A method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants

By combining numerical simulation methods of finite element and discrete element methods with standard calculations and experimental verification, the fatigue analysis problem of nuclear power plants in sea ice environments was solved, ensuring the safety and accuracy of the plant.

CN116702542BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-10CNNC MARINE NUCLEAR POWER DEV CO LTD
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310604394.0
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-26
Publication Date
2026-11-10
Estimated Expiration
2043-05-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies lack effective methods for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants in sea ice environments, especially for the analysis of internal equipment and connecting mechanisms, which makes it difficult to guarantee safety.

Method used

A numerical simulation method combining finite element and discrete element methods was adopted. By combining standard calculation, semi-empirical calculation of ice resistance and ship model ice pool test, a sea ice element bonding-fragmentation model was established to simulate the coupled motion state of ship-water-ice and obtain reliable ice load and acceleration spectrum for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants.

Benefits of technology

Reliable fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants in sea ice environments was achieved, ensuring structural safety. Multiple verification methods were used to improve the accuracy and reliability of the analysis.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN116702542B_ABST
    Figure CN116702542B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention belongs to the field of nuclear-powered ship design technology, specifically involving a method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue of marine nuclear power plants. It includes the following steps: (1) establishing an overall finite element model of the ship or platform carrying the HDL device; (2) selecting discrete element parameters for sea ice, constructing a sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model, and establishing a discrete element numerical ice pool; (3) calculating the ice load values ​​at four points on the bow based on the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS) POLAR CLASS standard; and (4) calculating the average ice resistance of the entire ship using a semi-empirical formula based on several sets of smooth ice conditions. The beneficial effects of this invention are: the use of a numerical simulation method combining finite element and discrete element methods; the triple verification of the reliability of the digital ice pool using standard calculations, semi-empirical calculations of ice resistance, and ship model ice pool tests; and the integration of different operating conditions and their probability distributions throughout the entire voyage cycle, ensuring that the obtained acceleration spectrum is closer to the actual operating environment.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention belongs to the field of nuclear-powered ship design technology, specifically relating to a method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants. Background Technology

[0002] For HDL (nuclear power) plants, long-term high and low frequency loads have a significant impact on the safety of the plant, and fatigue analysis is one of the important aspects of HDL plant design.

[0003] For ships or marine structures that navigate or operate in sea ice environments for extended periods, ice-induced loads are a significant factor inducing structural fatigue failure. Therefore, ice loads must be considered as one of the mechanical inputs for fatigue analysis using the HDL apparatus.

[0004] Currently, numerical simulation methods are widely used in ship design both domestically and internationally to analyze ice-induced fatigue loads. However, there is a lack of verification methods for the accuracy of these numerical simulations, and current analytical methods are often limited to the hull plating of ships or marine engineering structures, and are not applicable to fatigue analysis of internal equipment (such as nuclear power plants) and connecting mechanisms. Therefore, achieving reliable ice-induced fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants is crucial for their structural safety. Summary of the Invention

[0005] The purpose of this invention is to provide a fatigue analysis method applicable to nuclear power plants operating in sea ice environments for extended periods under ice-induced loads, thereby ensuring the safety of nuclear power plants.

[0006] The technical solution of the present invention is as follows: A method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants, comprising the following steps:

[0007] (1) Establish an overall finite element model of the ship or platform carrying the HDL device;

[0008] (2) Select the discrete element parameters of sea ice, construct the sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model, and establish a discrete element numerical ice pool;

[0009] (3) Based on the POLAR CLASS standard of the International Association of Classification Societies, calculate the ice load values ​​at four points on the bow;

[0010] (4) Based on several sets of smooth ice conditions, the average ice resistance of the whole ship is calculated using the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance.

[0011] (5) Based on the working conditions of flat ice of different thicknesses, conduct model ice pool tests to obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship;

[0012] (6) Simulate the impact of the ship's bow at four points on the edge of the sea ice in a numerical ice pool and obtain the ice load values;

[0013] (7) Simulate the ship's operation in a numerical ice pool under the same conditions as in steps (4) and (6) on smooth ice, and obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship accordingly.

[0014] (8) Compare the ice load value obtained in step (3) with the ice load value obtained in step (6) to confirm whether the error is within 20%;

[0015] (9) Compare the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (4) with the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (7) to confirm whether the error is within 20%.

[0016] (10) Compare the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (5) with the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (7) to confirm whether the error is within 20%.

[0017] (11) If any error exceeds 20%, adjust the discrete element parameters of sea ice;

[0018] Repeat steps (2)-(11) until all errors are within 20%;

[0019] (12) Analyze the navigation conditions and probability distribution of HDL vessels in ice zones;

[0020] (13) Simulate each navigation condition using a numerical ice pool to obtain the acceleration time history curves of the HDL device at the required position for each condition;

[0021] (14) Convert the acceleration time history curve into an acceleration spectrum that can be used for fatigue analysis of the HDL device;

[0022] (15) Establish the finite element model of the HDL device;

[0023] (16) Load the acceleration spectrum obtained in step 14 and perform fatigue analysis;

[0024] (17) Compare the fatigue analysis results with the designed fatigue life;

[0025] (18) Based on the analysis results, optimize the design and modify the model for areas that do not meet the design requirements, and repeat steps (16)-(17) until all analysis results meet the design requirements.

[0026] Preferably, the sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model in step 2 is used to simulate the coupled motion state of ship, water and ice when the ship is sailing in a sea ice environment; wherein, the sea ice discrete element model simulates the bonding force between units by using an elastic force model caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation, and establishes the bonding force failure criterion between units based on normal tensile strength and tangential bonding strength.

[0027] Preferably, the sea ice unit bonding force in step 2 adopts an elastic force model caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation; the sea ice unit failure criterion is expressed as σmax < σb or τmax < τb, where σb is the normal tensile strength and τb is the tangential bonding strength.

[0028] Preferably, in step 3, the ice load values ​​of the four collision points 3 of the bow structure of the ship are calculated according to the POLAR CLASS standard issued by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS); the sea ice thickness consistent with that of the ship is established in the numerical ice pool; the impact angle of the four collision points of the selected bow against the flat sea ice edge is calculated according to the standard; the ice load values ​​of each point are obtained; and the results are compared with the standard calculation results to verify whether the error is below 20%.

[0029] Select more than two different sets of sea ice environment parameters and ship speed, and calculate the average ice resistance of the entire ship according to the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance. Establish several operating conditions consistent with these conditions in a numerical ice pool, obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship under each condition, and compare it with the average ice resistance obtained by the semi-empirical formula to verify whether the error is below 20%.

[0030] Preferably, the ice leveling conditions in step 4 include at least the designed ice thickness condition and one or more other ice thickness conditions.

[0031] Preferably, the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance in step 4 is either the Lindqvist formula or the Riska formula.

[0032] Preferably, in step 9, the average ice resistance of the entire ship under several working conditions is obtained through model ice pool tests; several working conditions consistent with these conditions are established in a numerical ice pool, the average ice resistance of the entire ship under each working condition is obtained, and the average ice resistance is compared with the average ice resistance obtained from the model ice pool tests to verify whether the error is below 20%.

[0033] If all the above verification errors are below 20%, it proves that the established numerical ice pool has extremely high reliability and the results calculated through the ice pool have extremely high accuracy.

[0034] If the above verification error exceeds 20%, the sea ice parameters need to be adjusted, the sea ice unit bonding-failure model needs to be reconstructed, and the comparative verification needs to be carried out again until all verification errors are below 20%.

[0035] Preferably, in step 12, the number and probability distribution of different navigation conditions encountered by the nuclear-powered ship are determined by analyzing the ship's operation plan and route conditions; and the acceleration time history curves of the target position of the nuclear power plant under each condition are obtained by simulating the aforementioned conditions in a numerical ice pool.

[0036] Preferably, the required locations of the HDL device in step 13 include the device's center of gravity, the geometric center of the containment, the perimeter of the containment, and the points where the straight line connecting the center of the containment and the perimeter is divided at regular intervals.

[0037] Preferably, in step 14, the acceleration time history curve is converted into a constant amplitude or variable amplitude acceleration spectrum using the rainflow counting method. This converts the acceleration time history curve into an acceleration spectrum suitable for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants; the rainflow counting method is used to convert the acceleration time history curve into a variable amplitude or constant amplitude acceleration spectrum.

[0038] The beneficial effects of this invention are as follows: it employs a numerical simulation method combining finite element and discrete element methods; it uses standardized calculations, semi-empirical calculations of ice resistance, and ship model ice pool tests to triple-verify the reliability of the digital ice pool; it uses an elastic mechanics model to simulate the adhesion force of sea ice units; it outputs the ice load in the form of acceleration time history curves; it is applicable to design scenarios where hull design and HDL device design are carried out separately; it converts the acceleration time history curves under ice-induced loads into acceleration spectra that can be used as mechanical inputs for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants; and it integrates different operating conditions and their probability distributions throughout the entire voyage cycle, ensuring that the obtained acceleration spectrum is closer to the actual operating environment. Attached Figure Description

[0039] Figure 1 Flowchart of an ice-induced fatigue analysis method for a marine nuclear power plant provided by the present invention;

[0040] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of a numerical ice pool;

[0041] Figure 3 The bow struck the edge of the sea ice.

[0042] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the collision point;

[0043] Figure 5 Navigation conditions and probability distribution in ice-covered areas;

[0044] Figure 6 A schematic diagram showing the required location of a square containment HDL device;

[0045] Figure 7 This is a schematic diagram showing the required location of a cylindrical containment HDL device.

[0046] In the figure: 1 Finite element model of nuclear-powered ship, 2 Discrete element model of flat sea ice, 3 Collision point, 4 Geometric center point of containment, 5 Containment perimeter point, 6 Dividing point, 7 Center of gravity of HDL device. Detailed Implementation

[0047] The present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments.

[0048] like Figure 1 As shown, a method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants includes the following steps:

[0049] Step 1: Establish a global finite element model of the HDL (nuclear-powered) ship or platform;

[0050] Step 2: Select the discrete element parameters of sea ice, construct the sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model, and establish a discrete element numerical ice pool to simulate the coupled motion state of ship-water-ice when a ship is sailing in a sea ice environment.

[0051] The sea ice discrete element model is related to the sea ice discrete element parameters and the sea ice element bonding-fracture model. The sea ice elements are bonded together by the selected sea ice discrete element parameters and can break after contact with the ship model. The bonding force between the elements is simulated by using an elastic force model caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation, and the bonding force failure criterion between the elements is established based on the normal tensile strength and tangential bonding strength.

[0052] The bonding force of the sea ice unit is modeled as an elastic force caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation; the failure criterion of the sea ice unit is expressed as σmax < σb or τmax < τb, where σb is the normal tensile strength and τb is the tangential bonding strength.

[0053] Step 3: Calculate the ice load values ​​at four points on the bow based on the International Association of Classification Societies (IAS) POLAR CLASS standard.

[0054] The ice load values ​​at four collision points on the bow structure of the ship were calculated according to the POLAR CLASS standard issued by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS). The sea ice thickness was established in a numerical ice pool to match the ice thickness. The impact angles of the four collision points on the bow of the ship were calculated according to the standard to obtain the ice load values ​​at each point. The results were compared with the standard calculation results to verify whether the error was below 20%.

[0055] Select more than two different sets of sea ice environment parameters and ship speed, and calculate the average ice resistance of the whole ship according to the semi-empirical formula of ice resistance; establish several working conditions consistent with it in the numerical ice pool (sea ice thickness and ship speed are the same), obtain the average ice resistance of the whole ship under each working condition, and compare it with the average ice resistance obtained by the semi-empirical formula to verify whether the error is below 20%.

[0056] Step 4: Based on several sets of smooth ice conditions, calculate the average ice resistance of the entire ship using a semi-empirical formula for ice resistance.

[0057] The smooth ice condition includes at least the design ice thickness condition and one or more other ice thickness conditions. The semi-empirical formula for ice resistance uses either the Lindqvist formula or the Riska formula.

[0058] Step 5: Based on the flat ice conditions of thickness A and thickness B, conduct a model ice pool test to obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship.

[0059] Step 6: Simulate the impact of the ship's bow at four points on the edge of the sea ice in a numerical ice pool to obtain the ice load values.

[0060] Step 7: Simulate the ship's operation in a numerical ice pool under the same conditions as in Steps 4 and 6, and obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship.

[0061] Step 8: Compare the ice load value obtained in Step 3 with the ice load value obtained in Step 6 to confirm whether the error is within 20%.

[0062] Step 9: Compare the average ice resistance of the entire ship obtained in Step 4 with the average ice resistance of the entire ship obtained in Step 7, and confirm whether the error is within 20%.

[0063] Through model ice pool tests, the average ice resistance of the entire ship under several operating conditions was obtained; several operating conditions consistent with these conditions (same sea ice thickness and speed) were established in the numerical ice pool, and the average ice resistance of the entire ship under each operating condition was obtained. The average ice resistance was then compared with the average ice resistance obtained from the model ice pool tests to verify whether the error was below 20%.

[0064] If all the above verification errors are below 20%, it proves that the established numerical ice pool has extremely high reliability and the results calculated through the ice pool have extremely high accuracy.

[0065] If the above verification error exceeds 20%, the sea ice parameters need to be adjusted, the sea ice unit bonding-failure model needs to be reconstructed, and the comparative verification needs to be carried out again until the verification error is all below 20%.

[0066] Step 10: Compare the average ice resistance of the entire ship obtained in Step 5 with the average ice resistance of the entire ship obtained in Step 7, and confirm whether the error is within 20%.

[0067] Step 11: If any error exceeds 20%, adjust the discrete element parameters of the sea ice.

[0068] Repeat steps 2-11 until all errors are within 20%.

[0069] Step 12: Analyze the navigation conditions and probability distribution of HDL vessels in ice-covered areas.

[0070] By analyzing the operational planning and route conditions of nuclear-powered ships, the number of different navigation conditions they encounter and their probability distribution are determined; by numerical ice tank simulation of the aforementioned conditions, the acceleration time history curves of the target position of the nuclear power plant under each condition are obtained.

[0071] Step 13: Simulate each navigation condition using a numerical ice pool to obtain the acceleration time history curves of the required positions of the HDL device for each condition.

[0072] The required locations for the HDL device include the device's center of gravity, the geometric center of the containment, the containment perimeter, and the points where the straight line connecting the containment center and the perimeter is divided at regular intervals.

[0073] Step 14: Convert the acceleration time history curve into an acceleration spectrum that can be used for fatigue analysis of the HDL device.

[0074] The acceleration time history curves are converted into constant-amplitude or variable-amplitude acceleration spectra using the rainflow counting method. This converts the acceleration time history curves into acceleration spectra suitable for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants.

[0075] Step 15: Establish the finite element model of the HDL device.

[0076] A finite element model of the nuclear power plant was established, and the aforementioned acceleration spectrum was loaded to conduct fatigue analysis. The fatigue life obtained from the fatigue analysis results was compared with the design life. For those components whose fatigue life did not meet the requirements, the design was optimized and re-analyzed until the fatigue life of all components met the design requirements.

[0077] Step 16: Load the acceleration spectrum obtained in Step 14 and perform fatigue analysis.

[0078] Step 17: Compare the fatigue analysis results with the designed fatigue life.

[0079] Step 18: Based on the analysis results, optimize the design and modify the model for areas that do not meet the design requirements, and repeat steps 16-17 until all analysis results meet the design requirements.

Claims

1. A method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: (1) Establish an overall finite element model of the ship or platform carrying the HDL device; (2) Select the discrete element parameters of sea ice, construct the sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model, and establish a discrete element numerical ice pool; (3) Based on the POLAR CLASS standard of the International Association of Classification Societies, calculate the ice load values ​​at four points on the bow; (4) Based on several sets of smooth ice conditions, the average ice resistance of the whole ship is calculated using the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance. (5) Based on the working conditions of flat ice of different thicknesses, conduct model ice pool tests to obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship; (6) Simulate the impact of the ship's bow at four points on the edge of the sea ice in a numerical ice pool and obtain the ice load values; (7) Simulate the ship's operation in a numerical ice pool under the same conditions as in steps (4) and (6) on smooth ice, and obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship accordingly. (8) Compare the ice load value obtained in step (3) with the ice load value obtained in step (6) to confirm whether the error is within 20%; (9) Compare the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (4) with the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (7) to confirm whether the error is within 20%. (10) Compare the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (5) with the average ice resistance of the whole ship obtained in step (7) to confirm whether the error is within 20%. (11) If any error exceeds 20%, adjust the discrete element parameters of sea ice; Repeat steps (2)-(11) until all errors are within 20%; (12) Analyze the navigation conditions and probability distribution of HDL vessels in ice zones; (13) Simulate each navigation condition using a numerical ice pool to obtain the acceleration time history curves of the HDL device at the required position for each condition; (14) Convert the acceleration time history curve into an acceleration spectrum that can be used for fatigue analysis of the HDL device; (15) Establish the finite element model of the HDL device; (16) Load the acceleration spectrum obtained in step 14 and perform fatigue analysis; (17) Compare the fatigue analysis results with the designed fatigue life; (18) Based on the analysis results, optimize the design and modify the model for areas that do not meet the design requirements, and repeat steps (16)-(17) until all analysis results meet the design requirements.

2. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: The sea ice unit bonding-fragmentation model in step 2 is used to simulate the coupled motion state of ship, water and ice when a ship is sailing in a sea ice environment. The sea ice discrete element model simulates the bonding force between units by using an elastic force model caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation, and establishes the bonding force failure criterion between units based on normal tensile strength and tangential bonding strength.

3. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: The bonding force of the sea ice unit in step 2 adopts an elastic force model caused by normal and tangential elastic deformation; the failure criterion of the sea ice unit is expressed as σmax < σb or τmax < τb, where σb is the normal tensile strength and τb is the tangential bonding strength.

4. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: In step 3, the ice load values ​​at the four collision points 3 of the bow structure of the ship are calculated according to the POLAR CLASS standard issued by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS). The sea ice thickness is established in a numerical ice pool to match the ice thickness. The impact angle of the four collision points of the selected bow on the edge of the flat sea ice is calculated according to the standard. The ice load values ​​at each point are obtained and compared with the results calculated according to the standard to verify whether the error is below 20%. Select more than two different sets of sea ice environment parameters and ship speed, and calculate the average ice resistance of the entire ship according to the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance. Establish several operating conditions consistent with these conditions in a numerical ice pool, obtain the average ice resistance of the entire ship under each condition, and compare it with the average ice resistance obtained by the semi-empirical formula to verify whether the error is below 20%.

5. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: Step 4, the ice leveling conditions, includes at least the designed ice thickness condition and one or more other ice thickness conditions.

6. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: In step 4, the semi-empirical formula for ice resistance adopts either the Lindqvist formula or the Riska formula.

7. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: In step 9, the average ice resistance of the entire ship under several working conditions is obtained through model ice pool tests; several working conditions consistent with these conditions are established in the numerical ice pool, the average ice resistance of the entire ship under each working condition is obtained, and the average ice resistance is compared with the average ice resistance obtained from the model ice pool tests to verify whether the error is below 20%. If all the above verification errors are below 20%, it proves that the established numerical ice pool has extremely high reliability and the results calculated through the ice pool have extremely high accuracy. If the above verification error exceeds 20%, the sea ice parameters need to be adjusted, the sea ice unit bonding-failure model needs to be reconstructed, and the comparative verification needs to be carried out again until all verification errors are below 20%.

8. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: In step 12, the number and probability distribution of different navigation conditions encountered by nuclear-powered ships are determined by analyzing their operation plans and routes; the acceleration time history curves of the target positions of the nuclear power plants under each condition are obtained by simulating the aforementioned conditions in a numerical ice pool.

9. The method for ice-induced fatigue analysis of marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: The required locations for the HDL device in step 13 include the device's center of gravity, the geometric center of the containment, the perimeter of the containment, and the points where the straight line connecting the center of the containment and the perimeter is divided at regular intervals.

10. The method for analyzing ice-induced fatigue in marine nuclear power plants as described in claim 1, characterized in that: In step 14, the acceleration time history curve is converted into a constant amplitude or variable amplitude acceleration spectrum using the rainflow counting method; the acceleration time history curve is converted into an acceleration spectrum that can be used for fatigue analysis of nuclear power plants; and the acceleration time history curve is converted into a variable amplitude or constant amplitude acceleration spectrum using the rainflow counting method.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Automobile cantilever structure part vibration fatigue analysis method

    CN109029884A

  • Satellite transportation environment low-frequency fatigue analysis method based on acceleration response

    CN114659738A