A pulse Doppler radar angle measurement method based on amplitude comparison
By establishing an angle deviation table and weighted average method, the error problem of pulsed Doppler radar in target angle measurement is solved, and the measurement accuracy is improved, and it is suitable for multi-frame and adjacent target scenarios.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111605401.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-12-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-12-25
AI Technical Summary
When measuring target angle, pulse Doppler radar has insufficient measurement accuracy due to the distance blind spots of different PRF frames and the errors close to the target, especially when multi-frame detection and adjacent target processing.
By establishing an angle deviation table of the antenna pattern, the precise angle information is calculated based on the target amplitude of the continuous beam scan, and the angle estimation is performed using linear interpolation and weighted average methods to process discontinuous frame and multi-frame detection situations to distinguish adjacent targets. Improve measurement accuracy.
It significantly reduces the error of target angle measurement, improves the angle measurement accuracy of pulsed Doppler radar, and is suitable for measurement scenarios of different angles.
Smart Images

Figure CN114265051B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the field of radar detection, and in particular relates to a pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method. Background Art
[0002] Pulse Doppler radar is an important system of modern radar. It is widely used to detect targets on the ground, at sea, in the air, in space and even underground. It plays an important role in military, remote sensing, air traffic control, ship safety and astronomy. The spatial orientation detection of the target of interest is one of the important tasks of pulse Doppler radar. The commonly used methods include beam switching technology, single pulse technology, centroid method (amplitude weighting), etc. In the radar search mode, the centroid method is a commonly used angle measurement method. When a target is detected by multiple continuous beams (multiple frames), the angles of the multiple frames are weighted according to the amplitude of the detected target, so that a more accurate angle of the target can be obtained. However, in order to improve the detection power, pulse Doppler radar is often designed as a multi-pulse repetition frequency (PRF) mode. Frames with different PRFs have different distance blind spots, which means that the target may not be observed by continuous frames. At this time, if the centroid method is used for measurement, it may cause large errors. In addition, when two targets are close in distance and orientation, the angle measurement using the centroid method will also have large errors. Therefore, for different angle measurement problems in pulse Doppler radar applications, different methods or strategies need to be used to further improve the angle measurement accuracy. Summary of the invention
[0003] In view of the above problems, the present invention proposes a pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method to improve the measurement accuracy of the target angle. According to the antenna gain pattern, the target has different amplitudes in different directions of the main lobe. Therefore, according to the target amplitude obtained by continuous beam scanning, the precise angle information of the target can be specifically analyzed. Specifically:
[0004] Step 1: Create an angle deviation table. First, establish the precise correspondence between the angle deviation of the antenna and the corresponding antenna direction amplitude gain ratio, and build a table. The specific method is as follows:
[0005] (1): Assume that the one-dimensional directional amplitude gain of the radar antenna is G(θ), where θ is the angle in this dimension and the 3dB beam width is θ B Assume that the radar uses a uniform frame angle interval, denoted by θ d .
[0006] (2): In the main lobe βθ B Within the width range, β>0, a table is established that corresponds to the angle and amplitude. Assume that the number of angle points in the table is I, and let i=0,1,…,I-1, then for the angle q(i)=-βθ B / 2 + iβθ B / (I - 1), calculate the corresponding gain ratio p(i) respectively:
[0007] p(i) = G(q(i) + θ d / 2) / G(q(i) - θ d / 2) (1);
[0008] (3): Let p = [p(0), p(1), …, p(I - 1)] T and q = [q(0), q(1), …, q(I - 1)] T , make the amplitude p and the angle deviation q correspond one by one, form an angle deviation table and store it for subsequent use.
[0009] Step 2: Angle calculation method, Figure 1 shows a schematic diagram of amplitude comparison for angle measurement. According to the amplitudes of the target detected in two frames, calculate the amplitude ratio, and then according to the previously established angle deviation table, find the angle deviation corresponding to this amplitude ratio. Finally, estimate the true angle of the target based on the angle deviation. The specific method is as follows:
[0010] (4): Assume that the radar detects a target in two consecutive frames (denote the true angle as θ T ), and its frame angles are θ1 and θ1 + θ d , and the amplitudes are denoted as A1 and A2 respectively. Calculate the amplitude ratio
[0011]
[0012] (5): Load the angle deviation table stored in Content 1. According to the value, select the two closest values in p, denoted as p(i1) and p(i2) respectively, where i1 < i2, and at the same time record the corresponding frequency deviations, denoted as q(i1) and q(i2) respectively.
[0013] (6): Estimate the angle deviation by linear interpolation:
[0014]
[0015] Furthermore, perform deviation compensation based on the first frame angle, and the estimated target angle can be obtained:
[0016]
[0017] Furthermore, (7): Processing for targets detected in discontinuous frames. Since different frames of a pulsed Doppler radar have different range blind zones, there are often cases where targets are detected in discontinuous frames. For two discontinuous frames, the angle interval θ in Content 1 dIncrease to the angle interval between the two frames, build a table, and the θ in the angle measurement method d Also carry out corresponding processing.
[0018] Furthermore, (8): Processing of targets detected in multiple frames. Collect the multiple frames of data in which the target is detected and process them together. Assume that the target is detected by K frames, and the corresponding frame angles are θ1, θ2, …, θ K , the amplitudes are recorded as A1, A2, ..., A K .
[0019] Separate order
[0020]
[0021] In the formula, k=1,2,…,K-1. Use the corresponding angle deviation table to measure the angles, and record the measurement results as φ1, φ2, …, φ K , and then taking the weighted sum to get the estimate of the target angle:
[0022]
[0023] In the formula, α1, α2, …, α K ≥0 is the weight coefficient.
[0024] For the weight coefficient, a relatively simple choice is average weighting, and another option is to weight according to the measurement accuracy, assigning a larger weight to the estimator with higher theoretical accuracy. Assume that the measurement results φ1, φ2, …, φ K The precisions are r1, r2, …, r K (unit °), a method based on the weight of accuracy is to let The estimated result is
[0025]
[0026] Assume φ1, φ2, …, φ K If they are independent of each other, the accuracy of the angle estimate is
[0027]
[0028] Furthermore, (9): Processing of angularly adjacent targets. When two targets are close in angle, the amplitude measured in the frame between the two target angles is no longer considered as the amplitude of one target. At this time, selecting the "outer" target data for angle measurement can obtain a more accurate solution. A method is proposed to distinguish whether two measured values φ1 and φ2 are the same target. The precision corresponding to the measured values φ1 and φ2 is r1 and r2 respectively, and the precision of calculating φ1-φ2 is
[0029]
[0030] If the following conditions are met:
[0031]
[0032] In the formula, η>0, that is, when the absolute difference between φ1 and φ2 is within η times the measured accuracy r, it is considered that the measured values φ1 and φ2 belong to the same target. Then it is the estimated value of the angle of this target, otherwise the measured values φ1 and φ2 do not belong to the same target and cannot be processed together. Generally speaking, the commonly used value can be η = 3. Using the above method, the adjacent measured values are processed separately, and the measured values belonging to the two targets can be obtained. The measured values belonging to the same target are processed according to the method in step 8 to obtain the angle estimation of the target.
[0033] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:
[0034] The present invention establishes a table with accurate one-to-one correspondence between the ratio of target amplitude and the angle deviation, and proposes a method for table lookup angle calculation. Corresponding strategies are proposed for common problems in applications, which can obtain smaller errors and improve the angle measurement accuracy of pulse Doppler radar. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0035] Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the principle of angle measurement by amplitude ratio
[0036] Figure 2 For example, the radar antenna pattern
[0037] Figure 3 Schematic diagram of table content for example 1
[0038] Figure 4 Schematic diagram of angle measurement accuracy for example 2
[0039] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the angle and amplitude measured for the target in Example 2 DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0040] The present invention will be described in further detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0041] Example 1: Create and store an angle deviation table, see Figure 2 and 3 .
[0042] (1) Assume a pulse Doppler radar, using M = 100 uniform linear array electronically scanned antenna, array element spacing d = λ / 2, λ is the wavelength of its radiated signal. Its directional power gain after windowing is
[0043]
[0044] Where j is the imaginary unit and W(m) is the window function. In this example, a Hamming window is used. The antenna pattern is shown in Figure 1 , the 3dB beam width can be measured to be approximately θ B =1.5°.
[0045] (2) Assume that the radar frame angle interval is θ d =0.3°, the number of points to establish the table is I=61. Take β=2, and establish the table in the range of 2 times the beam width at the center of the main lobe. Let i=0,1,…,I-1 respectively, then for q(i)=-βθ B / 2+iβθ B / (I-1), calculate the corresponding gain ratio:
[0046] p(i)=G(q(i)+θ d / 2) / G(q(i)-θ d / 2) (12)
[0047] (3) Let p = [p(0), p(1), …, p(I-1)] T and q=[q(0),q(1),…,q(I-1)] T , p and q are matched one by one, and an angle deviation table is made and stored. The specific content is shown in Table 1.
[0048] (4) Similarly, set θ d =0.6° and θ d =0.9° again to create a table and store it, see Table 2 and Table 3 for details. Figure 3 The contents of Tables 1 to 3 are shown.
[0049] Table 1 61-point angle deviation table with interval of 0.3°
[0050]
[0051] Table 2 61-point angle deviation table with interval of 0.6°
[0052]
[0053]
[0054] Table 3 61-point angle deviation table with interval of 0.9°
[0055]
[0056]
[0057] Example 2: Multi-frame single target angle measurement example, see Figure 4 and 5 .
[0058] (1) Using the radar in Example 1, for convenience, assume that the angle of a target is 0°. Assume that the target is detected in 3 frames, and its angles θ1, θ2, θ3 are -0.65, -0.35, 0.25, respectively, and its amplitudes A1, A2, A3 are 42.5598, 49.4899, 51.1301, respectively.
[0059] (2) Calculate the amplitude ratio respectively:
[0060]
[0061]
[0062]
[0063] for Since the angular interval between θ1 and θ2 is 0.3°, the angle deviation table in Table 1 can be loaded and the distance can be quickly obtained by binary search. The two closest values are p(n1) = 1.1790 and p(n2) = 1.1569, and the corresponding angle deviations are q(n1) = -0.45 and q(n2) = -0.4. From formula (3), the angle deviation is
[0064]
[0065] Thus, The estimated angle is
[0066]
[0067] Similarly, using the angle deviation table in Table 2, we can find The corresponding angular deviation is Angle estimation φ2 = -0.0012, using the angle deviation table in Table 3, we can find The corresponding angular deviation is Angle estimate φ3 = -0.0296.
[0068] (3) Using the average weighted strategy in step 8, let the weight coefficients all be 1, then the target angle estimate is
[0069]
[0070] It can be seen that the absolute error between the estimated value and the true value of the target angle is 0.0379°.
[0071] (4) If the precision-weighted strategy in step 8 is used, the precision of the angle measurement is first estimated based on the signal-to-noise ratio. Figure 4The following figure shows the angle measurement accuracy curve estimated by Monte Carlo method when the signal-to-noise ratio after target pulse compression is 20dB. Using this accuracy curve, we can find The corresponding accuracies are approximately 0.0335°, 0.0177° and 0.0124°. Using the strategy of formula (7) and weighting by accuracy, we can get
[0072]
[0073] It can be seen that the absolute error between the estimated value and the true value of the target angle is 0.0255°, which is smaller than the average weighted error.
[0074] Example 3: Angle measurement of two adjacent targets
[0075] (1) Using the radar in Example 1, assume that the angle of one target is -2° and the angle of the other target is 0°. Assume that there are a total of 12 frames observing these two targets, and their frame angles and amplitudes are shown in Table 4 and Figure 5 .
[0076] Table 4 Target detection angle and amplitude
[0077]
[0078] (2) According to the strategy of step 9, the angles of each pair of adjacent angles are estimated according to the amplitude ratio using the method of content 2. The results are -2.0256°, -1.9337°, -1.7729°, -1.6207°, -1.3129°, -0.9974°, -0.6859°, -0.4002°, -0.2316°, -0.0711°, and 0.0131°, respectively. According to the accuracy curve of example 2, the accuracy of the results is approximately 0.0357°, 0.0341°, 0.0332°, 0.0334°, 0.0334°, 0.0334°, 0.0334°, 0.0334°, 0.0329°, 0.0339°, and 0.0357°.
[0079] (3) For each pair of adjacent angle measurements, the absolute values of the angle differences are calculated to be 0.0920°, 0.1608°, 0.1522°, 0.3078°, 0.3155°, 0.3155°, 0.2857°, 0.1686°, 0.1605°, and 0.0842°, respectively. The accuracy of the angle differences calculated according to formula (9) is 0.0494°, 0.0476°, and 0.0471°, respectively. , 0.0473°, 0.0473°, 0.0473°, 0.0473°, 0.0469°, 0.0473°, and 0.0493°. The ratios of the calculated angle difference absolute value and the angle difference accuracy are 1.8630, 3.3795, 3.2308, 6.5100, 6.6743, 6.5880, 6.0438, 3.5950, 3.3960, and 1.7084, respectively.
[0080] (4) In this example, η=3 is selected, and only the ratio of the first to the last value satisfies the condition (10). Therefore, the first two frames are selected to estimate the angle of the first target. According to the precision weighting in step 8, the result is -1.9775°, which is 0.0225° compared with the true value of -2°. Similarly, the last two frames are selected to estimate the angle of the second target. The result weighted by precision is -0.0312°, and the absolute error is 0.0312°.
[0081] The present invention is not limited to the above specific implementations, and the present invention may have various modifications and variations. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made to the above implementations based on the technical essence of the present invention shall be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method, characterized in that: Step 1: Create an angle deviation table, and create a table showing the relationship between the antenna angle deviation and the corresponding antenna direction amplitude gain ratio: (1): Assume that the one-dimensional directional amplitude gain of the radar antenna is G(θ), where θ is the angle in the one-dimensional direction and the 3dB beam width is θ B , the radar uses a uniform frame angle interval denoted as θ d ; (2): In the main lobe βθ B Within the width range, β>0, a table is established that corresponds to the angle and amplitude. Assume that the number of angle points in the table is I, let i=0,1,…,I-1, then for the angle q(i)=-βθ B / 2+iβθ B / (I-1), calculate the corresponding gain ratio p(i), p(i)=G(q(i)+θ d / 2) / G(q(i)-θ d / 2) (1); (3): Let p = [p(0), p(1), …, p(I-1)] T and q=[q(0),q(1),…,q(I-1)] T , the amplitude p and the angle deviation q are matched one by one, and an angle deviation table is prepared and stored; Step 2: Angle calculation: Calculate the amplitude ratio of the target detected in the two frames, then find the angle deviation corresponding to the amplitude ratio according to the established angle deviation table, and finally estimate the true angle of the target based on the angle deviation: (4): Assume that the radar detects a target in two consecutive frames, and the true angle is θ T , whose frame angles are θ1 and θ1+θ respectively d , the amplitudes are recorded as A1 and A2 respectively, then the amplitude ratio is: (5): Based on the angle deviation table, according to the value, select the two closest values in p, denoted as p(i1) and p(i2) respectively, where i1 < i2, and at the same time record the corresponding frequency deviations, denoted as q(i1) and q(i2) respectively; (6): Estimate the angle deviation by linear interpolation: Then, the deviation is compensated according to the angle of the first frame to obtain the estimated value of the target angle:
2. A pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: Since different frames of the pulse Doppler radar have different distance blind spots, there are situations where discontinuous frames detect targets. For two discontinuous frames, the frame angle interval θ d Increase the angle interval between the two frames to create the table.
3. A pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: For targets detected in multiple frames, the multi-frame data of the detected target are collected together for processing. Assuming that the target is detected by K frames, the corresponding frame angles are θ1, θ2, …, θ K , the amplitudes are recorded as A1, A2, ..., A K , then the amplitude ratio is: In the formula, k=1,2,…,K-1, respectively Use the corresponding angle deviation table to measure the angles, and record the measurement results as φ1, φ2, …, φ K , and then taking the weighted sum to get the estimated value of the target angle: In the formula, α1, α2, …, α K ≥0 is the weight coefficient.
4. A pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method as claimed in claim 3, characterized in that: When weighting according to measurement accuracy, a larger weight is assigned to the estimator with higher theoretical accuracy. Assuming that the measurement results φ1, φ2, …, φ K The precisions are r1, r2, …, r K ,make The estimated result is: Assume φ1, φ2, …, φ K If they are independent of each other, the accuracy of the angle estimate is 5. A pulse Doppler radar amplitude ratio angle measurement method as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that: When the two targets are close in angle, the measured values are recorded as φ1 and φ2, and the corresponding accuracies are r1 and r2 respectively. The accuracy of calculating φ1-φ2 is: If the following conditions are met: In the formula, η>0, that is, when the absolute difference between φ1 and φ2 is within η times the measured accuracy r, it is considered that the measured values φ1 and φ2 belong to the same target. It is the estimated value of the target angle, otherwise the measured values φ1 and φ2 do not belong to the same target.
