Pre-screening and tuning of heterojunctions for topological quantum computers
A two-stage method using RF junction admittance mapping and sub-RF conductance measurements effectively identifies suitable semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for topological quantum computers, addressing fabrication challenges and enhancing operational stability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2022552304
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2020-05-28
- Filing Date
- 2021-01-20
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-09
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-01-20
AI Technical Summary
Current methods for fabricating semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for topological quantum computers are prone to material defects and unpredictable operating parameters, making it difficult to achieve the desired topological behavior necessary for stable qubit operation.
A two-stage method involving RF junction admittance mapping and sub-RF conductance measurements is employed to identify regions of unbroken topological phase and topological gaps in semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, using density-based clustering and non-local conductance to refine data and reduce false positives/negatives.
This approach allows for the accurate identification of suitable heterojunctions for qubit registers, ensuring stable and reproducible operation of topological quantum computers by minimizing errors and improving fabrication success rates.
Smart Images

Figure 0007596395000012 
Figure 0007596395000013 
Figure 0007596395000014
Abstract
Description
[Background technology]
[0001] A quantum computer is a physical machine configured to perform logical operations based on or influenced by quantum mechanical phenomena. Such logical operations may include, for example, mathematical calculations. Current interest in quantum computer technology is motivated by analyses suggesting that the computational efficiency of properly configured quantum computers, when applied to certain types of problems, may exceed that of any practical non-quantum computer. Such problems include computer modeling of natural and artificial quantum systems, integer factorization, data exploration, and function optimization applied to simultaneous linear equations and machine learning. Furthermore, it is predicted that the continued miniaturization of conventional computer logic structures will eventually lead to the development of nanoscale logic components that exhibit quantum effects and thus must be addressed according to the principles of quantum computing.
[0002] Different types of quantum computers operate based on different quantum mechanical phenomena. A "topological" quantum computer is a quantum computer that operates based on non-Abelian phases of matter that can support "braidable" quasiparticles. This type of quantum computer is less susceptible to quantum decoherence problems than other types of quantum computers, and therefore may serve as a relatively fault-tolerant quantum computing platform. Summary of the Invention [Means for solving the problem]
[0003] One aspect of the present disclosure is directed to a method of characterizing a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer. The method includes measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data to find one or more regions of a parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. The method also includes measuring a sub-RF conductance, including a nonlocal conductance, of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data, and analyzing the refinement data to find a boundary of an unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space.
[0004] This Summary is provided to introduce a selection of concepts in a simplified form that are further described in the Detailed Description. This Summary is not intended to identify key features or essential features of the claimed subject matter, nor is it intended to be used to limit the scope of the claimed subject matter. The claimed subject matter is not limited to implementations that solve any or all of the disadvantages noted in any part of this disclosure. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0005] [Figure 1] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary quantum computer.
[0006] [Diagram 2] The Bloch sphere is a diagrammatic representation of the quantum state of one qubit in a quantum computer.
[0007] [Diagram 3] 1 illustrates aspects of exemplary signal waveforms for performing quantum gate operations in a quantum computer.
[0008] [Figure 4] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary qubit architecture that includes a linear Tetron array.
[0009] [Diagram 5] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction device that was evaluated according to the methods herein.
[0010] [Figure 6] We present aspects of an exemplary method for evaluating semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for use in qubit registers in topological quantum computers.
[0011] [Figure 7] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary radio frequency (RF) reflection measurement test circuit.
[0012] [Figure 8] Aspects of an exemplary method for measuring the RF junction admittance of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction are presented.
[0013] [Figure 9] Analysis of the data from the method of FIG. 8 illustrates aspects of an exemplary method for finding regions of parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0014] [Figure 10] Figure 9 illustrates various aspects of the analysis of mapping data by this method.
[0015] [Figure 11] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary sub-RF conductance test circuit.
[0016] [Figure 12] Aspects of an exemplary method for measuring the sub-RF conductance of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction are presented.
[0017] [Figure 13] Analysis of the data from the method in Figure 12 illustrates aspects of an exemplary method for finding unbroken topological boundaries in parameter space and the topological gap of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0018] [Figure 14] 14 illustrates aspects of the analysis of refined data according to the method of FIG. 13.
[0019] [Figure 15] We show the effect of a smooth potential at the right end of a semiconductor wire in a 1D model of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0020] [Figure 16] We present the effect of a smooth potential at the center of a semiconductor wire in a 1D model of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0021] [Figure 17] We present the results of data analysis on the field / plunger parameter space for a 1D model of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction with a potential bump in the center of the semiconductor wire.
[0022] [Figure 18] We present the results of a data analysis on the field / plunger parameter space of a strongly disordered 1D model of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0023] [Figure 19] Aspects of an exemplary apparatus configured to evaluate semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for use in qubit registers of a topological quantum computer are presented.
[0024] [Figure 20] 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary method for constructing a topological quantum computer. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0025] Quantum Computer Architecture FIG. 1 illustrates aspects of an exemplary quantum computer 10 configured to perform quantum logic operations (described below). While traditional computer memories store digital data in an array of bits and perform bit-wise logical operations, quantum computers store data in an array of qubits and quantum-mechanically operate on the qubits to achieve the desired logic. Thus, the quantum computer 10 of FIG. 1 includes at least one qubit register 12 that includes an array of qubits 14. The illustrated qubit register is eight qubits long, although qubit registers including longer and shorter qubit arrays and quantum computers having two or more qubit registers of any length are envisioned.
[0026] The qubits 14 of the qubit register 12 can take a variety of forms, depending on the desired architecture of the quantum computer 10. While the present disclosure relates to qubits embodied as quasiparticles in non-Abelian topological phases, the qubits may alternatively include, by way of non-limiting examples, superconducting Josephson junctions, trapped ions, trapped atoms coupled to highly microscopic cavities, atoms or molecules confined within fullerenes, ions or neutral dopant atoms confined within a host lattice, quantum dots exhibiting discrete spatial or spin electronic states, electron-holes in semiconductor junctions captured via electrostatic traps, coupled quantum wire pairs, atomic nuclei addressable by magnetic resonance, free electrons in helium, molecular magnets, or metallic-like carbon nanospheres. More generally, each qubit 14 may include any particle or system of particles that can exist in two or more discrete quantum states that can be experimentally measured and manipulated. For example, a qubit may be implemented with multiple processing states corresponding to different modes of light propagation through linear optical elements (e.g., mirrors, beam splitters, and phase shifters), as well as states stored within a Bose-Einstein condensate.
[0027] FIG. 2 is an illustration of a Bloch sphere 16 that provides a pictorial description of some quantum mechanical aspects of an individual qubit 14. In this description, the north and south poles of the Bloch sphere correspond to the standard basis vectors, respectively. The set of points on the surface of the Bloch sphere contains all possible pure states of the qubit, while the interior points correspond to all possible mixed states. Mixed states of a given qubit can result from decoherence, which can arise due to undesired coupling to the external degrees of freedom.
[0028] Returning now to FIG. 1, quantum computer 10 includes controller 18A. The controller includes at least one processor 20A and associated computer memory 22A. Processor 20A of controller 18A may be operatively coupled to peripheral components, such as network components, to allow the quantum computer to be operated remotely. Processor 20A of controller 18A may take the form of a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU), or the like. As such, the controller may include classical electronic components. The terms "classical" and "non-quantum" are used herein to refer to any component that can be accurately modeled as an ensemble of particles without considering the quantum state of any individual particle. Classical electronic components include, for example, integrated microlithographed transistors, resistors, and capacitors. Computer memory 22A may be configured to hold program instructions 24A that cause processor 20A to perform some function or process of the controller. The computer memory may be configured to hold additional data 26A. In examples where qubit register 12 is a low temperature or cryogenic device, controller 18A may include components operable at the low temperature or cryogenic temperature, for example, a field programmable gate array (FPGA) operated at 77 K. In such examples, the low temperature control components may be operatively coupled to interface components operable at room temperature.
[0029] The controller 18A of the quantum computer 10 is configured to receive a number of inputs 28 and provide a number of outputs 30. The inputs and outputs may each include digital and / or analog lines. At least some of the inputs and outputs may be data lines through which data is provided to and / or extracted from the quantum computer. Other inputs may include control lines through which the operation of the quantum computer may be regulated or otherwise controlled.
[0030] The controller 18A is operatively coupled to the qubit register 12 via a quantum interface 32. The quantum interface is configured to exchange data bidirectionally with the controller. The quantum interface is further configured to exchange signals corresponding to the data bidirectionally with the qubit register. Depending on the architecture of the quantum computer 10, such signals may include electrical, magnetic, and / or optical signals. Through signals transmitted through the quantum interface, the controller can interrogate or otherwise affect the quantum state held in the qubit register, which is defined by the collective quantum state of the array of qubits 14. To this end, the quantum interface includes at least one modulator 34 and at least one demodulator 36, each operatively coupled to one or more qubits of the qubit register. Each modulator is configured to output a signal to the qubit register based on modulation data received from the controller. Each demodulator is configured to sense a signal from the qubit register and output data to the controller based on that signal. The data received from the demodulator may, in some instances, be an estimate of the observable versus a measurement of the quantum state held in the qubit register.
[0031] In some examples, a suitably configured signal from the modulator 34 may physically interact with one or more qubits 14 of the qubit register 12 to trigger a measurement of a quantum state held in the one or more qubits. The demodulator 36 may then sense a result signal emitted by the one or more qubits according to the measurement and provide data corresponding to the result signal to the controller 18A. In other words, the demodulator may be configured to output an estimate of one or more observables reflecting the quantum state of the one or more qubits of the qubit register based on the received signal and provide the estimate to the controller. In one non-limiting example, to initiate a measurement, the modulator may provide an appropriate voltage pulse or pulse train to the electrodes of the one or more qubits based on data from the controller. Immediately, the demodulator may sense a photon emission from the one or more qubits and assert a corresponding corresponding digital voltage level on the quantum interface line to the controller. In general, a measurement of a quantum mechanical state is defined by an operator O corresponding to the observable to be measured, and the result R of the measurement is guaranteed to be one of the allowed eigenvalues of O. In quantum computer 10, R is statistically related to the qubit-register state prior to the measurement, but is not uniquely determined by the qubit-register state.
[0032] Subject to appropriate input from controller 18A, quantum interface 32 may be configured to implement one or more quantum logic gates to operate on the quantum states held in qubit register 12. While the functionality of each type of logic gate in a classical computer system is described according to a corresponding truth table, the functionality of each type of quantum gate is described by a corresponding operator matrix that operates on (i.e., multiplies by) a complex vector representing the qubit register state to perform a specified rotation of that vector in Hilbert space.
[0033] For example, the Hadamard gate HAD is defined as follows:
number
[0034] A HAD gate operates on a single qubit, mapping the basis state |0〉 to (|0〉 + |1〉) / √2 and |1〉 to (|0〉 - |1〉) / √2. Thus, the HAD gate creates a superposition of states that have equal probability of being |0〉 or |1〉 when measured.
[0035] The phase gate S is defined as follows:
number
[0036] The S-gate leaves the ground state |0〉 unchanged but changes |1〉 to e iπ / 2 |1〉. Thus, this gate does not change the probability of measuring |0〉 or |1〉, but it does shift the phase of the quantum state of the qubit. This is equivalent to rotating ψ by 90 degrees along the circle of latitude of the Bloch sphere in Figure 2.
[0037] Some quantum gates operate on more than one qubit. For example, the SWAP gate operates on two different qubits and swaps their values. This gate is defined as follows:
number
[0038] The foregoing list of quantum gates and associated operator matrices is not exhaustive and is provided for ease of explanation. Other quantum gates include, by way of non-limiting examples, the Pauli-X, -Y, and -Z gates,
number
number
[0039] Continuing with FIG. 1 , a suitably configured signal from a modulator 34 of the quantum interface 32 can physically interact with one or more qubits 14 of the qubit register 12 to assert any desired quantum gate operation. As mentioned above, a desired quantum gate operation is, in particular, a defined rotation of a complex vector representing the qubit register state. To implement a desired rotation O, one or more modulators of the quantum interface 32 are modulated for a predetermined duration T i for a given signal level S i In some examples, multiple signal levels may be applied at multiple sequenced or otherwise related durations to assert a quantum gate operation to one or more qubits in a qubit register, as shown in FIG. 3. In general, each signal level S i and each duration T i is a control parameter that can be adjusted by appropriate programming of the controller 18A.
[0040] The term "oracle" is used herein to describe a predefined sequence of elementary quantum gate and / or measurement operations executable by quantum computer 10. Oracles can be used to transform the quantum state of qubit register 12, for example, to perform classical or non-elementary quantum gate operations or to apply density operators. In some examples, oracles may be used to perform predefined "black box" operations f(x), which may be combined into a complex sequence of operations. To ensure adjoint operations, an oracle that maps n input qubits |x〉 to m output or ancillary qubits |y〉=f(x) can be used to perform quantum gates acting on n+m qubits.
number
number
[0041] Implicit in the description herein is that each qubit 14 in qubit register 12 may be interrogated via quantum interface 32 to reliably reveal the canonical basis vector |0〉 or |1〉 that characterizes the quantum state of that qubit. However, in some implementations, measurements of the quantum state of a physical qubit may be subject to errors. Thus, any qubit 14 may be implemented as a logical qubit, which includes a grouping of physical qubits that are measured according to an error-correcting oracle that reliably reveals the quantum state of the logical qubit.
[0042] Topological quantum computer In a topological quantum computer, the quantum state held by each qubit is that of two or more braidable quasiparticles, or "anyons," observed in a non-Abelian topological phase of matter. World lines of different anyons are quantum mechanically forbidden from crossing or merging. This feature forces their paths to form stable braids that pass around each other in spacetime. Compared to the trapped particles used in other types of quantum computers, anyon braids are more resistant to quantum decoherence, a source of error in quantum computing. However, the realization of a topological quantum computer requires the ability to create suitable topological phases and manipulate anyons within them.
[0043] Early experiments in topological quantum computing focused on a two-dimensional "electron gas" of supercooled, thin layers of gallium arsenide (GaAs) sandwiched between layers of aluminum gallium arsenide (AlGaAs) and manipulated in strong magnetic fields. Implementing a quantum computer using that architecture requires the braiding of individual quasiparticle excitations combined with measurements based on anyon interferometry, which requires coherent quasiparticle transport over significant distances.
[0044] More recently, a one-dimensional topological qubit architecture has been proposed that may be more suitable for practical implementation. The proposed system uses a semiconductor-superconductor heterostructure in which superconductivity, strong spin-orbit coupling, and magnetic fields cooperate to form a topological superconducting state supporting the Majorana zero mode (MZM). This new architecture eliminates the need to move quasiparticles by employing a “measurement-only” method in which a series of measurements has the same effect as a braiding operation. This architecture does not require that quasiparticles be moved through an interference loop, but rather exploits the distinction between “fermion-parity-protected topological phases” (the actual genus of the proposed heterostructure) and true topological phases. Advantageously, the topological charge in the fermion-parity-protected topological phase can be manipulated by the process of electron tunneling into the MZM. Transport through a pair of MZMs can provide a measure of their combined topological charge in the presence of large charging energy.
[0045] In view of these and other useful properties, MZMs can be used as the basis for qubits in topological quantum computers. MZMs are created at the ends of semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures tuned into the topological regime by appropriate magnetic fields and gate voltages. A series of practical implementations are described in [1]. Suitable heterostructure materials and material properties are described in [2]. [Non-Patent Document 1] Karzig et al., Scalable Designs for Quasiparticle-Poisoning-Protected Topological Quantum Computation with Majorana Zero Modes, arXiv:1610.05289v4 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 21 Jun 2017 [Non-Patent Document 2] Lutchyn et al., Majorana Fermions and a Topological Phase Transition in Semiconductor-Superconductor Heterostructures, arXiv:1002.4033v2 [cond-mat.supr-con] 13 Aug 2010
[0046] An exemplary implementation includes at least two topological superconducting segments in the qubit, resulting in a total of at least four Majorana zero modes per qubit. In contrast to non-degenerate quantum computing architectures, where the two states of a qubit have different energies, the states used for quantum computing are the degenerate basis states of the qubit. The degeneracy of the qubit states and the spatial separation of the Majorana zero modes ensure long coherence times and the feasibility of precise application of a set of Clifford gates.
[0047] FIG. 4 shows an example of a topological qubit architecture that includes a linear tetron array 38. The linear tetron array includes segments 40 and 42 that include a classical superconductor such as aluminum (Al), a segment 44 that includes a semiconductor such as indium arsenide (InAs) or indium antimonide (InSb), and a number of MZMs 46. The length of the non-topological segments is l c is the corresponding coherence length ξ in the non-topological domain. c is much larger than the length of the topological segment l t is much larger than the coherence length ξ of the topological regime. The dashed box in Fig. 4 represents a single qubit in the form of a linear Tetron. Additional topological superconducting links and semiconductor structures allow suitable measurements to manipulate and entangle the linear Tetron.
[0048] Qubit structures such as that shown in Figure 4 are difficult to fabricate with the degree of reproducibility required for practical quantum computing. Due to material or fabrication defects, some candidate structures may not operate in the desired topological region. Even for candidate structures that do operate in the desired topological region, the appropriate terminal-bias and magnetic field levels required for qubit operation cannot necessarily be predicted a priori. Thus, candidate semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions must be “prescreened” for appropriate topological behavior, and successful heterojunctions must be “tuned” to find the appropriate operating parameters before being incorporated into a qubit register.
[0049] Overview of the method This disclosure provides a method for pre-screening and tuning candidate semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for topological qubits. The method includes a procedure for extracting the “topological gap” (described below) of the candidate heterojunctions using at least two stages of measurement followed by analysis. Measurements are performed on devices with three current-carrying contacts (one of which is superconducting) (herein “three-terminal devices”). The “mapping” phase of the method includes fast RF measurements that roughly identify promising regions. A subsequent “refinement” phase includes slower sub-RF (e.g., DC) measurements performed on each of the promising regions identified in the mapping phase. In some examples, the method uses a density-based clustering algorithm on two-sided zero-bias peak (ZBP) data to extract predicted topological regions and uses peak finding or machine learning to classify the bias traces. This improves the accuracy of previous methods by checking the stability of the ZBP against variations in the cutter gate voltage and checking for gap closure at the boundaries of the suspected topological regions. Meta-analysis of the ZBP data is used to extract the probability of finding a topological region across many devices of the same creation. This feature can be used to characterize the growth and / or fabrication methods for topological qubit structures.
[0050] As used herein, a "false positive" identifies a trivial system as topological, and a "false negative" identifies a topological system as trivial. The technique herein improves upon the basic ZBP search by including separate ZBP searches on both sides of the three-terminal device, thereby reducing the probability of false positives. It also includes nonlocal measurements to extract energy gaps in the candidate system, providing additional information for the detection of topological gaps. Finally, it includes non-discriminatory measurements in a region of the parameter space with predefined boundaries, thereby eliminating false positives that originate from confirmation bias and selection bias (which can arise if the measurement region is selected by a human).
[0051] FIG. 5 illustrates aspects of an exemplary semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction device 48 that has been evaluated according to the methods herein. In general terms, a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction suitable for testing will have at least three terminals supporting electronic admittance and conductance measurements in addition to multiple electrostatic control terminals. The device 48 of FIG. 5 is a three-terminal device with a topological intermediate segment 50 coupled to a grounded probe 52 through a trivial superconductor and two regular probes 54R and 54L coupled to opposite ends of the semiconductor wire. This geometry allows for simultaneous measurement of the tunneling signature of the topological phase at both ends of the intermediate segment 50 for correlation with the zero-bias features at both ends. Additionally, the nonlocal signal between the two regular probes provides information about the lowest energy of the extended state of the topological segment that can be used as a proxy for the topological gap (e.g., in a sufficiently long semiconductor wire, the nonlocal signal is set at a bias value corresponding to the lowest energy extended mode in the wire). Thus, the methods herein do not directly measure the topological properties of a system, but instead measure a set of proxy variables known to correlate well with topological invariants from analytical calculations and numerical simulations. The proxy criteria for identifying topologically non-trivial regions are as follows:
[0052] 1. Correlated zero-bias differential conductance peaks arise on both sides of the device through topological regions with well-separated Majoranas.
[0053] 2. For low magnetic field values, the bulk of the system is gapped. As the magnetic field is increased, the bulk gap closes and reopens in the topological regime. The value of the energy gap in the bulk of the wire can be detected in a three-terminal device via nonlocal conductance measurements.
[0054] Within regions in parameter space that meet the criteria for being topological, the magnitude of the bulk gap varies. The operational meaning of the term "topological gap" in the context of this disclosure is the magnitude of the largest bulk gap in such a topological region.
[0055] To be able to distinguish between topological and non-topological systems, the method must correctly identify topological regions in an idealized numerical test data set. Thus, the method herein exhibits high overlap between topologically identified regions and numerically determined topological indices (e.g., as shown in Figure 10). Furthermore, the method must correctly label currently known candidates for false positive signatures as non-topological. This includes:
[0056] 1. Trivial localized bound states induced by cutters, impurities, or smooth potentials (e.g., pairs of quasi-Majorana modes at the edge of a device). These are examples of non-topological zero-bias peaks.
[0057] 2. Disorder-induced low-energy subgap states (featuring a non-topological zero-bias peak and possible accidental gap closure / reopening).
[0058] 3. Trivial gap closure without proper reopening in finite-sized systems (e.g., Coulomb-blocked systems), where a finite-sized gap closes at small magnetic fields, giving rise to oscillations of low-energy states (false gap closure / reopening features).
[0059] 4. Trivial accidental closure-like features caused by a set of discrete states straddling zero energy (false gap closure / reopening features).
[0060] The way this method reduces such false positives is by using data collected over a wide range of parameter values. Accidental or tweaked points should not persist under parameter value changes, as the topological phase should persist. Furthermore, the method correlates different indicators of the topological phase. Both of the above criteria should be verified, i.e., the zero-bias conductance peaks must be present simultaneously at both ends, and the system must exhibit gap closure and reopening features in the nonlocal conductance. Considering these criteria, the above false positives can be correctly identified because:
[0061] 1. False positives 1 and 2 in the above enumeration lack the signature of gap closure / reopening in nonlocal conductance.
[0062] 2. False positives 3 and 4 lack correlated stable zero-bias peaks at both ends of the semiconductor wire.
[0063] The co-occurrence of different types of false positives is not expected to be stable to variations across the parameter space.
[0064] A remaining concern with this method is preventing false negatives, which is addressed further below. In particular, we provide a specifically constructed example that combines features 1 and 4 with a false positive region, along with an example for a strongly disordered system. Disorder can result in zero-bias peaks, but does not generally result in a broadening of the region of correlated ZBPs. A similar stability requirement rules out potential false positive 3 in the enumeration above.
[0065] The method is guided by the following principles.
[0066] 1. The method must ensure that both criteria listed above can be verified.
[0067] 2. It is necessary to measure as wide a range as possible of the device's parameter space for the following reasons:
[0068] a. There may be high initial uncertainty about the existence and location of topological phases.
[0069] b. Checking the stability of the zero-bias peak in parameter space helps to rule out possible false positives.
[0070] c. It reduces unwanted selection bias.
[0071] 3. The method should be completed in a reasonable amount of time (a few days at most) and should require minimal human judgment during its implementation.
[0072] 4. Nonlocal conductance measurements are currently much slower than local measurements and should be restricted to promising candidate regions so that the method can be completed in a reasonable time.
[0073] 5. For a given implementation of the method, the sequence of measurements should be predetermined and of finite length to prevent open-ended searches, which may take a long time and introduce selection bias, especially given a large parameter space. Nevertheless, the measurement sequence can be improved over time, for example by applying lessons learned from previous implementations.
[0074] 6. For a given implementation of the method, the data analysis procedures should be determined before the data are collected and examined, and should have predetermined outputs to avoid overfitting and confirmation bias and ensure that the method has results. Again, it is possible for data analysis code to be improved over time, for example, by using improved algorithms and applying lessons learned from previous implementations.
[0075] In light of the above considerations, Figure 6 illustrates aspects of an exemplary method 56 for evaluating semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer. The method 56 includes a mapping phase 58 and a refinement phase 60. In some examples, the mapping and refinement phases may be performed separately, for example, to evaluate a new experimental setup or implementation changes.
[0076] The mapping phase 58 and refinement phase 60 each involve measurements followed by analysis. The mapping phase involves high-speed RF measurements 62 of normal-superconductor (NS) junction admittances to provide mapping data. Measured quantities include local conductance at each end of the semiconductor wire across a wide parameter space in bias, field, plunger, and left or right cutter gate voltage. In some examples, the “mapping data” from measurements 62 includes two 5D data sets of RF signal versus field, left cutter, right cutter, plunger, and left or right bias. The associated data analysis 64 then looks for extended regions in the parameter space where correlated ZBPs exist. In some examples, the output 64 of the analysis includes a list of “promising” regions in the 4D parameter space (field, left cutter, right cutter, plunger), ranked by the likelihood that an unbroken topological phase with a finite topological gap exists within the region.
[0077] Each promising region thus identified is then further investigated in an iterative manner in a refinement phase 60. The refinement phase includes slower sub-RF measurements 66 of the full conductance matrix, including local and nonlocal conductances, in each promising region using a lock-in amplifier. In some examples, the "refined data" from the measurements 66 includes the full conductance matrix for each promising region as a function of bias. The associated data analysis 68 of the full conductance matrix, and in particular the nonlocal conductance, yields information on the behavior of the bulk gap to identify the region as topological according to the criteria described above. It is also possible to quantitatively evaluate the size of the gap in each topological region. In some examples, the analysis 68 includes the determination of the boundaries of the topological phase (or the absence of a topological phase) in each measured region based on a joint analysis of the local and nonlocal conductances. Furthermore, the value of the topological gap (if any) is determined for each region. In the refinement phase 60, measurements over promising regions may be repeated with adjusted range and resolution, but only under appropriate circumstances, e.g., not indefinitely. Thus, the refinement phase 60 may include a heavily regulated feedback loop that adjusts the bias range and / or resolution in the parameter space. The feedback loop may include, e.g., up to two iterations.
[0078] Upon completion of the refinement phase 60, a region having optimal properties of the topological phase is identified. The region may be defined, for example, by a combination of a large gap and a high degree of confidence in the topological properties. To further increase the confidence, an additional validation phase 70 may be optionally performed in which the stability of the optimal region is subjected to additional testing. In some examples, the validation phase 70 includes validating the ZBP in the region identified in the refinement phase 60 by checking the stability of the ZBP against variations in the cutter gate voltage. Such variations may be of any desired magnitude, including large variations. Furthermore, in examples where the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, the validation phase may include a meta-analysis of the ZBP data across the series. The meta-analysis may be performed to calculate the probability of finding the topological region in other similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions.
[0079] As mentioned above, the measurements in method 56 are performed on a three-terminal device, as shown in FIG. 5. Some constraints on the device to be measured will now be discussed with continued reference to that figure. The device 48 of FIG. 5 includes a semiconductor wire 72, typically a nanowire. In some implementations, the semiconductor wire may include a selective-area grown (SAG) nanowire. In the device 48, the semiconductor nanowire 72 is proximate by a superconductor 74. The superconductor extends laterally away from the hybrid wire. FIG. 5 shows a representative position of the MZM 75 in a scenario in which the device 48 is operating in the topological regime. The "T" shape of the superconductor is not necessary, and the width of the vertical superconducting section may extend over the entire length L of the device. Regular contacts 54R and 54L contact the semiconductor wire at each end of the device. Contacts 52 are bonded to the superconductor 74, making the device with three terminals suitable for electrical transport measurements. The entire device is covered in a dielectric layer (not shown). Electrostatic cutter gates 76R, 76L are used to create tunnel barriers at each end of the semiconductor wire 72. An electrostatic plunger gate 78 tunes the chemical potential within the device.
[0080] In the illustrated example, the important dimensions include:
[0081] L: maximum length of the topological region,
[0082] L S : the length of the superconducting segment connecting the topological region to the lead ground superconductor 74,
[0083] W: width W (or more generally cross-section) of semiconductor wire 72;
[0084] L C : the distance between the cutter gate 76 and the superconductor 74,
[0085] W C : Width of each cutter gate 76,
[0086] L N : the spacing between each cutter gate 76 and the associated normal lead 54.
[0087] The distance of the plunger gate 78 from the semiconductor wire 72 can be important to the potential profile and lever arm in the semiconductor wire, depending on the dielectric material used. Another variable is the geometry of the plunger gate 78 with respect to the semiconductor wire. If the plunger gate wraps around the semiconductor (wrap gate), the lever arm becomes larger and can significantly change the chemical potential in the semiconductor wire. Then, if the plunger gate is too tightly coupled to the semiconductor wire, a small voltage noise on the plunger gate can have a large effect and artificially spread the chemical potential in the semiconductor wire 72.
[0088] One of the most important parameters is the length L of the nearby semiconductor wires. Here, two effects compete with each other. On the one hand, the semiconductor wires need to be long enough to avoid finite size effects and to make the signature of the topological phase transition and the correlated ZBP clear. On the other hand, longer wires may increase the practical difficulty of growing or fabricating a functioning device and reduce the nonlocal signal. In particular, with increasing semiconductor wire length, it becomes more difficult to ensure sufficient uniformity in the semiconductor wire and to be free of strong defects (such as poor contacts to the superconductor that suppress the proximity effect). Very little data is currently available for devices longer than 2 μm. From a theoretical point of view, 5ξ, where ξ is the topological coherence length, presents the minimum length scale at which finite size effects are sufficiently suppressed. Even in clean wires, the nonlocal signal is suppressed with increasing length of the semiconductor wire. The above issues lead to a device quality-dependent upper limit on L for the successful extraction of nonlocal information.
[0089] Length L S is chosen so that leakage of quasiparticles into the central lead is suppressed. A practical estimate is L S >10ξ S where ξ S is the coherence length of the superconductor 74 (for disordered Al, L S = 200 nm). In a typical experiment, L S can reach the millimeter scale and thus exceed the minimum by several orders of magnitude.
[0090] Experimental evidence shows that to avoid spurious end states and enable high-resolution tunneling spectroscopy, the distance L to the cutter gate 76 is C This indicates that the thickness must be less than 100 nm. C The optimal choice for the cutter-gate design can be determined by combining simulations from electrostatics, realistic transport, and manufacturability. C <40 nm may be used. Note that the cutter design is based on the cutter width W C and the distance between the cutter and the normal lead. For InSb wires, it may be desirable to reduce the spacing between the cutter and the normal lead, since these wires are normally-off and the cutter must also open this segment of the wire.
[0091] It should be noted that the wire width parameter W is not necessarily critical for the feasibility of the disclosed method, but it does affect the likelihood of obtaining positive results from the method: for example, the width controls the number of channels, and numerical simulations show that fewer channels are beneficial for reaching a topological phase.
[0092] Table 1 summarizes current estimates for the various requirements on device geometries in terms of currently used materials, and gives estimated material-specific requirements for device dimensions. For these values, the following estimates for the coherence length at the point of maximum gap were used; ξ(InSb / Al)=400 nm, ξ(InAs / Al)=300 nm, and ξ S =200nm. [Table 1]
[0093] To obtain a system with a sufficiently large topological gap, a proper choice of materials is necessary. However, method 56 is agnostic to semiconductor wire materials. Although the material stack is still under investigation (both theoretically and experimentally), current results indicate that InAs with barrier materials and InSb without barriers are promising choices to obtain a topological gap in the favorable energy range. In some instances, a topological gap in the range of 25-200 μeV may be suitable to support the operation of a topological quantum computer. Narrower and wider ranges are also envisioned.
[0094] The current choice of superconductor is aluminum because it produces a hard induced gap in the heterostructure with no subgap states at zero magnetic field. Again, the method is largely agnostic to the choice of superconductor as long as the measurement parameters are adapted accordingly, e.g., by extending the bias scan range for larger gap superconductors or by adjusting the device dimensions based on the values shown in Table 1.
[0095] The choice of dielectric is highly dependent on the SAG material stack used. Hybrid systems limit the temperature to which a given material stack can be exposed. The maximum gate voltage that can be applied to the electrostatic gate before dielectric breakdown occurs (breakdown voltage V break) is a critical material quantity that is preferably known for a given dielectric layer and SAG material system since it imposes fundamental limitations on device operation. The breakdown voltage can be measured on a test device or determined by standard electrical characterization measurements. If experimentally feasible, a realistic V break To allow measurement of the .DELTA..times ...
[0096] 6, before a device is subjected to detailed measurements, the device may be qualified to determine that it meets a set of criteria. Thus, method 56 includes an initial qualification phase 80. The initial qualification phase may include preliminary evaluation of conductance, tunneling spectroscopy, and time stability, as described below.
[0097] The device conductance is the resistance through the device at a high bias voltage V bias,high The device is considered conductive if it is less than 25kΩ between all three terminals when measured at >2Δ, where Δ is the superconducting gap. For InSb-based devices, this may require initially opening the channel by applying a positive voltage to the cutter gate. For gate pinch-off, all gate resistances should be >500MΩ to ground. All gates (cutters) used to form the tunnel barrier must pinch off the device individually. To test for gate pinch-off, the conductance between the superconducting terminals and the corresponding normal terminals is measured as a function of the cutter gate voltage at high bias. 0.005e 2The device is considered pinched off when a conductance of less than 1 / h is reached. The plunger gates used to tune the chemical potential in the topological segments should be able to tune the conductance through the device to some extent. The effect of the plunger gates is most easily tested in the tunneling regime using tunneling spectroscopy, as described further below. Hysteresis in both the cutter and plunger gates may be acceptable, since all measurements can be performed in the same sweep direction. However, it is necessary that the state does not measurably shift in gate space after a hysteresis loop at either gate, as detailed below.
[0098] For tunneling spectroscopy, once the cutter gate is in place, the high bias conductance is 0.1e 2 Once tuned into a region where the order of 1000 kV / h, the conductance as a function of bias and gate voltage (plunger or tunnel gate) is measured at zero field. The peak in differential conductance versus bias should be clearly identifiable at bias around the expected induced superconducting gap and should not change position for small gate voltage changes (as the high-bias conductance does not change significantly). At zero field and energies below the superconducting gap, the number of finite conductance features should be low to reduce the probability of false positives. Ideally, the zero-field conductance trace should lack features of discrete subgap states. This can be quantified by requiring that the average subgap conductance be less than 1 / 4 of the high-bias conductance.
[0099] Regarding time stability, the high bias conductance should be stable in the tunneling region. This means that the conductance should be stable for a time scale of t = 10 min, with Δg ~ 0.2e 2This means that the device does not jump or drift more than 100 kΩ / h. Regarding the RF response, the resonance used for fast RF measurements should be identified for a particular device, for example by comparing the resonances in the open and pinch-off regions. For every terminal where fast measurements are required, a clear response of one resonance as a function of the corresponding tunnel gate should be visible. Effective impedance matching is required to obtain optimal sensitivity to conductance changes. Based on typical device resistances of the order of 100 kΩ or more and resonator inductance values of the order of 200 nH, the parasitic capacitance of the device should be less than 1 pF to allow high sensitivity.
[0100] Returning briefly to FIG. 6, measurements 62 of the mapping phase 58 may include benchmarking of electrical noise and energy spread. This step is valuable because the energy spread due to the measurement setup provides a lower limit for detectable topological gaps. To ensure that the spread due to electrical noise is negligible, the integrated voltage noise RMS amplitude between 1 Hz and 500 Hz should be smaller than 3 μV.
[0101] FIG. 7 shows aspects of an exemplary measurement setup for RF reflection measurements. In an RF reflection measurement, the sample is bonded to a transmission line via a resonator. The sample resistance changes the impedance match of the resonator to the transmission line, changing the reflection coefficient of the RF signal sent to the line. Each of the two normally conductive leads of the device are connected to a resonant frequency f for the left and right sides, respectively. l,res and f r,resThe resonators for RF reflection measurements are coupled to the resonators having a frequency difference between the left and right resonators, f = 100 Hz and f = 100 Hz. The frequency difference between these resonators on the left and right side should be larger than the linewidth of each resonator. An intermediate frequency (IF) source generates RF pulses within the frequency bandwidth of the readout system. These pulses are upconverted to the frequency range of the resonators coupled to the device. For this, a mixer with high (>30 dB) carrier suppression mixes the IF signal with a local oscillator (LO) signal. The LO frequency is set to a value within the bandwidth f of the acquisition system. ADC and both resonator frequencies f l,res and f r,res The frequency difference between
[0102] If the RF source does not have separate I and Q outputs, one of the upconverted sidebands must be filtered out. This is called f LO >max f l,res ,f r,res and the cutoff frequency is f LO This can be achieved by placing a low-pass filter between the upconversion mixer and the input port of the fridge. After the signal is reflected from the sample, it passes through a low-noise amplifier. It is then downconverted in the mixer using the original LO signal, low-pass filtered to the acquisition system bandwidth, and sent to the acquisition system input.
[0103] To measure the local conductance using RF reflection measurements, the reflected RF signal value must be calibrated against the directly measured differential conductance, for example with a low-frequency lock-in amplifier. This is a sample-dependent procedure that can be performed in parallel with the actual measurement and is therefore described below together with the measurement procedure.
[0104] To benefit from the fast acquisition speed, the gate and bias voltage scans on the device are triggered by hardware to minimize the time spent on software communication (typically on the order of 10 ns). This can be done with a hardware-triggered two-dimensional scan synchronized with the acquisition system. One voltage is ramped with a sawtooth function and sampled N times during each ramp, while the second voltage is at a slower rate during M cycles of the faster ramp, resulting in an N x M point scan. These voltage scans are applied on a low-pass filtered DC line to be compatible with the DC values of the voltages applied to the contacts and gates. The fastest ramp speed must be below the cutoff frequency of the low-pass filter at the fridge lines, typically 1 kHz.
[0105] Mapping Phase 58 in detail FIG. 8 shows additional aspects of measuring radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions to obtain mapping data. Method 62A of FIG. 8 shows fast measurement of local conductance by RF reflectometry, performed to satisfy the first of the two topological gap criteria mentioned above. This allows rapid characterization of the device and identification of candidate topological regions based on ZBP correlations. Identification of these regions sets the stage for nonlocal measurements in the refinement phase 60. Fast local measurements on three-terminal devices are closely related to fast measurements of conventional NS junctions.
[0106] At 82 of method 62A, the magnetic field is set to 0 T. At 84, for each side of the three terminal device, the reflected RF signal is measured as a function of frequency around the estimated resonant frequency (100 MHz for each side) at a large bias voltage (e.g., 1 mV). The corresponding cutter voltage is from the open channel set point (i.e., typically 0 V for InAs and 1 V for InSb) to 100 mV beyond the full pinch-off voltage. The resonant frequency f resis identified as the frequency at which the change in signal as a function of the cutter gate voltage is steepest, and tunn,res , the dip in the reflected signal as a function of frequency has the smallest absolute value.
[0107] At 86, the frequency is f res The cutter voltage range V is fixed at 100V and satisfies the following three conditions: c,min ~V c,max is determined.
[0108] a. This range is free of hysteresis as measured by the repeatability of measurements after the hysteresis loop.
[0109] b. The local conductance measured well above the superconducting gap (e.g., at 1 mV for Al) is less than 0.05 e 2 / h to 0.2e 2 / h.
[0110] c. The non-local conductance signal, measured via standard low-frequency lock-in amplifier techniques, is above the noise level.
[0111] For significant electrostatic crosstalk between the plunger and the cutter (geometry and material specificities), this step may be repeated for different values of the plunger-gate voltage.
[0112] At 88, the RF read power is optimized. In some examples, this involves finding a region in the cutter space that exhibits a clear gap with a well-defined coherence peak. To this end, the RF read power on each side is scanned and measured at the sample (bottom of the fridge) from -80 dBm to -130 dBm in 1 dB increments. For each RF power, a fast scan of the bias voltage is performed on each side from -1.5Δ0 to 1.5Δ0 (Δ0 is the gap of the parent superconductor, leading to a bias range of -350 μV to 350 μV for Al) with a maximum increment size of 5 μV, and the reflected RF signal is measured. For each side, the maximum RF power that does not broaden the features in the measurement, e.g., the coherence peaks, is found and set as the operating RF power.
[0113] At 90, the magnetic field angle is calibrated to be parallel to the semiconductor wire. To this end, the magnetic field is set to a value where the superconducting gap is not closed for fields parallel to the semiconductor wire, but is significantly reduced in size for fields perpendicular to the semiconductor wire, e.g. 500mT for InAs and InSb SAGs. The magnetic field angle is scanned around the value expected from the wire geometry, and for each value of angle, the bias on one side of the device is scanned from -1.5Δ0 to +1.5Δ0 (-350μV to +350μV for Al) with a maximum step size of 5μV. The reflected RF signal is then measured. The magnetic field angle is set to the angle that gives the maximum gap size. Here, the aim is an alignment accuracy of better than 2° in both azimuthal and polar angles.
[0114] The RF signal reflected from the superconductor at 92 was measured as a function of frequency to determine the maximum magnetic field B at which the superconductor bulk gap closes. max At 94, the magnetic field is changed from 0 T to B max The field is scanned in steps of 100 mT up to 100 mT. For each field value the following additional calibration is performed:
[0115] At 96, the optimum RF read frequency is determined. This can be done as a repetition of step 84. However, once the read frequency is identified, a quicker method can be followed. In one example, the cutter gate voltage is determined to be V at which the dip in the reflected RF signal as a function of frequency had the smallest absolute value at zero magnetic field. c,res The RF reflected signal is measured as a function of RF frequency, from 50 MHz to each side of the resonant frequency found for the current magnetic field value. The dip in the magnitude of the RF signal closest to the previously found dip is found and set as the RF readout frequency. The results of this measurement can be stored in a database.
[0116] At 98, an RF-DC calibration curve is measured. On each side, the bias voltage is set to a high bias (e.g., 1 mV for Al) to be above the superconducting gap. Each cutter gate voltage is scanned from the open channel set point (i.e., typically 0 V for InAs and 1 V for InSb) to 100 mV beyond the pinch-off voltage. For each cutter voltage, the local conductance is measured with a lock-in amplifier on each side, as well as the reflected RF signal. The results of this measurement are stored in a database for later establishing a calibration function between the reflected RF signal and the conductance.
[0117] At 100, the magnetic field is again set to 0 T. At 102, the magnetic field is increased from 0 T to B max The field is ramped in steps of ΔB until the field reaches 0. The field steps ΔB depend on the g-factor and are such that states moving with the field can be tracked. A reasonable range for an InAs or InSb SAG is 10 mT≦ΔB≦50 mT. For each value of the field, the following additional steps are performed:
[0118] At 104, the cutter gate potential is V c,min From V c,max Up to N, independently on each side c= 15 steps scanned, totaling 2N c Such independent scanning is justified for local conductance measurements when the extent of the cutter-gate scanning and the lever arm for cutter-plunger crosstalk are small enough not to change the effective plunger voltage by more than the size of the plunger voltage step. For each cutter-gate configuration, the following measurements are performed: c,min and V c,max will be decided at 86.
[0119] At 106, a fast scan of the plunger voltage and bias voltage is performed on each side. The plunger voltage is V p,max From V p,min The plunger limits are material specific and are determined by the upper and lower breakdown voltages (V break The resolution of the plunger scan needs to be sufficient to resolve the individual sub-gap states (lever arm dependent) across the gap. For each value of the plunger gate, the bias voltage at its terminal is scanned from -1.5Δ0 to +1.5Δ0 (-350μV to +350μV for Al) with a resolution of 5μV or better. The reflected RF signal is measured as a function of the plunger and bias voltages. The resulting 2D scans are stored in a database.
[0120] The mapping data generated as output of method 62A includes:
[0121] 1. A calibration data set consisting of two 2D cutter field scans, one for the left and one for the right side. For each point in this scan, three parameters are measured: the RF in-phase component, the RF out-of-phase component, and the conductance for each side.
[0122] 2. A measurement data set containing two 5D field-left cutter-right cutter-plunger-bias scans, where the bias scans are performed on the left and right. For each point in this scan, two parameters are measured: the RF in-phase component and the RF out-of-phase component.
[0123] The goal of data analysis at this stage is to identify promising regions in parameter space that are likely to contain an unbroken topological phase. Figure 9 illustrates further aspects of the analysis of mapping data to find one or more regions in parameter space that are consistent with an unbroken topological phase of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0124] At 108 of method 64A, the RF signal input is converted to conductance using a calibration data set to define a transfer function. At 110, each point in the (field, plunger, cutter) parameter space is calculated using the local conductance G of the respective left and right terminals from the bias trace measured at that point. ll , G rr As input, the conductance traces are classified as (potentially) topological or trivial. In one example, the classification may check for the presence of a ZBP in both conductance traces.
[0125] Analysis of the mapping data includes density-based clustering on the bilateral ZBP data. At 112, clusters of points classified as topological are found and clusters whose volume or shape in parameter space is deemed incompatible with a topological topology are filtered out. In some examples, the cluster volume must be greater than 0.03 V×T in plunger voltage-field space. Clusters that survive filtering are promising regions for the presence of a topological topology. In some examples, this step may be performed using density-based clustering for each 2D plunger-field scan, excluding regions that extend to zero field. At 114, promising regions are ranked by the likelihood that they contain a topological topology. In some examples, the ranking score is determined by the average plunger gate voltage of each cluster, with priority being associated with more negative gate voltages.
[0126] Figure 10 shows aspects of the analysis of mapping data by method 64A. The analysis is illustrated and verified using a simulated data set of an InSb / Al nanowire with length L = 3 μm and mean free path 3 μm. From left to right, as a function of plunger gate (in V) and magnetic field (in T), the figure shows: the topological index Q calculated from the scattering matrix; a binary array where 1 corresponds to ZBPs present on both sides of the device; and the clustered ZBP Boolean data with cluster colors corresponding to the corresponding cluster scores (smaller corresponds to better). With such data, it is possible to find regions containing true topological regions for further analysis.
[0127] The results of the data analysis performed in the mapping phase 58 of the method 56 determine the measurements to be performed in the subsequent refinement phase 60. For each promising region in the ranking above, the range of field, plunger and cutter values surrounding that region are specified as input for the refinement phase. In some examples, the refinement phase may be performed on the various identified regions in the ranking order. It is necessary to minimize the latency between the end of measurements in the mapping phase and the start of measurements in the refinement phase in order to minimize the effects of gate drift, gate jump and other issues that may occur while the device is idle. For this reason, it is important that the data analysis outlined above is performed in a time-efficient manner. The raw data generated in the RF measurement phase can be very large, with existing RF datasets of this kind exceeding 100 GB in total size, and reduction and analysis taking several hours. Thus, to avoid bottlenecks in the execution of the method, it is important that a data pipeline is in place to make the data quickly available for analysis on the computational cluster. Note that the implementation of the pipeline may require different solutions for measurements made at different sites. Data acquisition, transfer and analysis should also be parallelized wherever possible: for example, the first step of the data analysis outlined above requires individual bias traces as input and can therefore be performed in parallel with data acquisition.
[0128] Refinement Phase 60 Details The differential conductance of the device under evaluation can be measured using standard low-frequency lock-in amplifier techniques, as shown in Figure 11. The total conductance matrix is calculated for two different AC excitation frequencies, f l and f r are used to apply a DC bias voltage V bias,l / r and AC voltage δV l / rThese frequencies must be below the low-pass filter cutoff in the system and low enough to minimize parasitic capacitance effects. To ensure this, the phase shift of the current with respect to the voltage excitation must be less than 10°. The in-phase AC currents δI flowing in the left or right direction l / r is measured with the intermediate superconducting lead connected to ground. To suppress spurious voltage divider effects, the connection to ground needs to be low resistance compared to the resistance of the other two lines (i.e. typically less than a few kΩ). For this purpose, a low-pass filter may be designed accordingly or the superconducting lead may be grounded at PCB level (cold ground).
[0129] This three-terminal setup allows us to measure all four elements of the conductance matrix G between the left (l) and right (r) terminals:
number
[0130] Conductance matrix element G ll =dI l / dV l , G rr =dI r / dV r is called the "local conductance" and G lr =dI l / dV r , G rl =dI l / dV r is called the "nonlocal conductance".
[0131] The input for the refinement measurement 66 includes regions in (cutter gate, plunger gate, field) space that are candidates for further investigation. The size of the regions in plunger gate / field space may, in some instances, be increased by 20% to ensure that the refinement measurement fully captures the topological phase transition surrounding each region.
[0132] 12 illustrates further aspects of measuring the sub-RF conductance of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of one or more mapped regions of parameter space to obtain refinement data. In particular, method 66A describes local and nonlocal conductance measurements suitable for extracting the energy gap of a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
[0133] At 116 of method 66A, the magnetic field is set to the minimum magnetic field value in the candidate region. To observe whether the induced gap closes in the candidate region, this magnetic field should be small enough that the induced gap is still open. At 118, the cutter gate is set to, for example, its median value in the candidate region. At 120, V L and V R A correction is applied for the small bias voltage offset of V (see Figure 11) to ensure that the extraction of the antisymmetric components of the local and nonlocal signals is straightforward. This is because L -V R The summed absolute current value in parameter space (|I L |+|I R This can be achieved by finding the minimum of |. At 122 the magnetic field is ramped in the candidate region in steps of ΔB. For each value of the field, a bias-plunger scan is performed as described immediately below.
[0134] At 124, the plunger voltage is calculated based on the maximum plunger voltage (V p,max ) The plunger voltage is set to V max The minimum plunger voltage V within the region searched from p,min ΔV pIn another example, the plunger voltage may be scanned in the opposite direction. For each plunger voltage value, the bias voltage at the left terminal is scanned from -50μV to +50μV in 5μV increments. If the data indicates that the topological gap is outside this window, the scan is repeated with a larger window size. The resulting 2D scan is stored in a database.
[0135] The refined data generated by the slower full conductance matrix measurements is a data set for each candidate region. Each data set consists of two 3D field-plunger-bias scans, where the bias is scanned separately on the left and right sides. For each point in the scan, two parameters are measured: left and right conductance. In some instances, each conductance may include the complete conductance matrix for the corresponding side of the device.
[0136] 13 illustrates additional aspects of finding unbroken topological phase boundaries and topological gaps of semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions in parameter space by analysis of refinement data for at least one of the one or more regions of parameter space queried in method 66A. In some examples, the illustrated method is performed iteratively for each promising region in turn.
[0137] At 126 of method 68A, step 110 of method 64A is repeated to verify that the measured regions are still promising, and potentially to adjust the boundaries of the candidate topological regions. At this point, analysis of the refinement data includes verifying gap closure at the boundaries of each of the one or more regions of parameter space. At 128, a check is made to determine what fraction of the boundaries of the promising regions are gapless based on the non-local conductance signal. At 130, the size of the gap Δ for each point i in region j is calculated. (j)is extracted by thresholding the nonlocal conductance. At 132, a score is assigned to the region based on the extent of the gapless boundary and the value of the gaps in the candidate topological region. The score reflects the likelihood that the promising region is indeed topological and gapped. In some examples, the score S is i =X median i (x (j) ) In 134, the largest gap in each topological region is obtained, along with an estimate of the error. In some instances, the error bar is determined by the uncertainty in the thresholding of the nonlocal conductance at the point of the largest gap.
[0138] The output of this analysis includes a set of probabilities corresponding to the regions identified in the mapping phase 58 of method 56, i.e., the probability of hosting an unbroken topological topology. Each probability is associated with the largest (topological) gap in each (non-trivial) region. Figure 14 shows aspects of the analysis of refined data by method 68A, using the same simulation as in Figure 10. From left to right: gaps extracted from the non-local data; the score of the ZBP cluster defined by the average gap in the region times the proportion of gapless boundaries; and the score of the ZBP cluster, as in the middle figure, but with the average gap replaced by the median gap in the region. The largest gap in the region is 175 μeV. Thus, the overall output of method 56 is an estimate of the value of the topological gap in each promising region and its position in the explored parameter space.
[0139] Detailed examples of false positives and false negatives One possible problem with quasi-Majoranas is that they may arise as precursors of true topological regions. This means that a topological region may be directly adjacent (in parameter space) to a non-topological quasi-Majorana regime. In that case, the current algorithms that cluster regions of correlated ZBPs may identify regions that are too large in the mapping phase. In other words, while including a topological region, the identified region may extend much farther, including parts of the quasi-Majorana regime. In that case, the current analytical setup in the refinement phase fails by either identifying too much of the parameter space as topological or by not recognizing a topological region due to the lack of gap closing / reopening in the quasi-Majorana regime.
[0140] The solution to this problem is to implement another clustering algorithm in the refinement phase that identifies lines of gap closure-reopening features in parameter space (specifically field-plunger space) and then determines the intersections of these lines with regions of correlated ZBPs to find the topological topology. Note that this is primarily a data analysis problem in the refinement phase. The mapping phase is still good for identifying promising regions of the data, which are then examined in more detail in the refinement phase.
[0141] Unstable behavior in data analysis can result from cutting the data for a fixed cutter voltage. Stability can be improved by using one or both cutter gate potentials as additional dimensions in refined data analysis 68. This should improve clustering and make better use of the available data set.
[0142] The next example deals with the smooth potential at the end of a semiconductor wire, which is associated with quasi-Majorana and false negatives. The presence of long-range inhomogeneities (smooth potential variations) can make it more difficult to observe gap closing / reopening features and lead to false negatives. Interestingly, smooth potential variations are also the regime where quasi-Majorana modes are expected. Here we discuss the interplay between the two effects.
[0143] A typical scenario in which quasi-Majorana modes emerge is when a system is close to the topological phase but is tuned out of it. For concreteness, let us say that at a fixed magnetic field, the chemical potential μ is tuned to the critical chemical potential μ required to enter the topological phase. C Consider a smaller example. The smooth potential variation can be interpreted as a spatially varying chemical potential μ(x)=μ0V(x), where V(x) is the potential. In the above scenario, as shown in Fig. 15, a potential dip close to the end of the semiconductor wire (here on the right) locally pushes the system into the topological regime μ(x)>μ C to , which leads to a local Majorana mode pair. The latter manifests itself in the local conductance at the right end at much lower magnetic fields as a topological phase transition in the bulk of the semiconductor wire (which can be read off via the local conductance at the other end (left end) where there are no smooth potential variations).
[0144] Figure 15 shows the effect of a smooth potential at the right end of the semiconductor wire in a 1D model. Left: spatial dependence of the potential of the semiconductor wire (lower panel) and the position of the superconducting shell (orange, upper panel) implemented via the self-energy. Right: conductance matrix including the antisymmetric part of the nonlocal conductance. Note that the nonlocal conductance has no gap reopening feature. The only feature of a phase transition is the onset of weak Majorana oscillations.
[0145] Specifically, in the example of FIG. 15, the phase transition at a fixed chemical potential is
number
number
[0146] In conclusion, quasi-Majorana modes at the ends of semiconductor wires do not lead to false positive features in the nonlocal conductance, but once the system is tuned to a topological phase, the presence of quasi-Majorana modes increases the probability of false negatives.
[0147] The second example deals with a smooth potential at the center of a semiconductor wire, related to a false positive. Here we discuss the only example where it is possible to have ZBPs at both ends of a semiconductor wire, and thus to have non-trivial features in the non-local conductance that could be interpreted as gap closure (and potentially reopening), but where the bulk of the system is confirmed to be non-topological.
[0148] The setup is depicted in Fig. 16. The bulk of the semiconductor wire is tuned to be non-topological, while the smooth potential bump in the center of the semiconductor wire reaches the topological regime of the potential. We can therefore consider a pair of Majorana zero modes nucleating in the center of the semiconductor wire. The central region is chosen to be too small for well-separated Majorana modes, but the smoothness of the potential can lead to a closely spaced, but weakly coupled, quasi-Majorana mode in the center of the semiconductor wire.
[0149] Due to finite size effects, the corresponding zero modes can be probed as correlated ZBPs in the conductance at each end, as shown in Fig. 16. Moreover, since the low-energy modes at the center overlap with both sides, they also contribute to the nonlocal conductance, which can be misinterpreted as gap closure.
[0150] Figure 16 shows the effect of a smooth potential at the center of the semiconductor wire in a 1D model. Left: spatial dependence of the potential of the semiconductor wire (lower panel) and the position of the superconducting shell (orange, upper panel) implemented via the self-energy. Right: conductance matrix including the antisymmetric part of the nonlocal conductance. Note that due to finite size effects, the quasi-Majorana modes nucleated in the central regions are visible as correlated ZBPs and also contribute to the nonlocal conductance.
[0151] Figure 17 shows the data analysis on the field / plunger parameter space of the GAP method for a 1D model with a potential bump in the center of a semiconductor wire. Left: detected ZBPs, right: gaps determined from the data. In this case, the ZBP finder detects two overlapping regions, one centered at plunger=0 (bulk topological region) and one centered at plunger=0.0025 (central bump topological). It is unclear whether this case represents a false positive (outside the bulk topological region) since there is a small topological region in the center and finite size effects are prominent. Indeed, finite size effects lead to gap closure signatures for each region (central and bulk) in the estimated gaps extracted from the data.
[0152] This problematic example illustrates the value of continued development of the data analysis used in the methods herein. Note that the ZBP clustering algorithm identified both regions (center and bulk) as a single region. This example illustrates how non-topological regions adjacent to topological regions can be relatively difficult to separate and may require further refinement in data analysis.
[0153] The third example concerns non-topological ZBPs due to strong disorder. Here, we show an example of a one-dimensional model with strong disorder. To illustrate, Figure 18 shows the data analysis on the field / plunger parameter space of a strongly disordered 1D model. Left: points of correlated ZBPs (red), right: extracted gaps at each point in the parameter space. Although ZBPs are present, the data in Figure 18 show that the regions of correlated ZBPs are sparse and mostly disjoint. Thus, strongly disordered regions can be excluded by the gap method by adding requirements on the size and continuity of the identified regions.
[0154] Apparatus and Additional Methods Although the features and examples disclosed herein relate to methods for evaluating semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer, such features and examples are also applicable to related apparatus. FIG. 19 illustrates aspects of an exemplary apparatus 136 configured to evaluate semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer. The apparatus has a controller 18B. The controller includes at least one processor 20B and computer memory 22B operatively coupled to the processor. The computer memory is configured to hold instructions 24B that cause the processor to perform various measurement and analysis methods described herein. To this end, the processor may be operatively coupled to an RF admittance measurement device 138 and a sub-RF conductance measurement device 140. The RF admittance measurement device may include features as shown in FIG. 7, and the sub-RF conductance measurement device may include features as shown in FIG. 11. In the illustrated example, the device 136 includes an interface 142 that couples the processor to the measurement device and also provides control signals to the electrostatic gate and magnet 144 of the device 48 .
[0155] The features and examples disclosed herein relate equally to methods for constructing a topological quantum computer. Figure 20 illustrates aspects of an exemplary method 146 for constructing a topological quantum computer.
[0156] At 148 of the method 146, a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction having at least three terminals configured to support electronic admittance testing is fabricated. At 62, an RF junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is measured to obtain mapping data. At 64, the mapping data is analyzed to find one or more regions of parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. At 66, a sub-RF conductance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is measured in each of the one or more regions of parameter space to obtain refinement data. At 68, the refinement data is analyzed to find a boundary of an unbroken topological phase in parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of parameter space. At 150, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is incorporated into a qubit register of a topological quantum computer if the found boundary and topological gap are each within a predetermined range. In the operation of a topological quantum computer constructed in this way, one or more values characterizing the boundaries in the parameter space can be used as tuning parameters to address semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions in a qubit register.
[0157] For additional context, the following references are provided:
[0158] [Non-Patent Document 3] T. ¨O Rosdahl, A. Vuik, M. Kjaergaard, and AR Akhmerov, Andreev rectifier: A nonlocal conductance signature of topological phase transitions, Phys. Rev. B97, 045421 (2018)
[0159] [Non-Patent Document 4] Jeroen Danon, Anna Birk Hellenes, Esben Bork Hansen, Lucas Casparis, Andrew P. Higginbotham, and Karsten Flensberg、Nonlocal conductance spectroscopy of Andreev bound states: Symmetry relations and BCS charges, arXiv:1905.05438 [cond-mat] (2019), arXiv:1905.05438 [cond-mat]
[0160]
Direct Environment 5
[0161]
Outdoor Configuration6
[0162] [Non-Patent Document 7] MITEQ AFS4-00100800-14-10P-4
[0163] conclusion In conclusion, certain aspects of the present disclosure are directed to a method of characterizing a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer, the method including: measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data; analyzing the mapping data to find one or more regions of a parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction; measuring a sub-RF conductance, including a nonlocal conductance, of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data; and analyzing the refinement data to find a boundary of an unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space.
[0164] In some implementations, analyzing the mapping data includes density-based clustering of zero-bias peak data from both ends of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. In some implementations, the method further includes validating a zero-bias peak (ZBP) in each of the one or more regions by checking stability of the ZBP to variations in cutter gate voltage. In some implementations, analyzing the refined data includes verifying gap closure at the boundaries of each of the one or more regions of parameter space. In some implementations, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, and the method further includes meta-analysis of zero-bias peak data across the series to calculate a probability of finding a topological region in other similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions. In some implementations, measuring the sub-RF conductance includes performing local and nonlocal conductance measurements suitable for extracting an energy gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. In some implementations, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction comprises a semiconductor wire and at least three terminals supporting admittance and conductance measurements at opposing ends of the semiconductor wire, hi some implementations, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction comprises a plurality of electrostatic control terminals.
[0165] Another aspect of the present disclosure is directed to an apparatus configured to characterize a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer, the apparatus comprising: a controller having a processor and a computer memory operatively coupled to the processor, the controller configured to perform the steps of: measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data; finding one or more regions of a parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction by analysis of the mapping data; measuring a sub-RF conductance, including a nonlocal conductance, of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data; and finding a boundary of the unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space by analysis of the refinement data.
[0166] In some implementations, the controller is configured to analyze the mapping data using density-based clustering on zero-bias peak data from both ends of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. In some implementations, the controller is further configured to validate a zero-bias peak (ZBP) in each of the one or more regions by checking stability of the ZBP to variations in cutter gate voltage. In some implementations, the controller is configured to analyze the refined data by verifying gap closure at the region boundaries of each of the one or more regions of parameter space. In some implementations, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, and the controller is configured to meta-analyze zero-bias peak data across the series to calculate a probability of finding a topological region in another similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. In some implementations, the apparatus is operatively coupled to an RF admittance measurement apparatus and a sub-RF conductance measurement apparatus.
[0167] Another aspect of the present disclosure is directed to a method for constructing a topological quantum computer, the method including: fabricating a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction having at least three terminals configured to support electronic admittance testing; measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data; finding one or more regions of a parameter space consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction by analysis of the mapping data; measuring a sub-RF conductance including a nonlocal conductance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data; finding a boundary of the unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space by analysis of the refinement data; and incorporating the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction into a qubit register of a topological quantum computer if the found boundary and topological gap are within respective predefined ranges.
[0168] In some implementations, the analysis of the mapping data includes density-based clustering of zero-bias peak data from both ends of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction. In some implementations, the method further includes validating a zero-bias peak (ZBP) in each of the one or more regions by checking stability of the ZBP to variations in cutter gate voltage. In some implementations, the analysis of the refinement data includes verifying gap closure at a boundary of each of the one or more regions in a parameter space. In some implementations, the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, and the method further includes meta-analysis of zero-bias peak data across the series to calculate a probability of finding a topological region in other similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions. In some implementations, one or more values characterizing the boundary in a parameter space are used as tuning parameters for addressing the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in a qubit register.
[0169] Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to a two-stage approach towards the extraction of topological phases. Importantly, this includes separation by stage, where the mapping phase allows for broad exploration of the parameter space while still generating false positives, and the refinement stage allows for slow scanning of regions of interest from the mapping phase to remove false positives. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to the use of density-based clustering algorithms on the two-sided ZBP data to extract predicted topological regions. Importantly, this includes the clustering algorithm used for this purpose. This appears to be the first systematic approach to discover promising regions. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to a mapping between RF and DC conductance for the purpose of fast conductance extraction in RF measurements. Importantly, this includes the use of said mapping to bypass DC conductance measurements, yet extract the same data much faster due to the faster RF technique. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to classification of bias traces using peak finding or machine learning. Importantly, this includes machine learning of topological traces and statistical characterization of how good the peak finding is. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to extracting the gaps from non-local conductance traces, particularly with experimental noisy bias traces or by filtering and smoothing bias / field scans. Importantly, this includes automatic gap extraction. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to improving the accuracy of previous methods by checking for gap closure at the boundaries of suspected topological regions. Importantly, this includes application of the extraction of the gaps from the data to classify regions into topological / trivial regions. Another aspect of this disclosure is directed to meta-analysis of ZBP data to extract the probability of finding a topological region across many devices of the same creation. This can be used to characterize growth / fabrication methods via topological phase diagrams.Another aspect of the present disclosure is directed to using any of the above to tune up qubits in a topological quantum computer.
[0170] It will be understood that the configurations and / or approaches described herein are exemplary in nature, and that these specific embodiments or examples should not be considered in a limiting sense, as many variations are possible. The specific routines or methods described herein may represent one or more of any number of processing strategies. Thus, the various steps shown and / or described may be performed in the sequence shown and / or described, in other sequences, in parallel, or omitted. Similarly, the order of the processes described above may be altered.
[0171] The subject matter of the present disclosure includes all novel and non-obvious combinations and subcombinations of the various processes, systems, and configurations, as well as other features, functions, steps, and / or properties disclosed herein, and all equivalents thereof.
Claims
1. 1. A method for evaluating a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer, the method being performed by a controller having a processor and a computer memory operatively coupled to the processor, the method comprising: measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data; analyzing the mapping data to find one or more regions in parameter space that are consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction; measuring sub-RF conductance, including nonlocal conductance, of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data; and finding, by analysis of the refined data, boundaries of the unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space. method.
2. The method of claim 1 , wherein the analysis of the mapping data comprises density-based clustering of zero bias peak data from both ends of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
3. 2. The method of claim 1, further comprising validating a zero bias peak (ZBP) in each of the one or more regions by checking stability of the ZBP against variations in cutter gate voltage.
4. The method of claim 1 , wherein the analysis of the refinement data includes verifying gap closure at a boundary of each of the one or more regions of the parameter space.
5. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, the method further comprising meta-analysis of zero-bias peak data across the series to calculate the probability of finding a topological region in other similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions.
6. The method of claim 1 , wherein measuring the sub-RF conductance comprises performing local and non-local conductance measurements suitable for extracting the energy gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
7. 10. The method of claim 1, wherein the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction comprises a semiconductor wire and at least three terminals supporting admittance and conductance measurements at both ends of the semiconductor wire.
8. The method of claim 1 , wherein the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction has a plurality of electrostatic control terminals.
9. fabricating a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction having at least three terminals configured to support electronic admittance testing; If the boundary and topological gap found are within respective predetermined ranges, incorporating the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction into a qubit register of the topological quantum computer. The method of claim 1.
10. 1. An apparatus configured to evaluate a semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for use in a qubit register of a topological quantum computer, the apparatus comprising: A controller having a processor and a computer memory operatively coupled to the processor, the controller comprising: measuring a radio frequency (RF) junction admittance of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction to obtain mapping data; analyzing the mapping data to find one or more regions in parameter space that are consistent with an unbroken topological phase of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction; measuring sub-RF conductance, including nonlocal conductance, of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction in each of the one or more regions of the parameter space to obtain refinement data; and finding, by analysis of the refined data, boundaries of the unbroken topological phase in the parameter space and a topological gap of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction for at least one of the one or more regions of the parameter space. Device.
11. 11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the controller is configured to analyze the mapping data using density-based clustering on zero bias peak data from both ends of the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
12. 11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the controller is further configured to validate a zero bias peak (ZBP) in each of the one or more regions by checking stability of the ZBP against variations in cutter gate voltage.
13. The apparatus of claim 10 , wherein the controller is configured to analyze the refinement data by verifying gap closure at a boundary of each of the one or more regions of the parameter space.
14. 11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction is one of a series of similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunctions, and the controller is configured to meta-analyze zero bias peak data across the series to calculate a probability of finding a topological region in another similarly fabricated semiconductor-superconductor heterojunction.
15. The apparatus of claim 10 , wherein the apparatus is operatively coupled to an RF admittance measurement apparatus and a sub-RF conductance measurement apparatus.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Universal topological quantum computers based on majorana nanowire networks
US20170141287A1
Form and fabrication of semiconductor-superconductor nanowires and quantum devices based thereon
US20200027030A1
