A method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on autoradiography film

By using autoradiodevelopment film and Monte Carlo simulation in proton heavy ion therapy, the film gray value is calculated by least squares method, which solves the problems of low spatial resolution and quenching effects in the prior art, and achieves high resolution Proton heavy ion dose verification and LET distribution measurement improve the accuracy of treatment plans.

CN115317808BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-19INST OF MODERN PHYSICS CHINESE ACADEMY OF SCI
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210936625.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-08-05
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2042-08-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing proton heavy ion therapeutic dose verification methods cannot achieve high spatial resolution, and the response sensitivity of the autoradiode film in the LET region with high energy transfer line density is reduced, resulting in a quenching effect and the inability to effectively measure the proton heavy ion dose distribution.

Method used

Proton heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification is achieved by using autoradiode film, combined with Monte Carlo simulation and least squares method, the film grayscale value is calculated to obtain the absorbed dose and compared with the dose calculated by the planned system.

Benefits of technology

The dose distribution information acquisition with a spatial resolution of less than 1 mm is achieved, and the LET and dose distribution can be obtained simultaneously, which is used to evaluate the therapeutic efficacy and judge the accuracy of dose verification through the gamma pass rate.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN115317808B_ABST
    Figure CN115317808B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method for realizing proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on autoradiographic film, comprising the following steps: using different energy transfer linear energy density LET beams to perform dose calibration on autoradiographic film to obtain a dose calibration curve; preparing a dose verification plan, setting a dose control standard, and irradiating the autoradiographic film with a proton beam or a heavy ion beam according to the prepared dose verification plan; reading out the gray value of the autoradiographic film after irradiation, using the dose calibration curve to obtain the dose measured by the autoradiographic film after irradiation; comparing and analyzing the dose measured by the autoradiographic film after irradiation with the dose calculated by the planning system, and completing the verification of the treatment plan dose. The present invention is based on an algorithm that can calculate the absorbed dose of the irradiation from the gray value of the film, and compare it with the dose calculated by the planning system, thereby realizing heavy ion dose verification.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of quality assurance and quality control of proton and heavy ion radiotherapy, and in particular to a method for realizing proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on radioautographic film. Background Art

[0002] In recent years, proton and heavy ion therapy has become more and more widespread. Compared with traditional photon therapy, proton and heavy ion therapy has biological and physical advantages, and its dose verification is a very important quality control content in clinical practice. Previous dose verification methods mainly used multiple sharp point ionization chamber arrays or two-dimensional ionization chamber matrices to measure dose distribution, but the dose distribution of proton and heavy ion therapy varies greatly in space, so previous measurement equipment cannot achieve high spatial resolution. The spatial resolution of multiple sharp point ionization chambers is 10mm, and the minimum spatial resolution of the two-dimensional ionization chamber matrix is ​​5mm. Therefore, the use of radioautographic film can achieve a spatial resolution of less than 1mm. In addition, when the sharp point ionization chamber array is placed in the radiation field, it will disturb the radiation field, and this disturbance will introduce certain errors. The radioautographic film is considered to be water equivalent. When placed in a water phantom (or solid water phantom) for dose measurement, it will not disturb the radiation field, so it will not introduce corresponding measurement errors.

[0003] Radiation autoradiographic film is a thin film with organic molecules as photosensitive materials. After being irradiated, the organic molecules aggregate into larger molecules and appear as color changes on a macro scale. When scanned in transmission mode using a film scanner, it will cause changes in the transmitted light density, and the magnitude of the light density change can reflect the size of the irradiation dose. The size of the radiation-sensitive photosensitive organic molecules is about a few microns, and the macroscopic light density changes they produce can distinguish changes of hundreds of microns. Therefore, the film can provide a dose distribution with a spatial resolution of hundreds of microns.

[0004] Autoradiographic films have been widely used in dose verification of photon radiotherapy. However, when using autoradiographic films to measure heavy ion doses, the response of the film shows reduced sensitivity in the high energy transfer line density LET region, that is, the measured dose is lower than the actual irradiation dose. This phenomenon is called the quenching effect or local saturation effect. The reduced sensitivity manifested by the quenching effect varies with the LET of the proton and heavy ion beams, and cannot be corrected by a constant or a simple formula. Therefore, there is currently no method to correct the reduced sensitivity of the film detector caused by the quenching effect. Therefore, there is no way to use film to measure the dose distribution of protons and heavy ions. Summary of the invention

[0005] In response to the above problems, the purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on radiation autoradiography film. Through an algorithm, the absorbed dose of the film can be calculated from the grayscale value of the film and compared with the dose calculated by the planning system, thereby realizing heavy ion dose verification.

[0006] To achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions:

[0007] The method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on radioautographic film of the present invention comprises the following steps:

[0008] The dose calibration of the radioautographic film was carried out using different LET beam currents to obtain the dose calibration curve.

[0009] Prepare the dose verification plan, set the dose control standard, and irradiate the autoradiographic film with a proton beam or a heavy ion beam according to the prepared dose verification plan;

[0010] Read out the grayscale value of the irradiated autoradiographic film, and use the dose calibration curve to obtain the dose measured by the irradiated autoradiographic film;

[0011] The dose measured on the radiation autoradiography film after irradiation is compared and analyzed with the dose calculated by the planning system to complete the verification of the treatment plan dose.

[0012] In the method, preferably, the step of performing dose calibration on the autoradiographic film comprises the following steps:

[0013] A1) Select a monoenergetic beam and use Monte Carlo simulation to simulate the distribution curve of LET versus depth and the distribution curve of dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam; use a three-dimensional water tank to measure the distribution curve of dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam in water, and compare it with the distribution curve obtained by Monte Carlo simulation. If the dose curve has deviation, adjust the simulation parameters and re-simulate until the distribution curve of dose versus depth coincides with the measured distribution curve of dose versus depth. Read out the depths corresponding to n typical LET values ​​on the distribution curve of LET versus depth obtained by Monte Carlo simulation, which are d1, d2, ..., dn respectively;

[0014] A2) At each measurement depth, use i gradient doses to irradiate the radiographic film for exposure. Before irradiation, use a dosimeter and an ionization chamber to calibrate the dose according to the dose measurement procedure;

[0015] A3) After irradiation for a preset time, the autoradiographic film is scanned using a scanner, the red channel pixel values ​​are extracted for data analysis, and the net optical density value netOD of the autoradiographic film is calculated using formula (1):

[0016]

[0017] In the formula, PV unexp and PV exp are the pixel values ​​of the unexposed and exposed autoradiographic films, respectively; PV bckg is the pixel value of black opaque cardboard;

[0018] A4) The relationship between net optical density and dose is:

[0019] Dose=α LET netOD+β LET ·netOD 2 (2)

[0020] In the formula, netOD is the net optical density; Dose is the dose; α LET , β LET are the coefficients of the linear and quadratic terms, respectively, and are functions of LET;

[0021] A5) Determine the coefficient α using the least squares method LET and β LET , to best fit the measured data of each LET;

[0022] A6)α LET Relationship with LET, β LET The relationship with LET is expressed using the following formula:

[0023] α LET =a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α (3)

[0024] β LET =a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β (4)

[0025] In the formula, a α 、b α 、c α is α LET The fitting parameter, a β 、b β 、c β β LET The fitting parameters of ; LET is the linear energy transfer density of the measurement point;

[0026] A7) Use the least squares method again, α LET The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (3)α 、b α 、c α and β LET The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (4) β 、b β 、c β .

[0027] The method, preferably, the preparation of the dose verification plan comprises the following steps:

[0028] B1) Import the plan designed by the planning system into the verification phantom and determine the dose distribution;

[0029] B2) Derive the dose distribution for the slice of interest and note the depth of that slice.

[0030] In the method, preferably, the irradiating the autoradiographic film comprises the following steps:

[0031] C1) Two irradiation methods are used, the first one is based on the dose calculated by the planning system. x Irradiate once, and irradiate for the second time at n times the dose calculated by the planning system, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 2, and the dose after irradiation is n*Dose x , the irradiation depth is the depth determined in step B2);

[0032] C2) Process the autoradiographic film according to the method in step A3) and calculate netOD according to formula (1) x and netOD nx , the netOD obtained here x and netOD nx All are two-dimensional distributions;

[0033] C3) The relationship between the dose and the net optical density is as follows:

[0034] Dose x =α LET ·netOD x +β LET ·netOD x 2 (5)

[0035] n*Dose x =α LET ·netOD nx +β LET ·netOD nx 2 (6)

[0036] C4) Substitute α in equations (5) and (6) LETand β LET Substitute into equations (3) and (4), and then eliminate Dose from equations (5) and (6): x , we get the quadratic equation containing only the LET variable, which is:

[0037] 0=(a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α )(n·netOD x -netOD nx )+(a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β )(n·netOD x 2 -netOD nx 2 ) (7)

[0038] C5) Solve equation (7) and take the positive value obtained as the correct solution;

[0039] C6) Substitute the determined LET into formulas (3) and (4) to determine the parameter α LET and β LET ;

[0040] C7) Substitute the netOD value of the first irradiation into formula (2) to calculate the dose distribution Dose value.

[0041] The method, preferably, the comparison and analysis of the dose measured from the radiation autoradiographic film after irradiation with the dose calculated by the planning system to complete the verification of the treatment plan dose includes the following steps:

[0042] D1) comparing the dose distribution determined in step B2) with the dose distribution calculated in step C7);

[0043] D2) Use the gamma pass rate to compare the results and determine whether the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement. If the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement, the verified plan can be used for treatment, otherwise it cannot be used for treatment.

[0044] The present invention adopts the above technical solution, which has the following advantages:

[0045] (1) The present invention can realize film as a two-dimensional detector for proton and heavy ion therapy dose verification, providing dose distribution information with a spatial resolution of less than 1 mm.

[0046] (2) The present invention can simultaneously obtain the distribution of LET and dose, and the dose distribution can be used for dose verification. The two-dimensional LET distribution information is also information of clinical concern and can be used to evaluate the therapeutic efficacy. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0047] Various other advantages and benefits will become apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art by reading the detailed description of the preferred embodiments below. The accompanying drawings are only for the purpose of illustrating the preferred embodiments and are not to be considered as limiting the present invention. Throughout the accompanying drawings, the same reference numerals are used to represent the same components. In the accompanying drawings:

[0048] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0049] The exemplary embodiments of the present invention will be described in more detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Although the exemplary embodiments of the present invention are shown in the accompanying drawings, it should be understood that the present invention can be implemented in various forms and should not be limited by the embodiments described herein. On the contrary, these embodiments are provided in order to enable a more thorough understanding of the present invention and to fully convey the scope of the present invention to those skilled in the art.

[0050] The present invention provides a method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on radioautographic film. Dose verification of proton and heavy ion therapy is a very important clinical quality control procedure. Currently, commonly used verification technologies mainly use a sharp point ionization chamber array or a two-dimensional ionization chamber matrix. The resolutions of these two devices are 10 mm and 5 mm, respectively. The gradient variation of proton and heavy ion doses is very large, and a dose verification device with a spatial resolution of less than 1 mm is required. As a two-dimensional detector, film can provide a spatial resolution of less than 1 mm. However, when using film to measure the heavy ion dose, due to the quenching effect, a unique dose cannot be obtained from the film grayscale. The present invention uses an algorithm to calculate the absorbed dose of the irradiation from the film grayscale value, and compare it with the dose calculated by the planning system, thereby realizing heavy ion dose verification.

[0051] Embodiment 1:

[0052] like Figure 1 As shown, the method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on radioautographic film provided by the present invention comprises the following steps:

[0053] 1) Using different linear energy density (LET) beams to calibrate the dose of the radiographic film and obtain a dose calibration curve;

[0054] A1) Select a film scale depth of 4 LET, select a monoenergetic beam, such as a monoenergetic beam of 260 MeV / u, and use Monte Carlo simulation to simulate the distribution curve of LET versus depth and the distribution curve of dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam; use a three-dimensional water tank to measure the distribution curve of dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam in water, and compare it with the Monte Carlo simulation. If the dose curve has deviations, adjust the simulation parameters and re-simulate until the distribution curve of Dose versus depth coincides with the measured distribution curve of Dose versus depth. At this time, read the depths corresponding to the four LET values ​​of 20, 50, 100 and 150 keV / μm on the Monte Carlo simulated LET versus depth curve as 113.1, 149.0, 153.0 and 153.6 mm respectively;

[0055] A2) At each measurement depth, eight doses were used to irradiate the film, namely, 0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, and 5.0 Gy. Before irradiation, the dose was calibrated using a dosimeter and an ionization chamber using the dose measurement procedure specified in IAEA Report No. 398.

[0056] A3) 24 hours after irradiation, the film was scanned using an Epson 12000XL scanner with a resolution of 150 dpi and saved as a 48-bit RGB tiff format file. The red channel pixel value PV was extracted for data analysis, and the net optical density value netOD of the film was calculated using formula (1):

[0057]

[0058] In the formula, PV unexp and PV exp are the pixel values ​​of the unexposed and exposed films respectively; PV bckg is the pixel value of black opaque cardboard;

[0059] A4) The relationship between net optical density and dose is:

[0060] Dose=α LET netOD+β LET ·netOD 2 (2)

[0061] Where netOD is the net optical density, α LET , β LET are the coefficients of the linear and quadratic terms, respectively, and are functions of LET.

[0062] A5) Determine the coefficient α using the least squares method LET and β LET, to best fit the measured data for each LET. Using the Dose data and the netOD corresponding to each LET value, a total of 4 fits were performed to obtain α 20 , β 20 ; α 50 , β 50 ; α 100 , β 100 ; α 200 , β 200 .

[0063] A6)α LET Relationship with LET, β LET The relationship with LET is expressed using the following formula:

[0064] α LET =a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α (3)

[0065] β LET =a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β (4)

[0066] A7) Use the least squares method again, α 20 , α 50 , α 100 , α 200 The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (3) α 、b α 、c α and β 20 , β 50 , β 100 , β 200 The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (4) β 、b β 、c β .

[0067] 2) Prepare a dose verification plan, set dose control standards, and irradiate the autoradiographic film with a proton beam or a heavy ion beam according to the prepared dose verification plan;

[0068] Preparation of the dose verification plan includes:

[0069] B1) Import the plan designed by the planning system into the verification phantom and determine the dose distribution;

[0070] B2) Derive the dose distribution for the slice of interest and note the depth of that slice.

[0071] The irradiation of the autoradiographic film includes:

[0072] C1) Two irradiation methods are used, the first one is based on the dose calculated by the planning system. x Irradiate once, and the second irradiation is twice the dose calculated by the planning system, that is, the dose is 2*Dose x , the irradiation depth is the depth determined by B2);

[0073] C2) Process the film according to the method in step A3) and calculate netOD according to formula (1) x and netOD nx , which is different from step A3), in which the pixel values ​​of a region in the center of the film are averaged to a fixed value, while the netOD obtained here is x and netOD nx All are two-dimensional distributions;

[0074] C3) The relationship between dose and net optical density is as follows:

[0075] Dose x =α LET ·netOD x +β LET ·netOD x 2 (5)

[0076] n*Dose x =α LET ·netOD nx +β LET ·netOD nx 2 (6)

[0077] C4) Substitute α in equations (5) and (6) LET and β LET Substitute into equations (3) and (4). Then eliminate Dose from equations (5) and (6) x , we get the quadratic equation containing only the LET variable, which is:

[0078] 0=(a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α )(n·netOD x -netOD nx )+(a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β )(n·netODx 2 -netOD nx 2 ) (7)

[0079] C5) Solve this quadratic equation. The equation has two solutions. One solution is a negative value, which is unrealistic for LET. Therefore, the positive value is the only correct solution. At this time, we get a two-dimensional distribution of LET values.

[0080] C6) Substitute the determined LET into formulas (3) and (4) to determine the parameter α LET and β LET , (parameter α LET and β LET also refers to a two-dimensional distribution);

[0081] C7) Substituting the netOD value of the first irradiation into equation (2), the two-dimensional distribution of Dose value can be calculated.

[0082] It should be noted that, starting from step B2), all the following operations are two-dimensional distribution operations, which are mathematically represented as matrix operations. The results can be easily calculated using the matrix operation method in the Matlab program.

[0083] 3) reading the grayscale value of the irradiated autoradiographic film and using the dose calibration curve to obtain the dose measured by the irradiated autoradiographic film;

[0084] 4) Compare and analyze the dose measured by the radiation autoradiography film after irradiation with the dose calculated by the planning system to complete the verification of the treatment plan dose:

[0085] D1) comparing the dose distribution determined in step B2) with the dose distribution calculated in step C7);

[0086] D2) Use the gamma pass rate to compare the results and determine whether the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement. If the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement, the verified plan can be used for treatment, otherwise it cannot be used for treatment.

[0087] It should be noted that in step B2), only a two-dimensional dose distribution of a layer of interest is derived. A three-dimensional dose distribution can also be derived and reconstructed through dose measurements at multiple layers, and the three-dimensional dose verification can be achieved using the three-dimensional gamma pass rate.

[0088] The so-called gamma pass rate is a dose comparison method widely used in radiotherapy dose verification. Two two-dimensional or three-dimensional dose distribution maps are superimposed together, and the gamma factor at each pixel is calculated. If the gamma factor is less than 1, the point is considered to have passed the dose verification. The product of the percentage of all passing points to all points is the gamma pass rate. It is generally believed that the gamma pass rate should be greater than 95%.

[0089] The radiation autoradiographic film used in the present invention is GAFchromic produced by Ashland ISP Company of the United States. TM Film, models include EBT series (including EBT, EBT2, EBT3, etc.) and HD series (including HD, HD-V2). Its photosensitive particles are LiPCDA crystals, which will aggregate into larger molecules after being irradiated.

[0090] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or make equivalent replacements for some of the technical features therein. However, these modifications or replacements do not deviate the essence of the corresponding technical solutions from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for proton and heavy ion radiotherapy dose verification based on autoradiographic film, characterized in that: The steps include: The dose calibration of the radioautographic film was carried out using different LET beam currents to obtain the dose calibration curve. Prepare the dose verification plan, set the dose control standard, and irradiate the autoradiographic film with a proton beam or a heavy ion beam according to the prepared dose verification plan; Read out the grayscale value of the irradiated autoradiographic film, and use the dose calibration curve to obtain the dose measured by the irradiated autoradiographic film; Compare and analyze the dose measured by the radiation autoradiography film after irradiation with the dose calculated by the planning system to complete the verification of the treatment plan dose; The step of performing dose calibration on the radiographic film comprises the following steps: A1) Select a monoenergetic beam and use Monte Carlo simulation to simulate the distribution curve of LET versus depth and the distribution curve of dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam; use a three-dimensional water tank to measure the distribution curve of dose Dose versus depth of the monoenergetic beam in water, and compare it with the distribution curve obtained by Monte Carlo simulation. If the dose curve has deviation, adjust the simulation parameters and re-simulate until the distribution curve of Dose versus depth coincides with the measured distribution curve of Dose versus depth. Read out the depths corresponding to n typical LET values ​​on the distribution curve of LET versus depth obtained by Monte Carlo simulation, which are d1, d2, ..., dn respectively; A2) At each measurement depth, use i gradient doses to irradiate the radiographic film for exposure. Before irradiation, use a dosimeter and an ionization chamber to calibrate the dose according to the dose measurement procedure; A3) After irradiation for a preset time, the autoradiographic film is scanned using a scanner, the red channel pixel values ​​are extracted for data analysis, and the net optical density value netOD of the autoradiographic film is calculated using formula (1): Where, PV unexp and PV exp are the pixel values ​​of the unexposed and exposed autoradiographic films, respectively; PV bckg is the pixel value of black opaque cardboard; A4) The relationship between net optical density and dose is: Can LET netOD+β LET netOD 2 (2) In the formula, netOD is the net optical density; Dose is the dose; α LET , β LET are the coefficients of the linear and quadratic terms, respectively, and are functions of LET; A5) Determine the coefficient α using the least squares method LET and β LET , to best fit the measured data of each LET; A6)α LET Relationship with LET, β LET The relationship with LET is expressed using the following formula: α LET =a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α (3) β LET =a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β (4) In the formula, a α , b α 、c α is α LET The fitting parameter, a β , b β 、c β β LET The fitting parameters of ; LET is the linear energy transfer density of the measurement point; A7) Use the least squares method again, α LET The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (3) α , b α 、c α and β LET The parameter a is fitted with LET by formula (4) β , b β 、c β .

2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The preparation of the dose verification plan includes the following steps: B1) Import the plan designed by the planning system into the verification phantom and determine the dose distribution; B2) Derive the dose distribution for the slice of interest and note the depth of that slice.

3. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that The irradiation of the autoradiographic film comprises the following steps: C1) Two irradiation methods are used, the first one is based on the dose calculated by the planning system. x Irradiate once, and irradiate for the second time at n times the dose calculated by the planning system, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 2, and the dose after irradiation is n*Dose x , the irradiation depth is the depth determined in step B2); C2) Process the autoradiographic film according to the method in step A3) and calculate netOD according to formula (1) x and netOD nx , the netOD obtained here x and netOD nx All are two-dimensional distributions; C3) The relationship between the dose and the net optical density is as follows: can x =a LET netOD x +β LET netOD x 2 (5) n*Dose x =a LET ·netOD nx +b LET ·netOD nx 2 (6) C4) Substitute α in equations (5) and (6) LET and β LET Substitute into equations (3) and (4), and then eliminate Dose from equations (5) and (6): x , we get the quadratic equation containing only the LET variable, which is: 0=(a α ·LET 2 +b α ·LET+c α )(n·netOD x -netOD nx )+(a β ·LET 2 +b β ·LET+c β )(n·netOD x 2 -netOD nx 2 ) (7) C5) Solve equation (7) and take the positive value obtained as the correct solution; C6) Substitute the determined LET into formulas (3) and (4) to determine the parameter α LET and β LET ; C7) Substitute the netOD value of the first irradiation into formula (2) to calculate the dose distribution Dose value.

4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The comparison and analysis of the dose measured by the radiation autoradiography film after irradiation and the dose calculated by the planning system to complete the verification of the treatment plan dose includes the following steps: D1) comparing the dose distribution determined in step B2) with the dose distribution calculated in step C7); D2) Use the gamma pass rate to compare the results and determine whether the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement. If the gamma pass rate is greater than the quality control requirement, the verified plan can be used for treatment, otherwise it cannot be used for treatment.