Efficiency monitoring system for production stops of packaging lines

The automated monitoring system for packaging lines addresses the unreliability of current efficiency monitoring by calculating an ideal stop duration based on reference times and recipes, providing a more accurate evaluation and reducing manual intervention, thus enhancing the reliability and efficiency of packaging line performance.

WO2024230914A2PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-14SIDEL PARTICIPATIONS SAS
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/EP2023/062027
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-05
Publication Date
2024-11-14

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current efficiency monitoring systems for packaging lines are unreliable due to factors unrelated to actual efficiency influencing production stop duration, leading to distorted evaluations.

Method used

An automated monitoring system that calculates an ideal stop duration by removing non-technical factors from the actual duration, using a reference time to repair value based on previous stops, causes, or recipes, to provide a more accurate evaluation of line efficiency.

Benefits of technology

The system offers a reliable monitoring method that accurately reflects the packaging line's performance by filtering out irrelevant factors, reducing manual intervention, and optimizing operator work, while being easily implementable in existing machinery.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 000021
    Figure 000021
  • Figure 000022
    Figure 000022
  • Figure 000023
    Figure 000023
Patent Text Reader
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001]“EFFICIENCY MONITORING SYSTEM FOR PRODUCTION STOPS OF PACKAGING LINES” TECHNICAL FIELD The present invention relates to an efficiency monitoring system for pourable product packaging lines. In the field of packaging lines, which notoriously comprise a plurality of machines, it is known to face stops of production which can be due to specific causes. The production restarts after a time interval which is dependent on the efficiency of the human and material resources of the line. Currently, the efficiency of the line is monitored with methods which are at risk of distorting the evaluation, as the duration of the time interval can be affected by factors which are not related to the actual efficiency. SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION A monitoring method according to present description or according to any of the appended method claims, is more reliable than the current methods. A monitoring system according to the present description or according to any of the system claims is configured for performing a method according to present description or according to any of the method claims. An apparatus according to the present description or according to any of the apparatus claims comprises a system according to present description or according to any of the system claims. The following detailed description is referred to a possible embodiment of a monitoring system according to present description, a possible embodiment of an apparatus according to present description, and a possible embodiment of a method according to present description. In the possible embodiment of the apparatus, the apparatus corresponds to a line comprising a plurality of machines. Anyway, the apparatus may alternatively correspond to a single machine. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING The following detailed description is referred to the appended drawings, in which: - Figure 1 shows a schematic plan view of the line - Figure 2 shows a schematic plan view of a group of lines, each of which can have one or more features of the line of Figure 1, or all the features of the line of Figure 1; and - Figure 3 is a schematic representation of the method and shows a first generic type of value which can be used in the method; - Figure 4 is a schematic representation of the method and shows a second type of value which can be used in the method and which is more specific than the value of Figure - Figure 5 is a schematic representation of the method and shows another value of the second type; - Figure 6 is a schematic representation of the method and shows a third type of value which can be used in the method and which is more specific than the value of Figures 4 and 5; - Figure 7 is a schematic representation of the method and shows a fourth type of value which can be used in the method and which is more specific than the value of Figure 6. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EXEMPLARY EMBODIMENTS The system 2 is for monitoring the efficiency a line 1 for packaging a pourable product. The system 2 is configured for automatically carrying out a monitoring process which, for each production stop of the line which is based on alarm, comprises an operative sequence. The line 1 is indicated in Figure 1. Each stop is triggered by a respective alarm, and therefore each stop is a stop based on alarm. The alarm is triggered by a problem. The alarm can be triggered automatically or manually. The alarm can be for example triggered automatically, based on an automatic detection of the problem, for example by means of a sensor. The alarm can alternatively be triggered manually. The problem can be considered a cause of the alarm. In Figure 3 the axis of the ordinates is indicated with “Alarm” because each stop is triggered by an alarm. The axis of the ordinates can be considered as the axis representing the history of alarms and therefore of the stops of the production. The cause of the alarm can be for example any one or more of the following: lack of raw material; a jamming of containers; failure of one of components of the machines, for example an incorrect application of the labels; a mould not correctly closed in a blowing machine; incorrect closure of a door; incorrect start-up process; conveyors which are not correctly positioned. The cause can be also a specific operation which need to be carried out by an operator to ensure a correct or a more correct production. The line may comprise one or more of the following: a filling machine F, for filling the containers with the product; a machine for producing the containers, which can be for example a blowing machine B for forming for example plastic containers starting from preforms; a decoration machine, for decorating the containers, which can be for example a labelling machine L; a capping machine for capping the containers; a packing machine; a palletizing machine; a wrapping machine; a depallettizing machine; a crating machine; a decrating machine; a washing machine for washing the containers; a rinsing machine for rinsing the containers; a cooling machine for cooling the containers. The containers may be for example bottles or cans or flacons or jars or kegs. The bottles may be for example plastic bottles or glass bottles. The pourable product may be a pourable food product. The product may be sparkling water, a soft drink, beer, natural water, fruit juice, wine, tea, milk, flavored water, an emulsion, a suspension, a high viscosity liquid, or a drink containing pulp and / or solid pieces. The product may alternatively be a product for home and personal care. The line 1 comprises the system 2. The system 2 may comprise an automatic control unit ECU, which may comprise at least one processing module and / or at least one memory. The system 2 may comprise a user interface for presenting the results of the monitoring, and in particular for informing the user about the monitored efficiency. The line 1 may belong to a group G of lines. The group is indicated in Figure 2. The group G comprises also a second line 1’ and a third line 1’’. The system 2 is configured for automatically informing a user about the monitored efficiency. The operative sequence comprises detecting an actual duration AD of the stop. The actual duration AD is indicated in Figures from 3 to 7. The operative sequence comprises, if the actual duration AD is bigger than a reference time to repair value RTTR, calculating an ideal duration ID of the stop by removing from the actual duration AD an exceeding part EP. The exceeding part EP is the part of the actual duration AD which exceeds a reference time to repair RTTR value. The ideal duration ID and the exceeding part EP are indicated in Figures from 3 to 7. The operative sequence comprises updating the efficiency of the monitored line by means of the ideal duration ID, or, if the actual duration AD is not bigger than the reference time to repair value RTTR, by means of the actual duration AD. The reference time to repair value RTTR is a value based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops. In this way, the relevance of not technical factors is lower, to provide a monitoring system which is more reliable and is configured for performing a more reliable monitoring activity for monitoring the efficiency of the line. In particular, the system is configured for automatically cleaning the data which are not related to the actual efficiency, without manual interaction of the operator. By removing the exceeding part EP, anomalous durations can be automatically cleaned or filtered. In case that the stop of the machine is shorter than the reference time to repair RTTR value, than the alarm is considered correct to be considered in the line efficiency performance evaluation. In a first variant, the system 2 may be configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for each specific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes. In this first variant, for each process, the operative sequence is performed for each stop which is caused by the respective cause. Moreover, in this first variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is a value associated to the respective cause. In this first variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops which have been caused by the respective cause. A reference time to repair value associated to a first cause is represented by the value RTTR1 in Figure 4. A reference time to repair value associated to a second cause is represented by the value RTTR2 in Figure 5. In Figure 4, the axis of ordinates is indicated with “ALARM1” because the stops of Figure 4 are caused by the first cause. In Figure 5, the axis of ordinates is indicated with “ALARM2” because the stops of Figure 5 are cause by the second cause. In this way, the method is more accurate in detecting a variation of the efficiency depending on the cause of the stop, or more sensitive to said variation. In a second variant, the system may be configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for each specific production recipe among a plurality of a production recipes. In this second variant, for each process, the operative sequence is performed for each stop which occurs during production with the respective recipe. Moreover, in this second variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is a value associated to the respective recipe. In this second variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops which have occurred during production with the respective recipe. This second variant is not shown, but falls within the terms of the generic example, to which Figure 3 is referred. In this way, the method is more accurate in detecting a variation of efficiency depending on the recipe, or more sensitive to said variation. In a third variant, which is a combination of the first variant and the second variant, the system 2 may be configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for each combination between a specific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes and a specific production recipe among a plurality of recipes. In this third variant, for each process, the operative sequence is performed for each stop which is caused by the respective cause and which occurs during production with the respective recipe. Moreover, in this third variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is a value associated to the respective combination. In this third variant, for each process the respective reference time to repair value is based on the actual durations of a reference set of stops which have been caused by the respective cause and which have occurred during production with the respective recipe. In this way, the method is more accurate in detecting a variation of efficiency depending both on the cause of the stop and on the recipe, or more sensitive to said variation. For example, it may be that the line 1 is configured for packaging the pourable product according to any of a plurality of recipes. The recipe is defined for example by any one or more of the following: type of container; format of container; material of container; type of cap; format of cap; material of cap; type of decoration or label of the container; format of decoration or label of the container; material of decoration or label of the container; type of product; nature of product; physical properties of the product; chemical properties of the product. The refence time to repair value of Figure 7, which is represented by RTTRG2R3, is associated to the combination given by the second cause, indicated by “2”, and the specific recipe “R3”. In Figure 7, the axis of ordinates is indicated with “ALARM2” because the stops of Figure 7 are caused by the second cause. In any of the above variants, or in the generic example, the reference time to repair value may be based on a reference set of previous stops of the lines of the group G. In Figure 6, for example, the reference time to repair value is indicated with RTTRG2, where "G” is related to the value being based on the group G, and 2 is related to the second cause. Also in the case shown in Figure 7, the letter "G” in RTTRG2R3 stands for the group G. RTTRG2 of Figure 6 is a reference time to repair value based on the group of lines G and associated to the second cause of Figure 5. RTTRG2R3 of Figure 7 is a reference time to repair value based on the group of lines G, associated to the second cause of Figure 5, and associated to the recipe “R3”. For example, a reference time to repair value which is based on the group can be a value which has been calculated using a sub set of previous stops of the line 1, a sub set of previous stops of the second line 1’ and a sub set of previous stops of the third line 1’’. The system 2 may be configured for automatically obtaining automatically the current recipe. The system 2 may be configured for automatically obtaining or detecting the cause of the stop, for example by means of an automatic alarm system. The system 2 may be configured for monitoring the efficiency of the group G by monitoring the efficiency of each line of the group G. The method comprises the steps mentioned above. The method can serve to monitor the efficiency of the group G. The reference time to repair value is calculated by means of a statistical approach or a statistical model, based on the reference set of stops. Alternatively or in addition, the reference time to repair value may be calculated by means of a machine learning model, based on the reference set of stops. The machine and the packaging line 1 disclosed above have a plurality of advantages. The system is configured for carrying out a monitoring process which results in a detected efficiency which is very close to the actual efficiency. Firstly, the efficiency monitoring system 2 permits to achieve an overview of the performance of the packaging line 1, which is very close to the reality. In other words, the use of the reference time to repair value RTTR allows to calculate a time interval which is closer (in particular correspond) to the real time (namely the effective time) which has been needed to fix the problem and restart the production, without taking into account the additional time periods not correlated to the fixing of the problem (cause) itself. In particular, the system 2 permits to study the distribution of the duration concerning to each type of alarm so as to achieve the mean time to repair, namely the average time to repair this specific alarm. The monitoring system 2 permits also to recognize, which parameter influences said alarm. For example, it is possible to obtain a correlation between the operational step of the packaging line 1 and the occurrence of the alarm. Therefore, the efficiency monitoring system 2 is very accurate in the evaluation of the performance of the monitored packaging line 1. The monitoring system 2 allows to carry out a very reliable monitoring method. Secondly, the efficiency monitoring system 2 permits to automatically detect the nature of the alarm. In other words, the system 2 permits to identify if an alarm is anomalous (or outlier) and which alarm is, instead, consistent (or correct). Furthermore, the efficiency monitoring system 2 permits to automatically identify the part of the duration of the alarm, which should be considered in the evaluation of the performance of the line 1, and the other part of the duration, which has to be removed (namely, ignored) during this evaluation. The efficiency monitoring system 2, furthermore, avoids manual interventions by the user, which clearly requests, in turn, a lot of time. In particular, since the efficiency monitoring system 2 permits to evaluate more than one packaging line 1, it is clear that the avoid of manual intervention turns out to be even more advantageous when the monitored lines 1 are more than one. In addition, the monitoring system 2, which stores all the information, in order to identify eventual patterns in the data by machine learning. Furthermore, the monitoring system 2 permits also to optimize the programming of an operator's work. The information obtained by the monitoring system 2 permits also to recognize which of the operators needs any support or refresher courses. In addition, the monitoring system 2 is easily implementable also in already existing machines or lines 1. The system 2 is configured for detecting anomalous time to repairs, in order to reallocate them. The monitoring system 2 may be applied also to a single machine.

Claims

C L A I M S 1. An efficiency monitoring system (2) for monitoring the efficiency of an apparatus (1) for packaging a pourable product, which is configured for automatically carrying out a monitoring process which, for each production stop of the apparatus which is based on alarm, comprises the following operative sequence: - detecting an actual duration (AD) of the stop; - if the actual duration (AD) is bigger than a reference time to repair value (RTTR), calculating an ideal duration (ID) of the stop by removing from the actual duration (AD) the exceeding part (EP) which exceeds the reference time to repair (RTTR) value; and - updating the efficiency of the apparatus (1) by means of the ideal duration (ID), or, if the actual duration (AD) is not bigger than the reference time to repair value (RTTR), by means of the actual duration (AD); the reference time to repair value (RTTR) being a value based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops.

2. The system (2) according to Claim 1, wherein the apparatus comprises a packaging line, the line comprising a plurality of machines.

3. The system (2) according to Claim 1 or 2, configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for eachspecific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes, so that, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop caused by the respective cause, and the reference time to repair value (RTTR1; RTTR2) is a value associated to the respective cause, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops caused by the respective cause.

4. The system (2) according to Claim 1 or 2, configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for each specific production recipe among a plurality of a production recipes, so that, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop occurred during production with the respective recipe, and the reference time to repair value is a value associated to the respective recipe, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops occurred during production with the respective recipe.

5. The system (2) according to Claim 3, configured for carrying out a respective monitoring process for each combination between a specific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes and a specific production recipe among a plurality of recipes, so that, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop caused by the respective cause and occurred during production withthe respective recipe, and the reference time to repair value (RTTRG2R3) is a value associated to the respective combination, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops caused by the respective cause and occurred during production with the respective recipe.

6. System (2) according to any of the previous claims, wherein the reference time to repair value (RTTRG2R3) is based on a reference set of previous stops of the apparatuses of a group (G) of apparatuses (1, 1’, 1’’), the group (G) comprising the monitored apparatus (1).

7. System (2) according to Claim 6, wherein the system (2) is configured for monitoring the efficiency of the group (G) by monitoring the efficiency of each apparatus (1, 1’, 1’’) of the group (G).

8. System (2) according to any of the previous claims, wherein the system (2) is configured for calculating the reference time to repair value based on the reference set of stops, through a statistical model and / or through a machine learning model.

9. Packaging apparatus for packaging a pourable product by means of containers, comprising a system according to any of the previous Claims.

10. An efficiency monitoring method for monitoring the efficiency of an apparatus (1) for packaging a pourableproduct, which comprises carrying out a monitoring process which, for production stop of the apparatus (1) which is based on alarm, comprises the following operative sequence: - detecting an actual duration (AD) of the stop; - if the actual duration (AD) is bigger than a reference time to repair value (RTTR), calculating an ideal duration (ID) of the stop by removing from the actual duration (AD) the exceeding part (EP) which exceeds a reference time to repair (RTTR) value; and - updating the efficiency of the monitored apparatus (1) by means of the ideal duration (ID) or, if the actual duration is not bigger than the reference time to repair value (RTTR), by the actual duration (AD); the reference time to repair value (RTTR) being a value based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops.

11. The method according to Claim 10, comprising carrying out a respective monitoring process for each specific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes, wherein, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop caused by the respective cause and the reference time to repair value (RTTR1; RTTR2) is a value associated to the respective cause, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stopscaused by the respective cause.

12. The system (2) according to Claim 10, comprising carrying out a respective monitoring process for each specific production recipe among a plurality of a production recipes, wherein, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop occurred during production with the respective recipe, and the reference time to repair value is a value associated to the respective recipe, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of previous stops occurred during production with the respective recipe.

13. The method according to Claim 11, comprising carrying out a respective monitoring process for each combination between a specific cause of the stop among a plurality of causes and a specific production recipe among a plurality of recipes, wherein, for each process: the operative sequence is performed for each stop caused by the respective cause and occurred during production with the respective recipe, and the reference time to repair value (RTTRG2R3) is a value associated to the respective combination, and is based on the actual durations of a reference set of stops caused by the respective cause and occurred during production with therespective recipe.

14. Method according to any of the previous claims from 10 to 13, wherein the reference time to repair value (RTTRG2R3) is based on a reference set of previous stops of the apparatuses of a group (G) of apparatuses (1, 1’, 1’’), the group (G) comprising the monitored apparatus (1).

15. Method for monitoring the efficiency of a group of apparatuses (1, 1’, 1’’), each apparatus (1; 1’; 1’’) being for packaging a pourable product, wherein the method comprises, for each apparatus (1, 1’, 1’’), a respective method according to any of Claims from 10 to 14.

16. Method according to any of Claims from 10 to 15, wherein the reference time to repair value is calculated based on the reference set of stops and through a statistical model and / or through a machine learning model.