Operation optimization of industrial steam and power utility systems

By using a computer system to verify the quality and energy balance, the problem of real-time data accuracy in industrial steam and power utility systems was solved, system optimization and efficiency improvement were achieved, and carbon dioxide emissions were reduced.

CN118891431APending Publication Date: 2024-11-01SAUDI ARABIAN OIL CO
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202380026109.X
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-03-10
Filing Date
2023-03-07
Publication Date
2024-11-01

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In industrial steam and power utility systems, issues arise regarding the accuracy of real-time data due to missing instruments or uncalibrated measurement results, which impact system optimization and efficiency improvement.

Method used

Using computer-implemented methods, real-time operational data and thermodynamic properties are utilized to verify mass and energy balance at the equipment and system levels, adjust operational physical parameters to optimize system performance, and provide real-time closed-loop optimization suggestions.

Benefits of technology

It achieves improved system efficiency and reduced carbon dioxide emissions at low cost, provides reliable and accurate operational recommendations, solves the problem of real-time data accuracy, and optimizes the operation of steam and power systems.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118891431A_ABST
    Figure CN118891431A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Operational optimization of an industrial plant implementing a steam and power system and including a plurality of equipment including a cogeneration system and a steam turbine includes, for each equipment, a computer system receiving, during operation of each equipment, a measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation. The computer system uses the received operational physical parameter values to determine mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment. The computer system uses the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters to verify the operation of the equipment. After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for all equipment, the computer system determines mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant using the parameters of each equipment. The computer system verifies operation of the plant using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] Priority declaration

[0002] This application claims priority to U.S. patent application No. 17 / 691,747, filed on March 10, 2022, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. Technical Field

[0003] The present disclosure relates to computer-implemented methods, computer-readable media, and computer systems for implementing energy management, particularly energy management of industrial steam power and utility systems. Background Art

[0004] In industrial operations (e.g., industrial steam power and utility systems), different types of processes consume multiple steam levels, electricity, and other forms of energy to obtain output results or produce desired products or compounds. For large-scale processes that consume large amounts of steam, energy consumption can be optimized through careful operation, design, or reconfiguration of the plant and the equipment used to improve efficiency. Accurate and timely measurement of the operating parameters of each piece of equipment in the plant can achieve this optimization. Summary of the invention

[0005] The present disclosure describes computer-implemented methods, computer-readable media, and computer systems that can optimize the operation of industrial steam and power utility systems.

[0006] Certain aspects of the subject matter described herein can be implemented as a computer-implemented method. The method is implemented in an industrial plant that implements a steam and power system. The industrial plant includes multiple equipments including a cogeneration system and a steam turbine. For each equipment, a computer system receives a measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation during operation of each equipment. The computer system uses the received operational physical parameter value to determine the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment. The computer system uses the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters to verify the operation of the equipment. After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for all equipment, the computer system uses the parameters of each equipment to determine the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant. The computer system uses the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to verify the operation of the plant.

[0007] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features. For each equipment, verifying operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters is implemented as a level in a multi-level verification process. The multi-level verification process includes verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment.

[0008] Aspects combinable with any other aspect include the following features.The multi-level verification process includes comparing each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment with stored historical data including historical measured operational physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment.

[0009] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features. The multi-level verification process includes: based on the result of verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within the threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment, and based on comparing each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment with stored historical data including historical measured operational physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment, classifying each measured operational physical parameter value as a value that accurately represents the operational stage of the equipment or a value that relatively inaccurately represents the operational state of the equipment.

[0010] An aspect that may be combined with any other aspect includes the following features. Verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment is a first level in the multi-level verification process. Classifying each measured operational physical parameter value is a last level in the multi-level verification process.

[0011] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features. To verify the operation of the industrial plant using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant, determine that the industrial plant is operating outside of threshold parameters associated with the industrial plant using the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant. In response to determining that the industrial plant is operating outside of the threshold parameters, determine a level to which a physical process input to one or more equipment is to be modified in order to cause the industrial plant to operate within the threshold parameters. Transmit instructions to modify the operation of the physical process to the determined level.

[0012] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features: The physical process is a flow of steam to one or more of the plurality of equipments. The level to which the physical process is to be modified includes changing a flow rate of steam to the equipment.

[0013] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features. For each equipment, results of verifying the operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters are displayed in a user interface displayed on a computer monitor operably connected to the computer system. Results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are displayed on the computer monitor.

[0014] Aspects that may be combined with any other aspect include the following features. Verifying the operation of each of the plurality of equipment and verifying the operation of the industrial plant are performed at a certain frequency. The displayed results of verifying the operation of the equipment and the displayed results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant are updated on the computer monitor at the frequency.

[0015] Certain aspects of the subject matter described herein may be implemented as a computer-readable medium (e.g., a non-transitory computer-readable medium) storing instructions that can be executed by one or more computers or computer systems to perform the methods described herein. Certain aspects of the subject matter described herein may be implemented as a computer system (including one or more computers or computer systems) and a computer-readable storage medium (e.g., a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium) storing computer instructions that can be executed by the one or more computers or computer systems to perform the operations described herein.

[0016] The details of one or more embodiments of the subject matter described in this specification are set forth in the following drawings and the description. Other features, aspects, and advantages of the subject matter will become apparent from the description, drawings, and claims. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017] Figure 1 It is a schematic representation of an industrial steam power and utility system operating multiple equipment.

[0018] Figure 2 is a schematic representation of a user interface displayed on a computer monitor.

[0019] Figure 3 is a schematic representation of the optimization operations performed by a computer system on an industrial steam power and utility system.

[0020] Figure 4 is a workflow illustrating an example data validation procedure for equipment in industrial steam power and utility systems.

[0021] Figure 5 is a workflow illustrating an example heat exchanger data validation procedure.

[0022] Figure 6 is a workflow illustrating an example CHP data validation procedure.

[0023] Figure 7 is a workflow illustrating an example boiler data validation procedure.

[0024] Figure 8 is a workflow illustrating an example process heater data validation procedure.

[0025] Fig. 9 is a diagram showing the workflow of the data validation procedure for mechanical drives and generators.

[0026] Fig.10 is a diagram showing the workflow of the electric pump / compressor data validation procedure.

[0027] Fig.11 is a diagram showing the workflow of the gas turbine data validation procedure.

[0028] Fig.12 is a flow chart of an example of a data validation and optimization method for an industrial steam power and utility system.

[0029] Fig.13 is a block diagram of an example computer system for providing the computing functionality associated with the algorithms, methods, functions, processes, procedures, and programs described in this disclosure.

[0030] Like reference numbers and designations throughout the various drawings indicate like elements. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0031] The present disclosure describes a real-time advisory system for industrial steam and power utility systems. Optimal operation of such industrial steam and power utility systems helps reduce operating costs, improve operating efficiency, and reduce carbon dioxide emissions. One challenge faced when implementing such an advisory system is the accuracy of real-time data due to missing instruments or uncalibrated measurements. The present disclosure describes techniques for overcoming challenges by implementing an advisory system even in the absence of instruments or incorrect / improper calibration of measurements. To this end, the present disclosure describes techniques for using real-time operating data, thermodynamic properties, and energy correlations of equipment representing industrial steam and power utility systems.

[0032] By first considering constraints such as reaching material balance and energy balance at the equipment level and then at the system level, the present disclosure describes basic case operation and optimized case operation. In these operations, the operating physical parameter values ​​received from each equipment and the corresponding values ​​of the entire system are compared with the maximum and minimum operating limits and steam and power reserve requirements. The comparison results are used to verify the equipment and system. The results are also used to adjust the operating physical parameters of the equipment to optimize the performance and operation of each equipment and the performance and operation of industrial power and utility systems. The user interface displayed on the computer monitor is presented to the user (e.g., a factory or equipment operator) in real time, so as to allow the user to adjust the operating physical parameters. In some cases, the measurement results and the comparison results can be used to automatically adjust the operating physical parameters (e.g., by transmitting computer instructions to the equipment) without human intervention.

[0033] The techniques described in the present disclosure may be implemented to achieve one or more of the following advantages. The techniques represent a simple but accurate real-time advisory model that can provide meaningful recommendations with potential benefits. Implementing these techniques can provide operating set points to plant operators even if the plant has limitations in key measurements. The techniques described herein achieve heat and mass balances for steam without requiring a full set of measurements. The techniques provide real-time closed-loop optimization that is inexpensive, reliable, and accurate. The methods utilized by these techniques address metering and measurement issues for industrial steam and power utility systems, provide recommended actions to achieve energy savings, improve system efficiency, and reduce CO2, and in some cases, implement these recommended actions without human intervention.

[0034] Figure 1 is a schematic representation of an industrial steam power and utility system 100 (sometimes referred to as an "industrial plant") that operates a plurality of equipment including, for example, a combined heat and power unit 102a, a steam turbine 102b, a boiler 102c, etc. The following list shows Figure 1 Description of the abbreviations shown in .

[0035] BFW: boiler feed water flow

[0036] BD: Discharge flow

[0037] CC: Discharge Concentration Cycle

[0038] STM: Steam Flow

[0039] H_: Enthalpy

[0040] HHV: High Heating Value of Fuel

[0041] SF: Supplementary combustion flow

[0042] GT_load: Gas turbine load %

[0043] W_rated_adj: Degradation factor of gas turbine power output

[0044] S_eff: Steam turbine isentropic efficiency

[0045] MAX_W: Maximum power output when S_eff = 100%

[0046] W: is the actual power of the equipment (i.e., cogeneration, steam turbine, etc.)

[0047] H_OUT: Enthalpy output

[0048] H_IN: Inlet enthalpy

[0049] H_ise: isentropic enthalpy

[0050] H_OUT_M: Enthalpy output of MP extraction stage

[0051] H_OUT_L: Enthalpy output of LP extraction stage

[0052] H_OUT_C: Enthalpy output of the condensing stage

[0053] X_C: Steam quality of the existing steam turbine condensing stage

[0054] P_OUT_C: Steam pressure at the condensing stage

[0055] CR: Process condensate return factor

[0056] Each equipment implements one or more processes, and system 100 implements all equipment together to convert steam into energy. While implementing one or more processes, each equipment outputs an operational physical parameter value. For example, the operational physical parameter may include the temperature, pressure, flow rate or similar parameters experienced by the equipment. The operational physical parameter is a value representing a corresponding parameter, for example, a temperature value, a pressure value, a flow rate value. A plurality of sensors (not shown) may be operably coupled to each equipment to measure the operational physical parameter. A sensor (e.g., a thermocouple for sensing a temperature value, a pressure gauge for sensing a pressure value, a flow meter for sensing a flow rate value, and similar sensors) may transform the sensed physical parameter into a digital signal, which is then transmitted to a destination.

[0057] In some embodiments, the system 100 is operably coupled to a computer system 104 that includes one or more data processing devices 106a (e.g., one or more data processors) and a computer readable medium 106b (e.g., a non-transitory computer readable medium) that stores computer instructions that can be executed by the one or more data processing devices 106a to perform the operations described herein. For each equipment in the system 100, the computer system 104 receives an operational physical parameter value measured by a sensor mounted on the equipment during operation of the equipment. For example, the computer system 104 receives a digital signal representing a sensed operational physical parameter value measured by the sensor. The computer system 104 can store the received signal to implement the processing described below.

[0058] In some embodiments, the computer system 104 can use the received operational physical parameter values ​​to determine mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment from which the operational physical parameter values ​​were received. Using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters, the computer system 104 can verify the operation of the equipment. Such verification can include comparing the mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for the equipment with threshold mass balance and energy balance parameters. If the comparison indicates that the threshold parameters are met, then the operation of the equipment is verified to be in compliance with the requirements. Conversely, if the comparison indicates that the threshold parameters are not met, then the operation of the equipment is verified to be in compliance with the requirements. Determining such parameters includes processing the received values, as described below with reference to Figures 4 to 12 In this manner, the computer system 104 can perform verification operations on each device in the system 100 .

[0059] In some embodiments, after verifying the operation of each device in the system 100 using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for each device, the computer system 104 can verify the operation of the entire system 100. To this end, the computer system 104 can use the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with each device to determine the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the system 100. Using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for the system 100, the computer system 104 can verify the operation of the entire system 100. This verification may include comparing the mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for the system 100 with the system-wide threshold mass balance and energy balance parameters. If the comparison results indicate that the threshold parameters are met, the operation of the system 100 is verified to meet the requirements. Conversely, if the results indicate that the threshold parameters are not met, the operation of the system 100 is verified to meet the requirements.

[0060] In some implementations, the computer system 104 is operably coupled to a computer monitor 108. Real-time output of the determination and validation operations may be displayed in the computer monitor 108. Figure 2 is a schematic representation of the user interface 200 displayed on the computer monitor 108. The "Current Operation Summary" section discloses the program for running the online optimization system. The program can be automatically run at a certain frequency, for example, once an hour. The "System Efficiency" section shows the supply side thermal efficiency under actual operation and optimization. The "Cogeneration Load" section shows the load of the cogeneration system (actual operation and optimization). The "Boiler Load" section shows the load of the boiler system (actual operation and optimization). The "Energy KPI" section shows the energy intensity KPI (key performance indicator) under actual operation and optimization. The "Operating Cost" section shows the operating cost under actual operation and optimization. The "CO2 Emissions" section shows the carbon dioxide emissions under actual operation and optimization.

[0061] Figure 3 is a schematic representation of optimization operations performed by computer system 104 on system 100 . Figure 3 It is shown that these optimization operations are cyclic. For example, at step 302, the computer system 104 implements data validation operations at the equipment level. The computer system 104 performs step 302 for each equipment in the system 100. In some embodiments, the computer system 104 can implement data validation operations in parallel for all equipment. At step 304, after implementing data validation operations for all equipment in the system 100, the computer system 104 coordinates the basic situation operations of each equipment. At step 306, the computer system 104 implements mass balance and energy balance for the entire system 100. Optionally, at step 308, the computer system 104 implements optimization and uses the results of the previous steps to identify the consulting optimal set point of the entire system 100. At step 310, the computer system 104 displays the results of executing the previous steps, including any output and trend, for example in the computer monitor 108.

[0062] At step 312, the computer system 104 repeats the loop of steps 302, 304, 306, 308, and 310. In some embodiments, the computer system 104 may repeat the loop at a certain frequency, such as once every hour, or once every different duration that may vary in response to user input. In this way, the computer system 104 can periodically monitor the system 100 at both the equipment level and the system-wide level, implement verification and optimization measures, and provide verification and optimization output for display in the user interface. Reference Figures 4 to 11 An example of verification is described.

[0063] Figure 4 1 is a workflow of an example data validation program 400 for equipment in industrial steam power and utility systems. The data validation program 400 is a general program applicable to any equipment used or that can be used in the system 100. The program 400 includes a plurality of operations, each of which can be implemented at least in part by the computer system 104. To this end, the computer executable code can be stored in a computer readable medium 106b and executed by a data processing device 106a. When implementing the operation, the computer system 104 receives an operational physical parameter value from the equipment and compares the received value with a threshold value associated with the equipment. In some embodiments, the computer system 104 can process the received value to determine mass balance and energy balance parameters, and compare the determined parameters with threshold parameters.

[0064] In addition, program 400 can be implemented in multiple levels arranged in a hierarchical structure. Example program 400 includes three levels--first level 402, second level 404 and third level 406. Some programs can have more levels, while other programs can have fewer levels. First level 402 can represent the root level, and the last level (e.g., third level 406) can represent the leaf level without or with the middle level (e.g., second level 404). In operation, computer system 104 can first implement the root level, and then implement subsequent levels along the hierarchy until the leaf level. For each level (except the leaf level), computer system 104 can determine the output and use the determined output as the input of the next lower level in the hierarchy.

[0065] For example, the computer system 104 can implement step 410 in the first level 402 to extract status data for each equipment. The status data is received from sensors installed to the equipment. For example, the status data is a DCS tag that provides the on / off status of the equipment. In the context of the present disclosure, a "generator" is a steam generating equipment, such as a boiler, a cogeneration system, or a process heater with a convection section, which produces steam connected to a steam header. In the context of the present disclosure, a "user" is a steam consuming equipment, such as a heat exchanger or a reboiler.

[0066] At 412, the computer system 104 verifies whether the user / generator is running. If the computer system 104 determines that the user / generator is not running (decision branch "no"), the computer system 104 reports the stream flow rate as zero and the verification procedure ends. If the computer system 104 determines that the user / generator is running (decision branch "yes"), then at 416, the computer system extracts the steam flow value. The steam flow value and all other values ​​are extracted from a data historian system called a process interface (PI) system, which collects all information from the DCS in real time.

[0067] At this point, the implementation of the first level 402 has been completed. The computer system 104 passes the extracted steam flow value to the second level 404 as input.

[0068] The computer system 104 can implement step 418 in the second level to check whether the received steam flow value is within a threshold range (i.e., maximum and minimum limits). If the computer system 104 determines that the value is not within the threshold range (decision branch "no"), the computer system 104 implements user correlations to quantify the relationship of the steam flow to a function of the process area feed rate (if applicable). The correlation equations are an alternative way to provide more accurate steam consumption values ​​for steam flows that have incorrect readings (e.g., due to incorrect DCS tags or incorrect sensors attached to the equipment or both). These correlations are developed based on historical trends of key parameters that have a direct impact on steam consumption. These correlations are developed externally to the system and are revised from time to time to more accurately represent the equipment and its performance.

[0069] If the computer system 104 determines that the value is within the threshold range (decision branch "yes"), the computer system 104 uses the value extracted from the PI. The procedure involves three categories - Class A, Class B, and Class C. Class A is the classification class that distinguishes accurate measurements from other measurements. Values ​​in Class A are credible values ​​and minimal adjustments will be made to achieve the energy and material balance of the steam header.

[0070] Returning to the decision branch "No", after implementing the user correlation at step 420, the computer system 104 checks whether the value is within the threshold range (i.e., maximum and minimum limits). If the computer system 104 determines that the value is not within the threshold range (decision branch "No"), then at step 430, the computer system 104 uses the steam flow design value or the user-defined default value. Class C is a category class that distinguishes accurate measurements from other measurements. The values ​​in Class C are given values ​​(i.e., default values, common averages suggested by experience users), where the design value is the value mentioned in the design document for this particular user. Both values ​​are not credible values, and significant adjustments will be made compared to Class A to achieve the energy and material balance of the steam header.

[0071] If at step 420, the computer system 104 determines that the value is within the threshold range (decision branch "yes"), the computer system 104 uses the relevant steam flow value. Class B is a classification class that distinguishes accurate measurements from other measurements. The values ​​in Class B are relatively more accurate values ​​compared to Class C. The values ​​will be slightly adjusted to achieve the energy and material balance of the steam header. The optimization technology will adjust the boundary limits of Class A, Class B, and Class C in a consistent manner as needed to ensure that the energy and material balance is always achieved.

[0072] In this manner, if the computer system 104 determines that the operating physical parameter value received from the sensor attached to the equipment in the system 100 is accurate, the computer system 104 uses the value in subsequent mass balance and energy balance determinations. If not, the computer system 104 performs correlation operations to determine the closest approximation of the sensor value, and uses the associated value in the mass balance and energy balance determinations. Moving to step 428, the computer system 104 reflects the steam values ​​in the steam table, i.e., stores the values ​​in the steam balance database portion along with a specific timestamp identifying when the value was determined.

[0073] The computer system 104 outputs the steam value with a classification (Class A - trusted value requiring no adjustment; Class B - good value requiring minimal adjustment; Class C - default value requiring some adjustment).

[0074] The computer system 104 can implement step 432 in the third level 406 to report the steam value received as the output of the second level 404. In some embodiments, the computer system 104 can associate a weight with the value based on the class associated with the received value. Because the Class A value is credible, the weight can be 1. Because the Class B value is relatively untrustworthy, the weight can be less than 1. Because the credibility of the Class B value is between the credibility of the Class A value and the Class C value, its weight can be between the weight of the Class A value and the weight of the Class C value. The computer system 104 can output the steam value, its classification, and optionally its weight as the output of the verification program 400. As previously described, the optimization technique will adjust the boundary limits of Class A, Class B, and Class C in a consistent manner as needed to ensure that energy and material balances are always achieved.

[0075] Figures 5 to 12 4 is a flowchart illustrating example data validation procedures for heat exchangers, cogeneration systems, boilers, process heaters, mechanical drives and generators, electric pumps / compressors, and gas turbines, respectively. Each data validation procedure is substantially similar to data validation procedure 400. Although data validation procedure 400 is common to any equipment in system 100, Figures 5 to 12 Each data verification procedure shown in is implemented with reference to a specific device.

[0076] For example, Figure 55 is a workflow of an example data validation procedure 500 for a heat exchanger. Heat exchanger steam users include all facility reboilers and process heaters connected to different steam headers. The heat exchanger steam consumption data validation procedure 500 (HX-DVR) includes three validation and coordination levels. At the first level 502, the exchanger is checked to be online or offline by the process stream outlet temperature. The temperature limit that the exchanger is considered to be in is based on design data or historical data or a combination of both. If the temperature is below the set limit and the steam flow of the exchanger is reflected as zero, the steam flow reading from the PI is not considered. At the second level 504, the extracted steam flow reading is refined by minimum and maximum limits. At level 504, the limits are set based on the steam flow design data of the exchanger. If the data extracted from the PI is within the set limits, the PI value reading is reflected in the steam table with classification A. If the PI reading exceeds the minimum and maximum limits, the relevant steam flow reading based on historical data is used. If the relevant value is within the minimum and maximum limits, the value is reflected in the steam table with classification B. At the end of the validation procedure, if the associated value is not within the minimum and maximum limits, the steam flow reading is designed to use category C. The third validation level 506 is used to ensure that the reported values ​​in the steam table are balanced and the steam flow value is adjusted based on its classification as Category A - a trusted value that does not require adjustment; Category B - a good value that requires minimal adjustment; Category C - a default value that requires some adjustment. For any PI reading of a heat exchange specific operating parameter value received from a sensor (e.g., implemented as a distributed control system), regardless of the issues associated with the subject PI value, there is always a reliable value representing that specific operating physical parameter as the output of the data validation procedure 500, thereby ensuring as reliable a system as possible with accurate results.

[0077] Figure 6 is a workflow illustrating an example combined heat and power data validation procedure 600 for a combined heat and power system. The combined heat and power data validation procedure 600 (CGN-DVR) forms part of an online CHP model (i.e., combined heat and power system model) of an industrial plant, which is an optimization model developed to represent the steam and power systems of an industrial facility.

[0078] The verification procedure 600 includes three data verification and coordination levels. Key measurements from the DCS related to the cogeneration system are used as input to determine the current operating conditions of the cogeneration equipment (such as gas turbines and heat recovery steam generators (HRSG)). In the first level 602, the status of the gas turbine is checked to see whether it is online or offline. The power generation and steam flow of the HRSG can be used to check whether the cogeneration system is operational. The power and steam limits of the cogeneration system under the condition of being considered online are usually based on design data or historical data or a combination of the two. On the other hand, if the temperature is below the set limit and the steam flow of the HRSG is reflected as zero, the steam flow reading from the PI is not considered. At the second level 602, the interrelated variables are coordinated to ensure that the error of the measured and coordinated parameters is within 2%. The extracted power, steam flow, fuel flow and stack temperature values ​​are limited to reasonable lower and upper limits. If the data extracted from the PI is within the set limits, the PI value reading is reflected in the model. If the PI reading is outside the minimum and maximum limits, then the relevant value based on historical data is used. If the relevant value is within the minimum and maximum limits, then the value is reflected in the model. At the end of the verification process 600, if the relevant value is not within the minimum and maximum limits, then the design data is used. The third (and final) verification level 606 ensures that the values ​​reported in the model achieve balance.

[0079] Figure 7 is a workflow illustrating an example boiler data validation procedure 700. For boiler data validation and reconciliation, PI raw data of boiler steam, BFW flow, fuel flow, and stack temperature are received. A validation step is implemented to identify whether the boiler is running. This step is based on whether the flue gas (stack) temperature is below 150°F. If so, the boiler is shut down and the reported flow is zero. If the boiler is running, another cross-check is performed based on steam, fuel flow, and BFW flow and boiler efficiency. If the boiler efficiency determined based on the heat input / output method is greater than 90%, the boiler efficiency is calculated using the related equation (below), and the fuel value is adjusted accordingly. If the efficiency is within the range, the fuel consumption is verified based on the expected value and the actual value. If the error is within 2%, the fuel value is used as is or adjusted to within 2% error. The inputs to the boiler efficiency related equation are stack temperature (Stack Temp, °F) and excess oxygen (Excess O2, %). Both are collected from PI data. The relevant parameters (AO2, BO2, AT, BT) are generated for each specific boiler and updated periodically, for example, once a year or once every different duration.

[0080] Eff=(AO2*Excess O2+BO2)*(1-AT*Stack Temp)+BT*Stack Temp

[0081] Figure 8 is a workflow illustrating an example process heater data validation procedure 800. The validation procedure 800 (PH-DVR) is part of an online CHP model of an industrial plant 100. The process heater may be in the form of a furnace or a waste heat boiler. For the unit, PI data for the generated steam, BFW flow, fuel flow, and stack temperature are extracted. Then, a validation step is implemented to identify whether the boiler is running. This step is based on whether the flue gas (stack) temperature is below 150°F. If so, the process heater is turned off and the reported flow is zero. If the process heater is running, another cross-check is performed based on the steam, fuel flow, and BFW flow and boiler efficiency. If the boiler efficiency determined based on the heat input / output method is greater than 90%, the boiler efficiency is calculated using the relevant equation (below), and the fuel value is adjusted accordingly. If the efficiency is within range, the fuel consumption is verified based on the expected value and the actual value. If the error is within 2%, the fuel value is used as is or adjusted to within 2% error. The inputs to the boiler efficiency related equations are stack temperature (Stack Temp, °F) and excess oxygen (Excess O2, %). Both are collected from PI data. The related parameters (AO2, BO2, AT, BT) are generated for each specific boiler and updated periodically, for example, once a year or once every different duration.

[0082] Eff=(AO2*Excess O2+BO2)*(1-AT*Stack Temp)+BT*Stack Temp

[0083] Fig. 9900 for mechanical drives and generators. The data validation procedure 900 (ST-DVR) covers mechanically driven equipment, such as compressors, pumps, blowers, etc. Such turbines are typically operated at a speed relative to the driven process equipment. For mechanical drives and generators, PI data for each stage of the steam turbine (i.e., entry, extraction, intake, etc.), RPM, and the driven process stream flow rate are retrieved. Then, a validation step is performed to identify whether the unit is running. This is based on whether the RPM is less than the design operating range. If the mechanical drive and generator are running, another cross-check is performed based on the steam flow rate. The steam turbine efficiency is based on actual operation and isentropic operation extracted from the steam temperature of the turbine. If there is a steam flow PI tag for the steam delivered to the steam turbine and the value is within the minimum and maximum range, the value will be used on the model. If there is no steam reading or the reading is outside the minimum and maximum range, a correlation is used to quantify the expected steam consumption based on the process parameters related to the steam turbine, or the design value is used. The value is then subjected to a data coordination layer change within an acceptable range.

[0084] Fig.10 1 is a flowchart of an electric pump / compressor data validation program 1000. The motor includes all facility motors that drive all pumps and compressors. The data validation program 1000 (MT-DVR) includes three validation and coordination levels. In the first level 1002, the state of the motor is extracted from the PI to check whether the motor is on or off. If the motor is off, the power consumption of the motor is considered to be zero. If the motor is on, the second validation level 1004 is implemented. In the second level 1004, a check is performed to see if there is an available power consumption PI tag. If there is an available motor power consumption PI tag, the power consumption data is extracted from the PI system. If the motor power consumption PI tag is not available, the power consumption of the motor is determined based on other process parameters of the pump (e.g., differential pressure, flow, temperature difference, specific gravity, etc.). In the last validation level 1006, if the determined value is not within the design limit due to an erroneous reading of one of the other used process parameters, the power consumption design rate of the motor is used as the user default value.

[0085] Fig.111 is a flow chart showing the workflow of the gas turbine data validation program 1100 (GT-DVR). The program 1100 is implemented in three data validation and coordination levels. Key measurements from the DCS associated with the simple cycle gas turbine unit are used as input to determine the current operating status of the gas turbine. In the first level 1102, the status of the gas turbine is checked to see if it is online or offline. The power generation or mechanical drive unit (e.g., pump or compressor) is used to check whether the unit is operational. The power limit when the gas turbine unit is considered to be online is usually based on design data or historical data or a combination of the two. At the second level 1104, the interrelated variables are coordinated together to ensure that the error of the measured and coordinated parameters is within 2%. The extracted power, fuel flow and stack temperature values ​​are limited to reasonable lower and upper limits. If the data extracted from the PI is within the set limits, the PI value reading is reflected in the model. If the PI reading exceeds the minimum and maximum limits, the PI value reading based on the design data or historical data or a combination of the two is used. If the relevant value is within the minimum and maximum limits, the value is reflected in the model. At the end of the validation procedure, if the relevant value is not within the minimum and maximum limits, the design value is used. The last validation level (level 1106) ensures that the values ​​reported in the model achieve balance.

[0086] Gas turbine efficiency (%) = BHP output or MW output of the driven equipment / fuel consumption of the gas turbine unit

[0087] The computer system 104 implements each of the data validation procedures described above as computer executable instructions. Subsequently, the computer system 104 performs overall steam system data reconciliation to ensure that balance is achieved in the most accurate manner possible. The computer system 104 performs steam system data validation and reconciliation to achieve balance based on the following points:

[0088] 1. PI data related to the following variables will be maintained as is to establish a base case:

[0089] a. Boiler steam output

[0090] b. Steam and electricity generation in the combined heat and power system

[0091] c. Release steam flow

[0092] d. Excess steam flow

[0093] 2. Adjustments will be made to steam process users with PI issues or high errors and will follow the procedures identified for each equipment flow diagram.

[0094] 3. The adjustment factor of each steam user is the decision variable of the optimization layer, which aims to achieve the steam balance of the individual headers as well as the overall system.

[0095] The computer system 104 implements the problem formulation for minimizing the error and achieving balance on each other header and the entire steam system by executing the following equation: Objective Function = Minimum Header Error Subject to the following constraints:

[0096] - Keep the steam produced by the boiler constant,

[0097] - Cogeneration steam and power production unchanged,

[0098] - The discharge station flow remains unchanged,

[0099] - Equipment steam consumption will be adjusted between minimum and maximum limits based on each equipment / user specific flow chart.

[0100] In some embodiments, the computer system 104 implements an optimization layer that provides advisory recommendations to adjust the load of major equipment in the operating facility, which helps improve the efficiency of the steam and power system and reduce carbon dioxide emissions. The computer system 104 implements the optimization by executing an objective function based on variables and constraints. The objective function aims to minimize the cost of facility operation, including fuel costs, power input and output costs, and feed water and water treatment costs. The variables in the optimization include the steam and power load of the major equipment in the steam system (e.g., all the equipment for which the verification procedure is described above). The optimization is subject to several constraints representing operating constraints and equipment constraints. Examples include:

[0101] -Supply all steam and power needs of the facility,

[0102] - Steam, power, fuel and water requirements are subject to contractual agreements with third parties or joint suppliers,

[0103] - Environmental regulations or similar requirements regarding CO2 emissions,

[0104] - Energy and material balances for steam and power networks within the facility,

[0105] - Maximum and minimum output limits of equipment,

[0106] - non-negative flows in the steam distribution network,

[0107] - the amount of steam and power reserves required for the facility,

[0108] - Minimum number of operational equipment to meet reliability requirements (if applicable).

[0109] Fig.121 is a flow chart of an example of a data verification and optimization method 1200 for an industrial steam power and utility system. The method 1200 is implemented by a computer system (e.g., computer system 104) in an industrial plant (e.g., industrial plant 100) that implements a steam and power system. The industrial plant includes a plurality of equipments including a cogeneration system and a steam turbine. At 1202, for each equipment, the computer system (during the operation of each equipment) receives a measured operation physical parameter value output by the equipment during the operation of the equipment. At 1204, the computer system 104 uses the received operation physical parameter value to determine the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment. At 1206, the computer system 104 uses the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters to verify the operation of the equipment. After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for a plurality of equipments, at 1208, the computer system 104 uses the mass balance and energy balance parameters of each equipment to determine the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant. At 1210, the computer system 104 uses the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to verify the operation of the industrial plant. At 1212, the computer system 104 displays the output of the validation operation. At 1214, the computer system waits a predetermined duration (e.g., one hour, or less than or greater than one hour) and repeats steps 1202 to 1212. The validation solution implemented by the computer system 104 eliminates erroneous readings and ensures an accurate representation of the steam and power utility systems of the operating facility.

[0110] Fig.13 1 is a block diagram of an example computer system 1300 (e.g., computer system 104) for providing computing functions associated with the algorithms, methods, functions, processes, flows, and programs described in the present disclosure according to some embodiments of the present disclosure. The computer 1302 shown is intended to cover any computing device, such as a server, desktop computer, laptop / notebook computer, wireless data port, smart phone, personal data assistant (PDA), tablet computing device, or one or more processors within these devices, including physical instances, virtual instances, or both. The computer 1302 may include input devices that can accept user information, such as keypads, keyboards, and touch screens. In addition, the computer 1302 may include output devices that can transmit information associated with the operation of the computer 1302. The information may include digital data, visual data, audio information, or a combination of information. The information may be presented in a graphical user interface (UI) (or GUI).

[0111] The computer 1302 can act as a client, a network component, a server, a database, a persistence, or a component of a computer system for performing the subject matter described in the present disclosure. The computer 1302 is shown to be communicatively coupled to a network 1330. In some embodiments, one or more components of the computer 1302 can be configured to operate in different environments, including cloud-based environments, local environments, global environments, and combinations of environments.

[0112] At the highest level, the computer 1302 is an electronic computing device operable to receive, transmit, process, store, and manage data and information associated with the described subject matter. According to some embodiments, the computer 1302 may also include an application server, an email server, a web server, a cache server, a streaming data server, or a combination of servers, or be communicatively coupled to these servers.

[0113] Computer 1302 may receive a request from a client application (e.g., executing on another computer 1302) over network 1330. Computer 1302 may respond to the received request by processing the received request using a software application. Requests may also be sent to computer 1302 from internal users (e.g., from a command console), external parties (or third parties), automated applications, entities, individuals, systems, and computers.

[0114] Each component of the computer 1302 can communicate using a system bus 1303. In some embodiments, any or all components of the computer 1302 (including hardware or software components) can interface with each other or with an interface 1304 (or a combination of both) via the system bus 1303. The interface can use an application programming interface (API) 1312, a service layer 1313, or a combination of an API 1312 and a service layer 1313. The API 1312 can include specifications for routines, data structures, and object classes. The API 1312 can be independent of or dependent on a computer language. The API 1312 can refer to a complete interface, a single function, or a set of APIs.

[0115] The service layer 1313 can provide software services to the computer 1302 and other components (whether displayed or not) that are communicatively coupled to the computer 1302. All service consumers using the service layer can access the functions of the computer 1302. Software services, such as those provided by the service layer 1313, can provide reusable, defined functions by defining interfaces. For example, the interface can be software written in JAVA, C++, or a language that provides data in an extensible markup language (XML) format. Although shown as an integrated component of the computer 1302, in alternative embodiments, the API 1312 or service layer 1313 can be an independent component relative to the other components of the computer 1302 and the other components that are communicatively coupled to the computer 1302. In addition, without departing from the scope of the present disclosure, any or all parts of the API 1312 or service layer 1313 can be implemented as a child or submodule of another software module, enterprise application, or hardware module.

[0116] Computer 1302 includes interface 1304. Although Fig.13 1302 and the like. In the example embodiment of the present invention, the computer 1302 is shown as a single interface 1304, but two or more interfaces 1304 may be used depending on the specific needs, expectations, or specific implementation of the computer 1302 and the functions described. The computer 1302 can use the interface 1304 to communicate with other systems connected to the network 1330 (whether or not shown) in a distributed environment. In general, the interface 1304 may include logic encoded in software or hardware (or a combination of software and hardware) that is operable to communicate with the network 1330, or be implemented using the logic. More specifically, the interface 1304 may include software that supports one or more communication protocols associated with the communication. In this way, the network 1330 or the hardware of the interface may be operable to transmit physical signals inside and outside the computer 1302 shown.

[0117] Computer 1302 includes processor 1305. Although Fig.13 1302, two or more processors 1305 may be used depending on the particular needs, desires, or particular implementation of the computer 1302 and the functions described. In general, the processor 1305 may execute instructions and manipulate data to perform operations of the computer 1302, including operations using algorithms, methods, functions, processes, procedures, and routines as described in this disclosure.

[0118] Computer 1302 also includes a database 1306 that can store data from computer 1302 or other components connected to network 1330 (whether or not shown). For example, database 1306 can be an in-memory database, a traditional database, or a database that stores data consistent with the present disclosure. In some embodiments, database 1306 can be a combination of two or more different database types (e.g., a hybrid in-memory database and a traditional database) depending on the specific needs, desires, or specific implementation of computer 1302 and the functions described. Although in Fig.13 1302, two or more databases (of the same type, different types, or a combination of types) may be used, depending on the particular needs, desires, or particular implementation of the computer 1302 and the functionality described. Although the database 1306 is shown as an internal component of the computer 1302, in alternative implementations, the database 1306 may be external to the computer 1302.

[0119] The computer 1302 also includes a memory 13013 that can store data for the computer 1302 or a combination of components connected to the network 1330 (whether or not shown). The memory 13013 can store any data consistent with the present disclosure. In some embodiments, the memory 13013 can be a combination of two or more different types of memory (e.g., a combination of semiconductor and magnetic memory), depending on the specific needs, desires, or specific implementation of the computer 1302 and the functions described. Although in Fig.13 1302, two or more memories 13013 (of the same type, different types, or a combination of types) may be used, depending on the particular needs, desires, or particular implementation of the computer 1302 and the functionality described. Although the memory 13013 is shown as an internal component of the computer 1302, in alternative implementations, the memory 13013 may be external to the computer 1302.

[0120] The application 1308 may be an algorithmic software engine that provides functionality according to the specific needs, desires, or specific implementation of the computer 1302 and the described functionality. For example, the application 1308 may function as one or more components, modules, or applications. Further, although illustrated as a single application 1308, the application 1308 may also be implemented as multiple applications 1308 on the computer 1302. Additionally, although illustrated as being internal to the computer 1302, in alternative implementations, the application 1308 may be external to the computer 1302.

[0121] The computer 1302 may also include a power supply 1314. The power supply 1314 may include a rechargeable or non-rechargeable battery that may be configured to be user replaceable or non-user replaceable. In some embodiments, the power supply 1314 may include power conversion and management circuitry that includes recharging, standby, and power management functions. In some embodiments, the power supply 1314 may include a power plug for plugging the computer 1302 into a wall outlet or power source to, for example, power the computer 1302 or charge a rechargeable battery.

[0122] There may be any number of computers 1302 associated with or external to the computer system containing computer 1302, with each computer 1302 communicating via network 1330. Further, the terms "client," "user," and other appropriate terms may be used interchangeably as appropriate without departing from the scope of the present disclosure. Furthermore, the present disclosure contemplates that many users may use one computer 1302, and that one user may use multiple computers 1302.

[0123] For purposes of the present disclosure, the terms "real time", "real time / realtime", "rapid real time (RFT)", "near real time (NRT)", "quasi real time" or similar terms (as understood by one of ordinary skill in the art) mean that an action and a response are close in time such that an individual perceives the action and the response substantially simultaneously. For example, the time difference in a response to the display of data (or the start of display) after an individual's action to access the data may be less than 1 ms, less than 1 second, less than 5 seconds, etc. In another example, the time difference in a response to the transmission of the value (e.g., display or processing) after the measurement of the measured value may be less than 1 ms, less than 1 second, less than 5 seconds, etc. Although the requested data does not necessarily need to be displayed (or begin to be displayed) or the operation does not necessarily need to be performed immediately, given the processing limitations of the described computing systems and, for example, the time required to collect, accurately measure, analyze, process, store, or transmit (or a combination of these or other functions) the data, the requested data is displayed (or begin to be displayed) or the operation is performed without any intentional delay.

[0124] Although this specification contains many specific implementation details, these should not be interpreted as limitations on the scope of any invention or what may be claimed, but rather as descriptions of features specific to specific embodiments of specific inventions. Certain features described in this specification in the context of separate embodiments may also be implemented in combination in a single embodiment. Conversely, different features described in the context of a single embodiment may also be implemented in multiple embodiments individually or in any suitable sub-combination. In addition, although the features described above may be described as working in certain combinations and even initially claimed as such, in some cases, one or more features from the claimed combination may be removed from the combination, and the claimed combination may involve sub-combinations or variations of sub-combinations.

[0125] Similarly, although the operations are depicted in a specific order in the accompanying drawings, this should not be understood as requiring such operations to be performed in the specific order shown or in an ordered order, or requiring all displayed operations to be performed to achieve the desired results. In some cases, multitasking and parallel processing may be advantageous. In addition, the separation of the various system components in the embodiments described above should not be understood as requiring such separation in all embodiments, but should be understood as the described program components and systems can generally be integrated together in a single software product or packaged into multiple software products.

[0126] Thus, particular embodiments of the subject matter have been described. Other embodiments are within the scope of the following claims. In some cases, the actions recited in the claims can be performed in a different order and still achieve the desired results. Furthermore, the processes depicted in the accompanying drawings do not necessarily require the particular order shown or sequential order to achieve the desired results. In certain embodiments, multitasking and parallel processing may be advantageous.

Claims

1. A method comprising: In an industrial plant implementing a steam and power system, the industrial plant comprises several installations including a combined heat and power system and a steam turbine: For each device in the plurality of devices: receiving, by the computer system during operation of each piece of equipment, a measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment, determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment using the received operating physical parameter values, and verifying, by the computer system, operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters; as well as After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for the multiple equipment: determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant using the mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for each of the plurality of equipment, and The determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are used by the computer system to verify operation of the industrial plant.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein: For each of the multiple equipment, verifying the operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters is implemented as a level in a multi-level verification process, wherein the multi-level verification process further includes verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein: The multi-level verification process further includes comparing each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment to stored historical data including historical measured operational physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment.

4. The method of claim 3, wherein: The multi-level verification process further includes: based on the result of verifying that each measured operating physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within the threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment, and based on comparing each measured operating physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment with stored historical data including historical measured operating physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment, classifying each measured operating physical parameter value as a value that accurately represents the operating state of the equipment or a value that relatively inaccurately represents the operating state of the equipment.

5. The method of claim 3, wherein: Verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment is the first level in the multi-level verification process, and classifying each measured operational physical parameter value is the last level in the multi-level verification process.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein: Using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to verify the operation of the industrial plant includes: using the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to determine that the industrial plant is operating outside of threshold parameters associated with the industrial plant; In response to determining that the industrial plant is operating outside the threshold parameters, determining a level to which a physical process input to one or more of the plurality of equipment is to be modified in order to cause the industrial plant to operate within the threshold parameters; and Instructions are transmitted to modify the operation of the physical process to the determined level.

7. The method of claim 6, wherein: The physical process is a flow of steam to one or more of the plurality of equipments, wherein the level to which the physical process is to be modified includes changing a flow rate of the steam to the one or more of the plurality of equipments.

8. The method of claim 1, further comprising: for each piece of equipment in the plurality of equipment, displaying in a user interface displayed on a computer monitor operably connected to the computer system results of using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters to validate operation of the piece of equipment; and Results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are displayed on the computer monitor.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein: Verifying the operation of each of the plurality of equipment and verifying the operation of the industrial plant are performed at a frequency, wherein displayed results of verifying the operation of the equipment and displayed results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant are updated on the computer monitor at the frequency.

10. A non-transitory computer readable medium storing instructions executable by one or more computers to perform operations comprising: In an industrial plant implementing a steam and power system, the industrial plant comprises several installations including a combined heat and power system and a steam turbine: For each device in the plurality of devices: receiving, by the computer system during operation of each piece of equipment, a measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment, determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment using the received operating physical parameter values, and verifying, by the computer system, operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters; as well as After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for the multiple equipment: determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant using the mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for each of the plurality of equipment, and The determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are used by the computer system to verify operation of the industrial plant.

11. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 10, wherein: For each of the multiple equipment, verifying the operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters is implemented as a level in a multi-level verification process, wherein the multi-level verification process further includes verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment.

12. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 11, wherein: The multi-level verification process further includes comparing each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment to stored historical data including historical measured operational physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment.

13. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 12, wherein: The multi-level verification process further includes: based on the result of verifying that each measured operating physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within the threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment, and based on comparing each measured operating physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment with stored historical data including historical measured operating physical parameter values ​​output during past operation of the equipment, classifying each measured operating physical parameter value as a value that accurately represents the operating state of the equipment or a value that relatively inaccurately represents the operating state of the equipment.

14. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 12, wherein: Verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment is the first level in the multi-level verification process, and classifying each measured operational physical parameter value is the last level in the multi-level verification process.

15. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 10, wherein: Using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to verify the operation of the industrial plant includes: using the mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant to determine that the industrial plant is operating outside of threshold parameters associated with the industrial plant; In response to determining that the industrial plant is operating outside the threshold parameters, determining a level to which a physical process input to one or more of the plurality of equipment is to be modified in order to cause the industrial plant to operate within the threshold parameters; and Instructions are transmitted to modify the operation of the physical process to the determined level.

16. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 15, wherein: The physical process is a flow of steam to one or more of the plurality of equipments, wherein the level to which the physical process is to be modified includes changing a flow rate of the steam to the one or more of the plurality of equipments.

17. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 10, the operations further comprising: for each piece of equipment in the plurality of equipment, displaying in a user interface displayed on a computer monitor operably connected to the computer system results of using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters to validate operation of the piece of equipment; and Results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are displayed on the computer monitor.

18. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 17, wherein: Verifying the operation of each of the plurality of equipment and verifying the operation of the industrial plant are performed at a frequency, wherein displayed results of verifying the operation of the equipment and displayed results of verifying the operation of the industrial plant are updated on the computer monitor at the frequency.

19. A system comprising: one or more computers; as well as A computer-readable medium storing instructions executable by one or more computers to perform operations including: In an industrial plant implementing a steam and power system, the industrial plant comprises several installations including a combined heat and power system and a steam turbine: For each device in the plurality of devices: receiving, by the computer system during operation of each piece of equipment, a measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment, determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the equipment using the received operating physical parameter values, and verifying, by the computer system, operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters; as well as After verifying the mass balance and energy balance parameters for the multiple equipment: determining, by the computer system, mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant using the mass balance and energy balance parameters determined for each of the plurality of equipment, and The determined mass balance and energy balance parameters associated with the industrial plant are used by the computer system to verify operation of the industrial plant.

20. The system of claim 19, wherein: For each of the multiple equipment, verifying the operation of the equipment using the determined mass balance and energy balance parameters is implemented as a level in a multi-level verification process, wherein the multi-level verification process further includes verifying that each measured operational physical parameter value output by the equipment during operation of the equipment is within a threshold physical parameter value range associated with the equipment.