A method for dual-edge feedback compensation of oblique incidence multilayer optical films
By generating the Bragg wavelength distribution and calculating the feedback quantity to update the design band, the correspondence between the normal short-wavelength edge and the oblique-incident long-wavelength edge in the oblique-incident multilayer optical film was solved, realizing the continuous connection of film thickness and the stability of feedback results.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611182948.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-08-05
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
In existing oblique incidence multilayer optical film designs, it is difficult to correspond the normal short-wave edge and the oblique incidence long-wave edge to the film generation parameters respectively. After the design parameters change, the Bragg wavelength distribution and the film thickness are inconsistent, and the feedback results are easily affected by the sampling position, making it difficult to coordinate continuously.
By acquiring refractive index dispersion data and the target application band, the Bragg wavelength distribution is generated, the reflection spectrum and feedback quantity are calculated, the design band and film thickness are updated, and candidate compensation film system states are formed until the feedback quantity meets the edge judgment condition.
It achieves continuous correspondence between the normal short-wave edge and the obliquely incident long-wave edge, reduces the inconsistency between the design wavelength and thickness of the film layer after the design boundary changes, reduces local spectral ripples and polarization differences, and improves the stability and accuracy of film system design.
Smart Images

Figure CN123113146A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the fields of optical thin film design and interference filtering technology, and in particular to a method for dual-edge feedback compensation of obliquely incident multilayer optical films. Background Technology
[0002] In the field of optical thin film design, multilayer optical films typically consist of alternating high-refractive-index and low-refractive-index layers on a substrate. By setting the center wavelength, design band, number of layers, and optical thickness of each layer, a film system with a target reflection spectrum is formed. Existing oblique incidence compensation schemes usually employ methods such as center wavelength pre-biasing, overall scaling of film thickness, high-refractive-index material configuration, or multi-angle objective function iteration to adjust the film system parameters based on the normal reflection spectrum and oblique incidence reflection spectrum.
[0003] When the incidence of a multilayer optical film changes from normal to oblique, the propagation angle and phase thickness within the film layer change accordingly, and the reflection band usually shifts towards the shorter wavelength direction. When using a single center wavelength offset or uniform adjustment of the thickness of all film layers, the coverage state of the long-wavelength edge under oblique incidence and the reflection state of the short-wavelength edge under normal incidence can easily interfere with each other. When using multi-parameter iteration involving film layer thickness, number of film layers, and material refractive index, there is no clear correspondence between the edge states under the two incidence conditions and the specific film system parameters.
[0004] Existing solutions typically involve directly modifying part of the film thickness or recalculating the general objective function when film parameters change. This can easily lead to inconsistencies between the design band, the design wavelength corresponding to the film layer group, and the total film thickness. Furthermore, spectral ripples and polarization differences may exist near the edges of obliquely incident long-wavelength areas. When using a single wavelength point for edge determination, the feedback results are prone to changing with the sampling position, making it difficult to continuously coordinate the edges of normal short-wavelength areas and obliquely incident long-wavelength areas.
[0005] Therefore, it is necessary to design multilayer optical films for fixed target application bands, and solve the problems that it is difficult to correspond the normal short-wave edge and the obliquely incident long-wave edge to the film generation parameters respectively, and that it is difficult to synchronously connect the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers after the design parameters change. Summary of the Invention
[0006] To address the aforementioned technical problems, this invention provides a method for oblique incidence multilayer optical film dual-edge feedback compensation, comprising: S100: Acquire refractive index dispersion data, fix the target application band, target oblique incidence angle, initial design band and edge determination conditions; take the initial design band as the current design band, generate Bragg wavelength distribution according to its start and end wavelengths, and calculate the thickness of all film layers in combination with the refractive index dispersion data to form the film system design state. S200. Based on the membrane system design state, calculate the normal reflection spectrum and the reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle; calculate the difference between the short-wave edge reflectivity and the weighted average of multiple reflectivity values in the long-wave edge neighborhood and the corresponding reflectivity threshold, respectively, to form the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity, and generate a dual-edge feedback state. S300. Based on the dual-edge feedback state, update the starting wavelength of the current design band with the first feedback amount and update its ending wavelength with the second feedback amount to form an updated design band; regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and all film thicknesses according to the updated design band to form a candidate compensation film system state. S400: Regenerate the dual-edge feedback state based on the candidate compensation membrane system state; when both the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity meet the edge determination condition, output the updated design band and membrane thickness; otherwise, return to S300 with the updated design band as the current design band.
[0007] Furthermore, the multilayer optical film corresponding to the film system design state includes a substrate and multiple film layer groups sequentially disposed on the substrate; each film layer group consists of a high refractive index film layer and a low refractive index film layer; the refractive index dispersion data includes the refractive indices of the high refractive index film layer, the low refractive index film layer and the substrate in the fixed target application band and the current design band.
[0008] Furthermore, the generated Bragg wavelength distribution includes: Multiple Bragg wavelengths are generated at wavelength intervals between the start and end wavelengths of the current design band. According to the arrangement order of multiple film layers, multiple Bragg wavelengths are associated with multiple film layers one by one; Based on the refractive indices of the high-refractive-index film and the low-refractive-index film at each Bragg wavelength, the optical thicknesses of the high-refractive-index film and the low-refractive-index film in the corresponding film group are calculated, and the optical thicknesses are converted into physical thicknesses.
[0009] Furthermore, the short-wave edge reflectance is the reflectance of the normal reflection spectrum at the wavelength corresponding to the short-wave edge of the applied band of the fixed target; The long-wavelength edge neighborhood is composed of multiple wavelength sampling points set at wavelength intervals on both sides of the long-wavelength edge of the fixed target application band. The corresponding reflectivity threshold includes a first reflectivity threshold corresponding to the shortwave edge reflectivity and a second reflectivity threshold corresponding to the weighted average value; The first feedback quantity includes the difference between the shortwave edge reflectivity and the first reflectivity threshold, and the second feedback quantity includes the difference between the weighted average value and the second reflectivity threshold.
[0010] Furthermore, the updating of the start and end wavelengths of the current design band includes: Starting from the initial wavelength of the current design band, multiple candidate initial wavelengths are generated in the short-wave and long-wave directions with a coarse step size; the Bragg wavelength distribution and the total film thickness are regenerated according to each candidate initial wavelength, and the corresponding first feedback quantity is calculated; two adjacent candidate initial wavelengths with different states at their normal short-wave edges are combined to form the design initial boundary search interval. Starting from the termination wavelength of the current design band, multiple candidate termination wavelengths are generated in the short-wave and long-wave directions with a coarse step size; the Bragg wavelength distribution and the total film thickness are regenerated according to each candidate termination wavelength, and the corresponding second feedback quantity is calculated; two candidate termination wavelengths that are adjacent and have different states at the obliquely incident long-wave edge are combined to form the design termination boundary search interval.
[0011] Further, the median value of the design start boundary search interval and the design end boundary search interval are calculated respectively, and the median value is used as the candidate design boundary; Based on the candidate design boundary, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and calculate the first feedback quantity or the second feedback quantity corresponding to the candidate design boundary. Based on the edge satisfaction state corresponding to the first or second feedback quantity, the candidate design boundary replaces one end of the corresponding boundary search interval that has the same edge satisfaction state. Repeat the calculation of the intermediate value until the width of the corresponding boundary search interval is no greater than the boundary search precision.
[0012] Furthermore, when neither the first feedback quantity nor the second feedback quantity meets the corresponding edge determination condition: First, update the starting wavelength of the current design band based on the first feedback quantity, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and regenerate the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity. Then, based on the regenerated second feedback quantity, update the termination wavelength of the current design band, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and regenerate the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity again. When any feedback quantity changes from meeting the corresponding edge determination condition to not meeting the corresponding edge determination condition, the next round of updating the start wavelength and the end wavelength continues.
[0013] Furthermore, when the first feedback quantity corresponding to multiple candidate start wavelengths or the second feedback quantity corresponding to multiple candidate end wavelengths does not change monotonically according to the order of the corresponding candidate wavelengths, the preset design boundary allowable adjustment range is divided into multiple sub-intervals. Search for adjacent candidate starting wavelengths or candidate ending wavelengths with different edge states in multiple sub-intervals, and form a design starting boundary search interval or a design ending boundary search interval with adjacent candidate starting wavelengths. When there are multiple design start boundary search intervals or multiple design end boundary search intervals, calculate another feedback quantity for the candidate compensation membrane system state corresponding to each boundary search interval, and select the boundary search interval with the smaller absolute value of the other feedback quantity for bisection refinement.
[0014] Furthermore, the reflection spectrum at the oblique incidence angle of the target includes TE polarization reflection spectrum and TM polarization reflection spectrum; The reflectance of the TE polarization reflectance spectrum and the TM polarization reflectance spectrum at multiple wavelength sampling points in the long-wavelength edge neighborhood is extracted respectively. At each wavelength sampling point, the smaller reflectance of the TE polarization reflectance spectrum and the TM polarization reflectance spectrum is selected, and a weighted average is performed on the multiple smaller reflectances. The resulting weighted average is used to form the second feedback quantity.
[0015] Furthermore, it also includes: When the starting wavelength of the current design band is not less than the ending wavelength, the previous valid design band is restored to the current design band. When the number of iterations reaches the maximum number of iterations and the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity do not simultaneously meet the edge determination condition, a non-converged state is generated, and the previous effective design band and its corresponding total film thickness are output. After both the first and second feedback quantities meet the edge determination conditions, the physical thickness of each film layer is compared with the minimum and maximum film thicknesses, and the sum of the physical thicknesses of all film layers is compared with the total film thickness limit. If the corresponding limit is not met, a manufacturing constraint conflict state is generated. If the corresponding limit is met, the film material sequence, film thickness table, normal reflection spectrum and oblique incidence reflection spectrum are output.
[0016] The key innovations of this invention include: (1) The fixed target application band is set separately from the current design band used for film thickness calculation. The Bragg wavelength distribution is defined by the start wavelength and end wavelength of the current design band. The thickness of all films is calculated in conjunction with the Bragg wavelength and the one-to-one correlation between multiple film groups.
[0017] (2) Under the same film system design state, the short-wave edge reflectivity of the normal reflection spectrum and multiple reflectivity values of the long-wave edge neighborhood under the oblique incident angle of the target are used as feedback basis respectively. The edge reflectivity difference and the neighborhood reflectivity weighted average difference are used to form the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity, and are respectively associated with the starting wavelength and the ending wavelength of the current design band.
[0018] (3) The update of any boundary of the design band is linked with the regeneration of the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity are verified based on the regenerated candidate compensation film system state; if the edge judgment conditions are not met at the same time, the updated design band is used as the current design band in the next round to continue the double boundary adjustment.
[0019] The following are its main beneficial effects: (1) By distinguishing between fixed target application bands and adjustable design bands, edge evaluation is always based on the same application wavelength range. At the same time, the Bragg wavelengths corresponding to the design bands and film layers and the thickness of all film layers are kept in continuous correspondence, reducing the inconsistency between the design wavelength and film thickness after the design boundary changes.
[0020] (2) By corresponding the normal short-wave edge and the obliquely incident long-wave edge to two design boundaries respectively, the mutual restraint between the two edges caused by a single center wavelength offset or overall adjustment of the film thickness is reduced; the long-wave edge adopts the weighted average result of multiple reflectivity values in the neighborhood, which can reduce the influence of local spectral ripples and single sampling position on the second feedback quantity.
[0021] (3) By regenerating the complete membrane system and verifying the two feedback quantities after each design boundary change, the cross-effect of one design boundary adjustment on the other edge state can be identified, reducing the discontinuity of Bragg wavelength distribution caused by local modification of membrane thickness, and the situation where edges that have met the edge determination conditions are mismatched again in subsequent adjustments and are not identified. Attached Figure Description
[0022] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating a method for oblique incidence multilayer optical film dual-edge feedback compensation provided in an embodiment of this application. Detailed Implementation
[0023] Example 1: Refer to Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating a method for oblique incidence multilayer optical film dual-edge feedback compensation provided in an embodiment of the present invention. The process may include at least steps S100-S400: S100: Acquire refractive index dispersion data, fix the target application band, target oblique incidence angle, initial design band and edge determination conditions; take the initial design band as the current design band, generate Bragg wavelength distribution according to its start and end wavelengths, and calculate the thickness of all film layers in combination with the refractive index dispersion data to form the film system design state. S200. Based on the membrane system design state, calculate the normal reflection spectrum and the reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle; calculate the difference between the short-wave edge reflectivity and the weighted average of multiple reflectivity values in the long-wave edge neighborhood and the corresponding reflectivity threshold, respectively, to form the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity, and generate a dual-edge feedback state. S300. Based on the dual-edge feedback state, update the starting wavelength of the current design band with the first feedback amount and update its ending wavelength with the second feedback amount to form an updated design band; regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and all film thicknesses according to the updated design band to form a candidate compensation film system state. S400: Regenerate the dual-edge feedback state based on the candidate compensation membrane system state; when both the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity meet the edge determination condition, output the updated design band and membrane thickness; otherwise, return to S300 with the updated design band as the current design band.
[0024] S100: Acquire refractive index and dispersion data, fix the target application band, target oblique incidence angle, initial design band, and edge determination conditions; using the initial design band as the current design band, generate Bragg wavelength distributions according to their start and end wavelengths, and calculate the thickness of all film layers in conjunction with the refractive index and dispersion data to form the film system design state: This implementation is performed by an optical film design device. The optical film design device includes a memory, a processor, a material refractive index and dispersion database, and a reflectance spectrum calculation program. The memory stores the film material, substrate, number of film layers, fixed target application wavelength, target oblique incidence angle, initial design wavelength, and edge determination conditions. After reading the above information, the processor first establishes the distinction between the fixed target application wavelength and the current design wavelength, and then generates the film structure according to the current design wavelength. The fixed target application wavelength does not change with the design boundary during the compensation process; its short-wavelength edge and long-wavelength edge serve as fixed wavelength positions for subsequent normal reflectance spectrum evaluation and oblique incidence reflectance spectrum evaluation, respectively. The current design wavelength is the internal design range used to calculate the thickness of each film layer, and its starting and ending wavelengths are updated during subsequent feedback processes.
[0025] Refractive index dispersion data includes the refractive indices of high-refractive-index film materials, low-refractive-index film materials, and the substrate within the fixed target application wavelength band and the initial design wavelength band. The refractive index dispersion data is provided by material measurement results or a material refractive index dispersion database. After reading the dispersion data, the processor checks whether the effective wavelength range of each material covers the fixed target application wavelength band and the current design wavelength band. When a material has discrete wavelength intervals within its effective wavelength range, interpolation is performed according to adjacent measured wavelengths and their corresponding refractive indices to obtain the material's refractive index at the Bragg wavelength. If the current design wavelength band exceeds the material's effective wavelength range, the excess portion is not directly extrapolated; instead, the previous effective design wavelength band is retained, and a refractive index dispersion data insufficiency state is generated. This state prevents the current film system from entering S200 until refractive index dispersion data within the corresponding wavelength range is supplemented or the current design wavelength band is narrowed.
[0026] The multilayer optical film includes a substrate and multiple layers sequentially disposed on the substrate. Each layer group includes one high-refractive-index layer and one low-refractive-index layer. The layer groups are arranged from the substrate side to the incident medium side, or from the incident medium side to the substrate side, but the arrangement direction remains unchanged within the same round of film system calculation. The layer group configuration includes the number of layer groups, the arrangement order of the high-refractive-index and low-refractive-index layers, the refractive index of the substrate, and the refractive index of the incident medium. The number of layer groups remains constant during a round of dual-edge compensation to avoid abrupt changes in the reflection band structure caused by changes in the design boundary and the number of layer groups simultaneously. If the number of layer groups needs to be changed, the current round is ended and S100 is re-executed with the new layer group configuration.
[0027] The Bragg wavelength distribution is generated by the starting wavelength, ending wavelength, and number of film layers in the current design band. Let λa be the starting wavelength, λb be the ending wavelength, and N be the number of film layers. When multiple Bragg wavelengths are arranged with equal wavelength intervals, the Bragg wavelength corresponding to the i-th film layer is the i-th sampling wavelength between λa and λb, where the first film layer corresponds to λa, the last film layer corresponds to λb, and the remaining Bragg wavelengths are arranged with the same wavelength interval. The processor associates multiple Bragg wavelengths with multiple film layers one-to-one according to the arrangement order of the film layers, so that the short-wavelength end of the design band corresponds to the film layers at one end, and the long-wavelength end of the design band corresponds to the film layers at the other end. After the boundary update, multiple Bragg wavelengths are recalculated based on the new starting and ending wavelengths, and the Bragg wavelengths before the boundary update are not used.
[0028] In another implementation, the Bragg wavelength distribution employs non-uniform wavelength spacing. The processor, based on bandwidth allocation rules at different locations within the target reflection band, sets denser Bragg wavelengths near the edges and larger wavelength spacing in the middle of the reflection band. Regardless of the distribution method, both the design start wavelength and the design end wavelength participate in the calculation of all Bragg wavelengths; after a boundary change, not only are the design wavelengths of the film layers adjacent to that boundary altered, but the entire Bragg wavelength distribution within the current design band is also recalculated. Each Bragg wavelength in the Bragg wavelength distribution retains its corresponding film layer group number, and the material arrangement is maintained unchanged according to this number when subsequently regenerating the film thickness.
[0029] The processor calculates the film thickness of the corresponding film group based on the refractive index dispersion data at each Bragg wavelength. In one embodiment, the high-refractive-index film and the low-refractive-index film use quarter-wave optical thickness. The physical thickness of the high-refractive-index film is obtained by dividing the corresponding Bragg wavelength by four times the refractive index of the high-refractive-index film at that wavelength, and the physical thickness of the low-refractive-index film is obtained by dividing the corresponding Bragg wavelength by four times the refractive index of the low-refractive-index film at that wavelength. Since the refractive index varies with wavelength, each film group uses the refractive index at its own Bragg wavelength, rather than uniformly using the refractive index at the center wavelength. All the resulting film thicknesses are arranged in order of film group and together with the film material sequence to form the current film thickness set.
[0030] In another implementation, the film layers employ a preset phase thickness ratio. The processor first calculates the reference optical thickness based on the Bragg wavelength and the material's refractive index, and then allocates the corresponding physical thickness according to the phase thickness coefficients of the high-refractive-index and low-refractive-index films. The phase thickness coefficient remains unchanged during a compensation cycle, and the feedback process only updates the start and end wavelengths of the design band. With this setting, the design boundary still acts on all film thicknesses through the Bragg wavelength distribution, without setting each film thickness as an independent feedback variable.
[0031] After all film thicknesses are generated, the processor checks whether the starting wavelength of the current design band is less than the ending wavelength, and verifies whether each film layer group has the corresponding Bragg wavelength, material refractive index, and two physical thicknesses. If a film layer group lacks a Bragg wavelength, the material refractive index cannot be obtained, or the physical thickness is non-positive, the current film system design state will not be included in the reflection spectrum calculation; the processor will restore the previous valid design band, or restore the initial design band during the first calculation, and regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution. After the above verification is successful, the processor combines the current design band, Bragg wavelength distribution, film material sequence, all film thicknesses, substrate refractive index, and incident medium refractive index into a film system design state. S200 reads the film layer arrangement relationship and film thickness in this film system design state, and calculates the normal reflection spectrum and the reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle, respectively.
[0032] In one engineering implementation, the fixed target application wavelength is set to 450–650 nm, the target oblique incidence angle is set to 45°, the initial design wavelength is set to 450–720 nm, and the number of film layers is set to 24. The refractive index dispersion data of the high-refractive-index film material and the low-refractive-index film material cover 400–800 nm, respectively. The short-wavelength edge of the fixed target application wavelength is 450 nm, and the long-wavelength edge is 650 nm. The processor generates 24 Bragg wavelengths in the 450–720 nm range and associates them according to the order of the film layers from the substrate side to the incident medium side. This parameter constitutes only one implementation; the fixed target application wavelength, the initial design wavelength, the target oblique incidence angle, and the number of film layers are set according to the actual operating conditions of the optical element.
[0033] S200. Based on the membrane system design state, calculate the normal reflection spectrum and the reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle; calculate the difference between the short-wave edge reflectance, the weighted average of multiple reflectance values in the long-wave edge neighborhood, and the corresponding reflectance threshold, respectively, to form the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity, generating a dual-edge feedback state: After the membrane system design is established, the reflectance spectroscopy calculation program reads the membrane material sequence, total membrane thickness, material refractive index and dispersion data, substrate refractive index, and incident medium refractive index. Both normal reflectance and oblique incidence reflectance spectra are calculated for the same membrane structure; the difference lies in the incident angle and the propagation angle within the membrane. The wavelength calculation range of the reflectance spectrum covers the fixed target application band, and reserves the calculation range beyond the short-wavelength edge and the long-wavelength edge, ensuring that subsequent edge neighborhood sampling is not truncated by the fixed target application band boundary. The reflectance spectrum wavelength interval is set according to the resolution required for edge determination and is smaller than the interval between adjacent wavelength sampling points within the long-wavelength edge neighborhood.
[0034] In one implementation, the reflectance spectrum is calculated using the transfer matrix method. For each calculation wavelength, the processor first obtains the refractive indices of the incident medium, each film layer, and the substrate from the refractive index dispersion data. At normal incidence, the propagation angle within each film layer is 0°. The phase thickness is obtained based on the refractive index, physical thickness, and calculation wavelength of each film layer. Subsequently, the characteristic matrices of each film layer are multiplied sequentially according to their arrangement to obtain the characteristic matrix of the entire film system. The normal reflectance is then calculated by combining the optical admittance of the incident medium and the optical admittance of the substrate. The processor repeats the above process for all calculation wavelengths to form the normal reflectance spectrum.
[0035] When calculating the reflection spectrum at an oblique incidence angle, the processor calculates the propagation angle in each film layer based on the oblique incidence angle, the refractive index of the incident medium, and the refractive index of each film layer. The propagation angle is then incorporated into the phase thickness and optical admittance. The first occurrence of transverse electric polarization is denoted as Transverse Electric polarization (TE polarization); the first occurrence of transverse magnetic polarization is denoted as Transverse Magnetic polarization (TM polarization). TE polarization and TM polarization are respectively used to calculate the film layer characteristic matrix using the corresponding optical admittance, forming TE polarization reflection spectra and TM polarization reflection spectra. When the incident light has a specified polarization state, the oblique incidence reflection spectrum uses the corresponding polarization reflection spectrum; when the incident light does not have a specified polarization state, the TE polarization reflectance and TM polarization reflectance are combined according to preset polarization evaluation conditions.
[0036] In one implementation, the polarization evaluation condition employs a wavelength-wise smaller reflectance rule. The processor compares the TE-polarized reflectance and TM-polarized reflectance at each wavelength sampling point in the long-wavelength edge neighborhood, selecting the smaller reflectance for calculation of the second feedback quantity. This rule ensures that the second feedback quantity corresponds to the polarization state with lower reflectance under oblique incidence conditions. In another implementation, the two polarization reflectances are weighted according to the ratio of the TE and TM polarization components in the incident light; the polarization ratio is given by the incident light conditions of the optical system and remains constant within the same round of boundary search.
[0037] After the normal reflection spectrum is generated, the processor reads the wavelength corresponding to the shortwave edge of the fixed target application band and obtains the normal reflectance at that wavelength, which is recorded as the shortwave edge reflectance. The edge determination condition includes a first reflectance threshold corresponding to the shortwave edge reflectance. The processor calculates the difference between the shortwave edge reflectance and the first reflectance threshold and records this difference as a first feedback quantity. In one embodiment, the first feedback quantity is calculated by subtracting the first reflectance threshold from the shortwave edge reflectance; when the first feedback quantity is not less than 0, the normal shortwave edge state is recorded as compliant; when the first feedback quantity is less than 0, the normal shortwave edge state is recorded as non-compliant. In addition to indicating the compliant state, the first feedback quantity also retains the magnitude of the difference, which S300 uses to compare the shortwave edge states corresponding to the starting wavelengths of different candidate designs.
[0038] After the oblique incidence reflection spectrum is generated, the processor sets up a long-wavelength edge neighborhood around the long-wavelength edge of the fixed target application band. The long-wavelength edge neighborhood consists of multiple wavelength sampling points located on both the short-wavelength and long-wavelength sides of the long-wavelength edge. These sampling points are arranged at preset wavelength intervals and include the wavelength corresponding to the long-wavelength edge. When the long-wavelength edge is located between two sampling points, the processor interpolates the reflectance corresponding to the long-wavelength edge using adjacent reflectance values and uses this reflectance as a sample value in the neighborhood calculation. When a sampling point exceeds the current reflection spectrum calculation range, the reflection spectrum calculation program first expands the calculation wavelength range, then extracts the corresponding reflectance, and directly calculates the weighted average without using missing sampling points.
[0039] The processor performs a weighted average of multiple reflectivity values within the neighborhood of the long-wavelength edge. The weights are set according to the wavelength distance between each sampling point and the target long-wavelength edge, and are normalized so that the sum of all weights is 1. In one implementation, sampling points closer to the target long-wavelength edge have a larger weight, and sampling points farther away have a smaller weight; sampling points equidistant from each other on both sides of the long-wavelength edge have the same weight. This weighting method does not rely on local peaks or troughs at a single wavelength point and maintains the reflection level near the target long-wavelength edge corresponding to the feedback quantity. The processor calculates the difference between the weighted average and a second reflectivity threshold, and records this difference as the second feedback quantity. When the second feedback quantity is not less than 0, the oblique incidence long-wavelength edge state is recorded as compliant; when the second feedback quantity is less than 0, the oblique incidence long-wavelength edge state is recorded as non-compliant.
[0040] In another implementation, multiple reflectance values are first subjected to local linear or local polynomial fitting, and then the smoothed reflectance at the target long-wavelength edge is read from the fitted curve. The difference between this smoothed reflectance and a second reflectance threshold is used to form a second feedback quantity. When using the fitting method, the fitting order and the width of the long-wavelength edge neighborhood remain unchanged in one round of boundary search. When the fitting residual is greater than a preset residual range, the processor expands the long-wavelength edge neighborhood or reduces the fitting order and recalculates the second feedback quantity; candidate film systems that fail to fit are not considered valid sampling points for the boundary satisfaction state.
[0041] The first feedback quantity, the second feedback quantity, the normal short-wave edge state, the oblique incidence long-wave edge state, and the corresponding current design band together constitute the dual-edge feedback state. The dual-edge feedback state does not treat the entire reflection spectrum as the direct adjustment target of S300, but rather retains the feedback results corresponding to the two design boundaries. The first feedback quantity corresponds to the starting wavelength of the current design band, and the second feedback quantity corresponds to the ending wavelength of the current design band. After reading the two feedback quantities and their compliance states, S300 updates the design boundaries that do not meet the edge determination conditions; when a certain feedback quantity already meets the corresponding condition, the design boundary corresponding to that feedback quantity remains unchanged in the current update stage, but it is still re-verified after the other boundary is updated and the film system is regenerated.
[0042] S300. Based on the dual-edge feedback state, update the starting wavelength of the current design band with the first feedback amount and update its ending wavelength with the second feedback amount to form an updated design band; regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers according to the updated design band to form a candidate compensation film system state: Design boundary updates are performed by the design band adjustment procedure. This procedure receives the dual-edge feedback state generated in S200 and reads the current design band, the allowable adjustment range of the design boundary, the coarse step size, and the boundary search accuracy. The design start wavelength and design end wavelength are not treated as a unified translation amount for the same center wavelength; the first feedback quantity only participates in the search for the design start wavelength, and the second feedback quantity only participates in the search for the design end wavelength. When a feedback quantity meets its corresponding edge determination condition, the design boundary corresponding to that feedback quantity is kept unchanged; after the other boundary is updated and a candidate compensation membrane system state is formed, S400 recalculates the two feedback quantities and then decides whether to continue updating.
[0043] When the first feedback quantity does not meet the edge determination condition, the design band adjustment program takes the current design starting wavelength as the starting point and sets candidate starting wavelengths in both the short-wave and long-wave directions within the allowable adjustment range of the design starting boundary. A coarse step size is used between adjacent candidate starting wavelengths. For each candidate starting wavelength, the design termination wavelength is kept at its current value; the processor uses the candidate starting wavelength and the current design termination wavelength to form a candidate design band, and regenerates all Bragg wavelengths according to the Bragg wavelength generation rule in S100. Since the change of the starting boundary will change the design band span, the processor recalculates the Bragg wavelengths and film thicknesses corresponding to all film layers, modifying not only the film layers adjacent to the starting boundary.
[0044] After generating the complete film thickness for each candidate design band, the reflectance spectrum calculation program calculates the normal reflectance spectrum according to the S200 method and forms the first feedback quantity corresponding to the candidate starting wavelength. The processor compares the normal shortwave edge states of adjacent candidate values according to the order of the candidate starting wavelengths; when a candidate value corresponds to a compliant state and an adjacent candidate value corresponds to a non-compliant state, the two are combined into a design starting boundary search interval. If no state change occurs, the candidate values continue to be expanded within the allowable adjustment range of the design starting boundary. If a search interval is not formed after reaching the endpoint of the allowable adjustment range, the current starting boundary search is recorded as a state with no effective search interval, and binary refinement is not directly performed.
[0045] When the second feedback quantity does not meet the edge determination condition, the design band adjustment program generates multiple candidate termination wavelengths starting from the current design termination wavelength, respectively, in the short-wave and long-wave directions. For each candidate termination wavelength, the design starting wavelength is kept at its current value; the processor regenerates the entire Bragg wavelength distribution and the total film thickness based on the candidate termination wavelength, and then calculates the reflection spectrum and the second feedback quantity at the target oblique incidence angle. When the oblique incidence long-wave edge states corresponding to adjacent candidate termination wavelengths are different, the two form a design termination boundary search interval. One end of the search interval corresponds to the conforming state, and the other end corresponds to the non-conforming state, providing a boundary state basis for subsequent binary refinement.
[0046] After the initial boundary search interval is formed, the processor calculates the median value between the two endpoints of the interval and uses this median value as the new candidate design starting wavelength. The design termination wavelength retains the existing value from this round. The processor regenerates all Bragg wavelengths and all film thicknesses based on the new candidate design bands and then calculates the first feedback quantity. When the normal shortwave edge state of the candidate design starting wavelength is the same as the state at one end of the search interval, that end is replaced with the candidate design starting wavelength; the other end is retained. The processor repeats the calculation of the new interval median value until the search interval width is no greater than the boundary search accuracy. Within the refined interval, the candidate design starting wavelength that meets the edge determination criteria and is close to the end that does not meet the criteria is selected as the updated design starting wavelength.
[0047] The design termination boundary search interval is processed using the same binary search method, but a second feedback quantity is calculated for each intermediate value trial. During the refinement of the design termination wavelength, the wavelength sampling points, weights, and second reflectivity thresholds in the long-wavelength edge neighborhood remain unchanged to avoid changes in the evaluation conditions during the boundary search. After the width of the binary search interval is no greater than the boundary search accuracy, the candidate design termination wavelength corresponding to the obliquely incident long-wavelength edge conforming to the state is selected as the updated design termination wavelength.
[0048] When the feedback quantity corresponding to the candidate design boundary does not monotonically change with the order of the candidate design boundaries, the processor does not directly perform bisection within the entire allowable adjustment range. The allowable adjustment range of the design boundary is divided into multiple sub-intervals according to the obtained candidate design boundaries, and adjacent candidate values whose edge states change are searched in each sub-interval. When multiple search intervals are formed, the processor generates the candidate compensation membrane system state in each search interval and calculates another feedback quantity. When multiple search intervals are formed, the processor generates the candidate compensation membrane system state in each search interval and calculates another feedback quantity. For multiple search intervals of the starting boundary, the absolute values of the second feedback quantities of each candidate membrane system are compared; for multiple search intervals of the ending boundary, the absolute values of the first feedback quantities of each candidate membrane system are compared. The processor selects the search interval with the smaller absolute value of the other feedback quantity for bisection refinement to avoid the current boundary adjustment causing a large reverse deviation of the other edge.
[0049] When neither the first nor the second feedback quantity meets the corresponding edge determination condition, the design band adjustment procedure first updates the design starting wavelength. Immediately after the update, the Bragg wavelength distribution and all film thicknesses are regenerated, and the first and second feedback quantities are recalculated. Subsequently, the design termination wavelength is updated based on the recalculated second feedback quantity. After the design termination wavelength is updated, the complete film system is regenerated again, and the two feedback quantities are recalculated. This sequence does not directly use the second feedback quantity obtained in the first calculation for the termination boundary update, because the change in the starting boundary has altered the entire Bragg wavelength distribution and all film thicknesses; the second feedback quantity needs to be re-obtained based on the changed film system.
[0050] In another implementation, when the absolute value of the deviation of the second feedback quantity is greater than the absolute value of the deviation of the first feedback quantity, the design termination wavelength is updated first, followed by the design start wavelength. When this sequence is used, the entire film thickness is regenerated and the two feedback quantities are recalculated after each boundary update. The boundary update order is determined by the configuration before the start of the current round, or by the magnitude of the deviation of the two feedback quantities after normalization according to their respective reflectivity thresholds; the sorting rules are not repeatedly changed during the same round of boundary refinement.
[0051] If the updated design start wavelength is not less than the updated design end wavelength, the updated design band is not considered a valid candidate. The processor reads the previous valid design band, recovers its start wavelength, end wavelength, Bragg wavelength distribution, and all film thicknesses, and narrows the allowable adjustment range of the intersection boundary. After recovery, the coarse step search is re-executed. The previous valid design band is the most recent design band where the start wavelength is less than the end wavelength, all film thicknesses are positive, and the refractive index and dispersion data are complete.
[0052] After the design start wavelength and design end wavelength are updated in this round, they form the updated design band. The processor recalculates all Bragg wavelengths within the updated design band according to the generation method in S100, reassociates multiple Bragg wavelengths to multiple film layers, and calls the refractive index and dispersion data at the corresponding wavelengths to recalculate the thickness of all film layers. The updated design band, the regenerated Bragg wavelength distribution, the film material sequence, the total film layer thickness, the substrate refractive index, and the target oblique incidence angle together form the candidate compensation film system state. This candidate compensation film system state enters S400 and is not directly used as the final film system output.
[0053] S400: Regenerate the dual-edge feedback state based on the candidate compensation film system state; when both the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity meet the edge determination condition, output the updated design band and film thickness; otherwise, return to S300 with the updated design band as the current design band. After the candidate compensation film system state is formed, the reflectance spectrum calculation program recalculates the normal reflectance spectrum and the reflectance spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle according to the same calculation wavelength range, polarization evaluation conditions, long-wavelength edge neighborhood, and reflectance threshold in S200. The processor re-extracts the short-wavelength edge reflectance and calculates its difference from the first reflectance threshold; simultaneously, it extracts multiple reflectance values within the long-wavelength edge neighborhood, calculates the weighted average value according to the original weights, and calculates its difference from the second reflectance threshold. The recalculated first and second feedback quantities replace the corresponding feedback quantities in the previous round of dual-edge feedback state, forming a new dual-edge feedback state corresponding to the candidate compensation film system state.
[0054] When both the first and second feedback quantities meet their respective edge detection conditions, the processor first checks whether the updated design band and the thickness of all film layers meet the structural validity conditions. Structural validity conditions include: the design start wavelength being less than the design end wavelength; each film layer group having corresponding high-refractive-index film layer thickness and low-refractive-index film layer thickness; each film layer's physical thickness being positive; and all film layer thicknesses maintaining a one-to-one correspondence with the current Bragg wavelength distribution. If the structural validity conditions are not met, the candidate compensation film system state does not transition to the output state, the processor reverts to the previous valid design band, and re-enters S300.
[0055] Once the structural validity conditions are met, the processor compares the physical thickness of each membrane layer with the minimum and maximum membrane thicknesses, and compares the sum of all membrane layer physical thicknesses with the total membrane thickness limit. If any membrane layer is below the minimum membrane thickness, any membrane layer is above the maximum membrane thickness, or the total membrane thickness exceeds the total membrane thickness limit, the candidate compensation membrane system is marked as a manufacturing constraint conflict state. The design results in the manufacturing constraint conflict state retain their double-edge feedback and reflection spectrum, but are not output as normal membrane thickness tables; the processor returns to S300, and while maintaining the fixed target application band and edge determination conditions, narrows the allowable adjustment range of the design boundary, or ends the current membrane layer group configuration and re-executes S100 with a new number of membrane layer groups.
[0056] When the first feedback quantity, the second feedback quantity, the structural effectiveness condition, and the manufacturing constraints all meet their respective conditions, the candidate compensation membrane system state is transformed into the target compensation membrane system state. The processor output updates the design band, the final Bragg wavelength distribution, the membrane material sequence, and the total membrane thickness, forming a membrane thickness table in the order from the substrate side to the incident medium side. The normal reflection spectrum and the oblique incidence reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle use the same membrane system version as the membrane thickness table to avoid mixing the states where the spectrum corresponds to the old membrane thickness and the membrane thickness corresponds to the new design band. When the polarization evaluation uses the smaller values of TE polarization and TM polarization, the output retains the TE polarization reflection spectrum and the TM polarization reflection spectrum, respectively.
[0057] If any feedback quantity fails to meet the corresponding edge determination condition, the processor does not output the current film thickness table. Instead, it determines the updated design band in the candidate compensation film system state as the new current design band and transmits the regenerated dual-edge feedback state to S300. If the first feedback quantity fails but the second feedback quantity does, S300 only initiates the design start wavelength search; if the second feedback quantity fails but the first feedback quantity does, it only initiates the design end wavelength search; if neither feedback quantity fails, the two design boundaries are adjusted alternately according to the preset boundary update order. Feedback quantities that have already met are recalculated by S400 after the other design boundary is updated. If they change from a met state to a non-met state, the next round of corresponding boundary search begins.
[0058] Before returning to S300 in each round, the processor retains the current design band, the first feedback value, the second feedback value, and the total film thickness as the starting point for the next round of boundary search and the basis for anomaly backoff. Only valid film system states are saved; candidate states rejected due to insufficient refractive index dispersion data, design boundary intersections, or non-positive film thicknesses do not replace the previous valid design band. When the design boundary changes repeatedly across multiple rounds, the processor compares the updated design bands of consecutive rounds; if the same starting and ending wavelengths appear in multiple consecutive rounds and the feedback state remains unchanged, the current state is recorded as a non-converged state, and the same film system is no longer generated repeatedly.
[0059] When the maximum number of iterations is reached, and the first and second feedback values still do not simultaneously meet the edge determination criteria, the processor terminates the current round of compensation calculation. At this point, it outputs the previous effective design band and its corresponding total film thickness, along with the non-converged state, the first feedback value, and the second feedback value, enabling subsequent design processes to identify edges that do not meet the criteria. If multiple candidates exist for the previous effective design band, the candidate design band with the smaller sum of the normalized differences between the two feedback values and their respective reflectivity thresholds is selected. This output is not marked as the target compensation film system state.
[0060] In one implementation, the maximum number of iterations is set to the upper limit of the sum of the number of design start boundary updates and the number of design end boundary updates, the boundary search accuracy is set to 0.1 nm, and the coarse step size is set to 5 nm. For a fixed target application band of 450–650 nm and a target oblique incidence angle of 45°, the processor first searches for intervals in the coarse step size candidate values where the normal short-wavelength edge state and the oblique incidence long-wavelength edge state change, and then performs binary refinement on each interval. The above values are used to illustrate the boundary search process; the actual values are set according to the reflection spectrum sampling interval, the design band range, and the dispersion characteristics of the film material.
[0061] After outputting the film thickness gauge, the optical film design equipment uses it as the film thickness input during the coating process preparation stage. If the measured reflection spectrum of the actual prepared film is subsequently obtained, the measured result is used as the external input for another round of film system correction, without changing the processing relationship in this embodiment where the normal short-wavelength edge and the obliquely incident long-wavelength edge are fed back to the design start wavelength and design end wavelength, respectively. When the current compensation process ends, the fixed target application band, the final updated design band, the final Bragg wavelength distribution, all film thicknesses, and the corresponding reflection spectra remain in the same design state.
Claims
1. A method for dual-edge feedback compensation of obliquely incident multilayer optical films, characterized in that, include: S100, acquire refractive index dispersion data, fix target application band, target oblique incidence angle, initial design band and edge determination conditions; Using the initial design band as the current design band, a Bragg wavelength distribution is generated according to its start and end wavelengths. Combined with the refractive index dispersion data, the thickness of all film layers is calculated to form the film system design state. S200. Based on the membrane system design state, calculate the normal reflection spectrum and the reflection spectrum at the target oblique incidence angle; The difference between the shortwave edge reflectivity and the weighted average of multiple reflectivity values in the neighborhood of the longwave edge, and the corresponding reflectivity thresholds are calculated to form the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity, thus generating a dual-edge feedback state. S300. Based on the dual-edge feedback state, update the starting wavelength of the current design band with the first feedback amount and update its ending wavelength with the second feedback amount to form an updated design band; regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and all film thicknesses according to the updated design band to form a candidate compensation film system state. S400: Regenerate the dual-edge feedback state based on the candidate compensation membrane system state; when both the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity meet the edge determination condition, output the updated design band and membrane thickness; otherwise, return to S300 with the updated design band as the current design band.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The multilayer optical film corresponding to the film system design state includes a substrate and multiple film layer groups sequentially disposed on the substrate; each film layer group consists of a high refractive index film layer and a low refractive index film layer; the refractive index dispersion data includes the refractive indices of the high refractive index film layer, the low refractive index film layer and the substrate in the fixed target application band and the current design band.
3. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that, The generated Bragg wavelength distribution includes: Multiple Bragg wavelengths are generated at wavelength intervals between the start and end wavelengths of the current design band. According to the arrangement order of multiple film layers, multiple Bragg wavelengths are associated with multiple film layers one by one; Based on the refractive indices of the high-refractive-index film and the low-refractive-index film at each Bragg wavelength, the optical thicknesses of the high-refractive-index film and the low-refractive-index film in the corresponding film group are calculated, and the optical thicknesses are converted into physical thicknesses.
4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The shortwave edge reflectance is the reflectance of the normal reflection spectrum at the wavelength corresponding to the shortwave edge of the applied band of the fixed target; The long-wavelength edge neighborhood is composed of multiple wavelength sampling points set at wavelength intervals on both sides of the long-wavelength edge of the fixed target application band. The corresponding reflectivity threshold includes a first reflectivity threshold corresponding to the shortwave edge reflectivity and a second reflectivity threshold corresponding to the weighted average value; The first feedback quantity includes the difference between the shortwave edge reflectivity and the first reflectivity threshold, and the second feedback quantity includes the difference between the weighted average value and the second reflectivity threshold.
5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The update of the start and end wavelengths of the current design band includes: Starting from the initial wavelength of the current design band, multiple candidate initial wavelengths are generated in the short-wave and long-wave directions with a coarse step size; the Bragg wavelength distribution and the total film thickness are regenerated according to each candidate initial wavelength, and the corresponding first feedback quantity is calculated; two adjacent candidate initial wavelengths with different states at their normal short-wave edges are combined to form the design initial boundary search interval. Starting from the termination wavelength of the current design band, multiple candidate termination wavelengths are generated in the short-wave and long-wave directions with a coarse step size; the Bragg wavelength distribution and the total film thickness are regenerated according to each candidate termination wavelength, and the corresponding second feedback quantity is calculated; two candidate termination wavelengths that are adjacent and have different states at the obliquely incident long-wave edge are combined to form the design termination boundary search interval.
6. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that, Calculate the median value of the design start boundary search interval and the design end boundary search interval respectively, and use the median value as the candidate design boundary; Based on the candidate design boundary, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and calculate the first feedback quantity or the second feedback quantity corresponding to the candidate design boundary. Based on the edge satisfaction state corresponding to the first or second feedback quantity, the candidate design boundary replaces one end of the corresponding boundary search interval that has the same edge satisfaction state. Repeat the calculation of the intermediate value until the width of the corresponding boundary search interval is no greater than the boundary search precision.
7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, When neither the first feedback quantity nor the second feedback quantity meets the corresponding edge determination condition: First, update the starting wavelength of the current design band based on the first feedback quantity, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and regenerate the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity. Then, based on the regenerated second feedback quantity, update the termination wavelength of the current design band, regenerate the Bragg wavelength distribution and the thickness of all film layers, and regenerate the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity again. When any feedback quantity changes from meeting the corresponding edge determination condition to not meeting the corresponding edge determination condition, the next round of updating the start wavelength and the end wavelength continues.
8. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that, When the first feedback quantity corresponding to multiple candidate starting wavelengths or the second feedback quantity corresponding to multiple candidate ending wavelengths does not change monotonically according to the order of the corresponding candidate wavelengths, the preset design boundary allowable adjustment range is divided into multiple sub-intervals. Search for adjacent candidate starting wavelengths or candidate ending wavelengths with different edge states in multiple sub-intervals, and form a design starting boundary search interval or a design ending boundary search interval with adjacent candidate starting wavelengths. When there are multiple design start boundary search intervals or multiple design end boundary search intervals, calculate another feedback quantity for the candidate compensation membrane system state corresponding to each boundary search interval, and select the boundary search interval with the smaller absolute value of the other feedback quantity for bisection refinement.
9. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The reflection spectrum at the oblique incidence angle of the target includes TE polarization reflection spectrum and TM polarization reflection spectrum; The reflectance of the TE polarization reflectance spectrum and the TM polarization reflectance spectrum at multiple wavelength sampling points in the long-wavelength edge neighborhood is extracted respectively. At each wavelength sampling point, the smaller reflectance of the TE polarization reflectance spectrum and the TM polarization reflectance spectrum is selected, and a weighted average is performed on the multiple smaller reflectances. The resulting weighted average is used to form the second feedback quantity.
10. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, Also includes: When the starting wavelength of the current design band is not less than the ending wavelength, the previous valid design band is restored to the current design band. When the number of iterations reaches the maximum number of iterations and the first feedback quantity and the second feedback quantity do not simultaneously meet the edge determination condition, a non-converged state is generated, and the previous effective design band and its corresponding total film thickness are output. After both the first and second feedback quantities meet the edge determination conditions, the physical thickness of each film layer is compared with the minimum and maximum film thicknesses, and the sum of the physical thicknesses of all film layers is compared with the total film thickness limit. If the corresponding limit is not met, a manufacturing constraint conflict state is generated. If the corresponding limit is met, the film material sequence, film thickness table, normal reflection spectrum and oblique incidence reflection spectrum are output.
