Method, device, and program for correcting sensory evaluation values, and method of performing sensory evaluation of food and beverages
The method and device address inconsistencies in sensory evaluations by calculating a correction value based on evaluator health and circadian rhythm, improving the reliability and accuracy of sensory evaluations in food and drink development.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024070752
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-04-26
- Filing Date
- 2024-04-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-04-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing sensory evaluation methods in food and drink development are affected by variations in human taste and smell due to factors like physical condition and time of day, leading to inconsistencies in evaluation results.
A method and device that calculate a correction value for sensory evaluation by considering the health condition and circadian rhythm of the evaluator, using an estimation model to adjust for fluctuations in taste and smell, incorporating health evaluation values and time information to improve accuracy.
The method and device reduce the influence of human taste and smell variations, enhancing the reliability and stability of sensory evaluations by providing a more accurate correction for sensory evaluation values.
Smart Images

Figure 2024159631000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method, an apparatus, and a program for correcting an evaluation value of a sensory evaluation by an evaluator. [Background technology]
[0002] In food and beverage development and research, sensory evaluation using the five senses is conducted. Since sensory evaluation using the five senses is conducted by humans, not machines, there is variation in the evaluation values. Various efforts have been made to improve the accuracy and stability of sensory evaluation.
[0003] For example, the method and device disclosed in Patent Document 1 listed below can quantify the similarity in flavor between foods and drinks from waveform data of muscle activity when an evaluator swallows a food or drink. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] Patent Publication No. 2021-032770 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] Even when the same evaluator performs a sensory evaluation of the same food or drink, the taste and smell perceived by the evaluator may differ depending on, for example, his / her physical condition or the time of the evaluation. Such variations in human taste and smell are often discussed among the people in charge of sensory evaluation at companies and research institutes, and there are concerns about their impact on sensory evaluation.
[0006] However, no specific measures have been taken so far to address such variations in human taste and smell. Patent Document 1 mentions that factors such as sensory fatigue and changes in physical condition may affect sensory evaluation. However, Patent Document 1 does not disclose any specific measures or methods for reducing such effects. In the context of sensory evaluation of foods and beverages, there is a demand for reducing the effects of variations in human taste and smell on the sensory evaluation of foods and beverages.
[0007] An object of the present invention is to provide an improved method, device, and program for correcting an evaluation value of a sensory evaluation. [Means for solving the problem]
[0008] The present invention for solving the above problems includes, for example, the following aspects. (Section 1) A step of obtaining a sensory evaluation value regarding taste by an evaluator; obtaining a health evaluation value relating to the health condition of the assessor; calculating a correction value of the sensory evaluation value based on an estimation model including a correlation between a health evaluation value and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population, the sensory evaluation value, and the health evaluation value; A sensory evaluation value correction method comprising: (Section 2) Item 2. The method according to Item 1, wherein the sensory evaluation value related to taste includes a sensory evaluation value related to at least one selected from the group consisting of taste intensity, taste preference, taste aftertaste, taste detection ability, taste recognition ability, and taste evaluation. (Section 3) Item 3. The method according to item 1 or 2, wherein the health condition includes at least one selected from the group consisting of fatigue, insomnia, and physical and mental health conditions. (Section 4) The estimation model is A first correlation representing a correlation between the insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value regarding a taste aftertaste; A second correlation representing a correlation between the insomnia score and the sensory evaluation value regarding taste preference; A third correlation represents a correlation between the insomnia score and the sensory evaluation value regarding the taste evaluation of the food. The method according to any one of items 1 to 3, comprising at least one of the following: (Section 5) The method further includes a step of acquiring time information when the sensory evaluation is performed by the evaluator, The estimation model further includes a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste in a human population and a sensory evaluation value related to taste, 5. The method according to any one of items 1 to 4, wherein the step of calculating the correction value calculates a correction value of the sensory evaluation value further based on the time information of the evaluator. (Section 6) The estimation model is A fourth correlation represents the correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste and the sensory evaluation value of taste intensity; The fifth correlation represents the correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste and the sensory evaluation score on taste recognition ability; Item 6. The method according to item 5, comprising at least one of the following: (Section 7) Item 5. The method according to any one of items 1 to 4, wherein the estimation model includes a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste, a health evaluation value, and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population. (Section 8) A step of obtaining a sensory evaluation value regarding the taste of the food or drink by an evaluator; A step of correcting the sensory evaluation value related to the taste of the food or drink based on the sensory evaluation value correction method according to any one of items 1 to 7; A method for sensory evaluation of food and beverages, comprising: (Section 9) a sensory evaluation value acquisition means for acquiring a sensory evaluation value regarding taste by an evaluator; a health evaluation value acquisition means for acquiring a health evaluation value related to the health condition of the assessor; a correction value calculation means for calculating a correction value of the sensory evaluation value based on an estimation model including a correlation between a health evaluation value and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population, the sensory evaluation value, and the health evaluation value; A sensory evaluation value correction device comprising: (Section 10) A program for causing a computer to execute each step of the method according to any one of items 1 to 8. (Section A) The method according to any one of items 3 to 8, wherein the fatigue includes physical fatigue and mental fatigue as factors. (Section B) The method according to any one of items 3 to 8, wherein the mental and physical health conditions include factors such as physical symptoms, anxiety and insomnia, social activity disorders and depression tendencies. (Section C) The method according to any one of items 1 to 8, wherein the taste includes at least one selected from the group consisting of sweetness, saltiness, sourness, bitterness, and umami. Effect of the Invention
[0009] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide an improved method, device, and program for correcting an evaluation value of a sensory evaluation. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating a usage mode of a sensory evaluation value correction device according to an embodiment of the present invention, and is a diagram for explaining a usage mode when correcting an evaluation value of a sensory evaluation. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating a usage mode of the sensory evaluation value correction device according to one embodiment of the present invention, and is a diagram for explaining a usage mode when a taste test for creating an estimation model is carried out. [Diagram 3] 1 is a block diagram for explaining functions of a sensory evaluation value correcting device according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. [Figure 4] 4 is a flowchart showing a sensory evaluation value correcting method according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 5] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing the concentrations of aqueous solutions used for each taste in the taste test in Example 1. [Figure 6]1 is a graph showing the results of the taste test in Example 1, and illustrating the results regarding the circadian rhythm of taste. (A) shows the evaluation value of the taste intensity for a sweet aqueous solution. (B) shows the evaluation value of the taste intensity for a bitter aqueous solution. [Figure 7] 1 is a graph showing the results of the taste test in Example 1, and illustrating the results regarding the circadian rhythm of taste. (A) shows the perception threshold (the lowest concentration that could be recognized as bitter) and the acceptable concentration for bitterness. (B) shows the perception threshold (the lowest concentration that could be recognized as umami) and the preferred concentration for umami. [Figure 8] 1 shows the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is a graph for explaining the results regarding taste and poor physical condition. (A) shows the change in aftertaste for sweetness for the healthy group and the insomnia group. (B) shows the change in aftertaste for umami for the healthy group and the insomnia group. (C) shows the change in aftertaste for sourness for the healthy group and the insomnia group. [Figure 9] 1 is a graph showing the results of the taste test in Example 1, illustrating the results relating to taste and poor physical condition. The preferred concentration of sweetness is shown for a healthy group and an insomnia group. [Figure 10] 1 is a graph showing the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is intended to explain the results relating to taste and poor physical condition. (A) shows the taste evaluation scores of bitter chocolate for the healthy group and the insomnia group. (B) shows the taste evaluation scores of dry sausage for the healthy group and the insomnia group. [Figure 11] 1 shows the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is an example of a model showing the influence (large influence) of the evaluator's state on taste and taste preference. [Figure 12] 1 shows the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is an example of a model showing the influence (moderate) of the evaluator's state on taste and taste preference. [Figure 13] 1 shows the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is an example of a model showing the influence (small influence) of the evaluator's state on taste and taste preference. [Figure 14]1 shows the results of the taste test in Example 1, and is an example of a sensory evaluation model showing the influence of environmental factors such as evaluation time and room temperature, and poor physical condition such as insomnia on taste evaluation. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0011] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings. In the following description and drawings, the same reference numerals denote the same or similar components, and therefore, redundant description of the same or similar components will be omitted.
[0012] [Apparatus and Method Overview] 1 and 2 are diagrams for explaining a usage mode of a sensory evaluation value correction device according to an embodiment of the present invention. Fig. 1 shows a usage mode when correcting the evaluation value of a sensory evaluation, and Fig. 2 shows a usage mode when a taste test for creating an estimation model is carried out. The taste test shown in Fig. 2 is carried out in advance before the correction of the evaluation value shown in Fig. 1.
[0013] Correction of sensory evaluation values FIG. 1 is referred to. The sensory evaluation value correction device 100 (hereinafter, simply referred to as the device 100) according to one embodiment is a device that calculates a correction value of a sensory evaluation value (hereinafter, also referred to as a sensory evaluation value) for taste (for example, sweetness, saltiness, sourness, bitterness, and umami) by an evaluator 98. The correction value of the sensory evaluation value calculated by the device 100 is a correction value that takes into account the variation in the taste and smell of the evaluator 98. A person's taste sensitivity and desire (preference) for each taste are affected by the person's physical condition and time of day. In this embodiment, when calculating the correction value of the sensory evaluation, information on the health condition of the evaluator 98 who performs the sensory evaluation is taken into account. This reduces the influence of the variation in the taste and smell of the evaluator 98 on the sensory evaluation of the food and drink. In the example shown in FIG. 1, for the sweetness intensity evaluated between values 0 to 5, a correction value of the sweetness intensity that takes into account information on the health condition of the evaluator 98 is calculated between values 0 to 5.
[0014] The procedure will be described below. The evaluator 98 performs a sensory evaluation of the taste (e.g., sweetness) of the food or drink 99, and inputs a sensory evaluation value related to the taste (e.g., a value of "3" as the intensity of sweetness) into the device 100. The evaluator 98 answers questions related to health evaluation displayed on, for example, the display unit 32 of the device 100, and inputs a score (hereinafter also referred to as a health evaluation value) related to his / her own health condition (e.g., fatigue) into the device 100.
[0015] The device 100 stores an estimation model 24 including a correlation between a health evaluation value and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population. The estimation model 24 may include a plurality of correlations. Such correlations between health evaluation values and sensory evaluation values related to taste stored in the estimation model 24 are generated in advance by a taste test in a human population, which will be described later with reference to FIG. 2.
[0016] The device 100 calculates a corrected value of the sensory evaluation value by the evaluator 98 (for example, a corrected sweetness intensity of "4.2") based on the acquired sensory evaluation value and health evaluation value of the evaluator 98 and the estimation model 24. The calculated corrected value is displayed on, for example, the display unit 32 of the device 100.
[0017] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the evaluator 98 inputs time information at which the sensory evaluation of the food or drink 99 was performed to the device 100. The device 100 calculates a correction value of the sensory evaluation value by the evaluator 98 based on the acquired time information of the evaluator 98. In this case, the estimation model 24 further includes an association between the circadian rhythm of taste in a human group and the sensory evaluation value related to taste. The circadian rhythm of taste is a daily rhythm in which subjective taste sensitivity and preferences change throughout the day.
[0018] - Conduct taste tests to create estimation models Please refer to Fig. 2. The estimation model 24 used by the device 100 to calculate the correction value of the sensory evaluation value includes the correlation between the health evaluation value and the sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population. Such correlation included in the estimation model 24 is generated in advance by conducting a plurality of types of taste tests by a plurality of evaluators 198 targeting a plurality of types of food and drink 199 as taste tests in a human population.
[0019] The evaluator 198 performs a sensory evaluation of taste for each of a plurality of types of food and drink 199, and inputs the sensory evaluation value for taste into the device 100. The taste tests include, for example, a test on taste intensity, a test on taste preference, a test on taste aftertaste, a test on taste detection ability and taste recognition ability (cognitive threshold), and a taste evaluation. The sensory evaluation for taste is performed for each of the five tastes, for example, sweetness, saltiness, sourness, bitterness, and umami.
[0020] The evaluator 198 inputs a health evaluation value related to his / her own health condition (e.g., fatigue, insomnia, and mental and physical health condition) into the device 100 by answering, for example, three types of questions related to health evaluation displayed on, for example, the display unit 32 of the device 100. In this embodiment, the questions related to health evaluation are three types: the Chalder Fatigue Scale, the Athens Sleep Scale, and the General Health Questionnaire. The estimation model creation unit 14 provided in the device 100 generates an association between the health evaluation value and the sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human group based on the sensory evaluation values related to taste and the health evaluation values obtained from the multiple evaluators 198, and creates an estimation model 24 including the generated association.
[0021] In the taste test, the evaluator 198 can input time information when the sensory evaluation of the food or drink 199 was performed to the device 100. The estimation model creation unit 14 can further create a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste in a human group and the sensory evaluation value related to taste based on the time information when the sensory evaluation was performed by the evaluator 198, which is obtained from the multiple evaluators 198, and can include the correlation in the estimation model 24.
[0022] [Device configuration] FIG. 3 is a block diagram for explaining the function of the sensory evaluation value correcting device according to one embodiment of the present invention.
[0023] The sensory evaluation value correction device 100 according to an embodiment includes a data processing unit 10, an auxiliary storage device 20, an input unit 31, a display unit 32, and a communication interface unit (communication I / F unit) 33. The data processing unit 10 is configured as software, and the auxiliary storage device 20, the input unit 31, the display unit 32, and the communication I / F unit 33 are configured as hardware. The sensory evaluation value correction device 100 can be configured using, for example, a general-purpose computer such as a personal computer, a tablet terminal, a smartphone, or the like. Although not shown in the figure, the sensory evaluation value correction device 100 further includes, as hardware configuration, a processor such as a CPU that processes data, and a memory that the processor uses as a working area for data processing.
[0024] The data processing unit 10 is a functional block that is realized by a processor executing a sensory evaluation value correction program 29 (hereinafter, also simply referred to as the program 29), which will be described later. In this embodiment, the data processing unit 10 is provided as a software functional block.
[0025] The sensory evaluation value acquiring unit 11 acquires data 21 of a sensory evaluation value relating to taste by the evaluator 98. The time information acquiring unit 12 acquires data 22 of time information at which the sensory evaluation was performed by the evaluator 98. The health evaluation value acquiring unit 13 acquires data 23 of a health evaluation value relating to the health condition of the evaluator 98. The sensory evaluation value data 21, time information data 22 and health evaluation value data 23 are acquired, for example, via the input unit 31 or the communication I / F unit 33, and stored in the auxiliary storage device 20.
[0026] In this embodiment, the sensory evaluation value data 21 and health evaluation value data 23 are input by the evaluator 98 via dialog boxes 81, 82 displayed on the display unit 32 of the device 100, as shown in Fig. 1. The time information data 22 is obtained from a clock function of an operating system (OS) included in the device 100 in this embodiment.
[0027] The estimation model creation unit 14 functions when a taste test is performed in a human population. The taste test is performed in advance before correcting the evaluation value of the sensory evaluation. The estimation model creation unit 14 generates an association between the health evaluation value and the sensory evaluation value of the taste in the human population based on the sensory evaluation value and the health evaluation value regarding the taste obtained from the multiple evaluators 198, and creates an estimation model 24 including the generated association. The estimation model creation unit 14 can further create an association between the circadian rhythm of taste in the human population and the sensory evaluation value regarding the taste based on the time information obtained from the multiple evaluators 198 when the sensory evaluation was performed by the evaluators 198, and include it in the estimation model 24. The created estimation model 24 is stored in the auxiliary storage device 20.
[0028] In this embodiment, the sensory evaluation value and the health evaluation value are input to the device 100 by the evaluator 198 during the taste test, as exemplified in FIG. 2, through dialog boxes 71 to 75 displayed on the display unit 32 of the device 100. The dialog boxes 71 to 74 are dialog boxes for the evaluator 198 to input the sensory evaluation value, and are, in order, a dialog box for a test on taste intensity, a test on taste preference, a test on taste aftertaste, and a taste evaluation. The dialog box 75 is a dialog box for the evaluator 198 to input the health evaluation value during the taste test. In this embodiment, the time information at which the sensory evaluation is performed by the evaluator 198 during the taste test is acquired from a clock function of an operating system (OS) provided in the device 100.
[0029] The correction value calculation unit 15 calculates a correction value for the sensory evaluation value data 21 of the evaluator 98 based on the estimation model 24 and the sensory evaluation value data 21 and health evaluation value data 23 of the evaluator 98. The calculated correction value data 25 is stored in the auxiliary storage device 20. In this embodiment, the calculated correction value data 25 is displayed on the display unit 32 of the device 100 via a dialog box 83, as exemplified in FIG.
[0030] The auxiliary storage device 20 is a non-volatile storage device that stores an operating system (OS), various control programs, data generated by the programs, etc., and is configured, for example, by a flash memory, an eMMC (embedded multi media card), an SSD (solid state drive), etc. In this embodiment, the auxiliary storage device 20 stores sensory evaluation value data 21, time information data 22, health evaluation value data 23, an estimation model 24, correction value data 25, and a sensory evaluation value correction program 29.
[0031] In the present embodiment, the estimation model 24 includes five associations. The first association represents an association between the insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value related to (the transition of) the aftertaste of taste. Preferably, the target taste in the first association includes at least one of sweetness, sourness, and umami. The second association represents an association between the insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value related to taste preference. Preferably, the target taste in the second association includes sweetness. The third association represents an association between the insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value related to the taste evaluation of the taste. Preferably, the target taste in the third association includes at least one of saltiness and bitterness. The fourth association represents an association between the circadian rhythm of taste and a sensory evaluation value related to the intensity of taste. Preferably, the target taste in the fourth association includes at least one of sweetness and bitterness. The fifth association represents an association between the circadian rhythm of taste and a sensory evaluation value related to the recognition ability (cognitive threshold) of taste. Preferably, the taste targeted in the fifth correlation includes at least one of bitterness and umami. The correspondence between the five correlations included in the estimation model 24 and the embodiments described below is as follows. The first correlation is based on Fig. 8(A) to Fig. 8(C). The second correlation is based on Fig. 9. The third correlation is based on Fig. 10(A) and Fig. 10(B). The fourth correlation is based on Fig. 6(A) and Fig. 6(B). The fifth correlation is based on Fig. 7(A) and Fig. 7(B). The estimation model 24 can be realized, for example, as a computer program. For example, when the estimation model 24 is realized as a computer program, the computer program is programmed to show the trends shown in each of the above-mentioned five correlations.
[0032] The sensory evaluation value correction program 29 is a computer program for implementing the units 11 to 15 in the data processing unit 10, which are functional blocks implemented by software. The program 29 can be installed in the device 100 via a network 39, such as the Internet, connected by the communication I / F unit 33. Alternatively, the program 29 can be installed in the device 100 by having the device 100 read a computer-readable, non-transitory, tangible recording medium, such as a memory card, on which the program 29 is recorded.
[0033] The input unit 31 can be configured with, for example, a mouse and a keyboard, and the display unit 32 can be configured with, for example, a liquid crystal display and an organic EL display. The communication I / F unit 33 transmits and receives data to and from an external device via a wired or wireless network. The communication I / F unit 33 can be configured with various wired or wireless connections such as Ethernet (registered trademark), Wi-Fi (registered trademark), and Bluetooth (registered trademark). The input unit 31 and the display unit 32 may be integrated to be realized as a touch panel type display device.
[0034] [Processing Procedure] FIG. 4 is a flowchart showing a sensory evaluation value correcting method according to an embodiment of the present invention.
[0035] The processing in steps S1 to S4 shown in FIG. 4 is executed by each functional block included in the data processing unit 10 (that is, by the sensory evaluation value correction device 100).
[0036] In step S1, sensory evaluation value data 21 regarding taste by the evaluator 98 is obtained. In step S2, time information data 22 at which the sensory evaluation was performed by the evaluator 98 is obtained. In step S3, health evaluation value data 23 regarding the health condition of the evaluator 98 is obtained.
[0037] In step S4, a corrected value of the sensory evaluation value data 21 of the evaluator 98 is calculated based on the estimation model 24, and the sensory evaluation value data 21, time information data 22, and health evaluation value data 23 of the evaluator 98.
[0038] As described above, according to one embodiment of the present invention, an improved method, device, and program for correcting the evaluation value of a sensory evaluation can be provided. A person's taste sensitivity and desire (preference) for each taste are affected by the person's physical condition and time of day. In one embodiment of the present invention, when calculating the correction value of the sensory evaluation, information on the health condition of the evaluator 98 who performs the sensory evaluation is taken into consideration. This reduces the influence of the variation in the taste and smell of the evaluator 98 on the sensory evaluation of the food and drink 99. That is, the correction value of the sensory evaluation value calculated in one embodiment of the present invention is a correction value that takes into account the variation in the taste and smell of the evaluator 98. In this way, according to one embodiment of the present invention, the influence of the variation in the taste and smell of a person on the sensory evaluation of the food and drink can be reduced, and the accuracy and stability of the sensory evaluation can be improved. As a result, it becomes possible to use the sensory evaluation as a more reliable index.
[0039] [Other formats] Although the present invention has been described above with reference to specific embodiments, the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiments.
[0040] In the example shown in FIG. 1 of the above embodiment, the sweetness intensity correction value is calculated taking into account the information on the health condition of the evaluator 98 for the sweetness intensity evaluated between values 0 and 5, but the correction value of the sensory evaluation value for taste to be calculated is not limited to this. The correction value of the sensory evaluation value for taste to be calculated is not limited to the correction value of sweetness, but may be at least one correction value selected from the group consisting of sweetness, saltiness, sourness, bitterness, and umami. Furthermore, the correction value of the sensory evaluation value for taste to be calculated is not limited to the correction value of taste intensity, but may be at least one correction value selected from the group consisting of taste intensity, taste preference, taste aftertaste, taste detection ability, taste recognition ability, and taste evaluation. The scale range of the sensory evaluation value when performing the sensory evaluation is also arbitrary, and is not limited to values 0 to 5 when performing a taste intensity test, or values 0 to 12 when performing a taste evaluation shown in the examples described later.
[0041] In the above embodiment, the device 100 uses the time information when the evaluator 98 performed the sensory evaluation to calculate the correction value of the sensory evaluation value, but such time information by the evaluator 98 is not essential information but is optional information for the device 100 to calculate the correction value of the sensory evaluation value. The device 100 can calculate the correction value of the sensory evaluation value without using the time information when the evaluator 98 performed the sensory evaluation.
[0042] In the above embodiment, when correcting the evaluation value of the sensory evaluation, the evaluator 98 inputs a health evaluation value related to his / her own health condition into the device 100 by inputting an answer to a question related to the health evaluation into the device 100 via the input unit 31, but the manner in which the health evaluation value is input into the device is not limited to this. The answer to the question related to the health evaluation may be, for example, data previously answered by the evaluator 98, which may be acquired from the external server 97 via the network 39. Instead of the answer to the question related to the health evaluation, the biometric data of the evaluator 98 (e.g., biorhythm, fatigue level, working hours, sleeping hours, number of steps, heart rate, blood pressure, etc.) may be automatically measured via a wearable smart device (e.g., a smart watch) worn by the evaluator 98, and a part or all of the automatically measured biometric data may be input into the device 100. In this case, the device 100 may appropriately reinterpret or convert the acquired biometric data of the evaluator 98 and use it as the health evaluation value of the evaluator 98. Such modified forms of inputting health evaluation values into the device are not limited to the case where the sensory evaluation values are corrected as described above, but also apply to the case where multiple evaluators 198 input their own health evaluation values into the device 100 in a taste test for creating an estimation model 24.
[0043] In the above embodiment, the tastes to be subjected to the sensory evaluation are five tastes, namely sweetness, saltiness, sourness, bitterness, and umami (five tastes), but the tastes to be subjected to the sensory evaluation are not limited to these five tastes. The tastes to be subjected to the sensory evaluation do not need to include all five tastes, and may be, for example, four tastes, namely, sweetness, saltiness, sourness, and bitterness, or may include at least one of these five tastes. In addition to these exemplified tastes, the taste to be subjected to the sensory evaluation may further include flavor, deliciousness, and aroma. The meaning of taste in this specification includes the usual meaning of taste, as well as the aroma and flavor (smell), appearance (sight), texture (touch), and chewing sound (hearing) that are recognized in conjunction with taste, and should also be understood as a composite sensation (e.g., deliciousness) in which these elements are combined. In the example shown in the examples described later, for example, in the case of bitter chocolate, the aroma is, for example, a sweet aroma or a cacao aroma, and the flavor is, for example, an oily and fat feeling. In the case of dry sausage, for example, the aroma is, for example, a smoked aroma, and the flavor is, for example, a spicy feeling, a meaty flavor, or a greasy feeling.
[0044] In the above embodiment, the questions regarding health evaluation are three types, namely, the Chalder Fatigue Scale, the Athens Sleep Scale, and the General Health Questionnaire, but the questions regarding health evaluation are not limited to these three types. The questions regarding health evaluation may be any content that can determine a health evaluation value regarding the health state of the assessor 98,198. For example, questions regarding fatigue can be used other than the exemplified Chalder Fatigue Scale. Similarly, questions regarding insomnia can be used other than the exemplified Athens Sleep Scale, and questions regarding physical and mental health states can be used other than the exemplified General Health Questionnaire.
[0045] In the above embodiment, the sensory evaluation value correction device 100 is realized as an integrated device, but the sensory evaluation value correction device 100 does not need to be an integrated device, and the processor, memory, auxiliary storage device 20, etc. may be located in different locations and connected to each other via a network. The input unit 31 and the display unit 32 also do not necessarily need to be located in one place, and may be located in different locations and connected to each other so as to be able to communicate with each other via a network.
[0046] In the above embodiment, each of the functional blocks 11-15 constituting the data processing unit 10 is realized by software, but each of these functional blocks 11-15 may be realized partly or entirely as hardware. The processing of each of the functional blocks 11-15 constituting the data processing unit 10 does not need to be processed by a single processor, and may be distributed and processed by multiple processors. Some or all of the functions of the data processing unit 10 and the data items in the auxiliary storage device 20 may be cloud-based in an external server device 37 connected via the communication I / F unit 33.
[0047] The following examples of the present invention will make the features of the present invention clearer. EXAMPLES
[0048] In Example 1, a taste test was conducted in a human population, and the relationship between the sensory evaluation of taste in the human population, the health evaluation value, and the circadian rhythm of taste was considered. The taste test was conducted by multiple evaluators for multiple types of food and drink.
[0049] <Method> The taste test was conducted three times, in the morning (8:00 AM), afternoon (12:00 PM), and evening (7:00 PM), on 19 research participants (ages 20-50). The amount of saliva produced by the research participants was measured before the taste test. The research participants refrained from eating, drinking coffee, or other leisure items for two hours prior to the start of the test. Five aqueous solutions with five different concentrations, as shown in Figure 5, were used in the test. Five aqueous solutions with five different concentrations were prepared and used for each of the five tastes (sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and umami).
[0050] Taste Intensity, Discrimination Ability, and Preference Tests The research collaborators put the solutions in their mouths in order of decreasing concentration and rated the intensity of the taste they detected from 0 to 5 (0: no taste, 1: very weak taste, 2: weak taste, 3: moderate taste, 4: strong taste, 5: very strong taste). The taste intensity test was rated on a 6-point scale from 0 to 5. If the participants rated the strength as 1 or higher, they answered which of the five taste categories (sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and umami) the solution tasted. Based on the answers, the concentration of the solution with the lowest concentration that allowed them to correctly answer the taste was recorded. The taste discrimination test was rated on a 5-point scale from 1 to 5. Furthermore, the research collaborators selected one solution with the most preferred (or in another embodiment, not unpleasant and acceptable) concentration from the five solutions with five different concentrations. The taste preference test was rated on a 5-point scale from 1 to 5.
[0051] Aftertaste test The research participant placed about 15 ml of the most highly concentrated aqueous solution in Figure 5 into their mouth and tasted it thoroughly with their entire mouth. After about 10 seconds, they spat out the solution, and evaluated the aftertaste every 10 seconds for 120 seconds. The evaluation was done using a 12 cm line scale. The aftertaste test was a continuous evaluation between 0 and 12. The aftertaste test was done for each of the five tastes.
[0052] Physical condition evaluation After the evening taste test, the participants answered three questionnaires about fatigue, insomnia, and mental and physical health over the past week. Fatigue was asked using the Chalder Fatigue Scale (evaluated on a scale of 0 to 33, with a score of 16 or more indicating possible chronic fatigue). Insomnia was asked using the Athens Sleep Scale (evaluated on a scale of 0 to 24, with a score of 6 or more indicating possible insomnia). Mental and physical health was asked using the General Health Questionnaire GHQ-28 (evaluated on a scale of 0 to 28, with a score of 6 or more indicating possible poor mental health). Mental and physical health includes the mental state, which is the state of the mind, and the physical health, and the GHQ-28 can capture four symptoms: physical symptoms, anxiety / insomnia, impaired social activities, and depression.
[0053] Taste evaluation The research participants tasted both the bitter chocolate and the dry sausage, and evaluated the aroma, taste, flavor, and deliciousness of each. The taste evaluation was done on a continuous scale ranging from 0 to 12. A 12 cm (120 mm) line scale was also used for the taste evaluation. The position on the line scale where the research participant made a mark was measured in millimeters (mm) and used as an evaluation score. For example, if the research participant could not smell anything at all, the score would be 0, and if the research participant smelled a very strong aroma, the score would be 120.
[0054] <Result> -Regarding the circadian rhythm of taste In the taste intensity test, circadian rhythms were observed for sweetness and saltiness. The taste intensity rating for a low-concentration sweet solution (concentration 1: 0.125%) was significantly lower at night than during the day (P<0.05, Fig. 6(A)). For bitterness, the intensity ratings for all concentrations were lower at night than during the day (P<0.05, Fig. 6(B)).
[0055] Furthermore, when we looked at the concentration at which the type of taste could be accurately recognized (cognitive threshold), for bitterness, a lower concentration was recognized as a bitter aqueous solution in the daytime compared to the morning and evening (P<0.05, Fig. 7(A) left). This result showed that bitterness sensitivity increased in the daytime, and as a result, the acceptable concentration of bitterness was lower in the daytime compared to the evening (P<0.05, Fig. 7(A) right). On the other hand, for umami, taste sensitivity decreased in the daytime (P<0.05, Fig. 7(B) left), and it was revealed that a higher concentration of umami aqueous solution was preferred (P<0.05, Fig. 7(B) right).
[0056] Regarding taste and physical discomfort Regarding insomnia, 18 subjects were analyzed, excluding 1 subject with incomplete data, and 8 out of 18 subjects were found to have a tendency toward insomnia. When the results of the aftertaste test (daytime data) were compared between the healthy group (10 subjects) and the insomnia group (8 subjects), it was found that the aftertaste of sweetness and umami in the insomnia group tended to disappear more quickly than in the healthy group (P<0.10, Figure 8(A) and Figure 8(B)). For sourness, the strength of the aftertaste after 40 to 80 seconds was significantly lower in the insomnia group (P<0.05, Figure 8(C)). This result suggests that insomnia may have accelerated the disappearance of tastes in the oral cavity. In addition, the insomnia group preferred a lower concentration sweet solution than the healthy group (P<0.05, Figure 9), indicating a decreased preference for sweetness.
[0057] In a taste evaluation of bitter chocolate (approximately 32% fat, approximately 72% cacao) conducted at lunchtime, the insomnia group tended to have lower ratings for saltiness and melting in the mouth (P<0.10, Figure 10(A)). In a taste evaluation of dry sausage, the insomnia group also tended to have lower ratings for saltiness (P<0.10, Figure 10(B)), and lower ratings for bitterness and spiciness (P<0.05, Figure 10(B)).
[0058] <Example of a model showing the effect of evaluator state and evaluation time on taste and taste preference> 11 to 13 are examples of models showing the influence of the evaluator's condition (physical condition) on taste and taste preference. These illustrated models were created by analyzing the results of the taste test in this Example 1. Stepwise multiple regression analysis was used to analyze the relationships between the factors. Factors with a large influence are shown in FIG. 11, those with a medium influence are shown in FIG. 12, and those with a small influence are shown in FIG. 13. In the following description, the ability to detect taste means the ability to detect the presence of a certain taste, and the ability to recognize taste means the ability to accurately recognize which taste the detected taste is, for example, of the five tastes.
[0059] Referring to Figure 11, we consider the model with the greatest influence. When the evaluator is sleepless, the aftertaste disappears more quickly. When the evaluator is mentally fatigued, the ability to detect weak flavors decreases, and the evaluation value of the intensity of strong flavors (subjective taste intensity across the five tastes) also decreases, resulting in a lower taste evaluation value. Note that the path values shown in the model are standard partial regression coefficients, ** :p<0.01.
[0060] Referring to Figure 12, a model with a medium degree of influence will be considered. When the evaluator feels physically tired, their ability to detect flavors increases and the aftertaste tends to linger, leading to a higher taste evaluation value. When the evaluator feels physically tired or feels that their daily activities (work, etc.) are stalled, their preference for saltiness increases. On the other hand, when the evaluator's physical health is declining (headache, fatigue, etc.), their preference for saltiness, sourness, and umami decreases. When their mental health is declining (anxiety, insomnia), their preference for sweetness decreases. Note that the path values shown in the model are standard partial regression coefficients, ** :p<0.01.
[0061] Referring to Figure 13, we consider a model with a small effect. If the evaluator produces a large amount of saliva, the aftertaste disappears more quickly. If the evaluator's body temperature is high, their ability to detect flavors increases, so they can detect even weak flavors (low concentrations). On the other hand, if the evaluator's body temperature is high, their preference for sweetness decreases. If the evaluator is experiencing insomnia, their preference for umami increases. Note that the path values shown in the model are standard partial regression coefficients, * :p<0.05.
[0062] <Example of a model showing the relationship between evaluator's condition (physical condition) and sensory evaluation> Fig. 14 is an example of a sensory evaluation model showing the influence of environmental factors such as evaluation time and room temperature, and poor physical condition such as insomnia on the taste. The illustrated model was created by analyzing the results of the taste test in this Example 1, in which dry sausage was used as the sample. Stepwise multiple regression analysis was used to analyze the relationships between each factor.
[0063] The sensory evaluation model shown in Figure 14 is considered. The factor that had a major impact on the taste of dry sausage was "how easily it leaves an aftertaste." Aftertaste was significantly reduced by insomnia, and it was shown to contribute not only to lowering the strength of the food's saltiness and sourness, but also to the strength of the meat's flavor and oiliness. Furthermore, the sourness and meat flavor that are affected by the aftertaste also influenced the overall evaluation value of the food's "deliciousness." On the other hand, it was suggested that a decline in mental health, as indicated by anxiety and insomnia, may reduce preference for sweetness, indirectly lowering the evaluation value of deliciousness. Note that the path values shown in the model are standard partial regression coefficients. * :p<0.05, ** :p<0.01.
[0064] <Example of calculating the correction value of the sensory evaluation value based on a model> Regarding taste evaluation, which is rated on a continuous scale between 0 and 12, the saltiness evaluation value (y) and the tendency for the aftertaste to linger (α) when eating a sample (dry sausage) can be calculated using the model in Figure 14 using the following formulas.
[0065] y=0.48α-5.7β+127 α=-4.22a+3.59b-17.53c+42.23 Where: y: Actual measured value of saltiness sensory evaluation by panelists (evaluators) α: Value indicating how easily the aftertaste lingers β: High taste rating a: Insomnia score b: Physical fatigue score c: saliva amount It is.
[0066] The corrected value (Y=68.3) of the sensory evaluation of the saltiness of dry sausage by panelist A (insomnia score a=7), who showed a tendency to insomnia, was calculated by removing the effect of insomnia from the measured value (y=59), as shown below. Note that panelist A was not suspected of being fatigued, so only the effect of insomnia was corrected.
[0067] Y=0.48α-5.7β+127+0.48(α'-α) Y = y + 0.48 (α'-α) =y+0.48(-4.22a'+4.2a) =59+0.48x-4.22(2.4-7)≒68.3 (where a≧6) Where: Y: Panelist A's sensory evaluation correction value of saltiness α': Aftertaste lingering score for non-insomniacs a': Average insomnia score of non-insomniacs It is.
[0068] Next, for the saltiness evaluation score (y=55) of panelist B who exhibited insomnia and fatigue (insomnia score a=10, fatigue score b”=16, physical fatigue score b=12), the corrected value (corrected value: Y=63.0) that removes the effects of insomnia and fatigue is calculated as follows: Y=0.48α-5.7β+127+0.48(α'-α) Y = y + 0.48 (α'-α) =y+0.48{(-4.22a'+4.22a)+(3.59b'-3.59b)} =55+0.48x{-4.22(2.4-10)+3.59(7.7-12)} =55+0.48x(32.1-15.4)≒63.0 (where a≧6, b”≧16) Where: Y: Panelist B's sensory evaluation correction value of saltiness α': Aftertaste lingering score for non-insomniacs a': Average insomnia score of non-insomniacs b': Average physical fatigue score of non-fatigued individuals b”: Fatigue score of panelist B It is. [Explanation of symbols]
[0069] 10 Data Processing Section 11 Sensory evaluation value acquisition unit 12 Time information acquisition section 13 Health evaluation value acquisition unit 14 Estimation Model Creation Department 15 Correction value calculation section 20 Auxiliary storage 21 Sensory evaluation data 22 Time information data 23 Health evaluation data 24 Estimation model 25 Correction value data 29 Sensory evaluation value correction program 31 Input section 32 Display section 33 Communication interface section (communication I / F section) 37 Server equipment 39 Network 71-75 Input dialog box for taste testing 81,82 Input dialog box 83 Output Dialog Box 97 Server equipment (cloud server) 98 reviewers 99 Food and drink 100 Sensory evaluation value correction device 198 Taste Test Evaluators 199 Food and drink for taste testing
Claims
1. A step of obtaining a sensory evaluation value regarding taste by an evaluator; obtaining a health evaluation value relating to the health condition of the assessor; calculating a correction value of the sensory evaluation value based on an estimation model including a correlation between a health evaluation value and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population, the sensory evaluation value, and the health evaluation value; A sensory evaluation value correction method comprising:
2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the sensory evaluation value related to taste includes a sensory evaluation value related to at least one selected from the group consisting of taste intensity, taste preference, taste aftertaste, taste detection ability, taste recognition ability, and taste evaluation.
3. The method of claim 1 , wherein the health condition comprises at least one selected from the group consisting of fatigue, insomnia, and physical and mental health conditions.
4. The estimation model is A first correlation representing a correlation between an insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value related to a taste aftertaste; A second correlation representing a correlation between the insomnia score and the sensory evaluation value regarding taste preference; and A third correlation representing a correlation between the insomnia score and a sensory evaluation value related to taste evaluation; The method of claim 1 , comprising at least one of:
5. The method further includes a step of acquiring time information when the sensory evaluation is performed by the evaluator, The estimation model further includes a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste in a human population and a sensory evaluation value related to taste, The method according to claim 1 , wherein the step of calculating the correction value calculates the correction value of the sensory evaluation value further based on the time information of the evaluator.
6. The estimation model is A fourth correlation expressing a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste and a sensory evaluation value regarding taste intensity; A fifth correlation represents a correlation between the circadian rhythm of taste and a sensory evaluation value related to taste recognition ability; The method of claim 5 , comprising at least one of:
7. The method according to claim 1 , wherein the estimation model includes an association between a circadian rhythm of taste, a health evaluation value, and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population.
8. A step of obtaining a sensory evaluation value regarding the taste of the food or drink by an evaluator; A step of correcting the sensory evaluation value related to the taste of the food or drink based on the sensory evaluation value correction method according to claim 1; A method for sensory evaluation of food and beverages, comprising:
9. a sensory evaluation value acquisition means for acquiring a sensory evaluation value regarding taste by an evaluator; a health evaluation value acquisition means for acquiring a health evaluation value related to the health condition of the assessor; a correction value calculation means for calculating a correction value of the sensory evaluation value based on an estimation model including a correlation between a health evaluation value and a sensory evaluation value related to taste in a human population, the sensory evaluation value, and the health evaluation value; A sensory evaluation value correction device comprising:
10. A program for causing a computer to execute each step of the method according to any one of claims 1 to 8.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Food product evaluation device and food product evaluation method
JP2021032770A
