Method for discriminating penetration effect of projectile body in penetration environment

Advanced finite element analysis methods simulate projectile penetration to accurately predict residual velocity and acceleration, addressing limitations in existing evaluation methods and enhancing design precision for protective structures and weapon systems.

CN119089746APending Publication Date: 2024-12-06SHAANXI NPU SCI PARK CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411212669.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-30
Publication Date
2024-12-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating projectile penetration effects are limited by model simplification, computing resource constraints, and experimental test limitations, making it difficult to accurately simulate and predict the penetration process of projectiles in complex environments.

Method used

A method utilizing advanced finite element analysis technology, incorporating mechanical properties of projectiles and penetration media, to simulate and predict penetration effects by establishing geometric and material models, determining failure criteria, and extracting velocity and acceleration curves.

Benefits of technology

Provides accurate and efficient evaluation of projectile penetration, enabling precise design of protective structures and weapon systems by predicting residual velocity and acceleration through detailed simulation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119089746A_ABST
    Figure CN119089746A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention belongs to the technical field of structural performance verification, and particularly relates to a method for judging the penetration effect of a projectile body in a penetration environment, which is based on a finite element analysis technology and comprises the following steps of: establishing an accurate dynamical model of the projectile body and a penetration medium; the residual velocity and acceleration of the projectile body after the projectile body penetrates concrete with different media, different strengths and different reinforcement ratios are accurately evaluated through a finite element analysis technology in combination with actual engineering, and by means of the method, the penetration process of the projectile body to various different hard targets can be more accurately predicted; the technical and method blank in the aspect of projectile body penetration effect evaluation in the current penetration environment is filled up, an accurate and reliable basis is provided for designing a protective structure and improving a weapon system, and meanwhile the method has the advantages of being efficient and accurate.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of structural performance verification, and specifically is a method for judging the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment. Background Art

[0002] Evaluating the penetration effect of a projectile in a penetration environment is a key task in the military, security and engineering fields, and the acceleration curve of the projectile and the residual velocity after penetration are a direct manifestation of the penetration effect. At present, with the rapid development of high-tech weapons and equipment, the material structure of bunkers is changing with each passing day. Rapidly and accurately judging the penetration effect of a projectile is of great significance for designing protective structures, improving weapon systems and evaluating impact effects. It is the top priority for the precise strike application of new penetrating weapons.

[0003] However, existing methods and technologies have limitations in solving this problem. This problem can be solved by establishing a more accurate finite element analysis model. By deeply studying the material mechanical properties of the projectile and the penetrating medium and incorporating them into the finite element analysis model, the penetration process of the projectile and related projectile parameters can be simulated and predicted more accurately.

[0004] At present, finite element analysis models are often affected by model simplification and computing resource limitations, making it difficult to fully describe the complex nonlinear penetration process. In addition, experimental tests are still affected by environmental conditions and equipment limitations and cannot fully simulate real penetration situations. Summary of the invention

[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to avoid the shortcomings of the prior art and provide a method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment. The method is based on advanced finite element analysis technology, and through in-depth research on the mechanical properties of the projectile and different penetration medium materials, it is incorporated into the finite element analysis model to provide a more accurate and reliable penetration effect evaluation. By combining the finite element analysis results, the acceleration and residual velocity of the projectile can be quickly and accurately determined to grasp and evaluate the penetration effect of the projectile on a variety of different protective material structures, and provide more effective decision support for military and security engineering fields such as improving weapons and protective facilities that penetrate hard targets.

[0006] To achieve the above object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is a method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment, comprising the following steps:

[0007] Step 1: Establish the geometric model of the projectile, steel plate, concrete plate and rock plate in the finite element analysis software, set the parameters of the projectile, initial velocity and the constraints between the steel bar and concrete, and determine the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves as the model output;

[0008] Step 2: Assign material parameters to the established geometric model, including material density, elastic modulus, and yield strength. The concrete slab is modeled using the concrete damage plasticity model (CDP), including constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters, and plasticity parameters.

[0009] Step 3: Use finite element analysis software to simulate, take different thicknesses, strengths and reinforcement ratios as model inputs, establish multiple penetration models covering concrete, rock, steel plates of different thicknesses, and concrete plates of different strengths and reinforcement ratios, and generate INP files;

[0010] Step 4: Use the erosion contact algorithm to determine the failure criterion of the material model. By adding the Erode keyword, the erosion surface and internal erosion area are determined. When the maximum principal strain reaches the failure threshold, the failed units in the penetration process are deleted, and the contact constraint is imposed using the penalty function method.

[0011] Step 5: Batch extract the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves of the finite element model, analyze the projectile velocity loss percentage and acceleration peak, and quickly complete the projectile penetration performance evaluation based on the maximum and minimum values.

[0012] Furthermore, the finite element described in the first step uses a parametric modeling method to complete a series of modeling, including the shape, size, different thickness of the projectile, steel plate, concrete slab and rock slab, and the arrangement of steel bars in the concrete slab. The constraints between the steel bars and concrete use embedded area constraints, and the deformation constraints of the steel bar nodes are set on the concrete nodes.

[0013] Furthermore, the material modeling described in the second step is to model the concrete slab using the CDP model. The CDP model mainly includes constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters and plasticity parameters.

[0014] The constitutive relationship parameters are mainly composed of two parts: compression and tension. The compression constitutive parameters are:

[0015] σ=(1-d c )Eε (1)

[0016]

[0017]

[0018]

[0019]

[0020] α c =0.157f c,r 0.785-0.905 (6)

[0021]

[0022] The tensile constitutive parameters are:

[0023] σ=(1-d t )Eε (8)

[0024]

[0025]

[0026]

[0027] α t =0.312f t,r 2 (12)

[0028] ε t,r =f t,r 0.54 ×65×10 -6 (13)

[0029] Where: σ, ε and E represent the stress, strain and elastic modulus of concrete respectively; n, ρ c and ρ t It is a parameter in the derivation process and has no practical meaning; f c,r and f t,r represents the uniaxial compressive and tensile strength of concrete; x is the ratio of strain to peak strain; α c and α t It represents the parameter value of the descending section of the stress-strain curve of concrete under uniaxial compression and tension; ε c,r and ε t,r represents the peak compressive strain and peak tensile strain of concrete; d c and d t is the damage evolution parameter of concrete material under uniaxial compression and tension;

[0030] The damage parameters are:

[0031] Based on the energy dissipation principle, the damage factor is defined as:

[0032]

[0033]

[0034] Where: ε in is the inelastic strain; d is the damage factor; W is the energy of concrete deformation; the subscripts “0” and “d” represent the non-destructive or damage-considered state, respectively;

[0035] The plasticity parameters are:

[0036]

[0037] σ b0 / σ c0 =1.57f c -0.09 (17)

[0038] K c =0.71f c -0.025 (18)

[0039] Where: G represents flow potential; e is the eccentricity of flow potential, which is generally taken as 0.1; σ t0 is the uniaxial tensile strength; represents the expansion angle; is the equivalent effective stress; is the equivalent effective pressure; σ b0 / σ c0 is the ratio of biaxial to uniaxial compressive strength; f c is the uniaxial compressive strength; K c is the second stress invariant on the tensile meridian plane and the compression meridian plane; in addition, μ is the viscosity coefficient, which ranges from 0.01 to 0.0001.

[0040] Furthermore, the thickness range of the concrete slabs, rock slabs and steel plates of different thicknesses used in the third step is 10mm to 200mm, the strength range of the concrete slabs of different strengths is 30MPa to 60MPa, the reinforcement ratio of the concrete slabs is 0% to 1%, the concrete slabs are used as the penetrating medium, the loading conditions are set, the grid is divided, and the INP file is generated.

[0041] Furthermore, the failure criterion described in the fourth step is an erosion contact algorithm, which defines the failure area and failure surface, determines the slave point-main sheet contact pairs and their corresponding contact directions, calculates the contact points using a non-iterative method, deletes the damaged failure units when certain parameters reach predetermined values, and completes the erosion contact algorithm; this method adds the keywords Erode, Surface, and *Concrete failure in the INP file to set the maximum principal strain as the failure threshold, ensuring that the material constitutive model can accurately describe the damage behavior under high strain rates, and finally submits and calculates the models in batches.

[0042] Furthermore, the calculation results of the batch extraction finite element model described in the fifth step are velocity and acceleration time curves, and the residual velocity loss percentage and acceleration peak value after the projectile penetrates different targets are compared and analyzed to quickly evaluate how these variables affect the penetration performance of the projectile.

[0043] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the present invention provides a method for distinguishing the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment. The method is based on finite element analysis technology, and by establishing an accurate dynamic model of the projectile and the penetration medium, and combining the actual engineering with finite element analysis technology to accurately evaluate the residual velocity and acceleration of the projectile after penetrating different media, different strengths and different reinforcement ratios of concrete. By using this method, the penetration process of the projectile on a variety of different hard targets can be more accurately predicted, filling the technical and methodological gaps in the current evaluation of the penetration effect of the projectile under the penetration environment, thereby providing a precise and reliable basis for designing protective structures and improving weapon systems, and at the same time having the advantages of high efficiency and accuracy. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0044] Figure 1 It is an implementation flow chart of the present invention;

[0045] Figure 2 is the residual velocity after the projectile penetrates under a set of different thicknesses and materials of the present invention;

[0046] Figure 3 The effect of the concrete slabs of different strengths and reinforcement ratios on the residual velocity of the projectile according to the present invention;

[0047] Figure 4 It is the influence of the concrete slabs of different strengths of the present invention on the acceleration-time curve of the projectile. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0048] The principles and features of the present invention are described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. The examples given are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the scope of the present invention.

[0049] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following specific implementation methods: Figure 1 As shown, based on the finite element analysis performed by ABAQUS software, the method for judging the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment comprises the following steps:

[0050] Step 1: Establish the geometric model of the projectile, steel plate, concrete plate and rock plate in the finite element analysis software, set the parameters of the projectile, initial velocity and the constraints between the steel bar and concrete, and determine the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves as the model output;

[0051] Step 2: Assign material parameters to the established geometric model, including material density, elastic modulus, and yield strength. Use the Concrete Damage Plasticity (CDP) model to model the concrete slab, including constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters, and plasticity parameters.

[0052] Step 3: Use finite element analysis software to simulate, take different thicknesses, strengths and reinforcement ratios as model inputs, establish multiple penetration models covering concrete, rock, steel plates of different thicknesses, and concrete plates of different strengths and reinforcement ratios, and generate INP files;

[0053] Step 4: Use the erosion contact algorithm to determine the failure criterion of the material model. The erosion surface and internal erosion area are determined by adding the Erode keyword. When the maximum principal strain reaches 0.003, the failed units in the penetration process are deleted, and the contact constraint is imposed using the penalty function method.

[0054] Step 5: Batch extract the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves of the finite element model, analyze the percentage of velocity loss and the peak acceleration of the projectile, and quickly complete the evaluation of the projectile penetration performance based on the maximum and minimum values, providing valuable reference for related engineering design and safety assessment.

[0055] Furthermore, the finite element described in the first step uses parametric modeling to complete the series modeling, including the shape, size, different thickness of the projectile, steel plate, concrete plate and rock plate, and the arrangement of steel bars in the concrete plate, where the mass of the projectile is 0.386kg, the total length is 152mm, the diameter is 25.3mm, and the head coefficient is 3. In addition, the constraint between the steel bar and the concrete uses the embedded region constraint (Embedded region), which constrains the deformation of the steel bar node to the concrete node. This constraint does not need to consider whether the embedded position structure is empty, avoiding the node overlap between the two components due to node interference.

[0056] Furthermore, the material modeling described in the second step is to model the concrete slab using the CDP model, and the CDP model mainly includes constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters and plasticity parameters.

[0057] The constitutive relationship parameters are mainly composed of two parts: compression and tension. The compression constitutive parameters are:

[0058] σ=(1-d c )Eε (1)

[0059]

[0060]

[0061]

[0062]

[0063] α c =0.157f c,r 0.785 -0.905 (6)

[0064]

[0065] The tensile constitutive parameters are:

[0066] σ=(1-d t )Eε (8)

[0067]

[0068]

[0069]

[0070] α t =0.312f t,r 2 (12)

[0071] ε t,r =f t,r 0.54 ×65×10 -6 (13)

[0072] Where: σ, ε and E represent the stress, strain and elastic modulus of concrete respectively; n, ρ c and ρ t It is a parameter in the derivation process and has no practical meaning; f c,r and f t,r represents the uniaxial compressive and tensile strength of concrete; x is the ratio of strain to peak strain; α c and α t It represents the parameter value of the descending section of the stress-strain curve of concrete under uniaxial compression and tension; ε c,r and ε t,r represents the peak compressive strain and peak tensile strain of concrete; d c and d t is the damage evolution parameter of concrete material under uniaxial compression and tension.

[0073] The damage parameters are:

[0074] Based on the energy dissipation principle, the damage factor is defined as:

[0075]

[0076]

[0077] Where: ε in is the inelastic strain; d is the damage factor; W is the energy of concrete deformation; the subscripts “0” and “d” represent the non-destructive or damage-considered state, respectively.

[0078] The plasticity parameters are:

[0079]

[0080] σ b0 / σ c0 =1.57f c -0.09 (17)

[0081] K c =0.71f c -0.025 (18)

[0082] Where: G represents flow potential; e is the eccentricity of flow potential, which is generally taken as 0.1; σ t0 is the uniaxial tensile strength; represents the expansion angle; is the equivalent effective stress; is the equivalent effective pressure; σ b0 / σ c0 is the ratio of biaxial to uniaxial compressive strength; f c is the uniaxial compressive strength; K c is the second stress invariant on the tensile meridian and the compression meridian. In addition, μ is the viscosity coefficient, which ranges from 0.01 to 0.0001.

[0083] The thickness of the concrete slabs, rock slabs and steel plates of different thicknesses described in the third step are 10mm, 30mm, 50mm, 70mm, 150mm and 200mm, the compressive strength of the concrete slabs of different strengths is 30MPa, 40MPa, 50MPa and 60MPa, the reinforcement ratio of the concrete slabs is 0%, 0.3%, 0.6% and 1%, the concrete slab is used as the penetrating medium, the loading conditions are set, the geometric model is meshed, and other boundary conditions such as constraints are set, and the INP file is generated.

[0084] The failure criterion described in the fourth step is the erosion contact algorithm, which defines the failure area and failure surface, determines the slave point-main sheet contact pair and its corresponding contact direction, calculates the contact point using a non-iterative method, deletes the damaged failure unit when certain parameters reach a predetermined value, and completes the erosion contact algorithm. This method is implemented by adding the keywords Erode, Surface, and *Concrete failure in the INP file and setting the maximum principal strain to 0.003, ensuring that the material constitutive model can accurately describe the damage behavior under high strain rates, and finally submitting and calculating the model in batches.

[0085] The calculation results of the batch extraction finite element model described in step 5 are velocity and acceleration time curves, which compare and analyze the remaining velocity loss percentage and acceleration peak after the projectile penetrates different targets, so as to quickly evaluate how these variables affect the penetration performance of the projectile. Figure 2-4 shown.

[0086] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: The first step is to establish the geometric model of the projectile, steel plate, concrete plate and rock plate in the finite element analysis software, set the parameters of the projectile, the initial velocity and the constraints between the steel bar and the concrete, and determine the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves as the model output; The second step is to assign material parameters to the established geometric model, including material density, elastic modulus, and yield strength. The concrete slab is modeled using the concrete plastic damage model, including constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters, and plasticity parameters. Step 3: Use finite element analysis software to simulate, take different thicknesses, strengths and reinforcement ratios as model inputs, establish multiple penetration models covering concrete, rock, steel plates of different thicknesses, and concrete plates of different strengths and reinforcement ratios, and generate INP files; Step 4: Use the erosion contact algorithm to determine the failure criterion of the material model. By adding the Erode keyword, the erosion surface and internal erosion area are determined. When the maximum principal strain reaches the failure threshold, the failed units in the penetration process are deleted, and the contact constraint is imposed using the penalty function method. The fifth step is to batch extract the velocity-time and acceleration-time curves of the finite element model, analyze the percentage of velocity loss and the peak acceleration of the projectile, and quickly complete the evaluation of the projectile penetration performance based on the maximum and minimum values.

2. A method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The finite element described in the first step uses parametric modeling to complete a series of modeling, including the shape, size, different thickness of the projectile, steel plate, concrete slab and rock slab, and the arrangement of steel bars in the concrete slab. The constraints between the steel bars and concrete use embedded area constraints, and the deformation constraints of the steel bar nodes are set on the concrete nodes.

3. The method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The material modeling described in the second step is to use the CDP model to model the concrete slab. The CDP model mainly includes constitutive relationship parameters, damage parameters and plasticity parameters. The constitutive relationship parameters are mainly composed of two parts: compression and tension. The compression constitutive parameters are: σ=(1-d c )Ee (1) α c =0.157f c,r 0.785 -0.905 (6) The tensile constitutive parameters are: σ=(1-d t )Ee (8) α t =0.312f t,r 2 (12) e t,r =f t,r 0.54 ×65×10 -6 (13) Where: σ, ε and E represent the stress, strain and elastic modulus of concrete respectively; n, ρ c and ρ t It is a parameter in the derivation process and has no practical significance; f c,r and f t,r represents the uniaxial compressive and tensile strength of concrete; x is the ratio of strain to peak strain; α c and α t It represents the parameter value of the descending section of the stress-strain curve of concrete under uniaxial compression and tension; ε c,r and ε t,r represents the peak compressive strain and peak tensile strain of concrete; d c and d t is the damage evolution parameter of concrete material under uniaxial compression and tension; The damage parameters are: Based on the energy dissipation principle, the damage factor is defined as: Where: ε in is the inelastic strain; d is the damage factor; W is the energy of concrete deformation; the subscripts "0" and "d" represent the non-destructive or damage-considered state, respectively; The plasticity parameters are: s b0 / s c0 =1.57f c -0.09 (17) K c =0.71f c -0.025 (18) Where: G represents flow potential; e is the eccentricity of flow potential, which is generally taken as 0.1; σ t0 is the uniaxial tensile strength; represents the expansion angle; is the equivalent effective stress; is the equivalent effective pressure; σ b0 / σ c0 is the ratio of biaxial to uniaxial compressive strength; f c is the uniaxial compressive strength; K c is the second stress invariant on the tensile meridian plane and the compression meridian plane; in addition, μ is the viscosity coefficient, which ranges from 0.01 to 0.0001.

4. A method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The thickness range of the concrete slabs, rock slabs and steel plates of different thicknesses used in the third step is 10mm to 200mm, the strength range of the concrete slabs of different strengths is 30MPa to 60MPa, the reinforcement ratio of the concrete slabs is 0% to 1%, the concrete slabs are used as the penetrating medium, the loading conditions are set, the grid is divided, and the INP file is generated.

5. The method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The failure criterion described in the fourth step is an erosion contact algorithm, which defines the failure area and failure surface, determines the slave point-main sheet contact pairs and their corresponding contact directions, calculates the contact points using a non-iterative method, deletes the damaged failure units when certain parameters reach predetermined values, and completes the erosion contact algorithm; this method adds the keywords Erode, Surface, and *Concrete failure in the INP file to set the maximum principal strain as the failure threshold, ensuring that the material constitutive model can accurately describe the damage behavior under high strain rates, and finally submits and calculates the model in batches.

6. A method for determining the penetration effect of a projectile under a penetration environment according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that: The calculation results of the batch extraction finite element model described in the fifth step are velocity and acceleration time curves, which compare and analyze the remaining velocity loss percentage and acceleration peak after the projectile penetrates different targets, so as to quickly evaluate how these variables affect the penetration performance of the projectile.