A robustness assessment method for an integrated electrothermal energy system

By establishing a dynamic model based on energy flow analysis and link importance indicators, the key links of the integrated electrothermal energy system are identified, solving the problem that traditional methods cannot reflect actual operating characteristics and improving the robustness and safety of the system.

CN116127683BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-17XUZHOU NORMAL UNIVERSITY
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210794932.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-07-07
Publication Date
2026-11-17
Estimated Expiration
2042-07-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies are insufficient to effectively assess the robustness of integrated electric and thermal energy systems, and traditional complex network theory fails to fully reflect the actual operating characteristics and cascading failure processes of the system, resulting in a high risk of large-scale power outages.

Method used

A dynamic model based on energy flow analysis is adopted, combined with complex network theory, to propose the importance index of link flow out-degree and in-degree. By simulating attack scenarios, critical links are identified, and the structural and functional robustness of the system is evaluated.

Benefits of technology

It improves the safe and stable operation of the integrated electric and thermal energy system, enables more accurate identification and protection of key components, provides targeted decision support, and reduces the risk of large-scale power outages.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN116127683B_ABST
    Figure CN116127683B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention discloses a robustness assessment method for an integrated electrothermal energy system, belonging to the field of energy systems. The method includes: establishing a dynamic model based on system topology information, integrated power flow characteristics, and cascading failure mechanisms. This model is based on energy flow analysis methods and draws on complex network theory to reflect the actual operating mechanism of the integrated electrothermal energy system; improving existing complex network indices, proposing new critical link identification indices, and quantifying the system's structural and functional characteristics through robustness assessment indices; simulating potential attacks on the system, and analyzing the dynamic process of the system under cascading failures using the proposed robustness assessment method to obtain robustness conclusions. This invention comprehensively considers the system's structure and physical characteristics, providing strong support for improving the safe and stable operation capability of integrated electrothermal energy systems.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of energy systems, and more specifically to a robustness assessment method for an integrated electrothermal energy system. Background Technology

[0002] Energy utilization is a fundamental aspect of human societal development, the lifeblood of national economies, and a matter of national importance. Therefore, energy issues have always been a focus of international attention, and technological changes and innovations in the energy sector have kept pace with the times. With the development of ICT (Information and Communication Technology), important concepts such as smart grids, integrated energy systems, and the energy internet have emerged in the energy network field. Furthermore, with the application of combined heat and power (CHP) units, electro-thermal coupling networks have developed rapidly. In recent years, numerous large-scale power outages worldwide, such as the 2021 Texas blackout and the 2019 London blackout, have caused enormous economic losses and severe social impacts. As a complex system, the integrated electro-thermal energy system, once damaged, will cause losses on an even larger scale and in a wider area. The causes of these large-scale destructive accidents are mostly due to the failure of an initial component, which triggers a series of overloads in the power flow redistribution process, leading to widespread cascading failures and ultimately causing system collapse. Therefore, robustness analysis and optimization of integrated electric and thermal energy systems, identification of system vulnerabilities, and targeted protection are of great significance for preventing power outages, improving economic efficiency and energy utilization, and thus provide theoretical support for building a strong smart grid and energy internet.

[0003] Applying complex network theory to the robustness analysis of electrothermal coupled networks can identify weak links in the network, providing support for improving the robustness of such networks. Previous studies have investigated the robustness of individual energy systems such as power and thermal systems, and complex network theory has been applied relatively maturely to power systems. Pure topology models, betweenness virtual flow models, and DC power flow models have all been successfully applied to the robustness analysis of single networks. However, few scholars have applied it to specific studies of electrothermal coupled systems. Furthermore, most models based on complex network theory focus on network topology, rarely reflecting the physical characteristics and internal connections of the system, resulting in discrepancies with the actual dynamic processes of system operation. Therefore, it is necessary to establish a dynamic model that reflects the actual operating characteristics and cascading processes of electrothermal coupled systems, proposing indicators from both structural and functional perspectives to jointly evaluate and analyze the robustness of integrated electrothermal energy systems. Summary of the Invention

[0004] To comprehensively address the aforementioned problems, especially the shortcomings of existing technologies, this invention provides a robustness evaluation method for integrated electrothermal energy systems that can comprehensively solve the above-mentioned problems.

[0005] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention employs the following technical means:

[0006] A robustness assessment method for an integrated electrothermal energy system, the method comprising:

[0007] (1) A dynamic model is established based on the system topology information, integrated power flow characteristics and cascading failure mechanism. This model is based on energy flow analysis method and draws on complex network theory to reflect the actual operation mechanism of the integrated electric and thermal energy system.

[0008] (2) Improve existing complex network metrics and propose new critical link identification metrics, including link flow out-degree importance metrics. Importance metrics for inbound power flow ;

[0009] (3) Quantify the system structure and functional characteristics through robustness evaluation indicators;

[0010] (4) Simulate possible attacks on the system. Based on the proposed robustness assessment method, use the critical link identification index described in step (2) to identify the critical links of the integrated electrothermal energy system. Use the identified critical links as the attack targets, simulate and analyze the dynamic process of the system under cascading failures, and obtain robustness conclusions.

[0011] A further preferred embodiment of the present invention: The method of step (1) is as follows:

[0012] Based on the hydraulic-thermal model of the heating network and the AC power flow model of the power system, a comprehensive calculation of the electrical and thermal power flow is performed.

[0013] 1) Heating network modeling

[0014] The hydraulic model includes the nodal flow balance equations and the head loss equations, which are specifically expressed as follows:

[0015]

[0016]

[0017]

[0018] In the formula: This is the network correlation matrix; This refers to the flow rate of the heating network pipeline. For the load flow into the node; The loop incidence matrix; This refers to the pipeline pressure drop caused by frictional losses. This refers to the pipeline resistance coefficient.

[0019] The thermal model includes the heat power equation, the pipe temperature drop equation, and the power balance equation for the mixed nodes:

[0020]

[0021]

[0022]

[0023] In the formula: For heat load; This is the specific heat capacity of water; , For the water supply and return temperatures of the nodes; , Temperatures at the beginning and end of the pipeline; The ambient temperature; The heat transfer coefficient; , It refers to the flow rate in and out of the pipeline. , These are the hot water temperatures at the injection and outflow nodes, respectively;

[0024] 2) Power Grid Modeling

[0025] In the multi-energy power flow calculation of the integrated energy system, the power grid model is described by the classic AC power flow model, and the link power expression is:

[0026]

[0027] In the formula: and Branch roads Active power and reactive power; and They are nodes With nodes The voltage amplitude; For nodes and nodes The voltage phase angle difference; and These are the admittance matrices of the power grid nodes. The line, number The real and imaginary parts of column elements;

[0028] 3) Modeling of coupled parts

[0029] Currently, most CHP units are extraction-condensing units. These units are variable heat-to-electricity ratio units, and their model is as follows:

[0030]

[0031] In the formula: The thermal power output of the CHP unit; The electrical power output of the CHP unit; For the condensing efficiency of the CHP unit; For fuel input efficiency; Thermoelectric ratio is a variable value.

[0032] Electric boilers use electricity as an energy source and can convert it into heat energy. The relationship between their heat production capacity and electricity consumption is as follows:

[0033]

[0034] In the formula: For the heat production efficiency of electric boilers, The thermal power output of the electric boiler;

[0035] Traditional complex network models treat components and links as nodes and edges, using... It means that, among them A collection of components. If a complex network is a set of links, then... The connection relationships between nodes can be used 3D correlation matrix Description, matrix elements are This indicates that the complex network is undirected and unweighted. Extended to a directed weighted network that better reflects the actual situation of electrothermal coupled networks. , The set of weights for the links; network The connection relationships between nodes and the distribution of link traffic can be adopted using 3D flow matrix Description, element Defined as a link The traffic on the platform is specifically described as follows:

[0036]

[0037] In the formula: Indicates that by node Flow to Node The power;

[0038] element The initial value is the link when the system is running normally. The initial flow of traffic changes as the network is attacked, leading to a redistribution of traffic and changes in link traffic. Consequently, the model is updated, resulting in a dynamically changing network model.

[0039] A further preferred embodiment of the present invention: The method of step (2) is as follows: Link power flow out-of-degree importance index Importance metrics of inbound power flow Quantify the importance of the link;

[0040] Complex network theory divides nodes The degree is the number of edges directly connected to it, and the link. The degree is defined as the sum of the number of links connected to it; considering the weighted directional characteristics based on the electrothermal power flow model, the in-degree and out-degree of the link power flow are defined separately.

[0041] In a containing In a network of nodes, links The maximum possible number of connection links is

[0042] The weighting degree is defined as the degree of the link. Connected The sum of traffic on each side of the link;

[0043] Link flow out-degree represents the outflow link The normalized sum of power is defined as follows:

[0044]

[0045] Link flow in-degree represents the inflow to the link. The normalized sum of power is defined as follows:

[0046]

[0047] A further preferred embodiment of the present invention: The method of step (3) is as follows: Define two indicators, network connectivity and traffic survival rate, and evaluate them from the two levels of structural robustness and functional robustness respectively;

[0048] 1) Structural robustness

[0049] Structural robustness assessment metrics reflect the structural integrity of an integrated electrothermal energy system after an attack. A network connectivity metric is used to measure this, overcoming the limitation of traditional complex network methods that only consider the largest connected subgraph. Specifically, it is the ratio of the number of normally functioning links in all isolated islands of the network after the attack to the initial total number of links. This is expressed as:

[0050]

[0051] In the formula, and These represent the number of links that did not experience overload after a cascading fault, did not trip due to relay protection device operation, or were disconnected from the generator, and the initial number of links in the power grid.

[0052] 2) Functional robustness

[0053] Functional robustness assessment index reflects the degree of network function damage of the integrated electric and thermal energy system after being attacked. Since the main function of the integrated electric and thermal energy system is to transmit electrical and thermal energy, the flow survival rate index is used to measure it.

[0054] Traffic survival rate refers to the ratio of the sum of power transmitted through links in the isolated network formed after a cascading failure in an electric heating network to the sum of power transmitted through links in the initial state. Specifically, it is expressed as:

[0055]

[0056] In the formula, , and , These represent the electrical and thermal power that still meets the load demand after the cascading fault ends, and the initial total electrical and thermal power of the power grid.

[0057] A further preferred embodiment of the present invention: The method of step (4) is as follows:

[0058] The cascading failure of an integrated electrothermal energy system can be defined as a series of cascading failure events between the power system and the thermal system caused by interdependence under an initial fault. The cascading failures between systems mainly propagate through coupling elements and transferable loads; a fault in any system can lead to a cascading effect. If the initial fault occurs in the power system, the cascading failure process of the electrothermal coupling system is as follows:

[0059] Step 1: Initial failure of a single power system link; Due to weather, human factors, and other factors, the power system may experience failures, causing a link to go out of service;

[0060] Step 2: Power system readjustment; Due to the initial fault, the power flow of the power system will be redistributed. If the initial fault causes the link traffic to exceed the threshold and the link to become overloaded, it will trigger a chain of faults.

[0061] Step 3: Impact of power system failures on the thermal system; After the power system cascading failure ends, due to the redistribution of power flow, the output of each unit is adjusted successively, and the output of the CHP unit is adjusted accordingly; The output adjustment of the CHP unit will cause the thermal system load adjustment and power flow redistribution.

[0062] Step 4: Thermal system readjustment; Due to the adjustment of the output of the CHP unit, the thermal system needs to readjust all generator sets and loads to eliminate power imbalance;

[0063] Step 5: Impact of thermal system readjustment on the power system; The output adjustment of CHP units will affect the power balance of the power system; If the output of CHP units increases, there will be excess heat. Since some electrical loads and thermal loads are convertible and substitutable, the demand for electrical load will decrease; Conversely, if the thermal output is insufficient, the electrical load will increase.

[0064] A further preferred embodiment of the present invention: if the power system still finds an imbalance, the power system readjustment process in step 2 will continue until the chain effect stops;

[0065] If the initial fault occurs in the thermal system, the chain reaction process will begin from step 4. The chain reaction of the integrated electrothermal energy system can be considered as a cyclical process.

[0066] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows:

[0067] 1. This invention comprehensively considers the structure and physical characteristics of the system, and establishes a dynamic model that is more in line with the actual situation of the system, providing strong support for improving the safe and stable operation capability of the integrated electric and thermal energy system.

[0068] 2. The key link identification index of the electrothermal integrated energy system of the present invention is helpful to identify important links of the system and protect them. The system robustness evaluation index can more realistically reflect the performance level of the electrothermal integrated energy system.

[0069] 3. This invention establishes a complete process from scenario creation to fault analysis of the integrated electric and thermal energy system, so as to clearly understand the performance status of the integrated electric and thermal energy system and help managers make more targeted decisions. Attached Figure Description

[0070] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating the cascading failures of the integrated electrothermal energy system described in an embodiment of the present invention.

[0071] Figure 2 This is a framework diagram of the robustness assessment method for the integrated electrothermal energy system described in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0072] Figure 3 This is a topology diagram of the integrated electrothermal energy system described in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0073] Figure 4 This is a power flow distribution diagram of the integrated electrothermal energy system described in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0074] Figure 5 This is a diagram illustrating the system robustness changes in network connectivity of the integrated electric and thermal energy system described in this embodiment of the invention after an attack on the power grid link.

[0075] Figure 6 This is a graph showing the system robustness variation of the flow survival rate after the power grid link of the integrated electric and thermal energy system described in this embodiment of the invention is attacked.

[0076] Figure 7 This is a diagram illustrating the system robustness changes in network connectivity after the heat network link of the integrated electric and thermal energy system described in this embodiment of the invention is attacked.

[0077] Figure 8 This is a graph showing the system robustness change of the flow survival rate after the heat network link of the integrated electric and thermal energy system described in this embodiment of the invention is attacked. Detailed Implementation

[0078] To facilitate understanding, the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and thoroughly described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. The described embodiments are only a part of the embodiments of the present invention.

[0079] Example 1

[0080] A robustness assessment method for an integrated electrothermal energy system, the method comprising:

[0081] (1) A dynamic model is established based on the system topology information, integrated power flow characteristics and cascading failure mechanism. This model is based on energy flow analysis method and draws on complex network theory to reflect the actual operation mechanism of the integrated electric and thermal energy system.

[0082] (2) Improve existing complex network indicators and propose new critical link identification indicators;

[0083] (3) Quantify the system structure and functional characteristics through robustness evaluation indicators;

[0084] (4) Simulate the possible attacks that the system may suffer. Based on the proposed robustness assessment method, simulate and analyze the dynamic process of the system under cascading failures to obtain robustness conclusions.

[0085] The specific method for step (1) is as follows:

[0086] This invention performs integrated calculations of electrical and thermal power flow based on a hydraulic-thermal model of a heating network and an AC power flow model of a power system.

[0087] 1) Heating network modeling

[0088] The hydraulic model includes the nodal flow balance equations and the head loss equations, which are specifically expressed as follows:

[0089]

[0090]

[0091]

[0092] In the formula: This is the network correlation matrix; This refers to the flow rate of the heating network pipeline. For the load flow into the node; The loop incidence matrix; This refers to the pipeline pressure drop caused by frictional losses. This refers to the pipeline resistance coefficient.

[0093] The thermal model includes the heat power equation, the pipe temperature drop equation, and the power balance equation for the mixed nodes:

[0094]

[0095]

[0096]

[0097] In the formula: For heat load; This is the specific heat capacity of water; , For the water supply and return temperatures of the nodes; , Temperatures at the beginning and end of the pipeline; The ambient temperature; The heat transfer coefficient; , It refers to the flow rate in and out of the pipeline. , These are the hot water temperatures at the injection and outflow nodes, respectively;

[0098] Because the power flow equations of a heating network are nonlinear, with a strong coupling relationship between temperature and flow rate, and include exponential equations, the computational complexity is high, and numerical stability is difficult to guarantee. Therefore, [the following is omitted as the original text is incomplete and cannot be translated]. Simplify the solution.

[0099] 2) Power Grid Modeling

[0100] In the multi-energy power flow calculation of the integrated energy system, the power grid model is described by the classic AC power flow model, and the link power expression is:

[0101]

[0102] In the formula: and Branch roads Active power and reactive power; and They are nodes With nodes The voltage amplitude; For nodes and nodes The voltage phase angle difference; and These are the admittance matrices of the power grid nodes. The line, number The real and imaginary parts of column elements;

[0103] 3) Modeling of coupled parts

[0104] Currently, most CHP units are extraction-condensing units. These units are variable heat-to-electricity ratio units, and their model is as follows:

[0105]

[0106] In the formula: The thermal power output of the CHP unit; The electrical power output of the CHP unit; For the condensing efficiency of the CHP unit; For fuel input efficiency; Thermoelectric ratio is a variable value.

[0107] Electric boilers use electricity as an energy source and can convert it into heat energy. The relationship between their heat production capacity and electricity consumption is as follows:

[0108]

[0109] In the formula: For the heat production efficiency of electric boilers, This refers to the thermal power output of the electric boiler.

[0110] Pure complex network methods have limitations, rarely considering the physical characteristics of the system. This invention combines complex network methods with power flow analysis methods, considering link traffic to form a directed weighted network. Traditional complex network models treat components and links as nodes and edges, using... It means that, among them A collection of components. If a complex network is a set of links, then... The connection relationships between nodes can be used 3D correlation matrix Description, matrix elements are This indicates that the complex network is undirected and unweighted. Extended to a directed weighted network that better reflects the actual situation of electrothermal coupled networks. , The set of weights for the links; network The connection relationships between nodes and the distribution of link traffic can be adopted using 3D flow matrix Description, element Defined as a link The traffic on the platform is specifically described as follows:

[0111]

[0112] In the formula: Indicates that by node Flow to Node The power;

[0113] element The initial value is the link when the system is running normally. The initial flow of traffic changes as the network is attacked, leading to a redistribution of traffic and changes in link traffic. Consequently, the model is updated, resulting in a dynamically changing network model.

[0114] The specific method for step (2) is as follows:

[0115] Since a small number of link failures in real-world networks can significantly impact the network's structure and function, identifying critical links is of great research importance. This invention proposes a link flow output degree importance index. Importance metrics of inbound power flow Quantify the importance of the link;

[0116] Complex network theory divides nodes The degree is the number of edges directly connected to it, and the link. The degree is defined as the sum of the number of links connected to it; considering the weighted directional characteristics based on the electrothermal power flow model, the in-degree and out-degree of the link power flow are defined separately.

[0117] In a containing In a network of nodes, links The maximum possible number of connection links is

[0118] The weighting degree is defined as the degree of the link. Connected The sum of traffic on each side of the link;

[0119] Link flow out-degree represents the outflow link The normalized sum of power is defined as follows:

[0120]

[0121] Link flow in-degree represents the inflow to the link. The normalized sum of power is defined as follows:

[0122]

[0123] The specific method for step (3) is as follows:

[0124] To overcome the inability of traditional robustness assessment indicators for complex networks to accurately reflect the operational characteristics and failure mechanisms of integrated electric and thermal energy systems after cascading failures, two indicators, network connectivity and traffic survival rate, are defined to evaluate the system from the perspectives of structural robustness and functional robustness, respectively.

[0125] 1) Structural robustness

[0126] Structural robustness assessment metrics reflect the structural integrity of an integrated electrothermal energy system after an attack. A network connectivity metric is used to measure this, overcoming the limitation of traditional complex network methods that only consider the largest connected subgraph. Specifically, it is the ratio of the number of normally functioning links in all isolated islands of the network after the attack to the initial total number of links. This is expressed as:

[0127]

[0128] In the formula, and These represent the number of links that did not experience overload after a cascading fault, did not trip due to relay protection device operation, or were disconnected from the generator, and the initial number of links in the power grid.

[0129] 2) Functional robustness

[0130] Functional robustness assessment index reflects the degree of network function damage of the integrated electric and thermal energy system after being attacked. Since the main function of the integrated electric and thermal energy system is to transmit electrical and thermal energy, the flow survival rate index is used to measure it.

[0131] Traffic survival rate refers to the ratio of the sum of power transmitted through links in the isolated network formed after a cascading failure in an electric heating network to the sum of power transmitted through links in the initial state. Specifically, it is expressed as:

[0132]

[0133] In the formula, , and , These represent the electrical and thermal power that still meets the load demand after the cascading fault ends, and the initial total electrical and thermal power of the power grid.

[0134] The specific method for step (4) is as follows:

[0135] The cascading failure of an integrated electrothermal energy system can be defined as a series of cascading failure events between the power system and the thermal system caused by interdependence under an initial fault. The cascading failures between systems mainly propagate through coupling elements and transferable loads; a fault in any system can lead to a cascading effect. If the initial fault occurs in the power system, the cascading failure process of the electrothermal coupling system is as follows:

[0136] Step 1: Initial failure of a single power system link; Due to weather, human factors, and other factors, the power system may experience failures, causing a link to go out of service;

[0137] Step 2: Power system readjustment; Due to the initial fault, the power flow of the power system will be redistributed. If the initial fault causes the link traffic to exceed the threshold and the link to become overloaded, it will trigger a chain of faults.

[0138] The maximum allowable transmission capacity of a power transmission link is called the transmission link capacity threshold. To reflect the impact of the transmission link capacity threshold on the cascading failure evolution path, a tolerance coefficient is introduced for evaluation and analysis, specifically expressed as follows:

[0139]

[0140] In the formula: Indicates the tolerance coefficient; Indicates the capacity of the power transmission link; This represents the flow rate transmitted through the power transmission link;

[0141] If an initial fault in the power grid causes the link flow to exceed the link threshold, it will cause a cascading fault. Since the relay protection device of the high-voltage transmission link will act immediately when the link flow exceeds the capacity, this paper assumes that the power grid link overload will immediately cause it to shut down. If the heating network pipeline ruptures due to human factors or pipeline corrosion that causes the pipe wall to thin, the thermal valve will be activated, causing the pipeline to shut down.

[0142] Step 3: Impact of power system failures on the thermal system; After the power system cascading failure ends, due to the redistribution of power flow, the output of each unit is adjusted successively, and the output of the CHP unit is adjusted accordingly; The output adjustment of the CHP unit will cause the thermal system load adjustment and power flow redistribution.

[0143] Step 4: Thermal system readjustment; Due to the adjustment of the output of the CHP unit, the thermal system needs to readjust all generator sets and loads to eliminate power imbalance;

[0144] Step 5: Impact of thermal system readjustment on the power system; The output adjustment of CHP units will affect the power balance of the power system; If the output of CHP units increases, there will be excess heat. Since some electrical loads and thermal loads are convertible and substitutable, the demand for electrical load will decrease; Conversely, if the thermal output is insufficient, the electrical load will increase.

[0145] Chain failure process as follows Figure 1 As shown, if the power system still finds an imbalance, the power system readjustment process in step 2 will continue until the chain reaction stops.

[0146] If the initial fault occurs in the thermal system, the chain reaction process will begin from step 4. The chain reaction of the integrated electric and thermal energy system can be regarded as a cyclic process.

[0147] Example 2

[0148] like Figure 2 As shown in the figure, this invention discloses a robustness assessment method for an integrated electric-thermal energy system. The following detailed description uses an integrated electric-thermal energy system formed by coupling an IEEE 118-node power grid and a 23-node heating network through CHP units and electric boilers as an example. Its robustness under cascading failures is assessed. The system topology diagram and power flow distribution diagram are shown below. Figure 3 and Figure 4 As shown.

[0149] (1) A dynamic model is established based on the system topology information, integrated power flow characteristics and cascading failure mechanism. This model is based on the energy flow analysis method and draws on the complex network theory to reflect the actual operation mechanism of the integrated electric and thermal energy system.

[0150] (2) Improve the existing complex network indicators and propose new key link identification indicators.

[0151] (3) Quantify the system structure and functional characteristics through robustness evaluation indicators.

[0152] (4) Simulate the possible attacks that the system may suffer. Based on the proposed robustness assessment method, simulate and analyze the dynamic process of the system under cascading failures to obtain robustness conclusions.

[0153] Because the fault process differs when the initial link failure occurs in the power grid and the heating network, this paper considers the changes in the structural and functional robustness of the electrothermal network when the initial failure occurs in the power grid link and the heating network link respectively, and analyzes the network's ability to resist attacks. To intuitively reflect the impact of the initial fault location on the robustness of the integrated electrothermal energy system, Figure 5 and Figure 6 This shows the changes in network connectivity and traffic survival rate of the integrated electric and thermal energy system when each link of the power grid is attacked. Figure 7 and Figure 8This describes the changes in the robustness of the integrated electrothermal energy system when the initial fault location is in the heating network. This is used to assess the robustness of the integrated electrothermal energy system after an attack.

[0154] Depend on Figure 5 and Figure 6 It can be seen that the tolerance coefficient is generally positively correlated with robustness. The larger the tolerance coefficient, the greater the network capacity margin, and the lower the possibility of link failure due to power overload. Therefore, increasing the tolerance coefficient can improve the robustness of the network. When the tolerance coefficient is greater than the critical value, the link capacity margin is already sufficient, and the degree of network performance degradation tends to be gradual.

[0155] Table 1. Robustness assessment results of the integrated electric and thermal energy system under power grid attack.

[0156]

[0157] Depend on Figure 5 , Figure 6 As shown in Table 1, regardless of whether the evaluation metrics for network structural robustness (LS) or network functional robustness (CS and PS) are used, the damage caused by attacking link [30,8] is extremely large. This link is also the most critical link identified based on the FOD importance index. Furthermore, links [49,66] rank 11th in link FID importance and 15th in FOD importance; links [68,69] rank 4th in link FID importance; links [92,89] rank 8th in link FID importance; links [9,10] rank 12th in link FID importance; and links [37,38] rank 20th in link FB importance. These results also demonstrate the effectiveness of the critical link identification index proposed in this paper.

[0158] Table 2. Robustness Assessment Results of the Integrated Electric-Heating Energy System During Attacks on the Heating Network

[0159]

[0160] from Figure 7 , Figure 8 As can be clearly seen from Table 2, regardless of the value of Alpha, the top five links attacking the heating network, namely attack links [49,119], [119,120], [120,121], [121,122], and [122,123], cause far greater losses to the heating network than other links in the heating network. These five links are also the top five most critical links identified by the link flow betweenness index.

[0161] Finally, it should be noted that the above descriptions are merely preferred embodiments of the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the foregoing embodiments, those skilled in the art can still modify the technical solutions described in the foregoing embodiments or make equivalent substitutions for some of the technical features. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc., made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included within the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system, characterized in that, The method includes: (1) A dynamic model is established based on the system topology information, integrated power flow characteristics and cascading failure mechanism. This model is based on energy flow analysis method and draws on complex network theory to reflect the actual operation mechanism of the integrated electric and thermal energy system. (2) Improve existing complex network metrics and propose new critical link identification metrics, including link flow out-degree importance metrics. Importance metrics for inbound power flow ; (3) Quantify the system structure and functional characteristics through robustness evaluation indicators; (4) Simulate possible attacks on the system. Based on the proposed robustness assessment method, use the critical link identification index described in step (2) to identify the critical links of the integrated electrothermal energy system. Use the identified critical links as the attack targets, simulate and analyze the dynamic process of the system under cascading failures, and obtain robustness conclusions.

2. The robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system according to claim 1, characterized in that, The specific method for step (1) is as follows: Based on the hydraulic-thermal model of the heating network and the AC power flow model of the power system, a comprehensive calculation of the electrical and thermal power flow is performed. 1) Heating network modeling The hydraulic model includes the nodal flow balance equations and the head loss equations, which are specifically expressed as follows: In the formula: This is the network correlation matrix; This refers to the flow rate of the heating network pipeline. For the load flow into the node; The loop incidence matrix; This refers to the pipeline pressure drop caused by frictional losses. This refers to the pipeline resistance coefficient. The thermal model includes the heat power equation, the pipe temperature drop equation, and the power balance equation for the mixed nodes: In the formula: For heat load; This is the specific heat capacity of water; For the water supply and return temperatures of the nodes; , Temperatures at the beginning and end of the pipeline; The ambient temperature; The heat transfer coefficient; It refers to the flow rate in and out of the pipeline. These are the hot water temperatures at the injection and outflow nodes, respectively. 2) Power Grid Modeling In the multi-energy power flow calculation of the integrated energy system, the power grid model is described by the classic AC power flow model, and the link power expression is: In the formula: and Branch roads Active power and reactive power; and They are nodes With nodes The voltage amplitude; For nodes and nodes The voltage phase angle difference; and These are the admittance matrices of the power grid nodes. The line, number The real and imaginary parts of column elements; 3) Modeling of coupled parts Currently, most CHP units are extraction-condensing units. These units are variable heat-to-electricity ratio units, and their model is as follows: In the formula: The thermal power output of the CHP unit; The electrical power output of the CHP unit; For the condensing efficiency of the CHP unit; For fuel input efficiency; Thermoelectric ratio is a variable value. Electric boilers use electricity as an energy source and can convert it into heat energy. The relationship between their heat production capacity and power consumption is as follows: In the formula: For the heat production efficiency of electric boilers, The thermal power output of the electric boiler; Traditional complex network models treat components and links as nodes and edges, using... It means that among them A collection of components. If a complex network is a set of links, then... The connection relationships between nodes can be used 3D correlation matrix Description, matrix elements are This indicates that the complex network is undirected and unweighted. Extended to a directed weighted network that better reflects the actual situation of electrothermal coupled networks. , The set of weights for the links; network The connection relationships between nodes and the distribution of link traffic can be adopted using 3D flow matrix Description, element Defined as a link The traffic on the platform is specifically described as follows: In the formula: Indicates that by node Flow to Node The power; element The initial value is the link when the system is running normally. The initial flow of traffic changes as the network is attacked, leading to a redistribution of traffic and changes in link traffic. Consequently, the model is updated, resulting in a dynamically changing network model.

3. The robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system according to claim 1, characterized in that, The specific method for step (2) is as follows: Link flow out-of-degree importance index Importance metrics of inbound power flow Quantify the importance of the link; Complex network theory divides nodes The degree is the number of edges directly connected to it, and the link. The degree is defined as the sum of the number of links connected to it; considering the weighted directional characteristics based on the electrothermal power flow model, the in-degree and out-degree of the link power flow are defined separately. In a containing In a network of nodes, links The maximum possible number of connection links is The weighting degree is defined as the degree of the link. Connected The sum of traffic on each side of the link; Link flow out-degree represents the outflow link The normalized sum of power is defined as follows: Link flow in-degree represents the inflow to the link. The normalized sum of power is defined as follows:

4. The robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system according to claim 1, characterized in that, The specific method for step (3) is as follows: Define two indicators, network connectivity and traffic survivability, and evaluate them from the perspectives of structural robustness and functional robustness, respectively; 1) Structural robustness The structural robustness assessment index reflects the structural integrity of the integrated electrothermal energy system after an attack; it uses a network connectivity index to measure this, overcoming the shortcomings of traditional complex network methods that only consider the largest connected subgraph, i.e., the ratio of the number of normally functioning links in all isolated islands of the network after the attack to the initial total number of links, specifically expressed as: In the formula, and These represent the number of links that did not experience overload after a cascading fault, did not trip due to relay protection device operation, or were disconnected from the generator, and the initial number of links in the power grid. 2) Functional robustness Functional robustness assessment index reflects the degree of network function damage of the integrated electric and thermal energy system after being attacked. Since the main function of the integrated electric and thermal energy system is to transmit electrical and thermal energy, the flow survival rate index is used to measure it. Traffic survival rate refers to the ratio of the sum of power transmitted through links in the isolated network formed after a cascading failure in an electric heating network to the sum of power transmitted through links in the initial state. Specifically, it is expressed as: In the formula, , and , These represent the electrical and thermal power that still meets the load demand after the cascading fault ends, and the initial total electrical and thermal power of the power grid.

5. The robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system according to claim 1, characterized in that, The specific method for step (4) is as follows: The cascading failure of an integrated electrothermal energy system can be defined as a series of cascading failure events between the power system and the thermal system caused by interdependence under an initial fault. The cascading failures between systems mainly propagate through coupling elements and transferable loads; a fault in any system can lead to a cascading effect. If the initial fault occurs in the power system, the cascading failure process of the electrothermal coupling system is as follows: Step 1: Initial failure of a single power system link; Due to weather factors, human factors, etc., the power system may experience failures, causing a certain link to go out of service; Step 2: Power system readjustment; Due to the initial fault, the power flow of the power system will be redistributed. If the initial fault causes the link traffic to exceed the threshold and the link to become overloaded, it will trigger a chain of faults. Step 3: Impact of power system failures on the thermal system; After the power system cascading failure ends, due to the redistribution of power flow, the output of each unit is adjusted successively, and the output of the CHP unit is adjusted accordingly; The output adjustment of the CHP unit will cause the thermal system load adjustment and power flow redistribution. Step 4: Thermal system readjustment; Due to the adjustment of the output of the CHP unit, the thermal system needs to readjust all generator sets and loads to eliminate power imbalance; Step 5: Impact of thermal system readjustment on the power system; The output adjustment of CHP units will affect the power balance of the power system; If the output of CHP units increases, there will be excess heat. Since some electrical loads and thermal loads are convertible and substitutable, the demand for electrical load will decrease; Conversely, if the thermal output is insufficient, the electrical load will increase.

6. The robustness evaluation method for an integrated electrothermal energy system according to claim 5, characterized in that, If the power system is still found to be unbalanced, the power system readjustment process in step 2 will continue until the chain reaction stops. If the initial fault occurs in the thermal system, the chain reaction process will begin from step 4. The chain reaction of the integrated electric and thermal energy system can be regarded as a cyclic process.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • An integrated energy system risk assessment method based on electrothermal coupling

    CN109377008A

  • Network management based on assessment of topological robustness and criticality of assets

    US20160285689A1