Information processing systems and programs

The system addresses inconsistencies in manual confidentiality level setting by using historical data to validate and correct user assignments, enhancing the reliability of confidentiality management through performance-based feedback.

JP7948033B2Active Publication Date: 2026-11-11FUJIFILM BUSINESS INNOVATION CORP
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023031567
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-03-02
Publication Date
2026-11-11
Estimated Expiration
2043-03-02

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Manual confidentiality level setting for documents lacks consistency and validity due to variations in understanding and perception among users, leading to potential misassignment of confidentiality levels.

Method used

An information processing system that refers to a history of confidentiality level determinations to generate performance information, comparing user and group performance against actual levels, and provides feedback to users and administrators to ensure valid assignments.

Benefits of technology

Ensures consistent and valid confidentiality level assignments by displaying performance information and notifying users and administrators of deviations, thereby improving the accuracy and reliability of confidentiality management.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007948033000001
    Figure 0007948033000001
  • Figure 0007948033000002
    Figure 0007948033000002
  • Figure 0007948033000003
    Figure 0007948033000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide information which serves as an index for a user to determine adequacy of confidentiality which is to be added to a document, by referring to a history of determining the confidentiality that the user added to documents in the past.SOLUTION: A confidentiality management system 10 includes: an acquisition unit 111 which acquires a result of determining confidentiality which is to be added to a document by a user; an adequacy determination unit 113 which determines adequacy of a result of the determination by referring to determination history information regarding confidentiality which has been added to documents in the past; a display information generation unit 114 which generates, when inadequacy is determined, display information for presenting, to the user, the result of determination and past confidentiality actually added; and an information management unit 12 which acquires, when the determination result is corrected after the user refers to the display information, the corrected confidentiality and registers the confidentiality in the determination history information together with the determination result.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

TECHNICAL FIELD

[0001] The present invention relates to an information processing system and a program. BACKGROUND ART

[0002] In order to protect documents that are corporate information assets, it is not uncommon to set and manage confidentiality levels for documents. For example, Patent Document 1 proposes a technique for setting a confidentiality level for a document based on confidentiality level classification rules that are set by associating confidentiality levels with each of words, document usage purposes, and job titles and positions. PRIOR ART DOCUMENTS PATENT DOCUMENTS

[0003] PATENT DOCUMENT 1 Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 2021-052332 SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION PROBLEMS TO BE SOLVED BY THE INVENTION

[0004] By the way, there are cases where a confidentiality level for a document is set by a confidentiality level setter such as the creator of the document. That is, the process of setting the confidentiality level for a document may not be automatically performed using a computer, but may be performed by a person. In this case, in order to minimize variations caused by different people, confidentiality level setting criteria and the like may be created in advance, and may be referred to by the confidentiality level setter when setting the confidentiality level.

[0005] However, in the manual confidentiality level setting work, the validity of the confidentiality level to be assigned to a document cannot always be guaranteed due to factors such as the degree of understanding of the setting criteria and perceptual deviations that accompany long-term setting work.

[0006] The present invention aims to make it possible to provide information that serves as a judgment indicator for the validity of a confidentiality level assigned by a user to a document, by referring to the confidentiality level judgment history that the user has assigned to documents in the past. [Means for solving the problem]

[0011] The information processing system according to the present invention is The system includes a processor, which, upon obtaining the confidentiality level assigned to a document to be processed as a result of a confidentiality level setter's determination, refers to a history of confidentiality level determinations previously assigned to documents to generate confidentiality performance information, including personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality level setter, and controls the display of the confidentiality performance information according to the relationship between the confidentiality level determination result obtained by the confidentiality level setter and the confidentiality level performance indicated by the confidentiality performance information. The judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to a document as a judgment result, at least one of the user's attribute information or the document's attribute information, and the processor generates the confidentiality performance information by further including group performance information relating to the confidentiality level performance assigned to documents associated with a group formed based on the attribute information included in the judgment history information.

[0012] Furthermore, the processor is characterized in that it displays the confidentiality performance information when the confidentiality determination result by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality performance indicated in the confidentiality performance information and the actual confidentiality performance assigned to the document associated with the group.

[0014] Also, In another aspect of the present invention, the information processing device is Equipped with a processor, The processor, upon obtaining the confidentiality level assigned to the document to be processed as a result of a confidentiality level setter's determination, refers to the determination history information regarding confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents to generate confidentiality performance information, including personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality level setter. The processor controls the display of the confidentiality performance information according to the relationship between the acquired confidentiality level determination result by the confidentiality level setter and the actual confidentiality levels indicated by the confidentiality performance information. The determination history information is generated by linking the user identification information of the user who assigned the confidentiality level as a determination result to the document, the confidentiality level assigned by that user, and the performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by that user. The processor analyzes the determination history information to generate confidentiality determination performance information regarding the validity of the user's confidentiality level determination result, and transmits the confidentiality determination performance information to the administrator. The processor is characterized by analyzing the judgment history information to extract users whose degree of discrepancy between the judgment result of confidentiality and the actual confidentiality level assigned in the past exceeds a predetermined value, and notifying the administrator of the extracted users.

[0015] Furthermore, the judgment history information is further associated with group information indicating the group to which the user belongs, and the processor analyzes the judgment history information to generate group characteristic information indicating characteristics related to the confidentiality performance assigned by users belonging to the group, and notifies the administrator of the generated group characteristic information.

[0016] The program according to the present invention provides a computer with the following functions: to obtain the confidentiality level assigned to a document to be processed as a result of a confidentiality level setter's determination, to refer to a history of confidentiality level determinations previously assigned to documents, and to generate confidentiality performance information including personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality level setter; and to control the display of the confidentiality performance information according to the relationship between the obtained confidentiality level determination result by the confidentiality level setter and the actual confidentiality levels indicated by the confidentiality performance information. A program for the purpose of generating confidentiality performance information, wherein the judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to a document as a judgment result, at least one of the user's attribute information or the document's attribute information, and the program causes the computer to generate confidentiality performance information, further including group performance information relating to the confidentiality level performance assigned to documents associated with a group formed based on the attribute information included in the judgment history information. . [Effects of the Invention]

[0021] Claim 1 According to the invention described above, it is possible to display information not only about the confidentiality assignment record of an individual confidentiality setter, but also about the confidentiality assignment record of documents linked to a group formed based on the attributes of the confidentiality setter or the attributes of the documents being processed.

[0022] Claim 2 According to the invention described above, it is possible to inform the confidentiality setter if the confidentiality level assigned this time differs from the confidentiality level assigned to the document associated with the group.

[0024] Claim 3 According to the invention described above, administrators can be notified of users who may have problems interpreting the confidentiality criteria.

[0025] Claim 4 According to the invention described, the characteristics related to the assignment of confidentiality to a group can be communicated to the administrator. [Brief explanation of the drawing]

[0027] [Figure 1] This is a block diagram showing the confidentiality management system in this embodiment. [Figure 2] This figure shows an example of the data structure of the determination history information stored in the memory unit in this embodiment. [Figure 3]This is a diagram illustrating an example of items and item data set in user attribute information included in determination history information in the present embodiment. [Figure 4] This is a diagram illustrating an example of items and item data set in document attribute information included in determination history information in the present embodiment. [Figure 5] This is a flowchart illustrating confidentiality level setting support processing in the present embodiment. [Figure 6] This is a diagram illustrating an example of display information displayed on a user terminal in the present embodiment. [Figure 7] This is a diagram illustrating another example of display information displayed on a user terminal in the present embodiment. [Mode for Carrying Out the Invention]

[0028] Hereinafter, preferred embodiments of the present invention will be described based on the drawings.

[0029] FIG. 1 is a block configuration diagram showing a confidentiality level management system 10 according to the present embodiment. FIG. 1 shows the confidentiality level management system 10 and a user terminal 2 of a user who sets a confidentiality level for a document. The confidentiality level management system 10 is connected to the user terminal 2 via a network (not shown), and manages the confidentiality level set for the document by the user of the user terminal 2. Further, the confidentiality level management system 10 in the present embodiment provides a characteristic confidentiality level determination support service to the user of the user terminal 2 in the present embodiment. The confidentiality level management system 10 manages confidentiality levels set for documents by a plurality of users each using the user terminal 2. Since the user terminals 2 used by the respective users have equivalent functions, only one unit is illustrated in FIG. 1 for convenience.

[0030] Note that when a user sets a confidentiality level for a document, the confidentiality level set by the user is assigned to the document. As described above, since the confidentiality level is assigned to the document by the user's setting operation, the terms "setting" and "assignment" of the confidentiality level are used synonymously in the present embodiment.

[0031] The confidentiality management system 10 in this embodiment corresponds to the information processing device according to the present invention. The confidentiality management system 10 may be implemented by a plurality of information processing devices. It may also be an information processing system formed by distributing each part shown in Figure 1 across a plurality of information processing devices connected by a communication network. For example, it may be divided into an information processing device that manages confidentiality and an information processing device that provides a confidentiality determination support service, or it may be divided into an information processing device that executes a program and an information processing device that manages a database. However, in this embodiment, the description assumes that the confidentiality management system 10 is implemented by a single information processing device. In this embodiment, "system" includes both those composed of multiple devices and those composed of a single device.

[0032] The confidentiality management system 10 in this embodiment can be implemented using a conventional, general-purpose hardware configuration such as a personal computer (PC). Specifically, the confidentiality management system 10 includes storage means such as a CPU, ROM, RAM, and hard disk drive (HDD), communication means for a network interface for communicating with a user terminal 2 via a network, and a user interface capable of input and output for data management, etc.

[0033] Furthermore, user terminal 2 can be implemented using existing general-purpose hardware configurations such as PCs and tablet devices. User terminal 2 is also equipped with an application for users to set confidentiality levels for documents. This application works in conjunction with the confidentiality management system 10 to provide users with a service to assist in assigning confidentiality levels.

[0034] As shown in Figure 1, the confidentiality management system 10 includes a confidentiality determination unit 11, an information management unit 12, a notification processing unit 13, an information analysis unit 14, a control unit 15, and a storage unit 16. Note that components not used in the description of this embodiment, such as functions for conventional confidentiality management and existing functions, have been omitted from the figure.

[0035] The confidentiality determination unit 11 is a key component in providing the confidentiality determination support service, which is a characteristic feature of this embodiment. The confidentiality determination unit 11 includes an acquisition unit 111, a confidentiality performance information generation unit 112, a validity determination unit 113, and a display information generation unit 114.

[0036] The acquisition unit 111 acquires the document sent from the user terminal 2 and the confidentiality level set by the user for that document. The document acquired by the acquisition unit 111 is a document for which no confidentiality level has yet been set, and is a document that is subject to processing for assigning confidentiality in the confidentiality management system 10. Furthermore, the confidentiality level acquired by the acquisition unit 111 from the user terminal 2 is the result of the user's determination of the confidentiality level they wish to set for the document, based on the document attributes and content of the document. As will be clear from the explanation below, this user's determination of confidentiality level is not necessarily the confidentiality level that will actually be assigned to the document being processed. The confidentiality level that the user has specified as the confidentiality level they wish to set for the document will also be referred to as the "determination result" by the user, i.e., the person who sets the confidentiality level. In this embodiment, the confidentiality level is set in three levels. Details of the confidentiality levels will be described below. Furthermore, if the user modifies the confidentiality level that was initially set for the document, i.e., the above determination result, by referring to the display information displayed on the user terminal 2, the acquisition unit 111 acquires the modified confidentiality level. The confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 generates confidentiality performance information that shows the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents, by referring to the judgment history information. Details of the confidentiality performance information will be described later. The validity judgment unit 113 determines the validity of the judgment result by the user acquired by the acquisition unit 111. If the user's judgment result is determined to be invalid, the display information generation unit 114 generates display information by arranging the confidentiality performance information in a format that can be provided to the user. The display information is transmitted by the notification processing unit 13 under display control by the control unit 15 and displayed on the user terminal 2.

[0037] The information management unit 12 manages information such as judgment history information stored in the storage unit 16. The notification processing unit 13 notifies administrators and users of information. The content of the information to be notified is provided together with an explanation of the operation. The information analysis unit 14 analyzes the judgment history information and creates information to be provided to administrators as needed. The control unit 15 controls the operation of each component of the confidentiality management system 10. The storage unit 16 stores documents to which confidentiality is assigned and judgment history information.

[0038] Figure 2 shows an example of the data structure of the judgment history information stored in the storage unit 16 in this embodiment. The judgment history information is information obtained when the user who sets the confidentiality level sends the document to be processed and the confidentiality level that they think should be set for that document, i.e., the judgment result described above, from the user terminal 2 to the confidentiality management system 10. In other words, one record of judgment history information is generated for each document. The judgment history information is configured by associating the date and time the confidentiality judgment result was obtained with document attribute information, user attribute information, confidentiality level information, and confidentiality level performance information.

[0039] Document attribute information is attribute information about a document to which confidentiality settings are to be applied. Document attribute information includes document ID, document name, document type, project, and creation date. The document ID is the identification information of the document. The document name is the name of the document. For each of the items, document type, project, and creation date, the item data shown in Figure 3 is set. Figure 3 shows an example of item data, but it is not necessary to limit it to this item data, and other item data may be set. However, in this embodiment, statistical processing such as the calculation of group performance information is performed based on the item data, so it is preferable to set one of the item data examples shown in Figure 3 for the document. The document type is the type of document. The project is the project in which the document is used, or the project for which the document was created. The creation date is the time when the document was created, and one of the creation dates is assigned by referring to the corresponding date and time.

[0040] User attribute information refers to attribute information about the user who sets the confidentiality level for the documents to which confidentiality levels are to be set, i.e., the confidentiality setter. User attribute information includes user ID, department, job title, and occupation. For each of the items User ID, department, job title, and occupation, the item data shown in Figure 4 is set. Figure 4 shows an example of item data, but it is not necessary to limit it to this item data, and other item data may be set. However, in this embodiment, statistical processing such as the calculation of group performance information is performed based on the item data, so it is preferable to set one of the item data examples shown in Figure 4 for the confidentiality setter. As shown in Figure 4, a user ID common to the system is also set for the confidentiality setter. The user ID is the identification information of the confidentiality setter. The department is the department to which the confidentiality setter belongs. The job title and occupation are the job title and occupation of the confidentiality setter, respectively.

[0041] Confidentiality information is information indicating the confidentiality level set by the confidentiality setter. Confidentiality information includes user settings and user modifications. "User settings" are the confidentiality levels set by the confidentiality setter for the document being processed, and correspond to the judgment results mentioned above. In this embodiment, the confidentiality setter is presented with display information as past confidentiality assignment performance information. However, the confidentiality setter may, after referring to the display information, want to change the judgment result of the confidentiality level they initially attempted to set and therefore reset the confidentiality level. The reset confidentiality level is set in "User modifications". If the confidentiality setter adopts the judgment result as the document's confidentiality level without modifying it, the "User modifications" field will remain blank. Thus, the confidentiality level set in "User settings" may be modified and is not necessarily assigned to the document as is.

[0042] Confidentiality performance information refers to performance information regarding confidentiality levels assigned to documents prior to the current setting of confidentiality levels for documents being processed, i.e., in the past. Confidentiality performance information includes "Users," which correspond to individual performance information, and "Groups," which correspond to group performance information. "Users" refers to the performance information of the individual who set the confidentiality level. Users who have previously set confidentiality levels for documents can be grouped by user attribute information such as department and job title. Documents subject to confidentiality assignment can also be grouped by document attribute information such as document type. "Groups" contain performance information regarding the confidentiality levels assigned to documents associated with groups formed by grouping users or documents based on user attribute information or document attribute information.

[0043] In this embodiment, the judgment history information includes two types of attribute information: user attribute information and document attribute information, but it is sufficient if at least one of the attribute information is included. Thus, the judgment history information includes, for each document, the document attribute information of the document, user attribute information including the user ID of the user who assigns confidentiality to the document, and further information regarding confidentiality, specifically, the confidentiality "user setting" which is the result of the confidentiality setting by the person who sets the confidentiality for the document to be processed, as well as personal performance information "user" regarding the confidentiality level that the individual confidentiality setter has assigned in the past, and group performance information "group" regarding the confidentiality level that has been assigned to documents linked to a group formed based on the attribute information.

[0044] Each component 11-15 of the confidentiality management system 10 is realized through the coordinated operation of the computer forming the confidentiality management system 10 and the program running on the CPU installed in the computer. The storage unit 16 is realized by an HDD installed in the confidentiality management system 10. Alternatively, RAM or an external storage means may be used via a network.

[0045] Furthermore, the program used in this embodiment can be provided not only via communication means, but also stored on a computer-readable recording medium such as a CD-ROM or USB memory. The program provided via communication means or recording medium is installed on the computer, and various processes are realized by the computer's CPU executing the program sequentially.

[0046] Next, the operation in this embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, the user will set the confidentiality level for documents that have not yet had a confidentiality level set. The user will determine and set the confidentiality level to be set for the document by referring to the document's attributes, etc. In this embodiment, the confidentiality management system 10 provides information on past assignment records as needed in the confidentiality determination support service to assist the user in setting the confidentiality level. The confidentiality setting support process in this embodiment will be described below using the flowchart shown in Figure 5.

[0047] The user, from a predetermined settings screen (not shown) displayed on user terminal 2, specifies the document to be subject to confidentiality settings and the confidentiality level to be set for that document as the result of the determination, and then selects a predetermined setting button.

[0048] In the confidentiality management system 10, the acquisition unit 111 of the confidentiality determination unit 11 acquires the information when the user ID of the user who intends to set the confidentiality level, i.e., the confidentiality setter, is transmitted from the user terminal 2 (step 101).

[0049] In this embodiment, the judgment history information described using Figure 2 is generated in a later processing step (step 108) and registered in the storage unit 16. The information to be set in the user attribute information included in the judgment history information may be obtained from the user terminal 2 along with the user ID, etc. Alternatively, the confidentiality management system 10 may retain the user's personal information or obtain the user attribute information itself based on the user ID from a predetermined storage location that it can access. Similarly, the confidentiality management system 10 may also obtain the document attribute information from the user terminal 2 along with the user ID, etc. Alternatively, the confidentiality management system 10 may extract it by analyzing the document, etc. At this point, the confidentiality management system 10 has obtained the date and time, document attribute information, user attribute information, and "user settings" for confidentiality information from the item data included in the judgment history information linked to the document to be processed.

[0050] Next, the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 generates confidentiality performance information by referring to the judgment history information (step 102). The generated confidentiality performance information is set as the confidentiality performance information included in the judgment history information. Details of the confidentiality performance information generation process by the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 will be described later.

[0051] Next, the validity determination unit 113 refers to the confidentiality performance information generated by the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 and determines the validity of the determination result by the confidentiality setter (step 103).

[0052] Figure 6 shows an example of the display information presented to the person setting the confidentiality level when the judgment result is deemed inappropriate. The display information will be explained later, but here we will explain "confidentiality level" using Figure 6.

[0053] For example, in this embodiment, the level of confidentiality assigned to a document is set to three levels: Level 1 (publicly available level, displayed as "unspecified"), which does not require confidentiality; Level 3 (top secret level, displayed as "top secret"), which must be treated as extremely confidential; and Level 2 (non-public level, displayed as "secret"), which does not require top secret but must be treated as a confidential document. The display information shown in Figure 6 includes "Personal Evaluation (This Time)," which corresponds to the evaluation result of the confidentiality setter in this case, as well as "Personal Evaluation (Normal)" and "Organizational Evaluation (Normal)" as confidentiality performance information. "Personal Evaluation (Normal)" corresponds to personal performance information obtained in accordance with the confidentiality levels set by the confidentiality setter for one or more documents in the past. "Organizational Evaluation (Normal)" corresponds to group performance information obtained in accordance with the confidentiality levels assigned to documents in the past by users belonging to the same department ("Department" is an example of a group) as the aforementioned confidentiality setter. This "Personal Evaluation (Normal)" and "Organizational Evaluation (Normal)" correspond to confidentiality performance information.

[0054] Having explained "confidentiality," we will now explain the confidentiality performance information generation process (step 102) in the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112.

[0055] The confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 generates confidentiality performance information by referring to the judgment history information and performing statistical processing. For example, the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 obtains the confidentiality levels previously set by the confidentiality setter, who can be identified from the user ID, and aggregates the obtained confidentiality levels for each level. The confidentiality levels previously set by the confidentiality setter are set in the confidentiality information of the judgment history information. Specifically, the confidentiality levels assigned to documents are included in "User Modification" if the confidentiality setter has modified the judgment result, and in "User Setting" if the judgment result has not been modified, so these are referred to and aggregated. This obtains the mode of each level. The period for referring to the judgment history information, i.e., the aggregation period, may be set in advance, or all records may be referred to. The confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 sets the confidentiality level that is the mode of the three confidentiality levels, in other words, the maximum value of the aggregated value, as the confidentiality performance information of the individual confidentiality setter, "Self-Evaluation (Normal)". The confidentiality performance information of the individual confidentiality setter obtained in this way is stored in the "User" section of the confidentiality performance information of the judgment history information.

[0056] Furthermore, the confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 refers to the judgment history information and, for example, obtains the confidentiality levels previously set by other users belonging to the same department (where "department" is an example of a group) as the person who set the confidentiality level, and aggregates the obtained confidentiality levels by level. The confidentiality levels previously set by other users are set in the confidentiality information of the judgment history information. Specifically, the confidentiality level assigned to a document is included in "User Modification" if the other user has modified the judgment result, and in "User Setting" if the judgment result has not been modified, so these are referenced and aggregated. This obtains the mode for each level. The period for referencing the judgment history information, i.e., the aggregation period, may be set in advance, or all records may be referenced. The confidentiality performance information generation unit 112 sets the confidentiality level that is the mode among the three levels of confidentiality to the confidentiality performance information of the department, "Organizational Evaluation (Normal)". The confidentiality levels previously set are set in the confidentiality information of the judgment history information, and are saved in "User Modification" if the person who set the confidentiality level has modified the judgment result, and are saved in "User Setting" if the person who set the confidentiality level has not modified the judgment result. The confidentiality performance information of the department to which the person who set the confidentiality level belongs, obtained in this way, is stored in the "group" of confidentiality performance information in the judgment history information.

[0057] In this embodiment, the confidentiality level obtained by acquiring the mode as described above is expressed as "normal" in the displayed information. Of course, the confidentiality performance information does not have to be the mode. For example, it may be the average value of the confidentiality level, or it may be calculated by referring to the date and time and giving more weight to judgment history information that is closer to the present or within a predetermined period.

[0058] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the department to which the confidentiality setter belongs was used as an example of a group, but it is not limited to this, and groups may be formed based on other attribute items included in the user attribute information. Also, instead of user attribute information, document attribute information may be referred to. For example, if the document type of the document to be processed this time is a design drawing, the confidentiality performance information corresponding to the group may be calculated based on the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents of the document type being a design drawing. When displaying the confidentiality performance information corresponding to a document of the document type being a design drawing, the displayed information will be given a title such as "Design Drawing Evaluation (Normal)". It should be noted that various types of confidentiality performance information can be calculated for groups. In this case, the performance information for multiple groups may be listed and presented, or a multiple regression equation may be created and presented as a single piece of performance information.

[0059] Incidentally, document attribute information includes "creation date," as shown in Figure 2. For example, even for the same document type, documents at the end of the fiscal year or other period may tend to be assigned a relatively higher level of confidentiality than usual because they contain management indicators. In this embodiment, we have made it possible to analyze the trend of assigning confidentiality according to the time of year.

[0060] Next, we will describe in detail the validation process (step 103) in the validation determination unit 113 for determining the validity of the judgment result by the confidentiality setter.

[0061] In this embodiment, the validity of the judgment result is determined based on the relationship between the judgment result of the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality level shown in the confidentiality performance information. If it is determined that the result is not valid, the control unit 15 controls the display of the confidentiality performance information, i.e., the display information, on the user terminal 2. In this embodiment, the validity determination unit 113 determines the validity of the judgment result based on whether the confidentiality level value shown in the judgment result deviates by a predetermined level or more from the confidentiality level value shown in the performance information. For example, if the validity is determined by whether the confidentiality levels match or not, the predetermined level can be said to be 1. In this embodiment, since there are relatively few confidentiality levels (3 levels), the validity is determined by whether the confidentiality level value shown in the judgment result deviates by 1 or more from the confidentiality level value shown in the performance information, i.e., whether the confidentiality levels match or not.

[0062] Referring to the display information illustrated in Figure 6, the confidentiality assessment made by the person who set the confidentiality level this time (i.e., "Unspecified," corresponding to confidentiality level 1) does not match the confidentiality assessment that is usually set based on past performance (i.e., "Confidential," corresponding to confidentiality level 2). In other words, the person who set the confidentiality level would normally set it to confidentiality level 2, but this time they assessed it as confidentiality level 1. Thus, when the evaluation result this time does not match past performance, the validity determination unit 113 determines that the evaluation result made by the person who set the confidentiality level this time may not be valid.

[0063] In this embodiment, two indicator values, "Self-evaluation (normal)" and "Organizational evaluation (normal)," are presented as confidential performance information. The validity determination unit 113 determines that the information is not valid if it does not match at least one of these values. Alternatively, the determination may be made based on whether the result matches the "Self-evaluation (normal)," prioritizing the individual. In this case, the group performance information "Organizational evaluation (normal)" will be treated as reference information only. Conversely, the determination may also be made based on whether the result matches the "Organizational evaluation (normal)," prioritizing the group. In this case, the group performance information "Self-evaluation (normal)" will be treated as reference information only. This method may be used appropriately depending on the user, document attributes, or the time of year.

[0064] In this embodiment, the level of confidentiality was set to three levels as described above. For example, if the level of confidentiality is set to a relatively large number of levels, such as 10 or more levels, the predetermined level used to determine whether it is appropriate or not may be set to 3, and the appropriateness determination unit 113 may determine that a deviation of about one level is within an acceptable range and determine that it is appropriate.

[0065] Returning to Figure 5, the validity determination unit 113 determines that the evaluation result (confidentiality level 1) is not valid if it does not match past performance (confidentiality level 2) as illustrated in Figure 6 (N in step 104). In this case, the display information generation unit 114 refers to the determination history information and generates display information as illustrated in Figure 6 (step 105). The control unit 15 then controls the display of the display information by having the notification processing unit 13 send the display information to the user terminal 2 (step 106).

[0066] The person setting the confidentiality level can confirm the validity of their assessment of the confidentiality level of a document by referring to the display information shown on the user terminal 2. Furthermore, as illustrated in Figure 6, the display information may include guidance messages that help review the assessment results in accordance with the actual confidentiality level information. The validity determination unit 113 may also determine that the assessment result by the confidentiality setter is invalid because it is valid in statistical processing based on one attribute but not on statistical processing based on another attribute. In such cases, the display information generation unit 114 may generate the display information including attribute information that caused the validity determination unit 113 to determine a deviation of more than a predetermined level—in other words, attribute information that forms the basis for the judgment that the result is invalid.

[0067] If a person setting the level of confidentiality wants to modify their evaluation by referring to the displayed information, they enter the level of confidentiality they wish to modify in the input field 22 on the display screen of the displayed information and select the "Modify" button 24. On the other hand, if they do not wish to modify the evaluation, they select the "Do not modify" button 26.

[0068] In the confidentiality management system 10, the acquisition unit 111 of the confidentiality determination unit 11 acquires information input from the user terminal 2 (step 107). Then, the information management unit 12 completes the determination history information for the document to be processed based on the information acquired through the above process and registers it in the storage unit 16 (step 108). The document to be processed is stored in the storage unit 16 or in a predetermined storage location as before. If the confidentiality setter wants to correct the evaluation result made in advance, the information acquired in step 107 includes the corrected confidentiality level, and the information management unit 12 sets the corrected confidentiality level in the "User Modification" field of the confidentiality information in the determination history information. On the other hand, if the confidentiality setter selects the "Do not modify" button 26, or if the validity determination unit 113 determines that the evaluation result by the confidentiality setter is valid (Y in step 104), nothing is set in the "User Modification" field of the confidentiality information. Therefore, "User Modification" remains blank.

[0069] Subsequently, the notification processing unit 13, under the control of the control unit 15, provides information to the administrator as necessary (step 109). "As necessary" mainly refers to cases where the judgment result by the person who set the confidentiality level is not valid. The information notified includes, for example, information such as the user ID that identifies who the person who set the confidentiality level is, as well as both the judgment result showing the degree of discrepancy and the actual confidentiality level information. This notification to the administrator will be described further later.

[0070] In this embodiment, if the person setting the confidentiality level determines that the evaluation result is not valid, the user terminal 2 displays information indicating that the evaluation result may be invalid, along with past confidentiality level assignment records that form the basis for the determination that the result may be invalid. This allows the person setting the confidentiality level to correct their evaluation of the confidentiality level as needed by referring to the displayed information.

[0071] Figure 7 shows another example of the display information in this embodiment. The display information illustrated in Figure 7 includes, as in Figure 6, the evaluation result of the confidentiality level given by the person who set the confidentiality level, and the confidentiality level performance information assigned in the past. The difference between Figure 6 and Figure 7 is that Figure 6 shows only one confidentiality level, while Figure 7 shows the percentage of the total relevant judgment history information as statistical information. The total relevant judgment history information refers to all judgment history information in which the user ID of the confidentiality setter is set in the user attribute information, in the case of an individual confidentiality setter. In the case of a group, for example, a department, it refers to judgment history information in which the user ID of any of the users belonging to the same department as the confidentiality setter is set in the user attribute information.

[0072] In Figure 6, for example, if the mode is used as the past performance, there may be cases where the difference between the mode (i.e., the first confidentiality level) and the second most confidentiality level is small. Also, if the mean value is used instead of the mode as the confidentiality performance information, even if the mean value is 2.49, which is close to confidentiality level 3, the person setting the confidentiality level will be presented with past performance as confidentiality level 2. In this way, even when the past performance information such as the mode or mean value presented to the person setting the confidentiality level is close to the next highest level, the person setting the confidentiality level is only presented with performance information of one level, such as confidentiality level 2. Taking such cases into consideration, Figure 7 presents the ratio of each confidentiality level to the total as statistical information so that the distribution of confidentiality levels can be seen. The "mode value" can also be said to indicate the trend in the determination of confidentiality, but Figure 7 shows the trend in the determination of confidentiality level as a ratio.

[0073] In this embodiment, the display information is shown only when the judgment result by the person setting the confidentiality level is deemed inappropriate. However, the display information may be shown at all times regardless of whether it is appropriate or not.

[0074] Incidentally, from a security management perspective, the level of confidentiality assigned to a document is important information, and it is desirable that it be assigned at an appropriate level regardless of who sets it. Therefore, in this embodiment, a function is provided to analyze the user's confidentiality assessment results and, if necessary, generate confidentiality assessment performance information regarding the validity of the confidentiality assessment results and notify the administrator. The process for notifying the administrator may be performed periodically or may be included in the process of step 109.

[0075] The Information Analysis Unit 14 analyzes the validity of the user's judgment process. Specifically, by analyzing the judgment history information, the Information Analysis Unit 14 extracts users whose judgment result for confidentiality and their past performance in assigning confidentiality levels differ from a predetermined value or greater. For example, if a confidentiality judgment criterion has been established as an indicator for determining confidentiality, a user who has made a judgment that deviates from past performance may have set the confidentiality level according to the confidentiality judgment criterion, but there may be a problem with the interpretation of the confidentiality judgment criterion, causing them to gradually deviate from the criterion, and as a result, they may have set an inappropriate confidentiality level. Alternatively, it may simply be an oversight. By analyzing the judgment history information, the Information Analysis Unit 14 extracts users who seem to have such problems and notifies the administrator.

[0076] The degree of deviation can be determined by referring to the number of judgments or transitions that differ from past performance. The "predetermined value" used to compare with the degree of deviation can be a threshold corresponding to the degree of deviation. In addition, the confidentiality judgment performance information generated by the information analysis unit 14 may include not only the extracted users, but also attribute information that serves as the basis for extracting those users.

[0077] Furthermore, the Information Analysis Unit 14 analyzes the validity of judgment work performed not by individual users, but by other users belonging to the group to which the user belongs, such as departments and job types that can be identified from user attribute information, in other words, the judgment trends of the group. The Information Analysis Unit 14 then generates group characteristic information, which shows the characteristics of the confidentiality levels assigned by users belonging to that group, as confidentiality judgment performance information, and notifies the administrator of the generated confidentiality judgment performance information. For example, while each department as a whole tends to set confidentiality level 2, a particular department tends to assign confidentiality level 3 at the end of the fiscal year. Such characteristics regarding the assignment of confidentiality levels to a group can be made known to the administrator.

[0078] Upon receiving the above notification, the administrator can refer to the received confidentiality assessment results and, if necessary, take appropriate corrective action against the identified users or groups.

[0079] In the above embodiment, the term "processor" refers to a processor in a broad sense, and includes general-purpose processors (e.g., CPU: Central Processing Unit, etc.) and dedicated processors (e.g., GPU: Graphics Processing Unit, ASIC: Application Specific Integrated Circuit, FPGA: Field Programmable Gate Array, programmable logic device, etc.).

[0080] Furthermore, the operation of the processor in the above embodiments may not be performed by a single processor, but may be performed by multiple processors located in physically separate locations working together. Also, the order of each processor operation is not limited to the order described in the above embodiments, but may be changed as appropriate.

[0081] (Note) (((1))) Equipped with a processor, The aforementioned processor, When the confidentiality level assigned to the document to be processed as a result of the confidentiality level setter's determination is obtained, confidentiality performance information is generated, which includes personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality setter, by referring to the judgment history information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents. The display of the confidentiality performance information is controlled according to the relationship between the confidentiality determination result obtained by the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality performance information shown in the confidentiality performance information. An information processing system characterized by the following: (((2))) The information processing system according to (((1))), characterized in that the processor displays the confidentiality performance information when the result of the confidentiality determination by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality indicated by the confidentiality performance information. (((3))) The aforementioned judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to the document as a judgment result, at least one of the attribute information of the user or the attribute information of the document. If the confidentiality determination result by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality level indicated by the confidentiality performance information, the processor notifies the confidentiality setter of the attribute information referenced when determining the deviation. The information processing system according to (((2))) or (((3))), characterized in that... (((4))) The information processing system according to (((2))), characterized in that the processor notifies the administrator if the result of the confidentiality determination by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality indicated by the confidentiality performance information. (((5))) The aforementioned judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to the document as a judgment result, at least one of the attribute information of the user or the attribute information of the document. The processor generates the confidentiality performance information by further including group performance information relating to the confidentiality performance assigned to documents associated with a group formed based on the attribute information contained in the judgment history information. An information processing system according to any one of (((1))) to (((4))) characterized by the above. (((6))) The information processing system according to (((5))), characterized in that the processor displays the confidentiality performance information when the result of the confidentiality determination by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality performance indicated by the confidentiality performance information and the actual confidentiality performance assigned to the document associated with the group. (((7))) The aforementioned judgment history information is generated by linking the user identification information of the user who assigned confidentiality levels to the document as a result of the judgment, with the confidentiality levels assigned by that user and the performance information regarding the confidentiality levels that the user has assigned in the past. The aforementioned processor, By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, confidentiality judgment performance information regarding the validity of the user's judgment result on confidentiality is generated. The confidentiality determination results information is transmitted to the administrator. An information processing system according to any one of (((1))) to (((6))) characterized by the above. (((8))) The aforementioned processor, By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, users whose discrepancy between the resulting confidentiality judgment and their past confidentiality performance is greater than or equal to a predetermined value are extracted. Notify the administrator of the extracted users. The information processing system described in (((7))) characterized by the above. (((9))) The aforementioned judgment history information is further associated with group information indicating the group to which the user belongs. The aforementioned processor, By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, group characteristic information is generated that shows characteristics related to the confidentiality performance assigned by users belonging to the group. The generated group characteristic information is notified to the administrator. The information processing system described in (((7))) characterized by the above. (((10))) On the computer, The function obtains the confidentiality level assigned to a document to be processed as a result of a judgment by the confidentiality level setter, and then, by referring to the judgment history information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents, generates confidentiality performance information that includes personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality level setter. A function to control the display of confidentiality performance information according to the relationship between the confidentiality determination result obtained by the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality performance information shown in the confidentiality performance information. A program to achieve this.

[0082] According to the invention described in (((1))), it is possible to provide information that serves as an indicator for determining the appropriateness of the level of confidentiality assigned to a document by the user, by referring to the history of confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents by the user. According to the invention described in (((2))), confidentiality performance information can be displayed only when there is a possibility that the judgment result made by the confidentiality setter is not valid. According to the invention described in (((3))), attribute information that caused the determined confidentiality level to deviate from past confidentiality levels can be notified to the person setting the confidentiality level. According to the invention described in (((4))), it is possible to inform the administrator that there is a possibility that an inappropriate confidentiality assessment has been made. According to the invention described in (((5))), it is possible to display information not only about the confidentiality assignment record of an individual confidentiality setter, but also about the confidentiality assignment record of documents linked to a group formed based on the attributes of the confidentiality setter or the attributes of the documents being processed. According to the invention described in (((6))), the confidentiality setter can be notified if the confidentiality level assigned this time differs from the confidentiality level assigned to the document associated with the group. According to the invention described in (((7))), information regarding the validity of the user's determination of confidentiality can be provided to the administrator. According to the invention described in ((8)), it is possible to notify administrators of users who may have problems with the interpretation of the confidentiality criteria. According to the invention described in ((9)), the characteristics related to the assignment of confidentiality to a group can be communicated to the administrator. According to the invention described in (((10))), it is possible to provide information that serves as an indicator for determining the appropriateness of the level of confidentiality assigned to a document by the user, by referring to the history of confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents by the user. [Explanation of symbols]

[0083] 2 User terminal, 10 Confidentiality management system, 11 Confidentiality determination unit, 12 Information management unit, 13 Notification processing unit, 14 Information analysis unit, 15 Control unit, 16 Storage unit, 111 Acquisition unit, 112 Confidentiality performance information generation unit, 113 Validity determination unit, 114 Display information generation unit.

Claims

1. comprising a processor, The aforementioned processor, When the confidentiality level assigned to the document to be processed as a result of the confidentiality level setter's determination is obtained, confidentiality performance information is generated, which includes personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality setter, by referring to the judgment history information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents. The display of the confidentiality performance information is controlled according to the relationship between the confidentiality determination result obtained by the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality performance information shown in the confidentiality performance information. The aforementioned judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to the document as a judgment result, at least one of the attribute information of the user or the attribute information of the document. The processor generates the confidentiality performance information by further including group performance information relating to the confidentiality performance assigned to documents associated with a group formed based on the attribute information contained in the judgment history information. An information processing system characterized by the following:

2. The information processing system according to claim 1, characterized in that the processor displays the confidentiality performance information when the confidentiality determination result by the confidentiality setter deviates by a predetermined level or more from the actual confidentiality performance indicated in the confidentiality performance information and the actual confidentiality performance assigned to the document associated with the group.

3. comprising a processor, The aforementioned processor, When the confidentiality level assigned to the document to be processed as a result of the confidentiality level setter's determination is obtained, confidentiality performance information is generated, which includes personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality setter, by referring to the judgment history information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents. The display of the confidentiality performance information is controlled according to the relationship between the confidentiality determination result obtained by the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality performance information shown in the confidentiality performance information. The aforementioned judgment history information is generated by linking the user identification information of the user who assigned confidentiality levels to the document as a result of the judgment, with the confidentiality levels assigned by that user and the performance information regarding the confidentiality levels that the user has assigned in the past. The aforementioned processor, By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, confidentiality judgment performance information regarding the validity of the user's judgment result on confidentiality is generated. The aforementioned confidentiality determination results information is transmitted to the administrator. By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, users whose discrepancy between the resulting confidentiality judgment and their past confidentiality performance is greater than or equal to a predetermined value are extracted. Notify the administrator of the extracted users. An information processing system characterized by the following:

4. The aforementioned judgment history information is further associated with group information indicating the group to which the user belongs. The aforementioned processor, By analyzing the aforementioned judgment history information, group characteristic information is generated that shows characteristics related to the confidentiality performance assigned by users belonging to the group. The generated group characteristic information is notified to the administrator. The information processing system according to feature 3.

5. On the computer, The function obtains the confidentiality level assigned to a document to be processed as a result of a judgment by the confidentiality level setter, and then, by referring to the judgment history information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned to documents, generates confidentiality performance information that includes personal performance information regarding the confidentiality levels previously assigned by the confidentiality level setter. A function to control the display of confidentiality performance information according to the relationship between the confidentiality determination result obtained by the confidentiality setter and the actual confidentiality performance information shown in the confidentiality performance information. This is a program to achieve this. The aforementioned judgment history information includes, in addition to the confidentiality level assigned to the document as a judgment result, at least one of the attribute information of the user or the attribute information of the document. A program for causing the computer to generate the confidentiality performance information, further including group performance information relating to the confidentiality performance assigned to documents associated with a group formed based on the attribute information contained in the judgment history information.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • File management device, file management system, and program

    JP2015133087A

  • Label management support method and system

    JP2018049407A

  • Paper document management system and paper document management method

    JP2021052332A