Method and system for developing cyber attack scenario for ship

The ship cyber attack scenario development method and system address the unique cybersecurity challenges of maritime environments by visualizing attack paths and identifying potential surfaces through a combined Cyber Attack Tree and Diamond model, enhancing response strategies and resilience in ship systems.

WO2024248515A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-12-05HANWHA OCEAN CO LTD (KR) +1
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/KR2024/007427
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-06-02
Filing Date
2024-05-31
Publication Date
2024-12-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current cybersecurity measures lack specific regulations and scenarios tailored for the unique characteristics of ship systems, particularly in maritime environments, where conventional cyber attack visualization methods like Cyber Attack Trees are inadequate due to linear and hierarchical limitations, and semantic graphs become complex with increased data.

Method used

A ship cyber attack scenario development method and system that identifies ship systems and stakeholder assets, analyzes threat data, selects attack targets, creates and executes attack scenarios, and outputs attack graphs combining Cyber Attack Tree and Diamond models to visualize all infiltration paths and identify potential attack surfaces, using the MITER ATT&CK Framework for comprehensive analysis.

Benefits of technology

Enables the visualization of all attack paths and identification of potential attack surfaces, providing a response strategy by capturing the range of attack techniques and characteristics, enhancing cyber resilience and improving detection of sophisticated intrusions in ship systems.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure KR2024007427_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure KR2024007427_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention presents a method and a system for developing a cyber attack scenario for a ship, which are capable of: using a ship attack scenario model so as to visualize, through an attack graph, all paths through which an attacker can infiltrate an attack target; and capturing the range of attack technology and characteristics so as to identify a potential attack surface.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Method and system for developing ship cyber attack scenarios

[0001] The present invention relates to a method and system for developing a ship cyber attack scenario, which can visualize all paths through which an attacker can penetrate an attack target through an attack graph using a ship attack scenario model, and identify a potential attack surface by capturing the range of attack techniques and characteristics.

[0002] As the threat of cyberattacks continues to increase, governments and international organizations are demanding the development of countermeasures against them. To address this need, research on developing cyberattack scenarios is being conducted domestically. The Electronics and Telecommunications Research Institute (ETRI) published "Cyberattack Simulation Technology Trends" in 2020, emphasizing the importance of developing cyberattack simulations to early identify system security status and attack surfaces. To develop cyberattack scenarios, the Agency for Defense Development (ADD) registered a domestic patent in 2018 titled "Method and System for Responding to Security Vulnerabilities Based on Standard Data for Creating and Validating Cyberwarfare Scenarios." This patent identifies vulnerabilities suitable for creating cyberwarfare scenarios based on open standard data for managing security vulnerability data, and develops a system that provides countermeasures based on standard data. Another scenario development approach, "Design and Implementation of Cyber ​​Attack Simulator based on Attack Techniques Modeling," published in the Journal of the Korea Computer Information Society, models cyberattack techniques to derive various attack scenarios and develops a simulator for cybersecurity training. Furthermore, "A Study on a Stage-Based Flow Graph Model for Representing Cyber ​​Attack Training Scenarios," published in the Journal of the Korean Society for Information Security, presents a stage-based flow graph model capable of representing various cyber attack training scenarios that were previously difficult to represent using attack tree modeling techniques. Despite this active research, the shipbuilding and marine industries have been actively investing in autonomous and smart ships, also known as maritime mobility. However, specific regulations and scenarios for cybersecurity have not been developed.

[0003] Furthermore, prior art techniques fail to account for the unique characteristics of ships operating at sea, limiting their application. One of the unique characteristics of ship systems is that ship communication systems utilize communication protocols optimized for maritime use, distinguishing them from land-based communication protocols. Furthermore, the computer-based systems (CBS) used on ships require specific hardware and software designed specifically for ship use. Given the unique characteristics of ship systems, it is essential to develop a ship cyberattack scenario system that reflects the unique characteristics of ship communication protocols and the specific hardware and software used in ship systems.

[0004] Conventional cyberattack scenarios, designed to visualize the attack process, utilize a Cyber ​​Attack Tree (CAT), which limits its ability to explain the interconnectedness of cyberattacks due to its linear and hierarchical nature. Semantic graphs, on the other hand, suffer from the problem of graph complexity and difficulty in interpretation as data volumes increase.

[0005] As a related prior art document, Republic of Korea Patent No. 10-1697189 (January 17, 2017) is published.

[0006] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method and system for developing a ship cyber attack scenario, which visualizes all paths through which an attacker can infiltrate an attack target through an attack graph using a ship attack scenario model, and identifies potential attack surfaces and prepares a response strategy by analyzing various infiltration techniques, attack technologies, properties, and effects.

[0007] A method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario according to one aspect of the present invention for achieving the above technical task may include an asset identification step of identifying ship systems and stakeholder assets; a threat data verification step of analyzing asset information identified through the asset identification step to verify the presence of threat data; an attack target selection step of selecting an attack target if at least one of the assets identified through the threat data verification step belongs to the attack target; an attack scenario writing step of writing an attack scenario for the attack target selected through the attack target selection step; and an attack graph output step of outputting an attack graph according to the scenario written through the attack scenario writing step.

[0008] In addition, in a ship cyber attack scenario development method according to one aspect of the present invention, the attack scenario writing step may include: an attack target vulnerability assignment step of assigning vulnerabilities to a selected attack target; an attack execution step of executing an attack based on a vulnerability of the attack target assigned through the attack target vulnerability assignment step; a follow-up attack execution step of executing a follow-up attack through a different technique or tactic after the attack execution step; an attack target hitting step of hitting the attack target after the follow-up attack execution step; a post-condition derivation step of deriving a post-condition after hitting the attack target through the attack target hitting step; an additional attack surface identification step of identifying an additional attack surface based on the content derived through the post-condition derivation step; and an attack graph formation step of forming an attack graph according to the executed attack scenario.

[0009] In addition, in the ship cyber attack scenario development method according to one aspect of the present invention, the attack scenario writing step may further include a follow-up attack execution step and an additional attack target n strike step, in which an additional attack surface is identified in the additional attack surface identification step, to execute an additional attack.

[0010] In addition, in the ship cyber attack scenario development method according to one aspect of the present invention, the attack graph output step can visualize and output the attack graph by combining a cyber attack tree (CAT) model and a diamond analysis model.

[0011] Additionally, in the method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario according to one aspect of the present invention, the attack graph output step can capture the range of attack techniques and characteristics and identify potential attack surfaces.

[0012] In addition, a ship cyber attack scenario development system according to another aspect of the present invention may include an asset identification unit that identifies ship systems and stakeholder assets; a threat data verification unit that analyzes asset information identified through the asset identification unit to verify the presence of threat data; an attack target selection unit that selects an attack target if at least one of the assets identified through the threat data verification unit belongs to the threat data; an attack scenario writing unit that writes an attack scenario for the attack target selected through the attack target selection unit; and an attack graph output unit that outputs an attack graph according to the scenario written through the attack scenario writing unit.

[0013] In addition, in a ship cyber attack scenario development system according to another aspect of the present invention, the attack scenario writing unit may include: an attack target vulnerability assignment unit that assigns vulnerabilities to a selected attack target; an attack execution unit that executes an attack based on a vulnerability of an attack target assigned through the attack target vulnerability assignment unit; a follow-up attack execution unit that executes a follow-up attack through a different technique or tactic than the attack execution unit; an attack target hitting unit that strikes an attack target subsequently attacked by the follow-up attack execution unit; a post-condition derivation unit that derives a post-condition after striking an attack target in the attack target hitting unit; an additional attack surface identification unit that identifies an additional attack surface based on the content derived through the post-condition derivation unit; and an attack graph formation unit that forms an attack graph according to the executed attack scenario when no additional attack target is identified by the additional attack surface identification unit.

[0014] In addition, in a ship cyber attack scenario development system according to another aspect of the present invention, the attack scenario writing unit can execute an additional attack by further including a follow-up attack execution unit and an additional attack target n strike unit when an additional attack surface is identified in the additional attack surface identification unit.

[0015] In addition, in a ship cyber attack scenario development system according to another aspect of the present invention, the attack graph output unit can visualize and output an attack graph by combining a cyber attack tree (CAT) model and a diamond analysis model.

[0016] Additionally, in a ship cyber attack scenario development system according to another aspect of the present invention, the attack graph output unit can capture the range of attack techniques and characteristics and identify potential attack surfaces.

[0017] According to the present invention, a ship attack scenario model visualizes all paths through which an attacker can penetrate an attack target through an attack graph, and analyzes various penetration techniques, attack technologies, properties, and impacts to identify potential attack surfaces and prepare response strategies.

[0018] Figure 1 is a flowchart illustrating a method for generating a ship cyber attack scenario model according to the present invention.

[0019] Figure 2 is a flowchart showing the flow of a method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario according to the present invention.

[0020] Figure 3 is a flowchart showing the flow of an attack scenario creation method according to the present invention.

[0021] FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating a ship cyber attack scenario algorithm according to one embodiment of the present invention.

[0022] FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an attack graph for an algorithm according to one embodiment of the present invention of FIG. 4.

[0023] FIG. 6 is a diagram illustrating a ship cyber attack scenario algorithm according to another embodiment of the present invention.

[0024] FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an attack graph for an algorithm according to another embodiment of the present invention of FIG. 6.

[0025] The purpose and technical configuration of the present invention and the resulting operation and effects will be more clearly understood through a detailed description based on the drawings attached to the specification of the present invention.

[0026] The terminology used herein is merely used to describe specific embodiments and is not intended to limit the present invention. For example, terms such as "consist of" or "include" used herein should not necessarily be construed to include all of the various components or various steps described in the invention, but should be construed to mean that some of the components or some steps may not be included, or that additional components or steps may be included. Furthermore, the singular expression "a" or "an" as used herein includes the plural expression unless the context clearly dictates otherwise.

[0027] Hereinafter, the present invention will be described in detail by describing preferred embodiments thereof with reference to the attached drawings. The embodiments described below are provided to facilitate the technical concept of the present invention for those skilled in the art to understand, and should not be construed as limiting the present invention. It should be understood that the embodiments of the present invention will have various applications to those skilled in the art.

[0028] In the ship cyber attack scenario development method and system according to the present invention, the ship attack scenario model visualizes all paths through which an attacker can penetrate an attack target through an attack graph, and the attack graph provides comprehensive insight into the dependencies between cyber attacks by using a graph that combines a cyber attack tree (CAT: Cyber ​​Attack Tree) and a diamond analysis model (Diamond Model).

[0029] Additionally, the MITRE ATT&CK Framework can be utilized to analyze various infiltration techniques, attack techniques, properties, and impacts, and attack scenario models can be analyzed to capture the range of attack techniques and characteristics, thereby identifying potential attack surfaces.

[0030] As illustrated in Fig. 1, this is a flowchart showing a method for creating a ship cyber attack scenario model according to the present invention.

[0031] It may include an asset identification step (S100) for identifying assets of ship systems and stakeholders, a threat determination step (S200) for checking whether the identified asset information belongs to a set of threat databases (DB), and an attack scenario modeling step (S500) for generating a cyber attack scenario by performing modeling of an attack scenario if the identified asset information belongs to a set of threat databases in the threat determination step (S200).

[0032] In addition, if the identified asset information does not belong to the set of threat databases in the threat determination step (S200), a threat data collection step (S300) for collecting additional threat data and a verification step (S400) for confirming whether the identified asset information belongs to the set of threat databases additionally collected through the threat data collection step (S300) may be further included. Accordingly, if the identified asset information belongs to the set of threat databases additionally collected, attack scenario modeling can be performed to generate a cyber attack scenario.

[0033] More specifically, referring to FIGS. 2 and 3, the flow of the ship cyber attack scenario development method and the flow of the attack scenario writing method according to the present invention may include a ship system and stakeholder asset identification step (S510), an attack target selection step (S520), an attack scenario writing step (S530), and an attack graph output step (S540).

[0034] At this time, the asset identification step (S510) may include a step (S510-1) of checking whether the identified asset information belongs to a threat database set and a step (S510-2) of analyzing the asset information to collect assets with vulnerabilities.

[0035] Additionally, the attack target selection step (S520) can select one or more of the assets collected through the asset identification step as an attack target.

[0036] In addition, the attack scenario writing step (S530) assigns a vulnerability to an attack target (S531), executes a vulnerability-based attack (S532), executes a follow-up attack after the vulnerability-based attack (S533), strikes the attack target (S534), derives a post-condition (S535), identifies an additional attack surface after deriving the post-condition (S536), and forms an attack graph if there is no additional attack surface (S539).

[0037] Additionally, in the additional attack surface identification step (S536), if there is an additional attack surface, a follow-up attack can be executed (S537), additional attack targets n can be hit (s538), and an attack graph can be formed (S539).

[0038] Furthermore, as cyberattack tactics exploiting vulnerabilities in specific systems become more sophisticated, detecting intrusions as quickly as possible becomes crucial to identify vulnerabilities and minimize the damage caused by attacks. Among the mechanisms used for intrusion detection, the Cyber ​​Attack Tree (CAT), which represents the attack process in a tree format, can provide a systematic and organized solution for establishing security measures against various attacks on network systems.

[0039] In addition, the ship cyber attack scenario development system according to the present invention may include an asset identification unit (100) that identifies ship systems and stakeholder assets, a threat data verification unit (200) that analyzes asset information identified through the asset identification unit to verify the presence of threat data, an attack target selection unit (300) that selects an attack target if at least one of the assets identified through the threat data verification unit belongs to the threat data, an attack scenario writing unit (400) that writes an attack scenario for the attack target selected through the attack target selection unit, and an attack graph output unit (500) that outputs an attack graph according to the scenario written through the attack scenario writing unit.

[0040] Additionally, the attack graph output unit (500) can visualize and output an attack graph by combining a cyber attack tree (CAT) model and a diamond analysis model.

[0041] Additionally, the attack graph output unit (500) can capture the range of attack techniques and characteristics and identify potential attack surfaces.

[0042] FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating a ship cyber attack scenario algorithm according to one embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an attack graph for the algorithm according to one embodiment of the present invention of FIG. 4.

[0043] Looking at the attack graph using the Cyber ​​Attack Tree (CAT) and Diamond Analysis Model, the Cyber ​​Attack Tree can be depicted as a variety of attack methods with multiple nodes (Root Nodes) to achieve the ultimate goal of the attack target (Victim).

[0044] In the diamond analysis model, nodes represent attack techniques and status, vectors represent activity threads, and graphs represent attack graphs.

[0045] An attack scenario can be created from one or more nodes in the attack direction from top to bottom, targeting the victim, thereby forming an attack graph.

[0046] Looking at the algorithm, it selects a node belonging to the prior data representing a potential attack vector, and then selects a victim from the target representing a ship or a CBS (Computer Based System).

[0047] Next, we iterate over each node in the attack vector to see if it is a subset of the previous node, and if so, we move on to the next node.

[0048] Additionally, if the node belongs to a subset of the attack targets, it moves to the next node in the attack vector.

[0049] Next, if the node is a subset of the target, the cyberattack is considered successful.

[0050] Data collection criteria can be used to collect a threat database (DB) based on maritime threat intelligence information (IoC, CVE, CPE, CWE, CVSS, Dark Web, Attack Case).

[0051] Ship system and stakeholder asset identification can identify assets from ship system information, stakeholder accounts including crew members, and network information (IP, domain, DNS, etc.) of related companies.

[0052] The reason for selecting the Cyber ​​Attack Tree (CAT) model and the Diamond Analysis Model used in the present invention is that the combination of the models can provide a comprehensive and flexible approach to understanding cyber attack scenarios, and the top-down and vertical attack directions can provide an in-depth understanding of the dependencies between cyber attacks.

[0053] Additionally, the compatibility of the MITRE ATT&CK framework with the Diamond Model is useful for analyzing intrusion techniques, attack techniques, and attack strategies.

[0054] This allows for effective analysis of various types of cyber attack scenarios.

[0055] Therefore, in analyzing cyber attack models, the MITRE ATT&CK framework is used to systematically understand the various stages and components of an attack.

[0056] The attack stages of the model can be classified using the framework's techniques, and the attack status and techniques of each node can be analyzed through sub-techniques or tactics.

[0057] This approach provides a deeper understanding of the tactics and strategies used by attackers, helping to determine their motivations. Furthermore, by referencing the IACS No. 171 guidelines, it is possible to assess the impact of cyberattacks on the availability, confidentiality, integrity, and traceability of systems and equipment.

[0058] Additionally, to determine the extent of damage and potential impact of CBS on board a ship, refer to the impact of a potential incident in the UR E22 guideline.

[0059] As a method for developing countermeasures, cyberattack scenario models provide insight into the tactics and strategies employed by cyber attackers. Mitigation, as defined by the MITRE ATT&CK framework, is utilized as a countermeasure to mitigate the damage caused by an attack. The framework analyzes attacker behavior and suggests mitigation strategies to counter cyberattacks, enabling the development of countermeasures against the attack surface.

[0060] Additionally, it can assess the potential damage to ships in the event of a cyberattack, establish mitigation measures, strengthen cybersecurity posture, and mitigate cyberattacks through preemptive planning.

[0061] FIG. 6 is a diagram showing a ship cyber attack scenario algorithm according to another embodiment of the present invention, and FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an attack graph for the algorithm according to another embodiment of the present invention of FIG. 6.

[0062] If we look at the attack scenario at each node for the attack target, we can represent the attack techniques and tactics through three phases.

[0063] When examining cyberattack scenarios against VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) communications, a vulnerability list is used to gather threat intelligence on VSAT assets. This list, known as Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE), is compiled by MITRE, a non-profit research and development organization sponsored by the U.S. federal government, to identify and classify vulnerabilities in software and firmware. This list serves as a preliminary source of threat data for VSAT assets.

[0064] At this time, select the node belonging to the CVE data and select VSAT as the attack target.

[0065] Active scanning performs information collection when node n1 belongs to node n0, and cross-site scripting is performed when node n2 belongs to node n1.

[0066] If node n5 belongs to node n2, it performs web session hijacking.

[0067] Additionally, if node n3 belongs to node n1, it writes random content, and if node n4 belongs to node n1, it spoofs the code.

[0068] Additionally, if the attack target (t0) belongs to any of the n3, n4, and n5 nodes, credential theft is performed.

[0069] Additionally, if the n6 node belongs to the attack target (t0), the ship network is scanned, and if the n6 node belongs to the n7 node, diffusion and propagation are performed.

[0070] Additionally, if the new attack target (t1) belongs to node n7, it is considered that the access to the ship system cyber attack was successful.

[0071] Therefore, according to the present invention, a system can be constructed that combines a cyber attack tree (CAT) model and a diamond analysis model to represent an attack graph, and develops ship cyber attack scenarios to identify potential attack surfaces for ship systems and secure cyber attack response capabilities.

[0072] In addition, according to the present invention, it is possible to detect vulnerabilities and potential vulnerabilities inherent in a ship system through a cyber attack scenario.

[0073] In addition, according to the present invention, a preventive response plan is obtained by creating a cyber threat scenario that may occur as a cyber attack scenario, and by identifying and analyzing the entire scope of a cyber attack through an attack graph, a potential attack surface is identified and an effective cyber attack response strategy is established, thereby helping to improve overall cyber resilience.

[0074] In addition, according to the present invention, by evaluating a scenario-based graph through a threat analysis approach, it is possible to improve practitioners' cyber response capabilities and cyber risk management.

[0075] The embodiments of the present invention described above may be implemented in the form of program commands that can be executed through various computer components and recorded on a computer-readable recording medium. The computer-readable recording medium may include program commands, data files, data structures, etc., either singly or in combination. The program commands recorded on the computer-readable recording medium may be specially designed and configured for the present invention or may be known and available to those skilled in the art of computer software. Examples of computer-readable recording media include magnetic media such as hard disks, floppy disks, and magnetic tapes, optical recording media such as CD-ROMs and DVDs, magneto-optical media such as floptical disks, and hardware devices specifically configured to store and execute program commands, such as ROMs, RAMs, and flash memories. Examples of program commands include not only machine language codes generated by a compiler, but also high-level language codes that can be executed by a computer using an interpreter, etc. Hardware devices may be changed into one or more software modules to perform processing according to the present invention, and vice versa.

[0076] The embodiments described above are provided to enable those skilled in the art to easily understand the technical concept of the present invention, and should not be construed as limiting the present invention thereby. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the embodiments of the present invention can be variously modified and altered without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Accordingly, such modifications or variations should be considered to fall within the scope of the claims of the present invention.

Claims

1. Asset identification step to identify ship systems and stakeholder assets; A threat data verification step that analyzes the asset information identified through the above asset identification step to confirm the presence of threat data; An attack target selection step for selecting an attack target if at least one of the assets identified in the threat data through the above threat data verification step belongs to it; An attack scenario writing step for writing an attack scenario for an attack target selected through the above attack target selection step; and A method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario, comprising an attack graph output step for outputting an attack graph according to a scenario created through the above attack scenario creation step.

2. In claim 1, The above attack scenario writing steps are: Attack target vulnerability assignment step that assigns vulnerabilities to the selected attack target; An attack execution step for executing a vulnerability-based attack on an attack target assigned through the above attack target vulnerability assignment step; A follow-up attack execution step that executes a follow-up attack through another technique or tactic after the above attack execution step; An attack target hitting step for hitting the attack target after the above follow-up attack execution step; A post-condition derivation step for deriving a post-condition after hitting an attack target through the above attack target hitting step; An additional attack surface identification step for identifying additional attack surfaces based on the content derived through the above post-condition derivation step; and A method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario, comprising an attack graph formation step of forming an attack graph according to an executed attack scenario.

3. In claim 2, The above attack scenario writing steps are: If additional attack surfaces are identified during the Additional Attack Surface Identification phase, Follow-up attack execution phase; and A method for developing a ship cyber attack scenario, which includes additional attack target n strike steps to execute additional attacks.

4. In claim 1, The above attack graph output step is, A method for developing ship cyber attack scenarios by combining a cyber attack tree (CAT) model and a diamond analysis model to visualize and output an attack graph.

5. In claim 4, The above attack graph output step is, A method for developing ship cyber attack scenarios that captures the range of attack techniques and characteristics and identifies potential attack surfaces.

6. Asset identification section for identifying ship systems and stakeholder assets; A threat data verification unit that analyzes asset information identified through the above asset identification unit to check for the presence of threat data; An attack target selection unit that selects an attack target if at least one of the assets identified in the threat data through the threat data verification unit is included; An attack scenario writing unit that writes an attack scenario for an attack target selected through the above attack target selection unit; and A ship cyber attack scenario development system including an attack graph output unit that outputs an attack graph according to a scenario created through the above attack scenario creation unit.

7. In claim 6, The above attack scenario writing department, Attack target vulnerability assignment unit that assigns vulnerabilities to selected attack targets; An attack execution unit that executes a vulnerability-based attack on an attack target assigned through the above attack target vulnerability assignment unit; A follow-up attack execution unit that executes follow-up attacks using techniques or tactics different from the above attack execution unit; An attack target striking unit that strikes the attack target that has been attacked in the follow-up attack execution unit above; A post-condition derivation unit that derives a post-condition after hitting the attack target in the above attack target hitting unit; An additional attack surface identification unit that identifies an additional attack surface based on the content derived through the above post-condition derivation unit; and A ship cyber attack scenario development system, comprising an attack graph formation unit that forms an attack graph according to an executed attack scenario when no additional attack targets are identified in an additional attack surface identification unit.

8. In claim 7, The above attack scenario writing department, If additional attack surfaces are identified in the Additional Attack Surface Identification Unit, Follow-up attack execution unit; and A ship cyber attack scenario development system that executes additional attacks by including additional attack targets and strike units.

9. In claim 6, The above attack graph output section is, A ship cyber attack scenario development system that visualizes and outputs an attack graph by combining the Cyber ​​Attack Tree (CAT) model and the Diamond Analysis model.

10. In claim 9, The above attack graph output section is, A ship cyber attack scenario development system that captures the range of attack techniques and characteristics and identifies potential attack surfaces.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • System and Method for Cyber Attack History Tracking based on Scenario

    KR101697189B1

  • Cyber Attack System for Vulnerability Assessment and Method Thereof

    KR100851521B1

  • System and method for cyber prediction based on attack graph

    KR102079687B1

  • Method and apparatus for predicting attack target based on attack graph

    KR102295654B1

  • System for Managing Cyber Security of Autonomous Ship

    KR102433928B1