A method for optimizing the design of special thread interference of oil well pipe

By optimizing the interference fit design of oil well pipe threads using response surface methodology and an improved non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm, the problems of blindness and inefficiency in the traditional design process are solved, and the sealing performance and stability under complex working conditions are improved.

CN112131766BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-26CHINA NAT PETROLEUM CORP +1
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202010879531.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2020-08-27
Publication Date
2024-11-26
Estimated Expiration
2040-08-27

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In existing technologies, the design of thread interference for special threaded joints in oil well pipes mainly relies on experience and analogy, which leads to high blindness in the design process and increased costs. Furthermore, traditional non-dominated sorting genetic algorithms are inefficient in multi-objective optimization problems and cannot meet the sealing and stability requirements under complex working conditions.

Method used

An optimization design model is established using the response surface methodology, and combined with a non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm improved by sensitivity analysis. Through multi-objective optimization calculations, the Pareto optimal solution set is obtained, and the optimal solution is selected based on actual working conditions to ensure that the threaded joint maintains meshing contact pressure under different service conditions.

Benefits of technology

It improves the sealing integrity and design efficiency of threaded joints, ensures sealing performance and stability under complex working conditions, and reduces the uncertainty and cost of the calculation process.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112131766B_ABST
    Figure CN112131766B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention discloses a method for optimizing the design of special thread interference of oil well pipes, and belongs to the technical field of performance optimization of special threaded joints of oil well pipes. An optimization objective function is constructed based on the quantitative requirements of sealing surface sealing at multiple typical extreme load points, and the top diameter of the taper thread processing and / or measurement control points are used as optimization design variables. The constraint conditions of the optimization design variables are determined based on the requirements of no sticking when the special thread is unfastened and the structural integrity requirements of the threaded joint. Finite element numerical simulation is used to establish the connection between the sealing objective function of the sealing surface and the design variables of different thread interferences. Experimental data points for evaluating the response function are constructed through numerical simulation, and an optimization model is constructed. The optimization design model is optimized by multi-objective optimization using a non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm improved based on a sensitivity analysis method, and a Pareto optimal solution set is obtained. The thread interference design is optimized in a targeted and accurate manner through the method of the present invention, taking into account both the accuracy and efficiency of the design.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of performance optimization of special threaded joints for oil well pipes, and in particular relates to an optimization design method for the interference amount of special threaded joints for oil well pipes. Background Art

[0002] With the continuous development of high-pressure natural gas reservoir exploration and development, special threaded joints for oil well pipes with high-pressure gas sealing capabilities have been more widely used. Special threads are widely used in production casing and tubing in all sections of deep wells, ultra-deep wells, high temperature and high pressure oil and gas well conditions. Special threaded oil well pipes have the characteristics of large volume and high value in the category of oil pipes.

[0003] For the commonly used special threads for oil well pipe gas sealing, the metal-to-metal interference contact sealing structure is the key to product design and quality control. The guarantee of the sealing integrity of oil well pipe joints depends on the sealing surface always maintaining a high meshing contact pressure and a suitable contact width under various complex composite load conditions. The industry generally uses the integral of the contact pressure over the contact width to characterize the size of the sealing strength. In addition to the design level of the special thread joint sealing structure directly affecting the joint sealing performance, other major influencing factors include thread interference, thread taper, external thread nose thickness, etc. The coordinated design of these key parameters together constitutes the key technology of special thread design, and the thread interference has the greatest indirect effect on the joint sealing. Under the premise of ensuring that the thread is smoothly threaded without sticking and the overall structural integrity of the threaded joint, the appropriate thread interference provides the main basis for the reasonable contact of the sealing surface. Furthermore, excessive thread interference will significantly reduce the actual contact pressure of the sealing surface, which will directly lead to the loss of gas sealing of the joint; too small thread interference will reduce the stability of the joint connection under the composite load conditions of downhole service, which will indirectly lead to a significant reduction in the joint sealing. Therefore, thread interference design is one of the core tasks in the design of special threaded joints for oil well pipes.

[0004] Traditional thread interference design mainly relies on experience and analogy. The scheme is determined by repeated redesign and multiple oil well pipe gas seal physical test verification. The blindness and contingency of the design process reduce the design quality and increase the design cost. Applying the optimization design method to practical engineering problems can subvert the traditional design concept and process. A non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm (NSGA-II) is characterized by: a multi-objective genetic algorithm based on the Pareto strategy. Generally speaking, there is no optimal solution for multi-objective optimization problems. There are conflicts and incomparable phenomena between optimization objectives. All possible non-inferior solutions are called Pareto solutions. The Pareto optimal solution set can be obtained by using this genetic algorithm. It is a set of solutions composed of solutions where the improvement of any objective function value must sacrifice the value of other objective functions. This method is based on a randomly generated parent population, represented by a specific virtual fitness value, and performs genetic operations such as replication, hybridization, and mutation to generate a large number of offspring populations. The parent and offspring populations are merged, and the elite strategy is used to protect the excellent population, expand the optimization space, and protect the excellent solutions in the iterative process, thereby improving the optimization accuracy. This method is suitable for solving the optimization design application of comprehensive joint sealing under different typical composite load conditions in actual service. In the specific algorithm, the virtual fitness evaluation process introduces a crowding comparison operator to evenly expand the evaluation individuals to the entire Pareto domain, but only obtains and evaluates the Pareto ranking values ​​of all genetic individuals through non-dominated sorting to continuously approach the frontier of the optimal solution set, and cannot evaluate the sensitivity to the population density information around individuals of different levels. As a result, individuals with different optimization trends sometimes still have the same opportunity to reproduce offspring, which reduces the optimization efficiency. In addition, for solving the huge multi-objective optimization problems based on complex engineering cases, especially for optimization problems where the objective function cannot be directly obtained by analyzing the design variables, this method resorts to a large number of genetic operations and finite element-assisted calculations, which greatly reduces the design efficiency and is not suitable for the optimization design of special thread interference. Summary of the invention

[0005] In order to solve the above problems, the purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for optimizing the design of special thread interference of oil well pipes, which accurately optimizes the design of thread interference in a targeted manner, and takes into account both design accuracy and efficiency.

[0006] The present invention is achieved through the following technical solutions:

[0007] A method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes comprises the following steps:

[0008] Step 1: Establish an optimization design model for the special thread interference of oil well pipe based on response surface methodology;

[0009] Step 2: Use the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm improved based on the sensitivity analysis method to perform multi-objective optimization on the optimization design model established in step 1 to find the Pareto optimal solution set;

[0010] Step 3: Based on the actual working conditions of the oil well pipe and the applicability design requirements, select the optimal solution from the Pareto optimal solution set obtained in step 2.

[0011] Preferably, step 1 is specifically as follows: constructing an optimization objective function based on the quantitative requirements for sealing surface sealing at several typical extreme load points, taking the top diameter of the tapered thread processing and / or measuring control points as optimization design variables, determining the constraints of the optimization design variables based on the requirement for no sticking when removing the thread from the special thread and the requirement for the structural integrity of the threaded joint, using finite element numerical simulation to establish the relationship between the sealing surface sealing objective function and the design variables of different thread interference amounts, and constructing a series of test data points for evaluating the objective function through numerical simulation.

[0012] Further preferably, after the test data points are constructed, an approximate response surface function is constructed based on the test results according to the constructed test data points, and a significance test and optimization calculation are performed on the response surface function.

[0013] Further preferably, the optimization objective function is constructed based on the quantitative requirements of the sealing performance of the sealing surface at several typical extreme load points, and the optimization objective function is constructed to meet the maximum difference between the sealing strength of the sealing surface at multiple typical extreme load points and the critical leakage threshold, that is:

[0014] F(σ c )=Max(W a -W ac ),

[0015] Among them, the sealing strength W a for:

[0016]

[0017] In the formula, σ c is the actual contact pressure of the sealing surface, L ES is the actual contact width of the sealing surface;

[0018] Leakage critical threshold W ac for:

[0019]

[0020] Where P gas is the internal pressure of the tube, P atm is atmospheric pressure.

[0021] Further preferably, the requirement for no galling during make-up of special threads is that the contact pressure between the top and bottom of the threads after the threads are engaged is less than or equal to 90% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe.

[0022] Further preferably, the structural integrity requirement of the threaded joint is: the maximum equivalent stress at the stress concentration location at the end of the coupling after the thread is made up is less than or equal to 95% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe.

[0023] Preferably, in step 2, performing multi-objective optimization includes evaluating the Pareto ranking value of individuals during the fitness evaluation process, and evaluating the sensitivity of the optimization trend to the population density information around the individuals by introducing the mean and standard deviation of individual variables and the Pareto ranking value.

[0024] Further preferably, during the fitness evaluation process, a 6σ level sensitivity method is used to evaluate the population density information around individuals of different levels, so that the next generation of individuals are genetically away from inactive areas of the population.

[0025] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial technical effects:

[0026] The invention discloses a method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes. After establishing an optimization design model of the interference of special threads of oil well pipes based on the response surface method, a non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm improved based on the sensitivity analysis method is used to perform multi-objective optimization on the optimization design model to obtain a Pareto optimal solution set. Finally, the optimal solution is selected from the Pareto optimal solution set in combination with the actual working conditions of the oil well pipes according to the design requirements of applicability. An optimization design problem containing multi-objectives, multi-variables and constraints is constructed to carry out the optimization design of the interference of special threads of oil well pipes, so as to ensure that the required meshing contact pressure is always maintained under different service conditions. This new method for optimizing the interference of threads is oriented to the service conditions of oil casings, and improves the sealing integrity of threaded joints in a targeted and accurate manner. An optimization design model is established based on finite element numerical simulation and the response surface method, taking into account both the accuracy and efficiency of the design. An improved non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm is used to perform multi-objective optimization calculations on the established optimization model to obtain a Pareto optimal solution set. The reliability and robustness of the calculation process are increased, and the calculation efficiency is improved.

[0027] Furthermore, step 2 is based on the optimization design concept of the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm, and the process includes genetic coding generation, random initial population determination, fitness evaluation, and offspring population calculation such as selection, crossover, and mutation. In the fitness evaluation process, the original algorithm adopts the Pareto sorting strategy, and by introducing the crowding comparison operator, the evaluation individuals are evenly expanded to the entire Pareto domain. However, the Pareto sorting values ​​of all genetic individuals are obtained and evaluated only through non-dominated sorting, thereby continuously approaching the frontier of the optimal solution set, and the sensitivity to the population density information around individuals of different levels cannot be evaluated, so that sometimes individuals with different optimization trends still have the same opportunity to reproduce offspring, which reduces the optimization efficiency. Aiming at this shortcoming of the original algorithm, an improvement is made based on the sensitivity analysis method. That is, in addition to evaluating the Pareto ranking value of individuals, the sensitivity of the optimization trend to the population density information around the individuals is evaluated by introducing the mean and standard deviation of individual variables and Pareto ranking values. On the basis of homogenizing the genetic Pareto domain of the population by the crowding comparison operator, the number of next-generation inheritance of individuals is moderately reduced in the inactive areas of the optimization trend population, and the deviation of the fitness evaluation value is reduced, which increases the reliability and robustness of the optimization iteration, minimizes the number of genetic operations as much as possible without missing excellent solutions, and improves the optimization calculation efficiency.

[0028] Furthermore, when performing multi-objective optimization, the 6σ horizontal sensitivity method is used to evaluate the population density information around individuals of different levels during the fitness evaluation process, so that the next generation of individuals can be genetically separated from inactive areas of the population, which can reduce the deviation of the fitness evaluation value and increase the reliability and robustness of the optimization iteration. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0029] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the process of the present invention;

[0030] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the special thread structure of oil well pipe;

[0031] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the load points of the special thread composite loading of the oil well pipe in the embodiment and the thread equivalent stress distribution obtained after optimization by the method of the present invention.

[0032] In the figure, 1 is a sealing surface, 11 is an external thread, 12 is an internal thread, 2 is a top diameter of a control point for processing and / or measuring an external thread, 3 is a top diameter of a control point for processing and / or measuring an internal thread, 21 is a 95% yield stress ellipse, and 22 is a 100% yield stress ellipse. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0033] The present invention is further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments, which are intended to explain the present invention rather than to limit it.

[0034] like Figure 2 As shown, the method for optimizing the sealing surface of special thread of oil well pipe of the present invention is applied to a special thread structure, wherein after the metal-to-metal sealing surface 1 of the external thread 11 and the internal thread 12 are meshed, a certain interference contact pressure should be maintained. The top diameter 2 of the external thread processing and / or measuring control point and the top diameter 3 of the internal thread processing and / or measuring control point are used as optimization design variables to describe the interference amount of the thread after the thread is buckled into place.

[0035] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of the method of the present invention, which uses external thread processing and / or measuring the top diameter of the control point and internal thread processing and / or measuring the top diameter of the control point to describe the actual interference after the thread is buckled into place (corresponding to step S21). The sealing surface contact pressure design requirements (i.e., the sealing surface sealing strength is greater than the critical threshold of leakage) of the oil well pipe under different tensile, compression and internal and external pressure composite loading are used as the target for optimization. Figure 3 As shown, a schematic diagram of load points of the composite loading of the special threaded oil well pipe of the present invention, a 95% yield stress ellipse 21, a 100% yield stress ellipse 22, and 14 objective functions (corresponding to step S22) are constructed for the sealing contact pressure requirements of load points 1 to 14 (the typical limit load points are selected with reference to "ISO13679-2002 Test procedures for casing and tubing connections in the petroleum and natural gas industry") under the composite loading conditions of tension, compression and internal and external pressures that the oil well pipe with a pre-designed thread structure is usually subjected to in actual working conditions.

[0036] The constraints are defined according to the multi-boundary constraints of no sticking after the threads are made into place and the structural integrity of the threaded joint (corresponding to step S23), and the constraints of the optimized design variables are: meeting the requirement that no sticking occurs when the special threads are made up and unmade (i.e., the contact pressure between the tooth top and the tooth bottom after the threads are made into engagement is less than or equal to 90% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe), and meeting the structural integrity requirements of the threaded joint (i.e., determining that the maximum equivalent stress at the stress concentration site at the end of the coupling after the threads are made up is less than or equal to 95% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe).

[0037] There is no logical order among the corresponding internal and external thread processing and / or measurement of the control point top diameter to describe the definition of multiple optimization design variables for thread make-up interference (step S21), the construction of the multi-objective function of the sealing surface contact pressure (step S22), and the application of multiple boundary constraints for make-up without sticking and joint structural integrity (step S23) in the above steps.

[0038] Next, according to the above-established objective function and constraint conditions, the finite element numerical simulation is used to establish the connection between the design variables of different thread interference amounts and the sealing surface sealing objective function, that is, a series of test data points for evaluating the response function are constructed through a large number of numerical simulations (corresponding to step S24). An appropriate response surface approximation function model is selected, that is, the application of the response surface method is used (corresponding to step S25), and an approximate response surface function is constructed based on the test results, that is, an optimization design model is established according to the test data points of the evaluation response function established by the finite element numerical method (corresponding to step S26), and a significance test and subsequent optimization calculations are performed.

[0039] The established optimization model with multiple objectives, multiple design variables and constraints is optimized by using an improved non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm. In this embodiment, an improved NSGA-II is used for solution (corresponding to step S27). In the improved fitness evaluation process, the population density information around individuals of different levels is evaluated by using a 6σ horizontal sensitivity method, so that the next generation of individuals is away from the inactive area of ​​the population, the deviation of the fitness evaluation value is reduced, and the reliability and robustness of the optimization iteration are increased.

[0040] The Pareto optimal solution set is obtained by optimizing the calculation (corresponding to step S28). The Pareto optimal solution set includes the Pareto optimal solutions under different working conditions. In the actual application process, the designer designs the specific special threaded oil well pipe according to the actual service working condition applicability design requirements (for example, Figure 3 Within the composite load limit yield strength envelope and range of the joint shown, the composite bearing capacity of the oil well pipe such as resistance to internal pressure / external pressure, tension / compression, etc. is selected to meet different design requirements for applicability to working conditions such as different well depths and gas layer pressures) to select the optimal solution (corresponding to step S29).

[0041] like Figure 3 As shown in the figure, the contact stress distribution diagram of the sealing surface obtained after optimization according to a certain working condition. It can be seen from the figure that under 14 extreme composite load conditions, the sealing surface and the thread meshing part maintain a relatively ideal equivalent stress.

[0042] It should be noted that the above is only a part of the implementation of the present invention, and equivalent changes made to the system described in the present invention are all included in the protection scope of the present invention. Those skilled in the art of the present invention can replace the specific examples described in a similar manner, as long as they do not deviate from the structure of the present invention or exceed the scope defined by the claims, they all belong to the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes. It is characterized in that The following steps are involved: Step 1: Based on the response surface method, an optimization design model for the interference of special threads of oil well pipes is established. Specifically, the step 1 is as follows: an optimization objective function is constructed based on the quantitative requirements of the sealing performance of the sealing surface at several typical extreme load points, the top diameter of the tapered thread processing and / or measurement control point is used as the optimization design variable, the constraint conditions of the optimization design variables are determined based on the requirements of no sticking when the special thread is unfastened and the structural integrity requirements of the threaded joint, the connection between the sealing objective function of the sealing surface and the design variables of different thread interference amounts is established by using finite element numerical simulation, and a series of test data points for evaluating the objective function are constructed by numerical simulation; the constructed optimization objective function satisfies the maximum difference between the sealing strength of the sealing surface at multiple typical extreme load points and the critical threshold of leakage, that is: , Among them, the sealing strength for: , In the formula, is the actual contact pressure of the sealing surface, is the actual contact width of the sealing surface; Leakage critical threshold for: In the formula, is the internal pressure of the tube, is the atmospheric pressure; Step 2: Use the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm improved based on the sensitivity analysis method to perform multi-objective optimization on the optimization design model established in step 1 to find the Pareto optimal solution set; Step 3: Based on the actual working conditions of the oil well pipe and the applicability design requirements, select the optimal solution from the Pareto optimal solution set obtained in step 2.

2. The method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes according to claim 1, It is characterized in that After the experimental data points are constructed, an approximate response surface function is constructed based on the constructed experimental data points and the experimental results, and the response surface function is tested for significance and optimized.

3. The method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The requirement for special thread bends to prevent galling is that the contact pressure between the top and bottom of the threads after thread bends is less than or equal to 90% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe.

4. The method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The structural integrity requirement of the threaded joint is: the maximum equivalent stress at the stress concentration point at the end of the coupling after the thread is made up is less than or equal to 95% of the minimum yield strength of the pipe.

5. The method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes according to claim 1, It is characterized in that In step 2, multi-objective optimization is performed, including evaluating the Pareto ranking value of individuals during the fitness evaluation process. At the same time, the sensitivity of the optimization trend to the population density information around the individuals is evaluated by introducing the mean and standard deviation of individual variables and Pareto ranking values.

6. The method for optimizing the interference of special threads of oil well pipes according to claim 5, It is characterized in that During the fitness evaluation process, the 6σ horizontal sensitivity method is used to evaluate the population density information around individuals of different levels, so that the next generation of individuals will be genetically away from the inactive areas of the population.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method for mechanical and capillary seal analysis of a hydrocarbon trap

    CN101297097A

  • Optimization design method for non-API (American petroleum institute) thread sealing face

    CN102609566A

  • Optimization design method for oil casing screwed-joint sealing structure

    CN104573212A

  • Method for determining manufacturing parameters of sealing structure of oil well pipe joint, and sealing method

    WO2019184470A1