SBS modified asphalt anti-aging performance comprehensive evaluation method based on stress-strain curve

Through stress and strain curve analysis and hierarchical analysis, a comprehensive evaluation method for anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt was constructed, which solved the problem of inconsistent evaluation indicators and inability to quantify large strain plastic deformation in the existing technology, and realized the modification of SBS Accurate anti-aging performance evaluation of asphalt.

CN118980629APending Publication Date: 2024-11-19HARBIN INST OF TECH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411039718.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-31
Publication Date
2024-11-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The evaluation index of the existing SBS modified asphalt anti-aging performance evaluation methods is not uniform, the plastic deformation under large strains and complex stresses cannot be quantified, and the key mechanical behavior transition state cannot be accurately identified.

Method used

Using a comprehensive evaluation method based on the stress and strain curve, the stress and strain curve is obtained through the force ductility test, and basic indicators such as initial modulus, peak stress, yield strength, hardening strength, and fracture strength were analyzed, and six comprehensive indicators were constructed, including The toughness index, strength index and stiffness index are used to calculate the comprehensive evaluation value through hierarchical analysis method to judge the anti-aging performance.

Benefits of technology

The problem of rheology method only considering small strain ranges is solved, and the key mechanical state transitions in high strain states can be quantified, and a comprehensive anti-aging performance evaluation with multi-level analysis is provided, which makes up for the single and inconsistent existing evaluation indicators. The deficiency can accurately identify the anti-aging properties of different types of asphalt at different aging stages.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118980629A_ABST
    Figure CN118980629A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a stress-strain curve-based comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt, and relates to a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of the SBS modified asphalt. The method aims at solving the technical problems that an existing SBS modified asphalt anti-aging performance evaluation method is not uniform in evaluation index, plastic deformation under the large strain and complex stress state cannot be quantified, and the key mechanical behavior transformation state cannot be accurately recognized. Based on the mechanical state of plastic deformation in a small strain range, a large strain and a complex stress state, comprehensive anti-aging performance evaluation indexes based on toughness, strength and rigidity are provided, and the technical problems that in the past, evaluation indexes are single, and evaluation rules are not uniform are solved; the invention provides a method for evaluating the anti-aging performance of different types of asphalt in different aging stages through multi-level analysis, and overcomes the defect that only one anti-aging performance evaluation can be given for the same asphalt in the past.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt. Background Art

[0002] Styrene-butadiene-styrene (SBS) triblock copolymers are widely used worldwide to improve the performance of asphalt. When SBS is added to asphalt, a cross-linked network is formed through the polystyrene segments, while the polybutadiene segments serve as soft segments, increasing the flexibility and elasticity of asphalt. The addition of chemical stabilizers not only improves the compatibility of SBS polymers with asphalt, but also enhances the high-temperature stability of SBS modified asphalt. Due to the presence of stabilizers and SBS polymers, the aging mechanism of SBS modified asphalt is more complicated than that of base asphalt. After aging, the asphalt components, SBS polymers and stabilizers will undergo physical and chemical changes. Evaluating the anti-aging properties of SBS modified asphalt can predict its life under actual road conditions and improve its anti-aging properties by optimizing the material formulation. Therefore, it is particularly important to propose a suitable evaluation method for the anti-aging properties of SBS modified asphalt.

[0003] In the past, many methods have been used to evaluate the anti-aging properties of SBS modified asphalt. For example, some scholars have found that for different SBS modified asphalts, the change rate of ductility after short-term aging varies greatly based on conventional physical properties, such as penetration, softening point, ductility, rotational viscosity, etc. On the other hand, although these indicators have obvious changing patterns with aging time, they have no obvious corresponding relationship with the degree of laboratory aging, and are not suitable for establishing the relationship between basic physical properties and aging time. Many scholars have also used rheological methods to evaluate anti-aging performance. Complex shear modulus and phase angle are two commonly used viscoelastic parameters. Studies have found that the phase angle change rate of different asphalts after short-term aging and long-term aging is basically the same, while the complex shear modulus has large differences. This means that different indicators have different laws in aging, and it is difficult to describe anti-aging performance with a single indicator. In addition, rheological methods are often based on the assumption of linear viscoelasticity, considering viscoelastic deformation within a small strain range. However, SBS modified asphalt can no longer be regarded as a simple viscoelastic material due to the addition of SBS polymer. The SBS modifier changes the asphalt from a low-toughness material with single-phase yield to a high-toughness material with multi-phase yield. The rheological method alone cannot identify the key mechanical state transitions during the aging process, such as the visco-tough state, visco-elastic state, and visco-hard state. Therefore, in addition to the viscoelastic deformation within a small strain range described by rheology, it is also necessary to consider the plastic deformation under large strain and complex stress states.

[0004] The method based on stress-strain curve reflects the strength, ductility, stiffness, toughness and plastic deformation capacity of the material, including important information from general elastic deformation, viscoelastic deformation, plastic deformation to destruction, and covers the overall elastic-plastic mechanical behavior from small strain to large strain, which can more carefully and intuitively describe the performance changes of SBS modified asphalt during aging, such as toughness degradation transition and tough-brittle transition. Therefore, it is of great significance to construct a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve. Summary of the invention

[0005] The present invention aims to solve the technical problems that the existing SBS modified asphalt anti-aging performance evaluation method has inconsistent evaluation indicators, the plastic deformation under large strain and complex stress state cannot be quantified, and the key mechanical behavior transition state cannot be accurately identified, and proposes a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve.

[0006] The comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve of the present invention is carried out according to the following steps:

[0007] Firstly, asphalt samples of different asphalts at different aging stages were prepared, and then force-ductility tests were carried out on all the prepared asphalt samples to obtain the stress-strain curves of different asphalts at different aging stages. The basic indicators of anti-aging performance were obtained by analyzing the stress-strain curves: initial modulus, peak stress, yield strength, hardening strength and fracture strength. Six comprehensive indicators were constructed based on the basic indicators of anti-aging performance, including two toughness indicators: BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor; two strength indicators: peak stress and strength retention rate; two stiffness indicators: initial modulus and modulus retention rate. Based on the six comprehensive indicators, the comprehensive evaluation values ​​of the six indicators were calculated by the hierarchical analysis method, and the anti-aging performance of the asphalt was judged by accumulating the comprehensive evaluation values. The larger the accumulated comprehensive evaluation value, the better the anti-aging performance of the asphalt.

[0008] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:

[0009] 1. The present invention is based on the mechanical state of plastic deformation under small strain range, large strain and complex stress state, which solves the technical problem that the rheological method used in the past only considers small strain when evaluating the anti-aging performance of asphalt, but the high and low temperature performance is not uniform. At the same time, the method proposed by the present invention can better quantify the key mechanical state transformation of SBS modified asphalt under high strain state;

[0010] 2. The present invention proposes a comprehensive anti-aging performance evaluation index based on toughness, strength and stiffness, which solves the technical problems of single evaluation index and inconsistent evaluation rules in the past; the present invention proposes a method for evaluating the anti-aging performance of different types of asphalt at different aging stages through multi-level analysis, which makes up for the deficiency that only one anti-aging performance evaluation can be given to the same type of asphalt in the past. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0011] Figure 1 The sample preparation process for the eight asphalts in Test 1;

[0012] Figure 2 This is the stress-strain curve of 70-5%L3-0.15%S in test 1;

[0013] Figure 3 is the stress-strain curve of 90-5%L3-0.15%S in test 1;

[0014] Figure 4 is the stress-strain curve of 70-5%L3-0.00%S in test 1;

[0015] Figure 5 is the stress-strain curve of 90-5%L3-0.00%S in test 1;

[0016] Figure 6 is the stress-strain curve of 90-5%L4-0.15%S in test 1;

[0017] Figure 7 This is the stress-strain curve of 90-5%S3-0.15%S in test 1;

[0018] Figure 8 This is the stress-strain curve of 90-8%L3-0.24%S in test 1;

[0019] Fig. 9 is the stress-strain curve of 90-8% L3R-0.24% S in experiment 1;

[0020] Fig.10 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 70-5%L3-0.15%S in test 1;

[0021] Fig.11 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-5% L3-0.15% S in experiment 1;

[0022] Fig.12 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 70-5% L3-0.00% S in test 1;

[0023] Fig.13 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-5% L3-0.00% S in test 1;

[0024] Fig.14 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-5% L4-0.15% S in test 1;

[0025] Fig.15 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-5%S3-0.15%S in experiment 1;

[0026] Fig.16 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-8% L3-0.24% S in experiment 1;

[0027] Fig.17 This is the ductile-brittle transition phase diagram of 90-8% L3R-0.24% S in experiment 1;

[0028] Fig.18 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 70-5% L3-0.15% S in test 1;

[0029] Fig.19 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-5% L3-0.15% S in test 1;

[0030] Fig. 20 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 70-5% L3-0.00% S in test 1;

[0031] Fig.21 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-5% L3-0.00% S in test 1;

[0032] Fig. 22 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-5% L4-0.15% S in test 1;

[0033] Fig.23 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-5%S3-0.15%S in test 1;

[0034] Fig.24 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-8% L3-0.24% S in test 1;

[0035] Fig.25 This is the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of 90-8% L3R-0.24% S in test 1;

[0036] Fig.26 This is a schematic diagram of anti-aging evaluation based on the analytic hierarchy process in Experiment 1;

[0037] Fig. 27 This is the comprehensive evaluation data chart of eight asphalt samples in test 1;

[0038] Fig.28 This is the comprehensive evaluation data of eight asphalts of TFOT in Test 1;

[0039] Fig.29 This is the comprehensive evaluation data of eight asphalts in TFOT+10h PAV in Test 1;

[0040] Fig.30 This is the comprehensive evaluation data of eight asphalts in TFOT+20h PAV in Test 1;

[0041] Fig.31 This is the comprehensive evaluation data of eight asphalts in TFOT+30h PAV in Test 1;

[0042] Fig.32 This is the comprehensive evaluation data chart of eight types of asphalt in TFOT+40h PAV in Test 1. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0043] Specific implementation method 1: This implementation method is a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve, which is specifically carried out in the following steps:

[0044] Firstly, asphalt samples of different asphalts at different aging stages were prepared, and then force-ductility tests were carried out on all the prepared asphalt samples to obtain the stress-strain curves of different asphalts at different aging stages. The basic indicators of anti-aging performance were obtained by analyzing the stress-strain curves: initial modulus, peak stress, yield strength, hardening strength and fracture strength. Six comprehensive indicators were constructed based on the basic indicators of anti-aging performance, including two toughness indicators: BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor; two strength indicators: peak stress and strength retention rate; two stiffness indicators: initial modulus and modulus retention rate. Based on the six comprehensive indicators, the comprehensive evaluation values ​​of the six indicators were calculated by the hierarchical analysis method, and the anti-aging performance of the asphalt was judged by accumulating the comprehensive evaluation values. The larger the accumulated comprehensive evaluation value, the better the anti-aging performance of the asphalt.

[0045] Specific implementation method 2: This implementation method is different from specific implementation method 1 in that: the abscissa of the stress-strain curve is deformation, and the ordinate is load; stress is load divided by the original cross-sectional area of ​​the material; strain is deformation divided by the original length of the specimen; the method for obtaining the basic index of anti-aging performance by analyzing the stress-strain curve is as follows: perform first-order derivative and second-order derivative on each stress-strain curve respectively;

[0046] The elastic limit point is the point where the first-order derivative decreases and the second-order derivative is non-zero. The elastic limit point is the critical point between the elastic and elastoplastic stages. The initial modulus is the ratio of stress to strain corresponding to the elastic limit point.

[0047] The yield point is the point where the second-order derivative reaches its minimum value and the first-order derivative decreases. The yield point is the starting position of the obvious plastic deformation stage; the yield strength is the stress value corresponding to the yield point on the stress-strain curve;

[0048] The peak stress point is the point where the first-order derivative is zero and the second-order derivative is negative. The peak stress point is the maximum stress point. The peak stress is the stress value corresponding to the peak stress point on the stress-strain curve.

[0049] The strain hardening point is the point where the first-order derivative is zero and the second-order derivative is positive. The strain hardening point is the minimum stress point and the starting point of hardening. The hardening intensity is the stress value corresponding to the strain hardening point on the stress-strain curve.

[0050] The point before the load suddenly changes to zero is the fracture point; the fracture strength is the stress value corresponding to the fracture point on the stress-strain curve. The rest is the same as the first specific implementation method.

[0051] Specific implementation method three: This implementation method is different from the specific implementation method two in that the method of constructing two toughness indicators through the basic indicators of anti-aging performance is:

[0052] The toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages is drawn based on the fracture strength and yield strength data. The horizontal axis corresponding to the intersection of the fitting line segment of yield strength and the fitting line segment of fracture strength in the phase diagram represents the toughness-brittleness (BDT) transition point of the material, and the vertical axis is the fracture strength and yield strength. The horizontal axis corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages.

[0053] According to the fracture strength and hardening strength data, the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages is drawn. The horizontal axis corresponding to the intersection of the fitting line segment of hardening strength and the fitting line segment of fracture strength in the phase diagram represents the toughness degradation (TDT) transformation point of the material, and the vertical axis is the fracture strength and hardening strength. The horizontal axis corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages.

[0054] The BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor are calculated according to the following formula:

[0055]

[0056]

[0057] Where: BDT and λ TDT They are BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor respectively; It is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness-brittleness transition point in the toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time; It is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness degradation transition point in the toughness-deterioration transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time. The rest is the same as the second specific implementation.

[0058] Specific implementation method 4: This implementation method is different from the specific implementation method 3 in that the formula for constructing the strength retention rate through the basic index of anti-aging performance is:

[0059]

[0060] RRS=100%-RSC

[0061] Where: RSC and RRS are the strength change rate and strength retention rate respectively; σ aged and σ unaged They are the peak stress after aging and the peak stress before aging. Other aspects are the same as those of the third embodiment.

[0062] Specific implementation method 5: This implementation method is different from the specific implementation method 4 in that the formula for constructing the modulus retention rate through the basic index of anti-aging performance is:

[0063]

[0064] RRM = 100% - RMC;

[0065] Where: RMC and RRM are modulus change rate and modulus retention rate respectively; E aged and E unaged They are the initial modulus after aging and the initial modulus before aging. Others are the same as those in the fourth embodiment.

[0066] Specific implementation method 6: This implementation method is different from specific implementation method 5 in that the data of the six comprehensive indicators of each asphalt sample are normalized, and the normalized data are multiplied by the weight coefficients corresponding to the six comprehensive indicators to calculate the corresponding weighted values. The weighted values ​​of the six comprehensive indicators are summed to obtain the comprehensive evaluation value of each asphalt sample. The higher the comprehensive evaluation value, the better the anti-aging performance; the weight coefficients corresponding to the BDT duration factor, TDT duration factor, peak stress, strength retention rate, initial modulus and modulus retention rate of the six comprehensive indicators are 0.41, 0.8, 0.34, 0.27, 0.2 and 0.13 respectively. The rest is the same as specific implementation method 5.

[0067] Specific implementation method 7: This implementation method is different from specific implementation method 6 in that the force measurement ductility test method is:

[0068] 1. Stir the asphalt sample evenly and pour it into the ductility mold. Let the mold filled with the sample stand at room temperature for 1.5 hours;

[0069] 2. Use a hot scraper to correct the surface of the sample so that it is flush with the mold, and then place the test piece in 4°C water for 1.5 hours;

[0070] 3. After the heat preservation is completed, the sample is stretched in 4°C water at a stretching speed of 5 cm / min, and the stretching measurement value is accurate to 0.1N to obtain the stress-strain curve of the sample in the stretched state. The rest is the same as the sixth embodiment.

[0071] Specific embodiment eight: This embodiment differs from specific embodiment seven in that the different aging stages are conducted by simulated aging tests, including film oven tests and pressure aging container tests. Other aspects are the same as specific embodiment seven.

[0072] Specific embodiment 9: This embodiment is different from specific embodiment 8 in that the method of the thin film oven test is: the asphalt sample is coated on an aging plate to form a thin film, and then the sample is placed in a thin film oven at 163°C for uniform heating for 5 hours. The rest is the same as specific embodiment 8.

[0073] Specific embodiment 10: This embodiment differs from specific embodiment 9 in that the pressure aging container test method is: after the film oven test is completed, continue to perform the test at 90°C to 110°C for 10h to 40h under a pressure of 2.1MPa. Others are the same as specific embodiment 9.

[0074] The present invention is verified by the following tests:

[0075] Test 1: This test is a comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve, which is carried out in the following steps:

[0076] The specific process of sample preparation is as follows:

[0077] Eight types of asphalts were prepared, including different base asphalts (70# and 90#), SBS modifiers with different molecular structures (star-shaped and linear), SBS modifiers with different block ratios (3 and 4) and SBS modified asphalts prepared with different SBS modifier mass contents. The specific formulas of the eight asphalts and the simplified names of each asphalt are shown in Table 1 below:

[0078] Table 1 Formulas and simplified names of eight types of asphalt

[0079]

[0080] The preparation method of 90-5%L3-0.15%S is as follows: 90# base asphalt and 5wt.% SBS1301 linear modifier are subjected to high-speed shearing for 30 minutes at a temperature of 180°C and a rotation speed of 4000rpm / min; then mechanically stirred at 180°C for 1 hour at a rotation speed of 500rpm / min, and then 0.15wt.% sulfur stabilizer is added, and stirring is continued for 1.5 hours to allow the SBS modifier to produce chemical crosslinks in the asphalt.

[0081] The preparation method of 70-5%L3-0.15%S is the same as that of 90-5%L3-0.15%S except for using 70# base asphalt.

[0082] 90-5%L4-0.15%S has the same steps as 90-5%L3-0.15%S except that SBS1401 modifier is used.

[0083] Since star-shaped SBS has a higher molecular weight, the preparation method of 90-5% S3-0.15% S is as follows: 90# base asphalt and 5wt.% SBS4303 linear modifier are high-speed sheared for 50 minutes at a temperature of 190°C, and the shear rate is 6500rpm / min; then mechanically stirred at 190°C for 2 hours at a speed of 1000rpm / min, 0.15wt.% sulfur stabilizer is added, and stirring is continued for 1.5 hours.

[0084] The preparation process of 90-8%L3-0.24%S is as follows: 90# base asphalt and 8wt.% SBS1301 linear modifier are used for high-speed shearing at a temperature of 180°C for 30 minutes at a rotation speed of 4500rpm / min; then mechanical stirring is carried out at a temperature of 180°C for 1 hour at a rotation speed of 500rpm / min, and then 0.24wt.% of sulfur stabilizer is added and stirring is continued for 1.5 hours.

[0085] The preparation process of 90-8% L3R-0.24% S is as follows: 90# base asphalt, 8wt.% SBS1301 linear modifier and 10wt.% high elastic agent RBS are high-speed shear mixed at a temperature of 180°C for 30 minutes and a rotation speed of 5000rpm / min; then 3wt.% rubber oil is added and shearing is continued for 15 minutes. The other preparation processes are consistent with 90-8% L3-0.24% S.

[0086] The specific process of laboratory simulation aging test for eight asphalt samples is as follows:

[0087] The eight types of asphalt prepared were subjected to simulated aging tests. The Thin Film Oven Test (TFOT) was used to simulate the short-term aging of asphalt mixture during storage, transportation, paving, etc. for 1h to 3h; the Pressure Aging Vessel (PAV) test was used to simulate the long-term aging of the pavement during actual use.

[0088] The TFOT test is to coat the asphalt sample on the aging tray to form a thin film, and then put the sample into a 163℃ thin film oven for uniform heating for 5 hours; the PAV test is to be carried out at 90℃~110℃ for 10h~40h under 2.1MPa pressure after the TFOT test; the asphalt samples after 10h PAV, 20h PAV, 30h PAV and 40h PAV are equivalent to 3 years, 6 years, 9 years and 12 years of use respectively. Therefore, the present invention sets 6 samples with different aging degrees, namely original sample, TFOT, TFOT+10h PAV, TFOT+20h PAV, TFOT+30h PAV and TFOT+40h PAV, so as to simulate the full time domain aging process of the asphalt pavement from the unaged state to the asphalt pavement used for 12 years, with a total of 48 asphalt samples.

[0089] The specific process of obtaining the stress-strain curve is as follows:

[0090] In order to analyze the stress-strain curves of eight different SBS modified asphalts, the force-ductility test method was used to conduct tensile tests on the sample samples, and the load and deformation curves were recorded. The stress-strain curve stages were divided according to the basic theory of polymer deformation. The specific method is as follows:

[0091] 1) Stir the asphalt sample evenly and pour it into the ductility mold. Let the mold filled with the sample stand at room temperature for 1.5 hours;

[0092] 2) Use a hot scraper to correct the surface of the sample so that it is flush with the mold, and then place the test piece in 4°C water for 1.5 hours;

[0093] 3) After the heat preservation is completed, the sample is stretched in 4°C water at a stretching speed of 5cm / min (±5.0%), and the stretching measurement value is accurate to 0.1N. A total of 48 stress-strain curves of the sample in the stretched state are obtained, such as Figure 2-Figure 9 shown.

[0094] Analysis of stress-strain curve results:

[0095] According to the results of the force-ductility test, the stress-strain curves of eight SBS modified asphalts under six aging conditions were obtained. It can be seen that the base asphalt grade has a great influence on the SBS modified asphalt. The SBS modified asphalt prepared based on the 90# base asphalt has a greater fracture strain and ductility. For the SBS modified asphalt without sulfur stabilizer, the SBS modified asphalt of the two base asphalt grades has a lower ductility, which means that the addition of sulfur stabilizer leads to better deformation ability and strength of SBS modified asphalt. For high viscosity SBS modified asphalt and high viscosity and high elastic SBS modified asphalt (SBS content 8%), the higher SBS content leads to a significant increase in the peak strength of SBS modified asphalt and a decrease in ductility. After adding the high elastic agent RBS, the fracture strain increases, while the peak strength decreases slightly. This is because the main component of the high elastic agent RBS is de-crosslinked rubber. The reduced crosslinking points make it easier for the molecular chain to slide under the action of external force, and this plasticization of the molecular chain also reduces the resistance during stretching, resulting in a decrease in peak strength.

[0096] Quantification process of basic indicators for anti-aging performance evaluation based on stress-strain curve:

[0097] According to the polymer mechanical state and transition theory, the three main mechanical properties that describe material behavior are usually strength, stiffness and toughness. These three aspects can show the reaction mode of the material when subjected to stress and reveal the mechanical state of the material, namely, strength, stiffness, toughness and brittleness. In order to evaluate the anti-aging performance of eight modified asphalts in 48 states at six different aging times, six comprehensive evaluation indicators of anti-aging performance were proposed based on toughness, strength and stiffness, including two indicators based on toughness: toughness-brittle transition (BDT) duration factor and toughness-degradation transition (TDT) duration factor; two indicators based on strength: peak stress and strength retention rate; and two indicators based on stiffness: initial modulus and modulus retention rate.

[0098] In order to calculate the comprehensive evaluation index of anti-aging performance, it is necessary to quantify the basic anti-aging performance indicators of the stress-strain curve: ductility-brittle transition (BDT) and toughness degradation transition (TDT), peak stress and initial modulus.

[0099] The abscissa of the stress-strain curve is deformation, and the ordinate is load; stress is load divided by the original cross-sectional area of ​​the material; strain is deformation divided by the original length of the specimen; the method for obtaining the basic index of anti-aging performance by analyzing the stress-strain curve is as follows: first-order derivative and second-order derivative are performed on each stress-strain curve respectively;

[0100] The elastic limit point is the point where the first-order derivative decreases and the second-order derivative is non-zero. The elastic limit point is the critical point between the elastic and elastoplastic stages. The initial modulus is the ratio of stress to strain corresponding to the elastic limit point.

[0101] The yield point is the point where the second-order derivative reaches its minimum value and the first-order derivative decreases. The yield point is the starting position of the obvious plastic deformation stage; the yield strength is the stress value corresponding to the yield point on the stress-strain curve;

[0102] The peak stress point is the point where the first-order derivative is zero and the second-order derivative is negative. The peak stress point is the maximum stress point. The peak stress is the stress value corresponding to the peak stress point on the stress-strain curve.

[0103] The strain hardening point is the point where the first-order derivative is zero and the second-order derivative is positive. The strain hardening point is the minimum stress point and the starting point of hardening. The hardening intensity is the stress value corresponding to the strain hardening point on the stress-strain curve.

[0104] The point before the load suddenly changes to zero is the fracture point; the fracture strength is the stress value corresponding to the fracture point on the stress-strain curve.

[0105] The identification method of each feature point is shown in Table 2 below:

[0106] Table 2 Stress and strain identification feature points

[0107]

[0108] The method of constructing two toughness indices through the basic indicators of anti-aging performance is:

[0109] Based on the above fracture strength and yield strength data, the toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages was drawn. The intersection of the fitting line segment of yield strength and the fitting line segment of fracture strength in the phase diagram corresponds to the abscissa representing the toughness-brittleness (BDT) transition point of the material, the ordinate represents the fracture strength and yield strength, and the abscissa corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages (such as Figure 10-Figure 17 shown);

[0110] According to the fracture strength and hardening strength data, the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages is drawn. The horizontal axis corresponding to the intersection of the fitting line segment of the hardening strength and the fitting line segment of the fracture strength in the phase diagram represents the toughness degradation (TDT) transformation point of the material, the vertical axis is the fracture strength and hardening strength, and the horizontal axis corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages (such as Figure 18-Figure 25 shown);

[0111] The construction process of comprehensive index for anti-aging performance evaluation is as follows:

[0112] In order to evaluate the anti-aging performance of eight modified asphalts in 48 states at six different aging times, based on the above definitions of toughness-brittle transition (BDT) and toughness-degradation transition (TDT), BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor were proposed to describe the anti-aging performance of the eight asphalts based on toughness at each aging time point. The BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor can be described by the time ratio and the logarithm of the aging time. The time ratio reflects the position of the current aging time relative to the state transition time. The smaller the aging time, the lower the duration factor, which means better anti-aging performance. The two factors can be calculated according to the following formula:

[0113]

[0114]

[0115] Where: BDT and λ TDT They are BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor respectively; is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness-brittleness transition point in the toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time (for example, Fig.10 For example, the horizontal axis can be defined as follows: the original is 2, TFOT is 4, 10h PAV is 6, 20h PAV is 8, 30h PAV is 10, and 40h PAV is 12. The horizontal axis value corresponding to the ductile-brittle transition point is 10.2, so the original corresponds to 10.2 divided by 2 equals 5.1. Because the two are on the same horizontal axis, the value defined for each scale does not affect the final result); It is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness degradation transition point in the toughness-deterioration transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time.

[0116] Comprehensive evaluation indexes of anti-aging performance based on strength: peak stress and strength retention rate. When SBS modified asphalt has higher strength and lower strength change rate (Rate of Strength Change, RSC), it means that it has better anti-aging performance. In order to make the evaluation direction of anti-aging performance index consistent, that is, the larger the value of all indicators, the better the anti-aging performance, the strength retention rate (Retention Rate of Strength, RRS) is used to describe the anti-aging performance. The specific calculation formula is:

[0117]

[0118] RRS=100%-RSC

[0119] Where: RSC and RRS are the strength change rate and strength retention rate respectively; σ aged and σ unaged are the peak stress after aging and the peak stress before aging, respectively.

[0120] Similarly, the comprehensive evaluation index of anti-aging performance based on stiffness: initial modulus and modulus retention rate (Retention Rate of Modulus, RRM), the specific calculation formula is:

[0121]

[0122] RRM = 100% - RMC;

[0123] Where: RMC and RRM are modulus change rate and modulus retention rate respectively; E aged and E unaged are the initial modulus after aging and the initial modulus without aging, respectively.

[0124] Based on the above six indicators, the analytic hierarchy process is used to comprehensively evaluate the anti-aging performance of eight SBS modified asphalts as follows:

[0125] 1) Build a hierarchical model

[0126] like Fig.26 As shown, the target layer is the anti-aging performance evaluation; the criterion layer is the evaluation criteria for the target layer, including strength (strong or weak), stiffness (hard or soft), and toughness (tough or brittle); the sub-criteria layer is a further refinement of the evaluation criteria, including peak stress, strength retention rate, initial modulus, modulus retention rate, BDT time factor, and TDT time factor; the scheme layer is the specific evaluation object, which is 8 different modified asphalts in this experiment, and each asphalt corresponds to 6 aging states.

[0127] 2) Construct a judgment matrix

[0128] Compare the importance between the criterion layers (strength, stiffness, and toughness), construct the pairwise comparison matrix of the criterion layers and calculate the weight vector of the criterion layers, and calculate the pairwise comparison matrix of the criterion layers:

[0129]

[0130] Based on the pairwise comparison matrix, compute the column sum vector s:

[0131]

[0132] Calculate the criterion layer weight vector ω, where A norm is the normalized judgment matrix:

[0133] Represents column-wise division of matrix elements.

[0134] The weight vector τ of the sub-criteria layer is consistent with the above calculation process. The difference is the assignment method in the initial paired comparison matrix. The mean and standard deviation are calculated by the Z-score method according to the six types of indicator data of the sub-criteria layer. According to the proportional relationship of the average value, the value of the paired comparison matrix is ​​assigned a relatively high average value, which indicates that the criterion is more important. The overall weight vector can be calculated as follows: η1, η2, η3, η4, η5 and η6 are the weight coefficients corresponding to the BDT duration factor, TDT duration factor, peak stress, strength retention rate, initial modulus and modulus retention rate, respectively.

[0135]

[0136] 3) Calculate the comprehensive evaluation value

[0137] The data of all sub-criteria are normalized. The normalized data are multiplied by the corresponding weight coefficient to calculate the weighted value, and the weighted values ​​of each sub-criteria are summed to obtain the comprehensive evaluation value of each asphalt under various aging conditions. The higher the comprehensive evaluation value, the better the performance under all sub-criteria and the better the anti-aging performance. Figure 27-32The anti-aging performance evaluation results of eight types of SBS modified asphalts at different aging stages are shown (corresponding to original sample, TFOT, TFOT+10hPAV, TFOT+20hPAV, TFOT+30hPAV and TFOT+40hPAV, respectively). It can be seen that with the progress of aging, the toughness indicators of the eight asphalts, such as BDT time factor and TDT time factor, decrease, while the peak stress and initial modulus increase. In the early stage of aging, the comprehensive evaluation value of each type of asphalt is mainly dominated by the toughness indicator, while in the later stage of aging, the proportion of strength and stiffness increases significantly. In the early stage of aging (from original to 20h PAV), the comprehensive evaluation values ​​of the two asphalts with 8% SBS content were significantly higher than those of other asphalts, but the advantage was not maintained after aging for 20h PAV, indicating that increasing the SBS content mainly exerts a positive effect on the anti-aging performance by improving the toughness stability. At 5% SBS content, 90-5% L3-0.15% S maintained the maximum comprehensive evaluation value in the original sample and TFOT, 90-5% L4-0.15% S reached the maximum comprehensive evaluation value at 10h PAV aging, and 90-5% S3-0.15S reached the maximum comprehensive evaluation value at aging stages of 20h, 30h, and 40h PAV, respectively. This shows that the same asphalt exhibits different anti-aging properties at different aging stages, and at the same time, it can finely characterize the intrinsic reasons for the difference in anti-aging properties before and after aging, which reflects the superiority of this method. The comprehensive evaluation values ​​of the eight asphalts (from 70-5% L3-0.15S to 90-8% L3R-0.24S) when not aged were 1.294, 1.406, 1.249, 1.291, 1.305, 1.229, 1.585, and 1.426, respectively. Therefore, the anti-aging performance of the eight asphalts is ranked as follows: 90-8% L3-0.24% S>90-8% L3R-0.24% S>90-5% L3-0.15% S>90-5% L4-0.15% S>70-5% L3-0.15% S>90-5% L3-0.00% S>70-5% L3-0.00% S>70-5% S3-0.15% S. It can be seen that 8% SBS content has the best anti-aging performance, including 90-8% L3-0.24% S and 90-8% L3R-0.24% S. The second is 90-5% L3-0.15% S with 5% SBS content. Star-shaped SBS has poor anti-aging performance due to its faster toughness degradation rate. Regardless of the type of asphalt, the comprehensive evaluation value of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages after adding stabilizers is significantly improved, which shows that stabilizers have a positive effect on the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt.

[0138] In summary, this method for evaluating the anti-aging properties of different SBS modified asphalts can distinguish the aging stages according to the key mechanical states, accurately quantify the different anti-aging properties of the same asphalt at different aging stages and the different anti-aging properties of different types of asphalt at the same aging stage, and at the same time, carefully characterize the inherent differences in the different anti-aging properties in the early and late stages of aging.

Claims

1. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve, characterized in that The comprehensive evaluation method of the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve is carried out in the following steps: Firstly, asphalt samples of different asphalts at different aging stages were prepared, and then force-ductility tests were carried out on all the prepared asphalt samples to obtain the stress-strain curves of different asphalts at different aging stages. The basic indicators of anti-aging performance were obtained by analyzing the stress-strain curves: initial modulus, peak stress, yield strength, hardening strength and fracture strength. Six comprehensive indicators were constructed based on the basic indicators of anti-aging performance, including two toughness indicators: BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor; two strength indicators: peak stress and strength retention rate; two stiffness indicators: initial modulus and modulus retention rate. Based on the six comprehensive indicators, the comprehensive evaluation values ​​of the six indicators were calculated by the hierarchical analysis method, and the anti-aging performance of the asphalt was judged by accumulating the comprehensive evaluation values. The larger the accumulated comprehensive evaluation value, the better the anti-aging performance of the asphalt.

2. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 1, characterized in that The abscissa of the stress-strain curve is deformation, and the ordinate is load; stress is the load divided by the original cross-sectional area of ​​the material; Strain is the deformation divided by the original length of the specimen; the method for obtaining the basic index of anti-aging performance by analyzing the stress-strain curve is as follows: the first-order derivative and the second-order derivative of each stress-strain curve are taken respectively; The elastic limit point is the point where the first-order derivative decreases and the second-order derivative is non-zero. The elastic limit point is the critical point between the elastic and elastoplastic stages. The initial modulus is the ratio of stress to strain corresponding to the elastic limit point. The yield point is the point where the second-order derivative reaches its minimum value and the first-order derivative decreases. The yield point is the starting position of the obvious plastic deformation stage; the yield strength is the stress value corresponding to the yield point on the stress-strain curve; The peak stress point is the point corresponding to the first-order derivative being zero and the second-order derivative being negative, and the peak stress point is the maximum stress point; The peak stress is the stress value corresponding to the peak stress point on the stress-strain curve; The strain hardening point is the point where the first-order derivative is zero and the second-order derivative is positive. The strain hardening point is the minimum stress point and the starting point of hardening. The hardening intensity is the stress value corresponding to the strain hardening point on the stress-strain curve. The point before the load suddenly changes to zero is the fracture point; the fracture strength is the stress value corresponding to the fracture point on the stress-strain curve.

3. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 2, characterized in that The method of constructing two toughness indices through the basic indicators of anti-aging performance is: The toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages is drawn based on the fracture strength and yield strength data. The horizontal axis corresponding to the intersection of the fitting line segment of yield strength and the fitting line segment of fracture strength in the phase diagram represents the toughness-brittleness transition point of the material, and the vertical axis is the fracture strength and yield strength. The horizontal axis corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages. According to the fracture strength and hardening strength data, the toughness degradation transformation phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt at different aging stages is drawn. The horizontal axis corresponding to the intersection of the fitting line segment of hardening strength and the fitting line segment of fracture strength in the phase diagram represents the toughness degradation transformation point of the material, and the vertical axis is the fracture strength and hardening strength. The horizontal axis corresponds to the average distribution of different aging stages. The BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor are calculated according to the following formula: Where: BDT and λ TDT They are BDT duration factor and TDT duration factor respectively; It is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness-brittleness transition point in the toughness-brittleness transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time; It is the ratio of the abscissa value corresponding to the toughness degradation transition point in the toughness-deterioration transition phase diagram of SBS modified asphalt to the abscissa value corresponding to the corresponding aging time.

4. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 3, characterized in that The formula for constructing strength retention rate through the basic indicators of anti-aging performance is: RRS=100%-RSC Where: RSC and RRS are the strength change rate and strength retention rate respectively; σ aged and σ unaged are the peak stress after aging and the peak stress before aging, respectively.

5. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 4, characterized in that The formula for constructing the modulus retention rate through the basic indicators of anti-aging performance is: RRM = 100% - RMC; Where: RMC and RRM are modulus change rate and modulus retention rate respectively; E aged and E unaged are the initial modulus after aging and the initial modulus without aging, respectively.

6. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 5, characterized in that The data of the six comprehensive indicators of each asphalt sample were normalized, and the normalized data were multiplied by the weight coefficients corresponding to the six comprehensive indicators to calculate the corresponding weighted values. The weighted values ​​of the six comprehensive indicators were summed to obtain the comprehensive evaluation value of each asphalt sample. The higher the comprehensive evaluation value, the better the anti-aging performance. Among the six comprehensive indicators, the weight coefficients corresponding to the BDT time factor, TDT time factor, peak stress, strength retention rate, initial modulus and modulus retention rate are 0.41, 0.8, 0.34, 0.27, 0.2 and 0.13, respectively.

7. The comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 1, characterized in that The force-ductility test method is: ①. Stir the asphalt sample evenly and pour it into the ductility mold. Let the mold filled with the sample stand at room temperature for 1.5 hours; ② Use a hot scraper to correct the surface of the sample so that it is flush with the mold, and then place the test piece in 4°C water for 1.5 hours; ③. After the insulation is completed, the sample is stretched in 4°C water at a stretching speed of 5cm / min. The stretching measurement value is accurate to 0.1N, and the stress-strain curve of the sample in the tensile state is obtained.

8. The comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 1, characterized in that The different aging stages are carried out by using simulated aging tests, including thin film oven tests and pressure aging container tests.

9. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 8, characterized in that The method of the thin film oven test is: coating the asphalt sample on an aging tray to form a thin film, and then placing the sample in a thin film oven at 163° C. and heating it evenly for 5 hours.

10. A comprehensive evaluation method for the anti-aging performance of SBS modified asphalt based on stress-strain curve according to claim 9, characterized in that The method of the pressure aging container test is: after the film oven test is completed, continue to test at 90° C. to 110° C. for 10 h to 40 h under a gas pressure of 2.1 MPa.