Snowfall detecting system
The snow detection system addresses the need for cost-effective snow removal and performance guarantees in solar power plants by using surveillance cameras and meteorological data to optimize snow removal planning and power generation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023080341
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-15
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-27
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Conventional snow removal systems in solar power plants require additional equipment like snow gauges and sensors, which are costly and time-consuming to install, and existing performance guarantee systems fail to account for snowfall impacts on power generation, leading to inefficiencies and high introduction hurdles.
A snow detection system that calculates snow coverage ratios using surveillance cameras and meteorological data, determining the need for snow removal without additional equipment, and provides performance guarantees by analyzing snow accumulation and weather data to optimize power generation.
Enables accurate, automated snow removal planning and performance guarantees by quantitatively assessing snow conditions, reducing system costs and improving power generation efficiency in snowy areas.
Smart Images

Figure 2024164680000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] FIELD OF THE DISCLOSURE Embodiments of the present invention relate to a snow accumulation detection system. [Background technology]
[0002] Generally, photovoltaic power plants are unmanned power plants, and information is transmitted within the power plant through a monitoring system within the power plant. In snowy areas, snow accumulation and snowfall conditions within the photovoltaic power plant premises are checked using snow gauges and snowfall meters.
[0003] On the other hand, at solar power plants in such snowy regions, snow accumulation on the panels poses the risk of damaging or breaking down the panels, so snow removal work must be carried out at the appropriate time.
[0004] In addition, when constructing a solar power plant, it is common for the client and the contractor to agree on a power generation performance guarantee, but when constructing a solar power plant in a snowy region, it is difficult to set a power generation performance guarantee that takes snow into account. Therefore, there is a need for a system that makes it possible to provide a performance guarantee even in snowy regions.
[0005] In addition, in recent years, there has been a demand for more accurate prediction of the amount of power generated when selling solar power. Therefore, solar power plants in snowy regions need a system that quantitatively and automatically checks the snow accumulation on solar panels and provides a snow removal plan. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0006] [Patent Document 1] JP 2017-163632 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2017-191044 A [Patent Document 3] JP 2005-275491 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0007] A known system for snow removal calculates the amount of electricity generated before and after melting the snow using the thickness of snow measured using an optional snow accumulation determination device and future weather forecast values (solar radiation and snowfall), and if the increase in electricity generated corresponding to the difference between the two is higher than the predicted snow melting cost, it instructs the installed snow melting equipment to melt the snow.
[0008] Another known system for snow removal is one that photographs the snow surface from two locations with a camera, calculates the snow depth from the distance between the two locations, and combines this with weather data to determine whether snow removal work is necessary.
[0009] Also, as a performance guarantee system, a system is known that calculates a guaranteed power generation amount and a predicted power generation amount corresponding to fluctuations in weather (amount of solar radiation, hours of sunshine, temperature, wind direction and wind speed), and if the calculated predicted power generation amount is smaller than the guaranteed power generation amount, presents compensation for the shortfall.
[0010] Conventional snow removal systems for solar power plants require additional equipment such as a snow accumulation system and snowfall meter to analyze snow accumulation on solar panels. The introduction of such additional equipment is costly and time-consuming, making it difficult to introduce the system.
[0011] Furthermore, in conventional performance assurance systems for solar power plants, although there are known techniques for calculating performance assurance in response to weather changes other than snowfall, there are no known techniques that take into account snowfall on solar panels.
[0012] Therefore, an embodiment of the present invention provides a snow removal plan based on the snow accumulation conditions at a solar power plant without introducing additional equipment, and also provides a snow accumulation detection system for ensuring effective power generation performance even when snow accumulates. [Means for solving the problem]
[0013] According to one embodiment, the snow accumulation detection system includes an acquisition unit that acquires a first snow covering ratio, which is a ratio of an area of snow on a solar panel to an area of the solar panel, and meteorological data related to snow accumulation conditions. The snow accumulation detection system further includes a first calculation unit that performs snow accumulation analysis and meteorological analysis based on the meteorological data. The snow accumulation detection system further includes a determination unit that determines whether or not snow removal work is required based on the first snow covering ratio and the results of the snow accumulation analysis and the meteorological analysis. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0014] [Figure 1] 1 is a schematic configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a first embodiment. [Diagram 2] 3 is another schematic configuration diagram of the snow accumulation detection system in the first embodiment. FIG. [Diagram 3] 1 is a functional block diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a first embodiment. [Figure 4] 4 is a flowchart when the snow accumulation detection system in the first embodiment performs snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification. [Diagram 5] FIG. 11 is a schematic configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a second embodiment. [Figure 6] 13 is a flowchart showing a process performed by the snow accumulation detection system in the second embodiment for performing snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification. [Figure 7] FIG. 11 is a functional block diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a third embodiment. [Figure 8] 13 is a flowchart showing a process for calculating each PR value by the snow accumulation detection system according to the third embodiment. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is a functional block diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a fourth embodiment. [Figure 10] 13 is a flowchart showing a process performed by the snow accumulation detection system in the fourth embodiment for performing snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification. [Figure 11] A figure showing the difference between the increase in predicted electricity sales revenue and snow removal costs in the fourth embodiment. [Figure 12]FIG. 13 is a hardware configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to a fifth embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0015] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. The present embodiment does not limit the present invention. The drawings are schematic or conceptual, and the ratio of each part is not necessarily the same as the actual one. In the specification and drawings, elements similar to those described above with respect to the previous drawings are given the same reference numerals, and detailed descriptions are omitted as appropriate.
[0016] (First embodiment) FIG. 1 is a schematic configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to the first embodiment.
[0017] A snow accumulation detection system 6 in an embodiment of the present invention is installed, for example, in a building 400 of a photovoltaic power plant 1, and performs snow accumulation analysis on the snow accumulation condition on the solar panels 100 in the photovoltaic power plant 1 to determine whether snow removal work is required.
[0018] In FIG. 1, a string configuration 500 of solar panels 100 includes a plurality of solar panels 100 connected in series. Furthermore, in FIG. 1, an array configuration 700 of solar panels 100 includes a plurality of string configurations 500 connected in parallel. The array configuration 700 shown in FIG. 1 includes a plurality of string configurations 500 extending in the horizontal direction and adjacent to each other in the depth direction, and each string configuration 500 includes a plurality of solar panels 100 arranged in one or more rows in the horizontal direction. In the present embodiment, snowfall analysis is performed using, for example, an image of a portion of the array configuration 700 captured by a monitoring camera 2. In the present embodiment, snowfall analysis can be applied not only to an image of a portion of the array configuration 700 captured by a monitoring camera 2, but also to an image of a portion of the solar panel 100 or the string configuration 500 captured by a camera.
[0019] Furthermore, a monitoring system 7 that monitors the sunlight conditions, weather conditions, and power generation conditions within the solar power plant 1 is installed in the building 400 of the solar power plant 1. These sunlight conditions, weather conditions, and power generation conditions are stored in a memory unit 15 within the monitoring system 7 as actual solar radiation data, weather data, and actual power generation data, respectively. Furthermore, the operator of the solar power plant 1 can monitor these sunlight conditions, weather conditions, and power generation conditions through a display unit 13.
[0020] In this embodiment, an external system 5 is installed in the building 400 of the solar power plant 1, which calculates a first snow covering ratio from a video or image captured by a monitoring camera 2 installed in the premises of the solar power plant 1. The first snow covering ratio refers to the ratio of the area of snow present on the solar panel 100 to the area of the solar panel 100. This first snow covering ratio may be calculated as the ratio of the area of snow present on the array configuration 700 to the area of the array configuration 700 in the shooting range 3 of the monitoring camera 2, rather than the solar panel 100 alone. The first snow covering ratio calculated by the external system 5 is stored in the memory unit 17 in the snow detection system 6.
[0021] In this embodiment, the snow accumulation detection system 6 acquires a value of a first snow accumulation covering rate from the external system 5 when performing snow accumulation analysis. The acquired value is stored in a memory unit 17 in the snow accumulation detection system 6. Furthermore, the snow accumulation detection system 6 acquires weather data from the monitoring system 7 when performing snow accumulation analysis. The acquired data is stored in the memory unit 17. Furthermore, these values and data are transmitted and received, for example, via a LAN (Local Area Network) constructed by the network device 20.
[0022] FIG. 2 is another schematic configuration diagram of the snow accumulation detection system in the first embodiment.
[0023] The snow accumulation detection system 6, the monitoring system 7, and the external system 5 may be installed, for example, in a management station 600 away from the solar power plant 1. In this case, the video or images captured by the monitoring camera 2 are transmitted via the network 30.
[0024] The network 30 is constructed, for example, by a transmission medium such as a wired line, such as an optical cable or a metal cable, or a wireless line, such as a satellite line or a micro-radio, in addition to the network device 20. The network device 20 is also constructed, for example, by equipment required for transmitting videos and images, such as a router, a switch, a media converter, etc. For the sake of explanation, the following description will be given using the configuration in FIG. 1.
[0025] FIG. 3 is a functional block diagram of the snow accumulation detection system in the first embodiment.
[0026] The snow accumulation detection system 6 includes an acquisition unit 9, a first calculation unit 10, a determination unit 11, a transmission unit 12, and a memory unit 17. The snow accumulation detection system 6 can be realized by installing a program for the snow accumulation detection system 6 in, for example, a PC (Personal Computer). A CPU (Central Processing Unit) in the snow accumulation detection system 6 executes the program for the snow accumulation detection system 6 to realize the functions of the acquisition unit 9, the first calculation unit 10, the determination unit 11, the transmission unit 12, and the memory unit 17. The memory unit 17 is constructed on an auxiliary storage device such as an HDD (Hard Disk Drive).
[0027] In this embodiment, the acquisition unit 9 of the snow accumulation detection system 6 is configured to acquire the first snow accumulation covering rate from the external system 5, but it is also possible to construct a functional block of a calculation unit in the snow accumulation detection system 6 and configure it to calculate the first snow accumulation covering rate.
[0028] Although detailed configuration is omitted, a memory unit 15 is constructed in the monitoring system 7, and actual solar radiation data, actual power generation data, and weather data are stored in the memory unit 15. A memory unit 16 is also constructed in the external system 5, and a first snow covering rate is stored in the memory unit 15. Each functional block of the snow detection system 6 will be described below.
[0029] The acquisition unit 9 acquires the value of the first snow covering rate from the external system 5. The acquisition unit 9 stores the acquired value in the storage unit 17. The acquisition unit 9 also acquires actual solar radiation data, actual power generation data, and weather data of the solar power plant 1 from the monitoring system 7. The acquisition unit 9 stores the acquired data in the storage unit 17. The actual solar radiation data is, for example, the solar radiation (kW / m^2) at the solar power plant 1 for a predetermined period, and data collected by an actinometer installed for the monitoring system 7 can be used. The actual power generation data is, for example, the power generation (kWh) generated at the solar power plant 1 for a predetermined period, and data collected by a power meter installed for the monitoring system 7 can be used. The weather data is, for example, data on the current or past snowfall (m) at the solar power plant 1, and data collected by a snow gauge installed for the monitoring system 7 can be used. The weather data is, for example, data on current or past temperatures (° C.) in the photovoltaic power plant 1, and data collected by a thermometer installed for the monitoring system 7, etc. can be used.
[0030] The weather data may be data measured on-site at the photovoltaic power plant 1, or may be weather data provided by, for example, a government agency or a private company. The acquisition unit 9 may acquire these data from the storage unit 15 of the monitoring system 7, or may acquire the data via the Internet, for example, by using a Web API (Application Programming Interface).
[0031] The first calculation unit 10 performs a snowfall analysis using the weather data acquired by the acquisition unit 9. In this embodiment, the first calculation unit performs a snowfall analysis and a temperature analysis as the snowfall analysis. In the snowfall analysis, for example, current or past temperature data and snowfall amount data are used to analyze whether snowfall will continue for a certain period of time or more. In the temperature analysis, the first calculation unit 10 uses, for example, current or past temperatures to analyze whether a temperature of 0°C or less will continue for a certain period of time or more. In addition, the first calculation unit 10 may use actual solar radiation data when performing the snowfall analysis.
[0032] The snowfall analysis and temperature analysis may be performed by a commonly used analysis method, or may be performed by supervised machine learning using the data acquired by the acquisition unit 9 as an input.
[0033] The determination unit 11 determines whether or not snow will continue for a certain period of time or more in the solar power plant 1, based on the results of the snow accumulation analysis and temperature analysis performed by the first calculation unit 10. The determination unit 11 also determines whether or not an air temperature of 0°C will continue for a certain period of time or more in the solar power plant 1. When it is determined that snow will continue for a certain period of time or more, or when it is determined that an air temperature of 0°C will continue for a certain period of time or more, the determination unit 11 determines that the first snow covering rate acquired by the acquisition unit 9 is a correct value.
[0034] The determination unit 11 may also have a function of determining whether or not snow removal work is necessary based on the first snow covering rate. For example, the determination unit 11 may determine that snow removal work is necessary when the first snow covering rate is equal to or greater than a threshold value and the first snow covering rate is determined to be a correct value as a result of snow analysis.
[0035] In the following, for simplicity of explanation, an example will be described in which the transmission unit 12 unconditionally transmits the value of the first snow covering ratio and a snow removal notification to the monitoring system 7 as a result of the snow analysis when the determination unit 11 determines that the snow covering ratio is correct. The snow removal notification may be displayed as an icon in addition to being displayed as text information on the display unit 13 of the monitoring system 7. This allows the operator of the solar power plant 1 to visually confirm the snow removal notification. The snow removal notification may also be presented to the operator as light information through a light or the like or sound information through a speaker or the like.
[0036] FIG. 4 is a flowchart showing how the snow accumulation detection system according to the first embodiment performs snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification.
[0037] In step S1, the acquisition unit 9 acquires a first snow covering ratio from the external system 5. For example, the acquisition unit 9 may access the memory unit 16 of the external system 5 to acquire the first covering ratio. The acquisition unit 9 also stores the acquired first covering ratio in the memory unit 17 in the snow detection system 6. In step S2, the acquisition unit 9 acquires weather data from the monitoring system 7. As in the above, for example, the acquisition unit 9 may access the memory unit 15 of the monitoring system 7 to acquire weather data. The acquisition unit 9 also stores the acquired weather data in the memory unit 17 in the snow detection system 6. Note that steps S1 and S2 may be performed in the reverse order.
[0038] In step S3, the first calculation unit 10 performs a snowfall analysis using the acquired weather data. In step S4, the first calculation unit 10 performs a temperature analysis using the acquired weather data. Note that steps S1 and S4 may be performed in the reverse order.
[0039] In step S5, the determination unit 11 determines whether or not snow accumulation will continue for a certain period of time or more based on the result of the snow accumulation analysis. Also, the determination unit 11 determines whether or not the temperature at the solar power plant 1 will continue for a certain period of time or more based on the result of the temperature analysis. Also, in step S5, if the determination unit 11 determines that snow accumulation will continue for a certain period of time or more, or if the temperature at 0°C or less will continue for a certain period of time or more, in step S6, the transmission unit 12 transmits the value of the first snow accumulation covering rate as the result of the snow accumulation analysis to the monitoring system 7, and also transmits a snow removal notification. In step S5, if the determination unit 11 does not determine that snow accumulation will continue for a certain period of time or more and if the temperature at 0°C or less will not continue for a certain period of time, the transmission unit 12 does not transmit the snow removal notification, etc., and ends the process.
[0040] The snow accumulation detection in this flowchart is repeated, for example, at predetermined time intervals. For example, it is possible to carry out the detection at predetermined intervals, such as once every 30 minutes or once every hour. The repetition timing may be changed during operation of the snow accumulation detection system 6. For example, it is possible to provide a functional block of a setting unit in the snow accumulation detection system 6, and have the operator change the repetition timing from a user interface displayed on the display unit 13.
[0041] According to this embodiment, the snow accumulation detection system 6 can determine whether the first snow accumulation covering ratio is correct or not based not only on the value of the first snow accumulation covering ratio at the time of acquisition, but also on a prediction of the continuation of snow accumulation and a prediction of the temperature condition based on the snow accumulation analysis. This makes it possible to quantitatively, automatically, and accurately check the snow accumulation condition on the solar panel 100. In addition, the operator of the solar power plant 1 can avoid snow removal work in cases where snow accumulation does not continue or the temperature becomes high, making it unnecessary to remove snow due to melting, and can create an appropriate snow removal plan.
[0042] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the snowfall detection system 6 can perform snowfall analysis without introducing additional equipment such as sensors for acquiring meteorological data or the monitoring camera 2. This makes it possible to reduce the system introduction cost.
[0043] Second embodiment FIG. 5 is a schematic configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to the second embodiment.
[0044] In this embodiment, snowfall is analyzed using an image captured by a surveillance camera 2 of an area where solar panels 100 are installed in the premises of a solar power plant 1, as in the first embodiment. The capturing range 3 of the surveillance camera 2 and the facility configuration are the same as those in the first embodiment, and therefore will not be described.
[0045] In addition, since the functional block diagram of the snow accumulation detection system 6 in this embodiment is the same as that in Fig. 3, the description will be given again with reference to Fig. 3. In this embodiment, the capacity (kW) data of the solar panel 100 required for calculating the amount of contributed solar radiation, which will be described later, is stored in advance in the memory unit 17 of the snow accumulation detection system 6.
[0046] Similar to the first embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 in this embodiment performs snowfall analysis using the weather data acquired by the acquisition unit 9. Specifically, the first calculation unit 10 performs snowfall analysis and air temperature analysis as the snowfall analysis.
[0047] Further, the first calculation unit 10 in this embodiment calculates a second snow covering ratio based on the first snow covering ratio acquired from the external system 5 and the actual power generation amount data and the actual solar radiation amount data acquired from the monitoring system 7. The second snow covering ratio is the ratio of the area of snow present on the solar panel 100 to the area of the solar panel 100 in the entire solar power plant 1. The first calculation unit 10 may use data for any period as the actual power generation amount data and the actual solar radiation amount data for calculating the second snow covering ratio. For example, the first calculation unit 10 may use relatively recent data such as data for the past few hours or data for the past day as the actual power generation amount data and the actual solar radiation amount data. The snow detection system 6 can calculate the second snow covering ratio by acquiring additional information such as the actual power generation amount data and the actual solar radiation amount data from a part of the shooting range of the solar power plant 1 photographed by the monitoring camera 2, and perform snow analysis of the entire solar power plant 1.
[0048] The second snow covering rate is calculated taking into account the solar radiation shading rate, which is the ratio of the amount of solar radiation blocked by snow on the solar panel 100 to the amount of solar radiation contributed to the solar panel 100 when the solar panel 100 is not covered with snow at all.
[0049] Hereinafter, a method for calculating the solar radiation shading factor A and the solar radiation shading factor B for calculating the second snow covering factor will be described.
[0050] For the solar radiation blocking rate A, the first snow covering rate calculated in the above-mentioned shooting range 3 is used.
[0051] The solar radiation blocking rate B is calculated by comparing the contributed solar radiation (kW / m^2), which is the amount of solar radiation that contributed to the actual power generation, with the actual solar radiation data. The contributed solar radiation is calculated by calculating the capacity of the solar panel 100 backwards from the actual power generation.
[0052] In addition, the solar radiation blocking rate defined in this embodiment only considers the amount of solar radiation blocked by snowfall, and therefore excludes the amount of solar radiation blocked by the shadow of the solar panel 100 as a shadow ratio. Here, the shadow ratio refers to the ratio of the total area of the shadow cast by each solar panel 100 to the total area of the solar panels 100 within the premises of the solar power plant 1. Shadows are caused by the array configuration 700 arranged in the preceding stage and surrounding obstacles, and the shadow ratio also varies depending on the season and time of day. The shadow ratio solar radiation amount (kW / m^2), which is the amount of solar radiation as a shadow ratio, can be calculated, for example, by multiplying the actual solar radiation amount by the shadow ratio.
[0053] The shading ratio is calculated using power plant design data (the north-south distance between the arrays, the array tilt angle, the solar altitude, the array dimensions, and the height of surrounding obstacles, etc.). The solar radiation shading ratio B is expressed by the formula (1). It is considered that the power plant design data is stored in advance in the memory unit 17 of the snow accumulation detection system 6. Solar radiation shading rate B = (actual solar radiation - contributed solar radiation - shaded solar radiation) ÷ (actual solar radiation) (1)
[0054] Moreover, in order to calculate the second snow covering rate, a correction coefficient K is calculated from the solar radiation shading rates A and B. The correction coefficient K is expressed by, for example, equation (2). Correction coefficient K = (solar radiation shading factor A + solar radiation shading factor B) ÷ 2 ÷ solar radiation shading factor A (2)
[0055] In addition to using equation (2), the correction coefficient K may be calculated by calculating the proportion of the area of the solar panel 100 corresponding to the solar radiation shading factor A to the area of the solar panel 100 corresponding to the solar radiation shading factor B, and weighting the solar radiation shading factors A and B, respectively.
[0056] The second snow covering rate is expressed by the formula (3) using the above-mentioned correction coefficient K. The first calculation unit 10 may store the calculated second snow covering rate in the storage unit 17 as statistical data. Second snow cover rate = First snow cover rate × Correction coefficient K (3)
[0057] The first calculation unit 10 calculates the second snow covering rate by the above-mentioned formulas (1) to (3). The first calculation unit 10 also stores the calculated second snow covering rate in the storage unit 17.
[0058] Furthermore, the determination unit 11 determines whether or not snow will continue for a certain period of time or more in the solar power plant 1, based on the results of the snow accumulation analysis and temperature analysis performed by the first calculation unit 10. The determination unit 11 also determines whether or not an air temperature of 0°C will continue for a certain period of time or more in the solar power plant 1. If it is determined that snow will continue for a certain period of time or more, or if it is determined that an air temperature of 0°C will continue for a certain period of time or more, the determination unit 11 determines that the second snow covering rate calculated by the first calculation unit 10 is a correct value.
[0059] FIG. 6 is a flowchart showing how the snow accumulation detection system according to the second embodiment performs snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification.
[0060] In step S21, the acquisition unit 9 acquires the first snow covering rate from the external system 5. In step S22, the acquisition unit 9 acquires actual solar radiation data, actual power generation data, and weather data from the monitoring system .
[0061] In step S23, the first calculation unit 10 performs a snowfall analysis using the acquired weather data. In step S24, the first calculation unit 10 performs a temperature analysis using the acquired weather data.
[0062] Steps S25 to S29 will be described as being executed in parallel with steps S23 to S24. These processes may be executed before or after steps S23 to S24. In step S25, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the attributable solar radiation from the actual power generation amount data and the panel capacity of the solar panel 100. In step S26, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the shadow ratio from the power plant design data. The calculated attributable solar radiation and shadow ratio values may be stored in the storage unit 17.
[0063] In step S27, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the solar radiation shading factor B from the actual solar radiation data, the attributable solar radiation, and the shadow ratio. For the actual solar radiation (see formula (1)) used in calculating the solar radiation shading factor B, for example, the actual solar radiation for any predetermined period in the past may be used. In step S28, the first calculation unit 10 calculates a correction coefficient K from the solar radiation shading factor A and the solar radiation shading factor B, assuming the first snow covering rate acquired in step S21 as the solar radiation shading factor A.
[0064] In step S29, the first calculation unit 10 calculates a second snow covering rate from the correction coefficient K and the solar radiation shading rate A. In step S30, the determination unit 11 determines whether or not snow will continue for a certain period of time or more based on the result of the snow analysis. Also, the determination unit 11 determines whether or not the temperature at the solar power plant 1 will remain below 0°C for a certain period of time or more based on the result of the temperature analysis.
[0065] Furthermore, in step S30, if the determination unit 11 determines that snow accumulation will continue for a certain period of time or more, or if the temperature is determined to be below 0°C for a certain period of time, in step S31 the transmission unit 12 transmits the value of the first snow accumulation covering rate to the monitoring system 7 as a result of the snow accumulation analysis to the monitoring system 7, and also transmits a snow removal notification. In step S30, if the determination unit 11 does not determine that snow accumulation will continue for a certain period of time or more, and if the temperature is determined to be below 0°C for a certain period of time or more, the transmission unit 12 does not transmit a snow removal notification or the like, and ends the process.
[0066] The snowfall analysis in this flowchart is repeated, for example, at predetermined time intervals. For example, it may be performed at predetermined intervals, such as once every 30 minutes or once every hour. The repetition timing may be changed during operation of the snowfall detection system 6.
[0067] According to this embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the solar radiation shading factor B based on the actual power generation amount data, the actual solar radiation data, and the power plant design data. The first calculation unit 10 also calculates the second snow covering factor by multiplying the first snow covering factor by a correction coefficient K calculated based on the solar radiation shading factor B. The snow detection system 6 performs snow analysis using not only the first snow covering factor calculated from the shooting range of the monitoring camera 2, but also the second snow covering factor that incorporates additional information in the solar power plant 1 into the calculation. Therefore, the snow detection system 6 can perform snow analysis of the entire solar power plant 1 from a portion of the shooting range.
[0068] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the judgment unit 11 determines that the value of the second snow covering rate is correct through snow analysis, and the transmission unit 12 sends a snow removal notification, thereby enabling the operators of the solar power plant 1 to create a more appropriate snow removal plan.
[0069] Third embodiment FIG. 7 is a functional block diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to the third embodiment.
[0070] The snow accumulation detection system 6 in this embodiment includes a second calculation unit 14 that calculates an actual PR value, a theoretical PR value, and a virtual PR value as a system performance ratio PR (Performance Ratio). Other functional block diagrams are the same as those in the second embodiment, and therefore description thereof will be omitted. In this embodiment, the solar panel capacity data, which is capacity data of the solar panel 100 required for calculating PR, is stored in advance in a storage unit 17 of the snow accumulation detection system 6. Hereinafter, a method for calculating the actual PR value, the theoretical PR value, and the virtual PR value will be described.
[0071] The actual PR value is a PR value calculated based on the actual power generation amount and the actual solar radiation amount of the solar power plant 1. The second calculation unit 14 acquires the actual power generation amount data, the actual solar radiation amount data, and the solar panel capacity data from the storage unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. The second calculation unit 14 also substitutes the acquired data into formula (4) to calculate the actual PR value. Actual PR value = Actual power generation ÷ (Capacity of solar panels × Accumulated actual solar radiation) (4)
[0072] The cumulative solar radiation (kWh / m^2) is calculated from the actual solar radiation data for a predetermined period. This predetermined period may be any period, and may be, for example, the predetermined period for the entire period of the actual solar radiation data stored in the storage unit 17, or may be the predetermined period for a part of the period. Similarly, the actual power generation amount is calculated as the predetermined period for an arbitrary period.
[0073] The theoretical PR value is a theoretical PR value calculated based on the amount of solar radiation in the photovoltaic power plant 1 without considering snow accumulation on the solar panel 100. The second calculation unit 14 acquires actual power generation amount data and solar panel capacity data from the storage unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. Note that, if these data have been acquired when calculating the actual PR value, the second calculation unit 14 does not need to acquire them again from the storage unit 17.
[0074] The second calculation unit 14 also inputs the actual solar radiation data into a PR calculation model to calculate theoretical power generation data, which is a theoretical power generation amount (kWh) (hereinafter, theoretical power generation amount). This PR calculation model can be calculated using a calculation formula that is generally used in photovoltaic power generation simulators, etc. The second calculation unit 14 also substitutes the theoretical power generation amount data into formula (5) to calculate the theoretical PR value. Theoretical PR value = theoretical power generation ÷ (solar panel capacity × cumulative actual solar radiation) (5)
[0075] As in the above, the theoretical power generation amount and the accumulated solar radiation amount are calculated from data for a predetermined period of time, and this predetermined period may be any period of time.
[0076] The virtual PR value is a virtual PR value calculated based on the amount of solar radiation in the photovoltaic power plant 1, taking into account snow accumulation and shadows on the solar panels. The second calculation unit 14 acquires actual power generation amount data and solar panel capacity data from the storage unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. Note that, if these data have been acquired when calculating the actual PR value, the second calculation unit 14 does not need to acquire them again from the storage unit 17. In addition, the second calculation unit 14 acquires the second snow covering rate from the first calculation unit 10.
[0077] The second calculation unit 14 also inputs the actual solar radiation data and the second snow covering rate into the PR calculation model to calculate virtual power generation data, which is a virtual power generation amount (kWh) (hereinafter, virtual power generation amount). Here, the second snow covering rate is used, for example, in the calculation formula of the PR calculation model to correct the area on the solar panel 100. The first snow covering rate may be used instead of the second snow covering rate. This PR calculation model can be calculated by a calculation formula generally used in photovoltaic power generation simulators, etc. The second calculation unit 14 also substitutes the virtual power generation amount data into formula (6) to calculate the virtual PR value. Virtual PR value = Virtual power generation amount ÷ (Solar panel capacity × Accumulated actual solar radiation) (6)
[0078] As in the above, the virtual power generation amount and the accumulated solar radiation amount are calculated from data for a predetermined period, and this predetermined period may be any period.
[0079] The transmission unit 12 transmits the calculated values of each PR value to the monitoring system 7. Each PR value may be displayed as an icon, in addition to being displayed as text information on the display unit 13 of the monitoring system 7. The transmission unit 12 may also transmit the value of the second snow covering rate to the monitoring system 7.
[0080] FIG. 8 is a flowchart showing a process performed by the snow accumulation detection system according to the third embodiment to calculate each PR value.
[0081] In step S41, the second calculation unit 14 acquires actual solar radiation data, actual power generation data, and solar panel capacity data from the memory unit 17. In step S42, the second calculation unit 14 acquires a second snow covering rate from the first calculation unit 10. In addition, when the second snow covering rate is stored in the memory unit 17, the second calculation unit 14 may acquire the second snow covering rate from the memory unit 17.
[0082] In step S43, the second calculation unit 14 calculates the actual PR value (see formula (4)) using the actual solar radiation data, the actual power generation data, and the solar panel capacity data.
[0083] Steps S44 to S46 and steps S47 to S49 will be described as being executed in parallel with step S43. These processes may be executed before or after step S43. In step S44, the second calculation unit 14 incorporates the acquired actual solar radiation data into the PR calculation model. In step S45, the second calculation unit 14 calculates theoretical power generation data from the calculation formula of the PR calculation model.
[0084] In step S46, the second calculation unit 14 calculates the theoretical PR value (see formula (5)) using the theoretical power generation amount data, the actual solar radiation amount data, and the solar panel capacity data. In step S47, the second calculation unit 14 incorporates the acquired actual solar radiation amount data and the second snow covering rate into the PR calculation model.
[0085] In step S48, the second calculation unit 14 calculates the virtual power generation amount data from the calculation formula of the PR calculation model. In step S49, the second calculation unit 14 calculates the virtual PR value (see formula (6)) using the virtual power generation amount data, the actual solar radiation amount data, and the solar panel capacity data.
[0086] In step S50, the transmission unit 12 transmits each PR value and the value of the second snow covering rate to the monitoring system 7.
[0087] According to this embodiment, the second calculation unit 14 calculates the actual PR value, the theoretical PR value, and the virtual PR value, and the transmission unit 12 displays these results on the display unit 13 of the monitoring system 7. This allows the operator to check more detailed information by comparing the PR values, and to create an appropriate snow removal plan.
[0088] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the operator can compare the virtual PR value that takes into account snow accumulation with the theoretical PR, which is the PR value that does not take snow accumulation into account, and therefore can compare performance between when there is snow accumulation on the solar panel 100 and when there is not.
[0089] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the operator can compare the PR values displayed on the display unit 13 and use them to guarantee power generation performance taking snow accumulation into consideration. Furthermore, the snow accumulation detection system 6 can analyze the amount of power sold in the past by comparing the PR values, and learning these PR values can lead to accurate prediction of the amount of power sold in the future.
[0090] (Fourth embodiment) FIG. 9 is a functional block diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to the fourth embodiment.
[0091] The snow accumulation detection system 6 in this embodiment uses weather forecast data to calculate the increase in the predicted value of the income from selling electricity obtained after snow removal work and the snow removal cost, and determines whether snow removal is necessary based on the difference. The following describes how to calculate the predicted value of the income from selling electricity obtained after snow removal work and the snow removal cost.
[0092] The acquisition unit 9 acquires weather forecast data. In this example, the acquisition unit 9 acquires solar radiation forecast data and snowfall forecast data as the weather forecast data. For example, the weather forecast data may be weather forecast data provided by a government agency or a private company. The weather forecast data may be calculated by the first calculation unit 10 from the weather data by machine learning or the like. In this example, an example will be described in which the acquisition unit 9 acquires weather forecast data using a Web API via the Internet 40.
[0093] The first calculation unit 10 acquires the second snow covering rate from the memory unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. The first calculation unit 10 also calculates a predicted snow covering rate based on the weather forecast data and the second snow covering rate. The predicted snow covering rate is the ratio of the area of snow predicted to accumulate on the solar panel 100 to the area of the solar panel 100, calculated taking into account the shadow cast on the solar panel 100. The predicted snow covering rate is calculated by substituting predicted data into the past data portion of the solar radiation shading rate B (see formula (1)) used when calculating the second snow covering rate.
[0094] For example, the first calculation unit 10 calculates a predicted snow coverage rate using the second snow coverage rate from the statistical data of past second snow coverage rates when the past snowfall amount was equivalent to the snowfall amount predicted from the snowfall amount prediction data.
[0095] Also, for example, the first calculation unit 10 substitutes the predicted solar radiation and predicted contributing solar radiation into the actual solar radiation and contributing solar radiation used in calculating the second snow covering rate. The solar radiation blocking rate B' of the predicted snow covering rate is expressed by the formula (7). The predicted solar radiation and predicted contributing solar radiation in any predetermined period are substituted for the predicted solar radiation and predicted contributing solar radiation. The calculation method of the predicted snow covering rate is one example, and various calculation methods for predicting snow accumulation on the solar panels are also adopted. Solar radiation shading rate B' = (forecast solar radiation - forecast contributing solar radiation - shading rate) ÷ (forecast solar radiation) (7)
[0096] The first calculation unit 10 also calculates a predicted power generation loss using the predicted snow covering rate as a predicted solar radiation blocking rate. The predicted power generation loss (kWh) is the amount of power generation lost due to snow predicted to accumulate on the solar panel 100. The predicted power generation loss can be calculated, for example, by multiplying the calculation formula for the power generation amount by the predicted solar radiation blocking rate.
[0097] The first calculation unit 10 also calculates the increase in the predicted power selling income obtained after the snow removal work by multiplying the predicted power loss by the power selling price. The power selling price may be stored in advance in the storage unit 17. In order to be able to respond to changes in the power selling price, the snow detection system 6 may be provided with a functional block of an input unit to receive input of the changed power selling price from the operator.
[0098] In parallel, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the predicted total snow area on the solar panel 100 from the predicted snow covering rate and the total area of the solar panels 100 present in the solar power plant 1. When calculating the predicted total snow area on the solar panel 100, the total area of the solar panel 100 may be stored in the memory unit 17 in advance, for example.
[0099] The first calculation unit 10 also calculates the snow removal cost by multiplying the predicted total snow cover area by the snow removal cost unit price. The snow removal cost unit price may be stored in advance in the storage unit 17. The first calculation unit 10 also calculates the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales income value and the snow removal cost.
[0100] The determination unit 11 compares the increase in the predicted electricity sales income with the snow removal cost, and determines that snow removal work is necessary when the difference between the increase and the snow removal cost is equal to or greater than a threshold value.
[0101] When the determination unit 11 determines that snow removal work is necessary, the transmission unit 12 transmits a snow removal notification to the monitoring system 7 as a result of the snow accumulation analysis. The snow removal notification may be displayed as character information on the display unit 13 of the monitoring system 7, or may be displayed as an icon. The snow removal notification may also be presented to the operator as light information through a light or the like, or sound information through a speaker or the like. The transmission unit 12 may also transmit to the monitoring system 7 the increase in the predicted electricity sales revenue and the snow removal cost. These pieces of information are displayed as character information or the like on the display unit 13 of the monitoring system 7 in the same manner as described above.
[0102] FIG. 10 is a flowchart showing how the snow accumulation detection system according to the fourth embodiment performs snow accumulation analysis and snow removal notification.
[0103] In step S61, the acquisition unit 9 acquires solar radiation forecast data and snowfall forecast data as weather forecast data. In this flowchart, the acquisition unit 9 acquires these data from a weather information distribution server (not shown) that provides a weather information distribution service on the Internet. In step S62, the first calculation unit 10 acquires the second snow covering rate from the memory unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. In this example, the first calculation unit 10 acquires the second snow covering rate corresponding to a past snowfall amount equivalent to the snowfall amount predicted from the snowfall amount forecast data from among the statistical data of the past second snow covering rates.
[0104] In step S63, the first calculation unit 10 calculates a predicted snow covering rate by applying the predicted amount of solar radiation and the predicted amount of contributed solar radiation to the solar radiation shading rate B' (see formula (7)). In step S64, the first calculation unit 10 calculates a predicted power loss by using the predicted snow covering rate as the predicted solar radiation shading rate.
[0105] In step S65, the first calculation unit 10 acquires the electricity selling price from the memory unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. In step S66, the first calculation unit 10 multiplies the predicted power generation loss by the electricity selling price to calculate an increase in the predicted electricity selling income obtained after the snow removal work.
[0106] Steps S67 to S70 will be described as being executed in parallel with steps S64 to S66. These processes may be executed before or after steps S64 to S66. In step S67, the first calculation unit 10 acquires the total area of the solar panels 100 of the solar power plant 1 from the memory unit 17 via the acquisition unit 9. In step S68, the first calculation unit 10 multiplies the predicted snow covering rate by the total area of the solar panels 100 to calculate the predicted total snow area on the solar panels 100.
[0107] In step S69, the first calculation unit 10 acquires the unit snow removal cost via the memory unit 17 and the acquisition unit 9. In step S70, the first calculation unit 10 multiplies the predicted total snow covered area by the unit snow removal cost to calculate the snow removal cost.
[0108] In step S71, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales income calculated in step S66 and the snow removal cost calculated in step S70. In step S72, the determination unit 11 determines whether the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales income and the snow removal cost is equal to or greater than a threshold. If this difference is equal to or greater than the threshold in step S72, the transmission unit 12 transmits a snow removal notification to the monitoring system 7 as a result of the snow accumulation analysis in step S73. If the difference is not equal to or greater than the threshold in step S72, the transmission unit 12 does not transmit a snow removal notification, etc., and ends the process.
[0109] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales income and the snow removal cost in the fourth embodiment.
[0110] In FIG. 11, the horizontal axis represents time (t) and the vertical axis represents cost (yen). The solid line in the figure is a graph showing the increase in the predicted power sales income, and the dashed line in the figure is a graph showing the snow removal cost. This figure shows that the amount of snow on the solar panel 100 increases with time, and the increase in the predicted power sales income increases. It also shows that the amount of snow on the solar panel 100 increases with time, and the snow removal cost increases. In this embodiment, the determination unit 11 of the snow detection system 6 determines that snow removal work is necessary when the difference between the increase in the predicted power sales income and the snow removal cost is equal to or greater than a threshold value.
[0111] According to this embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the predicted snow covering rate based on the second snow covering rate. This allows the snow detection system 6 to calculate the snow covering rate for future snowfall on the solar panel 100, which can be useful for snow removal planning.
[0112] According to the present embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the increase in the predicted value of the electricity sales income obtained after the snow removal work based on the predicted snow accumulation covering rate. This allows the operator to create a snow removal plan taking into account the increase in the predicted value of the electricity sales income.
[0113] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the snow removal cost for all the solar panels 100 in the solar power plant 1 based on the predicted snow covering rate. This allows the operator to create a snow removal plan taking the snow removal cost into consideration.
[0114] According to this embodiment, the first calculation unit 10 calculates the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales income and the snow removal cost, and then the determination unit 11 determines whether this difference is equal to or greater than a threshold. This allows the operator to know the appropriate timing for snow removal work by the snow accumulation detection system 6, which can be useful for planning snow removal.
[0115] Fifth embodiment FIG. 12 is a hardware configuration diagram of a snow accumulation detection system according to the fifth embodiment.
[0116] 12 includes a processor 52 such as a CPU, a main memory device 53 such as a RAM, an auxiliary memory device 54 such as a HDD, a network interface 55 such as a LAN (Local Area Network) board, a device interface 56 such as a memory slot or memory port, and a bus 57 that connects these devices to each other. The snow detection system 6 is, for example, a computer such as a PC, and includes input devices such as a keyboard and a mouse, and an output device such as an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display) monitor.
[0117] In this embodiment, a program for causing a computer to execute information processing of the snow accumulation detection system 6 is installed in the auxiliary storage device 54. The snow accumulation detection system 6 deploys this program in the main storage device 53 and executes it by the processor 52. This realizes the functions of each block shown in FIG. 3 within the snow accumulation detection system 6, making it possible to perform the snow accumulation analysis and the like described in the first embodiment. Note that data generated by this information processing is temporarily held in the main storage device 53, or is stored and saved in the auxiliary storage device 54.
[0118] This program can be installed, for example, by attaching an external device 58 on which this program is recorded to the device interface 56 and storing this program from the external device 58 in the auxiliary storage device 54. Examples of the external device 58 are a computer-readable recording medium and a recording device incorporating such a recording medium. Examples of the recording medium are a CD-ROM (Compact Disk Read Only Memory), a CD-R (Compact Disk Recordable), a flexible disk, a DVD-ROM (Digital Versatile Disk Read Only Memory), and a DVD-R (Digital Versatile Disk Recordable), and an example of the recording device is a HDD. Also, this program can be installed, for example, by downloading this program via the network interface 55.
[0119] According to this embodiment, the functions of the snow accumulation detection system 6 in the first embodiment can be realized by software.
[0120] Although several embodiments have been described above, these embodiments are presented only as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. The novel snow detection system 6 described in this specification can be embodied in various other forms. In addition, various omissions, substitutions, and modifications can be made to the form of the snow detection system 6 described in this specification without departing from the gist of the invention. The appended claims and their equivalents are intended to include such forms and modifications that fall within the scope and gist of the invention. [Explanation of symbols]
[0121] 1: Solar power plant, 2: Surveillance camera, 3: Shooting range, 5: External system, 6: Snow accumulation detection system, 7: Monitoring system, 9: Acquisition unit, 10: First calculation unit, 11: Determination unit, 12: Transmission unit, 13: Display unit, 14: Second calculation unit, 15: storage unit, 16: storage unit, 17: storage unit, 20: network device, 52: processor, 53: main memory device, 54: auxiliary memory device, 55: network interface, 56: device interface, 57: Bus, 58: External equipment, 100: Solar panel, 400: Building, 500: String configuration, 600: Management station, 700: Array configuration
Claims
1. An acquisition unit that acquires a first snow covering rate, which is a ratio of an area of snow on the solar panel to an area of the solar panel, and meteorological data related to snow accumulation conditions; A first calculation unit that performs snow accumulation analysis and weather analysis based on the meteorological data; and a determination unit that determines whether or not snow removal work is required based on the first snow covering rate and the results of the snow analysis and the meteorological analysis. Snow detection system.
2. The first calculation unit analyzes whether snow accumulation on the solar panel will continue for a predetermined time or more, or whether an air temperature will continue to be equal to or lower than 0° C., based on the snow accumulation analysis and the weather analysis. The snow accumulation detection system of claim 1, wherein the determination unit determines that the first snow accumulation covering rate is a correct value when snow accumulation on the solar panel continues for a predetermined period of time or when the air temperature continues to be below 0°C, and determines whether or not snow removal work is necessary.
3. The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 1 , further comprising a transmission unit that outputs the result of the determination of the necessity of snow removal work to a display unit.
4. The acquisition unit further acquires actual solar radiation data, actual power generation data, and power plant design data in the photovoltaic power plant, The first calculation unit is Further calculating a second snow covering rate, which is a ratio of an area of snow on the solar panels to an area of the solar panels in the entire solar power plant, based on the actual solar radiation data, the actual power generation data, and the power plant design data; The determination unit is The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 1 , further comprising a step of determining whether or not the snow removal operation is required based on the second snow accumulation covering rate and the results of the snow accumulation analysis and the meteorological analysis.
5. The first calculation unit is Calculate a solar radiation shading rate B, which is the ratio of the amount of solar radiation blocked by snow on the solar panel to the amount of solar radiation contributed to the solar panel if the solar panel were not covered with snow, based on the actual solar radiation data, contributed solar radiation data, which is the amount of solar radiation contributed to the actual power generation amount, and a shadow ratio, which is the ratio of the area of the shadow on the solar panel to the area of the solar panel; Calculating a correction coefficient K based on the first snow covering rate and the solar radiation shading rate B; The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 4 , wherein the second snow accumulation covering rate is calculated by multiplying the first snow accumulation covering rate by the correction coefficient K.
6. A second calculation unit is further provided for calculating an actual PR value which is an actual system performance coefficient, a theoretical PR value which is a theoretical system performance coefficient, or a virtual PR value which is a virtual system performance coefficient, The second calculation unit is Calculating the actual PR value based on the actual power generation amount data, the solar panel capacity data of the solar panel, and the actual solar radiation data; Calculating the theoretical PR value based on the solar panel capacity data and the actual solar radiation data, or Calculating the virtual PR value based on the second snow covering rate, the solar panel capacity data, and the actual solar radiation data. The snow accumulation detection system of claim 4.
7. The second calculation unit is The actual solar radiation data is input into a PR calculation model, and theoretical power generation data, which is a theoretical power generation amount that does not take into account snow accumulation on the solar panel, is calculated. Calculating the theoretical PR value based on the theoretical power generation data, the solar panel capacity data, and the actual solar radiation data. The snow accumulation detection system of claim 6.
8. The second calculation unit is The actual solar radiation data and the second snow covering rate are input into a PR calculation model, and virtual power generation amount data, which is a virtual power generation amount taking into account snow and shadows existing on the solar panel, is calculated; Calculating the virtual PR value based on the virtual power generation amount data, the solar panel capacity data, and the actual solar radiation amount data. The snow accumulation detection system of claim 6.
9. The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 6 , further comprising a transmission unit that outputs the actual PR value, the theoretical PR value, or the virtual PR value to a display unit.
10. The first calculation unit is Further calculate a predicted snow covering rate, which is the ratio of the area of snow predicted to accumulate on the solar panel to the area of the solar panel, calculated based on the solar radiation prediction data, the snow amount prediction data, and the second snow covering rate, taking into account the shadow that will be cast on the solar panel; Further calculating a predicted power loss amount, which is the amount of power generation lost due to snow predicted to accumulate on the solar panel, based on the predicted snow covering rate; or Further calculating a predicted total snow cover area based on the predicted snow cover rate and the total panel area of the solar panel; The snow accumulation detection system of claim 4.
11. The first calculation unit is Further calculating an increase in a predicted amount of revenue from selling electricity obtained after the snow removal work on the solar panel by multiplying the predicted amount of power loss by a selling price of electricity, or The cost of removing snow from the solar panels is further calculated by multiplying the predicted total snow area by a unit cost of removing snow. The snow accumulation detection system of claim 10.
12. The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 11 , wherein the determination unit determines whether or not the snow removal work is necessary based on a difference between an increase in the predicted value of the electricity selling income and the snow removal cost.
13. The snow accumulation detection system according to claim 12 , wherein the determination unit determines that the snow removal work is necessary when the difference between the increase in the predicted electricity sales revenue and the snow removal cost is equal to or greater than a threshold value.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
System for compensation for generated output of photovoltaic generation
JP2005275491A
Controller and method of controlling snow melting apparatus, photovoltaic power generation system, and control program
JP2017163632A
Snow coverage detection device and snow coverage detection system
JP2017191044A
