METHOD AND DEVICE FOR PREDICTING DRIFT IN CONTROL EQUIPMENT

The method and device predict equipment drift by analyzing post-intervention statistical patterns to trigger alerts, addressing inefficiencies in existing algorithms and optimizing maintenance schedules, thereby reducing costs and improving operational efficiency.

FR3143783B1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-01GRTGAZ
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
FR2022013384
Authority / Receiving Office
FR · FR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-12-14
Publication Date
2024-11-01
Estimated Expiration
2042-12-14

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing anomaly detection and forecasting algorithms struggle with insufficient data and heterogeneous materials in industrial equipment, leading to inefficient maintenance interventions and increased costs due to unnecessary or costly on-call actions.

Method used

A method and device for predicting equipment drift by analyzing statistical patterns post-intervention, setting limit values, and extrapolating future values to trigger alerts before abnormal conditions occur, reducing the need for preventive maintenance.

Benefits of technology

This approach allows for automated detection of equipment drift without extensive learning, minimizing unnecessary interventions and optimizing maintenance schedules based on urgency and availability, thus reducing costs and improving efficiency.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000013_0000
    Figure 00000013_0000
  • Figure 00000014_0000
    Figure 00000014_0000
  • Figure 00000015_0000
    Figure 00000015_0000
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

TITLE: METHOD AND DEVICE FOR FORECASTING THE DRIFT OF CONTROL EQUIPMENT The method (70) for predicting the drift of a physical quantity regulated by control equipment includes a step (71) of intervening on the equipment causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity and a step (72, 75) of regularly measuring this physical quantity providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity.This process further comprises: - a first step (73) of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined period following the intervention step, - a calibration step (74) providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this first statistical analysis, - a second step (76) of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second rolling period following the intervention step, - a step (77) of extrapolating a future value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this second statistical analysis, and - a step (78, 79) of determining whether the future extrapolated value exceeds one of the limit values ​​within a predetermined future time interval, and if so, a step (80) of triggering an alert. Figure for the abstract: Figure 8.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Title of the invention: METHOD AND DEVICE FOR PREDICTING DRIFT OF REGULATION EQUIPMENT Technical field of the invention

[0001] The present invention relates to a method and a device for predicting drift in regulation equipment. It applies, in particular, to regulation equipment (for example, flow, pressure, temperature or level) subject to drift (for example, valves, regulators, pumps, compressors) and whose measurements of the regulated quantities are available "continuously" or at fairly short time intervals with respect to the drift dynamics of the equipment. More particularly, the present invention applies to a gas expansion station. Prior art

[0002] Anomaly detection algorithms operate with a learning phase that requires a large amount of data, both measurements of physical quantities (for example, pressure) and anomalies (for example, poor regulations), to establish a link between these data. In practice, however, the number of anomalies collected is too low and the materials considered too heterogeneous to allow sufficient learning of this type of algorithm.

[0003] Time series forecasting algorithms are designed in particular to predict periodic phenomena (e.g., seasonal). However, the drifts observed on industrial equipment do not correspond to such patterns. In addition, external interventions such as maintenance actions carried out by operators create discontinuities in the time series, which limit their learning potential.

[0004] In the particular case of gas pressure relief stations, operators regularly intervene on these stations, in particular to correct deviations and / or change settings, which has the following disadvantages: - excessive deviations of materials between two interventions; - interventions on equipment when it is not necessary and - on-call interventions, for example on public holidays, which are more expensive. Statement of the invention

[0005] The present invention aims to remedy all or part of these drawbacks. To this end, according to a first aspect, the invention aims at a method for predicting drift of a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment, which comprises: - an intervention step on the equipment causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity, - a regular measurement step of this physical quantity providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity, characterized in that it further comprises: - a first step of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step, - a calibration step providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, depending on the result of this first statistical analysis, - a second stage of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second sliding period after the intervention stage, - a step of extrapolation of a future value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this second statistical analysis, and - a step of determining whether the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​in a predetermined future time interval, and if so, a step of triggering an alert.

[0006] Thanks to these provisions, without using long-term learning, the method automatically determines an abnormality criterion for a drift in the equipment, after an intervention on the equipment, then a forecast of the occurrence of this abnormality. This method thus makes it possible to decide on a new preventive intervention to avoid too significant a drift from occurring. It also makes it possible to intervene on the equipment only when a drift is predicted. Finally, it avoids, or at least limits, on-call interventions, which are more costly.

[0007] In embodiments, during the first statistical analysis step, an average and a standard deviation of the values ​​of the physical quantity are calculated and, during the calibration step, at least one limit value is equal to the calculated average added to the product of the measured standard deviation by a predetermined number.

[0008] Thanks to these provisions, the detection criterion implemented depends on the initial stability of the values ​​of the physical quantity monitored.

[0009] In embodiments, during the second statistical analysis step, a regression, for example linear, of the values ​​of the physical quantity is carried out.

[0010] This provides a measurement of the trend evolution of the physical quantity, without consuming significant computing power. A single server can thus implement the method on a large number of devices subject to drift.

[0011] In embodiments, during the extrapolation step, a future value is extrapolated for a third duration following the second duration.

[0012] A horizon is thus set, equal to this third duration. It is at this horizon, that is to say at a predetermined deadline, that we determine whether the physical quantity risks becoming abnormal. For example, this horizon is a number of hours or days. Note that this horizon can vary depending on the availability of a maintenance operator, so that a forecast of abnormal drift can cause an in- preventive intervention.

[0013] In embodiments, the third duration depends on the day and / or time of the second duration.

[0014] For example, this horizon is a normal working day for a maintenance operator. This horizon is thus set to cross the last two days of the week and public holidays in order to be on a working day. The operator can thus intervene before these days which would impose a duty period on him.

[0015] In embodiments, during the extrapolation step, a duration following the second duration is measured before crossing a limit value.

[0016] Thus, the expected duration before the drift becomes abnormal is evaluated and makes it possible to schedule an intervention well in advance. This duration represents a degree of urgency of the maintenance operation. In particular, if several pieces of equipment are subject to a drift forecast according to the method which is the subject of the invention, the order of the next interventions can be determined according to this degree of urgency and, possibly, other criteria, such as the accessibility of the equipment, the proximity to other equipment or the availability of a maintenance operator.

[0017] According to a second aspect, the present invention relates to a device for predicting drift of a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity, which comprises: - a means of regular measurement of this physical quantity providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity, - a first means of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step, - a means of calibration providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this first statistical analysis, - a second means of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second sliding period after the intervention stage, - a means of extrapolating a future value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this second statistical analysis, and - a means of triggering an alert if the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​within a predetermined future time interval.

[0018] The advantages, aims and particular characteristics of this device being similar to those of the method which is the subject of the invention, they are not recalled here.

[0019] In embodiments, the control hardware is configured to control a flow rate, pressure, temperature, or level.

[0020] In embodiments, the control hardware is configured to control a physical quantity of a valve, an expander, a pump or a compressor.

[0021] The inventor has determined that the invention applies particularly well to the prediction of these physical quantities and / or the regulation of this equipment.

[0022] According to a third aspect, the present invention relates to a gas pressure relief station comprising a device which is the subject of the invention, in which the regulation equipment regulates the pressure at the outlet of a regulation valve.

[0023] The inventor has noted the effectiveness of implementing the invention for such a relaxation station. Brief description of the figures

[0024] Other advantages, aims and particular characteristics of the invention will emerge from the following non-limiting description of at least one particular embodiment of the method and device which are the subject of the invention, with reference to the appended drawings, in which:

[0025] [Fig.l] schematically represents a particular embodiment of a device which is the subject of the invention installed in a gas pressure reduction and / or delivery station,

[0026] [Fig.2] represents a change in gas pressure at the outlet of an expansion station and / or gas delivery and a determination of limit values ​​for changes in gas pressure at the outlet of a pressure reduction and / or gas delivery station,

[0027] [Fig.3] represents a first forecast of the evolution of gas pressure at the outlet of a gas pressure and / or delivery station,

[0028] [Fig.4] represents a second forecast of the evolution of gas pressure at the outlet of a gas pressure and / or delivery station,

[0029] [Fig.5] represents a third forecast of the evolution of gas pressure at the outlet of a gas pressure and / or delivery station,

[0030] [Fig.6] represents, in the form of a flowchart, steps of an embodiment particular aspect of the invention applied to the regulation of pressure at the outlet of a pressure reduction station,

[0031] [Fig.7] represents a supervision interface of a network of relaxation stations and / or gas delivery, and

[0032] [Fig.8] represents, in the form of a flowchart, steps of a particular embodiment of the method which is the subject of the invention. Description of the embodiments

[0033] The present description is given without limitation, each characteristic of an embodiment being able to be combined with any other characteristic of any other embodiment in an advantageous manner.

[0034] Since the transport of natural gas is carried out at high pressure (for example 70 bar) and the distribution in town at low pressure (for example 5 bar), a pressure reduction station has the following functions: aim of expanding the gas from high pressure to low pressure. At each supply point in the network as well as at each delivery point, metering systems measure the quantities of natural gas passing through these points.

[0035] In [Fig.l], we observe an installation 10 comprising a pressure reducing station 13. This pressure reducing station 13 is a piece of equipment whose function is to lower the pressure of the gas distributed by a general network 11 to pressure levels usable by the different types of customers, for example domestic, tertiary or industrial, connected to a distribution network 12. The pressure reducing and metering station (“PDC”) is an installation used to control the pressure and metering of the natural gas. In addition to the upstream 11 and downstream 12 gas pipes, this station 13 comprises various components: pressure regulator 14, pressure measuring sensor 15 downstream of the regulator 14, meter (not shown), volume corrector (not shown), safety valves (not shown), valves (not shown), filter (not shown), data processing device 16 and data transmission device 17.

[0036] The pressure regulator 14 is subject to a drift which has the effect of varying the downstream pressure in the downstream gas pipe 12. However, this downstream pressure must remain within a range of values, between a minimum value ensuring the operation of the customer's installations and a maximum value avoiding the risks of leakage at the level of these installations or of rupture of the pipe 12. A maintenance operation makes it possible to correct this drift by modifying the values ​​of operating parameters of the pressure regulator 14. The present invention makes it possible to anticipate the need for such maintenance operations.

[0037] In [Fig.2], we observe a time graph 20 of pressure downstream of a pressure regulator. The successive values ​​of the pressure are represented by the curve 21. These successive values ​​are obtained either by a continuous measurement of the downstream pressure, or by regular measurements of this pressure. At a time 23, an intervention is carried out on the regulator, which causes a discontinuity of the curve 21. In the case represented in [Fig.2], this is an increase in the downstream pressure.

[0038] During a first predetermined duration following time 23 of the intervention, extending until time 24, a first statistical analysis of the measured values ​​of the pressure is carried out. This first duration is also called a “calibration window”. This first statistical analysis makes it possible to determine an average value 25 and, preferably, a standard deviation of the variations of this pressure and an amplitude of these variations.

[0039] A lower limit value 26 and an upper limit value 27 are then set, depending on the result of the first statistical analysis. According to a first example, the lower limit value 26 is equal to the average value reduced by a percentage predetermined, for example five percent. According to a second example, the lower limit value 26 is equal to the mean value reduced by a predetermined number of times the standard deviation, for example three times. According to a third example, the lower limit value 26 is equal to the mean value reduced by a predetermined proportion of the amplitude, for example half the amplitude and a predetermined percentage of the mean value or a predetermined number of times the standard deviation. Of course, any other combination of the results of the first statistical analysis can be used to set the lower limit value 26. Similarly, the upper limit value 27 is determined in one of these ways by replacing the decrease with an increase.

[0040] Once these limit values ​​26 and 27 have been set, as illustrated in Figures 3 and 4, a second statistical analysis of the pressure values ​​is carried out during a second sliding time, 28 in [Fig.3] and 31 in [Fig.4], subsequent to the intervention step. This second statistical analysis provides a time function, 29 in [Fig.3] and 32 in [Fig.4], which can extend after the end of the second sliding time. This second sliding time 28 or 31 is also called a “sliding window”. It ends at the current time. The pressure values ​​subsequent to this sliding window are therefore not known when processing the pressure values ​​in this sliding window. This time function for modeling the evolution of the pressure therefore allows extrapolation into the future of the pressure value.For example, the second statistical analysis is a regression, for example linear, as in the embodiment illustrated in figures 3 and 4. The modeling time function is therefore a linear function, of which curve 29 or 32 is a straight line.

[0041] Based on this time function, a future value, 30 in [Fig. 3] and 33 in [Fig. 4], of the pressure is extrapolated. In the embodiment illustrated in Figures 3 and 4, the future value 30 or 33 is the value of the time function 29 or 32 after a third predetermined duration 36 starting at the end of the sliding window. This third predetermined duration is also called a “horizon”. In other embodiments, this future value is equal to one of the limit values ​​26 and 27 and the duration 37 between the end of the sliding window and the instant when the time function 29 or 32 is equal to one of the limit values ​​26 and 27 is determined.

[0042] If the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​26 or 27 in a predetermined future time interval, the device 13 triggers an alert, locally or remotely. In the case of using a horizon 36, this condition is fulfilled if the future value 30 or 33 is greater than the upper limit value 27 or less than the lower limit value 26. In the case of determining the duration 37 before crossing a limit value 26 or 27, this condition is fulfilled if this duration is less than the predetermined future time interval duration.

[0043] In the variant illustrated in [Fig.5], instead of or in addition to the time function 32, the same processing is carried out on at least one of: - time function 34, with the same slope as function 32 but shifted so that all pressure values ​​in the sliding window are greater than the value of function 34, - time function 35, with the same slope as function 32 but shifted so that all pressure values ​​in the sliding window are lower than the value of function 35.

[0044] This variant makes it possible to take into account the amplitude of variation of the pressure observed in the sliding window 31. In variants, time functions offset from the function 32 are applied by adding and subtracting half the amplitude of variation of the pressure in the sliding window. Other variants are based on a predetermined number of times of the standard deviation of the values ​​of the pressure in the sliding window 31, and / or an amplitude or a standard deviation calculated over a duration other than that of the sliding window 31.

[0045] As illustrated in [Fig.6], an embodiment 40 of the method for predicting drift of a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment comprises different steps starting at the end of an intervention 41 on the regulation equipment. During a step 42, a horizon is determined. In embodiments, this horizon is fixed, for example equal to one or more days. In embodiments, this horizon varies according to the intervention time of an operator, depending on his place of work or residence or instantaneous geographical position and the travel time necessary for him to reach the regulation equipment.In embodiments, this horizon varies over time, for example, it depends on the day and / or the time of the sliding window, so that this horizon, greater than a minimum value, for example one day, does not end outside intervention time slots (for example between eight o'clock and six o'clock), nor on a Saturday or a Sunday, nor on a public holiday.

[0046] During a step 43, a regular measurement of the pressure downstream of the regulating device is carried out. This regular measurement provides a set of values ​​of this pressure.

[0047] During a step 44, a first step of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this pressure is carried out during a first predetermined duration following the intervention, i.e. the calibration window.

[0048] During a step 45, a calibration is carried out providing at least one limit value of this pressure, depending on the result of the first statistical analysis.

[0049] During a step 46, the regular measurement of the pressure downstream of the regulating device.

[0050] During a step 47, a second statistical analysis of the pressure values ​​is carried out during a sliding window subsequent to the intervention step.

[0051] During a step 48, an extrapolation of the future value of the pressure at the horizon is carried out, based on the result of this second statistical analysis.

[0052] During a step 49, the future value at the horizon is compared with each limit value. During a step 50, it is determined whether one of the limit values ​​is exceeded by the extrapolation to the horizon. If the result of step 50 is negative, we return to step 46.

[0053] If the result of step 50 is positive, that is to say if the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​in the horizon (predetermined future time interval), during a step 51, a remote alert is triggered, and possibly locally, and a return is made to step 46. At the same time, during a step 52, an analysis of the alert is carried out remotely. For example, it is determined whether meteorological conditions can explain this alert and whether the weather forecasts predict a return to normal conditions. Finally, during a step 53, an intervention decision is made, for example an order between interventions on several control equipment, depending on the shortest path to carry out the interventions. Then, a return is made to step 41, as soon as this intervention is carried out.

[0054] In the embodiment illustrated in [Fig.6], during the first statistical analysis step 44, an average and a standard deviation of the values ​​of the physical quantity are calculated and, during the calibration step 45, at least one limit value is equal to the calculated average added to the product of the measured standard deviation by a predetermined number.

[0055] In the embodiment illustrated in [Fig.6], during the second statistical analysis step 47, a regression, for example linear, of the values ​​of the physical quantity is carried out.

[0056] In the embodiment illustrated in [Fig.6], during the extrapolation step 48, a future value is extrapolated for a horizon, i.e. a third duration following the second duration. Preferably, the horizon depends on the day and / or the time of the sliding window. Alternatively, during the extrapolation step 48, a duration following the sliding window is measured before crossing a limit value.

[0057] As illustrated in [Fig.7], an interface 60 for viewing alerts can take the form of a map 61 on which the positions of the regulation equipment 62 to 66 are represented. Associated with the representation, by an outer circle, of each of these pieces of equipment is a color representation of the duration before crossing a limit value obtained by the calibration of this equipment. In [Fig.7], more the darker the central circle, the shorter this duration. A digital representation 67 of this duration is also displayed below the representation of each control equipment. This double representation of the urgency of an intervention allows an operator to prepare an intervention tour on the control equipment 62 to 66 represented on the map 61, for example according to the emergencies and the access routes to this equipment.

[0058] In [Fig.8], we observe a particular embodiment 70 of a method which is the subject of the invention, more generally applied to a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment which is the subject of a step 71 of intervention on this equipment causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity.

[0059] During a step 72, a regular measurement of this physical quantity is carried out, providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity.

[0060] During a step 73, a first statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity is carried out during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step.

[0061] During a step 74, a calibration is carried out providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, depending on the result of this first statistical analysis.

[0062] During a step 75, the regular measurement of the value of the physical quantity is continued.

[0063] During a step 76, a second step of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity is carried out during a second sliding duration subsequent to the intervention step.

[0064] During a step 77, an extrapolation of a future value of this physical quantity is carried out, based on the result of this second statistical analysis.

[0065] During a step 78, the future values ​​are compared with the limit values.

[0066] During a step 79, it is determined whether one of the limit values ​​is exceeded.

[0067] If the result of step 79 is positive, that is to say if the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​in the horizon (predetermined future time interval), during a step 80, an alert is triggered and a return is made to step 75. At the same time, during a step 81, an analysis of the alert is carried out remotely. Finally, during a step 82, a decision to intervene is made. Then, a return is made to step 71, as soon as this intervention is carried out.

[0068] Of course, all the technical characteristics, embodiments and variants set out with regard to figures 1 to 6 apply to the method 60 illustrated in [Fig.7].

[0069] Returning to [Fig.l], the regulating equipment is the pressure regulator 14. The sensor 15 continuously measures the pressure downstream of the pressure regulator. pressure 14. The data transmission device 17 transmits to a remote server 18 the pressure values ​​measured by the sensor 15 and / or the results of the processing carried out by the data processing device 16.

[0070] More generally, a device 19 which is the subject of the invention applies to a regulating equipment configured to regulate a measurable physical quantity, for example a flow rate, a pressure, a temperature or a level. For example, this regulating equipment is configured to regulate a physical quantity of a regulating valve, a pressure reducer, a pump or a compressor, in particular of gas.

[0071] The data processing device 16 and the remote server 18, which are part of the device 19 which is the subject of the invention, are jointly configured to carry out the steps of the method which is the subject of the invention and to constitute, by the implementation of at least one computer program, at least: - a first means of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step, - a means of calibration providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, depending on the result of this statistical analysis, - a second means of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second sliding period after the intervention stage, - a means of extrapolating a future value of this physical quantity, based on the result of this second statistical analysis, - a means of comparing the extrapolated future value with each limit value and - a means of triggering an alert if the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​within a predetermined future time interval.

Claims

Claims

1. Method (40, 70) for predicting drift of a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment (14), comprising a step (41, 71) of intervention on the equipment causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity, a step (43, 46, 72, 75) of regular measurement of this physical quantity providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity, characterized in that it further comprises: - a first step (44, 73) of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step, - a step (45, 74) of calibration providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, as a function of the result of this first statistical analysis, - a second step (47, 76) of statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second sliding duration subsequent to the intervention step, - a step (48,77) of extrapolation of a future value of this physical quantity, depending on the result of this second statistical analysis, and - a step (49, 50, 78, 79) of determining whether the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​in a predetermined future time interval, and if so, a step (51, 80) of triggering an alert.,

2. Method (40, 70) according to claim 1, in which, during the first step (44, 73) of statistical analysis, an average and a standard deviation of the values ​​of the physical quantity are calculated and, during the step (45, 74) of calibration, at least one limit value is equal to the calculated average added to the product of the measured standard deviation by a predetermined number.

3. Method (40, 70) according to one of claims 1 or 2, in which, during the second step (47, 76) of statistical analysis, a regression, for example linear, of the values ​​of the physical quantity is carried out.

4. Method (40, 70) according to one of claims 1 to 3, in which, during the extrapolation step (48, 77), a future value is extrapolated for a third duration following the second duration.

5. The method (40, 70) of claim 4, wherein the third duration depends on the day and / or time of the second duration.

6. Method (40, 70) according to one of claims 1 to 5, in which, during the extrapolation step (48, 77), a duration following the second duration is measured before crossing a limit value.

7. Device (19) for predicting drift of a physical quantity regulated by regulation equipment (14) causing a variation in the value of this physical quantity, which comprises a means (15) for regular measurement of this physical quantity providing a set of values ​​of this physical quantity, characterized in that it further comprises: - a first means (16, 18) for statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a first predetermined duration following the intervention step, - a calibration means (16, 18) providing at least one limit value of this physical quantity, as a function of the result of this first statistical analysis, - a second means (16, 18) for statistical analysis of the values ​​of this physical quantity during a second sliding duration subsequent to the intervention step, - a means (16, 18) for extrapolating a future value of this physical quantity,depending on the result of this second statistical analysis, and - means (16, 18) for triggering an alert if the future extrapolated value crosses one of the limit values ​​in a predetermined future time interval.,

8. The device (19) of claim 7, wherein the control hardware is configured to control a flow rate, pressure, temperature or level.

9. Device (19) according to one of claims 7 or 8, in which the regulation equipment is configured to regulate a physical quantity of a valve, a regulator, a pump or a compressor.

10. Gas pressure relief station (13) comprising a device (19) according to one of claims 7 to 9, in which the regulating equipment (14) regulates the pressure at the outlet of a regulating valve.