Abnormality determination method, abnormality determination system, and program
By comparing evaluation target data with a determination model and calculating adjustment directions for selected variables, the method addresses the lack of abnormality guidance in existing technologies, enabling effective abnormality management and state restoration in mechanical equipment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021136225
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-08-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-08-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing abnormality determination methods for mechanical equipment using machine learning struggle with insufficient data on abnormal conditions, leading to models that only identify abnormalities without providing guidance on how to return to a normal state.
A method that compares evaluation target data with a determination model created from normal data, calculates the distance for each variable, determines abnormality based on the sum of distances, and outputs adjustment directions for selected variables to reduce abnormality.
Enables not only the identification of abnormalities but also provides guidance on how to return to a normal state by adjusting specific parameters, enhancing the effectiveness of abnormality management in mechanical equipment.
Smart Images

Figure 0007584376000001 
Figure 0007584376000002 
Figure 0007584376000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an abnormality determination method, an abnormality determination system, and a program. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, methods have been proposed for determining abnormalities in machinery and equipment and work using machine learning. When there is sufficient data on normal and abnormal situations, a model that distinguishes between normal and abnormal situations can be constructed by supervised learning. However, since there is generally little data on abnormal situations regarding machinery and equipment and work, models are often constructed by learning data on normal situations (for example, Patent Document 1). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2020-160618 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] It is possible to determine whether an evaluation target is normal or abnormal by using a trained model built using normal data. However, if an evaluation target is determined to be abnormal, it is unclear how to return the evaluation target to a normal state.
[0005] The present disclosure provides an abnormality determination method, an abnormality determination system, and a program that can solve the above problems. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] The anomaly determination method disclosed herein includes a step of comparing a determination model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each of the plurality of variables, and calculating a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data; a step of determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the abnormality degree; a step of calculating a value adjustment direction for reducing the abnormality degree for at least one of the plurality of variables; and a step of outputting the adjustment direction. In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, a predetermined number of the variables are selected in order from the largest distance, and a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variables is calculated as the adjustment direction. In the step of outputting the adjustment direction, the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable are output.
[0007] The anomaly determination system of the present disclosure includes a means for comparing a determination model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each of the plurality of variables, and calculating a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data, a means for determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the abnormality degree, a means for calculating a direction of adjustment of a value for at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the abnormality degree, and a means for outputting the adjustment direction. The adjustment direction calculation means selects a predetermined number of the variables in order from the largest distance, and calculates a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variables as the adjustment direction, and the adjustment direction output means outputs the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each of the selected variables.
[0008] The program disclosed herein includes a step of causing a computer to compare a judgment model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculate a distance between the evaluation target data and the judgment model for each of the plurality of variables, and calculate a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data; a step of determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the abnormality degree; a step of calculating a direction of adjustment of a value for at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the abnormality degree; and a step of outputting the adjustment direction. In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, a predetermined number of the variables are selected in descending order of the distance, and a direction in which the distance is reduced is calculated as the adjustment direction for the selected variables. In the step of outputting the adjustment direction, the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable are output. Execute the command. Effect of the Invention
[0009] According to the above-described abnormality determination method, abnormality determination system, and program, in addition to the result of the abnormality determination, it is possible to obtain information on the cause of the abnormality and information on how to return to a normal state. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0010] [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram showing an example of an abnormality determination system according to an embodiment; [Diagram 2] 1 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a method for constructing a determination model according to an embodiment. [Figure 3A] FIG. 2 is a first diagram showing an example of a determination method according to an embodiment. [Figure 3B] 11A and 11B are diagrams illustrating a method for calculating an abnormality degree and a direction according to an embodiment. [Figure 4A] 1A to 1C are diagrams illustrating a determination method based on a probability density distribution according to an embodiment. [Figure 4B] 1A to 1C are diagrams illustrating a determination method based on reproducibility according to an embodiment. [Diagram 5] 5 is a flowchart illustrating an example of an abnormality determination process according to the embodiment. [Figure 6] 1 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a parameter evaluation method according to an embodiment. [Figure 7] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of the abnormality determination system according to the embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0011] The abnormality determination method of the present disclosure will be described below with reference to FIGS. <Embodiment> (composition) FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing an example of an abnormality determination system according to an embodiment. The abnormality determination system 1 is a system that determines abnormalities in monitored machinery and equipment, work, etc. For example, the abnormality determination system 1 acquires measurement values measured by sensors installed in the machinery and equipment, control signals issued by a control device, and the like, and determines whether or not an abnormality has occurred in the machinery and equipment during operation. Alternatively, the abnormality determination system 1 acquires measurement values measured by sensors of tools and equipment used by workers, or measurement results of work results, and determines whether or not an abnormality has occurred in the work. In addition to such abnormality determination, when the abnormality determination system 1 determines that an abnormality has occurred, it provides guidance information that indicates the cause of the abnormality and a method for improving it.
[0012] The abnormality determination system 1 includes an abnormality determination device 10 and a simulator 20. The abnormality determination device 10 includes a data acquisition unit 11, a setting reception unit 12, a control unit 13, an output unit 14, and a storage unit 15.
[0013] The data acquisition unit 11 acquires learning data used to construct a judgment model for abnormality judgment. The data acquisition unit 11 also acquires evaluation target data that is the subject of abnormality judgment. The learning data and the evaluation target data include a plurality of parameters such as measured values by sensors such as temperature and pressure, control signals such as command values for valve opening and rotation speed, and information on the time when each parameter is measured, commanded, etc.
[0014] The setting reception unit 12 receives settings of normal state sections for the learning data acquired by the data acquisition unit 11. The normal state section is setting information that specifies the range of learning data in normal times, such as a time period when the operating state of the mechanical equipment is normal. The setting reception unit 12 also receives settings such as a threshold value for determining an abnormality. Furthermore, the setting reception unit 12 receives settings regarding whether or not to present a parameter determined to be a cause of an abnormality as guidance information, or whether or not to present the parameter preferentially. For example, the guidance information presents the parameters of the abnormality cause and a method for improving the parameter, but parameters that cannot be operated by the user can be excluded from the presented information. On the other hand, parameters that are effective in returning the state of the mechanical equipment to normal and that can be controlled and operated by the user can be presented preferentially as guidance information (weighting coefficients described later).
[0015] The control unit 13 controls each of the processes of constructing a judgment model, the abnormality judgment, and the output of guidance information. The control unit 13 includes a model construction unit 131, an abnormality judgment unit 132, and a factor evaluation unit 133. The model construction unit 131 learns learning data (normal data) in the normal state section and constructs a determination model. The abnormality determination unit 132 determines whether the mechanical equipment or the work is normal or abnormal based on the determination model and the evaluation target data. When the abnormality determination unit 132 determines that an abnormality has occurred, the factor evaluation unit 133 selects a predetermined number of parameters that have a large influence from among the parameters that caused the abnormality determination, and evaluates how the values of those parameters should be (for example, by increasing or decreasing them) to bring them closer to the normal state.
[0016] The output unit 14 outputs the normal / abnormal determination result obtained by the abnormality determination unit 132. The output unit 14 creates guidance information based on the evaluation result obtained by the factor evaluation unit 133, and outputs the guidance information. The storage unit 15 stores various information such as learning data, a judgment model, and settings of normal state intervals.
[0017] The simulator 20 is a computational model that simulates the operation of the machine equipment to be monitored and work such as welding. For example, when parameters included in the learning data are given, the simulator 20 simulates the operation and work of the machine equipment and outputs a value indicating the state of the machine equipment after a certain period of operation, an evaluation value for the work result, and the like.
[0018] (Building a decision model) FIG. 2 is a flowchart showing an example of a method for constructing a judgment model according to the embodiment. First, the data acquisition unit 11 acquires learning data (step S1) and records the learning data in the storage unit 15. For example, the learning data is time-series data on a plurality of parameters such as temperature, pressure, current, and voltage, and most of the learning data is data on normal conditions. Next, the user sets a normal state section (step S2). The setting reception unit 12 receives the setting of the normal state section and records it in the storage unit 15. For example, if a certain mechanical equipment is operating normally from time t1 to t2, the user sets the time t1 to t2 as a normal state section. Next, the user instructs the abnormality judgment device 10 to construct a judgment model. Then, the model construction unit 131 starts constructing the judgment model. First, the model construction unit 131 extracts learning data belonging to the normal state section (step S3). For example, the model construction unit 131 extracts data of the normal state section from the learning data at time t1 to t2. Next, the model construction unit 131 learns the extracted learning data in normal times and constructs a judgment model (step S4). Most of the parameters that can be collected during operation of the machinery equipment or during actual work are data in normal times. Therefore, a normal state section is set, normal data is extracted from all learning data, and the extracted data is learned to construct a judgment model in which a range of normal values for each parameter is determined. The method of constructing the judgment model is not particularly limited. For example, a range that envelopes the distribution of normal data may be used as the judgment model, or a probability density distribution of data in normal times may be calculated to use the probability density distribution as a judgment model. For example, a probability density distribution (probability density function) for each parameter included in the normal data is calculated and used as the judgment model. Alternatively, a model that performs an abnormality judgment based on the reproducibility of the value of each parameter in data in normal times may be constructed. Specifically, a model that reproduces each parameter of the normal data to be learned (for example, an autoencoder that outputs a similar value when normal data is input) may be constructed, and this model may be used as the judgment model. Alternatively, a judgment model may be constructed by learning the correlation between multiple parameters in normal times.
[0019] Fig. 3A shows an overview of the process of determining an abnormality using a determination model constructed from learning data under normal conditions. The determination model M shown in Fig. 3A is a schematic diagram of a determination model in which normal data is plotted in space and the distribution range is determined as the normal region.
[0020] (Example of a decision model) Point x and point k shown in FIG. 3A are points that conceptually indicate values calculated from a plurality of parameters included in the learning data and the evaluation target data, where point x indicates the evaluation target data, and point k indicates the point closest to point x among the points included in the judgment model M (not limited to the nearest point, and may be, for example, any point within a predetermined range including the n-th nearest point or the nearest point). When performing an abnormality judgment of the evaluation target data (point x), the abnormality judgment unit 132 identifies a neighboring point k included in the judgment model M and calculates the distance (degree of abnormality) between point x and point k. If the distance is equal to or greater than a threshold value, the abnormality judgment unit 132 judges that the evaluation target data indicated by point x is abnormal. When point x is judged to be abnormal, the factor evaluation unit 133 identifies a parameter that has a high contribution to the distance among the parameters constituting point x and point k, compares the identified parameters with each other, and calculates how to make the value of the identified parameter at point x approach normal. These processes will be specifically described below with reference to FIG. 3B.
[0021] (Calculation method of abnormality level, abnormality factor, and direction) 3B shows specific examples of a method for calculating distance (degree of anomaly), a method for identifying the cause of anomaly, and a method for calculating the direction of value adjustment. As an example, the learning data and the evaluation target data contain three parameters, which are parameters 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Furthermore, the evaluation target data x is represented as x=(x1, x2, x3), and the neighboring point k of the evaluation target data x contained in the judgment model M is represented as k=(k1, k2, k3). Note that the number of parameters (three) is just an example, and there is no limit to the number.
[0022] ·Distance (abnormality) The abnormality determination unit 132 calculates the distance D(x) between the evaluation target data x and the neighboring point k by the formula (1a) in Fig. 3B. The distance D(x) is also called the degree of abnormality. As shown in the formula (1a), the degree of abnormality is a single value obtained by adding up the differences between the respective parameters. The abnormality determination unit 132 determines that the distance D(x) is abnormal if it is equal to or greater than the threshold Th, and determines that the distance D(x) is normal if it is less than the threshold Th. Furthermore, the abnormality determination unit 132 may calculate the distance D(x) by weighting each of the parameters 1 to 3. For example, the abnormality determination unit 132 multiplies each of the parameters 1 to 3 by the weighting coefficients A1 to A3, and calculates the distance D(x) by the formula (1b) in FIG. 3B. If it is known that the parameter 1 has a large effect on the state of the equipment or work, and the user places importance on the parameter 1, the user sets a large value for A1. This can improve the accuracy of abnormality detection. Note that the distance may be calculated using the Mahalanobis distance or the Manhattan distance in addition to the Euclidean distance.
[0023] ·factor The factor evaluation unit 133 calculates (k 1 -x 1 ) 2 , (k 2 -x 2 ) 2 , (k 3 -x 3 ) 2 A predetermined number of parameters are selected in descending order from the largest. That is, the factor evaluation unit 133 selects a parameter that contributes greatly to the distance as a factor of the abnormality. The factor evaluation unit 133 may assign weighting to each of the parameters 1 to 3 to identify the parameter that is a factor of the abnormality. For example, the factor evaluation unit 133 may select a predetermined number of parameters in descending order of the value obtained by multiplying each of the parameters 1 to 3 by the weighting coefficients A1 to A3. If parameter 1 is a parameter that is effective in terms of control (easy to control, likely to affect the driving state, etc.), the user can set a large value to A1 to make parameter 1 more likely to be selected as a factor of the abnormality.
[0024] ·direction The factor evaluation unit 133 calculates the direction of adjustment of the parameter identified as the abnormality factor to bring the parameter closer to normal using a formula for calculating the difference before squaring. For example, when parameter 1 is identified as the abnormality factor, the factor evaluation unit 133 calculates the direction of adjustment of the parameter to bring the parameter closer to normal using a formula for calculating the difference before squaring. 1 -x 1 ) and calculate (k 1 -x 1 ) to 0. Specifically, (k 1 -x 1 If x is a positive value, the factor evaluation unit 133 1 It is evaluated that the direction of increasing is the direction approaching normal, and (k 1 -x 1 ) is negative, then x 1 It is evaluated that the direction in which the value decreases is the direction in which the value approaches normal.
[0025] Other examples of the judgment model are shown in Figures 4A and 4B. Figure 4A shows an example in which a probability density distribution is used as the judgment model, and Figure 4B shows an example of a judgment model in which anomaly judgment is performed based on the degree of reproducibility. The upper left diagram of FIG. 4A shows the probability density distribution of parameter 1 among the multiple parameters included in the normal data. The probability density distribution calculated from the normal data illustrated in the upper left diagram is the judgment model. The lower left diagram of FIG. 4A shows the probability density distribution of parameter 1 among the multiple parameters included in the evaluation target data. The vertical axis of each graph shows the probability density, and the horizontal axis shows the value of parameter 1. The abnormality judgment unit 132 calculates the probability density distribution using a data set of the evaluation target data measured during a predetermined period (for example, t1 to t2), and calculates a density ratio with respect to the probability density distribution of the normal data (= judgment model) calculated in advance. More specifically, the abnormality judgment unit 132 calculates the density ratio (ratio of probability density functions representing the curve of the probability density distribution) of the probability density distribution of the normal data and the evaluation target data in the range of v1 to v2 in which the value of the evaluation target data exists as the degree of abnormality, and judges that the parameter 1 is abnormal if the density ratio deviates from the allowable range centered on "1". An example of the calculated density ratio is shown in the right diagram of FIG. 4A. In the illustrated example, since the density ratio deviates from "1", parameter 1 of the evaluation target data is determined to be abnormal. The abnormality determination unit 132 calculates a density ratio (degree of abnormality) for each of a plurality of parameters included in the evaluation target data, and determines that the evaluation target data measured in a predetermined period is abnormal if there is even one parameter whose density ratio deviates from the allowable range centered on "1". Alternatively, the abnormality determination unit 132 may be configured to determine that there is an abnormality when there are a predetermined number or more parameters whose density ratio deviates from the allowable range.
[0026] Furthermore, the factor evaluation unit 133 may perform logarithmic conversion of the density ratios (degrees of abnormality) calculated for each parameter, and identify a predetermined number of parameters as abnormal factors in ascending order of the density ratio, or identify a predetermined number of parameters as abnormal factors in descending order of the variance of the probability density distribution, or identify a predetermined number of parameters as abnormal factors in descending order of the area of the range deviating from the allowable range centered on the density ratio "1", or calculate the distance L between the average value of the probability density distribution of normal data and the average value of the probability density distribution of the evaluation target data, and identify a predetermined number of parameters as abnormal factors in descending order of the distance L. Furthermore, the factor evaluation unit 133 may identify an abnormal factor by combining these methods. For example, the factor evaluation unit 133 may identify a parameter identified as an abnormal factor by a plurality of methods as a final abnormal factor, or may identify all parameters identified as an abnormal factor by any of a plurality of methods as a final abnormal factor. In addition, for each parameter identified as an abnormality factor, the factor evaluation unit 133 evaluates that the direction of the value with the highest probability density of normal data (the average value of the probability density distribution) (the direction of the thick arrow in the lower left diagram of Figure 4A) is the direction approaching normal.
[0027] Next, a process of performing an anomaly determination using a determination model based on reproducibility will be described with reference to FIG. 4B. (Step 1) The model construction unit 131 constructs a determination model (for example, an autoencoder) that uses normal data including parameters 1 to 3 as learning data, learns to output the input data itself even if any normal data is input, and reproduces the normal data. (Step 2) The anomaly determination unit 132 inputs parameters 1 to 3 (Q1 to Q3) of the evaluation target data to the constructed determination model. If the values of parameters 1 to 3 output by the determination model are Q1' to Q3', the anomaly determination unit 132 calculates |Q1-Q1'|, |Q2-Q2'|, and |Q3-Q3'|, and sets these values as reproducibility (anomaly). The smaller the reproducibility (anomaly), the better, and the anomaly determination unit 132 determines that the evaluation target data is abnormal if the reproducibility of at least one parameter exceeds a threshold value. Alternatively, the anomaly determination unit 132 may be configured to determine that the evaluation target data is abnormal if there are a predetermined number or more parameters whose reproducibility exceeds a threshold value. Furthermore, the factor evaluation unit 133 identifies a predetermined number of abnormality factors in descending order of reproducibility (degree of abnormality). For example, when |Q1-Q1'|=0, |Q2-Q2'|=2, and |Q3-Q3'|=5 and only one abnormality factor is identified, the factor evaluation unit 133 identifies parameter 3 as the abnormality factor. Furthermore, the factor evaluation unit 133 evaluates the direction in which reproducibility (degree of abnormality)=0 is the direction approaching normal. For example, for Q3' of the evaluation target data, the unit evaluates the direction in which |Q3-Q3'|=5 becomes |Q3-Q3'|=0 as the direction approaching normal.
[0028] In addition, when a judgment model is created by learning the correlation between multiple parameters and the correlation is expressed by a correlation coefficient calculated by a predetermined method, for example, the abnormality judgment unit 132 calculates the difference between the correlation coefficient between parameter 1 and parameter 2 of the evaluation target data and the correlation coefficient between parameter 1 and parameter 2 in the judgment model. The abnormality judgment unit 132 also calculates the difference in correlation coefficients between other parameters, and if the sum of these is equal to or greater than a threshold, judges the evaluation target data to be abnormal. When the evaluation target data is judged to be abnormal, the factor evaluation unit 133 selects a predetermined number of parameters in descending order of the difference between the parameters, and calculates how to make the parameter values approach normal. For example, when the correlation coefficient between parameter 1 and parameter 2 and the correlation coefficient between parameter 3 and parameter 4 are significantly higher or lower than the correlation coefficients of those parameters in the normal state, the factor evaluation unit 133 selects the set of parameters 1 and 2 and the set of parameters 3 and 4. Then, the factor evaluation unit 133 compares the correlation coefficient between corresponding parameters in the data under normal conditions with the correlation coefficient in the data to be evaluated, and calculates the direction of adjustment of each parameter required to bring the correlation closer to normal, such as increasing parameter 1 and decreasing parameter 2, or decreasing parameter 3 and increasing parameter 4.
[0029] By presenting to the user the judgment result of the abnormality judgment unit 132, together with the evaluation result of the abnormality factors identified by the factor evaluation unit 133 and the direction to bring the equipment closer to normal, the user can understand how to return the state of the machinery and equipment and the work to a normal state.
[0030] (Abnormality determination process) Next, the flow of anomaly determination processing by the anomaly determination system 1 will be described using an example in which the anomaly determination method, the anomaly cause identification method, and the method of evaluating the direction toward normality described with reference to FIGS. 3A and 3B are applied. FIG. 5 is a flowchart illustrating an example of an abnormality determination process according to the embodiment. Prior to the abnormality determination, thresholds and the like are set (step S10). For example, the user sets the abnormality degree threshold Th used to determine whether the device is normal or abnormal, a weighting coefficient such as A1 when formula (1b) is used, the maximum number of factors that will cause an abnormality to be presented in the guidance information (for example, three), and parameters to be excluded from the parameters to be presented in the guidance information. Regarding the setting of the maximum number of abnormality factors to be presented, a number that can be handled by a person is set when the user visually recognizes the guidance information and uses it as a reference for subsequent control. Alternatively, if the information is used in cooperation with a control device or the like and applied to computer control, several tens of parameters may be presented. Regarding the setting of parameters to be excluded from the parameters to be presented in the guidance information, parameters that cannot be controlled or parameters that may cause a malfunction when controlled are set. The reason for excluding parameters that cannot be controlled is that the guidance information is presented with a direction for adjusting the value to return to a normal state, and therefore only parameters that can be controlled by the user are presented. Parameters that may cause a malfunction will be described next with reference to FIG. 6. Furthermore, instead of setting parameters to be excluded, parameters that can be presented as guidance information may be set. The setting reception unit 12 receives these settings and records the set information in the storage unit 15 .
[0031] Next, the data acquisition unit 11 acquires the evaluation target data (step S11). For example, the abnormality determination device 10 may be communicably connected to the machine equipment to be monitored, and the data acquisition unit 11 may acquire the evaluation target data online. Alternatively, the data acquisition unit 11 may acquire the evaluation target data previously collected in an offline state. As an example, the evaluation target data is assumed to be x. Furthermore, x is composed of three parameters 1 to 3, and x=(x1, x2, x3). The data acquisition unit 11 outputs the acquired evaluation target data to the abnormality determination unit 132.
[0032] Next, the abnormality determination unit 132 calculates the degree of abnormality (step S12). For example, the abnormality determination unit 132 calculates the distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each parameter, and calculates the sum of the distances as the degree of abnormality. The degree of abnormality is the distance D(x) described with reference to FIG. 3B. The abnormality determination unit 132 calculates the neighboring point k in the determination model, and calculates the degree of abnormality by formula (1a) or formula (1b) in FIG. 3B.
[0033] Next, the abnormality determination unit 132 compares the calculated degree of abnormality with the threshold value Th set in step S10 to determine whether it is normal or abnormal (step S13). The abnormality determination unit 132 determines that there is an abnormality if the degree of abnormality is equal to or greater than the threshold value Th, and determines that there is a normality if the degree of abnormality is less than the threshold value Th. If it determines that there is normality (step S13; No), the abnormality determination unit 132 outputs the determination result "normal" to the output unit 14. The output unit 14 outputs the determination result "normal" to a display device or the like (step S17).
[0034] When it is judged that there is an abnormality (step S13; Yes), the abnormality judgment unit 132 outputs the judgment result "abnormal" to the output unit 14, and instructs the factor evaluation unit 133 to calculate which parameter is the cause of the high abnormality level and the direction in which the abnormality level can be reduced. The factor evaluation unit 133 identifies the cause of the abnormality (step S14). The factor evaluation unit 133 calculates the distance ((k 1 -x 1 ) and so on) and selects a predetermined number of parameters in descending order of distance (excluding those set as parameters to be excluded in step S10, or selecting from among presentable parameters if such parameters have been set). For example, if the top two are set to be selected in step S10, the factor evaluation unit 133 selects two parameters from parameters 1 to 3 in descending order of distance (parameters 1 and 2). Next, the factor evaluation unit 133 calculates a direction for moving the parameters selected in step S14 closer to the normal state (step S15). For example, the factor evaluation unit 133 calculates the direction for moving parameter 1 closer to normal by (k 1-x 1 ) is calculated, and if the calculation result is negative, the value of parameter 1 is decreased, and if the calculation result is positive, the value of parameter 1 is increased. In addition, the factor evaluation unit 133 calculates (k 2 -x 2 ) and if the calculation result is negative, the value of parameter 2 is decreased, and if the calculation result is positive, the value of parameter 2 is increased. The factor evaluation unit 133 outputs to the output unit 14 the parameter that is the identified factor of the abnormality and information about the direction for bringing the parameter closer to normal.
[0035] Next, the output unit 14 outputs the determination result and guidance information (step S16). For example, the output unit 14 displays on the display device the determination result of "abnormality has occurred" and guidance information indicating that the cause of the abnormality is parameter 1 and parameter 2, and instructing the operator to decrease the value of parameter 1 and increase the value of parameter 2. This allows the operator of the machinery and equipment to not only know that the operating condition of the machinery and equipment has become abnormal, but also to know by looking at the displayed guidance information that the abnormality is caused by parameters 1 and 2. Furthermore, the operator can adjust parameters 1 and 2 so that the operating condition of the machinery and equipment becomes normal.
[0036] In general, when machine learning is used to judge anomalies in machinery equipment such as processing machines and in work such as welding, data during abnormality is scarce, so a judgment model is often constructed using only data during normal times. Usually, such a judgment model only outputs the level of anomaly as an anomaly degree, and cannot guide the cause of the anomaly or a method for reducing the anomaly degree. However, in machinery equipment and work, in order to ensure quality, cost, and lead time, it is necessary to suppress rework as much as possible, and responsiveness is required in dealing with anomalies. For this reason, it is necessary to know the cause of the anomaly and the method for dealing with it as soon as possible when an anomaly occurs. In contrast, according to this embodiment, the distance between the evaluation target data and the judgment model is calculated for each parameter, and the sum of the distances is calculated as the anomaly degree. Then, when the anomaly degree exceeds a threshold value, it is possible to present which parameter is the cause of the increase in the anomaly degree based on the distance calculated for each parameter. In addition, by evaluating the method (direction) for reducing the anomaly degree, it is possible to present how to move the parameter to reduce the anomaly degree.
[0037] As described above, the information on the parameters that are abnormal factors and the direction for bringing the parameters closer to normal, which are presented as guidance information, has the effect of quickly normalizing the state of the work, etc., particularly when applied to online work or the operation of machinery and equipment. However, for example, there is a possibility that the accuracy of the judgment model is insufficient due to a lack of learning data, etc., and that inappropriate parameters are presented, or that changing a certain parameter affects other parameters and does not have a beneficial effect overall. In order to prevent such problems, the abnormality judgment system 1 of this embodiment can use the simulator 20 to confirm in advance whether it is appropriate to adjust the parameters identified as abnormal factors. Next, an example of a process for evaluating whether it is appropriate to adjust (bring the parameters closer to normal) the parameters identified in step S14 will be described with reference to FIG. 6.
[0038] (Method of evaluating abnormality factor parameters) 6 is a flowchart showing an example of a parameter evaluation method according to an embodiment of the present invention. The same steps as those in FIG. 5 are assigned the same reference numerals and will be briefly described. The abnormality determination device 10 and the simulator 20 are connected to be able to communicate with each other. The simulator 20 is a calculation model that simulates the operation of a mechanical equipment, and is configured to simulate the operation of the mechanical equipment when a user sets calculation conditions such as initial conditions and instructs to simulate the operation. The simulator 20 outputs calculation results (temperature, pressure, valve opening, etc.) calculated during the simulation, which become evaluation target data. The data acquisition unit 11 acquires the evaluation target data output by the simulator 20 during the simulation, and the abnormality determination device 10 performs abnormality determination and the like on this data. The control unit 13 can output control information to the simulator 20 through the output unit 14. Alternatively, the user may input the control information to the simulator 20. When the simulator 20 receives the control information, it reflects the contents of the control information in the simulation calculation. For example, when the control unit 13 outputs control information to the simulator 20 to decrease the value of parameter 1 by a predetermined amount, the simulator 20 simulates, based on the control information, the operation of the mechanical equipment when an operation is performed to decrease parameter 1, and calculates a state in which the value of parameter 1 has decreased by the predetermined amount. The following description will be given on the assumption that the abnormality determination device 10 and the simulator 20 are configured in this way.
[0039] First, the user sets thresholds and the like (step S10). Next, the user sets calculation conditions and starts the simulator 20. The simulator 20 starts simulating the mechanical equipment (step S101). The data acquisition unit 11 acquires the evaluation target data output by the simulator 20 (step S11). The abnormality determination unit 132 calculates the abnormality degree (step S12) and performs abnormality determination (step S13). In the case of an abnormality (step S13; Yes), the factor evaluation unit 133 identifies a predetermined number of parameters that are the cause of the abnormality (step S14) and calculates a direction to approach normal for each parameter (step S15). The control unit 13 creates control information for adjusting one of the parameters identified by the factor evaluation unit 133 as the cause of the abnormality in a direction to approach normal by a predetermined amount, outputs the control information to the simulator 20, and reflects it in the simulation content (step S18). The control unit 13 executes the process of step S18 for the predetermined number of parameters identified in step S14. The simulator 20 simulates the operation of the mechanical equipment after the parameter adjustment. The data acquisition unit 11 records the calculation results calculated by the simulator 20 after the parameter adjustment in the storage unit 15 (step S19). Regarding steps S14 to S18, if adjustments of multiple parameters are reflected at once, it becomes unclear which parameter adjustment has had an effect on the mechanical equipment. Therefore, only one parameter (for example, the parameter that contributes most to the degree of abnormality) may be selected, and only the value of that parameter may be adjusted in a direction closer to normal and reflected in the simulator 20.
[0040] The user evaluates whether it is appropriate to adjust the parameter identified in step S15 based on the simulation result by the simulator 20 recorded in the storage unit 15 (step S20). For example, if the calculation result after the parameter adjustment indicates that the operating state of the mechanical equipment has returned to normal, it is considered that it was appropriate to adjust the parameter in the direction calculated in step S15. On the other hand, if the calculation result after the adjustment indicates that the operating state of the mechanical equipment remains abnormal even after the adjustment, it is considered that the adjustment of the parameter identified in step S14 may not be appropriate. If the adjustment of the parameter is not appropriate, the user can set the parameter to be excluded from the parameters to be presented as guidance information. For example, in step S10 of FIG. 5, the parameter is set as a parameter to be excluded from the evaluation target. Then, in step S14, the factor evaluation unit 133 excludes the excluded parameter from the identification target. As a result, the excluded parameter is no longer presented as guidance information, and it is possible to prevent the parameter from being erroneously adjusted when an abnormality is determined.
[0041] FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of the abnormality determination system according to the embodiment. The computer 900 includes a CPU 901, a main storage device 902, an auxiliary storage device 903, an input / output interface 904, and a communication interface 905. The abnormality determination system 1 described above is implemented in the computer 900. The above-mentioned functions are stored in the auxiliary storage device 903 in the form of a program. The CPU 901 reads the program from the auxiliary storage device 903, loads it in the main storage device 902, and executes the above-mentioned processing according to the program. The CPU 901 also secures a storage area in the main storage device 902 according to the program. The CPU 901 also secures a storage area in the auxiliary storage device 903 for storing data being processed according to the program.
[0042] In addition, a program for realizing all or part of the functions of the abnormality determination system 1 may be recorded in a computer-readable recording medium, and the program recorded in the recording medium may be read into a computer system and executed to perform processing by each functional unit. The term "computer system" as used herein includes hardware such as an OS and peripheral devices. In addition, if a WWW system is used, the term "computer system" also includes a homepage providing environment (or display environment). In addition, the term "computer-readable recording medium" refers to a portable medium such as a CD, DVD, or USB, and a storage device such as a hard disk built into a computer system. In addition, if the program is distributed to the computer 900 through a communication line, the computer 900 that receives the program may deploy the program in the main storage device 902 and execute the above processing. In addition, the above program may be for realizing part of the above-mentioned functions, and may further be capable of realizing the above-mentioned functions in combination with a program already recorded in the computer system.
[0043] As described above, several embodiments according to the present disclosure have been described, but all of these embodiments are presented as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. These embodiments can be implemented in various other forms, and various omissions, substitutions, and modifications can be made without departing from the gist of the invention. These embodiments and their modifications are included in the scope of the invention and its equivalents as described in the claims, as well as in the scope and gist of the invention.
[0044] <Additional Notes> The abnormality determination method, the abnormality determination system, and the program described in each embodiment can be understood, for example, as follows.
[0045] (1) The anomaly judgment method according to the first aspect includes a step of comparing a judgment model created by learning normal data (data when mechanical equipment or work conditions are normal) including a plurality of variables (parameters) with data to be evaluated including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the data to be evaluated and the judgment model for each of the variables, and calculating the sum of the distances as the degree of anomaly of the data to be evaluated (S12), a step of judging whether the data to be evaluated is abnormal or not based on the degree of anomaly (S13), a step of calculating a direction of adjustment of a value for at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the degree of anomaly (S14, S15), and a step of outputting the adjustment direction (S16). This allows you to not only determine if there is an abnormality, but also how to return the system to a normal state.
[0046] (2) A second aspect of the abnormality determination method is the abnormality determination method of (1), in which, in the step of calculating the adjustment direction, a predetermined number of the variables are selected in order from the largest distance (S14), and a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variables is calculated as the adjustment direction (S15). In the step of outputting the adjustment direction, the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable are output. This makes it possible not only to determine an abnormality, but also to understand which parameter is causing the abnormality to become severe, and how to return that parameter to a normal state.
[0047] (3) A third aspect of the abnormality determination method is the abnormality determination method according to (2), in which when selecting the predetermined number of variables, controllable variables are selected. This makes it possible to control the parameters presented as guidance information and restore the state of the machinery and equipment or work.
[0048] (4) A fourth aspect of the abnormality determination method is an abnormality determination method according to any one of (1) to (3), wherein the adjustment direction is, for one of the variables, from the value of the variable contained in the evaluation target data to the value of the same variable contained in the determination model that is closest to the variable. This makes it possible to calculate the direction in which a parameter identified as the cause of an abnormality should be brought closer to normal. By adjusting the parameter in the calculated direction, it may be possible to return the monitored machinery and equipment or work conditions to their normal state.
[0049] (5) The abnormality determination method according to a fifth aspect is the abnormality determination method of (1) to (4), further comprising the steps of setting a normal interval for data of the plurality of variables, and learning the data included in the normal interval as the normal data, and creating the determination model that specifies a normal range for each of the variables. Even if only normal data can be obtained from the monitored object and only a normal model learned from the normal data can be constructed, the normal model can be used not only to determine abnormalities but also to understand how to return the object to a normal state.
[0050] (6) A sixth aspect of the present invention relates to an abnormality determination method according to any one of (1) to (5), in which a weight is set for each of the variables to calculate the distance. This makes it possible to preferentially present guidance information regarding parameters that meet the user's intention (for example, parameters that are effective in terms of control) by setting desired weighting for the relationship between the parameters.
[0051] (7) An abnormality determination method according to a seventh aspect is an abnormality determination method according to any one of (1) to (6), further comprising the steps of: inputting the value of the variable adjusted in a direction to reduce the degree of abnormality into a simulator that simulates the operation of a specified device or a specified task, and causing the simulator to simulate the operation or the task (S18); and evaluating, based on the results of the simulation, whether to adjust the variable for the purpose of reducing the degree of abnormality (S20). This makes it possible to check in a simulation environment whether the parameters presented in the guidance information and the methods for improving them are appropriate.
[0052] (8) An eighth aspect of the anomaly determination method is an anomaly determination method according to any one of (1) to (7), wherein the determination model is a probability density distribution of the variable contained in the normal data, and the step of calculating the degree of anomaly calculates a density ratio between the probability density distribution of the variable contained in the data to be evaluated and a probability density distribution of the variable based on the normal data, and the step of calculating the adjustment direction calculates the direction of adjustment of the value based on a positional relationship between the probability density distribution of the data to be evaluated and the probability density distribution of the normal data. This makes it possible to calculate the degree of abnormality of the evaluation target data based on the likelihood of occurrence (probability density distribution) of the values of multiple variables that constitute normal data.
[0053] (9) An abnormality determination method according to a ninth aspect is an abnormality determination method according to any one of (1) to (8), wherein the determination model is a model that reproduces normal data constructed to output the normal data when the normal data is input, and the step of calculating the degree of abnormality calculates a reproducibility indicating the degree to which the data output by the determination model when the data to be evaluated is input to the determination model reproduces the input data to be evaluated, and the step of calculating the adjustment direction calculates a direction to adjust the value based on the reproducibility. This makes it possible to calculate the degree of abnormality of the evaluation target data based on the degree of reproduction of the evaluation target data by a model that reproduces normal data.
[0054] (10) The abnormality judgment system 1 according to the tenth aspect has a means (abnormality judgment unit 132) for comparing a judgment model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with data to be evaluated including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the data to be evaluated and the judgment model for each of the variables, and calculating the sum of the distances as the degree of abnormality of the data to be evaluated, a means (abnormality judgment unit 132) for judging whether the data to be evaluated is abnormal or not based on the degree of abnormality, a means (factor evaluation unit 133) for calculating a direction of adjustment of a value to reduce the degree of abnormality for at least one of the plurality of variables, and a means (output unit 14) for outputting the adjustment direction.
[0055] (11) A program relating to an eleventh aspect causes a computer 900 to execute the steps of comparing a judgment model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with data to be evaluated including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the data to be evaluated and the judgment model for each of the variables, and calculating the sum of the distances as the degree of abnormality of the data to be evaluated; determining whether the data to be evaluated is abnormal based on the degree of abnormality; calculating a direction of adjustment of a value for at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the degree of abnormality; and outputting the adjustment direction. [Explanation of symbols]
[0056] 1. Anomaly Judgment System 10...Abnormality determination device 11 Data acquisition section 12. Settings reception section 13. Control section 131...Model Construction Section 132...Abnormality determination section 133...Factor Evaluation Section 14 Output section 15...Storage section 20. Simulator 900...Computer 901··CPU 902...Main memory 903...Auxiliary storage device 904 Input / Output Interface 905 Communication Interface
Claims
1. a step of comparing a determination model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each of the variables, and calculating a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data; determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the degree of abnormality; calculating a direction of adjustment of a value of at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the degree of abnormality; outputting the adjustment direction; having In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, Select a predetermined number of the variables in descending order of the distance; Calculating a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variable as the adjustment direction; In the step of outputting the adjustment direction, outputting the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable; Abnormality determination method.
2. When selecting the predetermined number of variables, the controllable variables are selected. The method for determining an abnormality according to claim 1 .
3. The adjustment direction is a direction from a value of the variable included in the evaluation target data to a value of the same variable included in the judgment model that is closest to the variable. The method for determining an abnormality according to claim 1 or 2.
4. setting a normal interval for data of the plurality of variables; A step of learning the data included in the normal interval as the normal data and creating the determination model that specifies a normal range for each of the variables; The method for determining an abnormality according to any one of claims 1 to 3, further comprising:
5. A weight is set for each of the variables to calculate the distance. The method for determining an abnormality according to any one of claims 1 to 3.
6. inputting the value of the variable adjusted in a direction to reduce the degree of abnormality into a simulator that simulates an operation of a predetermined device or a predetermined task, and causing the simulator to simulate the operation or the task; evaluating whether to adjust the variables to reduce the degree of anomaly based on the results of the simulation; The abnormality determination method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, further comprising:
7. the determination model is a probability density distribution of the variables contained in the normal data, In the step of calculating the degree of anomaly, a density ratio between a probability density distribution of the variable included in the evaluation target data and a probability density distribution of the variable based on the normal data is calculated; In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, a direction of adjustment of the value is calculated based on a positional relationship between a probability density distribution of the evaluation target data and a probability density distribution of the normal data. The method for determining an abnormality according to any one of claims 1 to 6.
8. the judgment model is a model that reproduces the normal data and is constructed so as to output the normal data when the normal data is input, In the step of calculating the degree of anomaly, a reproducibility indicating to what extent data output from the judgment model when the evaluation target data is input to the judgment model reproduces the input evaluation target data is calculated; In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, an adjustment direction of the value is calculated based on the reproducibility. The method for determining an abnormality according to any one of claims 1 to 7.
9. a means for comparing a determination model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each of the variables, and calculating a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data; a means for determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the degree of abnormality; means for calculating a direction of adjustment of a value for reducing the degree of abnormality for at least one of the plurality of variables; A means for outputting the adjustment direction; having The means for calculating the adjustment direction includes: Select a predetermined number of the variables in descending order of the distance; Calculating a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variable as the adjustment direction; The means for outputting the adjustment direction includes: outputting the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable; Anomaly detection system.
10. On the computer, a step of comparing a determination model created by learning normal data including a plurality of variables with evaluation target data including the plurality of variables, calculating a distance between the evaluation target data and the determination model for each of the variables, and calculating a sum of the distances as an abnormality degree of the evaluation target data; determining whether the evaluation target data is abnormal or not based on the degree of abnormality; calculating a direction of adjustment of a value of at least one of the plurality of variables to reduce the degree of abnormality; outputting the adjustment direction; having In the step of calculating the adjustment direction, Select a predetermined number of the variables in descending order of the distance; Calculating a direction in which the distance is reduced for the selected variable as the adjustment direction; In the step of outputting the adjustment direction, outputting the selected variables and the adjustment direction for each variable; A program that executes the following.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Plant abnormality diagnostic device
JP1986016307A
Operation support device
JP1993119191A
Abnormality diagnosis device
JP2016014961A
Process diagnostic device, process diagnostic method, and process diagnostic system
JP2018120343A
Abnormality diagnosis system of pump equipment and abnormality diagnosis method of pump equipment
JP2019178625A
