Information sharing system, information sharing method, analysis device

The information sharing system anonymizes and analyzes data from multiple organizations based on trust levels to address secure and reliable information exchange challenges, enhancing cybersecurity by preventing sensitive information leakage and maintaining trust scores.

JP7596564B2Active Publication Date: 2024-12-09HITACHI LTD
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023570625
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-12-28
Publication Date
2024-12-09
Estimated Expiration
2041-12-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing information sharing technologies struggle to facilitate secure and reliable information exchange among multiple organizations, particularly in the context of cybersecurity, where diverse cyber threats require collective defense strategies, and there is a risk of sensitive information leakage.

Method used

An information sharing system that anonymizes and analyzes data from multiple organizations based on trust levels, using a concealment processing unit, analysis unit, and information transmitting unit to ensure secure and reliable information exchange.

Benefits of technology

Enables safe and efficient information sharing among multiple organizations by maintaining data confidentiality and updating trust scores based on data contribution and analysis results, preventing information leakage and ensuring reliable data utilization.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007596564000001
    Figure 0007596564000001
  • Figure 0007596564000002
    Figure 0007596564000002
  • Figure 0007596564000003
    Figure 0007596564000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This information sharing system comprises: a concealment processing unit for concealing information collected from one or more of a plurality of organizations on the basis of the degree of trust between the organizations; an analysis unit for performing analysis by using the information concealed by the concealment processing unit and analysis logic collected from one or more of the plurality of organizations; and an information transmission unit for transmitting an analysis result produced by the analysis unit to one or more of the plurality of organizations to share the same between the organizations.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a system, method and apparatus for sharing information among multiple organizations. [Background technology]

[0002] In the field of information processing, it has been common for each organization to process information individually using various information held by each organization. However, there are limitations to the various processes and measures that can be taken using information held by a single organization. For this reason, in recent years, the use of systems that share information between multiple organizations has been promoted in order to obtain more beneficial effects.

[0003] For example, in the field of cybersecurity, as cyberattacks by attackers become more diverse and sophisticated, it is becoming difficult for each organization to adequately prevent the threat of cyberattacks using only the information they possess. As a result, as one of the measures against cyberattacks, multiple organizations are sharing and using the cyberattack information they each possess among themselves to improve the security systems of each organization. In fact, public organizations such as the Information-technology Promotion Agency, Japan (IPA) and the Information Sharing and Analysis Center (ISAC) are working on such information sharing among multiple organizations.

[0004] Although efforts toward information sharing are being made in this way, there are issues that hinder the promotion of information sharing due to the risk of information being leaked, the possibility that the information being shared may contain sensitive information of each organization, etc. To solve this problem, a technology has been proposed that evaluates the trustworthiness of the sharing destination and uses this to share information.

[0005] For example, the technology of Patent Document 1 below is known regarding transactions using trustworthiness (credit score) via the Internet. Patent Document 1 describes an object of facilitating transactions of transaction objects via the Internet, in which a credit score is obtained based on the online behavior of a seller who sells a transaction object, and if the seller's credit score meets a predetermined condition, a part or the entire sales price of the transaction object is provided to the seller from the time the transaction object is put up for sale until the purchaser of the transaction object registers receipt of the transaction object. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0006] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2021-18587 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0007] The technology described in Patent Document 1 promotes transactions by obtaining a credit score of a seller and providing a part or the entire sales fee of the transaction subject only if the credit score meets certain conditions. However, Patent Document 1 only assumes one-to-one transactions, and does not assume one-to-multiple organization transactions. Therefore, it cannot be used to share information with multiple organizations.

[0008] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above, and aims to provide a technology that can realize information sharing with multiple organizations based on trust. [Means for solving the problem]

[0009] The information sharing system according to the present invention includes a concealment processing unit that conceals information collected from one or more of a plurality of organizations based on the degree of trust between the organizations, an analysis unit that performs analysis using the information concealed by the concealment processing unit and analysis logic collected from one or more of the plurality of organizations, and an information transmission unit that transmits the analysis results by the analysis unit to one or more of the plurality of organizations to share the results among the organizations. The information sharing method according to the present invention comprises: By computer, Collect information from one or more of the multiple organizations, and By the computer The information is anonymized based on the degree of trust between each organization, and the anonymized information and analysis logic collected from any one or more of the multiple organizations are used to perform the analysis. The above The analysis is carried out by computer. The computer The results of the analysis are sent to one or more of the multiple organizations to be shared among the organizations. The analysis device according to the present invention includes an analysis unit that performs analysis using information of one or more of a plurality of organizations that has been anonymized based on the degree of trust between the organizations and analysis logic collected from one or more of the plurality of organizations, and an information transmission unit that transmits the analysis results by the analysis unit to one or more of the plurality of organizations to share the results among the organizations. The details of at least one implementation of the subject matter disclosed herein are set forth in the accompanying drawings and the description below. Other features, aspects, and advantages of the disclosed subject matter will become apparent from the following disclosure, drawings, and claims. Effect of the Invention

[0010] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a technique that enables information sharing with multiple organizations based on the degree of trust. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0011] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is an example of an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system according to a first embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of the configuration of the transmitting device and the receiving device. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a diagram illustrating an example of a configuration of the analysis device. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating an example of a data structure of the masking policy. [Diagram 5] FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of a data structure of the logic information table. [Figure 6] FIG. 6 is a diagram illustrating an example of a data structure of the organization information table. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is a diagram illustrating an example of a data structure of the confidence score table. [Figure 8] FIG. 8 is a diagram illustrating an example of a data structure of the reliability table. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 is a diagram illustrating an example of the data structure of the anonymization definition table. [Figure 10] FIG. 10 is an example of a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system according to the first embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is an example of a flowchart of a process for updating reliability information from an analysis requesting organization to an information sharing organization. [Figure 12] FIG. 12 is an example of a flowchart of a process for calculating a trust score from an information sharing organization to an analysis requesting organization. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of the analysis request screen. [Figure 14] FIG. 14 is a diagram showing an example of the analysis result display screen. [Figure 15] FIG. 15 is a diagram showing an example of the organization information editing screen. [Figure 16] FIG. 16 is an example of an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system according to the second embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 17] FIG. 17 is an example of an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system according to the third embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 18]FIG. 18 is an example of a flowchart showing a case where it is determined that analysis is necessary in the overall processing of the information sharing system according to the third embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 19] FIG. 19 is an example of a flowchart showing a case where it is determined that analysis is not necessary in the overall processing of the information sharing system relating to the third embodiment of the present invention, and information related to the shared information held within one's own organization is returned to the information providing organization. [Figure 20] FIG. 20 is an example of an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 21] FIG. 21 is an example of a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 22] FIG. 22 is an example of a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system according to the fifth embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0012] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. In this embodiment, the same components are generally designated by the same reference numerals, and repeated explanations are omitted. Note that this embodiment is merely an example for realizing the present invention, and does not limit the technical scope of the present invention.

[0013] (First embodiment) An information sharing system according to a first embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to Figures 1 to 15. In the information sharing system of this embodiment, when information is shared between a plurality of organizations (e.g., companies, business establishments, schools, etc.) connected to each other via a network, information collected from one or more of the organizations is anonymized by an analysis device, analyzed, and the analysis results are shared between the organizations, thereby realizing secure information sharing between the multiple organizations.

[0014] In the following embodiment, an example will be described in which a computer executes a program to realize the functions of the information sharing system of the present invention, but similar functions may be realized by hardware logic. The program may be one that is pre-stored in the computer, or one that is installed in the computer from a device equipped with an external non-transitory storage medium via a network or via a portable non-transitory storage medium.

[0015] Fig. 1 is an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system 1 according to a first embodiment of the present invention. The information sharing system 1 shown in Fig. 1 is configured by connecting a plurality of organizations, each having a transmitting device 101 and a receiving device 102, and an organization having an analyzing device 104 to the Internet 106 via networks 103 and 105. The networks 103 and 105 may be, for example, a wired LAN (Local Area Network) or a wireless LAN, or may be a global network. The Internet 106 is a type of global network that relays communications between the organizations, and the communication method is not important.

[0016] The transmitting device 101 of each of the organizations A, B, and C requests the analyzing device 104 of the organization D to perform analysis by transmitting information required for analysis (hereinafter referred to as analytical information) held by each of the organizations and information indicating the reliability between the organizations. Meanwhile, the receiving device 102 of each of the organizations A, B, and C receives the analysis result transmitted from the analyzing device 104. In response to an analysis request from any of the organizations A, B, and C, the analyzing device 104 collects the analytical information transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of each organization, and performs analysis after concealing the collected analytical information. The analysis result by the analyzing device 104 is transmitted from the organization D to each of the organizations A, B, and C, and is received by the receiving device 102 of each organization. In this way, information sharing between multiple organizations is performed in the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment.

[0017] Although an example is shown in which organizations A to C each have transmitting device 101 and receiving device 102, and organization D has analyzing device 104, there are no restrictions on the number of organizations constituting information sharing system 1 or the combination of devices each organization has. Information sharing system 1 can be configured in any form as long as it is made up of multiple organizations and has at least one analyzing device that collects and analyzes analytical information from one or more of the organizations.

[0018] Next, the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102 will be described with reference to Fig. 2. Fig. 2 is a diagram showing the configurations of the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102. Fig. 2 illustrates the configurations of the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102 of organization A, but the transmitting devices 101 and the receiving devices 102 of organizations B and C also have similar configurations.

[0019] The transmitting device 101 is realized by using a general information processing device such as a PC (Personal Computer). As shown in Fig. 2, the transmitting device 101 includes a communication interface (communication IF) 111, a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 112, a main memory 113, a storage device 114, an input / output interface (input / output IF) 116, and a communication path 115 connecting these respective parts. The communication path 115 is, for example, an information transmission medium such as a bus or a cable.

[0020] The communication IF 111 operates under the control of the CPU 112 , and performs interface processing for various types of information transmitted and received between the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102 or the analyzing device 104 .

[0021] The input / output device 117 is a device for receiving input from an administrator in charge of managing the information sharing system 1 in organization A and outputting information to be presented to the administrator, and is configured using, for example, a mouse, a keyboard, a display, etc. The input / output IF 116 is connected to the input / output device 117, and mediates the input / output of data between the administrator and the input / output device 117.

[0022] The main memory 113 is, for example, a semiconductor storage device such as a RAM (Random Access Memory), and temporarily stores programs that are loaded from the storage device 114 and executed by the CPU 112, and necessary work data.

[0023] The CPU 112 executes programs stored in the main memory 113 and controls each part of the transmission device 101 .

[0024] The storage device 114 is, for example, a large-capacity non-transitory magnetic storage device or semiconductor storage device such as a hard disk drive (HDD) or a solid state drive (SSD), and stores programs executed by the CPU 112 and data used by the CPU 112. As described above, some or all of the programs and data may be stored in the storage device 114 in advance, or may be introduced from outside as necessary.

[0025] In this embodiment, in the transmission device 101, a predetermined program is loaded from the storage device 114 to the main memory 113 and executed by the CPU 112, thereby realizing each of the functional blocks of a request transmission unit 121, an information transmission unit 122, and an analysis logic transmission unit 123. In addition, an analysis logic 131 and a concealment policy 132 are stored in the storage device 114 as data used in the processing of these functional blocks.

[0026] The request sending unit 121 generates an analysis request for the analysis device 104 and outputs it to the communication IF 111. This analysis request includes the analysis information of organization A, information for identifying the analysis logic used in the analysis, and the concealment policy 132 of organization A read from the storage device 114, and is sent from the communication IF 111 to the analysis device 104 via the network 103. In addition, when analysis logic information is necessary for determining the analysis content in organization A, the request sending unit 121 can also output a transmission request for analysis logic information held by the analysis device 104 to the communication IF 111. The transmission request for analysis logic information output from the request sending unit 121 is transmitted from the communication IF 111 to the analysis device 104 via the network 103.

[0027] When receiving device 102 receives a request to share analytical information necessary for analysis performed by analytical device 104, information transmitting unit 122 acquires analytical information corresponding to the request from receiving device 102 and outputs it to communication IF 111. The analytical information output from information transmitting unit 122 is transmitted from communication IF 111 via network 103 to analytical device 104, and is used in the analysis process performed by analytical device 104.

[0028] When the receiving device 102 receives a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 from the analysis device 104, the analysis logic transmitting unit 123 outputs the analysis logic 131 stored in the storage device 114 to the communication IF 111 in response to the request. The analysis logic 131 output to the communication IF 111 is transmitted to the analysis device 104 via the network 103.

[0029] The analysis logic 131 is a program for performing analysis held by organization A. The content of this analysis logic 131 differs depending on each organization.

[0030] The anonymization policy 132 is information for defining the level of information anonymization for each organization when the analysis results by the analysis device 104 are shared among the organizations. The anonymization policy 132 will be described in detail later.

[0031] Like the transmitting device 101, the receiving device 102 is also realized by a general information processing device such as a PC, and includes a communication IF 141, a CPU 142, a main memory 143, a storage device 144, and a communication path 145 connecting these respective units, as shown in Fig. 2. The functions of these units are similar to those of the communication IF 111, the CPU 112, the main memory 113, the storage device 114, and the communication path 115 in the transmitting device 101, respectively.

[0032] In this embodiment, in the receiving device 102, a predetermined program is loaded into the main memory 143 and executed by the CPU 142, thereby realizing the functional blocks of an information search unit 151 and an analysis result evaluation unit 152.

[0033] When the transmitting device 101 generates an analysis request or when an information sharing request is received from the analyzing device 104, the information searching unit 151 searches and acquires analytical information required for the analysis performed by the analyzing device 104 from various information held by organization A and stored outside the receiving device 102. The analytical information acquired by the information searching unit 151 is output from the receiving device 102 to the transmitting device 101 by the communication IF 141, and is transmitted to the analyzing device 104 by the information transmitting unit 122 in the transmitting device 101 as described above.

[0034] Analysis result evaluation unit 152 receives the analysis results transmitted from analysis device 104 via communication IF 141, and evaluates the analysis results. The analysis result evaluation by analysis result evaluation unit 152 will be described in detail later.

[0035] 2 shows an example in which the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102 are configured as separate devices, the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102 may be integrated into one device. Furthermore, the programs executed by the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102, and the data used when these programs are executed, may be stored in a portion separate from the transmitting device 101 and the receiving device 102.

[0036] Next, the analysis device 104 will be described with reference to Fig. 3. Fig. 3 is a diagram showing the configuration of the analysis device 104.

[0037] The analysis device 104 is also realized by a general information processing device such as a PC, like the transmission device 101 and the reception device 102 in Fig. 2. As shown in Fig. 3, the analysis device 104 includes a communication IF 161, a CPU 162, a main memory 163, a storage device 164, and a communication path 165 connecting these respective units. The functions of these units are similar to those of the communication IF 111, the CPU 112, the main memory 113, the storage device 114, and the communication path 115 in the transmission device 101, respectively.

[0038] In this embodiment, in the analysis device 104, a predetermined program is loaded into the main memory 163 and executed by the CPU 162, thereby realizing each of the functional blocks of a request sending unit 171, an information sending unit 172, a concealment processing unit 173, an analysis unit 174, and a reliability update unit 175. In addition, as data used in the processing of these functional blocks, a logic information table 181, an organization information table 182, a reliability score table 183, a reliability table 184, and an anonymization definition table 185 are stored in the storage device 164. The details of each of these tables will be described later.

[0039] When an analysis request is transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of any of the organizations A to C, the request transmitting unit 171 refers to the organization information table 182 stored in the storage device 164 to identify an organization among the organizations A to C that has analytical information corresponding to the requested analysis content, and transmits a request to share the analytical information to the receiving device 102 of that organization. Also, refers to the logic information table 181 and the organization information table 182 stored in the storage device 164 to identify an organization among the organizations A to C that has the analytical logic 131 required for analysis, and transmits a transmission request for the analysis logic 131 to the receiving device 102 of that organization.

[0040] When the information transmitting unit 172 receives a transmission request for analysis logic information from the transmitting device 101 of any of the organizations A to C, it transmits the logic information table 181 stored in the storage unit 162 in response to the transmission request. In addition, the analysis results performed in response to the analysis request are transmitted to one or more of the organizations A to C, thereby sharing the analysis results between the organizations.

[0041] When an analysis request is sent from the transmitting device 101 of any of the organizations A to C, the anonymization unit 173 performs anonymization processing on the analytical information and analysis results collected from each organization using the anonymization policy 132 included in the analysis request.

[0042] The analysis unit 174 performs an analysis using the analytical information collected from each organization in response to an analysis request from any one of organizations A to C. This information analysis is performed using the analytical information of each organization that has been anonymized by the anonymization unit 173 and the analysis logic 131 acquired from any one of the organizations in response to a transmission request from the request transmission unit 171.

[0043] The reliability update unit 175 uses the analysis information collected from the transmission device 101 of each organization and the evaluation results from each organization on the analysis results shared among the organizations to update the contents of the reliability score table 183 and the reliability table 184 stored in the storage unit 162. Details of the reliability update process by the reliability update unit 175 will be described later.

[0044] The analysis device 104 may be connected to an input / output device configured using a mouse, keyboard, display, etc., and may include an input / output IF for inputting and outputting data between the analysis device 104 and the input / output device, so that an administrator in charge of managing the information sharing system 1 in organization D can edit each table stored in the storage device 164. The analysis device 104 may be integrated with the transmission device 101 and the reception device 102 shown in Fig. 2 to configure them as a single device. Furthermore, the programs executed by the analysis device 104 and the data used when executing the programs may be stored in a location other than the storage device 164 of the analysis device 104 or in a location separate from the analysis device 104.

[0045] Next, the data structure used in the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment will be described with reference to FIGS.

[0046] First, an example of the masking policy will be described with reference to Fig. 4. Fig. 4 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of the masking policy 132 stored in the storage device 114 of the transmission device 101.

[0047] In the information sharing system of this embodiment, the confidentiality level of information shared between different organizations varies depending on the trust between the organizations. The anonymization policy 132 is a threshold of the confidentiality level of information shared from one organization to another organization for each type of information. When performing anonymization processing of the analysis information, the analysis device 104 refers to the anonymization policy 132 and determines the confidentiality level according to the trust level of each organization with which the information is shared. In the example of FIG. 4, the confidentiality level of the shared information is divided into three levels, "low trust", "medium trust", and "high trust", but the number of levels of confidentiality may be more or less than this.

[0048] An entry of the anonymization policy 132 has fields of an ID 401, a type of information to be shared 402, a medium reliability threshold 403, and a high reliability threshold 404. The ID 401 stores an identifier that uniquely identifies data corresponding to each record of the anonymization policy 132. The type of information to be shared 402 stores the name of the type of information held by each organization and to be shared between the organizations. The medium reliability threshold 403 stores a boundary value that distinguishes between "low reliability" and "medium reliability" among the above-mentioned stages of the degree of anonymity. On the other hand, the high reliability threshold 404 stores a boundary value that distinguishes between "medium reliability" and "high reliability". The medium reliability threshold 403 and the high reliability threshold 404 may be manually set by an administrator, or may be automatically set based on the content of the data, for example, by increasing the threshold value when personal information is included in the data.

[0049] Next, an example of a logic information table will be described with reference to Fig. 5. Fig. 5 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of logic information table 181 stored in storage device 164 of analysis device 104.

[0050] The logic information table 181 is a table that stores information on the analysis logic 131 held by each organization. An organization that issues an analysis request to the analysis device 104 can determine the analysis logic 131 to be used for the analysis by acquiring and referring to this table before issuing the analysis request.

[0051] An entry in the logic information table 181 has fields of ID 501, logic name 502, name of organization holding 503, analysis content of logic 504, confidentiality of required information 505, and information required for analysis 506. The ID 501 stores an identifier that uniquely identifies data corresponding to each record of the logic information table 181. The logic name 502 stores the name of the analysis logic. The name of the organization holding 503 stores the name of the organization that holds the analysis logic 131. The analysis content of logic 504 stores an explanation of the analysis content performed by the analysis logic 131. The confidentiality of required information 505 stores information regarding the confidentiality level of information used in performing the analysis. The information required for analysis 506 stores the type of analytical information used in performing the analysis.

[0052] The logic information table 181 is a table that can be edited by an organization that owns the corresponding analysis logic 131. When any organization makes a change to the analysis logic 131, that organization corrects the contents of the logic information table 181.

[0053] Next, an example of the organization information table will be described with reference to Fig. 6. Fig. 6 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of organization information table 182 stored in storage device 164 of analysis device 104.

[0054] The organization information table 182 is a table that records the connection destination of each organization and the type of information that each organization holds. When the analysis device 104 receives an analysis request from any organization, it refers to the information in this table and requests each organization to share the necessary analytical information.

[0055] An entry in the organization information table 182 has fields of ID 601, organization name 602, destination IP 603, security 604, electricity 605, finance 606, and other industry names 607. The ID 601 stores an identifier that uniquely identifies data corresponding to each record in the logic information table 181. The organization name 602 stores the name of the organization. The destination IP 603 stores, for example, destination IP information as information indicating the access destination from the analysis device 104 to the receiving device 102 of each organization. The fields of security 604, electricity 605, finance 606, and other industry names 607 store 1 if the corresponding organization holds information related to these industries, and 0 if the corresponding organization does not hold information. These pieces of information are used when the analysis device 104 determines the organization with which it requests the sharing of analytical information. In the example of FIG. 6, 1 or 0 is stored in each field depending on the presence or absence of information for each organization, but any number from 0 to 1 may be stored depending on the amount of information held by each organization. It may also be a Boolean value.

[0056] Next, an example of the reliability score table will be described with reference to Fig. 7. Fig. 7 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of reliability score table 183 stored in storage device 164 of analysis device 104.

[0057] The trust score table 183 is a table showing the trust scores between the organizations for each combination of the organizations constituting the information sharing system 1. The trust score is a score obtained by an organization evaluating the behavior of another organization. In the trust score table 183 in FIG. 7, the names of the organizations in the information sharing system 1 are arranged in columns 701 and rows 702, respectively, and the column 701 shows the name of the organization that made the evaluation, and the row 702 shows the name of the organization that was evaluated. In each field located at the intersection of the row and column corresponding to each organization name, the trust score between the corresponding organizations is stored. That is, in each field of the trust score table 183 in FIG. 7, the trust score from each organization in the column 701 to each organization in the row 702 is stored. For example, the value of the trust score from organization A to organization B is 6.6 in FIG. 7. This trust score is a score of the degree of trust determined by organization A evaluating the behavior of organization B.

[0058] Next, an example of the reliability table will be described with reference to Fig. 8. Fig. 8 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of reliability table 184 stored in storage device 164 of analysis device 104.

[0059] The trust table 184 is a table showing the trust between each organization for each combination of organizations constituting the information sharing system. The trust is the above-mentioned trust score shown in the trust score table 183 normalized in the range of 0 to 1. In the trust table 184 in FIG. 8, similar to the trust score table 183 in FIG. 7, the names of each organization in the information sharing system 1 are arranged in a column 801 and a row 802, and the column 801 shows the name of the organization that is the evaluation source, and the row 802 shows the name of the organization that is the evaluation target. Each field located at the intersection of the row and column corresponding to each organization name stores the normalized trust between the corresponding organizations. For example, the value of the trust from organization A to organization B is 0.3 in FIG. 8.

[0060] Next, an example of the anonymization definition table will be described with reference to Fig. 9. Fig. 9 is a diagram showing an example of the data structure of the anonymization definition table 185 stored in the storage device 164 of the analysis device 104.

[0061] The anonymization definition table 185 defines what type of anonymization is performed by the analysis device 104 for each piece of information shared between the organizations. In the anonymization definition table 185 in Fig. 9, the shared information is listed in column 801, and the reliability is listed in row 802, and the details of anonymization performed by the analysis device 104 are defined for each combination of these. For example, if the reliability of any piece of information, such as incident handling information, is low, that information may not be shared between organizations as information for analysis. In this case, the analysis device 104 does not anonymize the information for analysis, and the information for analysis is not used for analysis.

[0062] Next, the processing of the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment will be described with reference to FIGS.

[0063] First, an overview of the processing of the information sharing system 1 will be described with reference to Fig. 10. Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment of the present invention. In the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment, the overall processing shown in the flowchart in Fig. 10 is executed every time an analysis request is made to the analysis device 104 from any of organization A, organization B, and organization C. Note that while Fig. 10 shows an example in which organization A makes an analysis request, the same applies when organizations B and C make analysis requests.

[0064] First, the transmission device 101 held by organization A requests logic information from the analysis device 104 (S1001).

[0065] When receiving a logic information request from the transmitting device 101 of organization A, the analyzing device 104 transmits the logic information table 181 to the receiving device 102 of organization A via the information transmitting unit 172 (S1002).

[0066] Organization A, which has received the logic information table 181 by the receiving device 102, refers to the logic information shown in the logic information table 181 and determines which analysis the analysis device 104 will perform among the analyses it can perform. After the determination, the receiving device 102 of organization A searches for analysis information from the information held by organization A using the information search unit 151 and outputs the information to the transmitting device 101. The transmitting device 101 generates an analysis request using the analysis information acquired from the receiving device 102, information for identifying the analysis logic 131 to be used for the analysis, and the anonymization policy 132 stored in the storage device 114 using the request transmitting unit 121, and transmits the analysis request to the analysis device 104 to request the analysis (S1003).

[0067] When receiving an analysis request from the transmitting device 101 of organization A, the analysis device 104 extracts information for identifying the analysis logic 131 from the received analysis request by the request transmitting unit 171, and identifies the analysis logic 131 to be used for analysis and the organization that holds the analysis logic based on the information and the logic information table 181. Then, the connection destination of the identified organization is obtained using the organization information table 182, and a request is made to the obtained connection destination to transmit the analysis logic 131 (S1004). FIG. 10 shows an example of a case where a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 is made to organization C, and this example will be described below, but the same applies when a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 is made to other organizations.

[0068] Upon receiving a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 from the analysis device 104, the transmission device 101 of organization C transmits the analysis logic 131 stored in the storage device 114 to the analysis device 104 via the analysis logic transmission unit 123 (S1005).

[0069] Upon receiving the analysis logic 131 transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of organization C, the analysis device 104 uses the request transmitting unit 171 to refer to the logic information table 181 to identify the analytical information corresponding to the analysis logic 131. Then, the analysis device 104 refers to the organization information table 182 to determine each organization having the identified analytical information and its connection destinations, and requests each of the connection destinations to share the analytical information (S1006). Fig. 10 shows an example in which a request to share analytical information is made to organizations B and C, respectively, and this example will be described below, but the same applies when a request to share analytical information is made to other organizations.

[0070] In organizations B and C, which have been requested by the analysis device 104 to share the analytical information, the information search unit 151 in each receiving device 102 searches for information related to analysis within each organization as the analytical information. Then, using each transmitting device 101, the information transmitting unit 122 transmits the analytical information searched within each organization and the anonymization policy 132 stored in the storage device 114 to the analysis device 104 (S1007).

[0071] Upon receiving the analytical information and anonymization policy 132 transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of organization B and organization C, the analysis device 104 performs anonymization processing of the analytical information by the anonymization processing unit 173 using the analytical information and the anonymization policy 132 included in the analysis request transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of organization A in S1003 (S1008). In this anonymization processing, analytical information that is determined to be low in trustworthiness from the transmitting organization and therefore not to be shared and used for analysis is excluded, and the analytical information collected from each organization is anonymized. Details of the anonymization processing performed in S1008 will be described later.

[0072] Next, the analysis device 104 performs the analysis requested by organization A using the analysis logic 131 acquired from the transmission device 101 of organization C in S1004 and the analysis information anonymized by the anonymization processing in S1008, by the analysis unit 174 (S1009). For example, in an analysis such as extracting suspicious IP addresses from access logs, the analysis is performed using the access log information of each organization as analysis information, and if the IP address of the access destination with high abnormality is common in the access logs of multiple organizations, it is determined that the access from this IP address is highly likely to be an access from a cyber attacker. Note that at this time, as described above, the analysis information excluded in the anonymization processing is not used in the analysis.

[0073] Next, the analysis device 104 performs an update process of the reliability information from organization A to organization B and organization C by using the reliability update unit 175, with organization A making the analysis request as the evaluation source organization and organizations B and C sharing the analysis results as the evaluation destination organizations (S1010). Details of the reliability information update process performed in S1010 will be described later.

[0074] Next, the analysis device 104 transmits the analysis result of S1009 to each organization, except for the organization determined to have low reliability and not to be shared when performing the concealment processing in S1008, by the information transmission unit 172, and shares the analysis result among the organizations (S1011). At this time, the analysis device 104 may transmit the analysis result in response to a request from the transmission device 101 possessed by each organization, rather than forcibly transmitting the analysis result to each organization. Fig. 10 shows an example of a case where the analysis result is shared among these organizations by transmitting the analysis result to each of organizations A, B, and C, and this example will be described below, but the same applies to a case where the analysis result is shared among organizations by a combination of different organizations.

[0075] The analysis results transmitted from the analysis device 104 are received by the analysis result evaluation unit 152 in the receiving devices 102 held by each of organizations A, B, and C. As a result, the receiving devices 102 of organizations A, B, and C acquire the analysis results of the analysis device 104 and share them among the organizations (S1012).

[0076] Next, the receiving devices 102 of organizations B and C each use the analysis result evaluation unit 152 to evaluate the analysis results acquired from the analysis device 104 in S1012, and calculate a trust score for organization A, which has made an analysis request from each organization, based on the evaluation results (S1013). Details of the trust score calculation process performed in S1013 will be described later.

[0077] Next, in organizations B and C, the reliability scores calculated in S1013 are output from the receiving devices 102 to the transmitting device 101, and are transmitted to the analysis device 104 using the transmitting device 101 (S1014).

[0078] Upon receiving the trust scores transmitted from the transmission devices 101 of organizations B and C, the analysis device 104 performs, by the trust update unit 175, an update process of trust information from organizations B and C to organization A, with organization A that made the analysis request as the evaluation destination organization and organizations B and C that evaluated the analysis results as the evaluation source organizations (S1015). Details of the trust information update process performed in S1015 will be described later.

[0079] When the process of S1015 is completed, the process shown in the flowchart of FIG. 10 is terminated, and the entire process of the information sharing system 1 is terminated.

[0080] Next, the concealment processing used in the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment will be described. This processing corresponds to S1008 in Fig. 10. This concealment processing is performed by the concealment processing unit 173 loaded into the main memory 163 of the analysis device 104, using the analytical information and the concealment policy 132 sent from the transmission device 101 of each organization.

[0081] As described in Fig. 10, the analysis device 104 performs a concealment process on the analytical information by the concealment process unit 173 before performing the analysis. The reason for this is that the concealment process unit 173 is a program held by the analysis device 104, whereas the analysis logic 131 is a program developed and held by each organization, and therefore there is a risk that the analytical information may be leaked to the outside by using the analysis logic 131. Therefore, before performing the analysis using the analysis logic 131, the analysis device 104 conceals the analytical information used in the analysis. This makes it possible to minimize the damage even if the analysis logic 131 leaks the analytical information to the outside intentionally or negligently.

[0082] As described above, the degree of confidentiality of analytical information in the concealment process varies depending on the trust between the organizations. Specifically, the degree of confidentiality for each organization is determined by comparing the trust between the organizations with a predetermined threshold. This threshold is determined for each type of analytical information to be shared according to the concealment policy 132 held by the transmitting device 101 of each organization.

[0083] In the analysis device 104, the anonymization unit 173 refers to the anonymization policy 132 included in the analysis request sent from one of the organizations in S1003 of Fig. 10, and the reliability table 184 and the anonymization definition table 185 stored in the storage device 164, and determines the degree of anonymity of the analytical information shared between the organizations for each organization. The reliability used here is the reliability of the organization that has provided the analytical information and requested the analysis device 104 to perform the analysis. Thereafter, the anonymization unit 173 performs an anonymization process on the analytical information collected from each organization according to the degree of anonymity, using a program for performing anonymization process.

[0084] 10, for example, organizations B and C that provided analytical information are regarded as source organizations, and organization A that made an analysis request is regarded as a destination organization, and the trust between these organizations is found from the trust table 184. The found trust is then compared with a threshold value indicated in the anonymization policy 132 to determine the degree of trust from organization B to organization A and the degree of trust from organization C to organization A. Once the degree of trust between the organizations has been determined in this manner, the anonymization definition table 185 is referenced to find the anonymization content corresponding to the degree of trust in organization A for each of organizations B and C, and anonymization processing is performed according to the content.

[0085] Here, the anonymization process performed when organization A requests the analysis device 104 to perform an analysis and organization B provides analytical information in response to the analysis request will be described using examples of the reliability table 184 and the anonymization definition table 185 shown in Fig. 8 and Fig. 9, respectively. In this case, it is assumed that the anonymization policy 132 sent from organization A specifies 0.4 for the medium reliability threshold 403 and 0.65 for the high reliability threshold 404 as thresholds corresponding to the analytical information to be shared. In this case, the reliability table 184 in Fig. 8 shows that the reliability is 0.6 when organization B, which provides the analytical information, is the evaluation source organization and organization A, which makes the analysis request, is the evaluation destination organization. Comparing this reliability 0.6 with the aforementioned thresholds shown in the anonymization policy 132, 0.4<0.6<0.65, so that the degree of reliability from organization B to organization A is determined to be equivalent to "medium reliability". Therefore, for example, when the analytical information to be shared is incident handling information, the tool information and the like are anonymized in the anonymization process according to the anonymization definition table 185 in FIG.

[0086] Next, the details of the process of updating the trustworthiness information from the organization that requested the analysis device 104 to the organization that shared the analytical information will be described with reference to Fig. 11. Fig. 11 is a flowchart of the process of updating the trustworthiness information from the analysis requesting organization to the information sharing organization. This process corresponds to S1010 in Fig. 10, and is performed by the trustworthiness update unit 175 loaded into the main memory 163 of the analysis device 104.

[0087] The reliability update unit 175 executes the following processes of S1102 to S1107 for each organization shown in the organization information table 182 (S1101).

[0088] First, the reliability update unit 175 determines whether the organization to be processed provided the analysis logic 131 to the analysis device 104 in S1005 of FIG. 10 (S1102).

[0089] If it is determined in S1102 that the organization in question has provided the analysis logic 131 (S1102: Yes), the trust update unit 175 sets the organization that requested the analysis device 104 to perform the analysis as the evaluation source organization and the organization in question as the evaluation target organization in the trust score table 183, and adds 1 to the trust score corresponding to the combination of these organizations (S1103). Note that the value added to the trust score at this time is not limited to 1, and may be more or less than this. On the other hand, if it is determined in S1102 that the organization in question has not provided the analysis logic 131 (S1102: No), the process of S1103 is not executed.

[0090] Next, the reliability update unit 175 determines whether the analytical information collected from the organization to be processed was used in the analysis performed by the analysis unit 174 in S1009 of Fig. 10 (S1104). For example, for an organization that was determined to have low reliability and not to share analytical information when performing the concealment processing in S1008 of Fig. 10, or an organization that does not hold the necessary analytical information and does not share the analytical information, the analytical information collected from that organization was not used in the analysis, so a negative determination is made in S1104.

[0091] If it is determined in S1104 that the analysis unit 174 used the analysis information collected from the organization in question for analysis (S1104: Yes), the reliability update unit 175 sets the organization that requested the analysis device 104 to analyze as the evaluation source organization and the organization in question as the evaluation target organization in the reliability score table 183, and adds 1 to the reliability score corresponding to the combination of these organizations (S1105). Note that the value added to the reliability score at this time is not limited to 1, and may be more or less than this.

[0092] Next, the reliability update unit 175 evaluates how much the analytical information collected and shared from the organization was involved in the analysis (S1106). For example, when an analysis is performed to find suspicious destination IP addresses using the access logs of a forward proxy, the amount of access logs in the analytical information shared from the organization and the number of suspicious IP addresses contained therein can be used to evaluate how much the analytical information was involved in the analysis. The method of evaluation at this time may or may not depend on the analysis logic 131.

[0093] Next, the trust update unit 175 determines an additional value to be added to the trust score of the organization from the organization that requested the analysis device 104 to perform the analysis according to the evaluation result of S1106, and updates the trust score table 183 using the determined value (S1107). At this time, if the evaluation value of S1106 is low, the additional value to the trust score may be set to 0, or the additional value to the trust score may be subtracted from the trust score as a negative value.

[0094] On the other hand, if it is determined in S1104 that the organization has not provided the analysis logic 131 (S1102: No), the processes in S1105 to S1107 are not executed.

[0095] After exiting the loop of S1101, the trust update unit 175 normalizes the trust scores calculated between each organization to calculate the trust (S1108). Here, the trust scores between each organization are normalized by multiplying them by a predetermined coefficient so that the trust between all organizations falls within the range of 0 to 1, for example, to calculate the trust. The trust values ​​calculated here are recorded in the trust table 184, whereby the trust table 184 is updated to reflect the latest trust scores recorded in the trust score table 183.

[0096] In the analysis device 104, the reliability update unit 175 performs the process of updating the reliability information from the analysis requesting organization to the information sharing organization as described above. This makes it possible to update the reliability recorded in the reliability table 184 for each organization based on the history of provision of the analysis logic 131 by each organization and the contribution of the analytical information from each organization to the analysis performed by the analysis unit 174. Note that the flowchart in Fig. 11 described in this embodiment is an example of the processing procedure when performing the process of updating the reliability information from the analysis requesting organization to the information sharing organization, and the reliability table 184 may be updated by adding or subtracting the reliability score of each organization using other evaluation items.

[0097] Next, the details of the trust score calculation process will be described with reference to Fig. 12. Fig. 12 is a flowchart of the trust score calculation process from the information sharing organization to the analysis requesting organization. This process corresponds to S1013 in Fig. 10, and is performed by the analysis result evaluation unit 152 loaded into the main memory 143 of the receiving device 102 in each organization.

[0098] 12 is performed in the receiving device 102 of each organization when the analysis result is obtained from the analysis device 104, or when a certain time has passed since the organization shared the analytical information. The time from sharing the analytical information until processing may be set by the administrator for each organization.

[0099] First, the analysis result evaluation unit 152 judges whether or not there has been any leakage of analytical information that the organization transmitted to and shared with the analysis device 104 (S1201). This judgment is made using, for example, a declaration from an organization that provided the analysis logic 131 to the analysis device 104 or an organization that requested the analysis device 104 to perform an analysis, or a report from another organization.

[0100] If it is determined in S1201 that a leak of the shared analytical information has occurred (S1201: Yes), the analysis result evaluation unit 152 subtracts 1 from the trust score of the organization that requested the analysis device 104 from that organization (S1202). Note that the value to be subtracted from the trust score is not limited to 1, and may be more or less than 1. The initial value of the trust score is, for example, 0, and the trust score may take a negative value by being subtracted from the initial value. On the other hand, if it is determined in S1201 that a leak of the shared analytical information has not occurred (S1201: No), the process of S1202 is not executed.

[0101] Next, the analysis result evaluation unit 152 determines whether the analysis result by the analysis device 104 is useful for the organization (S1203).

[0102] If it is determined in S1104 that the analysis results are useful to the organization (S1203: Yes), the analysis result evaluation unit 152 adds a predetermined additional value to the trust score of the organization that requested the analysis from the organization to the analysis device 104 (S1204). The additional value at this time may be a preset value, or may be determined depending on the usefulness of the analysis results to the organization.

[0103] The flowchart of FIG. 12 described in this embodiment is an example of a reliability score calculation process procedure, and the reliability score may be increased or decreased using other evaluation items.

[0104] Next, a detailed description will be given of the process of updating trustworthiness information from an organization that has shared information to an organization that has requested analysis from analysis device 104. This process corresponds to S1015 in Fig. 10, and is executed when the trustworthiness update unit 175 loaded into main memory 163 of analysis device 104 receives the calculation results of the trustworthiness scores transmitted from transmission device 101 of each organization in S1014 in Fig. 10.

[0105] When the reliability update unit 175 receives reliability scores from the transmitting device 101 of each organization that shared the analytical information, it uses the received reliability scores to update the reliability score table 183. Here, the organization that transmitted the reliability score is regarded as the evaluation source organization, and the organization that requested the analysis device 104 to perform an analysis is regarded as the evaluation target organization, and the received reliability score is added to the reliability score of the field corresponding to the combination of these organizations.

[0106] Next, the reliability update unit 175 normalizes the reliability scores using the updated reliability score table 183, and stores the result in the reliability table 184. Here, the reliability score is normalized to calculate the reliability in the same manner as in S1108 of Fig. 11, and the reliability table 184 is updated to reflect the calculation result.

[0107] In the analysis device 104, the reliability update unit 175 performs the above-described process of updating reliability information from the information sharing organization to the analysis requesting organization, based on the reliability scores calculated for each organization by the reliability score calculation process in Fig. 12 and transmitted to the analysis device 104. This makes it possible to update the reliability recorded in the reliability table 184 for each organization, based on the usefulness of the analysis results in each organization.

[0108] Next, an example of a method for determining the reliability when a new organization enters the information sharing system 1 of this embodiment will be described.

[0109] Here, it is assumed that organization N newly joining the information sharing system 1 does so through an introduction from organization A which is already participating in the information sharing system 1. In this case, it is considered that a certain degree of trust already exists between organization A and organization N. Therefore, the administrator of organization A determines the degree of trust from organization A to organization N, and the administrator of organization N determines the degree of trust from organization N to organization A, and they can set the degree of trust between organization A and the newly joining organization N.

[0110] However, the above-mentioned method of determining the trust level cannot be used between organizations other than organization A and the newly joining organization N. Therefore, a method of calculating the trust level between organization N and each organization other than organization A that has already participated in information sharing system 1, using the trust level set between organization A and organization N, will be described below.

[0111] Let organization X be the organization for which we want to calculate the trust between organization N and organization A. Let T be the trust from organization X to organization A. X to A , the trust level from organization A to organization N is T A to N Then, the trust level from organization X to organization N is T X to N is calculated, for example, by the following formula (1). T X to N =T X to A ×T A to N (1)

[0112] In addition, the trust level from organization A to organization X is T A to X , the trust level from organization N to organization A is T N to A Then, the trust level from organization N to organization X is T N to X is calculated, for example, by the following formula (2). T N to X =T N to A ×T A to X (2)

[0113] In addition, by multiplying the right-hand sides of the above formulas (1) and (2) by a predetermined coefficient, the reliability T from organization X to organization N calculated by formula (1) can be calculated as follows: X to N and the trust level T from organization N to organization X calculated using equation (2) N to Xand may be adjusted arbitrarily.

[0114] Next, an analysis request screen displayed on the input / output device 117 of an organization that issues an analysis request to the analysis device 104 will be described with reference to Fig. 13. Fig. 13 is a diagram showing an example of the analysis request screen. The analysis request screen 1301 shown in Fig. 13 has discloseable data 1302.

[0115] Discloseable data 1302 is an area that displays the contents of logic information table 181. When making an analysis request to analysis device 104, the administrator of each organization can select which analysis logic 131 to use based on the information shown in this discloseable data 1302 and determine the analysis contents.

[0116] Next, an analysis result display screen displayed on the input / output device 117 of each organization to which the analysis results are transmitted from the analysis device 104 will be described with reference to Fig. 14. Fig. 14 is a diagram showing an example of the analysis result display screen. The analysis result display screen 1401 shown in Fig. 14 is a screen for displaying past analysis results performed by the analysis device 104, and has an analysis result selection portion 1402 and an analysis result display area 1403.

[0117] The analysis result selection section 1402 is a section where the administrator of each organization selects the analysis results that he / she wishes to display. For example, in the transmission device 101 of each organization, past analysis results are stored in the storage device 114 under names that combine the analysis execution date and numbers that uniquely identify the analysis result with an underscore. By selecting this, the administrator can display any analysis result on the analysis result display screen 1401.

[0118] The analysis result display area 1403 is a section for displaying the contents of the analysis result. For example, the analysis result of a suspicious IP address is displayed as a graph showing the suspiciousness level of each suspicious IP address, as shown in Fig. 14. Note that the analysis result displayed in the analysis result display area 1403 may be displayed in, for example, a table format, instead of a graph as in Fig. 14, or in other formats. Also, a text explaining the details of the analysis result may be added.

[0119] Next, an organization information editing screen displayed on the input / output device 117 of each organization will be described with reference to Fig. 15. Fig. 15 is a diagram showing an example of the organization information editing screen. The organization information editing screen 1501 shown in Fig. 15 is a screen for an administrator of each organization to edit information about his / her own organization and request changes to the logic information table 181 stored in the storage device 164 of the analysis device 104, the organization information table 182, and the anonymization policy 132 stored in the storage device 114 of the receiving device 102 according to the editing results, and has a logic information editing unit 1502, an anonymization policy editing unit 1503, and an organization information editing unit 1504.

[0120] The logic information editing section 1502 is an area where, when a new analysis logic 131 is developed in one's own organization or when an existing analysis logic 131 is changed in one's own organization, the administrator can edit the logic information table 181 that stores information on the analysis logic 131 in accordance with the changes. The analysis logic 131 displayed in this area is only the content related to the analysis logic 131 held by the organization among the contents described in the logic information table 181 stored in the memory device 164 of the analysis device 104, and the analysis logic 131 of other organizations is not displayed.

[0121] The masking policy editing section 1503 is an area for the administrator to edit his / her own organization's masking policy 132. In this area, the contents of the masking policy 132 held by the organization are displayed.

[0122] The organization information editing section 1504 is an area for the administrator to edit the organization information table 182 of his / her own organization. The organization information displayed in this area is only the content related to the organization among the contents described in the organization information table 182 stored in the storage device 164 of the analysis device 104, and information on other organizations is not displayed.

[0123] According to the first embodiment of the present invention described above, the following advantageous effects can be obtained.

[0124] (1) In the information sharing system 1, the analysis device 104 includes a concealment processing unit 173 that conceals analytical information collected from one or more of the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1 based on the trust between the organizations, an analysis unit 174 that performs analysis using the analytical information concealed by the concealment processing unit 173 and analysis logic 131 collected from one or more of the multiple organizations, and an information transmission unit 172 that transmits the analysis results by the analysis unit 174 to one or more of the multiple organizations to share the results among the organizations. This makes it possible to realize secure information sharing among multiple organizations.

[0125] (2) The analysis device 104 includes a trust updating unit 175 that updates the trust. This makes it possible to keep the trust between the organizations up to date according to the operational status of the information sharing system 1.

[0126] (3) The trust updating unit 175 updates the trust for each organization based on the history of each organization's provision of analysis logic, the contribution of the analytical information to the analysis, the usefulness of the analysis results, etc. (S1010, S1015). In this manner, the trust between each organization can be appropriately determined according to the degree of involvement of each organization in the analysis in the information sharing system 1.

[0127] (4) The information transmission unit 172 judges whether or not the analysis results can be shared for each organization based on the reliability, and transmits the analysis results to each organization except for organizations that have decided not to share the analysis results (S1011). In this way, for organizations with low reliability, the analysis results are not shared, thereby preventing information leakage.

[0128] (5) The concealment processing unit 173 judges whether or not the analytical information can be used in the analysis for each organization based on the reliability, and conceals the analytical information except for the analytical information judged not to be used in the analysis (S1008). In S1011, the information transmission unit 172 judges not to share the analysis results with the organization that provided the analytical information judged not to be used in the analysis by the concealment processing unit 173. In this manner, it is possible to prevent inappropriate analytical results from being obtained using analytical information provided by an organization with low reliability, while not sharing the analysis results with such an organization.

[0129] (6) Each of the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1 has a transmitting device 101 and a receiving device 102. The transmitting device 101 of each organization transmits analytical information to the analyzing device 104 connected via the networks 103, 105 and the Internet 106, which are communication lines (S1003, S1007). The analyzing device 104 has a concealment processing unit 173, an analyzing unit 174, and an information transmitting unit 172, and collects analytical information by receiving analytical information transmitted from the transmitting devices 101 of the multiple organizations (S1004, S1006) and conceals the collected analytical information (S1008). The receiving device 102 of each organization receives the analysis results transmitted from the analyzing device 104 (S1012). In this way, an information sharing system 1 can be realized in which analytical information collected from one or more organizations is concealed and then analyzed, and the analysis results can be shared between the organizations.

[0130] Second embodiment An information sharing system according to a second embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to Fig. 16. Fig. 16 is an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system 1A according to the second embodiment of the present invention. The information sharing system 1A according to this embodiment has a part of a configuration different from the information sharing system 1 according to the above-mentioned first embodiment.

[0131] As shown in FIG. 16, in the information sharing system 1A, organization A has an analysis device 104 in addition to a transmission device 101 and a reception device 102. The transmission device 101 of each organization has the concealment unit 173 that was held by the analysis device 104, and the concealment of the analytical information to be shared is performed by the transmission device 101 of each organization before it is transmitted to the analysis device 104. As a result, even if sensitive information is included in the analytical information to be shared between organizations B and C, organization A that holds the analysis device 104 does not know the sensitive information. However, as described in the first embodiment, the reliability table 184 indicating the reliability between the organizations is stored in the analysis device 104 and is managed collectively. Therefore, in the information sharing system 1A of this embodiment, the transmission device 101 of each organization needs to communicate with the analysis device 104 and obtain reliability information for each of the other organizations before concealing the analytical information.

[0132] In addition, apart from the above, the configurations and functions of the transmitting device 101 and receiving device 102 owned by each organization in the information sharing system 1A, and the configuration and functions of the analysis device 104 are similar to those of the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment.

[0133] According to the second embodiment of the present invention described above, the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1A each have a concealment processing unit 173, a transmitting device 101, and a receiving device 102. The concealment processing unit 173 of each organization collects and conceals the analysis information of the organization. The transmitting device 101 of each organization transmits the concealed analysis information to the analysis device 104 connected via the network 103 and the Internet 106, which are communication lines. The analysis device 104 has an analysis unit 174 and an information transmitting unit 172, and collects concealed analysis information by receiving the analysis information transmitted from the transmitting devices 101 of the multiple organizations. The receiving device 102 of each organization receives the analysis results transmitted from the analysis device 104. In this manner, it is possible to realize the information sharing system 1A in which the analysis information is concealed before being shared in each organization and the analysis results can be shared between the organizations.

[0134] (Third embodiment) An information sharing system according to a third embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to Figs. 17, 18, and 19. Fig. 17 is an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system 1B according to a third embodiment of the present invention. Like the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment, the information sharing system according to this embodiment is configured by connecting organizations A, B, and C, each having a transmitting device 101 and a receiving device 102, and organization D having an analyzing device 104 to the Internet 106 via networks 103 and 105.

[0135] The transmitting device 101 owned by each of the organizations A to C has a concealment processing unit 173, similar to the transmitting device 101 of the information sharing system 1A according to the second embodiment. In other respects, the configurations and functions of the transmitting device 101 and receiving device 102 of the organizations A to C and the configuration and functions of the analysis device 104 of the organization D are similar to those of the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment. Note that the analysis device 104 may be owned by any of the organizations A to C.

[0136] The difference between the information sharing system 1B according to this embodiment and the information sharing systems 1 and 1A described in the first and second embodiments, respectively, is the starting point when the analysis device 104 executes the analysis process. That is, in the first and second embodiments, an organization requests the analysis device 104 to perform the analysis process, but in this embodiment, an organization performs the analysis process when it determines that a detailed analysis is necessary based on the shared analytical information. Specifically, first, each organization provides its own analytical information to other organizations and shares it every time the information is updated. The analytical information shared among multiple organizations in this way is hereinafter referred to as "shared analytical information." Next, when any organization views the shared analytical information provided by the other organizations and determines that analysis is necessary, it requests the analysis device 104 to analyze. After that, the process flow of FIG. 10 described in the first embodiment is started.

[0137] On the other hand, an organization that judges that analysis is unnecessary after viewing the shared analytical information provided by another organization may extract analytical information related to the shared analytical information held within its own organization (hereinafter referred to as "related analytical information") and return it to the organization that provided the information. In this case, the organization that provided the shared analytical information may use the related analytical information returned from the organization that judged that analysis is unnecessary to perform a trust update process for the organization. In this way, even if the other organization judges that analysis is unnecessary, the organization that first provided the shared analytical information can obtain analytical information highly related to the shared analytical information held by the other organization as related analytical information and obtain profits. In addition, the organization that returned the related analytical information can expect an improvement in the trust in its own organization, and can conduct advantageous transactions in information transactions from the next time onwards. Therefore, it is expected that information sharing among multiple organizations will be further promoted.

[0138] Next, an overview of the processing of the information sharing system 1B according to this embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 18 and Fig. 19. Fig. 18 and Fig. 19 are flowcharts showing the overall processing of the information sharing system 1B according to the third embodiment of the present invention. Fig. 18 is a flowchart when an organization that has viewed the shared analytical information determines that analysis is necessary.

[0139] When the transmitting device 101 of organization A detects that analytical information to be shared with other organizations has been added or updated, it starts the process shown in the flowchart of FIG. 18 (S1801). Note that the process shown in the flowchart of FIG. 18 may be started at other times. For example, the process may be started when it is detected that analytical information has been added or updated multiple times, or the administrator of organization A may start the process manually. Note that while FIG. 10 shows an example in which the transmitting device 101 in organization A starts the process, the same applies when the transmitting device 101 in organizations B and C starts the process.

[0140] When the process starts in S1801, the transmission device 101 of organization A requests the anonymization definition table 185 from the analysis device 104 (S1802).

[0141] Upon receiving a request for the anonymization definition table 185 from the transmission device 101 of organization A, the analysis device 104 transmits the anonymization definition table 185 to organization A (S1803).

[0142] When the anonymization definition table 185 is transmitted from the analysis device 104, organization A receives it using the receiving device 102 and outputs it to the transmitting device 101. The transmitting device 101 uses the received anonymization definition table 185 to anonymize the analytical information held by its own organization, and creates groups of analytical information (anonymized information groups) anonymized with different degrees of anonymity for each organization (S1804).

[0143] Next, the transmitting device 101 of organization A transmits the anonymized information group created in S1804 to the analyzing device 104 together with the threshold information of the reliability of the analytical information obtained by referring to the anonymization policy 132 (S1805).

[0144] When the analysis device 104 receives these pieces of information from the transmitting device 101 of organization A, the analysis device 104 uses the reliability table 184, the organization information table 182, and the received reliability threshold information to separate the anonymized information group provided by organization A into analytical information (anonymized information) anonymized at a degree of anonymization according to the reliability from organization A to each of the other organizations, and transmits the anonymized information to each organization except organization A as shared analytical information by organization A (S1806). For example, for organization B, the reliability from organization A to organization B is obtained from the reliability table 184, and the degree of anonymization from organization A to organization B is obtained based on the reliability and the reliability threshold information received from organization A. Then, the anonymized information with the obtained degree of anonymization is extracted from the anonymized information group, and transmitted to the receiving device 102 of organization B as shared analytical information. The information of the destination at this time is specified by obtaining the connection destination IP address of organization B from the organization information table 182. In addition, for organization C, the anonymized information as shared analytical information is transmitted from the analysis device 104 to the receiving device 102 in a similar procedure. That is, in the analysis device 104, the information transmitting unit 172 transmits information anonymized by the anonymizing unit 173 of organization A with a different anonymization degree for each organization based on the reliability to organization B and organization C to share between the organizations. In this way, analytical information anonymized with a different anonymization degree for each organization based on the reliability between the organizations can be transmitted from the analysis device 104 to each organization and shared between the organizations. At this time, similar to S1011 in FIG. 10 described in the first embodiment, the analysis device 104 may transmit the anonymized information in response to a request from the transmitting device 101 of each organization, rather than forcibly transmitting the anonymized information to each organization.

[0145] When the receiving device 102 receives the confidential information (shared analytical information) transmitted from the analysis device 104 (S1807), organizations B and C may view the received information and analyze it according to their own judgment.

[0146] At this time, organizations B and C may perform a process of evaluating the received concealed information (shared analytical information) and updating the reliability. In this case, organizations B and C each determine whether the received shared analytical information is useful to their own organizations. If it is determined that the shared analytical information is useful to their own organizations as a result of this determination, a predetermined additional value is added to the reliability score from organizations B and C to organization A, which is the provider of the shared analytical information. The additional value at this time may be a preset value, or may be determined depending on the usefulness of the shared analytical information to their own organizations. The reliability scores thus determined are transmitted from organizations B and C to the analysis device 104, whereby the analysis device 104 performs a reliability information update process.

[0147] Thereafter, organizations B and C each determine whether a more detailed analysis of the received concealed information (shared analytical information) is necessary. If, as a result of this determination, organization C determines in S1807 that a more detailed analysis is necessary, for example, the transmitting device 101 of organization C requests logic information from the analyzing device 104 (S1808), similar to S1001 in Fig. 10. In response, the analyzing device 104 transmits the logic information table 181 to the receiving device 102 of organization C (S1809), similar to S1002 in Fig. 10.

[0148] Organization C, which has received logic information table 181 via receiving device 102, determines which of the analyses that can be performed by analysis device 104, with reference to the logic information shown in logic information table 181. After the determination, transmitting device 101 of organization B generates an analysis request and transmits this to analysis device 104 to request analysis (S1810).

[0149] Thereafter, in information sharing system 1B, analysis processing is executed (S1811). In this analysis processing, processing similar to S1004 to S1015 in Fig. 10 is executed, and analysis is performed by analysis device 104 using analytical information collected from multiple organizations.

[0150] FIG. 19 is a flowchart showing a case where an organization that has viewed the shared analytical information determines that analysis is not necessary and returns related analytical information held within its own organization to the organization that provided the shared analytical information.

[0151] The processes of S1901 to S1907 are the same as those of S1801 to S1807 in Fig. 18. If it is determined in S1907 that a more detailed analysis is not required, the organization searches within each organization whether there is related analytical information corresponding to the received shared analytical information. In Fig. 19, it is assumed that organizations B and C determine that a detailed analysis is not required, and in addition, organization B finds related analytical information within the organization through a search.

[0152] The transmission device 101 of organization B requests the anonymization definition table 185 from the analysis device 104 (S1908).

[0153] Upon receiving a request for the anonymization definition table 185 from the transmission device 101 of organization B, the analysis device 104 transmits the anonymization definition table 185 to organization B (S1909).

[0154] When the anonymization definition table 185 is transmitted from the analysis device 104, organization B receives it using the receiving device 102 and outputs it to the transmitting device 101. The transmitting device 101 uses the received anonymization definition table 185 by the anonymization processor 173 to perform multiple anonymizations with different degrees of anonymity on the related analysis information held by its own organization, and creates a group of anonymized related analysis information (anonymized related analysis information group) (S1910).

[0155] Next, the transmitting device 101 of organization B transmits the group of anonymization-related analytical information created in S1910 to the analysis device 104 together with the reliability threshold information calculated by referring to the anonymization policy 132 (S1911).

[0156] Upon receiving this information from the transmitting device 101 of organization B, the analysis device 104 uses the reliability table 184, the organization information table 182, and the received reliability threshold information to select anonymization-related analysis information with a level of confidentiality according to the reliability of organization B to organization A from the group of anonymization-related analysis information provided by organization B, and transmits the selected information to organization A (S1912).

[0157] The anonymized associated analytical information transmitted from the analysis device 104 is received by the receiving device 102 held by organization A (S1913).

[0158] Organization A that has received the anonymization-related analytical information may use this information to perform a process of updating the trust from organization A to organization B. In this case, the trust is updated by the same process as S1012 to S1015 in FIG.

[0159] According to the third embodiment of the present invention described above, the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1B each have a concealment processing unit 173, a transmission device 101, and a reception device 102. The concealment processing unit 173 of each organization collects and conceals the analysis information of the organization. The transmission device 101 of each organization transmits the concealed analysis information to the analysis device 104 connected via the networks 103 and 105, which are communication lines, and the Internet 106. The analysis device 104 has an analysis unit 174 and an information transmission unit 172, and collects concealed analysis information by receiving the analysis information transmitted from the transmission devices 101 of the multiple organizations, and transmits the concealed analysis information collected from each organization to another organization. The reception device 102 of each organization receives the concealed analysis information and analysis results transmitted from the analysis device 104. In this way, each organization can determine whether or not analysis is necessary based on the analysis information shared while being kept confidential from other organizations, and if it is determined that analysis is necessary, it can perform the analysis using analysis device 104, and even if it is determined that analysis is not necessary, it is possible to realize information sharing system 1B that allows feedback of related information.

[0160] Furthermore, the transmitting device 101 of each organization transmits to the analyzing device 104, among the analytical information held by the organization, related analytical information related to the anonymized shared analytical information provided by other organizations and transmitted by the analyzing device 104. The information transmitting unit 172 transmits the related analytical information transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of each organization other than the organization to the organization that is the provider of the anonymized shared analytical information among the multiple organizations. At this time, the information transmitting unit 172 transmits the anonymized related analytical information transmitted from the transmitting devices 101 of the multiple organizations to the organization that is the provider of the anonymized shared analytical information with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability. In this manner, an information sharing system 1B that can further promote information sharing among multiple organizations can be realized.

[0161] (Fourth embodiment) An information sharing system according to a fourth embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to Figs. 20 and 21. Fig. 20 is an overall configuration diagram of an information sharing system 1C according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. Like the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment, the information sharing system according to this embodiment is configured by connecting organizations A, B, and C, each having a transmitting device 101 and a receiving device 102, and organization D having an analyzing device 104 to the Internet 106 via networks 103 and 105.

[0162] The transmitting device 101 owned by each of the organizations A to C has a concealment processing unit 173, similar to the transmitting device 101 of the information sharing systems 1A and 1B according to the second and third embodiments. In addition, the receiving device 102 owned by each of the organizations A to C has the analysis unit 174 that was held by the analysis device 104. In other respects, the configurations and functions of the transmitting device 101 and receiving device 102 of the organizations A to C and the configuration and functions of the analysis device 104 of the organization D are respectively similar to those of the information sharing system 1 according to the first embodiment. Note that the analysis unit 174 may be held by the transmitting device 101 in the organizations A to C.

[0163] The difference between the information sharing system 1C according to this embodiment and the information sharing systems 1, 1A, and 1B described in the first to third embodiments is that the analysis unit 174 does not perform analysis using analytical information from multiple organizations, but performs analysis using analytical information from a single organization. That is, in this embodiment, first, an analysis is performed in a single organization using analytical logic acquired from one or more organizations, and the analysis results are shared with multiple organizations after being made anonymous. Next, the analysis results are evaluated using the method shown in the first embodiment, and a reliability update process is performed.

[0164] An overview of the processing of the information sharing system 1C according to the present embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 21. Fig. 21 is a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system 1C according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention.

[0165] First, the transmission device 101 held by organization A requests logic information from the analysis device 104 (S2101).

[0166] When receiving a logic information request from the transmitting device 101 of organization A, the analyzing device 104 transmits the logic information table 181 to the receiving device 102 of organization A via the information transmitting unit 172 (S2102).

[0167] Organization A, which has received logic information table 181 via receiving device 102, determines which analysis to perform with reference to the logic information shown in logic information table 181. After the determination, transmitting device 101 of organization A transmits information for identifying analysis logic 131 to be used for the analysis to analysis device 104, and attempts to acquire analysis logic 131 (S2103).

[0168] When the analysis device 104 receives information for identifying the analysis logic 131 transmitted from the transmission device 101 of organization A, the request transmission unit 171 of the analysis device 104 identifies the analysis logic 131 to be used for analysis and the organization that holds the analysis logic based on the received information and the logic information table 181. Then, the connection destination of the identified organization is obtained using the organization information table 182, and a request is made to the obtained connection destination to transmit the analysis logic 131 (S2104). FIG. 21 shows an example of a case where a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 is made to organization C, and this example will be described below, but the same applies when a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 is made to other organizations.

[0169] Upon receiving a request to transmit the analysis logic 131 from the analysis device 104, the transmission device 101 of organization C transmits the analysis logic 131 stored in the storage device 114 to the analysis device 104 via the analysis logic transmission unit 123 (S2105).

[0170] Upon receiving the analysis logic 131 transmitted from the transmitting device 101 of organization C, the analysis device 104 transmits the analysis logic 131 to organization A.

[0171] Upon receiving the analysis logic 131 transmitted from the analysis device 104, the receiving device 102 of organization A uses the received analysis logic 131 and the analysis information held by its own organization to perform the analysis determined in S2103 by the analysis unit 174 (S2106).

[0172] Next, the transmission device 101 of organization A requests the anonymization definition table 185 from the analysis device 104 (S2107).

[0173] Upon receiving a request for the anonymization definition table 185 from the transmission device 101 of organization A, the analysis device 104 transmits the anonymization definition table 185 to organization A (S2108).

[0174] When the anonymization definition table 185 is transmitted from the analysis device 104, organization A receives it using the receiving device 102 and outputs it to the transmitting device 101. In the transmitting device 101, the anonymization processing unit 173 uses the received anonymization definition table 185 to anonymize the analysis results obtained in S2106 based on the trust between the organizations, and creates a group of analysis results anonymized with different degrees of anonymity for each organization (anonymized analysis result group) (S2109).

[0175] Next, the transmitting device 101 of organization A transmits the anonymized analysis results created in S2109 to the analysis device 104 together with the threshold information of the reliability of the analytical information used during the analysis, which was obtained by referring to the anonymization policy 132 (S2110).

[0176] Upon receiving these pieces of information from the transmitting device 101 of organization A, the analysis device 104 uses the reliability table 184, the organization information table 182, and the received reliability threshold information to separate the anonymized analysis results provided by organization A into analysis results (anonymized analysis results) anonymized at different levels of anonymity for each organization, and transmits them to each organization except organization A (S2111). That is, in the analysis device 104, the information transmitting unit 172 transmits the analysis results anonymized by the anonymizing unit 173 of organization A at different levels of anonymity for each organization based on the reliability to organization B and organization C to be shared between the organizations. In this way, the analysis results anonymized at different levels of anonymity for each organization based on the reliability between the organizations can be transmitted from the analysis device 104 to each organization and shared between the organizations. At this time, similarly to S1011 in FIG. 10 described in the first embodiment, the analysis device 104 may transmit the anonymized analysis result in response to a request from the transmission device 101 possessed by each organization, rather than forcibly transmitting the anonymized analysis result to each organization.

[0177] In organizations B and C, the anonymized analysis results transmitted from the analysis device 104 are received by the respective receiving devices 102 (S2112).

[0178] Thereafter, in the information sharing system 1C, a trust degree update process is executed (S2113). In this trust degree update process, the same processes as S1013 to S1015 in Fig. 10 are executed, and the trust degree of organization A from each organization that shared the analysis result is calculated and updated.

[0179] According to the fourth embodiment of the present invention described above, the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1C each have the concealment processing unit 173 and the analysis unit 174, the transmission device 101, and the reception device 102. The analysis unit 174 of each organization performs analysis using the analysis information of the organization. The concealment processing unit 173 of each organization conceals the analysis result by the analysis unit 174 of the organization. The transmission device 101 of each organization transmits the concealed analysis result to the analysis device 104 connected via the networks 103, 105 and the Internet 106, which are communication lines. The analysis device 104 has an information transmission unit 172, and transmits the concealed analysis results transmitted from the transmission devices 101 of the multiple organizations to the other organizations. That is, the information transmission unit 172 transmits the information concealed by the concealment processing unit 173 of one of the organizations with a different concealment degree for each organization based on the reliability to one or more organizations among the multiple organizations to share the information among the organizations. Receiving device 102 of each organization receives the anonymized analysis results transmitted from analysis device 104. In this manner, each organization performs analysis based on its own analysis information and shares the analysis results with other organizations after anonymizing them, thereby realizing information sharing system 1C that can realize even more secure information sharing.

[0180] Fifth embodiment An information sharing system according to the fifth embodiment of the present invention will be described below with reference to Fig. 22. The overall configuration diagram of the information sharing system according to the fifth embodiment of the present invention is similar to the overall configuration diagram of the information sharing system 1B according to the third embodiment shown in Fig. 17. Therefore, the present embodiment will be described below using the configuration of the information sharing system 1B in Fig. 17.

[0181] The fifth embodiment differs from the third embodiment in the process contents in the phase (S1806 in FIG. 18, S1906 in FIG. 19) in which the analysis device 104 transmits anonymized analytical information (anonymized information) to each organization to share it. In the third embodiment, as described above, the analysis device 104 receives anonymized information sets and reliability threshold information from the transmission device 101 of organization A, and transmits the anonymized information sets provided from organization A to each organization other than organization A at different anonymization levels according to the reliability of organization A to each of the other organizations, using the reliability table 184, organization information table 182, and the received reliability threshold information. On the other hand, in the present embodiment, an example will be described in which not only reliability but also another index is used as a criterion for determining which organization to transmit analytical information with which anonymization level.

[0182] The above index is preferably one that allows each organization to determine whether it is worth providing the anonymized analytical information before providing the anonymized analytical information to the organization. In this embodiment, for example, the similarity between the analytical information provided by organization A and the analytical information held by each organization is used as the index. Here, if the similarity between the analytical information provided by organization A and the analytical information originally held by another organization is high, it is considered that the organization has a common problem with organization A and has highly relevant analytical information. Therefore, when determining the degree of anonymization of the analytical information to be transmitted from the analysis device 104 to each organization, by introducing an index of the similarity between the analytical information and the analytical information held by each organization, organization A, which is the information provider, can evaluate whether the related analytical information received from each organization is likely to be beneficial to organization A. If there exists an organization that holds analytical information with a high degree of similarity, and if there is a high possibility that related analytical information fed back from organization A to organization A after organization A provides shared analytical information to organization A will benefit organization A, organization A can allow sharing of analytical information with a low degree of confidentiality with organization A in order to gain benefits, even if organization A's trust in organization A is relatively low.

[0183] For example, suppose organization A is planning to share information about suspicious IP addresses with other organizations B and C. In this case, the suspicious IP address list held by organization A is compared with the access logs of organizations B and C to determine the similarity between them. For example, if the access log of organization B has a high similarity with the suspicious IP address list of organization A, organization B has a lot of communications from the same access destination as organization A. Therefore, the related analysis information returned as feedback from organization B in response to the provision of shared analysis information from organization A is likely to be useful to organization A. In addition, the information about suspicious IP addresses that organization A provides to organizations B and C as shared analysis information is useful to organization B, which holds information that is highly similar to that information. Therefore, it is expected that the trust between organizations A and B will improve and more useful information will be shared from the next time onwards.

[0184] 22 is a flowchart showing the overall processing of the information sharing system according to the fifth embodiment of the present invention. The processing in S2201 to S2205 is the same as the processing in S1801 to S1805 in FIG.

[0185] When the analysis device 104 receives the anonymized information group created in S2204 and the reliability threshold information obtained by referring to the anonymization policy 132 from the transmission device 101 of organization A, the information transmission unit 172 searches whether information similar to the anonymized information group received from organization A is present in each organization other than organization A. Here, information similar to the analytical information can be searched for using, for example, a well-known secret search technology that allows a search while keeping the search content secret by encryption. As a result, for organizations where information similar to the anonymized information group is searched for, the similarity between these pieces of information is calculated (S2206). On the other hand, for organizations where information similar to the anonymized information group cannot be searched for, the similarity is calculated as 0.

[0186] Next, the analysis device 104 divides the anonymized information group provided by organization A into anonymized analysis information (anonymized information) with an anonymized degree according to the trust from organization A to each of the other organizations and the similarity of the information between organization A and each of the other organizations by using the reliability table 184, the organization information table 182, the reliability threshold information received from organization A, and the similarity calculated in S2206, and transmits the anonymized analysis information to each organization except organization A as shared analysis information by organization A (S2207). At this time, it may be determined whether or not to adopt an anonymization degree based on the similarity depending on the reliability. For example, for an organization determined to have a low reliability, a judgment is made using the similarity, and when the similarity is determined to be high, analysis information with a low reliability but a low anonymization degree (high sensitivity) is transmitted (S2207). Furthermore, at this time, similarly to S1011 in FIG. 10 described in the first embodiment, the analysis device 104 may transmit the anonymized information in response to a request from the transmission device 101 possessed by each organization, rather than forcibly transmitting the anonymized information to each organization.

[0187] When the receiving device 102 receives the anonymized information (shared analytical information) transmitted from the analysis device 104 (S2208), each organization B and organization C may view the received information and analyze it according to their own judgment. Then, it is determined whether a more detailed analysis is necessary for the received anonymized information (shared analytical information), and processing is performed according to the judgment result (S2209). Here, if it is determined that analysis is necessary, the same processing as the processing of S1808 to S1811 in FIG. 18 is performed. On the other hand, if it is determined that analysis is not necessary and the related analytical information that is shared and held within the organization is to be returned to organization A, the same processing as the processing of S1908 to S1913 in FIG. 19 is performed.

[0188] According to the fifth embodiment of the present invention described above, the multiple organizations constituting the information sharing system 1B each have a concealment processing unit 173, a transmission device 101, and a reception device 102. The concealment processing unit 173 of each organization collects and conceals the analysis information of the organization. The transmission device 101 of each organization transmits the concealed analysis information to the analysis device 104 connected via the networks 103 and 105, which are communication lines, and the Internet 106. The analysis device 104 has an analysis unit 174 and an information transmission unit 172, and collects concealed analysis information by receiving the analysis information transmitted from the transmission devices 101 of the multiple organizations, and transmits the concealed analysis information collected from each organization to another organization. The reception device 102 of each organization receives the concealed analysis information and analysis results transmitted from the analysis device 104. Furthermore, information transmission unit 172 calculates the similarity between the analytical information anonymized by anonymization processing unit 173 of each organization and the analytical information held by each of the multiple organizations, and transmits the anonymized analytical information to one or more of the multiple organizations with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability and similarity. As a result, in information sharing system 1B, analytical information provided from one organization can be transmitted to each of the other organizations with an appropriate degree of anonymization. For example, even if an organization providing analytical information has low trust in an organization receiving the analytical information, the provided analytical information can be compared with analytical information held by the organization receiving the analytical information, and the similarity calculated and used, thereby realizing information sharing among multiple organizations with a low degree of anonymization and easier use.

[0189] Also, similar to the third embodiment, each organization can determine whether or not analysis is necessary based on the analytical information shared in a confidential state from other organizations, and if it is determined that analysis is necessary, it can perform the analysis using analysis device 104. On the other hand, even if it is determined that analysis is not necessary, it is possible to realize an information sharing system that allows feedback of related information.

[0190] The present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment and modifications, and may be implemented using any components without departing from the spirit of the present invention. In addition, the embodiments and modifications may be implemented in any combination.

[0191] The above-mentioned embodiments and modifications are merely examples, and the present invention is not limited to these contents as long as the characteristics of the invention are not impaired. In addition, although various embodiments and modifications have been described above, the present invention is not limited to these contents. Other aspects that are conceivable within the scope of the technical idea of ​​the present invention are also included in the scope of the present invention. [Explanation of symbols]

[0192] 1, 1A, 1B, 1C...information sharing system, 101...transmission device, 102...reception device, 104...analysis device, 121...request transmission unit, 122...information transmission unit, 123...analysis logic transmission unit, 131...analysis logic, 132...anonymization policy, 151...information search unit, 152...analysis result evaluation unit, 171...request transmission unit, 172...information transmission unit, 173...anonymization processing unit, 174...analysis unit, 175...trust update unit, 181...logic information table, 182...organization information table, 183...trust score table, 184...trust table, 185...anonymization definition table

Claims

1. a concealment processing unit that conceals information collected from one or more of the multiple organizations based on the degree of trust between the organizations; An analysis unit that performs analysis using the information anonymized by the anonymization unit and analysis logic collected from any one or more of the multiple organizations; an information transmission unit that transmits the analysis results by the analysis unit to one or more of the multiple organizations to share the results among the organizations.

2. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, An information sharing system comprising a reliability update unit that updates the reliability.

3. 3. The information sharing system according to claim 2, The reliability update unit is an information sharing system that updates the reliability for each organization based on a history of provision of the analysis logic by each organization.

4. 3. The information sharing system according to claim 2, The reliability update unit updates the reliability for each organization based on the contribution of the information to the analysis.

5. 3. The information sharing system according to claim 2, The reliability update unit updates the reliability for each organization based on the usefulness of the analysis results.

6. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, The information sending unit determines whether or not to share the analysis results for each organization based on the reliability, and sends the analysis results to each organization except for organizations that have determined not to share the analysis results.

7. 7. The information sharing system according to claim 6, The concealment processing unit judges whether or not the information can be used in the analysis for each of the organizations based on the reliability, and conceals the information except for information that is judged not to be used in the analysis; An information sharing system in which the information transmission unit determines not to share the analysis results with an organization that has provided information that is determined not to be used in the analysis.

8. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, The information transmission unit transmits the information anonymized by the anonymization processing unit to one or more of the multiple organizations with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability.

9. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, The concealment processing unit conceals the analysis results with a different concealment degree for each organization based on the reliability, The information transmission unit transmits the analysis results, which have been anonymized by the anonymization processing unit with a different degree of anonymity for each organization based on the reliability, to one or more of the multiple organizations to share the results among the organizations.

10. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, The information transmission unit calculates a similarity between the information anonymized by the anonymization processing unit and the information held by each of the multiple organizations, and transmits the anonymized information to one or more of the multiple organizations with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability and the similarity.

11. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, Each of the plurality of organizations has a transmitting device and a receiving device; the transmitting device of each organization transmits the information to an analyzing device connected via a communication line; The analysis device has the concealment processing unit, the analysis unit, and the information transmission unit, and collects the information by receiving the information transmitted from the transmission devices of the plurality of organizations, and conceals the collected information; The receiving device of each organization receives the analysis results transmitted from the analyzing device.

12. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, Each of the multiple organizations has the concealment processing unit, a transmitting device, and a receiving device, The concealment processing unit of each organization collects and conceals the information of the organization, The transmitting device of each organization transmits the anonymized information to an analysis device connected via a communication line, The analysis device includes the analysis unit and the information transmission unit, and collects the anonymized information by receiving the information transmitted from each of the transmission devices of the plurality of organizations; The receiving device of each organization receives the analysis results transmitted from the analyzing device.

13. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, Each of the multiple organizations has the concealment processing unit, a transmitting device, and a receiving device, The concealment processing unit of each organization collects and conceals the information of the organization, The transmitting device of each organization transmits the anonymized information to an analysis device connected via a communication line, The analysis device has the analysis unit and the information transmission unit, and collects the anonymized information by receiving the information transmitted from each of the transmission devices of the plurality of organizations, and transmits the anonymized information collected from each organization to another organization; The receiving device of each organization receives the anonymized information and the analysis results transmitted from the analysis device, respectively.

14. 14. The information sharing system according to claim 13, The transmission device of each organization transmits to the analysis device, relevant information related to the anonymized information provided by other organizations and transmitted by the analysis device, among the information held by the organization, The information transmission unit transmits the related information transmitted from the transmitting devices of each organization other than an organization that is a source of the concealed information among the multiple organizations.

15. 15. The information sharing system according to claim 14, The concealment processing unit of each organization collects and conceals the relevant information of the organization, The transmission device of each organization transmits the anonymized related information to the analysis device, The information transmission unit transmits the anonymized related information transmitted from the transmitting devices of the multiple organizations to an organization that is a source of the anonymized information, with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability.

16. 14. The information sharing system according to claim 13, The information transmission unit calculates a similarity between the information anonymized by the anonymization processing unit and the information held by each of the multiple organizations, and transmits the anonymized information to one or more of the multiple organizations with a degree of anonymization based on the reliability and the similarity.

17. 2. The information sharing system according to claim 1, Each of the multiple organizations has the concealment processing unit, the analysis unit, a transmitting device, and a receiving device, The analysis unit of each organization performs the analysis using the information of the organization, The concealment processing unit of each organization conceals the analysis results by the analysis unit of that organization, the transmitting device of each organization transmits the anonymized analysis result to an analysis device connected via a communication line; The analysis device includes the information transmission unit, and transmits the anonymized analysis results transmitted from the transmission devices of the plurality of organizations to another organization; An information sharing system in which the receiving device of each organization receives the anonymized analysis results transmitted from the analysis device.

18. A method for collecting information from any one or more of a plurality of organizations by a computer, The collected information is concealed by the computer based on the degree of trust between each organization, performing an analysis by the computer using the anonymized information and analysis logic collected from any one or more of the plurality of organizations; The information sharing method further comprises transmitting the results of the analysis to one or more of the plurality of organizations by the computer, thereby sharing the results among the organizations.

19. An analysis unit that performs analysis using information of one or more of a plurality of organizations that has been anonymized based on the degree of trust between the organizations and analysis logic collected from one or more of the plurality of organizations; and an information transmission unit that transmits an analysis result by the analysis unit to one or more of the plurality of organizations to share the analysis result among the organizations.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Data communication system, data analysis device, data communication method and program

    JP2014095931A

  • Information processing program, apparatus, method and system

    JP2020092748A

  • Provision device, provision method, and provision program

    JP2021018587A