Alternative thinking assistance device, alternative thinking assistance program, and alternative thinking assistance system

The alternative thinking support device and program address the lack of effective tinnitus treatment by using cognitive behavioral therapy principles to help patients replace negative thoughts, thereby supporting tinnitus treatment through the alternative thinking support device and program, improving emotional states and motivating patients to continue therapy.

WO2024228341A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-07SUSTAINABLE MEDICINE INC +1
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2024/015631
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-01
Filing Date
2024-04-19
Publication Date
2024-11-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current medical practices lack effective solutions for tinnitus treatment, as cognitive behavioral therapy, recommended in tinnitus treatment guidelines, is not widely used due to time and effort constraints, and there is no established drug therapy for tinnitus, often resulting in patients being advised to 'not worry' about their condition.

Method used

An alternative thinking support device and program that utilizes cognitive behavioral therapy principles by prompting patients to input events and thoughts related to tinnitus, providing support information to replace negative thoughts with neutral ones, facilitating emotional change and follow-up messages to encourage continued therapy.

Benefits of technology

Enables patients to correct cognitive biases by replacing negative thoughts with neutral ones, supporting the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy for tinnitus treatment, improving emotional states and motivating patients to continue therapy.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2024015631_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2024015631_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This alternative thinking assistance device comprises: an event information input unit 11 for inputting event information indicating an event that a patient is concerned with regarding tinnitus; a thought information input unit 12 for inputting thought information indicating an idea that came to the patient's mind when the event occurred; and an assistance information presentation unit 13 for presenting assistance information for substituting a negative thought of the patient with another thought in accordance with the event information and the thought information that have been input. Once the patient inputs the event the patient is concerned with regarding tinnitus and the thought that came to the patient's mind at the time of the event, the assistance information for substituting a negative thought of the patient with another neutral thought is presented. By replacing the negative thought with the other thought in accordance with the presentation, the patient can correct the patient's perception bias.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Alternative thinking support device, alternative thinking support program, and alternative thinking support system

[0001] The present invention relates to an alternative thinking support device, an alternative thinking support program, and an alternative thinking support system, and is particularly suitable for use in information processing technology that supports the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy for tinnitus.

[0002] Tinnitus is one of the most common complaints in daily medical practice. Tinnitus is an abnormal sound sensation felt despite the absence of any apparent external sound source. Due to the stress caused by aging and changes in the social environment, the number of tinnitus patients is expected to increase. Severe tinnitus is likely to be accompanied by mental disorders such as depression, anxiety, and insomnia, and it has also been pointed out that it can affect the cognitive function of the elderly, making how to deal with this condition one of the important issues in otolaryngology clinical practice.

[0003] However, because there is no established drug therapy worldwide, even if patients visit an otolaryngologist, the doctor is unable to cure the tinnitus, and the patient is simply told by the doctor to "just learn to live with it" or "try not to worry about it as much as possible."

[0004] In response to this, the Tinnitus Treatment Guidelines (see Non-Patent Document 1) were published in 2019. These guidelines recommend the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy. Cognitive behavioral therapy focuses on the fact that a person's mood and behavior are influenced by their way of thinking and perception, and aims to treat mental illness by correcting cognitive biases. However, due to issues such as the significant time and effort required for doctors, it is currently not widely used in daily clinical practice.

[0005] Tinnitus Treatment Guidelines 2019 Edition (Japan Audiology Society)

[0006] The present invention has been made in view of the above-described circumstances, and aims to provide an information processing technique that supports the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy for tinnitus.

[0007] In order to solve the above-mentioned problems, the substitutional thinking support device of the present invention inputs event information that indicates an event that the patient is concerned about in relation to tinnitus, as well as thought information that indicates the thoughts that came to the patient's mind when the event occurred, and presents support information to replace the patient's negative thoughts with other thoughts based on the input event information and thought information.

[0008] According to the present invention configured as described above, when a patient inputs into the substitutional thinking support device the events that concerned them regarding tinnitus and the thoughts that came to their mind at that time, the substitutional thinking support device presents support information to help the patient replace negative thoughts with other thoughts. By following this suggestion, the patient can correct cognitive bias by replacing thoughts that tend to be negative with other thoughts. This can support the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy for tinnitus.

[0009] 1 is a block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of an alternative thinking support device according to a first embodiment. FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of an event input IF. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of a thought input IF. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion degree input IF. FIG. 4 is a diagram showing a specific example of advice and example sentences presented in accordance with event information and thought information. FIG. 5 is a diagram showing a specific example of advice and example sentences presented in accordance with event information and thought information. FIG. 6 is a diagram showing a specific example of advice and example sentences presented in accordance with event information and thought information. FIG. 7 is a diagram showing a specific example of advice and example sentences presented in accordance with event information and thought information. FIG. 8 is a diagram showing a specific example of advice and example sentences presented in accordance with event information and thought information. FIG. 9 is a diagram showing a specific example of a screen presented when the degree of painful emotion is equal to or lower than a predetermined level. FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a screen presented when the degree of painful emotion is greater than a predetermined level. FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion change input IF. FIG. 12 is a diagram showing an example of a follow message display screen. FIG. 13 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation of an alternative thinking support device according to this embodiment. FIG. 14 is a block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of an alternative thinking support device according to a second embodiment. FIG. 15 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion selection IF according to the second embodiment. FIG. 16 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion degree input IF according to the second embodiment. FIG. 17 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion change input IF according to the second embodiment.

[0010] (First Embodiment) A first embodiment of the present invention will now be described with reference to the drawings. Fig. 1 is a block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of an alternative thinking support device 10 according to the first embodiment. As shown in Fig. 1, the alternative thinking support device 10 according to the first embodiment includes, as its functional configuration, an event information input unit 11, a thought information input unit 12, an emotion level information input unit 13, a support information presentation unit 14, an emotion change information input unit 15, and a follow-up information presentation unit 16.

[0011] The functional blocks 11 to 16 can be configured using any of hardware, a DSP (Digital Signal Processor), and software. For example, when configured using software, the functional blocks 11 to 16 are actually configured with a computer's CPU, RAM, ROM, etc., and are realized by the operation of a program stored in a recording medium such as the RAM, ROM, hard disk, or semiconductor memory.

[0012] For example, the alternative thinking support device 10 is configured by an information processing device such as a smartphone, a personal computer, or a tablet, and an alternative thinking support program is installed on the information processing device. The alternative thinking support program is a type of therapeutic app that utilizes cognitive behavioral therapy to support the treatment of illnesses through lifestyle improvements, such as reviewing daily behavior and ways of thinking (hereinafter, the alternative thinking support program will also be referred to as an alternative thinking support app). The processes provided by the above-mentioned functional blocks 11 to 16 are executed by the installed alternative thinking support program operating under the control of a CPU.

[0013] The event information input unit 11 inputs event information representing events that the patient finds concerning regarding tinnitus. For example, the event information input unit 11 displays a user interface (hereinafter referred to as the event input IF) of an event selection list containing multiple pieces of event information on a screen, and inputs event information representing events selected by the patient through the event input IF. For example, the event information input unit 11 displays the event input IF on the screen of an alternative thinking support app once a week, allowing the patient to select something that has bothered them over the past week. Because asking the patient every day can be bothersome and may worsen the psychiatric symptoms associated with tinnitus, it is preferable to input event information about once a week.

[0014] The options included in the event selection list are of the following types (hereinafter, E1 to E6 may be referred to as event types): It is preferable that the number of options included in the event selection list be around 5 to 10. E1) Not applicable E2) Related to the condition E3) Related to the impact on life E4) Related to the impact on the future E5) Related to accompanying comorbid symptoms E6) Related to knowledge of the disease

[0015] Fig. 2 shows an example of an event input IF. In the example of Fig. 2, eight options are displayed: "It doesn't bother me," "The tinnitus suddenly got louder," "The tinnitus bothered me more than usual," "I couldn't concentrate because of the tinnitus," "I worried about the future," "I had trouble sleeping," "I hesitated to do fun things," and "I was worried about the cause of the tinnitus."

[0016] The thought information input unit 12 inputs thought information representing thoughts that come to the patient's mind when the event selected by the event information input unit 11 occurs. For example, when an event is selected from the event selection list shown in FIG. 2 and the Next button is pressed, the thought information input unit 12 displays a user interface (hereinafter referred to as the thought input IF) of a thought selection list containing multiple thoughts on the screen, and inputs thought information representing the thought selected by the patient through the thought input IF. "Thoughts that come to mind" refers to thoughts that come to the patient's mind automatically when an event occurs. "Automatic thoughts" refers to thoughts that arise automatically, regardless of one's will. The aim is to change the patient's emotions by transforming these thoughts in the subsequent process.

[0017] Here, if an option ("Nothing to worry about") classified as event type E1 ("None") is selected by the event information input unit 11, the thought information input unit 12 does not execute the process, and the intervention process for the patient is terminated. This is because it is not useful to have a patient who does not actually have any events that concern them practice alternative thinking. On the other hand, if an option classified as event types E2 to E6 is selected by the event information input unit 11, the thought information input unit 12 executes the process.

[0018] The thought information input unit 12 determines multiple pieces of thought information to be included in the thought selection list according to the event information input by the event information input unit 11. For example, a thought selection list of thought types C2 to C6 is constructed for each of the event types E2 to E6. Then, the thought information input unit 12 presents one of the thought selection lists of thought types C2 to C6 according to which of the event types E2 to E6 the event information input by the event information input unit 11 corresponds to. It is preferable that each thought list contains around 3 to 10 options.

[0019] Each of the thought selection lists for thought types C2 to C6 includes negative thought information representing negative thoughts and non-negative thought information representing thoughts that are not negative (e.g., neutral thoughts). Here, negative thoughts refer to "negative, dismissive, introverted, withdrawn, pessimistic, and other thoughts that are directed in a negative direction," and are also called negative thoughts. The neutral thought options are based on example thoughts presented by the support information presenting unit 14, which will be described later. This is because the example thoughts are thoughts that neutrally capture the event selected by the event information input unit 11.

[0020] The thought selection list for each of the thought types C2 to C6 can be configured, for example, as follows:

[0021] C2) Thought selection list presented when event information classified as event type E2 "medical condition related" is selected 1. Options representing neutral thoughts 2. Options representing negative thoughts a. Worrying about further worsening b. Believing that the condition is getting worse over time c. Believing that future improvement is unlikely d. Wanting to escape e. Expressing disgust at having unpleasant feelings f. Expressing anger about tinnitus g. Worried about not being able to rest physically and mentally and affecting daily life

[0022] C3) Thought selection list presented when event information classified as event type E3 "related to impact on daily life" is selected 1. Options representing neutral thoughts 2. Options representing negative thoughts a. Believing that one is unable to perform necessary activities in daily life b. Believing that one must give up activities or goals in daily life c. Believing that necessary or enjoyable activities in daily life are less enjoyable than before d. Believing that necessary or enjoyable activities in daily life make one's tinnitus worse

[0023] C4) Thought selection list presented when event information classified as event type E4 "regarding future impact" is selected 1. Options representing neutral thoughts 2. Options representing negative thoughts a. Those who believe that tinnitus will cause them to suffer from other illnesses b. Those who believe that tinnitus will reduce their happiness in future life c. Those who believe that tinnitus causes them to feel excessive stress or depression

[0024] C5) Thought selection list presented when event information classified as event type E5 "related to concomitant symptoms" is selected 1. Options representing neutral thoughts 2. Options representing negative thoughts a. Those who believe that tinnitus is causing them to not get enough sleep b. Those who believe that not being able to sleep due to tinnitus is interfering with their daily lives c. Those who believe that tinnitus is getting worse before and after sleep

[0025] C6) Thought selection list presented when event information classified as event type E6 "related to disease knowledge" is selected 1. Options representing neutral thoughts 2. Options representing negative thoughts a. Those who believe it is a sign of a serious disease other than tinnitus b. Those who believe that the sensory organs around the ear are damaged c. Those who are thinking of seeking measures that they are not aware of

[0026] Fig. 3 is a diagram showing an example of a thought input IF. The example in Fig. 3 shows an example of a thought selection list presented when the event information "My tinnitus suddenly got louder" classified as event type E2 is selected. Five options are displayed: "That happens sometimes," "It's getting louder and louder. I wonder what will happen in the future," "It's worse than before," "It's gotten louder and won't go back to normal. This is the worst," and "I'm worried about how far it will go."

[0027] The thought selection list is preferably set so that the ratio of negative to non-negative thought information falls within a predetermined range. For example, the ratio of options representing negative thoughts to options representing neutral thoughts is set to approximately 1:1 to 4:1. A high ratio of negative options increases the likelihood that patients will make negative choices, potentially making it difficult for patients to feel that they are perceiving events with neutral thoughts. On the other hand, if the number of negative options is too few or the range of negative concepts covered is too narrow, patients may be unable to select their own thoughts as personal concerns, potentially reducing the effectiveness of treatment. Therefore, it is preferable to configure the thought selection list so that the number of negative options is neither too large nor too small.

[0028] The emotion degree information input unit 13 inputs emotion degree information that indicates the degree of distress of the patient when the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12 corresponds to a negative thought. Here, when the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12 corresponds to a neutral thought, the emotion degree information input unit 13 does not execute processing and the intervention process for the patient is terminated. This is because it is not useful to have a patient who perceives events with neutral thoughts practice alternative thinking.

[0029] A painful emotion refers to an emotion that arises as a result of a negative automatic thought that the patient has. For example, when a negative thought is selected from the thought selection list shown in Figure 3 and the next button is pressed, the emotion level information input unit 13 displays on the screen a user interface (hereinafter referred to as emotion level input IF) that allows the user to select the degree of pain, and the degree of pain of the patient is input through the emotion level input IF.

[0030] Fig. 4 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion level input IF. The emotion level input IF shown in Fig. 4 shows an example in which the degree of distress of a patient is input using a VAS (Visual Analogue Scale). The VAS is a visual scale indicating the degree of distress, with 0% representing "not distressed at all" and 100% representing "the most distressing of my life." The example in Fig. 4 shows a scale in which the degree of distress can be selected in 11 stages from 0% to 100%.

[0031] In addition, in the emotion level input IF in Figure 4, specific examples of emotions such as "sad, lonely, anxious, depressed, irritated, depressed, tense, frustrated, and resigned" are listed and displayed to make it easier for patients to recall their emotions.

[0032] The support information presenting unit 14 presents support information for substituting another thought for the patient's negative thought, according to the event information input by the event information input unit 11 and the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12. For example, when the emotion level information input by the emotion level information input unit 13 indicates that the degree of distress is greater than a predetermined level, the support information presenting unit 14 presents an example sentence of another thought to substitute for the patient's negative thought and encourages the patient to read it aloud. On the other hand, when the degree of distress is indicated to be equal to or less than the predetermined level, the support information presenting unit 14 presents the example sentence and ends the intervention.

[0033] For example, the support information presenting unit 14 determines whether the VAS response input by the emotion level information input unit 13 is 0-30% or 40-100%. If the VAS response is 0-30% (corresponding to a case where the emotion level information input by the emotion level information input unit 13 indicates that the degree of distress is below a predetermined level), the support information presenting unit 14 only presents example sentences of alternative thoughts to replace the patient's negative thoughts, without displaying a prompt to read aloud. Patients whose VAS response is 0-30% can be considered to have a low level of tinnitus interference in their daily lives. Furthermore, because the level of distress is low, there is little room for improvement, and the patient may not fully realize the improvement. Therefore, the support information presenting unit 14 presents example sentences and terminates the intervention. In this case, the emotion change information input unit 15 and the follow-up information presenting unit 16 do not execute their processing. Alternatively, the intervention may be terminated by displaying other advice information without presenting example sentences.

[0034] Note that the numerical values ​​shown here are merely examples. For example, the VAS response may be determined to be 0-20% or 30-100%, or 0-10% or 20-100%, or 0-40% or 50-100%. While FIG. 4 shows an example in which the VAS response is made in 10% increments from 0 to 100%, the VAS response may be made in any increments, such as 5% or 1%, and the value corresponding to that increment may be used as a boundary to determine whether the degree of distress is below a predetermined level.

[0035] Specifically, the support information presenting unit 14 presents a plurality of example sentences. At this time, the support information presenting unit 14 presents a plurality of example sentences whose contents correspond to the event information input by the event information input unit 11 and the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12. Advice information may also be presented together with the example sentences. FIGS. 5A to 5D are diagrams showing specific examples of advice and example sentences presented according to event information and thought information. FIG. 6 is a diagram showing an example screen presented by the support information presenting unit 14 when the VAS response is 0 to 30%. Here, four example sentences based on neutral thinking are presented.

[0036] On the other hand, patients whose VAS response is 40-100% can be considered to be patients whose tinnitus has a significant impact on their daily lives. Furthermore, because of their high level of distress, there is significant room for improvement, and they are considered to be patients who would benefit from more in-depth intervention. Therefore, when the VAS response is 40-100% (corresponding to a case where the emotion level information input by the emotion level information input unit 13 indicates that the level of distress is greater than a predetermined level), the support information presenting unit 14 presents multiple example sentences and encourages the patient to select one of them (a thought that the patient can try) and read it aloud. The advice and example sentences presented when the VAS response is 40-100% may be the same as the advice and example sentences presented when the VAS response is 0-30%.

[0037] Figure 7 shows an example screen presented by the support information presenter 14 when the VAS response rate is between 40 and 100%. The example screen shown in Figure 7 prompts the patient to reminisce about the scene in which an event selected from the event selection list occurred, imagine it, and then mutter aloud a sample sentence three times. It is said that when a patient replaces a negative thought with another thought, it takes about 10 to 15 seconds for them to realize the resulting emotional transformation. Therefore, by having the patient mutter a sample alternative thought aloud three times, the aim is to force the patient to ruminate the sample sentence in their head for 10 to 15 seconds.

[0038] The emotion change information input unit 15 inputs emotion change information that indicates how the patient's painful emotions have changed after reading aloud another example thought. For example, when the patient reads aloud another example thought and then presses the Next button on the screen shown in Fig. 7, the emotion change information input unit 15 displays a user interface (hereinafter referred to as emotion change input IF) of an emotion change selection list that includes multiple pieces of emotion change information on the screen, and inputs emotion change information that indicates the change in emotion selected by the patient through the emotion change input IF.

[0039] Fig. 8 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion change input IF. The emotion change input IF shown in Fig. 8 is a screen for selecting from options how the resulting emotion has changed after reading aloud an example sentence, and displays four options: "greatly improved," "improved," "slightly improved," and "no change." Since it is best to prevent the patient from thinking "nothing has changed," three options are set, each representing a different degree of improvement.

[0040] While the emotion level information before reading aloud the sample sentences is input using a VAS, the emotion change information after reading aloud is input by selecting from the four options mentioned above. This is because what we want the patient to recognize is the amount of change in emotion, not the absolute value of the degree of emotion. It is possible to input emotion level information using a VAS both before and after reading aloud and recognize the difference, but because there is a possibility that the patient may not accurately remember what answer they gave on the first VAS, emotion change information is input in the form of a selection from four options.

[0041] The follow-up information presenting unit 16 presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with the emotion change information input by the emotion change information input unit 15. Fig. 9 is a diagram showing an example of a follow-up message display screen. Fig. 9(a) shows an example of a screen presented when "Nothing changed" is selected from the emotion change selection list. In this example screen, a follow-up message is displayed to prevent the patient from becoming depressed, such as by reassuring the patient that there is no need to worry even if they are unable to successfully substitute their thoughts, or by praising the patient for having read aloud the sample sentences.

[0042] 9(b) shows an example of a screen that is presented when one of "greatly improved," "improved," or "slightly improved" is selected from the emotion change selection list. In this case, a follow-up message is displayed praising the successful implementation of thought substitution.

[0043] Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation of the alternative thinking support device 10 according to the first embodiment configured as described above. The process of the flowchart shown in Fig. 10 is started, for example, when the alternative thinking support app measures the elapsed time since the previous process execution in the background and the elapsed time reaches one week. At the start of the process shown in Fig. 10, the alternative thinking support app may send a predetermined push notification to prompt the patient to start the process. In this case, the process of the flowchart shown in Fig. 10 starts when the patient instructs the start of the process in response to the push notification.

[0044] First, the event information input unit 11 inputs event information representing an event that concerns the patient regarding tinnitus (step S1). That is, the event information input unit 11 displays the event input IF illustrated in Fig. 2 on the screen, and inputs event information representing an event selected by the patient through the event input IF.

[0045] Next, the event information input unit 11 determines whether the event information input through the event input IF corresponds to an option classified as event type E1 (step S2). If it is determined that an option classified as event type E1 has been selected, the processing of the flowchart shown in Fig. 10 is terminated without executing the subsequent processes. That is, if an event classified as event type E1 is selected in the event selection list exemplified in Fig. 2 and the Next button is pressed, a predetermined end message is displayed and the intervention process for the patient is terminated.

[0046] On the other hand, if the event information input through the event input IF does not correspond to an option classified as event type E1, that is, if the event information input unit 11 determines that the event information corresponds to an option classified as one of event types E2 to E6, the thought information input unit 12 inputs thought information that represents the thought that occurred to the patient when the selected event occurred (step S3). That is, if an event classified as one of event types E2 to E6 is selected in the event selection list shown in Fig. 2 and the next button is pressed, the thought information input unit 12 displays the thought input IF shown in Fig. 3 on the screen and inputs the patient's thought information through the thought input IF.

[0047] Next, the thought information input unit 12 determines whether the thought information input through the thought input IF corresponds to a neutral thought (step S4). If it is determined that a neutral thought has been selected, the process of the flowchart shown in Fig. 10 ends without executing the subsequent processes. That is, if a neutral thought is selected and the Next button is pressed in the thought input IF exemplified in Fig. 3, a predetermined end message is displayed, and the intervention process for the patient ends.

[0048] On the other hand, if the thought information input unit 12 determines that the thought information input through the thought input IF does not correspond to a neutral thought, i.e., corresponds to a negative thought, the emotion degree information input unit 13 inputs emotion degree information indicating the degree of the patient's painful emotion (step S5). That is, if a negative thought is selected in the thought input IF illustrated in Fig. 3 and the next button is pressed, the emotion degree information input unit 13 displays the emotion degree input IF illustrated in Fig. 4 on the screen and inputs the patient's emotion degree information through the emotion degree input IF.

[0049] Next, the support information presenting unit 14 determines whether the emotion level information input by the emotion level information input unit 13 indicates that the degree of distress of the patient is below a predetermined level (whether the VAS response is 30% or less) (step S6). If it is determined that the VAS response is 30% or less, the support information presenting unit 14 presents an example of a thought to replace the patient's negative thought on the screen shown in Fig. 6 (step S7), and ends the processing of the flowchart shown in Fig. 10. That is, if the Next button is pressed on the screen shown in Fig. 6, a predetermined end message is displayed, and the intervention process for the patient is ended.

[0050] On the other hand, if it is determined that the VAS response is not 30% or less, i.e., is 40% or more, the support information presenting unit 14 presents example sentences of alternative thoughts to replace the patient's negative thoughts on the screen shown in FIG. 7, and prompts the patient to select one of them and read it aloud (step S8).

[0051] Thereafter, when the Next button is pressed on the screen shown in Fig. 7, the emotion change information input unit 15 inputs emotion change information indicating how the patient's painful emotions have changed after reading aloud another example thought (step S9). That is, the emotion change information input unit 15 displays the emotion change input IF shown in Fig. 8 on the screen, and inputs emotion change information indicating the change in emotion selected by the patient through the emotion change input IF.

[0052] Next, the follow-up information presenting unit 16 determines whether the emotion change information input by the emotion change information input unit 15 corresponds to an improvement-related option (step S10). If it is determined that the emotion change information corresponds to an improvement-related option, the follow-up information presenting unit 16 displays a follow-up message praising the successful implementation of the thought substitution (step S11).

[0053] On the other hand, if the input emotion change information does not correspond to an improvement-related option, i.e., if the option indicating no change in emotion is selected, the follow-up information presenting unit 16 displays a follow-up message to prevent the patient from becoming depressed (step S12). After displaying the follow-up message in step S11 or S12, when the next button is pressed on the display screen, the follow-up information presenting unit 16 displays a predetermined end message and ends the processing of the flowchart shown in FIG.

[0054] As explained in detail above, in the first embodiment, the patient inputs event information that indicates an event that concerns them regarding tinnitus, and also inputs thought information that indicates the thoughts that came to the patient's mind when the event occurred, and, depending on the input event information and thought information, support information (examples of neutral thoughts and advice) is presented to replace the patient's negative thoughts with other thoughts.

[0055] According to the first embodiment configured in this way, when a patient inputs into the substitutional thinking support app the events that concern them regarding tinnitus and the thoughts that come to mind at that time, the substitutional thinking support app presents support information for the patient to replace negative thoughts with other thoughts. By following this presentation, the patient can correct cognitive bias by replacing thoughts that tend to be negative with other thoughts. In this way, according to the first embodiment, it is possible to support the implementation of cognitive behavioral therapy for tinnitus.

[0056] In addition, in the first embodiment, examples of neutral thoughts that can replace the patient's negative thoughts are presented and the patient is encouraged to read them aloud. Then, emotion change information indicating how the reading aloud has changed the patient's painful emotions is input, and a follow-up message with content corresponding to the input emotion change information is displayed. According to the first embodiment configured in this way, the patient can be strongly encouraged to practice alternative thinking. Furthermore, by presenting the patient with an appropriate follow-up message depending on the results of the practice, the patient can be motivated to continue treatment using the alternative thinking support app.

[0057] Second Embodiment A second embodiment of the present invention will now be described with reference to the drawings. Fig. 11 is a block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of an alternative thinking support device 10' according to the second embodiment. In Fig. 11, components with the same reference numerals as those shown in Fig. 1 have the same functions, and therefore will not be described again here.

[0058] As shown in Figure 11, the alternative thinking support device 10' according to the second embodiment has, as its functional configuration, an event information input unit 11, a thinking information input unit 12, an emotion level information input unit 13', a support information presentation unit 14', an emotion change information input unit 15' and a follow-up information presentation unit 16'.

[0059] The functional blocks 11, 12, 13' to 16' can be configured using any of hardware, DSP, and software. For example, when configured using software, the functional blocks 11, 12, 13' to 16' are actually configured with a computer's CPU, RAM, ROM, etc., and are realized by the operation of a program stored in a recording medium such as the RAM, ROM, hard disk, or semiconductor memory.

[0060] The emotion degree information input unit 13' inputs emotion degree information that indicates the degree of distress for each type of distress emotion of the patient when the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12 corresponds to a negative thought. Here, when the thought information input by the thought information input unit 12 corresponds to a neutral thought, the emotion degree information input unit 13' does not execute processing, and the intervention process for the patient is terminated.

[0061] In the second embodiment, as an example, emotion level information is input for each type of distress emotion prepared in advance. For example, an emotion selection list showing multiple types of emotions is presented to the patient, and emotion level information indicating the degree of distress for one or more emotions selected by the patient is input.

[0062] Specifically, when a negative thought is selected in the thought selection list shown in Fig. 3 and the Next button is pressed, the emotion degree information input unit 13' displays a user interface (hereinafter referred to as emotion selection IF) on the screen that allows the patient to select an emotion. Then, when the patient selects the type of painful emotion through this emotion selection IF, the emotion degree information input unit 13' displays an emotion degree input IF on the screen that allows the patient to select the degree of pain, and the patient inputs the degree of pain through the emotion degree input IF.

[0063] Fig. 12 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion selection IF according to the second embodiment. The emotion selection IF shown in Fig. 12 displays nine types of emotions along with facial expression icons, and the patient is prompted to select one to three emotions from the nine emotions. The patient selects an emotion by touching one to three facial expression icons, starting with the most painful emotion, for example, and then confirms the selection by pressing the Next button.

[0064] Fig. 13 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion degree input IF according to the second embodiment. The emotion degree input IF shown in Fig. 13 shows an example in which the patient inputs the degree of distressing emotion using a VAS for the emotion selected through the emotion selection IF shown in Fig. 12. Fig. 13 shows an example of an emotion degree input IF displayed when the patient selects three emotions, "sad," "anxiety," and "irritation." Although this shows an example of an input IF in which the degree of distressing emotions of multiple types is input on a single screen, emotion degree input IFs similar to those shown in Fig. 4 may be displayed by sequentially switching only the number of selected emotion types.

[0065] When the emotion level information input for each type of distress emotion by the emotion level information input unit 13' indicates that the degree of distress emotion is greater than a predetermined level, the support information presenting unit 14' presents an example of a thought to replace the patient's negative thought and encourages the patient to read it aloud. On the other hand, when the degree of distress emotion is indicated to be equal to or less than the predetermined level, the support information presenting unit 14' presents an example of a thought and ends the intervention.

[0066] For example, when at least one type of emotion degree information among the emotion degree information input for each type of painful emotion by the emotion degree information input unit 13' indicates that the degree of the painful emotion is greater than a predetermined level, the support information presenting unit 14' presents another example of thinking sentence to encourage reading aloud.

[0067] As an example, the support information presenting unit 14' determines whether the VAS responses input for each type of distressing emotion by the emotion level information input unit 13' are 0-30% or 40-100%. If the VAS responses for all selected emotions are 0-30%, the support information presenting unit 14' only presents example sentences of other thoughts and does not display a prompt for reading aloud. The screen presented in this case may be similar to that shown in FIG. 6. On the other hand, if the VAS response for at least one of the selected emotions is 40-100%, the support information presenting unit 14' presents example sentences and prompts the user to read aloud. The screen presented in this case may be similar to that shown in FIG. 7.

[0068] As another example, the support information presenting unit 14' may calculate an emotion score using a predetermined function using the emotion level information input for each type of distressing emotion by the emotion level information input unit 13', and if the calculated emotion score indicates that the degree of distressing emotion is greater than a predetermined level, present another example thought sentence to encourage reading aloud. One example of the predetermined function is a function that calculates the average value of the VAS values ​​input for each type of distressing emotion. If the calculated average value is greater than a threshold value (e.g., 30%), the support information presenting unit 14' may present another example thought sentence to encourage reading aloud.

[0069] The emotion change information input unit 15' inputs, for each type of painful emotion of the patient, emotion change information that indicates how the painful emotion has changed after the patient reads aloud another example thought. For example, when the patient reads aloud another example thought and then presses the next button on the screen shown in Figure 7, the emotion change information input unit 15' displays an emotion change input IF on the screen and inputs emotion change information that indicates the change in emotion selected by the patient through the emotion change input IF.

[0070] Fig. 14 is a diagram showing an example of an emotion change input IF according to the second embodiment. The emotion change input IF shown in Fig. 14 , like the emotion level input IF shown in Fig. 13 , shows an example in which the patient's level of distress is input using a VAS for each of one to three emotions selected by the patient. While this example shows an input IF in which the level of multiple types of distress is input on a single screen, an emotion change input IF configured in the same way as Fig. 4 may be configured to sequentially switch and display only the selected types of emotions.

[0071] The VAS value input through the emotion change input IF after reading aloud is used as emotion change information for the VAS value input through the emotion level input IF before reading aloud. That is, by comparing the VAS value input before reading aloud with the VAS value input after reading aloud, three types of emotion changes can occur: an improvement in the degree of distress, no change, or a worsening of the degree of distress.

[0072] The follow-up information presenting unit 16' presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with the emotion change information input by the emotion change information input unit 15' for each type of distressing emotion. For example, the follow-up information presenting unit 16' presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with a combination of emotion changes indicated for each type of distressing emotion. The emotion change indicated based on the emotion change information refers to an emotion change captured by comparing the VAS value input after the reading aloud with the VAS value input before the reading aloud, and there are three patterns: "improvement," "unchanged," and "worsening," as described above.

[0073] For example, if the emotional change for all of the distressing emotions selected by the patient is "improvement," a follow-up message is presented praising the patient for successfully implementing thought substitution. Also, if the emotional change for all of the distressing emotions selected by the patient is "unchanged" or "worsened," a follow-up message is presented that reassures the patient that there is no need to worry if thought substitution is not successful, or that praises the patient for even having read aloud the sample sentences. Also, if the emotional changes for the distressing emotions selected by the patient are a mixture of "improvement" and other changes ("unchanged" and / or "worsened"), both a follow-up message regarding "improvement" and a follow-up message regarding "unchanged" and / or "worsened" are presented.

[0074] According to the second embodiment configured as described above, it is possible to identify the emotional changes caused by reading aloud for each type of painful emotion of the patient and present a message to the patient, thereby enabling more detailed support for alternative thinking to be provided.

[0075] In the second embodiment, an example in which emotion change information is input using a VAS value has been described, but the present invention is not limited to this. For example, after reading a sample sentence aloud, emotion change information may be input for each type of painful emotion using an input IF that allows the user to select from options such as "improved," "no change," and "worsened" how the resulting emotion has changed.

[0076] In the first and second embodiments, the patient's tinnitus-related events and thoughts that occurred to the patient when the events occurred were input in the form of selecting options from a selection list, but the present invention is not limited to this. For example, event information may be input in free text format, and the input free text may be analyzed to select the appropriate event type from a list. Furthermore, thought information may be input in free text format, and the input free text may be analyzed to determine whether the thought is neutral or negative, and if it is negative, the appropriate type may be selected from a list.

[0077] As a modification of the first and second embodiments, some or all of the processes of the emotion level information input units 13, 13', emotion change information input units 15, 15', and follow-up information presenting units 16, 16' may not be executed. However, because cognitive behavioral therapy is meaningful to continue and this can be encouraged, it is preferable to execute the processes of the emotion level information input units 13, 13', emotion change information input units 15, 15', and follow-up information presenting units 16, 16'.

[0078] In addition, in the above first and second embodiments, examples of presenting sentences with neutral thoughts as examples to replace the patient's negative thoughts with other thoughts have been described, but sentences with more positive thoughts may also be presented.

[0079] In the first and second embodiments, the alternative thinking support app prompts the patient to perform the training once a week, but the present invention is not limited to this. For example, instead of or in addition to performing the training once a week, the patient may be configured to be able to perform the training at any time of their own volition.

[0080] Furthermore, in the first embodiment, an example has been described in which an alternative thinking support app installed on an information processing device such as a smartphone executes the processing of functional blocks 11 to 16, but the present invention is not limited to this. For example, the information processing device and a server device may be connected via a communication network, and the alternative thinking support app may execute the processing of functional blocks 11 to 16 in cooperation with the server device. For example, the alternative thinking support app may obtain and display the screens illustrated in Figures 2 to 4 and 6 and 7 from the server device.

[0081] For example, each time information is input into the event information input unit 11, the thinking information input unit 12, and the emotion level information input unit 13 of the alternative thinking support app, it may be transmitted to the server device, the server device may appropriately generate the screens of Figures 3, 4, and 6 to 8 based on the received information and transmit them to the alternative thinking support app, and the thinking information input unit 12, the emotion level information input unit 13, the support information presentation unit 14, and the emotion change information input unit 15 of the alternative thinking support app may present these screens to the patient. Similarly, when information is input into the emotion change information input unit 15 of the alternative thinking support app, it may be transmitted to the server device, the server device may generate the screen of Figure 9 based on the received information and transmit it to the alternative thinking support app, and the follow-up information presentation unit 16 of the alternative thinking support app may present this screen to the patient.

[0082] In the second embodiment, an example was described in which an alternative thinking support app installed on an information processing device such as a smartphone executes the processing of function blocks 11, 12, 13' to 16', but the present invention is not limited to this. For example, the information processing device and a server device may be connected via a communication network, and the alternative thinking support app may execute the processing of function blocks 11, 12, 13' to 16' in cooperation with the server device.

[0083] Furthermore, the first and second embodiments are merely examples of specific embodiments for carrying out the present invention, and the technical scope of the present invention should not be construed as being limited thereby. In other words, the present invention can be carried out in various forms without departing from the gist or main characteristics thereof.

[0084] 10, 10' Alternative thinking support device 11 Event information input unit 12 Thought information input unit 13, 13' Emotion level information input unit 14, 14' Support information presentation unit 15, 15' Emotion change information input unit 16, 16' Follow-up information presentation unit

Claims

1. A substitution thought support device comprising: an event information input unit for inputting event information representing events that have concerned the patient regarding tinnitus; a thought information input unit for inputting thought information representing thoughts that come to the patient's mind when the event occurs; and a support information presentation unit for presenting support information for replacing the patient's negative thoughts with different thoughts in accordance with the event information input by the event information input unit and the thought information input by the thought information input unit.

2. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 1, further comprising an emotion degree information input unit which inputs emotion degree information indicating the degree of the patient's distressed emotion when the thought information input by the thought information input unit corresponds to a negative thought, and wherein the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought that replaces the patient's negative thought and encourages the patient to read it aloud when the emotion degree information input by the emotion degree information input unit indicates that the degree of the distressed emotion is greater than a predetermined level.

3. The alternative thinking support device according to claim 2, further comprising: an emotion change information input unit that inputs emotion change information indicating how the painful emotion has changed after the patient reads aloud the example sentence of the other thought; and a follow-up information presentation unit that presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with the emotion change information input by the emotion change information input unit.

4. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 3, characterized in that, when the emotion degree information inputted by the emotion degree information input unit indicates that the degree of the painful emotion is below a predetermined level, the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought to replace the patient's negative thinking, while, when the emotion degree information inputted by the emotion degree information input unit indicates that the degree of the painful emotion is greater than the predetermined level, the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought and encourages the patient to read it aloud, and then executes processing of the emotion change information input unit and the follow-up information presentation unit.

5. The alternative thinking support device according to any one of claims 2 to 4, characterized in that the support information presentation unit presents a number of sample sentences and encourages the user to select one of them and read it aloud.

6. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 5, characterized in that the support information presentation unit presents the plurality of example sentences corresponding to the event information input by the event information input unit and the thought information input by the thought information input unit.

7. The alternative thinking support device described in any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that the event information input unit inputs event information representing an event selected by the patient through a user interface of an event selection list including a plurality of event information, the thought information input unit inputs thought information representing a thought selected by the patient through a user interface of a thought selection list including a plurality of thought information, and the plurality of thought information to be included in the thought selection list are determined according to the event information input by the event information input unit.

8. The alternative thinking support device described in claim 7, characterized in that the multiple thought information includes negative thought information representing negative thoughts and non-negative thought information representing thoughts that are not negative, and the ratio of the negative thought information to the non-negative thought information is set to fall within a predetermined range.

9. The alternative thinking support device according to claim 3, wherein the emotion change information input unit inputs emotion change information representing an emotion change selected by the patient through a user interface of an emotion change selection list including a plurality of pieces of emotion change information.

10. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 2, characterized in that the emotion degree information input unit inputs emotion degree information indicating the degree of the distressing emotion for each type of distressing emotion of the patient when the thought information input by the thought information input unit corresponds to a negative thought, and the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought to encourage reading aloud when the emotion degree information input by the emotion degree information input unit for each type of distressing emotion indicates that the degree of the distressing emotion is greater than a predetermined level.

11. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 10, characterized in that the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought to encourage reading aloud when at least one type of emotion degree information among the emotion degree information input for each type of painful emotion by the emotion degree information input unit indicates that the degree of the painful emotion is greater than a predetermined level.

12. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 10, characterized in that the support information presentation unit presents an example of the alternative thought to encourage reading aloud when the emotion score calculated by a predetermined function using the emotion degree information input for each type of painful emotion by the emotion degree information input unit indicates that the degree of the painful emotion is greater than a predetermined level.

13. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 10, further comprising: an emotion change information input unit that inputs emotion change information indicating how the painful emotion of the patient has changed after the patient reads aloud the example of another thought, for each type of painful emotion of the patient; and a follow-up information presentation unit that presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with the emotion change information input by the emotion change information input unit.

14. The alternative thinking support device as described in claim 13, characterized in that the follow-up information presentation unit presents a follow-up message to the patient in accordance with the combination of emotional changes indicated for each type of painful emotion by the emotional change information.

15. A substitution thought support program that causes a computer to function as: an event information input means for inputting event information representing events that have bothered the patient regarding tinnitus; a thought information input means for inputting thought information representing thoughts that come to the patient's mind when the event occurs; and a support information presentation means for presenting support information to replace the patient's negative thoughts with different thoughts in accordance with the event information input by the event information input means and the thought information input by the thought information input means.

16. A substitution thought support system comprising: an event information input unit for inputting event information representing events that have bothered the patient regarding tinnitus; a thought information input unit for inputting thought information representing thoughts that come to the patient's mind when the event occurs; and a support information presentation unit for presenting support information for replacing the patient's negative thoughts with different thoughts in accordance with the event information input by the event information input unit and the thought information input by the thought information input unit.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Tinnitus rehabilitation system based on sound therapy combined with cognitive behavior therapy and electronic equipment

    CN111420213A

  • State confirmation program

    JP2021117870A

  • System for supporting correction of distorted cognition, method of eliciting user consciousness information and program therefor

    WO2014080585A1