MÉTODO PARA ANÁLISE DA PROBABILIDADE DE OCORRÊNCIA DE ILHAMENTO NÃO INTENCIONAL
The method analyzes the probability of unintentional islanding by calculating failure and occurrence indices, adjusting protection system settings to minimize risk, ensuring the electrical network's safety and functionality.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- BR102025008620
- Authority / Receiving Office
- BR · BR
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-04-30
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing methodologies are not sufficiently effective for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence in electrical networks, leading to potential equipment damage and safety risks.
A method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding by determining circuit breakers/reclosers, active and reactive power demand curves, and anti-islanding protection system functions, calculating the probability of failure and occurrence of islanding using specific equations, and adjusting settings to minimize risk.
Ensures proper functioning of the electrical network by providing a comprehensive analysis of unintentional islanding probability, reducing the risk of equipment damage and safety hazards.
Description
1 / 24 “METHOD FOR ANALYZING THE PROBABILITY OF UNINTENTIONAL ISLANDING OCCURRENCE TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence used to evaluate the islanding detection capability of a given solution. BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] Islanding occurs when a portion (area / region) of the electrical grid, containing loads and distributed generators ("DGs"), loses connection to the main grid of the utility and remains sustained by the DGs unintentionally, i.e., without the planning or knowledge of the distributor. Its occurrence must be detected quickly to avoid damage to equipment of the distributor and consumers and risks of personal accidents involving both consumers and professionals of the electrical power companies. This situation is schematically represented in Figure 1 according to the state of the art. According to Figure 1, the opening of the substation circuit breaker D1 or the line recloser R1 leads to the formation of an island with the potential for sustained energization by the distributed generators GD1 and GD2.Although the burning of fuse link F1 also leads to the formation of an island in the low-voltage network, such events, i.e., islanding caused by the burning of fuse links, are not analyzed because they represent a lower risk of producing a sustained energized island by GD3. The island formed by the opening of recloser R1 is highlighted in Figure 1. In this case, the unintentional islanding situation must be detected in order to disconnect all generators before... Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, p. 35 / 67 2 / 24 attempt to close the recloser Ri, determining the maximum required time for islanding detection. Similar reasoning applies to the case where the island is formed by the operation of the circuit breaker Di.
[0003] The main solutions used for islanding detection in distributed generation (DG) systems are local passive and active techniques. Passive techniques operate by measuring a local quantity at the point of connection between the DG and the distribution network, and are widely used with synchronous generators (SGs) and inverter-based generators (IBGs) due to their low cost and simplicity. The main examples of these techniques are under / overfrequency protection functions (81U / O), rate of change of frequency (81R or ROCOF), and under / overvoltage protection functions (27 / 59). However, passive techniques can fail under operating conditions where the difference between the load and generation in the islanded region is small, resulting in "non-detection zones" (NDZs).Therefore, such ZNDs represent the operating conditions of active and reactive power imbalance that lead to the failure of islanding detection by protection in a timely manner (i.e., before an attempt to reclosing the substation circuit breaker or line recloser occurs). Active techniques, which employ the concept of positive feedback and are commercially used only with GBIs, aim to reduce ZNDs by introducing disturbances into the control loops of the distributed generators in order to destabilize the generator and, eventually, the electrical system during islanding, causing variations in voltage magnitude and / or frequency to be more pronounced, so that passive protection functions can detect the islanding. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 36 / 67 3 / 24
[0004] Figure 2a, according to the state of the art, schematically represents the concept of non-detection zone (NDZ). When islanding occurs due to the opening of recloser Ri, there is an imbalance of active power ΔP and reactive power ΔQ in the islanded section due to the difference between generation and load (including electrical losses). This imbalance of active and reactive power, which is equal to the power flow in recloser R1 at the instant the event occurs, causes the magnitude and frequency of the voltage to vary. These variations are used by the protection system of the generator set 1 (SPGD1) to disconnect it so that the system can be restored with the automatic closing of recloser R1. Figure 2b, according to the state of the art, graphically shows the concept of NDZ for a given maximum islanding detection time.The maximum detection time is restricted by the automatic reclosing time (ΔtR1) of the recloser Ri, since generator GD1 must be disconnected from the electrical grid before the reclosing attempt. If, at the instant of islanding, the system is operating at the point represented by the imbalance ΔΡ1 and ΔQ1, the protection system of generator GD1 (SPGD1) will not be able to act within the required time, i.e., before the recloser attempt ΔtR1. On the other hand, if the system is operating at the point represented by the imbalance ΔΡ2 and ΔQ2, the protection system of generator GD1 (SPGD1) will be able to act within the required time. Illustratively, this situation is hypothetically represented in Figure 2c according to the state of the art, considering that the generator protection system is adjusted to operate by underfrequency, sensitized with the value (fSPGD1) and timing (^íspgdi). Thus, if the system is operating... Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 37 / 67 4 / 24 with imbalance APi and AQi at the instant of islanding, the generator protection system will not be able to act before the recloser's automatic closing attempt (Aíspgdi > AtRi), since the frequency variation is not fast enough, as shown in Figure 2c. Therefore, this is a case of non-detection of islanding, i.e., the system is operating within the ZND. On the other hand, if the system is operating at the point represented by the imbalance AP2 and AQ2, the generator protection system will be able to act in the required time, i.e., before the recloser's closing attempt (AÍspgdi < AtRi). Consequently, this is a case of detection of islanding, since the system is operating outside the ZND.
[0005] Therefore, the ZND represents the mapping of all operational points represented in the active power imbalance (AP) versus reactive power imbalance (AQ) plan, where the anti-islanding protection will not act within the required time, i.e., islanding detection failure will occur. These power imbalances are equal to the power flow values in the substation circuit breaker and / or line recloser at the instant the islanding occurs. To facilitate analysis, per-unit (pu) values are used to represent the active and reactive power imbalances in the ZND, considering the generation capacity of the islanded network as base power. In principle, the smaller the ZND, the more effective the anti-islanding protection system.
[0006] Document EP 4 287 434 A1, entitled ROBUST AND CYBERSECURE COORDINATED UNINTENTIONAL ISLAND DETECTION FOR MICROGRIDS, published on December 6, 2023, describes a system and methods for detecting unintentional islanding. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, p. 38 / 67 5 / 24 intentional (UI) islanding for distributed energy resource (DER) circuits, including microgrids. The method for detecting unintentional islanding (UI) of a distributed energy resource (DER) circuit includes monitoring transmissions from a plurality of UI detection sources to identify indications of unintentional islanding and performing unintentional islanding detection of the DER circuit based on the consensus of these sources. The transmissions from the UI detection sources include a plurality of measurements, and the method includes identifying the indication of unintentional islanding by determining whether each measurement satisfies a respective measurement threshold and determining whether an indication of unintentional islanding is identified based on the number of measurements that satisfy the threshold. The method also includes determining whether or not to perform unintentional islanding detection based on the location of the UI detection source within the DER circuit.
[0007] Document EP 2 806 280 A1, entitled “DETECTING ELECTRICAL ISLANDS USING WIDE-AREA MEASUREMENTS,” published on November 26, 2014, describes a solution that allows confirmation of the existence or non-existence of an islanding event in a distribution or transmission utility, ensuring the safety of maintenance personnel, the stability of the power system, and the protection of switching devices. The disclosed techniques use wide-area information or measurement information obtained from multiple locations in a network to detect the existence of islands throughout the network. This information can be collected from a system of intelligent electronic devices (IEDs). The patent also describes a method for detecting islanding in a distribution network of Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 39 / 67 6 / 24 electrical power, which involves receiving local and remote phase angle data, as well as local and remote power data, and then evaluating phase angle differences and determining if the power supply is stable in the local and remote subnets. If an islanding condition is detected, an alarm indicator will be triggered.
[0008] US patent 9,620,994 B2, entitled “METHOD AND SYSTEM OF ANTI-ISLANDING OF A MICROGRID IN A GRID-CONNECTED MICROGRID SYSTEM”, published on July 17, 2014, discloses a system and method for detecting and preventing islanding in a microgrid, where a microgrid controller detects islanding and sends commands to control the injection of reactive power by the microgrid power sources. This is achieved by having the power sources produce active power and controlled reactive power injection, and the controllers control these power sources. The disconnecting device connects the microgrid output to the grid and disconnects it when necessary. A communication channel between the microgrid controller and the controllers allows the transmission of commands. In the case of islanding, the power sources are commanded to produce additional reactive power to prevent the islanding from continuing.
[0009] US patent 2016 / 0197479 A1, entitled “METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR ISLAND DETECTION AND ANTI-ISLANDING PROTECTION IN DISTRIBUTED POWER GENERATION SYSTEMS”, published on July 7, 2016, describes a passive method for detecting islanding in distributed power generation systems, called RoCoF-H, which stands for “Rate of Change Frequency-Histogram”. This method involves measuring and recording the histogram of the rate of change of frequency. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 40 / 67 7 / 24 (RoCoF) over a selected time period and then analyze the histogram to extract an index value that allows determining whether the system is islanded. This value is then used in an anti-islanding decision algorithm to command disconnection from the DER if an islanding condition is indicated, or to allow the DER not to be disconnected if an islanding condition is not indicated.
[0010] US patent 9,997,920 B2, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR ISLANDING DETECTION AND PREVENTION IN DISTRIBUTED GENERATION,” published January 14, 2016, addresses the safety risks and operational issues associated with islanding, a condition in which a distributed generator (DG) continues to feed a segment of a distribution network even though power from the utility grid is no longer present. Islanding can pose hazards to maintenance personnel and cause damage to grid-connected equipment. It can also lead to operational problems such as zones of no detection (ZNDs), where islanding detection methods fail to detect islanding.
[0011] US patent 11,018,507 B2, entitled “DETECTION APPARATUS, POWER CONDITIONER, DETECTION METHOD, AND COMPUTER READABLE MEDIUM,” published on June 27, 2019, presents a solution that detects islanding operations in a distributed power supply system, such as a photovoltaic power generation system, when there is a power outage in the electrical grid. Existing islanding detection systems may not function effectively due to the variable characteristics of the electrical grid to which the distributed power supply is connected. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, p. 41 / 67 8 / 24 oscillation detection in the power supplied by the power source and adjusts the time interval between terms to improve islanding detection accuracy. Additionally, the document provides a solution to change the length of the second term in response to oscillation detection and calculate the frequency parameters in the second term, fine-tuning the frequency parameters sampled during the second term.
[0012] Some prior art documents present applications with methodologies for evaluating islanding detection techniques, such as, for example, performance curve methods (in the document FREITAS et al., 2007: “Characteristics of vector surge relays for distributed synchronous generator protection”), zone-based and non-detection methods (in the document VIEIRA et al., 2008: “An investigation on the nondetection zones of synchronous distributed generation anti-islanding protection”) or setting map (in the document MOTTER; VIEIRA, 2018: “The setting map methodology for adjusting the DG anti-islanding protection considering multiple events”). However, none of the documents performs a risk analysis of non-detection of islanding.
[0013] Additionally, other prior art documents analyze the probability as a function of parameters that may be different, which changes the non-detection zone and may result in a higher or lower probability of an island being maintained. For example, in the document by Palm and Schegner (2019: Occurrence Probability and Prediction of Unintentional Islands Using Non-Detection Zones), a risk analysis is performed on generators connected via inverters and using a non-detection zone, and the non-detection zone is presented. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, p. 42 / 67 9 / 24 detection and comparison, in the active-to-reactive power plane, with the network's operating points, and thus it is possible to directly visualize when the system is in a non-detection region. Additionally, the document suggests that this process can be a strategy to verify network vulnerability by using historical active and reactive power data. In Iscuissati's document (2022: “Probabilistic methodologies for failure analysis of anti-islanding protection of distributed generators”), probabilistic methodologies were presented that consider the impact of events in the distribution system on the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system of distributed synchronous generators, employing the Monte Carlo method with stochastically modeled variables.
[0014] Regarding the risk analysis of non-detection of islanding, the document by Salles et al. (2012: “Nondetection index of anti-islanding passive protection of synchronous distributed generators”) develops a graphical and easy-to-apply methodology to determine the time period during which the passive protections of a distributed generator are unable to detect islanding. The method uses only distributed synchronous generators, feeder load curves, frequency- and voltage-based passive protection functions and their respective non-detection zones, and proposes a non-detection index which is the time the operation is within the unsafe region divided by the total time, i.e., without using a probability analysis of non-detection within a time frame and using opening history.
[0015] In the document by Ropp and Ellis (2013: “Suggested Guidelines for Assessment of DG Unintentional Islanding Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, p. 43 / 67 10 / 24 In the document titled "Risk"), a guide for risk analysis in distributed photovoltaic generators is suggested. The objective of this guide is to indicate in which situations the risk of islanding is low, thus reducing the need for very sensitive adjustments to protections in the interconnection of generators, and in which situations further studies are necessary. That is, there are no references to an assessment of the probability of an island forming.
[0016] In the document by Dysko et al. (2018: “Practical risk assessment of the relaxation of LOM protection settings in NIE Networks' distribution system”), a risk analysis of out-of-phase closure and electric shock occurring as a function of the protection system setting is presented. The document calculates the probability that a group of generators will be balanced with the load (within a margin given by the non-detection zone) above a period and includes a factor called “Nlog,1IP” which refers to the ratio between the total number of network losses multiplied by the number of islanding points and the time period of the samples. Eventually, the factors P23, Nlog,1IP are multiplied to verify risks of electric shock or damage to the generator.In other words, they estimate the risk of unintentional islanding occurring, given a specific protection setting and a maximum time for islanding detection and disconnection of the distributed generation (DG), and propose to estimate the probability of unintentional islanding causing accidents involving people and / or damage to equipment during out-of-phase reconnection. Therefore, the approach differs from the present invention by considering safety risks and a more comprehensive assessment, which seeks to perform a point-in-time analysis on a feeder with distributed generation, in order to identify the probability of islanding occurring. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 44 / 67 11 / 24
[0017] Thus, a problem with the state of the art is that the methodologies employed are not sufficiently effective for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurring, generating problems in the electrical network. SUMMARY
[0018] One objective of the present invention is to provide a method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding that overcomes the problem of the prior art.
[0019] This objective is achieved through a method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding, comprising: Prepare the main data by determining the circuit breakers / reclosers installed upstream of distributed generators (DGs), determining the analysis period, determining the net active and reactive power demand curves of the circuit breakers / reclosers and DGs, and determining the functions and settings of an anti-islanding protection system; to estimate the zones of non-detection (NDAs); Calculate the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system Pf using the equation below: Number of operational points within the ZND PF=---iP-----Ί1 :----Tã-----x Number of operational points measured r To make a decision in an initial stage regarding the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system, if Pf < X%, consider the current solution adequate and end the analysis; or if Pf > X%, there is an initial verification stage that checks if it is possible to select more sensitive adjustments to the protection system, and if so, select... Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 45 / 67 12 / 24 the most sensitive adjustments and returns to the ZND estimation step, and if not, proceeds to the second verification step which checks if it is possible to include a new protection function, in which, if so, it includes a new protection function and returns to the ZND estimation step, and, if not, proceeds to the third verification step which checks if it is possible to increase the reclosing time, in which, if so, it increases the reclosing time and returns to the ZND estimation step, and, if not, the verification is terminated and the method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding also includes the following steps: Calculate the probability of unintentional Pint islanding occurring using one of the formulas below; π„ ____ _ . .. PINI = ™ XΣPlNI,k XP(NA= k) if the 100% probability of the number of openings Na is known, that is, Na = k, where Na is the number of openings of the circuit breaker / recloser installed upstream of the GD, in a given analysis period (e.g., month, year, etc.), where: Pm,k =[1- (1-100^)^^100% or: Pim = ^ / .^ = (1- ':- — )' T100%, if Na is not known or if there are uncertainties in its estimation, employing Nmax which represents the estimated maximum number of circuit breaker / recloser operations; and make a decision in a second stage of probability of unintentional islanding occurrence, such that if Pint < Y%, consider the solution adequate and end the analysis, or if Pint > Y%, classify the case as critical and search for an alternative solution. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 46 / 67 13 / 24
[0020] Thus, the advantage of the method according to the present invention consists in providing a methodology that analyzes the probability of unintentional islanding occurring, ensuring the proper functioning of the electrical network. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0021] The objectives and advantages of the present invention will become clearer through the following detailed description of the non-limiting examples and drawings presented at the end of this document:
[0022] Figure 1 illustrates, schematically, an islanding situation according to the state of the art.
[0023] Figure 2a illustrates an isolated section according to the state of the art.
[0024] Figure 2b illustrates an example of ZND and different operating points according to the state of the art.
[0025] Figure 2c illustrates the frequency behavior after islanding considering two distinct operating points according to the state of the art.
[0026] Figure 3a illustrates an islanded system according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0027] Figure 3b illustrates a ZND of the protection system according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0028] Figure 3c illustrates the time interval during which the system is not protected according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0029] Figure 4 illustrates the concept of probability (risk) of failure of anti-islanding protection with an analysis Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 47 / 67 14 / 24 performed before the installation of the GD according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0030] Figure 5 illustrates the concept of probability (risk) of failure of the anti-islanding protection with an analysis performed after the installation of the GD according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0031] Figure 6 illustrates the flowchart of the method according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention.
[0032] Figure 7 illustrates the practical calculation of the probability (risk) of islanding detection failure, with an analysis performed before the installation of the DG and assuming that the reactive power imbalance is always equal to zero according to a preferred embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0033] Although the present invention may be susceptible to different embodiments, a preferred embodiment is shown in the following detailed discussion, it being understood that the present description should be considered an exemplification of the principles of the invention and that the present invention is not intended to be limited to what has been illustrated and described herein.
[0034] In this sense, the method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence, according to the present invention, employs the concept of ZND, and can determine whether the probability (or risk) of unintentional islanding occurrence is equal to the probability (risk) of an electrical system with distributed generation operating in a condition where the active and reactive power imbalances are located within the ZND of the anti-islanding protection functions. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 48 / 67 15 / 24
[0035] Thus, the method according to the present invention uses two relevant concepts to determine the quality of a given protection system and to select critical cases: (i) Probability (risk) of failure of the anti-islanding protection system Pf: index that determines the time interval in which the generator is not protected considering the analysis period, i.e., the period in which the system operates within the ZND. This index is determined as a percentage and is directly related to the quality (effectiveness) of the protection system adopted; and (ii) Probability (risk) of unintentional islanding occurrence Pini: index that determines the probability (risk) of opening circuit breakers and reclosers during the period in which the distributed generators are not protected.This index is determined as a percentage and depends both on the quality of the protection solution adopted and on the number of circuit breaker / recloser tripping occurrences on a given feeder, and can be used to determine and classify critical cases.
[0036] Figures 3a, 3b, and 3c illustrate the concept of the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system Pf for a hypothetical distributed generation (DG) anti-islanding protection system. Initially, only situations with variable active power imbalance are considered, i.e., it is assumed that the reactive power imbalance is always zero. In this case, the non-reactive power (NR) can be characterized by the operational points where the active power imbalance ΔP in the recloser Ri at the instant of islanding, as shown in Figure 3a, is between ΔP2 and ΔP1, as illustrated in Figure 3b. These situations can be mapped in time by evaluating the active power demand curve of the Precloser recloser, considering all the Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, page 49 / 67 16 / 24 electrical loads and losses, and the active power curve of the generator Pgd. The DG will not be protected when the difference between these two curves is between ΔP2 and ΔP1, as shown in Figure 3c. Therefore, it is possible to determine the time during which the system is unprotected considering the total analysis period, with these periods represented in this example by Δt1, Δt2 and Δt3 in a 24-hour analysis interval. Based on this analysis, a probability (risk) of failure (PF) index of the anti-islanding protection system can be determined, defined by the time the generator is not protected, according to the following equation (1): PF=^ x 100% (1)
[0037] where:
[0038] Pf is the probability (risk) index of failure of the anti-islanding protection system (%);
[0039] ΔtND is the total period during which the generator is unprotected (s); and
[0040] T is analysis period (s).
[0041] In fact, according to Figure 4, Pf must be determined by simultaneously considering the active and reactive power demand curves of the recloser, Precloser and Qrecloser, and of the generator, Pgd and Qgd, since it is necessary that both imbalances are within the ZND, characterized in a simplified way by ΔP1, ΔP2, ΔQ1 and ΔQ2, so that the anti-islanding protection fails, that is, does not act in the required time.
[0042] In the illustrated case, in an a priori analysis, it is considered that the active and reactive power demand curves in the circuit breaker / recloser, Precloser and Qrecloser, are known before the installation of the distributed generation. These values can Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 50 / 67 17 / 24 to be determined via the collection of measurements of these quantities at the switches (feeder circuit breaker or recloser) under analysis during the period of interest T. Additionally, it is considered that the active and reactive power generation curve, PGD and QGD, of the distributed generation to be installed are estimated.
[0043] Optionally, as illustrated in Figure 5, in a post-analysis, in cases where the generators are already installed, the active and reactive power demand curves measured at the circuit breaker / recloser are, in fact, the power imbalances in the islanded network due to the opening of the switch under analysis.
[0044] Regarding the probability of unintentional islanding risk Pint, for unintentional islanding to occur, the formation of the islanded system with distributed generation must occur during operation within the ZND, i.e., the circuit breaker / recloser must open at an instant when the active and reactive power imbalances are insufficient to trigger the protection of the distributed generation (DG) within the required time. Therefore, assuming that during the analysis period the number of trips Na of the circuit breaker / recloser under study is equal to k and that these trips can occur with equal probability both when the downstream system operates inside and outside the ZND, then the conditional probability of unintentional islanding for Na = k is given by equation (2) below and the total probability of unintentional islanding is given by equation (3) below, whose summation must consider all positive values of k with a non-zero probability of occurrence. * = M1-^)] x 100% (2) Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 51 / 67 18 / 24 ί „ _ _ ?INI = 1ÕÕ7X Σ / < X (^Λ = &)(3) 100%
[0045] where:
[0046] Naé is the number of trips of the circuit breaker / recloser installed upstream of the GD;
[0047] PxNx,k is the conditional probability index of unintentional islanding for Na = k (%);
[0048] PINI is the probability (risk) index of unintentional islanding occurrence (%);
[0049] Pf is the probability (risk) index of failure of the anti-islanding protection (%); and
[0050] P(NA=k) is the probability that Na is equal to the number k (%).
[0051] The calculation of Pini using equation (3) requires knowledge of the history of circuit breaker / recloser trips under analysis in order to allow the estimation of P(NA=k) for the different values of k verified. This history may be non-existent or unreliable / unrepresentative due to several factors such as: uncertainties about the quality of the records; short period of coverage of the history; changes in the circuit breaker / recloser settings during the period of coverage of the history; among others. For these cases, it is possible to use an alternative approach assuming that max trips of the circuit breaker / recloser will always occur during the period of interest, i.e., ( = max) = 100%, in such a way that the probability (risk) of unintentional islanding can be estimated according to equation (4) below. If max is conservative, i.e., there is a guarantee that the probability of the number of trips of the Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 52 / 67 19 / 24 circuit breaker / recloser being greater than Λ / max is negligible, so the index obtained through equation (4) will also be conservative. = ^,^= / (1,^0)1x 100% <4>
[0052] Based on the above, the method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence, according to the present invention, is mainly based on the concept of the non-detection zone (NDZ), the estimation of the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system (PF), and the occurrence of unintentional islanding (Pini).
[0053] Thus, the method according to the present invention, as illustrated in Figure 6, comprises a first step of preparing main data 100, in which the circuit breakers / reclosers installed upstream of distributed generators (DGs) are determined (i.e., determining the switches whose operation can create a sustained island), the analysis period, the net active and reactive power demand curves of the circuit breakers / reclosers and the DGs, and the functions and settings of the anti-islanding protection system.
[0054] The analysis period can be determined as 12 hours, 24 hours, 1 week, 1 month, 1 year, weekday, weekend / holiday, etc. In fact, it should be selected with representativeness in terms of load and generation curve and data availability.
[0055] The net active and reactive power demand curves of the circuit breakers / reclosers and distributed generators are determined with a post-hoc analysis, where, if the distributed generators are already installed, these curves refer to the measurements. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 53 / 67 20 / 24 active and reactive power in circuit breakers / reclosers, or with an a priori analysis, in which, if the distributed generators (DGs) are not installed, these curves refer to the active and reactive power measurements in the circuit breakers / reclosers minus the estimated generation from the DGs.
[0056] The functions and settings of the anti-islanding protection system are determined from the following sets of passive and active protection: Passive protection (used with both GS and GBI): Under / overfrequency protection: ANSI 81U / O, Under / overvoltage protection: ANSI 27 / 59 and Rate of change of frequency protection: ANSI 81R; Active protection (used only with GBI), which can be selected from any active protection that reduces ZNDs by introducing disturbances into the control loops of the GDs, in order to destabilize the generator and, eventually, the electrical system during islanding, causing the variations in voltage and / or frequency magnitude to be more pronounced.
[0057] Next, according to Figure 6, the method proceeds to the next step of estimating the non-detection zones ZNDs 200, with the estimation of the ZNDs being carried out using a methodology selected from a group that consists of a methodology based on electromagnetic transient simulations, a methodology based on analytical formulas, and a methodology based on spreadsheet queries.
[0058] Subsequently, according to Figure 6, the method proceeds to the next step of calculating the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system Pf” 300. In practical terms, this index can be estimated as the percentage of operating points within the ZND. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 54 / 67 21 / 24 considering the analysis period (e.g., 12 hours, 24 hours, week, 1 month, 1 year, etc.). Thus, equation (1), presented above, is simplified and used as follows: Pf = Number of operational points within the ZND ---:----Th---- X 100% Number of operational points measured
[0059] By way of example, considering that the active and reactive power flows of recloser R1 in Figure 3a are measured at 5-minute intervals, totaling 288 measurements in a 24-hour period, and assuming, for illustrative purposes only, that the reactive power imbalance is always zero, the anti-islanding protection failure probability of 18.4% can be obtained as exemplified in Figure 7.
[0060] Next, according to Figure 6, the method proceeds to the next step of making a decision in a first stage of probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system 400, where if PF < X%, the current solution is considered adequate and the analysis is terminated, or if PF > X%, there is a first verification step 510 that checks if it is possible to select more sensitive settings in the protection system, in which, if so, it selects the most sensitive settings and returns to the ZNDs estimation step 200, and if not, it proceeds to the second verification step 520 which checks if it is possible to include a new protection function, in which, if so, it includes a new protection function and returns to the ZNDs estimation step 200, and, if not, it proceeds to the third verification step 530 which checks if it is possible to increase the reclosing time, in which, if so, it increases the reclosing time Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 55 / 67 22 / 24 reconnection and returns to the ZNDs 200 estimation step, and, if negative, the verification is terminated and the method proceeds to the next step.
[0061] According to the present invention, X% is a predefined value, based on the experience of the electricity distributor and the level of risk taken below that considered acceptable by the distributor.
[0062] Additionally, the most sensitive settings are selected from the under / overfrequency, under / overvoltage and rate of frequency slew protection functions.
[0063] Furthermore, the reclosing time is achieved by increasing the delay time setting of a first reclosing. This increase can be made directly on the recloser or reclosing relay of the circuit breaker.
[0064] Thus, according to Figure 6, the method proceeds to the step of calculating the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence Pint 600.
[0065] By way of example, the probability of at least one unintentional islanding occurring during a month is calculated. It is assumed that there is a one-year history of openings of the circuit breaker / recloser under study, as indicated in Table 1, and that the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection obtained in the step of calculating the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system is Pf = 10%. Table 1: History of the number of openings (Na) of a circuit breaker / recloser during one year. Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Na 2 1 4 1 0 3 2 3 0 2 1 2 Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 56 / 67 23 / 24
[0066] Calculation of the probability that the number of openings of the circuit breaker / recloser is equal to the positive number k: sample number in which k openings occurred P (N = k) = ------------;--------V---------------------x 100% total number of samples P(Na = 1) = 3 / 12 X 100% = 25.0% P(Na = 2) = 4 / 12 x 100% = 33.3% P(Na = 3) = 2 / 12 / x 100% = 16.7% P(Na = 4) = 1 / 12 / x 100% = 8.33%
[0067] Calculation of conditional probabilities according to equation (2): Ρινι,ι = [1 - (1 - 10 / 100)1] Pini,2 = [1 - (1 - 10 / 100)2] X 100% = 19.0% Pini,3 = [1-(1-10 / 100)3] X 100% = 27.1% Pini,4 = [1 - (1 - 10 / 100)4] X 100% = 34.4%
[0068] Pini calculation according to equation (3): PINI= 777177 X (10.0 X 25.0 + 19.0 X 33.0 + 27.1
[0069] Finally, according to Figure 6, the method proceeds to the step of making a decision in a second stage of unintentional islanding probability of occurrence 700, where if Pini < Y%, consider the solution adequate and end the analysis, or if Pini > Y%, classify the case as critical and search for an alternative solution.
[0070] According to the present invention, Y% is a predefined value, based on the experience of the electricity distributor and the level of risk considered acceptable by the distributor.
[0071] In addition to the embodiments presented above, the same inventive concept may be Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 57 / 67 24 / 24 applied to other alternatives or possibilities for using the invention.
[0072] Although the present invention has been described in relation to certain preferred embodiments, it should be understood that the invention is not intended to be limited to those particular embodiments. Rather, it is intended to encompass all possible alternatives, modifications and equivalences within the spirit and scope of the invention, as defined by the appended claims. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 58 / 67
Claims
1 / 2 CLAIMS 1. Method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence characterized in that it comprises: preparing the main data (100), determining the circuit breakers / reclosers installed upstream of distributed generators (DGs), determining the analysis period, determining the net active and reactive power demand curves of the circuit breakers / reclosers and DGs, and determining the functions and settings of an anti-islanding protection system; estimating the non-detection zones (NDZs) (200); Calculate the probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system Pf (300) using the equation below: Number of operational points within the ZND PF =---7-----»-------:---:---------x 100% Number of operational points measured r make a decision in a first stage of probability of failure of the anti-islanding protection system (400), where: if Pf < X%, consider the current solution adequate and end the analysis;If Pf > X%, perform a first verification step (510) to determine the possibility of more sensitive adjustments in the protection system: if positive, select the more sensitive adjustments and return to the ZNDs estimation step (200); if negative, proceed to the second verification step (520) to check the inclusion of a new protection function: if positive, include the new protection function and return to the ZNDs estimation step (200); Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 59 / 67; 2 / 2 if negative, proceed to the third verification step (530) to assess the possibility of increasing the reclosing time: if positive, increase the reclosing time and return to the ZNDs estimation step (200); if negative, the verification is terminated and the method for analyzing the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence also includes the following steps: calculate the probability of unintentional islanding occurrence Pint (600) with one of the formulas below: 1 π „ ____ _ . .. PINI = ™ X Σ PlNI,k XP(NA = k) if the 100% probabilities of the number of openings Na are known, where PINIik = [1- (1-10^ 100°% °u hm = Pm.»m = [1 - (1 -100%)^] X 100% - if Na is not known or if there are uncertainties in its estimation; and make a decision in a second stage of probability of occurrence of unintentional islanding (700), such that if Pint < Y%, consider the solution adequate and end the analysis, or if Pint > Y%, classify the case as critical and search for an alternative solution. Petition 870250034893, dated 04 / 30 / 2025, pp. 60 / 67.
