A theoretical framework oriented towards subject knowledge dependency graphs; methods and systems for locating the spread of pollution in health audits.
By constructing a subject knowledge dependency graph and using a hierarchical verification method, the problem of error propagation in the subject knowledge system was solved, the source of pollution was located and systematically corrected, and the health and accuracy of the subject knowledge system were improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611446892.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-09-17
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies lack dependency analysis, pollution propagation analysis, and root cause analysis of the subject knowledge system, making it impossible to effectively detect errors and make systematic corrections. As a result, errors spread within the subject knowledge system and affect downstream conclusions and applications.
Construct a subject knowledge dependency graph, represent concept relationships through nodes and edges, label node states, perform verification according to priority, perform hierarchical verification and pollution propagation location, generate candidate errata drafts, perform reverse root cause backtracking and candidate errata output.
It enables a systematic health audit of the subject knowledge system, effectively locates pollution sources and generates corrective suggestions, thereby improving the accuracy and credibility of the subject knowledge system.
Smart Images

Figure FT_1 
Figure FT_2 
Figure FT_3
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of artificial intelligence and knowledge engineering technology, specifically relating to a method and system for health auditing and pollution propagation localization based on a theoretical system of subject knowledge dependency graphs. It particularly involves the construction of dependency graphs for subjects such as mathematics, logic, theoretical physics, chemistry, life sciences, materials science, environment, earth sciences, and artificial intelligence theory, as well as node state auditing, pollution propagation, reverse root cause tracing, and candidate errata draft generation. This invention collaborates with PA1 statement extraction, PA2 evidence object verification, PA3 cognitive honesty decision-making, PA4 long-chain reasoning auditing, PA5 intelligent retry, and PA6 verification budget and authorization gating governance, but does not redefine its internal algorithms. Background Technology
[0002] Errors in a subject's knowledge system often do not occur in isolated instances, but rather contaminate downstream along dependencies: incorrect root assumptions can affect laws and theorems, and incorrect theorems can affect models, applications, and engineering recommendations. Existing illusion detection or fact-checking methods are mostly oriented towards single-point responses, lacking dependency analysis, contamination propagation analysis, and root cause tracing of the subject's knowledge system itself; they also lack honest labeling of unverifiable nodes and authorization boundaries for candidate errata drafts. Summary of the Invention
[0003] S1 constructs or loads a subject knowledge dependency graph: nodes represent concepts, axioms, hypotheses, laws, theorems, lemmas, corollaries, models, data, and experimental conclusions; edges represent depends_on, cites, derived_from, applies_to, contradicts, generalizes, instantiates, version_of, or superseded_by; nodes and edges carry metadata about the domain, source, version, and confidence level.
[0004] S2 node state labeling: The state set is verified, contradicted, unsupported, deprecated, assumed, and open; verified indicates that it is formally supported or strongly supported by evidence; contradicted indicates that there are counterexamples or falsifications; unsupported indicates that data or proof is lacking; deprecated indicates that it has been replaced or its scope of application has been modified; assumed indicates that it is only an assumption; and open indicates an open question.
[0005] S3 Validation Priority Ranking: The validation order is determined by prioritizing root nodes, high fan-out nodes, high-risk nodes, and verifiable nodes; high fan-out refers to nodes heavily relied upon by downstream systems; high-risk refers to nodes that affect experimental safety, medical applications, engineering, regulatory compliance, or public communication.
[0006] S4 Layered Validation: Invokes one or more of the following methods: formal proof, symbolic computation, constraint solving, experimental data reanalysis, statistical review, literature tracing, and regulatory timeliness check; unsupported nodes are marked as unsupported and skipped.
[0007] S5 Contamination Propagation Location: When a node is judged as contradicted or deprecated, the contaminated mark is propagated downstream along the outgoing edge; output the contaminated subtree and a list of affected nodes.
[0008] S6 Reverse Root Cause Backtracking: When a leaf node has a counterexample, experimental failure, engineering anomaly, or prediction deviation, backtrack upstream along the incoming edge to assumption_error, boundary_error, stale_source, or root_hidden_assumption.
[0009] S7 Candidate Errata and Output: Generate errata drafts with candidate_only=true, including invalid nodes, suggested alternative statements, scope of application corrections, and supplementary data or proofs; output TheoryHealthAuditResult, including risk nodes, contaminated subtrees, evidence chains, unsupported lists, and candidate errata drafts.
[0010] Boundaries and Collaborations: Relationship with PA1: Receives ClaimStream, does not perform claim extraction. Relationship with PA2: Receives evidence object graph and evidence support relationships, does not repeat evidence anchoring. Relationship with PA3: PA3 performs final processing; this invention only provides audit evidence, contamination location, and candidate errata. Relationship with PA4: PA4 performs long-chain inference auditing and proof failure location; this invention handles graph-level system health and contamination propagation. Relationship with PA5: Candidate errata drafts are only processed after authorization. Relationship with PA6: Verification budget and authorization gating are governed by PA6. Attached Figure Description
[0011] Figure 1 A flowchart illustrating the methodology for locating the spread of pollution through health audits, based on a theoretical framework oriented towards subject-specific knowledge dependency graphs.
[0012] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the dependence of subject knowledge on location and the location of pollution transmission.
[0013] Figure 3 A diagram illustrating the priority and hierarchical toolchain for verifying theoretical frameworks.
[0014] Figure 4 This is a diagram showing the module and interface structure of the health audit system for the theoretical framework. Detailed Implementation
[0015] Example 1: Mathematical Theorem Auditing. A theorem subgraph of analysis is constructed. If a theorem references a non-existent lemma, the citation_error is located, and the three downstream corollaries are marked as contaminated.
[0016] Example 2: Audit of Statistical Misuse. If a life science conclusion is found to have an insufficient sample size and lack a control group, it is marked as unsupported, not contradicted, and it is suggested to supplement the experiment or downgrade it to a hypothesis.
[0017] Example 3: Backtracking. An engineering suggestion failed; the error was traced back to a material model whose applicable temperature boundary was incorrectly expanded, locating the `boundary_error`.
[0018] Example 4: Candidate Errata. Generate a candidate_only errata draft for the deprecated model, suggesting replacement with the new model and indicating the applicable scope.
Claims
1. A theoretical framework for health auditing and pollution transmission localization based on subject knowledge dependency graphs, characterized in that: include: Construct or load a subject knowledge dependency graph, where nodes represent concepts, axioms, hypotheses, laws, theorems, lemmas, corollaries, models, data, or experimental conclusions, and edges represent dependencies, citations, derivations, applications, refutations, generalizations, instantiations, versions, or substitutions. Label nodes with verified, contradicted, unsupported, deprecated, assumed, or open states. Determine the verification order based on root node priority, high fan-out node priority, high-risk node priority, and verifiable node priority. Perform hierarchical verification by invoking one or more of the following methods: formal proof, symbolic computation, constraint solving, experimental data reanalysis, statistical review, literature tracing, and regulatory timeliness checks. When a node is judged as contradicted or deprecated, a contamination marker is propagated downstream along the dependency edge; when a leaf node has a counterexample or failure case, the root cause is traced upstream along the dependency edge. Outputs a theoretical framework health audit report, a contamination subtree, a chain of evidence, an unsupported list, and candidate-only errata drafts.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The disciplines include at least one of mathematics, logic, theoretical physics, chemistry, life sciences, materials, environment, earth sciences, and artificial intelligence theory and algorithm correctness; the knowledge-dependent graph nodes and edges carry metadata about the domain, source, version, and confidence level.
3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The candidate errata draft marked with candidate_only=true includes invalid nodes, suggested alternative expressions, scope of application corrections, and data or evidence that needs to be supplemented; it is not directly released as a final conclusion.
4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The hierarchical verification calls theorem library matching and proof assistant for mathematical / logic nodes, dimensionality, limit cases and symbolic calculations for physical / chemical / material nodes, sample size, control and repeatability checks for life science nodes, and hypothesis testing, data version and goodness-of-fit checks for statistical nodes.
5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, The pollution propagation outputs the contaminated subtree, and the reverse root cause backtracking outputs assumption_error, boundary_error, stale_source, or root_hidden_assumption.
6. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that, This method works in conjunction with PA1 statement extraction, PA2 evidence object verification, PA3 cognitive honesty decision-making, PA4 long-chain reasoning auditing, PA5 intelligent retry, and PA6 verification budget and authorization gating governance. This method does not perform final OUTPUT / CAUTION / ABSTAIN decisions and does not automatically distribute repair results.
7. A theoretical framework for health auditing and pollution transmission localization system based on subject knowledge dependency graphs, characterized in that: include: The module includes a knowledge graph construction module, a node status and priority module, a verification and scheduling module, and a pollution location and candidate correction module. The system performs the method according to any one of claims 1–6.
8. An electronic device, characterized in that, It includes a processor and a memory, the memory storing instructions that, when executed by the processor, implement the method of any one of claims 1–6.
9. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that, The device stores instructions that, when executed by a processor, implement the method of any one of claims 1–6.
