Device and method for assessing emotions in infants and young children

By installing multiple electrodes on infant and toddler headsets, the problems of inconvenience and inaccuracy of infant EEG data collection in the prior art are solved, and accurate monitoring and analysis of infant emotional development are achieved.

CN112638256BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-06KEFU BRAND CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN201980057689.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2018-09-04
Filing Date
2019-08-30
Publication Date
2024-12-06
Estimated Expiration
2039-08-30

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The application of existing electroencephalography (EEG) technology in infants and young children is limited by age factors and EEG pattern stability, which leads to inconvenient and inaccurate data collection, making it difficult to effectively monitor infant emotional development.

Method used

Using EEG headsets positioned in the optimal position, contacting multiple electrodes on the scalp, collecting and synchronizing data for more precise measurement of infants and toddler attention and input, combined with a data analyzer for noise filtering and data Processing to achieve detailed monitoring of infant neural activity.

Benefits of technology

Improves the efficiency and accuracy of EEG data collection for infants and young children, can better monitor and understand infant emotional development, and provides a portable data collection system suitable for use in laboratories and in natural environments.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112638256B_ABST
    Figure CN112638256B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A system and apparatus for collecting electroencephalogram (EEG) data from infants and young children is disclosed.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a portable electroencephalogram (EEG) headset for studying cognitive and emotional development in infants and young children. Background Art

[0002] Emotional development is an important prerequisite for optimal cognitive growth in infants. This maturation process is based on the formation and synchronization of brain networks that will eventually characterize cognitive functions. Electroencephalography (EEG) is a suitable technology for exploring cognitive and emotional associations of brain activity. Nevertheless, the use of this technology in infants is limited by several practical and neurodevelopmental factors compared to EEG studies in adults. Age factors and EEG pattern stability can play an important role to ensure the functional interpretation of data collection and basic brain processes in infants. When conducting EEG studies in infant emotional development, there are technical and procedural barriers.

[0003] Conventional electroencephalogram (EEG) systems use scalp-level electrodes, typically attached to an elastic cap or band, to monitor neurological activity. Conductive gels and pastes are applied prior to placement of the scalp electrodes to improve sensitivity. However, applying conductive gels and pastes to infants and young children is often inconvenient, time-consuming, and undesirable.

[0004] Efforts have been made to develop more portable, efficient and effective EEG data collection mechanisms.

[0005] U.S. Patent Nos. 9,336,535 and 8,655,428 to Nielsen Company disclose a system for collecting neural response data, the system comprising a headset to collect first neural response data and second neural response data from a user when the user is exposed to a stimulation material, wherein the headset comprises a band, a first sensor and a second sensor each extending from the band (wherein the first sensor and the second sensor are rotatably positioned relative to the band), and a processor. Elastic caps or bands may be uncomfortable when used for long periods of time.

[0006] US Reissue Patent No. Re. 34,015 to Children's Medical Center, Inc. discloses an apparatus for generating a topographical display of information regarding electrical activity of the brain based on the response of electrical activity transducers placed on the skull.

[0007] US Patent No. 9,770,184 to Bittium Bioisignals OY discloses attaching an electrode configuration to a hairless area of ​​a patient's head to produce high quality measurement information.

[0008] U.S. Patent No. 9,370,313 and EP3087918A1 of Bio-signal Group disclose a device for performing an electroencephalogram on a patient, the device comprising a sagittal portion, the sagittal portion comprising: i) a forehead anchor, the forehead anchor comprising two arms, namely a first forehead anchor arm and an opposite second forehead anchor arm; ii) a neck anchor, the neck anchor comprising two arms, namely a first neck anchor arm and an opposite second neck anchor arm; iii) a middle section, the middle section is located between the forehead anchor and the neck anchor; and iv) a plurality of embedded electrodes, the plurality of embedded electrodes are located in the forehead anchor and the middle section. The device also includes: a coronal portion, the coronal portion comprising a plurality of embedded electrodes; and an electrical connector, the electrical connector being used to electrically connect the embedded electrodes in the sagittal portion and the coronal portion to the electroencephalogram.

[0009] French patent No. FR2975276B1 and WO2012156643A1 of the Jules Verne University of Picardy and the Central Hospital Affiliated to the University of Amiens-Picardy disclose a device for measuring brain activity signals of an individual, the device comprising a support structure (2) intended for carrying a sensor, characterized in that the support structure (2) forms a frame having connecting elements (5) and being hollowed out between the connecting elements, wherein the connecting elements (5) form at least one central chain (50) and side chains (51), wherein the side chains (51) are arranged on either side of the central chain and have gaps therebetween and are connected via connecting elements (8), and wherein the side chains (51) perform articulation relative to the central chain (50) and preferably exhibit articulation around at least two pivot axes.

[0010] WO2013124366A1 and GB2499595A by James IERoche disclose an electroencephalogram electrode system for neonatal brain monitoring, the system comprising a deformable substrate whose shape and size are designed to conform to an infant's head, the substrate preferably defining four circular protrusions, the system further comprising an electrode array arranged around the circular protrusions of the substrate and capable of making electrical contact with the head when the substrate is positioned on the head.

[0011] U.S. Patent Nos. 7,415,305 and US20060074336A1, to the trustee of Columbia University in New York City, disclose methods and systems for monitoring and evaluating brain electrical activity. The reference discloses that the system includes an EEG device for obtaining EEG information, the device including: a plurality of electrodes, the plurality of electrodes being placed to measure the brain electrical activity of a subject; and a processing device, the processing device for processing the EEG information to obtain information including local synchronization information, wherein the processing device is configured to execute a computer algorithm to reduce residual volume conduction artifacts in the obtained local synchronization information. "Local synchronization information" is defined as information that provides a quantitative measure of local synchronization, wherein adjacent electrodes (or other means for obtaining electrical activity measurements at a site) used to calculate the quantitative measure are spaced no more than 3 centimeters apart. In some embodiments, local coherence is used as a measure of local synchronization.

[0012] WO2007006976A3 and FR2888487A1 of the University of Picardy Jules Verne and the Centre Hospitalier de l'Universitaire Amiens-Picardie disclose a headgear for measuring brain activity of an individual, comprising a device (3) for measuring brain activity and a surrounding element (2) positionable on a human skull. The reference discloses that the surrounding element (2) is made entirely or partially of a material in the form of a deformable shape memory paste that can be molded to the skull of the individual.

[0013] CN103989473B by Ying Xue discloses a method for correctly positioning electrodes on a human head.

[0014] WO2008058343A1 of the University of Queensland discloses a method for detecting epileptic seizures in newborns or young children.

[0015] US Published Patent Application No. 20040030258 to True-Test Limited discloses a flexible, conformable sensor assembly including an electrode array that is particularly suitable for stable, long-term recording of EEG signals from premature infants or newborns in intensive care.

[0016] Grossman, T., The Development of Emotion Perception in Face and Voice During Infancy, Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience, Vol. 28 (2010): 219-236 provides a literature review of how the ability to interact with others develops in infancy and which brain processes support infants' perception of emotions in different modalities. Grossman published a set of electrophysiological studies that provide insights into the brain processes that underlie infants' developing abilities.

[0017] Available mechanisms have various limitations. It would therefore be desirable to provide improved mechanisms for collecting EEG data from infants and young children.

[0018] The present disclosure may be best understood by referring to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings which illustrate specific embodiments. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0019] Figure 1A and Figure 1B An example of a system for performing data collection and functional interpretation of fundamental brain processes in infants and young children is shown.

[0020] Figure 2A and Figure 2B Examples of electrode configurations for optimal data collection are shown.

[0021] Figure 3 Examples of EEG features that can be observed using the data collection system are shown.

[0022] Figure 4 One example of a technique for performing data synchronization is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0023] From birth, infants develop and demonstrate their ability to experience and express different emotions. They express biologically based emotions, such as when they are fed, they express satisfaction, or when they need attention, they express anxiety. Given the significant role that emotions have in overall brain function, research on the nature of infant emotions has generated considerable interest in recent decades. Currently, this interest is focused on the core brain patterns associated with infants' emotional perception and development.

[0024] Emotional expressions have been studied in standard infant populations for decades, noting that the facial component of emotional expressions is present very early after birth (Camras, Holland, & Patterson, 1993; Calhoun & Kuczera, 1996; Izard & Malatesta, 1987; Phillips, Wellman, & Spelke, 2002). If we consider facial expressions as external cues that represent internal emotional states, the question is, do infants experience emotions in the same way as children or adults? We know from multiple studies that infants are not aware of their emotional states until the age of 2 years. Infants experience what has been called a "dissociation between state and experience" (Lewis & Michalson; 1983; REF), which means that infants have experiences of emotions rather than emotional states. The ability to experience our own emotions depends on the development of many cognitive skills that do not emerge until the second year of life. One of these cognitive skills is the so-called "self-awareness" (also called self-perception), and its emergence is not automatic but the product of a maturation process of brain structures (primarily the prefrontal cortex, limbic cortex, basal forebrain, amygdala, hypothalamus and brainstem) that changes from birth and during different stages of infancy. Therefore, before the infant has acquired this level of neurodevelopment, the ability to experience any emotion as a state of one's own consciousness does not exist (see Lewis, 2003; 2011).

[0025] Thanks to recent advances in neuroimaging, we can delve deeper into the neural mechanisms associated with early affective states in terms of structural maturation and synapse formation. Studies using high spatial resolution techniques such as functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) have extensively documented the cortical and subcortical structures involved in processing specific emotions (such as fear) or emotional communication within the first year of life (e.g., primarily the amygdala, anterior insula, medial prefrontal cortex) (Callaghan et al., 2014; Johnstone, 2006; Wang et al., 2005). However, fMRI lacks the temporal resolution required to capture the ongoing neural operational changes associated with emotional processing (Banaschewski and Brandeis, 2007; Hajcak, Moser, and Simons, 2006). In contrast, given its high temporal resolution, EEG technology is particularly accurate for studying cognitive processes that occur on a millisecond time scale (deHaan, 2007; REF). This level of temporal accuracy is critical when exploring month-to-month changes in brain-behavior relationships (Cuevas and Bell, 2011). In addition, in order to measure the emotion-related activities of young infants, EEG has many key advantages over other neuroimaging methods. One of these advantages is that it allows the collection of brain-related data in a relatively unconstrained experimental environment compatible with the continuous behavior of infants. In addition, the use of high-density EEG allows greater spatial resolution, which is critical when making such comparisons across brain hemispheres (e.g., asymmetry) and scalp sites. In general, the EEG method has the advantage of being objective and is not subject to observational scoring metrics.

[0026] Electroencephalography (EEG) is a research method with a great deal of history and promise for continuing to advance the study of infant emotional development.

[0027] 2. Measuring emotions in young infants (by age) using EEG

[0028] Despite the remarkable growth in infant emotion research using EEG methods (see recent journal publications: Gomez et al., 2016; Walter et al., 2016; Tarol Colls & Pasco Fearon, 2015; Vanden Boomen, Munsters, & Kemmer, 2017), the data generally appear to be scattered and fraught with uncertainty regarding the neural features that underlie emotion processing in young infants and children. In most cases, this lack of consistency focuses on the type of emotion being measured (i.e., basic or derived), age factors, and methodological aspects such as appropriate EEG test paradigms.

[0029] A general problem when conducting EEG studies on infants refers to correct frequency identification. According to research, the standard main frequency bands of infant EEG are 4-6Hz and 6-9Hz (Calkins, Fox, and Marshall, 1996; Marshall, Bar-Ham, and Fox, 2002). These are slow wave brains that are thought to indicate neural activation in infants (Allen, Coan, and Nazarian, 2004; Davidson, 1988). However, the data often appear to be scattered and full of differences related to the frequency band boundaries. In most cases, this lack of consistency focuses on the type of emotion being measured (i.e., basic or derived), age factors, and methodological aspects such as the more relevant EEG methods. Furthermore, infants’ EEG is sensitive to the recording context, meaning that EEG changes are significantly influenced by the content of sensory input, stimulus valence (Davidson & Fox, 1982; Missana & Grossmann, 2015), action observation (Cuevas et al., 2014; Fox et al., 2016; Marshall & Meltzoff, 2011), and maternal psychological context such as depression (Field et al., 1995; Walter et al., 1997; Lusby, Goodman, Bell, & Newport, 2014).

[0030] Because the developing brain is a dynamic system, unstable patterns of neural activity are expected throughout the different age periods. Indeed, early emotional stimulation has been shown to be associated with significant changes in infants' EEG responses. Based on the reviewed literature, neural signatures of positive developmental effects in the first year can be explored in two age periods. In the next section, we review the latest EEG research insights in the field of infant emotions during the first year of life based on key age-related changes in infant brain activity. In addition, we will discuss the pros and cons of EEG methods currently applied to the study of emotion processing in clinical and non-clinical infant populations.

[0031] Age window: 0-6 months

[0032] Core Emotions

[0033] From a biological perspective, the emergence of the emotion network is a sequential process, as the development of certain emotions (fear, sadness, guilt, empathy, frustration, etc.) needs to precede that of other emotions (anxiety, comfort, interest). From birth (0-2 months), infants show an innate preference for facial expressions and emotional sounds. Currently, from neuroimaging studies, we know that basic emotions can be distinguished when presented with facial expressions such as happiness and sadness (Johnson, Dziurawiec, Ellis, & Morton, 1991) or speech with different emotional valence (Cheng et al., 2012; Walter et al., 2005; Wang et al., 2014). Specifically, face-specific activity in the infant brain appears before about 2 months (de Heering et al., 2005, 2012), but this does not necessarily require emotion recognition or processing as in adults. Prior maturation of limbic structures (amygdala) and complete development of the visual system will be necessary to achieve an adult-like emotion processing system.

[0034] As the visual representation areas of the cortex develop, the infant's limited vision rapidly develops into full binocular vision. According to the literature, early facial perception biases are thought to underlie networks associated with emotion processing ( and Nelson, 2008), because human faces have associated biologically relevant features (e.g., faces can indicate threat or happiness).

[0035] Between the ages of 3-6 months, infants' ability to recognize emotions improves dramatically, coinciding with significant growth in limbic structures (i.e., the hippocampus) involved in recognition memory and the deployment of key neural programs (i.e., the Flourishing Period). At this age, infants show excitement by smiling and laughing (before this age, smiling is considered reflexive, not emotional) when they see or experience pleasurable events; they cry when upset, seek comfort, and are able to understand differences between adults based on the way they look, talk, or feel.

[0036] In the next section, we describe infant EEG characteristics in relation to milestones of neurodevelopment.

[0037] Main EEG developmental changes

[0038] In the period of 0 to 5 months, it is important to identify the typical EEG features and the frequency band changes associated with the emotional behavior of infants. Various studies have clarified how the EEG signal changes according to different developmental stages. For example, we know that there are no typical alpha oscillations (power spectrum between 7Hz and 15Hz) (REF) before 10 months of age. Instead, infants show so-called post-"alpha-like" activity (oscillation range of 8-13Hz), similar to the classical alpha rhythm observed in adults (Lindsley, 1938, 1939; Smith, 1938, 1941). These post-rhythm changes can occur in a short period of time, from 3-9Hz at 1 week of age to 4-9Hz. By 3 months of age, the main peak is at about 5Hz (Diego, Jonesand and Field, 2009).

[0039] In early development studies, lower frequency EEG activity in the theta band has been associated with cognitive and emotional processing in young infants (Futagi et al., 1998; Kugler and Laub, 1971; Lehtonen et al., 2002; Paul, Dittrichova, and Papousek, 1996). Age-related increases in power in the theta band in infants have been reported from 3 to 6 months of age (Lehtonen et al., 2002; Stroganova and Orekhova, 2007). In some of these studies, theta activity has been associated with early expressions of positive emotions and negative emotions such as comfort or sleepiness in infants (Futagi et al., 1998). The specific theta frequency range that reflects the emergence of these affective states is susceptible to change due to neurodevelopmental events. For example, we know that the theta frequency range for infants used as a baseline is approximately 3-6 Hz, but these boundaries are inconsistent across studies, making it difficult to find an accurate interpretation of the functional significance of the EEG spectrum. Therefore, given the observed inter-individual variability in infant EEG frequency bands, assigning frequency intervals to specific oscillations can sometimes be misleading, and therefore age-adjusted calibration should not be arbitrary.

[0040] EEG Research and Methods

[0041] The most prominent signal of infants' early emotional processing is their attentional sensitivity to faces. Reviewed evidence indicates that infants begin to show some degree of face processing around 2 months of age (Easterbrook, Kisilevsky, Muir, & Laplante, 1999; Walton & Bower, 1993). Indeed, neuroimaging data indicate that subcortical structures such as the amygdala are functional at birth and therefore play a key role in the early neonatal attentional bias toward faces (Johnson, 2005; & Nelson, 2009). However, the development of more advanced facial emotion discrimination skills occurs after greater exposure to social interactions (LeGrand, Mondloch, Maurer, & Brent, 2001; Wang et al., 2005).

[0042] Regarding the neural correlates of facial emotion processing, event-related potential (ERP) studies have shown that in infants older than 3 months, the patterns of neural activity in response to the presentation of faces compared to non-face objects are different (Halit et al., 2003; 2004). However, unlike adults, it appears that the same infant face processing mechanisms are activated when a wider range of other stimuli (i.e., objects, animals) are presented, suggesting that the underlying network becomes more specialized for faces during development (Halit et al., 2003).

[0043] In newborns, it is difficult to precisely understand the level of attentional engagement with visual emotion triggers such as faces, as the connectivity patterns of the attention network are still immature. In addition, the ability to recognize different types of facial expressions does not exist until 5-7 months of age. In contrast, at birth, the auditory system is more developed than the visual system and can provide better EEG insights into emotion discrimination (Cartal et al., 2005; Gottlieb, 1971; Hááden et al., 2009; Trehub, 2003; Ruusuvirta et al., 2003). Therefore, in order to study emotion perception in young infants, it is more convenient to use multimodal methods rather than using visual stimuli such as facial expressions. For example, facial and vocal stimuli are synchronized to measure emotion discrimination.

[0044] Given the above, it is feasible to address EEG-related activity in emotion processing in young infants by employing classic auditory-based experimental paradigms. The mismatch negativity (MMN) is particularly adequate in newborns because it can be elicited without attention ( et al., 1993; 2007; Luck, 2005). Moreover, a modified auditory oddball paradigm is often used to measure the neural response of newborns to emotional sounds. In this regard, few studies have used corresponding paradigms that are also combined with ERP methods to identify the neural correlates of emotional speech processing in newborns (Cheng et al., 2012; Zhang et al., 2014). In one of these studies, it was shown that fearful and angry emotional speech elicited different neural association patterns in newborns (e.g., mismatch responses of about 150-250ms after stimulation) (Zhang et al., 2014). The authors concluded that the early brain may have different neural mechanisms to process fearful and angry voice expressions, but they agree that this early discrimination cannot be conceptualized as newborns having emotional experiences of fear or anger. More likely, it can be interpreted as a prior neural innervation for the development of later emotional skills.

[0045] discuss

[0046] A major issue in the study of the neural basis of emotions in young infants (primarily before 6 months of age) is which specific emotions are feasible to study with minimal reliability. Researchers often focus on observable displays of emotional expression to interpret infants' emotions. Although decoding facial and body expressions provides insights into recognizable emotions, researchers differ on the range of emotions that infants can experience (see Camras, 2004). In general, the emotional state of newborns has been defined as a continuum of emotional changes from anxiety to comfort (and vice versa), which is highly influenced by the state of the caregiver themselves (i.e., when the mother is irritable, they become irritable). However, the neural correlates of early fear or anger have been studied in young normal newborns (Cheng et al., 2012; Zhang et al., 2014), and the results are not conclusive. In fact, convergent evidence suggests that an attention bias towards threat-related stimuli emerges at 6-7 months of age, which corresponds to the developmental stage when fear emerges ( and Nelson, 2012). Thus, spontaneous angry or fearful facial responses in neonates may reflect the emergence of neural circuitry for processing more sophisticated affective stimuli with socioemotional relevance but do not indicate actual experience of anger or fear. Furthermore, we have found that dissociation of neonates' emotional states based on their associations with facial expressions is insufficient because infants of this age demonstrate a high ability to mimic adults (Heyes, 2011; Isomura and Nakano, 2016; Oostenbroek et al., 2016). The best approach to using EEG to explore infants' emotional experience (i.e., anger, comfort, fun) may be through stimuli that elicit interruptions or increase instrumental actions such as suction, feeding, or audiovisual emergencies (i.e., target blocking paradigms; Lewis et al., 1992).

[0047] We also found that a large number of EEG studies have focused on the emotion valence approach, addressing the neonatal experience of primary emotions such as pleasure or anxiety. Generally speaking, these early emotions have been explored based on differences in anterior right-left areas in response to a variety of positive / negative emotion elicitations (Davidson and Fox, 1982; Fox and Davidson, 1986; Fox and Davidson, 1987). This hypothesis comes from the EEG asymmetry model, in which anterior left activation is consistent with positive emotions, while anterior right activation is associated with negative emotions (Davidson, 1993, 2004; Coan and Allen, 2003). Such differential laterality has been reported in young infants in a limited number of studies, but the conclusions can be interpreted based on the sometimes difficult to determine whether these anterior asymmetries reflect different stimulus conditions (i.e., novel stimulus conditions vs. familiar stimulus conditions) related to emotion processing activities or perception. Therefore, researchers should keep in mind that measuring anterior EEG asymmetry in young infants often leads to a high level of ambiguity or inaccuracy due to neurodevelopmental factors and the lack of strong functional significance of anterior EEG asymmetry at this age.

[0048] Finally, differences in anterior EEG asymmetry are not only hypothesized to be associated with early emotional responses, but are also thought to reflect mechanisms underlying individual emotion regulation tendencies (Fox, 1994). Therefore, such early markers of anterior asymmetry are important precursors to understanding individual differences in emotional behavior.

[0049] 6-12 months: Neurodevelopmental deviations

[0050] Core Emotions

[0051] A more general question in the field of emotion research is whether specific emotions such as anger or happiness can be identified based on specific brain activity patterns. In infants, this question has become increasingly interesting given that neural responses can be used as early developmental markers for predicting infants' future socio-emotional skills (Fox et al., 1995; Harmon-Jones et al., 2010; Paulus et al., 2013; Tomarken et al., 1992; Reid et al., 1998).

[0052] As the brain develops, more sophisticated emotions emerge in response to more sustained environmental stimuli. By 6 months of age and older, other observable facial expressions (laughter, disgust, fear, etc.) are displayed along with sequences of body movements (shaking arms, shaking legs), suggesting the existence of states of surprise, interest, happiness, anger, fear, and disgust (Lewis, 2007). Some of these emotions (i.e., fear, surprise) may reflect underlying cognitive processes such as perceptual discrimination, short-term memory, or social development. For example, convergent evidence suggests that attentional bias toward fearful faces (appearing around 6 to 7 months of age) is associated with different neural responses compared to happy faces (Jessen and Grossmann, 2015). In contrast, this difference does not occur in younger infants who pay more attention to smiling faces, suggesting an enhancement of cortical responses after 6 months of age (Bayet, Quinn et al., 2015; Jessen and Grossmann, 2014, 2015; and Nelson, 2009, 2012; Yrttiaho et al., 2014). Between 5 and 6 months of age, infants begin to show stranger anxiety and they will appear visibly uncomfortable or more anxious.

[0053] By the end of the first year of life, infants become highly emotional, progressing rapidly from intense happiness to intense frustration or anger. They also begin to recognize the emotions of others, showing a more nuanced understanding of emotional communication cues (e.g., producing anticipatory smiles), and managing contextual emotional cues during the perception of facial expressions (VINZia, Messageinger, ThorpandMundy, 2004). At about 12 months of age, infants begin to make connections between facial expressions and specific emotions, thus showing a basic awareness of their own emotional states.

[0054] Main EEG changes

[0055] In general, changes in EEG spectral power due to neural development are expected to have a relative decrease in low-frequency rhythms (i.e., delta waves at 0.5-4 Hz). By 6 months of age, dominant theta oscillations (3-6 Hz) widely distributed over anterior and posterior scalp areas are elicited in response to various emotional triggers and behavioral contexts, including feeding, sleepiness, social interaction, or cognitive activity (e.g., anticipation).

[0056] In early studies, the distribution of pre-theta topography was associated with higher contributions of attention networks (Orekhova et al., 1999; Stroganova, Orekhova, & Posikera, 1998; Orekhova et al., 1999). In one of these studies, pre-theta activity during anticipatory periods of a game of hide-and-seek was compared with periods of quiet attention (i.e., viewing soap bubbles) in different age groups (7-8 months and 9-11 months). The authors reported differences in theta power (assessed in the range of 3.6-4.8 Hz) with relatively larger amplitudes observed in the younger age group (Orekhova et al., 1999; Stroganova & Orekhova, 2007). This is consistent with the maturation of executive cortical networks in infants and with other EEG studies reporting greater pre-theta synchronization (over 8 months of age) marking sustained attention (Bazhenova et al., 2007; Uhlhaas et al., 2010). However, whether there is an increase in theta amplitude during other tasks is unclear. Unlike infant alpha rhythm, little research has been done on the development of theta frequency during infancy.

[0057] In addition, with developmental changes in the spectrum and synchronization of neural oscillations, asymmetric brain activity becomes a more reliable index for measuring positive-negative emotional processing (Fox et al., 1992; REF). Based on the Davidson and Fox study (1982; REF), this lateralized EEG activity appears to be stable by 10 months of age, which is consistent with greater expression of social and emotional behavior. In fact, converging evidence suggests that right anterior asymmetry in the EEG is associated with behavioral inhibition and social withdrawal in infants, while left anterior asymmetry is associated with a characteristic tendency toward general approach or positive emotions (Fox and Henderson, 1999). Therefore, most of the reviewed studies characterizing the neural patterns of emotional behavior within this age group focus on EEG asymmetry in the 3-12 Hz range.

[0058] Although these asymmetries are currently the most powerful indicators of infants’ affective states, the assumed age stability is not well defined across studies. For example, Vuga and colleagues (2008) reported long-term anterior asymmetry stability across the 6–36 month interval, whereas Jones and colleagues (1997) reported long-term anterior asymmetry stability across the 24–30 month interval. More recent studies suggest that adequate stability lies between 10 and 24 months (Howarth, Fettig, Curby, & Bell, 2016). These differences make it difficult to precisely determine the functional nature of anterior asymmetries in studies of infants’ emotion processing and development.

[0059] EEG Research and Investigation Methods

[0060] Based on the reviewed literature, we have distinguished two lines of research to focus on. One refers to the neural patterns associated with emotion recognition. Therefore, the main question here is how infants perceive and recognize emotions in others and how their emotion perception develops. The second line of research interest explores the EEG markers of different affective states, which are expressed in infants as specific emotional states such as comfort, happiness, anxiety, sadness, involvement, etc. in response to arousing triggers or situations (new toys, mother's approach), which can further be modulated (or not) by neural marker properties. Next, we describe the main EEG evidence of emotion processing in infants that follows the above research lines.

[0061] First series of studies: ERP and anterior asymmetry

[0062] Given the enhanced operation of visual attention circuitry, probing emotions across modalities in infants can be relatively less ambiguous over the course of development. This allows researchers to use more trials, which is of particular interest given the typically lower signal-to-noise ratio in infant ERP studies. Furthermore, after 6 months of age, capturing infants' attention over longer periods of time is less challenging.

[0063] A large number of research methods for investigating the responsiveness of infants to emotions are based on ERP methods. The simplest assessment includes recording ERP activity (compared to the picture of the object) when the infant watches the picture of the happy face and the fearful face. The extended study exploring the face-sensitive ERP in infants has identified several components (i.e., N170, N290, Nc, P400) that are speculated to be associated with a variety of significant facial emotional expressions (Allison et al., 1994, 1999; Bubty and Taylor, 2006; DeHaan and Nelson, 1999; Nelson and DeHaan, 1996; Kobiella et al., 2007). The component Nc present between 400ms and 800ms is one of the most studied components in infant ERP research. This component has negative deflection and is mostly distributed on the front electrode site and the central electrode site. Although not elicited specifically in response to facial expressions, reviewed studies indicate that topographical and temporal properties differ from those associated with infants' object perception (deHaan & Nelson, 1999; Taylor, McCarthy, Saliba, & Degiovanni, 1999).

[0064] Based on ERP and anterior asymmetry methods, attentional sensitivity to angry faces (compared to pain and fear faces) has been studied in 7- to 8-month-olds (Missana, Grigutsch, & Grossmann, 2014; Kobiella, Grossmann, Reid, & Striano, 2008). In one of these studies, an Nc ERP component was reported in response to emotional expressions with greater enhancement to angry expressions. In this context, the Nc has been interpreted as reflecting infants' attention allocation. When the infants' anterior asymmetry pattern was compared to that of adults in response to angry faces, the results showed an opposite anterior asymmetry: adults had greater relative left anterior activation (associated with an approach tendency), while infants showed greater relative right anterior activation, indicating an avoidance motivation tendency.

[0065] In addition, the N290 appears in the second half of the first year, marking infants' discrimination of facial expressions based on social cues rather than just the negative-positive valence dichotomy. For example, it has been shown that angry expressions elicit larger N290 amplitudes than fearful expressions. Even though both emotions are negative, it is believed that angry expressions elicit more uncomfortable responses than fearful expressions, indicating a social cue discrimination process (Kobiella et al., 2007).

[0066] The neural basis of infant emotion processing across sensory modalities (visual-auditory-tactile) is a question of research interest. Very few EEG studies have explored emotion processing using multimodal experimental designs (Grossmann et al., 2006; Friedrich and Friederici, 2005). For example, in one of these studies, ERPs marking the processing of emotionally congruent and incongruent face-voice pairs were studied in a group of 7-month-old infants. The results showed that different patterns of ERPs (mainly Nc and Pc) were a function of cross-modal emotion consistency (Grossmann, Striano, & Friederici, 2006). Therefore, it is indicated that cross-modal integration of emotional information occurs relatively early in life.

[0067] In summary, the ERP method can provide different research guidance to answer questions about the emotional processing and development of human infants. However, the main limitation is that unlike adults, infants do not show ERP responses with clearly defined peaks. Instead, they mainly show large slow wave activity in the first two years of life, which indicates poor synaptic efficiency. As the consistency of brain responses increases with age, it is expected that clearly defined ERP waveforms will appear more clearly at about 4 years old (Nelson and Luciana, 1998; Taylor, Batty and Itier, 2004). ERP studies before this age must be conducted under a high level of experimental control, which sometimes interferes with the expected ecological assessment of emotions.

[0068] -Second series of studies :

[0069] In the development process, babies express emotional states through visible facial expression sets, which are more and more similar to the expression of adults. They smile to convey happiness and cry to express disgust or discomfort. In addition, in response to different arousal stimuli or events that change in intensity and duration, babies have shown "emotional style" (Davidson, 2003, 2004). This type of emotional tendency has been associated with the specific pattern of the front EEG that is characterized as the early characteristics of infant emotional ability. In the emotions examined at this age interval, happiness, fear, sadness and disgust have received more attention (for example, compared with anger), and the standard stimuli (for example, pictures, facial expressions, films) used in the laboratory to set up are relatively easier to arouse this attention.

[0070] Generally speaking, the pattern of anterior EEG asymmetry indicates the infant's tendency or bias towards approach-avoidance behavior (i.e., Fox, Henderson, Rubin, Calkins, and Schmidt, 2001), which can reflect activity in the amygdala (Davidson, 2000). In the resting baseline, anterior EEG asymmetry can be an important neural marker for predicting the infant's emotional response to arousing stimuli or events (Wheeler et al., 1993). For example, there are data showing that infants with resting right anterior asymmetry tend to cry more during maternal separation (Davidson and Fox, 1989; Fox et al., 1992). So far, anterior asymmetry is the most common method for studying infant emotional characteristics or abilities (Coan and Allen, 2004; Davidson and Fox, 1989; Davidson, 1992; 1993; Fox, 1991, 1994).

[0071] Consistent with the proposed anterior asymmetry model (approach / withdrawal and positive-negative valence; Davidson 1993; 2002), resting anterior EEG activity is assumed to reflect the propensity for positive versus negative affect and the future infant's ability to regulate emotion. Part of the interest in this line of research is its potential clinical application to predict infants' propensity for certain affective disorders or styles. Indeed, hemispheric anterior activity during the resting state is considered an early neurophysiological marker of depression risk (Allen and Reznik, 2015). For example, there is a large body of data showing greater relative right anterior EEG asymmetry during resting state sessions in infants (e.g., 10 months of age) of depressed mothers compared to non-depressed mothers (Dawson et al., 1992; Diego et al., 2006; Field et al., 1995; 2000; Field and Diego, 2009; Jones et al., 2001; Jones, Field, and Almeida, 2009). Other studies exploring neural markers of separation distress have also found that infants who cried in response to maternal separation had greater right anterior activation at rest compared to infants who did not cry (Davidson and Fox, 1989).

[0072] The anterior asymmetry elicited during the resting state period can change in response to a variety of emotional triggers. Therefore, a feasible method for predicting changes in infants' emotional states is to measure the effects of approach-directed stimuli (i.e., emotional contact, familiar sounds) on anterior activity compared to withdrawal-directed stimuli (i.e., strangers, intrusive interactions) (Coan et al., 2001; Coan and Allen, 2004; Ekman et al., 1990; Davidson and Fox, 1982). It is highly recommended to use appropriate paradigms (i.e., visual discrimination, toy social referencing, cross-modal transfer) to simultaneously measure physiological arousal (heart rate) and attentional engagement correlates (gaze duration and transfer), especially when the primary research goal is to assess changes in emotional state due to arousing stimuli.

[0073] In addition, the type of emotionally arousing stimulus used to investigate the anterior asymmetry pattern must be considered. It may be reasonable to expect that individual differences in anterior asymmetric activity affect infants' responses to the same arousal triggers (Davidson and Fox, 1989). However, depending on the purpose of the study, an individual difference approach or a normative approach can be adopted. Therefore, the former suggestion is suitable for studies that focus on exploring patterns of cortical activation asymmetry as stable characteristics to predict emotional reactivity or motivational trends to arousal stimuli. For example, the tendency of infants to cry or not cry in response to caregiver separation or to smile or feel shy in the presence of strangers can be predicted based on the individual anterior asymmetry pattern of infants. Within this method, it is recommended to add a longitudinal component to investigate the impact of early positive and negative affective emotional experiences on development (Calkins et al., 2002; Coan and Allen, 2003; Davidson, 1998; Walter et al., 2008; Hill-Sonderlund and Braungart-Rieker, 2008; Kochanska and Knaack, 2003; Wheeler et al., 1993). In contrast, the normative approach is appropriate for those studies that are more focused on measuring infants' anterior asymmetry associated with affective states elicited under controlled environmental experimental conditions (Buss et al., 2003; Cattell and Scheier, 1961; Diaz and Bell, 2012; Fox et al., 2001). Examples of this would include differences in infants' anterior asymmetry elicited by the presentation of happy-sad facial expressions, stressful situations such as stranger approach, or different types of novel stimuli.

[0074] In addition, when looking at anterior activity asymmetry in non-clinical populations, the combination of EEG recordings with other techniques such as simultaneous facial coding can further add insights to the emotional state categories of infants. The facial coding method includes examining right and left EEG patterns during baseline and emotional elicitation conditions (i.e., peek-a-boo games), while encoding infant affect (facial expressions) as positive, negative, and neutral, for example. In this regard, there is evidence of different and independent patterns of left anterior activation that mirrors two types of infant smiles: in response to mothers in response to strangers approaching (Fox and Davidson, 1988; see also Field et al., 2011; Jones et al., 2001). In addition, the functional importance of the temporary theta rhythm of infants has been addressed using simultaneous EEG-video recording methods (Dawson et al., 1992; Field et al., 2011; Futagi et al., 1998). In one of these studies, it was demonstrated that the anterior and posterior patterns of theta rhythms were associated with emotional responses, such as freezing and suctioning, and also with other cortical activities, such as fixation and processing (Futagi et al., 1998).

[0075] Finally, when measuring anterior asymmetry, the mosaic reference site used should be considered. When measuring EEG based on power spectra, traditional site references (i.e., Cz vertex, mastoid) are problematic (see Pivik et al., 1993; Hagemann et al., 2001). Therefore, the main recommendation is to use a recording reference scheme that is sensitive enough to account for individual variations in anterior asymmetry. We refer to the EEG literature for additional details on reference site guidelines (Hagemann, 2004; Nunez et al., 1994; Pivik et al., 1993).

[0076] Overall, anterior asymmetry is presented in the infant literature as a favorable method for measuring emotion at an early stage of development. However, we argue that inconsistencies remain, which may be due to different theoretical and empirical reasons. In the next section, we discuss these discrepancies and offer some suggestions for future research.

[0077] discuss

[0078] Most of the reviewed studies agree that asymmetric activity patterns in the anterior site can be used as a neural marker of emotional responses in infants. We also reviewed that this anterior asymmetry, which becomes stable starting at about 10 months of age, has been associated with motivational properties of affective states (approach-withdrawal behaviors) and with the experience and expression of positive / negative emotions (Dawson, 1994; Diaz and Bell, 2012; Fox, 1991, 1994). This does not mean that the anterior asymmetry is causal in generating these emotional responses, as the data supporting this hypothesis in infants are mainly based on correlational evidence and are therefore subject to alternative explanations. For example, the anterior activation pattern may also reflect functional developmental changes on the relevant neural circuits (i.e., the alerting attention network) or an effect on the reward value of the stimulus.

[0079] Furthermore, while the number of studies supporting this direct association in the adult literature is sufficiently large, in infant studies we found that pre-asymmetric activity and the corresponding emotional experience and expression have not been adequately addressed beyond the context of emotion recognition (e.g., primarily based on visual discrimination of facial expressions). The number of EEG studies exploring the relationship of pre-asymmetry to changes in emotional state is even smaller in non-clinical populations.

[0080] The second part of this discussion refers to the impact of individual differences in EEG anterior asymmetric activation and its functional significance in non-clinical research settings. When measuring cortical asymmetry in infants to infer their emotional state or predict their affective characteristics in relation to arousing stimuli, there are sources of variation to consider that are mainly related to individual differences. With regard to the hypothesis of infant-specific asymmetry, the high heritability of the EEG spectrum makes it difficult to determine precisely whether anterior asymmetry originates from genetic predisposition or from environmental influences (Coan, 2003; MacDhomhail et al., 1999; Lykken et al., 1982). In both cases, it is recommended to strengthen methodological aspects to ensure the reliability of their measures (e.g., increase sample size, resting time, appropriate mosaic of reference patterns). For example, measuring resting anterior asymmetry over multiple periods can help researchers distinguish changes due to stable characteristics of individuals from changes in response to specific experimental manipulations (see Hagemann, 2000). Several measurements of resting anterior activity within the same experimental period can increase data reliability, but implies certain disadvantages. In this regard, we note that most studies have performed only a single measurement of anterior asymmetry in a resting or baseline state. This is usually because it is difficult to keep infants still in the laboratory for long periods of time without undesired emotional changes affecting the recording.

[0081] Furthermore, to increase the internal validity of the study and avoid possible confounding, recent studies have reported similarities in mother / infant anterior asymmetry during emotionally salient situations (Collan and Allen, 2004; Jones et al., 2001; Atzaba-Poria, Deater-Deckard, Ann-Bell, 2017). In this regard, it may also be convenient to correlate anterior EEG responses with concurrent measures of maternal affect behaviors (i.e., positive affect versus negative affect) to determine whether the functional significance of EEG anterior asymmetry is based on motivation-specific factors or biological characteristics (LoBue, Coan, Thrasher, DeLoache, 2011; Wen et al., 2017). Finally, when using changes in anterior asymmetry according to specific emotional arousal conditions, it is recommended to control for individual differences due to age, as it can explain typical differences in EEG power changes relative to specific emotional triggers.

[0082] At some point, we found that the anterior asymmetry configuration in studies of infants points to an oversimplification, partly due to some data inconsistencies, but also due to the lack of precise definition of emotional valence and motivational anterior asymmetric activity that may exist in infants younger than one year of age (compared to adults). For example, for infants (4-9 months of age), it is unclear how right anterior EEG asymmetry is associated with anger, because some of the reviewed studies confounded emotional valence (positive-negative) with motivational direction (approach-avoidance), making it difficult to discern which of these (or a combination of both) the anterior asymmetry reflects (Davidson & Fox, 1989; Harmon-Jones, 2004; He, Degnan, McDermott, et al., 2010). Therefore, it remains very important for future research to examine situations in which anterior asymmetry is the most appropriate method for studying emotional changes during arousal tasks or stimuli. Alternatively, we find the ability model proposed by Coan and Allen (2006) promising, in which individual differences in anterior asymmetry are predicted to be more pronounced during arousal tasks or emotional stimulation rather than during the resting state.

[0083] 3. General considerations: current perspectives and research guidance

[0084] In this review, we have highlighted the most important advances and theoretical perspectives on infant emotional behavior as it varies with neurodevelopmental stage. In addition, we have discussed the main advantages and disadvantages of using EEG to investigate infant emotion as well as the strengths and weaknesses of current results.

[0085] In the past decade, the interest in EEG methods in the study of emotional development during the first year of infants has increased significantly. Although EEG lacks accurate high-resolution brain images, it provides a valuable tool in assessing the neural basis characteristics associated with human emotional development during the first year of life. Generally speaking, ERP and power spectrum measurements have become essential for investigating the cognitive neuroscience of infants. Other neuroimaging methods such as source localization can help further clarify the interpretation of ERP or band spectra, but it is quite difficult to map these activations to brain images collected by structural MRI. This is almost impractical in non-clinical studies of the age below 36 months. Alternatively, electroencephalography (MEG) is an interesting technology for studying emotions, considering the high accuracy of MEG signal localization compared to EEG. However, although it can be used well for infants, it requires higher costs and is more technically challenging (see Imada et al., 2006) compared to EEG.

[0086] The combination of EEG and other neuroimaging techniques has become a routine for studying cognitive and emotional fields. For example, the simultaneous recording of EEG and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) is a suitable method for measuring the role of prefrontal cortex activation in emotional processing (i.e., Nishitani, Doi, Koyama, and Shinohara, 2011). Such co-registration is feasible in infants because less collaboration is required from their side (e.g., Koch, Steinbrink, Villringer, and Obrig, 2006). Particularly promising is the hyperscanning technique (Hirata et al., 2014) for understanding mother-infant brain synchronization during arousing experiences (such as emotional boundaries, hand-holding, or voice).

[0087] Now will refer to some specific examples of the present invention in detail, including the best mode for implementing the present invention contemplated by the inventor. The examples of these specific embodiments are shown in the accompanying drawings. Although the present invention is described in conjunction with these specific embodiments, it should be understood that this is not intended to limit the present invention to the embodiments. On the contrary, it is intended to cover alternative forms, modifications and equivalent forms that may be included in the spirit and scope of the present invention defined by the appended claims.

[0088] Overview

[0089] The present invention provides an efficient and effective system and apparatus for collecting electroencephalogram (EEG) data from infants and young children.The system and method use an EEG headset with electrodes positioned at optimal locations.

[0090] Exemplary embodiments

[0091] Thus, the systems and devices of the present invention use EEG measurements to allow for more accurate measurement and monitoring of attention and engagement in infants and young children. According to various embodiments, an EEG headset is provided to a subject for use in a laboratory setting. In a particular embodiment, the EEG headset includes a plurality of electrodes positioned at optimal locations. Data from the individual electrodes may be processed prior to continuous transmission to a data analyzer. Processing may include filtering to remove noise and artifacts as well as compression and / or encryption. The individual electrodes are configured to contact the scalp in a plurality of regions.

[0092] The EEG electrodes allow for in situ monitoring and tracking of activity, including engagement levels. According to various embodiments, a data collection mechanism is synchronized with the stimulation material to allow for determination of aspects of the stimulation material that evoke specific neurological responses.

[0093] According to various embodiments, the EEG headset stores data collected from a user exposed to stimulation materials for transmission to a data analyzer.

[0094] The subject can wear the portable data collection mechanism during various activities. This allows data to be collected from multiple sources while the subject is in a natural state. In certain embodiments, data collection can be effectively performed in a corporate or laboratory environment.

[0095] A variety of neurological mechanisms, neurophysiological mechanisms, and effector mechanisms can be integrated in the data collection mechanism. EEG measures electrical activity associated with postsynaptic currents that occur in the millisecond range. Nevertheless, if analyzed correctly, surface EEG provides a wealth of electrophysiological information. Portable EEGs with electrodes provide a wealth of information.

[0096] According to various embodiments, the subject may be exposed to a predetermined or pre-selected stimulation material. In other examples, no predetermined or pre-selected stimulation material is provided, and the system collects data on the stimulation material that the user is exposed to during a typical activity.

[0097] For example, a portable EEG monitoring system with electrodes that allow monitoring of activity may be provided to multiple subjects. The response data is analyzed and integrated. In some examples, all response data is provided for data analysis. In other examples, the response data of interest is provided to a data analyzer along with the recorded stimulus material. According to various embodiments, the response data is analyzed and enhanced for each subject, and the response data is further analyzed and enhanced by integrating the data across multiple subjects.

[0098] According to various embodiments, individual and integrated response data are maintained numerically or represented graphically.Measurements from multiple subjects are analyzed to determine possible patterns, fluctuations, distributions, etc.

[0099] According to various embodiments, the data may show the specific effectiveness of the stimulus material on a specific subset of individuals. Various stimulus materials may be analyzed. According to various embodiments, a data analyzer that performs both intra-modality measurement enhancement and cross-modality measurement enhancement is used to generate enhanced data. According to various embodiments, brain activity is measured not only to determine the active area, but also to determine the interaction and interaction type between various areas. The techniques and mechanisms of the present invention recognize that the interaction between neural areas supports orderly and organized behavior. Attention, emotion, memory, retention, elicitation and other characteristics are not only based on part of the brain, but rely on network interactions between brain areas.

[0100] The techniques and mechanisms of the present invention also recognize that different frequency bands used for multi-region communication can indicate the effectiveness of stimulation. In certain embodiments, the assessment is calibrated for each subject and synchronized between subjects. In certain embodiments, a template is created for the subject to create a baseline for measuring the difference before and after stimulation.

[0101] FIG. 1 shows an example of a system for collecting data. The subject is associated with a data collection mechanism. According to various embodiments, during exposure to specific stimulus materials provided by a stimulus presentation mechanism, the subject actively uses a data collection mechanism such as an EEG cap. The data collection mechanism includes a permanent storage mechanism and a network interface for transmitting the collected data to a data analyzer. In other examples, the data collection mechanism includes an interface to a computer system that is configured to transmit data to a data analyzer via one or more networks.

[0102] Materials that elicit a response from the subject may include people, activities, images, personal care compositions, and may involve specific tastes, smells, sights, textures, and / or sounds. In some examples, stimulus materials are selected for presentation to the subject.

[0103] According to various embodiments, the subject is connected to a data collection mechanism. The data collection mechanism includes EEG electrodes, although in some specific implementations, a variety of measurement mechanisms may also be included, including neurological and neurophysiological measurement systems such as EOG, GSR, EKG, pupil dilation, eye tracking, facial emotion coding and reaction time equipment, etc. According to various embodiments, the data includes central nervous system, autonomic nervous system and / or effector data.

[0104] In certain embodiments, the collected data is digitally sampled and stored for later analysis. In certain embodiments, the collected data can be analyzed in real time.

[0105] In one specific embodiment, the data collection mechanism includes EEG measurements performed using scalp-level electrodes.

[0106] Figure 2Aand Figure 2B A data collection mechanism including a plurality of electrodes is shown. According to various embodiments, the data collection mechanism is a soft cap with electrodes configured to contact the scalp without the use of a conductive gel. The signals may be routed to a controller / processor for immediate transmission to a data analyzer or stored for later analysis. The controller / processor may be used to synchronize the data with the stimulation material.

[0107] Figure 2A and Figure 2B The data collection mechanism is shown. The data collection mechanism includes a plurality of electrodes. It should be noted that although the specific electrode arrangement may vary from implementation to implementation, a preferred electrode arrangement is provided herein.

[0108] According to various embodiments, data collection using the electrodes is synchronized with stimulation material presented to the user.The data collection mechanism also includes a transmitter and / or a receiver to send the collected data to a data analysis system.

[0109] In some examples, the transceiver may be connected to a computer system, which then transmits the data to a data analyzer over a wide area network.

[0110] It should be noted that some components of the data collection mechanism are not shown for the sake of clarity.

[0111] Response evaluation based queries can include attention scores, sentiment scores, and effectiveness scores. Such queries can obtain materials that elicit a specific score. Response measurement profile based queries can use mean measurement thresholds, variance measures, number of spikes detected, etc. Group response queries can include group statistics such as mean, variance, spike count, p-value, etc., group size, and outlier evaluation measures.

[0112] Figure 3 An example of data collection is shown. User information is received from a subject provided with a data collection mechanism. Data is received from a subject data collection mechanism. In some specific embodiments, EEG, EOG, pupil dilation, facial emotion coding data, video, images, audio, etc. can be transmitted from the subject to the data analyzer. In certain embodiments, only EEG data is transmitted. According to various embodiments, the response and associated data are transmitted directly from the EEG cap wide area network interface to the data analyzer. In certain embodiments, the response and associated data are transmitted to a computer system, which then performs compression and filtering of the data before transmitting the data to the data analyzer over the network.

[0113] In certain embodiments, the data communication device sends the data to a response integration system. According to various embodiments, the response integration system combines the analyzed and enhanced responses to the stimulus material while using the information about the properties of the stimulus material. In certain embodiments, the response integration system also collects and integrates the user behavioral responses with the analyzed and enhanced response data to more effectively measure and track responses to the stimulus material.

[0114] Although the foregoing invention has been described in detail for purposes of clarity of understanding, it is apparent that certain changes and modifications may be practiced within the scope of the appended claims. Therefore, the embodiments of the present invention should be considered as illustrative rather than restrictive, and the invention is not limited to the details given herein, but may be modified within the scope and equivalents of the appended claims.

[0115] References

[0116] A. Porto, J., L. Nunes, M., & Nelson, CA (2016). Behavioral and neural correlates of emotional development: typically developing infants and infants of depressed and / or anxious mothers. Jornal de Pediatria. https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.jped.2015.12.004

[0117] Addabbo, M., Longhi, E., Marchis, I.C., Tagliabue, P., & Turati, C. (2018). Dynamic facial expressions of emotions are discriminated at birth.PLoSONE. https: / / doi.org / 10.1371 / journal.pone.0193868

[0118] Allen,J.J.B.,Coan,J.A.,&Nazarian,M.(2004).Issues and assumptions onthe road from raw signals to metrics of frontal EEG asymmetry inemotion.Biological Psychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.biopsycho.2004.03.007

[0119] Allen,J.J.B.,Harmon-Jones,E.,&Cavender,J.H.(2001).Manipulation offrontal EEG asymmetry through biofeedback alters self-reported emotionalresponses and facial EMG.Psychophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1017 / S0048577201991255

[0120] Banaschewski,T.,&Brandeis,D.(2007).Annotation:What electrical brainactivity tells us about brain function that other techniques cannot tell us-Achild psychiatric perspective.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry andAllied Disciplines.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / j.1469-7610.2006.01681.x

[0121] Blau,V.C.,Maurer,U.,Tottenham,N.,&McCandliss,B.D.(2007).The face-specific N170 component is modulated by emotional facialexpression.Behavioral and Brain Functions.https: / / doi.org / 10.1186 / 1744-9081-3-7

[0122] Brooker,R.J.,Canen,M.J.,Davidson,R.J.,&Hill Goldsmith,H.(2017).Short-and long-term stability of alpha asymmetry in infants:Baseline and affectivemeasures.Psychophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / psyp.12866

[0123] Calkins,S.D.,Fox,N.A.,&Marshall,T.R.(1996).Behavioral andPhysiological Antecedents of Inhibited and Uninhibited Behavior.ChildDevelopment.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / j.1467-8624.1996.tb01749.x

[0124] Camras,L.A.,Holland,E.A.,&Patterson,M.J.(1993).Facialexpression.Handbook of emotions.

[0125] Cheng,Y.,Lee,S.-Y.,Chen,H.-Y.,Wang,P.-Y.,&Decety,J.(2012).Voice andEmotion Processing in the Human Neonatal Brain.Journal of CognitiveNeuroscience.https: / / doi.org / 10.1162 / jocn_a_00214

[0126] Constant,I.,&Sabourdin,N.(2012).The EEG signal:A window on thecortical brain activity.Paediatric Anaesthesia.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / j.1460-9592.2012.03883.x

[0127] Cuevas,K.,&Bell,M.A.(2011).EEG and ECG from 5 to 10months of age:Developmental changes in baseline activation and cognitive processing duringa working memory task.International Journal of Psychophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.ijpsycho.2011.02.009

[0128] Davidson,R.,&Fox,N.(1982).Asymmetrical brain activity discriminatesbetween positive and negative affective stimuli in humaninfants.Science.https: / / doi.org / 10.1126 / science.7146906

[0129] Davidson,R.J.(1988).EEG measures of cerebral asymmetry:Conceptual andmethodological issues.International Journal of Neuroscience.https: / / doi.org / 10.3109 / 00207458808985694

[0130] Diego,M.A.,Jones,N.A.,&Field,T.(2010).EEG in 1-week,1-month and 3-month-old infants of depressed and non-depressed mothers.BiologicalPsychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.biopsycho.2009.09.007

[0131] Field,T.,Fox,N.A.,Pickens,J.,&Nawrocki,T.(1995).Relative RightFrontal EEG Activation in 3-to 6-Month-Old Infants of“Depressed”Mothers.Developmental Psychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / 0012-1649.31.3.358

[0132] Fox,N.A.,&Davidson,R.J.(1986).Taste-elicited changes in facial signsof emotion and the asymmetry of brain electrical activity in humannewborns.Neuropsychologia.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / 0028-3932(86)90028-X

[0133] Fox,N.A.,&Davidson,R.J.(1988).Patterns of Brain Electrical ActivityDuring Facial Signs of Emotion in 10-Month-Old Infants.DevelopmentalPsychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / 0012-1649.24.2.230

[0134] Fox,N.A.,Yoo,K.H.,Bowman,L.C.,Cannon,E.N.,Ferrari,P.F.,Bakermans-Kranenburg,M.J.,...Van IJzendoorn,M.H.(2016).Assessing human mirror activityWith EEG mu rhythm:A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / bul0000031

[0135] A.,Quintero,L., N.,&Castro,J.(2016).An approach toemotion recognition in single-channel EEG signals:A mother childinteraction.In Journal of Physics:Conference Series.https: / / doi.org / 10.1088 / 1742-6596 / 705 / 1 / 012051

[0136] Harmon-Jones,E.,&Allen,J.J.B.(1997).Behavioral activation sensitivityand resting frontal EEG asymmetry:Covariation of putative indicators relatedto risk for mood disorders.Journal of Abnormal Psychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / 0021-843X.106.1.159

[0137] Howarth,G.Z.,Fettig,N.B.,Curby,T.W.,&Bell,M.A.(2016).FrontalElectroencephalogram Asymmetry and Temperament Across Infancy and EarlyChildhood:An Exploration of Stability and Bidirectional Relations.ChildDevelopment.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / cdev.12466

[0138] Johnson,M.H.,Dziurawiec,S.,Ellis,H.,&Morton,J.(1991).Newborns’preferential tracking of face-like stimuli and its subsequentdecline.Cognition.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / 0010-0277(91)90045-6

[0139] Kaneshige,T.,&Haryu,E.(2015).Categorization and understanding offacial expressions in 4-month-old infants.Japanese PsychologicalResearch.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / jpr.12075

[0140] Krompinger,J.W.,Moser,J.S.,&Simons,R.F.(2008).Modulations of theElectrophysiological Response to Pleasant Stimuli by CognitiveReappraisal.Emotion.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / 1528-3542.8.1.132

[0141] J.M.,&Nelson,C.A.(2009).Tuning the developing brain tosocial signals of emotions.Nature Reviews Neuroscience.https: / / doi.org / 10.1038 / nrn2554

[0142] Lewis,M.,Sullivan,M.W.,Stanger,C.,&Weiss,M.(1989).Self developmentand self-conscious emotions.Child Development.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / j.1467-8624.1989.tb02704.x

[0143] Lusby,C.M.,Goodman,S.H.,Bell,M.A.,&Newport,D.J.(2014).Electroencephalogram patterns in infants of depressed mothers.DevelopmentalPsychobiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1002 / dev.21112

[0144] Mai,X.,Xu,L.,Li,M.,Shao,J.,Zhao,Z.,Lamm,C.,...Lozoff,B.(2014).Soundselicit relative left frontal alpha activity in 2-month-oldinfants.International Journal of Psychophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.ijpsycho.2014.09.008

[0145] Marshall,P.J.,Bar-Haim,Y.,&Fox,N.A.(2002).Development of the EEG from5 months to 4 years of age.Clinical Neurophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / S1388-2457(02)00163-3

[0146] Marshall,P.J.,&Meltzoff,A.N.(2011).Neural mirroring systems:Exploringthe EEG mu rhythm in human infancy.Developmental CognitiveNeuroscience.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.dcn.2010.09.001

[0147] Maulsby,R.L.(1971).An illustration of emotionally evoked theta rhythmin infancy:Hedonic hypersynchrony.Electroencephalography and ClinicalNeurophysiology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / 0013-4694(71)90186-6

[0148] Missana,M.,&Grossmann,T.(2015).Infants’emerging sensitivity toemotional body expressions:Insights from asymmetrical frontal brainactivity.Developmental Psychology.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / a0038469

[0149] Miyoshi,M.,Katayama,J.,&Morotomi,T.(2004).Face-specific N170component is modulated by facial expressional change.NeuroReport.https: / / doi.org / 10.1097 / 00001756-200404090-00035

[0150] Morgane,P.J.,&Mokler,D.J.(2006).The limbic brain:Continuingresolution.Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.neubiorev.2005.04.020

[0151] Nelson,C.A.(2001).The development and neural bases of facerecognition.Infant Child Dev.https: / / doi.org / 10.1002 / icd.239

[0152] Pascalis,O.,De Haan,M.,Nelson,C.A.,&De Schonen,S.(1998).Long-termrecognition memory for faces assessed by visual paired comparison in 3-and 6-month-old infants.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning Memory andCognition.https: / / doi.org / 10.1037 / 0278-7393.24.1.249

[0153] Phillips,A.T.,Wellman,H.M.,&Spelke,E.S.(2002).Infants’ability toconnect gaze and emotional expression to intentionalaction.Cognition.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / S0010-0277(02)00073-2

[0154] Rose,S.A.,Feldman,J.F.,&Jankowski,J.J.(2004).Infant visualrecognition memory.Developmental Review.https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.dr.2003.09.004

[0155] Taylor-Colls,S.,&Pasco Fearon,R.M.(2015).The Effects of ParentalBehavior on Infants’Neural Processing of Emotion Expressions.ChildDevelopment.https: / / doi.org / 10.1111 / cdev.12348

[0156] van den Boomen, C., Munsters, N. M., & Kemner, C. (2017). Emotion processing in the infant brain: The importance of local information. Neuropsychologia. https: / / doi.org / 10.1016 / j.neuropsychologia.2017.09.006

[0157] Izard, C. E., & Malatesta, C. Z. (1987). Perspectives on emotional development I: Differential emotions theory of early emotional development. In J. D. Osofsky (Ed.), Wiley series on personality processes. Handbook of infant development (pp. 494 - 554). Oxford, England: John Wiley & Sons.

[0158] de Haan, M. (2007). Visual attention and recognition memory in infancy. In M. de Haan (Ed.), Studies in developmental psychology. Infant EEG and event - related potentials (pp. 101 - 143). New York, NY, US: Psychology Press.

Claims

1. A device comprising: Electroencephalogram (EEG) EEG ) electrode, the EEG The electrodes are configured to make optimal point contact with the infant or young child's scalp, wherein the EEG One or more of the electrodes are positioned respectively in the frontal, temporal and cranial regions, wherein the electrodes in the frontal region allow assessment of the infant's EEG asymmetry, the electrodes in the temporal region allow exploration of pleasantness-unpleasantness in the auditory domain, and the electrodes in the cranial region allow investigation of attentional engagement with emotional / social speech and body sensory activities.

2. The device of claim 1 further comprising a flexible support structure attached to the electrode.

3. The apparatus of claim 1 further comprising an amplifier associated with the electrodes, wherein data from each of the electrodes is individually amplified and isolated. The apparatus of claim 3 , wherein the amplifier is configured on a flexible printed circuit board.

5. The apparatus of claim 3, wherein the amplifier wirelessly transmits aggregated data to a remote data analyzer.

6. The apparatus of claim 5, wherein the remote data analyzer is configured to determine the effectiveness of the stimulation presented to the infant or the toddler.

7. The apparatus of claim 6, wherein determining the effectiveness of the stimulus presented to the infant or toddler comprises measuring attention, mood, and memory retention.

8. The device of claim 3, wherein the amplified data is EEG Amplified data from multiple other electrodes on the headset are aggregated.

9. Use of the device according to claim 1 for assessing EEG characteristic.

10. The use according to claim 9, wherein the age of the infant is greater than 0 months and less than 12 months.

11. The use according to claim 9, wherein the child is 1 to 3 years old.