METHOD FOR PERFORMING A TEST RUN ON A TEST BENCH
Patent Information
- Application Number
- DE502019012462
- Authority / Receiving Office
- DE · DE
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2018-12-10
- Filing Date
- 2019-12-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- 2039-12-09
AI Technical Summary
Current test bench methods using standardized test cycles fail to accurately predict a vehicle's compliance with real-world pollutant emission limits under the Real Driving Emissions (RDE) test procedure, leading to unpredictable development outcomes and potential costly rework for manufacturers.
A method and test bench configuration that includes a detection unit to determine deviations in simulation values from reference values, with a correction unit adjusting these values to minimize deviations, ensuring accurate simulation and compliance with RDE test procedures by continuously correcting simulation speeds and positions based on tolerance thresholds.
This approach allows for precise simulation and prediction of vehicle performance under RDE conditions, reducing the risk of non-compliance and associated development delays or rework, by continuously adjusting simulation parameters to match reference values, thereby ensuring accurate emission measurements and compliance with legal limits.
Description
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for carrying out a test run on a test bench with a test specimen, wherein a simulation unit is given a number of reference values by a reference unit, wherein the simulation unit simulates a number of simulation values using the number of reference values, wherein at least one target value and furthermore at least one control value for controlling the test specimen are determined from the number of simulation values.
[0002] Furthermore, the present invention relates to a test bench with a test specimen for carrying out a test run, wherein a reference unit is provided which specifies a number of reference values to a simulation unit, wherein the simulation unit is configured to simulate a number of simulation values using the number of reference values and to determine at least one target value from the number of simulation values and to transmit it to a control unit, wherein the control unit is configured to specify at least one control variable for controlling the test specimen based on the at least one target value.
[0003] The publication "Development of an Engine-in-the-loop Vehicle Simulation System in Engine Dynamometer Test Cell", Jiang, S. et al., SAE World Congress & Exhibition, 2009, reveals an engine-in-the-loop testing system.
[0004] There are legal requirements for permissible pollutant emissions from vehicles (especially CO₂, CO, NOₓ, and particle number), for example, Regulation (EC) No. 715 / 2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council, which defines the Euro 5 and Euro 6 standards. Compliance with these legal requirements is currently verified using standardized test cycles (such as the New European Driving Cycle (NEDC)) on test benches. For this purpose, the exhaust gas generated during the test cycle is extracted and analyzed on the test bench. The problem here is that the conditions on the test bench during the standardized test cycle are not comparable to real-world conditions when the vehicle is driven on a real road. Therefore, a vehicle may meet the legal requirements on the test bench but still exceed them in real-world driving.
[0005] To prevent this, legislators are striving to shift the verification of prescribed pollutant emission limits from the test bench to real-world driving conditions. This requires that pollutant emissions be measured and verified during actual vehicle driving on a real road using Portable Emission Measurement Systems (PEMS). Consequently, there is no longer a standardized test cycle, as driving on a public road with normal traffic is always subject to random influences. The legislator's goal is to ensure that a vehicle complies with pollutant emission limits under normal operating conditions, and not just on the test bench. The legislator also sets requirements for the evaluation of pollutant emissions after the test drive, such as the use of specific data analysis tools.
[0006] The legislator defines a Real Driving Emissions (RDE) test procedure for this purpose. This procedure specifies only certain requirements for the vehicle mass, ambient temperature, and the altitude at which the test drive must take place. Additionally, it defines the proportions to which different driving situations must be included in the test procedure, for example, a 33% ± 10% split between urban, rural, and motorway driving, with at least 16 km of driving on each, a vehicle speed on rural roads between 60 and 90 km / h, and a test drive length of 90 to 120 minutes, etc. Since this test is to be conducted on a public road, each test drive is subject to random influences, such as other traffic, the positioning and timing of traffic lights, etc. It is therefore immediately apparent that a real test drive is not reproducible but rather represents a more or less random sequence of events.
[0007] This paradigm shift also has a direct impact on vehicle manufacturers in the development of new vehicles and, in particular, new engines. Previously, every development step could be verified using standardized test cycles on the test bench. This simply required subjecting the respective test vehicle to the test cycle after each development step and examining its pollutant emissions. This is no longer possible with the new RDE test procedure, as it is fundamentally impossible to predict whether a newly developed vehicle will ultimately pass the RDE test procedure by complying with the pollutant emission limits. Only the finished vehicle can be driven on real roads; that is, the RDE test procedure can only be carried out at the very end of the development process.If the vehicle fails this test, it would understandably have enormous consequences for the vehicle manufacturer, who in extreme cases would have to at least partially restart years of development at enormous cost and expense.
[0008] The use of existing standardized test cycles during vehicle development is also of no help, since compliance with the limits of pollutant emissions using such standardized test cycles does not automatically ensure compliance with these limits under the RDE test procedure.
[0009] One could combine all possible operating states of a vehicle in a single test scenario and use this scenario to verify each development step. However, this is hardly practical, as implementing such a test scenario on a test bench would be very time-consuming, delaying development, increasing expensive test bench time, and generally being very costly. Arbitrarily creating a test scenario is also not practical, as it would not guarantee compliance with the legal requirements of the RDE test procedure.
[0010] Furthermore, not every driving maneuver, such as accelerating from low engine speed, overtaking on a country road, turning in city traffic, etc., will necessarily have the same effect on pollutant emissions in every vehicle. This means that a test scenario may be suitable for one vehicle but not for another.
[0011] The above principles generally apply equally to other developmental targets of a vehicle, such as fuel consumption, even though there are no (at least not yet) legal requirements for this. Fuel consumption is, however, usually a development goal in vehicle design, which is why achieving the target consumption, for example in the RDE test procedure, is also a priority.
[0012] For emissions tests in real-world driving conditions, the actual speed and position of a vehicle are recorded as reference values over a reference period during actual test drives. These reference values serve as a basis for driving maneuvers. During a simulation session on a test bench, these reference values are provided by a reference unit and can be processed before the simulation begins. The reference values can be varied and / or worst-case scenarios can be simulated. If the simulation is performed on a test bench, certain parts of the vehicle model, such as the engine or powertrain, can be replaced by corresponding parts on the test bench.
[0013] A vehicle simulation has three fundamental components: the simulated route, the simulated vehicle, and the simulated driver. The simulated driver controls the simulated vehicle along the simulated route at a simulated speed that should correspond to the predefined reference speed. To achieve this, the simulated driver can adhere to the reference time or the reference position. However, slight deviations of the simulated speed from the reference speed cannot be prevented. The simulated route can also include environmental characteristics such as temperature, air pressure, wind, and "opposing" traffic, such as other vehicles.
[0014] If the simulation speed is specified based on the reference time, slight deviations of the simulation speed from the reference speed will result in an accumulated deviation of the simulation position from the reference position. For example, if, during a simulation, an accumulated position deviation of 20 m occurs after a certain duration at a reference position of 80 km, this simulation position of 80 km and one meter has a relative error of only 0.025%. If the vehicle is to stop on a steep hill (i.e.,
[0015] If the simulation speed is zero, for example to test emissions during a hill start, the simulated vehicle, with a supposed reference position of 80 km, would already be at a simulation position of 80 km and 20 m. If this simulation position is located at a point on the track where there is no incline, a simulated stop and start of the vehicle would therefore lead to distorted results, especially regarding emissions measurements.
[0016] If the simulation speed is specified based on the reference position, slight deviations of the simulation speed from the reference speed will result in a deviation of the simulation time from the reference time. For example, if a reference speed of 130 km / h is initially specified and then reduced to 40 km / h at a specific reference time, perhaps due to a sharp curve at a highway exit, and the simulation time deviates from the reference time by a few seconds, this would result in a speed of 130 km / h during the sharp curve. This could, in turn, lead to problems during the simulation or reproduction, for example, due to very high, incorrectly simulated, lateral accelerations. Furthermore, with a position-dependent simulation speed, the simulation cannot restart after a stop at a specific reference position; it will freeze.
[0017] A time-based determination of a simulation speed therefore causes deviations of the simulation position from the reference position, a position-based determination of the simulation speed causes deviations of the simulation time from the reference time.
[0018] It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a method and a test rig that enables simulation while avoiding the aforementioned problems. The subject matter for which protection is sought is specified in the patent claims.
[0019] This problem is solved according to the invention by using a detection unit to determine a deviation of a comparison simulation value from the number of simulation values from a comparison reference value from the number of reference values, preferably by a tolerance; when a deviation x is detected, a correction unit determines a corrected reference value from a selected reference value from the number of reference values; the simulation unit is given the corrected reference value instead of the selected reference value to simulate a corrected simulation value, thereby reducing the deviation; and the at least one target value is determined using the corrected simulation value.
[0020] The problem is solved by a test bench on which a detection unit is provided, which is designed to detect a deviation of a comparison simulation value from the number of simulation values from a comparison reference value from the number of reference values, preferably by a tolerance, wherein a correction unit is provided, which is designed, in the event of a detected deviation, to determine a corrected reference value from a selected reference value from the number of reference values and to specify a corrected simulation value to the simulation unit instead of the selected reference value, thereby reducing the deviation and determining at least one target value using the corrected simulation value.
[0021] First, a comparison simulation value is compared with a comparison reference value that is equivalent to the comparison simulation value; that is, for example, a simulation position is compared with a reference position. Of course, several comparison simulation values can also be compared with their corresponding comparison reference values to identify any deviations. If a deviation between the comparison simulation value and the corresponding comparison reference value is detected, the comparison simulation value itself is not changed according to the invention. Instead, a selected reference value from the number of reference values is replaced by a corrected reference value, whereby the selected reference value does not correspond to the comparison reference value according to the invention.Since the simulation unit now calculates a corrected simulation value based on the corrected reference value instead of the (uncorrected) simulation value, the deviation is consequently reduced. This allows at least one target value to be determined using the corrected simulation value, thus correcting at least one target value as well.
[0022] Thus, the method, or rather the detection unit or correction unit, can also be integrated into an existing test bench. The selected reference value, which was previously provided to the simulation unit by the reference unit, is changed to a corrected reference value, which is then provided to the simulation unit instead of the originally selected reference value. The method therefore does not have to be integrated into the test bench but can also be retrofitted by connecting a suitable detection unit or correction unit between the reference unit and the simulation unit. Since only the selected reference value is replaced by a corrected reference value, the method can be used on all test benches where a simulation unit receives a number of reference values from a reference unit in this manner.The method can also be activated during an ongoing simulation to reduce or eliminate a deviation. This allows for the activation of the method on test benches, or the integration of the correction unit into test benches with simulation units using more complex driver models that require, for example, predictive information such as speed and inclination data.
[0023] It is also possible to specify a further target value for at least one load machine associated with the test specimen using the corrected simulation value.
[0024] The method according to the invention can be carried out in one or more cycles of the test run.
[0025] Advantageously, the corrected reference value can be continuously increased or decreased, thus enabling a rapid reduction of the deviation between the comparison simulation value and the comparison reference value without introducing jumps in the selected reference value. The method according to the invention is therefore carried out in several cycles of the test run.
[0026] The corrected reference value can be increased or decreased until no deviation occurs. This ensures that the comparison simulation value matches the comparison reference value.
[0027] Advantageously, the procedure is started at the beginning of the test run, thus minimizing or preventing deviations from the outset. Of course, the procedure can also be started when the simulation is already well advanced and a significant deviation may already exist. The procedure can also be applied during operation on the test bench, for example, to evaluate changes made during the simulation, such as changes to driver or transmission values, or it can be activated and deactivated several times during a test run.
[0028] The method can be performed throughout the entire test run to completely prevent or minimize deviations, e.g., within a tolerance band. Thus, the method according to the invention is carried out in all cycles of the test run.
[0029] Preferably, the number of reference values comprises a reference position at a reference time and a reference velocity at a reference time, wherein the number of simulation values simulated by the simulation unit comprises a simulation velocity at a simulation time and a simulation position at a simulation time. Thus, the reference velocity at the reference time is specified to the simulation unit by the reference unit, whereupon the simulation unit simulates the simulation velocity as well as a simulation position at a simulation time.
[0030] The simulation position can serve as a comparison simulation value, the reference position can serve as a comparison reference value, and the reference velocity can serve as a selected reference value.
[0031] Furthermore, a corrected reference velocity, which is lower than the reference velocity, can be specified for the simulation unit if the simulation position is larger than the reference position and the simulation velocity exceeds a velocity threshold, preferably zero.
[0032] Furthermore, a corrected reference velocity, which is greater than the reference velocity, can be specified for the simulation unit if the simulation position is smaller than the reference position and the simulation velocity exceeds a velocity threshold, preferably zero.
[0033] This means that the positional deviation of the simulation position from the reference position is considered as the deviation of the comparison simulation value from the equivalent comparison reference value. The reference velocity (selected reference value) is replaced by a corrected reference velocity (corrected reference value), which is higher or lower than the reference velocity. Consequently, the simulation unit no longer simulates a simulation position as before, but rather a corrected simulation position (corrected simulation value), thus reducing the deviation. As a result, at least one target value and subsequently at least one control value are specified using the corrected simulation position.
[0034] Preferably, the simulation time is adjusted to a corrected simulation time if it deviates from the reference time and the simulation speed does not exceed the speed threshold, preferably zero. For example, the simulation time can be accelerated or decelerated and thus adjusted to the reference time.
[0035] The speed threshold can be chosen such that a change in the simulation time has no significant effect on the simulation. This is particularly the case if the speed threshold is at zero, in the range of zero to 6 km / h, or between 3 and 6 km / h, i.e., the vehicle is stationary or moving slowly during a stop phase. Only the length of this stop phase is adjusted. This solves a singularity problem that occurs when only the simulation position is adjusted, since the simulation position cannot increase at a simulation speed of zero. Since many stop phases in which the vehicle is stationary are specified by the reference unit, especially in RDE tests, changing the duration of these stop phases by altering the simulation time can correct previously accumulated deviations, e.g.,Time and / or position deviations are reduced, ideally to zero. A position deviation can also be corrected by first correcting a time deviation.
[0036] The present invention is described below with reference to the Figuren 1 bis 7 In more detail, the invention is explained, and exemplary, schematic, and non-restrictive embodiments are shown. This includes showing Fig. 1a a typical test bench setup for a test specimen, Fig. 1 a possible embodiment of the simulation unit, Fig. 2 an exemplary reference run, Fig. 3 a time-based specification of the simulation speed, Fig. 4 a location-based specification of the simulation speed, Fig. 5 a test bench setup according to the invention, Fig. 6 a correction of the reference speed according to the invention, Fig. 7 a correction of the simulation time according to the invention during a stop phase.
[0037] In Fig.1 Figure 1 shows a typical test bench 1 for a test specimen 2, in this case an engine test bench for an internal combustion engine. The test specimen 2 is connected to a load machine 3, for example via a connecting shaft, as shown in Figure 2. Fig.1 As indicated, the test specimen 2 can also comprise a powertrain, an entire vehicle, or individual or multiple components such as transmissions, batteries, etc. Accordingly, test bench 1 can, for example, represent a powertrain test bench or a chassis dynamometer, and may also include more than one load machine 3, e.g., one for each driven half-axle or even one for each axle. The test specimen 2 is operated on test bench 1 according to the specifications of a test run in order to obtain information regarding certain measured variables m of the vehicle, such as pollutant emissions, fuel consumption, the vehicle's acoustic behavior, the vehicle's drivability, the vehicle's durability, and information on the design / optimization of individual components, etc. The measured variable is compared with a target variable. If the measured variable relates to the pollutant emissions of an internal combustion engine, or...Since the test subject 2 refers to the fuel consumption of an internal combustion engine, it naturally also includes an internal combustion engine.
[0038] A simulation unit 4 simulates a vehicle moving on a test track. For this purpose, a reference unit 5 provides simulation unit 4 with a number of reference values ref. During the simulation, simulation unit 4 determines a number of simulation values sim. From these simulation values sim, simulation unit 4 then determines at least one target value T, e.g., a torque, where this target value T can also correspond to a simulation value sim. The target value T can also represent a pedal position of an accelerator pedal or be calculated from a pedal position. The target value T is then transmitted to a control unit ECU, which, based on this target value T, controls the test object 2 with at least one control variable.The control unit ECU, implemented here as an engine control unit, can specify a throttle position α and / or a fuel quantity k (control variable) to the test specimen 2 based on a torque to be generated (target value T).
[0039] The simulation unit 4 can also supply at least one further setpoint, e.g. a rotational speed n, to another control unit 30, whereby the further control unit 30 can control a load machine 3, as in Fig. 1 The actual rotational speed of the load machine 3 acts here from the load machine 3 via the shaft on the test specimen 2.
[0040] Driving robots can also be used on a roller test stand, which operate the vehicle's controls, such as the accelerator pedal, brake pedal, and gearshift, according to the specifications of the test to be carried out.
[0041] Test bench 1 usually also has a number of (not shown in detail) measuring sensors, with which, for example, current actual values of the torque T is and the rotational speed n is of the test specimen 2 are recorded and transmitted to the simulation unit 4.
[0042] On test bench 1, a test run is performed with a specific test specimen 2, and pollutant emissions are measured as a parameter. Depending on the parameter being measured, appropriate measuring units may be provided on test bench 1, such as an emissions measuring unit 6, to which exhaust gas from the combustion engine is fed and which measures specific pollutant emissions, such as CO2, CO, NOx, total mass of hydrocarbons (THC) and / or particle number (such as soot particles), and / or a fuel consumption measuring unit 7, which measures the fuel consumption of the combustion engine.
[0043] Simulation unit 4 and control unit ECU can also be implemented as a single unit, or as shown in Fig.1 They are represented as independent units. The reference unit 5 is in Fig. 1 It can be executed as a standalone unit, but can also be combined with simulation unit 4. Simulation unit 4 includes simulation hardware and / or simulation software used to simulate the vehicle's test drive. For this purpose, simulation unit 4 implements a simulation model, which may include, for example, a driver model 11, a vehicle model 12, and a track model 13. Additional models, such as a tire model, can also be included.
[0044] The road model, etc., is implemented. Simulation unit 4 thus simulates the journey of a virtual vehicle (vehicle model 12), controlled by a virtual driver (driver model 11), along a virtual test track (environment model 13), whereby certain events, such as traffic signs, traffic lights, other traffic, etc., can also be simulated. Events are perceived by the virtual driver in driver model 11 and translated into corresponding reactions. A part of the vehicle, such as the combustion engine or a powertrain, is physically set up as real hardware on test bench 1 as test specimen 2 and is operated on test bench 1 according to the specifications of the simulation. This procedure for conducting a test is also well known and is often referred to as X-in-the-Loop testing, where the "X" stands for the respective test specimen 2, which is physically present.This method of conducting a test is very flexible and can closely resemble a real test drive with a real vehicle. Variations for worst-case scenarios can also be made and evaluated. These variations can be defined very abstractly, for example, in the form of increased vehicle mass, heavier traffic, strong headwinds, more aggressive driving behavior, etc.
[0045] The test run created in this way allows the vehicle development to be carried out at all development stages, and it can significantly increase the probability of complying with certain target parameters, such as legal limits for pollutant emissions during a test using an RDE (Real Driving Emissions) procedure. The same applies analogously to other metrics, such as fuel consumption, drivability, acoustic behavior, and durability, instead of pollutant emissions.
[0046] A test run typically includes many different driving maneuvers, such as acceleration, deceleration, standstill, constant speed driving, cornering, etc., under specific boundary conditions, such as engine speed, torque, steering angle, road gradient, traffic, etc. Driving maneuvers can include starting from a standstill, accelerating out of a curve, changing vehicle speed, overtaking a slow vehicle, coasting to a red light, etc. Every vehicle journey, and therefore also a test run, can be viewed as a temporal sequence of such driving maneuvers. It is immediately obvious that there can be a multitude of such maneuvers. The driving maneuvers are stored in reference unit 5 and originate, for example, from actual measured test drives, previously conducted simulations, etc.
[0047] A test run is now created as a temporal sequence of such driving maneuvers. This can be done manually by a user, through random selection of maneuvers, or through a targeted selection. The maneuvers must, of course, be linked together in such a way that there are no discontinuities in the test run, such as abrupt changes in speed. It must also be ensured that the test subject (test specimen 2), in combination with the simulation model, can follow the desired specifications. The test run should include many different driving maneuvers, preferably covering the broadest possible operating range (RPM, torque) of the vehicle. Therefore, there can be precise specifications regarding which maneuvers must be included and in what proportions.
[0048] To perform the simulation, simulation unit 4 receives, as mentioned, a number of reference values ref from reference unit 5, corresponding to the currently desired driving maneuver within the test run. These reference values ref include, for example, a reference speed v_ref and a reference position s_ref, each as a function of the reference time t_ref. Simulation unit 4 is thus given a reference speed v_ref according to the test run, which is simulated, for example, by driver model 11. Driver model 11 therefore follows the reference speed v_ref, which is calculated using vehicle model 12 and track model 13.
[0049] The test run, or rather the individual driving maneuvers, are defined in reference unit 5 as the course of the reference speed v_ref over the reference time t_ref and are transmitted as reference values ref to simulation unit 4. During the simulation, simulation unit 4 attempts to follow the reference speed v_ref with a simulation speed v_sim. This can be done in a position-based manner (i.e., the simulation speed v_sim at the simulation position s_sim always corresponds to the reference speed v_ref at the reference position s_ref) or in a time-based manner (i.e., the simulation speed v_sim at the simulation time t_im always corresponds to the reference speed v_ref at the reference time t_ref). However, since the simulation speed v_sim can never exactly follow the reference speed v_ref, a time deviation occurs with a position-based approach and a position deviation with a time-based approach.
[0050] Fig. 2, 3 ,4, 6 and 7 Each figure shows a time-velocity-distance graph, where time t is plotted on the positive abscissa, velocity v on the negative abscissa, and position s on the positive ordinate. Thus, the left side of the graph shows a velocity-time relationship, and the right side shows a distance-time relationship.
[0051] In Fig. 2 A reference run is achieved using corresponding reference values ref: A reference speed v_ref is specified for each reference time t_ref, and likewise a reference position s_ref is specified for each reference time t_ref, thus forming the respective reference curves: On the left, a reference speed v_ref as a function of the reference position s_ref, and on the right, a reference position s_ref at the reference time t_ref. This relationship also defines a reference speed v_ref for each reference time t_ref.
[0052] Fig. 3 In addition to the reference values ref, the graph displays the simulation values sim of a simulation, where the simulation speed v_sim is time-based. Thus, the simulation speed v_sim follows the reference speed v_ref at every point in the simulation time t_sim. Since the simulation speed v_sim cannot exactly follow the reference speed v_ref, there is still a speed deviation v_x between the simulation speed v_sim and the reference speed v_ref, as can be seen in the left quadrant of the graph. Here, the simulation speed v_sim is too low. Consequently, the deviation x results in a position deviation s_x of the simulation position s_sim from the reference position s_ref, as can be seen in the right part of the graph.
[0053] In Fig. 4 The simulation values shown are determined via a location-based specification of the simulation speed v_sim. Thus, the simulation speed v_sim follows the reference position s_ref at every point of the simulation position s_sim. Since the simulation speed v_sim cannot exactly follow the reference speed v_ref, there is also a speed deviation v_x between the simulation speed v_sim and the reference speed v_ref (again represented by an example of an insufficient simulation speed v_sim). Therefore, the deviation x is a time deviation t_x of the simulation time t_sim from the reference time t_ref.
[0054] As in Fig. 5 As can be seen, a detection unit 7 and a correction unit 8 are provided on test rig 1 according to the invention, which are connected here as a single unit between the simulation unit 4 and the reference unit 5. This is particularly advantageous because it does not interfere with the simulation unit 4 itself; only the corresponding simulation values sim need to be available in order to compare them with the equivalent reference values ref. Fig. 5 The simulation position s_sim is supplied to the detection unit 7 by the simulation unit 4.
[0055] The deviation x of a comparison simulation value from a comparison reference value is now determined using a detection unit 7. Here, the deviation x is the positional deviation s_x of the simulation position s_sim (the comparison simulation value) from the reference position s_ref (the comparison reference value). A tolerance band can, of course, be provided. Subsequently, the correction unit 8, which is advantageously integrated into the detection unit 7, changes the reference velocity v_ref (the selected reference value ref) to the corrected reference velocity v_ref', which is then provided to the simulation unit 4 instead of the reference velocity v_ref. Thus, a corrected simulation position s_sim' is subsequently simulated in the simulation unit 4, resulting in a smaller positional deviation s_x.
[0056] In Fig. 6 At time t1, a positional deviation s_x is detected, specifically a simulation position s_sim that is too low compared to the reference position s_ref. This positional deviation s_x can arise from an insufficient simulation speed v_sim, as indicated in the accompanying figures. Figur 4 It can be seen that after time t1 of simulation unit 4, instead of the reference velocity v_ref (as the selected reference value ref), a corrected reference velocity v_ref', which is higher here, is specified, as shown by the dashed section. In simulation unit 4, a higher simulation velocity v_sim is simulated based on this, since it now follows the corrected reference velocity v_ref'. The corrected reference value ref' (here, the corrected reference velocity v_ref') can be continuously increased or decreased.
[0057] From time t1 of simulation unit 4, the corrected simulation speed v_sim` is used instead of the simulation speed v_sim, thus reducing the position deviation s_x. In the illustrated case, no position deviation s_x occurs until time t2. Afterward, the corrected reference speed v_ref` is maintained to keep the position deviation s_x at zero. Therefore, the simulation speed v_sim follows the reference speed v_ref approximately, and the simulation position s_sim follows the reference position s_ref.
[0058] This results in the simulation unit 4, using at least one corrected simulation value sim', transmitting at least one corrected target value T to the control unit ECU. Using this at least one corrected target value T, the control unit ECU controls the test specimen 2 with at least one control variable, which is also corrected. At least one further target value n for the further control unit 30 of the load machine 3 can also be determined using the corrected simulation value sim'.
[0059] The procedure could, of course, also be started at the beginning of the test run and preferably carried out throughout the entire test run. This results in a small deviation x during the simulation, as this is preferably corrected continuously and as effectively as possible.
[0060] In the present embodiment, however, when reducing the reference speed v_ref (as the selected reference value ref) to a corrected reference speed v_ref`, it must always be ensured that the simulation speed v_sim exceeds a first speed threshold. Similarly, when increasing the reference speed v_ref, it must be ensured that the simulation speed v_sim exceeds the speed threshold. In particular, the simulation speed v_sim must not be zero.
[0061] At low reference velocities v_ref, and consequently low simulation velocities v_sim, the possibility of correction by adjusting the reference velocity v_ref as the selected reference value ref is limited, especially if the simulation position s_sim is greater than the reference position s_ref. Since the reference velocity v_ref is low, it cannot be reduced much further before reaching zero.
[0062] In Fig. 7The reference speed v_ref becomes zero at time t4. Due to a time deviation t_x, the simulation speed v_sim only becomes zero at time t3. Thus, the speed threshold (of zero) is reached by the simulation speed v_sim at time t3, meaning the speed threshold is no longer exceeded, which is preferably detected by the detection unit 7. The simulation time t_sim, which deviates from the reference time t_ref, is then adjusted, preferably by the correction unit 8. At time t5, the reference speed v_ref, and therefore the simulation speed v_sim, is increased again. To ensure these times are synchronized, the duration during which the simulation speed v_sim is zero is reduced. According to the reference, the stop duration should last from t4 to t5; in the simulation, the stop duration was reduced to t3 to t5.The change in the simulation time t_sim can also be seen as a faster or slower running of the simulation time t_sim or the reference time t_ref in the changed range of the simulation time t_sim.
Claims
1. Method for carrying out a test run on a test stand (1) with a test object (2), wherein a number of reference values (ref) is specified to a simulation unit (4) by a reference unit (5), wherein a number of simulation values (sim) is simulated by the simulation unit (4) using the number of reference values (ref), wherein at least one setpoint variable (T) and at least one control variable for controlling the test object (2) are determined from the number of simulation values (sim), characterized in that a deviation (x) between a comparison simulation value from the number of simulation values (sim) and a comparison reference value from the number of reference values (ref), preferably by a tolerance, is detected by a detection unit (7), wherein the comparison reference value is equivalent to the comparison simulation value, in that, when a deviation (x) is detected, starting from a selected reference value (ref) from the number of reference values, a corrected reference value (ref`) is determined by a correction unit (8), wherein the selected reference value (ref) does not correspond to the comparison reference value, and wherein the corrected reference value (ref') is increased or decreased as a function of the detected deviation (x) form the selected reference value (ref), in that, instead of the selected reference value (ref), the corrected reference value (ref`) is specified to the simulation unit (4) for simulating a corrected simulation value (sim`), and in that the at least one setpoint variable (T) is determined using the corrected simulation value (sim`).
2. Method according to claim 1, characterized in that at least one further setpoint variable (n) is determined for at least one loading machine (3) connected to the test object (2) using the at least one corrected simulation value (sim`).
3. Method according to either claim 1 or claim 2, characterized in that the corrected reference value (ref`) is continuously increased or decreased.
4. Method according to any of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that the corrected reference value (ref`) is increased or decreased until no more deviation (x) occurs.
5. Method according to any of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that the method is started at the beginning of the test run.
6. Method according to claim 5, characterized in that the method is carried out during the entire test run.
7. Method according to any of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that the number of reference values (ref) comprises a reference position (s_ref) at a reference time (t_ref) and a reference speed (v_ref) at the reference time (t_ref), in that the number of simulation values (sim) simulated by the simulation unit (4) comprises a simulation speed (v_sim) at a simulation time (t_sim) and a simulation position (s_sim) at the simulation time (t_ref).
8. Method according to claim 7, characterized in that the simulation position (s_sim) serves as a comparison simulation value, the reference position (s_ref) serves as a comparison reference value, and the reference speed (v_ref) serves as the selected reference value (ref).
9. Method according to claim 8, characterized in that a corrected reference speed (v_ref') that is lower than the reference speed (v_ref) is specified to the simulation unit (4), if the simulation position (s_sim) is greater than the reference position (s_ref) and the simulation speed (v_sim) exceeds a speed threshold, preferably zero.
10. Method according to claim 8, characterized in that a corrected reference speed (v_ref') that is greater than the reference speed (v_ref) is specified to the simulation unit (4), if the simulation position (s_sim) is smaller than the reference position (s_ref) and the simulation speed (v_sim) exceeds a speed threshold, preferably zero.
11. Method according to either claim 9 or claim 10, characterized in that the simulation time (t_sim) is changed to a corrected simulation time (t_sim'), if it deviates from the reference time (t_ref) and the simulation speed (v_sim) does not exceed the speed threshold, preferably zero.
12. Test stand (1) with a test object (2) for carrying out a test run, wherein a reference unit (5) is provided which specifies a number of reference values (ref) to a simulation unit (4), wherein the simulation unit (4) is designed to simulate a number of simulation values (sim) using the number of reference values (ref) and to determine at least one setpoint variable (T) from the number of simulation values (sim) and to transmit it to a control unit (ECU), wherein the control unit (ECU) is designed to specify at least one control variable for controlling the test object (2) based on the at least one setpoint variable (T), characterized in that a detection unit (7) is provided, which is designed to detect a deviation (x) between a comparison simulation value (sim) from the number of simulation values (sim) and a comparison reference value from the number of reference values (ref), preferably by a tolerance, and in that a correction unit (8) is provided, which is designed, to determine a corrected reference value (ref`) starting from a selected reference value (ref) from the number of reference values, when a deviation (x) is detected, wherein the selected reference value (ref) does not correspond to the comparison reference value, and wherein the corrected reference value (ref') is increased or decreased as a function of the detected deviation (x) form the selected reference value (ref), and to specify the corrected reference value instead of the selected reference value (ref) to the simulation unit (4) for simulating a corrected simulation value (sim`), to determine the at least one using the corrected simulation value (sim`).
