Method for alerting to a risk of instrument breakage
The method and handpiece system address the challenge of endodontic instrumental breakage by using real-time alerts and adaptive control based on root canal geometry and previous treatments to prevent breakage and improve treatment outcomes.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2021013220
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-12-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-12-09
AI Technical Summary
Endodontic treatment is prone to instrumental breakage due to complex canal geometries and unpredictable stress conditions, which are difficult to anticipate and manage, leading to treatment complications and failures.
A method and handpiece system that acquires root canal geometry and instrument position, detects risk zones, and provides real-time alerts through visual, haptic, or audible feedback, using a database of previous treatments to adapt and prevent breakage by adjusting instrumental dynamics.
Enables real-time identification of risk areas, reducing the likelihood of instrumental breakage by providing proactive alerts and adaptive control, thereby enhancing treatment safety and efficiency.
Smart Images

Figure 00000013_0000 
Figure 00000013_0001 
Figure 00000014_0000
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: Method for alerting to a risk of breakage of an instrument Technical field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of endodontics. Prior art
[0002] Endodontic treatment of a root canal consists of removing the tissues from the canal. To perform this operation, the practitioner uses canal instruments, such as exploration files, to locate the canal's trajectory, determine its precise length, and then remove the tissues using another file before shaping the canal for filling.
[0003] During endodontic treatment, instrument breakage is one of the most frequent complications. The direct complications of this instrument breakage are clinical: - if it is possible to recover the broken instrument, the consequences are an increase in the duration of treatment and a potential weakening of the tooth by a reduction in the residual wall thickness necessary for the removal of the broken instrument; - if it is not possible to recover the broken instrument, the consequences may (i) be linked to insufficient disinfection of the canal network leading to post-operative pain, non-healing and therefore failure of the endodontic treatment or (ii) be linked to the appearance of an infectious process not existing at the time of treatment and leading to pain and treatment failure in the more or less medium term.
[0004] The occurrences of instrumental breakage are generally reduced by the design of root canal instruments, in order to make them more resistant to the stresses exerted during endodontic treatment.
[0005] However, an instrumental failure is a rapid event, which can occur in less than a few seconds, and it is difficult to know the conditions under which the failure occurred.
[0006] Several parameters can influence the occurrence of a breakage, such as: - the geometry of the treated canal, in particular if it has a complex geometry, with a sudden change of direction forming a bend; - irrigation of the canal, implemented or not by the practitioner during certain phases of the treatment; - the effort that the practitioner exerts on the instrument.
[0007] The possibilities for improving the design of instruments are therefore limited by the lack of knowledge of these multiple parameters.
[0008] It is also difficult, even for an experienced practitioner, to know precisely how an instrument moves within the canal being treated. Even if the practitioner knows that the canal he is going to treat is complex, and he considers taking the necessary precautions, he may make a mistake and not correctly adapt his gesture or the dynamics of driving the instrument to the complexity of the canal, which can lead to instrument breakage. Statement of the invention
[0009] The aim of the invention is to overcome the drawbacks of the prior art, by proposing a method of assisting a practitioner during the treatment of root canals.
[0010] For this purpose, a method has been developed to warn of a risk of instrument breakage.
[0011] According to the invention, the method comprises the following steps: - acquisition of geometry data of a root canal to be treated; - identification of a risk area, based on complexities of the canal geometry such as bends or bifurcations of the canal; - real-time acquisition of the working depth of the instrument; - determination of the position of the instrument within the channel, and emission of an alert when the instrument reaches the risk zone.
[0012] In this way, it is possible to know in real time where the instrument is located within the canal during treatment, and consequently to determine whether the instrument will approach a predetermined risk zone of the canal before the treatment is carried out, for example by the practitioner, depending on the geometry of the canal.
[0013] So that the practitioner is alerted when the instrument is about to approach a risk area of the canal, the method comprises a step of informing the practitioner of the position.
[0014] In order to simplify the feedback of information to the practitioner, the alert is visual, haptic or audible.
[0015] Advantageously, the method comprises a step of comparing the geometry of the root canal to be treated with a database comprising records of previous root canal treatments, the records comprising: - the geometries of the treated canals; - local constraints within a material constituting the instruments used, obtained by finite element calculation based on the geometry of the channel, a geometry of the instrument, a working depth of the instrument at a given instant, or interval given, and a constraint undergone by the instrument at this same given instant, or given interval; the comparison step with records of previous treatments to identify risk areas of the canal to be treated, where local constraints will be high within the instrument.
[0016] Such a method makes it possible to further assist the practitioner, by automatically identifying risk areas on the basis of previous treatments already carried out, which guarantees the relevance of the identification of said areas, and simplifies the use of the method.
[0017] Since the database is scalable, the method can also adapt its criteria for determining risk zones to changes in the database or to changes in the design of the instruments and / or the intended conditions of use.
[0018] Advantageously, the method comprises a step of adapting the instrumental dynamics when the instrument reaches the risk zone. In this way, the assistance of the practitioner is complete, and the method plays an active role in preventing instrument breakage.
[0019] The invention also relates to a handpiece for endodontic practice, comprising a control unit executing a computer program, and designed to drive a root canal instrument.
[0020] According to the invention, the handpiece comprises means for detecting the distance between a reference point and a part of a tooth, as well as means for measuring mechanical stresses undergone by the instrument, connected to the control unit. The computer program is programmed to determine a depth at which the instrument is located during work as a function of a known length of the instrument, and the computer program is configured to detect risk zones of the canal to be treated by comparing its geometry with records of previous treatments, the records comprising: - the geometries of the treated canals; - local stresses within a material constituting the instruments used, obtained by finite element calculation based on the geometry of the channel, a geometry of the instrument, a working depth of the instrument at a given instant, or given interval, and a stress undergone by the instrument at this same given instant, or given interval.
[0021] The computer program is configured to alert the practitioner when the instrument is in a risk area.
[0022] The handpiece thus designed comprises all the structural elements necessary to implement the method according to the aforementioned characteristics, with the resulting advantages. Brief description of the drawings
[0023] [Fig-1] is a diagram of a tooth, illustrating the geometry of a canal to be treated.
[0024] [Fig.2] is a diagram of a root canal instrument.
[0025] [Fig.3] is an illustration of a handpiece according to the invention.
[0026] [Fig.4] is a diagram illustrating such a handpiece in use.
[0027] [Fig.5] is a diagram of a treatment in a first configuration.
[0028] [Fig.6] is a diagram of a finite element calculation in this first configuration.
[0029] [Fig.7] is a diagram of the treatment in a second configuration.
[0030] [Fig.8] is a diagram of a finite element calculation in this second configuration.
[0031] [Fig.9] is a diagram illustrating a database categorizing different root canal geometries. Detailed description of the invention
[0032] With reference to [Fig.l], an endodontic treatment consists of removing tissue from a root canal (42) of a tooth (40). During this treatment, an instrument (20), such as a file, should be used up to the apex (43) of the canal (42). The length between a part (41) of the tooth (40), generally a cusp, and the apex (43) is the working length (Lt).
[0033] Since the channel (42) is approximately filiform, the lengths are measured according to the development of the channel (42). However, the channel (42) can have different types of geometries, which has an influence on the complexity of the treatment to be carried out.
[0034] A channel (42) may be rectilinear, in which case the treatment will be simple. Conversely, a channel (42) having a curvature (44) will impose a stress on the instrument (20). In the extreme case where this curvature (44) takes the form of an elbow, the level of stress is such that it can lead to breakage of the instrument (20).
[0035] It is therefore common to obtain an acquisition of the geometry of the canal (42) to be treated, for example by radiography, so that the practitioner can best anticipate his action, and can predict which will be the risk zones where the instrument (20) risks breaking.
[0036] With reference to [Fig. 2], an instrument (20) is generally provided with a stop (25) made of elastomeric material. The position of this stop is adjusted by the practitioner so that the stop length (Lb), defined by the distance between the tip (23) of the instrument (20) and a sub-face (26) of the stop (25), is equal to the working length (Lt). The stop length (Lb) is therefore less than or equal to a useful length (Lu) of the instrument (20).
[0037] In this way, when the practitioner carries out his treatment and digs the canal (42) with the instrument (20), he knows that when the underside (26) comes into contact with the part (41), then the tip (23) is at the level of the apex (43). However, as long as the underside (26) is not in contact with the part (41), the practitioner has no precise information on the position of the instrument (20) within the canal (42) so that the instrument (20) can approach a curvature (44), or a risk zone, while the practitioner is not prepared for it.
[0038] With reference to figures 3 to 5, the handpiece (10) according to the invention comprises a control unit (30) controlling a motor intended to drive an instrument (20) according to a suitable dynamic, by means of a contra-angle (14).
[0039] The handpiece (10) comprises a depth gauge (11) making it possible to know in real time at what working depth (Lp) the instrument is located within the canal (42). The depth gauge (11) comprises detection means which measure a distance (Le) between the part (41) of the tooth (40) and the reference point (12) which is preferably on the handpiece (10).
[0040] Subtracting the distance (Le) from the useful length (Li) provides the working depth (Lp) at which the instrument (20) is located at a given time.
[0041] By using the acquisition of the geometry of the channel (42) and the working depth (Lp) at a given instant, it is possible to know if the tip (23) is about to approach a risk zone (44). More generally, it is also possible to reconstruct the geometry that the instrument (20) presents at this given instant, since it is shaped by the trajectory of the channel (42).
[0042] The handpiece (10) also comprises means (13) for measuring the mechanical stresses undergone by the instrument (20). The measuring means (13) are of any suitable type, and may be dynamometers or extensometers. Preferably, they are strain gauges, for example axial or in the form of rosettes. Indeed, these strain gauges are compact, durable, and their output signal is easy to interpret.
[0043] In order to ensure that the measurements are as error-free as possible, the depth gauge (11) and the measuring means (13) are preferably arranged on the contra-angle (14).
[0044] In order to have a maximum of information regarding the conditions of use of the instrument (20), the measuring means (13) are preferably configured to measure the stresses undergone by the instrument (20) along three axes of an orthonormal reference frame. With reference to [Fig. 4], this involves capturing the forces (x, y, z) as well as the torques (a, b, c). It is thus possible to completely obtain the torsor of the forces undergone by the instrument (20).
[0045] With reference to [Fig.6], knowledge of the configuration in which the instrument (20) is shaped by the channel (42) at each instant, as well as the mechanical stresses to which it is subjected, makes it possible to carry out a posteriori an analysis by the finite element method of the effective distribution of the mechanical stresses within the instrument (20).
[0046] This analysis takes into account the design of the instrument (20), that is to say the material which composes it, its nominal geometry such as its dimensions and its cutting lips, as well as any treatments which the instrument (20) has undergone during its manufacture, for example a heat treatment.
[0047] The subdivision of the instrument (20) into a mesh (27), the knowledge of the stress torsor to which the instrument (20) is subjected, and the choice of boundary conditions based on the acquisition of the geometry of the channel (42) make it possible to calculate how the stresses are distributed within the instrument (20), and in particular to know the zone(s) of maximum stresses (28) at the given instant chosen. In [Fig.6], the zone of maximum stresses (28) is located at a first length (Lcl).
[0048] The working depth (Lp) as well as the constraints evolve during the treatment.
[0049] In [Fig.7], the tip (23) of the instrument (20) reaches the apex (43). The channel (42) shapes the instrument (20) into a certain configuration, and it can be seen in [Fig.8] that the maximum stress zone (28) has moved to a second length (Lc2), less than the first length (Lcl).
[0050] Real-time recording of the working depth (Lp) of the instrument (20) as well as the stresses it undergoes makes it possible to carry out a posteriori a multitude of finite element analyses, allowing designers of endodontic equipment to best design the equipment as well as its conditions of use.
[0051] Based on the calculations made: - the manufacturer of the instrument (20) may modify the geometry, material or treatments of the instrument (20); - the manufacturer of the instrument (20) may modify the intended conditions of use, such as the rotation speed of the instrumental dynamics; - the manufacturer of the handpiece (10) can integrate additional safety functions into the computer program executed by the control unit (30).
[0052] In order to provide a sufficient database for hardware manufacturers, the program of the control unit (30) is programmed to record at regular intervals, for each treatment: - the working depth (Lp) of the instrument (20); - the mechanical constraints undergone by the instrument (20).
[0053] The intervals may be a distance, for example a step of 0.5 mm. The database therefore contains a record of the conditions of use of the instrument (20) in each configuration imposed by the geometry of the channel. The size of the database is limited.
[0054] The intervals can be a duration, for example a step of 0.5s. The database is larger because the practitioner makes back and forth movements during of the treatment: there will therefore be several recordings for a given working depth (Lp), but the recordings are much more complete and allow better monitoring of the evolution, at each moment, of the conditions of use of the instrument (20).
[0055] The recordings also include: - the reference of the instrument (20) used, which makes it possible to obtain the characteristics necessary for the finite element analysis, by consulting an additional database comprising the mechanical characteristics of the instruments (20) intended to be used in cooperation with the handpiece (10); - the acquisition of the geometry of the channel (42), which is preferably a three-dimensional acquisition so that the analysis by finite element method is as relevant as possible.
[0056] The recordings may be accompanied by additional data acquired by the control unit (30), for example the times when the irrigation of the canal (42) was activated or not, the irrigation making it possible to evacuate the debris and to lubricate the cup of the instrument (20). It may also be the parameters of the instrumental dynamics, such as the rotation speed, the reciprocity angles, or the torque exerted by the motor.
[0057] These recordings may also be accompanied by data entered by the practitioner, preferably by means of the control unit (30) or by means of a computer connected to the recording database. The practitioner may, for example, declare whether an instrument failure has occurred, so that the a posteriori analysis is targeted on the treatments which led to a failure.
[0058] For the purpose of automating the process, the breakage of the instrument (20) is detected automatically by the computer program, for example by identifying a discontinuity in the stress measurement: a sudden release of the stress means that the instrument (20) has broken.
[0059] The analysis of several successive recordings, in an incremental manner, makes it possible to reconstruct how the treatment took place and makes it possible to identify, or at least to suspect, the causes which led to the breakage. This may be a misuse of the instrument (20) if the practitioner used an unsuitable instrumental dynamic, or even insufficient irrigation.
[0060] The geometry of the channel (42) is of course the major criterion leading to instrumental breakage. The a posteriori analysis of a large number of treatments carried out makes it possible to identify, for treatments having common parameters, which are the conditions which led to the breakage or on the contrary which led to the success of the treatment.
[0061] The common parameters are of course the use of the same model of instrument (20), as well as a similar geometry of the root canal (42).
[0062] With reference to [Fig.9], different types of geometries (i-xii) of canals (42) are illustrated. Each geometry (i-xii) presents a more or less complex treatment difficulty. For example, profile (x) is rectilinear and does not present any particular difficulty. On the other hand, profile (ix), although generally rectilinear, presents a bifurcation at the level of which the practitioner must take care not to orient the instrument (20) towards the wrong extension.
[0063] The database of recordings preferably includes recordings from as many practitioners as possible, in order to have a sufficient population of data from different treatments, and in particular from different channel geometries (42). The analysis made from the recordings is therefore more complete, and makes it possible to limit the impact of certain usage biases.
[0064] These usage biases may be, for example, a practitioner who tends to always prefer a first instrument model (20) for a given type of treatment and canal geometry (42), while another practitioner prefers another instrument model (20). Analysis of the recordings makes it possible to decide on the most suitable instrument model (20), instrumental dynamics, or gesture.
[0065] The creation of the database of records has two uses: - a first use is to make possible new continuous improvement actions carried out by equipment manufacturers; - a second use is to be able to identify, for a tooth (40) to be treated, which areas will be at risk, how to approach them so that the treatment is successful, and on the contrary what are the conditions most likely leading to instrumental breakage.
[0066] Based on the acquisition of the geometry of a channel (42) to be treated, the computer program is programmed to identify within the database which profile (i-xii) is closest to it, consequently which will be the risk zones requiring vigilance on the part of the practitioner, and possibly an adaptation of the gesture or the instrumental dynamics.
[0067] This a priori analysis allows the practitioner to be guided during the treatment.
[0068] When the practitioner performs the treatment, the depth gauge (11) detects at what working depth (Lp) the instrument is located. If it turns out that the working depth (Lp) is close to the depth of a risk zone, the practitioner is alerted so that he can take the necessary precautions.
[0069] The control unit (30) actuates for this purpose alert means of the handpiece (10). This may be an audible alert, a haptic alert such as a vibration, or more simply a visual alert displayed by the interface (31).
[0070] A color code can be associated for example with three risk levels: - a first color, for example green, means that the instrument (20) is not in a situation of risk of breakage; - a second color, for example yellow, means that the probability of breakage occurring is average, vigilance by the practitioner may be sufficient; - a third color, for example red, means that the probability of occurrence is high and that adaptation is imperative.
[0071] Advantageously, the computer program also takes into account the level of mechanical constraints measured by the measuring means (13), so as to refine the analysis and guide the practitioner more precisely: for example, there is no need to alert the practitioner excessively if he is in a risk zone but the necessary adaptations are implemented.
[0072] That is to say that if the instrument (20) approaches a risk zone (44) but the practitioner has adapted the instrumental dynamics: - for example by reducing the rotation speed of the instrument (20); - or even if the practitioner performs much more flexible movements so as to exert only light mechanical stress on the instrument (20); then the computer program takes these adaptations into account in real time in order to adapt the alert signal, so as not to emit false alerts.
[0073] Conversely, if the measuring means (13) detect that the conditions of use of the instrument (20) are not in line with the risk level of the area approached by the instrument (20), for example with unsuitable instrumental dynamics or forces applied to the instrument (20) that are too high, then the computer program is programmed to emit an alert corresponding to a high probability of occurrence of breakage.
[0074] Finally, the computer program can be programmed to automatically adapt the dynamics of the motor driving the instrument (20) if it detects that the probability of breakage is too high: the rotation speed can be reduced, or the drive can be stopped.
[0075] In addition, the computer program is programmed to be able to adapt, by artificial intelligence, the lessons learned from the analysis of the prior recordings to a new channel geometry (42) or to a new instrument reference (20).
[0076] For example, a modification of the material of the instrument (20) can be taken into account and a posteriori analyses can be recalculated on the basis of the new parameters, to obtain a simulation of what such a modification would produce. The same applies to modifications of the geometry of the instrument (20), and more generally to any influential parameter.
[0077] Or again, if a channel (42) has for example a bend or a bifurcation at a depth different from what is known within the database, the computer program is programmed to identify all the same this critical zone so that the guidance of the practitioner is effective and efficient during the treatment.
[0078] Furthermore, the method and the handpiece (10) may be shaped differently from the examples given without departing from the scope of the invention, which is defined by the claims.
[0079] In particular, the control unit (30) generally covers any electronic equipment used for implementing the methods and the handpiece (10) described. This therefore concerns the microcomputer integrated into the handpiece (10), but also any computer or smartphone used by the practitioner and capable of executing the computer program, uploading or downloading records from the database.
[0080] The term “computer program” is also to be interpreted in a broad sense, and covers the sub-programs and additional functionalities implemented in the methods described. In a non-limiting manner, this concerns: - the program controlling the motor of the handpiece (10); - the program for acquiring the data measured by the depth gauge (11) and the measuring means (13), as well as their recordings; - the a posteriori analysis program by finite element method of the conditions of use of the instrument (20) in the different configurations; - the recording analysis program making it possible to establish the profiles of teeth (40) and canals (42) to be treated, including the corresponding critical zones; - the a priori analysis program of the critical zones of a channel to be treated (42).
[0081] In a simpler embodiment, it is the practitioner who identifies which areas are at risk, without using a database. For this, the practitioner uses the acquisition of the geometry of the canal (42) to be treated, and enters the depths of the areas at risk on the basis of his own analysis. During treatment, the handpiece (10) is able to alert the practitioner when he approaches an area at risk, on the basis of the measurements made by the depth gauge (11).
[0082] Furthermore, the technical characteristics of the different embodiments and variants mentioned above can be, in whole or in part, combined with each other. Thus, the method and the handpiece (10) can be adapted in terms of cost, functionality and performance.
Claims
Claims
1. Handpiece (10) for endodontic practice, comprising a control unit (30) executing a computer program, and designed to drive a canal instrument (20), characterized in that the handpiece (10) comprises means (11) for detecting the distance (Le) between a reference point (12) and a part (41) of a tooth (40), as well as means (13) for measuring mechanical stresses undergone by the instrument (20), connected to the control unit (30); in that the computer program is programmed to determine a depth (Lp) at which the instrument (20) is located during work as a function of a known length (Lu) of the instrument (20); and in that the computer program is configured to alert the practitioner when the instrument (20) is located in a risk zone (44) within the canal, and previously identified.
2. Handpiece (10) according to claim 1, characterized in that the alert is visual, audible, or haptic.
3. Handpiece (10) according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the computer program is configured to compare the geometry of the root canal (42) to be treated with a database comprising records of previous root canal treatments, the records comprising: - the geometries of the treated canals; - the local stresses within a material constituting the instruments used, obtained by finite element calculation based on the geometry of the canal, a geometry of the instrument, a working depth of the instrument at a given interval and a stress experienced by the instrument at this same given interval; in order to identify risk areas of the canal (42) to be treated, where local stresses will be high within the instrument (20).
4. Handpiece (10) according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the computer program is configured to adapt the instrumental dynamics when the instrument (20) reaches the risk zone (44).
5. Handpiece (10) according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the computer program is configured to take into account the level of mechanical constraints measured by the measuring means (13), and: - issue an alert if the conditions of use of the instrument (20) are not in line with the risk level of the risk zone (44) addressed by the instrument (20), - not issue an alert if the necessary adaptations are implemented artwork.
