Evaluation program, evaluation device, and evaluation system
The evaluation program assesses communication path reliability by estimating source, destination, and router locations, addressing risks of unintended passage and enhancing data security.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023078857
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Existing communication routes for data transmission may pass through unintended geographical areas, leading to risks such as interception or falsification, necessitating a method to quantitatively evaluate the reliability of these routes.
An evaluation program that estimates the locations of data transmission sources and destinations, identifies routers on the communication path, and calculates an evaluation value based on the geographical positions of these elements, using a probe system to determine the reliability of the communication path.
Enables the quantitative evaluation of communication path reliability before data transmission, thereby preventing security risks associated with unintended geographical passage.
Smart Images

Figure 2024162886000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical Field]
[0001] The present invention relates to an evaluation program, an evaluation device, and an evaluation system. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, there have been problems with information leaks, for example, when important confidential data related to personal information or national security is stored in countries or regions that users do not intend. A new approach to addressing this problem is to strengthen the reliability of data transmissions in cyberspace by verifying the physical information of the communication network, for example, the geographic location of the data transmission endpoint.
[0003] For example, the geographic location of an endpoint is estimated using a database that manages the geographic locations of endpoints on a communication network or an estimation service that estimates the geographic location of an endpoint, thereby strengthening the reliability of data transmission and reception in cyberspace based on the geographic location of the endpoint. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] Special Publication No. 2015-515764 [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2015-002378 [Patent Document 3] US Patent Application Publication No. 2013 / 0232565 [Patent Document 4] US Patent Application Publication No. 2017 / 0353435 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] However, for example, if the communication route used for data transmission passes through a country or region not intended by the user, there may be a risk of unexpected interception or tampering. Therefore, there is a need for a method for quantitatively evaluating the reliability of a communication route, for example, by determining to what extent the communication route used for data transmission passes through the geographical area intended by the user.
[0006] One aspect of the present invention is to provide an evaluation program or the like that can evaluate the reliability of a communication path before transmitting data. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In one aspect, the evaluation program causes a computer to execute a process of estimating the location of a data source and a location of a destination of the data, acquiring routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination, and estimating the locations of the acquired routers, and then causes the computer to execute a process of calculating an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated locations of the source, destination, and routers on the communication path. [Effects of the Invention]
[0008] According to one aspect, the trustworthiness of a communication path can be assessed before data is transmitted. [Brief explanation of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system according to a first embodiment. [Figure 2] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of a source host. [Figure 3] FIG. 3 is a block diagram illustrating an example of the functional configuration of a source host. [Figure 4A] FIG. 4A is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a weighting coefficient table in the default state. [Figure 4B] FIG. 4B is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the weighting coefficient table after user setting. [Figure 5]FIG. 5 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of the position estimation result table. [Figure 6] FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the allowable range of a communication path. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the operation from an evaluation request to a position estimation. [Figure 8] FIG. 8 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of location estimation of a source host, a destination host, and each router. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a protruding portion. [Figure 10] FIG. 10 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the estimation range. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a sequence diagram showing an example of processing operations related to evaluation of a communication path in the evaluation system. [Figure 12] FIG. 12 is a flowchart showing an example of the processing operation of the evaluation agent involved in the evaluation process. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a flowchart showing an example of the processing operation of the evaluation agent involved in the calculation process. [Figure 14] FIG. 14 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system according to the second embodiment. [Figure 15] FIG. 15 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system according to the third embodiment. [Figure 16] FIG. 16 is a block diagram illustrating an example of a computer that executes an evaluation program. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0010] Hereinafter, embodiments of the evaluation program and the like disclosed in the present application will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. Note that the disclosed technology is not limited to each embodiment. Furthermore, the embodiments described below may be appropriately combined within a range that does not cause contradictions. [Example]
[0011] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system 1 according to a first embodiment. The evaluation system 1 illustrated in FIG. 1 includes a communication network 2, a source host 3 for transmitting data, a destination host 4, multiple routers 5, and a probe system 6. The source host 3 is a computer that serves as a source communication device for transmitting data. The destination host 4 is a computer that serves as a destination communication device for receiving data transmitted from the source host 3. The router 5 is a communication device disposed in the communication network 2 and connects the communication device to the communication network 2. The probe system 6 includes multiple probe nodes 11 (11A, 11B, 11C, etc.) disposed on the communication network 2 and a probe management device 12 that manages the geographical positions, e.g., latitude and longitude, of the multiple probe nodes 11. The probe management device 12 uses each probe node 11 to estimate the geographical positions of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5. The source host 3, the destination host 4, each router 5, and each probe node 11 each belong to a geographical area, e.g., a country or a region.
[0012] Fig. 2 is a block diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the source host 3. The source host 3 shown in Fig. 2 has a first interface 21, a memory 23, and a processor 24. The first interface 21 is a communication interface that connects to the communication network 2. The memory 23 stores various information, programs, etc. related to the source host 3. The processor 24 controls the entire source host 3. The processor 24 has a function as an evaluation agent 50 that executes an evaluation process (described below) by executing an evaluation program stored in the memory 23.
[0013] Fig. 3 is a block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of the source host 3. The processor 24 shown in Fig. 3 has, as an evaluation agent 50, functions of an estimation unit 31, an acquisition unit 32, and an evaluation unit 33. The estimation unit 31 has a first estimation unit 31A, a second estimation unit 31B, and a collaboration unit 31C. The evaluation unit 33 has an estimation range calculation unit 33A, an allowable range determination unit 33B, a protrusion area calculation unit 33C, an attribute determination unit 33D, and an evaluation value calculation unit 33E.
[0014] When the evaluation agent 50 detects an evaluation request that includes the locations of the source host 3 and destination host 4 when transmitting data and the tolerance range described below, it calculates an evaluation value for the communication path between the source host 3 and destination host 4. The evaluation value for the communication path is a value that evaluates the reliability of the communication path before data transmission. The first estimation unit 31A uses the collaboration unit 31C to estimate, as a probe result from the probe management device 12, for example, an Src estimation range and a Dst estimation range shown in FIG. 6 described below, that include the estimated locations of the source host 3 and destination host 4. The Src estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of the source host 3. The Dst estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of the destination host 4.
[0015] The second estimation unit 31B uses the collaborating unit 31C to estimate, as a probe result from the probe management device 12, for example, an R1 to R4 estimation range, which will be described later, including the estimated location of each router 5 on the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4. The R1 estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of router 5A, the R2 estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of router 5B, the R3 estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of router 5C, and the R4 estimation range is a range that includes the estimated location of router 5D (see FIG. 7). For ease of explanation, the communication path is considered in terms of the geographical location of each router 5 on the communication path, and does not take into account the laying route of the links between routers 5 on the communication path.
[0016] The collaborating unit 31C is connected to and communicates with the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6, and transmits a probe request to the probe management device 12 while receiving a probe result in response to the probe request from the probe management device 12. The collaborating unit 31C notifies the probe management device 12 of the location information of the source host 3 and the destination host 4. The probe management device 12 notifies, for example, the probe request to a probe node 11 that is close to the location information of the source host 3.
[0017] Then, the probe node 11 transmits a probe packet to the source host 3 in response to the probe request. When the probe node 11 receives a response signal in response to the probe packet from the source host 3, it notifies the probe management device 12 of the delay time of the source host 3 from the transmission of the probe packet to the reception of the response signal. Then, based on the delay time of the source host 3, the probe management device 12 estimates an Src estimation range including the position of the source host 3 with the probe node 11 at the center.
[0018] Furthermore, the probe management device 12 notifies, for example, the probe node 11 that is close to the location information of the destination host 4 of a probe request. Then, the probe node 11 transmits a probe packet to the destination host 4 in response to the probe request. When the probe node 11 receives a response signal in response to the probe packet from the destination host 4, it notifies the probe management device 12 of the delay time of the destination host 4 from sending the probe packet to receiving the response signal. Then, based on the delay time of the destination host 4, the probe management device 12 estimates a Dst estimation range including the location of the destination host 4 with the probe node 11 at the center.
[0019] The acquisition unit 32 sends a search request to each router 5 on the communication network 2 for the router 5 to be used for the communication path connecting the source host 3 and the destination host 4, and receives the search result in response to the search request, including the IP address of the router 5 to be used for the communication path.
[0020] The linking unit 31C notifies the probe management device 12 of the location information and IP address of each router 5 on the communication path obtained as a result of the search. The probe management device 12 notifies, for example, the probe node 11 that is close to the location information of each router 5 of a probe request.
[0021] Then, the probe node 11 transmits a probe packet to the router 5 in response to the probe request. When the probe node 11 receives a response signal in response to the probe packet from the router 5, it notifies the probe management device 12 of the delay time of the router 5 from the transmission of the probe packet to the reception of the response signal. Then, based on the delay time of the router 5, the probe management device 12 estimates an estimated range including the position of the router 5 with the probe node 11 at the center. In other words, the probe management device 12 estimates an estimated range for each router 5 on the communication path, which is the search result.
[0022] The estimated range calculation unit 33A calculates the total area of the estimated range estimated by the first estimation unit 31A or the second estimation unit 31B. That is, the estimated range calculation unit 33A calculates the total area of each estimated range of, for example, the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5 on the communication path. The estimated range calculation unit 33A calculates the total area of the Src estimated range and the Dst estimated range estimated by the first estimation unit 31A. The estimated range calculation unit 33A calculates the total area of the estimated ranges of R1 to R4 estimated by the second estimation unit 31B.
[0023] The allowable range determination unit 33B calculates the area proportion of the allowable range for each estimated range and determines whether the area proportion of the estimated range is equal to or greater than a threshold. The threshold may be, for example, 80%, which is the percentage at which the communication device is expected to be within the allowable range. The allowable range is a geographical range, such as a country or region, that the user can accept as a communication path for data communication from the source host 3 to the destination host 4, as specified by the data source user.
[0024] The protrusion area calculation unit 33C calculates the protrusion area that protrudes from the allowable range for each estimated range. The protrusion area is the area calculated from the range of the protrusion part that protrudes from the estimated range and the allowable range. The protrusion area is the protrusion area for each estimated range that protrudes from the allowable range within the estimated range of the source host 3, destination host 4, and each router 5 on the communication path calculated by the protrusion area calculation unit 33C. When focusing on the protrusion range of the estimated range of the destination host 4 shown in Figure 10, the protrusion range is divided by attribute, and the protrusion area of the attribute other countries is 2000 km 2 The area of the ocean that is overflowing is 1500 km 2 is.
[0025] The attribute determination unit 33D references the weighting coefficient table 43 and determines the penalty attribute of the protruding range for each estimated range and a weighting coefficient corresponding to the penalty attribute. The penalty attribute is an attribute of the protruding range based on the allowable range, such as "ocean," "other country," or "region." The penalty attribute is, for example, an attribute specified by the user of the source host 3 for the portion that protrudes from the allowable range specified by the user. Focusing on the destination host 4 shown in FIG. 10, the penalty attributes are "ocean" and "other country," and the weighting coefficient corresponding to "ocean" in the weighting coefficient table 43 is 0.5, which indicates a small penalty, and the weighting coefficient corresponding to "other country" is 1.0, which indicates a large penalty. Furthermore, the attribute determination unit 33D calculates the weighted penalty area by multiplying the protruding area by the weighting coefficient corresponding to the penalty attribute of the protruding range of the estimated range.
[0026] The evaluation value calculation unit 33E calculates the matching rate for each estimated range based on, for example, (total area of estimated range - penalty area of estimated range) ÷ total area of estimated range. The matching rate is the matching rate for each estimated range, which is the ratio of the area of the allowable range to the area of the estimated range. The evaluation value calculation unit 33E calculates the evaluation value of the communication path based on all the matching rates for each estimated range on the communication path. If there is no range that extends beyond the allowable range, the matching rate can be calculated, for example, as (total area of estimated range ÷ total area of estimated range). When focusing on the source host 3, the matching rate is (31400 ÷ 31400) = 1.0. If there is a range that extends beyond the allowable range, the matching rate can be calculated, for example, as (total area of estimated range - (extending area × weighting coefficient)) ÷ total area of the estimated range. When attention is focused on destination host 4, the match rate is (45216-(2000×1.0)-(1500×0.5))÷45216=0.94.
[0027] The memory 23 has a map database (DB) 41, a location estimation result table 42, and a weighting factor table 43. The map DB 41 is a DB that holds map information including countries and regions. The location estimation result table 42 is a table that stores location estimation results related to the locations of communication devices related to the communication path of the evaluation request, such as the source host 3, destination host 4, and each router 5. The weighting factor table 43 is a table that manages weighting factors of penalty attributes used when calculating the evaluation value of the communication path.
[0028] FIG. 4A is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a weighting coefficient table 43 in a default state. The weighting coefficient table 43 shown in FIG. 4A stores, for each attribute 43A of the portion protruding from the allowable range, whether or not there is a penalty 43B and a weighting coefficient 43C. The weighting coefficient table 43 shown in FIG. 4A is a table in a default state. The attribute 43A of the protruding portion is, for example, various attributes of regions such as the sea, other countries outside the allowable range, and member states under a specified treaty. The whether or not there is a penalty 43B is information indicating whether or not there is a penalty according to the attribute. The weighting coefficient 43C is a coefficient used when calculating the penalty area according to the attribute. For example, if the attribute is the sea, the weighting coefficient 43C is, for example, 0.5, and if the attribute is another country, the weighting coefficient 43C is, for example, 1.0.
[0029] FIG. 4B is an explanatory diagram showing an example of weighting coefficient table 43 after user settings. Weighting coefficient table 43 shown in FIG. 4B is a table after the user has changed the default weighting coefficient settings. The table contents of weighting coefficient table 43 can be changed according to the user's setting operations. For example, when the attribute is ocean, penalty presence / absence 43B may be set to no penalty. When the attribute is a foreign country outside the allowable range and is a predetermined related country, weighting coefficient 43C may be set to, for example, 0.2, and when the attribute is a foreign country outside the allowable range and is not a predetermined related country, weighting coefficient 43C may be set to, for example, 1.0, and can be changed as appropriate.
[0030] 5 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the location estimation result table 42. The location estimation result table 42 is a table that stores location estimation results including an estimation range 42B for each piece of device information 42A of each communication device located on the communication path of the evaluation request.
[0031] The estimated range 42B is a range including the estimated position of the communication device obtained from the center of the probe node 11 obtained by the probe system 6. The estimated range 42B is the Src estimated range of the source host 3 and the Dst estimated range of the destination host 4 obtained by the first estimation unit 31A. For example, the Src estimated range is a range within a radius of 100 km from the probe node 11A of P1. For example, the Dst estimated range is a range within a radius of 120 km from the probe node 11D of P4. The estimated range 42B is also an estimated range of each router 5 (5A to 5D) on the communication path obtained by the second estimation unit 31B. For example, the R1 estimated range is a range within a radius of 70 km from the probe node 11A of P1, and the R2 estimated range is a range within a radius of 60 km from the probe node 11B of P2. The R3 estimation range is, for example, a range within a radius of 80 km from the probe node 11C of P3, and the R4 estimation range is, for example, a range within a radius of 70 km from the probe node 11D of P4.
[0032] Fig. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an acceptable range for a communication route. The acceptable range shown in Fig. 6 is a geographical range that a user can accept as a communication route to be used for data transmission from a source host 3 specified by the data sender user to a destination host 4. The acceptable range shown in Fig. 6 is assumed to specify Japan and the United States, for example.
[0033] 7 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the operation from an evaluation request to a location estimation. In response to the evaluation request, the evaluation agent 50 in the source host 3 receives the IP address IP S and the IP address of destination host 4 DThe acquisition unit 32 acquires the IP addresses of the routers 5 used on the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4 in response to a search request for searching for routers 5 on the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4. In the example shown in FIG. 7, the acquisition unit 32 acquires the IP address IP1 of the router 5A on the R1, the IP address IP2 of the router 5B on the R2, the IP address IP3 of the router 5C on the R3, and the IP address IP4 of the router 5D on the R4 on the communication path. The evaluation agent 50 then acquires the IP addresses of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and the routers 5A to 5D on the communication path. The evaluation agent 50 then uses the IP addresses to send a probe request to the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6, requesting an estimated range for the source host 3, the destination host 4, and the routers 5A to 5D on the communication path.
[0034] 8 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of location estimation for the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5. A first estimation unit 31A in the evaluation agent 50 uses the IP addresses of the source host 3 and the destination host 4 to send probe requests for the source host 3 and the destination host 4 to the probe management device 12. The probe management device 12 sends a probe packet to the source host 3 from a probe node 11A at P1 that is geographically close to the source host 3 using the IP address of the source host 3, and obtains an Src estimation range that includes the location of the source host 3 from the location of the probe node 11A based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the source host 3.
[0035] The probe management device 12 transmits probe packets from each probe node 11 to the destination host 4 using the IP address of the destination host 4. The probe management device 12 transmits probe packets to the destination host 4 from probe node 11D of P4, which is geographically close to the destination host 4, using the IP address of the destination host 4, and obtains a Dst estimation range that includes the location of the destination host 4 from the location of probe node 11D based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the destination host 4.
[0036] Furthermore, the second estimation unit 31B in the evaluation agent 50 sends probe requests from each of the routers 5A to 5D to the probe management device 12 using the IP addresses of the routers 5A to 5D on the communication path. The probe management device 12 sends a probe packet from the probe node 11A of P1, which is geographically close to the router 5A of R1, to the router 5A using the IP address of the router 5A, and obtains an R1 estimated range that includes the location of the router 5A of R1 from the position of the probe node 11A based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the router 5A. The probe management device 12 sends a probe packet from the probe node 11B of P2, which is geographically close to the router 5B of R2, using the IP address of the router 5B, and obtains an R2 estimated range that includes the location of the router 5B of R2 from the position of the probe node 11B based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the router 5B. The probe management device 12 transmits a probe packet from the probe node 11C of P3, which is geographically close to the router 5C of R3, to the router 5C using the IP address of the router 5C, and obtains an R3 estimated range that includes the position of the router 5C of R3 from the position of the probe node 11C based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the router 5C. The probe management device 12 transmits a probe packet from the probe node 11D of P4, which is geographically close to the router 5D of R4, to the router 5D using the IP address of the router 5D, and obtains an R4 estimated range that includes the position of the router 5D of R4 from the position of the probe node 11D based on the delay time of the response signal of the probe packet from the router 5D.
[0037] As a result, the evaluation agent 50 acquires from the probe management device 12 the estimated ranges of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and the routers 5A to 5D of R1 to R4 on the communication path, respectively.
[0038] 9 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an overflow portion. When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the Src estimation range of the source host 3, if the entire Src estimation range is within the allowable range, it determines that the Src estimation range has no overflow portion. When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the R1 estimation range of the R1 router 5A, if the entire R1 estimation range is within the allowable range, it determines that the R1 estimation range has no overflow portion. When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the R2 estimation range of the R2 router 5B, if the entire R2 estimation range is within the allowable range, it determines that the R2 estimation range has no overflow portion.
[0039] When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the R3 estimated range of the R3 router 5C, it determines that the R3 estimated range has an outlying portion because the R3 estimated range protrudes from the allowable range. Note that the outlying portion is Canada, another country, so the evaluation agent 50 determines that it is another country based on the weighting coefficient table 43.
[0040] When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the R4 estimated range of the router 5D of R4, if the entire R4 estimated range is within the allowable range, it determines that the R4 estimated range has no protruding portion.
[0041] When the evaluation agent 50 focuses on the Dst estimation range of the destination host 4, it determines that the Dst estimation range has an outlying portion because the Dst estimation range is outside the allowable range. Note that the outlying portion has two attributes, for example, the ocean and Mexico, which is another country, so the evaluation agent 50 determines that it is the ocean and another country according to the weighting coefficient table 43.
[0042] 10 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the estimation range. When the Src estimation range of the source host 3 is within a radius of 100 km from the probe node 11A of P1, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the Src estimation range as 31,400 km. 2 The protruding area of the Src estimated range is 0 km. 2 , that is, there is no penalty. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the match rate of the Src estimation range as (31400÷31400)=1.0.
[0043] If the estimated range of the router 5A of R1 is within a radius of 70 km from the probe node 11A of P1, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the estimated range of R1 as 15,386 km 2 The protruding area of the R1 estimated range is 0 km. 2 , i.e., no penalty. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the match rate of the R1 estimation range as (15386÷15386)=1.0.
[0044] If the R2 estimated range of the router 5B of R2 is within a radius of 60 km from the probe node 11B of P2, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the R2 estimated range as 11,304 km 2 The protruding area of the R2 estimated range is 0 km. 2 , i.e., no penalty. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the match rate of the R2 estimation range as (11304÷11304)=1.0.
[0045] If the estimated range of R3 of the router 5C of R3 is within a radius of 80 km from the probe node 11C of P3, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the estimated range of R3 as 20096 km 2 The area outside the R3 estimated range is 1000 km 2 , that is, there is a penalty. The penalty attribute of the protruding area is other country, and the weighting coefficient is 1.0. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the matching rate of the R3 estimated range as (20096 - (1000 x 1.0)) ÷ 20096 = 0.95.
[0046] If the R4 estimated range of the router 5D of R4 is within a radius of 70 km from the probe node 11D of P4, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the R4 estimated range as 15,386 km 2 The protruding area of the R4 estimated range is 0 km. 2 , i.e., no penalty. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the match rate of the R4 estimation range as (15386÷15386)=1.0.
[0047] If the Dst estimation range of the destination host 4 is within a radius of 120 km from the probe node 11D of P4, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the Dst estimation range as 45216 km 2 There are two types of attributes for the protruding part of the Dst estimated range, and the protruding area of other countries is 2000 km 2 , the area of the ocean that protrudes is 1500 km 2 The weighting coefficient for the sea is 1.0, and the weighting coefficient for other countries is 0.5. Therefore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the match rate of the Dst estimation range as (45216 - (2000 x 1.0) - (1500 x 0.5)) ÷ 45216 = 0.94.
[0048] Then, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the evaluation value of the communication path based on ((matching rate of Src estimation range + matching rate of R1 estimation range + matching rate of R2 estimation range + matching rate of R3 estimation range + matching rate of R4 estimation range + matching rate of Dst estimation range) ÷ number of communication devices on the communication path). In other words, the evaluation agent 50 calculates the evaluation value of the communication path as (1.0 + 1.0 + 1.0 + 0.95 + 1.0 + 0.94) ÷ 6 ≈ 0.98.
[0049] 11 is a sequence diagram showing an example of processing operations related to evaluation of a communication path by the evaluation system 1. The evaluation system 1 includes a source host 3, an evaluation agent 50 in the source host 3, a probe system 6, a router 5, and a destination host 4.
[0050] 11, the source host 3 notifies the evaluation agent 50 of a user's evaluation request (step S11). The evaluation request is information including the locations of the source host 3 and the destination host 4, and an acceptable range indicating the geographical range that the user accepts for the communication path from the source host 3 to the destination host 4.
[0051] When the evaluation agent 50 detects an evaluation request, it transmits probe requests for the source host 3 and the destination host 4 to the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 (step S12). The probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 transmits a probe packet from the probe node 11A closest to the source host 3 to the source host 3 (step S13). The probe packet is, for example, a ping. The probe node 11A receives a response signal to the probe packet from the source host 3 (step S14). The probe node 11A measures the distance from itself to the source host 3 based on the delay time of the response signal received from the source host 3, and uses the measurement result to obtain an estimated Src range of the source host 3, which corresponds to the distance from the probe node 11A to the source host 3.
[0052] Furthermore, the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 transmits a probe packet to the destination host 4 from the probe node 11D closest to the destination host 4 (step S13A). The probe packet is, for example, a ping. The probe node 11D receives a response signal to the probe packet from the destination host 4 (step S14A). The probe node 11D measures the distance from itself to the destination host 4 based on the delay time of the response signal received from the destination host 4, and uses the measurement result to obtain an estimated Dst range of the destination host 4 that corresponds to the distance from the probe node 11D to the destination host 4.
[0053] Then, the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 transmits the probe result including the Src estimation range of the source host 3 and the Dst estimation range of the destination host 4 to the evaluation agent 50 (step S15). When the evaluation agent 50 receives the probe result, it notifies the source host 3 of a search request to search for a router 5 to be used for the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4 (step S16).
[0054] The source host 3 sends a router search (for example, a Ping request message addressed to the destination host 4 with the Time To Live of the IP packet set to 1 to 4, respectively) in response to the search request (step S17). The source host 3 then receives a response signal (for example, an ICMP error in response to the Ping request message) from each router 5 in response to the router search (step S18). Based on the response signal from each router 5, the source host 3 notifies the evaluation agent 50 of the search result, including the IP address of each router 5 used for the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4 (step S19).
[0055] Based on the search result, the evaluation agent 50 transmits a probe request for each router 5 used on the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4 to the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 (step S20).
[0056] The probe system 6 transmits a probe packet from each probe node 11 to each router 5 on the communication path (step S21). Each probe node 11 in the probe system 6 receives a response signal to the probe packet from each router 5 (step S22). Based on the measurement results of each probe node 11, the probe management device 12 obtains an estimated range of each router 5, which corresponds to the distance from the probe node 11 to the router 5.
[0057] Then, the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6 transmits the probe result including the estimated range of each router 5 to the evaluation agent 50 (step S23). When the evaluation agent 50 receives the probe result, it executes a calculation process to calculate an evaluation value on the communication path (step S24), notifies the source host 3 of the evaluation response (step S25), and ends the processing operation shown in Fig. 11. The evaluation response includes the evaluation value of the communication path or an evaluation of NG.
[0058] 12 is a flowchart showing an example of the processing operation of the evaluation agent 50 related to the evaluation process. In FIG. 12, the evaluation agent 50 determines whether or not an evaluation request including an allowable range of a communication path has been received (step S31). If an evaluation request has been received (step S31: Yes), the first estimation unit 31A in the evaluation agent 50 estimates the positions (estimation range) of the source host 3 and the destination host 4 through the probe system 6 (step S32).
[0059] The evaluation agent 50 determines whether the estimated ranges of the source host 3 and the destination host 4 are within the allowable range (step S33). If the estimated ranges of the source host 3 and the destination host 4 are within the allowable range (step S33: Yes), the evaluation agent 50 searches for a router 5 to be used on the communication path (step S34).
[0060] The second estimation unit 31B in the evaluation agent 50 estimates the position (estimation range) of each router 5 on the communication path obtained by the search result through the probe system 6 (step S35). Then, the evaluation unit 33 in the evaluation agent 50 executes a calculation process to calculate an evaluation value of the communication path (step S36).
[0061] After executing the calculation process, the evaluation unit 33 outputs an evaluation response to the evaluation request including the evaluation result of the communication path (step S37), and ends the processing operation shown in Fig. 12. The evaluation response is, for example, an evaluation value of the communication path or an evaluation of NG.
[0062] Furthermore, if the evaluation agent 50 has not detected an evaluation request (step S31: No), it terminates the processing operation shown in Fig. 12. If the estimated ranges of the source host 3 and the destination host 4 are not within the allowable ranges (step S33: No), the evaluation agent 50 determines that the evaluation is NG (step S38), and proceeds to the processing of step S37 to output an evaluation response including the evaluation result of the communication path.
[0063] 13 is a flowchart showing an example of the processing operation of the evaluation agent 50 related to the calculation process. In FIG. 13, the evaluation agent 50 specifies one estimated range from among the unspecified estimated ranges of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and the router 5 on the communication path (step S41). The estimated range calculation unit 33A in the evaluation agent 50 calculates the total area of the specified estimated range (step S42).
[0064] The allowable range determination unit 33B in the evaluation agent 50 calculates the area ratio of the specified estimated range to the allowable range (step S43). Furthermore, the allowable range determination unit 33B determines whether the area ratio of the specified estimated range is equal to or greater than a threshold value (step S44).
[0065] If the area ratio of the specified estimated range is equal to or greater than the threshold (step S44: Yes), the attribute determination unit 33D in the evaluation agent 50 identifies the attribute of the protruding portion of the specified estimated range from the allowable range (step S45). The protruding area calculation unit 33C in the evaluation agent 50 calculates the protruding area for each attribute of the protruding portion (step S46). Furthermore, the attribute determination unit 33D determines a weighting coefficient for each attribute of the protruding portion from a weighting coefficient table (step S47).
[0066] The evaluation value calculation unit 33E in the evaluation agent 50 calculates the matching rate of the specified estimated range based on the total area of the specified estimated range and the penalty area according to the weighting coefficient of the protruding portion (step S48).
[0067] After calculating the matching rate of the specified estimated range, the evaluation value calculation unit 33E determines whether there is an unspecified estimated range on the communication path (step S49). If there is an unspecified estimated range (step S49: Yes), the evaluation agent 50 proceeds to the processing of step S41 to specify the unspecified estimated range.
[0068] If there are no unspecified estimated ranges (step S49: No), the evaluation value calculation unit 33E calculates the evaluation value of the communication path based on the matching rate of all estimated ranges on the communication path (step S50), and terminates the processing operation shown in Figure 13.
[0069] Moreover, if the area ratio of the specified estimated range is not equal to or greater than the threshold (step S44: No), the evaluation value calculation unit 33E determines that the evaluation is NG (step S51), and ends the processing operation shown in FIG.
[0070] The evaluation agent 50 in the first embodiment uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the Src estimated range of the source host 3 and the Dst estimated range of the destination host 4, and searches for routers 5 present on the communication path from the source host 3 to the destination host 4. Based on the search results, the evaluation agent 50 uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the estimated range of each router 5 on the communication path. The evaluation agent 50 calculates an evaluation value for the communication path based on the match rate of the area occupied by each estimated range of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5 within the allowable range. As a result, the evaluation agent 50 can quantitatively determine, as an evaluation value, whether the geographical location of the communication path when transmitting data is within the allowable range expected by the user before transmitting the data. Furthermore, based on the evaluation value of the communication path before transmitting the data, security risks such as data interception and tampering that may occur when data passes through countries or regions not intended by the user can be avoided.
[0071] The evaluation agent 50 can estimate an estimated range including the locations of the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5 based on the delay time of the response signal for each communication device on the communication path, i.e., the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5, from the probe node 11 whose geographical location has already been acquired.
[0072] The evaluation agent 50 specifies an allowable geographical range for a communication route, and calculates a penalty area for each estimated range based on a weighting coefficient and the area of the range that extends beyond the specified allowable range according to the attributes of that range for each estimated range. Furthermore, the evaluation agent 50 calculates a match rate, which is the proportion of the area of the allowable range within the estimated range, based on the total area and penalty area for each estimated range. Then, the evaluation agent 50 calculates an evaluation value for the communication route based on the match rates for all estimated ranges. As a result, the reliability of the communication route, including security risks, can be evaluated before data is transmitted.
[0073] The evaluation agent 50 sets a region or sea area different from the country to which the allowable range belongs as an attribute of the protruding range. As a result, the user can freely set a region or sea area in the weighting coefficient table 43 according to the setting operation.
[0074] The evaluation agent 50 changes the weighting coefficient for each attribute in response to the setting operation, so that the user can freely set the weighting coefficient for each attribute in the weighting coefficient table 43 in response to the setting operation.
[0075] The evaluation agent 50 sets the weighting coefficient of the attributes of countries different from the countries in the acceptable range so that the weighting coefficient of countries not related to the country in the acceptable range is larger than that of countries related to the country in the acceptable range, according to the setting operation. As a result, the user can increase the penalty area by setting the weighting coefficient of the non-related country larger than that of the related country, thereby lowering the evaluation of the communication route passing through the non-related country.
[0076] In the evaluation agent 50 of the first embodiment, the estimated range of the source host 3, destination host 4, and each router 5 on the communication path is compared with the allowable range, and the communication path is evaluated based on the area match rate. However, this is not limited to the estimated range, and the communication path may be evaluated based on the result of comparing the estimated positions of the source host 3, destination host, and router 5 on the communication path with the allowable range and determining whether or not the estimated positions are within the allowable range, and this can be changed as appropriate.
[0077] In the case of the sea as an attribute, for example, it may be classified into territorial sea, exclusive economic zone, high seas, etc. Also, in the case of other countries as an attribute, for other countries, for example, when the acceptable range is France and Spain, EU (European Union) member states with a different acceptable range country are related countries, and other countries outside the EU member states are non-related countries. And the weight coefficient of non-related countries may be made larger compared to the weight coefficient of related countries and can be changed as appropriate. Although the case where the weight coefficient X satisfies 0 < X ≤ 1 is exemplified, the weight coefficient may be 1 or more and can be changed as appropriate. Note that when the weight coefficient is 1 or more, the matching rate and the comprehensive evaluation value may become negative values.
[0078] In the calculation process shown in FIG. 13, after calculating the area ratio of the estimated range in step S43, it is determined whether the area ratio of the estimated range is equal to or greater than the threshold value, and the case where it is determined that the evaluation is NG when it is not equal to or greater than the threshold value in step S44 is exemplified. However, it is not limited to this, and after calculating the area ratio of the estimated range in step S43, the process may proceed to the process of step S45 to specify the attribute of the protruding portion.
[0079] Also, the probe management device 12 transmits a probe packet from the probe node 11 closest to the communication device to the communication device and receives a response signal for the probe packet from the communication device. The probe node 11 measures the distance from its own node to the communication device based on the delay time of the response signal received from the communication device, and obtains the estimated range of the communication device corresponding to the distance from the probe node 11 to the communication device using the measurement result. However, it is not limited to this. For example, the delay may be measured by probes from three probe nodes, and the overlapping portion of the estimated ranges may be used as the range for estimating the position of the communication device.
[0080] Note that although the case where the function of the evaluation agent 50 is provided in the transmission source host 3 of the first embodiment is exemplified, an evaluation device may be separately arranged in the communication network 2, and the embodiment thereof will be described below as the second embodiment.
Embodiment
[0081] FIG. 14 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an evaluation system 1A of the second embodiment. Note that the same components as those in the evaluation system 1 of the first embodiment are given the same reference numerals, and explanations of the overlapping components and operations will be omitted. The evaluation system 1A shown in FIG. 14 differs from the evaluation system 1 shown in FIG. 1 in that an evaluation device 100 is provided instead of the evaluation agent 50 in the source host 3. The evaluation device 100 is an information processing device that is communicatively connected to the source host 3 and the probe management device 12 in the probe system 6.
[0082] The evaluation device 100 has the same functional configuration as that shown in FIG. 3 and includes a processor 24 and a memory 23. The processor 24 includes an estimation unit 31, an acquisition unit 32, and an evaluation unit 33. The estimation unit 31 includes a first estimation unit 31A, a second estimation unit 31B, and a collaboration unit 31C. The evaluation unit 33 includes an estimation range calculation unit 33A, an allowable range determination unit 33B, a protrusion area calculation unit 33C, an attribute determination unit 33D, and an evaluation value calculation unit 33E. The memory 23 includes a map DB 41, a position estimation result table 42, and a weighting coefficient table 43.
[0083] The evaluation device 100 of the second embodiment uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the Src estimated range of the source host 3 and the Dst estimated range of the destination host 4, and searches for routers 5 present on the communication path from the source host 3 to the destination host 4. Based on the search results, the evaluation device 100 uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the estimated range of each router 5 on the communication path. The evaluation device 100 calculates an evaluation value for the communication path based on the match rate of the area occupied by each estimated range of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5 within the allowable range. As a result, the evaluation device 100 can quantitatively determine, as an evaluation value, whether the geographical location of the communication path to be transmitted when data is transmitted is within the allowable range expected by the user before data transmission. Furthermore, based on the evaluation value of the communication path before data transmission, security risks such as data interception and tampering that may occur when data passes through countries or regions not intended by the user can be avoided.
[0084] In addition, although the example of having the function of the evaluation agent 50 within the source host 3 in Example 1 has been given, an evaluation service that uses the evaluation agent 50 as a service may also be placed on the cloud, and an embodiment of this will be described below as Example 3. [Example]
[0085] Fig. 15 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an evaluation system 1B according to a third embodiment. Note that the same components as those in the evaluation system 1 of the first embodiment are given the same reference numerals, and explanations of the overlapping components and operations will be omitted. The evaluation system 1B shown in Fig. 15 differs from the evaluation system 1 shown in Fig. 1 in that an evaluation service 60A is placed on the cloud instead of the evaluation agent 50 in the source host 3.
[0086] The evaluation service 60A has the function services of an estimation unit 31, an acquisition unit 32, and an evaluation unit 33. The estimation unit 31 has a first estimation unit 31A, a second estimation unit 31B, and a collaboration unit 31C. The evaluation unit 33 has an estimation range calculation unit 33A, an allowable range determination unit 33B, a protrusion area calculation unit 33C, an attribute determination unit 33D, and an evaluation value calculation unit 33E. Furthermore, the evaluation service 60A stores a map DB 41, a position estimation result table 42, and a weighting coefficient table 43.
[0087] When the evaluation service 60A detects an evaluation request from the source host 3, it calculates an evaluation value of the communication path between the source host 3 and the destination host 4.
[0088] The evaluation service 60A of the third embodiment uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the Src estimated range of the source host 3 and the Dst estimated range of the destination host 4, and searches for routers 5 present on the communication path from the source host 3 to the destination host 4. Based on the search results, the evaluation service 60A uses the probe management device 12 to estimate the estimated range of each router 5 on the communication path. The evaluation service 60A calculates an evaluation value for the communication path based on the match rate of the area occupied by each estimated range of the source host 3, the destination host 4, and each router 5 within the allowable range. As a result, the evaluation service 60A can quantitatively determine, as an evaluation value, whether the geographical location of the communication path when transmitting data is within the allowable range expected by the user before transmitting the data. Furthermore, based on the evaluation value of the communication path before transmitting the data, security risks such as data interception and tampering that may occur when data passes through countries or regions not intended by the user can be avoided.
[0089] In the evaluation system 1 (1A, 1B) of Examples 1 to 3, a case has been exemplified in which the geographical positions of the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5 on the communication path are estimated using a probe system 6. However, the geographical positions of the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5 on the communication path may be estimated by referring to a location information DB that manages the geographical positions of the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5 on the communication path, and this can be changed as appropriate. Furthermore, the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5 may have a built-in GPS function that measures their own current location, and the current geographical positions may be obtained from the source host 3, destination host 4, and router 5, and this can be changed as appropriate.
[0090] The communication network 2 may be, for example, a communication network such as a LAN or the Internet, and can be changed as appropriate.
[0091] FIG. 16 is a block diagram showing an example of a computer 110 that executes an evaluation program. The computer 110 shown in FIG. 16 includes an interface 111, a hard disk drive (HDD) 112, a read-only memory (ROM) 113, a random access memory (RAM) 114, a processor 115, and a bus 116. The interface 111 is a communication interface that communicates with a communication network 2. The ROM 113 stores, for example, a first estimation program 113A, an acquisition program 113B, a second estimation program 113C, and an evaluation program 113D. The processor 115 reads the programs stored in the ROM 113 and loads the read programs on the RAM 114. The processor 115 then executes, as functions, a first estimation process 114A, an acquisition process 114B, a second estimation process 114C, and an evaluation process 114D.
[0092] The first estimation process 114A estimates the location of the data source and the location of the data destination. The acquisition process 114B acquires routers present on the communication path from the source to the destination. The second estimation process 114C estimates the locations of the acquired routers. The evaluation process 114D calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated locations of the source, destination, and routers on the communication path.
[0093] The computer 110 estimates the location of the data sender and the location of the data destination, acquires routers present on the communication path from the sender to the destination, and estimates the acquired locations of the routers. Furthermore, the computer 110 calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated locations of the sender, destination, and routers on the communication path. As a result, the reliability of the communication path can be evaluated before data is transmitted.
[0094] Furthermore, the components of each unit shown in the figure do not necessarily have to be physically configured as shown in the figure. In other words, the specific form of distribution and integration of each unit is not limited to that shown in the figure, and all or part of them can be functionally or physically distributed and integrated in any unit depending on various loads, usage conditions, etc.
[0095] Furthermore, the various processing functions performed by each device may be executed in whole or in part on a CPU (Central Processing Unit), DSP (Digital Signal Processor), FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array), etc. Also, the various processing functions may be executed in whole or in part on a program analyzed and executed by a CPU, etc., or on hardware using wired logic.
[0096] The area for storing various information may be configured, for example, with ROM (Read Only Memory), RAM (Random Access Memory) such as SDRAM (Synchronous Dynamic Random Access Memory), MRAM (Magnetoresistive Random Access Memory), or NVRAM (Non-Volatile Random Access Memory).
[0097] The following additional notes are provided regarding the above-described embodiments including the present example.
[0098] (Appendix 1) Estimate the location of the data source and the location of the data destination; Acquire routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; Estimating the location of the obtained router; Calculating an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated positions of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path. An evaluation program that causes a computer to execute a process.
[0099] (Supplementary Note 2) As a process for estimating the location of the source, the destination, and the router, An evaluation program as described in Appendix 1, characterized in that a signal is sent from a node whose geographical location has been acquired to the source, the destination, and the router, and an estimation range including the location of each communication device of the source, the destination, and the router is estimated based on response signals to the signal from the source, the destination, and the router.
[0100] (Appendix 3) As a process for calculating the evaluation value, An evaluation program according to claim 2, characterized in that it specifies a geographical allowable range that is acceptable for the communication route, calculates, for each estimated range, the proportion of the area occupied by the specified allowable range within the estimated range, and calculates an evaluation value for the communication route based on the proportion of the area for each estimated range.
[0101] (Appendix 4) An evaluation program according to appendix 3, characterized in that if there is a range for each estimated range that exceeds the allowable range specified within that estimated range, a penalty area is calculated based on a coefficient corresponding to the attribute of the exceeding range and the exceeding area of the exceeding range for each estimated range, and the proportion of the area occupied by the allowable range is calculated based on the total area for each estimated range and the penalty area.
[0102] (Appendix 5) The attributes of the protruding range are as follows: 5. The evaluation program according to claim 4, wherein the tolerance range is set to a region or sea area different from the country to which the tolerance range belongs.
[0103] (Appendix 6) An evaluation program as described in Appendix 4, characterized in that, among the attributes, the coefficients of countries other than the country to which the tolerance range belongs are increased in accordance with a setting operation for countries that are not related to the country to which the tolerance range belongs compared to countries that have a predetermined relationship with the country to which the tolerance range belongs.
[0104] (Supplementary Note 7) The evaluation program according to Supplementary Note 4, characterized in that the coefficient for each attribute is changed in response to a setting operation.
[0105] (Supplementary Note 8) As a process for estimating the location of the source, the destination, and the router, The evaluation program according to claim 1, characterized in that for each communication device of the source, the destination, and the router, the evaluation program refers to a memory unit that stores the positions of the source, the destination, and the router, and estimates the positions of the source, the destination, and the router.
[0106] (Supplementary Note 9) As a process for estimating the location of the source, the destination, and the router, The evaluation program according to claim 1, further comprising a location acquisition function for acquiring the current locations of the source, destination, and router, and for estimating the current locations of the source, destination, and router using the location acquisition function.
[0107] (Supplementary Note 10) A first estimation unit that estimates the location of a data source and the location of a destination of the data; an acquisition unit that acquires routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; a second estimation unit that estimates the acquired location of the router; a calculation unit that calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes, based on the estimated locations of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path; An evaluation device comprising:
[0108] (Supplementary Note 11) An evaluation system including a probe management device that estimates the locations of a source, a destination, and a router located in a communication network based on location information of each node located in the communication network, a source of data in the communication network, a destination of the data, and a response signal to a signal from each communication device of a plurality of routers, and an evaluation device that is connected to and communicates with the probe management device, The evaluation device a first estimation unit that estimates the locations of the source and the destination from the estimation result of the probe management device; an acquisition unit that acquires the routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; a second estimation unit that estimates the acquired location of the router from the estimation result of the probe management device; a calculation unit that calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes, based on the estimated locations of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path; An evaluation system comprising:
[0109] (Appendix 12) The computer: Estimating the location of a source of data and the location of a destination of the data; Acquire routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; Estimating the location of the obtained router; Calculating an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated positions of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path. An evaluation method comprising: [Explanation of symbols]
[0110] 1. Rating System 2. Communication Network 3. Source host 4 Destination host 5. Router 6 Probe System 11 Probe Nodes 12 Probe management device 31A First Estimation Section 31B Second Presumption 32 Acquisition Department 33E Evaluation value calculation unit
Claims
1. Estimating the location of the source of the data and the location of the destination of the data; Acquire routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; Estimating the location of the obtained router; Calculating an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes based on the estimated positions of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path. An evaluation program that causes a computer to execute a process.
2. The process of estimating the location of the source, the destination, and the router includes: The evaluation program according to claim 1, characterized in that a signal is transmitted from a node whose geographical position has been acquired to the source, the destination and the router, and an estimated range including the position of each communication device of the source, the destination and the router is estimated based on response signals to the signal from the source, the destination and the router.
3. The process of calculating the evaluation value includes: The evaluation program according to claim 2, further comprising: specifying a geographically acceptable range that is acceptable for the communication route; calculating, for each estimated range, the proportion of area that the specified acceptable range occupies within the estimated range; and calculating an evaluation value for the communication route based on the proportion of area for each estimated range.
4. The evaluation program according to claim 3, characterized in that, when there is a range for each estimated range that extends beyond the allowable range specified within the estimated range, a penalty area is calculated based on a coefficient corresponding to an attribute of the extending range and an area of the extending range for each estimated range, and a proportion of the area occupied by the allowable range is calculated based on a total area for each estimated range and the penalty area.
5. The attributes of the overflowing range are as follows:
5. The evaluation program according to claim 4, wherein the allowable range is set to a region or sea area different from a country to which the allowable range belongs.
6. The evaluation program according to claim 4, characterized in that, in the coefficients of other countries other than the country to which the tolerance range belongs, among the attributes, the coefficients of countries that have no relationship with the country to which the tolerance range belongs are made larger than the coefficients of countries that have a predetermined relationship with the country to which the tolerance range belongs, depending on a setting operation.
7. 5. The evaluation program according to claim 4, wherein the coefficient for each attribute is changed in response to a setting operation.
8. a first estimation unit that estimates a location of a source of data and a location of a destination of the data; an acquisition unit that acquires routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; a second estimation unit that estimates the acquired location of the router; a calculation unit that calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes, based on the estimated positions of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path; An evaluation device comprising:
9. An evaluation system including a probe management device that estimates the locations of a source, a destination, and a router located in a communication network based on location information of each node located in the communication network, a source of data in the communication network, a destination of the data, and a response signal to a signal from each communication device of a plurality of routers, and an evaluation device that is communicatively connected to the probe management device, The evaluation device includes: a first estimation unit that estimates the locations of the source and the destination from an estimation result of the probe management device; an acquisition unit that acquires the routers present on a communication path from the source to the destination; a second estimation unit that estimates a location of the router from an estimation result of the probe management device; a calculation unit that calculates an evaluation value of the communication path through which the data passes, based on the estimated positions of the source, the destination, and the router on the communication path; An evaluation system comprising:
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Route information search system and method
JP2015002378A
Trust-based secure routing
JP2015515764A
Secure Routing Based on the Physical Locations of Routers
US20130232565A1
Root of trust of geolocation
US20170353435A1
