Event scenario prediction system, event scenario prediction method, and program

The event scenario prediction system addresses the challenge of predicting plant event progression by integrating real-time equipment failure assessment and PRA recalculation, ensuring effective countermeasures against unexpected abnormalities.

JP7584356B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-15MITSUBISHI HEAVY IND LTD
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021090843
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-05-31
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
2041-05-31

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing systems fail to accurately predict the progression of events in a plant operation, leading to ineffective countermeasures against unexpected abnormalities and equipment failures.

Method used

An event scenario prediction system that includes equipment failure information acquisition, initiating event acquisition, PRA probability calculation, and real-time recalculation of scenario probabilities based on plant parameters and cut sets, enabling rapid assessment of changing plant conditions.

Benefits of technology

Enables accurate prediction of event scenarios, allowing for timely and effective countermeasures to minimize the impact of abnormalities and equipment failures, even in dynamically changing situations.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007584356000002
    Figure 0007584356000002
  • Figure 0007584356000003
    Figure 0007584356000003
  • Figure 0007584356000004
    Figure 0007584356000004
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a system that recalculates the risk of future event scenarios according to plant conditions.SOLUTION: An event scenario prediction system includes: an equipment failure information acquisition unit that acquires failure information on equipment in a plant; an initiating event acquisition unit that acquires information on initiating events occurring in the plant; a PRA probability acquisition unit that acquires, for one or more scenarios that show a pattern of event development when the initiating event occurs, an occurrence probability of the scenario based on PRA design information; and a risk recalculation unit that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information on the equipment and the cut-set of the scenario included in the PRA design information.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present disclosure relates to an event scenario prediction system, an event scenario prediction method, and a program for predicting an event scenario regarding an event that occurs in a plant. [Background technology]

[0002] When an abnormality occurs during plant operation, it is necessary to correctly grasp the progression of the event and deal with it in order to minimize its impact. For example, when it is predicted that event 1, which causes large damage, and event 2, which causes small damage, will occur with equal probability, it is possible to prioritize measures for event 1, which causes large damage. Patent Document 1 provides a system that, when an abnormality is detected during plant operation, predicts an abnormality that will occur at a future point in time and outputs information for dealing with the abnormality (Patent Document 1). However, unexpected abnormalities may occur during plant operation, and even if measures anticipated in advance are taken, there is a possibility that the measures will fail. In addition, depending on changes in the situation, such as unexpected equipment failure, the events that occur thereafter may change. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] Patent No. 6812312 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] In order to minimize the impact of an abnormality that does occur, it is necessary to accurately grasp the probability of occurrence of event scenarios that indicate the subsequent progression of the event, in accordance with the situation that is constantly changing.

[0005] The present disclosure provides an event scenario prediction system, an event scenario prediction method, and a program that can solve the above-mentioned problems. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] The event scenario prediction system of the present disclosure includes an equipment failure information acquisition unit that acquires failure information of equipment equipped in a plant, an initiating event acquisition unit that acquires information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant, a PRA probability acquisition unit that acquires the occurrence probability of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of event progression when the initiating event occurs, based on PRA design information, and a risk recalculation unit that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the equipment failure information and a cut set of the scenario included in the PRA design information. The plant has a data acquisition unit that acquires parameters including process values ​​and control signals of the plant, and an equipment failure estimation unit that estimates a failure of the equipment from the parameters acquired by the data acquisition unit, and when the equipment failure estimation unit can estimate an operating state of the equipment related to the parameter based on the parameter, it determines whether the equipment is in a desired operating state based on the parameter, and when it estimates that the equipment is not in the desired operating state, it estimates that the equipment is faulty, and when it cannot determine the operating state of the equipment, it determines whether the function of the system of the plant is being maintained based on the parameter, and when it is not being maintained, it estimates that all of the equipment included in the system is faulty, and an equipment failure information acquisition unit acquires information on the failure of the equipment estimated by the equipment failure estimation unit, and the risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the cut set related to the equipment estimated to be faulty.

[0007] The event scenario prediction method of the present disclosure includes: A step of acquiring parameters including process values ​​and control signals of a plant, a step of estimating a fault of a device included in the plant from the parameters acquired in the step of acquiring, and a step of estimating the fault of the device included in the plant. The method includes the steps of: acquiring information on equipment failures; acquiring information on initiating events that have occurred in the plant; acquiring the occurrence probability of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of progression of events when the initiating event occurs, based on PRA design information; and recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the equipment failure information and a cut set of the scenario included in the PRA design information. In the step of estimating a failure, if the operating state of the equipment related to the parameter can be estimated based on the parameter, it is determined whether the equipment is in a desired operating state based on the parameter, and if it is estimated that the equipment is not in the desired operating state, it is estimated that the equipment is faulty. If the operating state of the equipment cannot be determined, it is determined based on the parameter whether the function of the plant's system is being maintained, and if it is not being maintained, it is estimated that all of the equipment included in the system is faulty. In the step of acquiring equipment fault information, information on the failure of the equipment estimated in the step of estimating a failure is acquired, and in the step of recalculating, the probability of occurrence of the scenario is recalculated based on the cut set related to the equipment estimated to be faulty.

[0008] The program of the present disclosure is provided to a computer. A step of acquiring parameters including process values ​​and control signals of a plant, a step of estimating a fault of a device included in the plant from the parameters acquired in the step of acquiring, and a step of estimating the fault of the device included in the plant. A step of acquiring equipment failure information, a step of acquiring information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant, a step of acquiring the occurrence probability of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on PRA design information, and a step of recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the equipment failure information and a cut set of the scenario included in the PRA design information; In the step of estimating a failure, if an operating state of the equipment related to the parameter can be estimated based on the parameter, it is determined whether or not the equipment is in a desired operating state based on the parameter, and if it is estimated that the equipment is not in the desired operating state, it is estimated that the equipment is faulty. If the operating state of the equipment cannot be determined, it is determined whether or not a function of the system of the plant can be maintained based on the parameter, and if it is not maintained, it is estimated that all of the equipment included in the system is faulty. In the step of acquiring equipment fault information, information on the failure of the equipment estimated in the step of estimating the failure is acquired, and in the step of recalculating, a process of recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the cut set related to the equipment estimated to be faulty. Execute the command. Effect of the Invention

[0009] According to the above-described evaluation method, event scenario prediction system, event scenario prediction method, and program, it is possible to accurately predict the occurrence probability of an event scenario that indicates the subsequent development of an event, in accordance with a situation that changes from moment to moment. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a configuration diagram illustrating an example of an event scenario prediction system according to an embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 11 is a diagram illustrating recalculation of the occurrence probability of an event scenario according to the embodiment. [Diagram 3] 10 is a flowchart illustrating an example of an operation of the prediction system according to the embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a first diagram showing an example of a driving assistance screen according to the embodiment. [Diagram 5] FIG. 2 is a second diagram showing an example of a driving assistance screen according to the embodiment. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a third diagram showing an example of a driving assistance screen according to the embodiment. [Figure 7] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of an event scenario prediction system according to an embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0011] <Embodiment> Hereinafter, an event scenario prediction system according to the present disclosure will be described with reference to FIGS. (System Configuration) 1 is a configuration diagram showing an example of an event scenario prediction system 10 according to an embodiment. The event scenario prediction system 10 calculates the latest occurrence probability of an accident scenario according to the situation of the plant 1 based on, for example, design information of a Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) for a monitored plant 1 (not shown), such as a nuclear plant, failure information of equipment included in the plant 1, and a causative event of an accident that occurred in the plant 1. The event scenario prediction system 10 includes a data acquisition unit 11, an equipment failure estimation unit 12, a causative event acquisition unit 13, a PRA probability calculation unit 14, a storage unit 15, a display control unit 16, and an input unit 17.

[0012] The data acquisition unit 11 acquires process values ​​such as pressure, temperature, flow rate, etc. measured in the plant 1, control signals indicating the operating state of the plant 1, status signals indicating the operation and state of equipment such as pumps and valves equipped in the plant 1, and fault signals output from equipment when the equipment fails.

[0013] The equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates a failure of an equipment or a group of equipment in the plant 1 based on the process values, control signals, etc. acquired by the data acquisition unit 11. For example, if the control signal indicates that the operating state of the plant is "State 1", and it is decided that valve 1 is to be controlled to "closed" in "State 1", and if a state signal indicating the opening degree of valve 1 indicates that valve 1 is "open", the equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates that valve 1 is at fault (direct failure estimation for each equipment). Alternatively, in a system 1 including a pump 1, a valve 1, and a flowmeter 1, if the flow rate of a fluid flowing through the system 1 when the plant 1 is in "State 1" is X(m 3 / sec), and a status signal indicating the operating status of pump 1 and valve 1 cannot be obtained or the operating status of pump 1 and valve 1 cannot be specified from the status signal, and the flow rate measured by flowmeter 1 is, for example, 0 (m 3 / sec), the equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates that pump 1 and valve 1 of system 1 are suspected to be faulty equipment (indirect failure estimation for each equipment group). For example, in the calculation of the cut set described below, pump 1 and valve 1 are treated as having a failure. Furthermore, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates a failure of equipment 1 based on a failure signal that the data acquisition unit 11 indicates a failure of equipment 1.

[0014] The initiating event acquisition unit 13 acquires information on the initiating event that was the origin of the accident that occurred in the plant 1.

[0015] The PRA probability calculation unit 14 calculates the occurrence probability of accident scenarios that are considered in the design based on the PRA design information from the equipment failure information and the initiating event information. More specifically, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 sets the (initial) occurrence probability of the accident scenario based on the PRA design information for one or more accident scenarios that indicate the pattern of accident progression when the initiating event occurs. In addition, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 recalculates the occurrence probability of each accident scenario based on the equipment failure estimated by the equipment failure estimation unit 12 after the initiating event occurs and the cut set of the accident scenario included in the PRA design information. The PRA design information is information on the fault tree and event tree obtained by risk analysis of the plant 1. The accident scenario is various event progression patterns until the final event is reached in the event tree for a certain initiating event. The cut set is a combination of one or more base events (such as equipment failure) when each accident scenario occurs.

[0016] The memory unit 15 stores various information such as design information of the PRA of the plant 1. The display control unit 16 outputs a driving support screen displaying accident scenarios, their occurrence probabilities, and countermeasures for dealing with each accident scenario to the display device 20. The driving support screen displays information such as the occurrence probability of the event scenario, the initiating event, equipment failure information, and countermeasures. The driving support screen will be described later with reference to Figs. 4 to 6.

[0017] The input unit 17 is configured using input devices such as a keyboard, a mouse, a touch panel, buttons, etc. The input unit 17 accepts operations and information input by a user to the event scenario prediction system 10. The input unit 17 outputs the contents of the accepted input to the display control unit 16, etc.

[0018] (Recalculation of occurrence probability) FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating recalculation of the occurrence probability of an event scenario according to the embodiment. An example of an event tree 100 included in the design information of the PRA is shown in the upper and lower parts of FIG. 2. The event tree 100 models the progression of events that occur in the plant 1 after the occurrence of "accident K" as an initiating event. The headings of the event tree 100 are the initiating event (accident K) and mitigation measures L, M, and N. The mitigation measures L to N indicate equipment and operations that mitigate the progression of events that occur starting from accident K. If the mitigation measures are successful, the progression of the event can be avoided or suppressed, and if they fail, the event progresses to a severe accident (e.g., core damage). For example, in the case of a nuclear power plant, when an accident occurs, core damage can be prevented or may result depending on whether the subsequent mitigation measures L to N are successful. In the event tree 100, at the branching points of the mitigation measures L to N, success is represented by a horizontal line, and failure is represented by a vertical line. As shown in the figure, accident scenarios 1 to 4 are determined by the combination of success and failure of the mitigation measures L, M, and N. Accident scenario 1 is a scenario in which mitigation measures L and M are successful, accident scenario 2 is a scenario in which mitigation measure M fails after mitigation measure L is successful, accident scenario 3 is a scenario in which mitigation measure N succeeds after mitigation measure L fails, and accident scenario 4 is a scenario in which mitigation measures L and N fail. Of these, accident scenarios 1 and 3 can avoid core damage, while accident scenarios 2 and 4 will result in core damage.

[0019] In PRA (Probabilistic Risk Assessment), the probability of failure of the necessary mitigation functions is assigned to the behavior of plant 1 when an accident occurs, and the probability of a serious accident is evaluated. In the example of Figure 2, mitigation measures L, M, and N are considered when accident K occurs. In order to prevent a serious accident, the success of mitigation measures L and M, or the success of mitigation measure N if mitigation measure L fails, are necessary. The event tree 100 is constructed by analyzing what mitigation measures should be taken and how events will progress if the mitigation measures fail, based on the behavior of plant 1 previously evaluated by plant design and simulation. Furthermore, a fault tree is constructed that systematically represents the failure factors of the mitigation measures in order to evaluate the failure probability of each mitigation measure. According to the constructed event tree and fault tree, the risk (occurrence probability) of the accident scenario leading to a serious accident is calculated. The risk of an accident scenario is the accumulation of the probability of the combination of failure events (= cut set) that leads to that accident scenario. Q シナリオの発生確率 Let Q be the risk of accident scenario Q. カットセットi If is the occurrence probability of cut set i leading to accident scenario Q and n is the number of cut sets, the risk of accident scenario Q can be calculated using the following equation (1).

[0020]

number

[0021] For example, for "Pump A," "Valve B," "Valve C," "Tank A," and "Tank E," which are related to the occurrence of Accident Scenario 2, accident scenario 2 will occur if, for example, failures of Pump A, Valve B, and Tank A occur, or failures of Pump A, Valve C, and Tank E occur. In this case, "failure of Pump A, Valve B, and Tank A" and "failure of Pump A, Valve C, and Tank E" are cut sets for Accident Scenario 2. In addition, "failure of Pump A" and "failure of Valve B," which make up the cut sets, are base events. The cut sets are expressed by fault trees for each mitigation measure L to N, and the failure probability of the equipment that makes up each cut set (probability of occurrence of base events) is also given as design information for the PRA. Then, all cut sets in which mitigation measure L succeeds and mitigation measure M fails are extracted from the fault trees of mitigation measure L and mitigation measure M, the occurrence probability of the extracted cut sets is calculated from the occurrence probability of equipment failure, and these are summed up to calculate the probability that mitigation measure L succeeds and mitigation measure M fails. The occurrence probabilities of accident scenarios 1 to 4 calculated in advance based on the PRA design information are registered in the storage unit 15. Graph 101 in Fig. 2 shows the occurrence probabilities of accident scenarios 2 and 4 in the initial state (before accident K occurs) as risk values.

[0022] When accident K actually occurs, equipment failure may occur as the event progresses. For example, suppose that pump E related to mitigation measure L fails after the occurrence of the initiating event. Then, the occurrence probability of the accident scenario including the failure of pump E in the cut set changes. For example, in the case of the example of FIG. 2, the occurrence probability of pump E failure in the cut set of accident scenario 4 becomes "1", so the occurrence probability of the cut set including the failure of pump E increases compared to the initial state. The PRA probability calculation unit 14 sets the occurrence probability of pump E failure in the cut set including the pump E failure to "1" and recalculates the occurrence probability of each accident scenario by formula (1). For example, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 recalculates the probability of failure of mitigation measure L and failure of mitigation measure N for accident scenario 4, assuming that pump E failure has occurred. Specifically, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 recalculates the risk of accident scenario 4 as follows.

[0023] (1) The occurrence probability of accident scenarios 2 and 4 of core damage in the initial state and the occurrence probability of the cut sets that cause each accident scenario are calculated in advance and recorded in the memory unit 15. (2) An accident occurs, and at the same time, pump E, which is one of the devices required to achieve mitigation measure L, breaks down. Then, equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates that pump E has broken down based on process values ​​and the like. (3) The PRA probability calculation unit 14 recalculates the occurrence probability of each cut set by setting the occurrence probability of pump E failure to 1. This increases the probability of the cut set having pump E failure included in accident scenario 4. (4) The PRA probability calculation unit 14 uses the occurrence probability of the recalculated cut set to recalculate the occurrence probability of accident scenario 4. This increases the risk of accident scenario 4, and as a result, it is extracted as a scenario that is significant in terms of risk.

[0024] The occurrence probability of accident scenario 4 after the occurrence of a failure of pump E is shown as a risk value in graph 102 in the lower part of Fig. 2. In this manner, in this embodiment, the occurrence probability of each cut set calculated in advance is reflected in the estimated results of equipment failure obtained by monitoring the actual plant state, and the occurrence probability is recalculated, so that the risk value of the latest accident scenario according to the plant state can be reevaluated, and accident scenarios that are significant in terms of important risks in the future can be grasped.

[0025] If it is estimated by monitoring the plant status that Pump E is not at fault, it is possible to recalculate the probability of Accident Scenario 4 by inputting 0 as the failure probability of Pump E in the cut set for Accident Scenario 4. In this case, the risk of Accident Scenario 4 is reduced.

[0026] (operation) FIG. 3 shows a flowchart of a process for recalculating the occurrence probability of an accident scenario and displaying a driving support screen based on the recalculation result according to the embodiment. As a premise, design information of the PRA is recorded in the storage unit 15. For example, an event tree for each initiating event, cut sets for each accident scenario defined by each event tree, the occurrence probability (risk) of each accident scenario and the design value of the occurrence probability of each cut set, and the occurrence probability of the base event (e.g., the failure probability of pump E) constituting each cut set are recorded in the storage unit 15. In addition, the storage unit 15 records a system diagram of the plant 1 and design information of the operating state of each device for each operating state of the plant 1.

[0027] First, assume that an initiating event that may lead to a serious accident occurs in the plant 1. Then, the initiating event acquisition unit 13 acquires information on the initiating event (step S11). The initiating event information may be input by a user to the event scenario prediction system 10, or a monitoring system of the plant 1 may detect the occurrence of an abnormality and input information on the detected abnormality to the event scenario prediction system 10. The initiating event acquisition unit 13 outputs the initiating event information to the PRA probability calculation unit 14. In addition, the initiating event acquisition unit 13 records the initiating event information in the storage unit 15.

[0028] In parallel with this, the data acquisition unit 11 acquires process values, control signals, status signals, etc. (step S12). Next, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates equipment failure based on the process values, etc. (step S13). For example, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 determines the desired operating state of the equipment from the control signal (opening / closing of a valve, starting / stopping of a pump, etc.) and compares the operating state of the equipment indicated by the status signal. If the desired operating state is not achieved, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates that the equipment is broken. Also, for example, for equipment whose operating state cannot be acquired, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 determines whether the system as a whole is maintaining its function from the process value, and if not, identifies the equipment group included in the system based on the system diagram. The equipment failure estimation unit 12 estimates that all of the identified equipment group are broken. The equipment failure estimation unit 12 outputs information on the equipment estimated to be broken to the PRA probability calculation unit 14. Also, the equipment failure estimation unit 12 records information on the equipment estimated to be broken in the storage unit 15.

[0029] Next, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 recalculates the occurrence probability of the accident scenario (step S14). The PRA probability calculation unit 14 reads out an event tree corresponding to the initiating event from the storage unit 15. For the accident scenario shown in the read out event tree and the cut set that causes the accident scenario, the PRA probability calculation unit 14 sets the failure probability of the equipment whose failure is estimated to be "1" and recalculates the occurrence probability of the cut set and accident scenario related to the equipment. In addition, for example, while taking measures using mitigation measures L to N, for example, after the mitigation measure L is successful, the failure probability of the equipment related only to the mitigation measure L is set to "0" and the occurrence probability of the cut set and accident scenario is recalculated. The PRA probability calculation unit 14 records the occurrence probability of each accident scenario in the storage unit 15.

[0030] Next, the display control unit 16 outputs and updates the driving support screen (step S15). Here, reference is made to Figs. 4 to 6. Figs. 4 to 6 are first to third diagrams showing an example of a driving support screen according to an embodiment, respectively. The display control unit 16 generates a driving support screen 200 exemplified in Figs. 4 to 6, and outputs it to the display device 20. In addition, the display control unit 16 updates the driving support screen 200 based on a user operation input via the input unit 17.

[0031] (Driving assistance screen) First, refer to FIG. 4. In the area 201 of the driving support screen 200, a causative event is displayed. In the area 202, mitigation measures of the event tree corresponding to the causative event are displayed in a tree format. In the upper section 2022 of each block 2021, the content and name of the mitigation measure (e.g., “Countermeasure 1”) is displayed, in the left column 2023 of the lower section, the presence or absence of a failure of the equipment related to the mitigation measure (e.g., “valve”) is displayed as an icon in different colors, in the center column 2024 of the lower section, human errors that should be noted when implementing the mitigation measure are displayed, and in the right column 2025 of the lower section, the grace period until the final time when the mitigation measure must be implemented is displayed. The lines branching out to the right or down from the block 2021 respectively represent the success or failure of the procedure corresponding to the block 2021. Moreover, the block 2021 of the necessary mitigation measure is displayed on the line branching out to the right, regardless of success or failure. By selecting the arrow feather 2026 on the line branching out downward from the block 2021, it is possible to expand and display the tree beyond that point, or collapse and omit the display. When the tree display is omitted, the presence or absence of core damage in the omitted later accident scenario is displayed within the arrow 2026. OK indicates no core damage, and CD indicates that core damage is present. When both OK and CD are written within the arrow 2026, it indicates that both an OK scenario and a CD scenario exist among the omitted later accident scenarios.

[0032] In addition, the No. column 2027 displays the identification number of the accident scenario, and the identification column 2028 displays the presence or absence of core damage. In addition, the risk column 2029 displays the latest occurrence probability of each accident scenario calculated by the PRA probability calculation unit 14, and the graph column 202A displays the magnitude of the occurrence probability of each accident scenario (relative value between scenarios) in a bar graph. For example, immediately after the occurrence of an initiating event or when no equipment failure is detected, the risk column 2029 displays the design value (initial value) of the occurrence probability obtained by the PRA design. In addition, when an equipment failure or the like occurs after the occurrence of an initiating event, the risk column 2029 displays the occurrence probability of the accident scenario recalculated based on the conditional probability of the equipment failure. This makes it possible to visually recognize the latest risk according to the state of the plant, which changes from moment to moment. The display control unit 16 may display the values ​​of the columns 2027 to 202A related to no core damage (OK) and the values ​​of the columns 2027 to 202A related to core damage (CD) in different colors (for example, white and yellow, respectively). Furthermore, the display control unit 16 may display the values ​​in the columns 2027-202A relating to the accident scenario with the largest risk value in a manner different from the others (for example, by displaying them in red, or by underlining them in Figs. 4-5).

[0033] In addition, the area 203 displays an event selection button 2031, a one move ahead display button 2032, a two move ahead display button 2033, a full expansion display button 2034, and an image output button 2035. The user can switch the display contents of the countermeasures displayed in the area 202 by pressing the buttons 2031 to 2035 using the input unit 17. For example, when the user presses the event selection button 2031, the accident scenario to be displayed in the tree can be switched. There are two types of modes: a mode for automatically displaying the accident scenario and mitigation measures connected to the causative event automatically determined by another system, and a mode for manually switching the accident scenario and mitigation measures to be displayed. In the manual mode, the user can display a tree of mitigation measures for any accident scenario. In addition, when the user presses the one move ahead display button 2032, the display control unit 16 expands the arrow feathers 2026 of the tree displayed in the area 202 only for the mitigation measures one move ahead, and omits the display of the mitigation measures for two moves ahead and beyond. Furthermore, when the user presses the 2 move ahead display button 2033, the display control unit 16 displays the tree displayed in the area 202 by expanding the arrow feathers 2026 only for the mitigation measures one move ahead and the mitigation measures two moves ahead, and omits the display of the mitigation measures thereafter. Furthermore, when the user presses the full expansion display button 2034, the display control unit 16 displays the tree displayed in the area 202 in a fully expanded state. This allows the user to display mitigation measures only to the extent necessary, thereby improving convenience. Furthermore, when the user presses the image output button 2035, an image of the tree in a fully expanded state can be output as an image file.

[0034] Next, FIG. 5 will be referred to. When the user selects the block 2021 of "Countermeasure 1", the success or failure of the countermeasure can be registered (small window 300 described later). When the user registers the success of "Countermeasure 1", the display control unit 16 changes the color of the block 2021 of "Countermeasure 1" to, for example, blue and displays it. This makes it possible to manage the progress and results (success or failure) of the mitigation measures. Also, when the success of "Countermeasure 1" is registered, since a subsequent mitigation measure is not necessary in the case where "Countermeasure 1" fails, the display control unit 16 displays only the subsequent tree in the case where "Countermeasure 1" is successful. This makes it possible to prevent unnecessary information from being displayed. The display control unit 16 may automatically determine the success or failure of the countermeasure using process values ​​acquired by the data acquisition unit 11, etc.

[0035] If "Action 1" is successful but "Action 2" fails, the user selects block 2021 for "Action 2". Then, the display control unit 16 displays a small window 300. The user selects failure and presses the OK button. Then, the display control unit 16 changes the color of block 2021 for "Action 2" to, for example, red and displays it. Furthermore, when the failure of "Action 2" is registered, no subsequent mitigation measures are necessary if "Action 2" is successful, so the display control unit 16 displays only the subsequent tree when "Action 2" fails.

[0036] Also, when the user presses any one of the left column 2023, the center column 2024, and the right column 2025 in the lower part of the block 2021, the display control unit 16 displays a detailed screen 400 of the device status. FIG. 6 shows an example of the detailed screen 400 when the left column 2023 of Countermeasure 3 is pressed. The detailed screen 400 is provided with one or more status display columns 401, and the status of the device is displayed by system related to Countermeasure 3. For example, in the example of FIG. 6, the presence or absence of failures is displayed for the power system, the water source system, the control air system, and other devices. For example, in the case of the power system, it is shown that the emergency power supply 1 is broken and will take about 5 minutes to recover, and the power system as a whole is in a minor failure status. In the case of the water source system, it is shown that a water level abnormality has been detected in the tank 1, and recovery is not expected, and the water source system as a whole is in a major failure status. Of these pieces of information, the time required for recovery is acquired by the display control unit 16 from a system (not shown) that manages the operating state of the equipment, which is different from the event scenario prediction system 10 of this embodiment, and displayed. Information on abnormalities, such as a failure of the emergency power supply 1 and an abnormal water level in the tank 1, may be acquired from a system that manages the operating state of the equipment in a similar manner and displayed, or may be displayed based on the estimation result of the equipment failure estimation unit 12. In addition, the time information display field 403 of the details screen 400 displays the grace period for action 3. The grace period for action 3 is recorded in advance in the storage unit 15 together with the design information of the PRA. By referring to the details screen 400, the user can grasp the information on the equipment failure that is an obstacle to the execution of action 3, the time required for recovery, and the grace period for action 3, and can determine whether or not action 3 can be executed.

[0037] The event scenario prediction system 10 repeatedly executes the processes of steps S11 to S15 until the monitoring of the plant is completed (step S16; No). This allows the user to grasp the fluctuation of the risk value after the occurrence of an accident in the plant 1 in real time by referring to the operation support screen 200.

[0038] (effect) In plant operation, if a large-scale disaster occurs and an unexpected equipment failure occurs, the response measures assumed at the time of design may fail. In addition, in the case of an unexpected equipment failure or simultaneous failure of multiple equipment, it is difficult to consider a recovery plan on the spot. In contrast, according to this embodiment, the plant state is monitored based on real-time process values ​​obtained from the plant 1, and the occurrence probability of an accident scenario reflecting the equipment failure is quickly calculated and displayed, so that even if an unexpected equipment failure occurs, the scenario with the highest risk under the circumstances can be grasped. In addition, by displaying the occurrence probability of each accident scenario, the user can quantitatively grasp the risk of each accident scenario. In addition, by displaying the occurrence probability of each accident scenario, the response measures (mitigation measures) for dealing with the accident scenario and the status of the systems and equipment required to execute the response measures, the user can understand what kind of response should be made according to the situation even when an unexpected accident occurs. In addition, by registering the success or failure of the event response measures and the progress status on the operation support screen 200, progress management and recovery plan consideration can be performed.

[0039] In addition, in the calculation of the occurrence probability of the accident scenario, the conditional probability is calculated by setting the occurrence probability of the base event that actually occurred among the pre-designed cut sets and the occurrence probabilities of the base events that constitute the cut sets to 1 or 0. This makes it possible to speed up the recalculation of the occurrence probability. For example, the recalculation of the occurrence probability of the accident scenario can be performed by giving a pump E failure as a boundary condition in a general calculation tool of PRA. However, the method using the general calculation tool has a large calculation load when considering performing calculations in real time according to the behavior of the plant. In this embodiment, the occurrence probability of the accident scenario can be quickly recalculated by simply changing the occurrence probabilities of some of the base events that constitute each cut set using the cut sets obtained in advance and recalculating.

[0040] FIG. 7 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of the event scenario prediction system according to the embodiment. The computer 900 includes a CPU 901 , a main memory device 902 , an auxiliary memory device 903 , an input / output interface 904 , and a communication interface 905 . The above-mentioned event scenario prediction system 10 is implemented in a computer 900. Each of the above-mentioned functions is stored in the auxiliary storage device 903 in the form of a program. The CPU 901 reads the program from the auxiliary storage device 903, loads it in the main storage device 902, and executes the above-mentioned processing in accordance with the program. The CPU 901 also reserves a storage area in the main storage device 902 in accordance with the program. The CPU 901 also reserves a storage area in the auxiliary storage device 903 for storing data being processed in accordance with the program.

[0041] In addition, a program for realizing all or part of the functions of the event scenario prediction system 10 may be recorded in a computer-readable recording medium, and the program recorded in the recording medium may be read into a computer system and executed to perform processing by each functional unit. The term "computer system" as used herein includes hardware such as an OS and peripheral devices. In addition, if a WWW system is used, the term "computer system" also includes a homepage providing environment (or display environment). In addition, the term "computer-readable recording medium" refers to a portable medium such as a CD, DVD, or USB, and a storage device such as a hard disk built into a computer system. In addition, if the program is distributed to the computer 900 through a communication line, the computer 900 that receives the program may deploy the program in the main storage device 902 and execute the above processing. In addition, the above program may be for realizing part of the above-mentioned functions, and may further be capable of realizing the above-mentioned functions in combination with a program already recorded in the computer system.

[0042] As described above, several embodiments according to the present disclosure have been described, but all of these embodiments are presented as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. These embodiments can be implemented in various other forms, and various omissions, substitutions, and modifications can be made without departing from the gist of the invention. These embodiments and their modifications are included in the scope of the invention and its equivalents as described in the claims, as well as in the scope and gist of the invention.

[0043] <Additional Notes> The event scenario prediction system 10, the event scenario prediction method, and the program described in each embodiment can be understood, for example, as follows.

[0044] (1) The event scenario prediction system according to the first aspect includes an equipment failure information acquisition unit (equipment failure estimation unit 12) that acquires failure information of equipment equipped in a plant, an initiating event acquisition unit 13 that acquires information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant, a PRA probability acquisition unit (PRA probability calculation unit 14) that acquires the occurrence probability of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of event progression when the initiating event occurs, based on PRA (Probabilistic Risk Assessment) design information, and a risk recalculation unit (PRA probability calculation unit 14) that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the equipment failure information and a cut set of the scenario included in the PRA design information. This makes it possible to calculate the occurrence probability of an accident scenario according to changes in the plant situation. By using a cut set obtained in advance, the occurrence probability can be recalculated quickly, so the risk of an accident scenario can be calculated in real time according to changes in the plant situation.

[0045] (2) The event scenario prediction system according to the second aspect is the scenario prediction system of (1), further comprising a data acquisition unit 11 that acquires parameters including process values ​​and control signals of the plant (process values, control signals, status signals, etc.), and an equipment failure estimation unit 12 that estimates an equipment failure from the parameters acquired by the data acquisition unit, and an equipment failure information acquisition unit acquires information on the equipment failure estimated by the equipment failure estimation unit. This makes it possible to estimate failures of equipment or equipment groups necessary for risk calculations and response measures, even in the event of an unexpected disaster or accident.

[0046] (3) A scenario prediction system according to a third aspect is an event scenario prediction system according to (2), wherein the equipment failure estimation unit determines whether the equipment is in a desired operating state based on the parameters, and if it is determined that the equipment is not in the desired operating state, it determines that the equipment is faulty. The risk recalculation unit recalculates the probability of occurrence of the scenario based on the cut set involving the equipment determined to be faulty. This makes it possible to estimate whether or not a device is faulty for each device. By identifying the faulty device, the probability of occurrence of the cut set related to the device fault can be recalculated at high speed, thereby enabling the probability of occurrence of the accident scenario to be recalculated.

[0047] (4) A scenario prediction system according to a fourth aspect is an event scenario prediction system according to (2) to (3), wherein the equipment failure estimation unit determines whether or not the function of the plant system can be maintained based on the parameters, and if the function cannot be maintained, identifies the equipment included in the system as a group of equipment suspected of failure, and the risk recalculation unit recalculates the probability of occurrence of the scenario based on the cut set to which the group of equipment is related. This makes it possible to recalculate the occurrence probability of an accident scenario by estimating a failure of a group of devices and recalculating only the occurrence probability of a cut set related to the failure of the group of devices.

[0048] (5) A scenario prediction system according to a fifth aspect is an event scenario prediction system according to any one of (1) to (4), further comprising a display control unit 16 that outputs a screen (driving assistance screen 200) displaying the scenario, its occurrence probability, and equipment failure information, and the display control unit updates the occurrence probability displayed on the screen when the risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability. This allows the user to grasp the probability of occurrence of the latest accident scenarios in response to changes in the plant state.

[0049] (6) A scenario prediction system according to a sixth aspect is a scenario prediction system according to (5), wherein the display control unit displays on the screen the scenario along with response measures to mitigate the progression of the scenario, response measures to be taken if the measures are successful, and response measures to be taken if the measures are unsuccessful. This allows the user to understand the measures to be taken in response to an event that has occurred in the plant.

[0050] (7) An event scenario prediction system according to a seventh aspect is the event scenario prediction system of (6), wherein the display control unit displays only the next response action and the response actions to be taken when the response action is successful and when the response action is unsuccessful, or displays the response actions beyond that in a switchable manner. By switching between displaying only the necessary range of response actions and displaying all the final response actions, the user can see the response actions to be taken to the extent necessary, thereby improving user convenience.

[0051] (8) An event scenario prediction system according to an eighth aspect is an event scenario prediction system according to (6) to (7), wherein when a response action displayed on the screen is selected, the display control unit displays the status of an equipment related to the response action and the remaining time until the time limit for implementing the response action. This allows the user to determine whether or not the corrective action can be taken.

[0052] (9) The ninth aspect of the event scenario prediction system is an event scenario prediction system according to any one of (6) to (8), wherein the display control unit acquires information indicating whether the response action was successful or unsuccessful, and displays only the possible scenarios according to the information. Possible scenarios change depending on the progression of the event and the success or failure of the corresponding measures. By limiting the display to scenarios that may actually occur, the user's visibility can be improved.

[0053] (10) An event scenario prediction method according to a tenth aspect includes the steps of: acquiring failure information of equipment in a plant (S13); acquiring information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant (S12); acquiring the occurrence probability of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of event progression when the initiating event occurs based on design information of a Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA) (S14); and recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the equipment and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA (S14).

[0054] (11) A program according to an eleventh aspect causes a computer to execute the steps of acquiring failure information of equipment equipped in a plant, acquiring information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant, acquiring the probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios indicating a pattern of event progression when the initiating event occurs based on design information of a Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA), and recalculating the probability of occurrence of the scenario based on the failure information of the equipment and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA. [Explanation of symbols]

[0055] 10. Event Scenario Prediction System 11. Data acquisition section 12...Equipment failure estimation section 13. Initiating event acquisition section 14. PRA Probability Calculation Section 15...Storage section 16 Display control unit 17 Input section 900...Computer 901··CPU 902...Main memory 903...Auxiliary storage device 904 Input / Output Interface 905 Communication Interface

Claims

1. An equipment failure information acquisition unit that acquires failure information of equipment included in the plant; an initiating event acquisition unit that acquires information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant; a probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) probability acquisition unit that acquires a probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on design information of a PRA; A risk recalculation unit that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the device and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA; a data acquisition unit for acquiring parameters including process values ​​and control signals of the plant; an equipment failure inference unit that infers a failure of the equipment from the parameters acquired by the data acquisition unit; having When the equipment failure estimation unit can estimate an operating state of the equipment related to the parameter based on the parameter, the equipment failure estimation unit determines whether or not the equipment is in a desired operating state based on the parameter, and when it estimates that the equipment is not in the desired operating state, estimates that the equipment is broken; When the operating state of the equipment cannot be determined, it is determined whether or not the function of the system of the plant can be maintained based on the parameters, and when the function cannot be maintained, it is assumed that all of the equipment included in the system is broken; The equipment failure information acquisition unit acquires information on the equipment failure estimated by the equipment failure estimation unit, The risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the cut set involving the equipment estimated to be faulty. Event scenario forecasting system.

2. When the operating state of the plant indicates a predetermined first state, and when the operating state of the equipment is in the first state, the state of the equipment indicated by the parameter is not the second state even though the operating state of the plant indicated by the parameter is the first state, the equipment failure estimation unit determines that the equipment is broken, In a system including a plurality of the devices, if the state of each of the devices cannot be estimated from the parameters but the state of the system can be estimated, and it is determined that the state of the system is a predetermined fourth state when the operating state of the plant is a predetermined third state, and if the operating state of the plant indicated by the parameters is the third state but the state of the system indicated by the parameters is not the fourth state, identify all of the devices included in the system as an equipment group suspected of having a malfunction, and determine that all of the devices constituting the identified equipment group are malfunctioning; the risk recalculation unit sets a failure probability of the equipment estimated to be faulty to 1, and sets a failure probability of the equipment estimated to be not faulty to 0, and recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario. The event scenario prediction system according to claim 1 .

3. a display control unit that outputs a screen that displays the scenario, the occurrence probability thereof, and failure information of the device, the display control unit updates the occurrence probability displayed on the screen when the risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability. The event scenario prediction system according to any one of claims 1 to 2.

4. the display control unit displays, on the screen, the scenario, along with a countermeasure for mitigating the progression of the scenario, the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is successful, and the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is unsuccessful. The event scenario prediction system according to claim 3 .

5. The display control unit displays only the next response action and the response action when the response action is successful or when the response action is unsuccessful, or displays the response actions from the next response action onward in a switchable manner. The event scenario prediction system according to claim 4.

6. the display control unit, when the response action displayed on the screen is selected, displays a status of a device related to the response action and a remaining time until a time limit for performing the response action. The event scenario prediction system according to any one of claims 4 to 5.

7. An equipment failure information acquisition unit that acquires failure information of equipment included in the plant; an initiating event acquisition unit that acquires information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant; a probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) probability acquisition unit that acquires a probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on design information of a PRA; A risk recalculation unit that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the device and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA; a display control unit that outputs a screen that displays the scenario, the occurrence probability thereof, and failure information of the device; having the display control unit updates the occurrence probability displayed on the screen when the risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability; displaying on the screen the scenario together with a countermeasure for mitigating the progression of the scenario, and the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is successful and the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is unsuccessful; Displaying only the next response action and the response action when the response action is successful or when the response action is unsuccessful, or displaying the response actions beyond that in a switchable manner; Event scenario forecasting system.

8. An equipment failure information acquisition unit that acquires failure information of equipment included in the plant; an initiating event acquisition unit that acquires information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant; a probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) probability acquisition unit that acquires a probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios that indicate a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on design information of a PRA; A risk recalculation unit that recalculates the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the device and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA; a display control unit that outputs a screen that displays the scenario, the occurrence probability thereof, and failure information of the device; having the display control unit updates the occurrence probability displayed on the screen when the risk recalculation unit recalculates the occurrence probability; displaying on the screen the scenario together with a countermeasure for mitigating the progression of the scenario, and the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is successful and the next countermeasure in the case where the countermeasure is unsuccessful; When the corresponding action displayed on the screen is selected, the status of the device related to the corresponding action and the remaining time until the time limit for performing the corresponding action are displayed. Event scenario forecasting system.

9. the display control unit acquires information indicating whether the response action has been successful or unsuccessful, and displays only the scenarios that may occur according to the information. The event scenario prediction system according to any one of claims 4 to 8.

10. A step of acquiring parameters including process values ​​and control signals of a plant; a step of estimating a fault in a device included in the plant from the parameters acquired in the acquiring step; acquiring failure information of the device estimated in the step of estimating a failure; acquiring information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant; acquiring a probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios indicating a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on design information of a Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA); recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the device and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA; having In the step of estimating a fault, when an operational state of the device related to the parameter can be estimated based on the parameter, it is determined whether or not the device is in a desired operational state based on the parameter, and when it is estimated that the device is not in the desired operational state, it is estimated that the device is faulty; When the operating state of the equipment cannot be determined, it is determined whether or not the function of the system of the plant can be maintained based on the parameters, and when the function cannot be maintained, it is assumed that all of the equipment included in the system is broken; In the step of acquiring equipment failure information, information on the equipment failure estimated in the step of estimating the failure is acquired, In the recalculating step, the occurrence probability of the scenario is recalculated based on the cut set involving the equipment estimated to be faulty. Event scenario forecasting method.

11. On the computer, acquiring parameters including process values ​​and control signals of a plant; a step of estimating a fault in a device included in the plant from the parameters acquired in the acquiring step; acquiring failure information of the device estimated in the step of estimating a failure; acquiring information on an initiating event that has occurred in the plant; acquiring a probability of occurrence of one or more scenarios indicating a pattern of progression of an event when the initiating event occurs, based on design information of a Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA); recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the failure information of the device and a cut set of the scenario included in the design information of the PRA; having In the step of estimating a fault, when an operational state of the device related to the parameter can be estimated based on the parameter, it is determined whether or not the device is in a desired operational state based on the parameter, and when it is estimated that the device is not in the desired operational state, it is estimated that the device is faulty; When the operating state of the equipment cannot be determined, it is determined whether or not the function of the system of the plant can be maintained based on the parameters, and when the function cannot be maintained, it is assumed that all of the equipment included in the system is broken; In the step of acquiring equipment failure information, information on the equipment failure estimated in the step of estimating the failure is acquired, In the recalculating step, a process of recalculating the occurrence probability of the scenario based on the cut set involving the device estimated to be faulty; A program that executes the following.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Systems and methods for optimizing plant operations

    JP2012238308A

  • Plant monitoring device and plant monitoring method

    JP2018036939A

  • Device, method and program for supporting management of emergency activity level

    JP2021076563A

  • Plant support evaluation system and plant support evaluation method

    JP6812312B2