Autonomic nerve evaluation device, autonomic nerve evaluation method, and program

The autonomic nerve evaluation device uses age-adjusted deviation values of ccvHF and ccvLF to provide age-independent, rapid assessments of parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve functions, addressing the age-dependence of existing evaluation methods.

JP7579601B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-08FATIGUE SCI LAB
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023056307
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-06-15
Filing Date
2023-03-30
Publication Date
2024-11-08
Estimated Expiration
2043-03-30

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating autonomic nervous system function are age-dependent, making it difficult to use parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve indices as common indicators across subjects of different ages.

Method used

An autonomic nerve evaluation device that calculates deviation values of ccvHF and ccvLF using heart rate data and age-specific distribution data, allowing for age-independent evaluation of parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve functions through the Lorentz plot method, reducing measurement time from minutes to seconds.

Benefits of technology

Enables the use of parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve indices as common indicators across different age groups, providing rapid and reliable assessments of autonomic nervous system function in a shorter time frame.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007579601000022
    Figure 0007579601000022
  • Figure 0007579601000023
    Figure 0007579601000023
  • Figure 0007579601000024
    Figure 0007579601000024
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a technology that enables an indicator related to a parasympathetic nerve or an indicator related to a sympathetic nerve to be used as an indicator common to subjects.SOLUTION: Provided is an autonomous nerve evaluation device including: an acquisition unit that acquires age of a subject to be evaluated and heartrate data of the subject; a storage unit that stores distribution data indicating distribution of ccvHF or ccvLF for each age; and a calculation unit that calculates an HF value or an LF value of the subject on the basis of the heartrate data of the subject, calculates ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject by using the HF value or the LF value of the subject and the heartrate data of the subject, and calculates a deviation value of ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject by using calculated ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject, the age of the subject, and the distribution data.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 4
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to an autonomic nerve evaluation device, an autonomic nerve evaluation method, and a program. [Background technology]

[0002] Functional analysis of the autonomic nervous system has been attracting attention as an index for objectively evaluating fatigue. The autonomic nervous system consists of the sympathetic nervous system, which mainly works when awake or tense, and the parasympathetic nervous system, which mainly works when asleep or relaxed, and it is known that the two nerves function in balance to regulate physiological functions. For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a device for determining the autonomic nervous state of a vehicle occupant. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] Patent Publication No. 2022-23702 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] It is possible to evaluate the subject's state of relaxation by using the index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject. It is also possible to evaluate the subject's state of stress and concentration by using the index related to the sympathetic nerves of the subject. However, the normal values ​​of the index related to the parasympathetic nerves and the index related to the sympathetic nerves of the subject differ depending on the age of the subject, and therefore they cannot be used as common indexes for multiple subjects.

[0005] Therefore, an object of the present invention is to provide a technique that enables a parasympathetic nerve index or a sympathetic nerve index to be used as a common index for subjects. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] An autonomic nerve evaluation device according to one embodiment of the present invention includes an acquisition unit that acquires the age of a subject to be evaluated and heart rate data of the subject, a storage unit that stores distribution data showing the distribution of ccvHF or ccvLF by age, and a calculation unit that calculates an HF value or LF value of the subject based on the heart rate data of the subject, calculates the ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject using the HF value or LF value of the subject and the heart rate data of the subject, and calculates a standard deviation of the ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject using the calculated ccvHF or ccvLF of the subject, the subject's age, and the distribution data. Effect of the Invention

[0007] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a technique that enables a parasympathetic nerve-related index or a sympathetic nerve-related index to be used as a common index for subjects. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0008] [Figure 1] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of an evaluation device according to the present embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 shows the relationship between ccvTP and age. [Diagram 3] FIG. 1 shows the results of investigating the relationship between age and LF value and the relationship between age and HF value. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a functional block configuration of an evaluation device. [Diagram 5] 13 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure by which the evaluation device quickly evaluates autonomic nerve function. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a diagram for explaining a method for calculating a subject's total power by the Lorenz plot method. [Figure 7] FIG. 1 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age and TP. [Figure 8] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age and TP. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. [Figure 10] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. [Figure 11] FIG. 1 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age and TP. [Figure 12] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age and TP. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. [Figure 14] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. [Figure 15] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the correlation of LP.S. [Figure 16] 13 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure for the evaluation device to evaluate the parasympathetic nerves. [Figure 17] 13 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure for the evaluation device to evaluate the sympathetic nerves. [Figure 18] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between HFs. [Figure 19] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between HFs. [Figure 20] FIG. 1 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age and HF. [Figure 21] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age and HF. [Figure 22] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between HF and LP.S. [Figure 23] FIG. 1 shows the correlation between HF and LP.S. [Figure 24] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the results of a comparison between the proportion of HF in TP and the fatigue level of subjects. [Diagram 25] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a screen for outputting the measurement results of a subject. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0009] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS The present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which the same reference numerals denote the same or similar configurations.

[0010] <System configuration> 1 is a diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of an evaluation device 10 according to this embodiment. The evaluation device 10 (autonomic nerve evaluation device) includes a processor 11 such as a CPU (Central Processing Unit) or a GPU (Graphical Processing Unit), a storage device 12 such as a memory, an HDD (Hard Disk Drive) and / or an SSD (Solid State Drive), an input device 13, an output device 14, and a biological information acquisition device 15. The evaluation device 10 may be dedicated hardware or general-purpose hardware such as a personal computer.

[0011] The input device 13 is a device for inputting data related to the subject, and is configured, for example, with a keyboard, an operation button, or an input interface on a touch panel. In this embodiment, at least the subject's age is input to the input device 13 as data related to the subject. In addition to the subject's age, the subject's name, address, sex, etc. may also be input.

[0012] The output device 14 is a device for outputting information, and is, for example, a display, an LED, a touch panel, a printer, and / or a speaker.

[0013] The bioinformation acquisition device 15 is a device for collecting bioinformation data of a subject. The bioinformation data of a subject is either heartbeat data or pulse data. The bioinformation acquisition device 15 may be an electrocardiograph or a pulse meter. The evaluation device 10 may receive, via the input device 13, input of heartbeat data or pulse data measured by an external electrocardiograph or pulse meter. In this case, the evaluation device 10 may not be equipped with the bioinformation acquisition device 15. In the following description, the bioinformation data is assumed to be heartbeat data.

[0014] The LF (Low Frequency) value, which is an index showing the activity of the sympathetic nerves, and the HF (High Frequency) value, which is an index showing the activity of the parasympathetic nerves, can be obtained by frequency analysis of biological information data. A known analysis method can be used for the frequency analysis (time-frequency analysis), and examples of such methods include the maximum entropy method (MEM (Maximum Entropy Model) method), the fast Fourier transform method (FFT (Fast Fourier Transform) method), and the wavelet method. Among these, it is preferable to use the maximum entropy method. According to the maximum entropy method, an analysis with high time resolution can be performed. For example, the RR interval of the heartbeat data can be separated into low frequency components (LF: 0.04-0.15 Hz) and high frequency components (HF: 0.15-0.40 Hz) in the frequency domain using the maximum entropy method, and the sum of the power of the low frequency components and the high frequency components can be calculated as the LF value and the HF value, respectively.

[0015] Specifically, the LF value and the HF value can be calculated, for example, by the following Equations 1, 2, and 3.

number

number

number

[0016] The sum of the LF and HF values ​​(LF+HF) is an index showing the overall function of the autonomic nervous system and is called TP (Total Power). TP is also called "autonomic nervous activity" or "total autonomic nervous activity."

[0017] ccvTP (Coefficient of Component Variance TP) is a value calculated by correcting TP with the heart rate (more specifically, the average of the RR interval) during the time used to measure the LF value and the HF value. Like TP, ccvTP is also called "autonomic nerve activity" or "total autonomic nerve activity." Specifically, ccvTP can be calculated by the following formula 4.

number

[0018] Since it is known from experiments that TP is low when the heart rate is high, the autonomic nerve activity can be appropriately expressed regardless of the subject's heart rate by using ccvTP corrected according to the heart rate. Note that the inventors have clarified that the {LF+HF} value decreases with age, and the same is true for ccvTP.

[0019] As described later, the evaluation device 10 calculates the ccvHF by correcting the HF value with the heart rate (more specifically, the average of the RR intervals) within the time used for measuring the HF value. The HF value and ccvHF may be called an index related to the parasympathetic nerves, an index indicating the function of the parasympathetic nerves, a parasympathetic nerve activity amount, a parasympathetic nerve activity index, and a comfort level, etc. Furthermore, the HF value and ccvHF may be called a first index related to the parasympathetic nerves and a second index related to the parasympathetic nerves, etc., respectively. Furthermore, the evaluation device 10 calculates the ccvLF by correcting the LF value with the heart rate (more specifically, the average of the RR intervals) within the time used for measuring the LF value. The LF value and ccvLF may be called an index related to the sympathetic nerves, an index indicating the function of the sympathetic nerves, a sympathetic nerve activity index, and a sympathetic nerve activity amount, etc. Furthermore, the LF value and ccvLF may be called a first index related to the sympathetic nerves and a second index related to the sympathetic nerves, etc., respectively.

[0020] FIG. 2 shows the relationship between ccvTP and age. Curve G1 shows the boundary line where the top 25% of subjects with high ccvTP belong among subjects of the same age. Curve G2 shows the median ccvTP among subjects of the same age. Curve G3 shows the boundary line where the bottom 75% of subjects with low ccvTP belong among subjects of the same age. FIG. 2 shows that ccvTP decreases with age.

[0021] (Rapid assessment of autonomic nervous function) Currently, when evaluating a subject's autonomic nervous function, in order to obtain reliable evaluation results, it is common to measure the subject's heart rate continuously for 120 seconds and then perform frequency analysis using the maximum entropy method on the heart rate data obtained.

[0022] It is also known that when TP is analyzed using heart rate data obtained by continuously measuring a subject for 60 seconds, the correlation coefficient with TP obtained from heart rate data for 120 seconds is about 0.7. Therefore, when the same subject is repeatedly measured, the state of the subject's autonomic nerves is understood by analyzing TP using heart rate data for 60 seconds from the second measurement onwards.

[0023] In the maximum entropy method, in order to calculate LF, heart rate data measured for at least 25 seconds is required. This is because LF values ​​are low frequency components of 0.04 to 0.15 Hz, and therefore, one wavelength data cannot be obtained unless measurement is performed for at least 25 seconds. In addition, since measurement accuracy is insufficient with only one wavelength data, as described above, it is considered preferable to perform measurement for at least 120 seconds.

[0024] Here, when evaluating autonomic nervous function in a hospital or a testing center, there is no particular problem in measuring the subject for 120 seconds. However, evaluation of autonomic nervous function is used not only in hospitals and testing centers, but also in various places such as daily pre-employment tests for taxi drivers and truck drivers. Repeated daily measurements of heart rate data while remaining still for 120 seconds or 60 seconds are stressful for the subject, and therefore a method that can measure in a shorter time is desired.

[0025] The inventors have considered a method for measuring autonomic nerve function in a shorter time and have come to the conclusion that by using the Lorenz plot method instead of the maximum entropy method, TP can be calculated with high accuracy if there is about 7 seconds of heart rate data. Therefore, the evaluation device 10 according to this embodiment calculates TP using the Lorenz plot method instead of the maximum entropy method, making it possible to evaluate the autonomic nerve function of a subject in a shorter time than before.

[0026] (Evaluation of parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous systems) TP, which is an index showing the overall activity of the autonomic nervous system, changes with age. Therefore, in order to evaluate subjects of various ages in the same way, a common index that is not affected by the age of the subject is necessary. Therefore, the inventors decided to use the standard deviation of TP as a common index for the overall activity of the autonomic nervous system. Here, as described above, autonomic nervous activity is evaluated from two components, LF (0.04-0.15 Hz component) which mainly represents the activity of the sympathetic nervous system, and HF (0.15-0.40 Hz component) which mainly represents the activity of the parasympathetic nervous system. However, it has not been clear how each component changes with age, and there have been no reports of evaluating subjects by converting HF into a standard deviation.

[0027] Figure 3 shows the results of the inventors' investigation into the relationship between age and LF value and the relationship between age and HF value for 264 people aged 18 to 73. As shown in Figure 3, logLF shows a significant negative correlation with age (r=-0.524, p<0.001), and logHF shows a significant negative correlation with age (r=-0.423, p<0.001). In other words, it has been confirmed that health evaluation cannot be performed using LF and HF values ​​as they are when subjects are of different ages.

[0028] Therefore, in this embodiment, by clarifying the changes in HF and LF with age, HF and LF are converted into standard deviations, and by using the HF standard deviation and LF standard deviation, which are objective health indicators that exclude the age factor, it is possible to commonly evaluate the parasympathetic nervous function or sympathetic nervous function across subjects.

[0029] Here, when calculating the HF value using the maximum entropy method, since the HF value is a high frequency component of 0.15 to 0.40 Hz, one wavelength data can be obtained with about 6.6 seconds of heartbeat data. That is, the HF value can obtain a reliable measurement result in a shorter measurement time than the LF value, which requires 25 seconds to measure one wavelength. In consideration of this point, the inventors verified the correlation between the HF value obtained from 90 seconds of heartbeat data and the HF value obtained from about 10 seconds of heartbeat data, and found that these HF values ​​have a high correlation. Therefore, the evaluation device 10 according to this embodiment makes it possible to evaluate the parasympathetic nerve activity of the subject in a shorter measurement time than before by calculating the HF in a shorter measurement time than before.

[0030] The evaluation device 10 according to this embodiment may have only one of the functions for realizing "rapid evaluation of autonomic nervous function" and the functions for realizing "evaluation of parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous functions", or may have both.

[0031] <Function block configuration> FIG. 4 is a diagram showing an example of a functional block configuration of the evaluation device 10. The evaluation device 10 includes a storage unit 100, an acquisition unit 101, a calculation unit 102, and an output unit 103. The storage unit 100 can be realized by using a storage device 12 included in the evaluation device 10. The acquisition unit 101, the calculation unit 102, and the output unit 103 can be realized by the processor 11 of the evaluation device 10 executing a program stored in the storage device 12. The program can be stored in a storage medium. The storage medium storing the program may be a non-transitory computer readable medium. The non-transitory storage medium is not particularly limited, and may be, for example, a storage medium such as a USB memory or a CD-ROM.

[0032] The memory unit 100 stores distribution data (ccvTP) 100a showing the distribution of ccvTP (autonomic nerve activity) by age of the subject, distribution data (ccvHF) 100b showing the distribution of ccvHF values, which are an index of parasympathetic nerve activity, by age, and distribution data (ccvLF) 100c showing the distribution of ccvLF, which is an index of parasympathetic nerve activity, by age.

[0033] The distribution data (ccvTP) 100a is obtained by collecting ccvTP from many subjects of different ages and statistically analyzing them. For example, in this embodiment, the average value of ccvTP for each age of the subjects and the standard deviation (σ) of ccvTP for each age of the subjects are calculated from the ccvTP of many subjects of different ages collected in advance, and these may be stored in the storage unit 100 as the distribution data (ccvTP) 100a in a database.

[0034] The distribution data (ccvHF) 100b is obtained by collecting ccvHF from many subjects of different ages and statistically analyzing them. For example, in this embodiment, the average value of the ccvHF for each age of the subject and the standard deviation (σ) of the ccvHF for each age of the subject may be calculated from the ccvHF of many subjects of different ages collected in advance, and these may be stored in the storage unit 100 as the distribution data (ccvHF) 100b in a database.

[0035] The distribution data (ccvLF) 100c is obtained by collecting ccvLF from many subjects of different ages and statistically analyzing them. For example, in this embodiment, the average value of the ccvLF for each age of the subject and the standard deviation (σ) of the ccvLF for each age of the subject may be calculated from the ccvLF of many subjects of different ages collected in advance, and these may be stored in the storage unit 100 as the distribution data (ccvLF) 100c in a database.

[0036] The acquiring unit 101 acquires heart rate data and / or the age of a subject to be evaluated.

[0037] The calculation unit 102 calculates the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP (autonomic nerve activity) from the subject's heart rate data by using the Lorenz plot method. More specifically, the calculation unit 102 calculates TP, which is an index showing the overall function of the subject's autonomic nerves, from the subject's heart rate data based on the Lorenz plot method. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the subject's ccvTP (autonomic nerve activity) using the subject's TP and the subject's heart rate data, and calculates the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP using the distribution data (ccvTP) 100a and the subject's ccvTP.

[0038] The calculation unit 102 also calculates the HF value of the subject based on the heart rate data of the subject. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the ccvHF of the subject using the HF value of the subject and the heart rate data of the subject, and calculates the standard deviation of the ccvHF value of the subject using the calculated ccvHF value of the subject and the age and distribution data (ccvHF) 100b of the subject.

[0039] The calculation unit 102 may also calculate the HF value of the subject by frequency analyzing the subject's heart rate data, and calculate the subject's ccvHF and a deviation value of the subject's ccvHF from the calculated HF value of the subject. More specifically, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the subject's HF value by frequency analyzing the subject's heart rate data, calculate the subject's ccvHF using the calculated HF value and the subject's heart rate data, and calculate the deviation value of the subject's ccvHF value using the calculated ccvHF value of the subject and the subject's age and distribution data (ccvHF) 100b.

[0040] The calculation unit 102 may also use the Lorenz plot method to calculate the HF value of the subject from the heart rate data of the subject, and calculate the ccvHF of the subject and the deviation value of the ccvHF of the subject from the calculated HF value of the subject. More specifically, the calculation unit 102 may use the Lorenz plot method to calculate the HF value of the subject from the heart rate data of the subject, calculate the ccvHF of the subject using the calculated HF value and the heart rate data of the subject, and calculate the deviation value of the ccvHF value of the subject using the calculated ccvHF value of the subject and the age and distribution data (ccvHF) 100b of the subject.

[0041] The calculation unit 102 also calculates the LF value of the subject based on the heart rate data of the subject. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the LF value of the subject by performing frequency analysis on the heart rate data of the subject. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the ccvLF of the subject using the LF value of the subject and the heart rate data of the subject, and calculates the standard deviation of the ccvLF value of the subject using the calculated ccvLF value of the subject and the age and distribution data (ccvLF) 100c of the subject.

[0042] The calculation unit 102 may also use the Lorenz plot method to calculate the subject's TP (autonomic nerve activity) from the subject's heart rate data, and calculate the ratio of the subject's HF value to the subject's TP (i.e., HF / TP). Alternatively, the calculation unit 102 may use the Lorenz plot method to calculate the subject's ccvTP (autonomic nerve activity) from the subject's heart rate data, and calculate the ratio of the subject's ccvHF to the subject's ccvTP (i.e., ccvHF / ccvTP).

[0043] The output unit 103 outputs various data related to the subject's autonomic nerves calculated by the calculation unit 102 to a screen, paper, or the like. For example, the output unit 103 outputs the standard deviation of the subject's TP and / or ccvTP. The output unit 103 also outputs the standard deviation of the subject's ccvHF. The output unit 103 may also output the standard deviation of the subject's ccvHF and the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP (autonomic nerve activity) side by side. The output unit 103 also outputs the standard deviation of the subject's ccvLF. The output unit 103 may also output the standard deviation of the subject's ccvLF and the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP side by side. The output unit 103 may also output the standard deviation of the subject's ccvLF, the standard deviation of the subject's ccvHF, and the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP side by side. The output unit 103 may also output the standard deviation of the subject's ccvLF, the standard deviation of the subject's ccvHF, and the standard deviation of the subject's ccvTP side by side. The output unit 103 may also output the ratio of the subject's HF value to the subject's TP calculated by the calculation unit 102. Alternatively, the output unit 103 may output the ratio of the subject's ccvHF to the subject's ccvTP calculated by the calculation unit 102.

[0044] <Processing Procedure> (Rapid assessment of autonomic nervous function) FIG. 5 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure for the evaluation device 10 to quickly evaluate an autonomic nerve function.

[0045] In step S11, the acquisition unit 101 acquires the age and heart rate data of the subject.

[0046] In step S12, the calculation unit 102 calculates the TP of the subject using the Lorenz plot method.

[0047] 6 is a diagram for explaining a method for calculating the TP of a subject by the Lorenz plot method. The calculation unit 102 calculates the TP of the subject according to steps 1 to 4 below.

[0048] "Step 1": The calculation unit 102 calculates the n-th RR interval (hereinafter, "RRI") of the heart rate data of the subject from the heart rate data. n ) on the horizontal axis, and the nth and the consecutive n+1th (hereafter, (RRIn+1 That is, the calculation unit 102 calculates a point (x, y)=(RRI n , R.R.I. n+1 ) on the graph. For example, in 10 seconds of heart rate data, if the first RR interval is 1000 ms, the second RR interval is 900 ms, the third RR interval is 950 ms, and the fourth RR interval is 1050 ms, the calculation unit 102 plots, for example, points (1000, 900), (900, 950), and (950, 1050) on the graph.

[0049] "Step 2": The calculation unit 102 projects all the points plotted on the graph onto the y=x axis and the y=-x axis. For example, when point (1000, 900) is projected onto the y=x axis, the point is projected onto a position (any position on line A) where a perpendicular line is drawn from the coordinates (1000, 900) to the y=x axis. Similarly, when point (1000, 900) is projected onto the y=-x axis, the point is projected onto a position (any position on line B) where a perpendicular line is drawn from the coordinates (1000, 900) to the y=-x axis.

[0050] "Step 3": The calculation unit 102 calculates the average (LP.m) of the distance from the origin (0,0) to each point projected onto the y=x axis. Next, the calculation unit 102 calculates the standard deviation σx of the distance from the origin (0,0) to each point projected onto the y=x axis, and the standard deviation σ-x of the distance from the origin (0,0) to each point projected onto the y=-x axis.

[0051] "Step 4": The calculation unit 102 calculates the area (LP.S) of an ellipse M whose major axis is a predetermined coefficient (D) × σx and whose minor axis is a predetermined coefficient (D) × σ-x using the following formula 5. The smaller the area (LP.S) of the ellipse M, the smaller the fluctuation of the RR interval. Note that the predetermined coefficient (D) may be any value as long as it is a positive integer. For example, it may be 2 or 3. In the example of FIG. 6, an ellipse when the predetermined coefficient (D) = 2 is illustrated.

number

number

[0052] Regarding the above-described steps 1 to 5, the calculation unit 102 may consider data outside the ellipse M in FIG. 6 to be noise, remove the points that are noise, and then calculate the area (LP.S) of the ellipse M again. Specifically, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the area (LP.S) of the ellipse M by executing steps 1 to 4, remove the points that are outside the ellipse M among the points plotted on the graph, and calculate the area (LP.S) of the ellipse M after the noise removal by executing steps 1 to 4 again. Furthermore, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the total power of the subject by using the area (LP.S) of the ellipse M after the noise removal in step 5. In other words, the calculation unit 102 may perform the following processing. 1. Two consecutive RR intervals among the RR intervals of the heart rate data are plotted as points x and y on a graph with one axis as the x-axis and the other as the y-axis. 2. Calculate the first ellipse with the major axis being the first standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin (0,0) and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and the minor axis being the second standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 3. For points among the points plotted on the graph that are inside ellipse M, a second ellipse is calculated whose major axis is the third standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and whose minor axis is the fourth standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = -y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 4. The area of ​​the second ellipse is substituted into a specified formula (Formula 6) to estimate (calculate) the subject's TP.

[0053] 5, in step S13, the calculation unit 102 calculates the ccvTP of the subject using the TP of the subject calculated in step S12 and the subject's heart rate data. In addition, the calculation unit 102 calculates the standard deviation of the ccvTP of the subject using the ccvTP of the subject and distribution data (ccvTP) 100a. For example, the calculation unit 102 can calculate the standard deviation of the ccvTP of the subject by the following procedure. 1. Calculate the subject's ccvTP by correcting the TP calculated in step S12 with the subject's heart rate according to Equation 4. 2. From the distribution data (ccvTP) 100a, obtain the mean value and standard deviation (σ) of ccvTP corresponding to the subject's age. 3. Calculate the deviation value of the subject's ccvTP using the formula: "Deviation value of ccvTP = 10 × (subject's ccvTP - average value of ccvTP corresponding to subject's age) ÷ standard deviation of ccvTP corresponding to subject's age (σ) + 50."

[0054] (Variation 1 of the Rapid Assessment of Autonomic Function) In the method for evaluating autonomic nervous function described above, logarithmically transformed LP.S (hereinafter referred to as "logLP.S") and LP.m (hereinafter referred to as "logLP.m") may be used to estimate logarithmically transformed TP (hereinafter referred to as "logTP").

[0055] Specifically, in "Step 5" of the above-described processing procedure, logTP may be estimated by using the following formula 7 instead of formula 6. Note that the logarithm may be a common logarithm.

number

[0056] Furthermore, the calculation unit 102 may calculate an estimated TP (that is, TP before logarithmic transformation) from the estimated logTP, and execute the processing procedure of step S13 using the calculated estimated TP.

[0057] The noise removal process described in "(Rapid evaluation of autonomic nerve function)" may also be applied to this modification 1. That is, the calculation unit 102 may perform the following process. 1. Plot two consecutive intervals of heart rate data, designated x and y, on a graph with one axis as the x-axis and the other as the y-axis. 2. Calculate the first ellipse with the major axis being the first standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin (0,0) and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and the minor axis being the second standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 3. For points among the points plotted on the graph that are inside ellipse M, a second ellipse is calculated whose major axis is the third standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and whose minor axis is the fourth standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = -y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 4. The area of ​​the second ellipse is substituted into a specified formula (Formula 7) to estimate (calculate) the subject's logTF.

[0058] (Variation 2 of the Rapid Assessment of Autonomic Function) In the above-described "Step 1", the calculation unit 102 calculates a point (x, y)=(RRI n , R.R.I. n+1 ) on the graph, but points consisting of two non-consecutive RR intervals may be plotted on the graph. That is, the calculation unit 102 may plot a plurality of points, each of which represents two non-consecutive RR intervals among the RR intervals of the heartbeat data as x and y, on a graph with one axis as the x-axis and the other axis as the y-axis.

[0059] Specifically, in "Step 1", the calculation unit 102 calculates, from the heart rate data of the subject, the nth RR interval of the heart rate data as the horizontal axis, and the n+αth RR interval (hereinafter, (RRIn+α ), where α is an integer equal to or greater than 2) on the vertical axis. That is, the calculation unit 102 may calculate a point (x, y)=(RRI n , R.R.I. n+α ) may be plotted on a graph. The value of α may be an integer equal to or greater than 2, and may be, for example, α=4, 5, or 6 or greater.

[0060] Here, the n-th RR interval is expressed as RRI(n). When α=2, the calculation unit 102 may plot, for example, points (RRI(1), RRI(3)), (RRI(2), RRI(4)), and (RRI(3), RRI(5)) on the graph. When α=3, the calculation unit 102 may plot, for example, points (RRI(1), RRI(4)), (RRI(2), RRI(5)), and (RRI(3), RRI(6)) on the graph.

[0061] The value of α may be changed by any value equal to or greater than 1. The any value may be, for example, a value determined to skip heart rate data during a period in which heart rate data is not measured correctly. That is, the calculation unit 102 may plot a plurality of points, each of which is x and y, where the number of RR intervals between the two non-consecutive RR intervals is different, on a graph with one axis being the x-axis and the other axis being the y-axis. The value of α may be changed randomly.

[0062] Here, when the value of α is arbitrarily changed, the calculation unit 102 may plot, for example, points (RRI(1), RRI(2)), (RRI(2), RRI(4)), (RRI(3), RRI(6)), (RRI(4), RRI(5)), (RRI(5), RRI(7)), and (RRI(6), RRI(7)) on a graph.

[0063] The value of n does not necessarily have to be increased by 1, and may be increased by any value equal to or greater than 1. The any value may be, for example, a value determined to skip heart rate data during a period in which the heart rate is not measured correctly. The value of n may be increased by a random value. For example, the calculation unit 102 may plot points (RRI(1), RRI(2)), (RRI(2), RRI(4)), (RRI(4), RRI(8)), (RRI(5), RRI(6)), (RRI(8), RRI(9)), and (RRI(10), RRI(13)) on a graph.

[0064] Note that the method of estimating logarithmically transformed TP using logarithmically transformed LP.S described in "Variation 1 of rapid evaluation of autonomic nervous function" may be applied to this variation 2. Also, the noise removal process described in "(Rapid evaluation of autonomic nervous function)" may be applied to this variation 2. In this case, the process of "1. Plot points in which two consecutive intervals of the heartbeat data are x and y, respectively, on a graph with one axis being the x-axis and the other axis being the y-axis" in the noise removal process can be replaced with "1. Plot points in which two non-consecutive intervals of the heartbeat data are x and y, respectively, on a graph with one axis being the x-axis and the other axis being the y-axis."

[0065] Conventionally, when heart rate data is acquired at a hospital or an examination center, it is possible to acquire relatively stable data. On the other hand, when heart rate data is acquired at a place other than a hospital or an examination center, such as daily pre-employment examinations for taxi drivers or truck drivers, it is not always possible to acquire stable data, and it is assumed that heart rate data containing a lot of noise must be used. For example, it is assumed that the heart rate data is mixed with noise, and the heart rate data corresponding to the noise cannot be used. According to this modification 2, it is possible to evaluate the autonomic nervous function even in a situation where it is difficult to use continuous heart rate data. In addition, this makes it possible to realize measurement of the autonomic nervous function using a simpler heart rate interval measuring device in various environments (during exercise, working, studying, etc.) that are expected in the future.

[0066] (TP Experimental Results Part 1) In the explanation of "TP Experimental Results 1" and "TP Experimental Results 2" described later, "TPxx" means TP calculated by the maximum entropy method using heart rate data measured continuously for xx seconds. For example, "TP90" means TP calculated by the maximum entropy method using heart rate data measured continuously for 90 seconds. Also, "LP.Sxx" means LP.S (area of ​​an ellipse) calculated by the above-mentioned Lorentz plot method using heart rate data measured continuously for xx seconds. For example, "LP.S10" means LP.S calculated by the Lorentz plot method using heart rate data measured continuously for 10 seconds. Also, "LP.mxx" means LP.m (average distance from the origin) calculated by the above-mentioned Lorentz plot method using heart rate data measured continuously for xx seconds. For example, "LP.m10" means LP.m calculated by the Lorentz plot method using heart rate data measured continuously for 10 seconds.

[0067] FIG. 7 is a diagram showing the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age, and TP. More specifically, FIG. 7 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of 500 subjects with TP90 as the dependent variable and LP.S, LP.m, and age as independent variables. The number of seconds in FIG. 7 indicates the measurement time of the heartbeat data used in the multiple regression analysis. For example, the multiple correlation coefficient in the column where the measurement time of the heartbeat data is 15 seconds is 0.81955, and the degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination is 0.66967. This shows that the result of multiple regression analysis of the heartbeat data obtained by measuring 500 subjects for 15 seconds for TP90, LP.S15, LP.m15, and the age of the subjects was 0.81955, and the degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination was 0.66967.

[0068] According to FIG. 7, the multiple correlation coefficient obtained from the heart rate data with a measurement time of 3 to 11 seconds is 0.49 or more, and further, when the measurement time is 12 seconds or more, the multiple correlation coefficient is 0.8 or more. In addition, the degree of freedom adjusted determination coefficient exceeds 0.5 when the measurement time is 8 seconds or more. Therefore, when the measurement time is 8 seconds or more, it can be said that the mathematical formula 6 is at a level that can be used as an estimation model of TP. In addition, when the measurement time is 4 seconds or more, the multiple correlation coefficient exceeds 0.6, so it can be said that even heart rate data with a measurement time of 4 seconds or more and less than 8 seconds can be used as a simple measurement of the autonomic nerves.

[0069] FIG. 8 is a diagram showing the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age, and TP. Also, FIG. 9 and FIG. 10 are diagrams showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. FIG. 8 to FIG. 10 show the results of measurements on 500 subjects. In FIG. 8 to FIG. 10, the numbers in the upper row are correlation coefficients (r values), and the numbers in the lower row are significance probabilities (p values). According to FIG. 8, it can be seen that LP.S10 and LP.m10 are significantly correlated with TP90. It can also be seen that there is a negative correlation between the subject's age and TP90.

[0070] 9 and 10, it can be seen that LP.S4 to LP.S13 have a correlation coefficient with TP90 of 0.49 or more, and further, LP.S14 to LP.S90 have a correlation coefficient with TP90 of 0.8 or more. In other words, it can be seen that the area of ​​the ellipse calculated by the Lorenz plot method using heart rate data of 4 seconds or more is correlated with TP90 calculated by the maximum entropy method. From these results, it can be seen that by estimating TP using Equation 6 using the Lorenz plot method, it is possible to estimate the TP of the subject even if the measurement time of the heart rate data is short.

[0071] (TP Experimental Results Part 2) Figure 11 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age and TP. More specifically, Figure 11 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of 500 subjects, with TP90 as the dependent variable and LP.S, LP.m and age as independent variables. In Figure 11, logarithmic transformation values ​​were used for LP.S, LP.m and TP.

[0072] The number of seconds in Fig. 11 indicates the measurement time of the heart rate data used in the multiple regression analysis. For example, in the column where the measurement time of the heart rate data is 15 seconds, the multiple correlation coefficient is 0.83456 and the degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination is 0.69466. This shows that the result of multiple regression analysis of the heart rate data obtained by measuring 500 subjects for 15 seconds for TP90, LP.S15, LP.m15, and the subject's age was 0.83456 in multiple correlation coefficient and 0.69466 in degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination.

[0073] According to FIG. 11, the multiple correlation coefficient obtained from the heart rate data with a measurement time of 3 to 8 seconds is 0.67 or more, and further, when the measurement time is 9 seconds or more, the multiple correlation coefficient is 0.8 or more. In addition, the degree of freedom adjusted determination coefficient exceeds 0.5 when the measurement time is 4 seconds or more. Therefore, when the measurement time is 4 seconds or more, it can be said that the mathematical formula 7 is at a level that can be used as an estimation model of TP. In addition, when the measurement time is 3 seconds or more, the multiple correlation coefficient exceeds 0.6, so it can be said that even heart rate data with a measurement time of 3 seconds or more and less than 4 seconds can be used as a simple measurement of the autonomic nerves.

[0074] Fig. 12 is a diagram showing the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age, and TP. Figs. 13 and 14 are diagrams showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. Figs. 12 to 14 show the results of measurements on 500 subjects. In Figs. 12 to 14, the numbers in the upper rows are correlation coefficients (r values), and the numbers in the lower rows are significance probabilities (p values). In Figs. 12 to 14, logarithmic transformed values ​​were used for LP.S, LP.m, and TP.

[0075] 12, it can be seen that LP.S10 and LP.m10 have a significant correlation with TP90. It can also be seen that there is a negative correlation between the subject's age and TP90.

[0076] 13 and 14, it can be seen that LP.S3 to LP.S12 have a correlation coefficient with TP90 of 0.49 or more, and further, LP.S13 to LP.S90 have a correlation coefficient with TP90 of 0.8 or more. In other words, it can be seen that the area of ​​the ellipse calculated by the Lorenz plot method using heart rate data of 3 seconds or more is correlated with TP90 calculated by the maximum entropy method. From these results, it can be seen that by estimating TP using Equation 7 using the Lorenz plot method, it is possible to estimate the TP of the subject even if the measurement time of the heart rate data is short.

[0077] Based on the above-described experimental results 1 and 2, the acquisition unit 101 may acquire the subject's heart rate data by measuring the subject for 3 seconds or more and less than 60 seconds. The calculation unit 102 may calculate (estimate) the subject's TP by the Lorenz plot method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject for 3 seconds or more and less than 60 seconds. This makes it possible to evaluate the subject's autonomic nerve function in a shorter time than before.

[0078] The acquiring unit 101 may acquire the heart rate data of the subject by measuring the subject for 3 seconds or more and less than 25 seconds. The calculating unit 102 may calculate (estimate) the TP of the subject by the Lorenz plot method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject for 3 seconds or more and less than 25 seconds. As described above, when the maximum entropy method is used, a measurement for at least 25 seconds is required to calculate the LP. Therefore, by measuring the subject for less than 25 seconds, it becomes possible to evaluate the autonomic nerve function of the subject in a short time that was previously impossible.

[0079] However, without being limited to the above, the acquiring unit 101 may acquire the heartbeat data of the subject by measuring the subject for N seconds or more and less than M seconds. Furthermore, the calculating unit 102 may calculate (estimate) the TP of the subject by the Lorenz plot method using the heartbeat data acquired by measuring the subject for N seconds or more and less than M seconds. Any time may be set for N and M within a range of 4 seconds to 60 seconds. For example, N and M may be 3 seconds and 15 seconds, or 8 seconds and 60 seconds, respectively. Furthermore, N and M may be 8 seconds and 15 seconds, respectively. Furthermore, N and M may be 4 seconds and 15 seconds, or 4 seconds and 60 seconds, or 4 seconds and 25 seconds, respectively.

[0080] (Experimental results on the area of ​​an ellipse) FIG. 15 is a diagram showing the correlation of LP.S. LP.S(n, n+1) indicates the ellipse area LP.S when points consisting of two consecutive RR intervals are plotted. LP.S(n, n+2) indicates the ellipse area LP.S when points consisting of two non-consecutive RR intervals (when α=2) are plotted. LP.S(n, n+3) indicates the ellipse area LP.S when points consisting of two non-consecutive RR intervals (when α=3) are plotted. LP.S(n, random) indicates the ellipse area LP.S when points consisting of two non-consecutive RR intervals (when α=random) are plotted.

[0081] As shown in A of FIG. 15, it can be seen that there is a significant correlation between the ellipse area LP.S(n, n+1) and the ellipse area LP.S(n, n+2). Also, as shown in B of FIG. 15, it can be seen that there is a significant correlation between the ellipse area LP.S(n, n+1) and the ellipse area LP.S(n, n+3). Also, as shown in C of FIG. 15, it can be seen that there is a significant correlation between the ellipse area LP.S(n, n+1) and the ellipse area LP.S(n, random).

[0082] (Parasympathetic nervous evaluation) FIG. 16 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure performed by the evaluation device 10 to evaluate the parasympathetic nerves.

[0083] In step S21, the acquisition unit 101 acquires the age and heart rate data of the subject.

[0084] In step S22, the calculation unit 102 calculates the HF of the subject using the maximum entropy method.

[0085] In step S23, the calculation unit 102 calculates the ccvHF of the subject using the HF of the subject calculated in step S22 and the heart rate data of the subject. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the standard deviation of the ccvHF of the subject using the ccvHF of the subject and distribution data (ccvHF) 100b. For example, the calculation unit 102 can calculate the standard deviation of the ccvHF of the subject by the following procedure. 1. According to Equation 8, the HF calculated in step S22 is corrected by the subject's heart rate (more specifically, the average of the RR intervals) to calculate the subject's ccvHF.

number

[0086] In step S24, the calculation unit 102 calculates the ratio of the subject's HF calculated in the processing procedure of step S22 to the subject's TP calculated based on the Lorenz plot method (i.e., HF / TP). Note that the calculation unit 102 may calculate the ratio of the subject's ccvHF calculated in the processing procedure of step S23 to the subject's ccvTP calculated based on the Lorenz plot method (i.e., ccvHF / ccvTP). Also, the processing procedure of step S24 may be omitted.

[0087] (Variation 1 of the parasympathetic nervous system evaluation) In the processing procedure of step S22 of the parasympathetic nerve evaluation method described above, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the HF of the subject based on the Lorenz plot method.

[0088] Specifically, in "Step 5" of the process procedure for calculating the TP of the subject described in "(Rapid evaluation of autonomic nerve function)", the logHF may be estimated by using Formula 9 instead of Formula 6. The logarithm may be a common logarithm.

number

[0089] The noise removal process described in "(Rapid evaluation of autonomic nerve function)" may also be applied to a method for estimating the HF of a subject based on the Lorenz plot method. That is, the calculation unit 102 may perform the following process. 1. Plot two consecutive intervals of heart rate data, designated x and y, on a graph with one axis as the x-axis and the other as the y-axis. 2. Calculate the first ellipse with the major axis being the first standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin (0,0) and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and the minor axis being the second standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 3. For points among the points plotted on the graph that are inside ellipse M, a second ellipse is calculated whose major axis is the third standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = y axis by a specified coefficient (D), and whose minor axis is the fourth standard deviation obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x = -y axis by a specified coefficient (D). 4. The area of ​​the second ellipse is substituted into a specified formula (Formula 9) to estimate (calculate) the subject's logHF.

[0090] In addition, when calculating the HF of the subject based on the Lorenz plot method, the calculation unit 102 calculates the HF of the subject based on the Lorenz plot method by dividing the RR intervals of the heart rate data into two non-consecutive RR intervals (x, y)=(RRI n , R.R.I. n+α ) may be plotted on a graph to calculate LP.S and LP.m. Anything not specifically mentioned may be the same as the explanation of "Modification 2 of rapid evaluation of autonomic nerve function."

[0091] (Variation 2 of the parasympathetic nervous system evaluation) In the processing procedure of step S23 described above, the ccvHF is calculated using formula 8, but this is not limiting. In this embodiment, the ccvHF may be calculated using any of formulas 10 to 13 below. Note that the "average HF" is the average value of multiple HFs obtained by measuring a predetermined number of subjects. Also, the "standard deviation of HFs" is the standard deviation (σ) of multiple HFs obtained by measuring a predetermined number of subjects. Also, the "HF max " and "HF min " respectively refer to the maximum and minimum values ​​of multiple HF obtained by measuring a specified number of subjects.

number

number

number

number

[0092] (Variation 3 of the parasympathetic nervous system evaluation) In step S23, the calculation unit 102 calculates the ccvHF deviation value of the subject using the procedures 1 to 3. However, instead of this, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the HF deviation value of the subject using the following procedure.

[0093] 1. Calculate the Lorenz plot (LP) index using the following formula 14. The LP index may be called the first index related to the Lorenz plot method. When calculating LP.S and LP.m, the calculation unit 102 calculates a point (x, y)=(RRI) consisting of two non-consecutive RR intervals among the RR intervals of the heartbeat data, as described in "Modification 2 of the rapid evaluation of autonomic nerve function". n , R.R.I. n+α ) on a graph to calculate LP.S and LP.m. Any points not mentioned in particular may be the same as those described in "Modification 2 of Rapid Evaluation of Autonomic Nervous Function." Alternatively, the calculation unit 102 may calculate a point (x, y)=(RRI n , R.R.I. n+1 ) on a graph to calculate LP.S and LP.m.

number

[0094] In addition, when LP.S=S and LP.m=M, the S / M part in the formula 14 may be replaced with a logarithmic or normalized value. Specifically, the value of "S / M" may be replaced with any of the values ​​shown below. S / logM, S / rootM, logS / M, logS / logM, logS / rootM, rootS / M, rootS / logM, rootS / rootM, log(S / M), log(S / logM), log(S / rootM), log(logS / M), log(logS / logM), log(logS / rootM), log(rootS / M), log(rootS / logM), log(rootS / rootM), root(S / M), root(S / logM), root(S / rootM), root(logS / M), root(logS / logM), root(logS / rootM), root(rootS / M), root(rootS / logM), root(rootS / rootM).

[0095] 2. Calculate the standard deviation of the subject's LP index using the formula: "LP index standard deviation = 10 x (subject's LP index - average value of LP index corresponding to subject's age) ÷ standard deviation (σ) of LP index corresponding to subject's age + 50."

[0096] In order to make it possible to calculate the standard deviation of the LP index, the storage unit 100 may store distribution data indicating the distribution of the LP index by the age of the subject. Furthermore, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the standard deviation of the LP index of the subject based on the distribution data, the age of the subject, and the LP index of the subject.

[0097] 3. Calculate the HF deviation value using the following formula 15.

number

[0098] In Formula 15, the two coefficients (m, n) may be coefficients calculated by performing regression analysis with the HF deviation value calculated by frequency analysis for each measurement time of the heartbeat data as the dependent variable and the deviation value of the LP index as the independent variable. That is, a set of two coefficients (m, n) for each measurement time of the heartbeat data may be stored in advance in the storage unit 100, and the calculation unit 102 may obtain a set of coefficients corresponding to the measurement time of the heartbeat data from the storage unit 100 and apply the obtained coefficients to Formula 15 to calculate (estimate) the HF deviation value of the subject.

[0099] In addition, in the formula 15, the two coefficients (m, n) can be coefficients calculated from the coefficient o of the major axis and the coefficient p of the minor axis used in calculating LP.S. For example, the coefficients o=2σx and p=2σ-x may be used using the major and minor axes shown in FIG.

[0100] According to the third modification of the parasympathetic nerve evaluation, the LP index is calculated using the area and distance values ​​themselves, which are actual values ​​calculated by the Lorenz plot method, and the HF deviation value is calculated from the deviation value of the LP index. This makes it possible to reduce errors in the measurement value compared to the case where the HF value is first estimated and then converted into a deviation value.

[0101] (Evaluation of autonomic nervous function using the LP index) In "Modification 3 of Parasympathetic Evaluation", the HF deviation value is calculated from the LP index, but it is also possible to calculate the TP deviation value from the LP index. Specifically, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the deviation value of the subject's TP value by substituting the deviation value of the subject's LP index calculated in "Modification 3 of Parasympathetic Evaluation" into the following formula 16 instead of formula 15. That is, the calculation unit 102 may calculate the deviation value of the subject's TP value by substituting the deviation value of the subject's LP index into a predetermined calculation formula (formula 16).

number

[0102] In addition, in the formula 16, the two coefficients (q, r) can be coefficients calculated from the coefficient o of the major axis and the coefficient p of the minor axis used in calculating LP.S. For example, the coefficients q=3σx and r=3σ-x can be used using the major and minor axes shown in FIG.

[0103] According to the evaluation of autonomic nerve function using the LP index, the LP index is calculated using the area and distance values ​​calculated by the Lorenz plot method, and the TP deviation value is calculated from the deviation value of the LP index. This makes it possible to reduce the error of the measurement value compared to the case where the TP value is first estimated and then converted into a deviation value.

[0104] (Sympathetic nerve evaluation) FIG. 17 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure performed by the evaluation device 10 to evaluate the sympathetic nerves.

[0105] In step S31, the acquisition unit 101 acquires the age and heart rate data of the subject.

[0106] In step S32, the calculation unit 102 calculates the LF of the subject using the maximum entropy method.

[0107] In step S33, the calculation unit 102 calculates the ccvLF of the subject using the LF of the subject calculated in step S32 and the heart rate data of the subject. The calculation unit 102 also calculates the standard deviation of the ccvLF of the subject using the ccvLF of the subject and distribution data (ccvLF) 100c. For example, the calculation unit 102 can calculate the standard deviation of the ccvLF of the subject by the following procedure. 1. According to Equation 10, the LF calculated in step S32 is corrected by the subject's heart rate (more specifically, the average of the RR intervals) to calculate the subject's ccvLF.

number

[0108] (Sympathetic nerve evaluation variant 1) In the processing procedure of step S33 described above, the ccvLF is calculated using formula 10, but this is not limiting. In this embodiment, the ccvLF may be calculated using any of the following formulas 18 to 21. Note that the "average LF" is the average value of multiple LFs obtained by measuring a predetermined number of subjects. Also, the "standard deviation of LFs" is the standard deviation (σ) of multiple LFs obtained by measuring a predetermined number of subjects. Also, the "LF max " and "LF min " respectively refer to the maximum and minimum values ​​of multiple LFs obtained by measuring a specified number of subjects.

number

number

number

number

[0109] (HF Experimental Results Part 1) In the explanations of "HF Experimental Results 1" and "HF Experimental Results 2" described below, "HFxx" means HF calculated by the maximum entropy method using heart rate data measured continuously for xx seconds. For example, "HF90" means HF calculated by the maximum entropy method using heart rate data measured continuously for 90 seconds.

[0110] Since HF analyzes a frequency band of 0.15 to 0.4 Hz, one wavelength is at least 1 / 0.15 (≒6.66) seconds. In other words, if there is at least 1 / 0.15 second of heartbeat data, HF can be measured. FIG. 18 shows the results of a correlation analysis between HF and HF90 obtained from heartbeat data of 1 / 0.15 seconds or more. FIG. 18 shows the results of measurements performed on 500 subjects. In FIG. 18, the values ​​in the upper row are correlation coefficients (r values), and the values ​​in the lower row are significance probabilities (p values). FIG. 18 shows that HF6.66 to HF10 have correlation coefficients with HF90 of approximately 0.5 or more, and HF11 to HF60 have correlation coefficients with HF90 of approximately 0.8 or more. In other words, it can be seen that the HF calculated by the maximum entropy method using heartbeat data for 6.66 seconds is correlated with the HF90 calculated by the maximum entropy method. Furthermore, even when heart rate data was measured over the theoretically shortest time (i.e., 1 / 0.15 seconds), the correlation coefficient with HF90 was 0.5 or higher, confirming that it can be used as a simple measurement of the parasympathetic nervous system.

[0111] In some literature, the definition of HF is not 0.15 to 0.4 Hz but 0.2 to 0.5 Hz. According to the definition, the correlation analysis between the HF obtained by analyzing the 0.2 to 0.5 Hz frequency band and the HF90 obtained by analyzing the 0.2 to 0.5 Hz frequency band is shown in FIG. 19. As shown in FIG. 19, even in the theoretically shortest measurement of 5 seconds, the correlation coefficient with HF90 was confirmed to be 0.5 or more. Therefore, even if the definition of HF is changed and heart rate data is measured in the theoretically shortest time (1 / 0.2 seconds, i.e. 5 seconds), the correlation coefficient with HF90 is 0.5 or more, and it was confirmed that it can be used as a simple measurement of the parasympathetic nerves.

[0112] Based on the above-described first experimental result, the acquisition unit 101 may acquire the subject's heart rate data by measuring the subject for a time period that is equal to or longer than the shortest measurement time based on the definition of the frequency components when calculating the HF by frequency analysis and shorter than 60 seconds. The calculation unit 102 may calculate the subject's HF by the maximum entropy method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject for a time period that is equal to or longer than the shortest measurement time based on the definition of the frequency components when calculating the HF by frequency analysis and shorter than 60 seconds. This makes it possible to evaluate the deviation value of the subject's HF in a shorter time than before.

[0113] If the HF frequency component is defined as 0.15 to 0.4 Hz, the above-mentioned shortest measurement time is 1 / 0.15 seconds (≈6.66 seconds). If the HF frequency component is defined as 0.2 to 0.5 Hz, the above-mentioned shortest measurement time is 1 / 0.2 seconds (=5 seconds).

[0114] However, without being limited to the above, the acquisition unit 101 may acquire the heart rate data of the subject by measuring the subject for P seconds or more and less than Q seconds. The calculation unit 102 may calculate the HF of the subject by the maximum entropy method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject for P seconds or more and less than Q seconds. P and Q may be set to any time within the range of the shortest measurement time to 60 seconds. For example, P and Q may be 11 seconds and 60 seconds, respectively, or 11 seconds and 15 seconds, respectively.

[0115] (HF Experimental Results Part 2) Figure 20 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of LP.S, LP.m, age and HF. More specifically, Figure 20 shows the results of multiple regression analysis of 500 subjects, with HF90 as the dependent variable and LP.S, LP.m and age as independent variables. In Figure 20, logarithmic transformation values ​​were used for LP.S, LP.m and HF.

[0116] The number of seconds in Fig. 20 indicates the measurement time of the heart rate data used in the multiple regression analysis. For example, in the column where the measurement time of the heart rate data is 15 seconds, the multiple correlation coefficient is 0.85625 and the degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination is 0.73154. This shows that the result of multiple regression analysis of the heart rate data obtained by measuring 500 subjects for 15 seconds for HF90, LP.S15, LP.m15, and the subject's age was 0.85625 in multiple correlation coefficient and 0.73154 in adjusted coefficient of determination.

[0117] According to Fig. 20, the multiple correlation coefficient obtained from the heart rate data with a measurement time of 3 to 5 seconds is 0.71 or more, and furthermore, when the measurement time is 6 seconds or more, the multiple correlation coefficient is 0.8 or more. In addition, the degree of freedom adjusted coefficient of determination is greater than 0.5 when the measurement time is 3 seconds or more. Therefore, when the measurement time is 3 seconds or more, it can be said that Equation 9 is at a level that can be used as an estimation model for HF.

[0118] Fig. 21 is a diagram showing the correlation between LP.S, LP.m, age, and HF. Figs. 22 and 23 are diagrams showing the correlation between TP and LP.S. Figs. 21 to 23 show the results of measurements on 500 subjects. In Figs. 21 to 23, the values ​​in the upper rows are correlation coefficients (r values), and the values ​​in the lower rows are significance probabilities (p values). In Figs. 21 to 23, logarithmic transformed values ​​were used for LP.S, LP.m, and HF.

[0119] 21, it can be seen that LP.S10 and LP.m10 have a significant correlation with TP90. It can also be seen that there is a negative correlation between the subject's age and TP90.

[0120] 22 and 23, it can be seen that LP.S3 to LP.S9 have a correlation coefficient with HF90 of 0.6 or more, and further, LP.S10 to LP.S90 have a correlation coefficient with HF90 of 0.8 or more. In other words, it can be seen that the area of ​​the ellipse calculated by the Lorenz plot method using heart rate data of 3 seconds or more correlates with HF90 calculated by the maximum entropy method. From these results, it can be seen that by estimating HF using Equation 9 using the Lorenz plot method, it is possible to estimate the HF of the subject even if the measurement time of the heart rate data is short.

[0121] Based on the above-described second experimental result, the acquisition unit 101 may acquire the heart rate data of the subject by measuring the subject at an HF of 3 seconds or more and less than 60 seconds. The calculation unit 102 may calculate (estimate) the HF of the subject by the Lorenz plot method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject at an HF of 3 seconds or more and less than 60 seconds. This makes it possible to evaluate the deviation value of the HF of the subject in a shorter time than before.

[0122] However, without being limited to the above, the acquisition unit 101 may acquire the heart rate data of the subject by measuring the subject for R seconds or more and less than S seconds. The calculation unit 102 may calculate (estimate) the HF of the subject by the Lorenz plot method using the heart rate data acquired by measuring the subject for R seconds or more and less than S seconds. Any time may be set for R and S within a range of 3 seconds to 60 seconds. For example, R and S may be 6 seconds and 60 seconds, 6 seconds and 15 seconds, 3 seconds and 15 seconds, or 3 seconds and 7 seconds, respectively.

[0123] (Additional information on parasympathetic nervous system evaluation) FIG. 24 is a diagram showing the results of comparing the percentage of HF in TP with the subject's degree of fatigue. FIG. 24 shows data obtained by performing an autonomic nerve function evaluation on 19 healthy subjects before and after fatigue caused by mental workload, and the vertical axis "% HF" shows the percentage of HF in TP (i.e., HF÷TP×100). The horizontal axis shows a score indicating the subject's degree of fatigue, with a higher score indicating greater fatigue. According to FIG. 24, it can be seen that the lower the percentage of HF in TP, the higher the subject's degree of fatigue. Note that TP is calculated as LF+HF, so the lower the percentage of HF in TP, the higher the percentage of LF.

[0124] Therefore, the evaluation device 10 may calculate the ratio of the subject's HF to the subject's TP calculated based on the Lorenz plot method (i.e., HF / TP) and output information indicating the calculated HF ratio. As described above, the evaluation device 10 according to this embodiment can measure TP in a shorter time than before by using the Lorenz plot method, and can also measure HF in a shorter time than before. Therefore, the "ratio of HF to TP" of the subject can also be calculated in a shorter time than before. Therefore, in this embodiment, it is possible to determine the state of fatigue or stress-related disorder in an extremely short time under circumstances in which the burden of measurement on the subject is reduced.

[0125] (Example output) FIG. 25 is a diagram showing an example of a screen for outputting the measurement result of the subject. As shown in FIG. 25, the output unit 103 may display the deviation value of the subject's ccvTP and the deviation value of the subject's ccvHF value side by side on the screen. The upper part of FIG. 25 corresponds to the deviation value of the ccvTP, and the lower part of FIG. 25 corresponds to the deviation value of the ccvHF. This allows the subject to check the ccvTP and ccvHF at the same time. In addition, according to this embodiment, it is possible to calculate the deviation value of the ccvTP from heart rate data measured in a time period that was difficult to achieve in the past, such as less than 25 seconds, so that the subject can grasp the degree of fatigue and the magnitude of stress in his or her own brain without feeling stress.

[0126] In addition, by measuring the subject for less than 7 seconds, it is possible to evaluate the subject's parasympathetic autonomic nerve function in a short time that was previously impossible. In addition to estimating parasympathetic nerve activity from HF using frequency analysis, the reliability of short-term evaluations can be improved by estimating parasympathetic nerve activity from the area of ​​the Lorenz plot method.

[0127] <Summary> According to the embodiment described above, the Lorenz plot method is used instead of the maximum entropy method, so that it is possible to calculate TP from heart rate data measured in a short time. This makes it possible to more quickly evaluate the autonomic nerve function. According to the embodiment, the deviation value of ccvHF is calculated, so that the index related to the parasympathetic nerve can be used as a common index even between subjects of different ages. According to the embodiment, the deviation value of ccvLF is calculated, so that the index related to the sympathetic nerve can be used as a common index even between subjects of different ages. According to the embodiment, the HF is calculated from the heart rate data measured in a shorter time, so that it is possible to grasp the state of the parasympathetic nerve more quickly than before. According to the embodiment, the deviation value of ccvTP and the deviation value of ccvHF calculated from the heart rate data measured in a short time are simultaneously output, so that it is possible to grasp the state of the parasympathetic nerve more quickly than before. According to the embodiment, the ratio of the HF value measured in a short time to the TP (HF / TP) is output, so that it is possible to grasp the state of the parasympathetic nerve (for example, whether the ratio of HF to TP is high or low, etc.) more quickly than before. In addition, by estimating parasympathetic activity from HF by frequency analysis, and estimating parasympathetic activity from the area of ​​the Lorenz plot method, the reliability of evaluation in a short time can be improved. Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the deviation value of ccvTP and the deviation value of HF calculated by the heart rate data measured in a short time can be output simultaneously, so that the subject can grasp the state of his / her autonomic nerve in a manner that can be compared with other subjects without feeling stress.

[0128] The above-described embodiments are intended to facilitate understanding of the present invention, and are not intended to limit the present invention. The flow charts, sequences, elements included in the embodiments, and their arrangements, materials, conditions, shapes, sizes, etc. are not limited to those illustrated, and can be changed as appropriate. In addition, configurations shown in different embodiments can be partially substituted or combined. The HF value and the LF value may be referred to as HF and LF, respectively. [Explanation of symbols]

[0129] 10...Evaluation device, 11...Processor, 12...Storage device, 13...Input device, 14...Output device, 15...Biometric information acquisition device, 100...Storage unit, 100a...Distribution data (ccvTP), 100b...Distribution data (ccvHF), 100c...Distribution data (ccvLF), 101...Acquisition unit, 102...Calculation unit, 103...Output unit

Claims

1. An acquisition unit that acquires heart rate data of a subject to be evaluated, the heart rate data being measured for 3 seconds or more and less than 60 seconds, and the age of the subject; a calculation unit that calculates an ellipse area and an average distance in a Lorenz plot method based on the RR interval of the heartbeat data, and calculates an index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject based on the ellipse area, the average distance and the age of the subject; An autonomic nervous system evaluation device having the above configuration.

2. A memory unit that stores distribution data showing a distribution by age of the parasympathetic nerve index of the subject, the calculation unit calculates a standard deviation of the index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject by using the index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject, the age of the subject, and the distribution data; The autonomic nerve evaluation device according to claim 1 .

3. The calculation unit, Plotting a plurality of points, each of which represents two consecutive RR intervals among the RR intervals of the heartbeat data as x and y, on a graph having an x-axis and a y-axis as one axis; a first ellipse is calculated, the major axis of which is a first standard deviation obtained by multiplying a standard deviation of a distance between the origin and a projection point of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by a predetermined coefficient, and the minor axis of which is a second standard deviation obtained by multiplying a standard deviation of a distance between the origin and a projection point of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by the predetermined coefficient; a second ellipse is calculated for points that are inside the first ellipse among the points plotted on the graph, with a third standard deviation as its major axis being obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by the predetermined coefficient, and a fourth standard deviation as its minor axis being obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by the predetermined coefficient; Calculating an index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject by substituting the area of ​​the second ellipse, which is the ellipse area, the average distance, and the age of the subject into a predetermined calculation formula. The autonomic nerve evaluation device according to claim 1 .

4. The calculation unit, Plotting a plurality of points, each of which is an x-axis and a y-axis representing two non-consecutive RR intervals among the RR intervals of the heartbeat data, on a graph having an x-axis and a y-axis; a first ellipse is calculated, the major axis of which is a first standard deviation obtained by multiplying a standard deviation of a distance between the origin and a projection point of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by a predetermined coefficient, and the minor axis of which is a second standard deviation obtained by multiplying a standard deviation of a distance between the origin and a projection point of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by the predetermined coefficient; a second ellipse is calculated for points that are inside the first ellipse among the points plotted on the graph, with a third standard deviation as its major axis being obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=y axis by the predetermined coefficient, and a fourth standard deviation as its minor axis being obtained by multiplying the standard deviation of the distance between the origin and the projection points of the points plotted on the graph onto the x=-y axis by the predetermined coefficient; Calculating an index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject by substituting the area of ​​the second ellipse, which is the ellipse area, the average distance, and the age of the subject into a predetermined calculation formula. The autonomic nerve evaluation device according to claim 1 .

5. the calculation unit calculates a deviation value of the autonomic nerve activity of the subject from the heart rate data by using a Lorenz plot method; an output unit that outputs a deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nerve of the subject and a deviation value of the autonomic nerve activity of the subject side by side; The autonomic nerve evaluation device according to claim 2 .

6. the calculation unit calculates an amount of autonomic nerve activity of the subject from the heart rate data by using a Lorenz plot method, and calculates a ratio of an index related to the parasympathetic nerve of the subject in the amount of autonomic nerve activity of the subject; an output unit that outputs a ratio of an index related to the parasympathetic nerve of the subject to an amount of autonomic nerve activity of the subject; The autonomic nerve evaluation device according to any one of claims 1 to 5.

7. A step of acquiring heart rate data of a subject to be evaluated, the heart rate data being measured for at least 3 seconds and less than 60 seconds, and the age of the subject; calculating an ellipse area and an average distance in a Lorenz plot method based on the RR interval of the heart rate data, and calculating an index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject based on the ellipse area, the average distance and the age of the subject; An autonomic nerve evaluation method performed by an autonomic nerve evaluation device, comprising:

8. A step of acquiring heart rate data of a subject to be evaluated, the heart rate data being measured for at least 3 seconds and less than 60 seconds, and the age of the subject; calculating an ellipse area and an average distance in a Lorenz plot method based on the RR interval of the heart rate data, and calculating an index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject based on the ellipse area, the average distance and the age of the subject; A program for causing a computer to execute the following.

9. a storage unit that stores distribution data indicating a distribution of a first index related to the Lorenz plot method by age of subjects; An acquisition unit that acquires the age of a subject to be evaluated and heart rate data of the subject; Plotting a plurality of points, each of which represents two RR intervals of the heartbeat data as x and y, on a graph having one axis as the x-axis and the other axis as the y-axis, thereby calculating an ellipse area (LP.S) and an average distance (LP.m) in the Lorentz plot method; Calculating a first index for the subject related to the Lorenz plot method based on the ellipse area (LP.S) and the average distance (LP.m); calculating a standard deviation of the first index of the subject based on the distribution data, the age of the subject, and the first index of the subject; a calculation unit that calculates the deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nerves of the subject by substituting the deviation value of the first index of the subject into a predetermined calculation formula that outputs the deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nerves when a coefficient corresponding to a measurement time of the heartbeat data and the deviation value of the first index of the subject are input; An autonomic nervous system evaluation device having the above configuration.

10. storing distribution data indicating a distribution of the first index related to the Lorenz plot method by age of subjects in a storage unit; obtaining the age of a subject to be evaluated and heart rate data of said subject; Plotting a plurality of points, each of which represents two RR intervals of the heartbeat data as x and y, on a graph having one axis as the x-axis and the other axis as the y-axis, thereby calculating an ellipse area (LP.S) and an average distance (LP.m) in the Lorentz plot method; Calculating a first index for the subject related to the Lorenz plot method based on the ellipse area (LP.S) and the average distance (LP.m); calculating a standard deviation of the first index of the subject based on the distribution data, the age of the subject, and the first index of the subject; calculating a deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nervous system of the subject by substituting the deviation value of the first index of the subject into a predetermined calculation formula that outputs a deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nervous system when a coefficient corresponding to a measurement time of the heart rate data and the deviation value of the first index of the subject are input; An autonomic nervous system evaluation method comprising:

11. storing distribution data indicating a distribution of the first index related to the Lorenz plot method by age of subjects in a storage unit; obtaining the age of a subject to be evaluated and heart rate data of said subject; Plotting a plurality of points, each of which represents two RR intervals of the heartbeat data as x and y, on a graph having one axis as the x-axis and the other axis as the y-axis, thereby calculating an ellipse area (LP.S) and an average distance (LP.m) in the Lorentz plot method; Calculating a first index for the subject related to the Lorenz plot method based on the ellipse area (LP.S) and the average distance (LP.m); calculating a standard deviation of the first index of the subject based on the distribution data, the age of the subject, and the first index of the subject; calculating a deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nervous system of the subject by substituting the deviation value of the first index of the subject into a predetermined calculation formula that outputs a deviation value of the index related to the parasympathetic nervous system when a coefficient corresponding to a measurement time of the heart rate data and the deviation value of the first index of the subject are input; A program for causing a computer to execute the following.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Autonomic nerve evaluation apparatus, autonomic nerve evaluation method, program, and recording medium

    JP2018149262A

  • Information processor and program

    JP2019101928A

  • Crewman state determination device

    JP2022023702A