A Pure Plant-Based 3D Printed Butter Based on Crystallization Network and Parameter-Defined Method and Its Evaluation

By adjusting the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin and using a composite emulsifier, a flower-like crystal network was constructed, solving the problems of extrusion collapse and clogging of pure plant-based whipped cream in 3D printing. This achieved high shear thinning and self-supporting properties, meeting the requirements for healthy food.

CN123100709APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17JIANGNAN UNIV
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611251634.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-08-18
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies struggle to achieve high-shear thinning extrusion and high-energy-modulus self-support for pure plant-based whipped cream in 3D printing without relying on animal fats and exogenous colloidal thickeners, leading to problems such as easy collapse or blockage during the extrusion process.

Method used

By precisely controlling the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin, a pure plant-based 3D printed butter based on a crystal network is constructed. Combined with specific composite emulsifiers and colloids, a fine and dense flower-like β' crystal network is formed, achieving moderate fat globule aggregation and ensuring smooth extrusion under high shear and rapid recovery of structural strength after unconstraint.

Benefits of technology

It achieves high shear thinning and high storage modulus self-support in 3D printing of pure plant-based butter, avoiding the extrusion collapse and clogging problems of traditional butter, which is in line with the trend of healthy food, and provides a quantitative prediction and evaluation system.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123100709A_ABST
    Figure CN123100709A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention discloses a pure plant-based 3D-printed butter based on a crystalline network and parameter-defined structure. By mass percentage, it comprises an oil matrix, a composite emulsifier, a composite colloid, plant protein, sugars, and water. The oil matrix is ​​composed of palm kernel oil or palm kernel oil extract and palm stearin, with a mass ratio of palm kernel oil or palm kernel oil extract to palm stearin of 1.5:1 to 9:1. This invention completely eliminates the use of animal fats, combining palm kernel oil or its fractions with palm stearin. Based on its molecular-liquid oil synergistic mechanism, it fundamentally regulates the evolution of the network structure of the pure plant oil system. This formulation constructs a crystalline structure that combines rigidity and flexibility, enabling the stable release of internal interfacial tension. This allows the butter to exhibit excellent shear-thinning properties under mechanical extrusion, completely solving the problems of extrusion breakage and subsequent collapse in traditional plant-based butter.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the fields of food processing and additive manufacturing technology, and more specifically, to a pure plant-based 3D printed cream based on crystallization network and parameter limitation, and its evaluation method. Background Technology

[0002] Food 3D printing technology uses digital models to drive the layer-by-layer deposition of materials, showing broad application prospects in areas such as personalized nutrition customization and special medical purpose formula foods (e.g., diets for dysphagia). Whipped butter, a core decoration and filling material in baking and desserts, faces a typical "nonlinear" rheological contradiction in extrusion 3D printing: the material must exhibit sufficient shear thinning behavior in the high shear field at the nozzle to ensure continuous and uniform extrusion (extrudability); simultaneously, after being freed from shear constraints and deposited, the deposited layer must possess sufficient structural stiffness to resist its own weight and upper-layer loads, maintaining a precise three-dimensional shape (self-support). This contradiction places significantly higher technical demands on the structural strength and thixotropic recovery capability of the fat crystallization network than in traditional hand-made piping scenarios.

[0003] Currently, to address the aforementioned rheological challenges, commercially available conventional butter and most published improved technologies generally employ a strategy of blending animal-derived fats (such as anhydrous butter) with vegetable oils. The theoretical basis for this strategy lies in the fact that animal fats contain a broad triglyceride composition and melting temperature range, effectively broadening the crystallization temperature range and solidification rate of the oil system, thus providing necessary structural support for the printing process. For example, patent application CN120052431A proposes a highly stable whipped animal and vegetable butter, which improves system stability through the synergistic effect of animal butter and vegetable oils. However, this technical approach has inherent drawbacks: firstly, animal fats are accompanied by high levels of saturated fatty acids and cholesterol, contradicting the current health consumption trend of "vegan" and "clean label" products; secondly, the molecular structures of animal and vegetable oils differ significantly, resulting in poor crystallization compatibility. Under the frequent mechanical shearing and temperature fluctuations of 3D printing equipment, the oil-water interface is prone to irreversible polymorphic transformation or macroscopic phase separation, leading to weakened interlayer adhesion, increased surface roughness, and even extrusion breakage in the printed product.

[0004] To mitigate the health risks associated with animal-derived ingredients, some existing technologies attempt to develop purely plant-based whipped cream. For example, patent publication CN 118592497A discloses a purely plant-based vegetarian whipped cream, which primarily thickens the aqueous phase by adding exogenous plant proteins, polysaccharide colloids, or plant pulps to construct a non-covalently cross-linked network, thereby maintaining a three-dimensional morphology under static conditions. However, such solutions have fundamental shortcomings in the high shear stress environment of 3D printing: the weakly cross-linked network constructed from exogenous macromolecules is easily and irreversibly destroyed during extrusion, and its storage modulus is far lower than that of lipid crystalline networks, making it difficult to quickly recover sufficient elastic modulus to resist gravity after deposition, causing the printed model to collapse or slip between layers within seconds.

[0005] If we abandon the approach of using exogenous colloids for thickening and rely solely on the crystalline network of the oil itself to achieve the structural strength required for 3D printing, those skilled in the art will face significant physicochemical bottlenecks. Currently, most pure vegetable-based butter products use single palm kernel oil or hydrogenated vegetable oil as the base oil. Palm kernel oil is rich in medium-chain saturated fatty acids (such as lauric acid), which crystallizes rapidly, but mainly forms a loose and fragile β' crystal network. Its crystalline film strength is insufficient to securely trap air bubbles introduced during the mixing process, making the macrostructure highly susceptible to instability and "watering" after extrusion. A conventional improvement to address this problem is to simply introduce high-melting-point stearin components (such as palm stearin) to increase the overall hardness of the system. However, this often leads to a sharp overload of solid fat content (SFC), causing excessive rigidity of the fat globule interface film. This completely blocks the "partial coalescence" effect necessary for mixing and aeration, while simultaneously inducing the formation of large, radially crystalline aggregates that frequently clog the nozzles during printing, severely restricting printing continuity and accuracy.

[0006] In summary, the key challenge lies in how to precisely regulate crystallization kinetics and mesoscale fat globule aggregation behavior solely through the intermolecular physical complementarity of structural lipids, without relying on animal fats or exogenous macromolecular thickening colloids, thereby simultaneously achieving high-shear thinning extrusion and high-energy-modulus self-support, and establishing reliable quantitative prediction methods to completely resolve the technical contradiction of "collapse during extrusion and blockage during hardening" in pure plant-based butter during 3D printing. This is a long-standing technical difficulty that needs to be overcome in the field. Summary of the Invention

[0007] To address the issues of existing 3D printing cream's heavy reliance on animal fats (such as butter) for crystallization support or on exogenous colloids for thickening, resulting in high cholesterol, poor biocompatibility between plants and animals, and easy phase separation under high shear, existing pure plant-based cream presents extreme rheological contradictions: systems based on single palm kernel oil (PKO) form a loose and fragile β-crystal structure, leading to instantaneous collapse after deposition; while simply adding high-melting-point palm stearin (POS) for hardening causes an overload of solid fat content (SFC) and an overly hardened interfacial film, completely blocking the partial aggregation of fat globules and forming large clumps, leading to severe pipe blockage. This invention aims to provide a pure plant-based 3D printed cream based on crystal network and parameter constraints, as well as its preparation and evaluation methods. It abandons animal-derived fats and exogenous macromolecular thickening colloids, and is purely based on the physical complementarity of structural lipids in fatty acid carbon chain length. It precisely induces the evolution of microscopic crystal form and regulates the "moderate partial aggregation" of fat globules at the mesoscopic level, constructing a pure plant-based 3D printed cream with both "high shear thinning extrudability" and "high energy storage modulus", and establishes a quantitative prediction and evaluation system.

[0008] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention first provides a pure plant-based 3D printed cream based on a crystallization network and parameter limitations, comprising the following components by mass percentage: 25%~35% oil matrix, 1%~4% composite emulsifier, 0.05%~0.2% composite colloid, 0.5%~1.5% plant protein, 10%~20% sugar, and the balance being water; wherein, the oil matrix is ​​composed of palm kernel oil (PKO) or palm kernel oil extract and palm stearin (POS), and the mass ratio of palm kernel oil (PKO) or palm kernel oil extract to palm stearin (POS) in the oil matrix is ​​1.5:1~9:1, more preferably 2:1~6:1.

[0009] In one embodiment of the present invention, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil (PKO) or palm kernel oil extract to palm stearin (POS) in the oil matrix is ​​4:1 to 5:1.

[0010] In one embodiment of the present invention, the composite emulsifier is selected from at least two of sucrose fatty acid esters, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid esters, polysorbates (Tween), Span (sorbitan mono-fatty acid ester), sodium stearoyl lactylate, and propylene glycol fatty acid esters.

[0011] In one embodiment of the present invention, the composite emulsifier is a ternary compound of sucrose fatty acid ester, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid ester and polysorbate-60 (Tween-60), wherein the mass ratio of the three is 1:1:1 to 1:3:1, preferably 1:2:1.

[0012] In one embodiment of the present invention, the composite colloid is a mixture of carrageenan and gellan gum; the mass ratio of carrageenan to gellan gum is 6:4 to 4:6.

[0013] In one embodiment of the present invention, the plant protein is selected from at least one of soy protein isolate, pea protein isolate, broad bean protein, chickpea protein, oat protein, and rice protein, with soy protein isolate being preferred.

[0014] In one embodiment of the present invention, the solid fat content (SFC) of the pure plant-based 3D printed cream is 32%~65% at 25 °C; and the texture hardness of the cream after aeration and whipping is controlled at 130~1000 gf.

[0015] In one embodiment of the present invention, the pure plant-based 3D printing butter comprises the following components by mass percentage: 30% oil matrix, 1% sucrose fatty acid ester, 1% mono- and diglyceride fatty acid ester, 1% polysorbate-60 (Tween 60), 1% soy protein isolate, 0.05% carrageenan, 0.05% gellan gum, 15% white sugar, and the balance being purified water; wherein, in the oil matrix, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil (PKO) to palm stearin (POS) is 80:20.

[0016] In one embodiment of the present invention, after the pure plant-based 3D printed butter is whipped, the partial aggregation rate of fat globules in its emulsion is 14%~30%, preferably 20~30%, and the apparent viscosity of the butter is 420~2500 Pa. s, preferably 420~430Pa The elastic modulus is 17000~30000 Pa, preferably 17000~20000 Pa.

[0017] This invention also provides a method for preparing the above-mentioned pure plant-based 3D printing cream, comprising the following steps: S1. Preparation of aqueous phase: After dry mixing of sugars, composite emulsifiers, composite colloids and plant proteins, dissolve them in pure water, place them in a constant temperature water bath of 80~90 °C for 20~45 min to keep them hydrated, and stir at 300~800 r / min to make them completely hydrated and mixed evenly to obtain the aqueous phase. S2. Oil phase preparation: Weigh palm kernel oil and palm stearin according to the set ratio, place them in a constant temperature water bath at 80~90 °C and heat until completely melted, then stir magnetically for 20~45 min to obtain a uniform oil phase; S3, Primary Emulsification and High Shear: The oil phase obtained in S2 is slowly added to the aqueous phase obtained in S1, and pre-stirred at 80~90°C for 20~45 min; then, a high-speed disperser is used to shear at 8000~12000 r / min for 2~8 min to obtain the primary emulsion. S4. Homogenization and aging: The primary emulsion obtained in step S3 is injected into a high-pressure homogenizer and homogenized 1 to 3 times under a homogenization pressure of 15 to 35 MPa. After homogenization, the emulsion is rapidly cooled in an ice-water bath for 20 to 60 minutes, and then transferred to a freezing environment of -25 to -15 °C and left to stand for 10 to 30 hours for deep aging and crystallization. S5. Whipping and shaping: Thaw and equilibrate the aged emulsion from step S4 at 2~8 °C for 1~4 h, then whip it in a whipping machine until the surface of the cream forms peaks that do not fall off, thus obtaining the cream to be printed.

[0018] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, in step S1, the hydration temperature is 85 °C, the hydration time is 30 min, and the stirring speed is 500 r / min.

[0019] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, in step S2, the oil phase heating temperature is 85 °C and the magnetic stirring time is 30 min.

[0020] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, in step S3, the pre-stirring temperature is 85 °C and the pre-stirring time is 30 min; the high-speed shearing speed is 10000 r / min and the shearing time is 3.5 min.

[0021] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, in step S4, the homogenization pressure is 18~25 MPa (most preferably 20 MPa), the homogenization is performed twice; the ice-water bath cooling time is 30 min; the freeze aging temperature is -20 °C, and the freeze-standing time is 12~24 h.

[0022] In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, in step S5, the thawing equilibrium temperature is 4 °C and the thawing equilibrium time is 2 h; the whipping is a staged constant speed whipping, specifically: first whipping at low to medium speed (6th speed of whipping machine) for 60 to 120 s, and then whipping at high speed (8th speed of whipping machine) until peaks appear and do not fall.

[0023] This invention also provides a method for evaluating the printability of the above-mentioned pure plant-based 3D printing butter, comprising the following steps: (1) Basic printability screening: The solid fat content (SFC) of the plant-based whipped cream to be tested at 25 °C and the texture hardness after whipping; the material is determined to have basic 3D printability if and only if 130 gf ≤ hardness ≤ 1000 gf and 32% ≤ solid fat content ≤ 65% is satisfied. (2) Fine evaluation of printability grade: For materials that meet the basic printability requirements, the hardness is in the golden range of 130~300gf, and the rheological parameters meet the requirements of an initial apparent viscosity of 420~1100 Pa·s and an elastic modulus of 17000~20000 Pa, the printability grade is judged as "excellent"; if the hardness is greater than 600 gf or the elastic modulus is less than 2000 Pa, or the hardness is in the range of 200~300 gf and the elastic modulus is greater than 10000 Pa, the printability grade is judged as "medium"; other cases that meet the basic printability requirements are judged as "good".

[0024] This invention completely eliminates the use of animal fats (such as anhydrous butter). By refining and selecting a specific ratio of palm kernel oil (or its fractions) to palm stearin, and based on its molecular-liquid oil synergistic mechanism, it fundamentally regulates the network structure evolution of the pure vegetable oil system. This formula constructs a crystal structure that combines rigidity and flexibility, enabling the smooth release of internal interfacial tension. This allows the butter to exhibit excellent shear thinning properties under mechanical extrusion, completely solving the problems of extrusion breakage and subsequent collapse in traditional vegetable-based butter. Furthermore, this invention transforms the previously empirical printing operation into concrete physicochemical parameters (solid fat content and hardness), firmly locking in the optimal physical property window for printing, significantly improving the efficiency of new product development and quality control.

[0025] Beneficial effects: 1. This invention completely eliminates animal-derived oils, utilizing a blend of palm kernel oil (PKO) rich in medium-chain lauric acid and palm stearin (POS) rich in long-chain palmitic acid. The high-melting-point palmitic acid triglycerides act as heterogeneous nucleation seeds during cooling, inducing a strong molecular-liquid oil synergistic co-crystallization effect. This effect overcomes the tendency of pure vegetable oils to form porous structures. β Technical bias in crystal form induces the formation of small, dense "flower-like" clusters. β' The crystalline network significantly enhances the storage modulus and static yield stress at room temperature, giving the material excellent anti-gravity self-supporting stiffness. This precise evolution of the network structure not only provides the system with excellent support but also enables a truly 100% pure plant-based formula, fully aligning with the modern health food trend of "vegetarian and zero cholesterol." 2. This invention strictly controls the solid fat content (SFC) at 25°C within the range of 32% to 65%. Under mechanical agitation and shearing, the aforementioned "flower-like" crystals can pierce the oil-water interface film to a suitable depth, driving interface reconstruction. Under these parameters, fat globules achieve precise "moderate partial aggregation" of 20% to 30% (optimal 23.61%), avoiding the formation of disordered large clumps. This uniform, flexible fat globul-bubble composite network allows the cream to undergo smooth shear thinning under high shear in the nozzle (zero-shear apparent viscosity 425.32 Pa·s, smooth extrusion without clogging). After being freed from constraints, it can instantly complete stress reconstruction, completely solving the industry problem of traditional pure vegetable fat cream being "collapsed when soft and clogged when hard."

[0026] 3. This invention breaks through the inefficient R&D model of "formula trial and error, manual testing" that has long relied on food additive manufacturing. With a core initial screening based on hardness of 130 gf to 1000 gf and specific SFC (Surface Collective Facts), combined with fine grading of apparent viscosity and elastic modulus, the machine printability and molding grade of new formulas can be predicted with 100% accuracy in advance. The blind test verification accuracy is extremely high, providing a scientific tool and quantitative standard for high-throughput screening of industrial pure plant-based 3D printing materials. Attached Figure Description

[0027] Figure 1 These are comparison images of the actual 3D printed cream products prepared according to the embodiments and comparative examples of the present invention; Figure 2 This describes the microstructure of the plant-based whipped cream prepared in the embodiments and comparative examples of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0028] The following examples are used to illustrate the present invention, but do not limit the scope of the invention. Unless otherwise specified, the experimental materials, reagents, and instruments used in the embodiments and comparative examples of the present invention are all commercially available, and the technical means used in the embodiments and comparative examples are all conventional means well known to those skilled in the art.

[0029] Test method: (1) Determination of solid fat content (SFC): The solid fat content of the oil was determined using a pulsed nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer. 2 mL of sample was placed in a dedicated NMR tube, and then kept in an 85 °C water bath for 30 min to completely eliminate crystallization memory. Immediately afterwards, it was transferred to a 0 °C water bath and kept for 1.5 h. The solid fat content was measured at 0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, and 45 °C, and curves were plotted.

[0030] (2) Determination of cream hardness: The hardness of whipped cream was determined using a TA.XTC-18 texture analyzer. Whipped cream was filled into a 250 mL container. A TA probe (36 mm) was used to press the cream at a speed of 1 mm / s before, during and after the test. The triggering force was 20 N and the pressing displacement was 10 mm. The hardness value of the cream was then measured.

[0031] (3) Sensory evaluation: A panel of 10 professional food tasters conducted a blind taste test with a score of 100 points. The scoring criteria were as follows: taste and aroma (40 points, with a rich and pure fat aroma, no off-odors or waxy feel being excellent); appearance and color (40 points, with uniform printing lines, clear and non-collapsed structure, and uniform color being excellent); texture (20 points, with a light and delicate texture and no water separation being excellent). The average score was taken as the final score.

[0032] Example 1 A pure plant-based butter suitable for 3D printing, the formula of which consists of the following components by weight percentage: palm kernel oil (PKO) 24%, palm stearin (POS) 6%, sucrose fatty acid ester 1%, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid esters 1%, polysorbate-60 (Tween 60) 1%, soy protein isolate 1%, carrageenan 0.05%, gellan gum 0.05%, white sugar 15%, and purified water 50.9%.

[0033] Its preparation method is as follows: (1) Preparation of aqueous phase: Sucrose fatty acid ester, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid ester, polysorbate-60, soy protein isolate, carrageenan, gellan gum and white sugar are dry mixed evenly, then added to pure water, placed in an 85 °C constant temperature water bath and kept warm for 30 min, and stirred continuously at 500 r / min to make it completely hydrated and dissolved to obtain the aqueous phase.

[0034] (2) Preparation of oil phase: Weigh PKO and POS, place them in an 85 °C constant temperature water bath and heat until completely melted, then stir magnetically for 30 min to obtain a uniformly mixed oil phase.

[0035] (3) Emulsification and high shear: The oil phase was slowly poured into the aqueous phase and pre-stirred at 800 r / min for 30 min at 85 °C; then a high-speed disperser was used to shear at 10000 r / min for 3.5 min to obtain the primary emulsion.

[0036] (4) Homogenization and aging: The primary emulsion was injected into a high-pressure homogenizer, the homogenization pressure was set to 20 MPa, and the homogenization was repeated twice. After homogenization, the emulsion was quickly placed in an ice-water bath for 30 min to cool rapidly, and then transferred to a -20 °C freezer to stand for 24 h for deep aging and crystallization.

[0037] (5) Whipping and shaping: Take out the aged emulsion and place it in a 4 °C refrigerator to thaw and balance for 2 hours. Pour it into a planetary mixer and whip it at a constant speed (8) until the surface of the cream forms peaks that do not fall off. This is the cream to be printed.

[0038] 3D printing of pure plant-based butter: After whipping, the cream was placed in a 4 ℃ refrigerator to equilibrate for 10 minutes, and then transferred to the printing barrel. The barrel temperature was controlled at 25 ℃, and a 0.84 mm nozzle was used to print a 25 mm × 25 mm × 45 mm star cup model at a speed of 20 mm / s. The forming accuracy of the sample was measured and images were collected and recorded.

[0039] Example 2 The difference between Example 2 and Example 1 is that the mass ratio of palm kernel oil is adjusted to 21% and the mass ratio of palm stearin is adjusted to 9%, that is, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin in Example 1 is adjusted from 80:20 to 70:30.

[0040] Example 3 The difference between Example 3 and Example 1 is that the mass ratio of palm kernel oil is adjusted to 18% and the mass ratio of palm stearin is adjusted to 12%, that is, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin in Example 1 is adjusted from 80:20 to 60:40.

[0041] Comparative Example 1 The difference between Comparative Example 1 and Example 1 is that the mass ratio of palm kernel oil was adjusted to 30% and the mass ratio of palm stearin was adjusted to 0%, that is, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin in Example 1 was adjusted from 80:20 to 100:0.

[0042] Comparative Example 2 The difference between Comparative Example 2 and Example 1 is that the mass ratio of palm kernel oil was adjusted to 12% and the mass ratio of palm stearin was adjusted to 18%, that is, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin in Example 1 was adjusted from 80:20 to 40:60.

[0043] Comparative Example 3 The difference between Comparative Example 3 and Example 1 is that the palm kernel oil (PKO) in the oil matrix was replaced with soybean oil (i.e., soybean oil:POS = 80:20). The remaining excipients and the preparation, whipping, and printing processes were exactly the same as in Example 1.

[0044] Comparative Example 4 The difference between Comparative Example 4 and Example 1 is that the palm stearin (POS) in the oil matrix was replaced by coconut oil rich in medium-chain fatty acids (i.e., PKO:coconut oil = 80:20). The remaining excipients and the preparation, whipping, and printing processes were exactly the same as in Example 1.

[0045] Table 1. Summary of Physicochemical Properties, Sensory Properties, and Printing Effects of Pure Vegetable-Based Butter

[0046] From the data in Table 1 and Figure 1 It is known that the blending ratio of different vegetable oils in the oil matrix and their own fatty acid carbon chain structure have a decisive regulatory effect on the phase network, rheological properties and final 3D printing precision of pure plant-based whipped cream.

[0047] 1. Optimal performance and molecular-liquid oil synergistic mechanism in Example 1 Example 1 (PKO:POS = 80:20) exhibited the best overall physical properties and 3D printing performance. This specific ratio induced a molecular-liquid oil co-crystallization mechanism. The high-melting-point long-chain triglycerides (rich in palmitic acid) in POS acted as seed crystals for heterogeneous nucleation during cooling crystallization, effectively guiding the co-crystallization of the low-melting-point components (rich in lauric acid) in PKO. The system maintained a stable solid fat content (SFC) of 36.1% at 25°C, driving a uniform and dense flower-like structure. β' The formation of the crystalline network provides the butter with a sufficient and flexible crystalline framework. Simultaneously, this specific micro-network evolution promotes the optimal (23.61%) "partial aggregation" of fat globules during whipping, resulting in a robust crystalline composite layer at the bubble-water interface. From a rheological and textural perspective, the system's initial hardness reaches 173.31 gf, giving it excellent self-supporting capabilities under static conditions. Furthermore, its initial apparent viscosity (1072.81 Pa·s) and elastic modulus (17157.2 Pa) are within a moderate range, meaning that the material can undergo perfect "shear thinning" behavior under the high shear force of the 3D printing nozzle, achieving smooth extrusion without high resistance. Ultimately, the actual printed lines in Example 1 are continuous and uniform, with no collapse in the three-dimensional stack, and achieved the highest sensory evaluation score of 92.5, completely overcoming the common gelatinous texture of vegetable butter. It achieves molding precision comparable to or even surpassing that of mixed animal and vegetable butter (CN 120052431A) while maintaining a clean label.

[0048] 2. Crystallization imbalance caused by component shift (Comparative Examples 2 and 3 and Comparative Examples 1 and 2) Compared to Example 1, in Examples 2 (PKO:POS=70:30) and 3 (PKO:POS=60:40), with the increase of POS addition, the SFC of the system significantly increased to 48.2% and 55.7%, respectively, and the corresponding hardness also increased sharply to 576.33 gf and 760.23 gf. This compositional change reveals a key pattern: with the increase of saturated palmitic acid content, the crystal density in the system increases, leading to excessive hardening of the interfacial film. This causes the aggregation rate of fat globules during whipping to drop sharply from 23.61% and hover around 14.5%. Rheological data also show that its apparent viscosity and elastic modulus increased significantly, resulting in significant resistance to the material during extrusion. Although the model could still be formed, due to the limited material flowability, the interlayer fusion decreased, the model surface exhibited a slight roughness, and the sensory scores also dropped to 85.0 and 72.5 points, respectively, due to the hard texture and slight waxy feel. This fully demonstrates that 80:20 is the optimal ratio for balancing "structural rigidity" and "extrusion smoothness".

[0049] Comparative Examples 1 and 2, representing two extremes, demonstrate the necessity of the parameter limitations in this invention. In Comparative Example 1 (pure PKO, PKO:POS = 100:0), due to the short chain length of lauric acid, the system's SFC is extremely low (only 8.4%). Lacking a supporting framework provided by high-melting-point lipids, its hardness (22.89 gf) and elastic modulus (1645.06 Pa) plummet, completely failing to reach the threshold for resisting gravity accumulation. Therefore, the material, after extrusion through the nozzle, is semi-fluid and instantly collapses into water, resulting in molding failure.

[0050] In Comparative Example 2 (PKO:POS = 40:60), excessive POS caused severe over-crystallization, with SFC increasing to 73.6%. This extreme bulk crystallization led to emulsion inactivation, and the aggregation of fat globules almost ceased (only 1.8%). Macroscopically, the material hardness (1285 gf) and apparent viscosity (>20000 Pa·s) exceeded the operating limits of the equipment. The huge crystallization agglomerates directly caused severe nozzle clogging and filament breakage, completely eliminating the operability of 3D printing.

[0051] Combined with the aerated microstructure of whipped cream ( Figure 2 Further analysis revealed that in Comparative Example 1 (pure PKO system), the bubble interface was extremely fragile, the droplets were discretely distributed, and the bubbles were prone to merging and breaking, leading to macroscopic collapse; while in Comparative Example 2, excessive crystallization formed coarse clumps that punctured the bubble membrane and destroyed the gas-filling stability of the system.

[0052] In contrast, Example 1, through the precise blending of PKO and POS, elicited a significant molecular-liquid oil synergistic mechanism. PKO provided the basic crystal framework, while POS, acting as an interfacial activity modifier and nucleation seed, induced fine, dense "flower-like" crystals. β' The formation of the crystal network. This precise evolution of the microscopic network structure promotes the optimal partial aggregation of fat globules (around 23.6%), and synergistic crystallization at the bubble-water interface, resulting in a significant thickening of the bubble walls and a uniform pore size distribution.

[0053] 3. Performance analysis of butter with different fat combinations Comparative Example 3 (soybean oil:POS = 80:20) used soybean oil instead of palm kernel oil. Because soybean oil is rich in highly unsaturated fatty acids and is absolutely liquid at room temperature, its strong solvent dilution effect completely destroyed the crystalline network of POS, causing the theoretical SFC of the system to drop below 19.7%. The material completely lost its solid support (hardness only 15.45 gf, elastic modulus dropped to 950.4 Pa), and after extrusion, it became a thin, liquid paste.

[0054] Comparative Example 4 (PKO:coconut oil = 80:20) used coconut oil to replace palm stearin. Although both are solid fats, coconut oil and PKO are also rich in medium-chain fatty acids (lauric acid). The combination of the two not only failed to provide high-melting-point nucleating seeds, but also produced a "eutectic effect," which led to a significant decrease in the crystallization rate of the system. The SFC at 25°C was as low as 18.9%, and the hardness was only 18.62 gf. After extrusion, it suffered severe sagging and collapse.

[0055] Implementation and validation of the printability prediction and evaluation model To verify the scientific validity and universality of the evaluation system constructed in this invention (i.e., it is determined to have basic printability only when 130gf≤hardness≤1000gf and 32%≤SFC≤65%; and further classified according to rheological indicators), two different complex oil matrices were selected and compared in blind tests using comparative examples 3-4.

[0056] Example 4 A type of animal and plant whipped cream suitable for 3D printing has an oil matrix composed of 12% fully hydrogenated palm kernel oil (FHPKO) and 18% anhydrous milk fat (AMF) (i.e., FHPKO:AMF = 4:6, with a total oil content of 30%). The proportions of other auxiliary materials and the preparation, whipping, and printing processes are the same as in Example 1.

[0057] Comparative Example 5 The oil matrix is ​​100% pure palm stearin (POS). The proportions of other excipients and the preparation process are the same as in Example 1.

[0058] According to the detection method of this invention, the sample of Example 4 had an SFC of 36.77%, a hardness of 630.24 gf, an initial apparent viscosity of 754.22 Pa·s, and an elastic modulus (G') of 33717.58 Pa at 25 °C. Based on the judgment rules of this invention, the SFC (36.77%) and hardness (630.24 gf) of this sample fall within the basic printable range, and the initial screening judgment is "printable". Because its hardness > 600 gf and elastic modulus is relatively high, the model's detailed prediction of the printability level is "medium". The material was transferred to the 3D printer barrel and printed at 25 °C. The results show ( Figure 1 The material can be extruded normally and continuously stacked to form a shape without collapsing; however, due to its high hardness, the smoothness of the extruded filaments is slightly inferior, and the manual evaluation of the printing grade is "medium", which is 100% consistent with the model prediction result.

[0059] The sample in Comparative Example 3 had an SFC of 19.7% at 25 °C, a hardness of 15.45 gf, an initial apparent viscosity of 12.35 Pa·s, and an elastic modulus (G') of 950.40 Pa. The SFC (19.7% < 32%) and hardness (15.45 gf < 130 gf) of this sample were significantly lower than the baseline printability limit, and the model directly output the conclusion "unprintable." After whipping, the material was a liquid paste, unable to incorporate air, and completely softened into water after extrusion, thus being judged as "unprintable," perfectly consistent with the model prediction.

[0060] Similarly, the sample in Comparative Example 4 had an SFC of 18.9% at 25 °C, a hardness of 18.62 gf, an initial apparent viscosity of 15.60 Pa·s, and an elastic modulus (G') of 1120.51 Pa. The SFC (18.9% < 32%) and hardness (18.62 gf < 130 gf) of this sample were significantly lower than the basic printability limit, and the model directly output the conclusion "unprintable." After being whipped, the material was extremely soft, exhibiting severe sagging and collapse during printing, completely unable to support the accumulation of any three-dimensional structure, thus being judged as "unprintable," perfectly consistent with the model prediction.

[0061] In contrast, Comparative Example 5, at 25 °C, had an SFC of 75.69%, a hardness of 1796.08 gf, an initial apparent viscosity of 4865.02 Pa·s, and an elastic modulus (G') of 63421.30 Pa. This sample's SFC (75.69% > 65%) and hardness (1796.08 gf > 1000 gf) both significantly exceeded the upper limit of the printable range, leading the model to directly output the conclusion "unprintable." The material exhibited severe crystallization and hardening, triggering an overload alarm on the printer motor. The material was completely unable to be extruded from the nozzle, resulting in a complete printing failure and the determination of "unprintable," perfectly consistent with the model's prediction.

[0062] The test data of all embodiments (Examples 1-4) and comparative examples (Comparative Examples 1-5) of this invention were substituted into the prediction and evaluation model. The mapping relationship between the model prediction conclusions and the actual printing performance is shown in Table 2: Table 2 Summary of Full Gradient Validation of 3D Printing Printability Prediction and Evaluation Model

[0063] Table 2 shows that: Comparative Examples 1, 3, and 4, due to their SFC and hardness indices being below the lower limit (SFC < 32%, hardness < 130 gf), exhibited "collapse and watering" due to a lack of crystal framework and elastic support; Comparative Examples 2 and 5, due to their indices exceeding the upper limit (SFC > 65%, hardness > 1000 gf), experienced "nozzle clogging and overload" due to excessive crystallization. This confirms that the initial screening limits set in this invention have clear rheological critical significance.

[0064] The model's detailed predictions for Examples 1 ("Excellent"), 2 ("Good"), 3 ("Average"), and 4 ("Average") are 100% consistent with the actual printing accuracy, surface smoothness, and sensory evaluation. This demonstrates that the multidimensional evaluation model constructed in this invention breaks through the limitations of traditional 3D printing formulations that rely on "manual trial printing," and can achieve objective, quantitative, and high-throughput prediction of material machine printability and molding grade through simple physicochemical and rheological parameters.

[0065] The embodiments provided above are not intended to limit the scope of the invention, nor are the described steps intended to limit the order of execution. Any obvious modifications made to the invention by those skilled in the art based on existing common knowledge also fall within the scope of protection defined by the claims.

Claims

1. A pure plant-based 3D-printed butter based on a crystalline network and parameter-defined parameters, characterized in that, The product comprises, by mass percentage, the following components: 25%–35% oil matrix, 1%–4% composite emulsifier, 0.05%–0.2% composite colloid, 0.5%–1.5% plant protein, 10%–20% sugars, and the balance being water; wherein the oil matrix is ​​composed of palm kernel oil or palm kernel oil extract and palm stearin, and the mass ratio of palm kernel oil or palm kernel oil extract to palm stearin in the oil matrix is ​​1.5:1–9:

1.

2. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 1, characterized in that, The mass ratio of palm kernel oil or palm kernel oil extract to palm stearin in the oil matrix is ​​4:1 to 5:

1.

3. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 1, characterized in that, The composite emulsifier is selected from at least two of sucrose fatty acid esters, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid esters, polysorbates, sorbitan mono-fatty acid esters, sodium stearoyl lactylate, and propylene glycol fatty acid esters, and the plant protein is selected from at least one of soy protein isolate, pea protein isolate, broad bean protein, chickpea protein, oat protein, and rice protein.

4. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 3, characterized in that, The composite emulsifier is a ternary compound of sucrose fatty acid ester, mono- and diglyceride fatty acid ester and polysorbate-60, with a mass ratio of 1:1:1 to 1:3:

1.

5. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 1, characterized in that, The composite colloid is a mixture of carrageenan and gellan gum; the mass ratio of carrageenan to gellan gum is 6:4 to 4:

6.

6. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 1, characterized in that, The pure plant-based 3D printed butter comprises the following components by weight percentage: 30% oil matrix, 1% sucrose fatty acid ester, 1% mono- and diglyceride fatty acid ester, 1% polysorbate-60, 1% soy protein isolate, 0.05% carrageenan, 0.05% gellan gum, 15% white sugar, and the balance being purified water; wherein, in the oil matrix, the mass ratio of palm kernel oil to palm stearin is 80:

20.

7. The pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to claim 1, characterized in that, The pure plant-based 3D printed cream has a solid fat content of 32%~65% at 25 °C; and the texture hardness of the cream after aeration and whipping is controlled at 130~1000 gf. After whipping, the partial aggregation rate of fat globules in the emulsion of the pure plant-based 3D printed cream is 14%~30%, and the apparent viscosity of the cream is 420~2500 Pa. s, with an elastic modulus of 17000~30000 Pa.

8. A method for preparing pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: S1. Preparation of aqueous phase: After dry mixing of sugars, composite emulsifiers, composite colloids and plant proteins, dissolve them in pure water, place them in a constant temperature water bath of 80~90 °C for 20~45 min to keep them hydrated, and stir at 300~800 r / min to make them completely hydrated and mixed evenly to obtain the aqueous phase. S2. Oil phase preparation: Weigh palm kernel oil and palm stearin according to the set ratio, place them in a constant temperature water bath of 80~90 °C and heat until completely melted, stir magnetically for 20~45 min to obtain a uniform oil phase; S3, Primary Emulsification and High Shear: The oil phase obtained in S2 is slowly added to the aqueous phase obtained in S1, and pre-stirred at 80~90°C for 20~45 min; then, a high-speed disperser is used to shear at 8000~12000 r / min for 2~8 min to obtain the primary emulsion. S4. Homogenization and aging: The primary emulsion obtained in step S3 is injected into a high-pressure homogenizer and homogenized 1 to 3 times under a homogenization pressure of 15 to 35 MPa. After homogenization, the emulsion is rapidly cooled in an ice-water bath for 20 to 60 min, and then transferred to a freezing environment of -25 to -15 °C and left to stand for 10 to 30 h for deep aging and crystallization. S5. Whipping and shaping: Thaw and equilibrate the aged emulsion from step S4 at 2~8 °C for 1~4 h, then whip it in a whipping machine until the surface of the cream forms peaks that do not fall off, thus obtaining the cream to be printed.

9. The preparation method according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step S5, the thawing equilibrium temperature is 4 °C and the thawing equilibrium time is 2 hours. The whipping is a staged constant speed whipping, specifically: first, whip at low to medium speed (6th speed of the whipping machine) for 60 to 120 seconds, and then whip at high speed (8th speed of the whipping machine) until peaks appear and do not fall.

10. A method for evaluating the printability of pure plant-based 3D printing butter according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: (1) Basic printability screening: Obtain the solid fat content and texture hardness of the plant-based whipped cream under 25 °C conditions; the material is deemed to have basic 3D printability if and only if 130 gf ≤ hardness ≤ 1000 gf and 32% ≤ solid fat content ≤ 65%. (2) Fine evaluation of printability grade: For materials that meet the basic printability requirements, the hardness is in the golden range of 130~300gf, and the rheological parameters meet the requirements of an initial apparent viscosity of 420~1100 Pa·s and an elastic modulus of 17000~20000 Pa, the printability grade is judged as "excellent"; if the hardness is greater than 600 gf or the elastic modulus is less than 2000 Pa, or the hardness is in the range of 200~300 gf and the elastic modulus is greater than 10000 Pa, the printability grade is judged as "medium"; other cases that meet the basic printability requirements are judged as "good".

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Pure plant-based vegetarian whipping cream and preparation method thereof

    CN118592497A

  • Preparation method of high-stability whipped animal and plant cream and application of high-stability whipped animal and plant cream in 3D printing

    CN120052431A