Improved FMEA method and device for improving sorting rationality through comprehensive judgment

The risk factor score in FMEA was processed through the fuzzy hierarchy method and the CRITIC method, and the importance of the failure mode was calculated, which solved the problem of unconsidered factor importance in the prior art, and achieved accurate sorting and scoring of the failure mode.

CN118964920AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-15TONGJI UNIV
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410956202.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-17
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing FMEA method fails to fully consider the relative importance among factors when rating risk factors, which makes it difficult to accurately score and sort the importance of failure modes.

Method used

The fuzzy hierarchical analysis method and CRITIC method are used to obtain comprehensive weights through the relative importance scoring data processing, calculate the performance value of the failure mode and the normalized evaluation matrix, and then calculate the most ideal and least ideal situation values, and finally according to the optimal and inferior distances Sorting the progress to get the importance of the failure mode.

Benefits of technology

Accurate scoring of the relative importance of risk factors and the importance of failure modes is achieved, which improves the accuracy of scores and the rationality of sorting.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118964920A_ABST
    Figure CN118964920A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides an improved FMEA method and device for improving sorting rationality through comprehensive judgment, and the method is characterized in that the method comprises the following steps: S1, calculating a comprehensive weight corresponding to each risk factor; s2, calculating the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor; s3, obtaining a standardized evaluation matrix according to all the performance values; s4, obtaining the most ideal condition value and the least ideal condition value corresponding to each risk factor according to the standardized evaluation matrix; s5, calculating the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each failure mode according to the comprehensive weight, the standardized evaluation matrix, the most ideal condition numerical value and the least ideal condition numerical value; s6, obtaining a pasting progress according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance; and S7, obtaining an importance degree sorting result according to the pasting progress. In a word, the method can obtain an importance degree sorting result of each failure mode.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of reliability analysis methods, and specifically relates to an improved FMEA method and device for comprehensive judgment to improve the rationality of sorting Background Art

[0002] Failure Mode and Effects Analysis, hereinafter referred to as FMEA, this concept was proposed in the 1960s and is now widely used to analyze the failure modes and effects of various systems. As an effective method of quality management, FMEA aims to discover the potential failure modes of the object, explore the causes and impacts of the failure modes, and formulate reasonable improvement plans. It defines, identifies, analyzes, improves and eliminates the failure modes of various objects such as products, processes, and systems. The analysis results of the FMEA method are used to help staff identify and correct failure modes that have an adverse effect on the system, explore improvement possibilities in the early stages of system and product development, reduce the losses and repair costs that may be caused by failure modes, and effectively improve the efficiency of system development and application.

[0003] The FMEA method improves the safety and reliability of the entire system by monitoring and preventing failure modes that have not occurred in advance, providing a basis for decision-making for the management team and guiding information for the implementation team. Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of the principle of implementing FMEA. Figure 1 As shown in the figure, when implementing FMEA, a cross-domain expert team should first be established for the analysis object to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the problem, summarize the failure mode, and analyze the cause and impact of the analysis object in turn. After that, the team will determine the occurrence level O, the severity level S, and the detectability level D, and then perform the occurrence score, severity score, and detectability score respectively. Finally, according to the score, the risk priority number (RPN) calculation, failure mode ranking, improvement and optimization are carried out in turn, so as to implement the FMEA method.

[0004] However, the above FMEA analysis is too general and does not take into account the relative importance of various risk factors, making it difficult to accurately score risk factors. Summary of the invention

[0005] The present invention is made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and aims to provide an improved FMEA method and device for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting.

[0006] The present invention provides an improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of ranking, which is used to obtain the importance ranking results of m failure modes according to the relative importance scoring data of n risk factors by l analysts and the evaluation data of each risk factor of m failure modes. The method has the following characteristics, including the following steps: step S1, according to the fuzzy hierarchical analysis method and CRITIC (CRiteria Importance Through Intercriteria Correlation) method is used to process all relative importance score data to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each risk factor; step S2, based on all evaluation data, calculate the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor; step S3, normalize all performance values ​​to obtain a normalized evaluation matrix; step S4, based on the normalized evaluation matrix, calculate the most ideal and least ideal values ​​corresponding to each risk factor; step S5, based on the comprehensive weight, normalized evaluation matrix, the most ideal and least ideal values, calculate the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each failure mode; step S6, for each failure mode, calculate the corresponding progress according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance; step S7, sort all failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding progress, and obtain the importance sorting result, wherein the higher the ranking in the importance sorting result, the higher the importance of the corresponding failure mode.

[0007] The improved FMEA method for comprehensive judgment to improve rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein the risk factors include severity S, occurrence O, detectability D and correlation R, and the correlation R is used to describe the characteristics of mutual influence between failure modes.

[0008] In the improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention, it can also have the following characteristics: wherein, step S1 includes the following sub-steps: step S1-1, processing all relative importance score data according to the fuzzy hierarchical analysis method to obtain the subjective weight of each risk factor and the comprehensive subjective weight of each risk factor by each analyst; step S1-2, processing all subjective weights and comprehensive subjective weights according to the CRITIC method to obtain the objective weight of each risk factor; step S1-3, calculating the comprehensive weight of each risk factor according to all comprehensive subjective weights and objective weights.

[0009] In the improved FMEA method for comprehensive judgment to improve the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention, it can also have the following characteristics: wherein, step S1-1 includes the following sub-steps: step S1-1-1, converting the relative importance scores in each relative importance scoring data into corresponding fuzzy numbers to obtain a relative importance matrix; step S1-1-2, performing neutral expectation calculation on the relative importance matrix to obtain an expectation matrix; step S1-1-3, calculating the subjective fuzzy weights of each analyst for each risk factor based on the expectation matrix; step S1-1-4, for each risk factor corresponding to each analyst, calculating the expected value of the corresponding subjective fuzzy weight as the subjective weight; step S1-1-5, for each risk factor, calculating the average value of all corresponding subjective weights as the comprehensive subjective weight of the risk factor.

[0010] The improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein the expression of the relative importance matrix is: In the formula is a fuzzy number, is the relative importance matrix, The expression of the expected matrix is: In the formula is the expectation matrix, is the element in the pth row and qth column of the relative importance matrix, and the calculation expression of the subjective fuzzy weight is: In the formula is the analyst's subjective fuzzy weight for the pth risk factor, The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column N , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column L , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column P .

[0011] The improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein, in step S1-2, the calculation expression of the objective weight is: K j =S j ×R j , Where β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor, K j is the information content of the j-th risk factor, R j is the conflict of the jth risk factor, r tj is the correlation coefficient between the t-th risk factor and the j-th risk factor weight, p t is the subjective weight vector of the t-th risk factor, S j is the standard deviation of the j-th risk factor, is the comprehensive subjective weight of the j-th risk factor, p ij is the subjective weight of the i-th analyst on the j-th risk factor, Min(p j ) is the minimum value of the subjective weight corresponding to the j-th risk factor, Max(p j ) is the maximum value of the subjective weights corresponding to the j-th risk factor. In step S1-3, the calculation expression of the comprehensive weight is: Where ω j is the comprehensive weight of the j-th risk factor, α j is the comprehensive subjective weight of the j-th risk factor, β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor.

[0012] The improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein, in step S3, the expression of the normalized evaluation matrix is: A = (a ij ) m×n , Where A is the normalized evaluation matrix, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, q ij is the performance value of the i-th failure mode for the j-th risk factor.

[0013] The improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein the optimal value b of the jth risk factor is j * and the worst case value b j o The expression is:

[0014] Where i is the failure mode number, Max j (a ij ) is the maximum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, Min j (aij ) is the minimum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, where the extremely large index represents that the larger the value of the index is, the more it meets expectations, and the extremely small index represents that the smaller the value of the index is, the more it meets expectations.

[0015] The improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting provided by the present invention may also have the following characteristics: wherein the calculation expression of the optimal distance is: In the formula is the optimal distance of the ith failure mode, ω j is the comprehensive weight of the jth risk factor, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, b j * is the ideal value of the j-th risk factor, and the calculation expression of the worst distance is: In the formula is the worst distance of the ith failure mode, b j O is the worst case value of the j-th risk factor, and the calculation expression of the progress is: Where S i is the progress of the i-th failure mode.

[0016] The present invention also provides an improved FMEA device for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting, which is used to obtain the importance sorting results of m failure modes according to the relative importance score data of n risk factors and the evaluation data of each risk factor of m failure modes by l analysts, and has the following characteristics, including: a comprehensive weight calculation module, which is used to process all the relative importance score data according to the fuzzy hierarchical analysis method and the CRITIC method to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each risk factor; a performance value calculation module, which is used to calculate the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor according to all the evaluation data; a normalization module, which is used to perform normalization processing on all the performance values ​​to obtain the normalized evaluation value; The value matrix is ​​used; the numerical calculation module is used to calculate the most ideal and the most unideal values ​​corresponding to each risk factor according to the normalized evaluation matrix; the distance calculation module is used to calculate the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each failure mode according to the comprehensive weight, the normalized evaluation matrix, the most ideal and the most unideal values; the progress calculation module is used to calculate the corresponding progress of each failure mode according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance; the importance calculation module is used to sort all failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding progress, and obtain the importance sorting result, wherein the higher the ranking in the importance sorting result, the higher the importance of the corresponding failure mode.

[0017] Functions and Effects of the Invention

[0018] According to the improved FMEA method and device for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment involved in the present invention, first, the subjective weight is calculated by the comprehensive weight calculation module using the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process, and the objective weight is calculated by the CRITIC method; secondly, the fuzzy number evaluation method is performed by the performance value calculation module and the normalization module to obtain the normalized evaluation of each failure mode and each risk factor; then, the progress is obtained by weight and score calculation according to the numerical calculation module, the distance calculation module and the progress calculation module; finally, all failure modes are sorted according to the progress through the importance calculation module, so as to obtain the importance ranking results of each failure mode. Therefore, the improved FMEA method and device for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment of the present invention can consider the relative importance between each risk factor, accurately score the risk factors, and thus obtain the importance ranking results of each failure mode. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0019] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the principle of implementing FMEA;

[0020] Figure 2 is a block diagram of an improved FMEA device in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0021] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of a flow chart of ranking the importance of failure modes in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0022] In order to make the technical means, creative features, objectives and effects achieved by the present invention easy to understand, the following embodiments are combined with the accompanying drawings to specifically explain the improved FMEA method and device for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of sorting.

[0023] In this embodiment, an improved FMEA device for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of ranking is provided, hereinafter referred to as the improved FMEA device, which is used to obtain the importance ranking results of m failure modes based on the relative importance scoring data of n risk factors by l analysts and the evaluation data of each risk factor of m failure modes.

[0024] In this embodiment, the improved FMEA device is used to analyze and evaluate the Manufacturing Execution System (hereinafter referred to as MES).

[0025] In this embodiment, l=4, and the analysts include A, a senior manager of the MES informationization project, B, an MES implementation consultant, C, an MES informationization consultant, and D, a MES reliability researcher at a university.

[0026] In this embodiment, n=4, and the risk factors include severity S, occurrence O, detectability D, and correlation R. The correlation R is used to describe the characteristics of mutual influence between failure modes.

[0027] In this embodiment, MES includes 8 functional modules, namely, planning management module, logistics management module, quality management module, resource management module, data management module, interaction management module, expansion and innovation module and non-functional failure. Analysts have summarized m=27 failure modes, including errors in accepting bill of materials (BOM) drawings, errors in production resource transmission, errors in controlling order completion, errors in production planning, production scheduling and execution status cannot be fed back in time, errors in tracking different production processes, errors in reading inventory information, errors in tracking work-in-progress, errors in reading work-in-progress information, errors in transmitting material arrival information, failure to timely alarm or feedback monitoring information, errors in product process traceability, errors in product property analysis, errors in reading product information, unclear current status of equipment, unclear efficiency indicators of equipment, errors in identifying personnel capabilities, errors in processing the number of human resources, unclear material consumption, failure to implement improved noise reduction and other processing for collected data, errors in types of reports and analysis charts, errors in human-computer interaction docking, insufficient system scalability, errors in docking modules or different production line systems, equipment power risks, data security risks and natural disaster risks.

[0028] Figure 2 is a block diagram of an improved FMEA device in an embodiment of the present invention.

[0029] like Figure 2 As shown, the improved FMEA device 100 includes a comprehensive weight calculation module 10, a performance value calculation module 20, a normalization module 30, a numerical calculation module 40, a distance calculation module 50, a progress calculation module 60, an importance calculation module 70 and a control module 80 for controlling the operation of the above modules.

[0030] The comprehensive weight calculation module 10 is used to process all relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and the CRITIC method to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each risk factor. The comprehensive weight calculation module 10 includes a comprehensive subjective weight calculation unit 101, an objective weight calculation unit 102 and a comprehensive weight calculation unit 103.

[0031] The subjective weight calculation unit 101 is used to process all relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process to obtain the subjective weight of each analyst on each risk factor and the comprehensive subjective weight of each risk factor.

[0032] The subjective weight calculation unit 101 includes a relative importance matrix generation subunit 1011 , an expectation matrix generation subunit 1012 , a subjective fuzzy weight calculation subunit 1013 , a subjective weight calculation subunit 1014 and a comprehensive subjective weight calculation subunit 1015 .

[0033] The relative importance matrix generating subunit 1011 is used to convert the relative importance scores in each relative importance scoring data into corresponding fuzzy numbers to obtain a relative importance matrix.

[0034] Among them, the expression of the relative importance matrix is:

[0035]

[0036]

[0037] In the formula is a fuzzy number, is a relative importance matrix.

[0038] In this embodiment, the relative importance score data is the result of the analyst filling in the risk factor relative importance score table, and the risk factor relative importance score table is shown in Table 1.

[0039] Table 1 Risk factor relative importance score table

[0040] Risk Factors Severity Occurrence Detectability Relevance Severity 3 Occurrence —— 3 Detectability —— —— 3 Relevance —— —— —— 3

[0041] In Table 1, the first column is the risk factor, and the second to fifth columns are the relative importance scores of each risk factor compared with severity, occurrence, detectability, and association. For example, the cell in the third column of the second row represents the importance score of severity compared with occurrence. The value range of the relative importance score is [1,5].

[0042] The filling results of each analyst in this embodiment are shown in Table 2-5.

[0043] Table 2 Analyst A's rating of the relative importance of risk factors

[0044]

[0045]

[0046] Table 3 Analyst B's ratings of the relative importance of risk factors

[0047]

[0048] Table 4 Analyst C's ratings of the relative importance of risk factors

[0049]

[0050] Table 5 Analyst D's ratings of the relative importance of risk factors

[0051]

[0052]

[0053] In this embodiment, the risk factor relative importance matrix generation subunit 1011 converts the relative importance scores of the risk factors into corresponding fuzzy numbers according to the fuzzy number conversion table. The conversion standard table is shown in Table 6.

[0054] Table 6 Standard table for converting the relative importance scores of risk factors into corresponding fuzzy numbers

[0055]

[0056] In Table 6, the first column is the relative importance score of the risk factor, the second column is the meaning of each relative importance score, and the third column is the fuzzy number corresponding to each relative importance score. For example, the third row indicates that when the relative importance score is 2, it means that the corresponding horizontal factor, i.e., the risk factor in the first column of the risk factor relative importance score table, is not as important as the corresponding risk factor in the second to fifth columns of the vertical factor, and the corresponding fuzzy number is (0.2, 0.3, 0.4).

[0057] The expectation matrix generating subunit 1012 is used to perform neutral expectation calculation on the relative importance matrix to obtain the expectation matrix.

[0058] Among them, the expression of the expected matrix is:

[0059]

[0060]

[0061] In the formula is the expectation matrix, is the element in the pth row and qth column in the relative importance matrix.

[0062] In this embodiment, the subjective weight calculation unit 101 also calculates the consistency index CI of the expectation matrix, and its calculation expression is:

[0063]

[0064] Where ω i For the element The matrix of is used to obtain the eigenvector elements using the sum-product method.

[0065] The subjective weight calculation unit 101 selects the average random consistency index RI according to the number of risk factors n. If the consistency check is passed, the next step of calculation, that is, the calculation of subjective fuzzy weights, can be directly carried out. If the consistency check is not passed, the evaluation situation is analyzed in detail to determine whether to adopt the scoring result or adjust the scoring to pass the consistency check.

[0066] The subjective fuzzy weight calculation subunit 1013 is used to calculate the subjective fuzzy weight of each analyst for each risk factor according to the expectation matrix.

[0067] Among them, the calculation expression of subjective fuzzy weight is:

[0068]

[0069] In the formula is the analyst's subjective fuzzy weight for the pth risk factor, The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column N , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column L , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column P .

[0070] The subjective weight calculation subunit 1014 is used to calculate the expected value of the corresponding subjective fuzzy weight as the subjective weight for each risk factor corresponding to each analyst.

[0071] The comprehensive subjective weight calculation subunit 1015 is used to calculate the average value of all corresponding subjective weights for each risk factor as the comprehensive subjective weight of the risk factor.

[0072] The calculation results of the subjective weights of the risk factors in this embodiment are shown in Table 7.

[0073] Table 7 Calculation results of subjective weights of risk factors

[0074]

[0075] In Table 7, the first column is each risk factor, the second column is the subjective weight of each risk factor by analyst A, the third column is the subjective weight of each risk factor by analyst B, the fourth column is the subjective weight of each risk factor by analyst C, the fifth column is the subjective weight of each risk factor by analyst D, the sixth column is the comprehensive subjective weight of each risk factor, and the seventh column is the calculation result of the consistency ratio CR. For example, the cell in the second row and the second column indicates that the subjective weight of risk factor S by analyst A is 0.250.

[0076] The objective weight calculation unit 102 is used to process all subjective weights and comprehensive subjective weights according to the CRITIC method to obtain the objective weight of each risk factor.

[0077] Among them, the calculation expression of objective weight is:

[0078]

[0079] K j =S j ×R j ,

[0080]

[0081] Where β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor, K j is the information content of the j-th risk factor, R j is the conflict of the jth risk factor, r tj is the correlation coefficient between the t-th risk factor and the j-th risk factor weight, p t is the subjective weight vector of the t-th risk factor, S j is the standard deviation of the j-th risk factor, is the comprehensive subjective weight of the j-th risk factor, p ij is the subjective weight of the i-th analyst on the j-th risk factor, Min(p j ) is the minimum value of the subjective weight corresponding to the j-th risk factor, Max(p j ) is the maximum value of the subjective weights corresponding to the j-th risk factor.

[0082] In this embodiment, each analyst's standard evaluation score p′ for each risk factor ij The standard evaluation score matrix is ​​shown in Table 8.

[0083] Table 8 Standard evaluation score matrix for each risk factor by each analyst

[0084]

[0085]

[0086] The first column in Table 8 is for each analyst, and the second to fifth columns are the standard evaluation scores of severity S, occurrence O, detectability D, and relevance R by each analyst. For example, the cell in the second row and second column indicates that the standard evaluation score of severity S by analyst A is 0.00.

[0087] The standard deviation S of each risk factor in this example j That is, contrast intensity and conflict R j That is, the calculation results of conflict and objective weight are shown in Table 9.

[0088] Table 9 Comparative strength, conflict and objective weight of each risk factor

[0089] Risk Factors S O D R Contrast intensity 0.479 0.432 0.472 0.502 Conflict 3.792 3.515 4.508 3.882 Objective weight 0.245 0.205 0.287 0.263

[0090] The first row in Table 9 contains the risk factors, and the second row to the fourth column respectively contain the calculation results of contrast intensity, conflict and objective weight. For example, the cell in the second row and the second column indicates that the contrast intensity of severity S is 0.479.

[0091] The comprehensive weight calculation unit 103 is used to calculate the comprehensive weight of each risk factor according to all comprehensive subjective weights and objective weights.

[0092] Among them, the calculation expression of comprehensive weight is:

[0093]

[0094] Where ω j is the comprehensive weight of the j-th risk factor, α j is the comprehensive subjective weight of the j-th risk factor, β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor.

[0095] In this embodiment, the comprehensive weights of severity S, occurrence O, detectability D and relevance R are 0.303, 0.154, 0.197 and 0.346 respectively.

[0096] The performance value calculation module 20 is used to convert the evaluation level of each failure mode into a corresponding fuzzy number according to the evaluation level of the failure mode and the triangular fuzzy number corresponding to the evaluation level, calculate the average fuzzy number of the analyst, and calculate the expectation of the average fuzzy number. The obtained expectation is the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor.

[0097] In this embodiment, the analyst obtains evaluation data according to the failure mode scoring standard, and the failure mode scoring standard is shown in Table 10.

[0098] Table 10 Failure mode scoring criteria

[0099]

[0100] The first column in Table 10 is the evaluation data for each evaluation level, and the second to fifth columns are the standards for the corresponding evaluation levels under severity S, occurrence O, detectability D, and relevance R. For example, the cell in the second row and second column indicates that when severity S has little impact on system operation, the corresponding evaluation level is extremely low EL.

[0101] The triangular fuzzy numbers corresponding to the evaluation levels in this embodiment are shown in Table 11.

[0102] Table 11 Triangular fuzzy numbers corresponding to evaluation levels

[0103]

[0104]

[0105] The first column in Table 11 is the evaluation level, and the second column is the triangular fuzzy number corresponding to each evaluation level. For example, the cell in the second row and second column indicates that when the evaluation level is extremely low EL, the corresponding triangular fuzzy number is (0.1, 0.1, 0.2).

[0106] The normalization module 30 is used to perform normalization processing on all performance values ​​to obtain a normalized evaluation matrix.

[0107] Among them, the expression of the normalized evaluation matrix is:

[0108] A=(α ij ) m×n ,

[0109]

[0110] Where A is the normalized evaluation matrix, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, q ij is the performance value of the i-th failure mode for the j-th risk factor.

[0111] The normalized evaluation matrix composed of various failure modes in this embodiment is shown in Table 12.

[0112] Table 12 Normalized evaluation matrix of each failure mode

[0113]

[0114]

[0115] The first column in Table 12 is the number of each failure mode, and the second to fifth columns are the values ​​of the elements corresponding to each failure mode and severity S, occurrence O, detectability D and correlation R in the normalized evaluation matrix. For example, the cell in the second row and second column indicates that the value of the element corresponding to failure mode FM1 and severity S in the normalized evaluation matrix is ​​0.22.

[0116] The numerical calculation module 40 is used to calculate the optimal and the least optimal numerical values ​​corresponding to each risk factor according to the normalized evaluation matrix.

[0117] Among them, the ideal value b of the jth risk factor is j * and the worst case value b j o The expression is:

[0118]

[0119] Where i is the failure mode number, Max j (a ij ) is the maximum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, Min j (a ij ) is the minimum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, where the extremely large index represents that the larger the value of the index is, the more it meets expectations, and the extremely small index represents that the smaller the value of the index is, the more it meets expectations.

[0120] The most ideal and least ideal values ​​of each risk factor in this embodiment are shown in Table 13.

[0121] Table 13 The most ideal and least ideal values ​​of each risk factor

[0122] Risk Factors S O D R Best case scenario 0.28 0.34 0.33 0.30 Worst case 0.07 0.06 0.06 0.06

[0123] The first row in Table 13 contains the risk factors, the second row contains the best case values ​​corresponding to the risk factors, and the third row contains the worst case values ​​corresponding to the risk factors. For example, the cell in the second row and second column indicates that the best case value corresponding to the severity S is 0.28.

[0124] The distance calculation module 50 is used to calculate the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each failure mode according to the comprehensive weight, the normalized evaluation matrix, the optimal case value and the least ideal case value.

[0125] Among them, the calculation expression of the optimal distance is:

[0126]

[0127] In the formula is the optimal distance of the ith failure mode, ω j is the comprehensive weight of the jth risk factor, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, b j * is the optimal value of the j-th risk factor.

[0128] The calculation expression of the worst distance is:

[0129]

[0130] In the formula is the worst distance of the ith failure mode, b j O is the worst case value of the jth risk factor.

[0131] The progress calculation module 60 is used to calculate the corresponding progress of each failure mode according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance.

[0132] Among them, the calculation expression of the progress is:

[0133]

[0134] Where S i is the progress of the i-th failure mode.

[0135] The importance calculation module 70 is used to sort all failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding progress of posting, and obtain an importance sorting result. Among them, the higher the ranking in the importance sorting result, the higher the importance of the corresponding failure mode.

[0136] In this embodiment, the optimal distance, the worst distance, the progress and the ranking of the importance corresponding to each failure mode are shown in Table 14.

[0137] Table 14 The optimal distance, the worst distance, the progress and the ranking of each failure mode

[0138]

[0139] The first column in Table 14 is each failure mode, and the second to fifth columns are the rankings of the optimal distance, the worst distance, the progress and the importance of each failure mode. For example, the cell in the second row and the second column indicates that the optimal distance of failure mode FM1 is 0.123. In this embodiment, the ranking results were discussed by experts and verified to be in line with the actual situation. It can be seen that the ranking results can reflect the importance of each failure mode of the MES system, thereby helping the implementation of the MES system.

[0140] The control module 80 is used to store the control program for controlling the operation of each module.

[0141] The following describes the process of ranking the importance of failure modes using the improved FMEA device 100 in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

[0142] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of a flow chart of ranking the importance of failure modes in an embodiment of the present invention.

[0143] like Figure 3 As shown, using the improved FMEA device 100 to rank the importance of failure modes includes the following steps:

[0144] Step S1, using the comprehensive weight calculation module 10 to process all relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and the CRITIC method to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each risk factor.

[0145] Step S2: using the performance value calculation module 20 to calculate the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor based on all evaluation data.

[0146] Step S3: normalize all performance values ​​using the normalization module 30 to obtain a normalized evaluation matrix.

[0147] Step S4, using the numerical calculation module 40 to calculate the optimal and the most undesirable numerical values ​​corresponding to each risk factor according to the normalized evaluation matrix.

[0148] Step S5, using the distance calculation module 50 to calculate the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each failure mode according to the comprehensive weight, the normalized evaluation matrix, the optimal case value and the worst case value.

[0149] Step S6, using the progress calculation module 60 to calculate the corresponding progress of each failure mode according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance.

[0150] Step S7: Use the importance calculation module 70 to sort all failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding progress of posting, and obtain an importance sorting result.

[0151] Functions and Effects of the Embodiments

[0152] According to the improved FMEA method and device for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment involved in this embodiment, first, the subjective weight is calculated by the comprehensive weight calculation module using the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process, and the objective weight is calculated by the CRITIC method; secondly, the fuzzy number evaluation method is performed by the performance value calculation module and the normalization module to obtain the normalized evaluation of each failure mode and each risk factor; then, the progress is obtained by weight and score calculation according to the numerical calculation module, the distance calculation module and the progress calculation module; finally, all failure modes are sorted according to the progress through the importance calculation module, so as to obtain the importance ranking results of each failure mode. In short, this method can consider the relative importance between each risk factor, accurately score the risk factor, and thus obtain the importance ranking results of each failure mode.

[0153] Those skilled in the art should understand that the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and the above embodiments and descriptions are only for explaining the principles of the present invention. Without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention, the present invention may have various changes and improvements, and these changes and improvements fall within the scope of the present invention to be protected. The scope of protection of the present invention is defined by the attached claims and their equivalents.

Claims

1. An improved FMEA method for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of ranking, which is used to obtain the ranking results of the importance of m failure modes based on the relative importance scoring data of n risk factors by l analysts and the evaluation data of each risk factor of m failure modes, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step S1, processing all the relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and the CRITIC method to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each of the risk factors; Step S2, calculating the performance value of each failure mode to each risk factor based on all the evaluation data; Step S3, normalizing all the performance values ​​to obtain a normalized evaluation matrix; Step S4, calculating the optimal and the least optimal values ​​corresponding to each of the risk factors according to the normalized evaluation matrix; Step S5, calculating the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each of the failure modes according to the comprehensive weight, the normalized evaluation matrix, the optimal case value and the worst case value; Step S6, for each failure mode, calculate the corresponding progress according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance; Step S7: sort all the failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding posting progress to obtain the importance ranking result. The higher the ranking in the importance ranking result, the higher the importance of the corresponding failure mode.

2. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 1 is characterized by: in, The risk factors include severity S, occurrence O, detectability D and relevance R. The correlation R is used to describe the characteristics of the mutual influence between the failure modes.

3. The improved FMEA method of improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 1, Features: Wherein, the step S1 includes the following sub-steps: Step S1-1, processing all the relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process to obtain the subjective weight of each risk factor by each analyst and the comprehensive subjective weight of each risk factor; Step S1-2, processing all the subjective weights and the comprehensive subjective weights according to the CRITIC method to obtain the objective weight of each risk factor; Step S1-3, calculating the comprehensive weight of each risk factor according to all the comprehensive subjective weights and the objective weights.

4. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 3, Features: Wherein, the step S1-1 includes the following sub-steps: Step S1-1-1, converting the relative importance scores in each relative importance scoring data into corresponding fuzzy numbers to obtain a relative importance matrix; Step S1-1-2, performing neutral expectation calculation on the relative importance matrix to obtain an expectation matrix; Step S1-1-3, calculating the subjective fuzzy weight of each analyst for each risk factor according to the expectation matrix; Step S1-1-4, for each risk factor corresponding to each analyst, calculating the expected value of the corresponding subjective fuzzy weight as the subjective weight; Step S1-1-5: for each of the risk factors, calculate the average value of all the corresponding subjective weights as the comprehensive subjective weight of the risk factor.

5. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 4 is characterized by: in, The expression of the relative importance matrix is: In the formula is the fuzzy number, is the relative importance matrix, The expression of the expectation matrix is: In the formula is the expectation matrix, is the element in the pth row and qth column of the relative importance matrix, The calculation expression of the subjective fuzzy weight is: In the formula is the analyst's subjective fuzzy weight for the pth risk factor, The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column N , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column L , The relative importance matrix corresponding to the analyst The a corresponding to the element in the pth row and qth column P .

6. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 3 is characterized by: in, In step S1-2, the calculation expression of the objective weight is: K j =S j ×R j , Where β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor, K j is the information content of the j-th risk factor, R j is the conflict of the jth risk factor, r tj is the correlation coefficient between the t-th risk factor and the j-th risk factor weight, p t is the subjective weight vector of the t-th risk factor, S j is the standard deviation of the j-th risk factor, is the comprehensive subjective weight of the jth risk factor, p ij is the subjective weight of the i-th analyst on the j-th risk factor, Min(p j ) is the minimum value of the subjective weight corresponding to the j-th risk factor, Max(p j ) is the maximum value of the subjective weight corresponding to the j-th risk factor, In step S1-3, the calculation expression of the comprehensive weight is: Where ω j is the comprehensive weight of the j-th risk factor, α j is the comprehensive subjective weight of the j-th risk factor, β j is the objective weight of the j-th risk factor.

7. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 1 is characterized by: in, In step S3, the expression of the normalized evaluation matrix is: A=(a ij ) m×n , Where A is the normalized evaluation matrix, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, qi j is the performance value of the i-th failure mode for the j-th risk factor.

8. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 1 is characterized by: in, The optimal value b of the jth risk factor j * and the worst case value b j O The expression is: Where i is the failure mode number, Max j (a ij ) is the maximum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, Min j (a ij ) is the minimum value of all elements corresponding to the j-th risk factor in the normalized evaluation matrix, where the larger the value of the extremely large index represents, the more it meets expectations, and the smaller the value of the extremely small index represents, the more it meets expectations.

9. The improved FMEA method for improving the rationality of sorting by comprehensive judgment according to claim 1 is characterized by: in, The calculation expression of the optimal distance is: In the formula is the optimal distance of the ith failure mode, ω j is the comprehensive weight of the j-th risk factor, a ij is the element corresponding to the jth risk factor of the ith failure mode in the normalized evaluation matrix, b j * is the optimal value of the j-th risk factor, The calculation expression of the worst distance is: In the formula is the worst distance of the ith failure mode, b j O is the worst case value of the j-th risk factor, The calculation expression of the posting progress is: Where S i is the progress of the i-th failure mode.

10. An improved FMEA device for comprehensively judging and improving the rationality of ranking, used to obtain the ranking results of the importance of m failure modes based on the relative importance scoring data of n risk factors by l analysts and the evaluation data of each risk factor of m failure modes, characterized in that: include: A comprehensive weight calculation module is used to process all the relative importance score data according to the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and the CRITIC method to obtain the comprehensive weight corresponding to each of the risk factors; A performance value calculation module, used to calculate the performance value of each failure mode for each risk factor based on all the evaluation data; A normalization module, used for normalizing all the performance values ​​to obtain a normalized evaluation matrix; A numerical calculation module, used for calculating the most ideal numerical value and the most unideal numerical value corresponding to each of the risk factors according to the normalized evaluation matrix; A distance calculation module, used for calculating the optimal distance and the worst distance corresponding to each of the failure modes according to the comprehensive weight, the normalized evaluation matrix, the optimal case value and the least ideal case value; A progress calculation module is used to calculate the corresponding progress of each failure mode according to the corresponding optimal distance and the worst distance; The importance calculation module is used to sort all the failure modes from large to small according to the corresponding progress of the patch, and obtain the importance sorting result. The higher the ranking in the importance ranking result, the higher the importance of the corresponding failure mode.