PPA dynamic contour adjustment
The method dynamically adjusts PPA contours in CBRS systems to optimize spectrum use by maintaining or increasing CBSD transmission powers where interference is not an issue, addressing inefficiencies in existing power reduction methods.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2020007869
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2020-07-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2040-07-27
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for determining and adjusting the protection area contours in Citizens Broadband Radio Service (CBRS) systems result in unnecessary reductions of transmission power for CBSDs that are not causing interference, leading to wasted spectrum use.
A method for dynamically adjusting the protection area (PPA) contours based on changes in spectrum usage and signal quality, allowing CBSDs to maintain or increase their transmission power when interference is not an issue, by updating PPA contours only when necessary and considering signal quality.
This approach optimizes spectrum use by ensuring that CBSDs maintain higher transmission powers where interference is not a concern, thereby enhancing spectral efficiency and reducing unnecessary power reductions.
Smart Images

Figure 00000010_0000 
Figure 00000010_0001 
Figure 00000011_0000
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: Dynamic PPA contour adjustment Description of figures
[0001] [Fig.l] shows the architecture of the CBRS (“Citizens Broadband Radio Service”) in accordance with the state of the art.
[0002] [Fig.2] shows an example of CBSD deployment as well as the power maximum transmission authorized for each CBSD at the end of a first CP AS procedure.
[0003] [Fig.3] shows the steps for determining and transmitting to CBSDs the maximum transmission power authorized for each “grant” in accordance with the state of the art.
[0004] [Fig.4] shows a modification of the CBSD deployment described in [Fig.2] as well as the maximum transmission powers authorized for each CBSDs following a second CPAS procedure in accordance with the state of the art.
[0005] [Fig.5] shows the steps for determining and transmitting to CBSDs the maximum transmission power allowed for each “grant” in accordance with the present invention.
[0006] [Fig.6] shows a modification of the CBSD deployment described in [Fig.2] as well as the maximum transmission powers authorized for each CBSDs at the end of the procedure described in [Fig.5].
[0007] [Fig.7] shows an alternative to the procedure described in [Fig.5] in which the outline of a PPA is updated before the execution of the CPAS procedure.
[0008] [Fig.8] shows an example of PPA contour adjustment as a function of the signal quality.
[0009] State of the art on CBRS (Citizens Broadband Radio Service)
[0010] CBRS is a service defined by the regulatory authority FCC ("Federal Communications Commission", document 15-47) allowing the sharing of frequencies on the 3.5 GHz frequency band between three priority levels, or 3 tiers: - primary users (or priority users), - secondary users PAL (Priority Access Licensees), - users of the third tier GAA (General Authorized Access).
[0011] The Wireless Innovation Forum defines the architecture and protocols of the CBRS service, in accordance with FCC requirements.
[0012] [Fig.l] shows the architecture of the CBRS service. A centralized SAS ("Spectrum Access System") server or radio spectrum access controller controls access to and use of the spectrum of radio base stations, called CBSDs (Citizens Broadband Radio Service Devices), connected to this SAS. These CBSDs can be connected directly to the SAS (as illustrated by the “CBSD 4” in [Fig.l]), or indirectly through a Proxy Server (SP) connected to CBSDs.
[0013] The Proxy Server (SP) is also called Domain Proxy (DP) in the context of the CBRS service.
[0014] The protocol between the SAS and CBSDs or between the SAS and an SP allows to control the radio channels used by the CBSDs for radio transmission and / or reception, as well as the maximum authorized transmission power.
[0015] Before being able to transmit on a radio channel in the CBRS band at 3.5 GHz, each CBSD must request a transmission authorization or "grant" from the SAS, using the "Grant Request" message, indicating a maximum transmission power (via the "maxEirp" parameter).
[0016] The SAS cannot authorize a CBSD to transmit on the channels associated with a “grant” without first ensuring that the aggregation, at the location of each primary or secondary user located near this CBSD, of the transmissions of the “grants” already authorized, associated with other CBSDs, and of this new “grant” does not exceed the maximum interference threshold authorized for this primary or secondary user.
[0017] This verification is carried out at regular intervals, during a procedure called CPAS (“Coordinated Periodic Activities among SASes”).
[0018] Secondary users are protected from interference in areas called PPAs (or “PAL Protection Area”). A PPA is associated with a frequency interval and a set of CBSDs. The maximum contour of a PPA is determined from a union of the coverage of each CBSD belonging to this PPA, as illustrated [Fig.2],
[0019] For each PPA, during the CPAS procedure, the SAS determines the maximum transmission power of the “grants” of the CBSDs located outside this PPA, so that the aggregation of the emissions of these “grants” at any point of the PPA is lower than a predefined maximum threshold (for example -80 dBm / MHz).
[0020] The method for creating a PPA is described in requirement R2-PAL-02 of document WINNF-TS-0112.
[0021] [Fig.2] shows an example of CBSD deployment as well as the maximum transmission power authorized for each CBSD following a first CPAS procedure.
[0022] In this example, 6 CBSDs are deployed.
[0023] It is assumed that each CBSD has requested a grant on the same frequency, for example the interval 3550 MHz - 3560 MHz. The two values indicated below each CBSD indicate respectively the maximum transmission power requested by the CBSD for this grant and the maximum transmission power authorized for this “grant” at the end of the CPAS procedure.
[0024] For example, CBSD 2 requested to transmit with a power of “37 dBm / 10 MHz”, and is authorized to transmit at a power of “35 dBm / 10 MHz”.
[0025] In this example, a primary user is present (FSS 1, pointed by arrow A1 in [Fig.2]).
[0026] CBSDs 4, 5 and 6 belong to PPA 1. It is assumed that PPA 1 is associated with the frequency interval 3550 MHz -3560 MHz.
[0027] During the CPAS procedure, the SAS updates the maximum transmission power authorized for each CBSD so as to ensure that the aggregation of the emissions of all the "grants" does not exceed the maximum interference threshold authorized, for each primary and secondary user.
[0028] The SAS ensures that at each point of the grid overlapping with PPA 1, the aggregation of the grants of the CBSDs not included in this PPA is lower than the maximum interference threshold authorized for the PPAs. This grid is made up of points separated by a distance of two arc-seconds.
[0029] In this example, it is assumed that at the location of the black dotted square in [Fig.2] and pointed by arrow A2, the aggregation of the grants of CBSD 1 and 2 is greater than the maximum interference threshold allowed for the PPAs.
[0030] Therefore, during the CPAS procedure, the SAS reduces the maximum transmission power of CBSDs 1 and 2. In this example, the maximum transmission power allowed for CBSD 1 is 33 dBm / 10 MHz and the maximum transmission power allowed for CBSD 2 is 32 dBm / 10 MHz.
[0031] Furthermore, in this example, it is assumed that the aggregation of the “grants” of CBSDs 1 to 6 is lower than the protection threshold authorized for FSS 1. Therefore, at the end of the CPAS procedure, the maximum authorized transmission power remains identical to the value of the maximum transmission power requested (37 dBm / 10 MHz) for CBSDs 3 to 6.
[0032] [Fig.3] shows the steps for determining and transmitting to CBSDs the maximum transmission power allowed for each grant in accordance with the state of the art.
[0033] Firstly, the CPAS procedure is executed. The SAS in step 1.1 generates the FAD (or “Full Activity Dump”). This FAD is a set of files containing in particular the list of CBSDs recorded in this SAS as well as the list of PPAs recorded in this SAS.
[0034] During step 1.2, each SAS retrieves the FADs of all the other SASs. Thus, at the end of this step, each SAS has knowledge of all the CBSDs and PPAs deployed.
[0035] During step 1.3, the SAS executes the IAP procedure (or “Iterative Allocation Process”) at the location of each primary user and at each PPA point.
[0036] The purpose of this procedure is to determine the maximum transmission power authorized for each grant, such that the aggregation of all grants located near a primary user or near a PPA point does not exceed the maximum interference threshold authorized for this primary user or this PPA point. For example, the maximum interference threshold authorized by the FCC for a PPA point is "-80 dBm / 10 MHz".
[0037] This IAP procedure is defined in requirement R2-SGN-16 of the document “WINNF-TS-112 CBRS Operational and Functional Requirements” defined at the “Wireless Innovation Forum”.
[0038] At the end of the CPAS procedure, the SAS transmits to each CBSD and for each “grant” the maximum transmission power authorized for this “grant”, if this has changed since the previous execution of the CPAS procedure, by including this value in the “Hearbeat Response” message of the SAS-CBSD protocol. This protocol is defined in the WINNF-TS-0016 document of the “Wireless Innovation Forum”.
[0039] The procedure described in [Fig.3] is carried out daily.
[0040] [Fig.4] shows a modification of the CBSD deployment described in [Fig.2] as well as the maximum transmission powers authorized for each CBSDs following a second CPAS procedure.
[0041] In this example, two new CBSDs have appeared (CBSD 7 and CBSD 8). It is assumed that these two CBSDs have a "grant" on the frequency interval 3550 MHz - 3560 MHz and that the aggregation of CBSDs 1 to 8 at the location of FSS 1 (pointed by arrow A1 in [Fig.4]), is greater than the maximum allowed interference threshold of the FSSs.
[0042] Therefore, during the CPAS procedure, the SAS reduces the authorized transmission power so that the aggregation of grants at the location of FSS 1 (pointed by arrow A1 in [Fig.4]), is lower than the maximum authorized interference threshold of the FSS.
[0043] Thus, at the end of the CPAS procedure, the maximum transmission power authorized for CBSD 4 and CBSD 5 is “35 dBm / 10 MHz”, and “34 dBm / 10 MHz” for CBSD 6.
[0044] The maximum transmission power allowed for CBSD 1 and CBSD 2 is reduced in the same way as during the previous CPAS procedure ([Fig.l]).
[0045] Indeed, the contour of PPA 1 remains unchanged during the CPAS procedure, although the transmission power “grants” of CBSD 4, CBSD 5 and CBSD 6 belonging to PPA 1 has decreased.
[0046] However, this decrease in the maximum transmission power for CBSDs 1 and 2 is unnecessary because the point at which the aggregate interference of these CBSDs exceeds the authorized threshold (illustrated in A2 in [Fig.4]) is outside the coverage area of the CBSDs belonging to PPA 1. This results in a waste of spectrum usage.
[0047] Description of the invention
[0048] The present invention describes a method for dynamically adjusting the contour of a PPA according to the evolution of spectrum usage.
[0049] [Fig.5] shows the steps for determining and transmitting to CBSDs the maximum transmission power allowed for each grant in accordance with the present invention.
[0050] Steps 1.1 and 1.2 of [Fig.5] are identical to steps 1.1 and 1.2 of [Fig.3] and to the state of the art.
[0051] During step 1.3 of [Fig.5], the SAS executes the IAP procedure for each primary user to be protected (e.g. for each FSS and for each GWPZ), and updates the maximum transmission power authorized for each grant.
[0052] On the other hand, during this step 1.3 of [Fig.5], the SAS does not execute the IAP procedure on the PPAs, unlike step 1.3 of [Fig.3] and the state of the art.
[0053] At the end of step 1.3 of [Fig.5], the SAS checks, for each PPA, whether the maximum authorized transmission power of a “grant” of a CBSD belonging to this PPA has been reduced during this step.
[0054] In the case where the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step 1.3 of [Fig.5] is lower than the maximum transmission power requested for at least one of the “grants” of a given PPA, the SAS updates during step 1.4 of [Fig.5] the contour of this PPA by using, for each “grant” of this PPA, the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step 1.3 of [Fig.5].
[0055] During step 1.5 of [Fig.5], the SAS executes the IAP procedure at each point of the contour of each PPA, using the contours possibly updated during step 1.4 of [Fig.5].
[0056] During step 2 of [Fig.5], the SAS transmits to each CBSD and for each grant the maximum transmission power authorized for this grant, if this has changed since the previous execution of the CPAS procedure, by including this value in the “Hearbeat Response” message of the SAS-CBSD protocol. For a given grant, this value is the minimum between the value of the maximum authorized transmission power obtained at the end of step 1.3 and that obtained at the end of step 1.5.
[0057] [Fig.6] shows a modification of the deployment of the CBSDs compared to the initial deployment described in [Fig.2] as well as the maximum transmission powers authorized for each CBSDs at the end of the procedure described in [Fig.5].
[0058] In this figure, the contour of PPA 1 displayed corresponds to the contour calculated during step 1.4 of [Fig.5]. This contour is smaller than the contour of the previous day, displayed in black dotted lines, because the maximum transmission power of the "grants" of CBSDs 4, 5 and 6 was reduced following the deployment of CBSDs 7 and 8.
[0059] In this new configuration, the maximum transmission power of CBSD 1 and CBSD 2 has not been reduced (and remains at the value 37 dBm / 10 MHz) during execution of the procedure described in [Fig. 5]. Indeed, the location for which the aggregation of CBSD 1 and CBSD 2 exceeded the maximum interference threshold (illustrated by A2 in [Fig. 6]) is no longer included in PPA 1.
[0060] This example highlights the fact that the reduction of the PPA contour during the CPAS procedure as introduced in the present invention allows other CBSDs located in the vicinity of this PPA to obtain a maximum transmission power greater than the procedure defined according to the state of the art.
[0061] [Fig.7] shows an alternative to the procedure described in [Fig.5] in which the outline of a PPA is updated before the execution of the CPAS procedure.
[0062] During step 1 of [Fig.7], the SAS determines for each PPA whether the contour must be updated.
[0063] Step 2 of [Fig.7] is identical to step 1 of [Fig.3].
[0064] Step 3 of [Fig.7] is identical to step 2 of [Fig.3].
[0065] The criterion for updating the contour of a PPA during step 1 of [Fig.7] is based on one of the following criteria:
[0066] - an estimate of the maximum authorized transmission power of the “grants” of a PPA following the execution of the next CPAS.
[0067] - information on the quality of the signal inside the PPA.
[0068] These two criteria are described in more detail below.
[0069] 1. Estimation of the maximum transmission power authorized at the end of the execution of the next CPAS procedure
[0070] In an alternative, this estimation is based on the value of the transmission power obtained, for a given “grant”, at the end of the execution of the previous CPAS. For example, if this value is constant, for a given “grant”, during several consecutive CPAS, this same value can be used as the estimated value for the next CPAS.
[0071] In another alternative, the SAS obtains an estimate of the maximum transmission power that will be obtained during the next CPAS for a given “grant” by executing the IAP procedure for each primary user located near this “grant”.
[0072] The SAS can thus recalculate the contour of a given PPA based on the maximum transmission power estimated for each “grant” associated with this PPA, then execute the CPAS during step 2 of [Fig.7] in accordance with the state of the art.
[0073] 2. Updating the contour based on signal quality
[0074] It is advantageous to use a PPA contour lower than the maximum authorized PPA contour.
[0075] Indeed, the larger a PPA contour, the more the CBSDs located near this PPA are likely to have a reduced maximum transmission power at the end of the CPAS procedure, which contributes to a waste of spectrum usage.
[0076] A PPA operator may therefore choose to use a PPA contour smaller than the maximum authorized PPA contour (obtained according to requirement R2-PAL-02 of document WINNF-TS-0112), in order to limit the impact of this PPA on other CBSDs located in the vicinity of this PPA, and to increase the size of this contour only when the quality of the signal received from CBSDs associated with this PPA is not satisfactory.
[0077] [Fig.8] shows an example of PPA contour adjustment as a function of signal quality.
[0078] The dotted location Al indicates an area where the quality of the signal received from CBSD 1 belonging to the PPA is low.
[0079] Information on signal quality may for example be obtained by mobile terminals connected to the CBSDs belonging to the PPA. This information may include for example:
[0080] - the value of the RS RP (or “Reference Signal Received Power”), of the RSRQ (or “Reference Signal Received Quality”) or RSSI (or “Receive Strength Signal Indicator”) for a given latitude and longitude.
[0081] This information can be transmitted to the SAS by the CBSDs, for example in the “Heartbeat Response” message of the SAS-CBSD protocol.
[0082] When the signal quality or interference level information exceeds a predefined threshold, at a location outside the contour of a PPA, but within the maximum authorized PPA contour, the SAS may, during step 1 of [Fig.7], enlarge the contour of this PPA so that this location is included in the PPA, and thus protected from interference.
[0083] For example, in the right part of [Fig.8], the PPA contour has been enlarged by the SAS in order to include, in the updated PPA contour, the dotted area A1 where low signal quality has been detected. Following this contour update, this area is thus protected from interference as illustrated in A2.
Claims
Claims
1. A method for dynamically adjusting the contour of a PPA, or "Priority Access Licensees) Protection Area", according to the evolution of the use of the spectrum by the other CBSDs (Citizens Broadband Radio Service Devices) and primary users located in the vicinity of this PPA, said PPA being associated with a frequency interval and with one or more CBSDs, each CBSD (Citizens Broadband Radio Service Device) having one or more authorizations to transmit, or "grants", characterized by the following operations carried out by a spectrum access controller, or SAS, during the CPAS procedure, or "Coordinated Periodic Activities among SASes": i. Execution of the IAP procedure for each of said primary users and updating of the maximum transmission power authorized for each of said “grants”. ii. In the event that the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step i. is lower than the maximum transmission power requested for at least one of the grants of a given PPA, updating the contour of this PPA using, for each grant of this PPA, the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step i. iii. Execution of the IAP procedure, or “Iterative Allocation Process”, at each point of each PPA, using the contours possibly updated during step ii. iv. Transmission by the SAS, for each “grant”, of the maximum authorized transmission power, if this value has changed since the previous execution of the CPAS procedure, in the “Heartbeat Response” message, this value being made up of the minimum between the value of the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step i and the value of the maximum authorized transmission power obtained in step iii.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that said updating of the contour of said PPA is carried out before the execution of the CPAS procedure, and in that the criterion for updating the contour is based either on an estimate of the maximum authorized transmission power of the “grant” of this PPA at the end of the execution of the next CPAS, or on information on the quality of the signal within this PPA.
3. The method according to claims 1 to 2 characterized in that said information on the quality of the signal within said PPA is obtained by mobile terminals connected to the CBSDs belonging to this PPA, said information consisting, for a given latitude and longitude, in the value of the RSRP or “Reference Signal Received Power”, the value of the RSRQ or “Reference Signal Received Quality”, or the value of the RSSI or “Receive Strength Signal Indicator”.
4. The method according to claims 1 to 3 characterized in that the size of the contour of said PPA is increased during said updating of this contour when the quality of the signal received from CBSDs associated with this PPA is below a pre-defined threshold at a given location, so that this location is included in the updated PPA contour.
