Method for dynamic benchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations

IN606718BActive Publication Date: 2026-10-22DR RAHUL TIWARI +2
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
IN202321058261
Authority / Receiving Office
IN · IN
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-08-30
Publication Date
2026-10-22
Estimated Expiration
2043-08-30

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current public transport benchmarking methods in India are inadequate as they do not consider the socio-economic characteristics of commuters, leading to unfair comparisons between cities of varying sizes and populations, and fail to accurately reflect user aspirations, resulting in suboptimal service quality and reduced competitiveness.

Method used

A dynamic benchmarking method that uses a questionnaire to collect data on socio-economic characteristics such as gender, age, income, and qualification, and applies multinomial logistic regression analysis to assign weight scores to parameters like accessibility, comfort, cost, environment, reliability, safety, and time, thereby redefining Service Level Benchmarking (SLB) to better align with commuter perspectives.

Benefits of technology

This approach establishes a significant relationship between socio-economic characteristics and benchmarking parameters, allowing for a more accurate and dynamic evaluation of public transport services, improving user satisfaction and service quality by incorporating commuter aspirations into the benchmarking process, which can explain up to 30% variability in service quality.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention provides a method for dynamic benchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that aims to study the service level benchmarking for public transport systems in India, in light of commuter’s perspective and to establish the relevance of commuter’s socio-economic character in public transport benchmarking, in order to redefine it. The study is conducted with an objective to identify the parameters through literature review, which are being used to evaluate public transport services across various other geographies and to study the variation in the perceived weight allotted by the commuters to the identified parameters for benchmarking public transport, along with establishing relationship between the socio-economic characteristic of the user and the perceived weight allotted to the identified parameters for benchmarking public transport in order to re-define the service level benchmarking for public transport of India.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

[001] The present invention relates to the field of transportation, and more particularly, thepresent invention relates to a method for dynamic benchmarking of public transport to fulfillcommuter aspirations.BACKGROUND FOR THE INVENTION:

[002] The following discussion of the background to the invention is intended to facilitate anunderstanding of the present invention. However, it should be appreciated that the discussionis not an acknowledgment or admission that any of the material referred to is published, known,or part of the common general knowledge in any jurisdiction as of the priority date of theapplication. The details provided herein the background if belongs to any publication is takenonly as a reference for describing the problems, in general terminologies or principles or bothof science and technology in the associated prior art.

[003] Flourishing economy and rapid urbanization have made India witness a surge in traveldemand and the number of private vehicles, which led to increase in traffic congestion andtravel time. In order to cope up with the challenge of increasing vehicular population andreducing share of public transport a clear policy shift is required to bring people into the centerof the transport planning practice in India. Hence, the focus of transportation is now shiftingfrom vehicles to people, where National Urban Transport Policy (NUTP) 2006, India hasadopted a vision "Moving people and not vehicles", giving a clear preference to publictransport.

[004] Public transport systems offer essential services to the sustainability and livability ofany city. One of the main challenges facing transport agencies is to offer a consistent andpunctual service, or a reliable service, that is positively perceived by the public. During the pastdecade, transportation planning has shifted its focus from car mobility goals to embrace broaderenvironmental and social goals, by providing and improving transport alternatives that offeraccess to destinations regardless of car ownership. This shift in paradigm, supported byenormous funding, has encouraged cities and transit agencies to incorporate various strategiesto improve transport service operation with the goal of attracting new passengers and retainingexisting ones. This has been done with no clear understanding of the strategies actual effect onthe quality of service on people's perceptions.

[005] As it is said that, "What cannot be evaluated and measured, cannot be managed", whichmakes it evident that monitoring and evaluation of a service is an important component forensuring user satisfaction, competitiveness and management. To evaluate and benchmark theurban public transport services, an evaluation mechanism has been developed by the Ministryof Urban Development (MoUD), Government of India (GoI) based on Service LevelBenchmarks. MoUD, GoI issued Service Level Benchmarks (SLB) for Public Transport inDecember 2009. The derived mechanism for evaluating public transport services in any city isbased on six parameters viz. 1. Presence of organized public transport system in urban area (in%) 2. Extent of supply availability of public transport service 3. Coverage of public transportin the city 4. Average waiting time for public transport users (in min) 5. Level of comfort inpublic transport 6. Percentage of fleet as per Urban Bus Specification (UBS). The existingbenchmarking process is Level of Service (LoS) based, where the city is allotted a score againsteach of the parameters and these scores are cumulated in order to derive the final score. Themechanism is common across cities, where cities of varied sizes and population arebenchmarked on a set of similar benchmarking parameters.

[006] India is full of diversity, so are its cities, where a handful of cities are metropoliseshaving population over 10 million, whereas majority of them have population in range 1 - 10million. Transport being an indirect demand and demands are highly dependent on the usercharacteristics, and it seemed unfair to benchmark public transport services in cities likeMumbai, Delhi, and Kolkata etc. against the smaller towns like Bhopal, Jaipur, and Varanasietc. During the course of literature review, study found that the user's perspective plays a vitalrole in benchmarking the public transport services, where the user's transport requirements areinfluenced by his / her socio - economic characters like gender, age income and qualification.

[007] The public transport benchmarking for different other geographies is studied and afterdocumenting the set of parameters being used for public transport benchmarking it is observedthat prevalent parameters of public transport benchmarking could be broadly categorized intothe accessibility, comfort, cost, environment, reliability, safety and time. The study developeda hypothesis that the commuter's socio-economic characteristics are related to the relativeimportance of parameters for public transport benchmarking. In order to investigate thisrelationship, a questionnaire is designed to record the socio-economic character and importanceweight allotted to each of the identified parameters. Survey is done with the commuters on thecity buses in Bhopal, which is being operated by a SPV called Bhopal City Link Limited(BCLL) a fully owned venture of Bhopal Municipal Corporation (BMC). The surveys areconducted at bus stops and on board the buses and responses from users are recorded.

[008] In light of the foregoing, there is a need for a method for dynamic benchmarking ofpublic transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that overcomes problems prevalent in the priorart.OBJECTS OF THE INVENTION:

[009] Some of the objects of the present disclosure, which at least one embodiment hereinsatisfies, are as follows.

[010] The principal object of the present invention is to overcome the disadvantages of theprior art by providing a method for dynamic benchmarking of public transport to fulfillcommuter aspirations.

[011] An object of the present invention is to provide a method for dynamic benchmarking ofpublic transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that identifies principal parameters throughliterature review, which are used to evaluate public transport services.

[012] Another object of the present invention is to provide a method for dynamicbenchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that studies the variation inthe perceived weight allotted by the commuters to the identified parameters for benchmarkingpublic transport.

[013] Another object of the present invention is to provide a method for dynamicbenchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that establishes a relationshipbetween the socio-economic characteristic of the user and the perceived weight allotted to theidentified parameters for benchmarking public transport.

[014] Yet another object of the present invention is to provide a method for dynamicbenchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations that re-defines the ServiceLevel Benchmarking (SLB) for public transport in Indian context in light of the commuter'sperspective.

[015] Other objects and advantages of the present disclosure will be more apparent from thefollowing description, which is not intended to limit the scope of the present disclosure.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION:

[016] The present invention provides a method for dynamic benchmarking of public transportto fulfill commuter aspirations that aims to study the service level benchmarking for publictransport systems in India, in light of commuter's perspective and to establish the relevance ofcommuter's socio-economic character in public transport benchmarking, in order to redefineit. The study is conducted with an objective to identify the parameters through literature review,which are being used to evaluate public transport services across various other geographies andto study the variation in the perceived weight allotted by the commuters to the identifiedparameters for benchmarking public transport, along with establishing relationship between thesocio-economic characteristic of the user and the perceived weight allotted to the identifiedparameters for benchmarking public transport in order to re-define the service levelbenchmarking for public transport of India, in light of commuter's perspective.

[017] In one aspect of the present invention, the data is collected through a direct interviewmethod adopting random sampling. Responses are collected from users of city bus service inBhopal on a specifically designed questionnaire, where information regarding socio-economiccharacter of user viz. gender, age, income and qualification is recorded along with a weightscore allotted to identified parameters of public transport benchmarking i.e. accessibility,comfort, cost, environment, reliability, safety and time. Initially the data is analyzed for itsdistribution; secondly the hypothesis is tested whether there is any significant relation betweenthe socio-economic predictors and the weight scores. T-test analysis (for gender, being onnominal scale) is used to check the validity of the hypothesis whereas spearman correlation test(for age, income and qualification) is employed to check for relation between the socioeconomic characteristic with the allotted importance score to identified parameters and lastlyto develop a predictive model, where multinomial logistic model is used for regression analysis.The regression is done for each of the parameters, with the predictors which are found to besignificantly associated with the respective parameter using the chi-square test for association.

[018] The study found that there exists significant relationship between the socio-economiccharacter and the allotted score to public transport benchmarking parameters, additionally asapplicable keeping age, gender, income and qualification as variable, the perceived weight ofidentified parameters can be modeled using multinomial logit model analysis, and theregression models developed are found to be statistically significant and the models developedcould explain almost 30% variability. By studying these issues, the study explores an importantgap in the current practice of benchmarking public transport strategy, where the user and his / her aspirations from the public transport services of its city are not considered whilebenchmarking the quality of service. The study developed a Multinomial Logit Model forDynamic Benchmarking of Public Transport Services by incorporating the socio-economiccharacter of the people / users of the city to be included in the public transport benchmarkingmethodology. The Dynamic Benchmarking procedure is based upon the socio-economicvariables of commuters and the city which change with time like age, gender, income andqualification of the commuters which changes spatially (over geography) and temporally (overtime). Hence, this study provides a novel approach to evaluate and benchmark Public Transportin cities, which is dynamic and change as the character of the commuter's change.

[019] In another aspect of the present invention, the developing countries like India areundergoing continuous increment in population and economy, which in turn increases privatevehicle ownership. The motorization possesses a negative impact on the public transportmodalities. This in turn develops more challenges for the transport environment and the policymakers in providing a better environment. The urban transport system of many developingcountries is still substandard that makes the people move towards private vehicles (Ferreira andLake, 2002). India is full of diversity, so are its cities, where a handful of cities are metropoliseshaving population over 10 million, whereas majority of them have population in range 1 - 10million. Transport being an indirect demand and demands are highly dependent on the usercharacteristics, and that the user's perspective plays a vital role in benchmarking the publictransport services, where the user's transport requirements are influenced by his / her socio -economic characters like gender, age income and qualification. The development of a city isbasically dependent on the efficiency of the transport system that accommodates and movespeople throughout the city. Poor transport systems will reduce the competition of the city frommarkets (Henning et al., 2011). To improve efficiency and quality of transit services, Federaland State Governments along with ULBs are working towards providing safe, comfortable andaffordable transport. Thus, the following study holds its importance in terms of focusing on"Re-defining the service level benchmarking for public transport system in India", in light ofcommuter's perspective.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS:

[020] Reference will be made to embodiments of the invention, examples of which may beillustrated in accompanying figures. These figures are intended to be illustrative, not limiting.Although the invention is generally described in the context of these embodiments, it shouldbe understood that it is not intended to limit the scope of the invention to these particularembodiments.

[021] Figure 1: Research Methodology Process;

[022] Figure 2: Identifying the Parameters for the study;

[023] Figure 3: Association between dependent and independent variables;DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS:

[024] While the present invention is described herein by way of example using embodimentsand illustrative drawings, those skilled in the art will recognize that the invention is not limitedto the embodiments of drawing or drawings described and are not intended to represent thescale of the various components. Further, some components that may form a part of theinvention may not be illustrated in certain figures, for ease of illustration, and such omissionsdo not limit the embodiments outlined in any way. It should be understood that the drawingsand the detailed description thereto are not intended to limit the invention to the particular formdisclosed, but on the contrary, the invention is to cover all modifications, equivalents, andalternatives falling within the scope of the present invention as defined by the appended claim.

[025] As used throughout this description, the word "may" is used in a permissive sense (i.e.meaning having the potential to), rather than the mandatory sense, (i.e. meaning must). Further,the words "a" or "an" mean "at least one" and the word "plurality" means "one or more" unlessotherwise mentioned. Furthermore, the terminology and phraseology used herein are solelyused for descriptive purposes and should not be construed as limiting in scope. Language suchas "including," "comprising," "having," "containing," or "involving," and variations thereof, isintended to be broad and encompass the subject matter listed thereafter, equivalents, andadditional subject matter not recited, and is not intended to exclude other additives,components, integers, or steps. Likewise, the term "comprising" is considered synonymouswith the terms "including" or "containing" for applicable legal purposes. Any discussion ofdocuments, acts, materials, devices, articles, and the like are included in the specification solelyfor the purpose of providing a context for the present invention. It is not suggested orrepresented that any or all these matters form part of the prior art base or are common generalknowledge in the field relevant to the present invention.

[026] In this disclosure, whenever a composition or an element or a group of elements ispreceded with the transitional phrase "comprising", it is understood that we also contemplatethe same composition, element, or group of elements with transitional phrases "consisting of","consisting", "selected from the group of consisting of, "including", or "is" preceding therecitation of the composition, element or group of elements and vice versa.

[027] The present invention is described hereinafter by various embodiments with referenceto the accompanying drawing, wherein reference numerals used in the accompanying drawingcorrespond to the like elements throughout the description. This invention may, however, beembodied in many different forms and should not be construed as limited to the embodimentset forth herein. Rather, the embodiment is provided so that this disclosure will be thoroughand complete and will fully convey the scope of the invention to those skilled in the art. In thefollowing detailed description, numeric values and ranges are provided for various aspects ofthe implementations described. These values and ranges are to be treated as examples only andare not intended to limit the scope of the claims. In addition, several materials are identified assuitable for various facets of the implementations. These materials are to be treated asexemplary and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention.

[028] The present invention provides a method for dynamic benchmarking of public transportto fulfill commuter aspirations. The aim of the research is to study the service levelbenchmarking for public transport systems in India, in light of commuter's perspective and toestablish the relevance of commuter's socio-economic character in public transportbenchmarking, in order to redefine it. The study is conducted with an objective to identify theparameters through literature review, which are being used to evaluate public transport servicesacross various other geographies and to study the variation in the perceived weight allotted bythe commuters to the identified parameters for benchmarking public transport, along withestablishing relationship between the socio-economic characteristic of the user and theperceived weight allotted to the identified parameters for benchmarking public transport inorder to re-define the service level benchmarking for public transport of India, in light ofcommuter's perspective.

[029] The data is collected through a direct interview method adopting random sampling.Responses are collected from users of city bus service in Bhopal on a specifically designedquestionnaire, where information regarding socio-economic character of user viz. gender, age,income and qualification is recorded along with a weight score allotted to identified parametersof public transport benchmarking i.e., accessibility, comfort, cost, environment, reliability,safety and time. Initially the data is analyzed for its distribution; secondly the hypothesis istested whether there is any significant relation between the socio-economic predictors and theweight scores. T-test analysis (for gender, being on nominal scale) is used to check the validityof the hypothesis whereas spearman correlation test (for age, income and qualification) isemployed to check for relation between the socio-economic characteristic with the allottedimportance score to identified parameters and lastly to develop a predictive model, wheremultinomial logistic model is used for regression analysis. The regression is done for each ofthe parameters, with the predictors which are found to be significantly associated with therespective parameter using the chi-square test for association.

[030] The study found that there exists significant relationship between the socio-economiccharacter and the allotted score to public transport benchmarking parameters, additionally asapplicable keeping age, gender, income and qualification as variable, the perceived weight ofidentified parameters can be modeled using multinomial logit model analysis, and theregression models developed are found to be statistically significant and the models developedcould explain almost 30% variability. By studying these issues, the study explores an importantgap in the current practice of benchmarking public transport strategy, where the user and his / her aspirations from the public transport services of its city are not considered whilebenchmarking the quality of service. The study developed a Multinomial Logit Model forDynamic Benchmarking of Public Transport Services by incorporating the socio-economiccharacter of the people / users of the city to be included in the public transport benchmarkingmethodology. The Dynamic Benchmarking procedure is based upon the socio-economicvariables of commuters and the city which change with time like age, gender, income andqualification of the commuters which changes spatially (over geography) and temporally (overtime). Hence, this study provides a novel approach to evaluate and benchmark Public Transportin cities, which is dynamic and change as the character of the commuter's change.

[031] The developing countries like India are undergoing continuous increment in populationand economy, which in turn increases private vehicle ownership. The motorization possessesa negative impact on the public transport modalities. This in turn develops more challenges forthe transport environment and the policy makers in providing a better environment. The urbantransport system of many developing countries is still substandard that makes the people movetowards private vehicles (Ferreira and Lake, 2002). India is full of diversity, so are its cities,where a handful of cities are metropolises having population over 10 million, whereas majorityof them have population in range 1 - 10 million. Transport being an indirect demand anddemands are highly dependent on the user characteristics, and that the user's perspective playsa vital role in benchmarking the public transport services, where the user's transportrequirements are influenced by his / her socio - economic characters like gender, age incomeand qualification. The development of a city is basically dependent on the efficiency of thetransport system that accommodates and moves people throughout the city. Poor transportsystems will reduce the competition of the city from markets (Henning et al., 2011). To improveefficiency and quality of transit services, Federal and State Governments along with ULBs areworking towards providing safe, comfortable and affordable transport. Thus, the followingstudy holds its importance in terms of focusing on "Re-defining the service level benchmarkingfor public transport system in India", in light of commuter's perspective.

[032] The study may have relevance to the public transport services offered in the urban areasof India, only. The study is done with the commuters of public transport service and the presentstudy is limited to their defining the benchmarking parameters for the better evaluation andperformance of the public transport system. The study is emphasized only on the need forevaluation of public transport. The study is limited towards the comparison of the presentservice level benchmarks of the public transport system. The limitation of the present study ison the identification of newer parameters that will improvise the evaluation procedure andbetter operational practice of the public transport system of India.

[033] The study has been conducted in accordance with the basis of the research frameworkincluding designs, research paradigms, research approaches, sample size, sampling, datacollection, data analysis and ethical considerations etc. Both, the primary and secondaryresearch methods have been followed in the study to complete the study proficiently. Theprimary data has been collected following the quantitative analytical analysis method wherethe public had been interviewed and asked to convey the importance weightage to theparameters of urban public transport system along with revelation of their socio-economiccharacter i.e. age, gender, income and qualification. This has helped in identifying therelationship between parameters and user characteristics, for benchmarking public transport, inIndian context. On the basis of the statistical analysis tools, validation of the samples,distribution of response, and relationship between the variables has been developed to redefinethe SLB for public transport services in India. A detailed flow chart depicting the Methodologyis as presented in Figure 2.

[034] Referring now to Figure 1, the public transport benchmarking for different othergeographies is studied and after documenting the set of parameters being used for publictransport benchmarking it is observed that prevalent parameters of public transportbenchmarking could be broadly categorized into the accessibility, comfort, cost, environment,reliability, safety and time.

[035] The chapter includes understanding of technical terminologies including review ofprocedure of benchmarking public transport in other countries along with identification ofbroad parameters to benchmark public transport adopted by them. The chapter also elaboratelyreviews SLB for public transport in India. Additionally, this section has developed the researchobjectives in a detailed manner to meet the aim of the research work. The researcher hascollected the evidence from the different secondary resources like books, articles, journals andother websites that are relevant to the research topic.

[036] Besides that, he explores several works related to the Benchmarking Parameters, foreffective evaluation of the Public Transport Services. In association with this, the chapter givesa detailed view of the justification for the evaluation of public transport service. The currentscenario of the Indian public transport system is also analyzed. The comparison of theevaluation process of the public transport system is also studied in order to find its statusaccording to the Service Level Benchmarks. The study also focuses on the identification ofparameters required for evaluating the public transport evaluation. The literature review hasbeen done keeping the benchmarking philosophies adopted by various other countries andservice providers along with historical use of performance parameters. The literature reviewidentified fifty-one evaluation parameters for public transport and categorized them into sevenbroad parameters, as detailed in Figure 3. The literature review identified predictors i.e., thesocio-economic characteristic which can potentially affect the commuter aspiration from thepublic transport service, these are age, gender, income and qualification.

[037] The study developed a hypothesis that the commuter's socio-economic characteristicsare related to the relative importance of parameters for public transport benchmarking. In orderto investigate this relationship, a questionnaire is designed to record the socio-economiccharacter and importance weight allotted to each of the identified parameters. Survey is donewith the commuters on the city buses in Bhopal, which is being operated by a SPV calledBhopal City Link Limited (BCLL) a fully owned venture of Bhopal Municipal Corporation(BMC). The surveys are conducted at bus stops and on board the buses and responses fromusers are recorded. The data is collected through a direct interview method adopting randomsampling, in total 437 responses are recorded. Responses are collected from users of city busservice in Bhopal on a specifically designed questionnaire, where information regarding socioeconomic character of user viz. gender, age, income and qualification is recorded along with aweight score allotted to identified parameters of public transport benchmarking i.e.,accessibility, comfort, cost, environment, reliability, safety and time. The methodology isformulated to achieve the specifically framed objectives which are based on three stagequantitative data analysis. Initially the data is analyzed for its distribution; secondly thehypothesis is tested whether there is any significant relation between the socio-economicpredictors and the weight scores. T-test analysis (for gender, being on nominal scale) is usedto check the validity of the hypothesis whereas spearman correlation test (for age, income andqualification) is employed to check for relation between the socio-economic characteristic withthe allotted importance score to identified parameters and lastly to develop a predictive model,where multinomial logistic model is used for regression analysis. The regression is done foreach of the parameters, with the predictors which are found to be significantly associated withthe respective parameter using the chi-square test for association. Furthermore, this chapterfirst identifies and then introduces the study area in the beginning and thereafter focuses on thestudy methodology and design. The chapter also discusses in details the design of thequestionnaire used for achieving the specific objectives of the study. Later in the chapter, thesample size, sampling technique and details regarding the survey has been discussed. Finally,the analysis techniques used in the study has been discussed and elaborated along with detailsof the hypothesis formulated for achieving the objectives of the study. This is the third chapterof the thesis and provides an overview about research design, research strategy, samplingdesign, sampling plan, data types, data analysis and interpretation techniques that are used inthis research. In addition to these, this chapter discusses in detail about the research ethics andlimitations of the study. The researcher introduced the research methods that are used to collectthe data and complete the study properly. The comprehensive data analysis techniques used inthis section of the report include Mean Score Analysis, T-Test Analysis, Spearman Correlation,Chi-Square Test for Association, and Multinomial Logistic Regression Model.

[038] Referring now to Figure 3, the chapter elaborates the quantitative analysis in regards toachieving specific objectives, i.e., establishing relation, association and regression betweenpredictors and the variables. The chapter introduces the distribution of responses from the useropinion survey, then quantifies the relative weight allotted by commuters to identifiedparameters, thereafter checks the hypothesis, regarding the variations in the score andestablishes relation of the variation with socio-economic characteristics of the users. In the lastsection the regression model is developed using multinomial logistic regression method. In thischapter, the researcher has used various data analysis techniques and analyzed the collectedprimary data. The results have been presented in a theoretical manner or in the form of graphsand charts to make the readers understand it. The collected result has been interpreted in thissection of the study to verify whether the research hypothesis can be validated or not.

[039] The study found that there exists significant relationship between the socio-economiccharacter and the allotted score to public transport benchmarking parameters, additionally asapplicable keeping age, gender, income and qualification as variable, the perceived weight ofidentified parameters can be modeled using multinomial logit model analysis, and theregression models developed are found to be statistically significant and the models developedcould explain almost 30% variability. By studying these issues, the thesis explores an importantgap in the current practice of benchmarking public transport strategy in India, where the userand his / her aspirations from the public transport services of its city are to be considered whilebenchmarking the quality of service. The study also establishes the relationship betweenpassenger's characteristics and public transport benchmarking, giving policy guidance toadministrators and policy makers to keep "People" in the center of transport planning asenvisaged by the National Urban Transport Policy 2006 of India. The study proposes this to bedone by incorporating the socio-economic character of the people / users of the city to beincluded in the public transport benchmarking methodology in India, by adopting a dynamicbenchmarking procedure which is based upon the socio-economic variables like age, gender,income and qualification of the commuters as detailed in Figure 4. Hence, this study providesa detailed examination of the SLBs being utilized by the Ministry of Urban Development,Government of India to evaluate the public transport services in cities of India.

[040] The discussions are categorized on the basis of research questions and objectives.Hence it is attempted in this chapter to present answers to the research questions which areframed when the study is initiated. The findings and conclusions are elaborated in light of thesocial predictors identified and the overall aim of the study. The chapter after criticalexamination of the current SLB for public transport in India suggests a few proposals in orderto redefine the service level benchmarking of public transport system in India. Here, theresearcher has discussed the analyzed result from the collected primary data. The chapter alsoprovides justification about the outcomes of the present study, "Re-defining the Service LevelBenchmarking for Public Transport System in India" and provides informational outlook ofthe researcher which are based on the objectives of the research and research questions. In thisis chapter of the study where the researcher has described the whole study in brief. The resultsof the study have been summarized at the end of this chapter to verify the research objectives.The discussions are done with respect to the slated objectives of the study. Besides that, theresearcher has described the summary of results obtained through the data analysis section andalso provides conclusions to the research followed by recommendations and suggestions basedon the study findings.

[041] The disclosure has been described with reference to the accompanying embodimentsherein and the various features and advantageous details thereof are explained with referenceto the non-limiting embodiments in the following description. Descriptions of well-knowncomponents and processing techniques are omitted so as to not unnecessarily obscure theembodiments herein.

[042] The foregoing description of the specific embodiments so fully revealed the generalnature of the embodiments herein that others can, by applying current knowledge, readilymodify and / or adapt for various applications such specific embodiments without departingfrom the generic concept, and, therefore, such adaptations and modifications should and areintended to be comprehended within the meaning and range of equivalents of the disclosedembodiments. It is to be understood that the phraseology or terminology employed herein isfor the purpose of description and not of limitation. Therefore, while the embodiments hereinhave been described in terms of preferred embodiments, those skilled in the art will recognizethat the embodiments herein can be practiced with modification within the scope of theembodiments as described herein.

Claims

1. A method for dynamic benchmarking of public transport to fulfill commuter aspirations, the method comprises steps of: - collecting a plurality of data through a direct interview method adopting random sampling; and collecting responses from users of city bus service on a specifically designed questionnaire; - analyzing the data for a distribution thereof to define a hypothesis; - testing the hypothesis whether there is any significant relation between the socioeconomic predictors and the weight scores; - using comprehensive data analysis techniques used in this section of the report include Mean Score Analysis, T-Test Analysis, Spearman Correlation, Chi-Square Test for Association, and Multinomial Logistic Regression Model; and - doing regression for each of the parameters, with the predictors which are found to be significantly associated with the respective parameter using the chi-square test for association.

2. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the information regarding socio-economic character of user viz. gender, age, income and qualification is recorded along with a weight score allotted to identified parameters of public transport benchmarking i.e., accessibility, comfort, cost, environment, reliability, safety and time.

3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the T-test analysis (for gender, being on nominal scale) is used to check the validity of the hypothesis4. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the spearman correlation test (for age, income and qualification) is employed to check for relation between the socio-economic characteristic with the allotted importance score to identified parameters and lastly to develop a predictive model.

5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein the multinomial logistic model is used for regression analysis.