Test method for evaluating crashworthiness of evaluation components and method for evaluating crashworthiness

The collision performance evaluation test method for EV cabin frame members addresses the challenge of assessing fracture and energy absorption in EVs by using a specific shaped metal plate test, facilitating the production of structurally superior members with enhanced properties for side collisions.

JP7586129B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19JFE STEEL CORP
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2022074869
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-04-28
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2042-04-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating the collision performance of EV cabin frame members fail to accurately assess fracture and energy absorption characteristics during large bending deformations, which are critical for side collisions, due to differences in deformation modes between conventional gasoline vehicles and EVs.

Method used

A collision performance evaluation test method for EV cabin frame members, involving a metal plate material shaped into a top plate and side wall portions, using a testing machine with a moving part and fixed part to apply pinching pressure, and evaluating fracture and energy absorption characteristics through visual observation and measurement.

Benefits of technology

Enables easier evaluation of fracture and energy absorption characteristics in EVs, allowing for the production of structural members with improved rupture and energy absorption properties under large deformations.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007586129000002
    Figure 0007586129000002
  • Figure 0007586129000003
    Figure 0007586129000003
  • Figure 0007586129000004
    Figure 0007586129000004
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To allow a user to simply perform a test of collision breaking characteristics and collision performance in a deformation mode assumed upon side impact of an EV for an evaluation member corresponding to an automobile body structural member compared to a conventional evaluation test.SOLUTION: A collision performance evaluation testing method includes deforming an evaluation member obtained by processing a metal plate material into a form at least having a top plate part and a pair of side wall parts each continuing to both ends in a width direction of the top plate part, by using a test machine having a moving part and a fixing part to move the moving part relative to the fixing part. The evaluation member is fixed or installed to the moving part or the fixing part with a flange part continuing a reverse side end to the top plate part side of the side wall part or a reverse side end thereto.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a crashworthiness evaluation test method and a crashworthiness evaluation method for evaluation members corresponding to structural members for automobile bodies. How to This is related to. [Background technology]

[0002] In recent years, in the field of automobiles, collision safety standards have been getting stricter from the viewpoint of passenger protection, and there is a strong demand for the expanded application of high-strength steel and the development of vehicles with excellent collision safety performance. In particular, in the automobile industry in Europe, the United States, and China, there has been a rapid shift from gasoline-powered vehicles to electric vehicles (EVs) in order to achieve a carbon-free society, and the EV market is expected to expand in Japan in the future.

[0003] From the perspective of collision deformation, structural components for automobile bodies are broadly divided into two types: cabin frame components that are arranged around the cabin and therefore do not allow deformation during a collision due to their high load-bearing capacity, and energy absorbing components that have a certain degree of load-bearing capacity and absorb collision energy while allowing some deformation. Components such as side sills fall into the former cabin frame components, and are required to have high load-bearing capacity against bending deformation modes in the longitudinal direction of the components in particular during a side collision to prevent the impact body from entering the cabin. However, in actual fact, in conventional gasoline-powered vehicles, side sills are often designed to increase energy absorption capacity by allowing the components to intrude to a degree that does not affect the occupant injury value, while diverting the load to the surrounding structure.

[0004] On the other hand, in EV vehicle design, especially in the design of the battery surrounding structure, there is a tendency for high energy absorption performance to be required due to the increase in vehicle weight caused by the loading of batteries. However, from the viewpoint of battery protection, the battery surrounding structure itself is very robust and has a structure that allows almost no deformation, so it does not contribute much to energy absorption performance. Furthermore, from the viewpoint of aiming for longer driving range, there are many cases where a platform structure with a wider battery loading area is adopted, in which case the side sill will bear the majority of the energy absorption in the event of a side collision. Given such a design, the side sill is required to have a high load capacity by using high strength materials equivalent to or greater than the current one, while also being capable of large deformation and having high energy absorption performance.

[0005] Generally, cabin structural members have high load-bearing capacity due to the use of high-strength materials, but because they are high-strength materials, they often have low ductility. In this case, when a single member in an EV experiences a large deformation greater than that expected in a conventional gasoline-powered vehicle, the fracture may reduce the collision load, and the expected energy absorption may not be achieved. Therefore, EV cabin structural members are required to have excellent fracture properties and energy absorption properties when subjected to large deformation in the bending deformation mode. It is also important to be able to easily evaluate the above-mentioned collision properties at the material development stage.

[0006] Patent Document 1 discloses a test method for evaluating the collision performance of metal sheet material for automobile bodies, in which a flat test piece made of metal sheet material is subjected to a primary bending deformation into a V shape, and then the test piece that has been primarily bent is subjected to a secondary bending deformation in a direction intersecting the primary bending deformation direction by a bending test device. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0007] [Patent Document 1] International Publication No. 2020 / 129903 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0008] However, the method in Patent Document 1 is a testing method for reproducing the fracture of a component when it is crushed in the axial direction, and it is believed that the deformation mode is different from cases where fracture occurs due to large bending deformation, such as that expected in a side collision of an EV, as described above.

[0009] Therefore, in order to solve the above problems, the present invention provides a crash performance evaluation test method and evaluation method that can easily be performed at the material development stage to evaluate the crash fracture characteristics that occur when a material breaks due to a large bending deformation, such as that expected in a side collision of an EV. Suggest a way The purpose is to: [Means for solving the problem]

[0010] The present invention provides a method for evaluating the collision performance of a member to be evaluated, which advantageously achieves the above object, comprising: An evaluation member made by processing a metal plate material into a shape having at least a top plate portion and a pair of side walls respectively connected to both ends of the top plate portion in the width direction, the shape corresponding to an automobile body structural member. of, A test machine having a moving part and a fixed part is used, and the moving part is moved relative to the fixed part. By this, the movable portion and the fixed portion are sandwiched between the movable portion and the fixed portion. A collision performance evaluation test method in which deformation is performed, A punch having an arc-shaped or rectangular cross section and a longitudinal direction perpendicular to the cross section is connected to the moving part, A flat floor surface is used as the fixing portion, The evaluation member is attached to an end portion of the side wall portion opposite to the top plate portion or to a flange portion continuous with the end portion of the side wall portion. In the above On the fixed part, The longitudinal direction of the evaluation member is oriented in a direction intersecting with the longitudinal direction of the punch. The present invention is characterized in that it is implemented in a fixed or installed state.

[0011] Further, a method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member according to the present invention, which advantageously achieves the above object, comprises the steps of: A collision performance evaluation test of the evaluation member is carried out by the collision performance evaluation test method, The evaluation member Clamping pressureThe method is characterized in that the occurrence or non-occurrence of fracture of the evaluation component after the test due to deformation and / or the occurrence and propagation behavior of fracture during the test are judged or evaluated based on information obtained from at least one of visual inspection, photographed images, test load, and other measurement results.

[0012] The present invention advantageously achieves the above object. Using Automotive body structural members include: A structural member for an automobile body manufactured based on an evaluation by the collision performance evaluation method of the evaluation member, The evaluation component is characterized in that it is manufactured using a metal plate material that has been processed into an evaluation component that has been evaluated as having a low risk of fracture by carrying out the method for evaluating the collision performance of the evaluation component. Effect of the Invention

[0013] In the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member of the present invention, a metal plate material is processed into a shape having at least a top plate portion and a pair of side wall portions each continuing to both ends of the top plate portion in the width direction, which corresponds to a structural member for an automobile body, and a testing machine having a moving part and a fixed part is used to test the evaluation member by measuring the end portion of the side wall portion opposite the top plate portion or a flange portion continuing to the opposite end portion. In the above The movable part is fixed or installed on a fixed part, and the movable part is moved relative to the fixed part. By doing so, The evaluation member Clamping pressure Transform.

[0014] Therefore, according to the collision performance evaluation test method of the present invention, it is possible to more easily test the collision fracture characteristics and collision performance of evaluation components corresponding to structural components for automobile bodies in deformation modes expected in the event of a side collision of an EV, compared to conventional evaluation tests.

[0015] In the method for evaluating the collision performance of the evaluation member of the present invention, teeth, Arc Shape or the width of the rectangle having a cross section, The vertical direction of the cross section is the longitudinal direction. Shape punch To the moving part Connect the fixing portion to the flat floor surface. The evaluation member is attached to the fixing portion at an end portion on the opposite side of the side wall portion relative to the top plate portion or a flange portion continuous with the end portion on the opposite side, in a direction such that the longitudinal direction of the evaluation member intersects with the longitudinal direction of the punch.This makes it easy to test the crashworthiness and crash performance in the bending deformation mode assumed in a side collision of an EV.

[0016] In addition, in the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member of the present invention, a collision performance evaluation test of the evaluation member is carried out by the collision performance evaluation test method, Clamping pressure The occurrence or non-occurrence of fracture of the evaluation component after the test due to deformation and / or the occurrence and propagation behavior of fracture during the test are judged or evaluated based on information obtained from at least one of visual inspection, photographed images, test load, and other measurement results.

[0017] Therefore, according to the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation component of the present invention, it is possible to more easily evaluate the collision fracture characteristics and collision performance of an evaluation component corresponding to a structural component for an automobile body in a deformation mode expected in a side collision of an EV, compared to the conventional method.

[0018] In addition, the evaluation member is manufactured based on the evaluation by the collision performance evaluation method. by The structural members for vehicle bodies are manufactured using metal plate material that has been processed into an evaluation member that has been evaluated as having a low risk of fracture by carrying out the above-mentioned evaluation method for the collision performance of the evaluation member.

[0019] Therefore, the present invention Using The automobile body structural member can provide an automobile body structural member that has excellent fracture characteristics and energy absorption characteristics when subjected to large deformation in the bending deformation mode expected in the event of a side collision of an EV. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0020] [Figure 1] 1A, 1B and 1C are an end view, a side view and a perspective view showing an evaluation member used in a crash performance evaluation test method for an evaluation member according to one embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] 3(a) and 3(b) are an end view and a side view showing a crash performance evaluation test machine used in the crash performance evaluation test method of the evaluation member of the above embodiment. [Diagram 3] FIG. 4 is a characteristic diagram showing the results of a collision performance test performed using the collision performance evaluation test method for the evaluation member according to the embodiment. [Figure 4] 6(a) to 6(e) are photographs sequentially showing the deformation process when a collision performance test was conducted on the evaluation member of Example 3 using the collision performance evaluation test method for evaluation members of the above embodiment. [Diagram 5] 13(a) to 13(e) are photographs sequentially showing the deformation process when a collision performance test was conducted on the evaluation member of Example 5 using the collision performance evaluation test method for evaluation members of the above embodiment. [Figure 6] Photographs (a) to (e) show, at the top, the appearance of the broken state after a crash performance test was conducted on the evaluation members of Examples 1 to 5 using the crash performance evaluation test method for the evaluation members of the above embodiment, and at the bottom, an enlarged view of the outlined portion of the appearance of the broken state. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0021] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. Here, Fig. 1(a), Fig. 1(b) and Fig. 1(c) are an end view, a side view and a perspective view showing an evaluation member used in a method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member according to one embodiment of the present invention. The method for evaluating the collision performance of this embodiment is for performing a collision performance evaluation test of an evaluation member E having a hollow cross section extending in the longitudinal direction, which corresponds to an automobile structural member such as a side sill.

[0022] In the collision performance evaluation test of the evaluation member by the collision performance evaluation test method of this embodiment, the evaluation member is made by processing a metal plate material into a cross-sectional shape having at least a top plate portion and a pair of side wall portions each continuing to both ends of the top plate portion in the width direction, and the evaluation member is tested by using a testing machine having a moving part and a fixed part, and moving the moving part relative to the fixed part. Clamping pressure The movement of the movable part relative to the fixed part at that time is controlled by the evaluation member at the opposite end of the side wall part relative to the top plate part or at a flange part continuous with the opposite end. Before This is performed by fixing or installing the device to the fixed part.

[0023] Explaining this collision performance evaluation test in detail, as shown in Figures 1(a), (b) and (c), the evaluation part E has a hat-shaped hollow cross-sectional shape extending in the longitudinal direction (left-right direction in Figure 1(b)) and consisting of a top plate portion 1, a pair of side wall portions 2 each continuing to both widthwise ends of the top plate portion 1, and a pair of flange portions 3 each continuing to the opposite ends of the side wall portions 2 facing the top plate portion 1.

[0024] The width of the top plate portion 1 and the width of each vertical wall portion 2 are 40 mm, the width of each flange portion 3 is 20 mm, the angle between the top plate portion 1 and the two vertical wall portions 2 is 90°, and the angle between the two vertical wall portions 2 and the two flange portions 3 is 90°, and the top plate portion 1 and the vertical wall portions 2, and the vertical wall portions 2 and the flange portions 3 are each connected via a fillet-shaped ridge portion with an inner bending radius R of 5 mm.

[0025] The material of the evaluation member E was a metal plate such as a steel plate having a tensile strength of 1180 MPa or more, and the plate thickness was 1.4 mm. The above-mentioned cross-sectional shape of the evaluation member E was extended by 80 mm in the direction perpendicular to the cross section (longitudinal direction). In order to fix the evaluation member E, a thick plate-shaped installation jig J having dimensions of 100 mm x 100 mm x 10 mm was prepared, the evaluation member E was placed on the installation jig J, and the flange portion 3 of the evaluation member E and the installation jig J were welded and joined by a welded portion W, for example, by arc welding.

[0026] 2(a) and 2(b) are an end view and a side view showing a crash performance evaluation test machine used in the crash performance evaluation test method of the evaluation member of the embodiment. The crash performance evaluation test machine used in the crash performance evaluation test method of this embodiment is configured with an evaluation member E joined onto an installation jig J, a moving part M of the test machine, and a fixed part F of the test machine. The moving part M and the fixed part F of the test machine can be configured, for example, with a test machine such as an Amsler type test machine in which a slide as a moving part is raised and lowered by a hydraulic cylinder relative to a table as a fixed part.

[0027] The moving part M of the test machine has an arc shape. besideA punch P having a cross-sectional shape with high rigidity is connected. The fixed portion F of the testing machine is a flat floor surface with high rigidity. The collision test by the collision performance evaluation test method of the evaluation member of this embodiment is as follows: A punch P having an arc-shaped cross section and a shape with a vertical direction of the cross section as a longitudinal direction is connected to the moving part M, and the floor surface as the fixed part F is connected to the punch P. Orientation of installation jig J in contact with the top And the longitudinal direction of the evaluation member intersects with the longitudinal direction of the punch P. Then, the evaluation part E is placed on the test machine and the punch P is lowered. That is, it moves relative to the fixed part. The evaluation member E is then pressed against the floor surface serving as the fixed portion F.

[0028] Note that the described materials, plate thickness, dimensions, cross-sectional shape, installation or fixing method of the evaluation member E, the state of the moving part M and the fixed part F, and the cross-sectional shape of the punch P are merely examples. The test method of this embodiment is a more standard and simple test condition for testing in the material development stage for evaluating collision performance, but it may be adjusted to more specific conditions, for example by making the cross-sectional shape of the punch P rectangular, according to the expected collision mode and boundary conditions.

[0029] Furthermore, the cross-sectional shape of the evaluation member E may be composed of only the top plate portion 1 and the vertical wall portion 2, without the flange portion 3. The end portion of the vertical wall portion 2 opposite the top plate portion 1 may be directly joined or fixed to the fixing portion F, or may simply be placed thereon. Furthermore, the method of joining the evaluation member E to the fixing portion F or the installation jig J may be by means of bolt fastening, adhesives, or other methods other than welding. As a reference example The evaluation member E may be fixed to the moving part M side, and the shape of the fixed part F side may be an arc-shaped cross-sectional shape like the punch P, instead of being flat.

[0030] A collision test was conducted based on the collision performance evaluation test method for the evaluation member of the above embodiment. Two types of steel plates with different characteristics, 1180 MPa tensile strength (Examples 1 and 2) and three types of steel plates with different characteristics, 1470 MPa tensile strength (Examples 3 to 5), were prepared, and an evaluation member E was manufactured from each of them by bending and arc welding. The moving speed of the punch P of the testing machine was 10 mm / min. and the moving stroke of the punch P was 30 mm. The reaction force applied to the punch P and the moving part M during the collision test and the moving stroke of the punch P were recorded, and photographs were taken at intervals of one photograph per second to observe and evaluate the deformation and fracture state of the evaluation member E during the collision test.

[0031] Fig. 3 shows a characteristic diagram of the load-stroke curve (FS curve) created from the punch load and punch stroke data collected during the above-mentioned collision test. Fig. 4(a)-(e) and Fig. 5(a)-(e) show photographs of the deformation process at the points indicated by the arrows in the upper part of Fig. 3 for Example 3 and Example 5, respectively.

[0032] 3, the vertical wall portion 2 buckles and deforms to a peak load at time (2), and the deformation and load fluctuation are similar until the cross section is crushed at time (3). However, at time (4), no break occurs in Example 3 shown by curve E3, whereas a break (BR) occurs in Example 5 shown by curve E5, and the break penetrates the plate thickness, causing the evaluation member E to split and a sudden load drop to occur. In the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member according to one embodiment of the present invention, which uses an evaluation test according to the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member according to the above embodiment, the occurrence of breakage is evaluated from the photographs and the sudden load drop as described above, and the punch stroke at the time when the break first occurs is taken as the break stroke.

[0033] 6(a)-(e) show the appearance of the fractured state after the test for each of Examples 1-5 at the top and the enlarged framed area of ​​the appearance of the fractured state at the bottom. Table 1 below shows the strength level (MPa class), fracture state evaluation (fracture stroke (only when fracture occurs) (mm)), and energy absorption amount (kJ) of the materials for Examples 1-5. Here, the fracture state evaluation was rated on a three-level scale: × when fracture occurred, △ when a crack occurred but did not penetrate the plate thickness and did not break, and ◯ when no crack or fracture was confirmed. The energy absorption amount was calculated by integrating the punch load up to the fracture stroke by the punch stroke.

[0034] [Table 1]

[0035] According to the collision performance evaluation method of the evaluation member of this embodiment, it was possible to evaluate that cracks, fractures, and energy absorption are different at the same strength level. In addition, fractures were confirmed in Example 5 with a strength level of 1470 MPa, and it was found that the energy absorption was the lowest, including Examples 1 and 2 with lower strengths. From the viewpoint of increasing the tensile strength (high tensile strength) from 1180 MPa class material to 1470 MPa class material, it was evaluated that the material of Example 5 has a high fracture risk and there is a concern that the energy absorption will also decrease, while the material of Example 3 can be expected to have an increased energy absorption with the same fracture risk as the 1180 MPa class material.

[0036] Therefore, according to the collision performance evaluation test method and collision performance evaluation method for the evaluation member of this embodiment, tests on the collision fracture characteristics and collision performance of the evaluation member E corresponding to a structural member for an automobile body in a deformation mode expected in a side collision of an EV can be performed more easily than with conventional evaluation tests, and evaluation of the collision performance based on the test results can also be performed more easily than with conventional methods.

[0037] Based on the evaluation of the collision performance evaluation method of the evaluation member of the above embodiment, Manufactured structural components for automobile bodies According to the results, the evaluation component E is manufactured using metal plate material that has been processed into an evaluation component that has been evaluated as having a low risk of fracture by carrying out the collision performance evaluation method for evaluation component E, and therefore the evaluation component can be made into a structural component for automobile bodies that has excellent fracture characteristics and energy absorption characteristics when subjected to large deformation in the bending deformation mode expected in the case of a side collision of an EV.

[0038] The above has been explained based on the illustrated examples, but the present invention is not limited to the above examples. For example, in the above embodiment, both of the two flange portions 3 or vertical wall portions 2 of the evaluation member E are fixed or installed on the moving or fixed portion of the testing machine via the installation jig J or directly, but depending on the arrangement of the corresponding automobile body structural member, for example, one of the two flange portions 3 or vertical wall portions 2 may be fixed to the installation jig J and the other may be simply placed on the installation jig J, and the installation jig J may be fixed or installed on the moving or fixed portion of the testing machine. [Industrial Applicability]

[0039] Thus, according to the collision performance evaluation test method of the present invention, it is possible to more easily test the collision fracture characteristics and collision performance of evaluation components corresponding to structural components for automobile bodies in deformation modes expected in the event of a side collision of an EV, compared to conventional evaluation tests.

[0040] Furthermore, according to the method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation component of the present invention, it is possible to more easily evaluate the collision fracture characteristics and collision performance of an evaluation component corresponding to a structural component for an automobile body in a deformation mode expected in a side collision of an EV, compared to the conventional method.

[0041] And the present invention Using The automobile body structural member can provide an automobile body structural member that has excellent fracture characteristics and energy absorption characteristics when subjected to large deformation in the bending deformation mode expected in the event of a side collision of an EV. [Explanation of symbols]

[0042] E-evaluation material E1 to E5 Examples F Fixed part J Installation jig P Punch M Moving part W Welding 1 Top plate 2 Vertical wall section 3 Flange

Claims

1. A crashworthiness evaluation test method is provided, comprising the steps of: processing an evaluation member, which is made of a metal plate material and has at least a top plate portion and a pair of side walls each continuing to both widthwise ends of the top plate portion, and which corresponds to a structural member for an automobile body; using a testing machine having a moving part and a fixed part, the moving part is moved relative to the fixed part, and the evaluation member is subjected to a clamping deformation between the moving part and the fixed part, the method comprising the steps of: A punch having an arc-shaped or rectangular cross section and a longitudinal direction perpendicular to the cross section is connected to the moving part, A flat floor surface is used as the fixing portion, a flange portion continuous with the opposite end portion of the side wall portion facing the top plate portion or a flange portion continuous with the opposite end portion of the side wall portion, the flange portion being fixed or placed on the fixing portion in a direction such that the longitudinal direction of the evaluation member intersects with the longitudinal direction of the punch.

2. A collision performance evaluation test of the evaluation member is carried out by the collision performance evaluation test method according to claim 1, A method for evaluating the collision performance of an evaluation member, characterized in that the occurrence or absence of fracture of the evaluation member after testing due to clamping deformation of the evaluation member and / or the occurrence and propagation behavior of the fracture during the test are determined or evaluated based on information obtained from at least one of visual inspection, photographed images, the test load, and other measurement results.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Shock absorbing member

    JP2004114864A

  • Front bumper core

    JP2004168077A

  • Vehicular metal absorber, bumper system for vehicle, absorber for automobile bumper, and automobile bumper system

    JP2008265738A

  • Test method and equipment for evaluating collision performance of metal sheet for vehicle body

    WO2020129903A1