A flight plan minimum sample size confirmation method and device for airspace simulation analysis
By calculating the Pearson correlation coefficient and analyzing the differences in the evaluation index, the minimum sample size of the flight plan in the airspace simulation analysis was determined, which solved the problem of complex sample size determination in the existing technology, and improved the accuracy and operational efficiency of airspace simulation modeling.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111088691.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-09-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-09-16
AI Technical Summary
The prior art airspace modeling lacks quantitative standards and specific methods for sample size requirements of flight plan data, resulting in complex sample capacity determination and is not suitable for daily operations, affecting the accuracy of the simulation model.
By calculating the Pearson correlation coefficient of sector evaluation indicators, analyzing the differences in the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators in one or four weeks, determining the minimum sample size, finding the balance point between workload and accuracy, modeling and evaluation analysis for airspace simulation Provides a data foundation.
A balance between workload and accuracy is achieved, a quantitative minimum sample size standard is provided, and data accuracy and operational efficiency of airspace simulation modeling is improved, which is suitable for post-hoc analysis of airspace evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN113822564B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of civil aviation data processing, and in particular to a method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis, and a device for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis, which finds a balance between workload and accuracy and provides a data basis for airspace simulation modeling and evaluation analysis. Background Art
[0002] Sample size refers to the number of units contained in a sample. The determination of sample size is very important, because if the sample size is too large, it will cause a waste of resources; if the sample size is too small, the error will be too large and inconsistent with the actual situation, affecting the correctness of the research. The minimum sample size refers to the lower limit of the sample size required to meet the research purpose based on the resources that the research can provide.
[0003] For the sake of accuracy of estimation and prediction, and reliability of hypothesis testing, general mathematical statistics textbooks have systematic analysis on the determination of minimum sample size. These textbooks point out that the minimum sample size does not depend on the number of samples, but on (1) the degree of variation of the research object; (2) the required or allowed error (i.e., accuracy requirement); and (3) the required confidence level of the inference.
[0004] Therefore, when the research object is more complex and the difference is greater, the sample size requirement is larger; when the required accuracy is higher and the inferential requirement is higher, the sample size is larger. Determining the size of the sample size is a relatively complex issue, which requires both qualitative and quantitative considerations. The Air Traffic Management Bureau of the Civil Aviation Administration of China issued the "Guidance Materials for the Implementation of Airspace Modeling and Evaluation" on December 1, 2009. The guidance material requires in the input data step of establishing the benchmark model: "Complete data must be available" and "The more complete the data provided, the more accurate the simulation model process will be." These documents propose the principles for determining the minimum sample size and the requirements for data in airspace simulation modeling, but there are the following problems:
[0005] 1. The professional method of determining sample capacity is very complex, involving complex data, numerous steps, and large amounts of calculation. Determining sample capacity itself is a research direction in mathematics, and exploratory methods are not suitable for daily operations of airspace modeling.
[0006] The requirements of airspace modeling for simulation input data are mainly in terms of data content, but the requirements for the amount of data, especially the sample size of flight plan data, only put forward principled requirements without quantitative standards and specific methods. Summary of the invention
[0007] In order to overcome the defects of the prior art, the technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a method for confirming the minimum sample size of the flight plan for airspace simulation analysis, which can find a balance between workload and accuracy, provide a data basis for airspace simulation modeling and evaluation analysis, and can be extended to the post-analysis of airspace evaluation. When using historical air traffic control surveillance data to evaluate the airspace operation status, air traffic control surveillance data with a reasonable scale and appropriate accuracy can be collected for analysis.
[0008] The technical solution of the present invention is: the minimum sample size confirmation method of the flight plan for airspace simulation analysis comprises the following steps:
[0009] (1) Calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index
[0010]
[0011] Among them, r reflects the degree of linear correlation between two variables X and Y. The r value ranges from -1 to 1. The larger the absolute value, the stronger the correlation.
[0012] (2) Analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: Analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each day of a week, analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each week of four weeks, and analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for every two weeks of four weeks. The minimum sample size is determined by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficient analysis of the airspace simulation evaluation indicators of a certain regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks.
[0013] The present invention analyzes the correlation between airspace simulation evaluation indicators and, based on the principle that the correlation between variable elements in a sample will not change due to the size of the sample capacity, seeks the lower limit of the sample capacity at which the correlation remains unchanged, that is, the minimum sample size, and finds a balance between workload and accuracy, thereby providing a data basis for airspace simulation modeling and evaluation analysis. The minimum sample size of the flight plan in airspace simulation modeling is determined through the correlation between airspace simulation evaluation indicators, which can be extended to the post-analysis of airspace evaluation. When airspace operation status is evaluated using air traffic control monitoring historical data, air traffic control monitoring data with a reasonable scale and appropriate accuracy is collected for analysis.
[0014] A flight plan minimum sample size confirmation device for airspace simulation analysis is also provided, comprising:
[0015] Pearson correlation coefficient acquisition module, which is configured to calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index
[0016]
[0017] Among them, r reflects the linear correlation between two variables X and Y, and the r value is between -1 and 1.
[0018] Larger absolute values indicate stronger correlations;
[0019] A data processing module is configured to analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each day of a week, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each week of four weeks, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for every two weeks of four weeks, and determining the minimum sample size by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficient analysis of the airspace simulation evaluation indicators of a regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0020] Figure 1 Shown is an overall flow chart of the minimum sample size confirmation method for flight plan based on airspace simulation analysis according to the present invention.
[0021] Figure 2 Shown is a flow chart of a specific embodiment of step (2) according to the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0022] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the present invention.
[0023] In order to make the description of the present disclosure more detailed and complete, the following provides an illustrative description of the implementation and specific embodiments of the present invention; however, this is not the only form of implementing or using the specific embodiments of the present invention. The implementation covers the features of multiple specific embodiments and the method steps and sequences used to construct and operate these specific embodiments. However, other specific embodiments can also be used to achieve the same or equivalent functions and step sequences.
[0024] First, the meanings of the technical terms used in the present invention are given below:
[0025] Sample: A part of individuals under observation or investigation. The population is all the subjects of research.
[0026] Sample size: The number of units included in a sample.
[0027] Minimum sample size: The lower limit of the sample size required to meet the research objectives based on the resources available for the research.
[0028] Correlation: The degree to which two variables are related.
[0029] Correlation coefficient: A measure of the degree of linear correlation between variables. It was first devised by statistician Karl Pearson. There are many ways to define the correlation coefficient, the most common of which is the Pearson correlation coefficient.
[0030] Pearson correlation coefficient: also known as Pearson product-moment correlation coefficient, is used to measure the linear correlation between two variables, which is only between -1 and 1.
[0031] Positive correlation: When the independent variable increases (decreases), the dependent variable also increases (decreases), and the two variables change in the same direction. In this case, the correlation coefficient between the dependent variable and the independent variable is positive, that is, positive correlation.
[0032] Negative correlation: When the independent variable increases (decreases), the dependent variable decreases (increases), and the two variables change in opposite directions. In this case, the correlation coefficient between the dependent variable and the independent variable is negative, that is, negative correlation.
[0033] No correlation: There is no linear relationship between the independent variable and the dependent variable, and the correlation coefficient is 0.
[0034] like Figure 1 As shown, the minimum sample size confirmation method for the flight plan of the airspace simulation analysis includes the following steps:
[0035] (1) Calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index
[0036]
[0037] Among them, r reflects the degree of linear correlation between two variables X and Y. The r value ranges from -1 to 1. The larger the absolute value, the stronger the correlation.
[0038] (2) Analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: Analyze the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators for each day of a week, analyze the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators for each week of four weeks, and analyze the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators for every two weeks of four weeks. The minimum sample size is determined by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficients of the airspace simulation evaluation indicators of a certain regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks (see Figure 2 ).
[0039] The present invention analyzes the correlation between airspace simulation evaluation indicators and, based on the principle that the correlation between variable elements in a sample will not change due to the size of the sample capacity, seeks the lower limit of the sample capacity at which the correlation remains unchanged, that is, the minimum sample size, and finds a balance between workload and accuracy, thereby providing a data basis for airspace simulation modeling and evaluation analysis. The minimum sample size of the flight plan in airspace simulation modeling is determined through the correlation between airspace simulation evaluation indicators, which can be extended to the post-analysis of airspace evaluation. When airspace operation status is evaluated using air traffic control monitoring historical data, air traffic control monitoring data with a reasonable scale and appropriate accuracy is collected for analysis.
[0040] Preferably, in step (1), different colors represent the size of the Pearson coefficient: if the value is positive, the bluer the color, the positive correlation; if the value is negative, the redder the color, the negative correlation.
[0041] Preferably, in step (2), the correlation coefficients between the indicators for each day of the week are: traffic and maximum aircraft number 0.59-0.93, workload and direction change 0.24-0.83, maximum aircraft number and delayed number -0.3-0.63, average delay time and potential conflict -0.47-0.78.
[0042] Preferably, in step (2), the correlations between the indicators in one week are slightly different, the maximum difference in correlation coefficients is 0.62, and the variance of the correlation coefficients over four weeks is 0.25.
[0043] Preferably, in step (2), the correlation coefficients of the indicators every two weeks have small differences in correlation, with the maximum difference in correlation coefficients being 0.49 and the four-week variance of the correlation coefficient being 0.12.
[0044] Preferably, in step (2), the minimum sample size is determined to be one week.
[0045] Those skilled in the art can understand that all or part of the steps in the above-mentioned embodiment method can be completed by instructing the relevant hardware through a program, and the program can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium. When the program is executed, it includes the steps of the above-mentioned embodiment method, and the storage medium can be: ROM / RAM, disk, CD, memory card, etc. Therefore, corresponding to the method of the present invention, the present invention also includes a flight plan minimum sample size confirmation device for airspace simulation analysis, which is usually represented in the form of functional modules corresponding to the steps of the method. The device includes:
[0046] Pearson correlation coefficient acquisition module, which is configured to calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index
[0047]
[0048] Among them, r reflects the linear correlation between two variables X and Y, and the r value is between -1 and 1.
[0049] Larger absolute values indicate stronger correlations;
[0050] A data processing module is configured to analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each day of a week, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each week of four weeks, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for every two weeks of four weeks, and determining the minimum sample size by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficient analysis of the airspace simulation evaluation indicators of a regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks.
[0051] Preferably, in the Pearson correlation coefficient acquisition module, different colors represent the size of the Pearson coefficient: if the value is positive, the bluer the color, the positive correlation; if the value is negative, the redder the color, the negative correlation.
[0052] Preferably, in the data processing module, the minimum sample size is determined to be one week.
[0053] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and does not limit the present invention in any form. Any simple modification, equivalent changes and modifications made to the above embodiments based on the technical essence of the present invention are still within the protection scope of the technical solution of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis, characterized in that: It includes the following steps: (1) Calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index Among them, r reflects the degree of linear correlation between two variables X and Y. The r value ranges from -1 to 1. The larger the absolute value, the stronger the correlation. (2) Analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: Analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each day of a week, analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for each week of four weeks, and analyze the correlation coefficient of the evaluation indicators for every two weeks of four weeks. The minimum sample size is determined by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficient analysis of the airspace simulation evaluation indicators of a certain regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks; In step (2), determining the minimum sample size specifically includes the following steps: (I) Analyze the correlation coefficients of evaluation indicators for seven days in a week, taking one day as a unit; (II) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the correlation coefficient of each day, and if so, executing step (IV); if not, executing step (III); (III) determine the minimum sample size to be one day,end; (IV) Analyze the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators for four weeks on a weekly basis; (V) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the weekly correlation coefficient, and if so, executing step (VII); otherwise, executing step (VI); (VI) determine the minimum sample size to be one week, end; (VII) One more week was added to continue the analysis of the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators; (VIII) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the correlation coefficient after the increase, and if so, executing step (VII); otherwise, executing step (IX); (IX) Determine the minimum sample size to be the number of weeks after the increase.
2. The method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step (1), different colors represent the size of the Pearson coefficient: if the value is positive, the bluer the color, the positive correlation; if the value is negative, the redder the color, the negative correlation.
3. The method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 2, characterized in that: In step (2), the correlation coefficients between the indicators for each day of the week are: flow and maximum aircraft number 0.59-0.93, workload and direction change 0.24-0.83, maximum aircraft number and delayed aircraft number -0.3-0.63, average delay time and potential conflicts -0.47-0.
78.
4. The method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step (2), the correlations between the indicators in one week are slightly different, with the maximum difference in correlation coefficients being 0.62, and the four-week variance of the correlation coefficient being 0.
25.
5. The method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 4, characterized in that: In the step (2), the correlation coefficients of the indicators every two weeks have little difference in correlation, with the maximum difference in correlation coefficients being 0.49 and the four-week variance of the correlation coefficient being 0.
12.
6. The method for confirming the minimum sample size of a flight plan for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 5, characterized in that: In the step (2), the minimum sample size is determined to be one week.
7. A flight plan minimum sample size confirmation device for airspace simulation analysis, characterized in that: It is used to execute the method according to claim 1, comprising: Pearson correlation coefficient acquisition module, which is configured to calculate the Pearson correlation coefficient of the sector evaluation index Among them, r reflects the degree of linear correlation between two variables X and Y. The r value ranges from -1 to 1. The larger the absolute value, the stronger the correlation. A data processing module is configured to analyze the difference in correlation coefficients to determine the minimum sample size: analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation index for each day of a week, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation index for each week of four weeks, analyzing the correlation coefficient of the evaluation index for every two weeks of four weeks, and determining the minimum sample size by comparing the Pierce correlation coefficient analysis of the airspace simulation evaluation index of a certain regional control sector for one day, one week, two weeks, and three weeks; The determination of the minimum sample size specifically includes the following steps: (I) Analyze the correlation coefficients of evaluation indicators for seven days in a week, taking one day as a unit; (II) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the correlation coefficient of each day, and if so, executing step (IV); if not, executing step (III); (III) determine the minimum sample size to be one day,end; (IV) Analyze the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators for four weeks on a weekly basis; (V) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the weekly correlation coefficient, and if so, executing step (VII); otherwise, executing step (VI); (VI) determine the minimum sample size to be one week, end; (VII) One more week was added to continue the analysis of the correlation coefficients of the evaluation indicators; (VIII) determining whether there is a fundamental change in the correlation coefficient after the increase, and if so, executing step (VII); otherwise, executing step (IX); (IX) Determine the minimum sample size to be the number of weeks after the increase.
8. The flight plan minimum sample size confirmation device for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 7, characterized in that: In the Pearson correlation coefficient acquisition module, different colors indicate the size of the Pearson coefficient: if the value is positive, the bluer the color, the positive correlation; if the value is negative, the redder the color, the negative correlation.
9. The flight plan minimum sample size confirmation device for airspace simulation analysis according to claim 8, characterized in that: In the data processing module, the minimum sample size is determined to be one week.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Flight testing testability evaluation method for airborne product
CN107505126A
Capacity evaluation method and equipment based on historical capacity similarity characteristics
CN111598148A
Controller workload evaluation method based on sector dynamic traffic characteristics
CN113362604A
System and method for modelling a flight
US20090094011A1
