formula for calculating the core decay heat power in the current state is: In the formula: W′ D —Current state core decay thermal power; W′ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state; W′ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state; W′ TTB —The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state; —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from external heat sources in the current state, using values measured during the initial zero-power period. replace.
6. A method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant under low power conditions according to claim 5, characterized in that, Step 3 includes: using the core decay heat power obtained from the calculation formula of the current state in step 2, calibrating the time from the current reactor shutdown time in the semi-empirical formula of decay heat, and back-calculating the equivalent shutdown time.
7. A method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 6, characterized in that, In step 3, the semi-empirical formula for decay heat is: W D(t,T) =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 ) In the formula: W D(t,T) —The decay heat of the reactor after it has been running for T days and shut down for t days; t—Time remaining until the reactor shutdown time; T—Reactor operating time, expressed in days at equivalent full power; P—Reactor's long-term stable operating power before shutdown; Using the core decay heat power obtained in step 2, the time from the reactor shutdown time in the semi-empirical formula for decay heat is calibrated. The formula is as follows: W D(t,T) =W′ D =6.1×10 -3 ×P×(t -0.2 -(t+T) -0.2 ) Iterate for t until the equation holds true, and then deduce the equivalent shutdown time.
8. A method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 7, characterized in that, Step 4 includes: increasing the unit power to approximately 1%FP and stabilizing it for a period of time before the condenser is put into operation; at this time, there are core power, decay heat, and external heat sources in the reactor core; among them, decay heat and core power are coupled together, and the method of separation of variables is used to ignore the influence of 1%FP core power on decay heat, and decay heat is calculated using a semi-empirical formula for decay heat; when the unit is in thermal equilibrium, the core power in the current state is calculated based on the external heat power and the core decay heat power in the current state.
9. A method for measuring core power in a nuclear power plant at low power conditions according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step 4, the formula for calculating the core power in the current state is: In the formula: W″ R —The current core power refers to the power generated by nuclear fission; W″ TSA —The thermal power of steam discharged into the air in the current state; W″ ΔSG —The increased thermal power of the steam generator in its current state; W″ TTB —The heat power lost due to the blowdown of the steam generator in the current state; —The thermal power input to the reactor coolant system from external heat sources in the current state, using values measured during the initial zero-power period. replace; W″ D —The core decay thermal power in the current state, i.e., W D(t,T) .
