Method for improving discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetering equipment
By calibrating the inherent noise and optical noise of the photodetector and employing a fourth harmonic filtering method, the discrimination threshold of the laser methane remote sensing equipment was improved, solving the problem of detection accuracy for minute methane leaks and achieving a low-cost equipment upgrade.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202511990085.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-12-26
- Publication Date
- 2026-04-28
AI Technical Summary
Existing laser methane remote sensing equipment has a poor threshold for identifying minute methane gas leaks in inaccessible detection scenarios, and its detection accuracy is reduced due to optical and electrical noise.
The inherent noise of the photodetector was measured in a dark environment. By calibrating the ratio coefficients of electrical noise and optical noise, the influence of optical noise was eliminated by the fourth harmonic filtering method. The reliability criteria of the true telemetry value were calculated, and the discrimination threshold of the laser methane telemetry equipment was determined.
The detection threshold of the laser methane telemetry device has been improved, noise interference has been reduced, and accurate detection of minute methane leaks has been ensured without changing the device hardware, only upgrading the algorithm logic level.
Smart Images

Figure CN121933460A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of methane detection, and in particular to a method for improving the identification threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment. Background Technology
[0002] Laser methane telemetry equipment is based on tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) technology. It utilizes the narrow linewidth and tunable wavelength of a tunable semiconductor laser to measure the absorption lines of gas molecules, enabling long-distance detection of methane gas. This technology is suitable for various locations where methane leaks may occur, especially overhead pipelines, confined spaces, and residential kitchens—places where gas leaks are risky but inaccessible due to distance or obstacles. When the laser emitted by the equipment passes through a methane cloud, according to the Lambert-Beer law, the laser light is absorbed to a certain extent by the methane gas. The absorbed light is then diffusely reflected and received by the detector on the equipment, converted into an electrical signal. After amplification and A / D conversion, and data acquisition and processing, a telemetry value reflecting the degree of methane leakage is obtained. This value is expressed as the integral of the methane gas concentration over the optical path (unit: ppm·m).
[0003] For minute methane leaks in inaccessible detection scenarios, the low concentration and rapid diffusion of the leak place high demands on the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment. The primary factor determining this threshold is the electrical noise generated by the photodetector and its amplification circuit. Simultaneously, optical noise introduced by light interference and sunlight also affects the accuracy of the telemetry values, further lowering the discrimination threshold. Current technologies typically correlate the degree of methane leakage with the ratio of the detected second harmonic signal intensity to the first harmonic signal intensity. This approach often fails to effectively eliminate the influence of optical and electrical noise. While it provides good accuracy for more severe leaks, it cannot effectively detect minute amounts of methane gas leakage.
[0004] Therefore, there is an urgent need to provide a method to improve the identification threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment, which can compensate for electrical noise caused by the noise of photodetectors and their amplification circuits, and also eliminate the influence of some optical noise. Summary of the Invention
[0005] This invention provides a method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment, comprising the following steps:
[0006] S1. In a dark environment, turn off the laser of the laser methane telemetry device and measure its first harmonic intensity value I. 1c Second harmonic light intensity value I 2c Fourth harmonic light intensity value I4c ;
[0007] S2. The center wavelength of the laser is selected as 1653.72nm, and the telemetry value is selected as W. t Standard methane gas chamber;
[0008] S3. Calculate the proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of white noise. 21 Calculate the telemetry measurement value W after compensating for electrical noise. 21 ;
[0009] S4. Calculate the scaling factor k that takes into account the influence of optical noise. 41 And the estimated value W of the telemetry value 41 Calculate the credibility criterion F';
[0010] S5. Select the confidence interval [b] -1 [b], to eliminate the influence of false detection values caused by optical noise and obtain the true telemetry value W. real ;
[0011] S6. Slowly release gas from the standard methane gas chamber and calculate W in real time. real When the methane concentration in the standard methane gas chamber decreases to a level that makes the calculated W... real When all values are 0, measure the methane concentration C in the standard methane gas chamber at this time. min The discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device was calculated. min .
[0012] Furthermore, in step S2, W t This is 10% of the maximum measurement value, i.e., the maximum range, of the laser methane telemetry equipment.
[0013] Furthermore, in step S3, the scaling factor k, which takes into account the influence of white noise, is calculated. 21 ,include:
[0014] Continuously detect the second harmonic light intensity value I2 and the first harmonic light intensity value I1 n times, and calculate (I2-I 2c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 21ave The proportionality coefficient k, which takes into account the influence of white noise, is then considered. 21 =W t / d 21ave .
[0015] Further, in step S3, the telemetry measurement value W after compensating for electrical noise is calculated. 21 ,include:
[0016] W 21 =k 21 (I2-I 2c ) / (I1-I1c ).
[0017] Further, in step S4, the proportionality coefficient k is calculated. 41 ,include:
[0018] Continuously measure the intensity value of the fourth harmonic light (I4) and the intensity value of the first harmonic light (I1) n times, and calculate (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 41ave The proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of optical noise is then considered. 41 =W t / d 41ave .
[0019] Further, in step S4, the estimated value W of the telemetry value is calculated. 41 ,include:
[0020] W 41 =k 41 (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c ).
[0021] Further, in step S4, the calculation of the confidence criterion F' includes:
[0022] F' = W 21 / W 41 .
[0023] Further, in step S5, the confidence interval [b -1 b] is [0.8, 1.25].
[0024] Furthermore, in step S5, the actual telemetry value
[0025] Further, in step S6, the discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device is calculated. min ,include:
[0026] W min =C min L is the axial length of the standard methane gas chamber, which is the optical path length of the laser in the standard methane gas chamber.
[0027] This invention provides a method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment. It compensates for electrical noise by calibrating the intensity values of the first and second harmonics of the photodetector output signal after amplification and A / D sampling in a dark environment, and by calibrating the fitting ratio coefficient between the telemetry value and the ratios of the second and first harmonic intensity values. For optical noise, a filtering method introducing the fourth harmonic is used to filter out erroneous telemetry values caused by optical noise, obtaining the true measured value of the telemetry. Finally, the discrimination threshold of the methane concentration telemetry value after using this method is determined, which is the lowest detectable telemetry value of the target methane concentration. This application analyzes the noise sources of laser methane telemetry equipment and processes electrical and optical noise separately. It effectively compensates for electrical noise caused by the noise of the photodetector and its amplification circuit, and filters out some of the influence of optical noise, thereby improving the discrimination threshold of the laser methane telemetry equipment. It can avoid the influence of individual device differences on the consistency of the discrimination threshold improvement effect. In addition, this application has good adaptability to existing laser methane detection equipment, without the need to change or upgrade the hardware configuration of existing laser methane detection equipment. Only the algorithm logic level needs to be upgraded, which is low cost.
[0028] Other features and advantages of the invention will be set forth in the following description, and will be apparent in part from the description, or may be learned by practicing the invention. The objects and other advantages of the invention may be realized and obtained by means of the structures particularly pointed out in the written description, claims, and accompanying drawings. Attached Figure Description
[0029] The accompanying drawings, which are included to provide a further understanding of the invention and form part of this invention, illustrate exemplary embodiments of the invention and are used to explain the invention, but do not constitute an undue limitation of the invention. In the drawings:
[0030] Figure 1 This is a flowchart of a method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to an embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation
[0031] To address the technical problem of poor discrimination threshold in existing laser methane telemetry equipment due to electrical and optical noise, a method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment is provided.
[0032] The preferred embodiments of the present invention will be described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. It should be understood that the preferred embodiments described herein are for illustration and explanation only and are not intended to limit the present invention. Furthermore, the embodiments and features in the embodiments of the present invention can be combined with each other without conflict.
[0033] It should be noted that the terms "first," "second," etc., in the specification, claims, and accompanying drawings of the embodiments of the present invention are used to distinguish similar objects and are not necessarily used to describe a specific order or sequence. It should be understood that such data can be interchanged where appropriate so that the embodiments described herein can be implemented in a sequence other than that illustrated or described herein.
[0034] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating a method for improving the discrimination threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to an embodiment of the present invention. (See also...) Figure 1 The method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment includes the following steps:
[0035] S1. In a dark environment, turn off the laser of the laser methane telemetry device and measure its first harmonic intensity value I. 1c Second harmonic light intensity value I 2c Fourth harmonic light intensity value I 4c .
[0036] To improve the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment, the influence of noise signals, mainly electrical noise and optical noise, should be minimized.
[0037] The electrical noise of the laser methane telemetry equipment is caused by the photodetector and its subsequent discharge circuit and A / D sampling circuit. The main components are shot noise generated by the dark current of the photodetector and excessive noise generated by the gain mechanism of the photodetector.
[0038] Shot noise I generated by dark current in photodetector shot The expression is:
[0039] I shot =(2qi) shot M 2 FΔB) 1 / 2
[0040] Where q is the electron charge;
[0041] i shot This is the dark current of the detector;
[0042] M is the internal gain of the detector;
[0043] F is the detector's excess noise figure;
[0044] ΔB is the bandwidth of the detector-amplifier combination;
[0045] For the same laser methane telemetry device, all the above parameters are constant values. Therefore, shot noise can be regarded as a noise of a fixed magnitude, and its value can be determined by calibration.
[0046] Specifically, step S1 calibrates the inherent noise in the electrical noise. The laser methane telemetry device is placed in a dark, enclosed environment. The laser methane telemetry device is turned on, but the power supply to its laser is cut off. The average value of the first harmonic light intensity values of n consecutive groups (n>100, so that the compensation value is as close as possible to the average value of the shot noise) is taken to obtain I. 1c The first harmonic component, which is inherent noise, is obtained by averaging the intensity values of n consecutive sets of second harmonic light. 2c The second harmonic component, as an inherent noise, is obtained by averaging the intensity values of n consecutive sets of fourth harmonic light. 4c The fourth harmonic component is an inherent noise.
[0047] S2. The center wavelength of the laser is selected as 1653.72nm, and the telemetry value is selected as W. t A standard methane gas chamber.
[0048] For laser-based methane gas telemetry, the center value of the laser wavelength modulation must be selected. Most existing laser-based methane gas telemetry devices use 1653.72nm as the center wavelength because this is a methane absorption peak within 2000nm, and it also has low absorption of other gases commonly found in the atmosphere and industrial environment, meaning it has good absorption and selectivity for methane.
[0049] Determine the detection range of the laser methane telemetry equipment, and take the telemetry value W within the detection range. t A standard methane gas chamber for this telemetry value was constructed.
[0050] S3. Calculate the proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of white noise. 21 Calculate the telemetry measurement value W after compensating for electrical noise. 21 .
[0051] Excess noise I generated by the gain mechanism of photodetectors ex Its expression is:
[0052] I ex =(2qi) ex M 2 FΔB) 1 / 2
[0053] Where q is the electron charge;
[0054] i ex The photocurrent of the detector;
[0055] M is the internal gain of the detector;
[0056] F is the detector's excess noise figure;
[0057] ΔB is the bandwidth of the detector-amplifier combination;
[0058] i ex The magnitude of I increases with the increase of the received light intensity, therefore the excess noise I generated by the photodetector gain mechanism ex It exhibits white noise properties. Since the detection of methane telemetry is essentially about measuring the ratio of second harmonic intensity to first harmonic intensity, it can be determined by adjusting the proportionality coefficient k, which takes into account the influence of excessive noise. 21 Calibration is performed to eliminate the effects of excessive noise.
[0059] Furthermore, a methane concentration sensor is installed in the standard methane gas chamber to detect the methane gas concentration C inside the chamber, measured in ppm. Considering the influence of the methane concentration sensor's discrimination threshold, the axial length L of the methane gas chamber should be maximized during its fabrication, meaning the optical path of the laser passing through the chamber should be as long as possible, to reduce the requirements on the methane concentration sensor's discrimination threshold.
[0060] Generally, according to the Lambert-Beer law, when the telemetry value is large, it is related to I. 2c / I 1c The linearity will deteriorate; it is recommended to use W. t This is 10% of the maximum measurement value, i.e., the maximum range, of the laser methane telemetry equipment.
[0061] Perform k 21 During calibration, the laser is positioned 1 meter apart, directly facing the center of a standard methane gas chamber, ensuring that the diameter of the laser spot is much smaller than the cross-sectional diameter of the standard methane gas chamber into which the laser is incident. The second harmonic intensity value I2 and the first harmonic intensity value I1 are continuously measured n times, and (I2-I...) 2c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 21ave The proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of white noise was obtained. 21 =W t / d 21ave .
[0062] Calibration yields I 1c I 2c k 21 Then, electrical noise is compensated to obtain the measured value W of the telemetry value after compensation for electrical noise. 21 =k 21 (I2-I 2c ) / (I1-I 1c ).
[0063] S4. Calculate the scaling factor k that takes into account the influence of optical noise. 41 And the estimated value W of the telemetry value 41 The confidence criterion F' is calculated and used to distinguish the influence of optical noise values.
[0064] For laser methane telemetry equipment, optical noise is generally caused by interference between the incident laser and the reflected laser formed after passing through an irregular reflecting surface, resulting in false detection values greater than zero. This type of noise cannot be effectively distinguished by analyzing the second harmonic and the first harmonic alone; higher-order harmonics must be introduced.
[0065] According to the Lambert-Beer law, expanding the expression for light intensity into a Fourier series yields the nth (n>1) harmonic component I of the light intensity at the absorption peak. n (v c The expression for ) is:
[0066] I n (v c ) = 2 1-n I0Wv c n a n (v c ) / n!
[0067] Where W is the product of the concentration of the gas being measured and the optical path length;
[0068] v c The wavelength of the absorption peak;
[0069] a(v c () represents absorbance;
[0070] I0 is the initial light intensity.
[0071] For laser methane telemetry equipment, when the absorption peak v c At 1653.72 nm, for odd harmonics, a n (v c When I = 0, I n (v c ) = 0; For even harmonics, according to I n (v c The expression for ) can be used to obtain I. n (v c The value of I decreases as n increases. Therefore, it can be obtained that for the nth harmonic above the second harmonic, when n = 4, I n (v c The maximum value can be obtained at the absorption peak.
[0072] According to the Lambert-Beer law, for light intensity values n>1, the ratio of the nth harmonic to the first harmonic is directly proportional to the telemetry value. Therefore, the fourth harmonic is chosen, and the proportionality coefficient k is compared... 41 The calibration can yield an estimated value W for the telemetry data. 41 This serves as a reference condition for filtering out false detections caused by optical noise.
[0073] Use and calibration of k 21 Perform k under the same conditions 41 For calibration, continuously measure the intensity value of the fourth harmonic light (I4) and the intensity value of the first harmonic light (I1) n times, and calculate (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 41ave The proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of optical noise was obtained. 41 =W t / d 41ave .
[0074] Furthermore, the estimated value W of the telemetry value used to filter out false detections caused by optical noise is taken. 41 =k 41 (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c ).
[0075] Let F' = W 21 / W 41 As a reliability criterion for distinguishing the influence of optical noise values.
[0076] S5. Select the confidence interval [b] -1 [b], to eliminate the influence of false detection values caused by optical noise and obtain the true telemetry value W. real .
[0077] Specifically, the confidence interval [b -1 The range of values for F' is defined by [b], where b is a constant and b>1. As b increases, the confidence interval becomes wider, but the reliability of the telemetry values decreases. Conversely, if b is too small, it can easily filter out some true telemetry values. Therefore, based on empirical data, a value of b of 1.25, i.e., a confidence interval of [0.8, 1.25], can ensure the reliability of the telemetry values and prevent some true telemetry values from being filtered out.
[0078] When the value of F' is within the confidence interval, the telemetry value is determined to be the true value; when the value of F' is outside the confidence interval, the telemetry value is determined to be affected by optical noise and is not the true value, and the measured value is determined to be 0.
[0079] Specifically,
[0080] S6. Slowly release gas from the standard methane gas chamber and calculate W in real time. real When the methane concentration in the standard methane gas chamber decreases to a level that makes the calculated W... real When all values are 0, measure the methane concentration C in the standard methane gas chamber at this time. minThe discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device was calculated. min .
[0081] Specifically, W min =C min L is the axial length of the standard methane gas chamber, which is the optical path length of the laser in the standard methane gas chamber.
[0082] In summary, the method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment provided by this invention involves turning off the laser of the laser methane telemetry equipment in a dark environment and measuring its first harmonic intensity value I. 1c Second harmonic light intensity value I 2c Fourth harmonic light intensity value I 4c The center wavelength of the laser was selected as 1653.72 nm, and the telemetry value was selected as W. t A standard methane gas chamber; the proportionality coefficient k, which takes into account the effect of white noise, was calculated. 21 Calculate the telemetry measurement value W after compensating for electrical noise. 21 ; Calculate the proportionality coefficient k 41 The estimated value W of the telemetry value 41 Based on the proportionality coefficient k 41 The estimated value W of the telemetry value 41 Calculate the confidence criterion F', which is used to distinguish the influence of optical noise values; select the confidence interval [b -1 [b], to eliminate the influence of false detection values caused by optical noise and obtain the true telemetry value W. real Slowly release gas from the standard methane gas chamber and calculate W in real time. real When the methane concentration in the standard methane gas chamber drops to a level that makes all calculated Wreal values zero, the methane concentration value C in the standard methane gas chamber at this point is measured. min The discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device was calculated. minThe method for improving the discrimination threshold of laser methane telemetry equipment compensates for electrical noise by calibrating the intensity values of the first and second harmonics of the photodetector output signal after amplification and A / D sampling in a dark environment, and by calibrating the fitting ratio coefficient between the telemetry value and the ratio of the second and first harmonic intensity values. For optical noise, a filtering method introducing the fourth harmonic is used to filter out erroneous telemetry values caused by optical noise, obtaining the true measured value of the telemetry. Finally, the discrimination threshold of the methane concentration telemetry value after using this method is determined, which is the lowest detectable telemetry value of the target methane concentration. This application analyzes the noise sources of laser methane telemetry equipment and processes electrical and optical noise separately. It effectively compensates for electrical noise caused by the noise of the photodetector and its amplification circuit, and filters out some of the influence of optical noise, thereby improving the discrimination threshold of the laser methane telemetry equipment. It can avoid the influence of individual device differences on the consistency of the discrimination threshold improvement effect. In addition, this application has good adaptability to existing laser methane detection equipment, without the need to change or upgrade the hardware configuration of existing laser methane detection equipment. Only the algorithm logic level needs to be upgraded, which is low cost.
[0083] Although preferred embodiments of the invention have been described, those skilled in the art, upon learning the basic inventive concept, can make other changes and modifications to these embodiments. Therefore, the appended claims are intended to be interpreted as including the preferred embodiments as well as all changes and modifications falling within the scope of the invention.
[0084] Obviously, those skilled in the art can make various modifications and variations to this invention without departing from its spirit and scope. Therefore, if these modifications and variations fall within the scope of the claims of this invention and their equivalents, this invention also intends to include these modifications and variations.
Claims
1. A method for improving the discrimination threshold of a laser methane telemetry device, comprising the following steps: S1. In a dark environment, turn off the laser of the laser methane telemetry device and measure its first harmonic intensity value I. 1c Second harmonic light intensity value I 2c Fourth harmonic light intensity value I 4c ; S2. The center wavelength of the laser is selected as 1653.72nm, and the telemetry value is selected as W. t Standard methane gas chamber; S3. Calculate the proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of white noise. 21 Calculate the telemetry measurement value W after compensating for electrical noise. 21 ; S4. Calculate the scaling factor k that takes into account the influence of optical noise. 41 And the estimated value W of the telemetry value 41 Calculate the credibility criterion F'; S5. Select the confidence interval [b] -1 [b], to eliminate the influence of false detection values caused by optical noise and obtain the true telemetry value W. real ; S6. Slowly release gas from the standard methane gas chamber and calculate W in real time. real When the methane concentration in the standard methane gas chamber decreases to a level that makes the calculated W... real When all values are 0, measure the methane concentration C in the standard methane gas chamber at this time. min The discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device was calculated. min .
2. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S2, W t This is 10% of the maximum measurement value, i.e., the maximum range, of the laser methane telemetry equipment.
3. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S3, the calculation takes into account the proportionality coefficient k of white noise. 21 ,include: Continuously detect the second harmonic light intensity value I2 and the first harmonic light intensity value I1 n times, and calculate (I2-I 2c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 21ave The proportionality coefficient k, which takes into account the influence of white noise, is then considered. 21 =W t / d 21ave .
4. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 3, characterized in that, In step S3, the telemetry value W after calculating and compensating for electrical noise is... 21 ,include: W 21 =k 21 (I2-I 2c ) / (I1-I 1c )。 5. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 4, characterized in that, In step S4, the calculation of the proportionality coefficient k 41 ,include: Continuously measure the intensity value of the fourth harmonic light (I4) and the intensity value of the first harmonic light (I1) n times, and calculate (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c ), with the mean value being d 41ave The proportionality coefficient k that takes into account the influence of optical noise is then considered. 41 =W t / d 41ave .
6. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 5, characterized in that, In step S4, the estimated value W of the telemetry value is calculated. 41 ,include: W 41 =k 41 (I4-I 4c ) / (I1-I 1c )。 7. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 6, characterized in that, In step S4, the calculation of the confidence criterion F' includes: F’=W 21 / W 41 。 8. The method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 7, characterized in that, In step S5, the confidence interval [b -1 b] is [0.8, 1.25].
9. A method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step S5, the actual telemetry value 10. A method for improving the identification threshold of a laser methane telemetry device according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step S6, the discrimination threshold W of the laser methane telemetry device is calculated. min ,include: W min =C min L is the axial length of the standard methane gas chamber, which is the optical path length of the laser in the standard methane gas chamber.
