A Method and System for Recommending Teaching Resources Based on Intangible Cultural Heritage Knowledge Graph

By constructing an intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph to quantify the theoretical and practical biases of intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources, and combining local and global clustering, precise recommendations of intangible cultural heritage teaching resources are achieved. This solves the problem of mismatch between recommended resources and teachers' needs in existing methods, and improves the accuracy and practicality of recommendations.

CN123115532APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17BEIJING UNION UNIVERSITY
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611595091.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-10-15
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing teaching resource recommendation methods cannot effectively quantify the theoretical and practical biases of intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources in intangible cultural heritage teaching scenarios, resulting in a mismatch between recommended resources and teachers' actual teaching needs, leading to problems such as mismatch in types and low usability.

Method used

By constructing a knowledge graph of intangible cultural heritage, the first theoretical and practical degree of intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources is determined by matching the pre-set theoretical and practical dictionaries. By combining local clustering and global clustering cross-comparison, the theoretical and practical bias type of intangible cultural heritage projects is quantified, and layer-by-layer screening and recommendation are carried out based on teachers' teaching requests.

Benefits of technology

It enables precise clustering and hierarchical instructional design of intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources, improves the relevance, teachability and implementability of the recommended results, and ensures that the recommended resources match the needs of teachers.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123115532A_ABST
    Figure CN123115532A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This application relates to the field of teaching resource recommendation technology, specifically to a method and system for recommending teaching resources based on intangible cultural heritage (ICH) knowledge graphs. The method includes: determining the first theoretical-practical degree of ICH projects and their respective teaching resources; clustering the teaching resources based on their first theoretical-practical degree, and determining the second theoretical-practical degree based on the clustering results; combining the two theoretical-practical degrees to determine the theoretical-practical bias type; selecting ICH projects to form a candidate project set based on the teaching requests of instructors and the theoretical-practical bias type, and then filtering through these layers to obtain the final recommended projects; finally, selecting the final recommended resources based on their first theoretical-practical degree and pushing them to the teacher. This application solves the problem of mismatch between recommendation results and teachers' teaching needs by quantifying the theoretical-practical bias of ICH projects and resources and performing multi-level filtering accordingly, thus improving the accuracy and practicality of ICH course teaching resource recommendations.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This application relates to the field of teaching resource recommendation technology, specifically to a teaching resource recommendation method and system based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graphs. Background Technology

[0002] With the development of educational informatization, teaching resource recommendation technology has become an important means to alleviate the contradiction between massive teaching resources and personalized teaching needs. Existing recommendation methods mainly include: collaborative filtering-based methods, which push resources based on the similarity of resource usage behavior among teacher groups; content matching-based methods, which construct neighborhood knowledge graphs and combine them with multimodal retrieval technology to achieve semantic-level matching between resources and teaching content; and recommendation methods incorporating user interest models, which build user profiles by collecting historical user behavior data to achieve personalized resource recommendations. These methods have achieved good application results in general educational scenarios.

[0003] However, applying existing recommendation methods directly to intangible cultural heritage (ICH) teaching scenarios has limitations in adaptability. ICH projects exhibit distinct differences in their theoretical and practical attributes: some are more theoretical, such as literature and history projects; others are more practical, such as sports and crafts projects; and the degree of bias varies among projects, showing a continuous gradient distribution from strong theory to strong practice. Existing methods only focus on superficial features such as knowledge points, themes, and user interests, lacking a quantitative characterization mechanism for the theoretical and practical bias of ICH projects and teaching resources. This makes it difficult to clearly distinguish between the theoretical and practical types of ICH projects and teaching resources, leading to a mismatch between recommended resources and teachers' actual teaching needs, resulting in type mismatch and low usability. Summary of the Invention

[0004] To address the aforementioned technical problems, the purpose of this application is to provide a method and system for recommending teaching resources based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graphs. The specific technical solution adopted is as follows: In a first aspect, embodiments of this application provide a method for recommending teaching resources based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graphs, the method comprising the following steps: Each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it is matched with a pre-set theoretical dictionary and a pre-set practical dictionary to determine the first theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it. The teaching resources are clustered based on the first theoretical-practical degree, and the second theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item is determined based on the cross-comparison of the clustering results. The theoretical-practical bias type of each intangible cultural heritage item is determined by combining the first theoretical-practical degree and the second theoretical-practical degree. The system obtains the teaching requests of instructors and, based on their theoretical and practical orientations, selects intangible cultural heritage projects to form a candidate project set. The candidate project set is then filtered layer by layer to obtain the final recommended projects. Within each unit of the final recommended projects, the final recommended resources are selected based on the first degree of theoretical and practical application of the teaching resources. Finally, the final recommended projects and their corresponding final recommended resources are pushed to the instructors.

[0005] Optionally, the process for determining the first theoretical degree of practical application is as follows: Extract keywords from the word segmentation list corresponding to each intangible cultural heritage item and determine the TF-IDF value of each keyword; match all keywords with the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary respectively, and count the number of successful matches, denoted as n1 and n2 respectively; Calculate the sum of the TF-IDF values ​​of all successfully matched keywords in the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary, and denote them as TF1 and TF2, respectively; As the weight w1 of n1, As the weight w2 of n2; As the first theoretical and practical dimension, among which... , Both represent preset constants greater than 0. This indicates the minimum number of successful matches, and max() represents the maximum value function.

[0006] Optionally, the absolute difference between the normalized values ​​of the first theoretical and practical degrees of teaching resources within each intangible cultural heritage project can be used as the distance metric in the clustering process.

[0007] Optionally, the clustering results include theoretical local teaching resources, practical local teaching resources, theoretical global teaching resources, and practical global teaching resources.

[0008] Optionally, the process for determining the second theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item is as follows: The second theoretical and practical degree of intangible cultural heritage project i The expression is: In the formula, , These represent the total number of theoretical local teaching resources and the total number of practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i, respectively. This indicates the number of practical, global teaching resources among the theoretical, local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i. This indicates the number of theoretical global teaching resources among the practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i; This represents the total number of teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i.

[0009] Optionally, determining the theoretical and practical bias type of each intangible cultural heritage item includes: The average of the normalized values ​​of the first and second theoretical-practice degrees of each intangible cultural heritage item is denoted as the comprehensive theoretical-practice degree. The [0,1] range is divided into three intervals according to the ternary principle. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the first interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the practical type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the second interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the theoretical and practical balance type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the third interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the theoretical type. The first, second, and third intervals are arranged in ascending order of numerical value.

[0010] Optionally, the teaching request of the instructor includes the instructor's name, the student's HSK level, the type of course, and the teaching preference, wherein the teaching preference includes a preference for theory, a balance between theory and practice, and a preference for practice.

[0011] Optionally, the process for obtaining the final recommended items is as follows: The teaching type in the teaching request of the instructor is matched with the cultural type of each intangible cultural heritage project in the candidate project set. Projects that do not match are eliminated to obtain the initial candidate project set. Obtain the familiarity level of each intangible cultural heritage item among the instructors, and remove items in the candidate item set whose familiarity level is lower than the preset level to obtain the second set of candidate items. If the teaching preference leans towards theory, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the highest and second highest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects; if the teaching preference is a balance between theory and practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the first and second highest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set that are close to the preset values ​​will be selected as the final recommended projects; if the teaching preference leans towards practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the lowest and second lowest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects.

[0012] Optionally, the final recommended resource selection process is as follows: The HSK level of the current student in the teaching request is compared with the minimum HSK level of each teaching resource represented by the graded text of each teaching resource in each unit organization under the final recommendation project. Teaching resources that do not meet the current student's HSK level are eliminated, and the remaining teaching resources are used as the initial screening teaching resources. Based on the bias type corresponding to the teaching preference, teaching resources whose first theoretical and practical degree normalization value is in the corresponding interval are retained; where the interval is divided according to the interval division method of intangible cultural heritage projects. Within each unit organization under the final recommended project, the final recommended resources for each unit organization under the final recommended project are selected from the initial screening teaching resources based on the normalized value of the first theoretical and practical degree of the initial screening teaching resources.

[0013] Secondly, embodiments of this application also provide a teaching resource recommendation system based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, including a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and running on the processor. When the processor executes the computer program, it implements the steps of any of the above-described teaching resource recommendation methods based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph.

[0014] This application has at least the following beneficial effects: 1. Based on the current status diagnosis report and the intangible cultural heritage curriculum construction model and curriculum material sample set constructed by experts, this application constructs the first theoretical-practice degree by combining dictionary matching with TF-IDF weighting, which quantifies the degree of theoretical and practical bias of individual intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources at the text level. Furthermore, it introduces a cross-verification mechanism of local clustering and global clustering to construct the second theoretical-practice degree, which effectively eliminates the false judgment of "relative bias within the project but not globally". It also realizes the reliable classification of the theoretical-practice bias type of intangible cultural heritage projects through two-level comprehensive degree and ternary interval division. This method transforms the theoretical and practical attributes that can only be qualitatively perceived into a calculable, comparable and verifiable quantitative system, providing solid data support for the accurate clustering of teaching resources and the hierarchical teaching design of intangible cultural heritage courses. 2. This application constructs an intangible cultural heritage (ICH) knowledge graph in the form of triplets, based on ICH projects, unit organization, and their teaching resources. Key attributes such as theoretical and practical biases and HSK levels are solidified into the graph nodes, achieving a structured organization of course knowledge. Based on this, according to the teaching requests input by teachers, the final recommended projects are determined through multi-level screening including initial screening of bias intervals, cultural type matching, familiarity verification, and relational edge expansion. Then, through three stages of level matching, type screening, and ranking selection, the final recommended resources are output unit by unit, achieving personalized recommendations across the entire chain from project to resource. This mechanism organically integrates teaching preferences, students' language proficiency, and teachers' competence, ensuring that the recommended results are targeted, teachable, and implementable, thus improving the accuracy and practicality of ICH course teaching resource recommendations. Attached Figure Description

[0015] Figure 1 A flowchart illustrating the steps of a teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, provided in one embodiment of this application. Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the process of classifying intangible cultural heritage items according to one embodiment of this application. Detailed Implementation

[0016] The following section, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, details the specific scheme of the teaching resource recommendation method and system based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph provided in this application.

[0017] Please see Figure 1The diagram illustrates a flowchart of a teaching resource recommendation method based on an intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph according to an embodiment of this application. The method includes the following steps: Step S1: Match each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it with the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary respectively, and determine the first theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it; cluster the teaching resources according to the first theoretical-practical degree, and determine the second theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item based on the cross comparison of the clustering results; combine the first theoretical-practical degree and the second theoretical-practical degree to determine the theoretical-practical bias type of each intangible cultural heritage item.

[0018] Step S2: Obtain the teaching requests from the instructors, and select intangible cultural heritage projects to form a candidate project set based on the theoretical and practical orientation. Then, filter the candidate project set layer by layer to obtain the final recommended projects. Under the organization of each unit of the final recommended projects, select the final recommended resources based on the first theoretical and practical orientation of the teaching resources, and push the final recommended projects and their corresponding final recommended resources to the teacher's end.

[0019] In this embodiment, the specific process for determining the first theoretical-practice degree, the second theoretical-practice degree data, and the theoretical-practice bias type in step S1 is explained as follows: Preparatory work: 1. Through research and analysis of the current status and needs of intangible cultural heritage courses, a current status diagnosis report in the form of "problem list - needs profile - improvement direction" has been obtained.

[0020] 2. Based on the current situation diagnosis report and combined with the Delphi method, 25 representative intangible cultural heritage items were selected from the intangible cultural heritage projects, and then the intangible cultural heritage curriculum construction model and curriculum material sample set were obtained.

[0021] 3. In the intangible cultural heritage curriculum construction model, each intangible cultural heritage item should include at least: item name, cultural type (e.g., traditional crafts), hierarchical positioning (beginner, intermediate, advanced), unit organization (each intangible cultural heritage item is broken down into multiple unit organizations according to the background, process, impact, etc., for step-by-step and deconstructive teaching), learning tasks (the necessary teaching content of each unit organization), and evaluation elements (evaluation methods for each learning task).

[0022] The above data is stored in a structured JSON format, for example: "Culture Type": "Traditional Craft", {"Unit Organization": [{"Unit Number": 1", "Unit Name": "Background Introduction", "Learning Task": ["Understanding the Background", "Learning Origin"]}]}.

[0023] 4. The course material sample set includes at least the following for each course resource: a resource metadata table (recording basic information of each course resource, including at least a teaching tag system (e.g., hands-on practical experience) and graded text (HSK level, e.g., 5, indicating at least HSK-5 level)), micro-videos (teaching animations for each course resource), a glossary (recording relevant terms for each course resource, e.g., diabolo, face painting), a scenario task sheet (recording practical scenarios in each course resource, e.g., face painting), and a learning scaffold (e.g., skill teaching process templates for each course resource).

[0024] One intangible cultural heritage project includes multiple unit organizations, and one unit organization includes multiple teaching resources.

[0025] Each teaching resource's resource metadata table is stored in a JSON structured format, for example: "Resource Metadata Table": [{"Table Number": 1, "Project": "Face Painting", "Project Unit Organization": 1, ...}, {"Table Number": 2, ...}].

[0026] The remaining data is unstructured data. The glossary, contextual task sheet, and learning scaffold are all stored in separate Word or PPT documents, and the micro-videos are in MP4 format. This unstructured data does not participate in subsequent processing and is only used as part of the output of the recommendation system.

[0027] Data Collection Target 1: Analysis Report on the Curriculumization of Intangible Cultural Heritage.

[0028] Data collection method and results 1: Data such as cultural type, unit organization, and learning tasks of the selected intangible cultural heritage projects were obtained from the intangible cultural heritage curriculum construction model in the analysis report, and sample sets of curriculum materials were directly obtained from the analysis report.

[0029] Data collection target 2: Questionnaire survey system.

[0030] Data collection method and results 2: Create a questionnaire in the questionnaire survey system and send it to each instructor. After all instructors have completed the questionnaire, download the questionnaire results of each instructor from the questionnaire survey system. The questionnaire questions should include at least: familiarity with each intangible cultural heritage project (familiarity level is 1-5, with higher levels indicating higher familiarity), etc. The questionnaire results are stored in JSON format, and the final structured data is used as the self-evaluation data table of each instructor.

[0031] Preprocessing method and results: The data in each of the above JSON structured forms are used as input to the JSON interpreter to obtain the standardized data of each input data. Then, each standardized data is used as input to the jieba word segmentation algorithm to perform stop word removal and word segmentation on each standardized data to obtain the word segmentation list of each standardized data.

[0032] Therefore, each intangible cultural heritage item, each unit organization, and each teaching resource corresponds to a word segmentation list.

[0033] The jieba word segmentation algorithm enables new word HMM discovery mode and precise mode during processing, and loads dictionaries related to intangible cultural heritage, such as the National Intangible Cultural Heritage List, to ensure that various intangible cultural heritage professional terms are not incorrectly segmented during the word segmentation process, thereby improving the accuracy of the word segmentation results. The process of using the jieba word segmentation algorithm to segment text is a well-known technology and will not be described in detail here.

[0034] Calculation of the first theoretical degree of practice: Processing logic: Intangible cultural heritage projects include both literature-based projects that lean towards theory and skill-based projects that lean towards practice, and the degree to which different intangible cultural heritage projects lean towards theory or practice varies; at the same time, the degree of bias towards theory and practice will also vary among different unit organizations and teaching resources within the same intangible cultural heritage project. Therefore, this embodiment quantifies the degree of bias towards theory and practice of each intangible cultural heritage project at two levels: the overall project and the internal project.

[0035] Target objects: Word segmentation lists of various intangible cultural heritage projects and teaching resources.

[0036] Preliminary preparation: Based on the experience of experts in the field, analyze the theoretical vocabulary (e.g., history, development, principles, processes, documents, etc.) and practical vocabulary (e.g., experience, hands-on, textiles, painting, interaction, etc.) in intangible cultural heritage projects or teaching resources, and then construct a pre-set theoretical dictionary and a pre-set practical dictionary respectively. Both dictionaries are stored in the form of hash sets to support fast matching under hash lookup.

[0037] Processing content 1: First, all the words in each word segmentation list are used as input to the TextRank algorithm, which outputs the keywords in all the word segments. Then, all the keywords are used as input to the TF-IDF algorithm to calculate the TF-IDF value of each keyword.

[0038] Furthermore, for each keyword in the intangible cultural heritage project, a hash lookup method is used to match each keyword with the theoretical dictionary and the practical dictionary respectively, and the number of successful matches in each dictionary is counted and denoted as n1 and n2 respectively. The higher the n1, the more keywords are successfully matched with the theoretical dictionary, and the more the intangible cultural heritage project is biased towards theory; the same applies to n2.

[0039] Next, calculate the sum of the TF-IDF values ​​of all successfully matched keywords in the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary, and denote them as TF1 and TF2, respectively; As the weight w1 of n1, As the weight w2 of n2; As the first theoretical and practical dimension, among which... , All represent preset constants greater than 0. In this embodiment... The value is one-thousandth of TF1+TF2. The value of is one-thousandth of w2. In practical applications, as other implementation methods, implementers can also set it according to specific circumstances. This embodiment does not impose any special restrictions. This indicates the preset minimum number of successful matches, which is 1 in this embodiment; max() represents the maximum value function.

[0040] Processing content 2: Regarding teaching resources, the first theoretical-practice degree of the teaching resources is calculated according to the first theoretical-practice degree of the intangible cultural heritage project. The specific process will not be elaborated here.

[0041] Logical explanation: The first theoretical-practice degree is used to characterize the relative bias of the text content of a single intangible cultural heritage project or a single teaching resource in the two dimensions of theory and practice. This indicator is based on the number of successful matches between keywords and the preset theoretical dictionary and preset practical dictionary, and is corrected by the sum of the TF-IDF values ​​of the successfully matched keywords as the weight, so that keywords with high frequency and strong distinguishing ability contribute more to the quantitative results. The greater the degree of theoretical practice, the more keywords in the text of the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project or teaching resource that successfully match the theoretical dictionary, and the higher their importance. In other words, the content is mainly theoretical learning content such as knowledge teaching, principle explanation, and cultural origin tracing. This reflects the greater the degree to which the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project or teaching resource is biased towards theoretical types, and it is more suitable for undertaking background explanation and knowledge transmission teaching tasks in teaching applications. Conversely, the lower the first theoretical-practical degree, the more likely the successfully matched keywords come from the practice dictionary. That is, their content is mainly practical, such as operation demonstrations, technique training, and hands-on experience. This reflects the deeper the practical orientation of the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project or teaching resource, making it more suitable for practical demonstration and training teaching tasks. Thus, the first theoretical-practical degree transforms the theoretical and practical attributes that could only be qualitatively perceived into calculable and comparable quantitative values, providing a data foundation for subsequent cluster analysis of teaching resources and determination of the theoretical-practical orientation of intangible cultural heritage projects.

[0042] Calculation of the second theoretical degree of practice: Precondition judgment: Scenario 1: For each intangible cultural heritage project, calculate the standard deviation and range of the normalized values ​​of the first theoretical-practice degree of all its teaching resources. If both the standard deviation and range are less than or equal to the preset threshold, it indicates that the theoretical-practice bias level of all teaching resources within the intangible cultural heritage project is basically consistent and only a single type exists, so no further calculation is required. In this embodiment, the preset threshold is 0.1. In actual application, as other implementation methods, implementers can also set it according to specific circumstances. This embodiment does not impose any special restrictions. Scenario 2: If the number of teaching resources contained in each unit of the intangible cultural heritage project is less than or equal to 2, then the sample size condition required for clustering is not met, and no further calculation is needed.

[0043] For all other intangible cultural heritage items not falling into the two categories mentioned above, the following calculation of the second theoretical-practice degree shall be performed: Local Clustering: All teaching resources under each intangible cultural heritage project are used as input to the clustering algorithm. The absolute difference between the first theoretical and practical normalized values ​​of the teaching resources is used as the distance metric in the clustering process. The number of clusters is set to 2, and 2 clusters are output. The mean of the first theoretical and practical normalized values ​​of all teaching resources in each cluster is calculated. All teaching resources in the cluster with the largest mean are denoted as theoretical local teaching resources, and all teaching resources in the other cluster are denoted as practical local teaching resources.

[0044] Global Clustering: All teaching resources under all intangible cultural heritage projects are used as input to the clustering algorithm. The absolute difference between the first theoretical and practical normalized values ​​of the teaching resources is used as the distance metric in the clustering process. The number of clusters is set to 2, and 2 clusters are output. The mean of the first theoretical and practical normalized values ​​of all teaching resources in each cluster is calculated. All teaching resources in the cluster with the largest mean are denoted as theoretical global teaching resources, and all teaching resources in the other cluster are denoted as practical global teaching resources.

[0045] It should be noted that the clustering algorithm used in the above clustering process is the k-means clustering algorithm. In practical applications, as other implementation methods, implementers may also choose other clustering algorithms according to specific circumstances. This embodiment does not impose any special restrictions on the selection of clustering algorithms.

[0046] It should be noted that this embodiment uses the maximum value normalization method to normalize the first theoretical and practical degree of all teaching resources. Specifically, the maximum value among the first theoretical and practical degrees of all teaching resources is used as the maximum value parameter in the normalization method, thereby normalizing the theoretical and practical degree of the teaching resources to the interval [0,1]. The process of normalizing the data using the maximum value normalization method is a well-known technique and will not be described in detail here.

[0047] Furthermore, the second theoretical and practical dimension of each intangible cultural heritage project is constructed, and the specific process is as follows: The second theoretical and practical degree of intangible cultural heritage project i The expression is: In the formula, , These represent the total number of theoretical local teaching resources and the total number of practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i, respectively. This indicates the number of practical, global teaching resources among the theoretical, local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i. This indicates the number of theoretical global teaching resources among the practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i; This represents the total number of teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i.

[0048] Logical explanation: The second theoretical-practice degree is used to characterize the overall distribution structure of all teaching resources within an intangible cultural heritage project at both the theoretical and practical ends. It is a supplement and correction to the first theoretical-practice degree. This indicator is constructed based on the cross-comparison results of local clustering and global clustering: n3 and n4 reflect the comparison of the number of theoretical local and practical local teaching resources within the project, while n5 and n6 characterize the special resources that contradict the local type and the global type—that is, the resources that are "relatively theoretical within the project, but practically practical when measured in all projects" (n5), and the resources that are "relatively practical within the project, but theoretically theoretical when measured globally" (n6). The greater the degree of theoretical practice, the more theoretical teaching resources there are within the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project, and the higher the consistency between the relative theoretical orientation of the teaching resources within the intangible cultural heritage project and the overall measurement results. This reflects that the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project as a whole is indeed dominated by theoretical teaching resources, and it is reliable to judge that the project is theoretically biased. Conversely, a lower second theoretical-practice degree indicates a higher proportion of practical local teaching resources within the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project, or the existence of more resources that contradict the local and global judgments. This reflects that the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project as a whole is biased towards practice, or that the distribution of its resources has a particular bias. If the judgment is based solely on the first theoretical-practice degree, it will produce a deviation. Therefore, the second theoretical-practice degree, through cross-verification of local and global aspects, eliminates the illusion of "local bias but not global bias," and elevates the judgment of the theoretical-practice bias of intangible cultural heritage projects from a single-level quantification to a two-level cross-verification, significantly improving the accuracy and credibility of the judgment results.

[0049] The process of determining the theoretical and practical biases of intangible cultural heritage projects: After calculating the first and second theoretical degrees of practice for all intangible cultural heritage items, the first and second theoretical degrees of practice for all intangible cultural heritage items are normalized using the maximum value normalization method, so that the values ​​of the two types of normalized values ​​are both within the range of [0,1].

[0050] Then, the mean of the normalized values ​​of the first theoretical practice degree and the second theoretical practice degree of each intangible cultural heritage item is calculated and recorded as the comprehensive theoretical practice degree. For intangible cultural heritage items that have not undergone the calculation of the second theoretical practice degree (i.e., intangible cultural heritage items that skip the calculation because they meet the precondition judgment), the normalized value of their first theoretical practice degree is directly used as the comprehensive theoretical practice degree for subsequent processing.

[0051] Based on the ternary multiple principle, the range [0,1] is divided into three mutually exclusive and continuously overlapping intervals of equal width: where, For the first interval, This is the second interval. This is the third interval.

[0052] If the overall theoretical and practical degree of an intangible cultural heritage project falls within the first interval, it indicates that the project belongs to the practical type; if it falls within the second interval, it indicates that the project belongs to the balanced type of theory and practice; if it falls within the third interval, it indicates that the project belongs to the theoretical type.

[0053] If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the first interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the practical type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the second interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the balanced theoretical and practical type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the third interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the theoretical type. The first, second, and third intervals are arranged in ascending order of numerical value.

[0054] Preferably, the schematic diagram of the intangible cultural heritage item classification process provided in this embodiment is as follows: Figure 2 As shown.

[0055] In this embodiment, the specific process for constructing the intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, the selection process for the final recommended projects and resources in step S2 will be explained as follows: Construction of an Intangible Cultural Heritage Knowledge Graph: The standardized data of all intangible cultural heritage projects in the preprocessing step are used as input to a knowledge extraction tool (e.g., KnowLM). The input data is processed to extract entities, relations, and attributes, and triples are formed by combining "head entity - relation - tail entity" and "entity - attribute name - attribute value".

[0056] Entities include, but are not limited to, intangible cultural heritage project entities and unit organization entities; among them, examples of intangible cultural heritage project entities are such as "Peking Opera masks"; unit organization entities are unit organizations formed by breaking down each intangible cultural heritage project, such as "Unit Organization One" and "Unit Organization Two".

[0057] Relationships include, but are not limited to, the following three categories: The first category is the category affiliation relationship at the cultural type level, that is, the relationship between an intangible cultural heritage item and its cultural type, for example, "Peking Opera facial makeup" belongs to "traditional crafts"; The second category is the disassembly and subordination relationship between an intangible cultural heritage item and a unit organization, for example, "Peking Opera facial makeup" can be disassembled into "unit organization one" and "unit organization two", that is, "Peking Opera facial makeup" and each unit organization are connected through an "inclusion" relationship; The third category is the sequential logical relationship between unit organizations, such as the progressive relationship of "conducting unit organization one first, then unit organization two", or the parallel relationship of "conducting unit organization one and unit organization two simultaneously", etc.

[0058] It should be noted that "traditional crafts" refers to the category of intangible cultural heritage projects rather than the relationship between projects. Therefore, it is stored in the graph as an attribute value or category node. If there is a connection between two intangible cultural heritage projects in the actual project (e.g., inheritance of techniques, related themes, etc.), they can also be connected through the corresponding relationship edges. This application does not limit this.

[0059] Attributes include, but are not limited to, the hierarchical positioning of each intangible cultural heritage project, the theoretical and practical bias intervals (i.e., the judgment results of the first, second, or third intervals obtained from the interval division step, stored in the form of theoretical and practical bias types and their corresponding interval values), and the number of teaching resource hierarchical texts organized in each unit that are higher than HSK5, etc. Among them, the theoretical and practical bias type is directly written into the graph as an attribute of the intangible cultural heritage project entity for preference matching and screening in the subsequent teaching resource recommendation step.

[0060] The method of linking teaching resources: Various teaching resources (micro-videos, graded texts, glossaries, situational task sheets, learning scaffolds, etc.) are not stored as separate entity nodes, but as auxiliary data of unit organization entities. At the same time, the normalized value of the first theoretical and practical degree of each teaching resource is added to the resource metadata table of that teaching resource. The teaching resource establishes a connection with the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project entity and unit organization entity in the graph through the two fields of "belonging project" and "belonging project unit organization" in its resource metadata table.

[0061] All the triples extracted above are used as input to a knowledge graph construction tool (e.g., Neo4j) to construct an intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph. The open-source knowledge extraction tool and knowledge graph construction tool are well-known technologies, and their specific implementation methods will not be elaborated here.

[0062] Selection of final recommended projects and resources: First, instructors need to input teaching requests using a pre-set template. The teaching request fields must include at least: instructor's name, student's HSK level (e.g., 3), teaching type, and teaching preference. The teaching preference field uses a numerical coding format: code 0 indicates a preference for theory, code 1 indicates a balance between theory and practice, and code 2 indicates a preference for practice.

[0063] 1. Initial screening of candidate intangible cultural heritage items: Based on the coded values ​​of teaching preferences in the teaching request, intangible cultural heritage (ICH) project entities corresponding to the biased intervals are retrieved from the ICH knowledge graph (the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree of each ICH project has been written into the graph as an attribute), forming a candidate project set: If the coding value of teaching preference is 0, it means that the current teaching request is biased towards the theoretical type. Then, all intangible cultural heritage projects with a comprehensive theoretical and practical degree in the third interval (i.e. biased towards the theoretical type) are selected to form a candidate project set. If the coding value of teaching preference is 1, it means that the current teaching request is biased towards a balance between theory and practice. In this case, all intangible cultural heritage projects with a comprehensive theoretical and practical degree in the second interval (i.e., a balance between theory and practice) are selected to form a candidate project set. If the teaching preference code value is 2, it means that the current teaching request is biased towards the practical type. Then, select all intangible cultural heritage projects with a comprehensive theoretical and practical degree in the first interval (i.e. biased towards the practical type) to form a candidate project set.

[0064] Then, the "teaching type" field in the teaching request is read and matched with the "cultural type" attribute of all intangible cultural heritage projects in the initial candidate project set. Intangible cultural heritage projects that do not match the cultural type are removed from the initial candidate project set, and the remaining intangible cultural heritage projects are combined into a candidate project set.

[0065] Specifically, if the number of intangible cultural heritage (ICH) items in the initial candidate project set obtained after the above elimination is less than a preset threshold (the preset threshold is 3 in this embodiment), then starting from each ICH item in the candidate project set, a one-hop traversal is performed along the relationship edges between ICH items in the ICH knowledge graph (e.g., "similar techniques", "related themes"), and other ICH items that have a direct relationship with any candidate ICH item are added to the initial candidate project set. ICH items added by expanding from the relationship edges also need to pass the familiarity verification before they can be retained. Thus, when there are not enough candidate ICH items, the semantic associations between ICH items in the graph are used to supplement the candidates, ensuring the usability of the recommendation results.

[0066] 2. Candidate project selection based on teacher familiarity: Read the "Instructor's Name" field from the teaching request, retrieve the instructor's self-evaluation data table for intangible cultural heritage teaching from the self-evaluation data table, and extract the familiarity level of each intangible cultural heritage item; remove intangible cultural heritage items with a familiarity level lower than 3 from the candidate item set (familiarity level is 1-5, with the higher the level, the higher the familiarity), and obtain the updated candidate item set, which is recorded as the second-screen candidate item set, thereby ensuring that the final recommended items are all within the teaching scope that the instructor is capable of handling.

[0067] 3. Final selection of recommended projects: If the teaching preference leans towards theory, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the highest and second highest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects; if the teaching preference is a balance between theory and practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the first and second highest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set that are close to the preset values ​​will be selected as the final recommended projects; if the teaching preference leans towards practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the lowest and second lowest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects.

[0068] In this embodiment, the preset value is 0.5. In actual applications, as other implementation methods, implementers can also set it according to specific circumstances. This embodiment does not impose any special restrictions.

[0069] Quantity-based catch-all judgment: If the number of intangible cultural heritage items in the candidate project set obtained during the above processing is less than or equal to 2, then the subsequent sorting and selection will not be performed, and all intangible cultural heritage items in the candidate project set will be directly used as the final recommended projects; if the candidate project set is empty, then a prompt message will be sent to the instructor that there are no suitable projects.

[0070] 4. Final Recommended Resource Selection: For each final recommended project, starting from the final recommended project entity, traverse the subordinate unit organization entities along the "include" relationship edge in the intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, and locate all teaching resources under the unit organization through the "belonging project" and "belonging project unit organization" fields of the resource metadata table in the supplementary data of each teaching resource, and perform the following three steps of resource screening for each unit organization.

[0071] Level matching step: Read the student's HSK level field from the teaching request, denoted as l1 (e.g., l1=3); read the value corresponding to the "level text" field in the resource metadata table of each teaching resource, denoted as l0 (e.g., l0=2, indicating that at least HSK-2 level is required to use the teaching resource); calculate the difference between l1 and l0. If the difference is greater than or equal to 0, that is, the student's HSK level is not lower than the minimum level requirement of the teaching resource, then the match is successful; otherwise, the match fails, and the teaching resources that fail to match are removed. The remaining teaching resources in each final recommendation project are denoted as the initial screening teaching resources.

[0072] Type Filtering Step: Extract the first theory-practice normalized value 'b' from the resource metadata table of each teaching resource, and determine the interval of the first theory-practice normalized value of the teaching resource according to the same interval division method as the comprehensive theory-practice value; retain resources according to teaching preferences: if the code is 0, retain teaching resources whose first theory-practice normalized value is in the third interval; if the code is 1, retain teaching resources whose first theory-practice normalized value is in the second interval; if the code is 2, retain teaching resources whose first theory-practice normalized value is in the first interval.

[0073] The sorting and selection process involves sorting the retained teaching resources in descending order, following the same principle as the comprehensive theory-practice degree: when the code is 0, the first two teaching resources in the sorted results are selected as the final recommended resources; when the code is 2, the last two teaching resources in the sorted results are selected as the final recommended resources; and when the code is 1, the teaching resources with the first and second normalized values ​​of the first theory-practice degree that are close to 0.5 are selected as the final recommended resources. Thus, two teaching resources are selected as the final recommended resources for each unit organization. Based on the teaching implementation order represented by the "first...then..." or "simultaneously..." relationship edges between unit organizations, each unit organization and its final recommended resources are sequentially arranged and output.

[0074] Similarly, if a unit has two or fewer initial screening teaching resources, then the sorting and selection process will not be performed, and all of them will be directly used as the final recommended resources for that unit.

[0075] Based on the same inventive concept as the above methods, this application also provides a teaching resource recommendation system based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, including a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and running on the processor. When the processor executes the computer program, it implements the steps of any one of the above-described teaching resource recommendation methods based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph.

Claims

1. A teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, characterized in that, The method includes the following steps: Each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it is matched with a pre-set theoretical dictionary and a pre-set practical dictionary to determine the first theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item and any teaching resource within it. The teaching resources are clustered based on the first theoretical-practical degree, and the second theoretical-practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item is determined based on the cross-comparison of the clustering results. The theoretical-practical bias type of each intangible cultural heritage item is determined by combining the first theoretical-practical degree and the second theoretical-practical degree. The system obtains the teaching requests of instructors and, based on their theoretical and practical orientations, selects intangible cultural heritage projects to form a candidate project set. The candidate project set is then filtered layer by layer to obtain the final recommended projects. Within each unit of the final recommended projects, the final recommended resources are selected based on the first degree of theoretical and practical application of the teaching resources. Finally, the final recommended projects and their corresponding final recommended resources are pushed to the instructors.

2. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The process for determining the first theoretical degree of practical application is as follows: Extract keywords from the word segmentation list corresponding to each intangible cultural heritage item and determine the TF-IDF value of each keyword; match all keywords with the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary respectively, and count the number of successful matches, denoted as n1 and n2 respectively; Calculate the sum of the TF-IDF values ​​of all successfully matched keywords in the preset theoretical dictionary and the preset practical dictionary, and denote them as TF1 and TF2, respectively; As the weight w1 of n1, As the weight w2 of n2; As the first theoretical and practical dimension, among which... , Both represent preset constants greater than 0. This indicates the minimum number of successful matches, and max() represents the maximum value function.

3. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The absolute difference between the normalized values ​​of the first theoretical and practical degrees of teaching resources within each intangible cultural heritage project is used as the distance metric in the clustering process.

4. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The clustering results include theoretical local teaching resources, practical local teaching resources, theoretical global teaching resources, and practical global teaching resources.

5. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 4, characterized in that, The process for determining the second theoretical and practical degree of each intangible cultural heritage item is as follows: The second theoretical and practical degree of intangible cultural heritage project i The expression is: In the formula, , These represent the total number of theoretical local teaching resources and the total number of practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i, respectively. This indicates the number of practical, global teaching resources among the theoretical, local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i. This indicates the number of theoretical global teaching resources among the practical local teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i; This represents the total number of teaching resources under intangible cultural heritage item i.

6. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The determination of the theoretical and practical bias types of each intangible cultural heritage project includes: The average of the normalized values ​​of the first and second theoretical-practice degrees of each intangible cultural heritage item is denoted as the comprehensive theoretical-practice degree. The [0,1] range is divided into three intervals according to the ternary principle. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the first interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the practical type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the second interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the theoretical and practical balance type. If the comprehensive theoretical and practical degree is in the third interval, the corresponding intangible cultural heritage project is determined to be of the theoretical type. The first, second, and third intervals are arranged in ascending order of numerical value.

7. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 6, characterized in that, The teaching requests of the instructors include the instructor's name, the student's HSK level, the type of course, and the teaching preferences. The teaching preferences include a preference for theory, a balance between theory and practice, and a preference for practice.

8. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 7, characterized in that, The process for obtaining the final recommended projects is as follows: The teaching type in the teaching request of the instructor is matched with the cultural type of each intangible cultural heritage project in the candidate project set. Projects that do not match are eliminated to obtain the initial candidate project set. Obtain the familiarity level of each intangible cultural heritage item among the instructors, and remove items in the candidate item set whose familiarity level is lower than the preset level to obtain the second set of candidate items. If the teaching preference leans towards theory, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the highest and second-highest comprehensive theoretical and practical integration from the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects; If the teaching preference is a balance between theory and practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the highest and second highest comprehensive theoretical and practical scores that are close to the preset values ​​will be selected as the final recommended projects. If the teaching preference leans towards practice, then the intangible cultural heritage projects with the lowest and second lowest comprehensive theoretical and practical content in the second-screen candidate project set will be selected as the final recommended projects.

9. The teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in claim 6, characterized in that, The final recommended resource selection process is as follows: The HSK level of the current student in the teaching request is compared with the minimum HSK level of each teaching resource represented by the graded text of each teaching resource in each unit organization under the final recommendation project. Teaching resources that do not meet the current student's HSK level are eliminated, and the remaining teaching resources are used as the initial screening teaching resources. Based on the bias type corresponding to the teaching preference, teaching resources whose first theoretical and practical degree normalization value is in the corresponding interval are retained; where the interval is divided according to the interval division method of intangible cultural heritage projects. Within each unit organization under the final recommended project, the final recommended resources for each unit organization under the final recommended project are selected from the initial screening teaching resources based on the normalized value of the first theoretical and practical degree of the initial screening teaching resources.

10. A teaching resource recommendation system based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph, comprising a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and running on the processor, characterized in that, When the processor executes the computer program, it implements the steps of the teaching resource recommendation method based on intangible cultural heritage knowledge graph as described in any one of claims 1-9.